Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Sukkot Part 2Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 2Rabbi Uri Nahum · September 18, 2013−15Play+30Position0:001:18:32Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to the Halacha Hour.0:02It might be today an hour and a half, we don't know, we'll see.0:05We are having a special class today.0:07Usually we have the class on Wednesday afternoon.0:09Today we'll have it on Tuesday afternoon0:12because tomorrow Wednesday is Erev0:14Chag, and we wanted to get the halachot,0:16that we should know the halachot and our preparation for the holiday of Sukkot.0:21And we hope we finish the halachot within an hour.0:24If we don't finish it in an0:26hour, be'ezrat Hashem maybe we'll have a continuation by tomorrow to see what goes on.0:31This is actually the second class on0:34Hilchot Sukkah. Last time we did the halachot.0:35You'll probably hear it tonight on a rerun on Tuesday nights on JRoot Radio0:4197.5. And for now we will continue from where we left off last time.0:45Just before I begin, my kids are home and they're listening,0:48so I promise them I'll say hello.0:50Hi Yeshua, hi Moshe, hi Sophia, and hi Meir,0:53and I hope you enjoy the class as well.0:56Okay,0:58the numbers in the station also I have to mention.1:00If anybody would like to call in,1:01if you have any questions regarding the holiday of Sukkot,1:04anything that has to do with the mitzvah of the holiday,1:06you could call in at1:09718-683-5858. If you're too embarrassed to call or you don't want to call,1:11you want to text in a question or a comment,1:13you could send it in at1:17347-927-8398. I'm going to repeat the numbers again.1:18To call in,1:21718-683-5858, and you could text at1:27347-927-8398. Let's continue with our class.1:29We learned the halachot from the Ben1:32Ish Chai. We're in Parashat1:33Ha'azinu. We're up to1:34halacha gimmel. The last two halachot that we mentioned last time1:36are too long to go over them right now.1:39We basically discussed the mitzvah of1:43sukkah. We discussed sitting in the sukkah a little bit.1:45We discussed also mainly the canvas sukkot1:48that are very popular and they're sold everywhere,1:50and there are very, very important halachot over there1:53that everybody must know,1:55especially if you're1:57Sefardi. And to us it's very, very important1:59that we should know the details of these halachot2:01in order that we should fulfill the mitzvah of Sukkot properly.2:04Again, the class will be on a rerun tonight.2:06You can listen to it also. On JewRadio.com online,2:12you can have on the archives,2:13you can listen to last week's class.2:15Another thing that you'll find online2:16is we have a video2:18where we show how to make the walls of sukkah kosher,2:23especially when dealing with a canvas2:24sukkah, and that's a very, very important video to watch.2:27It's more important than listening2:28than the audio that we gave last time,2:30because in the audio you don't see it.2:31Here you see it.2:33There's pictures, it's a video,2:34and we go and we explain in detail2:37all the necessary halachot for the walls of a2:40sukkah. The next halacha we're up to is2:43halacha gimmel, and that is eating on Erev2:44Chag. Tomorrow, Wednesday2:469/18, that's tomorrow,2:47tomorrow will be the holiday of Sukkot,2:51and there's a mitzvah that's learned2:54in the Gemara Masechet2:56Sukkah. The Gemara says that we make a connection,2:59a gezeirah shavah, between the holiday of Sukkot3:01and the holiday of Pesach.3:02Just like on Pesach3:03we have an obligation at night3:06to eat matzah,3:09so too we have an obligation on Sukkot3:12to eat on the first night.3:14This is an obligation.3:15This is not optional.3:16Every person must eat on the night of Sukkot3:19at least a3:20kezayit. This every person refers to men only.3:23The Gemara makes a special3:25limud to exempt women from eating on the holiday of Sukkot.3:29So all men tomorrow night3:31must eat at least a3:32kezayit, and some say even a3:33kebeitzah. We'll talk about that a little bit later on.3:35But in preparation for the mitzvah,3:37the Chachamim, the Rama brings down3:39that a person should not eat Erev3:43Chag because then he'll be full.3:44He can't eat the kezayit at night.3:46It's very hard to eat the bread3:47when you're coming with a full stomach.3:49So he says a person from the beginning of3:51chatzot should not eat,3:51and that's where the Ben Ish Chai also goes with3:53it. The Ben Ish Chai says,3:56Lo yochal b'Erev Sukkot mechatzot v'eilach. A person should not eat on the eve of the holiday of Sukkot4:01from chatzot and onwards.4:02Why?4:05Kedei sheyochal בלילה לתיאבון. In order that he should eat at night,4:09l'te'avon, with an appetite.4:12Ki achilah ba'laylah harishonah de'oraita. There's an obligation from the4:14Torah for a person to eat the bread.4:24But he says,4:24Why am I telling you chatzot?4:25Why am I telling you midday?4:27Really, Erev Pesach,4:29we tell you that you're not allowed to eat4:30only from around the4:34sha'ah asirit, and over here we're telling you4:34to stop eating from midday already?4:37And he explains,4:40because hainu ki bilel Pesach ochlim matzah achar kriat Haggadah, shehu zman harbeh. Because by the time you get to the actual matzah4:43l'Pesach, you'll be hungry anyway.4:44Trust me,4:44you're going through the4:45Haggadah and the two cups of wine,4:47so by the time you reach the achilat kezayit,4:49or kebeitzah of matzah,4:51it's going to be way too long4:53and you're going to have an appetite for it.4:54Over here,4:55now you're going in4:56and you're eating right after Seudah Kochavim,4:59so we're worried that perhaps5:00you won't have such an appetite,5:02so stop eating from chatzot.5:03What time is chatzot?5:0612:49 p.m. Tomorrow 12:49 p.m. is chatzot,5:08is midday.5:09A person should stop eating what?5:10Not everything.5:11You don't have to fast.5:12Stop eating bread.5:15You shouldn't have a meal from 12:49 and onwards.5:20That's the opinion of the5:21Ben Ish Chai who follows the opinion of the5:23Rama. However, many Acharonim disagree with the5:25Rama, and they say,5:26No, just like Pesach,5:27it's enough to stop eating by5:29sha'ah asirit, which is around5:31five o'clock, so too by5:32Sefard, you don't have to stop eating from chatzot a meal5:34with bread.5:35You could stop eating from around 55:37p.m. And that's really also the opinion of Hacham Ovadia Yosef,5:42brings in pashut, that you don't have to stop eating a meal.5:44If a person wants to have bread tomorrow,5:45you can have up5:47till five o'clock. And really,5:47all depends on the person.5:49If you know yourself5:50that you're going to have a little bit of a meal5:52and you're not going to have such an appetite to eat at night,5:54so then5:55avoid eating a meal with bread.5:57Eat something else.5:57You could eat wraps,5:58you could eat5:59mezonot, you could eat fruits,5:59you could eat rice,6:00you could eat whatever you like.6:01Just don't eat bread.6:03And if you're a6:04person that might feel very weak throughout the day6:05and you're not going to be able to come into the holiday properly,6:07you need to have a little bit of bread,6:09so fine,6:09you could eat up6:11till five o'clock. But after6:12five, according to everybody,6:13you should not have any meal with bread.6:14Why?6:15Because we want you to have an appetite at night6:16so you could fulfill the mitzvah properly.6:19And you shouldn't6:20just—not just to eat the bread,6:21but you should eat it also,6:22as we can see,6:23eat it at night.6:25You're fulfilling6:26mitzvah d'Oraita, one of the few mitzvot that we have in the Torah6:28that a person gets by eating.6:31All the other things are not6:32min haTorah; v'hi mitzvah6:34min haTorah to eat bread that night.6:36We move on now to6:39Halacha Daled. Halacha Daled talks about reciting the bracha of6:42Shehecheyanu. So how do we say the bracha of Shehecheyanu at night?6:44So this is an important6:46halacha. On Sukkot,6:47we have many, many mitzvot,6:48and the rule by6:50Shehecheyanu, we said this a few times,6:51we repeat it again:6:52whenever we have a mitzvah6:56which we fulfill only once a year,6:59so the Shehecheyanu is recited on that mitzvah.7:05If you noticed,7:06if you were in shul on Yom Kippur at night,7:08by7:09Kol Nidrei everybody said7:10Shehecheyanu. What's the Shehecheyanu on?7:11We said in last week's class,7:13Shehecheyanu doesn't have anything to do with the7:16Kol Nidrei, not because the guy is holding the Sefer Torah,7:17not because the7:19rabbi is— the Shehecheyanu is going on the holiday of Kippur.7:21On the holiday of Kippur,7:22we make7:23Shehecheyanu because we have been zocheh now7:25to fulfill the mitzvah of Yom Kippur,7:27and we do it once a year,7:28so we recite the blessing of7:31Shehecheyanu. Good?7:32So too every Kiddush,7:33every holiday,7:34when we make Kiddush on that7:36holiday, we make the bracha of7:38Shehecheyanu. What's the reason why we make7:40Shehecheyanu? Because of the holiday.7:42It comes once a year,7:43and we get to do the mitzvah now once a year,7:45so we make7:46a bracha. On Sukkot,7:47we have many mitzvot that we have to say Shehecheyanu on.7:49First of all, the holiday of Sukkot itself,7:51we have to say7:52Shehecheyanu. Number two is the mitzvah of sukkah.7:54We're fulfilling the mitzvah of sukkah for the first time7:57in the new year,7:58right?7:58It only comes once a year.8:00So too, in the daytime, we make the bracha of Shehecheyanu when we shake the lulav.8:06That's— all these things, by the way, are for the men.8:09For the women, the only time they would say Shehecheyanu is only on the holiday of Sukkot,8:14which is the melacha not to do the melacha, to observe the holiday of Sukkot,8:18they would make a bracha of8:20Shehecheyanu. Good?8:21Now, when should you say the8:23Shehecheyanu? So some women have the minhag of saying Shehecheyanu when they light the candles,8:28which is fine. But like we said by Yom Kippur,8:30you have to make sure you already accepted the holiday in order to make the bracha of8:34Shehecheyanu. You're not making the bracha on the candles.8:36You've been lighting candles your whole life.8:38This is not why you make the bracha of8:40Shehecheyanu. You make the bracha of Shehecheyanu on the holiday,8:41so make sure that you've already accepted the holiday.8:43That's number one.8:46However, if a woman doesn't have such a minhag,8:48or she's not so makpid on minhag of making Shehecheyanu by candles,8:51it's preferable that she should reserve the8:54Shehecheyanu. She should not say it8:56and wait for the man