Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of SukkotBen Ish Hai – HolidaysRabbi Uri Nahum · September 17, 2014−15Play+30Position0:0057:23Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome back to JRoot Radio.0:03This is the Halacha Hour on Wednesday afternoons at 2 to 30:07p.m. We are here live today, and if you hear this tonight,0:11then you know that you're not hearing it live. This show, the Halacha Hour, will be0:16repeated on again tonight at 110:19o'clock. And let's give you the regular introductions before we get to today's0:23class. The regular introductions are the numbers to the station. If you'd like to0:26call in,0:26if you have a question in Halacha, the number to call in live is0:34718-683-5858. Some of us maybe have forgotten the number. We're going to repeat it again:0:42718-683-5858. To text in your question or comment,0:44you can text it in to0:50347-927-8398. Again,0:54347-927-8398. These are the numbers to contact0:56us in the station. And like we say every week, if you'd like to ask a question1:00offline, as soon as we finish the class, we'll be staying around for a few extra1:04minutes,1:05so we'll repeat the number later on by the end of the class1:08if anybody would like to call in with any question. The ways to listen to us,1:13you can listen to us on1:17JRootRadio.com. That's if you have internet. And if you have also the Pro app, that's really the1:22best way. It's like basically a live radio going with you all the time,1:26and you can download it. It's the JRoot Radio Pro app.1:30Also, we are on the1:33website. We're on video live, so if you want to watch us live,1:38okay, the advantage of that, I'm not sure exactly, but1:41you can watch us also at1:45JRootRadio.com. Okay, let's get to the class. This is the Halacha Hour. Usually we would do1:48the halachot from... The book, The1:52Bein Ish Chai. However, being that we are in the season of the holidays, we're in Elul,1:57we're exactly a week away from Rosh Hashanah.2:00Next week, Wednesday night will be Rosh Hashanah. And until now,2:04we have covered the main halachot of Rosh Hashanah. If you haven't heard it, you should go to the2:09jradio.com website, and you'll see over there the archives from last week and the week2:13beforehand.2:14Two weeks ago, in the beginning of the Chodesh of the month of Elul, we spoke2:18about the halachot of Erev Rosh Hashanah, as well as the2:21minhagim and some of the dinim of on Rosh Hashanah. Last week,2:26we spoke about all the halachot that one needs to know regarding shofar.2:31It was actually a very, very recommended class.2:34If you want to know what is shofar, and as far as the halachot are, and every2:38detail that you need to know2:39if you're baal tokea, even if you're not baal tokea, chovah if you're2:43baal tokea, you should go listen to that class. And today, we should continue about the2:47halachot of Rosh Hashanah, but2:48because we have much to2:51cover, so therefore we're going to take a little bit of a break from the halachot of Rosh Hashanah,2:55yamim noraim. We will speak, be'ezrat Hashem, today about the3:00halachot of Sukkot. Yes, I know it's a little bit early for Sukkot,3:03so we're going to discuss halachot that are relevant now for Sukkot:3:07buying the sukkah, setting up the sukkah. I already saw people already put up their3:12sukkot, and it's never too early. I mean, it is a little bit sometimes too early, but I mean to3:16say this is the season anyway,3:17so we need to cover, and we're not going to have time, just the week between3:21Yom Kippur and the holiday of Sukkot, so we'll talk about it today.3:25But today will only be part one. Part two will take place3:30in the week of Sukkot, and although we usually are here together on Wednesday3:35afternoons,3:36next week, because Wednesday afternoon is going to be Erev Rosh Hashanah,3:39the class will be pushed over to Tuesday3:42at two o'clock. So next week, again, will be Tuesday, two o'clock. Next week,3:46be'ezrat Hashem, we hope3:48to finish up the halachot of Rosh Hashanah that are relevant just3:50for Rosh Hashanah itself, like Yom Tov Sheni and whatever we have left over,3:54and we'll see exactly how to go about and to finish up with Sukkot.3:58Okay, let's get to the class today. Oh, dedication.4:02Today's class is dedicated in4:06honor of a special person, and that is none other than4:10Rav Nissim Lazari, him and the whole JRoot Radio staff,4:14Iran, as well as David Levine, and every single person, every rav,4:19every person that's involved with the JRoot Radio. You should know,4:23yizkeh harabim, and it's an honor to be part of this group, and everybody who is listening4:27will nod their heads and say, Yes, JRoot Radio, we miss it very much. Everybody's always4:31asking me,4:32JRoot, we want to hear it, we want to hear it. We have the numbers. We're able to4:35hear it, Baruch Hashem. So therefore, we want to dedicate this