Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRoot Radio. This is the Halacha Hour on Wednesday afternoon live at0:05 2 o'clock. We'll be here with you from 2 to 3 p.m., be'ezrat Hashem.0:09 The Halacha Hour is the class where we speak practical halacha. We work off the book, the Ben0:16 Ish Chai. And before we get to the regular numbers and everything, let's first tell you a very important announcement,0:21 and that is that the JRoot Radio is ready to come out with its second magazine.0:26 The first one was very, very well received, Baruch Hashem.0:30 As I was told, the moment they put it into the shuls, the boxes into the shuls,0:34 already the boxes, within the same day, they were called to bring more back to the shuls,0:38 and Baruch Hashem, we had great feedback for it,0:40 and they're ready to put out the second magazine, be'ezrat Hashem, for0:48 Chanukah, with articles by many of the rabbis and the people here from JRoot Radio.0:52 And there's still time for people, if they still want to buy an advertisement,0:58 or if they would like to participate in helping in the funding of this magazine,1:04 of course you can get in touch with JRoot Radio.1:07 The numbers, I don't know if they'll help right now, but you all know the numbers.1:10 You call in and you ask to speak to Iran, and he'll help you.1:14 And if anybody would like to be mishtatef, to be involved in this big mitzvah.1:18 Now let's get to the halacha,1:20 and before we get to the halachot, we'll give you the numbers to the station.1:24 The numbers here are1:29 718-683-5858, and the text line is1:32 347-927-8398. To listen, you can listen in a number of ways.1:34 You could go online,1:37 jrootradio.com. You could download the app, or if you have the app, just press the button and the app will go on.1:41 The app is called JRoot Radio Pro app.1:44 I'm surprised how many people who know about the website.1:47 And they know about the station, but they don't know about the app.1:49 Yes, the app is unbelievable. It's fantastic.1:52 Just press it and you can hear everything live.1:53 You can also see some of the archives.1:55 If you'd like to watch live, it's also on JoyRadio.com. We are being videoed live,2:02 and you can also listen on the phone,2:10 718-506-9099. We are up to part five in Parashat Vayishlach.2:14 Vayishlach, we said already in the introduction to2:17 the parashah, the halachah discusses the laws of what we can speak about on Shabbat.2:25 And like we said, that we're going to speak about also eventually the laws of2:30 amirah l'akum. That will not be for a little bit, but right now we are in the second part of the class,2:36 and that is the laws of what one could read on Shabbat.2:39 We started last week.2:40 If you didn't hear last week's class, it's very important that you go back to it2:43 because a lot of important fundamental points were mentioned in last week's class.2:47 This class is really building upon last week, which we weren't able to finish,2:52 and we're just going to more of the practical examples in this week's class.2:57 I forgot2:58 to—sorry, one more thing.2:59 The sponsor, the class this week is sponsored l'ilui nishmat Yaakov ben Jenny,3:04 and all those that were injured in Eretz Yisrael from last week's massacre,3:09 horrible attack in Har Nof, and also for the yeled Yosef ben Sofi.3:14 Let's continue.3:15 In the halachot that we learned last week, we learned what one could read and what one could not read.3:19 And just very, very short, just to summarize what we learned last week,3:23 and that is that Chachamim made a special gezeirah called3:26 shtarei hedyotot. This shtarei hedyotot literally means these are documents that are non-Torah documents.3:34 Specifically, they refer to documents that deal— With a person's bills, calculations,3:41 all these different types of things,3:43 practically something like a bank account or your credit card bill or your phone bill,3:48 all these are in the category of3:50 shtarei hedyotot. Chazal said you're not allowed to read it on Shabbat.3:52 Three reasons amongst the Rishonim why you cannot read it on Shabbat:3:55 maybe it might come to erase,3:57 maybe it might come to write.3:59 And so the Chachamim told, or like Rashi says,4:04 asur tafchatzecha. It's asur because you are doing your hafatzim, like the pasuk says, you cannot do on Shabbat.4:08 In any case, this is forbidden on Shabbat,4:10 and Chachamim made also additional gezeirot that are also forbidden on Shabbat,4:16 which are all part of the same category.4:18 Although they might not be shtarei hedyotot themselves,4:20 but there are additional things that the Chachamim forbade.4:24 And mainly, we mentioned last week what they were,4:26 but mainly, basically, these are things that may lead you either to4:31 read shtarei hedyotot or might lead you to erase on Shabbat.4:36 So we listed what they were last week from the4:39 Shulchan Aruch, but we only listed what they were.4:40 We didn't explain, we didn't go into basically the practical,4:46 the different cases that might come out of them.4:49 And we saw that there's many things, basically.4:52 Basically it comes down anything that's not Torah,4:54 you're really not allowed to read,4:57 to the point that there was at one point in history, not anymore,4:59 at one point in history, even things that we call Torah,5:02 like Ketuvim, the book of Daniel.5:04 It's a sefer, if it falls on the floor, you kiss it.5:06 There was a point in Jewish history that we're not allowed to read it5:09 because it took away from the learning of Torah.5:12 Not anymore, not nowadays anymore. You could read Sefer Daniel on Shabbat,5:15 but we're just pointing out that there's many, many things5:18 that the Chachamim also forbade that one could read on Shabbat.5:20 Now we moved on to the Ben5:24 Ish Chai. After this big introduction we went and we learned halachah zayin.5:26 Now we're up to halachah chet.5:27 We'll read from the Ben Ish Chai, basically a heter.5:31 And from this heter, we'll start already explaining5:33 all the different things that one could read5:38 and some things that really one cannot read.5:40 You'll actually see that there's machloket in some things between Ashkenazim5:43 and Sefardim, as we'll see.5:44 So let's go to the Ben Ish Chai, halacha chet in Parashat5:49 Vayishlach. Mi sherotze lizamen orchim l'seudat Shabbat. If a person wants to invite people for his house on Shabbat, v'kotev shmotam me'erev Shabbat5:55 b'mazgeret, and now he wants to write down their names to remember.5:58 This is, you know, one of those people that are very, very put together.6:02 They want to have everything organized,6:04 so they have a list exactly who's coming.6:09 Why? K'dei shelo yishkach likroam b'Shabbat. He shouldn't forget to read them on Shabbat,6:11 and when they come in, he knows this person,6:13 Abraham, is sitting over here, Yitzhak over here,6:15 Yaakov over here,6:16 Reuven, Shimon, and he has a sefer, everybody.6:18 He has them all written on a piece of paper.6:20 Here's another case.6:24 V'chen abia ben o chatan shemezamen o haba bikur, baba l'leil Shabbat. You have another case of a person is making a6:27 simcha, an aufruf, or what they call6:29 the שבת, and they have on Shabbat he's getting an aliyah to the Sefer Torah,6:32 and he has all his friends and relatives coming,6:34 and the gabbai says to6:35 him, Listen, I need to know who's going to get which aliyah.6:38 So of course, you don't want to offend anybody.6:39 You want to write everything down on a piece of paper.6:44 V'kotev, of course, kotev shemotam me'erev Shabbat. This is being done,6:45 the writing is being done from before Shabbat.6:52 Asur l'baal haseuda atzmo, abia ben, b'chatan, likrot bichtav zeh b'Shabbat. It's forbidden for the person making the party,6:55 in the case where he wrote the guest6:57 coming to eat by his house on Shabbat,6:59 or for the person, the7:01 abia ben, or the person who is inviting,7:02 the person who is in charge of the party,7:04 the one who is making that list,7:05 it's asur for him to read that what he wrote on Shabbat.7:09 You say, Why?7:10 It's a mitzvah.7:11 We're not talking about7:13 a seudot where people are doing7:15 hollelut, chas v'shalom, where they're just, you know, wasting time.7:17 No, it's seudat Shabbat.7:19 It's7:21 a simcha, it's7:23 a seudah shel mitzvah. It's seudat chatan v'kallah. It's better.7:24 What do you want better than that?7:24 It's a list for who's going to go up to the Sefer Torah.7:26 You can't get better than this.7:28 Still, it's7:29 asur. Why?7:30 The7:31 gezeirah, this is a gezeirah from the Gemara,7:32 which is also Shulchan Aruch,7:34 which we read a little bit last week.7:36 Shema yimchok shem7:41 mechamah keruim, ashen nicham alav, she... Maybe you don't want to invite somebody to go up to the Sefer Torah.7:44 Maybe you don't want to put somebody down in the7:47 seudah. You might come to erase one of those names.7:49 Chachamim said, Forget it.7:50 We're going to be7:52 gozer. How