to come home,8:57and he should make the bracha of Shehecheyanu when he makes it at night in making the kiddush.9:01It's better to say Shehecheyanu there,9:02or better to be yotzei the bracha of9:05Shehecheyanu then. Now, at night,9:06when the husband is making the bracha of9:08Shehecheyanu, or the man, whoever is making the bracha of9:11Shehecheyanu, is making by kiddush,9:12this Shehecheyanu is going on two mitzvot.9:15It's going on the mitzvah of the holiday of Sukkot,9:18and it's going also on the mitzvah of sitting in the sukkah.9:22Now, why am I telling you all of this?9:25I'm just going to— he's going to ask me—9:26I'm going to follow what it says in the machzor, in the9:29siddur, and it says Shehecheyanu, I'm going to say9:31Shehecheyanu. The reason why I tell you this9:33is that even if it rains,9:36chas v'shalom— Baruch Hashem, this year it doesn't look like it's going to rain—9:38but even if it rains9:39and you're not sitting in the sukkah,9:42you're still going to make the bracha of9:44Shehecheyanu because the bracha of Shehecheyanu is going on the holiday.9:46As far as Sukkah is concerned,9:48the brachah of Shehecheyanu depends now.9:50If you made the brachah of Shehecheyanu in the sukkah,9:54so then9:55the brachah of Shehecheyanu is going also on the mitzvah of sukkah,9:57so you're covered for the mitzvah of,10:00for the mitzvah of sukkah.10:01As far as Shehecheyanu is concerned10:02for sukkah, you're covered.10:03But if you didn't make the brachah of Shehecheyanu at night,10:07so technically,10:08since the Shehecheyanu that I said in my house10:10on the Kiddush10:11is going on the holiday,10:12it's not going on the mitzvah of sukkah,10:14just like I would have to make another brachah of Shehecheyanu in the morning10:17on the10:19Arbaat HaMinim, I would have to make a brachah of Shehecheyanu also10:21on the sukkah. That's what technically would be,10:23and really that's the opinion of10:25majority of opinions; they hold this way.10:27However,10:28there are two opinions, the10:30Bach and the Levushei Srad, who say,10:32no, we don't make a brachah of10:34Shehecheyanu. If you don't make a brachah of Shehecheyanu at night10:36because it rained, since you made a brachah of Shehecheyanu on the holiday,10:38that already covers the brachah of Shehecheyanu on Sukkot.10:42And10:43although10:45it's hard to understand10:47the real kavanah of the10:49Bach, but that's what he says,10:50and the Chacham Ovadia already says,10:53safek brachot lehakel. Here you have a few opinions saying10:54you don't make a brachah of10:56Shehecheyanu, so therefore it comes out10:57that whenever a person is not eating on the first night11:01of Sukkot in the sukkah,11:02and he never really said11:04Shehecheyanu on the mitzvah of sukkah,11:06then you don't make a brachah of11:09Shehecheyanu the next day11:10on the sukkah itself.11:12Okay,11:13that is the opinion of11:15Chacham Ovadia. It's an important11:17halacha. However—11:19In order to avoid such a thing,11:21if you're able to get your hands on a brand new fruit11:24and say shehecheyanu on the fruit11:25and have in mind for the sukkah,11:27next time you sit in it.11:27Or let's say you have a brand new suit11:29which you would normally make a shehecheyanu on,11:32and now you see that it looks like11:35in the weather like you're not going to be able to eat on the first night,11:37so don't wear your brand new suit on the first night of the holiday.11:40Save it for the next time11:41you're going to sit in the sukkah for the first time,11:43and this way you make bracha of11:45shehecheyanu on the suit,11:47and that covers you also for the sukkah.11:49Another good idea if you want to avoid,11:51for sure, again, you don't make a11:53shehecheyanu if you didn't make it on the first night11:55and you didn't eat on the first night.11:57You don't make a shehecheyanu afterwards,11:59okay, because you already said shehecheyanu on the holiday.12:01But if you want to still somehow cover yourself12:03according to all opinions,12:04some have a minhag, as we're going to learn later on,12:07to follow the opinion of the Arizal,12:09who used to make the bracha of lulav12:11in his sukkah every morning.12:13So the first day of Sukkot,12:14where you're shaking the lulav for the first time,12:16you have to make12:17a shehecheyanu. So since you make it in the sukkah,12:19have in mind that's going on the sukkah.12:21Now even though the only way we fulfill the mitzvah of sukkah12:23is really by eating there,12:26but still, since technically12:27you're also supposed to sit in the sukkah,12:29so sit in the sukkah for a little bit12:31and be mechaven that you're sitting12:33and doing mitzvah, somehow you squeeze in the shehecheyanu over there.12:36But again, bottom line is,12:39if you miss shehecheyanu on the first night,12:40you don't make shehecheyanu afterwards,12:42okay? Now let's just read a little bit over here12:45in the Ben Ish Chai, in12:47Halacha Daled, the order of how a12:49person should say12:50shehecheyanu in the night of Kiddush.12:53Yekadesh acha sheyihyeh laila vadai. First of all, making Kiddush,12:55make sure you make Kiddush12:57when it's for sure night.12:59If you happen to pray earlier in your shul,13:01in your minyan,13:02when you get home,13:04wait till it's for sure gets dark,13:06and for sure gets dark,13:0735 minutes is good enough already13:08for a person to already start making Kiddush.13:14Uvleil rishon yevarech leishev basukkah, v'achar kach shehecheyanu. And on the first night...13:16You should make the13:18bracha first of13:20leshev basukah, and then13:21after Shehecheyanu. Why?13:22Like we mentioned, the Shehecheyanu on the first night13:24is going on the holiday,13:26and is going also on the mitzvah of sukkah.13:29So after you make the13:32brachat ha-kiddush, and after you make the blessing13:33also on13:36leshev basukah, then you say13:37Shehecheyanu, which is going on both mitzvot,13:39the sukkah and the holiday.13:43However, on the second night,13:46being that you already made the13:47bracha of Shehecheyanu on the first night, second night13:48we also13:51make—second night Shehecheyanu is not going on the mitzvah of sukkah,13:52because that we're covered already for it.13:54Second night it's going on the holiday.13:55Now even though we observed the13:57holiday the night before and we said13:59Shehecheyanu, but that's a rule that we mentioned many times,14:01the chachamim, since they made the second day14:03of holiday, it's an obligation14:06in order for people not to be mezalzel,14:08not to disrespect the day,14:10so they made all the laws the same.14:12Whatever you do on the first day of the holiday,14:13you do on the second day when we live outside14:16of Eretz Yisrael.14:17And therefore we make Shehecheyanu also14:19on every holiday that we have two days,14:21that we observe two days. On both days we make14:23the bracha of Shehecheyanu, and that14:25should be also the14:27din over here. We make the bracha of Shehecheyanu also on the second night14:29of Kiddush, except then14:31we would make it before the14:33bracha of leshev basukah, because already14:36leshev basukah, the mitzvah of sukkah14:37was covered with the bracha of14:39Shehecheyanu from the night before.14:40That is halacha dalet.14:43Now we move on to14:48halacha hei. The14:50bracha of14:51the mitzvah of sukkah—let's just give14:52a short introduction.14:54The mitzvah in the Torah14:56of sitting in the sukkah is written14:59as follows:15:03Basukkot teishvu shivat yamim. You have to sit in the sukkah15:05for seven days.15:07Now what does that mean? How do you observe the mitzvah15:09of sitting in the sukkah?15:11So the Gemara says,15:14Teshvu k'ein taduru. You have to sit like the way you live.15:16And many people say, What do you mean?15:17It doesn't say that over there. It doesn't say to live in15:19the sukkah. It says you have to sit.15:21Well, trust me, the Chachamim are more lenient when they explain15:23the pasuk in such a way.15:25Because if you tell me that teshvu means15:27you actually literally have to sit,15:28then that means you can never get out of the sukkah.15:31Any time you want to sit down, you have to sit in the sukkah.15:33You can't sit anywhere. You can't sit on a bench on Ocean15:35Parkway. You have to sit in the sukkah.15:37So clearly that's not the meaning of the15:40pasuk. And especially the Chachamim have a15:41tradition that's not the meaning of the15:43pasuk. The meaning of the15:44pasuk, teshvu, is like a person is meyushav b'veito, he lives.15:47You have to live in your sukkah15:49the same way you live in the house,15:51you live in the sukkah.15:53Now what does this mean?15:54What does this include?15:55This includes everything.15:57Whatever you normally do in your house,15:58that's what you have to do over here.16:00Imagine you took a trip. You went away for a week.16:04You went to visit your relatives in Israel or in Europe,16:08or you went to a different city, whatever it is, you're on vacation.16:11You have a hotel room, you have a house, you have whatever it is.16:13You're living in a new house now. You moved apartments,16:16true, only temporarily, but you moved.16:18What would you normally do in the apartment?16:20What would you normally do in the hotel room?16:21That's what your sukkah is.16:23Your sukkah is your hotel room for the next seven, eight days,16:27okay? What would you do in your hotel room?16:30That's what you do in your house.16:32Now, of course, the sukkah has more kedushah. We'll talk about that later on.16:34But as far as the idea of it, that's what you have to do.16:37That's really the mitzvah,16:41lechatchila. B'diavad, if a person cannot do all that, it's hard for him, it's not so convenient for him, so fine.16:46So then there is a minimum that the chachamim required you to do there,16:50and this is not the requirement of the16:52chachamim. This is how the chachamim understood the pasuk in the Torah,16:56and that is eating and sleeping in the sukkah,16:59okay?17:00So although everything else you could do outside the sukkah if you have to,17:06it's not lechatchila, but b'diavad you could do it.17:08Still, these two things, eating and sleeping, could only be done in the sukkah,17:12and the details we'll discuss later on.17:16So since I'm eating, since if I have to eat in the sukkah, I have to make a17:20berachah. Why?17:22Because that's how I fulfill the mitzvah of sukkah,17:24by eating in the sukkah.17:26Chachamim said that the berachah is only on eating and not on sleeping,17:30and the reason for that is because sleeping has no set thing.17:33You can