to4:40their great work and unending efforts.4:43What we will discuss in today's4:47class—not today's class, but the halachot for Sukkot, they might seem simple. You4:51sit in the sukkah, it's over.4:53There's a lot of technicalities. They're harder4:57because you need to see it lemaaseh. I could sit there and describe to you5:01something that might take me many, many hours to explain, where in a video I could5:05show it to you5:06in about 15 to 20 minutes. And therefore, we recommend very, very highly5:10that you watch some of the videos that we have regarding the halachot of Sukkot.5:14Really, every single detail of the halachot almost needs a video,5:18and to really explain it without a video... is a little bit of a disservice, but what5:22could we do?5:23Even though I am on live, I know that we're being5:26videoed right now, but still I don't have a sukkah in front of me to show you. I don't5:31have a lulav and5:32etrog to show you exactly what to look for when buying a lulav and etrog. So therefore,5:36we have some videos on the JRadio.com website.5:39The video is how to build the walls of a sukkah. That's one video. The other video5:44is how to buy5:46an etrog. It's not such a greatly filmed,5:49but the information is very, very important and very5:52applicable and relative. So therefore, you should watch it. Bezrat Hashem, we hope to, in5:56the future,5:57come up with all the videos and hopefully, with the help of Iran and6:01BSD Productions, we'll have them also professionally made. The holiday6:05of Sukkot is a seven-day holiday,6:08with the eighth day being Shemini Atzeret.6:12And here in America, or chutz la'aretz, anywhere outside of6:16Eretz Yisrael, we celebrate the holiday an additional day.6:19That's called a sfeika d'yoma, which makes the holiday of Shemini Atzeret6:22a two-day holiday, ending off with the final day of6:26Simchat Torah. And therefore, there are many, many6:29halachot regarding this whole major holiday that comes right in the middle of6:34Tishrei and6:35towards the end of the month. Number one is all the laws regarding sukkah:6:38how to build it, where to set it up, what's the mitzvah of sitting in the sukkah,6:42and everything. Pretty much that's going to be the main chunk of our6:45halachot. The second part of the halachot also takes up about maybe twenty6:49simanim in Shulchan Aruch,6:50is the halachot, or the laws of lulav, etrog, and the6:54Arba Minim. This is almost impossible to do on6:58video—I mean, excuse me, to do on audio without a video.7:01So therefore, we again recommend that you should go and look7:05to buy some of the books that either... Show you7:08pictures how to exactly look for lulav and etrog. Go to a rabbi that's knowledgeable to show you7:13what to look for.7:14You could also look on the website as far as etrog,7:17lulav. We have it unedited yet. I don't know if we're going to be able to put it out this year or not,7:21but look out for these videos to show you, to guide you how to buy the7:26arba minim. The other mitzvot that are in this holiday, we have a total of seven7:30mitzvot in this holiday. The other mitzvot, the halachot that we need to know about,7:34is a mitzvah that's overlooked a lot, but it's a7:38mitzvah mideoraita, and that is the mitzvah of v'samachta b'chagecha, being happy during the holiday.7:42This includes Simchat Beit HaShoeva. It's not much halachot to talk about, but it's still a mitzvah there.7:48The other halachot also, or the mitzvah, is the mitzvah of Hallel, although7:53derabanan, but it's a mitzvah to say Hallel7:55with a beracha fully throughout the whole holiday of Sukkot. Then you have—8:00Of the halachot of Rosh Hashanah Rabba. Hoshana Rabba, Chazal tell us, is the final day8:05which we could do something about our gezar din, our decree that's going to be decreed on Rosh Hashanah.8:11Anything, if it's possible to be changed, then the last chance that we have is Hoshana8:18Rabba. When the next day comes, which is Shemini Atzeret—it's already too late. Shemini Atzeret already,8:23the Zohar tells us, the HaKadosh Baruch Hu gives the decrees to the angels in order for them to go8:27and execute what it says on the paper. Oh, you tell me, teshuvah, teshuvah, you can do teshuvah all the time.8:34True, but these are the days that are made for teshuvah. It makes it much easier.8:39Later on to do teshuvah, later on it's much, much harder. It's kind of like, I'll give you a mashal.8:43You know, when there's a store going out of business, they have a major sale, clearance.8:47You have to, you know, everything is 50% off, must sell, must move. You got to buy everything now.8:52The prices that you'll find are very, very hard to find again because the store is going out of business.8:56Now, is it impossible? Would you be able to find something maybe used or like semi-used, and you'll9:02be able to get it for very cheap? True, but after much search, and you have to go