Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Sukkot Part 1Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 1Rabbi Uri Nahum · September 4, 2013−15Play+30Position0:0056:00Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:03www.jrootradio.com, the preferred radio station for the...0:05Welcome to Halacha Hour.0:07Usually we're on together on Wednesday afternoon,0:10but being that tomorrow is Erev0:11Chag, Erev Chag Rosh Hashanah,0:12may Hashem be a new and blessed year,0:15so we're going to do the shiur0:17one day earlier0:18just because of the Erev0:20Chag. Next week we'll resume again with the proper time0:24on Wednesday0:25at 2 o'clock in the afternoon,0:28mazal Hashem. We're up to the halachot of Yom Kippur,0:30but we're going to reserve the second part0:32of the halachot of Yom Kippur0:33for next week,0:36na'aseh teshuvah. So we're going to0:38reserve the second part of the halachot of0:41Yom Kippur for next week,0:42na'aseh teshuvah. This way it's appropriate.0:44And for this week,0:45we're going to learn the halachot of0:48Sukkot,0:49Chag HaSukkot. Now, I have to tell you0:52that we're two days before Yom0:54HaDin. Rosh Hashanah is the day of Yom0:55HaDin, and we're going to0:57maybe reserve the last five, ten minutes0:58just to go over some quick halachot.1:00If there's any questions you want to call in,1:02you want to text any questions regarding the halachot1:04of anything you need to know regarding Rosh Hashanah,1:07we'll try to answer that at the end of the show.1:09But1:11the rest of the show, in the1:12beginning, we're going to talk about the halachot of Sukkot,1:14and in the holiday of Sukkot there's a lot of mitzvot.1:16There's a lot to talk about.1:18First of all, the main thing is sukkah,1:20the mitzvah of sukkah.1:21Also we have lulav and etrog1:23and1:25arba minim. There's a mitzvah also v'samachta1:27b'chagecha, which a lot of us don't realize,1:28but it's a mitzvah1:30de'oraita. There's an obligation.1:31There's actually halachot on how to fulfill this mitzvah.1:35We also say the full1:37Hallel on the holiday of Sukkot.1:40We have Hoshanah Rabbah,1:42Shemini Atzeret, and of1:42course the conclusion, the highlight, the climax1:45really of the holiday of Sukkot,1:47of Shemini Atzeret,1:48of the yamim1:50nora'im, of the month of Tishrei, is Simchat Torah,1:52when we finish the Torah and we begin1:53Sefer Bereishit all over again.1:55So there's a lot to talk about,1:58and we're going to have the first half2:00of the halachot of Sukkot today,2:02and be'ezrat Hashem the second half of Sukkot we'll have it2:05on the Tuesday before2:06the holiday of Sukkot,2:08and the holiday of Sukkot will be on Wednesday,2:11September 18th.2:12Wednesday night, that is. That's the first night.2:14So we're going to have the class on September 17th2:16with the second half2:18from what we speak about today.2:20Now, preparing for the halachot of Sukkot,2:24I have to let you know,2:24even though we're a few days before Yom HaDin,2:27and I, you know, a person, you know,2:29if you think about Yom HaDin,2:30if you think about all the possibilities2:32that could happen on Yom HaDin,2:33it gets us a little bit nervous.2:35And when we're not nervous enough2:37and we're not scared enough,2:38so we get more nervous.2:39How come? What's going on here?2:40What happened to those feelings I used to have2:42once upon a time?2:43When preparing for the halachot of Sukkot,2:46it's, for me, I don't know2:48personally, every time I learn2:50Masechet Sukkah, even if it's Mishnayot or the halachot Sukkot,2:52it puts me in such a simcha.2:54It says,2:57Vesamachta bechagecha, and it's a great simcha that comes2:58with the halachot of Sukkot.3:00So even though we're a few days before Yom HaDin,3:02but still, since the simcha is stemming3:04from the halachot,3:05I figured it should be fine.3:07One thing I want to point out3:10before we begin the halachot,3:11and like usual, we're learning the halachot3:13from the book Ben3:15Ish Chai, and these halachot are found3:16in3:18Parashat Ha'azinu. In Shulchan Aruch itself, the halachot are plenty.3:20There's a lot of halachot.3:22Here today, we're going to focus primarily3:24on the halachot of3:26sukkah. Building the sukkah is very hard to explain3:28on the air, and especially the3:30Ben Ish Chai doesn't leave so much room for explaining,3:32doesn't give so much time3:34for explaining how to build the3:36sukkah. So what we did is, a few years ago,3:38we made a video of how to make3:40the walls of3:41sukkah, and we're going to talk about it today in the shiur3:43regarding some sukkot that may be problematic in3:46halacha. So if a person really wants to see3:48how to build3:50a kosher sukkah, even if you have a sukkah already,3:51not necessarily is it qualified according to3:54halacha. So therefore, you should watch the video.3:56It's very, very recommended, highly recommended3:57that you should watch that video.3:59It's not online yet; we're going to have it,4:02be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully up this week or next week.4:04And just to see how to make a4:06sukkah, it's a very important video4:07to see that you should make sure4:09that you're building the right4:11sukkah, because it has a lot of things.4:12First of all, it's a4:13mitzvah de'oraita to sit in the4:15sukkah. If you don't have the4:16kosher sukkah, you're not fulfilling the4:18mitzvah. Number two is, the sukkah, the mitzvah of sukkah is so special,4:21it comes only once a year.4:23The mekubalim speak that the mitzvah of4:26sukkah is like the4:28cheder hayichud, the room of when the chatan and kallah enter after marriage,4:32and that's the closeness that we have together4:34with HaKadosh Baruch Hu in the4:36sukkah. As the Arizal says,4:38Vimino techabekeni, when His right hand of Hashem hugs me,4:41that's referring to the4:43sukkah, that Hashem hugs us.4:44We're sitting in His shadow in the holiday of Sukkot.4:47And more than that,4:49you're making berachah every time leshev basukkah.4:51And4:53if the sukkah is not kosher,4:57you make a berachah levatalah, and that's4:59an issur de'oraita according to most Rishonim.5:01So therefore, it's very highly recommended5:03that you either watch the video5:05or go to a competent talmid5:07chacham, a person, a rabbi, anybody who knows5:09the halachot of sukkot properly,5:11and come to examine your5:13sukkah. You know, people invite rabbis to their houses5:15for all different kinds of things,5:17Chanukat Habayit. And things,5:18and tell you the truth,5:20a hanukat habayit, the rabbi comes in, he says a few words of5:23divrei Torah, which is very nice, and then walks out.5:24Maybe he'll read a little bit of the Zohar.5:25But bring the rabbi to your house5:27to look at your5:29sukkah. If you don't have a, you know, if the rabbi can't come to everybody's house,5:31I'm sure maybe you know someone,5:33or you have a relative who's learning5:36halachot, a person learning kollel who knows5:38the halachot, or there's a lot, plenty of people who know5:39what the halachot are supposed to be.5:41Let them come and check out your5:43sukkah to make sure that you have it done properly.5:46First thing I'll tell you5:48is that when we check out5:53your sukkah, if we want to build in a proper place,5:54first thing you got to make sure,5:56and this is a problem that you find by most people5:58that don't realize this,5:59is that the sukkah