Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio.0:04 We are on JRoot Radio live0:06 on Wednesday at 20:09 o'clock. This is the Halacha Hour on Halachot.0:11 We use the book the Ben0:13 Ish Chai, and be'ezrat Hashem we are back to normal schedule now.0:17 We are into Rosh Chodesh; we are already in the month of0:20 Cheshvan, and be'ezrat Hashem we'll begin the halachot.0:22 Just a quick introduction.0:24 We usually start with the class.0:26 The Halacha Hour is where we discuss halachot,0:29 explaining, clarifying the halachot,0:31 and also speaking about the practical,0:35 or the application of the halachot0:38 in our daily lives.0:39 Over here we're discussing halachot Shabbat,0:41 so obviously we're going to be talking about the halachot0:43 that are relevant to Shabbat.0:45 And we start, and we usually use0:47 the book the Ben0:49 Ish Chai. However, it's not limited to the opinion of the Ben0:52 Ish Chai. We try to clarify everything:0:53 the source of the0:55 din, the opinion of...0:56 and if there's different opinions0:58 and the1:00 halacha. Whenever we can also, we try to accommodate1:03 for also the Ashkenazi audience as well.1:07 Mainly, obviously, it's a Sephardi class,1:09 but at the same time we do bring in the opinions1:10 also of the Ashkenazi1:13 Acharonim. If there is a machloket, we'll point it out.1:15 If there is no1:17 machloket, then it's assumed that this is something1:19 almost universal.1:21 Anyone who knows halacha knows that1:23 nothing is universal.1:24 There's many different opinions,1:24 but as far as1:28 psak halacha, you know, we do have a lot of opinions that1:30 are, or a lot of halachot that are universal,1:32 and therefore those will be mentioned,1:36 be'ezrat Hashem. Before we come to the class,1:38 let's talk. Let's give you the numbers to the station.1:40 We're here on JRoot Radio.1:41 If you want to listen to us,1:43 you can listen to us on1:46 JRootRadio.com. You can listen on the JRoot Radio Pro app,1:48 or you can call in the following phone number:1:55 718-506-9099. That's the number to call to listen in.1:58 When you call that number,1:59 you press 1 and 1 again,2:01 and you'll be hearing this live.2:02 If you'd like to watch this class live...2:06 It's nothing too exciting.2:07 It's pretty much just sitting here2:08 and talking, basically.2:10 But if you'd like to watch this class live,2:12 you go on JRoot Radio,2:14 and you can see live streaming2:16 right now as we speak.2:18 If you want to be involved in the class,2:21 if you would like to call in,2:22 you have a question on the halachot2:23 that we're learning,2:24 then you could call in.2:25 If it's on the halachot that we're not learning,2:28 or you have a safek2:29 if it's on the halachot that we're not learning,2:31 then please.2:32 The class will be in the station over here2:34 to answer any question that we can2:37 right at2:39 three o'clock. So any questions regarding the halachot2:41 that we're teaching2:42 and that we're talking about,2:43 you could call in the following number:2:48 718-683-5858. If it's halachot not relevant2:50 or directly as we're speaking about,2:52 then you could call the same number,2:56 718-683-5858. At the end of the class at2:58 three o'clock, Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll be around for a few more minutes.3:00 If you'd like to text in your question,3:01 regardless if it's on the subject3:07 or not, 8398.3:10 Again, 347-927-8398. With that,3:11 we'll come to our class,3:12 Be'ezrat Hashem. We are starting a new3:16 parashah and a new subject.3:17 This class is sponsored3:20 for refuah shelemah of Shafika Sofia3:25 Bat Rosa. If anybody would like also3:26 to sponsor this class3:27 or any other class,3:29 our class,3:31 halachah, or any other program3:32 on JRoot Radio,3:35 what we have over here,3:36 you could text in to the3:37 number we gave before,3:38 and you could just say,3:39 I'm interested in3:40 sponsoring, and we'll be in touch with you.3:43 Now, the halachot3:44 that we're going to talk about3:45 are the halachot of speech on Shabbat.3:49 That's a very, very important...3:52 What we could talk about on Shabbat3:54 and what we cannot talk about on Shabbat.3:56 We usually understand speech3:58 as communication3:59 between one person and another,4:00 but really we're going to see4:02 that speech is inclusive4:03 of many, many different areas as well,4:07 and we'll talk about it4:09 be'ezrat Hashem. But as a general introduction4:10 to the halachot of Shabbat,4:11 because we're starting it,4:12 let's begin with the following.4:14 We find in the Torah,4:15 in two different4:16 parashiyot, that the Torah commands us4:19 on the mitzvah of Shabbat.4:21 In Parashat Yitro,4:23 the Torah tells us,4:24 Yom HaShabbat4:26 lekadsho. Remember to make it4:28 kadosh, to sanctify it.4:29 We find in Parashat4:31 V'etchanan, in4:32 Sefer Devarim, again by4:33 Aseret HaDibrot, when Moshe repeats the Torah,4:35 and again over there4:36 we have a commandment4:37 regarding Shabbat.4:37 However,4:38 it's a little bit different.4:40 It doesn't say4:41 zachor et Yom HaShabbat,4:42 but it says4:43 shamor et Yom HaShabbat4:45 lekadsho, guard the day of Shabbat.4:47 So we have zachor in Parashat Yitro4:49 and shamor in Parashat4:51 V'etchanan. What is the4:52 difference between remembering Shabbat4:53 and guarding Shabbat?4:55 We all know we keep Shabbat.4:57 An answer4:58 is that it's a huge difference4:59 as far as the application,5:01 the halachot of these two mitzvot.5:04 Zachor are the mitzvot,5:06 basically, that have to do with the positive,5:09 what we have to go on and do5:10 in order to keep Shabbat.5:12 Most of these halachot,5:13 if not all,5:14 were discussed5:15 last year and a half5:17 that we've been on the radio,5:18 and those5:19 you can find them all in the archives.5:21 Those include the halachot of Kiddush.5:24 Those include the halachot of Havdalah.5:26 Also, part of that as5:28 well is the preparation for Shabbat,5:29 as well as5:31 kindling, all the halachot of bein hashmashot5:33 in that area,5:34 which is maybe night,5:36 maybe day,5:37 maybe both.5:38 All of these halachot5:39 are last year,5:41 basically5:41 under the category of zachor5:42 et Yom HaShabbat.5:43 The other category of halachot5:45 in Shabbat are—5:48 Shamor et Yom HaShabbat.5:49 Shamor means to guard,5:50 like a shomer.5:51 What does a shomer do?5:53 A real guard5:55 stands where he's supposed to be5:57 standing, and he's on the lookout.5:58 He has to be on the lookout5:59 for whatever he has to be on the lookout6:01 for.6:01 L'mashal, you have a department store.6:02 You put a guard in the front door,6:05 by the front door of the department store.6:07 Why? You're looking out6:08 if there's anybody stealing,6:09 if there's anybody running out6:10 with any merchandise.6:12 You're there on the lookout to stop him.6:13 You put a guard by a house.6:16 He's looking out for any intruders,6:18 any thieves that are trying6:19 to break into the house.6:20 He's on the lookout for them.6:22 Shamor, the Torah tells us,6:23 be on the lookout for any6:25 of the things that I forbid to do on Shabbat,6:27 and those are known as the 396:29 melachot. This is6:30 mid'Oraita. This means,6:32 biblically, this is what Hashem commanded.6:33 He expects us,6:34 and He commanded us,6:36 that we should be on the lookout6:37 for the 396:38 melachot, the famous 396:40 melachot, of what is forbidden on Shabbat.6:42 Now, those 396:45 melachot are a whole class6:46 and really a whole subject by itself,6:48 and we're not up to those halachot yet,6:49 believe it or not.6:50 There's actually two more categories of Shabbat,6:53 of the mitzvot of Shabbat,6:54 but they're not biblical.6:58 One category is7:00 midivrei