wait online,9:07and who knows who's going to get it before you. There's probably a very limited9:11amount of things are available, and it's not so easy. Likewise, teshuvah in this season that9:18we're in right now, in the days of Elul and all the way up to Hoshana Rabba, is much easier.9:23The earlier, the better. But later on in the year, it becomes much more difficult.9:28So therefore, there's also halachot of Shemini Atzeret, the holiday of Shemini Atzeret, as well9:34as Simchat Torah, and that's a lot of halachot over there, Simchat Torah, what to do and what to look9:39out for. So therefore, we have a lot, and let's get to it right away, b'ezrat Hashem. We'll begin.9:45With the halachot of Sukkah. Now, if you go on the archives, you listen last year, we also9:52gave the halachot of Sukkah. This class is going to be different from last year's class in the following. Last year it was based on the9:56Ben Ish Chai, because we're trying to also, besides our regular halacha class, we're trying to make10:00the Ben Ish Chai more accessible to everybody, really. Anybody who would like to learn from10:05the Ben Ish Chai would have over here a tutorial. You'll have the classes which go through each10:10halacha in the Ben Ish Chai, and it brings in all the poskim of our days and the practicality,10:16where it's practical, where it's not practical, where it's Kabbalah, where you skip or not.10:18Today's class is a class that's not really connected to the Ben10:23Ish Chai. Obviously, we'll bring whatever the Ben Ish Chai has an opinion, we'll bring it in.10:26But today's class is to focus specifically on the halachot of Sukkah and what to look out for.10:31And we'll begin, first of all, with the most relevant halacha in this time of the year,10:38or this time of the, of this, you know, where we are right now of the year,10:42and that is buying a Sukkah. Buying a Sukkah is not going to happen so easily10:47between Yom Kippur and Sukkot. If you want to get a good Sukkah, you want to know10:52to look for a Sukkah properly, you have to do your preparations from now: to learn the halachot,10:56to learn what to look for, and to go buy it now before it gets too busy and then you get11:01whatever is left over. So, rabotai, we know this happens every single year. And every single year,11:07there's always going to be people, besides there's going to be another 10,000 people11:10who are rushing right before the holiday of Sukkot to buy lulav and etrog and to buy a11:14Sukkah. So get a head start. Go and look for them right now. And don't tell me, How can I think11:20it's a simchah? And it is. When you learn about halachot Sukkot, you get this natural happiness.11:26It's still that simchah is what will carry over into the days of Aseret11:30Yemei Teshuvah and Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, u'vivazat Hashem, a zechut also that we should be written.11:34So a good year that Hashem sees us, how we're involved in His mitzvot and we're running after11:38His mitzvot, and Chazal tell us, shloshim yom lifnei haChag dorshin hilchot haChag. Thirty days before the holiday comes, we must begin already to learn11:46about the holiday, to understand about the holiday. So that's what we're doing right now.11:49We're in the thirty days before the holiday, and we're learning about the holiday of Sukkot.11:54When buying a Sukkah, what are you looking for? Well, a Sukkah is basically made up of walls.12:00And niskach. So that's what we're going to discuss. Let's begin with the walls.12:03The best thing when you walk into a store, you're looking for a sukkah. Of course, you12:08know it's got to be affordable to you. It's got to be worth your money. But we're talking about a guy12:11who could afford it and everything. And even if you can't afford it, you can figure out how to12:15make it cheap. Best thing that you want to buy for the walls of a sukkah is any wall that is solid,12:23that is not flimsy. It's a very solid wall. A few examples. For example, if you want to use12:29wooden walls, wooden panels, okay, they sell wooden panels sukkah, or you could go to the12:36Home Depot or any of those stores and make your own walls. You know the measurements. You could tell them. You could buy12:41plywood and tell them how to cut it. So the best walls to have is a solid wall, like a wooden wall.12:46Or if you want to buy them ready, they have fiberglass walls. And of course, if you want to12:52use the walls of your backyard, that's also mutar. It's not a problem. Walls can be made out of anything.12:56The best is to have something that's solid, that wouldn't move when the regular wind13:04blows it, okay? That is the first thing you're looking for. However, most people have sukkot already.13:12They have a sukkah ready, and a lot of them have the, what do you call it,13:17the easy sukkah, I think it's called, easy sukkah, or basically, you build it a very easy13:24way. So