Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of the 9 DaysBen Ish Hai – HolidaysRabbi Uri Nahum · July 3, 2013−15Play+30Position0:0056:22Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:17To all JRoot listeners, we're back to the weekly shiur, two o'clock on Wednesday, with Rabbi Uri, Hamuri. This week we're going to do Parashat Behar, in Sefer of Ben Ish Chai, of Rabbeinu Yosef Chaim, Hilchot that has to do with these days, בין המצרים.0:35Shalom, Baruchah, good afternoon. Baruchim Rabbi Shimon, how are you? First of all, thank you very much for the ride in the rain. I appreciate it very much. Okay, let's get to the halachot. Last week we spoke about the halachot of the three weeks, and we're just going to review very, very quickly the subjects that we spoke about. If you'd like to know the details, obviously you'll have to listen to the shiur. You go to jrootradio.com, and you can see the shiur over there in the files. We spoke about building and renovating houses in the three weeks. We spoke about preparing for weddings. Oh, sorry, that's, yeah, okay, and no. Okay, here we go. Let's start again. Last week we spoke about the things that are relevant during the three weeks. We spoke about being careful and the weddings, the machloket between the Ashkenazim and the Sefardim, even though the Sefardim in Chutz La'aretz are noheg like the Rama not to make weddings. Also, we spoke about music and dancing, to avoid music and dancing during the three weeks, shehiyanu should be avoided if it's possible, and hair cutting and shaving. We said that the Sefardim do not begin the issur until Shavua Shechal Bo, which we speak about today, and we mentioned towards the end regarding Tikkun Rachel. This week, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll speak about the halachot that are relevant to the month of Av, like we mentioned last week. As we get closer to Tisha B'Av, the laws become more restrictive and more similar to the laws of aveilut, because we are mourning the destruction of Yerushalayim and the destruction of the Beit HaMikdash. So the subjects that we will be speaking about today are building and renovating houses. Preparing for wedding, of course, like we said, during the—this is talking about during the nine days of Av. Also eating meat or drinking wine, and shopping, buying, and wearing new clothing. Bezrat Hashem, that's going to be the subjects of today. We're going to work from the Ben Ish Hai. Last week we barely0:36read from the Ben Ish Hai because there was not much that was mentioned during the three. But regarding the halachot of the nine days, the Ben Ish Hai has a few halachot, although they're a little bit scattered. I'm going to skip around just to go directly to the laws that pertain to the nine days. And let's begin with the first halacha, Halacha Aleph. Ben Ish Hai writes, Amru raboteinu zal, the rabbis tell us in Masechet Taanit, Bad Yisrael de it lei dina b'hadei akum, lishtamit minei ad Rosh Chodesh Elul. If a Jew has a court case with another person, with a goy, he should avoid it until Rosh Chodesh Elul. However, yesh omrim ad Tesha B'Av, d'hainu ad achar Tisha B'Av. And there's some who say that if you have a court case, you have to go to court with a goy, if you're able to push it off, that fits more properly. The answer is to wait until Rosh Chodesh Elul. A person doesn't have to avoid it until Rosh Chodesh Elul, אלא רק0:42עד אחר Tisha B'Av. Until after Tisha B'Av, a person should try to avoid going to court against a goy. Why? The Gemara says, de-reya mazaleh, because in this time the mazal of the Jewish people is lower, and like we mentioned last week, people avoid dangerous things, and also you should avoid things in these times. The Chacham Ovadia brings in Halichot Olam. Likewise, if a person has surgery to do, in these nine days he should try to push it away. There's a certain thing that our mazal is not so strong in these days, and in fact, a lot of people are noheg on their own to avoid things. I know people will not start a business in the nine days; they'll wait off. People will not move into a house. All of this, min hadin is mutar. It's not forbidden. It's just people like to avoid it because, like the Gemara says, the mazal is not so strong for the Jewish people. We move on now to Halacha Bet, and that is wedding preparations. Ben Ish Chai says, explaining the Gemara, the Gemara says, Mishenichnas Av, mema'atin b'simcha. Once Av comes in, we cut down on happiness. What does that mean? Says the Ben Ish Chai, what it means is, mema'atin b'masa u'matan me'Rosh Chodesh, ad tesha'ah b'Av, hainu shel simcha. We're talking about business dealings that have to do with simcha, kegon sorchei chuppah, like, for example, purchasing things for the wedding. However, other business transactions for business or whatever it is, a person can do it regular. V'afilu sorchei chuppah. And even when it comes to buying things for a wedding, im rotzeh liknot davar shelo yuchal liknoto achar Tisha B'Av, or davar she'ein shehu la'asoto achar Tisha B'Av, or let's say you cannot get this item after Tisha B'Av because it's not available. By the time you get it and you take it to the seamstress and she does it, it's going to take too long, then it'll be mutar. V'hu hadin davar sheyuchal liknoto achar Tisha B'Av, v'nish'atan l'msarlo b'zol. Likewise, the same rule will apply if a person is buying0:42something. And during the nine days, even for a simcha, if he has it on sale, and a sale, you have to know what a real sale is. You know, some stores, the sign sale doesn't move. It's exactly like the name. They always have a sale. Whenever you go, there's a sale. That's not what we mean, sale. Sale means you're unable to get this item for this price later on, and it's a very good deal, then you can get it. But otherwise, just the word sale doesn't allow you to get it from halacha. So that's what we conclude with. We conclude with this point that purchasing things that have to do with wedding preparations or things of simcha are forbidden. Likewise, Chacham Ovadia brings down, even if a person is not buying for a wedding, you know, when the guy and girl go out and then they're about to get engaged or after they get engaged, they