practical is it?7:53 How likely is it?7:54 It doesn't make a difference.7:55 The gezeirah took effect already.7:58 Chachamim saw the fear.8:00 For such a nisui to take place, and they already made the8:02 gezeirah. We cannot come now and uproot the gezeirah. The gezeirah is here.8:06 We just have to learn now how to apply the gezeirah and how to deal with it.8:11 So although you tell me, I know myself, I'm not going to erase anything.8:15 It's written in ink. It's printed. It's impossible to erase.8:18 It's, you know, printed from a printer. It doesn't make a difference.8:21 Once the gezeirah—we have to know a very important rule when it comes to gezeirot of8:26 chachamim. When Chazal make a gezeirah, they make a gezeirah all the way.8:28 The chachamim, when they—you know, it's kind of like you have a rule.8:32 If anybody who's been in a classroom, any teacher who's been in a classroom,8:36 or really parents who really want to make sure that the house runs in a certain fashion8:42 and you don't want to let the kids go out of control,8:44 so you make rules in the house and you don't make exceptions.8:47 Sometimes good people also go with it,8:50 meaning, let's say, for example, a teacher will say, No more going to the bathroom.8:54 Right? There's a 45-minute period. Nobody's allowed to go to the8:56 bathroom. It could be possible and likely that there's a few kids in there that are really good kids,9:02 that really don't abuse the rule of going to the bathroom,9:04 that really need to go to the bathroom,9:06 and they'll never go unless they really need to go,9:08 and they're not going to raise their hand unless they really need to go.9:10 But it doesn't make a difference.9:11 In order for the teacher to have that rule take effect,9:15 he has to ensure that his rule of not going to the bathroom will apply to everybody.9:20 He can't make exceptions.9:21 So I have, in the class, ten kids for sure will not abuse the rule,9:29 ten kids for sure will abuse the rule, and ten, you know, are there in9:32 safek. If I want to make this rule, and I want to make sure that this rule will be in effect,9:37 I have to be gozer on everybody.9:38 All 30 kids cannot go out of the class to the bathroom in the middle of the period, in the 45-minute period.9:43 You have to wait, either go before or go afterwards.9:46 It doesn't make a difference. You can't make exceptions.9:48 This is how chachamim made gezeirot as well.9:51 Chachamim saw there was a need to make9:53 a gezeirah in order to help us not to come to9:57 commit an aveirah. They didn't come and say, Okay, you, you're a tzaddik.10:00 You are, you're a person who is exceptional.10:03 You could be an exemption from the rule.10:05 It doesn't apply to— it doesn't work that way.10:07 Once the gezeirah was needed, it was made, and as the Gemara says,10:13 lo plug, without distinctions.10:16 Everybody is going to be under the category of the10:19 gezeirah, and that's the only way gezeirot will work.10:22 That's the only way the decrees of the rabbis will be able to take effect.10:26 Once you make exceptions for some10:29 who really do qualify for the exceptions,10:31 and even those who don't qualify for the exceptions10:33 will take advantage of the rule, and the rule will not take effect10:35 because they see, Hey, how come him? It's not fair. Only him and not me.10:39 Therefore, it doesn't apply. Gezeirah has to be all the way.10:41 So we come back to our list.10:43 You wrote a list in ink.10:45 There's no way possible you're going to erase it,10:47 but it doesn't make a difference.10:48 You wrote the list of who's going to get an aliyah to the Sefer Torah.10:51 Hachamim said any list that's written10:53 that person has to read himself on Shabbat.10:56 They said it might lead you to erase something from the list11:00 cannot be read on Shabbat.11:01 This doesn't make a difference11:04 if the list is written for something that is not a mitzvah,11:07 and even for a mitzvah, like getting11:09 an aliyah is also11:11 asur. There's an additional reason11:13 why Hachamim said you cannot read from the list.11:15 What is that?11:18 Vegam shema yikra bishter hedyotot. Here Ben Ish Hai brings the other reasons,11:20 but we saw in Haruch as well,11:22 that you might come to read11:25 in shter hedyotot. An additional reason is11:27 you might come to read from this list11:29 something else that is forbidden to read,11:32 because you're reading something that not necessarily is directly Torah.11:36 There's no pesukim on it.11:37 It doesn't say, you know, chidushei Torah on it. All it11:40 says, it's just a list of people.11:42 You might come to read also a list of items11:44 that you purchased on your credit card as well.11:46 So therefore, for these two reasons,11:48 hachamim made this gezeirah: you cannot read this document.11:52 Again, even though you,11:55 the person, you might say to yourself,11:56 I'm an exception.11:58 Me? I'm not going to erase.11:59 I never erase in my life,12:00 even during the weekday I don't erase,12:02 and it never will lead me to read something else.12:05 It doesn't make a difference.12:07 Lo plug, Rabbanan, hachamim made a gezeirah, and that's it.12:09 Once a gezeirah is done, it's all the way.12:12 Aval, but here's the exception to the rule.12:14 And from this exception,12:16 rabotai, that's where we'll see a lot of different heterim12:19 with this exception.12:20 Here's the exception to the rule.12:21 You should know, before I get to the exception,12:23 this exception is not agreed upon by everybody.12:28 There is a machloket by the12:31 Acharonim. The Bach holds that this exception is not an exception.12:34 You cannot use any12:36 exception, like we just said, gezeirah is12:38 gezeirah, no exceptions.12:39 And it's always going to be forbidden12:40 to read any sort of list by anybody.12:43 The Magen Avraham, however, disagrees,12:45 and most of the Acharonim go like12:48 the Magen Avraham. Not only that, the Magen Avraham says12:50 that is the minhag.12:51 And usually whenever we have a big,12:54 big rabbi12:55 saying—you know, not rabbi, you12:56 know, I mean to say12:57 a gadol, a big posek from the poskim12:59 the last two, three hundred years13:01 ago—saying this is the minhag,13:03 then already there's nothing to argue.13:05 This is the minhag, and then that's it.13:06 We follow what the minhag says.13:08 So the Magen Avraham says that the minhag13:10 is to be lenient with the following leniency.13:12 What is the leniency?13:24 אבל השמש מותר לחזור לעיין בכתב רשימת שמות האנשים ההם כדי לקרואם. The heter, the way that's permitted for this list13:28 to be read on Shabbat13:30 is with two conditions.13:32 Number one,13:33 it has to be read by somebody13:36 besides the owner,13:37 besides the one who made the list,13:39 besides the one that has the power13:42 to change the list.13:44 In this case, where a person,13:45 let's take a person who is getting married,13:47 his name is Yitzhak,13:48 like we just said,13:49 Hayitzhak. Oh no, this week's13:51 parsha, Yaakov Avinu. Yeah, let's say Yaakov is getting married,13:53 and Yaakov now makes a13:54 list of all the relatives13:55 that are coming to shul on Shabbat13:57 in order to give them aliyot.13:59 So he has on the list, of14:01 course, his father Yitzhak,14:01 and he has his brother14:03 Eisav, and his14:05 father-in-law Lavan, and he has his14:06 brother-in-laws and his cousins and his friends.14:08 All these people are supposed to get aliyot.14:10 Yaakov himself cannot read the list.14:12 However, Eliezer,14:13 the one who is14:15 the one in charge of the shul,14:17 the one who is going to honor people,14:18 you know, invite them to go get the aliyah,14:21 he's allowed to read the list14:22 because he's not the owner himself.14:25 He can't change the list.14:26 He's given the14:27 list, and that's it. He follows the14:28 rules. He says, You give Yitzhak Kohen,14:31 you give Yitzhak Kohen,14:32 you give14:34 Eisav Hagbah, you give14:35 Eisav Hagbah, Lavan Petichah, you give14:36 Lavan Petichah. That's it.14:36 He just follows the list.14:37 It doesn't make a difference to him.14:39 He cannot erase it.14:41 Also, condition number two is14:42 that whoever is reading the14:43 list, in this case the14:44 shamash, the person in charge of the14:46 shul who's giving out the aliyot, the14:49 gabbai, he cannot read it with his mouth.14:51 He can only read it with his eyes.14:52 That's what the Mishnah brings over here.14:54 This is, again, like we said,14:55 this is the14:57 heter for reading such lists14:58 as long as it's not read by the person himself,15:01 and it's being done only by reading15:04 through, only with your eyes.15:06 Now you're going to ask me,15:08 what happened to the15:10 gezeirah? He explains why this is not a15:13 gezeirah. Number one is,15:15 remember we said there's two reasons15:16 why a person cannot read this list.15:18 Number one is because—15:20 Meaning, let me correct myself,15:23 clarify myself.15:24 There are two reasons15:25 why a person