sleep now, take a nap, wake up, sleep again later on.17:36You can make a berachah and then you might not fall asleep,17:38so it's not really in your control so much as eating.17:40Eating, you have the food right in front of you,17:42you make a berachah, you eat right away.17:44So therefore, when we make a berachah to fulfill the mitzvah of sukkah,17:48we make it specifically when we come to eat.17:51Now, that doesn't mean when we eat anything.17:53There's specific foods when we eat them,17:55and that will be discussed later on,17:58be'ezrat Hashem, in halachah chet. But whenever we do have to make the berachah of18:01leishev basukkah, which is usually on bread,18:03the question arises: when do you make the18:06berachah? Do you make the berachah before you say hamotzi?18:09And that means you say first,18:13Asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu leshev basukkah, and then you say the bracha of hamotzi18:16lechem min haaretz, or do you first say the bracha of hamotzi18:19lechem min haaretz and then18:21leshev basukkah? This is18:22halacha he, and this is what the Ben Ish Chai discusses in this18:24halacha. Let's read his words.18:26He says like this:18:30B'chol ayt sheyesh kiddush, yevarech leshev basukkah achar birkat kiddush. If you're making kiddush in the sukkah,18:32and therefore you're going to have a meal,18:33like we learned in Hilchot Kiddush, Ein kiddush18:37ella bimkom seudah. If you're making kiddush, you must have a seudah over there.18:39So whenever you're having a real meal with bread,18:42like on Shabbat or the holiday,18:43and you make kiddush anyway,18:46so you know when you should say18:49birkat leshev basukkah? After you make the bracha of kiddush.18:50That means, let's say this Friday night,18:52Leil Shabbat,18:54you make the bracha of18:55hagafen, and then you make the bracha of mekadesh haShabbat,19:00and then afterwards you make bracha of19:03leshev basukkah, and then you drink from your cup of wine.19:05Then afterwards you go wash,19:06you make al19:07netilat yadayim, and then you make the bracha hamotzi.19:09That's the order whenever there's kiddush.19:12However, bat shelo yesh kiddush,19:15if you're eating a meal when there is no kiddush,19:17let's say19:18seudah shlishit, or not even19:20seudah shlishit, Sunday, Monday, Tuesday this week, this holiday,19:23all these days, Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday,19:25there's no holiday,19:26it's no Shabbat,19:28it's chol hamoed, it's a regular day.19:30So now you're not making kiddush.19:32When do you make the bracha of19:34leshev basukkah? Says the Ben19:35Ish Chai, Yesh19:37nohagin levarech leshev basukkah kodem birkat hamotzi,19:38achar birkat al19:40netilat yadayim. Some make the bracha of19:41leshev basukkah in between al netilat yadayim and hamotzi.19:46Vyes nohagin levarech leshev basukkah achar birkat hamotzi,19:49kodem sheyochel. And some say, no, first you make al19:52netilat yadayim, and then you make the bracha of hamotzi,19:54and then only afterwards19:55you make the bracha of19:57leshev basukkah. So the question is, why isn't this an interruption20:00between the bracha of hamotzi20:02to the eating?20:02And the answer is,20:05Veein chashuv hefsek. You know why?20:07Davek gamil ltorech. It's not considered a hefsek. We find instances in the Gemara,20:09it's brought down in Shulchan Aruch,20:11where a person may speak20:13after making the bracha of hamotzi.20:15Okay, so this should not be any worse.20:17Since it's necessary for the meal,20:20you're making the bracha of20:21the meal that you're eating in the sukkah,20:24it's not considered a20:25hefsek. These are the two different customs.20:27The Ben Ish Chai says,20:37ואנחנו בביתנו מזמן עטית ראשנו, רבא גאון ורבי זקני רבינו משה חיים, מנהגנו לברך לשב בסוכה קודם אחד מוציא, וכן עיקר. Ben Ish Chai rules, like his custom was20:39from the time of his grandfather,20:40who was also the chief rabbi20:42back then. He says that we first make the20:44bracha of leshev basukkah and then hamotzi,20:46which means you'd wash your hands,20:48and then you make the bracha of20:51leshev basukkah, standing up,20:52and then afterwards you'd sit down,20:55and then you make the bracha of hamotzi.20:58Okay,20:58that's what the Ben Ish Chai brings over here.21:01That was his custom, and he says that's really21:03ikar, that's preferable to do.21:05And me personally, I do the same way21:07unless you have a custom. Otherwise,21:08you can do according to your custom.21:10If you don't have a custom,21:11that's the preferable way of doing it:21:13first21:15netilat yadayim, then stand up, make asher21:19kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu leshev basukkah, and then afterwards sit down,21:20make the bracha of hamotzi,21:21and enjoy your meal.21:23Im21:24shachach v'lo berach קודם האכילה, and it happens so many times, a person is eating21:26and then he remembers, Oh, you know,21:28I forgot to say21:30leshev basukkah. So then,21:32יברך כל זמן שלא סיים אכילתו. You make the21:34bracha so long as you didn't finish your meal.21:39ואם הוא מצופה בברכה לב, לא יברך. But if you're middle of your meal21:40and then you don't remember,21:41then I make the bracha of21:43leshev basukkah or not? Don't make a21:51bracha, okay? And let's say a person now, he's eating his meal21:54and he doesn't remember if he finished his21:58meal—excuse me—he doesn't remember if he said22:01brachat leshev basukkah, so then what you could do is...22:03You finished your bread,22:04you had already more than22:06kezayit or22:07kebeitzah, you can make hamotzi.22:09Go wash again22:10in order to make the bracha of22:11leshev basukkah. That's not a22:12problem because you're having a new meal now22:15in the sukkah22:16and you make the bracha of22:17leshev basukkah. Okay? So let's review very quickly.22:20The preferable way of eating,22:22of making the bracha of leshev basukkah in the sukkah22:24whenever you have to make it,22:26and we can see when you have to make it in22:28halacha hei, is as follows.22:29First, make22:31al netilat yadayim, and then afterwards walk into your sukkah.22:33Stand up,22:34make the bracha of asher22:38kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu leishev basukkah, and then afterwards sit down,22:39make the bracha hamotzi,22:41rip from the bread22:42and eat and enjoy your meal.22:44Don't forget birkat hamazon, of course, afterwards.22:46Good. That is22:48halacha hei. We move on now to halacha vav.22:51A simple22:52halacha, our kavanah when sitting down in the sukkah.22:58On the first two nights of the holiday of Sukkot,22:59for us who live outside of Israel,23:04you have to be23:06mechaven that the first night is an obligation from the Torah.23:08And like we explained beforehand, the Gemara explains23:10there's a gezeirah shavah.23:11We find the Torah used the same word23:14in two different subjects,23:16and we have a tradition that these two words,23:19the same words in two different subjects,23:21have a connection.23:21And what's that word? Bachamishah asar.23:24On the fifteenth of the seventh month,23:27which is the month of Tishrei,23:28that's the holiday of Sukkot,23:29also says on the23:31chamishah asar, on the fifteenth of the first month,23:34which is the holiday of Pesach in Nisan.23:37And over there,23:38the Gemara Masechet Sukkah23:40says there's a connection23:41between these two holidays.23:42And what is that?23:44Just like, just like on the first night23:47it says,23:49Ba'erev tochlu matzot, you must eat matzah on the first night of Pesach,23:51so too on the first night of Sukkot23:54we must eat also.23:55Not matzah, but we have to eat bread. וטוב שיפרש דבר זה בפיו כשאומר.24:03And it's good that a person, when he's coming to eat that night, tomorrow night, when he's coming to eat in the sukkah,24:10before you wash, you should mention, express with your mouth and say,24:14I'm coming to fulfill a mitzvah min haTorah of eating bread,24:18okay? And even if you didn't do it, but at least think about it, that you're fulfilling the mitzvah min haTorah on both nights,24:23because the second night of the holiday for us in America, or outside of Israel, is considered24:29sfeika d'yoma; it's exactly like the first night.24:31There's another kavanah that you're supposed to have also,24:34and that is mitzvot tzrichot kavanah.24:36You have to have kavanah24:37why we have the mitzvah of sukkah.24:39And the hachamim tell us that the reason why we have a sukkah,24:42because when we came out of Egypt, Hashem surrounded us with clouds24:48that protected us from everything you could think about.24:50First of all, to protect us from the hot weather of the desert.24:55It's very hot in the desert,24:56and here we had clouds protecting us.24:58The clouds also protected us from the sight of the25:01goyim. The goyim were not able to realize where the Jewish people were because they were covered by clouds.25:05Wherever they looked in the desert, they saw fog,25:08and they didn't know that the Jewish people were really hiding behind those clouds.25:11Also protected us from snakes and scorpions.25:14It smoothed the roads, and the roads weren't rough.25:17Imagine walking on sand barefoot your whole life.25:19It's very, very difficult.25:20So therefore, we were protected the whole time from all these things, from the ananim,25:25and therefore as a commemoration for these clouds, we make the holiday of Sukkot.25:32Some say that—we have a question over here.25:36Say, you know, on the holiday of Sukkot,25:39we commemorate the gift that Hashem gave us when we came out of Egypt,25:42and the gift is that He gave us the25:44clouds. But really, the Gemara Masechet Ta'anit says25:46that we have three gifts that we were zocheh to in the desert,25:51and in the zechut of Moshe, Aharon, and25:53Miriam. In the zechut of Moshe, the Jewish people got the man.25:56In the zechut of Miriam, the Jewish people got the be'er Miriam, which is the water25:59which tasted like anything you thought about.26:01You want it to taste like wine, it tastes like wine.26:02You want it to taste like apple juice, it tastes like apple juice.26:06Even Coca-Cola, probably, if they had it back then.26:08If you had kavanah for be'er Miriam, it would taste exactly like it.26:11And we also got the clouds in the zechut of Aharon.26:13So how come we only make a holiday in commemoration of the clouds?26:17Why don't we make a holiday in commemoration of the other two things,26:21the man and also the26:25be'er Miriam? Many, many different answers are brought to this.26:28If you look in the Bnei Yissaschar, I think he brings