Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 We are in Parashat Toldot in the Ben0:03 Ish Chai. We are in the middle of learning Hilchot Shabbat,0:06 and this is the fourth class on Parashat Toldot.0:09 We are in the laws of the Kriat HaTorah, the Torah reading.0:13 This is part two. Last week was part one,0:15 and this week, Baruch Hashem, is part two.0:17 We hope, Baruch Hashem, to conclude the halachot this week,0:19 as well as to finish the parashah of Toldot0:24 so we can move on already next week to Parashat0:27 Vayetze. Before we begin the class,0:28 we want to say that this class is sponsored0:34 l'ilui nishmat Baruch ben Manzal, alav hashalom. And if anybody else would like to sponsor any classes,0:41 l'ilui nishmat or l'hatzlacha, l'refuah shelemah, in honor of somebody,0:43 you could text us into the radio station at0:49 347-927-8398. We want to apologize0:52 before we begin. We want to apologize to the ladies0:54 because I know that this class is,0:56 it's all about Kriat HaTorah,0:59 and this is where the ladies really kind of don't know what's going on so much,1:03 and they don't, and really shouldn't,1:06 because halachah, although halachah says ladies could go up,1:09 but before we go crazy on that halachah, there's a lot of explanations.1:12 Ladies do not get aliyot in the tzibbur,1:14 as Maran's posek. We don't give ladies aliyot to the Torah,1:18 and therefore ladies don't know what the halachot,1:21 or don't need to know really these halachot.1:23 So really this is a halachah primarily for men.1:26 Maybe we'll talk about musaf at the end,1:28 and that's a little bit practical,1:29 that's a little bit relevant to the ladies.1:31 But for now, this is really a halachah primarily for men,1:35 and especially if you're a person who is involved in the shul,1:39 where you give out aliyot, you're the gabbai,1:41 you're the rabbi also.1:43 If the rabbi of the shul has to know these halachot,1:44 these are very important halachot that we need to know.1:47 And not only that, in the summer people go away,1:50 and a lot of times the gabbai will be away,1:52 and therefore you may be in the position1:54 where you'll have to know these halachot and to know what to do.1:57 And a lot of times these halachot are very vague1:59 because they come up only when it's necessary.2:01 What we'll do, Baruch Hashem, today2:03 is we're going to review a little bit from last week.2:05 We're going to clarify a little bit from the halachot2:07 that we spoke about last week,2:09 add a few points that we weren't able to get to last week,2:12 and then discuss some of the other issues2:15 that are relevant to the halachot of Kriat HaTorah.2:18 Let's begin2:19 again. Some of it will sound familiar.2:21 Whatever we said last week, I'm going to say very quickly,2:24 although I was told I'm speaking too fast,2:26 so I'll speak a little bit slower today.2:28 Let's begin.2:29 Seven subjects we touched upon last week.2:32 We're reviewing them very quickly.2:34 Number one is, we mentioned the Zohar2:35 that when you take out the Sefer Torah from the2:39 Aron, the Sefer Torah, taking out the Sefer Torah,2:41 reading the Sefer Torah,2:42 according to the Zohar, is equivalent to standing by2:46 Har Sinai. It's like you are standing by2:49 Ma'amad Har Sinai, and therefore we'll add a2:52 segulah that just like by2:53 Ma'amad Har Sinai, Hashem healed all those who are sick,2:56 Hashem also completed anything that somebody was missing.3:00 Likewise, if we treat the shul,3:03 if we treat the kriat haTorah in the shul3:05 as if we're standing by3:07 Har Sinai, the halacha will be, the atmosphere will be the same.3:11 Hashem will answer3:12 our tefillot. Hashem3:15 yimaleh chesronenu. Whatever we're missing, Hashem will complete it.3:17 Second point that we mentioned last week is,3:20 when we take out the Sefer Torah,3:22 we mentioned that people follow it,3:24 and there's different minhagim.3:25 Basically, whether you do it before the reading of the Torah3:28 or after the reading of the Torah,3:30 we show the3:31 ketav, we show the writing of the Sefer Torah to the whole kahal,3:34 and people look at it.3:35 And we mentioned that there's a custom by the3:39 Ashkenazim that they point to the Sefer Torah with their pinky,3:43 and that's brought down.3:43 We said that's an old minhag that's brought down.3:45 I didn't have an answer for it.3:47 I didn't know a reason why they pointed the pinky.3:50 One caller suggested that's connected to the melikah3:52 that the Kohen Gadol does in the Beit HaMikdash.3:55 And what melikah is,3:56 just for those who are not familiar,3:58 melikah is like4:00 shechitah, but on a bird.4:02 In the Beit HaMikdash,4:02 two types of animals were brought:4:04 either an animal, like a cow or whatever it was,4:07 or a sheep,4:09 or you brought a bird.4:11 And the bird was not slaughtered4:13 like the way the cows and the sheep were.4:16 The birds had to4:18 be—you have to have a melikah performed by it.4:19 Now, the person suggested that maybe in the melikah,4:22 which is done with the4:23 pinky—really, this is,4:24 I didn't correct it last week,4:26 but really melikah is not done with the pinky of the kohen;4:29 it's done with the thumb of the kohen.4:31 But I still want to say to that person who called last week,4:34 like I tell the guys in the Gemara,4:36 we have a Gemara class,4:37 and my style of the Gemara class4:39 is not to just read the Gemara and translate and explain,4:42 but rather to get the class interactive.4:44 And I tell them that I'm more interested in the thought process4:47 that one through to try to give an answer4:49 more than the correct answer.4:50 So therefore, for the effort,4:52 you get an A4:53 plus, at least trying to figure out what the answer is,4:55 and we still don't have an answer.4:56 But has v'shalom for a person to be4:59 מבזה מנהג, to put down a minhag.5:00 Minhagim that Klal Yisrael do,5:02 even if we don't have an answer or reason for it,5:05 just because we're not familiar with it.5:06 If you see everybody's doing it,5:08 we don't knock down minhagim5:10 unless they are against5:13 halacha. In that case, a person has to know.5:15 If it's 100% against5:17 halacha, then that minhag has to be stopped in a certain, in a proper way.5:22 Of course, it has to be done with daat Torah.5:23 You have to ask the rabbis, the gedolim,5:25 who ask them if you should stop5:27 or you should say anything against minhag.5:30 But otherwise, any minhag that the Jewish people do,5:33 if it's not against5:35 halacha, so what's the problem with it?5:36 Okay, so you don't understand an answer,5:38 a reason, not a big deal.5:39 So they point with the pinky,5:40 they want to point with a different finger.5:42 It doesn't make a difference.5:43 The other point that we spoke about last week5:45 is the aliyot, the order of the aliyot.5:48 We said that al5:50 pi Kabbalah, the best aliyah for a person to have on Shabbat5:54 is the sixth aliyah. Which is aliyah5:57 tishi. This doesn't mean what it says in the Chumash,5:59 shishi. This means that the sixth person to go up to the Sefer Torah6:03 is the best aliyah.6:05 It represents the midah of Yesod,6:07 and according to Kabbalah,6:10 the least best aliyah is6:13 shevi'i. That's according to Kabbalah.6:14 Although once upon a time,6:15 people were machshiv the first aliyah6:17 or the last aliyah or the third aliyah,6:19 in this case, according to the Zohar and to the Mekubalim,6:22 the sixth person to go up is the best aliyah.6:25 And anybody that goes up after the seventh person,6:27 let's say there's a6:28 simchah in the shul and they want to add aliyot,6:30 like the way the Sefardim add,6:31 then all these people don't count as part of the seven.6:33 That's, of course,6:35 that's lower than even the seventh person.6:37 The greatest one, like we said,6:38 is to be one of the seven,6:39 and the best one is the sixth person.6:41 And so, or really, the Tur brings down,6:44 I didn't mention this last week,6:45 is that the reason why we have seven olim on Shabbat,6:48 we explained, al pi Kabbalah,6:49 seven represents the seven sefirot.6:51 But6:52 al pi pshat, some bring down,6:53 we know that every single day6:54 we say,6:55 Bar'chu et Hashem6:57 hamevorach in the shul, and you have to say that with a minyan.6:59 You can't say7:00 it beyachid because you're saying Hashem's name.7:02 It's kind of like a blessing,7:03 so you need a minyan for it.7:05 And the Sefarim bring down7:06 that a person doesn't get his soul completely back7:10 unless he says, Bar'chu et Hashem7:16 hamevorach. So that's Baruch Hashem hamevorach, excuse me, l'olam vaed. Therefore, it's very important for a7:18 person not to miss7:20 Bar'chu in shul. So in case a person was anus7:22 and he couldn't make it to the shul7:24 for whatever reason it may be,7:25 he couldn't make it to shul throughout the week,7:27 on Shabbat you're not busy.7:29 There's no work.7:30 You're not involved in other things.7:32 So on Shabbat, when you go7:33 and you hear the Sefer Torah,7:34 and you have seven people at least7:36 going up to the Sefer Torah,7:37 and each person is saying, Bar'chu et Hashem7:40 hamevorach, you could answer the seven Baruch7:43 Hashem7:44 hamevorach l'olam vaed that will substitute for the six or seven days7:47 that you missed in the shul.7:49 What you didn't say, the7:51 Baruchu. That's the way the Tur brings it down,7:53 why we have seven aliyim on