Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRadio here on0:05 jradio.com. This is the Halacha Hour, airing live0:08 on—thank you.0:09 This is the Halacha Hour, airing live at 2 o'clock on Wednesday afternoons.0:15 If you're listening to this at night, so we're not live.0:18 We are actually—this is a rerun, so therefore you can't call.0:21 A lot of people told me that they try to call at night.0:23 We're not here at night. We're actually here only at 2 o'clock in the afternoon, 2 to 30:27 o'clock. In the Halacha Hour, we work off the Ben Ish Hai, and we try to learn the halachot,0:34 to explain, to clarify, to understand the halachot, also to be able to0:41 just not just understand, but also to apply it and to make it very, very practical.0:45 We are up to a new parashah, Parashat Vayetze,0:49 and Parashat Vayetze in the Ben Ish Hai, in0:52 Shanah Sheniyah, the Ben Ish Hai talks about the laws of motzaei Shabbat.0:56 What the subjects in this week's parashah are, there's a lot of them.1:01 There is—and if anybody's interested to look further into the1:05 poskim, into the Shulchan Aruch, where all the sources come from,1:09 you can look. All these halachot are found in siman reish tzadi gimel until siman reish tzadi tet.1:14 That's what the parashah covers,1:16 and the subjects in this week's parashah are arvit of motzaei Shabbat,1:21 the times, including the times1:26 atah chonantanu, Havdalah tefillah, Yoshev b'seter. Also all the laws pertaining to Havdalah, eating and drinking before Havdalah,1:31 also the besamim, the me'orei ha'esh, also Havdalah for women,1:35 and we conclude the parashah with the subject of melaveh malka.1:39 This is this week's parashah.1:40 This is Parashat Vayetze, the halachot that we're up to.1:43 But before we get to the halacha, we want to take a little bit of time1:47 to address what happened this past week, the tragedy in the Jewish people.1:54 First of all, this class is l'ilui nishmat the three1:57 bachurim, Yaakov Naftali ben Aheda Vora, Gilad Michael ben Bat Gilam, and Eyal ben Iris Teshura.2:04 Hashem yikom damam,2:08 tehi nishmatam tzrurah bitzror hachayim. And really, it's very difficult to speak.2:12 It's very difficult to address the subject and to speak about it.2:15 When the tragedy happened, we were asked2:18 different rabbis from the radio to speak on the radio,2:21 and really not much to really say. Why?2:24 Because Chazal tell us in the Gemara Masechet2:27 Berachot, Amar Ra Papa, Ra Papa says,2:32 Agra dbeit hamya, shetikuta. The reward for a person going to the beit avel is silence.2:37 The Gemara over there brings a list of things2:40 where you get the most reward from.2:42 For example, the Gemara says2:44 the reward of learning Torah is the preparation for learning Torah,2:46 which is running to shul, running to the beit midrash,2:50 running to the shiur, to listen to the Torah.2:52 You get your reward already from there,2:54 and that's the main part of your reward.2:56 Likewise, the Gemara tells us2:57 when one is visiting the beit avel,2:59 one is visiting those who are mourning,3:01 the reward is silence.3:04 What does it mean, silence?3:05 It means to sit there and to be quiet.3:06 In fact, that's a3:08 halacha lemaaseh. Whenever you're visiting a beit avel,3:09 whenever you're visiting a person who's sitting in mourning,3:12 sitting in shiva,3:13 you're not supposed to address them first.3:16 You're supposed to go there and sit.3:18 Even if you're a very talkative person3:19 and the mourner is one of those very, very quiet people,3:22 halacha says you sit quietly.3:25 You show your sympathy,3:27 you sit next to them,3:29 and you don't say a word.3:30 Only once the mourner begins to speak,3:32 to start speaking to you,3:34 you're allowed to reply.3:35 And even when you reply,3:37 keep the Gemara's words in mind.3:39 Shetikuta is the greatest reward,3:41 which means sometimes it's better not to say3:43 than to say something that might be wrong.3:47 And really, I was listening last night to Dr.3:52 Baharav, and he said something very, very important,3:53 and he pretty much went along the same lines.3:55 There's not much to say here.3:56 There's really our role over here to the parents,3:59 for sure there's not much that we could tell them.4:01 Who are we to give an explanation of why it happened4:04 and what could happen?4:05 And what reminds me of over here4:07 is there's a famous story from one of the4:12 Vizhnitzer Rebbes. One of the Rebbes of Vizhnitz in the past,4:14 I think it's Rabbi Yisrael of4:15 Vizhnitz, I'm not 100% sure,4:17 but in any case,4:19 he once tells his gabbai,4:20 Come with me.4:21 We want to go visit a very wealthy person.4:23 Okay, so the gabbai doesn't know why.4:26 He thinks that maybe he's going to collect from this wealthy person.4:29 This wealthy person happened to be the manager of a certain bank.4:33 So the Vizhnitzer Rebbe goes with his gabbai,4:35 they knock on the door,4:36 and of course the manager of the bank,4:38 this wealthy man, sees the Vizhnitzer Rebbe4:40 and he gives him all the honor, all the kavod.4:41 He invites him into the house.4:43 He sits him down. He serves him.4:45 And meanwhile, the Vizhnitzer Rebbe is not saying a word.4:48 And out of respect for the Rebbe,4:50 the wealthy man sits there in silence,4:52 waiting for the Rebbe to address him.4:53 Obviously, he came to his house4:55 and he wants to tell him something,4:57 but the Rebbe doesn't say a word.4:58 He sits there in silence.4:59 And of course the gabbai is not saying a word.5:02 So the wealthy man looks at the gabbai,5:03 and the gabbai, you know, he says,5:07 I don't know. I don't know what to tell you.5:08 I don't know why he's here.5:11 So finally the wealthy man tells the Rebbe,5:15 Rebbe, is there anything we could do for you?5:18 Rebbe doesn't say a word. He sits there silently.5:21 Fifteen minutes pass. The Rebbe gets up.5:24 He says, Okay, thank you very much,5:25 and he starts heading out.5:26 So now the wealthy man can't contain himself.5:28 He says, Rebbe, Rebbe, you have to tell me,5:31 what was the purpose of the visit?5:32 How come? What did the Rebbe want to tell me?5:35 To that, the rabbi says,5:38 You know, what could I tell you?5:41 Chazal tell us that5:43 just like it's a mitzvah to say something5:45 when it has to be said,5:47 there's also a mitzvah not to say something5:50 when nothing should be said.5:52 I wanted to tell you something,5:54 but I know that if I tell you,5:55 you're not going to hear it,5:56 you're not going to accept it.5:57 So there's a mitzvah for me not to say something.5:59 But to not do anything about it,6:01 I can't do that either.6:03 So therefore,6:05 I came to the house,6:06 I did my6:07 hishtadlus, I did my effort,6:07 I came,6:09 but I can't say it6:10 because I know you're not going to be6:12 mekabel it. So the wealthy man was very moved.6:13 He said, No, no, you have to tell me.6:14 Tell me, please,6:15 I'm going to try to do it.6:16 He says, No, you're not going to listen.6:17 He says, No, you have to tell me.6:18 Finally he tells him, You6:19 know, there's an almana,6:20 and she owes a lot of money to the bank.6:22 And I know you have the right to collect the money6:25 from the almana,6:26 but you know, what could I tell you?6:27 She has no money.6:27 And she came to me crying,6:31 and I know that she owes you the money and there's really not much to do,6:32 but I can't just not do anything.6:34 I have to do something,6:36 but I can't tell you about it either.6:38 That moved the wealthy man6:39 that he sponsored6:40 to pay for the loan of the almana.6:42 But the idea was6:44 that you have to do something,6:46 but you can't say anything.6:47 That's really6:49 where we're standing right now.6:51 This is a mourning6:52 not just for the families6:54 of the three boys,6:55 but this is a mourning period6:57 for all of6:59 Klal Yisrael. Sefarim bring down7:01 that the7:02 neshamos of the Jewish people,7:03 you know, Chazal tell us7:05 that7:09 Kol Yisrael areivim zeh lazeh, Kol Yisrael areivim zeh lazeh. All the Jewish people7:12 are connected to each other,7:14 or we're guarantors for each other.7:16 There's a connection7:16 between all the Jewish people,7:17 and we feel for each other.7:19 Baruch Hashem,7:20 