like seven answers, eight answers.26:32A lot of them come from the26:34Chida. One short, quick answer, and that is26:37that the basar and the yayin that we eat on the26:40holiday—there's a mitzvah that in the Torah,26:42it's a mitzvah de'oraita called26:44v'samachta b'chagecha. You have to be happy.26:45How are you happy?26:47The Gemara says, each person, each to his own.26:50The ladies, you make them happy by giving them nice dresses,26:52buying them something nice, new jewelry for the holiday.26:55That's how you make them happy.26:56The children are happy by giving them candies and sweets.26:59That's what makes them happy.27:00The men are happy by having good food, meat, and wine.27:04Those two things are specified.27:06Even though that's really talking about the time when we had a Beit HaMikdash27:09and the korban shelamim that we brought,27:10that's the basar that we're talking about,27:12still we find that there's simcha, ein simcha27:15ela basar v'yayin, with meat and wine.27:16So the Chida says the meat that we eat on the holiday27:19is in commemoration of the man,27:20and the wine that we drink is in commemoration of the27:24be'er Miriam. And in the sukkah, we have all the three gifts together.27:26In any case, as far as halacha, practical halacha is concerned,27:30you must have27:32kavanah whenever you're sitting in the sukkah27:33that I'm fulfilling the mitzvah of27:34sukkah, zecher la'Ananei kavod, Hashem surrounded us with,27:38and because also according to the other opinion,27:39Hashem also put us in huts in the sukkah,27:43in the desert27:44He gave us huts and living places,27:50and that's why we have the holiday of27:51Sukkot. Okay?27:52Now, when you're eating27:54tomorrow night, when you're eating the bread,27:57like we said, this bread that you're eating is equal,28:00is equivalent to eating the matzah.28:01It's a mitzvah from the28:02Torah. So therefore, you got to make sure28:04the bread itself should not have any issues with it.28:09Number one is make sure that the bread is not an egg challah.28:13Make sure it's a water challah.28:15If you buy28:16challot, if you have egg challot and water28:17challah, make sure you only get water28:18challah. Make sure it has no juices at all.28:20This way it's brachav hamotzi according to all opinions.28:24This is not the time to talk about it.28:25Egg chalot, to make hamotzi on it,28:27is not such a simple thing.28:28We usually rely on certain opinions of28:30making—some people make hamotzi on egg chalot on Shabbat.28:33Okay, there's what to rely on.28:35However, on the holiday of Sukkot,28:37it's a28:39mezuman haTorah. Make sure you get water challah28:40or regular rye bread,28:41whatever it is, bread that you eat.28:43It shouldn't have any additives of eggs28:45or sweets, pure bread.28:47Number two is,28:49the bread should be eaten preferably,28:50the kezayit, within four minutes,28:52and you should not eat it with anything.28:55Don't dip it in tahina or hummus28:57or whatever it is, baba ghanoush,29:00or any dip that you like to eat it with.29:02Eat it plain, just like that.29:04That's the preferable way of eating the bread,29:06just like you eat the sukkah.29:07You don't dip your sukkah in dips.29:10You don't dip it in tahina or hummus.29:11So too, you shouldn't dip your bread29:14or whatever you're eating tomorrow night29:16in anything. Eat it like that.29:18So if it's hard to swallow it that way,29:20so have a great idea:29:22warm it up.29:23Buy fresh bread.29:24Don't buy last week's bread29:25and freeze it29:25and then expect it to taste so good.29:28Buy fresh bread tomorrow.29:29Go to the bakery.29:30Make sure you get something fresh.29:32Put it on the stove,29:33warm it up,29:34put it in the oven before the holiday,29:36and then you come on the holiday,29:37it's fresh and hot.29:38You won't need anything with it.29:39It'll just come down very, very easily,29:41and this way29:42you fulfill the29:43mitzvah b'te'avon; you fulfill it properly.29:44And also, like we said beforehand,29:46don't stuff yourself.29:47The other thing you got to keep in mind29:48is that you have a certain time limit29:50to eat the29:51kezayit. Preferably,29:52you should finish the29:53kezayit within four minutes.29:55If you cannot,29:57then you finish it up to seven and a half minutes,29:59that's fine,29:59but no more than that.30:00That's pushing it30:01already. Seven and a half minutes is pushing it.30:02Make sure30:03up to seven and a half minutes maximum30:05to finish your30:06kezayit. And like the Ben Ish Chai says over here,30:08even a30:08kebeitzah. A lot of people are30:10machmir; they should have a30:11kebeitzah. According to the Ben Ish Chai, he says,30:12l'kulei alma, everybody holds30:13you have to have a30:14kebeitzah. What is a30:15kebeitzah? What is that equal?30:17Well,30:17each30:18kezayit is 28.8 grams.30:21So30:22kebeitzah, we'll be just double that,30:23and that will be30:2458 grams about.30:26So about 60 grams30:27if you're able to eat them30:28in the sukkah.30:29And actually,30:30since you make30:31the30:33bracha of leshev basukkah, and we're going to learn soon30:34in30:36halacha chet, that in order to make30:37the30:38bracha of leshev basukkah, you must have30:40more than a30:41kebeitzah. So that means30:42you must have at least 60 grams30:44of bread in the sukkah.30:45But30:46as far as the30:49restrictions of eating it30:50within a time limit30:51without any30:52diffs, that applies at least to the30:54kezayit and not to the30:55kebeitzah, okay?30:56Another thing that's brought down30:57in the Rama also,30:58not mentioned over here30:58in the31:00Mishnah Berurah, and that is31:00try to eat it before chatzot.31:02Most of the time31:03you won't have an issue31:04with such a thing.31:04It's not like Leil Pesach,31:05by the time you eat the matzah31:06so late.31:07You're eating anyway31:08at chatzot,31:08like we said,31:09it's31:1012:49. By that time already31:11you'll be sleeping in your bed.31:12But still,31:13in case something delays,31:15make sure,31:15or you're waiting for a certain person31:17or whatever it is,31:18make sure you finish your31:21kezayit before the midnight time,31:23which is chatzot,31:24just like we do31:25with Pesach,31:26okay?31:28Halacha zayin. Move on to one more31:29halacha before we take a little bit of a break.31:32And31:33halacha zayin is very simple.31:33I'm not going to bother reading it31:34so much from inside,31:36but basically31:37the Zohar says31:37that on the holiday of Sukkot,31:39we have special guests that come in.31:41Who are these guests?31:42These are31:44a sample of the neshamot,31:45a part of the31:47neshama—I won't say sample,31:48take that31:49out—a part of the soul31:51of the following seven31:52great tzaddikim31:53that lived in our history:31:55Abraham,31:56Yitzchak, Yaakov,31:58Moshe,31:58Aharon, Yosef.32:00Yosef and David HaMelech. Yes, it's not just a nice idea. It's not something that we tell the kids. It's kipshuto, the Zohar says.32:09You have a part of their souls that enter every sukkah,32:13and therefore we have to know the kedushah. We're going to speak about the kedushah later on of the sukkah, but we have these seven guests with us,32:18and it's brought down that a person has to invite them. They come as guests,32:23and just like any guest, if you don't tell them,32:24Chavod, come in,32:26they won't come in. So too, you have to invite the guests before you come in.32:29And if you open up almost all32:33machzorim, almost all machzorim, and some benchers also,32:35Birkat Hamazon, you see in the front where the holiday of Sukkot is,32:38you see a whole thing to say,32:40Leshem yichud, and a special way to invite the Ushpizin in the sukkah.32:44Those take about maybe three minutes to read.32:48If you read very quickly, you could do it in a minute and a half.32:50It's very, very good to say those things,32:52even if you don't have the siddur or you don't have the time to do it.32:55At least invite them with any words.32:57Say, Bruchim haba'im, they should come in.33:00Come in, Abraham,33:02Yitzchak, Yaakov, we invite you to our sukkah.33:03And each day there's one special guest of honor,33:07and it goes in order exactly like we said it.33:08Abraham is the first day.33:10Second day is Yitzchak. Third day is33:12Yaakov. Fourth day is Moshe. Fifth day is Aharon.33:15Sixth is33:16Yosef HaTzadik, and finally on the last day it's David HaMelech.33:18That's the day of Hoshana33:20Rabbah. So a person should take the time out at night,33:22only once,33:24right before you begin the mitzvah of eating at night,33:26invite the appropriate guest for that day33:28with all the other Ushpizin into the sukkah.33:31Another thing the Mechaber mentions in this33:33halacha, and that is33:35hamavdil. He says whoever is making havdalah motzaei Shabbat,33:38make it in the sukkah,33:39preferably make it in the sukkah.33:41Why? Like we mentioned beforehand.33:42So this way you could have the,33:46what do you call it,33:47you could have33:51these... Just like you do in the house,33:53same thing that you do in the house.33:54Since you make a brachat sukkah in your house,33:56so too you should do33:58the34:00brachat habdalah in your sukkah, because remember,34:02the sukkah takes over your house34:05on the holiday of Sukkot.34:10Okay.34:13Now we're going to take a little bit of a break.34:15Let me just give the numbers again.34:16If anybody wants to call in with a question34:18or text in any question on the holiday34:20before we come back, you can send it in34:22and we'll answer it right after the break.34:24And the numbers are34:30718-683-5858. That's to call into the station.34:32To text,34:38347-927-8398. Okay, and Be'ezrat Hashem we'll answer34:39right after we come back from this break. B'shosh melech haMashiach bo, oy oy oy.42:36Okay, we're back to our halacha class. Again, the numbers in the studio are42:42768-35858. The text is 347-927-8398, 97.5 FM and jrootradio.com. Okay, we're up to the next halacha, halacha42:51chet. This halacha is a very important halacha. If you've been spacing out till now, you42:56have to listen to this halacha. And this halacha tells us which foods we actually make the43:01bracha of l'shev basukkah. Okay, we already gave the introduction. We already said that really43:05we're supposed, besukkot teishvu kein taduru, and you're supposed to really live in your sukkah and do almost everything that you do in your house,43:12do it in the sukkah, almost everything. But the minimum is eating and sleeping, but the43:17berachah only goes on eating. Now, which foods require us to say the bracha of43:21l'shev