these sukkot are made out of, the walls are made out of fabric. Now, fabric walls are not so pashut. It's not13:32so simple, fabric walls. You don't want to get fabric walls lechatchila. I'll tell you why. What are the13:38issues with it? Now, if you have fabric walls sukkah, pay attention now. Maybe you'll13:44fit into this category, maybe not. Let's begin in the following way, okay? A wall. In13:51halacha, may not match what you would call a wall in reality, okay? It means that if I'm looking at a14:01wall, you tell me right now, is this a wall? I'll tell you yes. If you tell me, look at this14:06according to halacha, it may be a wall, but according to you it might not be a wall. I'll give you a very,14:09very simple example. There's a din called levud. What is levud? Levud is a din, is a law that Moshe14:16Rabbeinu, when coming down from Sinai, he told it to the Jewish people. It's one of those oral laws,14:21Torah shebaal peh, that halacha l'Moshe miSinai teaches us that anytime I have two items, two14:31physical objects, that are within the distance of three tefachim to each other, then that constitutes a levud, that creates a spiritual wall, and that wall will qualify for14:40whenever I need a halachic wall. That's a very strange thing, which means I could look at a wall14:48and see nothing more than a bunch of sticks that are about 20 centimeters away from each other,14:55and I could, you know, for sure throw things in between it, and according to halacha that will be15:01considered a 100% halachic wall. Where if I would take a sheet of fabric, let's say, if I take a15:09tablecloth or I take the bed sheets and I go and I nail them in and I put them up, it may not qualify as15:17a wall. What do you mean? And you ask most people, this looks more like a wall than the sticks15:22standing next to each other. So we have to establish something from the beginning. These15:26halachot, just like sukkah, who told you to make a sukkah? Who said that the sukkah has to be the15:30way it is? The Torah, halacha l'Moshe miSinai. Likewise, when it comes, if you want to know now15:35the definition of a wall of a sukkah, or a wall in general according to halacha, you have to go15:39with the definition of the halacha, not what you think is a wall. So therefore, just because you15:46bought a sukkah, and listen, I don't know, the guy in the sukkah store, the guy who was selling it,15:51he told me it's a kosher sukkah. It has a kippah, it has a beard. It doesn't go by what the guy is15:55wearing; it goes by what the halacha says. Is a fabric wall considered a wall?16:00So according to halacha, I'm not saying it's not. I'm not saying it is either.16:04First, try to understand it. Let's talk halacha.16:08Shulchan Aruch. Obviously, this is coming from halachot.16:11Shulchan Aruch brings the following case.16:14Shulchan Aruch talks about building a sukkah where the walls are made out of the branches of the tree.16:20I'm not talking about the s'chach. We're just talking about the walls right now,16:23not talking about the roof, okay?16:26So if I'm building a sukkah and I want to make the walls made out of the branches of a tree,16:32can I do so or not? Says Shulchan Aruch,16:34listen to the words. It's very important.16:35I usually don't like to quote, you know, these books inside.16:39I figure you'll trust me, but in this case you have to see it because there's a16:44diyuk. We have to emphasize on the words of Shulchan Aruch.16:46We'll be able to learn much of the halachot.16:48Says Shulchan Aruch,16:53If a person makes a sukkah between the trees,16:57meaning to say that the trees are serving as a wall for it,17:06then, if they were very strong, or shekashar otam v'chizek otam, or even if they were not strong,17:09but you tied them to strengthen them,17:11how tight do they have to be?17:21Ad shelo tehei haruach metzuyah menidah otam tamid, until that a common wind, a regular wind—not a windy day, a regular day,17:23depends where you live,17:24depends the area of the world that you live17:26in—but if you have a regular wind blowing,17:29it will not constantly move them.17:31U'meleben ha'avinim—obviously now if you're making trees as a wall, they can have gaps in between.17:35So he says,17:39U'meleben bein ha'avinim b'teben u'vekash k'dei shelo tanido otam haruach, and you also filled up the gaps with different types of material17:44that a common wind will not move17:48them. Very good.17:50This is a kosher wall.17:52This is how he explains the trees.17:54Now, the emphasis is the next point.17:56Listen to what Shulchan Aruch writes afterwards.18:05He says, Al ken ein nachon la'asot kol ha-mechitzot mi-yeri'ot shel pishtan belo kanim. It is not proper for a person to make all of the walls of a sukkah18:11from linen. Pishtan is linen or flax, from linen material.18:18It shouldn't be made out of shades of linen18:22without any sticks attached to them.18:26Even