Shabbat.7:55 Next, we also mention the fourth7:58 halacha that we mentioned last week. Again, we—8:00 Saying it very quickly is that there's absolutely no problem for a Sefardi to get an aliyah in an Ashkenazi shul,8:08 where they're reading from an Ashkenazi Sefer Torah, and vice versa.8:11 There's also no problem for a Sefardi to get an aliyah by an Ashkenazi shul.8:20 Absolutely no problem. You could get an aliyah without any problem, even by Temanim.8:25 Now, why did I say even by Temanim? Chas v'shalom, I have nothing against anybody.8:28 Why even by Temanim? Because Temanim have a few changes in their Sefer Torah,8:33 different from the Ashkenazim and Sefardim as well.8:36 There's some words where they either add a letter or subtract a letter,8:41 replace a letter, sometimes with a hei, sometimes with an aleph. We're not going to go into it right now.8:45 But still, even though the Temanim have changes in their aliyot, we're still allowed to get an aliyah by them8:52 and to make a beracha and to answer on them.8:54 That is an important halacha we didn't mention last week about the Temanim.8:58 Now, regardless which eidah it is, and I don't want to bring it down,9:02 but I so brought down that I forgot who it was. He speaks very, very sharply.9:06 Anybody who goes up, anybody who refuses to go up from a different9:11 kehillah, chas v'shalom, he's, besides the fact that he's insulting the9:15 kehillah, he's motzi la'az also on the Sefer Torah, and it's a very, very big criticism on the person9:21 who refuses to get an aliyah by different, let's say Ashkenazi by Sefardi or Sefardi Ashkenazi,9:28 or Temani even. Chas v'shalom, he could need a lot of9:32 teshuvah, and the Sefarim speak very, very harshly about such a person.9:36 Okay. Now, we want to mention something we didn't mention last week.9:40 If you go to shuls, you see that when the person gets aliyah,9:44 there's three people standing by the teivah where they put the— There's Sefer Torah.9:49 There's a person who's reading, called the baal koreh.9:51 There's a person receiving the aliyah, who stands next to him,9:54 and there's also the person who invites people to go up.9:57 Or in some shuls, that person is called the9:59 somech; by the Sefardim, they call him the10:01 somech. He not necessarily invites, by the Ashkenazim10:03 he invites; by the Sefardim, he's standing there10:05 to make sure that the chazzan or the baal koreh doesn't make any mistakes,10:09 or if he needs some assistance sometimes. There's always three people.10:13 How come?10:14 And not only that, even when you see that the person, the baal koreh, is getting an aliyah,10:18 we still keep another person next to him.10:20 Where does that come from?10:22 So the Gra explains there's a pasuk that Moshe says,10:24 Ha'idoti bachem hayom et10:27 hashamayim ve'et haaretz. Moshe tells the Jewish people,10:28 I am warning you today in front of the heavens and the earth.10:31 I'm making them as my witnesses.10:33 And the halacha says, when you warn a person,10:36 in many places in the Torah we find when you warn a person,10:39 you need witnesses, and you need at least two witnesses.10:41 So likewise over here, when you're standing by the10:44 Torah and the baal koreh is reading, there should be two other people there,10:47 as if Hashem is speaking, there's two people there listening.10:50 The Levush gives a different reason, a beautiful explanation.10:53 He says the reading of the Torah, like going in line,10:56 like we said in the beginning, like the Zohar says,10:58 that it's like standing by Har Sinai.11:01 This somech, the one who's standing by the side,11:03 the one who invites people to go up, is like Hashem.11:05 He chooses who's going to go up, who's going to read.11:07 The baal koreh is like Moshe Rabbeinu,11:10 who is relaying the mitzvot to the Jewish people,11:13 and the person receiving the aliyah himself,11:16 he is the oleh. He represents the Jewish people themselves11:20 who are receiving the Torah.11:21 And that's, again, the same idea11:23 that we are like the Jewish people standing by Har Sinai.11:26 There's a sefer called11:28 Darchei Tzedek. He brings over there a very, very interesting idea.11:31 He says if a person has the right11:33 understanding—this doesn't mean you could do this;11:35 it has to be a special, special person11:37 who has the right11:39 understanding—he could figure out who the person is,11:45 begalui uvanistar, whether what we see on the outside11:47 and even what he does in hiding from the aliyah that he gets.11:50 It's an amazing concept.11:52 Rav Pesach Krohn used to say that all the time.11:53 He says, but it's brought down in11:56 Darchei Tzedek, that a person receiving an aliyah,11:57 you could tell what type of person is from the—12:00 Based on the aliyah.12:01 But again, we cannot do that.12:02 It has to be somebody special.12:03 I'll give you a midrash in Kohelet12:05 that brings an interesting story,12:06 and you can see the idea also reflected in the midrash.12:09 It says over there12:10 that Rabbi Elazar ben Arach, who was one of the students of12:13 Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, who was one of the greatest of the greatest students of12:17 Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, he went to live in a certain city12:19 where he basically, according to the midrash,12:22 he partook into materialism too much.12:26 And he got an aliyah by Parashat Bo,12:28 where it was supposed to say,12:31 Hachodesh hazeh lachem, and by mistake he read the words,12:35 Hacheresh hayah libam. Basically, if you look at the words12:37 Hachodesh hazeh lachem, you see how it's very easy to confuse those12:40 letters. And he read those words,12:43 Hacheresh hayah libam, which means their hearts became silent.12:47 And Chazal point out from there12:48 that he was pulled too much towards gashmiyut.12:52 On his level,12:53 he was pulled too much towards materialism,12:56 and therefore he ended up reading,12:57 he ended up making a mistake.12:59 There's no mistakes when a person gets an aliyah.13:01 It's a message from HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Hashem13:03 is relating to the person something.13:04 And if you're the one receiving an aliyah,13:07 don't look for other people's interpretations.13:08 You see the aliyah that you get,13:11 and try to see, try to keep your heart open.13:14 Sometimes if you go in there13:16 with that innocence,13:17 and you really13:18 mechaven l'shem shamayim, and you go up13:21 in bitmimut, you'll see that sometimes13:23 the words will stab you like a dagger.13:27 You'll hear it.13:28 Wow, that's a message from HaKadosh Baruch13:31 Hu. And that is the point that we wanted to make over13:34 here. When you're receiving an aliyah,13:37 you let Hashem is talking to you directly.13:40 Next point we mentioned,13:43 next halacha we mentioned that last week13:45 is that if a person is in the middle of tefillah13:48 and you're invited to go up to the aliyah.13:49 Now this invited, by the way,13:51 this only applies13:53 like the way it is by the Ashkenazim.13:55 You know, by the Ashkenazim,13:56 they call up your name to go up.13:57 For example, let's say,14:00 Ya'amod Harav Yitzchak14:00 ben Rav Yaakov14:01 shlishi.14:02 Okay? You're invited in front of everybody.14:04 And that's why by the Ashkenazim,14:05 you can't fall asleep during14:07 Kriat HaTorah. You got to always be alert,14:08 because they might call your name right away.14:10 But14:12 as Sefardim, they go up and they invite.14:13 How come there's different14:14 minhagim? So really, once upon a time,14:16 you see from the Torah, from the Gemara as well,14:17 that everybody was invited in front of everybody.14:20 Everybody was invited to go up to read the Sefer Torah.14:23 However, the halacha says14:24 if a person refuses—14:26 The person refuses to.14:32 So I'm getting a text right now14:33 that it's a Gemara, not a Midrash.14:35 I appreciate that comment,14:36 but it's also a Midrash in Kohelet as well.14:39 You look in Midrash in Kohelet.14:40 I'll give you the exact source,14:42 be'ezrat Hashem. Call me afterwards.14:45 So the chidah brings down that14:48 really, because of the halacha14:49 says that a person who refuses the aliyah14:53 is considered like they cut down his life.14:56 So therefore, because of that,14:58 the chidah says that there was a takanah by the rishonim,15:02 the earlier rabbis by the15:04 Sefaradim—excuse me, takanah in15:06 Yerushalayim—that they don't invite people with their names.15:08 That's why if you ever pray by the15:09 Sefaradim, they never call you up to your name,15:11 most15:12 Sefaradim. Why? Because of this15:14 takanah. Maybe a person will refuse aliyah,15:15 and chas v'shalom if a person refuses aliyah,15:18 then he is not going to be able to go up.15:23 He's not going to be able to go up, and chas v'shalom it could be like an insult to the Sefer Torah,15:27 and chas v'shalom there's a klalah with it.15:28 So we invite a person personally to go up to the aliyah.15:32 However, if you're in the middle of tefillah,15:33 even if you're Ashkenazi15:35 or you're praying by Ashkenazi15:36 and they invite you,15:37 you could go up15:38 as long as you're not in the middle of15:41 Kriat Shema—it means the actual reading of15:43 Shema—or the Amidah.15:44 Any other part,15:46 like the Berachot of Kriat Shema15:47 according to Minhag Ashkenaz, for sure15:49 