basukkah, and which foods are we not allowed to say the bracha of l'shev basukkah? Let's see the halacha43:26inside the Ben Ish Chai, and we'll explain as we go along. First of all,43:30lo yeh barech l'shev basukkah ela bifat gamur. You're only allowed to make a bracha of43:35l'shev basukkah when you're eating regular bread, and it has to be 100% bread.43:39Aval pat haba'ah b'kisnin shebirchato mezonot, lo yeh barech l'shev basukkah mishum43:44safek berachot lehakel. However, if you're eating anything that's mezonot, cakes, cookies, whatever it is, all these things,43:50if you're eating from them, you don't make a bracha of43:56l'shev basukkah. Although, we're going to see soon, Ben Ish Chai doesn't bring it, we'll see. Although there's an obligation to eat in the sukkah44:06above the kebeitzah of mezonot, but still, you're not allowed to make the bracha of44:13l'shev basukkah. So again, in order to eat in the sukkah, the obligation of eating in sukkah is only when you have44:18more than a kebeitzah of bread or mezonot. You must eat them in the sukkah.44:22Less than that, if a person wants to be lenient, you could eat it inside the house or outside the sukkah.44:27You don't have to eat it necessarily in the sukkah.44:30But once you're eating above a kebeitzah of mezonot or bread, then you have to eat in the sukkah.44:35However, as far as the berachah is concerned, you only make a berachah on bread.44:40You don't make a berachah on more than a kebeitzah of mezonot.44:44This is true only if your mezonot is your meal.44:49If your mezonot is your meal, and what does it mean your meal?44:51It means that you're having so much of it to the point that you're making hamotzi on it,44:56which is about, let's say, 250 grams about.45:03So in that case, or not even that,45:07Chacham Ovadia is even more lenient, 173 grams of mezonot—we're talking about cakes and45:12things—in that case you'd make bracha leishev basukkah as well on the mezonot,45:19okay? Uvchol עת שיברך לישב בסוכה, and any time a person45:22is making bracha leishev basukkah, you have to have the following in mind,45:24and that is,45:28יכוון לפטור בברכה זו ישיבה וטוב ואכילה טוב ושינה טוב. In the bracha leishev basukkah, you should have in mind,45:31although I'm making on the food, but it's covering everything that I do in the sukkah:45:35sleeping in the sukkah, sitting, relaxing, whatever I do in45:38the sukkah, the bracha leishev basukkah covers all of it.45:41Like we said, since the only thing that's in your control and you can do it is eating,45:48so that's when we require you to make the45:51bracha. But everything else is a mitzvah; just don't make a bracha on it.45:54So in this one bracha, you have in mind that covers you until the next time you eat bread.46:03ואף על פי דמן הדין מותר לאכול אכילת עראי חוץ לסוכה. Even though, according to halacha, if a person wants to eat outside the sukkah46:10things that are not bread or46:13mezonot, he's allowed to eat outside the sukkah as much as he wants.46:15He wants to eat fruits, rice—even though rice is mezonot, it's not one of the five grains.46:20So when we say mezonot, we mean anything in which the bracha acharona will be46:24al hamichya, that excludes rice, even though the bracha rishona is46:28mezonot, okay? Even though it's mutar to eat outside46:30the sukkah,46:35מכל מקום מחמיר שלא לשתות אפילו מים חוץ לסוכה, תבוא עליו ברכה. If a person is machmir not to even drink outside the sukkah,46:39then he should get a blessing.46:42He's getting a bracha. Minhag is giving you a bracha. You are careful that you even drink, only your drink is inside the sukkah,46:49you get a special bracha from the Ben Ish Chai and all the other poskim that says to46:53say a bracha. However, when it comes to sleeping, then over here it's much, much more stringent than eating.47:05Sleeping, afilu shenat arai, even a nap, not a full sleep, just a regular dozing off,47:12asur lishon chutz lasukkah. You're not allowed to sleep outside the sukkah.47:15So, in summary, you have two things which you have to do in the sukkah:47:20eating and sleeping.47:23In both eating and sleeping, there's what the halacha calls keva, a set thing,47:28and what the halacha calls arai, something temporary, it's not something set.47:32In eating, when a person is having his set meal, he's not snacking,47:36it's his regular meal, that's called achilat keva.47:39And achilat arai is like a snack.47:43Those things are not dependent on how a person eats it,47:46but it depends on what he's eating.47:48As far as us, the Sefardim, it depends on what the person is eating.47:53In order for it to be considered achilat keva, which obligates you to eat in sukkah,47:57it has to be above the size...48:00Of a kebeitzah. Kebeitzah translates in our days around between 50 to 60 grams.48:07So if you're eating, let's say, 55 grams and above, then you have to eat it in the sukkah.48:12And you only make a berachah if you're eating more than 55 grams of bread in the sukkah.48:19But if it's mezonot, you will not make a berachah on lesheb basukkah, but you still have to eat in the sukkah.48:24Now, mezonot doesn't only apply to cakes; it also applies to cooked mezonot as well,48:30like noodles, pasta, lasagna, all these things.48:34Even though it's dough that's cooked, that's what noodles are, pasta, right?48:36It's regular dough that you cook.48:39And normally, as much, we say that as much noodles or pasta that you have, you'll never make hamotzi on it.48:46Still, if a person is having so much of an amount of, let's say he's having for dinner pasta,48:52and he's having more than 180 grams of noodles, then he has to eat it inside the sukkah and make a berachah on it.49:02Even if he's having more than 55 grams of noodles, he has to eat in the sukkah, but without a49:07berachah. But if he's having so much, then as much as 178 and above, you'd have to make a berachah of lesheb basukkah in the sukkah as well.49:15That's your meal, and that's the amount that you're having.49:18Make sure you make a berachah inside the sukkah.49:21Everything else, achilat arai is considered49:24achilat arai. Fruits, rice, those are considered snacks.49:28Even though your rice you're eating it for dinner,49:30if you're having a whole dinner of rice and chicken and potatoes, and you're drinking all these things,49:36and that's your dinner, you're going to be more full than if you'd eat a sandwich.49:39It doesn't make a difference.49:40That's considered49:42achilat arai. You could eat it outside the sukkah,49:43but a person who's machmir to eat it even inside the sukkah, taavo alav berachah. You get a blessing from all the great holy rabbis,49:52okay? The other thing that you're required to do in the sukkah, and that's sleeping.49:56So over there, it's not as lenient.49:59Sleeping, even a nap, has to be in the sukkah.50:04The Gemara says even sheinat arai, that's a50:07halacha. Even a small little nap has to be.50:08Now, what's called a small little nap50:09that you're allowed to nap, less than that outside?50:11So the Mishnah Berurah brings down, based on what we learned in earlier simanim50:19in Orach Chaim, it comes out to about 54 seconds.50:21If a person is sleeping for 54 seconds even, it has to be done in the sukkah.50:26But if he's sleeping for less than 54 seconds, I don't know how you could do such a thing,50:31but let's say that's sheinat hasus.50:33If he's sleeping for less than that, then you could sleep technically outside the sukkah,50:37because that's not even50:39sheinat arai. And obviously this is very, very far from practical, to sleep less than that amount.50:45But still and all, sleeping is much more obligated than the regular thing.50:50And although there are a lot of people who are very lenient in the mitzvah of sleeping,50:54we have to know, sleeping in sukkah is not any less than eating in sukkah.50:58Just like a person has to eat in sukkah, he has to sleep in the sukkah.51:01And there's no such a thing, it's not our minhag, it's not our way, it's not our custom, we never did it.51:05Okay, so now you learned the halacha, now you have to do it.51:08Up till now you didn't know the halacha, or you thought there was a way out,51:10and there's really no way out.51:12Let me just bring something very interesting.51:14Although this is not so agreed upon, but he says if a person sees his friend,51:25he says, You see your friend napping in the middle of the shul,51:27you have to wake him up and tell him to go inside the51:30sukkah. The Acharonim disagree with this.51:33Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach says he doesn't understand the Ben51:39Ish Chai. He says, I don't understand. The guy fell asleep, and since he fell asleep51:44already, a person sleeping is not chayav in any51:47mitzvot, so what are you waking him up now at the time that51:50you're chayav? That's number one.51:51Number two is, they also bring down the whole concept of sleeping and living in the sukkah51:57is because51:59teshvu k'ein taduru. We mentioned beforehand, you live in the sukkah like you live in your house,52:03and nobody refrains himself from napping in the shul or sleeping in the middle of learning.52:10Nobody will stop and say, Oh, let me go to my house and take a nap52:14because I'm a little bit tired.52:15Right? People put their head down a little bit.52:17So that's what you do throughout the whole year.52:20So why over here should it be any different?52:21If a person fell asleep in the middle of shul, of Kriat HaTorah, whatever it is,52:25why should it be any different from throughout the year?52:27Throughout the year also he falls asleep in the middle of shul.52:29Why over here is he obligated to go back to the sukkah?52:32And therefore, the Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach disagrees,52:38and poskim bring it's a good idea if you could maybe wake him up and to tell him,52:42but otherwise technically it doesn't have to.52:44On the same note, since the mitzvah of sleeping in the sukkah52:49is because of teshvu k'ein taduru and52:51you have to live in the sukkah like you live in your house,52:53they also bring down that if a person is sleeping in the car,52:56hopefully not driving, I really hope so.52:58Let's say he's sleeping, he's in the passenger seat and he falls asleep.53:02It's okay, he could take a nap in the car,53:04because throughout the year he'll also sleep in the car.53:06He doesn't stop himself from sleeping in the car53:09because he's going to get home and sleep.53:11Of course, you get a much nicer sleep in the house,53:14but if a person naps a little