send gifts to each other, whether it's jewelry or flowers, all these things should not be done in the nine days. Even if you're planning to use it for after the nine days, it should not be done in this time. Now, regarding the people who are working with this, let's say you're the person who's selling jewelry, and you have, you know, obviously people are coming to buy jewelry for simchot. You, as far as a seller, first, if it's a goy, you don't have to worry about it. This is your business. This is what you're doing. If it's a Jew, also, if it's something that you need, let's say you can't pay your bills without working, you have to go to work, because otherwise, if you close, you're going to have a loss, so then you're allowed to sell. And especially if they need it, even if you don't need to go, even if you don't need the money, but if the people who are buying it need to buy it from you, it's also permitted to sell it to them. And we'll go on to halacha gimmel. Before we continue, I was told to announce that anybody who would like to ask a question should text in their question or call into the radio. We'll take questions. The call to0:43call in, we'll probably take it a little bit later on in the show, but as far as the text messages, if you text in your question, we'll be more than happy to answer. Let me give you the phone number. The text phone number is 347-927-8398. Kimatshi of text in English. 347-927-8398. If you want to call in, then you could call into the studio, 718-683-5858. Again, 718-683-5858 if you want to ask a question live.8:03Halacha gimel. Building or renovating houses during the nine days.8:08Says the Ben Ish Chai, Habinyan, building.8:11Im eino davar hechrechi, ein lehatchil meRosh Chodesh. If it's not necessary, then one should not begin on Rosh Chodesh.8:17Aval im hitchil kodem, but if you started before Rosh Chodesh Av,8:21ein mafsikin, then you don't have to stop when Rosh Chodesh Av comes.8:30V'hu davar hechrechi, sheyesh lachush lehefsed v'chosher ken lesakana, mutar lehatchil meRosh Chodesh. But if you're building something in your property8:33where if you don't build it now,8:36you might incur a loss.8:38L'mashal, let's say the city has put a fine on your property.8:44They said you're going to get a ticket if you don't build this thing,8:46you don't fix your fence,8:47you don't build something around your house,8:50whatever it is.8:51And if you don't build it now,8:52you're going to get a fine,8:54that's going to be8:55hefsed. Then for sure you can build it.8:57Also, if it's dangerous,8:59sometimes you have like a window9:01in the house which may fall out from the second floor,9:03and you have to get a contractor,9:04and he told you9:06you have to knock the wall down9:08and you have to fix9:08and you have to build.9:09All this is9:10mutar since it's9:12sakana, it's dangerous,9:13or there's a financial loss.9:15You could even begin after Rosh Chodesh.9:17Likewise,9:20v'chen ma'akeh mutar lehatchil gam achar Rosh Chodesh. Ma'akeh is a big mitzvah.9:22Some people are not aware of the mitzvah of9:24ma'akeh. Ma'akeh is9:25that if a person has like a balcony,9:28anything that's elevated from the ground9:30ten tefachim high,9:32then he has to build a fence around it.9:34This is a mitzvah from the Torah.9:36It's a mitzvah to avoid dangerous situations,9:40that people, chas v'shalom, should not fall off9:42and get hurt,9:42or worse than that.9:44So there's a mitzvah called9:45ma'akeh. Building a9:46ma'akeh even after the nine days,9:48meaning to say9:49within the nine days after Rosh Chodesh,9:51that's9:53mutar because you're doing it in order to avoid9:56sakana, dangerous things.9:57However,9:58the things that are forbidden to do10:00after Rosh Chodesh,10:09aval tiyur vechiyur, even til kodem asur la'asot Rosh Chodesh ad Tesha B'Av. Molding10:11or carving out things10:12that are just for decoration,10:14decorating the house10:15as far as building,10:17let's say painting,10:18anything that's not necessary for living,10:20then that's forbidden10:22after Rosh Chodesh10:24until10:25Tesha B'Av, even if you started beforehand.10:28Ve'afilu b'kabalanut, even if you paid a contractor,10:29it's good to try to avoid it.10:32Now,10:33let's10:34say—I'm going to skip the rest of the10:35Beit Sha because we don't have so much time;10:36I'll say it outside.10:37Let's say a person hired a contractor,10:39and the contractor is a Jew,10:40so the Jew understands.10:41Maybe you could tell10:42him, explain to him,10:43listen, it's the nine days.10:44You know,10:44I prefer that you shouldn't work in this time.10:46If he's fixing something10:49that's not necessary for living,10:51meaning to say10:52he's painting the house,10:53he's doing things that are not necessary for you10:55to move in right now,10:56this moment,10:58then it's better to push off the contractor11:01to do his job afterwards.11:02If it's a goy,11:03and a goy,11:04you're paying him.11:05You're paying him by the job;11:06you're not paying him by the day.11:08If you're able to push him off till afterwards,11:10even if you have to pay like a little bit of money,11:12fifty, a hundred dollars,11:13whatever it is,11:14a small amount of money11:15just to push him off,11:16that's preferable.11:17If the goy will not listen to you,11:19he doesn't care11:21about—he doesn't know what the Temple is11:23or Beit HaMikdash, and he doesn't understand what he's doing,11:25so then11:26in that case,11:26since he started already11:27and you hired him beforehand,11:29then it's mutar.11:29But if a person is hiring now11:31somebody to fix his house11:32or to build,11:33the rule is like this:11:35if it's something that you need to live in,11:37or it's something to avoid sakana11:40or financial loss,11:41it's mutar.11:42If it's something that— You're just doing it11:45because it looks nicer,11:47then that is forbidden during the nine days.11:51If a person, however,11:54needs to move into a new house,11:56and he already purchased a house11:57and the house is done,11:58there's no problem to move in during the nine days12:00if he needs an area to live.12:02Not only that,12:03Chacham Ovadia says you could even make12:05Hanukat Habayit, but without12:06a seudah. You put, like, maybe a little bit of12:08berachot, just