Pesukei D'zimra, you could go up,15:50 you could get your aliyah,15:51 you could say the15:52 berachot, read together with the15:53 chazzan, with the baal koreh,15:54 and that's it.15:55 Don't get a15:56 Mi Sheberach and just walk, and, you know, just finish the aliyah15:58 and that's it, you're done,15:59 and go back.16:00 Okay, that is only with16:03 that. But if you're Sephardi and they're coming to invite you,16:05 or you're Ashkenazi praying with a Sephardi and they're coming to invite for aliyah,16:08 you should simply just refuse it16:10 and, you know, wave your hand and explain to them16:13 that it's tefillah. And like we said last week,16:14 any justified reason to not get an aliyah16:19 works as long as it's a justified reason,16:21 and it could be out of embarrassment or whatever it may be16:23 that you don't want to get an aliyah.16:24 The klalah doesn't apply to such a person.16:27 Next halacha that we mentioned last week16:29 is the conduct of the kahal during reading,16:32 and I got a lot of comments for this,16:34 that, Baruch Hashem, I got a chazak16:36 u'baruch for the people who go to shul and they're sincere16:38 and they want to hear the Torah.16:40 And you16:41 said, No, rabotai, you got to be careful.16:42 Speaking in shul is already bad enough.16:44 I remember a family that they had a person16:48 who was in a very, very big sakana,16:51 and they called up all the gedolim to get berachot from them,16:54 and they went to Rav16:55 Chaim Kanievsky. And they asked Rav16:57 Chaim Kanievsky, What could we do as a17:00 zechut, as a merit, in order to speed up the refuah17:03 sheleimah of this person in our family?17:06 And Rav Chaim Kanievsky says,17:08 besides Shabbat, he says everybody should be mekabel Shabbat17:08 a little earlier, he says17:10 one person out of the family17:12 should accept upon himself not to talk in shul,17:16 not to speak at all in shul,17:18 no matter what, not to speak at all.17:20 And Rav Miller says17:21 the same story17:22 also. Rav Miller had a similar story.17:24 Rav Miller zatzal said17:25 that if a person wants a refuah17:28 sheleimah, even if he has to go and switch shuls17:29 in his davening,17:30 he should go to a shul where there's no talking at all17:33 during davening, at all,17:35 and that brings a lot of17:37 yeshuot. And17:37 rabotai, it's very important not to talk in shul,17:38 especially during17:40 Kriat HaTorah. You're standing by Har Sinai.17:41 How can you talk during17:43 Kriat HaTorah? We're not going to talk much about it,17:45 but we're going to bring17:47 a halacha that's important.17:48 What about learning during17:50 Kriat HaTorah? And we said that a person is not allowed to learn17:53 during the reading of the Torah.17:55 Even divrei Torah, you're saying words of17:57 Torah, it's asur.17:57 However, there is a heter.18:01 Maran brings it down,18:02 and that is to read18:03 shnayim mikra v'echad targum of that week's parasha.18:06 L'mashal, this parasha is Parashat Chukat.18:09 If a person is delayed,18:10 and the only time he could say18:12 shnayim mikra v'echad targum18:13 is during the reading of the18:16 Torah that's done in the shul,18:17 then the person could,18:18 according to Maran,18:19 according to one of the opinions that Maran brings down,18:21 you could read shnayim mikra v'echad targum18:23 during the reading of18:26 Kriat HaTorah. Now,18:27 really lechatchila a person shouldn't learn,18:29 and although Maran permits it,18:31 he allows it,18:32 some Acharonim like the Pri Chadash and18:34 the Shlah forbid it.18:35 So therefore,18:36 you should only rely on this opinion18:38 when it's really, really necessary.18:39 I personally,18:40 I'm18:41 somech, I rely on this opinion18:44 when Parashat18:46 Bereishit, like this year and last year,18:47 where we jump from Simchat Torah18:50 right into Shabbat,18:51 and I don't have time really to read,18:53 to go over the18:54 Parashat Bereishit, very, very long,18:55 and I don't have time to go over18:56 the whole Parashat shnayim mikra v'echad targum,18:58 whatever the reason may be,19:00 I'm exhausted,19:00 whatever it may be.19:02 So if I can't say19:03 before I get to Shacharit of Shabbat,19:06 then I'm somech on this opinion19:08 that once a year to say19:10 Parashat19:11 Bereishit, shnayim mikra v'echad targum19:12 during the reading of the Torah.19:13 Otherwise,19:14 a person should try to avoid it as well.19:16 Another point we want to bring out over here,19:18 that during the reading of the Torah,19:20 the tzibur should be mechaven,19:22 men or women over here,19:23 if we still have some ladies listening,19:25 men or women should be mechaven19:26 to the berachot,19:27 to the blessings19:29 of the people going up.19:30 Every person that's going up to the19:32 Torah is making two berachot,19:33 one before the Torah,19:34 one before the reading,19:35 and one after the reading.19:37 You need to have19:38 seven19:40 olim plus the maftir,19:40 that's already eight aliyot.19:42 Eight aliyot times two,19:43 that's sixteen extra berachot.19:45 Why is that important?19:46 Because on every single day,19:48 David HaMelech instituted that19:50 every single day19:50 a person should make one hundred blessings,19:53 every single day.19:54 During the weekday,19:55 where the Amidah is longer.19:57 We have 19 blessings in each Amidah,20:00 so we're saying three Amidot,20:01 three times 19,20:03 it comes out to 57,20:05 plus all20:06 birchot hashachar, birchot Kriat Shema,20:07 so it adds up,20:08 and a few berachot of eating,20:10 you're already there.20:11 But on Shabbat,20:12 our Amidah has only seven berachot.20:13 Although we have Musaf,20:15 but still20:16 that takes us from 5720:18 to seven times four,20:19 that's only 28.20:21 So we're missing a lot of berachot.20:22 So we try to get berachot20:23 as much as possible.20:24 We try to eat a little extra.20:26 We try to make berachot on things20:27 that we don't normally20:29 would make berachot on,20:30 like20:33 besamim, atzei besamim, minei besamim, whatever we could try to get,20:34 we try to get.20:35 Here's an easy way:20:36 be mechaven to the blessings20:37 of the person getting an aliyah,20:39 the first and after blessing.20:40 Also,20:42 tachazat hashatz, you don't need the20:43 kavanah of the person getting the aliyah.20:45 You could be mechaven to the berachot20:46 even without them having20:48 kavanah to be motzi you with the berachot.20:50 Just listening to the20:52 berachah from beginning to the end20:53 and answering amen,20:54 that berachah could count20:55 as one of the hundred blessings for you.20:57 So that's very important to keep in mind,20:58 men and women as well.21:00 If you're in21:01 shul, to be mechaven to the blessings21:02 that are being said either by21:05 chazarat hashatz or by21:06 kriat haTorah, and this way you could put on your list21:07 of the hundred berachot21:08 and makes it much easier21:10 to fulfill the hundred blessings21:11 on Shabbat.21:13 Next halachah that we discussed last week,21:15 and this is the last one from last week,21:16 and then we'll go into the halachot for this week,21:19 that the person who's getting an aliyah21:21 has to read together with the baal koreh.21:24 Of course, not out loud,21:26 but by himself silently,21:27 that he shouldn't disturb even the baal koreh.21:29 He doesn't have to hear it in himself.21:31 Meaning, let's say me,21:32 me personally, I'm getting an aliyah right now,21:34 and I'm not reading the aliyah;21:36 the baal koreh is reading.21:37 The baal koreh is reading out21:38 loud so the whole tzibbur should hear.21:39 Me, I should read together with him21:41 the words in the Sefer Torah,21:44 and only for myself.21:45 I don't even need to hear myself in my own ears.21:48 It could just go by itself.21:49 I could just hear together with21:51 the baal koreh, could just read,21:52 and I'm reading together along with him.21:55 What about if a person cannot read?21:57 Meaning to say he doesn't know how to read Hebrew.21:59 And this applies to a person22:01 either he's a baal22:02 teshuva, a person who is blind,22:03 or a person22:05 who is am ha'aretz, doesn't know how to read.22:06 What do you do in such a case?22:07 Actually,22:08 machloket. According to Maran,22:09 you can't give him an aliyah.22:10 According to the22:12 Rama, you could give him an aliyah.22:15 You could be somech on the22:16 opinions that say22:17 shomea k'oneh, you could give him an aliyah.22:18 So really, according to22:19 Sefaradim, you should try to avoid the situation22:21 as much as possible.22:22 There are certain people22:23 that you have to honor in shul,22:25 you have to give them some sort of kavod.22:26 Try to give them more22:28 petichah. Yes, of course,22:29 you have to give them aliyah22:30 once in a blue moon.22:31 So then you have what to be somech on.22:33 You have the22:34 Rama, you have22:36 Chacham Ovadia who's matir it b'diavad. But again, try to avoid it22:38 as much as possible.22:38 A person doesn't know how to read,22:40 then according to Maran,22:41 the bracha is22:43 levatalah, and therefore22:43 you have to warn the kahal about this.22:45 There are a lot of people22:46 who get aliyot22:47 and don't know the22:49 halacha. The rabbi has a responsibility22:51 to announce the halacha in shul22:53 because according to Maran,22:54 if you're not reading the aliyah22:56 and just baal koreh is reading,22:57 according to Maran22:58 it's a22:59 