though you might have tied them very, very well,18:33sometimes they, whatever you tied them with, rips apart,18:37and a person, or comes apart,18:39and a person doesn't even realize it.18:41And in such a case where what you tied has been untied,18:48havei le-mechitzah she-eina yecholah la'amod bifnei ruach metzuyah. It makes it a mechitzah that cannot be able to stand in a common wind.18:54Okay, so therefore Shulchan Aruch is telling you it's no good, right?18:59Look how he concludes his words.19:04Veharotzeh la'asot, dinim tov sheyerok bimechitzot ha-kanim perachot mishloshah. If you want to use this kind of19:07material, you want to use fabric for your walls,19:10then what he says, what you should do is you should sew them on to sticks19:15and align the sticks within three tefachim to each other.19:18What we learn from this Shulchan Aruch is19:20that anything that the wind moves is a problem.19:25And then he gives a suggestion. He says19:28it's not a good idea to make your walls out of fabric.19:31Pishtan is linen, right? That's fabric.19:33So he says you shouldn't make your walls out of19:35fabric. Even if you tie them, it's no good.19:38Let's analyze the words of Shulchan Aruch one statement at a time.19:42The first thing he says is that you cannot have the wind— Blowing them.19:48What kind of wind are we talking about,19:50rabotai? There's a very important thing to keep in mind.19:52The wind that we're discussing over here is a common wind,19:56not a stormy wind.19:57Because if you're dealing with a wind that's not common,20:01that comes whenever there's a storm,20:03then there's no end to it.20:05There's some winds that are able to destroy houses,20:08can pick up a whole house and completely destroy it,20:10pick up buildings and destroy them.20:12Are you going to tell me now that the walls of a house are not solid?20:16We live in a house.20:18It's not going to be any worse than the walls of a sukkah.20:21So obviously that's not the kind of walls that we're talking about, that kind of wind that we're talking about.20:25We're talking about a wind that's a common wind,20:27a regular wind. You walk outside and you see the wind and you feel the wind.20:30It's a very light wind, and that's it.20:32Good?20:32So that is the first thing to keep in mind.20:35We're talking about a regular common wind.20:37It says cannot move.20:39What's called moving?20:41So here we have three different opinions.20:43According to the Chazon Ish, what Maran Shulchan Aruch writes,20:45that the wind cannot move them,20:47he explains that that can move a little bit.20:51In fact, he says that they can even move up to three20:56tefachim. You know what that is, three20:57tefachim? That's up to like 24 centimeters.20:59If they're able to move up to 24 centimeters, that's fine,21:03even though if the wind is blowing it,21:05as long as it's not moving more than three tefachim, it's fine.21:09That's the opinion of the21:10Chazon Ish, which according to him, if I would take a fabric,21:13well, the ones, you know, that they sell, the sukkot that we're talking about till now,21:17the ones that they sell in the stores with the material that's made out of fabric,21:21and I make my walls of the sukkah out of this fabric,21:24according to the Chazon Ish, it's not going to move three21:27tefachim. We know that's reality.21:28According to the Chazon Ish, it's fine.21:29Let it move. Big deal if it's moving.21:31It's not moving three21:33tefachim. That's the opinion of21:35the Chazon Ish. Rav Moshe Feinstein. It's not as mekil as the21:40Chazon Ish. Most poskim says,21:41no, no, it doesn't mean it's moving21:43through. He says that it moves a little bit,21:45but it's not completely out of21:47there. I think he says about a21:48tefach. If it moves around21:51a tefach, that's not called moving.21:52That's not a big deal,21:52to move around21:53a tefach. That means within, if the walls move back and forth from the wind21:58within a21:58tefach, where the tefach is about eight centimeters,22:00that's what Shulchan Aruch means.22:01It's not a big deal.22:02However, Hacham Ovadia is very, very stringent.22:05Hacham Ovadia zatzal brings many22:08Acharonim, including the Mishneh Halachot,22:10the Ungvar Rav, the halichot22:14Shlomo, Rav Shlomo Zalman Orbach, and he explains22:15moving is a problem22:17even kol shehu,22:18even a little bit.22:19And many Acharonim, by the way,22:21go with Hacham22:23Ovadia, because Maran says,22:24shelo tiraa, hametzia, menida otam.22:26He doesn't explain how much.22:27If he wanted to tell me22:29a tefach, up to a22:30tefach, or up to three22:30tefachim, he should have said it.22:31But since Maran disqualified a moving wall,22:35so we have to say22:36even the wall moves a little bit22:38is going to be a problem.22:39So therefore, according to Hacham22:40Ovadia, if I have a sukkah22:42where the walls are made out of material,22:45it's going to be a problem,22:46because