Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio.0:03 This is the Halacha Hour on Wednesday,0:07 Chet Shevat, January 28th.0:10 We are here live on JRoot Radio.0:14 You can watch us and listen to us on0:18 JRootRadio.com. You can also access the show on the phone0:20 if you call0:26 718-506-9099. Also, you can download the0:28 app if you already have the app. Just put on the app0:30 JRoot Radio, which just came out with an update,0:33 JRoot Radio Pro app.0:35 This is how you can access the show,0:37 and of course the numbers to the station are0:42 718-683-5858. That's to call in.0:44 We suggest you call usually towards the end of the class.0:46 If there's any questions, any pointers, we'd love to hear from you.0:50 And if you have any questions by text,0:53 that's the simplest way to access or to reach us.0:56 It's by1:02 347-927-8398. Today's class is dedicated for two purposes.1:05 Number one is Leilui Nishmat of David Wuniar,1:09 who was a friend of ours here from the radio,1:12 and as well as1:17 ... yibadel l'chaim tovim, it's also for refuah shlema of Rita1:19 bat Fania. Hashem should give her a refuah shlema b'toch shaar cholei amo Yisrael.1:23 We are in the middle of the halachot in the Ben Ish Chai, Parashat Vayishlach.1:28 This class, we learn off the Ben Ish Chai, we work off the Ben1:33 Ish Chai, and we try to explain the sources of the1:36 halachot. We also try to explain the source of the halachot. We also try to explain and clarify and make it applicable.1:46 That's really our two goals:1:48 to clarify the source of the1:50 halachot and to bring them to1:53 halacha l'maaseh, to make them applicable,1:54 and that we could use them on a1:56 day-to-day. We work off the Ben Ish Chai. We're in the middle of Parashat Vayishlach,2:00 and we began a new subject,2:02 although it's in the middle of2:03 the parashah, but it's a new subject,2:04 and the subject is the laws of2:09 amirah l'akum, what one could tell the goy on Shabbat.2:10 We already gave an introduction in the last two classes.2:14 Last week there was something with the internet,2:16 and we couldn't be on,2:17 but two weeks ago, if you go to two weeks ago...2:20 And three weeks ago,2:22 we gave a class, an introduction to the laws of2:26 Amira l'akum. In the words of the2:29 Minchat Cohen, who wrote an unbelievable2:32 chapter—I don't want to say chapter,2:33 but a section in his book,2:35 Minchat Cohen. He wrote,2:36 for those who understand Hebrew,2:37 he has an unbelievably clear Hebrew,2:39 especially those that like to learn2:42 halacha b'iyun, that sefer Minchat Cohen on the2:44 halachot Amira l'akum is highly recommended.2:46 It's highly recommended in general,2:48 but on the2:49 halachot Amira l'akum, he writes in the beginning,2:50 he says that these halachot are spread out all over,2:54 and not only all over Shas,2:55 but they're all over2:57 as well as they're all over in the Shulchan Aruch,3:03 the spread out.3:04 So therefore,3:05 if a person is interested to find out these3:10 halachot, you have to study a lot.3:12 As an introduction to what we're going to learn now,3:14 we're going to start going into the Ben3:16 Ish Chai. I'm going to try to focus on3:19 Amira l'akum, on what one could tell the goy,3:21 what one could hint to the goy,3:22 today's3:24 halacha, and the like.3:26 There's a lot of other3:27 halachot that we will bring as a side point3:29 to understand our3:31 halacha, but be'ezrat Hashem, we will hopefully get to them eventually.3:34 We will get to them and give them the proper time3:37 and proper explanation,3:38 and that will happen, be'ezrat Hashem, in its time.3:40 But right now, again,3:41 we're focusing on3:46 Amira l'akum. Okay,3:47 so now, before we get to that,3:49 we have a question.3:50 I don't want to leave them hanging.3:52 The question is,3:54 when is it mutar to tell a goy3:56 to put on a3:58 blech, an AC,4:00 or an AC?4:01 That's the question.4:02 When is it mutar to tell a goy,4:03 one, to put on a blech or an AC?4:04 In general, I'd like to clarify and explain4:07 why, when, and what,4:08 but we will just give you a quick answer.4:11 A blech is a little bit more complicated than an AC.4:15 Why?4:16 Because the4:18 blech, which my understanding of the4:20 blech, I hope everybody's understanding the same way,4:22 is that it's a4:24 stovetop with a metal sheet on top.4:25 So you don't put on the4:26 blech; you're actually putting on the4:29 stovetop. Putting on the4:30 stovetop is4:32 melacha de'oraita, which means4:33 it's forbidden from the Torah.4:34 You're not allowed to put on fire on Shabbat.4:36 In fact, that is the4:39 melacha that sticks out more than the other4:41 melachot. It says clearly in the Torah,4:43 Lo teva'aru esh4:46 b'chol moshvoteichem. It's clearly4:48 de'oraita. So to tell a goy to put on the fire4:50 is actually almost never mutar.4:54 There are cases when it's mutar4:56 for specific special reasons.4:59 In normal Shabbat-to-Shabbat cases,5:02 I don't think you have these cases.5:04 You don't have the time5:05 when you're going to be able to tell the goy.5:07 So therefore,5:08 a blech almost,5:09 I mean to say, the fire under the5:12 blech, kim'at, almost always5:13 you will never be able to tell the goy.5:15 In fact, even if you don't tell the goy,5:17 even if you don't even hint to the goy,5:19 the goy does it on their own,5:20 they put on the fire for you,5:21 it will also be forbidden to use and benefit from5:24 on Shabbat.5:26 This is one case, the5:28 blech. The other case is the AC.5:30 AC is a little bit more lenient5:32 because the way the AC functions5:33 and also how do you categorize the AC.5:36 I'm not saying that everybody agrees on it,5:38 but if you're5:40 Sefardi and you follow the opinion of Hacham Ovadia Yosef,5:43 Hacham Ovadia is matir5:44 for a person to tell a goy to put on the AC.5:47 Again, I'm not giving this halacha the proper time,5:50 but this is just halacha very quickly.5:53 In special cases,5:54 Hacham Ovadia is matir to put on the AC.5:56 If it's very hot,5:57 you could tell a goy to put on the AC.5:58 Not all poskim agree to this,6:00 but those who are6:02 Sefardim certainly could rely on it.6:04 In the shul, you can certainly rely on it6:05 if you're not6:07 Sefardim. And those who are, what's it called,6:09 if you—we'll get to it,6:11 be'ezrat Hashem—hopefully we'll get to explain why6:13 and when it's mutar.6:14 And like all cases,6:16 all the time we said in the past,6:17 any time we give a6:19 halacha, any time we give a leniency6:21 when it's mutar,6:22 we ask, please make sure you don't connect it,6:25 you don't apply it to any other area.6:28 If we said right now on air6:30 that you could tell a goy to put on the AC6:33 according to6:35 Hacham Ovadia. This doesn't mean every single thing6:37 you can tell the goy to do.6:38 You can put on now something else.6:41 This is specifically for the AC.6:42 HaChacham Ovadia gives a special6:44 heter when it's very, very hot.6:45 Okay, with that, we'll move on now6:47 to the halachot inside the Ben6:51 Ish Chai. I'm going to try to do,6:52 if you're following the Ben6:53 Ish Chai, whenever you're listening to this,6:54 I know some people get the recording of this class,6:56 so if you're following with this Ben6:58 Ish Chai, you should know6:59 I'm going to read the main parts7:01 that I believe are applicable to today,7:03 or the parts which I believe7:06 will be connected to the subject7:08 that I want to speak about.7:09 Anything that I don't feel is