Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRoot Radio at jrootradio.com and to the Halacha Hour here on0:06 JRoot Radio. On Wednesday afternoon at 2 to 3, and we are here live from jrootradio.com. To listen to us0:12 besides through the online, you can also listen on the phone, and the phone number is0:19 712-432-4217. Or you can listen to 718-506-9099, and you'll dial 1 and then 1 again for live radio.0:27 Also, the JRoot Radio Pro app, and that's where you can also hear us here live on Wednesday afternoon, the Halacha Hour.0:35 We are back, and we are back from the holidays. However, we had a wonderful0:41 Shavuot, and the halachot that we're learning, we are learning from the sefer, the0:45 Ben Ish Chai. In the Halacha Hour, we work from the Ben Ish Chai. We go in the order of the0:48 Ben Ish Chai, and we discuss the halachot that are relevant, that are practical. We try to understand them as well.0:54 And like we said a long time ago, any halachot that we go, we read through0:58 the Ben Ish Chai. This is also good for a person who wants to learn the Ben Ish Chai inside; we follow along.1:03 However, the parts in the Ben Ish Chai which discuss subjects of Kabbalah or things that are a little bit esoteric,1:11 we try to avoid them, we skip them a little bit. We try to get to mainly the practical halachot.1:16 Let me give you the numbers to the station before we continue.1:20 The numbers are 718 to call in, 718-683-5858. Although there's no technician,1:26 I do have—I hope I learned how to answer the phone.1:30 So if you have any questions, you can call in live. Nobody will be able to screen.1:33 If you want to speak on the radio and you want to call in live, you'll call1:39 718-683-5858. If you don't want to be on the air, you want to ask a question after the class,1:42 so you'll wait till after 3 o'clock, and then you'll call in.1:46 I will announce the numbers then again,1:48 be'ezrat Hashem. If you want to text in, and that's the best way really because I have the computer right in front of me,1:52 if you want to text in your questions, you can text in at2:00 347-927-8398. Today's class is sponsored2:08 לעילוי נשמת ליאור בן רחיל. Le'ilui nishmat Rachel bat Zat Hashem, aleha hashalom. Today's class is sponsored in his memory.2:10 Let's begin.2:11 We are in Parashat Toldot, shanah sheniyah in the Ben2:15 Ish Chai. The subject that we are focusing on is Shabbat, and specifically the tefilot of Shabbat.2:21 Today's class will be focusing on the tefilot of Shabbat,2:25 and we'll be discussing also mistakes that happen when people pray on Shabbat,2:32 if you pray the wrong Amidah, and2:35 etc., etc. We are going to just catch up to those2:38 halachot. We'll begin with2:40 halacha vav. That's where we left off last time.2:41 Last time means a number of weeks ago when we were still in the Parashah of2:49 Toldot. Birkat Yishtabach. In tefilat Shacharit, we say every single day2:51 Yishtabach. It's a special2:53 tefilah. It's a praise where the Gemara tells us,2:56 Chachamim tell us, it was written.2:58 Some say it was written by Abraham3:00 Avinu, and some say it was written by Shlomo HaMelech.3:02 Either way, it goes and it dates very, very far back.3:05 And some say that even though Shlomo HaMelech wrote it,3:07 the blessing at the end...3:10 Baruch atah Hashem, Kel hahodaot, Adon niflaot,3:16 bon kol ma'aseh, habocher b'shirei Mosael, habocher b'shirei David3:17 Avdo. That's written by Abraham3:19 Avinu. Not to say the exact words,3:20 but the idea of the blessing was written by Abraham3:23 Avinu. So right away you see that's a very, very special3:26 shevach. It's a very special praise that we're saying to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.3:29 So he says over here,3:30 Birkat Yishtabach yesh3:33 yud-gimel shevachim. Now, thirteen praises that we praise Hashem in3:36 Yishtabach, and of course the number thirteen is not random.3:39 Vehem keneged yud-gimel mechilot d'rachamim, yud-gimel middot.3:43 They correspond to the thirteen attributes of Hashem.3:46 That's the one we say,3:47 Adonai, Adonai, Kel3:49 rachum v'chanun, when we say Vidui,3:50 and they also correspond to the thirteen ways3:52 that the Torah is3:54 nidreshet bahem. The number thirteen is very special in Judaism.3:56 Number thirteen is the gematria of echad, of one.4:00 The word echad, which means one,4:03 you find a lot of places, echad and echad.4:05 Number thirteen twice is4:07 twenty-six, which is the name of God,4:09 and there's a lot of connections to the number4:12 thirteen. So here also, in this praise,4:14 we say thirteen different praises of Hashem,4:17 and therefore,4:18 yomar otam4:20 b'nima uv'nachat ruach. When you're praying on Shabbat4:22 and you're saying these praises,4:23 not only on Shabbat, really4:24 in every single day,4:25 you should say them pleasantly,4:27 calmly,4:29 פי ולב שווים. Try to be4:30 mechaven, at least, at least over there in that4:32 Yishtabach. We know it's very hard to be4:33 mechaven throughout tefillah, but at least in the4:35 Yishtabach, you're giving praises to Hashem,4:37 at least over there4:38 try to think of the words,4:39 to understand what you're saying.4:43 Some of the poskim suggested4:45 that because we have, you4:47 know, this short-term memory,4:49 there's also short-term concentration,4:52 and because we can't concentrate4:53 for such a long time,4:55 so one of the poskim suggested4:57 that if you take a deep breath4:59 and you try to say everything in one shot,5:01 then you'll be able5:03 to at least focus right now5:04 on what you're saying.5:05 This way, because— You somehow5:08 could concentrate with one breath.5:10 Some suggested that.5:11 However, Ben Ish Chai says5:11 there's no obligation to do that,5:14 and because of that,5:14 some might as well take your time,5:16 say slowly,5:18 and try to understand what you're saying.5:20 Especially on Shabbat,5:21 and if you're praying in a shul5:22 and the chazzan is a little bit,5:24 you know, with5:25 na'imah, he's singing it anyway,5:26 take the opportunity5:27 to give the proper praise to5:29 HaKadosh Baruch Hu. That is a little bit more5:31 of5:31 musar halacha, but it's a little bit5:32 on the side of5:33 musar. Now we get to a little bit5:35 practical5:42 halachot. If a person is up to5:44 Yishtabach, and he's about to get to the 13 praises,5:46 where we say,5:49 Shir u'shvachah, lev, you know, all the praises are listed in5:52 Yishtabach, and you see that the kahal5:53 is about to get up to Kaddish,5:54 chazzan's already up to Kaddish,5:56 or maybe you're very behind5:58 and they're up to5:59 Nakdishach, basically they're saying6:01 the davar shebikdushah that you have to answer.6:03 Don't begin and then6:04 interrupt in the middle to answer,6:05 because you have to answer Kaddish.6:07 You have to say6:08 Kadosh, Kadosh, Kadosh, and you have to answer amen6:09 to the Kaddish.6:11 So what you should do is6:12 wait until they finish the Kaddish,6:15 or they finish6:17 Nakdishach, they finish the6:19 Kedushah. After you answer with them,6:19 you go back and you say6:20 the 13 praises al6:23 ha-seder, and you can continue from there.6:24 And that's important.6:25 Even if you got interrupted,6:26 you didn't pay attention,6:27 and in the middle of the 13 praises,6:28 and you got interrupted6:29 and you had to answer Kaddish,6:31 Ben Ish Chai, I believe,6:33 in Parashat Vayigash,6:35 he says that you should go back6:36 and repeat the 13 praises one more time,6:39 in this way that you don't interrupt6:40 in the middle.6:41 Okay, that's the6:43 halacha. That's in Halachah Vav. In Halachah Zayin,6:45 like we mentioned in the beginning6:47 of this class,6:48 it talks about the blessing6:49 of different parts of6:51 Yotzer, all different parts of the Amidah,6:53 and he brings some different6:56 פירושים, some6:57 al pi pshat, some6:58 al pi Kabbalah. You look inside on your own.6:59 Like we said,7:00 we're not going to go through7:02 halachot that are just7:03 mefaresh. We want to go,7:04 we want to touch on things7:05 that are practical.7:06 We move on now to7:08 Halachah Chet in Parashat Toldot.7:10 In7:11 Halachah Chet, the Ben Ish Chai says,7:15 Im techilah me'il la'aretz makom, hakol yaducha, k'mon hagoah bachol. So let's give a little bit of7:18 background before we come to this7:20 halacha. Every single day7:21 we say7:22 birchot of Kriat Shema.7:23 What are the blessings of Kriat Shema?7:26 They're not like a7:27 blessing on any other mitzvah.7:29 When you come to perform a mitzvah,7:30 let's say7:31 netilat7:32 yadayim, so you make the beracha on netilat7:36 