Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Hanukkah Part 1Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 1Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 13, 2013−15Play+30Position0:0056:38Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:02www.jrootradio.com, the preferred radio station for the Jewish home.0:07Welcome to Wednesday afternoon Halacha hour here on0:12JRoot Radio. So if you're listening, you're listening on 97.5 FM.0:16Online, you're listening at, I hope you're listening online,0:20jrootradio.com. And if you're not, you can listen to0:23jrootradio.com. And let me give the phone numbers before we0:26begin. The phone numbers to the station are0:31718-683-5858, if you have any questions in halacha, especially about what we are discussing.0:35And to text in the question, you can text it in at0:43347-927-8398. Again,0:48347-927-8398. Okay. Like we mentioned last week, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll be beginning now a new halachot.0:56Last week, up till now, we were talking about hadlakat nerot shel Shabbat, tomat dehalachot of hadlakat nerot shel Shabbat.1:02Be'ezrat Hashem, today we'll be discussing a new subject of halachot,1:07and the halachot are the halachot of Chanukah.1:10Obviously, as we know, Chanukah is coming up1:12in a few days, in, I guess, in two weeks, by the end of November, very early this year.1:19Wednesday night, November 27th, will be the first night of Chanukah,1:24and that's not so long from now.1:26So therefore, be'ezrat Hashem, we want to prepare ourselves for the halachot of Chanukah.1:31The halachot are found in Ben Ish Chai, Shanah Rishonah, Parashat1:37Vayeshev, Shanah Sheniyah. That's where you can find the halachot.1:40The Ben Ish Chai talks about halchot Chanukah.1:43Before we begin, I just want to say that this class is dedicated l'refuah shelemah of Eliyahu Chaim ben Shafika Sofiya.1:56Hashem should send him, be'ezrat Hashem, a refuah shelemah karov. She'ar kol cholei am Yisrael. Anybody else would like to have, to sponsor certain classes,2:00you could call into the station and request not only this class in halacha, but any class that you would like.2:05Usually it's aired on twice.2:08Here, for example, Halacha hours aired on on Wednesday 2 to 32:13p.m., and again will be on on Tuesday night. At 10 to 112:19p.m. Let's begin with a little bit of an introduction of2:24Hanukkah. We all know the miracle of2:26Hanukkah. The miracle of Hanukkah took place in the Second Beit HaMikdash,2:28and as the Chachamim explained, that the galut, the exile of Yavan,2:35the Greeks who took power over the Jewish people when they still had the Beit HaMikdash,2:40in the Second Beit HaMikdash, was a different galut.2:44The exile of Yavan, when the Greeks were in power, their purpose was not like the other2:51galuyot. For example, we know that Bavel, and we know that Edom, these kingdoms ruled over the Jewish people.2:57These kingdoms wanted to destroy the Jewish people physically.3:01The greatest example is when we see by Purim.3:05What happened by Purim?3:06Haman HaRasha, who was actually a descendant of Esav HaRasha, he was a descendant of Amalek,3:12and he wanted to annihilate the Jewish people.3:14He wanted to get rid of all the Jewish people.3:16He wanted to make a universal Holocaust of the Jewish people,3:18and that's exactly what happened.3:20He got the power, he got the okay, and he was ready to do it.3:24However, Baruch Hashem, Hashem saved us.3:26In the galut of Yavan, in the times of the Greeks,3:29when they powered over the Jewish people in Eretz Yisrael, their purpose was a little bit different.3:34They didn't care so much if you were alive.3:37If the Jew was alive, they didn't care so much.3:39They cared that he's alive as a Jew.3:41And so therefore, they set out to destroy the Jewish neshamot.3:44They wanted that the Jewish people should get rid of the customs3:52and what we call the mitzvot, the commandments that make us unique and the Jewish nation.3:57Many, many sefarim explain exactly the depth and why they chose certain4:03gezeirot, but in simple explanation, the Greeks wanted that the Jewish people should forget the religion,4:10and therefore they did something very smart.4:12I mean, smart, wicked, but smart.4:15So what they did is that they didn't say just— Forget about all the Torah, we're going to kill everybody.4:20No. They said, we're going to knock out certain mitzvot.4:23And they knew that's how the yetzer hara works.4:25When you knock out a little bit, you start to lose a little bit more and a little bit more.4:30And that's why we pray in the4:32Al Hanissim, and we say that You saved us from the Greeks who wanted us4:37l'shakecham Toratecha, who wanted that the Jewish people should forget Your Torah.4:39How did they make you forget?4:42Simple. They start a little bit, and they know how the yetzer hara works,4:45and eventually take the person completely away.4:47And therefore, the Greeks gained power over the Jewish people,4:52not that they decreed certain gezeirot on the Jewish people,4:55and the Jewish people, a lot of them fell,4:57and a lot of people became very Greek-minded, the5:03מתיוונים. So therefore, the Jewish people found themselves in a very difficult time,5:08not only spiritually, but eventually also physically.5:13The Greeks also started torturing the Jewish people,5:15and that's always a result.5:17Whenever we have a spiritual decline,5:20unfortunately we don't realize it,5:21but eventually it follows with a physical suffering.5:26And over here, although it started just a spiritual decline,5:29what did the Greeks say?5:30Don't keep Shabbat, don't keep Rosh Chodesh,5:34you know, don't keep brit milah, don't learn Torah.5:36Simple things, right?5:37However, when the Jewish people abided by it,5:39those who abided by the5:41gezeirot, it lowered us on a spiritual level,5:43and eventually the physical tzarot also came.5:46Eventually, since we were able to defile what's holy for us,5:50they had the power from Shamayim to be able to defile what's holy for us.5:55And that is, they were defiling the5:57women. Any girl that would get married,5:59or she's engaged to get married,6:01became defiled, she was violated.6:04And that was all because we started.6:07We started going down spiritually,6:09and like we said, usually physical suffering comes.6:11But Baruch Hashem, Hashem made a miracle.6:14Hashem allowed us to overcome the Greeks.6:16It started with just a few people,6:19just a few people who were inspired,6:20and they said,6:21No, we're not going to take this. We're going to stand up.6:23We're going to stand up for the Torah.6:25We're going to make sure to keep the Torah,6:27and to keep the Torah properly all the way,6:29without even one drop,6:31without dropping anything.6:33And these few men6:34who risked their own lives to keep the Torah fully.6:38Remember, the Greeks only wanted us6:40to not keep part of the Torah.6:42True, their eventual plan was6:44that they should eventually not keep anything,6:46but they said, knock out a few mitzvot.6:48Over here, the Hashmonaim were inspired,6:51and they said, We're going to keep the Torah all the way,6:54without negotiating on even a little detail.6:57And therefore, the Yevanim were overpowered7:01by the few Hashmonaim,7:03me'atim b'yad rabim. The few number, the