so practical,7:11 I'm going to skip,7:12 because I know most people7:13 are listening to this either in the car,7:15 driving,7:16 and they don't have a sefer in front of them.7:18 And of course, there's a lot of ladies7:19 that are probably busy with the kids7:21 in the background,7:22 in the carpool,7:23 or whatever it is.7:24 So we want to make it as interesting as possible,7:27 and at the same time7:28 to keep a class on the Ben7:30 Ish Chai. So let's begin with7:33 Halachah Tet, Parashat Vayishlach,7:36 Shanah Sheniyah. Kol7:38 davar she'asur l'Yisrael la'asoto b'Shabbat, says the Ben7:39 Ish Chai, anything—here's a general introduction,7:41 we gave all these introductions already,7:42 but now we're going to see it inside.7:43 The Ben Ish Chai writes,7:45 anything that's forbidden for the Jew to do on Shabbat,7:49 asur lomar l'nochri la'asoto. One may not tell the goy to do it on Shabbat either,7:53 afilu b'remez,7:54 even by just hinting to him.7:56 And this word, remez, hinting, is—8:00 People have a big misconception about what remez is.8:03 People think that remez, as long as I don't tell him anything, the goy does it, everything becomes mutar.8:07 Amirah is asur. For some reason, people think that remez is mutar.8:11 That's not what the Gemara says. The Gemara says that remez is also forbidden.8:16 Halacha brings that on. Remez, hinting to a goy, is forbidden.8:19 And like we've said many, many times, hinting to a goy, even if you don't hint to the goy and the goy does a melacha for you, it's also forbidden.8:26 Are there exceptions? Yes, there are exceptions.8:29 But here's the problem: when you take the exceptions and you make them the rule, that's when it becomes problematic.8:35 So we're going to see when the exceptions are, and we have to be careful not to apply the exceptions wherever we feel like.8:40 If there are cases that it's applicable for, or you might think that's applicable for, make sure you ask a competent8:48 rav. Here we go.8:52 This remez, says the Ben Ish Chai, I don't think it's only with words.8:57 Don't think if you, okay, so you tell me remez is asur. Maybe if I hint to the goy and I tell him,9:01 Oh, you know, it's dark in here, which alludes that, you know, you got to put on the light.9:05 I can't put on my light and the goy puts it on.9:08 You might think, okay, that's a case where it's asur, where I'm speaking to the goy.9:12 What if I give him a remez without speaking? What does that9:15 mean? That means I rub my eyes, and then he understands that it's too dark in here.9:20 I can't see in here, and he puts on the light for me.9:23 Maybe that's mutar? No.9:25 Even a remez, says the Ben Ish Chai, which is just by movement of the hands or any part of your body, that's also forbidden.9:32 Even to allude to the goy, to hint to the goy, to tell another goy to do something for you, that's also forbidden.9:46 I translated that loosely, but that is the9:50 halacha. Now, here is a remez. We're going to see a remez right now, which is mutar.9:55 In the case of the Ben Ish Hai over here, he brings down the case of a person, a Jewish person,10:02 who was owed money by another person who happens to be a goy.10:06 And now the person sees that the goy was available on Shabbat. You could have stopped him.10:12 The goy comes to visit on Shabbat because he knows the Jew can't do anything to him on Shabbat.10:16 And the Jew is owed, let's say, ten thousand dollars from this goy, and he needs to get his money.10:20 So to go up to him and tell him, Give me my money, you're talking about on Shabbat, and to ask for money, that's a problem.10:27 But what about to tell another goy? We just said even to hint to another goy is a problem.10:30 So what could you do?10:32 So the Ben Ish Hai says over here, you know what you could do?10:34 You could do the following.10:36 You could be meramez to the goy after Shabbat.10:40 Here, let's see this case.10:45 אתה מותר לו לומר לו בחול לשופט הנוכרי. You're allowed to tell a non-Jewish judge after Shabbat and tell him,10:51 מדוע לא לקחת הנוכרי בשבת שעברה? I don't understand. Don't you, the judge,10:53 don't you know that this person already filed and I told you that this person owes me money?10:57 How come you didn't do anything to this goy that came here last week?11:00 Why don't you stop him?11:06 אף על פי שמבין מתוך דבריו שיעקבינו ושבדות אבאים מזמן אז לעיר. Even though he understands, the judge now understands from this Jew11:11 that the next week, next Shabbat, when this goy comes, I'm going to have to stop him,11:14 it's still mutar.11:16 So what's going on?11:17 You just told me remez is asur. Now you tell me remez is mutar.11:21 Is this only by this case? Is this in general?11:25 So let's take a little bit of time to clarify this11:30 halacha. We want to talk a little bit about11:33 remazim, a little bit.11:34 This is, again, not the place for it.11:35 The real place for all these11:38 halachot, which, be'ezrat Hashem, b'siyata d'shmaya, we hope to cover them in depth,11:42 is in Parashat Terumah.11:44 And be'ezrat Hashem, we will jump from Parashat11:47 Beha'alotcha. After we finish the rules of halachot of11:50 amira l'akum, which is in Parashat11:52 Beha'alotcha, in Bein HaMetzarim, we will jump to Parashat Terumah,11:55 even though it's not in11:56 order, but in order that we should keep it on the same subject,11:59 amira l'akum, plus what you could tell the goy12:02 or what you could have hana'ah from melechet goy,12:04 we'll try to keep them all together12:05 to finish this way in one shot,12:07 all the halachot of12:09 amira l'akum. When it's going to happen, I don't know.12:11 I'm sorry,12:12 because the next week, next week is, I think, Tu B'Shvat.12:17 Next week is exactly Tu B'Shvat,12:19 and on Tu B'Shvat we like to speak a little bit about12:22 halachot berachot, so that'll be next week. Make sure you tune in.12:23 We'll speak a little bit12:25 of halachot berachot if you have any questions as well.12:26 And the following week after that,12:28 we have exactly two more or three more classes12:31 until we have to go into the halachot of the holidays of Purim,12:35 and then once we get into Pesach,12:37 after Pesach we have already12:39 Chol Hamoed, Sefirat HaOmer, so it's going to be a while till we finish these12:43 halachot. But still, keep tuned.12:45 We'll give you a little bit of, I guess, a preview today.12:49 Let's begin with laws,12:52 quick halachot of benefiting12:55 from what a goy does to you on Shabbat.12:58 Let's begin.13:01 Just like it's asur to tell a goy what to do on Shabbat,13:04 it's also asur for you to benefit from what a goy has done for you on Shabbat,13:08 whether you told him or whether you not tell him.13:10 That's called hana'ah mi'melechet goy13:13 b'Shabbat. Any time the goy does a melacha for you on Shabbat,13:16 you're not, in13:18 general—the general rule is you're not allowed to have hana'ah from it.13:20 Now, what kind of melacha are we talking about?13:22 What kind of thing did the goy do for you?13:23 Well, that depends.13:25 If the goy has done something for you13:26 that's asur min13:29 haTorah, then whatever this thing was13:32 done—now, even if it wasn't done for you,13:34 it was done for any Jewish13:36 person—no Jew may benefit from that melacha on Shabbat.13:39 Let's give you an example.13:41 An example is, here's two, three examples.13:43 Number one is what the questioner asked.13:45 The goy comes and puts on the fire on Shabbat.13:48 He sees your blech, he looks