cannot,15:27 why Yaakov, the15:29 chatan who is making the list,15:29 cannot read this list on Shabbat.15:31 Number one is15:31 he might come to erase from the list.15:33 Number two is15:34 that he might lead him to read other things.15:36 So the first reason doesn't apply15:38 by15:39 le'eizehu, in this case is the15:40 shamash. Why not?15:41 Because being the gabbai of the shul,15:44 he has no authority15:45 to change anything on the list.15:47 So the15:49 gezeirah shema yimchak doesn't apply,15:50 as the Ben Ish Chai says over here.15:54 But you might tell me,15:55 one second,15:56 what about the second reason15:57 why you can't read such a list?15:59 Because...16:00 You might come to read16:04 bishtarei hedyotot. Still, afilu hachi nahagu olam heter16:07 bazeh, sheshamash korei betoch haketav hazeh shemot16:10 hamuzmanim. Why?16:13 Dechashiv tzorech mitzvah, lo gazru bazeh mishum16:17 yikra bishtarei hedyotot. Because the other heter is that16:20 you—this is a list that's talking about a mitzvah.16:23 You have a list where you want to invite people to the Torah, to the16:27 Sefer Torah, to get an aliyah, to be honored for the Sefer Torah.16:31 That's a mitzvah, to read in the Torah is a mitzvah.16:34 So therefore, in cases of mitzvah,16:36 they did not make such a16:39 gezeirah. As we learned, one of the reasons why a person cannot16:42 read the other documents,16:43 because you might come to read16:46 shtarei hedyotot, is because the reason is,16:48 shtarei hedyotot is asur because of asot16:51 chafatzecha, you're doing your need.16:52 And Gemara says, and that's halachah mentioned in vav,16:54 is that chafatzecha asurim, but chefetzei Shamayim mutarim.16:59 Haza never will gozer on something that's a mitzvah.17:03 That's only in the category of asot17:06 chafatzecha. If it's a mitzvah, Chachamim will not17:08 gozer. So in this case, although you don't have the reason17:12 that you might, you know, because it's a mitzvah,17:14 it's not going to lead you—they won't17:16 gozer, it's a mitzvah—it's not going to lead you to read in other documents,17:19 but you might have the reason of17:21 shema yimchok, that you might come to17:22 erase. For that, we fix it.17:25 How? By letting somebody else read it.17:26 Somebody else who doesn't have the power to change it17:28 or the authority to change anything on the list,17:30 for him it's permitted to read such a list.17:33 But here is another condition with reading this document.17:37 Number one, like we said, it cannot be done by the person,17:40 or any person that has authority to change from the list.17:44 Number two, also it has to be done with reading his eyes.17:46 And there's another condition17:53 that... asur likrot la'ayin bo od bShabbat. Then, after reading it, you cannot go back to read it.17:56 You know what it says already.17:57 You already used it.17:59 There's no purpose in reading it anymore.18:01 That's it. You got to put it away.18:04 Another heter, another example of this18:13 heter. Another thing they used to do in their days18:15 was that they would read things that are being done.18:21 You know, sometimes the committee or the rabbis would get together18:24 and make a new takanah and make a18:26 new—would set up a new rule, a new law in the community or in the shul.18:31 And on Shabbat, they would come out and they would read on Shabbat18:35 what this new rule is.18:37 Similar to what we do today in many shuls I've seen,18:40 the president or the rabbi will get up right before,18:44 and in the schedule for Shabbat is as follows:18:47 Shacharit tomorrow will be at this time.18:49 Classes will be at this time.18:50 Mincha is at this time.18:52 ... this person.18:54 Then they read from a list.18:55 How could you read from that list?18:56 Didn't we just say you can't read from the list?18:58 It's the same18:59 heter. Why can you read from the list,19:01 or you personally, how could you read the schedule from in the shul?19:06 And the answer is because you're not the one who wrote it.19:09 You don't have the authority to change what it says on the schedule.19:13 It's not like you could go and say,19:14 No, I don't like Mincha being at19:15 four o'clock. Let me change it to19:16 3:50. It doesn't work that way.19:18 Mincha is19:19 four o'clock. That's the way it's going to be.19:20 And therefore, you don't have that problem19:23 of shema yimchok. Also, you're going to tell me, but what about the problem19:27 of shema yikra b'shטרי הדיוטות? You might come to read the forbidden documents.19:30 To that also, being that the schedule of Shabbat is a davar mitzvah, something that's a19:37 mitzvah, we don't have—the minhag is to be lenient to read it with your eyes.19:43 So now, we found a very, very important19:46 heter. The heter is that as long as it's something of a mitzvah,19:51 something, a document that's related to a mitzvah,19:53 although it might not be divrei Torah itself,19:55 we mentioned this already,19:57 anything that's divrei Torah, that's for sure20:00 mutar, because you're reading Torah on Shabbat. What do you want better than that?20:03 But something even that's not Torah,20:05 as long as it's related to a mitzvah,20:07 it's mutar on the condition that you don't have the ability to erase it,20:10 because you don't have the authority to erase anything from it.20:15 And now let's give you another example to this:20:19 a case where there's, in many shuls,20:23 they have a special prayer for the people who are sick,20:27 and they write the names of the people who are sick on a Mi Sheberach list.20:30 So they will say,20:38 Mi sheberach... and specifically to, and then they go and read from the list20:41 who is going to be, whose needs20:47 a refuah shlemah. Likewise, in many shuls also,20:49 they—I know we do this on Yom Kippur20:52 sometimes—is that sometimes you have to say20:54 a hashkabah. And especially on Yom Kippur,20:55 everybody wants the names of some relatives,20:57 and some people have 10, 15 relatives,20:59 and there's a big list.21:00 You have 10, 15 relatives times 100 people,21:02 that's a thousand names already.21:04 So to sit there and to go and read21:06 and to go and wait for everybody to come say it21:08 takes a long time.21:09 So in some shuls, what they do,21:11 we've done in the past,21:12 is that you write a list of everybody's names,21:14 whoever needs a21:16 Mi Sheberach, whoever needs a21:17 hashkabah, come and write your names before Yom Kippur.21:20 Or it could be the same thing.21:22 People sometimes want,21:24 you know, in order—the shuls want to help sponsor classes21:28 or the programs in the shuls,21:30 so they'll say,21:32 especially21:32 Mi Sheberach, for the people who are21:34 tomech, the people who are supporting the place,21:36 and they write their names on the list.21:37 Again, in all these cases,21:39 it's a list of a mitzvah.21:41 It's a list of people who need refuah21:43 sheleimah. It's a list of people who need to have21:46 hashkabah, or it's a list of people who are getting21:49 a Mishaberach for supporting the shul.21:50 It's a list of mitzvahs.21:51 So you have no problem of confusing a list,21:55 a document of mitzvah,21:56 with21:58 shtarei hedyotot, with another document that's not mitzvah.22:02 What's the other problem you might come to erase?22:04 No,22:04 you're not the one.22:05 You have no authority to erase.22:07 You're given the list22:08 and you read it.22:09 You're as the rabbi,22:10 you as the gabbai.22:12 This is the list.22:13 Whatever it is,22:14 you're going to read it.22:16 You're going to tell me,22:16 what about if,22:17 chas v'shalom, a person was sick22:18 and you found out on22:19 Shabbat that he passed away?22:21 You're still not going to erase it.22:22 It's not very, very unlikely.22:24 In such a case,22:24 you don't have to worry about it.22:25 The minhag is to be lenient.22:26 This is what the sefarim bring down.22:29 Minhag is to be lenient.22:29 This will apply also22:31 if a person has a22:34 simchah in the shul, and by the22:34 Mi Sheberach, when they say,22:35 you know, by the22:37 sefaradim, you can't get an aliyah on Shabbat for free.22:39 Right away when you finish the22:41 berachot, you get a22:43 Mi Sheberach. When you're getting a22:43 berachah, but it's going to cost you.22:45 It might cost you a few dollars.22:47 In some places22:47 it's a few hundred dollars.22:49 It's going to cost you,22:50 but Baruch Hashem,22:50 you know,22:51 it's a happy cost.22:52 It's a good cost.22:53 It's a good way to spend your money22:55 in shuls and for a mitzvah.22:57 In any case,22:58 so usually when a person gets a23:01 Mi Sheberach, especially if there's a simchah going on in the shul,23:03 so they want to say also23:05 l'chayei, you know, at the end23:06 they say, to the life,23:07 you know,23:07 Hashem should give life also to the23:09 baal simchah, this one and this family and that family.23:11 And a lot of times23:11 the family,23:12 one family is from the shul,23:13 other family is not from the shul,23:15 and the