yadayim when doing the mitzvah.7:37 You make a beracha on tefillin.7:40 You say the blessing7:41 and then you do the mitzvah of tefillin.7:43 We have berachot on mitzvot,7:45 and we say the berachot usually,7:47 usually before we perform the mitzvah.7:51 The berachot of Kriat Shema7:53 have nothing to do,7:54 like the Geonim already explained,7:56 the berachot, we find it,7:57 the berachot have nothing to do7:59 with the...8:01 Kriat Shema. They were instituted because it says,8:04 Sheva bayom hillalticha. It's a pasuk, it's a verse that David HaMelech says,8:08 Hashem, I praised You seven times a day,8:10 and therefore they instituted seven blessings around Kriat Shema.8:14 We say Kriat Shema in the morning, we say Kriat Shema in the evening.8:17 Kriat Shema in the morning, we have three blessings around it,8:20 two beforehand and one afterwards.8:22 What are the two blessings beforehand?8:29 The beracha of Yotzer HaMe'orot, and it begins, Baruch atah Hashem Elokeinu Melech ha'olam, yotzer or u'vorei choshech. That is the beracha, the first beracha, the first blessing before Kriat Shema.8:36 The second blessing is Ahavat Olam,8:38 some say Ahavah Rabbah, the Ashkenazim say Ahavah Rabbah,8:41 and it ends, Baruch atah Hashem, bocher b'amo Yisrael b'ahavah, right before we say Kriat Shema.8:47 And then after Shema, we say the third blessing in the morning,8:50 and that's the beracha of Ga'al Yisrael.8:52 These are the three blessings in the morning.8:55 In the evening, we have two berachot before Kriat Shema8:59 and two berachot after Kriat Shema.9:01 The two before Kriat Shema is9:04 HaMa'ariv Aravim, that's the first one.9:06 The second one before Kriat Shema of the evening is9:11 Ohev et amo Yisrael, and the third beracha after Kriat Shema in the evening9:14 is Ga'al Yisrael, and the fourth one is9:18 Hashkiveinu, which concludes with beracha of Shomer et amo Yisrael9:21 la'ad. Those are the seven blessings around Kriat Shema.9:24 Like we mentioned, it's not the blessing of Kriat Shema,9:28 but the blessings that were instituted around Kriat Shema,9:31 okay?9:32 It's important to keep that in mind when we get to, later on,9:35 when we get to it later on in the class, in the shiur today.9:39 Here, what happens, if you notice,9:41 you'll pay attention to it this Shabbat,9:43 and hopefully you already noticed beforehand,9:46 the blessing of Yotzer Or, which happens to be, by the way,9:48 Yotzer Me'orot, is the longest beracha that we have in Judaism.9:55 We have other berachot, but most berachot are very short.9:58 Even9:59 birkat hamazon—it's a birkat hamazon, not necessarily long.10:02 It's four different blessings plus10:04 haRachamans; it makes it long.10:05 But one single blessing in the whole Torah, the longest one,10:08 Yotzer10:09 Me'orot. This was pointed10:10 out—I realized it from listening to Rabbi Victor Miller, zatzal.10:13 The longest blessing that we have is Yotzer10:15 Me'orot. We praise God for the lights that He created,10:17 the luminaries that He created.10:19 That's the first one that we say in the morning.10:21 That's the first of the three berachot Kriat Shema that we say in the morning.10:26 Now, in the berachah on Shabbat, we change the text.10:30 It changes a little bit.10:31 We change the nusach to the Shabbat10:34 mode. It's a little bit different on Shabbat than it is during the weekday.10:37 Ben Ish Chai here talks about a person10:39 who knows, let's say, by10:40 heart—a lot of people already, after praying for so many years, already10:43 they know the berachot by heart.10:44 And a lot of times, although they have the siddur open in front of them,10:46 they might even be looking in the siddur, really saying it by heart.10:49 So let's say a person began the berachah of Yotzer,10:55 or he began the one that we usually say during the weekday.10:59 Instead of HaKol Yoducha, he started saying11:03 HaMe'ir LaAretz... instead of HaKol Yoducha, and whatever the text is on Shabbat.11:07 What should you do?11:09 So the halachah is, if you remember in the middle,11:11 so what you do is you go back and you say HaKol11:13 Yoducha. You go back and you say—you fix yourself.11:16 Here the Ben Ish Chai says that11:20 this halachah, and he says, however,11:23 if you get up to the end,11:27 when the person got up to the end,11:29 he got up already to this berachah where he says,11:31 Baruch Atah Hashem, Yotzer11:34 HaMe'orot, and only at the end he remembered11:36 that he forgot, you know, to say the berachah properly.11:40 So here the Ben Ish Chai says that11:43 what you should do is11:45 you should not go back to repeat the berachah,11:48 because you began properly.11:50 The beginning of that blessing you said Yotzer Or11:53 u'vorei choshech, and the end you said Yotzer11:55 HaMe'orot. Even though, you're right, the middle is different on Shabbat11:58 and he didn't say the proper thing that it's supposed to be said on Shabbat,12:04 still, yatza yedei chovah mi'dei avad. But he does recommend that a person should repeat the berachah12:09 of— Yotzer or without reciting Hashem's name,12:14 which means it should go like this:12:15 Baruch atah, without saying Hashem's name,12:17 just think about Hashem's name,12:19 which is Hashem Elokeinu melech haolam,12:21 yotzer or12:25 uvore choshech, hame'ir laaretz v'ladarim aleha b'rachamim, and continue till the end.12:26 When you get up to the end of the blessing,12:28 don't say Baruch atah Hashem yotzer12:29 hame'orot; just say Baruch atah.12:30 Think of Hashem's name in your12:32 mind, and then say yotzer12:33 hame'orot. That's what Ben Ish Chai says to do right there on the spot12:35 before the12:36 bracha v'ahavah rabbah. And he says it's not considered an interruption12:38 because it's part of the blessing,12:41 and therefore you could still say birkat yotzer12:45 hame'orot, but without Hashem's name.12:47 That's very important.12:48 That's the opinion of the Ben12:49 Ish Chai. So again, let's review very quickly.12:51 If on Shabbat we change the text12:54 of the first blessing of Kriat Shema,12:57 we say a different text that's specific for Shabbat.13:00 If a person by mistake said the one for the weekday,13:03 then you go and you remember13:05 before concluding the13:06 bracha, before saying Baruch atah Hashem yotzer13:08 hame'orot, then you go back and you begin from13:10 where the difference is.13:14 You begin from13:20 Hame'ir laaretz, you begin from13:21 Hamekol yoducha, and you continue along till the end.13:23 If you concluded that berachah,13:24 if you finished that first berachah,13:26 then you do not repeat it.13:28 The only thing you do is13:29 you do repeat without saying the name of Hashem.13:33 And even if you didn't say the thing,13:35 if you didn't repeat it,13:35 but13:36 ya'avad, you still13:38 yotzei yedei chovah. Now that we're on the subject of13:39 birchot Kriat Shema,13:40 I'm going to go off tangent just for a little bit,13:42 but a very important halacha.13:45 There's a halacha that a lot of people slip on.13:48 A lot of people don't realize13:49 the importance of this halacha,13:50 and I'm going to read you the words of13:52 Shulchan Aruch.13:52 Even though the words of Shulchan Aruch are not here,13:54 the words of Shulchan Aruch are found in—13:58 Siman nun, chelek in the halachot of14:00 Kriat Shema in the morning,14:02 but the applicable,14:04 most probably, will have an issue with this halacha14:07 specifically on Shabbat.14:08 Let me read the words of the Shulchan Aruch.14:10 He says,14:11 We know that there are two times,14:13 if you look on the calendar,14:14 you'll see two times on the calendar.14:16 One time14:17 it will say—I mean, one of the times,14:18 the zmanim on the calendar will14:20 say—the time,14:21 the latest time that a person could read Kriat Shema.14:24 There's another time on the calendar that will say14:26 the latest time for a person to pray,14:32 zman tefillah, סוף זמן תפילה. What סוף זמן תפילה for us means,14:36 very important, is that14:38 we cannot say the blessings of Kriat Shema after that time,14:42 and if one does,14:44 it's considered a14:46 berachah levatalah. Let me read to you the words of the Shulchan Aruch.14:53 Af al pi shezmanan nimshach ad sof hasha'ah hashelishit. Even though Kriat Shema,14:54 the time you could read Kriat Shema14:57 is until the end of the third hour,15:01 im avrah sha'ah gimel velo kara, if a person already didn't read Kriat Shema15:06 after the third hour,15:10 kore otah birchoteha kol shaah reviit, you could still read Kriat Shema15:13 with its blessing15:14 until the fourth hour.15:16 What is the