so people should say12:10berachot, and let people say the reading.12:12But12:13seudah during the12:14Hanukat Bayit with the12:16seudah, with a meal,12:16that becomes already a happy occasion.12:18A person should not do it.12:19If a person needs to buy a house,12:21if he's going to buy a house,12:22he's able to move in12:23because he needs the space to move in,12:25also not a problem.12:26But if he's buying a house12:29not to move in12:29and not for business,12:30he's buying a house12:31just because it's a nicer place,12:34it's a nicer area,12:35he's comfortable where he is right now,12:36but he wants to move into a nicer house,12:38it should not be done12:39during these nine days.12:41That is Halacha Gimel.12:42Move on now to Halacha Dalet.12:44Dalet, and here we mentioned last week,12:47Dalet speaks about weddings12:48from during the three weeks,12:49and we said that the12:50minhag of most Sefardim is like the12:53Rama, that we don't make weddings in these three weeks,12:55although Shulchan Aruch permits it12:57until Rosh Chodesh.12:59And Halacha Hey speaks about13:00music and dancing.13:01According to everyone,13:02even Sefardim and13:05Ashkenazim, music and dancing during the three weeks13:07is forbidden,13:09even through recorded music.13:12If you're leaning throughout the whole year13:13to listen to recorded music,13:14either through tape or radio,13:15during the three weeks it's forbidden.13:17Of course, we're talking about Jewish music.13:19Non-Jewish music is13:20forbidden throughout the whole year.13:22That's not a question.13:23We're talking about specifically Jewish music13:25that's kosher music.13:26It's even forbidden during this time.13:27It's only mutar13:29when it's l'tzorech mitzvah,13:31and one should ask13:32if he has such a case.13:36Halacha. Now, the next halacha is vav,13:38but we're going to skip to halacha tet,13:40because vav, zayin,13:41chet speak about13:42halachot that are relevant to13:44Shavuot shechal bo, which we're going to learn,13:45be'ezrat Hashem,13:45in the second half of the class.13:48Halacha tet speaks about13:51sewing and making new clothing.13:53Let's just give a little bit of background.13:55We're not going to do13:56halacha yud aleph inside;13:58it's too long and it's not practical.14:00So just to give you a little bit of14:01background. In the Beit HaMikdash,14:04we had different parts14:06and different areas14:07which were holier than the other.14:09We had the front part,14:10the main one14:10that you see the picture14:11with the14:12mizbeach, that's called the14:13azarah. And then where you see14:14that big building14:15in the Beit HaMikdash,14:16that's called the14:17heichal. Inside the14:19heichal was divided into three parts.14:21The first part,14:22when you come in from the front door,14:24is called the ulam.14:26As you walk in,14:27then you approach a14:29room called the kodesh.14:29That's where the14:32mizbeach hazahav, the menorah,14:33and the shulchan was.14:35And then you get closer,14:36you see a parochet,14:38and behind that parochet14:39was an area called14:40Kodesh14:42HaKodashim. In Kodesh14:43HaKodashim, we had in the first Beit HaMikdash,14:44for most of the time,14:45we had the aron.14:46And the aron stood specifically14:48on a certain stone,14:50and that stone was called14:52Even HaShetiyah. What does14:53mean Even HaShetiyah? The hachamim explain that14:54this was the first piece of14:58land that Hashem started14:59creating the world from.15:00This stone was the beginning.15:01This stone is still around today,15:04where today15:05the Dome of the Rock is.15:06We cannot enter there15:07because we're15:08tamei'im; we're not allowed to enter there.15:09It's a big issur to enter there.15:11So where the Dome of the Rock is,15:13it's the dome over that rock.15:14That's called the15:16Even HaShetiyah. Since we don't have it in our hands,15:19meaning that we don't have15:20the Beit HaMikdash,15:21we don't have the15:21aron to place on top of it,15:23we cannot get there.15:24Even the Kohen15:25Gadol cannot get there nowadays.15:26So therefore,15:27there's a custom that has—15:30That started a few hundred years ago15:34is that they wouldn't place15:36the strings of the sheti15:38when they make clothing.15:39We don't have this today15:40because we don't make clothing15:41in the same way they did.15:42But these old machinery,15:44if you want to call it,15:45they would place the strings15:47the long way, the vertical15:49and horizontal way,15:49and then they would put them together.15:51So they wouldn't start15:52sewing and making clothing15:54because Eben15:56HaShetiyah is not around nowadays.15:58It's been destroyed, the area of the—16:00The Beit HaMikdash was destroyed, so that's where the custom comes of not making the16:04shehecheyanu. As a result of that, we have also other halachot,16:08and that is making new clothing, and like the Rama says in Shulchan Aruch,16:11also buying new clothing is forbidden.16:13The details we'll speak about a little bit over here.16:16We'll mention a few things from the Ben16:18Ish Chai, and then we'll speak about some practical things that are very relevant nowadays.16:22Let's begin.16:23Halacha tet: Tefirat begadim v'chayotzeh. Sewing, stitching,16:29all of these things are asur b'Shavuah, forbidden min hadin in the week of Tisha16:36B'Av, v'yesh lehachmir meRosh Chodesh, and one shouldn't be stringent also from Rosh Chodesh.16:43So too, if you're a tailor and that's your income and that's your job,16:47it's forbidden to do it in this time from Rosh Chodesh until Tisha16:56B'Av. Even if you want to do it for free, it's asur,16:59and even if that's your parnassah, it is forbidden.17:02Okay?17:03Now, this issur is not only making it to wear in the nine days;17:09it's even asur to make it if you're planning to wear it after the nine days.17:13It's also still forbidden.17:15There is an exception.17:16When is there an exception?17:19Number one, when there is a loss of money.17:21For whatever reason, if you don't take this job right now,17:24if you don't do this person—let's say you're a tailor and you have to make somebody's17:27suit—and if you don't get this customer, he may never come back to you again,17:30and this person gives you a lot of your parnassah throughout