bit in the car, even on Sukkot,53:16it is not an obligation to refrain himself till he gets home.53:21Why?53:23Teshvu k'ein taduru. Now, like we mentioned, people have difficulty of trying to keep this halacha of sleeping in the sukkah.53:29You have to know it's a53:31mitzvat aseh d'Oraita. To sleep in the sukkah is an obligation,53:34just like putting on tefillin,53:35just like shaking53:37lulav and etrog, just like fulfilling the mitzvah of tzitzit,53:39and like all the other mitzvot.53:41You have to sleep in the sukkah just like you have to sleep.53:44Just like you have to put on tefillin.53:45So therefore, if once upon a53:48time, when it was very, very difficult for a person to get hold of a beged, of a cloth in order to make a tzitzit,53:54and it was very difficult to get a pair of tefillin,53:56and many people went throughout their lives53:59maybe fulfilling the mitzvah of tefillin only once in a while,54:02or mitzvah of tzitzit, right?54:04Difficult to get the money for it.54:05Baruch Hashem, today in our days, now we could do it,54:08and everybody jumps on doing it, Baruch Hashem.54:11It's a54:12mitzvat aseh. Sleeping in the sukkah is a54:14mitzvat aseh. If a person doesn't want to fulfill the54:16mitzvat aseh, okay, what can I54:17do? We can't force you.54:18We could try to force you54:19and have a beit din to force you,54:20but the idea is you have to know it's a54:22mitzvat aseh. If you're not on the level yet,54:24don't push it away and say,54:26Oh, it's not our minhag, it's not our way.54:27No, no, it's our way.54:29It's a mitzvah54:30min haTorah. Our way is to follow the mitzvot.54:31Our way is to follow the Shulchan Aruch.54:33And therefore, when the time comes,54:35understand that, you know what,54:36I'm not ready for it yet.54:37I'm still54:38chozer b'tshuvah. When the time comes, be'ezrat Hashem,54:40I'm going to come and sleep in the sukkah,54:42and maybe start sleeping a little bit54:44till you get to the level of fulfilling the54:48halacha k'tikunah. But nobody should just fool himself and say,54:50Oh, you know, it's not our way.54:52It is our way.54:53It's the halacha, it's Shulchan Aruch,54:54it's mitzvah54:55min haTorah. It's a din of the Gemara that nobody disagrees on.55:01Halacha tet. Conduct in the sukkah.55:02The Ben Ish Chai talks in this55:03halacha how a person should treat himself in the sukkah.55:05Like we mentioned,55:06because the sukkah is such a holy place,55:10therefore, even though you live in it55:12like you normally live in your house,55:14but still, unlike your house,55:16your house maybe has a kedushah55:18as much as you make it kadosh,55:20whatever, if you learn inside the house,55:21you have sefarim in the house,55:23you don't have that box55:24with things coming in into the house,55:26whatever you call it, internet TV.55:29In any case, when it comes to the mitzvah of sukkah.55:32It's kadosh,55:33and therefore55:34even things that you normally have in your house,55:35you cannot put it in the sukkah.55:36For example,55:40you cannot bring into your sukkah pots,55:44things that you cook inside of it.55:46Think about it like this:55:47what would you do55:48when you have a Shabbat table,55:51you have guests coming over?55:52Would you bring your pot to the dining room table55:55and serve from it?55:56Of course not.55:57You'd serve the food in a serving bowl in the kitchen.56:00And then you bring it. That's how it's discussed, got to be.56:02Pots, things that you don't normally bring to your table,56:06that's what you got to do also in the sukkah.56:08In fact, poskim bring down if you bring serving dishes to your table,56:13then it disqualifies the sukkah so long as they're there.56:16Not serving dishes, excuse me,56:18the cooking dishes.56:19If you bring cooking dishes, pots and things to your sukkah,56:22it disqualifies the sukkah so long as you're there.56:24So make sure you don't bring it to the sukkah.56:27You also, when you finish with your plates,56:30you have to take them out.56:31Cups, it's okay to keep them there even if you're done,56:33but the plates, once you're done,56:34there's no use for them anymore.56:36You should take them out of the sukkah.56:38Any tashmish that's bazui, that's not respectful to the sukkah,56:41should not be done in the sukkah.56:43Smoking is mutar in the sukkah.56:44You normally smoke in your house, you can smoke also in the sukkah.56:48Also, other things,56:49a person to be with his wife in the sukkah also is mutar.56:52Of course, it has to be kept within the area of56:57tzeniut, and that's the usual law.56:59You cannot go to the bathroom, obviously, in your sukkah.57:02You have to go upstairs in the house,57:05and you'll figure it out pretty much57:06what we would normally do in your living room, dining room.57:09That's how it's got to be.57:10You got to keep in mind57:11the sukkah is not just because the sheva Ushpizin are there.57:13You have the seven guests,57:14Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, and the rest are there.57:16You also have the Shechinah in your presence over there.57:18It's even brought down by57:20mekubalim. A person should even try to avoid having a goy in his sukkah.57:24A goy should not enter the Jewish sukkah.57:26That's what's brought down.57:26Now, it's not57:27halacha, but a person could try to keep it fulfilled.57:29I know of great rabbis, now very careful that57:32they'll clean up the57:33sukkah. They won't have the maid cleaning up the sukkah.57:35Why?57:36Because it's a very holy place,57:38and a goy should not enter in such a holy place.57:39It's brought down in the Zohar as well57:41that a goy should not walk into the sukkah.57:43Not again, not57:45a halacha, but just to show you how holy the sukkah is,57:50and kal vachomer other things. Next,57:51Halacha yud deals with things,57:54decorations that are placed in the sukkah,57:56and we don't have time really to read every single part of it,57:59but we'll just tell you outside.58:01Things that you hung up in the sukkah for decorations58:06become58:07muktzeh, and you cannot take it down on Shabbat and Yom Tov.58:10If things are hanging, you cannot take it down.58:12Even if they fell, they're considered58:14muktzeh. And let's say you hung up fresh fruits or even dried fruits,58:17things that you can necessarily use,58:19and you didn't make a condition,58:20then those fruits you cannot reap benefit from them58:23until the end of the holiday of Sukkot.58:25That's Halacha yud in short.58:27We'll go to Halacha yud58:30aleph. Halacha yud aleph is important,58:32and a lot of times we may skip this,58:35but just like there's an obligation for men to sit in the sukkah,58:40min haTorah, there's an obligation miderabanan for us to train our children to sit in the sukkah.58:43At what age is a child obligated,58:45or the father is obligated to train this child?58:48So it depends.58:52Katan harif mitachlat hamesh shanim chayav b'aviv lechancho b'mitzvat sukkah. Once he's already five years old,58:54if he understands the concept of sukkah,58:56then his father has to train him to sit in the sukkah.58:59Ve'eino harif, and if he's not so sharp,59:01mitachlat shesh shanim. By six years old.59:02That means any child from six and above,59:04already a person has to train them to sit in the sukkah.59:06What does it mean to train them in the sukkah?59:08The two mitzvot, like we mentioned,59:10are only eating and sleeping.59:13All the other things that are59:16humrot, even though it's good,59:17you don't have to train your child in59:19humrot. Medin, you have to train him what the din of sukkah is:59:20eating and sleeping.59:23Now you're going to tell me,59:24hold on a second,59:25I don't see any child sleeping in the sukkah.59:27We don't see people really bringing their children in the sukkah.59:30This doesn't mean that sleeping is not an obligation.59:32Sleeping is still an obligation,59:33but there's reasons why59:35maybe people don't let their children sleep in the sukkah.59:37Number one is,59:38sometimes it gets cold at night,59:40and without you realizing it,59:41the beginning of the night might start a little bit warm59:43and then gets very cold,59:44and children catch a cold much faster.59:46Their bodies are less immune,59:49so therefore59:51the children, they allow them to sleep inside.59:53That could be one reason.59:54There could be other reasons59:56why children might be59:58patur, not because children don't have to sleep;1:00:00they should sleep1:00:00just like they have to eat in the sukkah,1:00:03medin chinuch. But it's not done for other practical reasons.1:00:06Perhaps the child might need his parents,1:00:09or he needs his mother,1:00:11or the bathroom, whatever it is,1:00:12so that's why they don't let them stay in the sukkah.1:00:16That's the reason.1:00:17But otherwise, really,1:00:19children that age,1:00:20under age of bar mitzvah,1:00:21but in the age of1:00:23chinuch, are obligated to sit in the sukkah1:00:32miderabanan. Hanashim, af al pi d'min hadin peturot mishum d'sukkah mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama, im chozrot yeshvu b'sukkah, yeish lahen sechar mitzvah. Even though women are exempt from the mitzvah of sukkah,1:00:36still and all,1:00:37if a woman decides to sit in the1:00:38sukkah, she has a reward.1:00:40Namely, let's say the wife is home by herself,1:00:42nobody's home,1:00:43and she wants to have her meal in the sukkah.1:00:44She has nothing,1:00:45you know, she wants to sit in the sukkah.1:00:46Yes, it's preferable that she sits in the sukkah,1:00:48even though she's not obligated.1:00:50But like any mitzvat aseh1:00:53shehazman gerama, that women are1:00:54patur, but if they do it,1:00:55they get reward.1:00:55However, it's very important1:00:56they should not make a1:00:59berachah. Now, Ashkenazim do make a1:01:01berachah on mitzvat aseh1:01:03shehazman gerama, like lulav. You'll see a lot of1:01:05Ashkenazi women making1:01:06berachot, but you won't see them making berachah on sukkah.1:01:09And it's very interesting,1:01:10how come? Why not?1:01:11If you hold that you could make1:01:12berachah on mitzvat aseh1:01:13shehazman gerama, how come over here you do not?1:01:15That's an interesting1:01:17he'arah from the Ashkenazim.1:01:18In any case,1:01:19we move on now to1:01:21halachah yud-bet, which is the last1:01:24halachah in the1:01:25Ben Ish Chai dealing with Sukkot.1:01:26The next three halachot after1:01:29yud-bet discuss the halachot of the Arba1:01:31Minim, which we hope to cover also in this 15 minutes.1:01:34Let's begin.1:01:35Choleh. This halachah talks about1:01:36who's exempt from