is in the wrong location.6:02Sukkah, one of the halachot of6:04sukkah is that it's not allowed to be under a roof,6:08okay, or under a tree.6:10Those are the two most common things that we have today.6:12So therefore, check out your6:13sukkah. If it's on your balcony, look up6:15and make sure that the6:17sukkah or parts of the6:18sukkah should not be under any sort of roof6:21or should be under another balcony.6:22If there's parts of it are under a balcony,6:25it's fine. You just have to know, again,6:26which parts, and if it's able to be6:30machshir where you sit down.6:31The other thing is6:33look up to see if there's any trees in your backyard,6:35in your front yard,6:35depends where you're putting your6:37sukkah. Just make sure that no branches go over your6:40sukkah, or if they cover it to a certain extent,6:42and you have to know where they cover the6:45sukkah and where you're allowed to sit.6:46All these things, just basic things6:48you should look out for it6:50and ask. Take a picture of it6:52if the rabbi can't come to you.6:54Baruch Hashem, today everybody has a smartphone.6:56We can use it,6:58letovah, at least leto'elet. Take a picture of it or a video7:01and show it to your rabbi7:02and show him,7:03Rabbi, let me show you.7:04Is this a kosher sukkah?7:05Can I sit in this sukkah?7:07Can I make a berachah?7:08If the rabbi says, you know, it doesn't look good,7:10then he might send someone7:11or he might come over himself.7:13In our class, we will deal primarily with the halachot7:17of how to perform the mitzvah of Sukkot,7:20or the mitzvah of the7:21Arbaat HaMinim. We're not going to talk about what to look for.7:23Those, you have to watch the videos7:25and the classes7:26online7:27to see exactly what to look for7:28and how to build the sukkah7:29and how to buy the7:32Arbaat HaMinim. Okay,7:33let's get to the halachot,7:34and we'll begin with7:36Halacha Aleph in the Ben7:37Ish Chai. Short halacha in the Ben7:38Ish Chai, but actually we might spend some time on7:40it. Says the Ben7:41Ish Chai, Tzarich leshev b'avir sukkah.7:43A person, when sitting inside the sukkah,7:45we already just mentioned to you7:47that you have to make sure that your sukkah7:49should be under the sky;7:50it should not be under another roof,7:52under a tree.7:53Besides that,7:53when you sit in the sukkah itself,7:56you yourself have to be under the sukkah.7:58As a side point,7:59I didn't mention this before.8:00When men are obligated in sukkah,8:03and we're going to see later on that even children,8:05when they're able to understand, boys that is,8:07even though they're under bar mitzvah, you have to train them to sit in the sukkah.8:10Women and girls are exempt from sitting inside of the sukkah.8:13So as far as men are concerned,8:15when they're sitting in the sukkah, their obligation to sit in the sukkah,8:18they have to make sure that you sit in the airspace of sukkah,8:22which means that there should be a schach above you, a kosher schach above you.8:28And if you decide to sleep under a bed,8:31what does that mean, under a bed?8:33Let's say somebody has a bed inside,8:35and you decide to put a mattress under that person's bed.8:38Or as we're going to talk about a bunk bed soon,8:40put a bunk bed on the side for a second.8:42Let's just discuss, let's say a person wants to sleep under a bed8:44or under a table.8:46What's the halacha?8:47Could you sleep under it?8:49So technically, you're going to tell me,8:50listen, I'm not sitting in the airspace of the sukkah.8:52There's something dividing between me and the8:55schach, so it shouldn't be kosher, it shouldn't be good.8:58However, I'll ask you a question.9:00Could a person sleep with a cover in the sukkah?9:03Could a person sit with a hood on his head in the sukkah?9:06Of course, you're going to tell me, right?9:08So what's the difference?9:09Something's dividing between his head and the9:12schach. So you have to make some sort of difference,9:13and the answer is,9:14there cannot be a9:16chatzitza, there cannot be a divider between the person and the9:19schach. And to qualify as a divider,9:21you need to have two conditions.9:23Number one is that9:25whatever is dividing between you and the sukkah9:28has to have a roof of a9:32tefach, okay?9:34What does it mean, a roof of a9:35tefach? That means it has to be wide as a tefach above your head.9:38So let's take the hood.9:41The hood is technically not a9:43tefach. It goes right above your head.9:45It folds around your head.9:46Even if you want to tell me it's a9:47tefach, you need condition number two,9:48and that is9:49that it has to be a height of9:53ten tefachim high if it's standing,9:56and you measure the height from the legs of the, whatever the chatzitza is.10:00So for example,10:01if you have a table10:02and you have a mattress,10:03you want to sleep in the sukkah,10:04you're lying down on a mattress,10:05and you want to put the table above you.10:07If from under the table10:09until the legs,10:10where the legs are standing on the floor,10:12if you have less than10:15ten tefachim. Then you're allowed to sleep under the10:17table, even though it's dividing between you and the sukkah,10:18it's considered like a cover10:19that's not a divider.10:21But if the table is higher,10:23higher than ten tefachim, that is,10:25then you have an issue.10:27You're considered like you're not sitting in the sukkah,10:29and you're not10:30yotzei dei chovah of sleeping in the sukkah.10:32Now,10:36v'tzarich lizaher shelo yishan tachat shulchan shegavoha asarah tefachim. Ben Ish Chai concludes,10:37a person has to be careful10:38that if you want to sleep under a10:40table, for whatever reason that is,10:41make sure that the table from under it,10:44where the airspace is10:46that you're staying in it,10:48should not be higher than10:52ten tefachim. Now, what is10:54ten tefachim? So for this,10:55let me give you a small introduction.10:56You have to know,10:56when it comes to halachot of sukkot,10:59and I'm talking about all the halachot of sukkot,11:01including the11:02arba minim, including,11:04especially when it comes to sukkot,11:06you really have to know11:07a little bit of measurements of math11:09and what they mean,11:10because otherwise11:11you can be very lost.11:12Building a sukkah,11:12you have to know what a tefach is,11:14what an amah is,11:15what's a measurement11:16according to which opinion,11:17because otherwise11:20you will have major problems.11:21So let's begin by telling you11:23there are two main sizes11:24when dealing in the sukkah11:25as far as length is considered.11:28Size number one,11:29which is the most common,11:31and that's going to be used left and right.11:32We're going to mention this word,11:33but hopefully we'll give you11:35how it translates in the measurements in our days.11:37The first measurement, that is11:39a11:39tefach, okay?11:41Size number two11:42is something called an11:44amah, okay?11:45An amah is longer than a11:48tefach. Whatever the tefach is,11:49six times the tefach is an11:51amah. So each amah is really six11:53tefachim. Don't worry,11:54we'll get to explain what a tefach is.11:56As far as11:58tefach in our days, how does that translate in our days?12:01So in the12:03halachah, we find two12:05Acharonim, two rabbis of the later generations12:08in this past century,12:09that have discussed the measurement of a12:12tefach, and most people follow these two