this is one of7:21 the qualities of Jewish people,7:22 rachmanim, but they feel so much about each other.7:25 But the Sefarim bring down even more.7:27 They say that the souls7:28 of the Jewish people,7:30 they all come from the same place.7:32 As Chazal tell us,7:37 that7:40 Kudsha Brichu v'Oraysa v'Yisrael chad hu. All these7:42 components are all from the same source.7:44 But more than that,7:45 that they're just the same source,7:47 we're connected to each other,7:48 and the more the soul,7:50 the greater the soul is,7:52 it has a connection to more Jews.7:54 And they medaik from the words of the Rambam.7:56 The Rambam writes7:57 when it comes to a king,7:58 he has to keep—8:00 A Sefer Torah with him. The Torah tells us that a king must carry a Sefer Torah with him at all times.8:05 Why? says the Rambam, because the Torah says,8:10 V'lo yasur levavo, that his heart should not go astray.8:12 Why should his heart not go astray? Who cares?8:14 Let the king, you know what, if the king is a little bit crooked,8:19 he's not such a righteous king, how does that affect the Jewish people?8:22 Okay, so the Jewish people remain8:25 tzaddikim. Says the Rambam, no, that's not true.8:29 Shelibo hu lev kol Kahal Yisrael. The heart of the king is the heart of all the Jewish people.8:32 And the Sefarim explain that the king's8:35 neshama, the neshama of the Jewish king, is a very, very high and elevated8:39 neshama, and therefore has a connection to all the Jewish people.8:42 If the Jewish king makes a mistake, even if it's a small mistake,8:46 it could be felt by all the Jewish people.8:48 All the Jewish people are connected to the Jewish king.8:51 And therefore, when we see such a tragedy happening8:53 that just happened to us, which affected all the Jewish people,8:58 every single person was affected by this tragedy.9:00 Every person felt it.9:02 Everybody came to pray when we didn't know what really happened.9:07 Everybody prayed for them.9:08 Everybody was saddened.9:10 Everybody was in tears.9:12 Everybody's hearts were broken when we heard the tragic news on Sunday.9:17 And so, therefore, we are all connected to these neshamot,9:21 and therefore we are all also mourning for these neshamot.9:24 And at times of Beit Hamikdash, Hazal tell us, Shetikuta. The reward is to be silent9:30 and not to speak, really, to try to, you know, we try to understand,9:33 but how can we understand?9:34 What do we know about Hashem?9:36 How can we understand the ways of Hashem? Hashem9:39 tov lakol. Hashem is very good to everyone.9:42 Sometimes we see it, sometimes we don't.9:44 In these times that we don't see it, we have to understand,9:47 ultimately, that Hashem is good.9:49 And what we could do, though, is from this point onwards,9:54 from this state, what we could do from now onwards9:56 is what we could do to elevate their souls,9:59 to try to explain what happened in the past. That's not our area.10:04 That's shetikuta.10:05 For that, we need silence.10:06 But from now onwards, what we could do10:08 is we could do because no one really dies by the Jewish people.10:12 The souls just go to a different place.10:13 The neshamot are in a better place,10:15 and where they are right now, we could do for them.10:17 What they couldn't10:20 complete—they were taken so young, 16, 19 years old,10:22 they were taken away from us at such a young10:24 age—they couldn't accomplish much.10:25 By us, collectively as a Jewish people,10:28 on their merit and their zechuyot,10:29 we could do for them.10:31 We could learn Torah for them.10:32 We could do mitzvot on their behalf.10:33 We could do mitzvot10:35 l'ilui nishmatam. We could give tzedakah10:37 l'ilui nishmatam. Many things we could do,10:38 even blessings, berachot parties,10:40 or making berachot, answering10:42 amen l'ilui nishmatam, just like anybody would do by any other yahrzeit,10:44 or when a person is in the year of mourning.10:46 We're in the period of mourning for these three boys,10:49 and therefore we dedicate this class10:52 l'ilui nishmatam, that,10:54 be'ezrat Hashem, Hashem shall elevate their souls,10:55 and Hashem should protect all the Jewish people10:57 in all the places at all times,11:01 and that we should see,11:02 be'ezrat Hashem, in the geulah shleimah and11:05 techiyat hameitim, we're all united together again,11:07 learning Torah11:08 and nehenim11:09 m'ziv haShechinah. And now we'll move on to the laws of the parashah,11:13 Parashat11:14 Vayetze. Like we said, this week's11:17 parashah—this parashah, excuse me, not this week's parashah,11:19 but this parashah, particularly in11:21 Sefer11:22 Bereishit, high in the second year, discusses the laws of11:24 motzaei Shabbat, and there's a lot of11:26 important ideas. We'll begin with the first11:28 halachah. I don't think we'll get past the first halachah, and hopefully,11:31 hopefully, we'll be able to get past the first11:33 halachah. Let's begin with the words of the Ben11:36 Ish Chai. And he writes the following:11:38 Me'acharin tefilat Arvit kedei lehosif mechol11:42 al hakodesh. On Motzaei Shabbat,11:43 the first thing that we come when we meet Motzaei Shabbat,11:45 we're in shul, we come to11:46 pray Arvit. Even though11:49 you could pray Arvit from11:51 plag hamincha, and the Ashkenazim who pray after11:53 sheki'ah, technically you could pray Arvit as early11:55 as sunset, right?11:57 Still, we delay11:58 the prayer of Arvit. Why?12:00 Why do we delay the prayer? Why do we pray12:03 Arvit later than usual days?12:05 And the answer is kedei lehosif12:06 mechol al hakodesh, in order12:08 to add from the weekday on12:11 to the holy day of Shabbat. We mentioned12:12 this in the past as a mitzvah to add12:15 on to Shabbat. What does it12:17 mean to add on to Shabbat? There's a mitzvah to take from the12:19 days of the week before Shabbat12:20 and after Shabbat, and to add on12:22 to Shabbat. Shabbat should not be only12:24 24 hours. Shabbat should be12:27 24 hours plus.12:28 How much plus? We discussed this in the past.12:31 There are many different opinions,12:33 but this is one12:35 of the reasons why we add Motzaei Shabbat,12:37 why we add hours,12:39 or we add time on Motzaei Shabbat,12:41 or12:43 we pray—excuse me—we pray later on Motzaei Shabbat,12:44 is in order to add time from Motzaei Shabbat12:47 to the weekday, just like we would do12:49 when entering Shabbat. We said that12:51 you shouldn't come into Shabbat,12:52 you shouldn't stop melachah right when Shabbat begins.12:55 Rather, begin melachah a little bit before12:57 Shabbat begins. Likewise, we don't want to kick12:59 out Shabbat, right? You have a guest,13:01 somebody very important, he spent Shabbat by you.13:03 You don't look at your watch and say,13:04 Okay, Motzaei Shabbat, yalla, get your bags, get into the car,13:07 and out the door, sayonara, buddy,13:09 I don't want to see you again. Chas v'shalom, we don't do that13:11 to Shabbat. Queen Shabbat malkeita,13:13 we don't want to kick her out,13:15 and we delay Arvit just to add a few more13:17 moments. How much time do you have13:19 to leave? On when do you have to add on to it?13:21 Here's the Ben Ish Chai's opinion:13:24 V'tzarich lehosif zeman shehu vadai layla. The time that you add has to be a time13:27 that's for sure night.13:29 Upoirenu. So here the Ben Ish Chai discusses13:31 the minhag in Baghdad.13:33 I don't want to read the words inside, not to13:35 confuse everybody, but just to tell you13:37 that the Ben Ish Chai brings down13:39 over here two13:41 opinions that he had13:43 in Baghdad. He says13:45 that one should begin13:47 praying Arvit. In Baghdad, the minhag was13:49 to wait 27 minutes13:51 after sunset,13:53 27 minutes after sunset,13:55 and that's when you begin13:57 Arvit. And he says that his father,13:59 Rabbi Moshe14:02 Chayim, the Ben Ish Chai's father,14:03 had a minhag of waiting 37 minutes14:05 until he prayed14:07 Arvit. This is the14:09 halacha one must add on14:11 to the day of Shabbat.14:14 How does he add on14:15 motzaei Shabbat? By delaying the14:17 prayer of Arvit. Don't pray Arvit yet.14:19 Wait to pray Arvit until14:21 later than the right time.14:23 How much more time? The minhag14:25 in Baghdad at the time. Now we're going to discuss this at length,14:27 because we're