the year,17:33then it'll be mutar.17:36Okay?17:36But there's got to be a real loss of money over here.17:39Let's say you have a lot of material that you purchased17:41and the person needs it. It's a non-Jew; he doesn't understand,17:44he needs it, then it'll be mutar up to17:47Shavuah shechal bo. Okay, this is important.17:48From Rosh Chodesh Av to Shabbos Chazon, which is the week of Tisha17:51B'Av, the week of Tisha B'Av, that's forbidden.17:54Another example: even if there's no loss, but this is the person's only income.17:58Without it, he cannot pay his bills,18:01then he's allowed to work up to18:03Shabbos Chazon. In fact, if he's really in need of the money, he may even work up till Tisha18:09B'Av. Another case: if you have a factory, if you're the owner of the factory,18:12and you have people working for you, and you're producing clothing,18:16and they're sewing and they're making clothing,18:18and they're getting paid anyway.18:19This is a classic case of loss of money.18:21They have their monthly salary. You're paying them whatever it is,18:25three thousand, four thousand dollars a month. In any case, if you open, if you don't open,18:29so that's called a loss of money, because you're paying them18:31and they're not going to be working.18:33In that case, it will be permitted.18:35Now keep in mind, although this is mutar, this is only18:39b'diavad. Lechatchila, a person, even in these cases, could be18:46machmir, tavo alav beracha. Another case where someone would be mutar in the nine days,18:49and that is if a person is learning in a course how to sew, it's mutar,18:55because you're not sewing to make clothing; you're just sewing to learn.18:58A lot of women go to these classes to learn how to sew. This is mutar.19:03Also, another case: if the item was given before Rosh Chodesh19:08and a person started working on it, then the person may continue working19:12until Shabbos Chazon, until the week of19:15Tisha B'Av. And finally, needlepoint.19:18If a woman, I don't know, maybe even a man, if a person is doing needlepoint,19:23he's just sewing for fun, to relax, for therapy, that's mutar.19:29Why? Because he's not doing it in order to make clothing;19:32he's doing it just to relax. So then it will be mutar,19:35because it's just a therapeutic... thing that he's doing right now.19:41Okay. The Acharonim also mention, and really began from the19:46Rama, that a person may not buy clothing,19:51shopping, and this is a big thing. Everybody, you know, shops nowadays,19:55and especially, you know, the season or19:59back-to-school. This year happens to be that the three weeks are very early,20:01but usually, like next year, it's going to be closer to September,20:06and this is the back-to-school season.20:08So one, could a person buy something and not buy something?20:11In the nine days, a person should avoid buying anything.20:14The exceptions that he could buy is, like we mentioned before,20:18if he cannot get them afterwards for the same price.20:21And you have to know yourself. A store could say a sale,20:26and, you know, he could have a reduction on certain items,20:30but you know that if you come back after the nine days, you're able to get it.20:34Everybody knows.20:35You know certain stores and which stores are always having a sale,20:38so you have to be smart. You have to do it in your own way.20:41Even if there's no sale, even if there's no sale,20:44if you believe that this item is not going to be available afterwards,20:47even though you're not really getting a discount,20:49but there's one less item, you're a special size,20:51and they only have three pieces, now you're down to two,20:54and you're worried that your next-door neighbor,20:56who's the same size as you, and his son may get it,20:59so you're allowed to buy it during these nine days21:01because you are not going to be able to get it afterwards.21:04And even when you buy it, you're not allowed to wear it until after Tisha21:08B'Av. Another case where a person is allowed to buy new items,21:11and that is if he needs it now and he cannot do without it,21:17like new shoes for Tisha21:20B'Av. On Tisha B'Av, we're going to learn about it next week,21:22we cannot wear leather shoes.21:23We have to wear special kind of shoes, non-leather shoes.21:27And if a person only has leather shoes21:29and now he has to buy slippers or something that he doesn't have,21:32so that's called needing it now,21:34and one may purchase it during Tisha21:37B'Av. And again, we're talking about items that you don't have to make21:40shehecheyanu. We mentioned last week, anything that you have to make shehecheyanu on,21:42you're not allowed to buy it at all,21:44because then you'd have to make21:46a bracha shehecheyanu, unless you want to put it for Shabbat.21:48Let's move on now to Halacha Yud.21:53Halacha Yud,21:57Ben Ish Chai talks about fixing clothing.21:59Says22:03the Ben Ish Chai, דבר קרוע וכן בגד שקרע תפירתו. Something that rips,22:05or let's say something that the stitching became undone.22:11מותר לתפור, you're allowed to sew it, you're allowed to stitch it back on.22:16וכן מותר לתפור תלאי על בגד, also if you want to put a patch.22:18People don't do this so much today,22:19but if you want to fix clothing,22:21this includes putting, stitching back a button,22:25fixing a rip.22:26All of this is mutar during these nine days22:29because you're just clothing.22:31To make clothing is the issur, but not fixing clothing.22:34Halacha Yud Aleph, like we mentioned, is not practical,22:36we're going to skip it,22:37and we're going to move on to22:39Halacha Tet-Vav, which speaks about wine and meat,22:41and that's a big subject.22:42We'll come back right after the short musical break.24:05B'shem. Avilchot Bein HaMetzarim, three weeks with Chacham Uri from the Ben Ish Chai, Rabbeinu Yosef Chaim. You can send in your questions. Text us at 347-927-8398, 347-927-8398. Okay, over the break we got two questions, and let's answer them. First question is that somebody had a leak or mold in the bungalows, and they want to know, could they fix it? The contractor is coming in on Monday, but he won't begin until Tuesday. If you didn't know, this Monday is Rosh Chodesh Av, which means he's going to begin working during the nine