few Kohanim7:05from the Hashmonaid family,7:09they were able to overpower the massive,7:11enormous, strong army of the Greeks.7:14And when they were able to defeat them7:17and to get rid of them,7:18to throw them out of the Beit HaMikdash,7:19they came to light the menorah,7:22which was a mitzvah that every day had to light.7:24Every day we read in the korbanot7:26in the morning,7:28baboker, baboker, we have to bring the7:29ketoret. We also have to bring also the Kohen7:32has to be metiv hanerot7:33so that he should light the candles in the evening.7:37There was a menorah in the Beit HaMikdash7:38and had to be lit by shkia time7:41and stay lit for the whole evening.7:43They came to light the candles,7:45and they saw that there was enough oil just for one day.7:48And miraculously, the oil lasted for eight days.7:51Now, there's a big question that's asked:7:53what do you mean?7:54There's a halacha that7:56if something is tameh in the Beit HaMikdash, if—8:00If it's tumah b'tzibur, if it's a tumah that everybody has, so then it could be brought.8:06Lemashal, let's say we have to bring korban Pesach. Now, any korban that you bring cannot be brought when the person himself is8:12tamei. However, let's say the majority of the Jewish people on Erev Pesach happen to be8:16tamei. For example, there were tamei met, and they cannot purify themselves from this spiritual8:22tumah. Then what happens is we bring the korban Pesach anyway.8:26Why? Tumah is dechuya b'tzibur. That's the halacha.8:30And everybody asks the question, if it's tumah dechuya b'tzibur, so why in the world were they so machmir of waiting till they made pure tahor oil?8:40And that goes in line with what we said.8:43The Greeks didn't say get rid of all the Torah.8:46They said, you know, you could cut down on part of the Torah.8:50You could knock out, just knock out a few mitzvot.8:51But that already took away the authenticity of the Torah.8:56It didn't make the Torah shleimah. It didn't make it complete and pure.8:59So when the Yevanim were kicked out and the Chashmonaim took power of the Beit HaMikdash once again,9:06and the Beit HaMikdash was in their hands, they wanted to show a lesson for that generation and for all future generations.9:12We don't bargain on Torah. Every little detail of the Torah must be kept.9:16Even a hidur, even a hidur, we still keep.9:21We have to keep even something that's not part of the9:23mitzvah, even enhancement of the mitzvah, we keep.9:25Even though something could be mutar b'diavad, no, we want to do it9:31l'chatchilah. And that's why it's interesting, this holiday of Chanukah is a holiday that even the simplest of Jews, the simplest of Jews, keeps9:40b'hidur, lemashal. We have other mitzvot. Not necessarily people do9:44hidur. We have a mitzvah that's very, very holy.9:47It's a mitzvah for men, that to pray every single day with tefillin.9:52Even if you don't pray with tefillin, but at least to put on tefillin and to say Shema with it.9:57Even if you just put on tefillin, at least just put on tefillin, make a blessing on tefillin.10:01It's a mitzvah called tefillin.10:02It's a very holy mitzvah, and you should see what it's brought down about the mitzvah.10:05Yet not everybody is mehader. Check people's tefillin.10:09I don't know what good the quality of the tefillin is,10:13but the mitzvah of Hanukkah, the mitzvah is ner10:20ish u'beito. Minimum amount of candles a person has to light on Hanukkah is one. That's it.10:25And when circumstances are very difficult, whatever reason that may be, whether you're away or whether a person doesn't have money, you just light one candle.10:34However, over here, in the mitzvah of Hanukkah, the extra candles which are hiddur, even the simplest Jew lights extra candles.10:43Check this simple Jew. Check his tefillin.10:46A person who is ignorant about tefillin doesn't understand why you have to pay more than $250 for a pair of tefillin.10:51He doesn't understand. I could get it for $250. I don't understand.10:54When it comes to a trog, it's a lemon. He doesn't understand why you have to pay more.10:58When it comes to Hanukkah, no, no, no, no. You have to have eight candles on the eighth night, seven candles on the seventh night.11:02What happened? All you need is one candle. No, no, I don't care.11:06It's mitzvah of Hanukkah, you light eight candles.11:08That's the lesson that the Chashmonaim taught us in Hanukkah.11:12We don't bargain. We don't compromise on any mitzvah, and not just on any mitzvah, on even the details of mitzvah.11:22We do it b'hiddur. We do each mitzvah properly and fully.11:26That was the lesson of Hanukkah. That's the lesson of the menorah.11:30And with that, we could come to our11:33halachot. That's a beautiful introduction, I believe, to halachot in general.11:37A lot of people who don't understand11:39halacha, sometimes when they come in, let's say, in the middle of a class,11:42or they just hear randomly, they open the radio for two minutes,11:44they don't understand why all the details.11:46Big deal, just do the mitzvah and that's it.11:48Why do you have to be so intricate,11:50lechatchila b'diavad? According to this one, it's11:53a machloket. Who cares as long as you do the mitzvah, right?11:55This is not what counts. Hashem counts. Just you did the mitzvah.12:00No, that's not right.12:02You have to do the mitzvah to the best of the ability that we could do the mitzvah.12:07Now, being that the mitzvah is discussed by all the great rabbis throughout the generations,12:11so we want to be able to do it with all the12:13hidurim. We want to be able to do it to be yotzei according to all the opinions.12:16So therefore, there's something called12:18lechatchila, and we should strive, we should put our effort to do something on a lechatchila basis,12:23like the Chazon Ish said. They could have said that we could have used oil that's12:29tamei. No.12:30Even12:32though tumah hutrah b'tzibur, we want over here to be able to do it12:36lechatchila. And you know what Hashem says?12:38Hashem says, You put your effort to do to the best of your ability.12:42Where you can't do anymore, I'll kick in. I'll throw in. I'll come in and assist you.12:48Miraculously, the oil lasted for eight days.12:51Why was there such a miracle?12:54Especially in the times of12:56the Second Beit HaMikdash, there's no prophecy. There were far fewer miracles.12:58The regular miracles that used to take place in the13:01First Beit HaMikdash, we didn't have them in the13:03Second Beit HaMikdash. But the answer is because you sacrificed yourself.13:07You were moser nefesh. You went the extra mile for me,13:11I'll go the extra mile for you.13:13I'll also do miracles for you.13:15You went beyond the letter of the law,13:17I'll also go beyond the letter of the law of nature,13:20and I'll help you to fulfill the mitzvah in13:24the lechatchila that you want to fulfill it.13:26And that's, rabotai, that's a very important lesson to anybody who's listening13:30now or forever. You have this in mind.13:33Whenever we go the extra mile to be able to do the mitzvot13:37the way Hashem wants us to do it,13:39and to put in extra effort,13:41even though min hadin, min hadin, min halacha, I could have done just the minimum.13:45Still, if you put the extra effort to go the extra mile,13:51Hashem will also go the extra