Torah · HalachaHalachaHanukkah - When Electric Candles Are OkayHalachot HanukkahRabbi Uri Nahum · November 22, 2026−15Play+30Position0:00—Save⌄ShareTranscript0:00So we started talking about the halachot of the menorot, and we're specifically talking about electricity.0:06So when it comes to electricity, we said really a lot of poskim discuss,0:10you know, it should be similar to the way the menorah was lit in the Beit0:15Hamikdash, which means you got to have oil, you got to have a wick.0:17This is not a simple matter because really when you look at the poskim,0:21although Chacham Ovadia says it doesn't work, he brings a whole list of poskim that say you can't use electricity.0:26There are big names out there, like0:30Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach. They say also, Rav Dan, also name0:34Rav Elyashiv. Forgot one more also big name also that says, I think even Chacham Tzion says with a battery you could also do it, right,0:40with the berachah those poskim say.0:42So it's still a machloket poskim, you could say, machloket poskim if you could say it,0:48and I mean to say if you could make a berachah.0:51So therefore, lechatchilah, a person should definitely not rely on using electricity.0:55Now when we talk about electricity, we have to explain also what does it mean, you're lighting menorot hanukkah with electricity.0:59If you put on the lights in the room, that's not1:02menorot Chanukah. Menorot Chanukah has to be something that's not being used and specific only for1:08menorot Chanukah. So now, although it doesn't have to be in the shape of a menorah,1:11but it has to be at least what looks like a single light.1:15So therefore, if you have those menorot that are plugged in or that have, you know, maybe battery operated, I'm not sure,1:22and you could put on the light and it will be just one light, that's what we're talking about.1:27We're not talking about the regular ones in the house where you have all over.1:30That's because it's random lights, end lights that you're using.1:34So therefore, if you have such a, what's it called, if you have such a situation,1:39we have a question of machloket poskim.1:41So obviously, whenever we have a machloket like this, we say avoid it. Try to not get yourself in it.1:47But sometimes you're stuck, and if you are stuck, then you could rely on it.1:52I'll give you one case where a person is stuck.1:54It's rare. I'll tell you why it's rare,1:55because as we're going to learn, when people travel, all the... How to light the menorah, those are the easy stuff.2:02Everybody knows. Okay, every year you put it, whatever, you light it.2:05When you start traveling and you're not home, that's when the complications begin,2:10and that's what we're going to dedicate a lot of time for that.2:12So, there's a Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach says, and Rav Ovadia brings it down also.2:18It says if a person's traveling, he's not home, he has nobody to light for him.2:22It could be he's traveling with the whole family on the airplane,2:25or it could be by himself and he's living by himself, whatever the situation,2:29and he's on the airplane, and it's at night.2:32And by the time he lands, it's going to be the next day.2:35So this is it. This is the third night. What do you do?2:37He says on top of your seat, usually you have a light.2:42If you put on that light, that can count.2:44Now you can tell me there's a light. So let's slow down.2:47Ner ish uveito. This is your bayit for now.2:50It's one candle, good?2:52And me'ikar hadin, you can be yotzei the chovah with one candle.2:55So electricity, okay, so it's2:57machloket. There are poskim that say you can make a bracha, so we're going to tell you don't make a3:00bracha. But if you're stuck, you have no other choice, so at least have this in mind.3:04But make sure you don't read to it, because3:07asur lishtamesh bahem. How long do you have to keep it on for? A half an hour.3:10So for half an hour at night, if you're ever stuck in such a situation, you put on the light.3:16I don't want to say the next example, but the next example could also be a situation3:19for persons in jail, okay?3:22Believe it or not, they won't let you light flames, a candle with flames in jail.3:26That's what they told me. I don't know, but no doubt, I've never been there, but that's what they say.3:30So in jail would be another situation. But if you have a single light, maybe a night light—not you,3:35the guy who is in jail who has a light by his bed or something like3:39that—that could be also, again, there's no other choice.3:43So now you light it, but without a3:45bracha. So when you do light it, how does it work? What should you do?3:48And the answer is you go through the same procedure that you do when you light.3:52You just don't say Hashem's name.3:53You say the following words: Baruch atah Hashem Elokeinu, like the way I'm saying it right now,3:58and you say that with the two4:01brachot. Obviously, you have somebody around you, the other inmates should not answer amen,4:04and you light and you say,4:07Nerot Chanukah. You say exactly the same text as you normally would when you're lighting the regular thing.4:12But again, like we said, because of the safek, because of the machloket, we say. And it's nothing,4:16but it's not—the Chazon Ovadia should say, Oh, it doesn't mean4:19it does. There is, according to a lot of poskim, you are mekayem, you are keeping,4:23you are doing the mitzvah of hadlakat nerot Chanukah.