Kabbalah. Kabbalah here doesn't mean7:02 the classic Kabbalah as we know,7:04 which is mysticism. Rather,7:06 the Kabbalah here that we mean is7:08 from the prophets,7:10 Yeshayahu Hanavi, which we'll talk about in a second,7:13 or mitzvot or7:17 gezeirot derabbanan, which chachamim instilled,7:19 whether it's the chachamim or rabbis7:21 or, excuse me,7:22 or people before what we know7:24 as the period of7:26 Chazal instituted, to keep the sanctity of Shabbat.7:29 The mitzvot midivrei Kabbalah,7:31 the mitzvot from the7:32 Nevi'im, is— The pesukim,7:35 it comes from the pesukim that we say7:36 every single Shabbat when we say Kiddush.7:39 We all say,7:50 Im tashiv miShabbat raglecha, asot chafatzecha b'yom kodshi, v'karata laShabbat oneg, likdosh Hashem mechubad, v'chibadto me'asot derachecha, mimtzo cheftzecha v'daber davar. We'll translate.7:52 Pasuk says,7:53 if you pull back,7:54 if you restrain yourself,7:55 if you restrain your walk on Shabbat7:58 from doing your...8:00 On this holy day, you shall call Shabbat oneg, a pleasure, honor of God who is honored,8:08 and you shall honor the Shabbat. How do you honor the Shabbat? From asot8:14 derachecha, from doing your ways, which is mitzo cheftzecha, trying to find your needs, and speaking.8:23 Very vague, if you... but basically the idea of the pasuk is telling you8:28 there's two concepts over here. Karata laShabbat oneg. You have to declare that the Shabbat has to be8:34 a mitzvah midivrei kabbalah called oneg Shabbat. We discussed that last year as well in the halachot of seudah of8:42 Shabbat, having delicious food, preparing the delicious food for Shabbat. The other mitzvah is kevod Shabbat,8:48 the honor of Shabbat. Also part of it was discussed, which is preparation for Shabbat.8:53 When you have somebody honorable coming to you, part of the honor, part of the kavod that you show a person8:58 who's coming to your house is that you prepare for them. If your in-laws are coming to visit you,9:04 and you know that they're coming, they don't prepare anything for them. They come and you're just respectful.9:09 When you know, you have to go out and prepare something. I don't care what you prepare,9:13 you prepare something that shows at least you put some effort to show some appreciation or some basically respect.9:19 This is the same idea. You know Shabbat is coming every Shabbat, every seventh day of the week there's a Shabbat.9:25 That's one way. Another way to honor Shabbat, says in the pasuk,9:32 me'asot derachecha... And this is really the new category of halachot that we'll be discussing for now,9:36 and that is a subject in Parashat Vayishlach, and that is what is9:40 mitzo cheftzecha, trying to do your own ways. That is something we'll discuss later on.9:44 We are focused... The last two words of the parashah, of the pasuk, and that is9:55 the birdavar. Shabbat from the way you speak, which, in the words of the Gemara, that your words on Shabbat should not be like the words on the weekday.10:03 What does that mean? Your words on Shabbat should not be like the words on the weekday.10:07 There is a halachic definition of words, that your words on Shabbat should not be like the words on the weekday.10:14 The halachic definition basically fits into four categories.10:18 Number one is what can one speak about with other people.10:23 Number two, what could one say on Shabbat even when there's no other people around?10:27 If you're sitting by yourself, you're one of those people that likes to talk to themselves, that's fine.10:31 You look in the mirror and you like to talk to yourself.10:33 This, you don't feel abnormal. In any case, even—yes, you're talking to the mirror—but even if you're not talking to the mirror10:39 and you're talking to yourself, there are words you're restricted.10:43 The Torah is telling you, or the pasuk, excuse me, the prophet Yeshayahu is telling you10:47 there are words that you're allowed to speak about and there are things to speak about.10:51 Again, these are just categories. We're not giving examples yet,10:55 bezrat Hashem. That's what the class is all about. We'll discuss the halachot in detail.10:58 The third category of the mitzvah of vedaber davar is what could one read on Shabbat.11:04 Here, reading means reading with your mouth, like the way we pray or like the way we say Tehillim,11:10 where we're actually reading, not the way we read a science book or the way we read magazines,11:15 which is just reading with our eyes.11:17 What you could read and what you cannot is also included in vedaber davar, if you're reading it out loud.11:23 And finally, and this is the big, big subject, and bezrat Hashem we hope to cover it11:30 with siyata dishmaya, hopefully also clearly and without any mistakes,11:34 the fourth category of vedaber davar is the category of the laws of amira11:40 lakum, laws of what could one tell a goy on Shabbat to do. Do it on Shabbat,11:47 what are you telling him to do it after Shabbat? What are you telling him to do it from before11:51 Shabbat? All of these halachot are included in the mitzvah of11:57 vedaber davar. Like we said, daber davar means what you could speak about on Shabbat, and includes all these four things.12:03 Now that's a halachic definition of12:06 daber davar. There's a Shulchan Aruch on it, there's poskim on it, and the Gemara tells us clearly what it should be.12:11 However, you look in some of the poskim, when they speak about, when they discuss12:18 vedaber davar, see that a lot of tzaddikim took the words of the Gemara beyond the definition of halacha,12:24 and they kept to the words of the Gemara because they understood that there's more depth to the words of the Gemara.12:31 There's more depth to what the Navi has told us beyond the halachic aspect of it. Meaning,12:37 it says, Shelo yehei diburcha b'Chol k'diburcha b'Shabbat.12:43 Halacha means you cannot speak about, for example, you cannot talk about work,12:48 l'mashal, that's one of the examples, we'll talk about that in12:50 detail. But literally, if you just translate the Gemara, it says that what you speak, the way you speak on Shabbat12:59 should not be the way you speak during the week. There has to be13:01 a difference. So therefore, there were many tzaddikim that said that on Shabbat you should speak13:06 b'lashon hakodesh, speak Hebrew on Shabbat. Usually speak English, Chinese, Arabic, French.13:12 On Shabbat, speak13:14 lashon hakodesh. It shouldn't be the same as a weekday. It should be distinguished.13:17 Shabbat should be different than the weekday through the way you speak, a different language.13:25 They didn't even speak any mundane things.13:27 They only spoke about words of Torah.13:30 That's it. If it's not Torah or mussar, they wouldn't speak about it.13:33 And we find this concept also by the Beit HaKnesset.13:39 We know the Arizal says in the shul, the Arizal was so careful that in the shul he wouldn't speak about anything else,13:44 not talking about miltei d'fila. Miltei d'fila, that's13:46 asur. There's no question about that.13:48 You have to be the Arizal not to speak in the middle of13:50 tefila. That's an issur, outright13:52 issur. We're talking about in the shul when they're not praying, it's over,13:55 and it's, you know, basically just standing around.13:58 The Arizal was very careful not to talk any—even words of mussar he wouldn't speak. Why?14:02 It might lead him to words that are not words of Torah,14:07 and therefore he wouldn't even speak words of14:08 mussar, only divrei Torah, and that's it, or if he had to pray.14:10 Same idea on Shabbat, because Shabbat, we explained in the past, is of the kedusha of the makom.14:21 Meaning, in everything in the world, every concept in the world, every