gabbai is writing on a piece of paper23:17 who the families are on the shul,23:20 I mean to say,23:22 who the families are in the shul for the23:24 simchah. That's also mutar.23:26 The gabbai could read23:29 Mi Sheberach, sheyvarech l'chayei, and then he goes to the list:23:31 l'chayim mishpachat Cohen, mishpachat Levi,23:34 mishpachat Yisrael, mishpachat haLeviim. All that,23:35 that's all mutar.23:36 Again,23:37 it's a list of a mitzvah,23:38 and he doesn't have the authority23:40 to erase any person's name from the list.23:44 Another example that's brought down,23:46 and very, very practical.23:48 In yeshivot,23:48 they have something called23:50 toranut. What that is,23:51 is that every yeshiva,23:53 when they say for Shabbat,23:55 they have seudot on Shabbat,23:57 and in order to help the yeshiva with money and—24:00 The yeshiva shouldn't spend so much money, so what they do is they bring, they have24:04 the students, the talmidim, they take rotations, they do, you know, different shifts,24:09 and every, let's say, Shabbat, depends how big the yeshiva is, two to about two or24:14 four bachurim are in charge of setting up and cleaning up,24:18 and everybody has to read the list to see when his turn is.24:21 To read such signs on Shabbat is also24:23 mutar. Why?24:24 Because he's setting up for the seudah of Shabbat, and of course the talmid, as much as he wants24:27 maybe to erase his name off the list, that he doesn't want to be the one who wants to set up for24:33 the table, doesn't make a difference.24:35 The rosh yeshiva or the mashgiach already wrote your name on the list, and that's it,24:39 you're done,24:40 you have to go.24:41 All this is also24:43 mutar. There's a big chiddush that Rav Nissim Karelitz brings down.24:48 He says, in the case of a woman who needs to be so organized, and she needs to know24:54 exactly what's being served, and she needs to have, she needs to write the schedule. Let's say she's making25:00 a simcha in the house, and she has 50 people coming to the house.25:03 It's a lot of pressure.25:05 Us men, we just go and eat.25:06 We don't know what it takes for a woman to go and set up. Even though you might pay for25:10 the food, even though you might put some spices in the cholent, hazaku baruch, but at the end of the day,25:15 that pressure of preparing the house, that the house should look nice and everything25:20 should go smoothly, the wife feels it.25:22 Even if you buy all the food and she's not cooking anything, the woman feels that pressure25:27 still, that everything should run smoothly, everything should go nicely, everything should25:30 look nice and good.25:31 It's not just what you're serving, the food; it's also how you serve it and what you put.25:36 So a lot of women need to have everything organized, and they need to have, just for25:40 their own yishuv hadaat, they need to have this list of exactly what's being served.25:45 First we have kiddush, afterwards we have challah, and then we have, I don't know,25:50 asfaradi you have tahina, and if you're Ashkenazi you have egg salad and liver, and everything has to be organized25:56 exactly what's coming out. First and what's coming out, second what's coming out, third.26:01 Says Rav Nissim Karelitz, even though it's a list that you might come to erase, maybe26:05 shetarei deyotot, but being that it's for tzorech seudat Yom Tov, this could also be considered26:11 tzorkhei haguf. What does it mean, tzorkhei haguf? If you remember, we learned the halacha that a letter that comes to you on Shabbat,26:16 Maran says any letter that comes to you on Shabbat, you're allowed to read it if you don't know26:20 what it contains, because it might contain things that are for your physical26:26 well-being. As long as it doesn't talk about monetary things, but things for your physical well-being, it's26:31 mutar. Says Rav Nissim Karelitz, this type of list for this woman who needs to know what's going on,26:36 it's tzorkhei haguf, otherwise she'll go crazy.26:39 Because she's going to go crazy, it's not going to work.26:42 Therefore, we permit her to read such a list,26:45 even though you might read the halacha and say, What do you mean?26:48 It's not zeman or hem and things.26:50 Rav Nissim Karelitz is matir.26:53 Rav Shlomo Zalman—excuse me, Rav Nissim Karelitz is matir, but on a condition, sorry, that the lady doesn't read it herself,26:59 but she has somebody else reading it.27:01 But Rav Shlomo Zalman goes an extra step, and he's matir that the woman herself glance at27:08 it—not to read it, but to glance at it.27:11 Again, the heter by Rav Nissim Karelitz is that the woman should not read it, but she should have somebody else read it for her,27:16 because that person is not going to erase anything on the list.27:19 And Rav Shlomo Zalman says even if she wants to look at the list, but she can't read it, she just glances to remember.27:25 But she knows exactly what's going to come out.27:26 She knows there is fish, and there is this, and there is that.27:31 She knows exactly,27:32 but still she needs to be reminded sometimes; she gets nervous. That also is27:37 mutar. However, with all this, we're telling you some heterim, we have to point out something very, very important:27:42 don't mix up the heter of l'tzorech mitzvah. And to read something that's asur.27:48 All advertisements are forbidden,27:51 and it doesn't make a difference what the advertisement is about.27:54 Even if the advertisement is for something that's Jewish and, and, and, and Judaica and sefarim,28:00 the new sefer of Rav Chaim Kanievsky is coming out to the market,28:06 the new Yabia Omer, chelek yud aleph, is coming out.28:08 We have it on sale for28:12 $9.99. Wow, $9.99, unbelievable.28:14 Which sefer is $9.99 today?28:15 Get it while it's hot, because that's it. The next time the sefer is going to come out, it's going to be in two years,28:21 right? And you want to run to it.28:22 That's asur to read on Shabbat.28:24 Well, I'm telling you what it says already,28:25 but even to see, oh, there's a sefarim sale.28:28 Or right now we're coming up to28:30 Chanukah, menorah sale.28:31 It's a mitzvah to light candles.28:33 Or a wig sale.28:35 It's a mitzvah, she's coming her hair, the lady,28:37 some wigs, whatever.28:38 Tefillin sale.28:39 All these things are forbidden to read.28:42 That is28:43 shtarei hedyotot. Even though they're speaking about a mitzvah, that is the classic of28:48 shtarei hedyotot. The things that are we just mentioned are not real28:52 shtarei hedyotot. The heterim, the things that are permitted that we mentioned are not real28:55 shtarei hedyotot. They're just things that might lead you to28:58 shtarei hedyotot. This is actual29:00 shtarei hedyotot. The actual sale, that's mamash29:03 shtarei hedyotot, and therefore it's absolutely forbidden to read any sort of advertisement,29:08 even if they're advertising Jewish stuff.29:12 Even if I would advertise myself, it doesn't make a difference who's advertising.29:16 It is asur for a person to read advertisements for things on sale on29:21 Shabbat. Another example Chaim Davidoff brings down,29:27 in Israel it's more29:28 shayach. Here, most people for transportation, they'll use cars.29:32 In Israel, transportation, most people don't have cars.29:35 Most people use buses and trains.29:38 To read the schedule for the bus and the train is forbidden.29:42 Even if you're reading, by the way, in your own house29:44 and it's printed, you know how they have the MTA,29:46 you know, the subway line, exactly where it29:48 goes, that's assur on Shabbat.29:49 Even though you're planning to get on the train after Shabbat29:52 in order to go to a wedding, a mitzvah,29:54 or you're planning to go to shiur,29:56 or you're planning to go to the Agudath Yisrael convention,29:59 or you're planning to go,30:00 it doesn't make a difference.30:02 To read the bus schedule on Shabbat,30:05 that is mamash30:07 toldot. It's not something that might lead to30:09 shtarei hedyotot. That is30:11 shtarei hedyotot, and therefore it's forbidden for a person to look at the bus or train schedule on Shabbat,30:16 even if one doesn't express it with his mouth.30:18 It is still forbidden.30:21 Ad kan is30:24 halacha, het, and basically we brought a very, very important30:28 heter that much heterim, or much cases, that can be learned from it. Now,30:32 for the next part of the class,30:35 if you'd like to call in, by the way,30:37 you can call in any time now,30:38 because for this part of the class already,30:40 we're going to bring many, many examples30:42 of different things that people either do read on Shabbat,30:46 or might read on Shabbat,30:48 or probably, or want to read on Shabbat,30:51 and we're going to bring those examples.30:52 We're going to say what is permitted,30:54 what is forbidden, and why.30:56 So if you have a case,30:57 you have a case that you would like us to speak about,31:01 the best is by texting it in,31:02 because it's very possible31:04 that it's