days. It's a very nice question, very important question. And the question ended that he needs it for bein hazmanim, which means the three-week break from yeshiva after Tisha B'Av until Rosh Chodesh Elul. The answer is that even though the person is beginning to work after Rosh Chodesh Av, it's still permitted. And the reason for that is because that's considered necessary. Necessary doesn't only mean that you need to live in it now, in the nine days. Necessary means that I need to do it now because if I would wait after the nine days, I wouldn't have time to do it. So since the person, the contractor, could only do it during this time, because if he'd have to wait afterwards and the people, whoever's coming on the tenth of Av, will not have a place to be, so that's called necessary. Mold in the roof, especially with the unpredictable weather that we're having in the summer, is certainly a necessity. You don't want to have leaks, and therefore it's mutar, it's permitted to allow the contractor to fix your roof during these nine days so it could be ready right after the nine days. Yeah, another very interesting question. It says, do you suggest not to go to Six Flags Sunday before sundown, Rosh Chodesh Av? Okay, and I would answer the question as follows. Now, let's just explain. Six Flags is a theme park. It's a place, you know, where you go on rides and things, a lot of fun. It's right before Rosh Chodesh Av. The Gemara says, You should24:12cut down on simcha, but over here it's a little bit before Rosh Chodesh Av. So you have to know there's two things. Number one is, mitzad halacha. As far as halacha, din is concerned, there's nothing that should forbid a person to go in these three weeks. Repeat the question. Repeat the whole question. No, no, just... Okay. Again, one more time. The question is, can a person go to Six Flags on Sunday right before Rosh Chodesh Av? And the answer is as follows. The Gemara says, Mishenichnas Av mema'atin b'simcha. It sounds like only once Av comes, we have to cut down on simcha. But the Sefarim already bring down that these three weeks are the times where we're commemorating and we're mourning all the tragedies that have happened to the Jewish people during the Churban Bayit, the destruction of the first and second Beit HaMikdash, and really throughout all of Jewish history. Sefarim bring down it's because of these three weeks that we have all the tragedies throughout our history. So, although, min hadin, as far as halacha is concerned, there's nothing forbidding a person to go on Sunday to Six Flags, but it's a midat chasidut. It's a good thing that a person is able to minimize having fun in these times and to avoid it till afterwards. Again, halacha, there's absolutely no problem. A person really has to be smart to understand, to know when he should apply midat chasidut or not. If the father is usually very busy, and this is one of the few times he has to spend with his children, so of course you take them. You have to know schar and hefsed of everything. You have to know the benefits, the pros and cons every time you do something. In this case, if you don't go to Six Flags, what's going to happen? Are the kids going to get upset? Did you promise them, and therefore the father might come out sounding like a liar? The kids might be disappointed. So you have to know exactly.32:00Here are the cases. Certainly, if a person has no problem pushing it over to a different time, then it's not a problem.32:07Now, this is—I want to point out another point, and that is we're talking about Six Flags, the regular theme park.32:13The Six Flags water park, that's asur throughout the year. It's not only during the three weeks.32:21You know, ולא תטורו אחרי עיניכם ואחרי לבבכם. A person has to be careful with his eyes, especially in the summer, but that's a different question.32:26I don't think the person was asking for that.32:28Let's move on now to the laws of meat and wine during these nine days,32:33and these are very important halachot, and we all know about them.32:38We want to clarify a few things, and we hope that we could cover all the points that people have.32:43Let's begin.32:44We had a question before about if someone started a construction before the three weeks just for beauty, when should it stop, take off?32:54Good question. If somebody started construction, and the construction is not for—it's not a need, it's not something to live in, it's just for beauty.33:02He wants to decorate his house nicer, he should stop. It's asur to do it after, once Rosh Chodesh comes,33:11next Monday, Rosh Chodesh Av, a person should stop until after—what do you call it—after the fast.33:18But again, like we mentioned, that's if a person has control over the people who are working there.33:24If you paid the contractor, and the contractor doesn't want to listen to you because he wants to do his job and just get out of there, he wants to go on his vacation,33:33then it's out of your hands, and you have no obligation to kick him out to stop the construction.33:40Okay, let's get to33:41Halacha Tet-Vav. First, I want to read from inside the Ben Ish Hai, and then we'll touch on all the important points.33:48And there's a lot to speak on this33:49halacha. Number one:33:54אסור מכוח המנהג לאכול בשר ולשתות יין בשבוע שחל בו תשעה באב. In the week of Tisha B'Av, keep in mind, the week of Tisha B'Av, where Tisha B'Av falls in, from beginning that Saturday night,34:02it's forbidden min ha-din to eat meat and to drink wine.34:08V'yesh nohagim bazeh miRosh Chodesh,34:11v'yesh miShabbat Av Tammuz. In Shulchan Aruch, that's where the Ben Ish Chai gets his words from.34:15Shulchan Aruch writes, however, there are people who are stringent beginning from Rosh Chodesh,34:19and there are people who don't eat meat or drink wine beginning from the three weeks from Shabbat34:30Av Tammuz. U'po'erenu Bagdad, nohagin issur milel sheni shel Chodesh Av ad lel asiri. The minhag in Baghdad was that the issur begins on the second day of Av,34:36which means Monday night this year, they would stop eating meat.34:46Ki beyom Tisha B'Av nohagin l'shot tabachim ata b'shvil achlat le'asiri. But on the ninth of Av, they would begin slaughtering already,34:50so therefore they avoid meat