theme in the world that we have14:29 is expressed in our physical world in three different ways.14:32 One is through time,14:34 the second is through place, makom,14:36 and the third is through people.14:41 There's a concept called kedusha, holiness.14:45 Holiness is expressed in our world in three different parts, in three different areas.14:50 One is in time.14:51 There's holidays, there's Shabbat.14:53 There's concept of kedusha in place,14:56 and that's what we call Eretz Yisrael, Yerushalayim, Har Habayit, Beit HaMikdash.15:02 And there's a concept of kedusha as well in people.15:07 There are the Jews, and there are Kohanim amongst the Jews,15:10 the Shevet Levi amongst the Jews, there's the Kohanim amongst the Jews, there's Kohen Gadol.15:13 Everything is expressed, every concept is expressed in three different ways.15:17 Where we have the concept of kedusha. In place, we all know that there's an area in the world,15:24 great holiness, that's the Beit HaMikdash.15:26 Till today, even though we don't have a Beit HaMikdash, the area itself is still kadosh; we can't walk in there.15:31 So too, we have kedusha in time, and that is Shabbat.15:35 That means Shabbat, you're basically in the Beit HaMikdash.15:38 You don't have to be physically in15:41 Eretz Yisrael, in Yerushalayim. You could be where you are in Brooklyn, New York, or in China, wherever you are, but your Shabbat by you,15:49 you are in Beit HaMikdash.15:51 That is the Beit HaMikdash where you're in time.15:54 So therefore, in Beit HaMikdash, would a person speak nonsense? Would a person speak about something else?16:00 Likewise, on Shabbat, a person has to be careful with his speech.16:03 In fact, there is a Zohar, and it's the same thing,16:08 is that Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, when he saw his mother16:10 talking—and she wasn't talking words of issur;16:12 she got to be a very holy woman to be the mother of Rabbi16:17 Shimon—so Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai would see his mother talking about something a little extra,16:20 maybe too much, he'd say, Mommy, it's Shabbat.16:23 I don't know if he said Mommy; I think it says, Ima, it's Shabbat today.16:26 That's all he had to tell her, and she would know right away.16:28 She would remember, Oh, Shabbat, and she'd be quiet.16:31 As we know, a woman to keep quiet.16:34 And still, the mother of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, when she heard Shabbat alone,16:40 she realized, I'm in the Beit HaMikdash in time.16:42 Be careful with the extra words.16:44 So even with that, even what's permitted,16:47 even what the halacha16:50 permits, medaber davar, the Gemara tells us,16:52 Shelo yehei diburcha b'Shabbat k'diburcha b'chol. Your words on Shabbat should not be like the words you speak during the weekday.16:57 You have to treat it with more16:59 kedusha. And we're going to bring the Zohar a little bit later on17:01 to bring this idea a little bit more.17:04 Before we get to the halachot,17:06 I want to mention a very important rule when it comes to these halachot.17:09 These halachot are very, very important.17:12 They could be kept really pretty easily,17:15 but at the same time,17:18 that it's a little bit dangerous to give these halachot17:22 because—not dangerous, I mean to17:25 say—when you learn the heterim,17:27 unfortunately, it could be abused.17:29 We're going to speak about what one is permitted to talk about17:32 and what one is not permitted to talk about.17:35 Yet we find, you know, in the poskim,17:37 even in areas where it's permitted,17:39 the poskim will always mention,17:40 Oh, but, you know, even though it's mutar,17:43 because of the holiness of Shabbat,17:45 try to limit it, try to avoid it.17:47 I'll do it.17:48 You don't find the Chazal will tell you,17:49 Oh, you're allowed to eat this meat;17:51 it's kosher, but Yosef17:53 l'mehadrin, but avoid it.17:54 Why it's mutar, it's mutar.17:56 Why over here did they say17:57 it's mutar, but try to avoid it?17:59 And the answer is because it's very borderline.18:02 Even from that which is mutar,18:03 especially speech, which is something that18:05 is second nature.18:06 All day when they learn how to talk,18:08 and it's something that we do18:10 constantly, we're used to doing it,18:11 it could easily lead to things that are forbidden.18:13 And not only that,18:14 you could still follow Shulchan Aruch18:16 and be mechalel Shabbat18:18 and basically desecrate Shabbat18:20 without really transgressing any18:23 halachic principles. There's a famous story.18:25 It'd be funny if you heard it,18:27 then you're waiting for the punchline18:27 and you say, Oh, he didn't say it in a nice way.18:29 Okay. Famous story:18:31 there's three guys sitting in shul.18:33 Let's call them Abraham, Yitzhak, and Yaakov.18:36 Abraham turns to Yitzhak, he tells him,18:39 Listen, you can't talk about this really on Shabbat.18:42 You know, in Yiddish they say,18:43 It's nisht18:44 Shabbos geredt, but I heard that you have a car for sale.18:47 Is that true?18:48 So Yitzhak turns to18:50 Abraham, he tells him, Shh, you know,18:52 can't talk about this on Shabbat.18:54 It's asur. You can't talk about this on Shabbat.18:56 I'm happy to have a car for sale,18:57 but even though we can't talk about this on Shabbat.18:59 Oh, Abraham apologizes, I'm sorry,19:02 it's Shabbat, you're19:02 right, we can't talk about this,19:04 but is it in your house?19:06 So Yitzhak says, Yeah, yeah, yeah,19:07 but Shabbat we can't talk about it.19:08 It happens to be in my house,19:09 yeah, but it's Shabbat.19:11 But if you want to come by,19:13 you know, come over,19:14 you know, anytime you want to come over,19:16 come. Okay, fine.19:18 What happens? Basically,19:20 Abraham over to Yitzhak's house.19:22 He wants to see the19:23 car. He comes to Yitzhak's house.19:25 What time? At19:26 4:30. He comes to his house.19:27 He knocks on the door.19:28 Yitzhak welcomes him in.19:29 Good Shabbos, Shabbat shalom,19:31 how are you?19:31 Bruchim haba'im, come in.19:32 They sit down.19:34 So Avraham turns to his son, he says,19:35 Listen, nisht Shabbat.19:37 I talk about this on Shabbat,19:39 but I know, leave Shabbat alone for a second,19:41 but I'm just wondering about your car.19:43 I know it's Shabbat19:43 and we can't talk about it,19:44 but just wondering about your car.19:46 You know, you told me it's in the driveway.19:49 Can—do you mind if I go take a look at it?19:52 He says, You know,19:54 Avraham, Shabbat,19:55 you can't talk about this today.19:57 You know, but anyway,19:59 yeah, yeah, you can look at it,20:00 but Shabbat, you can't talk about this.20:01 But you should know20:02 there's no point in looking at it20:03 because Yaakov beat you already.20:04 Talk about Shabbat,20:05 but you still... in the world.20:07 And the classic example is the Shabbos app.20:15 They're coming out with an app called...20:17 It was ridiculous.20:19 Shabbos app basically is an app20:21 that you could text on Shabbat20:22 without transgressing the20:24 halacha. So right away I thought it was a joke,20:26 it's ridiculous,20:26 but then he actually showed it to me.20:28 No, it seems to be, at least20:30 from the advertisement,20:32 that it's something real.20:32 If it's something real,20:34 this is the most disgusting thing,20:36 and this is basically20:38 what I wanted to stress before this class.20:41 Every20:43 halacha should... but you are mechalel Shabbat.20:45 Let me define for you20:46 what mechalel Shabbat means.20:48 What does it mean, mechalel Shabbat?20:49 What is the word20:51 chalal? Not the meat by the Muslims.20:53 Chalal means empty,20:55 a hollow, empty space.20:58 Or it could also be from the word21:00 chol, which is mundane.21:01 