fourth hour?15:18 Shehu shlish hayom, which is the third part of the day.15:22 Veein lo sechar kikore bizmanah, but you don't have a reward of reading Kriat Shema15:25 like you read it on time.15:26 Meaning, with Kriat Shema it says in the Torah,15:29 bshochbecha uvkumecha. You must read it when you go to sleep15:31 and when you're waking up,15:33 which the Chachamim interpreted,15:35 it doesn't mean you, you personally;15:37 it means when most people go to sleep,15:39 when most people wake up.15:42 And the time for us to know when people wake up,15:44 the Gemara established15:45 that you have three hours15:47 from the time the morning begins.15:49 Until three hours later,15:50 that's the time to read Kriat Shema,15:52 says15:53 Shulchan Aruch, and that's the halacha in the Gemara.15:54 If you read past that time,15:55 if you didn't read Kriat Shema15:57 till after that time,15:58 okay, you lost the—16:00 You get reward for reading it on time, but you still have to read Kriat Shema.16:03 What about the blessings of Kriat Shema? Remember we mentioned the blessings of Kriat Shema have nothing to do with Kriat Shema.16:08 It's just something that was instituted around it,16:10 and that's really, those blessings are part of the tefillah, part of the prayer.16:14 And therefore, if a person was late in reading Kriat Shema,16:19 the blessings of Kriat Shema, you still have time to read it.16:22 Until when do you have time to read the berachot of16:26 Kriat Shema? Says Shulchan Aruch, up till the fourth hour.16:32 If a person already passed the fourth hour and he didn't read it yet,16:39 then you cannot read those blessings of Kriat Shema. You could only read Shema.16:43 It's over. You cannot say the blessings.16:45 So you see, according to Shulchan Aruch, a person who says Kriat Shema,16:49 or better yet, a person who says the berachot of Kriat Shema, which we just mentioned beforehand,16:53 the three berachot, the two before Kriat Shema and the one afterwards,16:56 he says them with the blessing.16:59 After the zman of tefillah, it's considered17:03 berachah levatalah. He says you're not allowed to read it afterwards.17:06 What's called four hours, he says over here in Shulchan Aruch, four hours.17:09 So there's a famous machloket. This is not the time to go into it.17:13 Bezrat Hashem, we hope to make a special class just on the subject.17:16 There's a machloket between the Magen Avraham and the17:19 Gra, because in the Gemara we find that daytime, we have two different times17:25 when the day is really considered day.17:27 We find some places, we find that the alot hashachar, which is what we call in English dawn,17:33 this is the first sign of daybreak.17:36 That's called daytime. We find some places it's called daytime,17:39 and we find also netz hachamah, which is sunrise, is called daytime.17:43 What's really considered daytime according to17:45 halacha? So lechatchilah, we rule that everything that has to be done in the day,17:49 like for example, brit milah, tefillin, lulav,17:52 all of these should be lechatchilah performed after sunrise.17:57 However, If they were performed before sunrise,18:00 if a person, b'poratefilin, if a person, let's say, did brit milah,18:07 circumcised someone before sunrise,18:10 as long as if it was after18:12 alot hashachar, and sometimes even after a certain time called mishyakir,18:16 then already18:19 yatzata b'dei chovah, b'diavad. This is only b'diavad; it's not a preferable way of fulfilling the mitzvah.18:22 The difference here now is not really in performing the mitzvah,18:25 but really in calculating.18:27 Remember, the Gemara says, Kriat Shema,18:30 also the Gemara says also zman tefillah,18:31 you have three hours for Kriat Shema from the beginning of the day.18:36 So what's called the beginning of the day?18:38 Is alot hashachar, dawn, which is much earlier than sunrise,18:40 or no, you begin the day from sunrise?18:43 So that is a machloket between Magen Avraham and the Gra.18:46 According to the Gra, the Omer Vilna,18:49 he holds that the day begins at sunrise18:51 and the day finishes at sunset.18:53 That's also the opinion of the Rambam.18:55 And therefore, when you calculate the time,18:57 when you calculate the time of the day,19:00 you calculate within these two times,19:03 between sunrise and sunset.19:04 And that's how he gets to his times,19:06 whether it's Kriat Shema, zman tefillah, whatever it is,19:09 that's called the zman of the Gra.19:11 According to the Gra, that's what it means.19:13 According to the19:15 Magen Avraham, based on the understanding of19:18 Shulchan Aruch, he says that the beginning—19:31 According to the—19:36 sorry, let's— technical difficulties, one more time.19:38 According to the19:40 Magen Avraham, the day begins at alot19:43 hashachar and ends19:46 by tzeit hakochavim. And therefore the time, according to the19:48 Magen Avraham, is calculated between alot and—19:53 Seta Kochavim. And therefore, when we say three hours you have to read Kriat Shema,19:56 it means you have to start counting from alot19:58 hashachar. And when it says you have four hours to pray,20:02 it means from, one, from alot20:05 hashachar. Obviously, the zman, the time of the Gaon of Vilna, the Gra,20:07 is going to be later than the time of the20:11 Magen Avraham, because Magen Avraham begins his day from alot20:14 hashachar, which is earlier, from dawn,20:15 while the Gra begins his day from sunrise.20:17 And this is when you see on the calendar20:19 the zman of the Gra, the zman of the20:21 Gaon of Vilna—I mean, the zman of the Gra, the zman, the time of20:25 Magen Avraham. This is what it's referring to.20:26 It's a question of how do you calculate the hours of the day.20:30 From when do you begin calculating it?20:33 Obviously, the time of the Gaon of Vilna,20:34 the Gra, will never change20:36 on any calendar. Whenever it says20:38 this is the zman of Kriat Shema for the Gra,20:40 it's always the same,20:41 because you take the time from sunrise to sunset20:43 and divide it by20:44 twelve. According to20:46 Magen Avraham, we said that you calculate the day20:48 from alot hashachar until tzet hakochavim.20:53 The question is, what's called alot20:55 hashachar and what's called tzet hakochavim?20:57 That is a big, big—I don't want to say21:01 machloket, but it's a big discussion.21:02 It's very, very complicated.21:04 For sure this is not the time.21:05 I don't know if we can even possibly make a whole class on this.21:08 So therefore, you'll see sometimes21:10 that the zman of21:12 the Magen Avraham varies in different calendars.21:14 Some will have it at this time,21:15 some will have it at a later time,21:16 because it all depends how you calculate alot21:18 hashachar and how you calculate tzet hakochavim,21:20 and then the time in between.21:21 In any case, what we do have for sure is21:24 that Kriat Shema,21:26 you have to read it three hours after21:31 daytime. You cannot read it past that time.21:34 And brachot Kriat Shema,21:35 you have four hours to read it.21:37 Now, I'm going to give you the times in June.21:40 June, you should know,21:43 the calendar, the zemanim calendar will always be the same21:46 every single day of the year21:47 because since it's based on the sun.21:49 So every June 11th will always be the same time.21:54 Every December 4th will always have the same time21:58 in that city that you're living in.21:59 It will always be the same22:00 zman because it works on the calendar of the sun,22:03 and the sun doesn't change.22:05 So therefore, in June,22:06 which we're right in right now,22:08 this is the time when you find that the day is the longest,22:11 and this is the time that you find the alot hashachar is the earliest.22:14 And the times right now for the latest time for a person22:17 to say the blessings of Kriat Shema22:21 is, according to the22:25 Magen Avraham, 9:38 a.m., and according to the Gra, it's22:28 10:25 a.m., okay? So that means, let's go with the later time,22:32 10:25 a.m. according to the22:34 Gra, okay? So let's say a person wakes up22:36 and he sees that it's already22:39 10:30 and he wants to pray right now,22:41 he cannot say the blessings of Kriat Shema.22:44 He is not allowed to say it.22:46 Why? Because according to Shulchan Aruch,22:48 saying it is considered22:50 bracha levatalah. You're not allowed to say the blessings22:51 after that time.22:52 Chachamim instituted that you should say it only after that time,22:54 and once it's past that time already,22:56 you have no permission to say it.22:57 Now, is this the only opinion? No.22:59 There's a