going to see what14:29 is the definition really of motzaei Shabbat14:31 and everything. But before we get to that, let's just get some14:33 points out of the way to clarify.14:36 What's so important about delaying14:38 Arvit? Why, besides just Kabbalat Shabbat,14:40 why should we delay it?14:41 Let's begin with the Gemara, and the Tur brings down.14:44 The Gemara Masechet Shabbat says,14:46 Amar Rabbi Yose. Rabbi Yose says,14:51 Yehei chelki im motzaei Shabbat b'Tzipori. Let my portion in Olam Haba14:53 be with those people. I would love to be14:55 part of the people who14:57 finish Shabbat, who live in14:59 Tzipori. Why? What was so special about this place,15:01 Tzipori? I think they call it Tziyon in English.15:07 Shehayta yoshevet bahar. The city15:07 was on top of a mountain.15:12 Vehayaner aleihem yom gadol ad tzet hakochavim. And to them, because they're sitting so high on the mountain,15:16 the sun was still15:17 visible to them. And since it15:19 was visible to them, even15:22 at a later15:23 time, after what we would see15:25 on a regular city, we would see as15:27 sheki'ah, so therefore Rabbi Yose said15:29 they would delay15:31 motzaei Shabbat tefillah. They would not finish15:33 Shabbat so quickly. He says, I would love to be part of that city.15:36 So because they finish later.15:38 And the Mishnah Berurah brings15:39 down, and he says that15:41 even though, min hadin, even though15:43 a person could do15:45 melacha, whenever the halacha permits you to do15:48 melacha, mikol makom, says the Mishnah Berurah,15:51 lechatchilah. It is preferable, ראוי ונכון וכן מנהג כל ישראל, לאחר את התפילה כדי שתוסף יותר מחול על הקודש.16:00 Tefillah, and this is what's proper and this is what's correct,16:02 and this is also the minhag of all the Jewish people.16:06 For a person to delay the tefillah until, he adds, from Nechol until the Kodesh.16:11 This is what Mishnah Berurah brings. A lot of people complain,16:13 Hey, you know, a lot of shuls where the people are not so learned,16:17 and they all complain, Why can't we pray Arvit earlier?16:20 What do you mean? It's over. The time is already over. No.16:23 The minhag of all the Jewish people and the history of the Jewish people,16:26 as every sefer, every halacha book brings down,16:28 that you don't pray Arvit until what you consider motzaei Shabbat,16:32 or at least close to it.16:34 So that's why we delay the16:35 Arvit. Even though technically you're right, you could go home and you could wait till16:38 motzaei—no. We pray Arvit only once we're ready to finish Shabbat,16:43 and we try to also delay it.16:45 You know, if you ever prayed by Sefardim on motzaei Shabbat,16:50 if you ever go to a Sefardi shul, you'll see that the chazzan sings Kaddish.16:53 You know why they sing Kaddish?16:54 Some will say, Yeah, because it's tefillah and things.16:57 Yeah, maybe today that's what the chazzan is thinking about,17:00 to show, look, his nice beautiful voice.17:02 But really it's brought down that the reason why we sing Kaddish17:05 is in order to stretch out the Kaddish17:07 so we can have a little bit more time, to delay a little bit more time.17:11 In the end of this halacha that we just read in17:13 Ben Ish Chai—Ben Ish Chai brings from Chayei Vital in the name of17:16 Chai Gaon—that when the chazzan says17:18 Bar'chu et Hashem17:19 hamevorach and the people respond,17:20 you should stretch out the Baruch Hashem17:24 hamevorach le'olam va'ed. Stretch out Baruch as much as you can.17:29 Why? First of all, it's brought down because it gives you success17:31 and it protects you, gives you17:34 shemirah and hatzlachah. But more than that, it's brought down—you know why?17:36 Because you stretch out the time of motzaei Shabbat.17:40 Till you start Arvit, you're not starting Arvit yet.17:43 Bar'chu is right before17:45 Arvit. You want to gain even those moments.17:46 You see how even a few moments, how17:48 much—it's a few17:49 seconds—even to delay the exit of Shabbat for a few seconds,17:52 it shows the love of Shabbat.17:54 You know, everybody who was engaged at one point in his life17:58 will remember. When18:01 you engage, yeah, only when you engage, unfortunately.18:03 Anyway, but those times, you know,18:04 you're talking to your18:06 fiancée, and she says, Okay, bye.18:08 Say, Okay, bye.18:09 You hang up.18:09 No, no, no, you hang up.18:10 No, no, you hang up.18:11 You don't want to hang up the phone.18:13 Something that you're very much like,18:16 and you know you have to leave,18:18 you know you have to depart,18:19 you know you have to go your own ways,18:20 but you don't want to hang up yet.18:21 Same thing, Shabbat should be18:23 something—it's a queen, it's a18:25 kallah, it's compared to a bride.18:26 We don't want to hang up from Shabbat.18:28 We don't want to let Shabbat go.18:29 You leave.18:30 No, you go, you go,18:31 and we try to stretch it out18:32 even for a few moments18:33 as much as you can.18:34 If you want a bigger incentive18:36 to delay the tefilah of18:38 Arvit, listen to what the Zohar brings down.18:39 And the18:41 Ben Ish Chai—sorry—brings down this Zohar.18:43 You'll see in the Zohar yourself.18:45 Zohar says something interesting.18:46 You know when the neshamot come back,18:49 there's different levels of the neshamot18:50 that are in18:51 Gehinnom. There's neshamot in18:53 Gehinnom, and on Shabbat they get a break.18:54 That's it.18:55 Shabbat they get off.18:56 Don't think it's only America,18:57 it's a weekend, it's only us.18:58 No.18:59 Shabbat and Yom Tov,19:00 the people, the neshamot in19:01 Gehinnom get a break. They don't burn.19:02 However, they come back19:04 once a person says already,19:06 Motzaei Shabbat,19:08 he starts19:09 Arvit, that neshama comes back already.19:11 The neshamot come back.19:12 There are many different parts of19:14 the neshama. Some parts of the neshama come back19:15 a little bit later and whatever,19:17 but the parts of19:19 the neshama already begin to come back to19:22 inside the levels of19:25 Gehinnom when—once we begin19:26 Arvit. So that's why it's a good idea19:29 to delay the tefilah of19:32 Arvit in order to keep the neshamot out of19:34 Gehinnom as much as possible.19:36 But that, rabotai,19:37 is good for you as well,19:39 not just for the souls that passed away,19:40 your relatives and only19:41 that. That's also good for you as well,19:43 because if, chas v'shalom, a person has to go to Gehinnom himself,19:47 when do they bring him back?19:48 They bring him back the way he kept Shabbat.19:51 Shabbat is all from19:52 Gehinnom, and when does he come back to19:54 Gehinnom? Well, we look at his track record.19:55 Let's see what you did in this world.19:56 When did you finish Shabbat?19:59 And like you finish Shabbat in this world,20:00 that's how you finish it also in that world.20:03 So that's another incentive for us20:05 to try to delay Shabbat a little bit more.20:07 How much should a person delay20:10 the exit of Shabbat?20:11 How much should a person wait?20:13 So we already brought you a few opinions.20:14 First of all—20:16 We said the opinion of Ben Ish Chai and his father,20:18 which is 27 minutes,20:21 and his father says 37 minutes.20:23 The Kaf HaChaim brings down the name of Ruach20:27 Chaim that a person should not finish20:31 Shabbat—I mean, excuse20:32 me—should not begin Baruchu of20:35 Arvit until at least 30 minutes after20:39 shekiah. Do not begin Baruchu of20:40 Arvit until at least 30 minutes after20:43 shekiah. Those are the minimum times that we find.20:45 Could you technically pray earlier?20:48 Yes, but like we said,20:49 the halacha says l'chatchila a person has to pray later.20:53 Now, what is the earliest time to pray20:55 Arvit? Arvit, rabotai, is no different20:57 than any other Arvit of the week.20:59 The earliest time to pray Arvit is21:01 plag hamincha. There's a machloket in the Gemara21:03 when you can pray Arvit. There's two opinions,21:05 and the halacha says you can do either one.21:07 Sefardim hold from21:09 plag hamincha, as you see21:09 any walk into any Sefardi shul in the summer,21:12 most of them are praying Arvit by21:14 plag hamincha, which means before sunset.21:17 The Ashkenazim, even throughout the21:19 weekday, will not pray Mincha until after plag