probably on my list.31:07 And in case it's not on my list,31:10 I'll say.31:12 You could also call in,31:13 and you could ask about your case, your specific case.31:15 The number is to the station,31:20 718-683-5858. And to text in31:22 whatever you would like to ask about,31:24 you could text in31:30 at 347-927-8398. Let's begin. Books.31:32 Which books can or cannot be read on Shabbat?31:36 First, we're going to31:37 describe what the book is, and then we're going to say why.31:39 Let's start with Jewish books.31:41 What do I mean by Jewish books?31:44 Jewish books mean31:46 any book that deals with the Torah subject,31:50 that's either based on Torah,31:53 based on or explaining the Torah,31:56 or it's works of the lessons from...32:00 Like, for example, let's say you have parenting books that are based on32:06 ma'amarei Chazal. So that's why I call over here Jewish books. Because remember,32:11 the real, real divrei Torah on Shabbat is permitted. You want to open up and learn Rashi? Of32:15 course it's mutar. Gemara, there's no question. Even not only that, even a person32:20 who wrote a chidush Torah, your son wrote a chidush Torah, and there's a32:24 mashal in the middle, and there's a story, and there's a joke in the middle of the32:27 article, it doesn't make a difference. All that, that's called Torah, mamash. They're explaining a concept32:31 in Torah in their own way. That's all mutar on Shabbat. Talking about even books that are not necessarily32:37 coming to explain Torah. They're coming to teach you about parenting. They're coming32:39 to teach you about how to become a more confident person, but they're using the Torah. You32:46 know, if you go to Barnes and Noble, you'll see a whole section of self-help books. And32:51 over there, of course, not based on Torah. It's based on whatever they base it32:54 on. Sometimes it's atheism, and sometimes it's other religions, Has v'shalom, Hashem yerachem. But over here, these33:02 things, these are subjects that are universal. Still, once it's based on the Torah, it's33:08 all mutar. So if you have a parenting book, I don't want to say names, but there33:12 are plenty of good ones. I just don't want to say one or two names, everybody will think33:15 the other ones are not good, so I don't want to say that. But there are33:18 plenty of parenting books which are based on ma'amarei Chazal. There are based, especially the ones33:23 that have an introduction by Gedolim. Obviously that's all pesukim and statements from the33:29 Gemara, and lessons that we can learn from them. All that is 100% permitted on Shabbat, no question. Also,33:37 books that lead you to do mitzvot. That means books that may speak something that's not33:44 directly explaining Torah, but it'll lead you to have love of God, it'll lead you to33:50 have fear of Hashem, ahavat Hashem, yirat Hashem, all permitted. You want an example?33:54 Somebody called last week and they said, Can we read biographies of Gedolim on Shabbat?33:59 That's an excellent question, because based on what we learned, it's not really Torah.34:03 They're telling you the stories of this great rabbi when he was a kid and how he grew and how he... They're34:08 not really giving you any chiddushei Torah over there. There's, I think, one book on Rav Aharon Kotler where the whole book is not a biography, but rather lessons or teachings of Rav34:19 Aharon Kotler. Most other biographies will just tell you basically the storyline of the gadol. Here,34:25 the most recent one, the most famous one recently is the Chacham Ovadia book. Fantastic,34:29 wonderful book, all the ones that came out on him. And each one talks about how he went to34:33 Egypt, and from Egypt he came back to Eretz Yisrael, and he became a dayan, and from becoming a dayan he34:38 went to become chief rabbi of Tel Aviv, and there he went to become chief rabbi34:41 over Eretz Yisrael, and then he opened up Shas. All these things, they're stories and they're tales. They're not34:46 giving you any chiddushim necessarily that he did. Still, those all mutar. Why?34:51 When you read about a gadol, it brings you to love of Hashem. It brings you to learning34:56 more Torah. Go read the biography of Rav Elyashiv. Go read about— you know what? Go read35:00 Rebbetzin Kanievsky's book, and you read a whole section about Rav Chaim35:04 Kanievsky and how he learned, what a masmid he was. Go read about Rav Shach also, and Rav35:12 Elyashiv, and Chacham Ovadia. Look how much— and when you read how much they dedicated their life35:18 to learning Torah and inspired you to learn Torah. So such books are in the category that35:23 I call Jewish books, and therefore those are all permitted lechatchila without a question.35:30 Next, Jewish novels. This is what we put— let's put it under fiction books, okay? All35:37 this has to be Jewish, by the way, because non-Jewish books, we mentioned last week, is forbidden35:42 even during the weekday. Non-Jewish books, stam letzanut and nonsense, that's35:48 assur. Things that the mamash talk about, things are forbidden. Even, I've seen some books from kids in high35:54 school that they have to read that mamash curses in there, and they speak about things35:58 that are asur for a person to read them. Even the ones from hundreds of years ago, like Shakespeare36:04 and everything, all those, they spoke about romance and love, and they put all different36:10 types of aveirot in a person's mind. That's for sure forbidden, even during the weekday,36:15 Hashem yerachem. But we're talking about Jewish novels now. So, can you read such books? Again, I'm36:20 not saying any names, but they sell them in bookstores. As a rule, by the way, something36:26 that's being sold in a Jewish bookstore doesn't give it a heter for everything. They sell36:29 candles in Jewish bookstores. Are you going to put them on Shabbat? No. They sell Jewish36:32 books in the bookstore because you can read them during the weekday. The question is, can36:36 you read them on Shabbat? Do they fall under the category of being mutar or of asur because36:43 shtarei hedyotot, or not? And the answer to this is as follows. If it's a book that gives a person36:51 musar and yirat shamayim, then there's something to rely on. You could be somech to read it.36:58 So, what I've been told, my wife reads plenty of these books, so she told me that most37:04 of the books, pretty much, that she read always bring out some point of37:11 musar and yirat shamayim. And therefore, even though you only feel the point by the end of the book, and you feel37:17 a little bit of musar and yirat shamayim, you know, like towards the end you see how the big lesson is,37:23 and it might take you two weeks to get there depending on how fast you read, still, since37:27 they bring out this point, it would be permitted to rely on such a book to read it. It's37:32 kind of like, to explain the heter a little bit, it's kind of like, you know,37:37 different types of speakers. There's a rabbi who has a point. Most rabbis have one point37:42 and they want to give it over. Some rabbis will use a story, some will use a joke, and37:48 some rabbis will take the same story and joke that they could have said in five minutes37:52 and stretch it for a full hour. Everybody has different ways, and you have to know who37:56 you're speaking to. If you're speaking to a crowd of yeshiva bachurim, so they don't38:00 need to hear a story for an hour. If you're speaking to a crowd of ladies, especially38:05 people who are not so close to Torah, and they need, you know, they can't follow so38:10 much different chiddushei Torah, so you need to take one chiddush and bring out a beautiful38:14 long story to attract them. So fine for them. It's the same idea. This book is a38:21 two-week journey to bring out this one small point. If there's such a book that has38:27 Musar and Yiras Shamayim, Midrash Navo, that brings out Musar and Yiras Shamayim, again, it's mutar38:32 if it's needed for a person. Of course, it's not like the other books, but a person who38:37 reads it on Shabbat has what to rely on, because at the end of the day it doesn't bring out38:41 Musar and Yiras Shamayim. But you have to know that it brings out such a thing.38:44 Next, speaking about books, what about textbooks, meaning science books, and you have encyclopedias,38:53 non-Jewish encyclopedias. These are books basically that contain wisdom, not Jewish,38:59 but wisdom. Tell you about nature. They tell you about chemistry. They tell you about39:05 electricity. I don't know. They tell you about all different types of things. Nothing39:08 asur hash, I'm not talking about things that are forbidden. Remember, things that speak about lashon hara and nibul39:13 peh, that's asur even on a weekday. Maran writes in ... We said, if you didn't39:18 hear last week's class, last week's class we mentioned anybody who prints out39:22 those books is machti et harabim. We're not talking about those books. We're talking about books39:25 that have