machloket regarding this.23:01 There's different opinions of when a person23:03 could say brachot Kriat Shema.23:04 Some say you have until23:07 chatzot, and some say you have the whole day23:08 to say the brachot of Kriat Shema.23:11 I'm talking now to23:13 Sefardim. Amongst Ashkenazim,23:14 you also have a big machloket over here.23:16 But amongst23:17 Sefardim, we are very, very particular when it comes to23:23 safek brachot lehakel. Whenever we have a23:24 machloket when it comes to the subject of23:27 berachah, we're always going to be23:30 machmir, and we're going to say23:31 since there's opinions that say23:32 you're not allowed to say23:33 a berachah, you can't say23:35 a berachah. Now, who are the opinions that say23:36 you cannot read the brachot of Kriat Shema23:41 after the zman of23:44 tefillah, after23:45 10:25 a.m.? This is, by the way, the earliest time that he gets,23:47 10:25. Who's the one who says this?23:50 So first, we already told you23:52 Shulchan Aruch.23:53 Also the Ben23:55 Ish Chai in the sefer23:59 Od Yosef Chai, the Kaf HaChaim, Chacham Ovadia Tiyeh, as Olat Zion brings.24:00 Or LeTzion himself, Hacham Ben Tzion Abba Shaul zatzal, and Hacham Ovadia. You have these Sefardi giants over here24:07 that are the poskim, first of all Kabbanu, Orot Maran, and also the Ben Ish Chai, Kaf HaChaim, Hacham Ezra Attiya, Or LeTzion, and24:14 Hacham Ovadia, all of them saying if it's after 10:25 a.m. in June, or whatever the time may be, if it's after four hours in the morning,24:21 you're not allowed to say the brachot of Kriat Shema. It's asur.24:25 Let me read you a quote from the Chida in24:28 Chaim Sha'al. Chida says,24:36 Bemotza'ei b'nafshi al rabim ba'arim ha'eil shekor'im Kriat Shema birchoteha achar sha'ah revi'it. He says, I have so much pain, so much suffering about the people in these cities who wake up and they read Kriat Shema with its blessings24:45 after the fourth hour.24:48 She'einam kamin bsha'ah shetzibur mitpalelim. They don't wake up on time when the tzibur is praying on time.24:51 Ukshekamim avazman Kriat Shema, by the time they wake up, already the time of Shema, they lost.25:00 Ukshemitpalelim vkorin Kriat Shema byachid, bsha'ah revi'it, by the time they pray, and they're praying byachid, already it's past the fourth hour. They're קורין קריאת שמע בברכותיה, and they're still reading Kriat Shema with25:12 its blessing. He says, Vkamma chataot chot'im lhitpalel byachid vlabeit knesset kedushah. And how many sins are they doing by praying alone?25:16 And when you pray alone, you don't have kaddish, you don't have nakdishach, you don't have25:22 kedushah, umvarchim brachot yotzer neged ma shepasak Maran, and they're making brachot of Kriat Shema, the brachah of Yotzer Or and Ahavat Olam,25:30 they're saying it with the blessing against what Maran ruled,25:33 because Maran said after the fourth hour you're not allowed to make a25:37 berachah. So therefore, a person has to be aware of this.25:40 A person has to know that if it's past this zman of tefillah, you cannot say the brachot Kriat Shema.25:46 Now, I just told you the earliest it gets is25:49 10:25 a.m. You can be meikil to go with the opinion of the Gra, because it's25:54 a din deRabbanan, safek deRabbanan lekula. But if it's past that time, you have to be careful.25:56 Now, when this is usually a problem.25:58 It's a problem in the following.26:00 Usually, during the weekdays, you don't really have such a problem.26:03 If you're that late, if you're waking up and you're praying Shacharit at 10:25, you have bigger issues.26:09 You know, it's a different discussion for right now.26:12 Most people during the weekday, they're going to work, they have something to do, they don't wake up that late.26:16 But it really happens, unfortunately, on Shabbat.26:18 On Shabbat, you know, most minyanim pray later,26:21 and that's brought down also in halacha, to pray a little bit later on Shabbat.26:24 And a lot of—majority of the minyanim that I know pray later on Shabbat,26:30 give you a little bit more time to sleep.26:32 But yet, halacha, what he does is he extends our sleep even longer than that little time.26:38 And what happens is we wake up much later,26:40 and that's when we have an issue on Shabbat.26:43 Not only that, sometimes the minyan that you're praying at could pray very late,26:47 and you're just following the minyan.26:48 You say, Hey, what's the big deal? I'm just following the minyan.26:50 In a lot of shuls, we have a very big shul.26:52 People come late.26:53 The main minyan starts on time,26:55 meaning to say on time of the halacha, whatever,26:57 and then you have a few26:59 youngsters—it doesn't have to be necessarily youngsters, but a few27:02 latecomers—and by the time they come to shul, so they have what they call a hallway minyan.27:06 They have like a side minyan on the side,27:08 and they catch no hazanut. They just go quickly to catch up.27:11 By the time they finish their Shacharit already,27:14 they caught up to the main minyan, up to the Hazarah, up to—27:20 Kriat Shema. You have to be careful.27:21 If they're praying after the zman of Kriat Shema,27:24 you cannot say the brachot of Kriat Shema.27:26 If you can tell them, if you can teach them and educate them,27:29 hazak27:30 u'baruch. But if you can't convince them,27:31 you can't show them all these opinions I just showed you,27:33 then you yourself have to know that it's assur for you to say the27:36 brachot. The second time this happens27:39 is sometimes they have bar mitzvahs in the morning27:41 and they have sometimes brit milahs in the27:43 morning, which begin very, very late.27:45 I don't know why they begin tefillah 9,27:48 9:30, sometimes even later than that,27:50 and it can happen maybe in the winter,27:51 maybe it happened, whatever it is,27:52 it happens that the zman of Kriat Shema27:55 or the brachot of Kriat Shema,27:57 by the time already they're getting up to it,27:58 especially if it's a Sunday brit milah28:00 and they started very late,28:01 already it's past the time of brachot Kriat Shema.28:06 And if you're praying in such a minyan,28:07 you're not allowed to say the brachot Kriat Shema.28:09 So what do you do?28:10 So what I tell everybody to do is28:13 pray somewhere else.28:13 And even if you have to pray28:15 ביחיד, you pray28:16 ביחיד. You rush the tefillah28:17 and you don't pray.28:18 You don't miss the zman tefillah28:19 because you have to go to your first cousin's brit milah28:23 or bar mitzvah.28:23 You can't miss the time.28:25 So if you're worried that,28:26 what do you mean,28:26 there's a video man28:27 and there's a cameraman,28:28 then what you do is28:29 you go28:31 and you pray already earlier,28:33 and then you come to the bar mitzvah,28:35 and when you come to the bar mitzvah,28:36 you put on your tefillin in front of everybody,28:38 and this way you get on camera28:39 and you read your Tehillim.28:40 Who knows what you're saying.28:41 We have a phone call.28:42 One second,28:43 we'll take it first.28:45 Hello?28:47 Hello?28:49 Hello?28:53 Hello?28:54 Yes,28:55 you're on the air.28:55 Hello?28:56 Yes.28:57 Is this29:00 J-Rock? J-Rock? The Jewish station?29:03 Yeah. Yeah, call later.29:04 Yeah, call later.29:05 Excuse me,29:06 could you talk a little?29:09 Hello?29:10 Hello,29:14 Jeru? Hello,29:14 you're on the air.29:16 Hello.29:17 You have a question for the29:20 halacha hour? Okay,29:21 I've done that.29:22 This is why we need a technician over here.29:24 Okay, let's go back.29:26 Maybe we'll take phone calls29:26 after the end of the class.29:28 Now that we finished with that,29:29 there's a question:29:30 what about ladies?29:32 Do ladies have the same29:33 halacha? Do they have to be careful29:34 not to say29:35 Birkhot Kriat Shema after the time?29:36 And the answer is as follows.29:37 There's a machloket amongst the29:40 Acharonim, Chacham Ovadia and Chacham Ben29:42 Tzion, if ladies should say29:43 Birkhot Kriat Shema29:44 in general,29:45 if they should or they should not say it.29:47 Depends what your minhag is.29:48 I don't know,29:49 you know,29:49 different places29:50 they teach them in Beit29:52 Yaakovs, different places,29:53 different things.29:54 Whatever your minhag is,29:55 if your minhag is not to say29:57 the name of Hashem,29:58 not to say the blessings29:59 of Kriat Shema,30:01 they mean to say30:02 Hashem,30:02 then anyway you don't have an issue,30:04 because you're saying it without30:05 the Shem of Hashem.30:06 You're not really making30:07 beracha. And if your minhag is30:10 to do say Birkhot Kriat Shema30:11 with the