hamincha. Excuse me, will not pray—sorry—the Ashkenazim will not pray Arvit until after shekiah, until after sunset.21:29 That's the Ashkenazim.21:31 Shabbat is no different.21:32 Technically, you could pray by21:34 plag hamincha. However, halacha brings down21:36 only in emergency circumstances21:39 is a person allowed to pray Arvit so early.21:42 What's called an emergency circumstance?21:44 The answer: emergency circumstance,21:47 really, if it's very, very necessary,21:48 a person has to ask his rabbi.21:50 But usually emergency circumstances,21:52 this is something that we all agree on,21:54 is the case of an21:55 onen. Lo aleinu, if a person has a relative21:58 that passed away, either on Shabbat or right before Shabbat,22:01 basically the relative died22:03 and they weren't able to bury him just yet.22:05 So halacha says that he's an onen22:08 until the person who died is22:10 buried, and then he becomes an22:12 avel. The halacha by an onen is that22:14 he's not allowed to do any mitzvah.22:16 That includes— Making Berachot when eating,22:21 answering amen, praying,22:22 say whatever it is.22:23 Any mitzvah is not allowed,22:24 even to the point of answering amen.22:25 He can't even answer amen,22:26 just one word; he cannot do it.22:27 Why?22:28 Because he has to be occupied with22:30 taking care of the dead body to be buried.22:32 And so long as he's going to be22:35 occupied with other things,22:36 he might get distracted by any mitzvah.22:38 He might say,22:40 You tell me not to do22:41 mitzvot. He might go pray and he starts to...22:43 So therefore, no22:44 mitzvot. He's not allowed to do any22:46 mitzvot. He has to drink;22:47 he drinks without making22:48 Berachot. This is only true22:50 when the time allows him to be able to bury his dead.22:54 But on Shabbat,22:55 where we are not allowed to bury a person on Shabbat,22:58 so therefore this person who is an onen23:00 is not forbidden to do23:02 mitzvot. In fact, he has to do all the23:04 mitzvot. There are certain things that he's limited from,23:06 but otherwise23:08 he is chayav in all the mitzvot,23:09 including tefillah,23:10 including23:12 Berachot, Birkat Hamazon, Kiddush, etc.23:14 So now,23:14 what my Rosh23:16 Yeshiva, kollel, did one23:17 time—now I learned one time23:18 a certain family23:19 whose father passed away on Friday night.23:21 So23:22 he told the boys of that family,23:24 when they came to pray23:26 Mincha in the shul, it was still before sunset.23:28 Right after they prayed23:28 Mincha, he told them,23:29 I want you to pray Arvit right away,23:30 right now,23:31 and make Havdalah right now.23:33 Of course,23:33 you make Havdalah only23:35 with the first and last blessing,23:36 Hagafen and23:39 Hamavdil bein kodesh lechol, and then you go home.23:41 Once sunset comes in,23:42 you're already not an onen anymore.23:45 I mean,23:45 you're back to being an onen,23:47 and you're forbidden to do mitzvot.23:48 So at least23:49 grab the23:51 Arvit, because afterwards23:51 you wouldn't be able to pray23:52 Arvit. The levayah was not going to take place23:54 until the morning,23:55 and we copied in this way.23:57 This is brought down,23:58 Yabia Omer;23:58 Chacham Ovadia says the same thing.24:00 And we copied this way one time, lo aleinu, lo aleichem. There was a person who was in our shul24:06 whose sister also passed away right before, an hour before Shabbat,24:09 and obviously the burial was going to take place on Sunday.24:11 And when he came also on Shabbat morning, he came to shul,24:14 we told him that after praying Mincha, he should pray Arvit right away,24:18 make Havdalah in the house on a cup of wine, first and last berachah, and that's it, let him go home24:24 and wait. Once already Motzaei Shabbat, he can pray Arvit or say24:27 Havdalah, and therefore at least let him grab the Arvit right now.24:29 That's called an emergency circumstance.24:32 However, the Ashkenazim, I don't know what the minhag Ashkenazim,24:35 I only saw brought down in the sefer24:36 Piskei Teshuvot, brings down in the name of some24:39 poskim that the minhag of Ashkenazim, even by an אונן, they wouldn't let him pray Arvit before sunset.24:44 So which means that Ashkenazim, lo aleinu, if a person is in such a situation24:48 where Motzaei Shabbat is becoming an אונן again, he will miss out on24:51 Arvit. Okay?24:53 Now, this is the mitzvah of delaying Shabbat, delaying the Arvit on Motzaei Shabbat.24:59 But now we come to a very important subject which will occupy the rest of the class,25:03 and I really hope we finish it by the time this class finishes.25:07 The question is, this is the million-dollar question:25:11 What time is Shabbat over?25:14 Okay?25:14 What time is Shabbat over?25:16 When do we say that's already Motzaei Shabbat?25:18 You could go ahead and do melachah, you could do whatever you want,25:20 you could drive a car, you could put on the light.25:23 For those who smoke and they anticipate and they wait for this,25:27 they could light a cigarette.25:29 Okay. In any case, what time is it that we're Motzaei Shabbat?25:34 So, to really understand this answer,25:36 let me first introduce it with the words of the25:38 Kaf HaChaim. The25:40 Kaf HaChaim, סימן רסא, הלכה א'. He writes the following. He says,25:47 בעניין בין השמשות, and when it comes to בין השמשות, הרבה מן הפוסקים נתחבטו בדבר זה. Many, many poskim were very confused when it comes to this part.25:54 You find so many opinions.25:56 There's books upon books written just on the subject.25:59 There's no way in a half an hour that we have left of the class,26:02 if you give me an hour or two,26:03 we're really able to cover the whole subject fully.26:06 There are opinions that we find as early as about nine minutes.26:11 To as late as over 96 minutes,26:15 sometimes even 110 minutes of waiting on Motzei Shabbat.26:19 What does it mean, nine minutes or 110 minutes?26:21 There are opinions that even up to 110 minutes you should wait26:24 Motzei Shabbat, Saturday night after sunset, to start doing26:29 melacha. And there's, excuse me, there's even opinions 120 minutes.26:32 And there's as early as nine minutes.26:33 And the question is, whoa,26:36 where'd you get from? How'd you get those numbers?26:37 How can such a big thing?26:39 So we're going to try to, we're going to take, spend some time.26:42 It's a little bit, I don't think it's so complicated.26:45 We're going to break it up.26:46 The subject itself, when you go into the books,26:48 yes, it is complicated.26:50 But, be'ezrat Hashem, with siyata d'shmaya, we hope to clarify the subject. They should understand26:55 this. Hopefully you'll understand when people say,26:57 I'm waiting Rabbeinu Tam,26:59 and you see some people walking out of shul,27:00 for them already they're driving,27:01 and the other guy says, No, for me Shabbat is not over.27:04 I hold Rabbeinu Tam.27:05 What in the world does that mean, I hold Rabbeinu Tam?27:08 So let's begin.27:10 Let's begin by introducing just some definitions that we need to know as we go along.27:16 The times of the day are split into three parts.27:18 There's three parts of the day.27:20 There's what we call daytime,27:22 there's nighttime,27:23 and there's any time in between,27:25 between day and night, between night and day.27:27 That's what we call in English twilight.27:29 That's called בין השמשות in Hebrew,27:33 and we'll discuss what that is.27:34 What is the definition of daytime according to halacha?27:37 Torah, open up,27:39 Parashat Bereishit, Yom27:40 Rishon. The Torah tells us,27:43 ויקרא אלוהים לאור יום. Hashem called the day yom.27:47 He called, excuse me, Hashem called the daylight, the light, yom.27:51 What's that light?27:52 Chazal tell us, the pesukim explain,27:54 this is referring to this, even though the sun was created,27:57 but when there's light in the world,27:59 that's called yom.28:01 Which means whenever you see the sun out,28:03 that is considered yom,28:05 daytime according to halacha.28:06 Every single thing that must be done in the day,28:09 like for example, brit milah,28:11 shaking the lulav, any28:12 mitzvot that could only be done in the day,28:14 shechita, whatever,28:16 could be done when the sun is out.28:19 That's halacha.28:20 Now, sometimes you're limited, but