mile.13:52Hashem will also perform13:54midah k'neged midah. The way we act, Hashem acts right back with us.13:57We put our full effort, we put our extra power14:02to be able to do what Hashem wants us to do,14:04Hashem also will do back to us.14:07Now, let's get to the halachot inside, bezrat Hashem.14:12Before we get to the halachot, I just want to say14:16the dates for the holiday of14:20Chanukah this year, in the year 5774,14:24tav-shin ayin dalet.14:26Chanukah this year will be, like we said already,14:28Wednesday night, 11 November 27th.14:32I hate to use this as a way to remember,14:35but, you know, that's, I believe, the way most people remember, unfortunately.14:38It's the night before Thanksgiving,14:40and it's going to run till December 4th.14:43Now, December 4th is when we start changing14:46from Barech Aleinu14:49in Maariv, from Barecheinu to Barech Aleinu.14:52So again, it's from November 27th until December 4th14:56will be the holiday of Chanukah, eight days.15:00So let's begin with halacha Aleph.15:02Halacha Aleph, the Ben Ish Chai talks about the berachot that we make15:05when lighting the menorah.15:07I'm not going to read every single halacha inside.15:09We have many15:10halachot, and I would like to finish the15:13halachot before we get to the holiday of Chanukah itself.15:17If I have to go in the holiday,15:18I'll talk about it during the holiday.15:20And some halachot are very, very important15:22that we should know about.15:24One is that we should know what to do,15:26and also there's a lot of extra15:28halachot that we may not necessarily see in the book,15:30the Ben Ish Chai itself,15:31but a lot of practical, important15:34halachot. Any questions that a person has regarding15:37Chanukah. Please do not call in till after15:412:45, or after the song, that is.15:43Or if you want, you could just text it. This way15:44I can read the text a little bit later.15:47Halacha Aleph, it says,15:50בליל ראשון מברכים שלושה ברכות. On the first night, we make three blessings,15:54and they are: Baruch Atah Hashem Elokeinu Melech HaOlam, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu.16:00Lehadlik ner Hanukkah. That's blessing number one.16:05Blessing number two is, Baruch Atah Hashem Elokeinu Melech16:08ha'olam, she'asa nisim la'avoteinu bayamim hahem bazman hazeh.16:12And the third blessing is, Shehecheyanu, which is, Baruch Atah Hashem Elokeinu Melech16:18ha'olam, shehecheyanu v'kiyemanu v'higi'anu lazman hazeh.16:23Those are the blessings on the first night of16:27Hanukkah. Three berachot. They are, again, lehadlik ner Hanukkah, she'asa nisim, and16:33shehecheyanu. Let me just take a little bit more of time to explain these blessings, what they're all about.16:39The first berachah, lehadlik ner Hanukkah, is a blessing that we say on the mitzvah of lighting.16:45As we know, the mitzvot, before we fulfill mitzvot, we should make a16:52blessing. L'mashal, we count Sefirat HaOmer, so before Sefirat HaOmer we say,16:55Asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu16:58al Sefirat HaOmer. That's a blessing that we say before17:01we—blessing, we were learning up till now Hilchot Nerot17:04Hanukkah—I mean, excuse me, Hilchot Nerot Shabbat.17:06And regarding Nerot Shabbat, we said before lighting the candles, you have to make the17:11berachah, Asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu lehadlik ner shel Shabbat.17:13Likewise, when it comes to lighting the Hanukkah candles, we have to make a17:18blessing on what? The blessing of fulfilling the17:22mitzvah. We are thanking You, Hashem, that You've made us holy with Your17:27mitzvot, and You've designated us, and You told us how to become holy:17:30by lighting the light of17:32Hanukkah. That's blessing number one.17:34Blessing number two, which is really the third berachah that we're going to make, is17:39Shehecheyanu. I'm skipping a little bit for a second.17:41Shehecheyanu, being that this is the first night.17:43And this is the first time we're coming to do this mitzvah this year.17:47We mentioned this in the past; we'll repeat it again.17:49Any time you have a17:51mitzvah, you have a commandment that comes once a year,17:54we make a blessing on it.17:55It doesn't go by the person himself;17:57rather, it goes by the17:58mitzvah. A mitzvah that comes once a year,18:01we make the bracha of Shehecheyanu on it.18:04L'mashal, here is our example.18:07We light the candles of menorah.18:10How often does the holiday of Chanukah come?18:12Once a18:13year. So therefore, the first time you're coming to fulfill the mitzvah of lighting the candles,18:17you'll make the bracha of18:20Shehecheyanu. Same thing would be by every single kiddush on the holidays.18:24Any holiday, whether it's Pesach, Shavuot, Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, or Sukkot,18:30since we make kiddush and the kiddush is going on the holiday itself,18:33we will make the blessing of Shehecheyanu on the holiday18:37the first time we're fulfilling the18:40mitzvah. For example, on Pesach,18:41although you may have—we make kiddush on the first two nights in18:46America—we'll make Shehecheyanu, actually, because18:48Sefardim... sorry, we have the first day of the holiday18:49and the last day that's also a holiday of Pesach.18:52The first two nights we make a blessing of Shehecheyanu during kiddush on the holiday of Pesach.18:57Why? Because it's the first time we're coming to fulfill the mitzvah in this year.19:03Any other mitzvah that doesn't come once a19:07year, but rather it's the first time that I'm keeping it, okay,19:11you don't get a19:13Shehecheyanu. Shehecheyanu is only on mitzvot that come once a year.19:15So, for example, a woman who gets married19:18and now she's in her new home19:20and is spending Shabbat in the house,19:22and she's so excited, she takes out the candles that she got for doing her engagement,19:26and she puts them on the silver and they're shining,19:29and she puts on the candles, and she's so excited.19:32She's dressed with her Shabbos19:34best, and she's coming to light the candles on Erev Shabbat, on Friday afternoon,19:41the first time in her life that she's lighting candles19:43and she has all the kavanot better than Narizal,19:46she does not make19:47Shehecheyanu, even though it's the first time she's doing it.19:49Shehecheyanu on mitzvot doesn't go by the person;19:52it goes by the19:53mitzvah. Even though maybe your first time doing it, it doesn't make a difference.19:56Rather, it goes by the19:58mitzvah. If this is the mitzvah, the first time you're doing it per year,20:01because that only comes once a year,20:04then you would make the bracha of20:06Shehecheyanu. This is for the same reason.20:08While we don't make Shehecheyanu on tefillin.20:12Tefillin is not once a year or whatever it is.20:15Tefillin is a mitzvah every day.20:16So when a boy becomes bar mitzvah and he's putting on tefillin his first time,20:19he doesn't make20:20a Shehecheyanu. Rather, just makes the regular blessing of tefillin, and that's it.20:25So you might ask me,20:27what about tallit?20:29A guy gets a new tallit, he makes a berachah on it.20:32Not only that, even though he's been wearing tallit all the time,20:35now he's making a berachah on it.20:36The answer to that is,20:38the reason why he makes Shehecheyanu on a new tallit20:41is not because