name of Hashem,30:13 then this30:14 halacha applies to ladies as well.30:15 That's the psak of my Rosh30:17 Kollel, Rabbi Max30:19 Mesaton, that you have to make sure30:22 to say the Birkhot Kriat Shema30:25 before the latest time of tefillah,30:27 before the end of zman tefillah.30:29 This is the30:33 halacha regarding Kriat Shema30:35 with its blessings30:35 after the latest time.30:37 If you have any questions on this,30:38 you could text it,30:39 or you could wait till after30:41 three o'clock, and you could call in30:44 at 718-683-5858. We're going to move on to the next30:46 halacha, halacha yud. In30:49 halacha yud. We're going to talk about30:49 a very important30:51 halacha. First, let me get the first subject30:52 out of the way.30:54 Gam30:56 b'Shabbat tzarich lismoch geulah litfilah. Even on Shabbat,30:57 a person has to30:59 be somech geulah litfilah, which means30:59 when you say Ge'al Yisrael,31:01 you have to jump into31:03 the berachah of the Amidah31:04 right away,31:05 just like we do31:06 during the weekday.31:10 Vizaher shelo yit'aleh tefillel shel chol. And this is very important.31:11 You have to be careful now,31:13 when you're praying the Amidah,31:15 not to mix yourself up31:17 and to pray the wrong Amidah.31:19 On Shabbat,31:20 make sure you don't pray31:21 the wrong Amidah.31:22 You don't pray the weekday Amidah.31:25 Ve'im ta'ah, if by accident31:26 you did pray31:27 the wrong prayer on Shabbat,31:29 you said the weekday prayer31:30 instead of the Shabbat prayer,31:32 then the sefarim bring down,31:36 yed'ag kol oto shavua v'yefashfesh b'ma'asav. You have to be worried31:38 the whole week.31:39 You have to do teshuvah.31:40 Why does Hashem allow you31:41 to make such a mistake?31:42 If He made such a mistake,31:44 then perhaps31:45 you're not honoring Shabbat31:46 the way it's supposed to be,31:47 and therefore31:47 you have to be31:48 mispashpesh. You have to search your ways31:50 and see31:52 where you're falling short31:54 on honoring Shabbat properly.31:55 Now,31:56 before we get to read31:57 the next part of the31:58 halacha in the Ben31:59 Ish Chai, I want to—32:00 Give you a little bit of a background to understand the following rules,32:03 because this happens a lot.32:04 A lot of times we make mistakes in the berachot, in the Amidah, especially on Shabbat,32:08 and we have to know. Let's begin already. Let's begin with a little bit of a background,32:12 and that is that on Shabbat we have the three regular tefillot that we have every single day,32:17 which is Arvit, beginning Friday night;32:20 Shabbat morning we have tefillah of32:23 Shacharit, Mincha; and we have an additional tefillah on Shabbat called the tefillah of Musaf.32:28 In the three Amidot that we pray in Arvit, Shacharit, and32:34 Mincha, we have three different nusach, three different texts for the Amidah,32:39 not like that we have on the holiday. We just had on the holiday,32:44 if you notice, the same Amidah that you said for Arvit of the holiday32:47 was the same Amidah that you said in Shacharit and32:50 Mincha. In fact, the same Amidah that you said for the holiday of32:52 Shavuot was the same Amidah that you said for Pesach32:55 and the same one that you're going to say in Sukkot. It's pretty much the same text;32:58 you just change the subject of the day,33:01 okay? That is the halacha. That is the difference between Shabbat and the holiday prayers.33:11 Shabbat prayer, you change it. Shabbat prayer, we have different33:16 text. In Arvit, we say33:18 Atah Kidashta. We begin the words after the three main blessings,33:20 we begin with33:22 Atah Kidashta, and that represents the kiddushin, which is, in the marriage,33:28 first step to getting married is kiddushin.33:30 What is the kiddushin?33:31 This is when you give the ring to the kallah and you say,33:34 Harei at mekudeshet li b'tabaat zu,33:36 and that's the Sefarim bring down.33:37 That's the same idea over here, Mikdash33:39 me'at begins in the name of the Arizal.33:41 That's the first part of Shabbat,33:43 we're getting married to HaKadosh Baruch Hu,33:45 Atah Kidashta. The second tefillah that we pray on33:48 Shacharit begins with the words33:50 Yismach Moshe,33:52 or Yismach... and both of them...33:55 Represents simcha. Yismach Moshe, be happy.33:57 That refers to the second part of the wedding,33:59 when we're celebrating and we're dancing,34:01 we're joyous.34:02 That's the happiness of the wedding.34:04 And finally, a mincha, the prayer that we say is34:08 Atah Echad, which is the union between34:10 chatan, kallah becoming one when they go home34:11 and they become united as one.34:14 This is the same idea also.34:15 We're getting married to HaKadosh Baruch Hu on Shabbat.34:17 It's every single Shabbat,34:18 we start Friday night,34:21 bo'i kallah, bo'i kallah, come bride, and Shabbat is referred to as a bride,34:23 and we're getting married to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.34:25 The first step is34:26 Atah Kidashta, you gave us kiddushin,34:28 and then we have the celebration in the daytime34:30 and then in the afternoon.34:31 That's a little bit of a background at the tefillot.34:34 If you notice that on the weekday we have 18 blessings.34:38 In the weekday we have 19 blessings, really,34:40 sorry, not 18, 19 blessings,34:42 and on Shabbat we have only seven blessings.34:44 How come we have such a short Amidah on Shabbat?34:45 And hachamim tell us, you know why?34:48 Because we don't want to burden you with such a long Amidah.34:52 To say 19 berachot, it's very, very long,34:54 so we give you only34:55 seven berachot. So a lot of people ask, what do you mean?34:56 If you're giving us such a short Amidah,34:58 why do we have such a long prayer in general?35:00 We have all these extra paragraphs that we say.35:02 So we mentioned already the Olat Zion explains35:04 that that's referring to only the35:08 people—this is referring to the people who used to have kavanah.35:09 To have kavanah, especially the right35:12 kavanot, the way the mekubalim have,35:14 for 19 blessings is much longer35:17 than it takes for only seven blessings.35:19 In any case, that's what we do.35:22 We pray the shorter Amidah of Shabbat on Shabbat35:26 instead of the weekday Amidah.35:27 But technically, we were supposed to pray the longer Amidah,35:31 the one of35:31 Ata Chonen, but hachamim wanted to make it easier for us.35:33 Now, here's where the halacha makes a difference.35:36 Ready?35:37 If a person was praying,35:40 began the tefillah of whatever it may be,35:42 Shacharit, Mincha, Arvit, it doesn't make a difference.35:45 By accident, he started praying35:49 Ata Chonen, the Amidah. He started praying the weekday35:51 tefillah. If he catches himself, he says,35:53 Whoa, I made a mistake.35:54 If you're in the middle of that blessing,35:56 you finish that blessing.35:58 That means if you're in the middle of36:01 Ata Chonen, the Amidah, and you realize that it's really Shabbat,36:02 what am I doing? I'm wearing a suit. This is Shabbat,36:05 and I'm supposed to be praying the Shabbat prayer.36:06 Don't stop, don't interrupt it.36:08 Finish that36:09 beracha. Say Baruch Atah Hashem,36:11 Chonen HaDaat, and then go back and continue.36:14 Let's say it was Shabbat morning,36:16 so you say Yismach Moshe36:18 b'matnat chelko. You'll continue that36:20 beracha. Same thing would be,36:21 even if you catch yourself by the later36:23 beracha of the Amidah.36:25 What does that mean?36:26 Let's say you started praying the36:28 tefillah, you're standing on Shabbat,36:29 you're supposed to say36:32 Yismach Moshe36:33 b'matnat chelko, and by mistake36:35 you started praying the weekday36:37 tefillah, and you only remembered36:42 by Al HaTzadikim, v'al hachasidim, v'al she'erit amcha Beit Yisrael, and you caught yourself36:44 by Al HaTzadikim, you finish that blessing.36:46 Even if you're after Shema36:47 Koleinu, you finish Shema36:49 Koleinu. You finish the blessing that you're in the middle of,36:51 and then you go back,36:52 and then you continue wherever you made the mistake.36:55 This is only true if you caught yourself36:58 before Retzeh.36:59 Once you began Retzeh,37:01 the halacha is different.37:02 Once you began Retzeh already,37:04 then you37:05 have—we're going to talk about it later37:06 on—but that's the37:08 halacha. If you said the wrong Amidah,37:10 or even if you said the wrong beracha in Amidah,37:12 you finish off that37:14 beracha. This is the37:16 halacha if you started the weekday Amidah by37:20 Shacharit, by37:21 Arvit, and by37:22 Mincha. However, by Musaf it's different.37:24 