bracha levatalah, and therefore23:00 it's the responsibility of the rabbi23:01 or anybody in the shul23:02 that's in the position23:03 to make such an announcement23:05 to warn and to tell everybody23:07 to read along.23:08 And Baruch Hashem,23:09 most people do know how to read;23:11 they just have to be aware of it.23:12 You're not insulting anybody.23:14 You make23:14 this halacha, you announce23:15 this halacha once, twice, three times23:16 till you drill it into them,23:18 and maybe the baal koreh himself23:19 should remind the people23:20 when they're getting an aliyah23:21 to read along23:24 with the baal23:25 koreh as they're getting the aliyah.23:27 And now we get to this week's questions,23:29 and we have a big question this week.23:31 Now we spoke about23:31 who could you give an aliyah.23:33 Question comes up now:23:35 you told me now23:36 I can't give an23:37 aliyah to a person who doesn't know how to read,23:39 mesader. What about a person23:39 who's mechalel Shabbat?23:41 Can I give an23:42 aliyah to a person who is mechalel Shabbat,23:45 or maybe not?23:47 Why do I say such a thing?23:49 Okay,23:50 so the answer is as follows.23:52 First of all,23:52 you have to know the status23:54 of a mechalel Shabbat.23:56 Halacha brings down23:57 a person who's mechalel Shabbat.24:00 Has the same din as a goy. He is like a goy in all cases.24:05 If he's a mechalel Shabbat and he touches your wine, it makes the wine yayin nesech.24:09 If he's a mechalel Shabbat and he lives in a neighborhood or an area that you need to make24:15 eruv chatzerot, he has the rules as a goy. I know it's very severe. It's a very sharp statement.24:19 It's a very strong statement, but I don't have to be apologetic for the halacha.24:24 This is what the halacha says. However, I'll clarify the halacha.24:27 The halacha says that this applies only to mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya and not24:33 a mechalel Shabbat b'tzina. What is b'farhesya? What is24:35 b'tzina? A mechalel Shabbat—there are a lot of people24:38 mechalel Shabbat. A lot of people mechalel Shabbat b'shogeg, by mistake. They don't know that's24:41 chilul Shabbat. How many people know the halachot of borer, that they could say that they never committed an issur of borer on24:47 Shabbat? When we get to hilchot borer, you'll be shocked how many times a person could be transgressing an issur d'oraita or b'shogeg sometimes,24:54 right? So we're not talking about that. We're talking about a person who knows that this is assur and he does it anyway.24:58 It could be done—the person could commit the issur Shabbat in one of two ways:25:03 either b'tzina, which means behind closed doors. He's embarrassed of somebody, of people.25:10 That means in his house he'll put on the TV, he'll change the channel, he'll make the volume louder.25:15 You know, that's called b'tzina. B'farhesya means he's not embarrassed of anybody.25:19 He'll do it in public, and there's not one person in the world that he's embarrassed from.25:22 I'll tell you a story. One time I was walking down a certain block. I was going to visit a relative of mine,25:27 and they happen to live by a certain block, whatever it is. And on the way to the block, I saw a friend of mine from many years ago25:34 that I haven't seen in many, many years, and he's walking out of his house.25:38 And I saw that there was another person who looked like a goy waiting for him, coming out of a car waiting for him.25:44 As he's walking out, I saw that he had a cigarette in his hand on Shabbat, and he had some sort of keys in his hand.25:51 And he's walking out into his car. This is on Shabbat. He turns a little bit to the direction where I was coming from.25:57 He notices me from far. Right away, I see him giving something to the goy. Obviously, he gave him the keys.26:02 He threw away his cigarette, and he told the goy—he whispered something to him. All of a sudden, the goy went away.26:08 And then he sees me. He gives me a hug, Shabbat shalom. How are you, Rabbi? What's going on?26:12 Hineni, Rabbi, we're friends. So what's going on? We're talking.26:15 It was very nice to see him. Nice to see you. Okay. And then, How you doing? Where you going?26:21 Nothing, just hanging out outside. I continued my way. He stood there, of course,26:26 and of course, once I turned the corner, I'm sure he continued to do whatever he did.26:28 So that person is embarrassed, even though I'm only his friend. But still, he's embarrassed.26:33 He's embarrassed to be mechalel Shabbat in front of other people that he knows.26:36 So that guy doesn't have the status of a goy.26:38 The person who has the status of a goy is that there's nobody in the world that he'll be embarrassed from.26:42 He'll smoke a cigarette in front of any rabbi, any person that he respects,26:46 in front of his father, in front of his friends, in front of his wife. He doesn't care about anybody.26:50 That person who's mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya, he has a din like a goy.26:55 Now the question is, how do you deal with this in shul?26:59 Even a person who's27:01 mechalel Shabbat b'tzina. The guy is riding a car. You're honoring a guy that everybody knows,27:04 this guy goes to work, and now he has a yahrzeit, he's coming to shul and you're giving him an27:08 aliyah. So this is a very complicated question.27:10 Before we begin to answer the question, I want to first quote to you,27:16 hacham Ovadia brings from a teshuva called Zekan Aharon,27:20 Wolkin, and he says—I'm going to translate it in27:21 English—he says, One must be very, very patient and sensitive in these cases,27:27 and don't be quick to make a decision.27:30 You should know, people who are coming to shul and expecting an aliyah,27:33 and you refuse them an aliyah, could go both ways.27:40 Sometimes you can make your point, and you'll make a point not only to the person but to the rest of the kahal,27:46 and sometimes it works backwards; it fires against you, where you could turn the person completely off.27:51 And sometimes you could, unfortunately, a person who makes a decision quickly without getting the right information,27:56 somebody might come up to the rabbi in the shul and say, Hey, that person is27:59 mechalel Shabbat, and you just take his testimony without asking any questions,28:01 and maybe the person is not mechalel Shabbat. Why is he28:04 mechalel Shabbat? Oh, because he doesn't know28:06 halachot borer. Hazak u'baruch, most people don't know28:07 halachot borer. Or a person may have just heard about him.28:10 Don't be quick to pasken who is a mechalel Shabbat or not.28:14 So that's number one. That's the first thing before we start off.28:17 But now we're talking about a guy that we know for sure is28:20 mechalel Shabbat. I'll give you an example.28:21 I was once coming to shul, and we had a simchah in the shul,28:24 and coming to the shul, I saw a person who, right in front of me, was driving,28:30 parked his BMW right outside the shul, and he walked into the shul,28:34 and he said hello to me.28:35 You know, Shabbat shalom. He didn't know I was a rabbi at the shul,28:38 right? He walked into the shul and he came down.28:40 At the same time that he was walking in, many people were coming to the shul.28:43 A lot of people from the kehillah were coming to the shul,28:45 and they came to me and said, Rabbi, you're not giving this guy an28:47 aliyah. We all saw him drive on28:49 Shabbat. So in such a case, that's clear. The guy drove on28:52 Shabbat, and we saw clearly that this guy is28:56 mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya, and he didn't care. Maybe he would have done it28:58 b'tzinah. Maybe there's somebody that he's embarrassed from,28:59 but in that case, it was very clear, obvious, that the person is29:03 a mechalel Shabbat, right?29:04 So these kind of things, you have to know.29:06 It's also a simchah, how to do it in a polite way,29:08 whatever, I had my way of doing it.29:10 But keep in mind again, don't jump to pasken who is a mechalel Shabbat or not.29:15 Make sure that you have your information from the right source,29:20 and then you can begin already discussing the29:22 halachah. Let's get to the halachah now about this person, the oleh, who's going29:26 up to Shabbat. Obviously, if you could try to avoid it.29:27 If a person has to get some sort of honor in the shul,29:31 and he's a29:34 mechalel Shabbat, so then you try to give him29:36 petichat heichal, let him carry the Torah,29:37 give him any other honors.29:39 But to give him an aliyah, then you already have to be careful.29:43 Now, question is as follows:29:45 Could he be counted as one of the29:48 olim? That's number one we have to discuss.29:49 We already mentioned that there's a minimum of seven olim that go up on29:53 Shabbat. Could this person who's mechalel Shabbat be counted as one of the29:55 olim? And number two we have to know is,29:58 could this person who's30:00 mechalel Shabbat, what about the part that he read?30:02 Are we yotzei the chovah from the part that was read in shul from that person?30:08 And the answer is as follows:30:09 A person who's mechalel Shabbat cannot be counted as one of the30:12 olim. A person who's known to be a30:15 mechalel Shabbat, you cannot count him as one of the30:16 olim. If you have to give him an aliyah,30:18 you have to give him an aliyah,30:20 then make sure that there should be