it's the first time he's doing the mitzvah of tallit.20:44That's for sure not.20:45In fact, even if you've been doing mitzvah for many years20:48and now you get a new tallit,20:49you make a berachah. You're making it because you have a new beged, a new cloth.20:52So again, the rule with Shehecheyanu on20:55mitzvot—again, Shehecheyanu on mitzvot, not20:56fruits—on mitzvot is20:58any mitzvah that comes once a year,21:00you make the berachah of21:02Shehecheyanu. Okay, I jumped to the third berachah on Hadlakat21:06Nerot, just to explain the21:07Shehecheyanu because they're both connected over here to each other.21:09The second21:11berachah, which is the third one that we're going to discuss right now,21:14is the berachah of Sheasa Nissim LaAvoteinu, by Yamim Hahem Ubazman Hazeh,21:18which21:20means—I'm going to translate21:21it—Baruch Atah Hashem21:23Elokeinu Melech HaOlam, that we know, blessed You are Hashem,21:25our God, the King of the world,21:30sheasa nissim laavoteinu, who has performed miracles21:32for our forefathers,21:34bazman hazeh,21:36in their days, bayamim hahem, in their days,21:38around the same time right now.21:40So therefore,21:42the— not therefore,21:44sorry—the Kedushat Levi,21:46Rabbi Levi21:47Yitzchak miDitchev, says a beautiful explanation:21:49bayamim hahem bazman hazeh,21:51just like the miracles were performed by Hashem21:54once upon a time,21:56bazman hazeh also now they're coming up again.21:58What does that mean, bayamim hahem bazman hazeh?22:00It means the same aura,22:02the same spiritual lights22:04that opened up during the times of the22:06Chashmonaim, when Hashem performed the miracles for them,22:08also opens up nowadays as well.22:11Those are the first three22:13berachot, and those are explanations.22:14There is a debate—I want you to keep in mind,22:16we can get to it a little bit more later22:19on—there is a debate amongst the poskim.22:21If the second two22:26berachot, She'asa nisim la'avoteinu bayamim hahem and22:27Shehechiyanu, is going on the act of lighting22:30the menorah candles,22:32or is it going on the holiday of22:34Chanukah? For example,22:35I'll give you an example.22:37Shehechiyanu, we said by the holiday,22:39is going on the— excuse me—22:40Shehechiyanu that we say during the holidays,22:43when we make kiddush, is going on the holiday.22:46What does that22:47mean? It means that let's say a person made kiddush22:50on the first night of22:52Shavuot, and then he forgot to say22:56Shehechiyanu. The next day,22:57he's in shul and he remembers,22:58Wow, you know, I forgot to say Shehechiyanu last night.23:03So the holiday,23:04the23:05berachah Shehechiyanu goes on the holiday.23:06So therefore he could even say Shehechiyanu in the daytime.23:08It doesn't have to be on kiddush.23:09He could even say it, like the Gemara says,23:11bashuk, even in the market he could say23:13the berachah of23:15Shehechiyanu. Okay? That's a berachah on the holiday.23:19A berachah on the mitzvah23:21is, for example,23:24a person who is fulfilling the mitzvah23:26of sukkah.23:29The mitzvah of23:30sukkah also comes once a year,23:31and we make a Shehechiyanu also on it.23:33We happen to include it together,23:35one Shehechiyanu for the holiday of Sukkot23:37and for the performance of the mitzvah of sukkah as well.23:40But really,23:42the mitzvah itself23:43also, you need to say Shehechiyanu on it.23:46So therefore,23:47in that case, you don't make the berachah of23:49Shehechiyanu unless you are23:53performing the mitzvah.23:55Okay?23:56Now keep that in mind.23:58This is a question.24:00Keep the following in mind.24:01There is a question when it comes to the shehecheyanu that we make on24:08Chanukah and the Birchav she'asah nisim24:11la'avoteinu. Is it going on the holiday itself,24:15means the holiday of Chanukah, these eight days,24:17or is it going on the act of lighting the candles?24:20I don't want to get so much into it; just keep that in mind,24:23and we'll get to it, be'ezrat Hashem, a little bit later on.24:25One more thing I want to talk about this halacha before we move on.24:29One more thing I want to talk before we move on,24:31and that is there are some opinions that say24:38that regarding the rest of the nights of the holiday,24:42when you make the berachot on24:45Chanukah, one should first say the berachah of24:50lehadlik ner Chanukah, and then light, and then afterwards say the berachah of she'asah nisim24:54la'avoteinu. Okay? There are such opinions.24:55Rabbeinu Yonah, it's brought down in the Beit Yosef, one of the Rishonim.24:59In fact, some Acharonim also said to say that. However,25:00the minhag is not that way.25:03The minhag is that we make all the blessings before we light.25:08The first night we make three blessings and then we light,25:11and regarding the rest of the holiday of25:15Chanukah, we make two berachot and then we light.25:18That's the minhag.25:19That's, in fact, I've seen video clips numerous times25:23of Chacham Ovadia, when lighting the25:28... when lighting the menorah, he would make first the blessing25:30and all the blessings,25:31and then he would light.25:32That's the way, the minhag.25:34If somebody has a minhag otherwise,25:36it should know it doesn't mean it's not correct.25:39No, it has its sources.25:40Some Mekubalim say it,25:41even the Yaskil Avdi brings it down.25:43But the minhag is to first make all the blessings25:47and then to light the25:49menorah. Let's move on to25:50halacha bet. Halacha bet is pretty simple.25:54He just, the Ben25:55Ish Hai point—I'm not going to read it inside,25:57not to be too25:58dry—the Ben Ish Hai just mentions the text of the26:01berachah, and that is.26:03That the proper blessing,26:06the first blessing on Hanukkah26:08is lehadlik ner Hanukkah,26:11different from Shabbat.26:12Shabbat has the word26:14shel. We say on Shabbat, asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu lehadlik ner shel Shabbat.26:21Not so when we come to the beracha of Hanukkah.26:25On Hanukkah, we take out the word26:28shel. We say lehadlik ner Hanukkah.26:29Some Ashkenazim have a little bit of a different custom.26:32Some will say lehadlik ner shel Hanukkah,26:34or what. We don't have such a thing.26:36Sefardim, three words,26:39and that's it: lehadlik ner Hanukkah.26:40In fact, the Arizal and the Mekubalim say26:44that the beracha of lehadlik ner Hanukkah26:48is supposed to be26:49mechaven for the first three letters,26:51rashei teivot, or the first letter of the three words26:53spells out the word nachal,26:55which means like a stream,26:56but it's the name of a holy name26:57which comes in protection,26:59to protect the person.27:00So therefore it has significance27:02al pi Kabbalah27:03and al pi pshat also.27:04It has a meaning.27:05It's different from Shabbat.27:07Why do we say on Shabbat27:09lehadlik ner shel Shabbat27:11and on Hanukkah27:11we say lehadlik ner Hanukkah?27:13The answer is27:15because shel Shabbat27:15means of, the lights of Shabbat,27:18because on Shabbat27:19we have many mitzvot.27:20There's a mitzvah27:22de'oraita, according to a lot of opinions,27:23there's a mitzvah27:25de'oraita that you have to make kiddush,27:27according to others27:28it's derabbanan, but according to others27:29it's mostly27:31de'oraita. There's a mitzvah midivrei Kabbalah27:33of oneg Shabbat,27:34kavod Shabbat.27:35There's also