Why?37:25 By Musaf,37:26 if you made the37:28 wrong—if by accident you started the weekday prayer,37:30 you're supposed to start the Musaf Amidah,37:32 and you started saying37:34 Ata Chonen, then you interrupt right in the middle of that37:37 beracha, and you go to the tefillah Musaf37:39 and you continue37:41 Al HaSinah. Why?37:41 Because the whole reason why we tell you37:44 to finish the beracha of the weekday,37:46 because really Chachamim made it easier for you.37:47 You all of a sudden decide to make it longer for yourself.37:50 You decide to say37:52 Ata Chonen, so then finish off the37:54 beracha. We're trying to make it easier for you.37:55 Now you want to go ahead and make it longer for you,37:57 and you want to say the weekday prayer,37:58 okay, so finish it off.37:59 That's only true38:01 where you would otherwise have prayed the weekday prayer.38:03 But on Musaf,38:04 you wouldn't have otherwise prayed Musaf.38:06 Musaf is only applicable on Shabbat.38:09 It's only there on Shabbat.38:10 It's especially only for Shabbat.38:11 So if by accident by Musaf38:13 you said the wrong Amidah.38:14 You interrupt yourself in the middle of that38:17 beracha, and you go back.38:19 This, by the way, applies also to the Musaf of Rosh Chodesh and38:22 Chol Hamoed. If a person, let's say on Rosh38:24 Chodesh, and you're praying38:25 and you're saying the Amidah of Rosh Chodesh—the, excuse me, the Musaf of Rosh38:29 Chodesh—and when you started,38:30 you started38:31 Atah honen l'adam daat, and then you caught yourself,38:32 you stop right in the middle,38:34 and you go back38:35 and you continue the38:38 beracha of—or you continue the tefillah of Musaf.38:40 Good?38:41 That is the38:43 halacha if a person made a mistake38:45 regarding mixing up the Amidot in the middle.38:48 Now, there's a question that's brought down in the38:51 poskim in the following case:38:52 What about a person who says,38:54 you know, you're supposed to say38:56 Atah honen l'adam daat, right?38:58 Not—sorry. You begin the Amidah on Leil Shabbat39:01 with the words Atah39:02 kidashta, and you begin the Amidah of Mincha of Shabbat39:04 with the words Atah echad.39:06 Notice the words begin with the word Atah.39:09 The tefillah begins with the word Atah.39:11 During the weekday,39:12 the first blessing of the middle parts of the Amidah39:15 begin the words39:17 Atah honen. What if a person said by accident Atah,39:20 and then he caught himself right away,39:22 said, Oh, I'm in the wrong prayer.39:23 He realized, Oh, this is39:25 tefillah shel chol. He didn't say39:26 honen, he didn't say39:27 Atah honen, he just says Atah.39:28 Now, that Atah could be Atah39:30 kidashta or could be Atah echad.39:32 So the halacha is that way,39:34 that if you were praying Arvit or39:38 Mincha, where the Amidah of Shabbat begins with the word Atah,39:40 even though you had intention to say the word Atah39:42 for the weekday prayer,39:44 it doesn't make a difference.39:45 We allow you to continue the words Atah39:49 kidashta or Atah echad,39:51 and you do not have to39:53 repeat—you do not have to finish that39:55 beracha. However, by39:56 Shacharit, which begins with the words Yismach Moshe,39:59 so the halacha...40:00 That's a little bit different. You don't necessarily have to continue Atah Honen.40:03 The only time you have to continue Atah Honen is the following two things.40:06 Number one is that if it's Shacharit, where it begins Yismach Moshe,40:11 and number two is if you didn't realize it was Shabbat.40:14 Sometimes you begin the word Atah without—you know it's Shabbat.40:17 You got up, you know it's Shabbat. You're wearing your suit,40:20 you're standing in shul with the tallit over your head.40:22 Your whole atmosphere is Shabbat, and the prayer of Shabbat.40:25 You're looking at the siddur, Shacharit of Shabbat.40:27 Just by accident, you're so used to praying the tefillah of40:30 Chol, the weekday prayer, that slips out of your mouth the word Atah.40:34 So in such a case, you could continue Yismach Moshe40:39 b'matnat chelko, even though you started the word Atah. We don't consider like you started the weekday prayer,40:42 because it's as if you mixed it up with the prayer of40:47 Mincha. Maybe you meant to say Atah Echad, so it works.40:50 But if you thought you're actually praying the tefillah40:53 shel Chol, you weren't paying attention, you thought you're praying tefillah40:55 shel Chol, and it's by the tefillah of Shacharit which begins with the word Yismach Moshe,41:00 and therefore you began the word Atah thinking you're praying the tefillah41:03 shel Chol, and then you caught yourself,41:04 then the halacha is you must finish41:06 that beracha. You must finish Atah Honen, say Baruch Atah Hashem Honen41:09 Daat, and then go back to Yismach Moshe.41:12 Okay, so again, if you started the word Atah by Arvit and Mincha of Shabbat,41:18 you can continue with the tefillah of Shabbat and say Atah Kidashta or Atah41:23 Echad. But if you started Atah in the tefillah of Shacharit shel Shabbat,41:28 then if you thought you were praying the tefillah of Shabbat,41:31 you could just continue Yismach Moshe.41:33 If you thought that you were praying the tefillah of41:36 Shacharit, then of the weekday, that means, then you'll have to repeat. You'll have to finish that blessing Atah Honen41:41 and then come back to the beginning of the Amidah of Shabbat.41:45 Now, this is all true by a regular person who is praying.41:49 The Ben Ish Chai here brings later on,41:51 what about a41:52 chazzan? Chazzan is standing in Amidah,41:54 and the chazzan is not paying attention.41:56 He's thinking of the nice tune that he just sang for41:59 Nakdishach. He's all excited about it.42:00 He had the whole kahal repeating after him,42:02 and then he comes, he finishes Baruch Atah Hashem,42:06 HaKel HaKadosh, and the chazzan, by accident, begins Atah42:10 chonen l'adam daat, and then everybody corrects him,42:12 right? He doesn't realize. He's so lost in the song,42:14 he forgot that he's praying the tefillah of Shabbat.42:18 So what do you do in such a case?42:19 Does he repeat or does he finish the berachah or not?42:21 And the halachah is no.42:23 You do not finish that42:26 berachah, that berachah. The chazzan interrupts right in the middle,42:29 and he goes back to the tefillah of Shabbat,42:31 and he continues42:33 על הסדר. Why is that so?42:34 For three reasons.42:35 Number one is, there's a Gemara Masechet Kiddushin that says42:37 that when he sends a shliach to do something for you,42:40 for your benefit,42:41 and he messes up,42:42 you could claim,42:46 לתקוני שדרתיך ולא לעוותי. I sent you in order to do what's good for me, not to mess me up.42:51 So here the chazzan is called42:54 a shliach tzibbur. He's a representative of the whole kahal.42:56 We sent him in order to help us, not to harm us.42:59 What did he do?43:00 He started saying Atah43:02 chonen, that's harming us.43:02 We don't want that.43:03 So therefore, he doesn't finish the berachah of Atah43:07 chonen. He interrupts right away,43:08 and he continues with Atah echad or Yismach Moshe.43:12 Second reason why the chazzan doesn't finish that43:16 berachah is43:18 טורח ציבור. The whole tzibbur has to wait now because of his mistake.43:20 So therefore, we tell him to go right away.43:22 The other one also,43:25 we tell the chazzan to stop right away and to begin the Shabbat prayer,43:30 because if the chazzan does say the wrong43:32 berachah, it's going to cause a lot of ruckus in the shul.43:34 Everybody's going to make a comment,43:35 and this one's going to say,43:36 Why'd you make it finish?43:37 And, Well, how come?43:37 A lot of people don't know the43:39 halachah. So therefore, for these three reasons,43:40 we say that the chazzan who makes a mistake,43:43 if he began the weekday prayer,43:45 he interrupts right in the middle,43:47 and he goes back43:48 and he begins the tefillah of Shabbat.43:50 This applies, by the way,43:51 even if the chazzan himself has not prayed his own Amidah yet.43:54 Let's say for whatever reason,43:56 maybe he forgot to say43:57 Ya'aleh v'Yavo and he has to repeat the Amidah.43:58 Now he's saying the chazarah,43:59 and he wasn't yotzei the chovah with his silent Amidah,44:02 and he made a mistake in Atah44:04 chonen. It doesn't make a difference.44:05 He interrupts right in the middle,44:06 he does not finish the berachah of Atah44:08 chonen, and he continues with the blessing of Shabbat.44:12 This is Halacha Yod,44:15 up to Halacha Yod Aleph.44:17 Halacha Yod Aleph says in44:19 Ben Ish Chai, Ta'ah v'hitpalel shel