additional aliyot.30:23 Give him the extra aliyah.30:24 That means, let's say you have a30:26 simchah. You have, by the Sefardim, when they have a bar mitzvah or a30:31 simchat chatan, so they add aliyot.30:32 So let's say you're giving anyway 15, 18, 20 aliyot anyway that30:37 Shabbat. Make sure30:38 you already, after number seven, you only invite this person who's mechalel Shabbat after number seven.30:42 Again, we're talking about a guy that you know is30:44 mechalel Shabbat. If you don't know, you don't have to go ask.30:47 If you have real suspicion, listen, the guy's car is parked outside.30:50 You didn't see it in the morning, and all of a sudden in30:52 the afternoon you see the guy's car parked in the shul parking lot,30:54 then you have room to suspect, okay.30:56 But otherwise, if you have nothing to suspect, don't ask.30:59 It's better not to know.31:00 But if you do know, try to avoid giving him an aliyah.31:02 If you can, you have to give him an aliyah,31:04 because if you don't give him, it could cause either a fight,31:07 it could cause things that are worse.31:08 Then you do give him an aliyah,31:10 then give him an aliyah.31:12 Make sure only after the seven31:14 olim. But he cannot be counted as one of the seven.31:16 What about the reading?31:18 The reading that he read, it's fine.31:21 You'll say because the reading is not being read by him;31:23 it's being read by the baal31:24 koreh. And number two is also, there's a whole arichut to explain this.31:28 To clarify more, I'm just going to say31:30 b'kitzur that the reading that's done is made for the sake of the31:34 tzibur. Not to be yotzei dechovah, but because it's a takanah to read in the shul31:38 Sefer Torah.31:39 And therefore, this person who, even though he read,31:43 or even though we're reading for him, the baal koreh is reading for him,31:46 he's still yotzei dechovah the reading.31:49 The proof is, in very short, that let's say there's a kohen in the shul31:54 and he's supposed to go up first.31:55 By mistake, you thought that there was no kohen,31:58 and you invited a...32:00 Please say to go up first.32:02 And now the kohen stands up and says,32:04 Hey, what about me?32:04 And already you started the aliyah for the person who went up.32:08 So could that reading count?32:10 And the answer is 100%,32:11 because the reading is made for the sake of the shul,32:13 for the kahal to hear,32:14 and not for that person is going to be32:17 motzi you. So that's one thing to keep in mind.32:20 The other thing that the sefarim bring down,32:22 it could be that this person is a32:25 tinok shenishba. What does that mean?32:26 It means really this person doesn't know any32:28 better. Yes, he knows that there's Shabbat.32:30 He knows he's not supposed to drive on Shabbat,32:32 but he doesn't know the importance of Shabbat.32:34 He doesn't think it's so important.32:35 He thinks it's like, I don't know,32:37 it's like waiting six hours between meat and dairy.32:40 Okay, he's supposed to wait six hours,32:42 so he waits five hours.32:43 This guy also, he doesn't think that's such a big deal.32:46 It's not accepted to drive on Shabbat,32:49 but he doesn't know the severity.32:50 He doesn't know the32:52 punishment, so he could be considered like a32:54 tinok shenishba. Like the Rambam brings down, he says,32:56 by the children of the32:59 Kara'im, Rambam says,33:01 Abal benei ha-to'im ha-elleh, referring to the children of the33:03 Kara'im, he says,33:08 Noladu bena Kara'im ve-giddelu otam al da'atam, harei hu ke-tinok shenishba beneihem. Even though his father is a Jew,33:10 even though his father told him wrong,33:12 still he's considered like a33:14 tinok that was captured by the goyim,33:15 because he doesn't know any better.33:16 He's like an anus.33:18 And therefore Rambam concludes33:19 regarding those people,33:28 Lefikhach ra'ui leachziran bi-teshuvah u-lemoshcham be-divrei shalom ad sheyachzeru le-etan ha-Torah. It's proper the person try to bring them back in33:30 teshuvah, try to bring them closer to the Torah.33:32 And therefore, in combination with what we said beforehand,33:35 that really he's not being33:37 motzi you. Also, he's getting the aliyah after the seventh33:40 aliyah, so there is room to be lenient,33:41 especially that you don't want to make a fight in the shul,33:44 you don't want people to have bad feelings in the shul,33:46 so then you could do it.33:47 If you could get him to get an aliyah33:50 that has been read already33:51 or is going to be repeated,33:52 that is the best.33:54 That's even much better than that,33:55 okay?33:56 And of course, the people who are going up again33:58 should be people33:59 who are, of course, shomrei Torah,34:00 shomer mitzvot.34:03 Now, up to here is the halacha of what you could do.34:06 What you could not do34:07 is what Rav Moshe Feinstein brings down.34:10 Rav Moshe Feinstein says,34:11 I'm going to read you his words.34:13 He says all this is to give the34:15 kibud for the people who are, you know,34:17 you have to give them34:18 because otherwise he's going to create a fight or whatever.34:23 But a baal kofrim mamash, not a person who's mechalel Shabbat,34:24 he's going to work34:25 because he feels that he needs the money.34:27 He feels that he has to open up today.34:28 If he doesn't open on Shabbat,34:30 he's not going to make money.34:31 That guy knows it's wrong to drive on Shabbat,34:32 but he's doing it because he feels he has to.34:35 We're talking about a guy over here34:36 who's34:38 kofer. He knows, and he34:39 denies that there's a God in the world.34:40 He denies the Torah.34:41 He's,34:43 all this from Rav Moshe Feinstein, a person who makes fun of religion.34:45 He puts down religion,34:46 and now his brother34:49 is making a simcha on Shul,34:50 and he has to come.34:51 He has to show his face,34:53 and he doesn't care about Torah.34:54 He thinks it's all a joke.34:56 Such a person,34:57 he says,34:58 says Rav Moshe Feinstein,35:02 Bechol ofen, ein likro laTorah. You should not call them to the Torah at all.35:06 How could you honor such a person in the shul?35:08 The guy is35:10 kofer. And not only that,35:10 if such a person,35:11 again, he has to be 100%35:13 kofer. He has to be a person that's known.35:15 He denies the35:16 Torah, he denies its religion,35:17 not a person who's questioning.35:19 Don't mix the two together.35:20 Now, a lot of people have questions.35:22 They haven't heard of Yosef Mizrahi.35:23 They haven't heard of Avno Yitzhak.35:25 They haven't heard people35:26 who convinced them35:27 of the truth of the Torah.35:29 So they have questions.35:30 We all have questions.35:31 But they keep,35:32 or they try to keep,35:32 but some people are not so inspired.35:35 We're talking about a person who is35:36 kofer. He denies it straight out.35:38 He goes, speaks against it.35:39 He'll eat pig on Yom Kippur35:41 that falls out on Shabbat35:43 while driving a car35:44 and smoking a35:44 cigarette in your face.35:46 That guy,35:46 that's the guy that we're talking about.35:47 That person,35:48 chas v'shalom, to give them aliyah.35:50 Can't give them any. You can't give them even any honors35:52 if you could.35:53 Even if you have to be able to put your foot down,35:55 you have to understand35:56 not to let it go.35:57 I've heard of a sickening story.35:59 This will show you how far it goes.36:00 There's a very, very wealthy person36:02 that came to shul.36:04 Where his daughter was engaged to a36:07 goy, okay?36:07 His daughter was engaged to a36:09 goy. He's sitting in36:10 shul, and it was Yom Kippur,36:11 and a person36:12 has a zalah money,36:14 and on Yom Kippur36:15 he buys the carrying of the Torah36:18 for his son-in-law, the goy.36:20 He brings his son-in-law, the goy,36:21 not a convert.36:22 Chas v'shalom, I'm not talking about converts.36:23 Converts are regular Jews.36:24 I'm talking about a goy, a real goy36:26 that never converted36:26 and not thinking of converting.36:28 And a person bought36:30 carrying the Torah to his nephew,36:31 who is a goy,36:32 and the shul gave it to him.36:33 What do you mean?36:34 The guy bought it.36:35 Now, if you're ready to throw away36:36 all our religion for a few bucks,36:38 then that's the wrong shul to be in.36:41 If you know such a shul,36:41 get out of that shul.36:42 You36:43 cannot—better to pray b'yachid. How can you give out such a thing?36:45 How can you sell it for that?36:47 For you sell it to a goy.36:48 And therefore also36:49 the sefarim bring down a person36:50 who's married to a36:52 goya, married to a36:52 non-Jew, also cannot get an aliyah.36:54 Everybody knows that's wrong.36:55 And as long as he's not doing anything36:57 for his wife36:57 to either get a conversion36:59 or to stop basically this intermarriage,37:01 you cannot give such a person aliyah.37:03 The rabbi has to be strong37:04 to be able to put his foot down37:06 and hold his ground.37:08 And if there's questions,37:10 there could be maybe a problem37:11 of parnassah, then you have to ask a37:13 she'eilah. I'm not paskening over here on the radio.37:16 It's each one.37:17 No, you don't have to give up your money37:18 necessarily for this,37:19 but you have to37:20 ask, for sure you have to ask a37:21 she'eilah from a37:23 gadolim, and Baruch Hashem37:23 plenty of37:24 gadolim. You could ask them37:25 what should be your position in the shul37:27 if there is such a case37:28 where people