wisdom. So such books that have wisdom, if you remember last week we mentioned39:30 the machloket in Shulchan Aruch. According to Shulchan Aruch, which is the opinion of39:34 the Sefardim, any books that don't lead to Torah and Yirat Shamayim directly. I mean, of39:39 course, you could apply anything and make it for Torah and Yirat Shamayim. I'm talking about, you know, you look at the39:45 world and you'll see, wow, what amazing how the tree works and how the leaves fall39:50 off the tree and how the snow comes down. And from that you could say, Mah rabu ma'asecha Hashem. But that's39:55 not the purpose of the book. The purpose of the book is written that you should learn how the39:59 leaves fall off the tree.40:00 That's all it is. Pure simple science. That's all it is.40:03 So such books of wisdom, according to Maran, ... Sefardim, it's assur to read on Shabbat.40:11 According to the Ashkenazi, according—Maran brings, however,40:16 yesh mi shematir, the Rashba. The Rashba is matir to learn such books on Shabbat.40:18 So therefore, we tell you like this: if it's very necessary for a person to read it,40:24 and he's not gonna—you know, he has nothing else to do, and he cannot come to learn Torah or whatever,40:29 and he wants to read it, he has what to be somech on.40:32 Children, for sure, under bar mitzvah, for sure, even Sefardi children can do it.40:36 Ashkenazim have what to rely on also. Ashkenazim—the Rama brings down,40:42 excuse me, the Mishnah Berurah brings down,40:44 v'chen nohagin minhag Ashkenazim is they go like the40:47 Rashba that permits reading books of wisdom.40:50 So therefore, such books, textbooks, if a person needs to read it on Shabbat,40:55 Sefardim should avoid it. Ashkenazim have what to rely on.41:00 Chacham Ovadia brings down, if a person has a41:05 test—let's say high school kids, teenagers above the age of bar mitzvah,41:08 because remember, under the age of bar mitzvah,41:10 you can be somech on the yesh mi shematir. That's for sure41:13 mutar. But above the age of bar mitzvah, and now they have a test on Sunday or Monday,41:18 and they have a final, and they have to study, and they have to catch up on their study,41:22 and the only time they can study is Shabbat.41:24 Of course you can study also motzaei Shabbat and Sunday,41:27 but they're not gonna be able to just study on motzaei Shabbat and Sunday.41:29 They need to review and to learn it on Shabbat.41:32 Or let's say a person in college who has a test coming up, a final exam,41:36 or he's becoming a doctor, he's becoming a lawyer.41:39 All these things, Chacham Ovadia says,41:41 as long as it's not being done on a regular basis,41:43 it's mutar for a person to rely on the41:46 yesh mi shematir. Again, only if it's not on a regular basis.41:49 You can't just go ahead, it's not a free41:51 heter, just open up any encyclopedia and read on Shabbat.41:54 Only if it's not done on a regular basis.41:57 Which leads us to the next question:41:58 what about cookbooks on Shabbat?42:00 Now, cookbooks have two issues over here.42:03 Number one is, like we said, it could be42:06 study Halachot. Number two is maybe it's like42:09 hachanah, because you read a nice thing in the cookbook.42:11 It says how to make waffle in a way that you never imagined.42:15 Wow, I didn't know you could make waffles with lemons and syrup,42:19 and wow, that's amazing.42:21 Or it's going to make a new dish.42:23 Men are going to read it.42:25 You know, for men it's not a problem42:26 of hachanah, because for men, they're just going to come to their wife and say,42:29 Aha, read page 49.42:31 You know, that's not a problem. They're not going to actually cook.42:33 We're talking about ladies.42:34 Could ladies read cookbooks on Shabbat?42:37 So that's one issue is42:39 hachanah. The other issue is study42:41 Halachot. As far as study Halachot, we said already42:43 that this is a book of wisdom.42:45 Books of wisdom is42:47 machloket. Ashkenazim, it's mutar.42:49 Sefardim should try to avoid it unless it's necessary.42:52 But in this case over here of42:56 hachanah, the Acharonim bring down that42:58 ladies who usually read cookbooks,43:01 not necessarily reading it because they're preparing themselves43:05 or they want to prepare a dish,43:07 they're learning how to actually cook.43:09 There's an enjoyment of just learning of what's out there,43:11 of the food that's out there,43:13 and interesting. It's kind of like a conversation.43:15 It's43:15 interesting. So therefore, the Acharonim, I believe43:20 Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and others bring down that it's mutar.43:21 Even Yalkut Yosef brings down that's mutar,43:25 and that's43:26 Hacham Ovadia also brings in43:28 Chazon Ovadia, Shabbat, chelek vav.43:30 But he concludes and he says,43:33 V'tov lehachmir. Which means if it's possible for a lady that she,43:36 you know, she has something else to read,43:38 let her read something else.43:39 She shouldn't read cookbooks,43:41 Sefardi lady, that is.43:42 A Sefardi lady shouldn't read the cookbooks on Shabbat.43:44 It's better to be43:47 machmir. But again, it falls under books of wisdom,43:50 which Sefardim have to try to avoid,43:52 Ashkenazim could read.43:54 And of course, this is43:56 all these things we keep on repeating.43:58 It's only for a person that have44:00 better things to read,44:01 things that everybody will agree44:04 that it's mutar lechatchila. Next category of things:44:07 the permitted or forbidden on Shabbat.44:11 The category is newspapers,44:13 magazines,44:14 flyers,44:16 invitations. Let's talk about these.44:17 Could you read them on Shabbat?44:18 What is mutar, what is not44:20 mutar? Let's begin with newspapers,44:22 and then we'll go on to magazines and the other things.44:25 Newspapers.44:26 Let's,44:27 before we continue,44:29 the only thing that44:30 when we say newspapers over here,44:31 it's got to be Jewish.44:33 It cannot be not religious newspapers.44:35 Why?44:36 Not religious newspapers,44:37 I don't know if anybody's picked up,44:39 for sure the New York Post,44:40 that's pure garbage.44:41 There's no question.44:42 Yes, I'm saying it live.44:43 There's no doubt.44:45 Once upon a time,44:46 I used to read them, Avoteinu Harabim.44:48 We know what's inside.44:49 That's pure nonsense.44:51 That's asur during the weekday even.44:53 Why?44:54 Non-religious newspapers have44:56 many things44:58 that are forbidden,44:59 content that are forbidden.45:01 They have images, pictures45:03 of ladies not dressed properly.45:04 That's asur.45:05 They have content,45:07 what they speak about,45:08 the way they speak about God,45:09 and the way they speak about different things,45:11 and how they describe different events.45:14 It's also asur.45:15 They also describe the Jewish people45:17 in a forbidden way.45:19 And of course,45:20 they have words of45:21 kefirah, mamash kefirah inside of it.45:22 So these are not my words;45:24 these are words of all the45:26 poskim. Non-Jewish newspapers are forbidden45:28 even during the weekday.45:29 Maybe, maybe during the weekday,45:31 during the weekday,45:32 if a person wants to read the sports section45:34 and it's clean,45:34 maybe over there,45:35 okay, I understand,45:36 for a little bit of entertainment.45:37 You want to know who's winning,45:38 which team is winning,45:39 fine. There's no forbidden images over there.45:41 It's only pictures of men,45:42 almost dressed properly.45:44 And there's also,45:45 you know,45:46 they're not describing world events,45:48 they're not attributing anything,45:50 chas v'shalom, to45:51 avodah zarah or anything else.45:52 Okay, fine, yes,45:53 you have what to rely on45:55 if a person needs,45:56 you know, likes to follow sports,45:57 there's what to rely on.45:58 But otherwise,45:59 all the other things in the newspapers46:00 are garbage.46:02 Maybe also the business section46:03 during the weekday.46:04 On46:05 Shabbat—no, that's different.46:07 On Shabbat,46:08 it's forbidden to read46:10 those parts in the newspaper46:12 that46:14 even during the weekday46:14 would be46:15 mutar. Which means,46:16 let's take the business section.46:17 Now we're already talking about46:18 all newspapers,46:19 talking about even Jewish newspapers.46:21 If you get46:22 the famous ones,46:24 Hamodia and the46:25 Yated,46:26 these two famous ones,46:27 right?46:27 Everybody reads those newspapers.46:29 You're allowed to read them46:29 during the weekday,46:31 almost.46:31 But on Shabbat,46:33 on Shabbat,46:34 you have to be46:35 careful of certain sections.46:36 Business section46:37 is asur. Stock market,46:38 up46:40 and down, huge ... Just because46:41 it's a Jewish newspaper,46:42 don't think that when they say,46:44 you know,46:44 we have gedolim46:45 behind our newspaper,46:47 don't think that the gadol46:48 actually46:48 every single week46:49 opens up the46:50 Hamodia from the beginning to the end46:52 and goes through every page46:53 and says,46:53 Oh, all this is46:54 mutar to read on