under the13:49 blech, he sees that the fire is out,13:51 on his own. It could be a housekeeper,13:53 it doesn't make a difference who it is.13:54 On their own, the goy comes13:56 and puts on the fire, clearly for the sake of the Jew.13:59 The goy doesn't use that fire;14:01 it's clearly for the sake of the Jew.14:03 Then no Jew may benefit from that fire on Shabbat.14:08 Even though there's a blech on it,14:10 you can't warm up food on14:11 it—not you, not your neighbor, not your cousin,14:13 not anybody else.14:14 It's a melacha which is forbidden from the Torah,14:18 and it was done for the sake of a Jew.14:21 Also, here's another example.14:23 It's completely dark in the room,14:25 and the goy puts on the candles.14:28 I'm specifically saying candles14:30 because everybody agrees that candles,14:32 lighting candles, is14:34 asur mid'oraita. Some even hold most electricity.14:37 Most opinions hold also that our electricity is also forbidden from the Torah.14:40 So let's say you have a light bulb,14:42 which most poskim hold14:43 that's asur mid'oraita, to light.14:45 So the goy puts on the light in the room,14:47 which is completely dark,14:48 and now you're able to see in that room.14:50 You may not sit in that room and read14:53 because the goy has put it on for the sake of you, of a Jew.14:56 But not only you,14:57 but any Jewish person cannot sit in that room and read15:00 because a melacha d'oraita was performed by a goy on Shabbat for the sake of a Jew.15:05 These are two small cases.15:08 Now, when are you allowed to have15:11 hana'ah? When are you allowed to derive benefit from the melacha that the goy has done for you,15:15 even though you didn't ask him, by the way,15:16 even though you didn't ask him?15:17 And the answer is, motzaei Shabbat.15:19 So had the goy warmed up water for15:21 you—warming up water, cooking water for15:24 you—is asur min haTorah. Bishul is one of the15:26 melachot, one of the 3915:27 melachot. The goy went ahead and he took a big pot of water.15:29 He knows that motzaei Shabbat you're planning to have this big party,15:32 and it's freezing cold outside.15:34 It's snowing,15:34 everybody's going to come cold,15:35 and you're going to make this hot water.15:37 You need this hot water in order to make this delicious soup,15:40 but you need to boil the water.15:41 So the goy goes ahead and cooks water for you.15:45 So how long does it take for that pot of water to15:47 cook? If it takes an hour,15:48 you may not benefit from that cooked water15:51 until Motzei Shabbat,15:53 an hour after Motzei Shabbat.15:55 This is applicable15:57 not only for you;15:58 that means the person who was done for.16:00 It's also true for any other Jew.16:02 Second example.16:05 The goy took a pot of water and warmed it up for me. I'm the baal habayit.16:10 My neighbor comes up from next door and he says,16:14 Hi, how you doing? Oh, hot water. I need some hot water.16:17 This is on Shabbat. It's forbidden for them also.16:20 Okay, motzaei Shabbat, he comes in.16:22 I can't give it to him motzaei Shabbat either.16:23 I have to tell him it was cooked by a goy.16:25 You have to wait the time it takes for the water to cook,16:28 in this case, an hour later,16:30 an hour after Shabbat is over.16:31 Let's say Shabbat is over at six, so16:34 seven o'clock, then every Jewish person, not only you,16:38 not only even your neighbor, anybody16:40 could have benefit from that hot water that was cooked on Shabbat.16:44 This is the halacha.16:46 The reasons for this halacha,16:48 we find two reasons in the16:50 poskim. Most opinions hold that the reason for this halacha is that,16:54 why is it? I didn't do anything.16:56 Did I ask the goy to cook for me?16:57 I didn't do anything. I didn't ask him.16:59 Why should it be asur that I shouldn't have hot water on Shabbat,17:03 that I shouldn't benefit from the fire that he put on17:05 or from the light that he put on?17:06 Nobody asked him. He did it on his own.17:08 And the answer is,17:09 we're scared that if we allow you to benefit from the17:12 melacha, from any forbidden thing that the goy has done for you,17:15 you may come to ask him the next week.17:17 You may come to ask him even that Shabbat.17:19 The point is that we're scared you're going to come to ask him.17:21 That's the reason the Rambam brings and most Rishonim bring.17:25 We find a second reason by Rashi.17:27 Rashi says17:28 the reason why we're forbidding you from the water or from the light17:31 or from the fire that the goy has done for you,17:33 even though you didn't ask him,17:34 it's because that you shouldn't benefit from any work that the goy has done for a Jew on Shabbat.17:41 That is category number one.17:43 Category number one, again,17:44 is when a goy does a melacha that's forbidden מן התורה for a Jew.17:47 No Jew may benefit from it until motzaei Shabbat,17:50 בכדי שיעשו, which means until the time it takes for that melacha to be performed.17:55 That's category number one.17:56 Category number two.17:58 When a goy does something for you that's only forbidden18:02 miderabbanan, what does that mean,18:02 it's only forbidden18:04 miderabbanan? Well, this takes a little bit more knowledge.18:07 We need to know, we need to have more information.18:10 We need to say, you have to know18:11 one is derabbanan, one is18:13 de'oraita. Let's take a case where it's18:16 miderabbanan. In the case where a person lives in a small little town18:19 where there's no street that qualifies as a street for reshut harabim.18:24 So let's say you live in a bungalow colony,18:28 or, you know, you happen to be there for Shabbat,18:30 even if you don't live there, you happen to be there for Shabbat,18:32 and the goy comes from the other bungalow colony to your bungalow colony,18:35 so that he traveled, he carried something18:37 from one bungalow colony to the second bungalow colony,18:40 and the distance between them was further from the techum of Shabbat,18:45 so that's carrying on Shabbat.18:46 He's carrying in reshut, you know, from reshut to18:51 reshut. Still, that is18:54 asur miderabbanan. He came from outside, he came all the way to your18:56 techum, he brought you something, clearly he brought it for the sake of a Jew.19:00 This is called19:02 a melacha derabbanan. It's forbidden for the Jew that was done for.19:06 That means he came to your house, knocked on your door, he says, Here,19:08 I am bringing you a whatever it may be,19:11 a gift, a present, whatever, I don't know what he's bringing you,19:15 a fruit platter.19:16 And the fruit platter, clearly the fruits were cut up from yesterday,19:19 and he's presenting it to you.19:20 You can't eat from that fruit platter today.19:22 What do you— you might say, I didn't ask him, he came on his own.19:26 Still, he carried it for you.19:27 He carried it in an area which is only forbidden19:30 miderabbanan. You can't benefit from it.19:32 But anybody else, anybody else that was not done for19:37 could benefit from it.19:37 What does that19:38 mean? Your neighbor comes in, he may have from the fruit platter.19:41 Because it wasn't done for your name, it was done for you.19:44 If your children want to have from the fruit platter, it's also forbidden,19:47 because when a goy is bringing you a present,19:50 when a goy is bringing you a fruit platter,19:52 he's not only bringing it for you.19:53 He knows he can't finish a whole fruit platter19:54 unless you're specific dimensions,19:57 but in general he's not bringing it just for