sitting in the sukkah.1:01:39Up to now, we should have learned by now1:01:41any man above the age of bar mitzvah1:01:44is obligated min haTorah to sit in the sukkah.1:01:47Any child boy above the age of six1:01:50is obligated1:01:51miderabanan to be trained to sit in the sukkah.1:01:54The following is a list of people1:01:55who are exempt from sitting in the sukkah.1:01:57Number one is1:01:59choleh. A person who is not feeling well,1:02:01choleh doesn't mean he's in the hospital.1:02:02Choleh doesn't mean he's in1:02:05sakanah. Choleh means,1:02:10afilu chash b'rosho or chash b'einav, patur, im yesho menuchah chutz lasukkah. Even if a person has a headache,1:02:12or even his eyes are bothering him,1:02:14he has sinuses,1:02:16anything in which he'll feel better1:02:18by walking away from the sukkah1:02:20will exempt him from being in the sukkah.1:02:23V'im ein hefsek haya, but if he has a headache1:02:25and he's going to have a headache in the sukkah1:02:27as much as he has it in the house,1:02:29so he's not patur from the sukkah1:02:30because he's not going to be1:02:32relieved by going into the house.1:02:34So that's why1:02:35choleh who's patur from the sukkah1:02:37is only one in which the sukkah1:02:39is causing the sickness1:02:42or his pain.1:02:44It doesn't have to be like we said,1:02:45sick in bed,1:02:45but even if it gives him a headache,1:02:47that's good enough to exempt him1:02:49from the sukkah.1:02:50But this is all true1:02:52throughout the halachot of Sukkot.1:02:55On the first night,1:02:56that's an obligation.1:02:58Like we said, it's like a matzah.1:02:59Every person has an1:03:00obligation to eat in the sukkah on the first night.1:03:05V'hamitzta'er, another person who is exempt from the sukkah,1:03:07a person1:03:12who's mitzta'er, mipnei hariach or yetushim, v'kיotzeh patur min hasukkah. A person1:03:13also, there's a smell outside.1:03:16Something happened outside.1:03:18They're digging up,1:03:18the city is digging up right outside your house,1:03:21and where your sukkah is,1:03:22or there's a bad smell,1:03:23the garbage truck is passing by,1:03:25and there's a stench coming into the sukkah.1:03:28If you walk into your house,1:03:29you won't smell it.1:03:29Inside the sukkah you'll smell it.1:03:31So in that case you'll be patur also.1:03:33Or let's say there's bees1:03:34and mosquitoes and things.1:03:35You don't have to sit there and get bit.1:03:38You don't have to, because you're1:03:39mitzta'er. If you'll be1:03:40protected from all these mosquitoes and things,1:03:42then you'll be1:03:43patur. This is again,1:03:47mi hu? Tzarich sheyihye lo tzaar sheyutzedek bnei adam mitztaarim bo. You have to be1:03:50mitzta'er. You have to be in pain1:03:51the amount that1:03:53average people are mitzta'er with it.1:03:57But if you're very finicky,1:03:58you're a person who is...1:04:00Every little thing bothers you, you will not be exempt.1:04:03You have to look at an average people,1:04:05how much it would bother them.1:04:07That's how much also would bother the person1:04:08over here. That's how also, in this case,1:04:10it will help the person to be exempt from the sukkah,1:04:12again, if he's going to be protected by leaving the sukkah.1:04:16Another thing that the Ben Ish Chai doesn't touch over here,1:04:18and that is sleeping,1:04:19and that is rain.1:04:20I guess in Baghdad, in the Middle East,1:04:23it doesn't rain.1:04:24It doesn't rain in the summer.1:04:25There's no such thing as rain in the summer or in these seasons.1:04:27So if it rains, it's only very, very, very rare.1:04:30So he doesn't even discuss the concept of rain.1:04:31But really, in America, where it rains a lot,1:04:34we have to know when we are patur from the rain or not.1:04:38If it rains and you're eating in the sukkah,1:04:42you have no heter to leave the sukkah1:04:44until it rains so much inside of your sukkah1:04:49that even the lightest food,1:04:52that any dish of food could get ruined from the rain,1:04:55okay, from the drops of rain.1:04:56So the halacha talks about a dish of beans.1:05:01I don't know what would that translate in our days,1:05:03but if you have any dish where water would come on it, it1:05:06would ruin it,1:05:06that's how much water would have to fall into your1:05:09sukkah in order for a person to be patur from the sukkah.1:05:11But let's say you have a thicker1:05:14schach, or it's drizzling1:05:15and there's little drops coming in,1:05:16but it's not enough to ruin the food,1:05:18then you still obligate to sit in the sukkah.1:05:21Also, another point:1:05:22even if it looks very, very cloudy1:05:24and it looks like a big storm is1:05:25coming, you can hear the thunderstorms,1:05:27a person is not exempt until it actually rains.1:05:30You don't have to start eating if you don't want.1:05:32If you think it's going to rain soon,1:05:33you could wait from eating,1:05:35and then afterwards go inside once it rains.1:05:38But you're not exempt from the sukkah1:05:40until it actually rains inside of your1:05:42sukkah to the point that it's going to spoil a food,1:05:45any type of food,1:05:46and then you're exempt1:05:47and you can walk into the sukkah,1:05:48even if you don't have that type of food in front of you, by the way.1:05:51Once that amount could spoil,1:05:52let's say this dish of beans that the Gemara talks about,1:05:55you know how it takes, let's say,1:05:58a certain amount to spoil it,1:06:00and you don't have that dish in front of you,1:06:01it doesn't make a difference.1:06:02Since that amount would spoil it,1:06:05then you could go inside of your house1:06:07and you have to stay in the sukkah.1:06:09But again, it has to rain inside.1:06:11That's as far as eating.1:06:13But if you're sleeping in the sukkah,1:06:15Then it's a little bit more lenient.1:06:18Drops of rain, any drops of rain,1:06:19since that disturbs you in the sukkah,1:06:22then you would be patur from the1:06:23sukkah again for falls in.1:06:25But like we mentioned before,1:06:26if you have a thicker1:06:29schach, you could be patur from the sukkah1:06:30and maybe you will be1:06:32chayav. Since in his sukkah,1:06:34drops of rain are coming in;1:06:35in your sukkah, barely any drops are coming in.1:06:37So therefore, you are only patur once it rains1:06:41and it disturbs your sleep,1:06:43and that's any sort of rain,1:06:44or if you're eating1:06:46and it could spoil any dish of food.1:06:48Not in general, are patur from the sukkah.1:06:51Another explanation,1:06:53another cases where the poskim bring down1:06:56where a person would be patur from the sukkah:1:06:59if it's way too hot.1:07:01We're not talking about hot, just,1:07:03oh, a little uncomfortable.1:07:03Sometimes if you get the AC on Shabbat1:07:06and you're in your house,1:07:07so okay, you're a little bit uncomfortable.1:07:10You don't leave your house for that.1:07:11You just say, Oh, it's so hot in here.1:07:12I can't believe you. Keep on blaming your wife.1:07:14I can't believe you forgot to put on the AC,1:07:16the air condition.1:07:17But otherwise, you don't leave your house.1:07:19The rule is like this.1:07:20I'll tell you a story.1:07:20When I first got married,1:07:22so you should know,1:07:23my landlord is very wonderful.1:07:25He's one of the best landlords I've heard about even.1:07:28He's really fantastic.1:07:29So they painted our house for us1:07:30before we got in.1:07:31So whoever painted the house1:07:33also painted over the heater,1:07:37and therefore the heat wasn't reaching from the basement,1:07:40or the first floor wasn't reaching to our apartment1:07:42all the way on the top floor.1:07:43Now, we didn't know this at the time1:07:45that it was because of the paint,1:07:46but it was already November1:07:48and the house was getting cold,1:07:51and they're blasting the AC from the first floor,1:07:53and it's not reaching all the way to the top.1:07:55I didn't move out of my house.1:07:56You know what I did?1:07:57I bought an electric heater.1:07:58But then after a while,1:07:59I couldn't bear it anymore.1:08:01I can't carry the electric heater with me1:08:02every room I sit in the house.1:08:04At that point, I felt it was too much,1:08:06and the cold got too much,1:08:07and I left the house,1:08:09and I moved into my parents' house1:08:10till the problem was fixed.1:08:11Baruch Hashem, it was fixed a week later.1:08:13Now this is the rule1:08:15when it comes to sukkah.1:08:17If this was your house,1:08:18if it gets cold1:08:19or if it gets too hot,1:08:21would you leave your house?1:08:22Would you1:08:23go to your in-laws' house?1:08:24Would you move into your neighbor's house?1:08:27If yes, you would move,1:08:28so you're right, you're patur from the sukkah.1:08:30If you wouldn't move,1:08:31then it's the same thing.1:08:35Teshvu k'ein taduru. You're exempt1:08:36because it's not your normal living conditions.1:08:39That's the general rule1:08:40when it comes to walking out of the sukkah.1:08:43I'll give you another few examples.1:08:46Let's say you're sitting in the sukkah1:08:48and you have your light on a timer,1:08:51or for whatever reason1:08:53it's at night1:08:54and the lights shut off.1:08:55Now you cannot see a thing.1:08:56It's very, very dark.1:08:58You cannot eat.1:08:59You literally can't see anything.1:09:01You have no1:09:01streetlight, nothing is shining.1:09:02You cannot see anything.1:09:04Also, you're patur from the sukkah.1:09:06Why?1:09:08Now obviously we're talking about1:09:09patur means patur even from eating bread in the sukkah,1:09:12because if this was your house,1:09:13you would not be able to eat in your house.1:09:18You'd move away to a different room1:09:19which has light,1:09:20and the same will apply over here.1:09:21But if it's in your house,1:09:23you know, such a thing happens,1:09:24you'd still be able to eat1:09:25with a little bit of light that's around,1:09:27then in your sukkah1:09:28it should be the same deal.1:09:30Another example that's brought down in the1:09:32poskim, Shlomo Zalman Orbach, in the name of Shlomo Zalman Orbach,1:09:35and that is1:09:36if you have guests in your sukkah1:09:38and you want to go to sleep,1:09:39and you can't sleep1:09:40because the guests are there1:09:41and you can't ask them to leave.1:09:42You know, let's say it's an afternoon nap,1:09:44you want to take an afternoon nap,1:09:46and your in-laws are there.1:09:47So you're going to tell your1:09:48father-in-law, Get out of my thing? You know,1:09:49he supported you the first couple of years of your marriage.1:09:51Now you're going to tell him,1:09:52Please get out of my sukkah,1:09:54and you're