Both have the same concept,21:03 the same idea.21:05 Chol, mundane, nothing special to it,21:07 which is like the weekday.21:09 And chalal is something that's empty,21:11 hollow really, not empty,21:13 something that's hollow,21:14 where on the outside it looks like there's something,21:15 but inside there's nothing there.21:17 The same idea.21:18 During the weekday21:19 there's nothing special about the weekday,21:20 it's another day.21:22 Shabbat is kadosh,21:24 with the kedushah on the inside,21:25 you look deeper in Shabbat.21:27 Another day on the calendar.21:28 What do you21:29 expect? Understand what Shabbat is.21:30 It's a revelation of...21:32 It's a time when we can connect21:33 and get closer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.21:36 Then that's kedusha.21:38 Chalal is empty.21:39 Mechalel Shabbat means21:41 you have a day which is full of holiness,21:44 and you remove the holiness,21:45 that you make it21:47 chalal, empty, hollow.21:48 That's why a corpse,21:49 that body21:50 is known as a21:53 chalal. Chalalim. Chalalim means empty.21:54 You have a person,21:55 you see him,21:56 he's there, right there in front of you.21:57 He has a nose,21:58 he has eyes,21:59 he has a body,21:59 he has a heart,22:01 he has limbs,22:02 he has everything,22:02 even blood,22:03 but he's a chalal because22:05 inside of him,22:06 the kedusha of this person22:08 is not inside of him.22:08 The soul left him.22:10 He's called a22:11 chalal. When you take the soul out of Shabbat,22:14 that is chillul Shabbat.22:16 You made the kedusha gone.22:19 It's empty.22:20 It's hollow.22:21 You're mechalel Shabbat.22:23 So now, the whole idea,22:24 when the22:26 Chazal saw that22:28 in the times of Nehemiah,22:29 we can talk about22:30 that when we get to22:31 Muktzeh, when they were,22:32 you know,22:33 basically22:34 the guy is doing22:35 whatever he's doing during the weekday.22:36 It didn't look like it's Shabbat.22:37 So therefore22:38 they made gezeirot upon gezeirot of22:40 muktzeh. So now,22:41 finally,22:41 we get one day a week22:42 when we're able to relax,22:44 and we're able to get away22:45 from this whole world22:46 that pulls us,22:47 olam hazeh22:48 has all22:48 these... bring down.22:51 It's like water22:52 that's not like water;22:53 it's like quicksand22:53 that pulls you down.22:55 One day a week22:56 that we22:57 finally—yes, even though it's difficult for some22:58 people—but we put away the22:59 phones and we can experience23:00 a bit the kedusha.23:01 You want to bring back23:02 the holiness out of Shabbat,23:04 but you're not23:04 trying to suggest anything important.23:05 But at the same time,23:07 we have to take it with caution,23:09 and we need a lot of yirat shamayim.23:11 I23:11 mean, even that which is mutar,23:13 we'll say what the poskim23:15 say. It's not my words;23:16 these are the words of the poskim.23:17 Even that which is mutar,23:19 you have to be careful to limit it23:20 or try to avoid it23:21 if it's not necessary,23:23 completely necessary.23:24 Why?23:24 Because otherwise23:25 you lose the concept. Shabbat.23:27 Now somebody will say,23:27 Well, it's so difficult.23:29 It's only difficult because23:31 you don't understand23:32 what the kedushah of Shabbat is.23:34 And perhaps23:34 maybe that's why you don't really enjoy Shabbat23:36 without these things,23:37 because you don't have23:38 a true experience of Shabbat.23:39 As we'll learn,23:40 and we're going to bring23:40 from big sefarim,23:42 important sefarim,23:43 there's such a kedushah of Shabbat.23:44 There's such a holiness of Shabbat.23:46 If you don't use it in the proper way,23:47 if you distract yourself23:49 with all the things23:50 that you can't do on Shabbat,23:52 you won't experience that23:54 kedushah. Remember,23:54 the kedushah is there.23:55 Ein atah mechalel it,23:57 ein atah metake away the kedushah.24:00 Which I tell you, it's impossible for you to experience.24:03 So therefore, we stress again.24:06 We will talk about it because we have to.24:08 This is a halacha; we have to tell you the24:10 din. But it's your responsibility to make sure Shabbos remains,24:15 and you do it in the proper way, in the proper fashion.24:18 And any question that you have, make sure you consult your rav in your specific...24:22 And of course, you want to ask us any specific question, halacha or whatever.24:27 And preferably, if it's a specific case that's going to take obviously a while,24:32 call in after the class. But otherwise, if it's just a quick halacha,24:35 of course you could call or text into the radio station.24:38 Let me give you the numbers again,24:39 and now, be'ezrat Hashem, we will begin the halachot of daber davar, what we can speak or what we cannot speak on Shabbat.24:48 Phone numbers to the station are24:52 718-683-5858. That's to call in to talk; you'll be on the air if you call before 324:57 o'clock. And if you want to text in your question, it's25:04 347-927-8398. Emerat Hashem, let's begin with halacha25:07 aleph, forbidden on Shabbat, and which speech is forbidden on Shabbat.25:12 And we will read from the Ben Ish Chai as we always do.25:17 Katuv gabei Shabbat in the Torah, it says,25:24 V'asit v'chibadto... me'metzo cheftzecha... on Shabbat. We focus just on the last words:25:29 from the way you speak, as we explained,25:34 that your words on Shabbat should not be like your words during the weekday.25:38 Says now the25:43 Ben Ish Chai, here's the halacha: V'lama me'baaya lomar l'chaveiro la'asot lo ma'aseh peloni. Not only are we talking about a case where you can't tell another Jew to do a certain thing for you;25:50 that's asur, that's for sure forbidden.25:52 There's no question about that,25:55 mishum damar mo'il la'asiyah. Because obviously, if you tell a person, Listen, do me a favor.25:59 Could you take my car and transfer it from Brooklyn to Manhattan?26:05 Of course, when you command him, that's leading to action,26:09 and that's for sure going to be mutar, even if he doesn't do it on Shabbat.26:17 Not only this, but even cases where speech about things that don't really have a direct benefit from your words,26:26 meaning to say that your words will not have an effect right away.26:29 You talking to your friend and he's saying, I want to do this tomorrow.26:39 Whether you say it or not, he's going to do it anyway.26:42 When you talk to people and you tell them, You know, I am going on an airplane tomorrow,26:47 it doesn't make a difference if you say it or not.26:48 You have your tickets reserved, and you are going to go on an airplane.26:51 So you might say, What's the problem with that? What am I doing? I'm just talking.26:57 Still forbidden to do it,27:00 as long as what you're speaking about is something that's forbidden to be done on Shabbat.27:09 Even if what you're speaking about, for example, Oh, I'm going to make a delicious barbecue tomorrow,27:14 so you have two melachot over there: bishul, you're cooking,27:18 and you have also hav'arah, you're putting on the fire.27:22 So you might say, I'm not speaking about that.27:27 I cannot do midderabanan on Shabbat.27:29 Even can asur lomar, do27:30 this tomorrow. I want to point out something.27:33 When we said you can't say something that's forbidden on Shabbat. On Shabbat, meaning it's not a problem because of hachana.27:43 I can tell my friend, I can tell my wife, I can tell my brother that I am going to make a barbecue tomorrow,27:49 not because I'm preparing for tomorrow,27:51 or there's nothing I'm doing.27:53 I'm going to make the barbecue regardless.27:55 I'm just telling them. By the way, it's a beautiful day.27:56 It's Sunday.27:58 Everybody's going to be here.27:59 You know, everybody's coming.28:00 It's Mother's Day, Brothers