opinions,12:16and they are the opinion of the12:17Chazon Ish and12:18Rav Chaim Naeh. This doesn't mean that there was12:19no such a measurement beforehand.12:21It just translated into the measurements12:23that we understand,12:24like centimeters and meters,12:26that has been done by the great12:30tzaddikim Chazon Ish and12:31Rav Chaim Naeh. The Chazon Ish explains,12:35and obviously12:36each one has his proof,12:37he has a larger size of a12:40tefach than the12:41Rav Chaim Naeh. He holds that a tefach equals 9.6 centimeters.12:46That in America, that's very hard.12:48We don't use centimeters;12:49we only use inches and feet.12:51So in inches,12:51it'll be exactly 3.78 inches,12:55okay?12:56That's the measurement of a12:58tefach according to the13:00Chazon Ish. According to13:01Rav Chaim Naeh, he holds that each tefach is 8 centimeters,13:04and in inches13:06that will be 3.15 inches.13:08Now you tell me,13:09anyway, both between 3 and 4 inches,13:11what's the difference?13:12The difference is not so major13:13when you're dealing with one13:14tefach, but when you're dealing with13:16ten tefachim, there's a big difference.13:18If you need13:19ten tefachim, like we have over here by the table,13:21according to the13:22Chazon Ish, the table could be up to 37.8 inches,13:27and if you see from under the13:29table to the floor there's 37.8 inches,13:31you're allowed to sleep under.13:31But according to13:33Rav Chaim Naeh, that's no good.13:34That's considered ten tefachim already.13:35For him, anything 31.5 and above,13:39that's considered already13:41ten tefachim, and you're not allowed to sleep under,13:43okay? Those are two opinions,13:44the13:45Chazon Ish and Rav Chaim Naeh. I don't want to confuse you,13:46especially13:49this halacha class is more leaning towards13:51Sefardim. Hacham Ovadia brings that the13:52minhag of the13:54Sefardim, as is clear,13:55he shows it from the Shulchan Aruch13:58and the Rambam,14:00that's my14:02manis, that the minhag we follow that of14:06Rav Chaim Naeh. And that means each tefach is going to be eight centimeters.14:08So from now on, whenever we mention a14:11tefach, we're talking about the shiur of14:12Rav Chaim Naeh, which is eight centimeters,14:143.15 inches.14:16Unless otherwise, I'll mention14:17if there's a need to mention the shiur,14:19the measurement of the14:20Chazon Ish, I'll mention it.14:20But otherwise, whenever we say a14:22tefach, we mean eight centimeters,14:23which is 3.15 inches.14:26Good? Okay.14:27So with that,14:29we could come back over here to our14:31halacha. The first halacha we learned, that14:32you have to sit in the sukkah,14:34and there cannot be anything dividing between you14:37and the s'chach of the sukkah.14:40So therefore,14:41the two conditions that will disqualify,14:43the two conditions that will make you14:46considered not sitting in the sukkah14:47are if you have a roof that's the size of a14:50tefach, which tefach wide, that is above you,14:52which is 3.15 inches, or eight centimeters,14:55and it's got to be a height of ten14:59tefachim, which is 80 centimeters or 31.5 inches.15:04Okay? That's what disqualifies15:06it. I measured myself.15:08Don't trust my measurement15:10because, you know, after I measured,15:11I asked the person.15:13You know, I saw in the books that said15:15that most tables are above ten15:18tefachim according to15:18Rav Chaim Naeh. However, I measured myself,15:20and I saw that the regular standard tables15:23that most people have15:24in, let's say, in a beit midrash or in a shul,15:27I'm talking about, you know, ones that people sit down on15:29to learn and whatever,15:31those types of15:32tables measure between 29.5 to 30 inches,15:36which is exactly 76.2 centimeters,15:39which means it's less than ten15:41tefachim. So the standard tables,15:42which is like the lifetime tables that most people have,15:45that measures to about 76.2 centimeters.15:47But again, don't trust me.15:49You take your measuring tape15:51and you go on, you15:52measure from under the table till the floor,15:55and you measure and you see,15:57does it have ten tefachim or not?16:00Does it have 80 centimeters? Is it less than 80 centimeters? If it's less than 80 centimeters, that's it.16:04It's less than ten tefachim, and you're fine.16:07You should be careful, though, because there's some lifetime tables that you could adjust the height.16:12You can make them taller or shorter.16:14So you have to be careful when16:15you measure. For some reason, if you want to sit under the table in Sukkot,16:19you are allowed to if it's less than 80 centimeters,16:23because it's less than16:25ten tefachim. Okay? With that, we'll come to a case, an example, which is more practical,16:30and that is that of a bunk bed.16:32Could you sleep in a bunk bed in the sukkah?16:36Just in case we're not sure what a bunk bed is, I'm told to explain it.16:39A bunk bed is two beds, one on top of the other.16:43Okay? Now, there's no question to sleep in the top one.16:45What's the problem with sleeping in the top one?16:46There's nothing dividing between you and the schach besides the fact that you have a cover.16:51What about sleeping under the top bed,16:54which means on the front bed? You want to sleep on the bottom bed,16:57and you have another bed on top of you.16:58Is that considered a17:02chatzitza? So according to what we learned, technically you should say,17:05okay, take a measuring tape and measure17:07from under the top, the high part of the bunk bed,17:10which is the board or above, talking about the bed above,17:14from under it till the person who's sleeping under. Measure it.17:18Do you have ten tefachim or not?17:20You have to measure to the floor, because the upper bed is standing on top of the bottom bed.17:28So the legs of the upper bed really begin from the sides, from the top of the bottom bed,17:35and that's where you measure from.17:36You measure from the person lying down above him.17:39Is he sitting in an area which is less than ten tefachim or not?17:44Is it less than 31.5 inches or not?17:47And that's how you find out.17:48If it's less, then it's fine.17:51You can sleep under it.17:53If it's more than that, if it's more than ten tefachim, you can't sleep on the bottom bunk bed,17:57okay?17:57Now, there's a discussion in halacha regarding bunk beds.18:00It's not as simple as I told you.18:02On the air, I can't go into the complications, really, of different18:06halachot, but we'll just tell you that the bunk beds,18:10there is some opinion, one opinion that says that it's a18:13problem. However, the big poskim like Shevet HaLevi, Rav Shmuel18:19Wosner, shyichyeh, in Eretz Yisrael, one of the biggest poskim today, holds that bunk beds are not a problem,18:23and you definitely have many more opinions to be not to be18:26somech on, but that they say even lechatchila, a person can sleep on the bottom bunk bed18:29as long as it's lower than ten tefachim between the person sleeping and the bed above him,18:35okay?18:36We move on now to halacha bet.18:39Halacha bet, the Ben Ish Chai talks about different requirements that you need for a kosher sukkah.18:44Now, you should know,18:45a lot of people might listen to this halacha and say,18:47Hey, you know, Baruch Hashem, I have a top kosher sukkah,18:51and I already got my rabbi to come check it out,18:53and I have my nephew and my cousin and my uncle, who is a rabbi,18:57and