embarrassed to do that,1:09:55and you don't want to go in your pajamas1:09:57or even in your suit1:09:58to sleep in front of them.1:09:59So in such a case,1:10:01also it would exempt you.1:10:02But that's again1:10:03if there's no way out of it.1:10:04Again, it would be the same thing.1:10:05If it's in your house,1:10:06let's say you have your family over your house,1:10:08you have guests in your house,1:10:09and you can't take a nap over there,1:10:10you would go over to, let's say, next door1:10:13or to a friend down the block1:10:14and take a nap over there,1:10:15that would be the same thing in the sukkah.1:10:18Another exemption for people in the sukkah1:10:20is in the case where1:10:22men— Has to help his wife in the middle of the night1:10:25to get up and to feed the kids1:10:27or to help the kids.1:10:28If you're a person who usually gets up in the night1:10:30and helps his wife,1:10:33and your wife needs your help in the night1:10:34for the kids, you1:10:35know, when the kids wake up1:10:36and you're the one who gets up,1:10:37then you're also exempt.1:10:39Okay, but again,1:10:39it has to be something that you normally do.1:10:41You can't just sleep in the house1:10:42and then the kids wake up,1:10:44tell your wife, Okay,1:10:44get up,1:10:46kids are crying,1:10:47okay? And if that's your normal way of doing it,1:10:48so you're not exempt from the sukkah,1:10:53because1:10:54normally here you would not do this in your house,1:10:56and all of a sudden now you decide to help,1:10:58it doesn't work that way.1:10:59Okay, up till now1:11:00we discussed halachot of sukkot.1:11:03Now, for the last few halachot1:11:05in the last few minutes,1:11:06we're going to talk about the halachot of Arba1:11:08Minim. As far as1:11:09the kashrut, how to buy the lulav1:11:12and etrog, we made two videos up till now.1:11:14One is how to check1:11:16an etrog, how to look for whatever,1:11:18what you need to look for in1:11:20an etrog. Number two is1:11:22what to look for in the lulav,1:11:23how to buy a lulav.1:11:25Both these videos need editing.1:11:26It might be online,1:11:28check1:11:30jewishradio.com, and you'll see over there1:11:31it needs editing,1:11:32but otherwise it'll be clear.1:11:33If you don't care so much about the fanciness1:11:36and everything should be perfectly nice,1:11:38so then you'll watch it1:11:39and it'll be very, very helpful.1:11:41We recommend that you watch these videos1:11:43before you buy your Arba1:11:45Minim, if you want to know what to look for1:11:46when you're buying your lulav1:11:48and etrog. In these halachot,1:11:49we're only going to talk about1:11:50how to fulfill the mitzvah of the Arba1:11:54Minim. And1:11:55be'ezrat Hashem, we're also going to make a special class in video1:11:57to show how to1:11:58fulfill. But let's begin with the time that we have.1:12:00Halacha Yud Gimel. The had to make the bracha on lulav.1:12:03Yevarech hanitilat lulav shehayanu1:12:06קודם שיטול האתרוג. The first day, you're going to make two berachot on the arba1:12:09minim. You're going to hold, first of all, your lulav, which should have with it the hadasim and aravot tied up already.1:12:18You should hold it in your right hand.1:12:20Make the bracha of1:12:23אשר קידשנו במצוותיו וציוונו על נטילת לולב, then make a bracha of1:12:28שהחיינו וקיימנו והגיענו לזמן הזה, and then afterwards pick up the1:12:30etrog. Why? Because if you pick up the lulav and the etrog in a normal way, then you fulfilled the1:12:36mitzvah, so how can you make the bracha afterwards?1:12:39So even though you're still involved in the mitzvah, you could still make a1:12:43beracha, because like candle lighting when it comes to1:12:48Chanukah. Chanukah, let's say it's the sixth night, and you're lighting the1:12:52candles, and you forgot to make a beracha, and you're up to candle number three, and you remember you didn't make a1:12:55beracha. The halacha says that you could still make a beracha since you're in the middle, you're still involved in the lighting.1:12:59So too over here, if you're holding the lulav and1:13:01etrog, even though you're not supposed to hold it because you're supposed to make the bracha עובר לעשייתן, before you pick them up,1:13:06if you held them up already and you didn't shake the lulav yet,1:13:10by us shaking the lulav, the Sefardim means we move it in all the different directions, we move around.1:13:15If you have not completed the moving of the lulav in all the directions, you could still make a1:13:19beracha. But lechatchila, you're supposed to make it beforehand.1:13:22The Gra says the best advice is a person should have in mind,1:13:25and the rabbis, whoever is in shul, if there's no rabbi or whoever makes the announcements in shul should make the announcement,1:13:30Rabotai, before you make the bracha on lulav, have in mind1:13:33that you don't want to be yotzei the mitzvah of lulav and etrog until you make the1:13:37bracha. So this way, even if there's some people who are not so learned and they hold the etrog in the right way,1:13:41they would still not be considered yotzei with the mitzvah until they make the1:13:49beracha. Okay, another thing you have to know as far as the first day is1:13:53that when you hold the lulav and etrog, the lulav, the thick part which we call the shidra, should be facing you.1:14:00The hadassim, if you do according to pshat, according to the Shlah, the hadassim should be on the right1:14:05and the aravot on the left,1:14:07unless you tie it in the special way according to the Arizal,1:14:09and the etrog should be in your left hand1:14:12and the lulav with the bundle of hadassim and aravah in your right hand.1:14:17Okay, another thing also, you're not—we're not allowed to eat before the mezonot lulav.1:14:22So let's say you don't have lulav and etrog this year,1:14:24and you went to shul and you prayed, but you didn't do the mezonot lulav and1:14:28etrog, you are not allowed to eat until you make a bracha of lulav and1:14:36etrog. Halacha yud dalet. Afilu holech, also when you make the bracha of arbaat haminim, you have to do it standing up.1:14:40Nothing should be on your hands, you shouldn't wear any gloves.1:14:43It should be just no chatzitza between you and the lulav.1:14:45Even a person who is sick should try to stand up just to make the1:14:54bracha. Also, when you walk around, we do hakafot on Sukkot.1:14:58We walk around basically the teivah and shul, the men walk around the teivah and shul.1:15:01When you walk around the teivah and shul, you have to hold the lulav in your right hand1:15:06and the etrog in your left hand.1:15:07Even though it's very hard to do it, and some people, they hold the siddur in one hand1:15:10and lulav and etrog in one hand.1:15:13According to a few opinions, your Chut HaYim, Mateh Yehuda, a person who's holding the etrog and lulav in the same hand,1:15:20he's not1:15:22yotzei yedei chovato. So make sure that you're holding the lulav in the right hand and the etrog in the left hand.1:15:26Even those who matirim, but still, you don't want to be not yotzei according to some opinions,1:15:32so therefore hold the lulav in the right hand and the etrog in the left hand,1:15:37and the siddur should be on your arms when you walk around to say the1:15:40hoshanot, and all you have to do is walk around the teivah one time.1:15:44Okay, it doesn't have to be. You have to run around the teivah 700 times.1:15:46Just walk around one time, and usually it'll be much faster and easier if you wait till everybody walks around1:15:52and then you go around. It'll take you much faster. It'll be easier to do in such a way.1:15:58Another thing a person has to know: when you hold the Lulav1:16:02and Etrog, they have to be facing up, and try to—the bottom of the etrog should be together with the bottom of the Lulav.1:16:10The last halacha for today:1:16:17Hakafot b'Lulav b'chol Yomot HaChag yuchal l'hakif et teivat beit knesset, af al pi she'ein al hesech Torah. Even though we put a Sefer Torah on the bimah when we walk around,1:16:21you could technically do the hakafot even without a Sefer Torah. Ein hachat Sefer Torah1:16:26ela l'atemah me'akevet ba'hakafot. Walking around the teivah is not me'akev; you don't have to necessarily have the Sefer Torah.1:16:30Of course, it's much better.1:16:34Ki hakol lefi hasovev zehu hateivah. Al pi Kabbalah, the main thing when you do the hakafot on Sukkot is that you should walk around the1:16:42teivah. Let's say some people can't make it to shul.1:16:44Let's say a person is away on a trip, he has no minyan. He has his arbaat haminim, but he doesn't have a teivah to walk around.1:16:50So Meirchai says, you know what you could do?1:16:56Menichim kiseh echad min habayit, makifim oto, vezeh nechshav teivah. Because then, by walking around the chair, that doesn't do so much.1:16:59Meirchai says, you know what you could do?1:17:04Yaniach kiseh b'veito, v'yaniach alav Sefer Tanach v'yakif. Put a chair or put a table, a coffee table, put on top of it a Tanach and walk around it,1:17:11k'dei shelo batel mitzvat hakafah, v'Hashem yitbarach b'rachamav lo yimna tov laholchim tamim. And Hashem will accept it. You know, we do it just because we have no other option.1:17:19It doesn't necessarily work, but just that we shouldn't forget the mitzvah hakafah,1:17:23so we put a Sefer Tanach, Torah, Chumash, or something, we put on top of the— The coffee table,1:17:32and this way we walk around it1:17:34one time, just not to forget the mitzvah of hakafot. That's if a person cannot make it to Minyan.1:17:38Otherwise, a person should make his greatest effort to go to Minyan and to go around the1:17:43teיבה, and preferably they should have a Sefer Torah. Even without a Sefer Torah, it would still work.1:17:47There are different customs when it comes to making hakafot on Shabbat, and everybody should follow1:17:51his customs. In any case, since we don't have lulav and etrog, we don't walk around.1:17:55Even those who say the hoshanot on Yom Shabbat, they don't walk around.1:17:59And with this, we'll finish. We wish you a Chag Sameach, a real Chag Sameach,1:18:04because there's a mitzvah of simchat b'chagecha, especially in the holiday of Sukkot.1:18:09And we just want to tell you that next week, be'ezrat Hashem, we're going to do the last parashah1:18:15in Sefer Bamidbar, Parashat Vezot HaBerachah, and we're going to have the class again on Tuesday1:18:21instead of Wednesday, our regular time. We're going to have it on Tuesday,1:18:23and the repeat, the rerun, will be on Tuesday night at 101:18:28o'clock. Until then, Chag kasher v'sameach.