the wind is certainly moving it a little bit.22:49That means only moving a centimeter22:50too. Who cares?22:51The walls of a regular sukkah,22:53of a wooden paneled sukkah,22:55or the walls of your house,22:56don't move even a little bit.22:57Can you imagine that?22:59Our walls in the house moved?23:00So therefore, says Hacham23:03Ovadia, sukkah made out of fabric walls23:06is no good.23:07Even if you want to tell me,23:09I'm going to tie it up,23:10he says,23:11what does Shulchan Aruch say?23:12You can't even tie it up,23:13because what if what you use to tie23:15rips,23:16and if it rips,23:17you're not going to have a wall,23:17and you're not even going to realize if it23:19ripped because you don't know.23:21You can't check over there,23:22and if the wind moves a little bit,23:23like he said,23:24it is a pasul. Sukkah,23:27or at least the walls are disqualified.23:30That is the opinion of23:32a Chacham Ovadia. So we have three opinions over here.23:34So now the question is as follows.23:37Okay, so I have already,23:38Rabbi, listen,23:39I'm not going to buy a sukkah.23:40I already have a sukkah.23:42I have a fabric wall sukkah.23:43In fact,23:43my neighbor, who's very religious,23:45and his father is a rabbi,23:46and he's a rabbi,23:46he also has a fabric wall sukkah.23:48And here,23:48I'll tell you the23:49truth, I even have a fabric wall sukkah.23:50What's going on over here?23:51How can it be?23:52Is our sukkah really kosher or not?23:54So one step at a time,23:55let me explain to you how it works.23:56First of all,23:58question comes up is—24:00Can you tie the sukkah24:02wall? We already said, Maran said even if you tie it, it doesn't seem to be okay,24:05right? That's the pashut pshat of Maran.24:07However, and we said the Chacham Ovadia says24:09even if you tie it very, very, it doesn't work.24:10However, you should know there's a great rabbi that used to live in our days,24:14maybe passed away about 15 years ago maybe.24:17His name is Rav Moshe Levi,24:19young but big, huge24:21talmid chacham. He's the author of24:23Menuchat Ahavah, as well as Birkat Hashem24:25and Tefillah24:26l'Moshe, many, many sefarim. In his young life,24:27he was a tremendous, tremendous24:31talmid chacham. Him and also his rosh yeshiva, Rav Mazuz,24:34this is all brought down in24:35the24:36Ish Matzliach. They make a very nice diyuk.24:39According to Maran, listen to the words.24:41He says, What's the problem with tying your sukkah?24:44What's the problem with tying your walls are made out of fabric?24:47The problem is that it might rip without you realizing it.24:50He says, What if I would have a sukkah24:52where the walls are made out of24:53fabric, but there's no way possible for this sukkah24:58to lose what I tied it with?25:01The only way it loses is if the whole sukkah will crumble down.25:04What's that talking about?25:05For example, if I have the fabric walls,25:06you know those walls where you have the metal pipes going25:10into the actual25:11mechitzah, and therefore, for sure25:14the place where it's hooked up to the metal poles25:17is not going to move.25:18It's mamash into the25:20mechitzah. I'm not stitching it, I'm not tying it.25:22The wall itself has a piece25:25that is the structure of the sukkah itself.25:27It's not going to fall.25:28Yes, true, in between the wind might push it,25:31but it's not going to fall down.25:33He says that's not a problem,25:35and you can be medayek from the25:36Shulchan Aruch. He says,25:40Why? Because it might rip without you realizing it.25:43But if it wasn't going to rip,25:44if you would make it out of25:46pishtan, who cares? The wind is pushing it just a little bit.25:47It's not a big deal.25:48So therefore he says it's25:50kosher if you have such a sukkah,25:52where the actual wall itself25:53is not just a wall that you tied on,25:56but the wall goes into the physical structure25:58of the sukkah,26:00like the case where the metal poles26:02are the ones going into the wall,26:05the fabric wall, and holding it up.26:06That's the opinion of Rav Moshe Levi zatzal26:10and26:12yibadel l'chaim haRav Meir Mazuz from26:15Kisei Rachamim. Okay, but still, Chacham Ovadia disqualified it.26:19You look at26:20Chazon Ovadia, he writes, no, it's pasul.26:22He doesn't let go.26:23He says, I don't care if you tied it.26:24He doesn't give an exception.26:27He says anytime you use a fabric wall sukkah,26:28it's pasul.26:30So you have to know a26:31rule that we're going to say again and again later on.26:34Sukkot is a special holiday.26:35It comes once a year.26:37It's considered by the Zohar26:39very, very holy,26:40as we'll discuss in length later on.26:42So therefore, you don't want to do a26:44mitzvah that's coming up only once a year.26:46You don't want to do it in a26:47way that some people are posel it,26:49especially somebody huge like26:50Chacham Ovadia who says it's pasul,26:52somebody like Halichot