from the second of Av until Tisha B'Av midday,34:58where they would not eat meat, but they would slaughter in order to prepare the meat.35:05Okay. Gam nahagu po'erenu shegam b'seudat milah ein ochlin basar bayamim elu. Also, the minhag in Baghdad was that they would not eat meat35:10even during the brit milah. People were making brit milah would make it dairy or parve;35:14they would not make it with meat.35:16Okay, so like the Ben Ish Chai mentioned, the Shulchan Aruch brings three different customs.35:21Most people have a custom to begin not eating meat from Rosh Chodesh until Tisha35:29B'Av, and some until Asar B'Av. That we'll talk about next week.35:32You should know, beginning Rosh Chodesh, beginning this Monday, it's only a minhag; it's a custom.35:38It's not a din, because if you look, and also in the words of Shulchan Aruch,35:43the din becomes forbidden is erev Tisha B'Av. On the eve of Tisha35:49B'Av, in the seudah hamafseket, a person is forbidden to have meat and wine. But otherwise, it's a custom.35:54Where did the custom come from, or where is the issur from, and why only meat and wine?35:59And the answer is because we had a mizbeach, we had an altar where we'd bring korbanot on it.36:04And the mizbeach mainly had meat, wine, and flour.36:10Hachamim, they couldn't forbid flour because otherwise you can't live.36:16Ki al lechem yichyeh adam. A person lives on bread. Without bread, it's a basic necessity.36:20However, meat and wine considered a little bit more of a luxury,36:23and for a period of time a person could do without them.36:25So that's where the issur began from, and that's where the minhag comes from.36:28We don't eat meat because we don't have the animals to sacrifice on the36:32mizbeach. We don't drink wine because we don't pour the wine on top of the36:36mizbeach. This is the source of the minhag.36:37However, everybody, different minhagim and different communities have them in different ways.36:45I'll begin.36:46The Ashkenazim, for example, they don't eat meat beginning Rosh Chodesh, beginning Sunday night.36:51And if you're a Sefardi and you want to go out to eat in any meat restaurant in Brooklyn,36:57none of them will be open because they all have Ashkenazi37:00hashgacha, and the Ashkenazim don't eat meat, so therefore they're all going to be closed.37:04But according to halacha for the Sefardim, the minhag of the37:09Sefardim is that we only begin on the second of Av, and that is sunset37:14on Monday. One should stop eating meat, or if he prayed Arvit even before sunset,37:19then he should stop eating meat.37:21Also, chicken. Most people have a custom not to eat chicken.37:25However, Nahar Mitzrayim, which was a great rabbi from Egypt,37:31and there are some from the Egyptian community,37:34they have a custom to eat chicken.37:36They only not eat meat and drink wine,37:40but chicken they do eat because we didn't bring chicken on the mizbeach; it was only meat.37:46Also, Chacham Ovadia brings down also that those who have a custom to drink wine.37:51The reason why I'm mentioning this, if you see people who are eating chicken or drinking wine37:56or eating ... know that they have a source for what they're38:00doing, and you don't have to stop them because they're keeping to their custom.38:05Fish is not a problem except for38:09seudat hamafseket, but grape juice is included in wine, and one cannot drink grape juice either38:13if he holds that wine is a minhag not to drink.38:17Also included in the minhag are dishes that are cooked with meat or chicken.38:23If you don't eat meat and if you don't eat chicken,38:25that includes also dishes that are cooked with38:28it, even if you're not eating the piece of meat or piece of chicken.38:30Let's say you made spaghetti with meatballs and you threw away the meatball,38:35so it's still forbidden to eat the spaghetti38:40because it's considered tavshil shel basar,38:43and the minhag is to be stringent on tavshil shel basar. However,38:46to cook in parve meat pots, that's fine.38:52To cook parve in meat pots, that's not a problem.38:55It's just cooking with meat, even though you're not eating the meat, that's forbidden.38:59And the rule of thumb is like this:39:01if you would have to wait six hours, then you should not eat it during the nine days.39:08If you don't have to wait six hours, then you can eat it,39:10which means that a piece of meat fell into a dish,39:13and the dish has sixty times more than the piece of meat39:15that you cannot even feel or taste the piece of39:19meat, then the Acharonim bring down that's not a problem.39:23We got a call-in question.39:25A lady asked if, according to the Ashkenazim regarding39:30Hallel, if there's any difference regarding Hallel during Rosh Chodesh,39:33Kodesh Av. So it shouldn't be mixed up with the halacha and the minhagim.39:40Excellent. Hallel is a din d'rabbanan that we say, although on Rosh Chodesh it's39:46d'rabbanan. We say Hallel on Rosh Chodesh—excuse me,39:49Rosh Chodesh it's a minhag that we say39:51Hallel, but still, even though... That Rosh Chodesh Av is the beginning of a sad time.39:56Rosh Chodesh in general is like a mini holiday,39:58especially Sefardim bring down holy stuff.40:00Rosh Chodesh, and one should say Hallel on Rosh Chodesh, and if he's singing it, he should also say it singing.40:07The issur of singing and music and all these things is not relevant to the areas of mitzvah,40:12and certainly in the times of tefillah, one should say it with a tune and singing,40:17and if it gives him simchah, then halavai. We're all jealous; we should all be in such a state of simchah when we say Hallel.40:24Okay, let's go back to meat and wine during the nine days.40:30Here are some important points to keep in mind.40:33Children, okay? When it comes to giving children meat in the nine days,40:39for the Ashkenazim, they're more stringent, and they don't give children, when they get to the age of understanding40:49what the Churban is, understand that there was a Beit HaMikdash and there was a great loss that we had in Jewish history.40:55So at that age already, the Rama brings down, the Ashkenazim don't eat, don't give the children meat.41:02However, for the Sefardim, up to the age of 12, a child up to the age of 12 could have