okay, that's daytime.28:23 What is the definition of night?28:25 Well, let's continue in the28:27 pasuk. Pasuk says, V'lachoshech kara layla,28:29 and Hashem called the evening,28:31 the darkness, Hashem called that night.28:33 Clearly, in the Torah it says,28:35 whenever it's dark,28:36 that is called night.28:39 Okay,28:41 but this is very confusing.28:44 Daytime, I understand,28:45 la'or, when the light is there,28:46 which is the sun,28:48 when the sun is out, that's called daytime.28:50 That's very easy to28:51 understand. But what in the world does night,28:54 what's darkness mean?28:55 It says nighttime is darkness,28:56 but what is the definition of darkness?28:58 Because when the sun is not there, it's not really dark yet.29:01 And the Torah doesn't say when the light is not there,29:03 it's called night.29:04 It says when the light is not there,29:07 it doesn't say anything.29:08 It says when darkness is in, then that's called night.29:12 So therefore,29:13 to understand this, we have to go to the Gemara,29:15 and we find in29:17 Chazal that there are two different ways29:19 Chazal told us29:21 what's considered nighttime.29:23 Okay, number one way is29:26 by waiting a certain amount of time.29:28 The other way is29:29 by looking up at the sky29:31 and seeing certain29:33 simanim, certain signs in the sky,29:34 and that's when we know it's called nighttime.29:37 What are those things? Let's begin.29:39 Waiting a certain time, we find in the Gemara29:42 that if you wait a certain time29:43 after the sun sets, then it's already called night.29:46 It's going to sound a little confusing now,29:48 but don't worry, we're going to clarify it later on.29:49 But we find two separate times in the Gemara29:53 that the Gemara says29:54 that a person has to wait until it's nighttime.29:56 The Gemara says after the sun sets,29:58 if a person waits29:59 the distance of three quarters of a30:02 mil. A mil is a certain distance.30:03 You want to call it a mile, whatever it is,30:06 it's the distance of about30:08 1,500 amot.30:10 How much is an30:11 amah? 1.6 feet about, or two feet30:14 almost, according to the30:15 Chazon Ish. The time it takes for an average person30:17 to walk 1,500 amot,30:20 that's a distance of30:21 three quarters of a30:23 mil. That's one place we find in the Torah, in the Gemara,30:25 that when you wait after sunset30:27 three quarters of a mil, it's already considered nighttime.30:30 In another Gemara,30:31 Masechet Pesachim, the Gemara tells us over there30:34 that from sunset until30:35 nighttime,30:37 it takes an average person to walk30:40 four30:42 mil. That's a huge difference.30:43 We just said beforehand it takes three quarters of a30:45 mil, now we're saying it's four30:47 mil. Keep those two in mind,30:48 because then we'll get back to it.30:51 That's one siman that's brought in the Gemara,30:52 if you wait this amount of time.30:54 Yet when we look in another Gemara,30:56 the Gemara gives another siman30:57 that everybody knows the following siman.30:58 There's also two simanim by looking at the sky.31:01 Number one is if you see three stars.31:04 If you see three stars, the Gemara tells us31:06 if you look up and you see three stars,31:08 and the Rishonim explain, and Ben Yehonah explains,31:10 we're talking about over here31:12 small tiny stars,31:13 because most people don't understand what a medium size is.31:16 Really the Gemara means medium,31:16 but we're going to tell you wait till you see three small stars,31:20 that's already nighttime,31:21 and they have to be next to each other.31:22 The other siman the Gemara tells us is31:25 when the sky gets dark.31:28 To explain this is very complicated.31:29 This is not our area31:32 over here to really explain it,31:32 but it's called31:35 hichsif ha'elyon. What is31:36 hachsif al yom? Basically,31:38 when the—where the sun is setting,31:40 it's always going to be more light.31:42 The sun, by the way, sets in the west,31:43 for those who are not familiar,31:44 right? The sun always sets in the west31:46 and arises in the east.31:48 So when the sun is setting in the west,31:49 obviously the western part of the sky31:51 is always going to be more light31:53 than the eastern part of the sky,31:55 because the further the sun is,31:57 the more down the sun is going,31:59 the sun is setting.32:00 The dark is going to be the exact opposite area where it's not getting any light, and that's in the east.32:05 So the Gemara says, when you have the east dark, the eastern part of the sky is dark,32:10 and the top, when you look at the top of the sky, you know, the dome of the sky,32:15 you see that there's no more redness over there. Had there been clouds,32:18 you know, when the sun is setting, you see that redness in the sky.32:20 If you don't see that redness from the top, from the upper part of the sky,32:24 that's already another siman for you that that's already called32:28 nighttime. Good? So we have, again, two simanim when it comes to night.32:33 Number one: when is it considered dark? Dark is night. Night equals dark. Dark equals night.32:38 When is it considered night? One siman is by waiting a certain time.32:42 The other siman is by looking in the sky to see either three stars32:47 or to see a certain amount of darkness in the sky. Fine.32:50 And what's bein hashmashot? What's twilight? And the answer is any time in between.32:55 Any time between day and night, that's called twilight.32:59 Everybody agrees, all the Rishonim, all the Acharonim, and the Gemara.33:03 The Gemara itself seems to be posek halacha at the end of the day33:07 that twilight is about three-quarters of a33:10 mil. It's three-quarters, the time it takes for an average person to walk33:13 1,500 amot. That's what twilight is, okay?33:16 Now we want to focus a little bit on nighttime a little bit, because that's our—we want to know33:20 when it is night on Motzaei Shabbat that we can begin doing33:23 melacha. We already mentioned the two33:26 simanim. The Shulchan Aruch, what does he write? He writes in two different places.33:31 One is in the laws of Keriat Shema, entering Shabbat,33:35 and one in the laws of Motzaei Shabbat.33:37 In siman רסא he writes, you know when nighttime is?33:40 When a person waits a certain amount of time.33:44 Then he waits a certain amount of time, and then you know when nighttime is.33:48 Basically he went with the Gemara that says33:50 that night begins after waiting a certain amount of time, which we said.33:54 Four mil or three quarters of a33:57 mil. In Siman Reish Tzadik Gimel, the Shulchan Aruch writes34:00 that when one looks up at the sky and he sees three stars,34:04 then you know it's already nighttime, and that's already motzaei Shabbat.34:08 And here, the Minchat Kohen, quoted by the Biur Halacha, says,34:13 from here you see that Shulchan Aruch, he wrote in both places the same.34:17 When he wanted to talk about when nighttime is, he said them in different words.34:21 You see from here clearly that the time when three stars come out34:26 is the same amount of time that it takes for, from sunset until you wait four34:35 milin. It's exactly the same time.34:37 Both times are really the same. The Gemara is not contradicting itself.34:40 The two simanim are different ways.34:43 Why should we have two different34:44 simanim? Well, think about it.34:45 If you're looking up at the sky to see when it's three stars,34:48 what would happen if the sky is cloudy?34:50 How would you know when three stars are out?34:52 And the answer is by waiting,34:54 right?34:54 When you know that the sun set a certain amount of time,34:56 if you wait the time it takes for a person to walk four35:00 mil, then you know that motzaei Shabbat has finished.35:03 Those are the reasons we can explain why there's two simanim in Shulchan Aruch.35:08 You're obviously now thinking there's a little bit of a contradiction here,35:12 like we mentioned35:13 beforehand. The Gemara says that you wait a certain amount of time,35:18 but there's a contradiction in the Gemara.35:20 In one Gemara it says from sunset until nighttime,35:25 which we defined already, nighttime means three stars,35:27 it takes an average person to walk three quarters of a35:32 mil. Another Gemara says from