Day, Sons Day,28:03 and we're going to do a barbecue.28:06 And I already have the meat.28:07 I already ordered the meat,28:09 fire and the grill.28:10 Everything is waiting.28:11 It's not a problem of hachana.28:13 The problem is because what you're doing is you speak about something that you couldn't have done on Shabbat.28:18 That's the rule.28:19 Anything that you can't do on Shabbat, you can't speak about on Shabbat.28:22 But had it been mutar to be done on Shabbat, then you could speak about on Shabbat.28:27 I'll give you an example.28:29 You want to go tomorrow,28:32 let me say Sunday,28:33 you want to go,28:34 you want to visit your parents.28:37 Now your parents live, let's say, three blocks away,28:39 so you're going to walk to your parents.28:40 So you say, Oh, you know, you tell your wife, I'm going to go visit my parents tomorrow.28:44 Would you like to come with me?28:45 It's not a problem.28:46 Even though you're talking about what you can do on Sunday, there's no problem to talk about what you're going to do after Shabbat.28:51 The problem is when your words are being said where they include things that cannot be done on Shabbat.29:00 So let's change the a little bit, and let's say the following.29:04 I need to go visit your parents, but they don't live three blocks down from you.29:08 You're not going to walk to them.29:09 They live in a different city,29:11 and you're going to drive to get to their house.29:14 Let's say they live in, let's make it New Jersey.29:19 Can't say, I am driving to my parents tomorrow.29:23 Would you like to come with me?29:25 Because the car, you don't want to hit traffic.29:27 That you can't say.29:28 Even leave the traffic part.29:30 Just because the fact that you said you're driving is forbidden to be done on Shabbat,29:35 therefore it's forbidden to say that driving to your parents on Shabbat.29:40 That is the rule.29:41 Not because of hachana, again,29:42 not because you're preparing yourself.29:44 The problem is that you are speaking about something that cannot be done on Shabbat.29:49 That is the general rule.29:50 So let's take another example.29:52 We spoke about barbecue.29:53 We spoke about traveling.29:55 Another scenario where you could also, you could speak about it or you cannot speak about it.30:00 Let's say a woman tells her friend, Oh, you know, I'm buying this item tomorrow.30:07 I'm going to buy this item tomorrow.30:09 That is forbidden,30:11 because buying is forbidden to be done on Shabbat.30:14 Buying is forbidden30:16 miderabanan. Still, that's forbidden to talk about on Shabbat.30:18 However, if you tell her, I'm going to get this item tomorrow,30:22 getting this item could be, you could get it.30:25 Let's say you have an eruv around you,30:27 you could have gotten it,30:27 so that's mutar.30:28 It's only a problem when you speak about something, when your words, excuse me,30:32 when your words include, you're mentioning in your words things that are forbidden to be done on Shabbat.30:39 Otherwise, if it's not forbidden to be done on Shabbat,30:41 you could say it even though it's going to be done tomorrow.30:46 The second part of this halacha, Ben Ish Chai talks about, what if you are talking about a mitzvah?30:52 So he says,30:53 v'im hu devar mitzvah.30:54 If you talk about something that's a mitzvah,31:02 כגון, שאומר בשבת שרוצה לכתוב למחר ספר תורה או תפילין ומזוזה וכיוצא בזה. Writing is one of the 3931:04 melachot. Writing is31:05 de'oraita, according to 99% of the31:08 poskim. Even writing in a foreign language like English is also31:13 de'oraita. So let's say a person now wants to write,31:17 but this time he's writing—what is he doing? He's writing a Sefer Torah.31:22 And he says, you know, we have hachnasat Sefer Torah.31:23 I'm so excited.31:25 I'm going to write letters in the Sefer Torah.31:29 So we said it's not a problem of hachanah,31:31 but the problem is that you're mentioning writing.31:33 Writing is asur on Shabbat.31:33 But what are you writing?31:35 You're writing something that's a mitzvah.31:38 It's a big mitzvah.31:39 You're writing tefillin.31:41 In such an area,31:42 yesh matirin mishum dechafetz shamayim hem v'yesh osrim.31:46 There's machloket31:48 Acharonim. I believe it's the Magen Avraham versus the31:51 Chida, that some are permitting it.31:53 Some say it's permitted,31:54 it's mutar,31:55 and the31:56 Chida—excuse me—some say it's mutar,31:57 that's the31:58 Chida, and the Magen Avraham says31:59 no, it's asur.32:00 Even though it's for a mitzvah, who cares? It's still forbidden because at the end of the day, you're doing something that's forbidden.32:07 So he says,32:11 even those—32:13 I have a third opinion who says, kind of makes a compromise. He says over here,32:17 there are those who permit it, but only on32:21 the condition—what are they permitted on? There are those who permit it only if the item that you're—if what you're32:25 speaking about,32:26 ein tzorech lotor dibur, because whether you say it or you don't32:33 say it.32:34 Wait, sorry. Yeah,32:39 there are those who say that it's only permitted to say something where32:43 there's no—you're just talking about it, you're just mentioning, Oh, I'm going to write.32:46 But to say something that you are going to do, those32:50 some people forbid it. However, I think Yosefitz about brings down32:54 that a person who's scared that if he doesn't32:58 say it, he's not going to do it. For example, sometimes, you know, you want to do something,33:02 but you know that as long as people don't know about it, you have nothing really33:06 obligates you. Once you tell people about it, then it's going to force you to do it.33:11 If it's a mitzvah, even though it is a33:15 melachah, to lezaruzei nafshei, in order to33:18 make sure that you do the item, so you want to say it, it's mutar. I'll give you an33:22 example. If a person now wants to write—he's a sofer and he has to33:26 write a mezuzah, and he knows himself that, you know, if he doesn't talk about it,33:30 he's not going to do it. So somebody comes to him—he tells him—not somebody comes to him.33:35 He knows he has to write this mezuzah.33:38 He kept on pushing it off, pushing it off. All he has to do is say. So now on Shabbat,33:42 he sees one of his friends. He tells him, Listen, I'm going to come. I want you to come33:47 tomorrow, and I want you to come pick up your mezuzah. Why, you have a mezuzah for me? No,33:50 but I'm going to write it, because he knows once I say I'm going to write it, I gave him my word,33:54 then I know for sure I'm going to be able to write it. I'm going to for sure write the mezuzah.33:58 In such a case, it would be mutar. Why? Because you're only doing it to inspire yourself.34:02 True, it is a machloket. It's34:07 machloket deRabanan. Could be mekil, but still, the Beit Yosef says,34:11 ra'ui lachush l'divrei ha'osrim, and even for a mitzvah, try to avoid it. But in the case,34:14 in this case where you want to inspire yourself, you want to push yourself to34:18 make sure to do the mitzvah, even though it's a melacha, you're allowed to speak about it.34:22 So let's review very quickly.34:25 Vedaber davar, the Navi tells us you're not allowed to speak about anything that you cannot do on Shabbat.34:29 It has no preparation for Shabbat, or preparation for Shabbat.34:35 You're mentioning in your words something that's34:38 forbidden, you cannot mention it on Shabbat. Example: you cannot say,34:42 I'm driving to New Jersey tomorrow. I'm going to make a barbecue tomorrow.34:45 I am buying this item tomorrow. That's all forbidden.34:50 However, to say that you're going to do something where in your words you don't34:54 mention anything that's forbidden, that you couldn't mean to say, you