he's a talmid chacham, and he's bigger than you,18:59and he checked out my sukkah and he said it's fine.19:00You're right.19:01We should still know the19:03halachot. Why?19:04Because— You will definitely find yourself in a sukkah other than yours.19:09I'll give you a small example.19:10You go to eat by your relative's house, right?19:12And you go to your relative's house. If you don't know the19:15halacha, and just because he has a sukkah doesn't mean it's 100%.19:17You have to make sure that his sukkah qualifies for a kosher sukkah.19:21Or sometimes people eat in the shul sukkah,19:23and don't just say, Oh, okay, it's a shul. They must know what they're doing.19:26Not necessarily.19:27I know for a fact of a shul that had a sukkah under a tree,19:33and many people used to sit on the side where the tree was.19:37And when the rabbi was confronted and he was asked,19:40he tried to get his way out of it,19:41but there's no way out of it.19:42There's a tree.19:43The sukkah is under19:44the tree. Sukkah tachat ilan is19:46pasul. So he quoted opinion in Tosafot,19:49that bediavad, but we don't hold like that opinion.19:51So you have to know what the halacha is,19:53and all that you should know which sukkah you're sitting in.19:56Also, in Chol Hamoed, there's a lot of people who take Chol Hamoed trips,20:00and you go to a park or amusement park or whatever,20:03something that the, Baruch Hashem, the Jewish people rent out,20:05and they make a beautiful sukkah.20:08But it's beautiful-looking sometimes.20:10You have to make sure that it's beautifully according to20:13halacha. And I've seen in my eyes a sukkah where20:17even the most lenient opinions would not agree to it,20:20and certainly according to20:21Sefardim, which are a little bit more machmir in these20:23halachot. So you have to listen to these halachot well.20:26They should know what's a requirement20:27or what would disqualify a20:29sukkah. They should know what to look out for during the holiday of Sukkot.20:32Okay,20:33let's begin with the first part.20:35We broke up the parts.20:37This is a20:38halacha. Ben Ish Chai brings a few dinim.20:40We broke it up into different parts.20:41Let's start with the beginning.20:43First halacha the Ben Ish Chai brings,20:45and this is,20:46we'll give you the background soon,20:48says the Ben20:52Ish Chai, Yizaher la'asot ha-defanot קודם הסכך. Make sure you put the walls before the20:55schach. Ve'im lehefech, pesulah.20:57But if you put the schach before the walls,21:00it's21:01pasul. Okay,21:02that's a first21:02halacha. According to Ben21:04Ish Chai, make sure you put the walls up before the21:07schach, okay?21:08Where does that come from?21:09So21:10there's a pasuk that says,21:12Hag haSukkot ta'aseh lecha shivat yamim.21:15Torah commands us that you have to make for yourself a holiday21:18sukkah. The Torah uses the word21:20ta'aseh. It doesn't say sit in the21:21sukkah; it says you have to make.21:23And the Gemara says,21:25ta'aseh v'lo min ha'asui. When the Torah says21:26ta'aseh, it emphasizes you have to make it,21:29and it shouldn't be just made on its own.21:31What does that mean, it's made on its own?21:32That means when the schach is put up,21:35it has to be put up for the sake of sukkah.21:38That's number one.21:39Also,21:39because if it just came on its own,21:41for example,21:41it just randomly happens to be21:43the wind just blew things,21:45put it together,21:45and now it happens to be21:46that you have a kosher sukkah,21:47it doesn't work.21:48Also,21:49there's a complicated part of the21:51Gemara. The Gemara explains how a person could dig up in a21:54ditch. Let's say,21:55you know, one of the things that you can make as a schach is straw,21:59because it grows from the ground22:00and it's detached.22:01So you have straw that's detached22:03and it's in a big pile.22:05A person digs up from the pile22:07and he makes the roof and the walls.22:11He makes the sukkah in such a way.22:12He didn't make the22:13sukkah; he didn't put the walls and then the22:16schach. Everything was made in one shot.22:17He put basically the22:18schach and then made the walls.22:19In that case,22:20it's a problem.22:21So you have one of the Rishonim22:23who is known by his book22:24called the22:25Hagahot Maimonim, and he brings an interesting22:27halacha that nobody else brought,22:29okay? And he says,22:30he applies it to making the sukkah walls22:33and the22:34schach. He says,22:35first you have to make the wall.22:37And then after you make the wall,22:39you have to put up the22:40schach. That's all he says.22:41Now,22:42he doesn't tell us,22:43is this only22:45lechatchila or even22:46bediavad? He just leaves it at that.22:47He just says,22:48make sure you make the walls first22:49and then the22:51schach. And number two is,22:52he's the only opinion that brings it down.22:56So, now this22:57is—he's one of the Rishonim.22:58Shulchan Aruch,22:59when he wrote his halacha book23:01called the Shulchan Aruch,23:03he doesn't bring this at all.23:04He doesn't bring this requirement23:06that you have to make the walls23:07and then the23:08schach. The one who brings it is the Rama.23:10And the Rama says,23:12lechatchila, a person should make the walls23:14and then afterwards make the23:16schach. Good?23:17But again,23:17he doesn't tell us,23:18what if a person does it the other way?23:20What if somebody takes four sticks,23:22he puts on top of it the23:23schach, and then afterwards he says,23:24you know,23:25I want to make walls,23:26let me put the walls now.23:27Does it work or not?23:29So here you have a23:31machloket of the early23:33Acharonim. You have the Levush and the Taz.23:35These are two big guns,23:37okay? And they hold23:38that if a person made the23:41schach, which is the roof,23:42before the walls,23:43the sukkah is not kosher23:45bediavad. It's23:46pasul. You're not sitting in the sukkah.23:47It's no good.23:49Torah says ta'aseh v'lo min ha'asui, and this is no good.23:51The Bach says23:52no,23:53this sukkah is kosher.23:55If you made the schach before the walls,23:57the sukkah is kosher.23:58Of course, lechatchila...24:00Preferably, you have to make the walls and then the24:01schach. But if a person does it the other way, it's24:04kosher, and he brings a beautiful proof.24:05His proof is from a Gemara. The Gemara says,24:07Hamishalshel hadefanot, a person who lowers the24:09walls. And Gemara clearly says over there that24:11you put a schach and then you're24:13making the walls after the24:15schach. And he brings a very strong proof.24:18Because of that,24:19the Bach rules24:22that it's kosher, and the24:23Chida, which came about maybe 200 years24:26after the24:27schach, the Chida was one of the major rabbis24:30of24:31the Sefardim, he holds the same also.24:33He holds also that if24:35lechatchila is supposed to make the walls before the24:37schach, but if you didn't,24:39if you made the schach before the walls,24:42then it's24:44kosher b'diavad. Clearly the Ben Ish Chai doesn't go with this.24:46The Ben Ish Chai rules that it's pasul.24:48The Ben Ish Chai went with the other24:49Acharonim, and he holds that it's pasul.24:51But he said, no, it's not only the24:53Chida. There are many Acharonim that hold24:55that if you made the walls24:57after the schach, it's fine.25:00Chacham Ovadia is one of them.25:01He says b'diavad it's25:03kosher. Rav Mazuz25:05in Ish Matzliach also, it's