a mitzvah of hadlakat ner shel Shabbat.27:38So therefore27:39the candles that you light27:40on Erev Shabbat,27:41it's a mitzvah,27:42it's one of the many mitzvot of Shabbat.27:47When it comes to ner Hanukkah,27:48Hanukkah,27:49we don't have anything else.27:51There's nothing else on Hanukkah27:53besides the candles.27:54So therefore27:55lehadlik ner Hanukkah,27:57that is the mitzvah,27:59the single mitzvah that we have on the holiday.28:01Although we say Hallel,28:03but Hallel is a separate thing,28:04it's a praise to God.28:05It's not part of the holiday of the Hanukkah.28:08It's just a praise that we give to Hashem.28:10It's not the mitzvah that's— Specific and unique28:14to the haldei of28:16Chanukah. So that's why28:17on28:17Chanukah we just say l'hadlik ner28:19Chanukah, the candle of28:20Chanukah. There's nothing else.28:21On Shabbat,28:21we say l'hadlik ner shel Shabbat28:24because it's only one of the few or many mitzvot28:28that we perform on Shabbat.28:30That's halacha28:32bet. Move on to halacha gimel28:36before we take the little bit of a musical break.28:39Halacha gimel:28:40Im lo28:44berach shehecheyanu בליל ראשון, יברך בליל שני. So now,28:44this is what we mentioned a little bit beforehand.28:46We said28:48the berachah shehecheyanu that you make on the holiday28:50or on the lighting of the candles,28:52says28:53the Ben Ish Chai, if you don't make shehecheyanu on the first night,28:56you make it on the second night.28:59What does that mean?29:00Let's give you an example.29:01A guy comes on the first night,29:02he's very excited.29:03He comes and he can't find the siddur29:05for whatever reason,29:06and he's ready.29:07He prepares the candles29:07and29:08his brush. He knows he has to light on time,29:09and he wants to be29:11mehader, to light it exactly the precise time29:13that it has to be lit.29:14He comes,29:15he puts on the candles,29:16and he says the two29:19berachot, l'hadlik ner Chanukah, and he says the berachah of29:22שעשה נסים לאבותינו, and he begins lighting.29:23Now his family,29:24his wife and kids,29:25you29:25know, they look at their father.29:26He's the man of the house.29:27He's the rabbi.29:27He knows everything.29:28So they keep quiet.29:29They forget that he's supposed to say29:31shehecheyanu. He lights.29:31He's done.29:32Later on in the evening,29:34maybe three hours later,29:36four hours later,29:37he remembers,29:38Wow,29:38you29:39know, I forgot to say the berachah of29:42shehecheyanu. Or maybe he remembers the next day.29:44The next day,29:45let's say Thursday morning,29:46he wakes up29:48and he remembers,29:49you know,29:49I didn't say shehecheyanu yesterday.29:51So what should he do?29:52Should he make the berachah of shehecheyanu then,29:56on the holiday itself?29:58Or should he wait till that night?30:00We mentioned beforehand30:02that when it comes to Shavuot,30:03a person who forgets to say30:05Shehecheyanu when he is making Kiddush on Leil Shavuot,30:07the next day he could say30:09Shehecheyanu even on the way home.30:11He's walking in the middle of the holiday,30:12he remembers he didn't say30:13Shehecheyanu, he could say Shehecheyanu on the spot.30:15He doesn't have to wait till the evening.30:17Over here, however,30:18we tell you30:19wait. Don't say Shehecheyanu yet.30:21Wait till you light it,30:23when you're lighting the candles,30:24because of the same30:26safek. Everyone will agree that by the time30:27you make the bracha of30:28Shehecheyanu on the second night,30:30you'll say according to all opinions.30:32According to the opinions that say30:33that Shehecheyanu is going on the mitzvah,30:35so beautiful.30:36Now that you're performing the mitzvah,30:38you said Shehecheyanu on the mitzvah.30:39According to the opinions that say30:40Shehecheyanu is going on the holiday,30:41so anyway you said it during the holiday.30:43So what happened?30:45Beautiful, you got it.30:46There's no problem whatsoever.30:47So this is30:50Halacha Gimmel, the first part of30:51Halacha Gimmel. Another part of the30:53Halacha Gimmel is regarding a mourner.30:56Says over here,31:00even a person who is a mourner31:02has to make the bracha of31:03Shehecheyanu. We say in general that31:05mourners do not say the bracha of31:07Shehecheyanu because they're not supposed31:07to have new clothing,31:09and, you know, it doesn't sound too good,31:13Shehecheyanu. Kiman v'gianu lazman hazeh. You know, a mourner doesn't want to say,31:16you know, Thank you, Hashem,31:16You brought me to this time.31:17You know, the guy lost,31:19the guy is mourning.31:20He has somebody who passed away31:21who was a31:22relative to him, so he doesn't want to say31:24Shehecheyanu. It's not the best thing to say31:26Shehecheyanu. However,31:26that's when it comes to31:28maybe eating new fruits,31:30new clothing.31:31You're right,31:31he shouldn't say Shehecheyanu on new clothing.31:33When it comes to mitzvot,31:34he could say31:36Shehecheyanu, and therefore,31:37if a mourner is lighting31:38his candles in his house,31:41he should make the bracha of31:42Shehecheyanu without a problem.31:44Now,31:45what kind of mourner are we talking about?31:47There's two types of31:48mourners that, when we say31:50avel, a mourner,31:51we mean one of two things.31:53It could either be31:55a person who is in the first seven days.31:58This is when we say a person sitting shiva.32:00In the first seven days that they're sitting, he's called an avel, okay?32:05Another meaning of an avel is a person who is, let's say, a person's parents passed away,32:11so he's an avel, he's a mourner throughout that whole year.32:14Why is he called a mourner even after the seven days?32:18Because he still has halachot of a mourner throughout the year.32:22For example, one of the halachot of the avelim throughout the year is that32:26they're not allowed to go to a party or social gathering.32:32So therefore, the avelim, they're considered avelim because they still have to follow this halacha for a whole year, for 12 months.32:40So that's why they're considered avelim, since they're keeping the halacha, okay?32:44If a person lost his sibling, where the halacha says that he's only an avel for 30 days, so the same idea.32:51Even though after a week he's allowed to take a32:53shower, okay, so he cannot take—but since from 7 to 30 days he's not allowed to take haircuts, he's not allowed to cut his nails,32:59he's not allowed to go to a social gathering or wedding unless there's special33:03exceptions. So in those cases, he's considered an avel since he's keeping the laws of avelut.33:09So in general, we'll say, let's say a person in the first seven days where it's heavy avelut,33:13the heaviest part of the avelut, where a person is actually sitting,33:16and the other one is throughout the year.33:18In both cases, the avel over here we're talking about, it doesn't make a difference.33:22Even in the first seven days, he says the brachah of Shehecheyanu when lighting in the house.33:30Avel onen33:33yadlik belo berachah. Onen, however, should light without a33:35berachah. What is an onen?33:37An onen is a person in the stage from the time of death of a relative to the point of burial.33:44That's an onen.33:45These are some subjects that most people try to, you know, avoid and not speak about, not to think about33:51it, lo aleinu, but in order to learn that, we need