sunset until nighttime,35:37 it takes an average person to walk four35:40 mil. Before we get to the question a little bit more,35:44 let's give you a little bit of a background.35:46 What is a35:47 mil? A mil is a certain amount of length of time.35:49 There is two ways of calculating when the mil is.35:52 In any case, there's either some hold that each35:57 mil, an average person walks in a mil 18 minutes,36:00 and some say he walks 24 minutes.36:02 For us, we're going to go with the opinion that says36:05 each mil is 18 minutes.36:07 That's the opinion of Shulchan Aruch in36:12 Siman Taf Nun Tet, Halacha Bet. Therefore, when we say a mil, we mean 18 minutes.36:15 So let's get back now to the Gemara.36:17 The Gemara says, from sunset, which is for sure day, right?36:21 Right before the sunset, that's for sure day,36:23 until the night, it takes three quarters of a36:27 mil. Three quarters of 18 minutes.36:28 How much is that?36:29 That's 13 and a half minutes.36:32 Another Gemara says, from sunset until nighttime,36:37 it takes an average person to walk four36:41 mil. How much is four36:42 mil? Well, four times 18 is 72 minutes.36:44 So I don't understand what's going on.36:46 Is it 13 and a half minutes after sunset is nighttime,36:50 or is it 72 minutes?36:53 There's a huge difference here.36:54 We're not talking about a few seconds.36:56 There's a difference of 58 and a half minutes.36:59 So what's going on?37:00 Which one does the Gemara mean?37:03 And here we have a machloket, believe it or not,37:07 in how to understand the Gemara.37:09 Let's begin with the way the Rabbeinu Tam explains,37:11 and this is the famous opinion of Rabbeinu Tam.37:13 When people say Rabbeinu Tam, Rabbeinu Tam,37:15 I hope they know what they're talking about.37:17 Most Bnei Torah, of course, know what they're talking about.37:19 But sometimes people say Rabbeinu Tam37:21 and they're not sure what it really means.37:23 Here now you'll see what it means,37:24 and you'll feel good about yourself.37:26 You'll know that, okay, now you know when somebody tells you Rabbeinu37:29 Tam, you know what you're saying.37:31 Rabbeinu Tam says, one Gemara says that37:34 it takes from sheki'ah, sunset,37:38 until motzaei Shabbat—until, excuse me, until37:40 nighttime—it takes three quarters of a37:41 mil. Another Gemara says it takes four37:44 milin. How can it be? He says, you know why?37:46 There are two different types of sheki'ah the Gemara is talking about.37:50 We are familiar with the famous sheki'ah, sunset,37:52 what we know is when the ball of the sun goes below the37:57 horizon. You're looking at the horizon and you see the ball of the sun.38:00 Once it goes below the horizon,38:02 then you know, okay, right now it is sunset.38:06 Rabbeinu Tam says, yes, that is true,38:08 but that's called the first38:11 sheki'ah. Gemara is telling us there's another38:13 sheki'ah. There's another sunset. What is that?38:15 That's when the rays of the38:18 sun—you know, the best way to see it,38:19 if you take a flashlight38:21 and you put it on top of a table,38:24 and you slowly take the bulb of the flashlight,38:26 where the light is coming from,38:27 you slowly take it under, under, under.38:29 You see, although the light is under,38:30 you don't see the flashlight;38:32 you see the rays of light still coming out.38:34 So although the sun is sinking38:36 and it's going below the horizon,38:37 you can't see the ball of the sun,38:39 but you still see the rays of the sun.38:41 The rays of the sun still shine in the day.38:43 It's not going to be pitch dark.38:45 So that's not called sheki'ah 100%, according to Rabbeinu Tam.38:48 That's called the first sheki'ah, and that's still daytime.38:51 The Gemara just means to tell you38:53 that when the ball sets from your eyes, it's nothing.38:56 Real sheki'ah, what the Gemara is telling us,38:58 that you have to wait three-quarters of a39:00 mil. That happens 58 and a half minutes later.39:02 That's called the second39:04 sheki'ah. So it comes out, according to Rabbeinu Tam,39:07 when we see the ball drop,39:09 when we see the sun is below the horizon,39:12 it's still daytime.39:13 It's not nighttime yet.39:14 You know when night begins?39:17 58 and a half minutes.39:18 It's not even nighttime then.39:20 58 and a half minutes,39:21 that's when the rays of the sun already also start to go below the horizon,39:27 and 13 and a half minutes after that is fully night.39:29 Combined, that's 72 minutes.39:31 That's why, according to Rabbeinu Tam,39:34 72 minutes after what we call sunset,39:38 which means after the ball of the sun sinks below the horizon,39:41 that's when already is considered fully night.39:44 That's where Rabbeinu Tam resolves the two39:47 Gemarot. Why does one Gemara say three-quarters of a39:49 mil, another Gemara says four39:51 milin? One Gemara talks about when the sun is sinks below39:54 that what we don't see.39:56 58 and a half minutes later on.39:58 The rays of the sun already begin.40:00 Begin to sink under, and that's when we begin bein hashmashot, 13 and a half minutes40:05 until finally 13 and a half minutes later, which is a total of 72 minutes when it's fully40:10 nighttime. However, the Geonim, Rav Sherira Gaon, Rav Hai Gaon, Rav Nissim Gaon,40:14 as well as one of the biggest Acharonim, the Gra himself, they explained,40:20 no, that's not the halacha. They say the halacha is simple, like the Gemara says.40:26 The Gemara says once we see the ball of the sky—excuse me—once we see the ball of the sun sink below the horizon,40:33 what we call sunset, you start counting. That's bein hashmashot already.40:36 Bein hashmashot begins right then, which is40:40 safek yom, safek laila. 13 and a half minutes already afterwards, it's fully night.40:42 So it comes out that according to Rabbeinu Tam, let's say motzaei Shabbat,40:47 motzaei Shabbat will not begin according to Rabbeinu Tam until 72 minutes later.40:51 According to the Geonim, no, after sunset, 13 and a half minutes after sunset, you can already begin motzaei Shabbat.40:58 Ah, you're going to ask me, what happened? How in the world are the Geonim going to explain the contradiction in the Gemara?41:05 To that, the Gemara says the reason why the Gemara tells us of two different times,41:11 one place it says 13 and a half minutes after sheki'ah there is already41:18 nighttime, it says already tzeit hakochavim, and another Gemara says that four mil, which is 72 minutes after sunset,41:25 it's tzeit hakochavim. The Gemara is talking about over there,41:28 if you look at the Gemara over there, that's in41:30 Masechet Pesachim, it's talking about a debate between the rabbis and the non-Jewish scientists,41:35 and they're discussing the universe and different parts of the universe,41:39 and therefore they were talking about when the sky gets full of stars.41:44 We know that the sky gets full of stars at a certain point in the night,41:49 and that's it. That's how it's going to be for the rest of the night.41:51 But it doesn't happen in one second. It's gradual.41:55 It begins with a few stars, one star, two stars, three stars, and more and more and more stars.41:59 Then it gets to a point when it's completely full of stars,42:01 and you're not going to see any difference afterwards in darkness.42:04 It's complete darkness. Whatever stars you see now, that's what you're going to see an hour later until the morning.42:09 So when the Gemara says that 13 and a half minutes after our sunset...42:15 It's seta kochavim. It's talking about three stars.42:18 What the Gemara says, that four mil, 72 minutes after sunset,42:22 is seta kochavim in a different Gemara, that's referring to when the sky is full of stars.42:29 When the sky is full of stars, that only happens after 72 minutes.42:33 But lehalacha, the Gra goes with the Geonim,42:35 that 13 and a half minutes after sunset is already considered nighttime.42:41 And this, by the way, would be applicable in both,42:45 in Shabbat coming in and motzaei Shabbat.42:46 But we're going to focus right now mainly on the motzaei Shabbat.42:52 Now, even though we said this is the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam,42:54 sounds like he's the only one,42:56 I want to give you a list,42:58 hacham Ovadia