brought down25:08that they also go with the same opinion.25:09They go with the25:10Chida. The Chida writes that if the25:12schach was made first and then the walls,25:15it's25:16kosher b'diavad. So therefore, a person25:19has a machloket over here,25:20and like every machloket,25:23lechatchila you should first25:24make the walls and then afterwards make the25:26schach. If it's your own sukkah,25:28so what you could do is, let's say the person put up the25:30schach first and then he put up the walls.25:32So what you do is just lift up the25:34schach, take a broom, and lift up25:36the schach a few25:38tefachim, a few inches up, and let it come down.25:40So this way it's considered that you25:42put the schach all new. When you took it off the sukkah,25:44it's considered like it's not there, and you put it back on.25:46This way you'll say25:48yedei chovah according to everyone. Now if it's not25:50your sukkah, you don't have to worry.25:53If you go into somebody25:54else's house, you don't have to worry if they put25:56the schach first or they put the25:58walls first. Why? Because you have a lot of26:00poskim, you have major poskim like26:04the Chida, the Bach, Chacham Ovadia, they all say that if you26:06made the walls...26:08After this chach is26:11kosher, bediavad. Even the26:12Shulchan Aruch didn't bring it as a requirement. So therefore,26:14you don't have to worry. You don't have to ask26:16if you go to somebody else's house. You don't have26:18to worry about this first26:20halacha, okay? Now,26:23you're going to ask yourself, hold on a second.26:26Who in the world would put26:28this chach before the walls?26:30It just doesn't make sense. Anyway, you're26:32putting up the walls. More סכות anyway.26:34The way you put them up is you put the walls and then26:36you put the chach. It doesn't make any sense that a26:38person should make the chach first and then the walls.26:40And the answer is, although you're right,26:42but26:44I'm going to introduce now a subject26:46that many people might be very upset about26:48or not so happy, but it's a very important26:50halacha, because this is where a big26:51michshol, a big stumbling block happens26:54to many, many people who don't know26:56about it.26:57I want to speak about the canvas sukkot,27:00the fabric sukkot, okay?27:02If you go to buy a sukkah,27:04you mainly have two parts.27:05There's that brown one, or you get it in different colors.27:08You know, those are the solid walls.27:10And/or you buy27:12the canvas sukkah, which is27:14basically just27:16canvas, and it comes with metal bars,27:18and it's called the easy27:20sukkah or easy build sukkah, something like that.27:23You just put the27:24metal bars together, and then you take27:26the canvas and you put it all around, and then afterwards27:28you put the chach. Now,27:30the canvas itself has an27:32issue. Many people don't realize, but there's27:34a big issue in the canvas walls. Why?27:36Because Shulchan Aruch writes27:38in siman taf reish lamed,27:40halacha yud. Listen to the words27:42of the27:44Shulchan Aruch. How says sukkato27:46bein ha'ilanot. If a person makes a sukkah27:48between the trees, meaning,27:49ha'ilanot defanot27:51lah, he makes the trees as walls.27:53So now a guy wants to build a sukkah, and27:56he's making the walls of the sukkah27:58from the tree. Im hayu28:00chazakim, if they were very strong,28:06שקשר אותם וחיזק אותם עד שלא תהא הרוח מצויה מנידה אותם תמיד. If a person28:08tied them. Very,28:10very strongly that a common28:12wind, a regular wind they have outside on a regular28:14day, not a day when it's stormy, a regular wind28:16is not able to move them,28:19right? Then,28:20harei zehu kesheirah. Then it's28:22kosher. And then he writes,28:24the Shulchan Aruch writes,28:26Aken, ein nachon la'asot kol hamechitzot28:28miyeri'ot shel pishtan belo kanim. It's not proper28:30to make the walls of the sukkah28:32from sheets of linen28:34without any sticks.28:36Af al pi28:37shekesharan b'tov, even though he tied them very well,28:40why?28:41Zimnin d'mintakei, v'lav ada'atei. Sometimes what you use to28:44tie could drip without the28:46person realizing it.28:49Therefore, if you just have these sheets,28:51it's considered a28:54wall that's not able to stand28:55in the common wind, and therefore,29:00according to29:01the29:03Shulchan Aruch, this presents a big problem.29:03Now, what's called29:06that the wind moves it?29:08So according to almost all29:10the Acharonim, they hold that29:12if it moves in the wind29:14even a little bit, that's not called29:16a wall. And the29:18logic is very simple.29:20The mitzvah of sukkah is to29:22live in the sukkah like you live in a29:24house. Would you live in a house where your29:26walls are constantly moving, even though they're moving29:28here and there? That's not a house.29:30You have to live in the29:32sukkah similar to the way you live in your29:34house. If the walls of your house move a little bit,29:36you wouldn't sit. Same thing in the sukkah. If the29:38walls move a little bit, it's no good.29:40So you're going to ask me now,29:42what's going on? How29:44could everybody sell it? How could everybody29:46sell it? Nobody speaks—everybody's selling it.29:48So Rav Moshe Feinstein writes29:50in the Igrot Moshe, he says, just because29:52people sell it in America—he talks about the29:54canvas sukkah—he says, just because you see people selling it,29:56it doesn't mean it's29:58al pi chachamim. It doesn't mean that the rabbis agree to it.30:00Yes, they sell it, but30:02who says30:03that, you know, that's according to halacha?30:06Somebody came up with a great idea,30:08or he thought it's a great idea,30:10and people are buying it without30:11thinking about it. But30:13I'm not trying to come down on30:15everybody has a canvas sukkah. There are30:18ways where the canvas sukkah would be30:21kosher. It's not by tying the walls very tight.30:23Making the30:26walls very tight is still no good, because you'll see, even if you30:27make it very tight, the wind moves it even a30:30little bit. It's a huge30:32difference when you have a solid30:34wall of a sukkah,30:35let's say made out of wood or even30:37out of plastic, than if you have it30:40made out of canvas. Canvas moves30:41even if you make it very tight, and even if you make it tight,30:44it doesn't help. We just saw the words of30:45Ruchan, and that's why Chacham Ovadia brings it down. Even if30:48you tie it very well, who knows? Maybe30:49the wind might rip it, or it might rip by itself30:51without you realizing it. So even if30:53you tie it very well, it's still not work.30:55The way to kosher it is,30:57if you notice, if you ever bought one30:59in the last four or five years, even ten years,31:02they sell the canvas sukkot with31:03a very long string.31:05Okay, I hope you didn't throw out that string, because really that's what31:08makes your sukkah31:10kosher. And these strings, they would sell31:11you about three of them. It's like a very31:13long string or rope, and those31:15are supposed to serve as your walls. That's really31:17what the wall is. The canvas31:19is just there31:21as fortseniaut, to cover you up31:23so when you're eating that nobody should see you.31:24So that's really what makes it31:26kosher. Now it's too complicated on the radio to explain without visual.31:29You really need visual for this.31:30And again, I highly recommend you watch that video31:32of