to know the33:55halacha. We'll discuss it a little bit.33:57And onen, he is—so the Chachamim said like this,34:02let's deal like this:34:03there's a mitzvah min haTorah, ki34:07kavor tikberenu. You have to bury him.34:08It's a mitzvah de'oraita. The person has to bury the dead.34:10And who does that responsibility fall on?34:14It falls on the34:16relatives, the seven relatives. The person who has one of the seven relatives passing away,34:22where he has to mourn for them,34:24they also have an obligation to bury him.34:27So therefore, the Chachamim said, what's going to happen now34:30if a person is too busy involved with many things?34:32Let's say he's involved with this mitzvah and that mitzvah,34:34what's going to happen with the dead person?34:36Nobody's going to take care of him.34:37So therefore, he's an onen.34:39He's asur to do any mitzvot until that person is buried.34:44We got to make sure that that person is34:45buried. That's one reason why there's an onen.34:47Another reason is because, out of the honor of the34:49met—it's not an aveilut class;34:50we won't talk about it in detail.34:52In any case, the onen cannot even, according to us34:55Sefardim, we hold,34:58even though there's a35:00chevra kadisha, an onen is not allowed to make any35:04berachot. He's not even allowed to answer amen to35:07berachot. He's not allowed to answer amen to35:08kedushah. He's not allowed to do any mitzvot.35:09Even blessings he's not allowed to say.35:11In this case, however, when it comes to35:14Chanukah, an onen lights, but he's not allowed to make a35:18berachah. And here the Beit Yosef says,35:21ve'im efshar b'sheliach, nachon adif yoter. But if there's nobody else except for him,35:26if there's nobody else besides the onen,35:27he's the only one, he lives alone35:29and he has the obligation of lighting,35:30as we will learn later on,35:31so then he has to light, but he cannot make the35:34berachah. But if there's an onen and he has a wife—35:36Or he has children that are above the age of bar mitzvah,35:39so wonderful.35:40Give the wife the light with35:42a berachah. Don't make her as a35:45shliach, because an onen, again, he's patur from the mitzvot,35:48and by making a shliach, they're also going to become35:50patur. Rather, the wife lights because it's also her obligation.35:52It's also her obligation to make sure35:54that the candles of Chanukah are lit in the house,35:57so they should light.35:58Okay, this is, in short, the halachot of onen36:01lanu. A person should not know these things.36:03And one more point I forgot to mention by36:06aveilim: the minhag that's brought down in Mishnah36:08Berurah is that although we light candles in the shul36:13and we make the berachah of shehecheyanu on it,36:15it should not be given to an avel.36:17Now, over there, the36:19Sha'ar HaTziyun, Mishnah Berurah brings the36:21Sha'ar HaTziyun, the avel in this case is referring to a36:23person even up to a year.36:25Any mourning, even within the year,36:27should not make a berachah of shehecheyanu in the shul.36:29We'll discuss this a little bit more.36:31I just wanted to point out that there is other opinions.36:34There are opinions that say that,36:36especially for36:38the Sefardim, that this is only referring to the first seven days.36:42Okay, the first seven days of36:45aveilut, that's the kind of avel that you should not say shehecheyanu in the shul.36:49Otherwise, it's fine. There are such other opinions,36:51but I think the minhag is anyway like the Mishnah36:53Berurah. Anybody who's an avel is not given36:57the honor of lighting the menorah in shul,36:59unless we'll see later on there's no other choice.37:01So we take a little bit of a music break right now.37:04If anybody has any questions,37:08you can text it in or call in right now,37:10and then, after this break, we will answer them.38:10Mit torgn, fin nekhtn, biz morgn, di kinderlekh vaksn dikh. Gur azoy gi, di yorn antloyfn dikh, dos lebn farkoyft men dikh. Keymol kumt tsayt nisht tsu kukn oyf zikh, vi gliklekh iz er, der shabes yid. Er geybn fin a39:19himl, a39:38mirye yidelekh aley, s'iz gevorn geshteln, s'iz fargesn fin der velt. Arayn in a likhtikeit, un nor mir tashtey. Zinget shoyn inter, der shabes vet neynter, tekhales de vayn oyfn tish, shoyn geshtelt. Der hertse der prayen zikh, neshomes banayen zikh, di lekhtelekh brenen, balaykhtn di velt. Vi gliklekh iz er, der shabes yid. Er geybn fin a himl, a mirye yidelekh aley. מה האָבע, פילט מען אין שבת מיט די מלאכים, במהלךים, מיר זינגען צוזאַמען.40:38We're back, be'ezrat Hashem. We continue talking about the halachot of Chanukah.40:45Before we continue, I want to give the number to the station.40:48It's40:51718-683-5858 if you want to call in with any questions that you have regarding today's class,40:54any classes in the past, whatever you like.40:57If you want to text in your questions, which is a little bit more easier for me, practical,41:02I can look at it and see it clear,41:05the number to text in is41:09347-927-8398. Again, 718-683-5858 if you want to call in.41:12If you want to text in,41:15347-927-8398. I want to make a few more announcements before we continue.41:18Number one is that we mentioned this last week,41:23be'ezrat Hashem, we began a regular Bnei Shai class.41:25If you want to come to Bnei Shai class live and to hear this,41:28we give a class on Friday night right after Shabbat prayers,41:33right after Arvit of Shabbat, on Avenue U and Ocean Parkway,41:36in the shul called Beit Yosef in the basement.41:38We're there, we're located there.41:39If you want to come and learn the halachot inside and hear live,41:44you can ask whatever questions you want,41:45or you can listen to other discussions that come up.41:49That will be, again, it's on Avenue U and Ocean Parkway,41:54in the basement of the shul Beit Yosef,41:57and Mincha is usually by candle lighting time,42:00and then afterwards we go into Kabbalat Shabbat and Arbit shel Shabbat,42:04Sefardi. The other announcement is, like we mentioned in the42:08beginning, this class is42:10l'refuah shelemah l'Eliahu Chaim ben Shafika Sofia b'toch she'ar cholei am Yisrael.42:14We have a few minutes left to the class.42:17Let's continue in the Ben Ish Hai, Halacha Dalet.42:21Now, Halacha Dalet is probably the most complex42:26halacha in this parashah that the Ben Ish Hai brings.42:30To read it, it is very complicated to read it and think,42:33so I really would like to read it inside,42:35because also one of the reasons why we give the halachot class42:38over here from the42:40Ben Ish Hai, besides that we have to know the information42:41and we use the Ben Ish Hai as a base to work on42:43and to bring a lot of other subjects and practical examples that come up,42:49we also would like a person who wants to go through the42:53Ben Ish Hai, you have over here the classes that you can hear42:55and you can listen and you'll be able to tell throughout the words.42:59You'll be able to read the words and understand what's going on.43:02So before we get to the halacha itself and reading it from the inside,43:07I just want to give a little bit of a background to this43:12halacha. Halacha discusses the location where a person should place his menorah43:16when coming to light the candles.43:19You should know, as a rule,43:22the miracle which took place in the