you.19:59 He knows he's bringing it for you and the whole family,20:01 or if you want to serve it to other people.20:03 So if your neighbor comes and he takes on his own, he's allowed to take.20:05 But for you to present it as if it's your own,20:08 you're benefiting from the melacha of the goy, that's20:11 asur. But this is, again, only in20:14 melacha d'rabbanan. So let's review.20:15 Melacha d'rabbanan performed by a goy for a Jew20:19 is forbidden for the Jew to benefit from it,20:22 but only the Jew that it was done for.20:25 Any other Jew, any other Jewish person20:28 who is not in this picture, that means the goy didn't have them in mind,20:31 if it's melacha d'rabbanan, they're allowed to benefit from it.20:34 Good?20:35 So this, now we come back over here.20:36 Now you're going to ask,20:38 so if you're telling me20:40 I can't tell a goy what to do on Shabbat,20:42 and I can't have hana'ah from a goy, what to do on Shabbat,20:46 when in the world does this whole thing come with hinting to the goy?20:49 It's dark in here.20:51 You're telling me if he comes on his own, I can't even20:55 have hana'ah. And now over here, you're telling me even b'nei Yisrael, you can't even hint.20:59 But then you tell me there's a case where you could hint.21:01 So make up your mind.21:02 Could you hint to the goy?21:03 Could you not hint to the goy?21:04 When can you hint to the goy?21:05 Good question.21:06 And let's answer it like this.21:10 The cases of benefiting from the goy's melacha for the sake of a Jew,21:15 whether it's d'oraita or21:17 d'rabbanan, if, like we just listed,21:18 it's always going to be asur.21:19 Whether you hinted to him, told it to him,21:23 or he did it on his own,21:25 it's always going to be asur for you21:26 to—it's forbidden for you to benefit from it.21:29 The only thing is, if you tell the goy to do something for you,21:33 then you're transgressing an issur d'rabbanan of commanding a goy.21:36 If you hint to him,21:38 you could also be transgressing an issur d'rabbanan of communicating to a goy.21:44 If he does it on his own, you have not violated anything21:48 because the goy did it on his own,21:50 but you may not derive benefit from it.21:52 When could you be meramez the goy?21:55 When could you hint to a goy?21:57 And the answer is, you can hint to the goy in the following case,22:00 in a case where you are not getting a clear benefit22:07 or direct benefit, let's call it. See,22:08 I'm translating from Hebrew to English,22:11 so I may not get the exact words, you forgive me.22:13 But basically, you cannot get a direct new benefit22:20 from the goy's22:21 melacha. That is when hinting is mutar.22:23 Let me give you the case. It'll be clear with the case.22:25 I don't think the words actually fit.22:27 The case is as follows.22:29 If you are in a room where the light was on,22:32 but the light was not so, you know,22:36 let's say you have a dimmer,22:38 or if you're in a room which has many light switches22:41 and only one light was on.22:43 So could you sit in the room? Yes.22:45 You could even sit in darkness.22:46 Could you read in the room?22:47 And the answer is yes, I could read in the room,22:49 but, you know, it's hard to read,22:51 so it's not so comfortable to read. Let's be honest.22:53 I want to be in a room where it's completely lit.22:56 So in such a scenario,22:59 you may hint to the goy.23:01 You could be meramez to the goy23:04 by telling him, It's dark in here.23:07 That is a hint23:09 which is not in the form of a command,23:13 which is permitted. To benefit from23:16 when the goy does something for you.23:18 Meaning, I'm sitting in the room,23:19 there's four switches,23:22 and I need another five switches to go on.23:25 So that means six switches are going on.23:28 Forty percent of the room is lit.23:30 I could sit in here, I could read anyway,23:32 but I would like it, you know, it's Shabbat,23:34 and the Shechinah and the light23:35 and all the things that the Zohar speaks about,23:38 I want it to be very lit in here.23:39 That's how I like my Shabbat.23:41 My kids played with the lights, whatever it may be.23:43 Now six switches are off.23:45 I call in the goy and I say, you know,23:47 it's very dark in here.23:50 And the goy understands23:51 and puts on the other six switches.23:55 I could benefit from it.23:57 I could still remain in the room.23:58 I could still read in the room.23:59 Why?24:00 He hasn't added anything more. I was able to read beforehand. He just enhanced it.24:05 There was already light. He just enhanced the light.24:07 Also, my hint, my remez, was not a direct command.24:14 That means I didn't tell him, Oh, could you maybe stretch out your arms right next to the light switch over there?24:22 I didn't tell him to put it on. I just said, Stretch out your arms next to the light switch.24:25 Well, that means he understands I'm commanding him in that way.24:28 Even though I'm not commanding him directly to put on the light, that would be24:32 amirah. I only hinted to him. A hint in the form of a command is24:36 asur. What I did over here, what I said is, It's dark in here.24:39 So that saying, It's dark in here, the goy understands on his own, Oh, he needs more light.24:46 He didn't command me. Then he puts on the light for you.24:49 In that case, where there was already light, then it's mutar.24:51 And that's really what the Ben Ish Chai is saying over here.24:54 The Ben Ish Chai is saying over here, in a case where the goy came on Shabbat,24:59 you can't tell the goy, Go and catch him, because you're commanding him.25:02 You could hint, Motzaei Shabbat, you come to the judge and you say, Hey, Mr. Judge, why don't you stop the guy last week?25:09 You're not saying any command. You're asking him a question. You may have missed him.25:14 He understands on his own to do it on Shabbat, the next Shabbat.25:18 He's not doing melachah d'oraita. He's stopping whatever he's doing. He's stopping him25:22 to be maybe perhaps derabbanan, but he's not doing it,25:27 right, melachah over there.25:29 Then in that form, in that case, it is mutar to be meramez to the goy.25:34 Like we said before, all the rules of hinting to a goy are not here.25:39 The real halachot are in Parashat Terumah,25:42 and there, בעזרת ה', we'll spend much more time on it.25:44 I brought out the case, specific case of hinting to a goy where it's completely dark,25:49 because I know a lot of people stumble upon it. I know a lot of people make that mistake.25:52 They think if you just hint to the goy, it's automatically mutar. The goy does it on his own.25:57 First of all, you have to know not every hinting is correct,26:00 and even if the hinting is done in the proper way according to halacha.26:05 The melacha itself could sometimes be asur.26:08 Like we said, it could be asur even without the goy's hint,26:10 so we need to pay special attention to it.26:13 Up to here is, I believe, enough from the halacha in Halacha Tet of what we need.26:20 We'll move on now to the next halacha,26:23 Halacha Yud in the Ben26:26 Ish Chai, and it seems to be something that was very common in Ben26:28 Ish Chai. He talks about over here telling a goy,26:35 telling a goy.26:36 All these cases seem to be things with goyim and taking them to court for money that they26:41 owe. It seems to be something that was very common in his days.26:43 Let's go to Halacha Yud.26:45 Im ha-goy haya tafus b'veit ha-asurim bishvil Yehudi shechayav lo.26:49 Let's say you have a case where