meat.41:09I don't know how practical it is if you're cooking for the house for your husband, so you're going to probably cook for the whole family.41:14But let's say the child wants to have meat, or you want to make a separate dish for your husband and for the kids,41:19the kids up to the age of 12 for the Sefardim are allowed to have meat in these nine days.41:26Also, weak people or sick people who need to eat meat could also eat it during these days.41:33Let's say a person has a cold or a fever, needs to have chicken soup, certainly he can have it during these days because he needs it.41:40If a person has to eat some sort of meat because he's low on his protein or whatever it is, he can't eat peanuts,41:45so then it's better to try to have chicken. As opposed to meat.41:50But if he cannot get a hold of chicken, or chicken is not good for him, he needs to have meat,41:54a person who is sick or weak could have meat during these days.41:58Another exception where a person would be allowed to have meat during the nine days, that is by a mitzvah.42:05Okay, there's three categories of mitzvah that we've broken up.42:07Number one is42:12siyum. In yeshiva, I don't know why, it seems like, you know, people are so careful to make siyumim during the nine days.42:20It becomes very difficult during these nine days to go without meat.42:24But of course, we want to show that for the sake of the mitzvah, when we make a siyum, we could even have meat,42:30because although the custom is that we're mourning Yerushalayim,42:33when we learn Torah, especially when we're completing and we're accomplishing, we're finishing42:39a sefer, that is the way we could rebuild Yerushalayim, and therefore we could have meat.42:42In any case, if a person is going to a siyum, then he could have meat.42:49But that's only on the condition that you're not going there just to eat the meat.42:53You're going there because you'd be invited anyway.42:55If it was in the middle of the year, this person would be invited,42:58whether the person making the siyum needs a minyan and you're part of the minyan,43:02or you're a person who is supporting financially this person who is making the siyum or sponsoring the43:08siyum. In that case, you're allowed to attend a siyum with meat and have meat as well.43:14Rav Ovadia brings down that if a person could even plan it, he could slow down his learning to make a siyum in the nine days,43:19or he could learn fast in order that he could make a siyum in the nine days.43:23The second area of a mitzvah where a person could have meat, that is by brit milah or pidyon.43:28Those are two semachot, two occasions where a person cannot delay or make it faster.43:36It's going to fall out in the nine days.43:37A brit milah is going to fall out in the nine days. It's going to fall out.43:39So a person could have meat. But here there's a difference.43:44If it's during the nine days but before43:48Shavuah shechal bo, then anybody who's invited to a brit milah could come and partake of the seudah if it's43:54a seudat mitzvah. But if a person is going only because he wants to eat meat, then that's not mutar.44:01That's not permitted to eat meat.44:02It should happen to be there, so then you're going anyway and they happen to serve meat,44:05then you're allowed to have it.44:07If it's during Shavuah shechal bo, then it's a little bit more stringent,44:11and a person should limit the people who are going to eat from the seudah of the meat44:17to a minyan or the close family and relatives.44:20The same would hold true by pidyon44:23haben. Next, we get to another area where we have an exception to eating meat or drinking wine,44:28and this is a machloket between Maran, Shulchan Aruch, and the44:33Rama, which is really a machloket between Ashkenazim and44:36Sefardim. And that is by havdalah and44:41kos shel bracha at the mazon. By havdalah, we're going to make havdalah on Motzaei Shabbat,44:44and we make havdalah on a cup of wine or grape juice.44:47So since you can't eat meat and drink wine or grape juice, so what are you going to do?44:51So the Ashkenazim, they make the beracha and then they give it to a young boy,44:56a person under the age of six or whatever it is, when he understands,45:00and they let him drink the grape juice.45:01According to Sefardim, you don't have to.45:03If you're making the mitzvah according to Maran,45:05you could drink from the wine and the grape juice yourself,45:09okay? The other case is regarding birkat hamazon.45:13So this is a little bit tricky,45:15so I don't want to get into it too long, but the rule is like this:45:18if you're very careful throughout the whole year that you always make birkat hamazon45:21on a cup of wine with a zimun,45:23let's say you have three people, you make it with a cup of wine,45:26so then even during the nine days, you're allowed to make birkat hamazon45:29on a cup of grape juice or wine.45:31If you're very careful to do it whenever you have the ability to do it.45:34But if you're a person who— Doesn't do it, you're not careful45:38on it. Oh, you've never heard of this halacha for sure,45:40then you shouldn't be doing it during the nine days.45:42Obviously, throughout the whole year, you didn't make birkat hamazon on a cup of45:44wine because you relied on the opinions that say45:46you don't need to make birkat hamazon on a cup of wine.45:49So then these nine days shouldn't be any different.45:53Now, we have a question over here.45:56What if someone made a beracha on a piece of meat during the nine days,46:00and then he remembered it was the nine days before he ate from it?46:03So this is also brought down. Chacham Ovadia brings down,46:05he says that if a person makes a beracha, he should take a bite from it.46:10Why? Because if he would make a beracha and not eat from it, it46:12would be beracha levatala. A beracha levatala, according to many opinions, is an issur46:19min haTorah. Not eating meat during the nine days is only a custom; it's a minhag.46:22Even if it's a din, it's a din miderabbanan on the46:27seudah mafseket. Still, in order to avoid the issur46:30de'oraita, a person should take a bite, that his beracha should not be46:36beracha levatala. Now, we're gonna... one last thing,46:39and that is the leftovers