Shlomo,26:54Rav Shlomo26:55Zalman Auerbach, the Ungvar Rav.26:56You don't want to do that.26:57So therefore, make sure you try to do27:01according to all27:02shitos. So I just mentioned before,27:03and I personally have a27:04sukkah where the walls are made out of fabric walls.27:06So how come I can do that?27:07And the answer is that27:09although the sukkah, to the person watching it27:13from the outside,27:14it seems like it's a sukkah made out of fabric walls,27:16I'm not relying on the fabric walls27:18to be the walls for my sukkah.27:22That's not what I really use for my walls,27:24for the halacha walls, that is.27:25Remember, keep in mind,27:27you could use whatever you want27:28as a wall for27:30tzniut, that people shouldn't see you,27:32what you're doing on the inside of the sukkah.27:33As far as halacha is concerned,27:35the wall has to qualify according to27:37halacha. And therefore, we said27:39you could technically make a wall27:41out of many sticks,27:43even though they're not right next to each other,27:45as long as they're within three tefachim of each other.27:49That's around 22 centimeters.27:52If I take many sticks27:53and I put them next to each other,27:54it doesn't make a difference27:55if it's going horizontally or vertically.27:58If I put many sticks next to each other28:01within a distance of 20 centimeters each.28:04They create a wall,28:07and therefore that's what I have to do.28:08I have to create a halachic wall,28:11and that's what I do in my house28:13with my balcony.28:14I have a28:15balcony, that's where I put the sukkah,28:17and the walls of the balcony28:19is what I use for a wall to be28:23kasher. How do I do that?28:24Well, you measure the balcony,28:25and the balcony has many rods in the middle.28:28There's no distance of three tefachim from each other.28:31That's it. I have a kosher sukkah.28:33Ah, how high does it have to be?28:35We're going to see later on28:36it's going to have to be ten tefachim high.28:37So I also make sure that the balcony wall itself28:41is higher than ten tefachim, according to28:43halacha, and then I have a28:45kosher wall. Now, I don't want people to look at me28:47when I'm eating or when I'm sleeping in my sukkah,28:49so then I'll put up beautiful walls28:51that came with the sukkah28:53in order to cover me,28:55to protect me from the28:57ayin hara, and of course when people are watching me,28:59for certain other reasons,29:00from watching me from inside the sukkah.29:01So therefore, if you have a fabric wall sukkah,29:04make sure to kosher up your walls.29:07How?29:08By either putting up the wooden sticks, like we said,29:11it could be metal bars,29:12it could be made of any material.29:14Just make sure you make enough of a space29:17that's going to qualify for a kosher sukkah,29:19which is ten tefachim high,29:24and the sticks should be within a29:27distance of three tefachim to each other.29:28This could be done with sticks.29:30This could be done even with strings.29:32You ever notice in some of the29:33sukkot they have like a string running on the bottom29:36of the whole sukkah,29:37running all around the sukkah?29:40So that string itself,29:42when it's— that is what's really there as a wall.29:45So therefore,29:47when it's coming there,29:49it's placed within a distance of the other string29:52within less than29:54three tefachim, that serves as a wall,29:56a halachic wall for you,29:57and that you have a kosher sukkah right then,30:00even though you have a fabric wall sukkah.30:02The strings is what makes the walls30:05kosher. That is the sukkah,30:06that is what you're looking out for,30:07and that is what you're looking out for30:08even if you already have a sukkah.30:09And of course, if you're coming to buy it,30:12you know,30:12lechatchila, if you can afford it30:13and buy the fiberglass or the wooden panels,30:16that's obviously the best.30:17But if not,30:18you can still use the fabric wall sukkah,30:21but just use it in such a way.30:22Now, anybody who is not machshir it this way—30:25Who doesn't want to kosher his sukkah this way.30:27That means he has a fabric wall sukkah,30:30and he doesn't want to put up the strings,30:31he doesn't want to put up the sticks.30:34According to the Chacham Avadia, you can't make a berachah in there.30:35However, of30:36course, according to Chazon Ish30:37and Rav Moshe Feinstein,30:39and in a certain way30:41according to Rav Moshe Levi,30:43you could still make a berachah inside.30:45You'll have to check30:45with your regular local rabbi30:47to ask him exactly what to do,30:49especially if you're eating30:50by other people's houses.30:51This is the first thing30:53we need to know about sukkah,30:54are the walls of a sukkah.30:56Next,30:57we come to the next item in the sukkah,31:01is the schach, the roof.31:03The roof of a sukkah is known as31:04schach. In fact, Rashi, Masechet Sukkah says31:06that the whole sukkah,31:08the name derives