Shabbat.46:55 You got to be kidding me.46:57 The newspaper is writing46:58 for a person to read46:59 on the weekday.46:59 They bring it,47:00 they print it already47:00 from Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday,47:02 and it's done47:03 for the news of the weekday.47:04 Doesn't mean it's47:05 mutar to be done on Shabbat.47:06 And I know,47:06 and I know47:07 that every hospital47:08 you go to,47:09 a Jewish hospital,47:10 they'll put out47:10 these newspapers on Shabbat.47:11 But you—47:13 As a person learning47:14 halacha, you have to be careful.47:15 You can't read sections47:16 that deal with business.47:19 This also includes advertisements,47:21 and advertisements47:22 are all over the newspaper.47:24 If you can't avoid47:25 the advertisements,47:26 you cannot read them.47:28 Advertisements,47:28 like we said,47:29 are forbidden to read on Shabbat.47:30 If you can read the47:32 article that you need to read about,47:33 let's say,47:33 you47:34 know, they have a chiddush Torah,47:35 which you're allowed to read47:37 from the newspaper on Shabbat,47:38 or they have an article47:39 that talks about parenting,47:41 or they have a section47:43 that talks about,47:44 you know,47:45 good health47:45 and all these things.47:46 Those are also47:48 chelek guf. Okay,47:48 you might have47:49 an issue of sefarim, but things that47:51 you're allowed to read.47:52 Any advertisement47:53 that are on the page47:54 is forbidden,47:56 and regardless47:56 what they're advertising,47:58 if they're47:59 advertising a sale...48:00 Selling anything, that's asur. Even if they're selling books, even if they're selling anything, that's asur.48:05 So you have to be careful to avoid that.48:09 The other sections in the newspaper, the other sections in the newspaper, like, let's see, I don't know, to your health, or let's say jokes and all other things.48:23 So now you have to be careful, because really things that are not based on Torah, then those things are—what are they then?48:33 Let's say current events. They're telling you what's going on in Israel.48:38 Is that mutar or asur on Shabbat?48:40 During the weekday, okay, it's mutar.48:42 Some are matir even to read about current events on Shabbat because it might help you. It's called48:47 tzorkhei haguf. It might be to your—it's important for you to know that there's anti-Semitism is growing, and be careful not to flash your Judaism in the face of the48:57 goyim. Oh, okay, it might be something that is important for you to know, or your son is going to Israel and you need to know which places that he should avoid, and you don't know what's going on49:06 in the news, now you see it in the newspaper. Some are matir49:09 it. Although, Menuchat Ahavah says, no, it's not mutar on Shabbat. You could have read it on Friday.49:13 You obviously got this newspaper before Shabbat, so how could you read it on Shabbat?49:17 So it's debatable. Somebody who does read it has what to rely on.49:22 However, however, the things that are not necessarily of current events, things of wisdom, like we said, the health section, or, you know, what's good to diet,49:31 all these things of a chokmah, we have the same machloket between Sefardim and Ashkenazim.49:36 Sefardim have to avoid it. Ashkenazim, it's mutar.49:38 And all of these things that we said that are mutar on Shabbat from the newspaper, wherever, you know, the few sections that you can select, it's only mutar to read it with your eyes.49:49 You cannot read it with your mouth. To glance at it with your eyes, that's all mutar.49:53 But again, only with the eyes and not to actually read it.49:57 This same will apply to magazines.50:00 And again, the magazine doesn't make a difference,50:02 even Jewish radio. Like we said, they're coming out with a magazine,50:07 wonderful magazine, Baruch Hashem, it's unbelievable. The last one was beautiful.50:11 You had everything pretty much. You had the radio in print.50:13 That's what it was. You had the radio in print.50:15 Not every section in there is mutar.50:18 If it's divrei Torah, there's no question.50:20 All, I know, the articles on the last one, all the Hebrew ones were all50:23 divrei Torah. There's no question about that.50:25 Even the other ones, meshalim, all the things are for sure mutar.50:27 The kosher section, mutar, all these things.50:29 Things that deal with a person's health, that's sifrei50:34 chochmah. If it's based on pesukim and ma'amarei Chazal, that's mutar.50:38 If it's not based on that, you cannot read that on Shabbat if you're50:44 Sefardi, and Ashkenazi have what to rely on that they can be50:48 noheg. Again, even if a Sefardi wants to read the health section in the newspaper or in a magazine,50:53 it's mutar if there's nothing else.50:56 They have what to rely on.50:58 Really, Sefardim lechatchilah should not.51:00 It's really because Maran, Kvod Maran,51:02 is asur. But since there's something to be somech on, I'm not going to go crazy and yell about it.51:07 In a magazine, you have another heter, and that is the pictures.51:11 Pictures are in the magazine.51:13 You're allowed to glance at the pictures.51:15 Again, permitted pictures.51:16 We're talking about kosher Jewish magazines.51:18 The other ones are not kosher.51:20 There's nothing to speak about.51:21 Kosher Jewish magazines are allowed to be. You're allowed to glance at it on Shabbat51:25 as long as you avoid reading the captions on the bottom.51:29 Like we mentioned last week, Maran writes, captions even of Jewish events,51:34 like David and Goliath fighting, is asur on Shabbat.51:36 So therefore, captions that describe who's who and they describe an event,51:41 those should not be read on Shabbat.51:42 But you could read—excuse me—you could just look at the pictures on Shabbat.51:49 Some are matir that if you have, like, a picture and you recognize the person,51:53 you just want to see quickly who the name is, that's51:55 mutar. Also, if you have pictures of tzaddikim. Of Gedolei Yisrael, rabbis,51:59 and they have their names on the bottom,52:03 and you want to know who that person is, is it mutar or not,52:07 then also, just to read the names of rabbis, that's also52:11 mutar. Or just as a quick reminder, that's also mutar to read the captions on Shabbat.52:15 This is from magazines.52:17 Now, you should know, we've spoken about magazines.52:19 I want to mention a little bit about JRadio magazine.52:22 I haven't seen any newspaper that does this.52:24 It was amazing.52:25 It has a whole story of, you know, just to let you know,52:28 the people behind the station of52:31 Nissim, Hashem should bless him. It's amazing.52:32 You know, he heard this halacha that you can't read advertisements on Shabbat,52:36 so he said, What do you mean?52:36 A newspaper can only exist, the only way you could fund the printing of52:41 newspapers is with52:42 advertisement, and we want the people to learn the Torah.52:44 And I'm sure the people who are advertising also, they're doing it because of52:47 JRadio, and they want to encourage the radio52:49 and encourage the people also to have more yirat Shamayim and things.52:53 So he did an amazing thing.52:54 He took all the advertisements, he put them in the back.52:57 During the weekday, open up the back and see all the supporters53:00 who support JRoot and the magazine.53:02 Go ahead and help them out,53:04 tizku l'mitzvot. But on Shabbat, he put a big sign,53:06 Nevotai, be careful.53:08 After this page, you're about to read advertisements.53:10 It was great.53:11 That's a big, big honor that he did in the magazine for Shabbat.53:15 Azat Hashem, he should come out with more and more prints,53:20 be'ezrat Hashem. Move on to the next category, flyers.53:21 I see a question on the text.53:23 I'm going to answer it, be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully by the end of the class.53:26 I have it actually on my list as well.53:29 Flyers,53:30 same thing.53:31 What is the content of the flyer?53:33 People put up these flyers in shuls.53:35 If they're advertisements, it's53:38 asur, you machshil harabim. If you're coming and you have a new restaurant53:40 and you want to put on,53:41 Come in, buy one meal,53:44 or, yeah, buy one meal, get a kids' meal free,53:46 and you're putting it in the shuls for people to read on Shabbat,53:49 that's a problem.53:50 You're putting it on the bulletin board53:52 because that's when people are walking in on Shabbat.53:53 That's a problem.53:54 You want to advertise, put it on the weekday.53:57 And now, if it's there on the weekday,53:58 now on Shabbat the people put a sign,54:00 Please do not read this on Shabbat.54:02 It's the same thing.54:02 You have these Torah pamphlets,54:04 these Torah flyers that they put out54:05 one, you know, one paper,54:07 and on the paper they have advertisements.54:09 You have to be54:10 careful. You cannot read54:11 the—not the whole flyer.54:13 You can't read the advertisements on Shabbat.54:14 You could read the Torah content,54:16 but