have to get an aliyah.37:29 The president of37:30 the shul is married to a37:31 goya, and37:32 I don't know how he's the president37:32 in the first place,37:33 but anyway,37:34 so question37:35 of parnassah, you ask a37:36 gadol. You don't just decide on your own.37:38 Now I'm going to go to the other extreme.37:39 We mentioned that's only a person37:40 who's a kofer mamash,37:42 you don't give an aliyah.37:43 A person who's mechalel Shabbat,37:44 but he's doing it37:46 out of ta'avot, even though he's doing it37:48 b'farhesya. Try to avoid it.37:49 I know we spoke about37:49 the person who is mechalel Shabbat37:52 b'tzinaa. You know, he'll put on the light37:53 when nobody is looking.37:54 He'll hide the volume on TV.37:56 You know, some people37:56 keep their TV on on Shabbat,37:58 and they just raise and lower the volume.38:00 They don't think it's wrong.38:00 That's also38:01 asur, but they don't think it's so bad.38:02 Some people text on Shabbat,38:04 lo aleinu, right?38:04 Again, they're embarrassed.38:06 They won't do it in public,38:07 and they pretty much38:08 keep everything else.38:09 It's just they have38:10 a yetzer hara towards something.38:10 That's called mechalel Shabbat38:12 b'tzinaa. Sometimes, you should know38:14 that even though38:14 min38:15 halacha it's permitted,38:17 absolutely permitted38:18 to give a person aliyah.38:18 He's not a38:19 kofer. He believes in the Torah.38:20 He keeps every other38:22 mitzvah. But sometimes a38:23 rabbi has to make a point in the shul,38:25 and therefore even though38:25 the halacha permits such a person38:27 to go up to aliyah,38:28 a rabbi has the authority38:29 and the right38:30 to prevent him from not going up.38:31 I'll bring you three proofs.38:32 My first proof is,38:33 if you look in the38:35 sefarim, the poskim bring down38:36 from the Megaleh Amukot38:38 that you cannot give a person38:39 who shaves with a razor,38:41 you cannot give him an aliyah.38:43 What in the world38:43 does that have to do with anything?38:44 Shaving with a razor?38:46 He's not38:46 kofer. He keeps every single38:48 mitzvah. He's the first person in38:50 Shacharit. He comes,38:51 I don't know if he comes to classes.38:53 He keeps shomer Torah,38:54 he keeps38:55 mitzvot, he keeps Shabbat.38:56 He's unbelievable,38:56 but he shaves with a razor.38:58 He wants to look good38:59 in front of the people,39:00 and back then39:01 they didn't have, you know, machines,39:03 so he shaves with a razor.39:04 Megaleh Amukot says39:05 you cannot give him an aliyah,39:05 and a lot of the poskim39:07 said the same thing.39:09 Why?39:09 And the answer is,39:10 it was a special39:12 takanah in their days. It's not a39:13 takanah that's applicable nowadays.39:14 A person who shaves with a razor39:15 nowadays, there's39:16 unfortunately worse things39:17 that people are doing,39:19 but back then39:19 it was a special39:20 takanah they had to do.39:21 Ah, he's not a39:22 kofer, he keeps every other39:23 mitzvah. And you see that39:24 in order to make a point,39:26 the person who was shaving with39:28 a razor was39:29 פורץ גדר. He was doing something39:30 which could have caused39:31 many people to follow,39:33 so the rabbis39:33 had to put his foot down.39:35 And even39:37 though medin you could have technically39:38 brought him up,39:39 still he put his foot down.39:40 He said no.39:41 Another proof is39:42 from Gemara, Masechet Shabbat.39:43 The Gemara says39:43 in Masechet Shabbat39:44 that one time39:44 there was a person39:45 in the times of the39:46 Yevanim, when the39:47 Yevanim were ruling over39:49 Eretz Yisrael, there was a Jewish person39:50 who was riding his horse39:51 on Shabbat,39:53 and the39:54 Beit Din took him and executed him.39:55 Now, to understand39:56 the severity of this,39:57 let's tell you two39:59 Gemarot. One Gemara in Masechet...40:00 The Gemara says, Kol hame'abed nefesh achat miYisrael, k'ilu me'abed kol ha'olam. If a person destroys or kills one Jewish soul, it's like he destroyed the whole world.40:09 The Gemara brings a proof to that40:12 from a pasuk. Very, very important to us, the life of a Jewish person.40:15 We go through crazy things just to try to save a person from being killed.40:21 The Gemara says, a person who ... kills once in seven years, according to another opinion, once in seventy years,40:27 it's considered a ... chovelet. It's a very damaging40:33 ... It's not a good ... that they executed a person, one person, in seventy years.40:38 Now, with that, let's review the case again.40:41 A person was riding a horse and they executed him.40:44 What's the issur of riding a horse on Shabbat?40:46 The answer is it's40:49 asur miderabanan. Miderabanan, it's asur to ride a horse.40:51 You might come to break a branch and whip with it the horse, and therefore it's40:56 an issur derabanan. What's the punishment of a person who is over41:00 an issur derabanan? The halacha says a person who is over an issur derabanan, we give him41:04 makat mardut. So why in the world, how could they execute him?41:07 He didn't do41:09 even issur de'oraita. You're executing a person for no—it's just for41:12 an issur derabanan. And the Gemara says, yeah, because sha'at shechak lakach. It was at a time when people were on that, like, borderline,41:19 on that verge where they were very relaxed in the mitzvot,41:23 and it could have caused a tremendous stumbling block for other Jews.41:28 They had to make a point and they executed him.41:30 And the halacha, yes, permits such a thing to happen.41:33 The Rambam brings it down in his41:35 halachot, that a beit din can sometimes do things even though Torah doesn't permit it,41:38 in order to make a point, they're allowed to do it.41:41 My third proof is what we just read two weeks ago.41:43 It says in Parashat Shelach that this person was mekoshesh atzim.41:46 He collected wood on Shabbat, and Torah says they didn't know what to do with him.41:50 They asked Hashem, Hashem says, Stone him, kill him.41:53 Question is why?41:56 Answer is no. He is not mechalel Shabbat41:59 midoraita; it's miderabanan. Chazal tell us that this person, his kavanah is not to collect wood;42:03 it was in order to prove a point.42:05 He wanted to prove a certain point, whatever that point was.42:07 So it really comes out that the mekoshesh etzim, according to42:12 some, was selofchad, he did a melacha she'eina tzricha legufah, which is only42:17 issur derabanan. Why in the world did they execute him in such a severe way?42:21 Secularly, usually you throw the guy off, let's say, the second floor.42:25 Over here, you executed him by throwing stones in such a severe way.42:29 And the answer is, it was the first person who was mechalel Shabbat,42:33 and Bnei Yisrael, Hashem had to make a point that nobody should learn42:37 and take example from this person.42:39 So again, you have to be careful with this.42:42 We repeat, you have to be very careful.42:44 You can't just go around making points.42:45 But as a rabbi who is in charge of his kahal, who knows his kahal,42:49 and he knows that he needs to make a certain point,42:50 sometimes even though a person is only mechalel Shabbat42:54 betzinaa, sometimes you have to put your foot down.42:55 I personally had such a story where a person went out to work on Shabbat,43:00 and he was working on Shabbat and he had a43:02 yahrzeit, and he asked somebody to ask me if he could get an aliyah.43:05 And he knows in the shul we don't give aliyot to people who are mechalel Shabbat,43:08 even though halacha permits it.43:09 I want to make a point because people who were in that specific shul,43:12 people were very relaxed in hilchot Shabbat, in keeping Shabbat,43:16 and I know a lot of people will probably do a lot of issurim on Shabbat,43:19 so I had to make a point of it.43:21 And I said, No, I cannot give you an aliyah.43:23 And he got very offended,43:24 and he said, I'm never coming back,43:26 da da da da, and one on and one on and one on,43:28 but I held my ground.43:30 And Baruch Hashem, you know what?43:31 The guy felt guilty.43:33 Two months later, I get a phone call from his son43:35 asking me to help him get a43:37 job. He doesn't want to work on Shabbat anymore.43:39 So I felt at that time that was the right thing to do.43:42 Each situation you may have to ask.43:43 You have to ask and find out.43:45 Again, you have to be very, very sensitive,43:47 not just extremely sensitive in these cases,43:50 because it could go both ways.43:52 If you have to make a point or you have to be sensitive,43:54 you could bring the person sometimes43:56 close or sometimes by giving an aliyah that can encourage him.43:58 It's not a black and white.43:59 That's I can tell you.44:00 It's not a psak, one psak for all.44:02 Each case has to be decided in the right way,44:06 in the right time,44:07 and— Of course, if there's a gadol you can ask,44:10 you should definitely ask a gadol and don't act on your own.44:13 Let's move on now.44:15 So the last halachot before we finish the class of44:19 Kriat HaTorah. Number one is,44:21 okay, next halachot is aliyot to children.44:23 Can you give aliyot to children?44:24 Even though halacha permits aliyot to children,44:26 many people have a minhag of not giving any aliyah to44:29 children. So therefore, if you have such a custom,44:32 you don't give aliyah to children.44:33 But if you don't have such a minhag,44:35 if you see that people do give