Beit43:24Hamikdash, that the candles stayed lit for eight days,43:26the rabbis who instituted that we have to light the43:31candles. The rabbis who said that we have to light the candles,43:33they wanted us to publicize the miracle.43:36This is called pirsumei nisa.43:38To pub- pirsumei is like pesomet, a publication.43:41They wanted us to publicize the nisa, the miracle of the43:48Chanukah. So therefore, the rule when you want to know43:52where should I place my menorah,43:54where should I light my43:56candles, the rule is wherever it would draw the most attention.44:01I know it's very unlikely.44:02Jews are usually very44:04tzanua; we're supposed to be very tzanua unto ourselves and not to draw attention.44:07Not in this case.44:09When we come to publicize the miracle of God,44:12we want it to be publicized.44:14We want everybody to know about it.44:15We want everybody to see it44:17in the mitzvah of44:18Chanukah. So therefore, as a general rule,44:21the trick to remember is to light the menorah,44:25to place the menorah, excuse me, in the location before lighting it44:29and lighting it in the place where it could draw the most amount of attention,44:32where people could see it.44:33Good?44:34Now, in the times of the44:36Chachamim, if you open up the Gemara,44:37you'll see the Gemara discusses44:39that the places where they would, the best place for them to light the menorah in their days44:44was outdoors,44:47because back then, once upon a time,44:50all the houses pretty much consisted of a one-floor house,44:52and all the houses were what we would call in today a44:56walk-in. Houses here in America are basically,44:59even if a person has a private house,45:01you have to go up a few steps to go into the first floor,45:04and then there's a basement.45:06And very few houses are just walk-in houses.45:10It's a little bit more, becoming a little more popular in certain neighborhoods,45:13but otherwise most houses here in New York at least45:16have to go up a few steps.45:17In their days, there's no such a thing.45:19Most houses were like a storefront.45:22Everybody would just walk in directly into the house;45:24it's45:25open. So therefore, where is the best location to put your menorah?45:29The windows, you should know back then also,45:31didn't consist like our windows today.45:33Our windows today have glass.45:35Once upon a time, you can see clearly,45:36it's evident from the Mishnah and the Gemara,45:38most windows were not that way.45:40Most windows were sealed,45:41were just a hole in the wall,45:43and they were sealed with a wooden plank.45:46When it got cold or you don't want people to come in,45:48whatever reason,45:49you just sealed it with a wooden plank.45:52Our windows today have a glass,45:54which means45:55you could have the windows shut45:56and still people could see through the windows.45:58Keep that in mind.45:59So back then,46:01they didn't have windows like the way we have.46:03So therefore,46:04the best place,46:05Chachamim said,46:05when you light your candles,46:07you have to put it outdoors46:08by the door,46:10so that this way46:11everybody, when they're walking by,46:12should be able to see it,46:14okay? This is in their days.46:16In our days,46:17you have to think46:18where you live46:20and where you're lighting your menorah,46:22and think of the rule:46:24pirsumei nisa, we have to publicize the miracle.46:26Where could I light the candle46:30in where it would make the greatest,46:32would draw the greatest,46:33the most amount of attention46:34that people should see it?46:36If I light it in my kitchen,46:38how many people will get to see it?46:39Me, my wife, and my kids,46:40and that's it.46:41Anybody who maybe will come over.46:43But if I light it outside,46:45how many people will be able to see it?46:46Where would it draw the most amount of attention?46:48So now,46:49I'll just give you a few examples.46:51You know, you probably have to consult46:53with your rabbi or things,46:53but take this again as a rule.46:55You want to light it in a place46:57where it would draw the most amount of attention.46:58So let's say46:59you have a regular New York private house.47:01You own the whole house.47:03So basically,47:04probably your house would probably look like this.47:06You come47:07and you see a few steps,47:09you go up,47:09whether you have a balcony or not,47:10and then you walk into the house,47:12and that's your first main floor,47:14okay?47:14In such houses,47:17so...47:17The best location would probably be47:19the front window of your house,47:21since that window47:22everybody could see from it.47:23That's the best location to light the menorah,47:26because everybody could see from it.47:27If you could light outside,47:31outside of your house,47:31or really technically even47:33in the front of your yard47:34where everybody could see that,47:35even better.47:36But most,47:37it's not so practical for most people,47:39as we'll talk about why later on.47:41Okay?47:42So either by the window47:43or from the, on the balcony47:46where people could see it47:47when they're walking by in the street.47:50If, however,47:51you don't own a whole house,47:52but you have just an apartment,47:55and your apartment's on the second floor.47:58Let's assume now,47:59regularly you're on the second floor.48:00Or even maybe on the third floor, very hard to find so much. But let's say you're on the second or third floor,48:06most probably from the ground level, from the street level all the way up to your apartment is not 20 amot.48:13We'll talk about measurements later on, Be'ezrat Hashem, Halacha hei. That's probably next week, not even later on.48:18So therefore, in such a case, you will light your menorah in the front of your window,48:24because the door to your house is a hallway, and in that hallway you would see it, and maybe your neighbor who lives downstairs will see it.48:35But in the window, anybody passing by the street will be able to see your menorah.48:39So for you, if you live on a second-floor apartment, like myself, you will light your menorah in the window.48:47If you live in an apartment building now, that's a little bit more complicated.48:52Okay, let's give two types of apartment buildings. Let's say two apartments where you live in an apartment building.48:56Let's say your apartment building, you live in an apartment building, and your apartment is on the, what's it called, second floor. Or, yeah, second floor. Let's say second floor.49:07So if it's on the second floor, most probably it's within 20 amot,49:12okay? It's within 20 amot from the ground level.49:1520 amot is about 31 to about 38 feet, okay, from the floor, from street level.49:24So therefore, in that case, you'll also light it in your window.49:26Which window? Window that's facing the street,49:32okay? If you live in an apartment building and your apartment is higher than that,49:38your apartment is all the way up, maybe fourth, fifth, you could even go higher, eleventh floor, twentieth floor.49:46Let's say you're in the city and your apartment is on floor number 21.49:49I don't know what you're doing Shabbat, but anyway, in any case,49:51so you're on the 21st floor and you have to light over there.49:55So in that case, it's above 20 amot. You have a big problem,49:59because how in the world are you going to light up