Torah · HalachaHanukkah - How Many Candles to LightRabbi Uri Nahum · November 17, 2026 · Halachot Hanukkah-15Play+30Position0:00—Save⌄ShareTranscript0:01We started the halachot of Chanukah. Yesterday we gave a little bit of an introduction to the background.0:07Somebody pointed out, you know, we have already, we've learned these halachot every year.0:12Why do we keep learning it every year? And the answer is, two answers.0:17Number one is, the ones in the past year I keep on deleting, so I have to send it again.0:21Hopefully now we'll save it on the site and we'll be done.0:23The second answer is really, and that's a really more important answer,0:27is that every holiday comes with a certain spiritual light.0:32And in order to tap into that light, a person needs hachanah, a person needs preparation.0:35So even if you know the halachot of Chanukah, and probably by the time you come to Chanukah0:39you might even know exactly what to do, the lights are there,0:42but if you do no preparations for any holiday, including Chanukah, any preparation at all,0:48you will have a very hard time tapping into that light.0:51You did the mitzvah, but as far as tapping into the kedushah of the day, you'll miss out.0:56So that's why there's an inyan of learning halachot, always preparing yourself in whatever way,1:01reading about it, different things, learning about the halachot.1:05Besides, now we just add a third reason, and that is things usually are forgotten by a year.1:10A year later, things are usually forgotten, and we need to refresh1:14our memory. And all these reasons will try to still focus on some of the main halachot.1:17So let's start with the Gemara. The Gemara talks about the chiyuv, the obligation of lighting the menorah.1:23The menorah, like we said, is in memory of the miracle that happened.1:26So the chiyuv is, the obligation is, in the words of the Gemara, is like this:1:31Ner, mitzvah Chanukah,1:33ner ish u'beito. Ner means a single, one candle for each family and his entire family, that's one.1:38Then the Gemara adds,1:41v'hamehadrin. However, those who like to beautify the mitzvah, then they light ner for each person.1:47And then, when ziman edrin, then they light that each night they are1:54mosif v'holech, and we're going with the opinion of1:56Beit Hillel. Every night they add on. That means the first night is one, the second night is two, the third night is three, and so on and so forth.2:02So it is a well-known machloket between the Rambam and the Tosafot2:07how to understand this Gemara.2:09Is the third level, the Gemara says, level one is one candle,2:12level two is light one candle per person,2:16level three is that you light an additional candle every night.2:21Third night is three, fourth night is four, and so on.2:24Okay, so the machloket between the Rambam and Tosafot is:2:28do we say that the third level is in addition to the second level,2:34or do we say that the third level is a completely different level?2:37That's a famous2:38machloket. According to Tosafot, that third level is not a continuation of the second level.2:47That third level is a new thing.2:50Mehadrin, if you only want to be mehader, you light one candle every night,2:54whether it's the fourth night, fifth night, sixth night, doesn't make a difference.2:57If you have seven members in the family, you always light seven every single night.3:01According to the third level, according to Tosafot, it makes no difference how many people you have in your house.3:07You light based on the number of the night.3:10So the first night will be one, second night will be two, three, and four,3:13like that.3:14According to the Rambam, no.3:16The third level is actually adding on to the second level.3:20If you want to do level one, because that's all you have, do one candle.3:24You want to do better than that, then you do—you have seven people,3:27you do seven candles on the first night.3:30Better than that, then you do seven candles on the first night,3:34fourteen candles on the second night,3:36fifteen, you know, whatever. Do the math3:38over time. I'm not here to, you know,3:40too early in the morning for me to do math, and my AI is not working right3:42now. So that's how you do it.3:44That's the famous machloket. And here the Acharonim bring down3:48that usually Tosafot is the Ashkenazi opinion,3:52the Ashkenazim follow that, right?3:53And the Sefardim follow the Rambam;3:55he is the opposite.3:56The Sefardim actually, their minhag is like Tosafot.4:00And we light per night,4:02and not—we don't care how many people are in the house.4:05You can have a family of 20 people, or of two people, or even a person by himself.4:09You light per night:4:11one, two, three, four, depends on the night.4:13According to the Ashkenazim, so people will say,4:16Oh, this is like the Rambam, right?4:18But it's really not exactly like the Rambam.4:20According to the Rambam, who has to light per family?4:23That means, let's say there's 10 members in the family.4:25So first night he's going to light 10; it's easy for me to do4:2810. Ten. Next night it's 20, 30, 40, right?4:30According to the Rambam, it's the baal habayit who has to light 10 candles on the first night,4:3520 candles on the second night, 30 candles on4:38the—right? That's the way the Rambam brings it down.4:40However, by the Ashkenazim, each member of the family lights his own menorah.4:44And Acharonim break their heads exactly to find out exactly where is the source of this.4:48Where is the source?4:49If you want to go with the Rambam, the Rambam says to light, right,4:53that he, the baal habayit, the owner, lights.4:55Why is every single person lighting?4:56Now, true, that's what the Rambam brings down,4:58but where is the source of the Rambam?5:00We'll leave it as an open question for you to find out.