a goy was arrested before Shabbat.26:53 And he's staying on Shabbat in a jail because he owes money to the Jew.26:58 In the olden days, that's how they did it.27:00 Here, you have to hire,27:01 and nowadays you have to go hire a lawyer,27:04 and then go pay the lawyer tons of money27:06 until you chase after the guy, you bring him to27:08 court, and then after you bring him to court, and then maybe you'll win.27:11 And even if you win, it's really a settlement,27:13 and you get half your money.27:14 And even then, you can't collect your money because you have to hire the collection agency27:18 and pay them the other half of the money that you are really owed.27:21 So by the time you collect half your debt, you pretty much spent more than money.27:25 So why do people do it?27:26 I don't know, kavod or whatever27:29 it may be. In any case, back then, if a guy owes you money, they arrested him.27:33 That's how they did it in the olden country.27:34 They put him in jail until he pays you money.27:36 Now, in such a case, let's say the goy is arrested because of you.27:41 He owes you money.27:45 Mutar lomar laYehudi l'Moshel l'kabel arvut acher. So the Jew could tell the judge that if the judge wants, you don't have to keep the guy in jail.27:51 You'll let him accept something else as a collateral.27:54 You could take something else in its place,27:57 but you can't tell him to write it down.28:00 Write down that this person came and he gave me this collateral until he pays me my money.28:04 He's not getting back his collateral,28:06 because you're commanding a goy to write.28:08 Commanding a goy to write, according to most opinions, is asur.28:12 Writing, according to most opinions, is asur28:15 mid'Oraita, even though it's one of the 3928:17 melachot. There is one opinion that says if it's a different language, it may be only asur28:24 d'Rabbanan. However, that's not the opinion of the majority of the28:28 poskim. The majority of Rishonim hold that writing is forbidden28:32 mid'Oraita in any language, in any font. It doesn't make a difference if it's Times New Roman or Arial,28:38 it doesn't make a difference.28:39 Any language, any font, it is forbidden28:42 min haTorah. So for you to tell a goy— To write something for you,28:46 that's assur, if the writing is done for you.28:48 However, if the goy is writing something,28:55 im hamoshel me'atzmo kotev, ein lachosh. If the judge, in this case, for his own personal notes, he writes it down for his own personal notes,29:03 even though it's really your case, it's fine. You don't have to worry about it.29:07 Why?29:09 Because in such a case, he's not writing for you; he's writing for himself.29:13 What do you mean? It's my case.29:15 Yeah, but the judge doesn't want to forget it.29:17 The judge sees a hundred people a29:19 day. You're just number 48,29:21 so he's not going to remember your case.29:23 He wants to write it down.29:24 You never told him to write.29:25 He's taking his own personal notes.29:27 That's29:28 mutar. Before we finish halacha, we'll go into another example.29:31 Let's give another example where such a scenario,29:33 and this is a very practical, applicable case.29:36 People are sometimes away.29:37 They go away for Shabbat, for the holidays, whatever it may be.29:42 I think there's vacation now.29:43 We just came off winter vacation.29:45 So let's say, imagine you're in a hotel,29:47 and you go downstairs,29:49 and they have over there, they have a place where you can get drinks,29:55 and you can get drinks.29:55 The only thing is they ask you, What room are you in?29:58 And you tell them, I'm in room whatever it may be. I'm in room 48.30:02 And the goy on his own writes down that you took30:06 three cups—let's not use tea—you took three cups of soda,30:09 two bottles of Snapple.30:10 He's writing it down.30:11 That's fine.30:12 That's none of your business.30:14 Why?30:14 You're not buying it on Shabbat.30:18 What they do is they write it down,30:19 they send you the bill after Shabbat.30:21 Really, you're asking the goy for something30:24 that's mutar. You're asking for a cup of soda,30:26 and he's giving you a can of30:30 Coca-Cola, or Sprite, whatever you like, or Snapple,30:33 and diet, that is,30:34 and you're getting your diet Snapple.30:37 And the goy wants to remind himself that he shouldn't forget to charge you,30:42 so he writes it down.30:44 He's not writing for you.30:45 In fact, you don't want him to write.30:47 You want him to forget.30:48 You want to have that free snapple,30:50 because in the hotel they're going to charge you ten dollars for a Snapple.30:53 So in this case, where the goy is writing in the hotel room,30:56 he's writing down what your room number is30:59 and that you took three Snapples.31:01 He's writing it down.31:03 That is for his own sake,31:04 even though writing in general31:07 is asur min haTorah. And the goy, you can't tell a goy to write for you.31:09 In the case where the goy is writing for his own sake,31:12 it's mutar, like the case that Binyan Shai brings over here.31:15 The goy is recording something on paper.31:17 The judge in this case is recording something on paper31:19 not for you, but for himself,31:21 not to forget what the ruling that he gave.31:26 Let's continue31:27 now in halacha. Says the Bnei Yisrael,31:28 but this whole thing of going to the31:31 goy and to the judge31:32 and telling him to stop31:33 or to let out the prisoner31:34 and all these things,31:40 that's only where it might cause you some financial loss.31:43 But31:45 if there's no financial loss in such a case,31:48 meaning if the goy could stay in jail31:50 and you're still going to get your money back31:52 and it's not going to affect you,31:53 you're not going to lose any money,31:55 then you can't just go ahead and do your businesses on Shabbat.32:00 Also, you can't hold somebody else's possessions in another Jew's hand because of this.32:06 So basically, this is something we discussed beforehand,32:09 that's assuming because of32:12 mimetzo cheftzecha. Mimetzo cheftzecha means to do something that otherwise would have been mutar,32:17 but you're doing it for the purpose of business or whatever it may be.32:20 Over here, you're exchanging.32:21 If I would come to your house and all of a sudden it starts raining,32:25 could you give me—and I have a wool coat, you32:28 know—you say, No, you can't walk out in the rain in a wool coat because it ruins the lining on the inside32:35 and it comes out very—it ruins your coat.32:36 So now I want to exchange my winter coat, my wool winter coat, for a rain jacket that you have in your house32:43 because it'll protect me, it'll protect my suit on Shabbat.32:46 Can I do that?32:48 A hundred percent. But when it's being done over there for the sake of business, then you come into problems.32:53 So that's what we're talking about over here.32:55 If you're doing it for the sake of business, or something clearly looks like you're doing it for the sake of business,33:00 even though you're not speaking about it, you're only thinking about it,33:02 but that could be a problem33:05 with mimetzo cheftzecha. We didn't discuss so much the dinim of33:08 mimetzo cheftzecha; we discussed it in short, but in the general rule of the issur of mimetzo cheftzecha that says in the pasuk33:14 is anytime you're doing something that's distinguishable,33:17 that's for the sake of—basically the sake of non-Shabbat things,33:24 that's something that the thing you're doing it