there?50:02Now, halacha says that ner Chanukah that's above 20 amot is50:07pasul. So if you light it in the window over there, who's going to see it?50:10So there's an opinion, a very big rabbi living in Eretz Yisrael, his name is Rav Shmuel50:18Wosner. He wrote a book called Shevet HaLevi, and he writes,50:22if you have other apartment buildings that are as tall as your building,50:26that means you're on the sixth floor, and you have another apartment building across the street from you50:31or by the side, and it's also on the sixth, there's people living on the sixth floor,50:35so they can also see it.50:36Although the people on the street level, it's above 20 amot from the people on the street level,50:41who cares? The other buildings can see it, so therefore, according to him,50:43you can also light it in the window in that case.50:45Others say, however, no. Over there, you're not going to be able to let anybody see outside,50:51so therefore, you have to take the menorah and put it in the next best option by the door.50:58By the door is what the halacha is over here in Ben51:01Ish Chai. Ben Ish Chai talks about lighting the menorah by your doorway.51:05Now, what the Ben Ish Chai is talking about, you should know, he's talking about the houses that they had once upon a time.51:11The times of the Ben Ish Chai, I believe the houses they had were pretty much the same as the times of the51:16Chachamim. Okay, maybe a little bit more decorated or whatever, but meaning they were like a51:22walk-in. They're on ground level, like the way we have stores today.51:25Most stores are, you have to go up the stairs and down the stairs.51:28Most stores you just walk in. So that's how pretty much they had their houses.51:32There's another type of houses where many people have their51:37houses, but they all share an area called like a chatzer, I guess you'd call it like a yard.51:43And you'd have to first, in order to get to the houses,51:46first you'd have to walk into this chatzer, to this yard,51:48and the yard has many houses over there.51:50Again, all houses were a51:53walk-in. They were all ground level.51:55You walk in right into the house,51:57okay? So if your house is on the street,52:01that means people are walking by in the street52:04and they're passing in front of your52:05house, like today's stores,52:07so then you would have to light the menorah outside of your house.52:11That's what Ben Ish Chai is talking about.52:13If you owned a house or you lived in a house52:16which was in a chatzer, in a courtyard,52:18and that courtyard was shared by many other houses,52:21and people don't walk in front of the house,52:22rather they walk in front of the courtyard,52:24so then you'd have to place your menorah. In the entrance to the courtyard on the52:30outside, okay? That's the halacha outside.52:34I want to spend just a few minutes to read it inside.52:38Anybody who would like to see what the halacha is,52:41this is the halacha dalet52:43in the Ben Ish Chai, Parashat Vayeshev.52:44He says as follows:52:48Mitzvah lenicha b'tefach samuch lapetach. There's a mitzvah to place the menorah within the tefach that's close to the doorway.52:55Meaning to say, if you're standing right in the front of your door,52:58okay, you imagine from the door towards the street.53:01It's very hard to explain this on the radio53:03if you're not watching in person.53:05Meaning to say,53:06samuch lapetach means to say53:08within a tefach to the street.53:11So you're putting it by the doorway.53:15Even nowadays that we light inside,53:18as we're going to talk about,53:19be'ezrat Hashem, next week,53:20many people have the custom of lighting on the inside53:22because they were scared to light on the53:24outside since there was a lot of53:30anti-Semitism. So they didn't want to have problems with the non-Jews and everything,53:33so they would light inside.53:35He says even still,53:36you should light it by the door,53:38in front of the door53:40a little bit. Now, which side of the door?53:42He tells me now this location53:43in front of the door53:45within the53:46tefach, but the door has two sides.53:48So he says,53:49when you walk inside the house53:52from the outside,53:53you walk inside the house,53:55so on the right-hand side53:56you should have a mezuzah.53:57On the left-hand side of the door,54:00there's no mezuzah.54:01So therefore54:01place the menorah on the left-hand side.54:04Why?54:04Because you have a mezuzah on the other side.54:10However,54:10if for some reason54:12you took out, let's say,54:13your mezuzot to be checked,54:14and you have no mezuzah on the right-hand side of the door,54:18so then you place the menorah on the right side.54:22But otherwise,54:23most houses will probably,54:24most doorways54:25will probably have a mezuzah,54:26so the menorah should be placed on the left-hand side.54:30Now,54:33veharei she'osam mezuzah b'yachad. By putting the menorah on the left-hand side54:36and the mezuzah being on the right-hand side,54:38you'll have three mitzvot.54:39What are they?54:42Ki adam hanichnas u'veit, tzarich sheyihyeh talit katan shel tzitzit. Because a person who's walking in54:44is usually wearing a talit katan,54:46a tzitzit.54:46So you have you wearing your tzitzit,54:48you have the mezuzah on the54:49right-hand, and you have the menorah on the left-hand side.54:53It's wonderful.54:53You have three mitzvot,54:54as the pasuk says,54:58Vechut hameshulash lo bimherah yinatek. And that's what the Ben Ish Chai says.55:00You know what?55:01It's even the three mitzvot55:03on Roshei teivot, semach. What is semach?55:05Tzitzit,55:05mezuzah,55:06and55:07Chanukah. And with that55:08zechut, you'll have the zechut of bringing Mashiach.55:11And as it says about Mashiach,55:14Pitchu she'arim v'yavo goy tzaddik, and open up,55:15as it says,55:16open up the doors55:17and let the goy tzaddik, the holy nation, come in.55:20And we know that semach,55:21as the pasuk says,55:24it's55:25the, it's meramez to the name of Mashiach.55:29Well, let's continue.55:31Uksheniach Chanukah mezuzah petach bismol. This is where it really gets complicated.55:33When you're placing the55:35Chanukah on the left-hand side of the door,55:39yaniach blaila rishonah. Okay, so this,55:39you know what,55:40I think because it's a very short time55:41and I have to explain it,55:43this actually is relevant to us.55:44Even if you're not lighting outdoors,55:46this is going to be relevant55:49also if you're lighting in front of your window55:51or wherever it may be.55:52And bezrat Hashem,55:53we'll talk about it next week.55:56We're out of time right now,55:57and whether I like it or not,55:58I think I'm just going to be cut off.56:00So therefore, I'm gonna pause over here. We're gonna stop over here.56:04If you want to text in your question or text in your comments,56:07you could text it in at56:10347-927-8398. If something important, bezrat Hashem, I'll bring it up to everybody's attention next week,56:13but I'll answer you privately if you need an answer right away.56:16Until then, have a wonderful week, bezrat Hashem.56:19Shabbat shalom.56:21It's too early to say Hanukkah sameach,56:22so we'll hold off that blessing till bezrat Hashem next time we meet.56:26We'll meet again next week, Wednesday at 256:29o'clock. Until then, have a wonderful day. You're listening to JRoot Radio.