don't mention anything that you couldn't34:58 have done on Shabbat. For example, you want to say, I'm going to35:02 Jersey tomorrow. I am coming to...35:05 I am getting this item tomorrow. I am visiting this person tomorrow.35:10 All that is fine because you haven't mentioned anything that you cannot do on Shabbat.35:15 Mitzvah. When it comes to mitzvah, there's a35:19 machloket. Some say that you cannot speak about it even though it's a mitzvah,35:22 and some say, listen, it's35:25 chatzei shamayim, the mitzvah, and the hachamim did not make a gezeirah. When you speak about something that's a mitzvah on Shabbat,35:30 but everybody will agree that if it's35:35 necessary, and in order to perform the mitzvah you have to35:38 speak about it, then you're allowed to speak about it, even on Shabbat.35:42 That's to push yourself to do it. Here we have a question now.35:47 If you told me that you can't mention anything you can't do on Shabbat,35:50 there's a big question here: how could we make... Donations35:54 or pledges in the shul on Shabbat,35:58 by asbad Sefardim, when you get an aliyah, you don't get off so easy.36:02 Yeah, you got up, but when you come down, everybody says, Mi sheberach, Hashem should bless36:06 Mr. So-and-so who just got an aliyah,36:08 shemitnadev, who's pledging, and then you have to say a certain amount,36:12 whatever, 52, 101,36:16 you pledge to the midrash. So how can you speak about Shabbat?36:19 That you have to be machmir. True, there are opinions who say when it comes to mitzvot, mutar.36:24 So the answer over here is as follows.36:28 The pasuk that we quoted above, we said, Im tashiv miShabbat raglecha, asot36:33 chafatzecha, Chazal told us clearly. Why does it say in the pasuk36:36 you have to refrain from doing36:40 chafatzecha, your needs? Shiv said, measot chefetz, from doing36:44 any need. So therefore, Chachamim explained when the pasuk is coming to tell us36:48 chafatzecha, specifically if they're your needs,36:52 that's asur, that's when it's forbidden. Hefzei Shamayim,36:56 needs for Shamayim, it's mutar. So therefore, we're going to give you a few examples37:00 where it's for mitzvah and you're allowed to speak, because37:04 that's not included in the issur. Anything37:08 that you're speaking about that has to do not of going to37:12 do—the difference between this case and the other case is beforehand when he said37:16 about writing a Sefer Torah, that's because you're talking about something that's forbidden to do, which is37:20 writing for a Sefer Torah. But here we're talking about the words that you're mentioning,37:24 the speech that you're talking about. It's not that you're speaking about37:28 issur. You're speaking about something that's mutar,37:31 but what? But it might include work, it might include other things,37:36 and it might be a mention of money. That's mutar, because you're not talking about37:39 what—you're just saying that the concept, you're talking about money,37:43 you're talking about things that are for a sacred mitzvah, that's fine. But you're not saying, I'm going to37:48 write a Sefer Torah, I'm going to deliver a Sefer Torah.37:51 Those are— Here,37:55 just the subject is not of Shabbat. Let me give you a few examples which are mutar.37:59 Hazal tell us, and the halacha tells us,38:04 cheshbonot shel mitzvah. What does it mean, cheshbonot mitzvah? You're allowed to speak about38:06 cheshbonot mitzvah, meaning, let's say you are meeting with the38:11 president of the shul, and you tell him, Listen, we have a siyum,38:14 be'ezrat Hashem. We're planning to make a siyum. We just finished a masechet, and we'd like to, you know,38:19 we need about a thousand dollars to make the seudah for the siyum.38:24 So you're talking about money.38:25 You're not talking about melachah, but you're talking about money.38:29 Since it's a discussion of money, money of mitzvah,38:34 it's mutar. The same would be true38:36 regarding seudah shelishit. We need to raise, you know, five hundred dollars for38:41 seudah shelishit. It's fine because it's cheshbonot shel mitzvah. That's all mutar.38:45 Another thing is also, if you are allowed to speak about things of the need of the38:49 tzibur. For example, the tzibur is in need of,38:54 they need, I can't think of an example38:57 right now, but let's say the shul needs to be fixed. The heat39:01 is not working. You know, the weather is changing right now, the heat is not working. It's a39:05 tzorech shel tzibur, it's not tzorech yachid. If we don't have heat in the morning, guys are not going to be able to pray good.39:10 They're not going to come to shul. So you're allowed to speak about that on Shabbat. Ah, you're talking about fixing39:13 the heat. Tzibur, they will not go there on39:18 tzorech tzibur. Arranging shidduchim. They're talking about, you know, this one will be39:21 matched to this one. You want to get people married. This is, we have a girl over here, you know,39:25 she's getting a little older. We have to get her married, and39:29 family that's able to support it. These people have money. You're allowed to talk about that, to arrange39:33 shidduchim. One of the main functions of getting married is to be able to support. So you could39:37 speak about which family could afford, basically, or which boy39:41 has the means to be able to afford such a girl. Another thing is,39:45 if you want to arrange a tutor or a teacher for your child,39:49 that's mutar. That means you want to go up to a person and say, Listen,39:53 you think you teach my child? Now, everybody knows a tutor, a teacher, anybody who teaches,39:58 you pay them. You can't—40:00 Speak about the actual money with the guy. You can't go over to the local40:05 avrech in your shul and say, Listen, two of my son has a test next week. Are you able40:09 to teach him? My son is getting bar mitzvah. Are you able to teach him? That you're40:12 allowed to tell him, but you can't tell him, How much do you charge? You can't tell him, Is40:19 fifty dollars good for you? You can't talk about that. You could tell him, and obviously it's known that40:24 there's going to be a price for it. That's fine. And that's speaking, arranging for somebody40:30 to teach your child, since it's a mitzvah. There's a mitzvah of teaching children Torah. There's40:35 even a mitzvah of teaching them a profession. In this case, you're teaching them how to40:38 read the Torah. For sure it's mutar to arrange. And finally, the halacha brings down,40:44 Lifsok tzedakah. You're allowed to pledge money. Now, pledging money, if you're a little bit40:51 more versed in the halacha, and it's mentioned in number ten that says, Ein makdishin. You're40:57 not to be makdish items on Shabbat. So how are we saying that pledging money41:01 is mutar? Basically, you're saying, I'm taking $101 from my bank account and I'm transferring41:06 it to the shul. Makdishin is when you take a specific item and you makdish it to the shul.41:12 For example, if you say, This bottle of whiskey over here, I would like to give it to the41:16 shul, that's a problem. That it could be a problem. So that you shouldn't do. If you have a bottle41:22 of whiskey that you think about and you want to pledge that to the shul, that's going to41:25 be a problem, according to a lot of opinions. Some are matir even in such a case, but you41:29 should try to avoid it. But if you want to say, for example, I want to give a bottle41:33 of whiskey, you're not thinking of any specific one, that's not a problem for sure. And especially,41:40 of course, in a place that has an eruv, that's not a problem, even though41:44 on Shabbat you get to say, I am giving this bottle of grape juice to the shul. That's41:48 all mutar. The only time that you