the other things,54:18 the advertisements over there,54:20 buy this from this place54:22 and hire this person,54:24 that's all forbidden to be read on Shabbat.54:26 Invitations.54:28 What about invitations?54:29 Can a person read an invitation on Shabbat?54:30 And the answer is, really,54:32 the invitation has the same halacha as letters.54:35 What does that mean?54:36 Technically, if you have an invitation,54:39 and, you know, usually54:41 you get an invitation by mail on Shabbat, for example,54:44 you shouldn't read it.54:45 You read it after Shabbat54:46 because you know it's going to invite you to somewhere,54:47 and it's not necessary that you need to know about it on Shabbat.54:51 However, Yalkut Yosef brings down54:53 that if it's very, very necessary,54:55 a person wants to give out the invitations on Shabbat,54:57 really you shouldn't do it.54:58 He writes you shouldn't do it.54:59 But if it's very, very necessary,55:01 you could allow it to be given on Shabbat.55:06 Again, of55:07 course, it has to be, of course,55:08 that there's an55:09 eruv and people are only going to55:11 carry—there's no problem of carrying on Shabbat, of course.55:13 But he says55:14 you could allow people to give it out on Shabbat.55:17 He saw with his own eyes55:18 that once Hacham Ovadia was55:20 matir. Why?55:21 Why is it mutar on Shabbat?55:23 Because sometimes people who don't get invited,55:26 they get very offended,55:27 and sometimes it could cause two55:28 machloket, real machloket, and I've seen55:30 many fights happen, unfortunately,55:32 because of invitations.55:33 People didn't get it55:33 and things like that.55:35 So therefore,55:36 if it's very necessary55:37 and you really can't do it55:38 except for Shabbat,55:39 you can't do it once Shabbat,55:40 for whatever reason,55:42 there's something what to rely on,55:43 again, with the condition55:44 that there's no other choice55:45 or that they're not going to carry it home.55:47 That's something to rely on.55:48 Also,55:49 if you feel that you have to55:50 glance at the invitation55:51 to see that something might be on Shabbat,55:53 for example, you have an invitation55:54 and it says on it55:55 that the simcha on Shabbat,55:57 the Shabbat meal will be,55:58 and you forgot where it's going to be, you forgot.56:00 The address, you can look at the invitation again if you need it on Shabbat.56:04 If you don't need it, if it's not for Shabbat, you want to know which day of the week is your neighbor's wedding,56:10 you can't read it on Shabbat. It's not for Shabbat.56:12 Read it Motzei Shabbat. Nothing is going to change if you read it on Shabbat.56:15 Motzei Shabbat is when you're going to decide if you're going to.56:18 On Motzei Shabbat, if you read it, it's going to be the same thing as if you read it on Shabbat.56:21 So those invitations cannot be read on Shabbat.56:23 And the rule with letters that we mentioned last week: once you read it once, that's it.56:27 You got to put it away. You can't use it again.56:30 Pretty much, we covered the main56:33 subject. We have a question which I have over here also,56:35 and that is: what about all these things?56:38 Could a person read them in the bathroom?56:41 Could a person read all these things that we mentioned in the bathroom?56:44 Is there any heter to read in the bathroom things that are forbidden?56:48 And this question bothered me also for a very long time.56:51 And the answer, really, the hard answer is that whatever is forbidden to read56:56 is forbidden in your dining room, in your kitchen, as well as your bathroom.57:00 If it's asur, it's asur.57:02 However, I'll tell you like this:57:03 in the bathroom, if a person's mind wanders and he's thinking the wrong things,57:07 for example, in the bathroom you're not allowed to think divrei Torah.57:10 So let's say you're a person that your mind is thinking about divrei Torah57:13 and you want to keep it, you know, from not focusing on57:16 divrei Torah, you can be somech on the things that we brought above as heterim.57:21 I'm not going to go through the whole class again,57:22 but all the heterim that we brought before, you could use it to be57:26 somech and read them in the bathroom when it's very, very necessary.57:32 The last thing that we're going to conclude with this before we finish,57:37 that is that after hearing this class,57:41 so you got to keep—or this class and last week's57:43 class—you got to keep the following points in57:44 mind. Number one is, if you heard this and you want to change, things are not permitted.57:49 I know it's not easy; it's very, very hard.57:51 So first of all, if you want to work on yourself and stop to read things that are forbidden,57:56 start like this:57:57 start with things that everybody agrees is asur.58:00 Non-Jewish newspapers, even during the weekday.58:02 Stop at least on Shabbat and then get to the weekday.58:05 And then slowly, slowly, as you get stronger and stronger and stronger,58:08 and you have to find yourself some good kosher reading material,58:12 start reading—start cutting down on materials that you need a heter to rely on.58:19 So that's how you start.58:21 Start, number one, with things that are forbidden completely.58:25 Stop doing it. Stop reading that on Shabbat,58:27 and then go on to the things that you'll gradually improve on,58:31 you know, things that it's only mutar according to this opinion,58:34 it's only mutar according to this opinion.58:35 Okay, slowly, slowly, you could find your heterim.58:38 You know, slowly, slowly cut down on these heterim58:40 till you read things that everybody agrees is58:43 mutar. Now here's the last point, and it's very important.58:46 After listening to this class,58:48 be careful how you go about shooting58:53 and, you know, shooting this58:55 issur. If you yourself want to change yourself,58:57 chazak u'baruch. But when you come into other people58:59 and you see them reading things that, you know,59:02 you just learned that could be possibly asur,59:04 so you have to know, first of all, that you have to know the halacha very well.59:07 If you heard last week's class fully and this week's class fully,59:10 and you feel that you got it very clear, fine,59:12 you know what's mutar and what's not59:14 mutar, then you have permission to possibly speak.59:18 But if you don't know the halachot fully,59:20 don't go around and saying, This is asur, this is not asur.59:22 It could be very possible that's59:23 mutar. Number two is, if they have a heter,59:27 then you have no obligation59:29 and sometimes no right to be mocheh, to stop them.59:33 So you see your wife reading something,59:35 and she's reading a Jewish novel.59:37 You just read—Jewish novel is not the best thing;59:38 she's Frum. Also,59:40 listen, if she has what to rely on, you don't have to say it,59:43 unless she appreciates it.59:44 That's a different story.59:46 If she appreciates it, okay, you can say,59:47 You know what I learned today on the halacha hour.59:50 The other thing is also,59:51 even if she's reading something that's forbidden,59:53 you always have to think of the alternative.59:55 What is the alternative?59:56 Remember we mentioned before59:57 we came to this class two weeks ago,59:59 we said that there's a concept called1:00:01 mutav sheyihyu shogegim v'al yihyu mezidin.1:00:03 If you're going to say something,1:00:06 and what's going to cause is1:00:08 it's going to cause fights,1:00:09 it's going to cause a person to now1:00:12 do worse aveirot than the reading.1:00:14 If he's reading these things,1:00:15 it's1:00:16 asur min haTorah. Now you're going to call,1:00:17 you're going to tell him,1:00:19 stopping these things,1:00:19 you're going to sit there, speak lashon hara.1:00:21 So you know what?1:00:22 Let them be shogegim v'al yihyu mezidin.1:00:24 Don't say anything,1:00:25 especially if you know1:00:27 that they're going to do something worse.1:00:29 What does that mean?1:00:30 Oh, they're not going to listen to you at all, at all.1:00:32 This is a1:00:33 seudah deRabbanan. If no chiyuv of1:00:36 tokhacha. In a1:00:37 seudah deRabbanan that you know for sure1:00:38 they're not going to listen to you,1:00:39 you have no obligation to be1:00:41 mochiach. And this is how we'll conclude1:00:43 the halachot of what you could be on Shabbat.1:00:45 I think for the next month,1:00:46 we're going to take a break from these1:00:48 halachot. The halacha hour will still be on1:00:51 Wednesday, but we'll have already halachot of the season.1:00:54 Next week, with be'ezrat Hashem, we'll be talking about1:00:56 the bracha of1:00:57 Barech Alenu. Next week will be December 3rd,1:00:58 because December 4th already1:01:00 we switch from Barech Aleinu1:01:02 to Barech Alenu. And very important class,1:01:03 make sure you listen to it next week.1:01:05 And then from then on,1:01:06 I think we'll be going into the halachot of Chanukah,1:01:10 which is coming up,1:01:12 be'ezrat Hashem. And until then,1:01:13 be'ezrat Hashem, have a wonderful week.