aliyot to children,44:37 halacha permits it and it's fine.44:39 Other halachot that we should know,44:41 we'll give you hopefully with the time that we have44:43 some quick44:44 halachot. If you have any questions, by the way,44:46 call in please after the show.44:49 We have another 15 minutes about till the class is over,44:52 but I'll be around for anybody who has any questions.44:54 The number to the studio is44:58 718-683-5858. We'll repeat again afterwards,44:58 or you could text it in at45:04 347-927-8398. Let's begin.45:05 There is a halacha that when we give out aliyot,45:08 there's an order45:09 who gets first, second, and third.45:10 And of course, if you've been to shul, you know45:12 the first aliyah is given to the Kohen.45:14 How come? Because the Torah says,45:16 v'kidashto. Everything in kedusha, you give the Kohen first.45:19 The second aliyah is given to the Levi.45:21 Why the Levi?45:22 Torah says that Moshe gave the Torah to the Kohanim bnei Levi,45:26 the Kohanim, the children of Levi.45:27 So the Gemara says,45:28 don't I know that the Kohanim are the children of Levi?45:31 And the Gemara answers,45:32 yes, we do know,45:33 but it's coming to teach us that Kohen comes up first,45:37 and then the Levi gets the second aliyah.45:39 And then afterwards already45:40 anybody who is not a Kohen or Levi45:42 could get an aliyah.45:42 That's what we call the Yisrael.45:44 If there is no Kohen in the shul,45:46 the Gemara says,45:49 nitpardah chavilah. Anybody could go up,45:51 and technically, even a Levi could go up as the first aliyah.45:54 There's no Kohen, even a Levi could go up.45:56 However, the Kaf HaChaim brings down that many— Many kehilot,46:02 like for example in the Syrian community,46:03 they don't bring up the Levi as the first46:07 oleh. They bring up Yisrael specifically.46:08 Okay, there is such a minhag.46:09 We have such a minhag.46:11 If you have such a minhag as well, fine.46:13 But min din, min hadin, a Levi could go up as the first46:18 oleh. That's according to the p'sak of the46:20 Ohr Letzion and Chazon Ovadia as well.46:22 Next, let's say there is no Levi in the shul.46:24 There is a kohen, but there's no Levi in the shul.46:26 The same kohen that gets the aliyah for a kohen,46:31 he himself goes up again as a Levi.46:33 Why the same kohen?46:35 Well, there's no Levi, so who are you going to put up?46:37 And if there is no Levi,46:39 so why don't you put up a different kohen?46:41 And the answer is, why don't we put another kohen46:43 is because we don't want people to say that46:48 the first kohen was pasul, he was not a good kohen,46:50 and that's why we are putting up the second kohen to make up46:56 because the first one was really no good.46:57 So that's why we keep the same kohen to go up.46:59 That's why we don't put up another Yisrael over there.47:03 Also, the halacha says two kohanim cannot go up after each other,47:10 or two Leviim cannot go up after each other.47:11 It's for the same reason,47:13 that what?47:15 That we should not have people saying,47:17 Oh, you know why they put a Levi right after Levi?47:20 Because the first one must have had a problem,47:22 so this new one is really a kosher one.47:24 Oh, you know why they put up the two kohanim after each other?47:25 For the same reason.47:26 The first one is not a real kohen,47:28 and that's why they put up this person as a kohen.47:30 Some kehilot, I know by the Ashkenazim,47:32 a lot of the Ashkenazim,47:33 they don't put up a kohen at all in the middle.47:36 Kohen gets the first aliyah and maybe the maftir, and that's it.47:39 They don't put up a kohen at all.47:40 Other kehilot, a lot of the47:43 Sefardim, will put up a kohen in the47:44 middle, but they'll announce47:48 Ya'amod, Mr. so-and-so, Ya'amod, even though he was Levi, or some say Beit Aharon,47:51 you know, shelishi, whatever it is,47:53 they'll give aliyot to kohanim in the middle as well.47:55 Maran brings down also47:58 another halacha: two brothers do not get...48:00 to each other. Why not?48:01 The answer is48:04 al ein hara. We don't give—even if they say,48:05 I don't care about ayin hara.48:06 I'm wearing the48:07 chamsa, I'm wearing the blue48:10 dot, I did the segulah48:11 from the Chida, it doesn't make a difference.48:12 Two brothers or father and48:14 son cannot give an aliyah after each other.48:16 The reason is ayin hara,48:17 and that's it.48:18 We don't look at anything else.48:20 Now,48:22 and it happens in the summer a lot.48:24 What if people go away in the summer48:25 and they go away for Shabbat48:27 and there is no Sefer Torah?48:28 What could they do?48:29 And the answer is,48:30 even though you don't have a Sefer Torah,48:32 you should still read from a48:36 Chumash without any48:37 berachot. Chas v'shalom, no48:38 berachot. Just one person,48:39 even if you're praying with a minyan,48:40 Shacharit, Musaf,48:41 a lot of people will pray Shacharit, Musaf,48:42 and that's it.48:43 No.48:44 Take out a48:45 Chumash and read that week's48:47 parashah. You don't have a Sefer Torah,48:47 but read that week's48:49 parashah and the haftarah.48:50 Could you make berachot on haftarah?48:51 And the answer is,48:52 you shouldn't make a berachah on haftarah48:53 unless you got a specific psak that you're allowed to.48:56 But really,48:56 try to avoid making a berachah on the haftarah.48:58 It's a big49:00 machloket. I don't want to get into it.49:02 Kaf HaChaim, the49:03 Chida, machmir. Even the Sefer Torah is pasul.49:05 Hacham Ovadia might be matir,49:06 but it's a big discussion.49:07 We'll leave it for a different time.49:08 We're running out of time.49:10 Now,49:10 the last—49:11 not the last49:12 halachah, let me see.49:14 A few more halachot regarding49:18 Kriat HaTorah, and here's a very important49:20 halachah. Please pay attention.49:21 Anybody who,49:22 again,49:22 who is a gabbai49:23 or rabbi in the shul,49:24 please pay attention to the following49:27 halachah. There's a question:49:27 what if a person is reading,49:29 getting an aliyah,49:30 and in the middle of reading the Torah,49:32 you discover a mistake?49:34 What do you do?49:35 What about if you discover a mistake in the Sefer Torah,49:36 which means it comes out that the Sefer Torah was pasul?49:39 So what's the halachah then?49:40 Very important, pay attention to the following details.49:43 I'm going to detail a little bit49:44 to make it clear49:45 so that you should know what to do49:46 when the time comes,49:48 okay?49:48 If you want to look at this,49:50 you want to see it clearly,49:51 the Mishnah Berurah in siman kuf49:52 mem49:54 gimmel, halachah dalet,49:55 in the introduction to halachah dalet,49:57 spells it out so clearly.49:59 Everything I got is straight from there.50:00 It's very, very clear50:01 the way the Mishnah Berurah brings it.50:02 Let's begin like this.50:04 First of all, the question is,50:05 what is the status of a Sefer Torah50:06 that is—50:08 I don't want to say kol pasul,50:09 but it has a mistake.50:10 There's a letter that's missing,50:13 or there's a letter that's not written properly;50:15 the vav looks like a50:16 yud, or whatever it is.50:17 What is the status of such a Sefer Torah?50:19 According to50:20 most Rishonim, that Sefer Torah is equal to a printed50:23 Chumash; it has no difference from it.50:25 Any Sefer Torah that's not 100%50:28 kosher is pasul. It's like a regular50:30 Chumash. You don't even keep it. Technically, you're not even supposed to keep it in the same50:33 aron. That's according to50:34 the Rishonim. However, the Rambam, in his50:35 letter to Pe'er HaDor,50:36 brings down50:37 that really50:38 such a Sefer Torah50:40 is50:41 kosher. You can even make berachot on it,50:42 not a problem.50:43 There's no other Sefer Torah;50:44 you can take out the Sefer Torah50:45 and even make berachot on it.50:46 It's not like a50:48 Chumash. And not only that, he says50:49 in front of the50:52 Ri ben Migash, Rabbi Yosef50:53 ben Migash, and50:54 Rabbeinu Yitzchak, referring to the50:56 Rif, people have read such a Sefer Torah50:57 that was pasul50:58 and they made50:58 berachot and they never said anything about it.51:00 Those are the two opinions.51:02 What's the difference?51:03 Well, the difference would be as follows.51:04 According to the ones that say51:06 that the Sefer Torah has a mistake51:07 is pasul,51:08 one mistake even,51:10 it means that anybody who got an aliyah51:12 really was not really an aliyah.51:14 So even though you had four people going up as an aliyah,51:16 it's not really considered an aliyah.51:18 So nobody went up.51:18 You still need to invite now51:20 seven people,51:21 and whatever you read51:22 means nothing.51:22 It's like you read from a Chumash.51:24 However, according to the other opinion,51:26 according to the Rambam51:27 in his51:29 teshuvot, it comes out that51:30 no,51:30 the Sefer Torah is51:31 kosher. Whatever you read was good.51:32 You can even make a berachot on it,51:34 keep it there.51:35 You can keep it there.51:36 But again,51:37 the Rambam is only51:39 b'diavad. Even the Rambam will agree to take out a kosher Sefer Torah.51:42 Those are the two opinions.51:43 One holds the Sefer Torah is pasul completely;51:45 it's like a regular Chumash.51:47 The other one holds that it's51:48 kosher, not a problem.51:49 You can even continue making berachot on it.51:50 What's51:53 the psak halacha? So we have two opinions:51:54 Maran and the51:56 