should try to avoid is when you're designating a specific41:53 item. Some poskim are machmir, also try to be machmir in such an area. Don't have something41:58 specifically in mind. Just say, Baruch Hashem, I would like to bring kiddush to the shul. I'd like to42:04 sponsor the kiddush for the shul. That's for sure mutar, even42:08 lechatchila; there would not go there. Why? It's a mitzvah. You're bringing something for the zechut of42:12 the rabbim, berachot, that people should have kiddush in the shul, that people should have oneg Shabbat. That42:17 is permitted on Shabbat. What about selling aliyot? Here you're buying. You're selling42:23 an aliyah. You're saying, Okay, who wants to open up the heichal, petichat heichal? So you're selling something42:28 over here. That's also mutar. Why? What is this? The rabbi just permitted. It's permitted42:34 to sell aliyot because nothing is really being sold. You're not giving an item. When you42:39 sell an item, I'll give you an example. You're selling the iPhone 6. So you give me money,42:46 700, 800 dollars, whatever it costs, and I give you something in exchange. I give you42:50 the phone. That's selling an item. You're receiving something. Over here, you're not42:54 receiving anything. You're just being honored. You're given the privilege to be able to open42:57 up the heichal. There's nothing that you're acquiring. You're not taking the sefer Torah43:00 home. I'm not selling it to you for a thousand even in shul. So that's the reason why selling43:06 aliyot is permitted in shul. Why? Because you're not selling an actual item in shul.43:12 The other question that's brought up over here, and since it's not discussed in43:17 Mishnah Berurah, I'm going to talk about it right now, is can one hire chazanim, rabbis,43:23 and mashgichim and waiters on Shabbat? And all these chazanim, they pray and they get paid for the43:29 fact that they're praying on Shabbat. Rabbis. Some rabbis are only work, they only43:35 work... You have also, sometimes you have people are hired to be a43:39 mashgiach in the kitchen on Shabbat. Waiters. A lot of times there are people who are makpid that only43:45 want to have Jewish waiters by my simcha, and therefore all the waiters are Jewish,43:49 but they work on Shabbat. So the issues, there are two issues that people have a43:56 question on, and number one is work. The guy is working on Shabbat. You just know you can't work on44:00 Shabbat. You can't even talk about work on Shabbat. Now you tell me the guy is working44:03 on Shabbat. Is this mutar or not mutar? Well, we see that they're doing it. How could it44:08 be mutar? The other issue with having these things is sechar Shabbat. You can't profit44:18 monetarily from Shabbat. How could you have this guy working, profiting on Shabbat? Let's answer44:25 each one by itself. Number one is working on Shabbat. Work doesn't mean what you define44:30 as work. For us, work means melacha. If it's not doing melacha, it's not an issue. So44:37 that's the first. For the chazzan who's singing, true, that might be. There's some44:42 chazzanim, le'ananah, they have a fantastic, wonderful voice, and everybody's coming to hear them,44:47 and therefore the price is higher, which is the rule, which fits in the rules of supply and demand, and44:52 they get paid a very high salary. In fact, because of their high salary, they don't have44:56 to work during the week. They could sit and go and learn all day, and they don't need45:01 to go out to get a job. Baruch Hashem, there's some chazzanim that. And of course rabbis,45:07 even the ones that, Baruch Hashem, they get their salary from what they...45:14 for sure, mashgichim are getting paid for that, what they get, and waiters are only working45:19 that se'udah. So what's going on? How could it be now that... That's not45:26 called—there's no melacha being done. There's nothing forbidden that they're doing. When the chazzan says45:30 his tefillah, when the chazzan sings in the synagogue, when the rabbi gives45:36 a derashah, when the mashgiach is standing in the kitchen making sure no issur Shabbat is being done,45:42 and waiters are serving also, they're just taking the food down on Shabbat, there's45:46 no melacha. So don't come and say that's work. That's number one. That's very important.45:52 Work is not what we define as work, even though it might be a person's source of income. Work45:58 means melacha. You have an issue now with sechar Shabbat. If you're worried that this46:03 guy is getting income on Shabbat, yeah, okay, that's called sechar Shabbat. That could46:07 possibly be an issue. But keep in mind, there's no melacha being done that's46:13 forbidden. And when you do things that are forbidden, you can't say, okay, you46:16 know, I could find the heterim. This is only applicable—these heterim only apply to a person who is46:22 not doing anything technically asur on Shabbat, things that are permitted to be done;46:27 just he's getting paid for it. When are there heterim, or what are the heterim? We'll give46:32 you a few heterim. Number one, the Rama writes regarding chazzanim that if they're hired to46:38 pray or they're hired to service you even on the weekday, so that's mutar. Even the46:47 money that they get is mutar. That's not called sechar Shabbat, because technically you're46:51 paying them for the weekday, although you're paying them a lot for the weekday, but you're46:55 mavlia; you throw in the money of Shabbat in the middle with the salary that47:00 they're getting on the weekday. Even though you both know that you're paying him extra for the47:05 weekday because he's doing on Shabbat, that's fine, because technically you're paying him47:09 for the week, for the year, lemashal. You hire a chazzan for a month. And you arrange with him that47:16 he's going to pray every single Shabbat and every single Wednesday. And he says, How much47:25 are you going to pay me? So he says, Okay, I'm going to pay you a thousand dollars for47:30 this month. Obviously, a thousand dollars is not because he's going to pay a small little47:35 shacharit in the weekday. That's nothing. He doesn't have—he can just—anybody can pray47:38 in the weekday. But he's being paid, really, the thousand dollars because on Shabbat he47:42 has to stretch out his voice, he has to raise his voice a lot more people. Still, you're47:47 paying him per month, and you're not calculating per day. If you calculate per day, say, Oh,47:51 there's four, as a result, we give you $250 per Shabbat, that's going to be a47:55 problem. But you're giving him one salary for the month, that's mutar. So.48:00 With this heter, we find a heter for most of the chazanim as well as the rabbis.48:05 If they are, or they are not—I won't say the word working,48:09 but basically—but they're certain on times which are not Shabbat,48:14 so therefore they gain their salary for the weekday.48:16 That includes Shabbat inside of it, but it's not singling out; it's not specifying only Shabbat.48:22 Therefore they do it by having havdalah. By us, by the48:25 Sefardim, havdalah is a whole show. For some48:28 chazanim, depends who, you know, which shul,48:30 but for some shuls it's a whole48:32 show, for 10, 15 minutes. Sometimes for some people that's the highlight,48:36 the way the chazan says the havdalah. That's the highlight of the whole Shabbat.48:39 So therefore it's being done on motzaei Shabbat.48:43 That's something that you need the chazan to do.48:46 So you're paying him for the havdalah, included in48:49 the—you're paying him also for what he does on Shabbat, but you're not specifying it.48:53 You're giving him one price per month. That is mutar.48:56 Or, like we said, if you have him pray any time during the