for33:27 is issur, then you cannot do it on Shabbat.33:29 Let's give you an example of this.33:32 The halacha says—let's give you first a question.33:36 Let's say a person is walking down the street and he gets tired.33:40 He wants to sit down.33:41 The only thing that he sees to be able to sit down is a bench by a bus stop.33:45 A lot of bus stops have little benches and he wants to sit there and rest.33:48 Is it mutar?33:49 And that's a gezeirah. It's mutar to sit there.33:52 Why? Because you're taking a break.33:53 You're not doing anything wrong.33:55 Ah, people might think.33:56 Well, let them think.33:57 What can I do?33:58 I'm tired. I need to sit down.34:00 However, being that most probably when people see me sitting by a bus stop,34:05 they're thinking that maybe I'm waiting for the bus.34:09 Now, nobody thinks I'm going to go on the bus now,34:11 but I'm waiting, really.34:13 They know me as a religious Jew.34:14 I got my beard and all,34:15 you know, and I got my kippah.34:17 But they know that I'm going to wait. I'm waiting by the bus stop until Motzaei Shabbat comes.34:22 So when Motzaei Shabbat comes right away,34:24 I want to get on that first bus out of the city,34:26 and I want to go to a different city.34:28 I'm waiting by the bus stop, sitting by a bus stop34:30 for the first bus to come, right when Shabbat is over.34:32 Since I'm sitting on Shabbat,34:34 and it looks like, clearly looks like when I sit on the bus stop34:37 that I'm waiting for the bus,34:39 even though I'm not doing technically anything wrong.34:40 I'm not saying anything.34:41 I'm not performing any34:44 melachah. I don't have my luggage with me.34:45 I don't have any bags with34:46 me. I'm just sitting by a bus stop.34:48 Since it's distinguishable, it clearly looks,34:51 my act of sitting down on the bus stop34:53 waiting for the first bus to leave on Motzaei Shabbat34:56 looks like I'm preparing myself for Motzaei Shabbat to leave on the bus,35:00 it would also be forbidden.35:02 That's the halachah. It may not be so applicable in New York City,35:05 where the buses, you35:07 know, most people don't use buses as transportation,35:09 but it's very applicable in Israel.35:11 In Israel, most people use the buses for transportation,35:14 not the cars, but buses,35:16 and you're going away by the bus stop,35:18 and the buses are running,35:19 and you want to take the first bus after Motzaei Shabbat out of the city35:25 to catch whatever you need to catch.35:27 You cannot do something that shows clearly that you're waiting to get out,35:31 that you're preparing yourself to get on that bus,35:34 such as sitting by the bus stop,35:35 waiting around the bus stop,35:38 because your action is distinguishable35:40 that you're doing35:43 mitzvah havshecha, you're doing your needs on Shabbat,35:45 even though you're not performing any35:47 melachah. In this case over here also,35:48 you're going and you're dealing with the courts35:51 and the judge and the police35:53 for your business dealings.35:55 They're only allowed if it's extremely,35:57 you know, there's a big financial loss35:58 and there's no other way to get around it,36:00 then they have a special heter.36:02 But otherwise, in a regular case,36:04 a person has to be36:06 careful and not to go and do such things.36:19 Halachah yud aleph. Im yesh l'Reuven al adam echad polisa, which means basically36:23 a document against him,36:26 sheba'al lomea echad al adam echad bizman yadua, I guess what we call a summons.36:34 V'zeh adam sheba alav hapolisa lo para bizmana Pharaoh. So now, this is a little complicated.36:37 I think we're going to skip this36:41 halacha. Okay, let's do36:44 halacha yud-bet, because case36:47 halacha yud-alef is a36:49 halacha which is not really applicable in our days,36:52 because in our days36:54 we don't, you know,36:56 I don't know what to tell you.36:58 I don't remember the last time I heard of such a case37:00 in our days.37:01 B'H, brings it, but we don't have such a thing in our days,37:03 so we're just going to skip it.37:14 Halacha yud-bet. Im ba lo ketav telegraph b'Yom Shabbat, v'goy lo mishallo oto l'Yisrael ella al yad sheyachtom ba'otam shelo, al neyar hakabbalah shehavi lo k'nahug. If a person gets a delivery on Shabbat,37:17 and this happens so often.37:20 People get deliveries on Shabbat.37:22 Why do people get deliveries on Shabbat?37:24 Well, it could be for a number of reasons.37:26 It could be because you ordered something online.37:30 It could be you ordered something to come for you on Shabbat.37:33 So as a general rule,37:35 you cannot order something37:37 from a store or from whatever, from a goy,37:40 and have it delivered for you on Shabbat.37:43 If you specify that it's going to come on Shabbat,37:46 that's asur,37:47 lemashal. If you order something online37:50 and they have, I think, an overnight delivery37:52 or the next day delivery will be exactly by your doorstep the next day37:57 within 24 hours,37:58 and you ordered this on Friday,37:59 you know it's going to be delivered on Shabbat,38:01 that's forbidden.38:02 You cannot do that.38:03 Same thing, it's not only if you order on Friday.38:05 If you tell the guy,38:06 if you tell the goy from a while ago,38:08 you tell him that38:10 I'm ordering something from you on Shabbat38:13 and I want you to deliver it for me, whatever,38:15 and the day comes out on Shabbat,38:17 that's forbidden,38:18 because here you're commanding the goy to do something for you.38:21 You can't say, No, I ordered and he's delivering it.38:23 Yeah, but you told him to come on Shabbat.38:25 Or you knew that it's going to come out on Shabbat,38:28 that's forbidden.38:29 Even if you don't mention the word Shabbat,38:32 Moshe Chachamim, even if you don't mention the word Shabbat,38:33 it's still forbidden.38:35 However, if you order something...38:37 And it happens to be they deliver on Shabbat,38:39 and there's no way you could control it.38:41 We all know that when you order something online,38:44 they deliver whenever they can.38:45 Even though they tell you38:47 if you choose the, you know, higher money,38:49 if you take the better shipping or, you know, option,38:53 we'll have it for you in five days.38:56 But otherwise, you're gonna have it in two weeks.38:57 We all know that you'll get it pretty much the same thing39:00 between five and seven days.39:02 Anyway, you're gonna get it,39:03 and you never know when you're gonna get it.39:04 Sometimes you'll get it in five days,39:05 sometimes you get it in four days.39:06 It's not something that you're paying for,39:07 so it's not guaranteed that it's gonna come or not on Shabbat.39:11 In that case, if it comes to you on Shabbat,39:14 you're allowed to receive it,39:16 but you have to be careful now afterwards.39:19 Once upon a time, they used to make you sign.39:21 Every time they delivered something,39:22 they used to make you sign.39:23 I don't remember the last time I was asked,39:25 and we order a lot of things online.39:27 A lot of things we can't go out,39:29 in my family we can't go out to shop and do,39:32 so a lot of things are ordered online.39:34 I don't remember the last time I was asked to sign something.39:37 But let's say you have such a case.39:39 That's the Bnei Shay's case over here.39:41 The delivery is made on Shabbat,39:43 not because you prompted it,39:45 not because you asked for it.39:46 It just happens to have come on Shabbat,39:49 and now they won't give it to you.39:50 It says over here,39:52 