Torah · HalachaHalachaHanukkah - Definition of A LightHalachot HanukkahRabbi Uri Nahum · November 20, 2026−15Play+30Position0:00—Save⌄ShareTranscript0:00Okay, so when we're talking about the shemanim, the oils, the fuel that you're supposed to use for nerot Chanukah.0:08So, although, like we said, although the halacha says, and the Gemara says, you can use anything that lights, as long as it lights,0:16the halacha also brings down, like the Rambam brings down, and that is that shemen zayit is0:21mitzvah min hamuvchar. The better the olive oil, like we said yesterday, that's also a preferable thing.0:25If you can do extra virgin olive oil, that's one that's in the market.0:30The reason why that's the best, it's because nobody plays with it.0:33It's just cold-pressed olive oil. That's all you're getting.0:37Other ones, they do different processes to it.0:41They cleanse it, they take away this, they take away that.0:44Those are things that may be good for health if you're on a certain diet or whatever.0:48But as far as nerot Chanukah, this is, there you go, shemen0:52zayit zach, baruch Hashem. We have it for breakfast as well, rabotai, if you'd like to light up your labneh.0:57Okay, now let's talk about electricity.1:02If we can light anything, so let's say somebody asks, hey, if you can light anything,1:06so maybe we can light also electricity.1:08Or somebody also asks, what about, could you light a piece of wood,1:12right? Can you make a torch?1:14So there's another halacha, and that is that the flame of the Chanukah candles1:20has to be one flame. It cannot be multiple flames.1:24So, for example, if you have, let's say you want to use a wax candle.1:28We said a wax candle, we hold that you could use a wax candle,1:31even though some people always say about wax candle you could.1:33But you cannot use what we call the havdalah candle,1:36which is many different wax candles intertwined together, coming out as one flame.1:41Even if all the wicks are spun together, being that's multiple wicks,1:46that would be a problem, even more than that.1:48The halacha says if you have a bowl of oil and you put one wick, okay, you have one candle.1:54If you put multiple wicks... As long as they're all still in the same bowl,1:58even though they're not close to each other, that's called2:01motzo kenes. It has to be a clear separation. That's one single candle.2:05So with that, you can understand why, in general, when you light up a fire from wood,2:11that's going to be a problem because you're going to be a flame.2:13Now, what are you going to tell me? What about the following?2:15I have—there's a certain type of wood, I just saw that recently,2:19is that they cut it very thin, and it lights exactly like a candle.2:24It's one small little thin piece of wood, and it does last for a half an hour.2:29Would that be okay for hadlakat nerot of Hanukkah?2:32So I saw that Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach was2:35mesupak. He wasn't sure what to say about it, because why?2:38Although we said every single light is fine,2:41but all the examples are given in halacha regarding the light that's fine have two ingredients.2:48They have a wick and they have a fuel.2:50The fuel is usually oil.2:52Even when you have wax, the wax melts, and that's why it melts,2:57it becomes liquidy, and that's why it's able to provide the light.3:00But over here, you don't have these two ingredients.3:03The same thing that's being used as a wick is also being used as the fuel as well.3:08So therefore, he wasn't sure.3:10He didn't want to say it's no good. He also didn't want to say it's good either.3:13So therefore, he said it's better, obviously, to avoid it.3:17You have no other choice,3:18obviously you have no other choice.3:19Okay, the next question is, which is what we want to talk about, is electricity.3:24According to what we just said right now, that you need a wick and you need fuel,3:30so in electricity you really don't have such a thing.3:33So then you might argue, and it depends which electricity.3:36So if you go back 40 years ago, when the light bulbs technically had—if you look inside3:42the, I forgot what they're called, incandescent?3:45Halogen lights.3:46The halogen lights, was it?3:47I hope you're saying that.3:48I don't know.3:48I think so.3:49But anyway, the light bulbs, if you look at the clear bulb,3:53you see inside where that metal wire was, right?3:59Huh? Incandescent. Okay,3:59incandescent4:01light. So those metal wires, according to some poskim, that's like the wick,4:06and the fuel would be the electricity that's running.4:09That is one sevara, one idea about the lights.4:13Not everybody likes it.4:14A lot of poskim don't like it.4:17But more shockingly, I used to think, oh, you know, the guys who light the light,4:20you know, it's like a4:22zecher. There's an opinion that says like the electricity4:25is a zecher. But I was surprised to find that other poskim bring down some big names.4:30If you have no other choice, you can light even with the4:33berachah. We'll talk about this be'ezrat Hashem a little bit more,4:36and when you could rely on it,4:38probably not for Pesach, but when you could rely on it4:39next time.