how to make a sukkah, because over there31:35we show a video31:37of a canvas sukkah and what makes31:39it kosher. Also, sometimes you see31:40canvas sukkot, you can say, I see a31:42canvas sukkah by a big rabbi,31:44and you're right, but it doesn't mean that31:46the canvas itself is serving as a wall.31:48Me personally, I only have room31:50to put a canvas sukkah, but my31:52canvas is not my wall. My wall is the balcony.31:55The metal bars on my balcony is my31:56wall, and even then it's not 100%. I have to31:58add other things.32:00Make it a kosher sukkah. Just because you see from people, rabbis, people who know halacha, that they have canvas32:06sukkot, this doesn't mean that the canvas itself will change the halacha. It's not. It's not the canvas32:12that will. The wall that they're using is probably something else, and therefore, if you have a canvas sukkah, make sure you ask what's the proper way to do it.32:22Also, another thing to be in the medzechut, and this is really more for Ashkenazim, doesn't apply for us.32:27The Chazon Ish writes that when Maran said, Shulchan Aruch says that if the canvas moves the wall—that, excuse me, if the wind moves the canvas wall by a little bit, right, that little bit means32:45three tefachim. Only if it moves three tefachim, that's considered like an uprooted wall. That's not considered a32:49wall. But if it moves just a little bit under three tefachim—now, each tefach, we said, eight centimeters, so that means if it moves 22 centimeters, according to the Chazon Ish, that's fine.32:58However, everybody almost disagreed with him. I told you, first of all, our rabbis, the Sefardim, Hacham Ovadia says it's a problem.33:07And also he brings down from Mishneh Halachot, R' Menashe Klein zecher tzaddik livrachah, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, zatzal, in Halichot Shlomo. Even Ashkenazim argued, and they all held that if it moves a little bit, it's no good.33:19So, and I know there's heterim, other people who brought it in other ways, but those are all bediavad. There were heterim one would use only when it wasn't possible in any other way.33:29So there is what to rely on, the Chazon Ish, but otherwise, today that's possible and it could be done, just a person has to prepare himself.33:35You must make sure that your wall is a kosher wall,33:41okay? Now, the issue with a canvas wall is as follows.33:46Besides that the wall is not kosher, but let's say a person, you know, makes his sukkah, he makes the walls, and he puts his schach, and then he says, you know, I'm going to make my walls kosher now.33:54Instead of relying on the canvas, I'm going to go get string, I'm going to get pieces of wood, and I'm going to make the wall—you know, all you need is ten tefachim height—I'm going to make the walls right now from wood.34:04So what ends up happening is that you made the schach and then you made the walls,34:08because the canvas wall means absolutely nothing.34:10So it comes out that you made the schach before the wall, and this is what we spoke about from the beginning.34:15According to the Bein Yishchai, if you made the schach before the wall, it's pasul,34:19okay? Now, even though there's a lot of opinions are machshir, but still it's a mitzvah that comes once a year.34:24Why do you want to put yourself in the34:26safek? Even though we could tell you that yes, there's definitely enough opinions and strong opinions that you can make34:34a berachah l'shev basukkah, but still, why do you want to put yourself in such a thing?34:38So the best thing to do, if you personally own such a sukkah and you already made the schach and then you made the walls kosher,34:46is like we said before, take a broom, lift up the schach and let it come down.34:49So this way it's considered that you are the one who made the sukkah. You made the schach come after the walls,34:59okay? Now, to summarize very quickly,35:03the walls should be placed first and then the35:07schach. If the schach came before the walls, according to the Bein Yishchai it's pasul.35:11According to many Acharonim, it's fine, it's kosher,35:15bediavad. Lechatchilah, a person should pick up the schach and put it back down,35:19and this could be an issue when you have a canvas sukkah35:23where a person might put up the schach first and then only make the walls kosher.35:27So in that case also, you should lift it up, put it down.35:29If you're eating somewhere else and you see a canvas sukkah that you see that has kosher walls,35:34made it properly with a string or whatever it may be,35:37you don't have to ask if the walls were done before the35:40schach. There's enough to rely on that a person can make a berachah in such a sukkah.35:44We take a little bit of a break and we'll come back. We'll finish up this35:47halachah, and then maybe we'll give some time for halachot Rosh Hashanah. Little family rendezvous here. We'll bring out Benny Friedman and Yiddle Werdiger, Yiddle Ben Rotze. Yitzchak, come into our...40:31Okay, we're back on with the halacha on Tuesday instead of Wednesday.40:34We're in the middle of talking about halachot Sukkot.40:37We're going to finish up this halacha, and then afterwards we'll go maybe spend some time just to quickly review some of the halachot of40:44Rosh Hashanah. If you want to call into the studio, if you have any questions regarding the holidays, Sukkot, Yom Kippur, or40:51obviously Rosh Hashanah coming up,40:52please, you can call in, and the number is40:56718-683-5858. If you want to text in the question, 347-927-8398. This shiur will repeat itself again on41:04Tuesday night, September 17th, the night before the holiday of Sukkot. So if you're listening then,41:11I guess you'll just have to text in your question,41:13and hopefully if somebody is by the studio, can forward it to me, and then I'll be able to answer you. Okay, let's come back.41:19Let's just review very quickly. We mentioned that the walls should come before the sukkah, and that's only41:25lechatchila. Now, the next part that the Ben Ish Chai in Halacha Bet talks about, next halacha,41:29he says like this:41:34'Yizaher shelo yaniach davar hamekabel tumah b'sechach.' Be careful in the schach itself, you shouldn't put something that's mekabel41:42tumah. 'V'lachen ha'etzim shel ha'sechach lo yihyeh bahem beit kibul.' Therefore, the wood itself should not have a place where they could be receptive; they as41:48bekablim tumah. Okay. Also, Ben Ish Chai talks about other things that we don't have so much today. It's not so practical today,41:54but I'll tell you like this.41:57The sukkah, if you're buying it from a place, a reliable place, if it comes with a hechsher or42:02even not with a hechsher, any schach that you buy from a kosher place, in42:06Judaica even, most of them I've seen, especially according to the Sefardim, you can be lenient. You can buy it,42:11there's no problem. You can also make a berachah with it. I've seen some very interesting42:15things that people use for42:17schach in Israel much more than here, but over here most people use either the mats or bamboo sticks.42:24So all these things are very good for schach. So much of this, since today42:29we're just buying prepared schach, I'm not going to bother to go into it. One thing42:33we will go into, and that is what the Ben Ish Chai says over here regarding decorations. He says like this.42:38He says if