Yosef zatzal in Yabia Omer brings down,43:00 of all the Rishonim that follow the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam.43:08 He says they are the following. Ready?43:10 Just pay attention to the name,43:11 just to show you how many people are with the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam.43:13 Don't think Rabbeinu Tam is the only opinion over here.43:15 Here we go:43:27 Rav D'raabad, the Raza, Ramban, Rashba, Ra'ah, Ritva, Ran, Rab Magid, Ohel Moed, Samag, Rokeach, Mordechi, Rabbeinu Peretz, the Rosh, and Rabbeinu Yocham. All of these opinions,43:29 according to hacham Ovadia, he proves it, of course,43:31 all of them go with Rabbeinu Tam.43:33 We're not talking about only one opinion.43:35 Okay, that's great.43:36 That we explained the Gemara.43:37 But we want to know now,43:39 halacha lemaaseh. You said this is a practical halacha class,43:41 halacha hours when we discuss practical43:43 halacha, so what in the world,43:44 what do we do,43:46 halacha lemaaseh? Well, Maran writes in Shulchan Aruch,43:50 he says that he goes with Rabbeinu Tam.43:53 He says that from the time the sun sets,43:57 when we don't see it anymore,43:59 until another 15 and a half minutes44:01 is considered completely day,44:03 and it's only afterwards,44:05 after 15 and a half minutes,44:06 we can begin to count this amount of bein hashmashot,44:08 which is 13 and a half minutes.44:10 So it comes out, according to Maran Shulchan Aruch,44:13 that when it comes to motzaei Shabbat,44:15 a person should wait 72 minutes until Shabbat finishes.44:19 Now really, technically,44:21 it also applies to— Entering Shabbat,44:23 but what we discussed already,44:25 that the minhag is that everybody accepts Shabbat44:28 when the sun sets by44:30 shekiah. Nobody today,44:32 chas v'shalom, will accept Shabbat after44:33 shekiah. Once upon a time, maybe,44:35 and there was—not maybe, there44:37 was—but in our days,44:38 everybody accepts Shabbat by44:41 shekiah. Even though Maran writes44:42 that really shekiah is like Rabbeinu Tam,44:44 which means it only begins44:45 fifty-eight and a half minutes later44:46 after what we know as44:48 shekiah. That's not the minhag of all44:51 Klal Yisrael, all of the Jewish people,44:52 no exceptions.44:53 Everybody accepts Shabbat by the sun setting.44:56 What about Motzaei Shabbat?44:58 So you might say,44:58 listen, Shulchan Aruch, Maran,45:00 and even the Rama agrees with this.45:01 The Rama doesn't disagree with this.45:02 So Maran, everybody,45:03 everybody should wait, Rabbeinu Tam.45:05 However, the minhag is not really that way.45:07 The minhag is that most people45:09 do not follow Rabbeinu Tam.45:10 I want to read you45:11 the45:12 Chida. The Chida lived about 200 years ago.45:15 Listen to what he writes,45:17 200 years ago.45:18 Minhag45:19 ha'olam, says the45:20 Chida, machazik b'yadcha the following words:45:21 Minhag45:29 ha'olam al פי ברכת גאונים, שתכף אחר שקיעה מתחיל זמן בין השמשות שהוא ג' רבעי מיל. The minhag of everybody45:30 is based on the45:32 Geonim, which means that right after the sun sets,45:35 we begin this man of bein hashmashot,45:37 which is three quarters of a mil.45:41 U'minhagan של ישראל תורה היא, and this is the minhag.45:42 Even though Maran writes opposite,45:44 and we always say,45:45 Kibalnu horaot Maran, we go with the Shulchan Aruch45:48 over here. It's a minhag,45:49 and therefore this becomes the Torah,45:53 vyesh lahem al ma sheyismochu, and they have what to rely on.45:54 You have the45:57 Geonim. U'mi sheyirtze l'hachmir k'Rabbeinu Tam, but if a person wants to be stringent like Rabbeinu Tam,46:02 tabo alav berachah. You get a special blessing from the46:04 Chida if you hold like Rabbeinu Tam.46:07 Ach, ein limchot b'yad hamekilim, but one cannot. Stop the people who are lenient,46:11 and therefore46:12 the minhag of the majority of the world,46:14 like we said,46:15 is not to wait Rabbeinu Tam,46:17 but they wait beforehand.46:18 How much beforehand?46:20 So you might say,46:20 okay, there's only two opinions:46:21 either Shabbat finishes at 13 and a half minutes,46:24 or Shabbat finishes at 72 minutes.46:26 But if you look,46:27 I have a list over here of poskim.46:29 I want to just go through the list.46:30 The poskim,46:32 the46:33 Acharonim, when they wrote46:34 when Shabbat is over,46:35 everybody says46:36 by46:36 there, all the46:37 Acharonim, almost almost everybody,46:38 that Shabbat comes in by sunset,46:40 like we said.46:40 That's not debatable.46:42 We're not even discussing that.46:43 We're talking about46:44 when does Shabbat46:46 finish. You'll find that46:47 most opinions do not go46:48 with either Geonim,46:49 which is 13 and a half,46:50 or Rabbeinu Tam.46:51 Let's begin with the following.46:52 Ready?46:53 Ben46:53 Ish Chai, we already mentioned,46:54 he says,46:54 you know,46:55 27 to about 37 minutes after sunset.46:58 The Kaf HaChaim brings down46:59 that the minhag in Eretz Yisrael,47:01 in Syria and Iraq,47:03 was to wait 40 minutes.47:05 Even all the whole Middle East,47:06 they would wait 40 minutes after sunset47:08 for Shabbat to be over.47:10 The47:11 Ginat Veradim, who was the Ab Beit Din in Mitzrayim, in Egypt,47:14 the Kaf HaChaim brings it down.47:15 He says that47:16 they waited about 36 to 44 minutes47:20 for Shabbat to be over.47:21 The Chazon Ish himself,47:22 the47:23 Chazon Ish, Ashkenazim even47:24 don't think it's only47:26 Sefardim. Chazon Ish was known to wait47:27 40 to 50 minutes in Eretz Yisrael.47:30 The47:31 Belzer Rebbe, the Maharam47:32 Belz, he used to say47:33 50 minutes in47:34 Eretz Yisrael to wait after sunset.47:37 Rav Chaim Naeh in Ketzot HaShulchan,47:38 he brings down47:40 that in the winter,47:42 motzaei Shabbat is 24 minutes,47:44 and in the summer47:44 it's a little bit longer,47:45 30 minutes.47:46 And there's a book called47:47 Dvar Yom,47:48 written by47:50 Rabbi Braunfeld. Somebody showed it to me.47:51 He brings a list of poskim,47:53 over 80 different poskim,47:56 over 80 opinions47:58 that don't go like Rabbeinu Tam.48:00 They don't go like digeoni, which means they choose a time in between 13 and a half minutes to the time to 72 minutes.48:08 So what's going on? The real question is, what's going on? We just learned the Gemara, we reviewed it,48:12 we know the two opinions. Either you hold 13 and a half minutes or 72 minutes. Where do all these times come from?48:16 And the answer is what the Gra said. When we gave those times, the Chazal told us,48:20 you wait four mil from sunset until motzaei Shabbat. This is talking about in each place according to the horizon, the place that you're living in.48:32 That means it could be that the times will change based on where you live, 100%.48:36 When the Gemara was talking, it was talking their place and their times.48:40 But where you live, then you have to follow. You look up at the sky and you see that's your siman.48:45 Once upon a time, people didn't have watches, and how would they know when Shabbat is over?48:48 You look up. When you see the siman, three stars, or when it gets dark, that's already when you know it's motzaei Shabbat.48:54 And that's how everybody did it, and all the poskim who brought all these different times,49:00 they were going based on the places that they lived in, and that's why we find so many different opinions.49:05 It all depends where you live. So now, okay, let's get to halacha lemaaseh. What do we do?49:11 Clearly, the minhag is not like to wait like Rabbeinu Tam, the minhag, I'm saying, according to the majority of people, right?49:17 And not to go with the geonim. So therefore, what should you do?49:21 Well, number one is if you have a rav, go ask your rabbi. If you don't have a rav, get a rav.49:28 If you have a rav and you don't trust your rabbi and you're not so close, you want to know, okay?49:32 So this is what I personally tell. The regular people in the shul by Sefardim, by us, what I tell them49:38 is to wait 40 to 50 minutes in America. Over here, you wait between 40 to 50 minutes at least.49:44 This is what I recommend to the guys in the shul. At least wait 40 to 50 minutes.49:48 If you could do more, 100% do more. If you could do Rabbeinu Tam, even the best.49:53 But if you could, again, I want to