Torah · HalachaHalachaHanukkah - When Extra Candles are Not LitHalachot HanukkahRabbi Uri Nahum · November 18, 2026−15Play+30Position0:00—Save⌄ShareTranscript0:00So we've been talking about the mitzvah, the candles, the number of candles a person is obligated to light.0:09We said by halachah, it's one, but of course, like the mehadrin — almost, not almost, everybody does the mehadrin0:16— some people don't even realize that's part of the mehadrin, and that is that we light per number of nights.0:22And we said yesterday in the halachot, Sephardim and Ashkenazim, how they light, number will continue to light.0:27The question now comes up: what happens if a person doesn't have enough candles for that night, but he has less than that?0:35What does that mean? It's a fourth night, so the fourth night he has to light four candles plus another one for0:41shamash, what we call the shamash, the shammes, Ashkenazim call it.0:45So now it's the fourth night, he's supposed to light that much. He looks in his things, he's on a trip, he can't get other candles.0:51All he has is just enough for three nights.0:56I don't mean three nights, three candles, excuse me, not three nights, three candles.0:59What's the fourth night? Is it better to do whatever he can, which is he has three candles, or is it better to say,1:07no, I can't do three candles, let me just do the minimum, which is one?1:11Three candles might be confusing people, think, but even if he's lighting inside, where he's not lighting for the people outside,1:16what's the preferable halachah? So poskim bring down such a scenario. So let's start with like this:1:21if you have four candles, and you don't have enough for the shamash, so it's not a question.1:28You light four candles, you don't light the1:31shamash. The shamash is an extra thing; we'll talk about him be'ezrat Hashem, why we light that extra candle.1:35So for sure that's what you should light, the four candles.1:38If you have, however, only three candles, and it's the fourth night, then you only light one candle.1:44You don't light just the three candles.1:47And there's, of course, there's no makeup for Chanukah, there's nothing to make up.1:50Like we said, the mitzvah is1:53ner ish u'veito. If it's not four, then it's not anything less. It's only one candle.1:57So it's either one or the number of night.2:01Now, similar, something a little bit similar: a person's going away, and he has enough candles for himself.2:08He bought exactly what he's supposed to, he's going away for the fourth night of2:11Chanukah, and he has another person he sees in the hotel who forgot to bring his menorah, forgot to bring his candles.2:19Now if you share with this guy, you're not going to have.2:22Do we say chayecha kodmin, like we usually do?2:26You got to take care of yourself first before you take care of others.2:28On the airplane, they tell you, what do you do first?2:30First they put on your mask, your oxygen mask, and then you take care of others.2:35So over here I'd say, look, I would love to help you.2:39I can give you a cigarette, you know, but that's not helping you.2:41But anyway, what's going to help you, I can give you.2:44Or do we say, no, you have four candles.2:47Do the minimum without the hiddur, and let your friend also2:51be able to say the bracha. So Chacham Ovadia brings2:53down—I don't believe this is based on the poskim; this is more of a hachra'ah of,2:58you know, logic—Chacham Ovadia brings down that the answer is, give the other guy one candle, and you do also one candle,3:04right? Because you only have four candles. It's the fourth night.3:07So therefore you give him one candle; he does the minimum. And since you have only three,3:12that you can't do the minimum, right?3:14Because you only have three, and you're not supposed to do three on the night of four,3:17so then you also do one candle. Why?3:20Because, like we said yesterday, this is a big rule:3:24net ish u'veito, da'ikar. You always have to go back to the source.3:27The source is one mitzvah is the main thing.3:29The extra things are3:31a hiddur, where your hiddur is gonna not make3:37somebody—God forbid—so it's not your problem. But still,3:40it's better to get the other person to do his minimum3:44chiyuv than for you to do your hiddur.3:46So these are two scenarios where you have to know the3:50... Another point—it's really for a later discussion, but we'll just bring it out now3:55because it's a little bit connected.3:56Sometimes a person may have candles from oil, and he has candles are wax.4:03So it is the fourth night. He has just enough oil for two cups,4:07but he could put two other candles from wax.4:09That also should not be done,4:11because the whole—let's not forget what hiddur means;4:14hiddur is also to beautify the4:16mitzvah. When it's different candles, it looks like it's two different people,4:19and it's not beautifying the mitzvah in such a way.4:21So also in that case, you do not light from two wax candles and two oil.4:27You'll go back to the basic and just light one candle.