a person is hanging something as a decoration,42:52Even if42:53you're hanging something that cannot qualify as a schach, metal objects, for example, they cannot qualify as a schach. Things that don't grow from the ground do not qualify as a42:58schach. So if you're hanging those decorations on top of the sukkah, even though you cannot use it as a43:05schach, still they're batel to the schach, and there's no problem to even sit under it.43:09But that's only if you hang it within four tefachim of the43:16schach. What is four tefachim? That's 32 centimeters, which is 12 and a half inches.43:22Okay, that's about a little bit over a43:24foot. So if you're hanging anything, that anything that's coming down from the s'chach within a foot of the43:29s'chach, it's considered part of the s'chach, and therefore it doesn't disqualify that part of the43:34s'chach. You could even sit under it. Talking about men, obviously, they could even sit under such a43:38thing, okay?43:42However, if there's more than four43:46tefachim, let's say you have something like a chandelier coming down, and some people have very high roofs in their sukkah, and43:53let's say they have a43:54big chandelier coming down from the sukkah, and43:58it's beyond the foot from the—it's hanging down more than a foot. It's not part of the44:02s'chach. It's considered a separate place by itself, and therefore it's considered like a s'chach pasul.44:07You may not sit under it.44:10Even though it's not wide44:12four tefachim, even though it's not wide four, still, if44:16we go there and you're not allowed to sit. If it's four tefachim wide, this decoration or the light, whatever you're using coming down44:23from the sukkah, then44:25that could disqualify that part of the sukkah. It's assur to sit under it, okay? Which brings us up to44:32a halacha that's very common that's usually asked always regarding sukkot, regarding lights and decorations hanging from the44:38s'chach. Let's review very quickly. Anything that hangs within four tefachim is considered part of the schach, and one can sit under it.44:46Four tefachim is 32 centimeters, or 12 and a half inches,44:50okay? So the best, take your measuring tape and measure. Within a foot of the44:54schach is considered part of the schach, and it's kosher. It's not a problem. It's there for decoration.45:00You cannot spread something. You cannot spread like a tarp or a nylon cover, anything plastic over the sukkah45:08if it's not for decoration. If you're spreading it to protect yourself from the rain, it doesn't work. It's not considered part of45:14the schach. It's only considered part of the schach when you put it for decoration.45:16Even if you want to spread a big sheet45:19under the schach and it's covering the whole thing, as long as it's within a foot of the45:24schach, it's considered part of the schach, and45:25it's not considered a45:28chatzitza. You consider like you're sitting there as long as it's a decoration. If it's there for decoration and45:34because you want it to be there45:36so it could protect you from either the rain or things falling into your sukkah, in that case45:42it disqualifies the sukkah. It has to be45:46your only reason why you're putting up such a thing is because of decoration, okay?45:53Now, there is a machloket when something starts from the schach and45:58is just so large that extends beyond the46:02four tefachim. According to46:03almost every opinion, actually I think everybody almost agrees that46:08since it started from the top, it's considered part of the46:12schach. We mentioned before the chandelier. The chandelier is not all the way on top. It's not connected to46:18the schach. It hangs down from the schach. There's a string and it comes down.46:23But if you have a decoration or light that's not from the top,46:29it's hanging down from the46:33schach above a foot, that's when it's a problem. When it's part of the46:36schach, that means it started from the top and it just extended beyond the foot,46:40that's not a problem. And just a46:44machmir, don't use such decorations. But in general, try to keep your decorations within a foot of the schach. Now here's a question.46:52Can goyim build the sukkah? Now, I know myself that I've heard many people46:58show their dislike when they say, Oh, you know, I saw this person;47:02he had a goy build his sukkah for him. And the question is, can a goy build it or not? So actually,47:09listen, the Gemara says like this. The Gemara says,47:17Sukkat ganbach kesheirah. A sukkah of47:18the following people—ganbach is roshei teivot: gimel, nun, bet, chaf. It stands for goyim,47:23nashim, behemah, and chaf is kutim. The sukkah of such people is kosher. What does it mean, sukkah of goyim?47:30What does that mean, sukkah of goyim?47:31It means, let's say a goy made for himself a sukkah. We're not talking about a halachah sukkah.47:36Once upon a time, before the AC or anything, a person wants to sit outdoors. He doesn't want to build a whole house.47:40He wants to build a thing, but the roof is not going to be from something like bricks or anything. He wants to use47:48branches or leaves that are detached from the ground, and he wants to use it as a roof. So that technically qualifies for a kosher sukkah.47:55If a goy made such a47:58roof or such a building...48:00And the wall happens to be kosher, and the schach happens to qualify for being kosher.48:05The Gemara says, even though the goy made it for himself,48:07you want to use it for a sukkah, it's48:09kosher. How come? Because we mentioned already beforehand,48:13the schach has to be placed for the sake of a48:16schach, not for the mezal schach, but it has to be as a shade.48:20Since this goy made the roof for the sake of a shade,48:23that should protect him from the sun,48:25that's considered already, that would qualify for a kosher sukkah.48:30So technically, if the goy is building your sukkah,48:33since he's making the schach, and the schach is made obviously for a cover,48:39for a roof, it's obviously to protect you from shade,48:42technically it should be not a problem.48:44So therefore, a goy could build the sukkah for you on the holiday.48:49However, some say it's still48:52an old, even though the Gemara says sukkat goyim is kosher,48:56still you should try to have only the Jew do it and not the48:59goy. How come?49:02Well, some opinions bring down that49:04since the Gemara is talking about a case where the goy made it as a shade,49:08over here when you hire a goy to build it for you,49:11he's not thinking so much that he's making it for shade.49:14You're just telling him, make me a hut, make me a sukkah.49:17He doesn't know what that is. He doesn't know what you're using it for.49:19He thinks it's a shol, like a menorah.49:21He doesn't know what exactly you're using it for; you said under it.49:25So since the goy is not thinking to putting up the roof of the sukkah for a shade,49:29he's doing it because that's what you're telling him to do,49:31some say so it doesn't qualify as the sukkah of the goyim that's mentioned in the Gemara,49:37which was made for shade.49:38So in such a case, in order to avoid the problem, tell the goy,49:40I want you to make me a sukkah, and when you're putting the roof,49:43you're putting it in order that it should be considered like a shade49:46to protect me from when I'm sitting under.49:48That's it. That simplifies