chol b'Shabbat v'lo hizkir shel Shabbat.44:23 Let's say by accident,44:25 a person prayed the whole Amidah of the weekday prayer.44:28 And by the way, this happens.44:29 I've had this question a number of times,44:31 where people came up to me44:32 and they said, Rabbi,44:33 I by accident44:35 prayed Tefillah shel Shacharit shel Shabbat44:36 or Mincha shel Shabbat,44:37 and I'm wondering,44:39 how in the world did you finish so quickly?44:41 You know, I didn't finish my Amidah.44:43 You finished before me,44:44 and you prayed the whole weekday prayer.44:45 In any case, that's a different discussion.44:47 The guy finishes his whole Amidah,44:49 and he didn't mention Shabbat inside.44:51 So what's the44:52 din? The din is,44:53 Im higia la'oseh shalom,44:54 af al pi shelo akar44:56 raglav, chozer l'rosh. If he got up to Oseh Shalom,44:57 even though he didn't step back,44:58 but he got up to the end of the Amidah,45:00 he must repeat the whole Amidah.45:01 He doesn't just begin;45:02 he goes and he repeats the whole Amidah.45:06 However,45:06 Im lo higia la'oseh shalom,45:08 if he remembered anywhere in the tefillah45:10 before Oseh Shalom,45:12 af al pi shesiyem tefilato, v'chozer ela shel Shabbat,45:15 even though he finished his tefillah,45:17 meaning to say45:18 he is, let's say,45:19 Baruch Atah Hashem,45:20 hamevarech amo Yisrael baShalom,45:21 and he remembers,45:22 Oh, I prayed the weekday prayer today,45:24 and I didn't say the thing of Shabbat,45:26 then what does he do?45:27 He goes back all45:28 the—he goes back,45:29 sorry, not all the way to the beginning of Amidah,45:31 but he goes back to45:32 Atah Kadosh or whatever it may be.45:35 V'im ta'ah v'hitpalel shel chol v'nizkar ela ad achar shehitpalel Musaf.45:38 So now it becomes more complicated.45:41 What about a case45:42 where a person prayed tefillah45:46 shel Shacharit of the weekday,45:47 and then he prayed Musaf of Shabbat.45:50 After Musaf of Shabbat,45:51 he starts thinking about it,45:53 and then he realizes that,45:54 wow, you45:55 know, I prayed the tefillah shel chol for46:00 Shacharit, and this is already after he prayed Musaf.46:02 So what do you do in such a case?46:04 So he says,46:04 Af al pi yesh mi shekatav she'eino chozer l'palel Shacharit shel Shabbat,46:07 even though there are some who hold—46:10 That you don't go back to pray the tefillah of Shacharit or Shabbat.46:18 Then in that case,46:18 what you do is46:20 as follows: you missed out on46:21 Shacharit because you already prayed Musaf.46:23 If you already prayed Musaf,46:24 according to some opinions,46:26 you already cannot pray tefillah of46:28 Shacharit. So what do you do afterwards?46:30 What you do afterwards is46:32 you pray the Amidah of Mincha twice,46:36 like any person who missed out on46:38 Shacharit. What happens if a person missed out on46:40 Shacharit and he comes to shul46:42 and he comes by46:44 Mincha and he missed the tefillah of46:45 Shacharit? Very simple.46:46 You pray the Amidah of Mincha, for46:48 Mincha, and then you repeat the Amidah of Mincha a second time46:51 to make up for the tefillah of46:53 Shacharit, and that's what you do over here also.46:58 If you only realize that you prayed the tefillah of the weekday47:02 after you prayed the tefillah of Musaf,47:05 the halacha is47:07 that you pray the tefillah of Mincha twice.47:10 Here we have a question as follows:47:16 What happens if a person realizes after47:20 Shema Koleinu? What does that mean?47:20 It's Shabbat day.47:22 He's supposed to pray tefillah of whatever it may be,47:25 Shabbat Shacharit or47:27 Mincha, but accidentally he started praying the weekday47:31 Amidah, Ata Chonen, and then finally, finally he remembered47:34 right before Retzei.47:35 He says, Baruch Atah Hashem,47:36 Shomea Tefillah,47:38 but he began Retzei. He began the tefillah of Retzei.47:41 What do you do in such a case?47:43 So according to Chacham Ben47:47 Tzion, he says what you do in that case47:49 is that you say47:51 the special nusach that we say on Shabbat,47:56 Retzei na b'menuchatenu. You say that right after Retzei,47:58 before Ve'ata b'rachamecha harabim.48:00 Which is the place where we usually say48:04 Yaaleh Veyavo. That's where you put in the beracha, you put in over there the text of48:10 Retzei na b'menuchateinu. This is where you mention Shabbat in your48:12 Amidah. According to the Mishnah Berurah, if he goes over here like the Ben Ish Chai says over here,48:16 if you finished—if you, sorry, if you realized that you got off to Shema48:21 Koleinu before you began Retzei, then you go back to the beracha of Mekadesh HaShabbat.48:24 That's the machloket over here between the Mishnah Berurah and the48:28 Olat Zion. You just mention it, instead of Yaaleh Veyavo you mention over there Shabbat.48:34 According to Mishnah Berurah, then you go back to the48:39 beracha and you say Baruch Atah Hashem, Mekadesh HaShabbat.48:41 You just say Retzei na. You go back to the regular blessing that you say on Shabbat,48:46 and you conclude Baruch Atah Hashem, Mekadesh HaShabbat.48:50 Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach brings a very good question.48:51 He says, what if a person is stuck somewhere?48:54 Let's say a person is in the hospital and he has no siddur, he's on Shabbat.48:59 Kriat Shema he was able to do. Now he has to pray Amidah,49:02 but Shabbat. He doesn't know how to say the Amidah of Shabbat by heart.49:09 He knows the weekday Amidah by heart. He doesn't know the Shabbat Amidah by heart.49:12 So what do you do in such a case? Do you just not pray at all,49:15 or do you say the weekday Amidah?49:17 So the halacha is that you say the weekday Amidah,49:21 and then you say Yaaleh Veyavo in the weekday Amidah,49:25 and over there you mention, instead of saying b'yom Rosh Chodesh hazeh,49:28 you mention b'yom haShabbat hazeh.49:31 That's a very important halacha to keep in mind, and it happens sometimes.49:33 If you're stuck somewhere, you have no siddur,49:36 or you only have the weekday Amidah49:38 and you don't have any way to know the Shabbat Amidah,49:41 and you have to pray before this man finishes,49:43 you say the weekday Amidah and you say49:47 Yaaleh Veyavo, but instead of Yaaleh Veyavo you mention b'yom haShabbat hazeh.49:51 This way you mention Shabbat in your tefillah.49:54 And,49:57 Yotze yedei chovah. This is Halacha Yud Aleph.49:59 If you have any questions, we have a few more minutes to the class over here.50:04 If you have any questions, you want to text it in,50:06 you can text it in50:11 at 347-927-8398. And if you want to call in, you can call in in five minutes when we finish the class.50:15 I'll be here in the station.50:18 718-683-5589. I know these halachot are a little bit50:20 complicated. Mixing up which tefillah and when is very complicated.50:24 And remember, one, because most of the halachot that we know how to follow50:27 are the halachot that are straightforward:50:29 Tell me what to do, Rabbi, and we just do it.50:32 But when we make mistakes, what ifs, you'll only remember these halachot if it happened to you.50:36 So that's why I know that there's a lot of details50:39 and there's a lot of complications over here.50:41 I still have—we have to mention it because we're going in the order of the Ben50:44 Ish Chai, but it's important in my mind. It's also important to have this on the side50:49 to know that for a person, especially if you're a rabbi of a shul,50:52 or people ask you questions on halachot, or on Shabbat,50:56 when people make mistakes, mistakes happen a lot.50:59 And although you may not make a mistake,51:00 but it's important to know these halachot51:02 if you need to answer someone or for yourself as well51:04 when you make the mistakes.51:07 Halacha Yud Bet. What about if a person makes a mistake on Leil Shabbat?51:11 So Ben Ish Chai talks as follows. He says as51:13 follows: Im b'Leil Shabbat hitpalel shel Yom chol b'vad v'lo hizkir Shabbat. If a person made a mistake on Leil Shabbat51:19 by accidentally, he's prayed the whole weekday Amidah on Leil Shabbat.51:27 So... Then you could make it up without having to repeat the Amidah51:31 by listening to that blessing in shul that the chazzan makes.51:34 It's called51:36 Birkat Me'ein Sheva. If you listen to it from the beginning till the end,51:38 beginning means from the words Baruch Atah Hashem51:40 until the end where he says,51:42 Mekadesh HaShabbat, you are yotzei yedei chovah the whole Amidah,51:46 and you don't have to repeat the Amidah.51:47 Ve'im lav, and if you weren't able to hear it from the beginning to end,51:50 or if