they won't give it to you unless you sign.39:54 So of course you have to39:55 decline. You're not allowed to sign.39:57 But in the Bnei Shay's case,39:59 so now if they—40:00 You're going to have to come pick it up. Okay, you can't sign.40:03 You can't sign for something on Shabbat.40:05 Remember, writing according to majority of opinions,40:09 writing even in a foreign language,40:11 that's m'deoraita. Even according to other ones,40:13 it's d'rabbanan. You can't do an issur d'rabbanan on Shabbat,40:14 especially the way they have the signatures today,40:17 it's electronic.40:18 So Bnei Yisrael, however, in their days,40:20 they wanted to confirm that whoever is writing it,40:23 whoever is receiving it, is the one who's supposed to receive it by a40:27 signature. So Bnei Yisrael gave a special heter, he says,40:35 that the Jew should have a signature that's already40:38 basically a piece of paper that's already signed,40:44 and write it in a foreign language.40:46 Have it already written in a foreign language.40:49 It shouldn't be in Hebrew.40:51 Like we mentioned before, according to the majority of opinions,40:54 the majority of opinions hold that writing even in any language is41:01 asur min haTorah. There are minority of opinions, not by the41:03 Or Zarua, and there's a few others that Rav Mordechai brings41:08 down, that hold that writing in a foreign language may be41:12 derabbanan. I think the Rama also goes with it as well.41:15 It's41:16 derabbanan. So therefore, according to those shittot at least, at least according to them,41:19 before the goy delivers41:30 it to you, before the goy gives it to you,41:38 he should leave it prepared for the41:40 goy, that this way the goy sees the signature right next to him,41:43 and he'll take the signature afterwards.41:45 He'll use it to sign, he'll use it to stamp, whatever it may be.41:48 Basically, you're meramez to the41:51 goy. Here's another form of41:53 remez. Here's a form of remez where it can otherwise incur a big financial loss.41:58 Bnei Yisrael is matir it only, why?41:59 Because there's no other option.42:01 Like we said, in our days, practically in our days,42:04 almost always when you order something42:07 and you say, I cannot sign it, it's my Sabbath,42:09 they respect it and they leave it alone.42:11 If in any case they tell you no, we need to take it back,42:15 you're gonna have to pick it up or you're gonna have to order it again.42:17 That's what you have to do. You can't sign.42:20 You can't even have them sign for you.42:21 You just take it.42:22 Most of the time, by the way, even if you don't answer the door,42:24 they leave it by your front door.42:26 So in our days, most of the things that you order, let's review again.42:29 If you're ordering things to be delivered to your house,42:31 if you have control to avoid delivery on Shabbat,42:38 then that's what must be done.42:40 If you don't have control to avoid delivery on Shabbat,42:44 which means it's not your option,42:45 you're just telling them to deliver it,42:48 and they could tell you two weeks or they could tell you seven to eleven days,42:53 and a delivery will come anytime,42:55 and it happens to be that it's delivered for you on Shabbat,42:57 let the goy put it down. You don't take it from his hand.43:00 A lot of times, even if you don't answer the door,43:01 they just drop it by your house,43:03 and everybody knows that they're not doing it.43:05 Nobody's gonna suspect you43:06 that you made sure that UPS delivers it to your house on Shabbat.43:10 Everybody knows43:11 you order things and they just come whenever they want.43:13 So you don't have that problem of accepting it.43:16 But you do have the problem if they ask you to sign43:18 and you have to say, I cannot sign,43:20 and if you have to pick it up, you have to pick it up.43:22 But most of the time, you don't have such a problem.43:24 Just tell them, I can't sign,43:25 or just let them drop the box on their own,43:28 and that will be fine with that.43:32 We have 15 minutes.43:34 Anybody would like to call in for a question43:37 or text in the question, which is probably better,43:39 text it to43:43 347-927-8398, or you could call43:51 718-683-5858. Halacha Yud Gimel. Maybe we can get one,43:54 the next43:58 halacha. You know, I'm gonna jump to44:02 Halacha Tet-Vav. Because it's connected a little bit,44:06 it's connected a little bit to what we just said.44:08 So a little bit out of order,44:09 but it's connected to what we just said.44:11 Hakhatat vav says,44:14 Goy shekanas sechorah miYisrael. Now let's do it the other way.44:16 Now the goy purchased something from a Jew,44:22 u'ba lehochabeshaban beShabbat. And now the goy wants to take it from your house on Shabbat.44:25 The purchase was made before Shabbat.44:27 He came to your house,44:27 you have some old, I don't know, some old furniture.44:31 It doesn't have to be furniture;44:32 it could be something small.44:33 You have an old watch,44:34 you had the garage sale,44:36 and the goy came,44:37 he liked what he saw,44:37 he paid you the money,44:39 he wants to take it now44:40 on Shabbat.44:42 Afilu beyesh eruv, even if there's eruv around44:44 and there's no problem of carrying,44:46 asur. Why?44:48 Kedei shelo yachsheduhu shemechalel lo beShabbat, because it looks like you're selling it to him on Shabbat.44:51 It looks like you're giving it to him to carry on Shabbat,44:53 and that will be44:58 asur. V'chein hu hadin hamarim u'gamanim shesachar etzlam laset lo masaot be'arvei Shabbat. Also,44:59 nowadays you have people coming doing pickups on Shabbat.45:03 Even though you hired them from before Shabbat,45:07 asur lehaniacham lavo lebeito beShabbat lehotzi masaot. You can't allow them to come to your house45:11 and pick up the deliveries.45:15 Af al pi shekatzatz. Even though45:16 the goy is doing it for his own sake,45:18 the goy is coming to do his job,45:19 he doesn't care about you anymore,45:20 he wants to get paid from the company,45:22 and because45:24 asur mipnei chashad, still, out of suspicion,45:26 it doesn't look good.45:27 People see the goy taking something from your house on Shabbat.45:31 That is a big problem,45:33 and it's asur on Shabbat.45:34 So let's make it a little bit practical.45:37 Sometimes you order things from certain websites.45:43 Let's use Amazon;45:44 it's very popular.45:46 And then you don't like what you received,45:48 whether it's45:50 damaged, whether it's45:50 whatever it may be.45:51 You receive something that you don't like,45:53 and you want to return it.45:55 So the process is that you call them up45:56 and you tell them,45:57 I'm not happy with my purchase,45:59 and they45:59 tell you, Okay, it's not a problem.46:01 We're going to send you a46:03 sticker, and you're going to put that sticker on the box.46:06 You put back the merchandise in the box,46:08 make sure everything is intact.46:10 Throw out anything else,46:12 put it in the box,46:13 put the sticker on it,46:14 and we're going to send UPS to pick it up from your house.46:17 Unbelievable customer service.46:18 You don't even have to take it to the next place.46:20 We're going to send you UPS to your door to pick it up.46:23 This happens.46:24 It happened to me.46:25 Again,46:26 if you, you have to tell them not to come on Shabbat.46:29 You have to tell them,46:31 please, I'm not home on Saturdays.46:32 I cannot do it on Saturday,46:34 whatever it may be.46:35 In case you forgot,46:36 they came on Shabbat,46:37 you can allow