stress, 40, 50 minutes at least.49:57 If a person could do more, should definitely do more.49:59 Hacham Ovadia has a teshuva in Chelek Bet, and he speaks very, very strongly to wait 72 minutes even in50:08 Eretz Yisrael. And he says, even if a person says, Okay, minhag, we understand the minhag,50:12 but because shulchan aruch, and because you have all these rishonim that we listed hold, you have to wait 72 minutes.50:18 So therefore, a person is very strongly urged that he should wait 72 minutes,50:25 at least bnei Torah, yirei shamayim. People, yirei shamayim, yirei Hashem, and bnei Torah, they should wait 72 minutes.50:33 Now, somebody is asking over here in the text line, and he wants to know, what about Chacham Baruch Zatzal?50:38 So you have to know, Chacham Baruch Zatzal used to be the chief rabbi of Brooklyn over here,50:45 and he gave a certain time for the kahal, what he felt the kahal.50:49 I don't believe that he himself waited that long. I don't know. I'll have to ask his son.50:53 So I never spoke to him personally about when the time was over.50:56 So also this is important to keep in mind.50:59 Although the halacha tells, there's many rabbis, like we said, there's so many different opinions,51:03 we have to know what is din and what a person, and depending on the person, people,51:07 the gedolim will always posek also how much people were able to handle in a certain time.51:14 Like we saw, Chacham Ovadia is very machmir. He says 72 minutes a person,51:17 and he says although the minhag is not that way, but at least a person who should try to do it,51:21 a person should strive to do it, bnei Torah should strive to do it.51:24 And then we come to the opinion of the gadol hador in America in the last generation, Rav Moshe Feinstein.51:31 The Igrot Moshe has a very interesting way of calculating the time.51:36 First of all, before we begin to say the opinion of Rav Moshe Feinstein,51:40 I want to tell you what he writes over here in his introduction to the51:44 teshuva. He says,51:50 Even though we cannot come along and start saying which opinion is correct and which opinion is correct.51:57 Why?52:00 Because there's questions on52:03 each opinion has its own questions.52:05 Still, he says,52:12 We have to be stringent. In the opinions of one motzaei Shabbat is like the two opinions.52:23 וכן היינו נוהגים במקומותינו, and he says that's the way it used to be in52:24 Europe.52:36 וכן יש לנהוג כאן באמריקה, שנתכבסו כאן מכל המדינות, ויש בכל עיר ועיר מערים הגדולות, וכל שכן בניו יורק וברוקלין, שיכא הרבה מקום מקום מקום שמראוי להחמיר. He says we can't decide who's correct,52:39 the Geonim, Rabbeinu52:40 Tam, who are we to decide?52:41 And therefore, he says, we have to try to be as stringent as we can.52:45 So based on the Gra that we said beforehand,52:47 the Gra says that when the Gemara says the sky is full of52:53 stars, when it says arbaa milin, right?52:56 It says in the Gemara, arbaa milin means,52:58 according to the Gra, it's full of stars,53:00 and each place depending on its time and horizon,53:02 its place on horizon.53:04 So Moshe says, so really it comes out53:07 that Rabbeinu Tam, who says the arbaa milin,53:09 four milin after53:13 sheki'ah is really motzaei Shabbat,53:14 it means four milin is when the sky gets full of stars, right?53:17 She says for New York and New Jersey,53:19 and he believes the same way for the rest of America as they told him,53:22 when he was in the summer camps, he said he tested it himself,53:26 and he saw that when it comes to 15 minutes after sunset,53:30 the sky is full of stars,53:33 and there's no difference 15 minutes after sunset53:36 to an hour or two or to midnight.53:39 The same stars will be around,53:40 which means that's called arbaa milin.53:43 And therefore, arbaa milin,53:47 according to Rav Moshe Feinstein in America,53:48 in New York particularly,53:50 equals 15 minutes.53:52 So technically, Rabbeinu53:54 Tam, if a person wants to keep Rabbeinu Tam in America,53:57 if he waits 15 minutes,53:59 he technically keeps it.53:59 But he says at the end,54:05 יש להטיל לאלו במוצאי שבת לאחר חמישים דקות, לאלו שממהרים לאיזה צורך. Only people who are in a rush54:07 and they have to go, according to Rav Moshe54:09 Feinstein, then you wait 15 minutes.54:11 But for others, he says,54:13 especially54:14 בני תורה, יראי שמים, he said they should wait 72 minutes,54:16 even up to 96 minutes after54:20 sheki'ah. That's the opinion of Rav Moshe Feinstein. So54:21 let's summarize, pretty much done.54:25 According to... The poskim,54:27 there's a big discussion54:28 what motzaei Shabbat is.54:30 We find so many different opinions54:31 throughout all the poskim,54:33 and therefore what should a person do?54:34 If you have a minhag,54:35 if you have a rav, so you ask him.54:37 If you don't,54:38 it's strongly—we're going to give you the grade54:40 A—it's strongly encouraged that a person54:41 should wait at least 72 minutes after sunset.54:45 If a person cannot do so,54:47 then at least 50 minutes.54:48 If not, at least, at least 40 minutes.54:51 Less than that, I cannot say.54:52 You have to ask your own rabbi,54:53 and you have to get a54:54 heter. Me personally, I cannot go lower than 40 minutes.54:57 In America over here,54:58 a person must find54:59 and go with his rabbi and see what he tells him.55:02 Just to point out, though,55:04 that when we said to try to keep Rabbeinu Tam,55:07 this doesn't mean you55:08 necessarily have to keep Rabbeinu Tam like this55:10 for all of the—what's it55:13 called—you have to keep it for every single law55:15 that has to do with55:18 nighttime. At least for things that are55:20 de'oraita, like, for example, motzaei Shabbat55:22 or motzaei Yom Kippur,55:24 there you keep Rabbeinu Tam.55:25 Other things which are55:26 derabanan, for example, like let's say55:29 motzaei ta'anit, when the fast, let's say55:31 Shiva Asar b'Tammuz finishes55:32 or Tisha55:32 B'Av, that's all55:33 derabanan. You don't have to wait Rabbeinu Tam.55:35 40 minutes, even 50 minutes,55:36 is already very, very good55:38 if a person wants to wait55:39 for things that are55:41 derabanan. Some say even 35 minutes.55:42 So therefore, a person55:43 who wants to be machmir Rabbeinu Tam,55:44 try to do it with de'oraita at least.55:47 Some are machmir de'oraita and derabanan, true.55:49 There's some communities and people55:52 machmir de'oraita, even de'oraita and55:53 derabanan, to hold like Rabbeinu Tam.55:54 One last question,55:55 and we'll leave it with this,55:56 and just before we finish off,55:59 we want to say that anybody—56:00 Who wants to call into this radio station to ask any questions, I'll be here after the class to answer any questions,56:08 718-683-5858, or you could text in at 347-927-8398. And this, bezrat Hashem, will be aired on again tonight for anybody who wants to hear it.56:16 Question is as follows: How can you tell me to wait 72 minutes and then it's going to become56:21 nighttime when I look at the sky and I see that it gets dark way before 72 minutes?56:26 So what are you telling me, wait, Rabbeinu Tam, wait 72 minutes? It gets dark way before that.56:30 I see three stars before. Doesn't the Gemara say three stars? Well, I see three stars before that.56:35 And the answer to that is that Rabbeinu Tam also had the sky,56:39 and not only Rabbeinu Tam lived in Europe. Rabbeinu Tam was going, explaining the Gemara in56:43 that lived where the rabbis in the Gemara lived, in Iraq and Israel.56:48 And Maran Shulchan Aruch lived in Sfat, in Israel.56:51 He also had a sky, and he also looked up, and he still ruled like Rabbeinu Tam.56:55 Obviously, what we call three stars and what the Rishonim and Maran are calling three stars is not exactly what we know.57:02 So therefore, when we say to go with the Rabbeinu Tam and to wait Rabbeinu Tam,57:09 yes, even though to our eyes we don't see it that way,57:12 must be they're talking about something that we don't understand.57:15 We'll finish with this. If anybody has any questions, we'll answer them,57:19 bezrat Hashem. Next week we'll continue with the laws of Motzaei Shabbat.57:23 We want to give thanks to Iran and J Radio, and everybody for listening.57:28 Until then, have a wonderful week, bezrat Hashem. Shabbat shalom.