you didn't hear it at all,51:52 chozer u'mitpalel, then you have to go back51:55 and pray the Amidah.51:57 Therefore, lachech yatzibur, yotzei yedei chovato b'Birkat Me'ein Sheva. Therefore, if you're the52:02 chazzan and you made a mistake in your Amidah,52:04 then you could just say the Birkat Me'ein Sheva later on52:08 and be yotzei52:10 yedei chovah. V'im adam mistapek im hitpalel shel chol im lav.52:14 What if a person is not sure?52:15 He prayed the Amidah, he prayed by heart.52:17 After he said Oseh Shalom,52:18 he steps back from the Amidah,52:19 he starts to think about it.52:21 He says, Hey, you know, I'm not sure if I was yotzei52:23 yedei chovah. I don't know if I said the weekday prayer52:25 or the Shabbat prayer.52:29 The halacha is, אינו חוזר להתפלל. He does not repeat the Amidah.52:30 Why? Deha mina mistama hitpalel shel Shabbat,52:33 because we say in general52:34 he probably prayed the Amidah of Shabbat.52:35 We hold,52:41 כי חומרו של יום גורם, דרמיא אנפשיה בעת תפילה, ומתכוין להתפלל תפילת שבת. We hold that the day itself,52:45 the awesomeness of the day of Shabbat,52:47 reminds a person about it,52:50 and you don't have to repeat the Amidah.52:51 This is the opinion of the52:53 Ben Ish Chai. However, according to the Ashkenazim,52:54 the52:57 Mishnah Berurah and the Magen Avraham as well,52:59 they hold that if a person is not sure53:02 if he said the weekday prayer53:03 or the Shabbat prayer,53:07 yesh safek, then you must repeat the Amidah.53:09 Why? Because we say,53:11 mistama, probably you said what you used to.53:13 That's the machloket between the Ashkenazim and53:15 Sefardim. The Kaf HaChaim and Kitzur Yosef also hold like the53:17 Ben Ish Chai. If you're not sure,53:19 then you repeat the Amidah53:21 according to the Ashkenazim.53:22 According to the53:24 Sefardim, if you're not sure if you said the weekday prayer53:25 or the Shabbat prayer,53:27 you do not repeat the Amidah.53:29 This is the simple way of explaining the53:31 machloket. You should know53:32 that some explain53:34 that when we said you have to repeat the Amidah53:37 when you're not sure,53:38 what does it mean you're not sure53:39 if you prayed the weekday or not?53:40 We're talking about not that you're not sure53:42 if you said the whole Amidah of Shabbat53:44 or the whole Amidah of the weekday.53:45 No.53:46 Some say that—53:48 If a person is not sure53:50 if he said53:53 within the weekday prayer that he prayed on Shabbat,53:55 if he mentioned Shabbat or not,53:57 what does that mean?53:58 That means, let's say we're talking about that guy in the hospital.54:00 He doesn't have a siddur with him.54:02 He doesn't know the tefillah of Shabbat,54:03 and he prayed now the weekday.54:05 We said, halacha is you pray the weekday prayer.54:06 What could you do?54:07 You pray the weekday prayer,54:08 and you mention Shabbat.54:08 He finished the Amidah.54:09 He's not sure now54:11 if I mentioned Shabbat inside of it or not.54:14 In that case,54:15 that's what Magen Avraham and Mishnah Berurah tell you to repeat.54:17 That's how some explain the54:19 machloket, which makes it even more lenient,54:21 which means that even according to the Ashkenazim, technically,54:23 in the regular person54:25 who is praying in a shul,54:26 who is54:26 not—and there's no reason to say54:27 maybe necessarily that he said the wrong54:29 prayer—but he's not sure after the Amidah.54:31 He's not sure if he prayed the weekday prayer54:32 or the Shabbat prayer,54:33 then perhaps he would not have to repeat the Amidah54:37 bechlal. Even maybe the Mishnah Berurah would agree to this,54:40 like54:40 Ben Ish Chai. In this case,54:42 I would tell you,54:42 ask your54:43 local rabbi. If54:44 you're Sefardi, halacha is if you're not sure54:45 which Amidah you said even,54:47 you do not have to repeat the Amidah.54:50 One last halacha before we leave.54:53 We have a question:54:54 What about a person who switches the wrong Amidah on Shabbat?55:01 Meaning, instead of praying the Amidah of55:04 Shacharit, he prays the Amidah of55:06 Arvit. Instead of saying55:06 Yismach Moshe,55:07 he says55:09 Ata Kidashta, and the same thing for55:11 Mincha, Shacharit, Mincha, and55:11 Arvit. What would be the55:12 din? So there are three cases over here.55:15 Number one is55:16 if a person switches any of these three Amidot,55:20 Arvit, Shacharit, and Mincha, with each other.55:21 He says the wrong one.55:23 He says, let's say for example,55:24 he says the Tefillah of55:25 Mincha instead of55:26 Shacharit. He says the Tefillah of55:28 Arvit instead of55:29 Shacharit. It doesn't make a difference.55:31 Since he mentioned Shabbat,55:32 he said55:33 Retzeh, Yismach Moshe, Baruch Atah Hashem55:36 Mekadesh HaShabbat, you're yotzei dei chovah. You don't have to repeat it.55:38 However,55:40 the halacha is different in case number two.55:43 In case number two,55:45 if a person mixed up the amidah of Musaf55:49 with a different amidah,55:50 or vice versa.55:51 For example,55:51 instead of Musaf,55:52 you prayed the tefillah of55:54 Shacharit. Instead of55:56 Arvit, you prayed the tefillah of Musaf.55:57 In that case,55:58 we have a machloket. According—56:00 According to the Ashkenazim, Mishnah Berurah and Magen Avraham, they hold that you must repeat the Amidah.56:05 The Sefardim, which is the Chida, Yalkut Yosef, and all the Tzion, all hold that if a person mixed up the tefillah of Musaf with another Amidah, or vice versa, then you do not have to repeat the Amidah,56:20 because you could rely on the Rambam that holds that if you mix it up,56:27 yatza yedei chovah b'diavad. The third case is a person who prays Musaf instead of56:33 Shacharit. Let's say you have a case where a person prayed the tefillah of Musaf in the morning.56:37 I mean, you come Shacharit morning, you're supposed to pray Shacharit, and by accident you prayed Musaf.56:41 The halacha says that really Musaf you can pray the whole day.56:43 So in that case, what happens over here? Do you repeat the Amidah of Shacharit or not?56:47 So here it gets a little bit complicated. According to the Ashkenazim, then although you prayed Musaf earlier, it doesn't make a difference.56:56 Musaf, yatza yedei chovah. You could pray Musaf the whole day.56:59 Even if you prayed before Shacharit, their whole day go like the opinion that holds that even if you said Musaf before Shacharit, yatza yedei chovah of Musaf. You just have to pray now the Amidah of Shacharit and you're done.57:09 And when the tzibbur gets up to Musaf, you don't repeat it. That's it. That's Ashkenazim, very57:14 glatt. The Sefardim, it's a little bit more complicated,57:17 because according to the Sefardim, we hold like the opinion that says that really, this is also57:23 machloket, Musaf, if it was said before Shacharit, there's a machloket if you're yotzei yedei chovah, if you could repeat Shacharit afterwards because you already prayed Musaf.57:32 So therefore, according to Chacham Ben Tzion, you do not repeat the Amidah, but you try to listen to the chazarah of Shacharit and of Musaf, making condition57:41 and saying, Listen, if I am yotzei yedei chovah Musaf with Shacharit, let this chazarah that I'm listening to by Shacharit cover me for57:51 Shacharit, and if I'm not, let it be nothing, I'm listening to57:54 chazarah. And then you listen to the chazarah Musaf and you say a condition:57:56 If I was not yotzei yedei chovah Musaf, let this chazarah cover me for the sake of tefillat Musaf.58:03 And if you didn't get a chance to listen, or let's say you're praying ביחיד, you don't repeat any Amidah, that's it.58:08 That one tefillah that you said for Musaf covers you.58:11 According to Yalkut Yosef, however, and Kaf HaChaim, they hold that if you cannot listen to the chazarah... And you said Musaf and Shacharit, then you must pray Shacharit again like the Ashkenazim.58:23 Musaf you don't pray. Everybody agrees Musaf you don't pray again.58:26 But Shacharit, you have to go back and pray it.58:29 This is the last halacha. Like we said beforehand,58:32 complicated halachot because all talking about ta'arovet, mixing up different amidot,58:36 but it's important to have them.58:38 If you want to hear this class again, it'll be on air tonight again at 11 to 12 on58:44 JRadio.com. And if anybody has any questions, we'll be here in the studio for the next 10-15 minutes.58:48 The number to call in is58:51 718-683-5858. And if you have any text, any questions through text, you can text it in at58:57 347-927-8398. Until then, have a wonderful day.58:59 Again, this class was sponsored l'ilui nishmat Leor ben Rachel.