them to come and take it from your house on Shabbat46:39 because it looks like they're coming and working for you,46:42 and like you command them,46:44 you told them to come take it for you on Shabbat.46:46 It's not like the case of a delivery.46:47 The case of delivery,46:48 everybody knows these guys come randomly.46:49 And even over here,46:51 it may say,46:52 Ah, but it's possible that people will know that they come randomly.46:56 It's not the same.46:57 It's not like the other case.46:59 The case where they're bringing to you,47:03 the case where they're bringing you the delivery on Shabbat,47:07 is a case everybody knows47:09 that the goyim work,47:10 the companies send out,47:12 whenever it comes to your house,47:14 it comes.47:14 But over here,47:15 that they're picking up from your house,47:16 you have more control of it.47:18 You could tell them.47:20 You could deny them from picking it up.47:22 So the fact that you haven't stopped them47:24 from picking up your package on Shabbat,47:26 it becomes a problem.47:29 And here we have a question:47:32 can the goy sign the package for you on Shabbat?47:35 The goy may not sign the package for you on Shabbat.47:38 Like we said,47:41 signing, writing is asur min47:43 haTorah. Writing in a foreign language,47:45 which is the signature is accepted here in America,47:47 which is, you know, English,47:50 is47:52 asur mideoraita according to majority of opinions.47:54 According to some opinions,47:56 signing in a foreign language,47:58 that means any language.48:00 Then Hebrew is48:03 asur miderabanan. So therefore, in such a case where the goy is going to sign for you,48:07 even though it's going to be in English, according to majority of opinions it's48:11 asur min deoraita, so you're telling the goy to do something48:14 asur min deoraita, and according to the others it's still48:17 asur miderabanan. To tell a goy to do an issur derabanan is only permitted in specific cases,48:21 and I'm not sure exactly what the case may be over here.48:24 If it's going to be a big financial loss or just no financial loss, just a little bit of uncomfortableness,48:31 you can't just tell the goy randomly, Oh, just sign for me.48:34 You could say, Listen, I can't sign; do whatever you like,48:38 and the goy does whatever he likes,48:40 even though he may end up signing, but you didn't tell him to sign.48:43 He's doing it because he just doesn't want to—whatever he, you know,48:47 he's thinking either to make his life easier, he doesn't want to come back again for you.48:51 He's doing it mostly for himself.48:53 You couldn't care less.48:54 You're telling him, I can't sign for you.48:56 You want to do whatever you like, do whatever you like.48:58 I can't do anything more.49:00 So that you could do for Shabbat, but you cannot command the goy to sign for you on Shabbat.49:05 That is49:08 halacha tet-vav. We will get to halacha yud-gimel, and I believe we'll finish with the time that we have.49:14 And again, if anybody would like to ask a question off the air,49:18 we'll be here for another five, ten minutes right after the class,49:21 and the number to the studio is49:25 718-683-5858. Maybe we just wait till after the class and we finish this49:28 halacha yud-gimel, and then if you have any questions, you call into the station.49:33 Halacha yud-gimel: Im ba lo get hatumah. Let's say you received a letter on Shabbat,49:39 and you need to know what it says inside of it.49:41 And this, we've discussed this in the halachot of49:46 shtarei hedyotot, and we mentioned over there that letters,49:49 if it comes on Shabbat49:50 and you feel it's an emergency that they need to inform you49:53 and you need to see what it says inside,49:56 so you have heter to read it on Shabbat49:59 according to the din of50:00 Shulchan Aruch.50:01 However, it's not such an easy heter.50:04 Why?50:05 Because the heter is built on the following.50:08 It's built on the fact that it could be something that's an emergency50:11 that you need to know.50:12 So Moshe Feinstein already knocks out this heter in our days.50:16 You know why?50:16 He says, in our days,50:19 if a person wants to contact you because of an emergency,50:23 he is not going to send a letter.50:25 The letter is the last thing that he'll do if it's an emergency.50:28 You know what a person is going to do?50:30 He's going to call you.50:31 He's going to call you, or he's going to text you,50:34 email you.50:35 Email may be slow,50:37 but it's definitely faster than sending a letter.50:43 So therefore, in our days,50:45 any letters that come on Shabbat,50:48 besides the fact that most probably50:50 all these letters are50:52 not coming from a person that needs to tell you vital information50:55 that's prevalent to your life being or your physical51:00 well-being, so any letter that comes to you on Shabbat,51:03 you cannot have to go open it.51:04 You cannot have to go rip up the envelope for you.51:08 You can't even read that letter,51:09 even if the envelope was ripped already.51:12 Why?51:13 Because of the problem of51:15 shtarei hedyotot. Only if it's divrei Torah, it's something else.51:17 But if it's not divrei Torah,51:18 they fall under the category of51:20 shtarei hedyotot. To command the goy to open it for you,51:22 again, you'll find the heterim51:25 in halacha, but when you try to apply it51:27 in our days, it's not applicable51:29 because nobody is going to inform you of an emergency through a51:33 letter. So although the Ben Ish Chai talks about the letters,51:35 I wanted to point it out51:36 that that's in their days.51:37 In our days, if a person—51:40 the heter, excuse me, let's review.51:41 A heter of telling you—51:43 or, the heter, excuse me, a heter of reading something off a letter51:47 or reading from a letter that was delivered on Shabbat51:50 is because it may contain vital information that could be emergency.51:55 And this is not shayach today.51:57 This is not relevant in our days51:58 because people will inform you in different ways.52:00 We're going to stop over here at the end of52:03 halacha yud-gimmel. Next week, בעזרת השם, we'll jump to52:06 halacha yud-daled, and we'll jump to next halachot,52:10 halacha tet-zayin, and finish the parashah.52:11 Oh, actually, no. Next week is Tu B'Shvat,52:14 sorry. Next week we're going to speak about hilchot of berachot,52:18 a special class on hilchot berachot.52:21 בעזרת השם, that'll be next week,52:23 and— The week after that, we'll continue52:25 and we'll finish the halachot of52:28 Parashat Vayishlach. And be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully we'll continue from there52:31 the other laws, the other halachot of how to deal with a goy on Shabbat,52:35 and that is really when it's much more practical,52:38 much more applicable, those cases.52:40 And be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully we'll give it at the right time.52:42 We thank you for joining us,52:44 and we thank Iran and JRadio staff52:47 for everything that they do52:49 and they constantly do with us and everybody else.52:51 We'll see, be'ezrat Hashem, next week.52:52 This class will be aired on again tonight on52:56 JRadio.com at52:57 11 p.m. If you'd like to call in right now for the question,52:59 for any questions or comments,53:01 call at53:04 718-683-5858, or text at53:07 347-927-8398. Until next week, have a wonderful week.53:09 Shabbat shalom,53:09 and Hashem should bless you with everything that you do,53:12 and simcha with everything.