Rama. Guess what?51:58 Machloket Sefardim, Ashkenazim, but not 100%.51:59 Let's explain.52:01 Maran goes with the opinion of52:02 Rabbi Yaakov52:03 Beirav. That's his rabbi.52:04 If you go to52:05 Tzfat, there's a shul of Rabbi Yaakov52:06 Beirav. That's the rabbi of52:08 Maran Shulchan Aruch.52:09 And his opinion is as follows.52:12 He makes a compromise between the two opinions,52:14 and he says as follows:52:15 that the Sefer Torah becomes pasul52:18 only once the mistake is discovered.52:21 Which means that whatever you read up to that point,52:24 the sefer Torah was52:26 kosher, all the olim were52:27 kosher, everything was fine.52:28 Every aliyah that was read up to that point is52:30 kosher. Now we discovered this pasul;52:32 from now on, there's a problem.52:34 Which means the berachot that were said were valid,52:37 but you can't continue anymore.52:38 So therefore, you take out a second sefer Torah,52:41 and you continue from the place52:43 where you found the mistake,52:44 the beginning of that pasuk.52:46 And for the new sefer Torah,52:48 you don't say beracha rishona. Remember,52:49 sefer Torah was valid up to your52:51 beracha rishona, up to you found the mistake.52:53 So now, when you take out the new sefer Torah,52:55 the same oleh stays up.52:56 You don't repeat the52:59 beracha rishona. You read from where the mistake was,53:02 and then you say53:03 beracha acharona only on this new kosher sefer Torah.53:06 So again, according to the53:08 Sefardim, all Sefardim follow this halacha.53:10 You don't have to worry.53:11 If you're Sefardi, you follow this halacha.53:13 If you find a53:14 mistake that for sure it's a mistake,53:16 then what you do is53:18 you close the sefer Torah,53:20 you keep it on the tebah,53:21 you bring out another sefer Torah,53:23 and then you don't make any53:25 beracha, not beracha acharona or53:27 beracha rishona. You bring out the new sefer Torah,53:29 you continue reading from where the mistake was,53:31 and then make a53:33 beracha acharona on the new kosher sefer Torah.53:35 The Rama has a different opinion.53:39 The Rama really is a little bit complicated.53:41 I don't have time.53:41 I'm really running out of time.53:43 I don't want to mention the whole.53:45 It is a little bit53:46 complicated to go through the opinion of the53:48 Rama, but I will point out53:49 that even the53:51 Ashkenazim, a lot of the53:52 Ashkenazim follow, especially the Chassidim,53:54 follow the psak of Shulchan Aruch over here.53:56 And because this is not such a common case,53:58 but it does happen once in a while,54:00 it's important that you should know the halacha.54:02 You should check with your54:04 posek what the halacha is when a person makes a mistake.54:06 And every rav has to be aware of this.54:08 I remember when I first became a rabbi of a shul.54:10 I got tested right in the first two weeks.54:13 I think it was the first month54:14 they took out a Sefer Torah,54:15 we found a pasul inside of it.54:17 So at the time,54:18 not necessarily did we know,54:20 did we define if it was a right kasher or not,54:23 whatever it was.54:24 But basically,54:25 you have to be very, very careful, by the way,54:27 not to just disqualify any Sefer Torah.54:29 You have to know what you're talking about.54:31 If you know what you're talking about54:31 and you find that it's really54:34 pasul, then you say.54:34 But just to open up your mouth54:35 just because you learned some halachot here and there,54:38 you have to be very, very careful54:39 not to be motzi la'az on the Sefer Torah,54:42 okay?54:43 So that's something to keep in mind.54:47 So rabbis have to know this54:48 halacha, and gabbaim have to know54:49 halacha if there's a54:50 pasul, what to do with it,54:51 okay?54:52 When you take out, by the way,54:53 for the54:54 Sefardim, when you take out the new Sefer Torah,54:55 the old Sefer Torah is kept on the54:57 teivah, and only once you're putting back the Sefer Torah54:59 like you usually do,55:01 right before Musaf,55:02 then you put back both Sifrei Torah.55:04 Ashkenazim, however,55:05 will take the Sefer Torah that's55:07 pasul, they'll put it back55:08 and take out a new kasher Sefer Torah.55:11 One more point I do want to bring out,55:12 a lot of people make a mistake in this.55:13 Sometimes, you know, halacha says55:15 you ask a katan to tell you,55:17 to define for you55:17 what's the letter,55:18 if it's kasher or not.55:19 So you should know,55:20 a katan that we're talking about over here55:21 is not anybody under55:22 bar mitzvah. It has to be a child55:24 who knows how to read the letters55:25 but cannot read the words yet.55:27 That's called a katan.55:29 And also,55:29 you don't just ask him the55:30 letter that you need to ask him.55:31 You ask him different letters in the Sefer Torah55:34 to see if he knows what he's talking about.55:36 For example,55:37 let's say you want to know55:37 if it's a vav or a55:39 yud, so you show him other letters55:40 that are clearly a vav,55:41 other letters that are clearly a55:42 yud, and if he answers correctly55:43 to the other letters,55:44 and you have to mix in the letter55:46 that's in question55:47 that he shouldn't figure out55:47 which letter that you're asking him,55:49 and then55:50 you could decide based on the psak of a katan,55:53 but not just55:55 any kid under55:56 bar mitzvah. We have a few minutes.55:57 Let me finish the halachot55:58 in the Ben55:59 Ish Chai. We have—56:00 Three halachot to go through, halacha chaf aleph.56:03 Ben Ish Chai talks about that the best aliyah for a mourner is the aliyah of maftir.56:09 Why is aliyah of maftir the best? That's al pi Kabbalah.56:12 So if a person is an avel within the first year, the best aliyah for him to get is the aliyah of maftir and to say the haftarah.56:21 The haftarah itself—to go very quickly, some very quick halachot about56:26 the haftarah—the haftarah should always follow the last reading.56:32 What does that mean?56:33 It means if you, like this Shabbat, this Shabbat we're going to read Parashat56:38 Chukat, and we're going to take out a second Sefer Torah because it's also Rosh Chodesh, Rosh Chodesh56:42 Tammuz, and we're going to read from the second Sefer Torah the parashah of Rosh Chodesh.56:47 If a person—excuse me—the haftarah that we read is the haftarah of Rosh Chodesh.56:53 Why? Because you always read the haftarah with the last subject that was read in the shul.56:59 And even though technically you could just begin the haftarah, but we, the halacha is that we read for the last oleh part of the Sefer Torah, part of the parashah57:08 of the honor Sefer Torah, we read part of the Sefer Torah, which is the oleh of maftir, together with the haftarah.57:14 When it comes to the haftarah itself, there's two minhagim: the Ashkenazim,57:19 Sefaradim. All Sefaradim, we follow the halacha of the Arizal, where each person should read the aliyah.57:24 You don't make the berachah; you listen to the berachot of the person getting the aliyah, but you yourself should read the haftarah.57:29 The Ashkenazim, however, they follow that the haftarah is read in tzibur, in public.57:36 One person, the person, just like Baal Koreh reads the Sefer Torah, they also have the person who is the last oleh who reads the haftarah.57:43 And again, you'll follow the minhag that you have. Whatever you have on the, what's it called, that's what you'll follow wherever you are.57:50 Okay, the last two halachot, Ben Ish Chai talks in halacha chaf bet about Musaf. And we say the Musaf. We don't have time to explain it,57:59 but basically, one quick halacha about Musaf is, if a person has to pray Musaf in Ha, he didn't pray yet Musaf,58:06 and he's delayed already to the time that he has to pray Mincha, first he prays Mincha and then Musaf.58:11 And a person should not delay the tefillah Musaf past seven hours from the morning.58:16 If he does, he's called a poshea. He's yotzei dei chovah, but he's called a58:19 poshea. And finally, the last halacha, we say keter in the chazarah of Musaf, and in keter we say,58:26 Ayeh mekom kevodo lehar'oto. When the chazzan is saying the word ayeh, he should stretch it out,58:31 because when you stretch out the word ayeh, at that moment we're receiving the third part of the neshama, called the neshama of the day.58:39 Okay, we say there's nefesh, ruach, and neshama that we receive on Shabbat in the evening,58:43 and again we receive them in Shabbat day, and that comes when we say the58:49 words ayeh. Now, I had to cut out on a lot of things, but pretty much we finished Parashat58:53 Toldot. Next week, be'ezrat Hashem, we hope to begin Parashat Vayetze, which discusses the laws of motzaei Shabbat,59:00 like what time Shabbat over, Rabbeinu Tam, etc., laws of havdalah, melaveh malka, and all these halachot.59:06 Until then, have a wonderful Shabbat and Rosh Chodesh, Rosh Chodesh Tov u'mevorach, be'ezrat Hashem,59:11 Hashem should protect us in the summer, us and all our children.59:14 This class will be aired on again tonight on JRadio.com at 1159:21 o'clock, and if anybody would like to call into the station, the number is59:27 718-683-5858. See if you people waiting online already, and the text line, if anybody wants to text,59:32 will be here for another few minutes,59:37 347-927-8398. We'd like to thank JRadio and Iran and BSD Productions for all their help as usual.59:43 Thank you very much. Have a wonderful week.