and solves the problem.49:52There's another reason that's brought down, and that is49:55that the kedushah of the sukkah is very, very holy.49:59That's brought down by many sefarim.50:01The Chida brings it. Chida HaYamim also brings it.50:04They all bring down how holy the sukkah is,50:07and if you read all the50:10chassidish sefarim, how they speak about the kedushah of the sukkah,50:12according to some, you shouldn't even let a goy walk into your sukkah50:15because the sukkah is so holy.50:18Now, like we said in the past,50:20this is al pi Kabbalah, it's not al pi50:21halacha. Anything that's not al pi50:23halacha, it's very good if a person could do it.50:25If a person cannot do it, he's not obligated to.50:27So if a person wants to do better,50:30he maybe have the goy build the walls,50:32and if you could do the50:34schach, chazak u'baruch, that's great if you could do it.50:35But if a person cannot do it, the person is older,50:38he shouldn't definitely not put himself in50:40sakana or make himself sick,50:42that he can't even fulfill the mitzvah of sukkah50:44because he's not feeling well since he made the sukkah.50:46If a person needs help,50:48he can get a goy to help him.50:49He can even get a goy to build it for him,50:51especially some shuls. A lot of people I know,50:53they showed this favor:50:54Hey, look at this shul, they have a goy build it.50:56Listen, you know, a goy is working there.50:58There's no Jew that has time right now to go build it,51:01and if they decide to hire a Jew or not,51:04that's their own reason.51:05But according to halacha, there's nothing wrong51:07with a goy building the sukkah.51:09If a person wants to be51:12machmir, and definitely there's definitely a lot of room to51:14machmir to have only the Jews build the sukkah,51:19ma tov u'ma na'im. So we did one, two51:21halachot in the Bein Hashmashot regarding Sukkot.51:23The rest of the51:25halachot actually will go much faster.51:27Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll cover them51:29on Tuesday, September 17th,51:31right before the holiday.51:33Until then, be'ezrat Hashem,51:34we'll just finish with a few minutes that we have,51:36just a quick review regarding the halachot of Rosh Hashanah.51:40Rosh Hashanah is tomorrow night.51:42All right, tomorrow night51:42it's going to be51:44year תשפ״א. It's a new year.51:45It should be a year of51:48siyata dishmaya, like the name is,51:50תשעד, and we have to prepare ourselves a little bit for the holiday.51:52Just quick halachot that we mentioned in the past,51:55and that is, number one,51:56a person should prepare52:00eruv tavshilin. You need to prepare52:01eruv tavshilin, and it has to be done tomorrow.52:02It should not be done tonight;52:04it should be done tomorrow. It's very simple.52:06You take something baked, preferably bread,52:08and something cooked, preferably something that's going to last.52:11Once upon a time they used to do eggs52:13because, you know, without refrigeration,52:15that's what used to last.52:16Today you can do it with anything.52:17If you didn't make the eggs, don't go crazy; it's fine.52:19Take anything that's cooked.52:20Take a steak. Take anything that's52:23whatever that was used to cook,52:24not something raw.52:25Take something that's cooked and baked,52:26and pick it up.52:27It should be at least a52:30kezayit, and pick it up and say,52:31With this...52:31I mean, first there's a52:33berachah. If you have a52:34machzor, it should say the berachah in the beginning,52:40Shekideshanu... על עירוב. Tavshilin, and then52:42after you make the52:43bracha, you say it in the language that you understand.52:45If you understand Aramaic, that's the best,52:47and say, With this,52:49I should be able to cook and bake52:51and do whatever I need for me and the rest of the52:54family. If you're eating by your52:55in-laws or eating by your parents,52:57and you're not eating at all on Shabbat in the house,52:59you're staying the whole holiday by relatives,53:02then you don't need to make your own eruv tavshilin.53:04The baal habayit, the owner,53:06just like he gives you food to eat,53:07he could also, even though you yourself53:10or your wife need to light candles,53:12still he could be somech on the eruv tavshilin53:13of the baal habayit. You don't need to make your own eruv.53:15A lot of people don't realize it.53:16Even though you're not eating the meals of Rosh Hashanah in your house,53:19you might be eating at home when it comes to Shabbat,53:22and the whole eruv tavshilin is preparing53:23from the holiday of Rosh Hashanah,53:26the second day on Friday,53:27for Shabbat. So make sure you make eruv tavshilin53:30if you need to cook or bake53:32or anything else53:34for Shabbat.53:35Okay, that's number one. Number two is53:38regarding the53:39simanim that we eat tomorrow night.53:41You should know a lot of these things are mentioned53:43in the simanim. The Gemara says,53:47Simana milta hi. It's something that has a name.53:49It's a good omen that we do53:52on Rosh Hashanah.53:53So you should know53:55that although it's a good53:57remez and everything,53:58it doesn't mean you could do an issur for it.53:59There's a lot of these things have bugs,54:01and it's very, very difficult to clean them.54:03It's not lo shaveh even to try it.54:06If something is buggy, it's assur to eat.54:08It's54:09issur d'Oraita. And the greatest siman on Rosh Hashanah54:11is a person should not54:13do an aveirah. So therefore, if you have something that's buggy,54:15check. There's a lot of things are infested54:17and it's seasonal usually. So what you should do is54:19just look at it. Look at it and say54:23the yehi ratzon. You don't have to eat it.54:25Or don't bring it on the table54:26bichlal if you're worried somebody's going to eat it.54:28There's no obligation to do an54:30issur d'oraita in order just to have54:32a simanah milta hi. Another thing that people should be aware of,54:35that the Yerushalmi says,54:37a person who sleeps on Rosh Hashanah54:39is mazal sleeps.54:40And the explanation of that is that54:42a person should be up from already alot54:44hashachar. Alot hashachar is 5:09 and54:465:10 on the first two days of Rosh Hashanah,54:48and it's good—not an obligation, but it's54:50good—a person should wake up beforehand.54:51That's why many people pray54:53Netz. And Yom Rosh Hashanah we spend most of the day54:56in the shul, therefore54:57the tefillot are very important.54:59We should be careful that55:01if we're not praying in a very, very good minyan,55:04even a regular minyan, we should be careful55:06not to speak in shul.55:08And for ourselves, not because of anybody55:11else—not, forget besides the fact that55:12interrupting other people—but for yourself,55:14not to speak in shul, not to interrupt yourself.55:16It's an amazing day,55:18and you could set55:20everything for the rest of the year,55:22so therefore make sure you take55:24full advantage of it.55:25And one last halacha, and that is we say55:28Shehecheyanu on both nights55:30in the Kiddush. If you forgot to say55:32Shehecheyanu on either night, you could still55:34say55:36Shehecheyanu on the following day55:38if you forgot it at night.55:39Okay, with that we'll end off with a wish55:42of55:44ketivah vachatimah tovah to everybody55:45in Klal Yisrael, especially those who are listening,55:48tizku leshanim tovot, na'imot. You're listening to JRoot Radio.