from Shabbat.46:43What a person should do with leftovers from Shabbat.46:45Let's say you have food that's left over from Shabbat46:48Chazon, which is Shabbat where we read Parashat Devarim, right before Tisha46:52B'Av. What is a person supposed to do with that food afterwards?46:57So the best thing is if you could freeze it and use it for later on, that's the best.47:01But if you're not gonna freeze it, you're gonna end up throwing it out,47:04so then give it to the kids,47:05like we said. Kids don't have the obligation.47:08Any child under the age of 12 doesn't have the obligation of not eating meat.47:13Give it to the kids to eat.47:14If even the kids don't want to eat, they're too spoiled,47:16they don't want to eat leftover food,47:19so then a person could have it himself on Saturday night,47:23on Motzaei Shabbat, of Shabbat47:25Chazon, even though it's in the week of47:28Shavua shechal bo. And if a person always is careful to eat the leftovers from the Shabbat food on Motzaei Shabbat,47:33then it's for sure not a problem.47:35If a person doesn't care to throw it out,47:39or he usually throws out his food, or he doesn't eat the leftovers,47:42there's no obligation that he should eat it.47:44But like we said, the best is try to avoid it and not to eat it.47:49Okay,47:51I think before the break now,47:53just one thing maybe we'll mention,47:56and that is a few quick points.47:59Tasting.48:00Food on Friday afternoon during the nine days, ta'amea chayim zachu, bediuk. So if a person usually tastes from the food48:07before Shabbat because he wants to fulfill the mitzvah, or he wants to see how it tastes like,48:13even though it's meat, that's mutar. And the issur of not eating meat only applies48:22to real meat. What they have in the stores, soy meat or fake meat, that's not a48:26problem. Also, even if you don't drink wine or grape juice during these days, it's mutar to drink beer or any alcoholic drink48:32like whiskey or vodka or arak. And the reason for that is because only wine was brought on48:38the mizbeach and not other things, and that's what we forbid, and that's the minhag. Other things are not part of the minhag.48:45If a person wants to avoid it because during the nine days he wants to avoid good times,52:13then52:38hazak u'baruch, tovah alav berachah. We'll take another short break, and then we'll come back to the end of the show.52:50A few audience questions that the rabbi would now answer that we got via text.52:57Okay, let's begin with the first question.53:00First question was, could a person buy and fix clothing during these days?53:04So we mentioned this already, and we said that a person should avoid and not buy during the weeks,53:11and we gave the exception.53:13If you haven't heard it, so I would recommend to go back to hear it.53:16I cannot go through it right now again, just because of the shortage of time.53:20Fixing clothing is not a problem.53:22Something that ripped, or let's say sewing back a button, that's fine.53:27Buying, there are exceptions when it would be53:29mutar, not be mutar. I'm sorry, but you have—just go, I have a few more questions I want to answer before we finish.53:34Number two, there was a very important question.53:36A soldier needs to have a surgery during these days, and he needs to have it during the nine days.53:43It's painful, but it's not an emergency.53:45What should he do?53:45Now, such a special case should be asked to a more local rabbi,53:50meaning to say with a person who understands the situation.53:53But like we mentioned, there's no issur. That's the first halacha that we started with.53:56There's no issur in these days to have surgery,53:59just because it says, rea mazalem, which means the mazal is not good for the Jewish people.54:05It's better to avoid it.54:05But if a person is going through pain and he cannot stand the pain, of course54:10he can have the surgery right away and take care of yourself.54:13And certainly if it's going to cause a person some sort of relapse54:16or it's going to cause him, chas v'shalom, some sort of disease,54:19take the surgery, have it right away,54:23and b'ezrat Hashem, Hashem will take care of what's necessary.54:29Quickly, another question, although we said this also, regarding leftovers on Shabbat.54:34So let's just go quickly again for leftovers on Shabbat,54:37and there's a few levels of leftovers on Shabbat.54:40The best thing is— If you don't want to get rid of your leftovers54:44and you're a person who is makpid on it, then try to freeze it.54:47If you cannot freeze it, give it to children under the age of bar mitzvah.54:51If they will not have it, then a person could have it on Motzaei Shabbat.54:56And certainly if a person usually eats leftovers on Motzaei Shabbat,55:00then he could have it on Motzaei Shabbat.55:01But this is only on Saturday night, Motzaei Shabbat.55:04After Saturday night, you can't have the leftovers anymore.55:06That's it. You have that one-night chance on Motzaei Shabbat hazon55:11to take care of the leftovers.55:14Now we're going to have to finish here because the time is up55:16and the commercials are going to go on whether I like it or not.55:19Next week, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll come to speak.55:21We'll continue from the Ben55:22Ish Chai. We really wanted to cover these halachot today, but we're not going to have time.55:26And we will talk about the halachot of55:30Shavua shechal bo, and because it's the last shiur before Tisha55:33B'Av, we'll try to cover as well the halachot of Tisha55:38B'Av as well as Erev Tisha B'Av, like seudat hamafseket and other things.55:42Make sure to tune in next week,55:43and if you have any questions, you can send it in like we sent again55:47to55:50347-927-8398. And any text messages that we have over the week,55:53we'll try to answer them in the beginning of the show next week.55:55And of course, JRootRadio.com is where to hear this shiur.56:00To hear it live is on 97.5 FM on Wednesdays 2 to 3, and again on Tuesday nights from 10 to 11.56:10I want to thank Jerut and of course Rabbi Shimon Nimni for being with us today.56:14We should be zocheh us that we should have him again week after week56:18and make this show much, much more lively. Thank you very much.