week,48:59 so that could— the chazan praying49:01 Mincha, or most chazanim, they also pray motzaei Shabbat,49:05 which is the tefilah of Arvit motzaei Shabbat.49:07 Once he's praying motzaei Shabbat, so that's considered like you're paying him for the weekday.49:12 Another heter, and this following heter we need for people who will not work on motzaei Shabbat.49:18 For example, let's say you have a simcha and you're having Shabbat49:22 seudah, so you have— and the person that's coming,49:28 you're getting a chazan or you're hiring a rabbi to come and give a dvar Torah,49:31 and you know that you pay him, let's say, $500 after Shabbat.49:34 So where's the heter for that? They're not doing anything on Shabbat.49:37 So in such a case, as long as you never spoke about price,49:42 even though it's known what the price is, you never spoke about price49:44 and not arranging the price, you're not telling him, I'm paying you just for this.49:48 So then, technically what you give him afterwards is a49:50 gift. Now you're going to tell me it's a game. I'm going to pay him $500 as a gift?49:54 I'm never giving him a gift unless he came and he sang by my son's simcha.49:59 And this is true, but when it's a gift, it makes a difference when it comes to the laws of choshen mishpat,50:06 monetary cases. Meaning, since it's only a gift, if you never pay him,50:10 he cannot come back to you and demand the money.50:13 And if he takes you to court, he can't really take you to court because it's a50:16 gift. A gift, you have no responsibility to give.50:19 Now it doesn't mean go ahead, hire a chazzan and don't pay him,50:22 right? That's not right. But technically, since it's being given as a gift,50:26 so therefore that's another heter.50:30 Another heter, and that is what the Beit Yosef brings in the50:35 Mordechai, b'shem Rabbeinu Shmuel. And that is, since the chazzan or the rabbi or the mashgiach are doing a mitzvah,50:41 why the rabbi is saying Divrei Torah,50:44 the chazzan is singing for you, and the mashgiach is making sure that everything goes well50:48 in the kitchen, no issur Shabbat or issur of kashrut is taking place,50:53 he's doing a mitzvah. So therefore, he's doing a mitzvah.50:58 What do you want from the guy?50:59 Hafsei shamayim. We said beforehand, it's a mitzvah51:04 chachamim didn't make a gezeirah on mitzvot. So there is such a heter that's also brought down.51:06 All these are heter.51:07 We want to know now, halachah lemaaseh, Maran, what does Maran hold?51:10 What is the halachah according to Maran?51:12 Does Maran permit or does Maran forbid a person to do this on Shabbat?51:18 So let me tell you two halachot in Shulchan Aruch.51:21 One is brought down here in Hilchot Shabbat, and the other one is brought down in Hilchot Rosh Hashanah.51:25 In Hilchot Shabbat, Shulchan Aruch writes,51:32 Asur liskor chazzanim l'hitpalel b'Shabbat, v'yesh mi shematir. Maran writes it's forbidden for a person to hire chazzanim from before Shabbat to pray on Shabbat.51:37 But those who permit it,51:41 sounds like from Maran, that's forbidden. Why?51:44 We have a rule,51:46 stam v'yesh, halacha k'stam. Maran told me that it's forbidden, but there are those who permit.51:50 Usually that's a rule that he's holding really it's forbidden.51:53 But there's another halacha now in Hilchot Rosh Hashanah,51:56 and he says like this:52:04 Hanotel sachar litkoa shofar b'Rosh Hashanah, o k'dei l'hitpalel, o l'argemesh ha-tov v'imim tovim, eino ro'eh me'oto sachar siman bracha. Anybody who takes money for blowing the shofar on Rosh Hashanah, or for praying, or targum,52:12 which is basically teaching Torah on Shabbat,52:15 doesn't see any sachar—excuse me, he doesn't see any blessing from that money.52:21 Maran never mentioned anything that's asur over52:23 here. He only said is you won't see any blessing from that money.52:29 Okay, Acharonim. According to some52:31 Acharonim, kil'avdi, he says really Maran holds52:33 it's asur, like he wrote in Hilchot Shabbat.52:36 When he writes in Hilchot Rosh Hashanah that there's no blessing,52:39 he's telling you there's no blessing and there's52:42 no—also it's52:44 asur. That's the way of the Yaskil Avdi,52:48 that really you cannot take money on Shabbat for what you do on Shabbat.52:51 What do you mean, how are we giving them money?52:52 And the answer is you're doing it in a different way, like we said before,52:55 either you're giving them as a gift or you're—what he does also during the weekday.53:02 However, he brings from many Acharonim that really not.53:06 Although Maran wrote that it's forbidden in Hilchot Shabbat,53:08 when he got to Hilchot Rosh Hashanah,53:10 he changed his mind, he retracted,53:12 and he says that it's not forbidden,53:14 but it is true that you will not see any blessing from that money.53:18 That's the way Acharon Ya'ah holds.53:20 Therefore, to avoid all problems,53:23 make sure that a payment arrangement is arranged in a way that's mutar according to all opinions.53:29 Allow the chazzan to do something during the week and pay him for that.53:33 Or let's say you have rabbis,53:34 you have rabbis that teach only—53:36 They come to give,53:38 and they come, and it's not going into Motzei Shabbat.53:41 They're only doing it on Shabbat.53:43 A person who's reading the Sefer Torah in the morning,53:45 all these people arrange in a way53:47 that they should do something, decide to be as a gift.53:50 You have that heter,53:51 and even with that, if you don't have that heter,53:53 you have all the Acharonim, like the Bach and all the53:55 Acharonim that say that the minhag is to.53:58 They all agree that there is no blessing from the money that one receives on Shabbat,54:02 but the minhag is that we're lenient.54:04 We do pay the people that have a need for their job they do on Shabbat.54:09 But again, there's no54:11 siman berachah, so therefore we want to avoid that. You want to get a berachah from your money54:14 and do it in a kosher way.54:16 And all of this, rabotai, I want to mention, and we're going to finish with this,54:20 all these halachot that we showed you right now about hiring chazanim, all these things,54:23 this is only permitted before Shabbat.54:27 You can't go on Shabbat and tell a rabbi or a54:30 chazzan and arrange with him to do something and talk about money on Shabbat.54:35 You can't come on Shabbat and tell a54:39 chazzan, Listen, I have a simchah tomorrow morning in the shul, Shabbat morning,54:44 and I want you to come and sing, be'ezrat Hashem, I'll give you54:48 five hundred dollars. All opinions. There's no heter for such a thing.54:50 It's only mutar to pay him afterwards for what he did,54:54 but you cannot speak about on Shabbat because of the issur of54:57 v'daber davar. And with this, we finish halachah aleph.54:59 Like we said, there's a lot of halachot, a lot of details in the55:02 halachot. Halachah aleph has a lot in it, and we hope, be'ezrat Hashem, we clarified what we could.55:08 If anybody has a question, we have to stop here,55:09 but if anybody has a question and you would like to call in,55:12 we'll be here for the next 15, 20 minutes.55:15 If you have any questions, the numbers to the station are55:20 718-683-5858, and if you'd like to text us any question, you could text in at55:27 347-927-8398. Be'ezrat Hashem, this class will be aired on again tonight on55:32 jradio.com. On jewishradio.com at 11 p.m., 11 to 1255:38 p.m. And you can always, of course, go to JRadio and listen to all the classes.55:44 And, be'ezrat Hashem, otherwise we'll see you next week, Wednesday afternoon,55:48 live from 2 to 355:50 o'clock. If you have any questions, you could call in now.55:52 Till then, till next week, have a wonderful week and a Shabbat Shalom.