from this31:10roof named as a31:11schach. Schach in Hebrew means31:13like a cover,31:14which is used as a shade to protect.31:18So the31:19schach, halacha tells us, Gemara tells us,31:22has three conditions31:23in order to qualify31:25as a kosher31:27schach. The roof of a sukkah31:28needs three conditions31:29in order to qualify as a kosher roof.31:31What are these three conditions?31:33Number one,31:34it has to be made31:36from natural material31:37that grows from the ground.31:40Natural material31:42means something that's not processed,31:45and it has to also grow from the ground,31:47like wood grows from the ground.31:52But metals, which come from the ground,31:54but they don't grow into the ground.31:56Same thing as stones.31:57Stones come from the ground.31:58You can't get more than that, right?31:59Dirt.32:00And stone. These things are found in the ground, but they don't grow.32:04They don't develop like the way wood is, branches.32:07So therefore, plastic, polyester, metal, stones, all these things cannot be used as sechach at all.32:14Second condition in order to be qualified as a sechach, even though it grows from the ground,32:19still it cannot be still attached to the ground.32:22So we just mentioned beforehand, wood is something that grows from the32:25ground. Branches of a tree would be good as a sechach as long as they are not connected to the tree.32:35As long as they're connected to the tree, then it disqualifies it from32:40a sechach. You have to rip them off the tree in order for them to be able to be32:44sechach. So branches of trees that you want to pull down from your tree that you have in your backyard and use as a sechach will not work.32:51You have to first cut off the branches and put it back and put it on as32:54a sechach. The third condition, you may have something that's made out of wood or whatever it is,33:00made out of something that could be used, that grows from the ground,33:04but if it's possible for it to become tamei, even though you have the other two conditions,33:08grows from the ground and it's not attached, but if it's possible for it to become33:13tamei, then the halacha tells us that it's also pasul for33:17sechach. I'll give you an example: fruits. Right, a fruit is something that grows from the33:23ground. If I rip it off the tree, it could basically, you know, I could eat—it's not attached to the ground, and maybe you could think I could use it as33:34a schach. The answer is no, you cannot use it as a schach. Why can't you use it as33:37a schach? Because it's able to be mekabel tumah.33:39Anything that is edible by humans has the din of possibly, potentially becoming tameh and cannot be used as33:47a schach. So you can say, What in the world am I going to use as schach that would be food?33:50No, no, no. You have lettuce. You went and bought yourself lettuce and your wife yelled at you,33:55What are you doing? What do you think, I have four hours to sit there and clean every head of lettuce?33:58I don't need it. So now you say, Hey, you know what? Maybe let me use it as34:03a schach, at least for one day. Who cares? Only here for one night.34:05Okay, so such a thing, when you take the leaves, look, they grow from the ground,34:09and they are basically—they're not attached to the ground.34:12I can use it. No, it's food. Food is edible by humans.34:16The lettuce is edible by humans, and therefore it will be disqualified to be used as34:21a schach, even though there are other reasons for the lettuce, but that's the34:24halacha. Good, those are three conditions. Again, it has to be natural material growing from the ground.34:29It cannot be connected to the ground, and it cannot be able to get34:35tumah. The most common thing that people use is bamboo sticks.34:39Bamboo sticks are basically regular wood that grows from the ground.34:42It's obviously detached—the fact that you're getting it to your34:46house—and it's not made to be a receptacle,34:49and therefore it's not going to be34:52mekabel tumah, and that's the best, best material you can use for34:55schach. You can also use, by the way, if the lulav—you wait up on the lulav in the tree34:58and you let it grow like the palm trees, that's what lulav is from,35:02really—you can take those things from the palm trees and you can use that as35:05a schach. In fact, in Eretz Yisrael, a lot of people use that35:07just because they have a lot of palm trees over there.35:08So if you're listening to this, in Florida we have also a lot of palm trees.35:12Go ahead, you have palm trees in your backyard,35:14take off the branches and take off the things and you can use it as35:18a schach. No problem. You're not eating it. It's detached, and it naturally grows from the ground.35:22Fine.35:24Now, there's something else that you have to keep in mind when looking for35:29a schach, and that is there's a din of something that35:33bah hama'amid. I don't want to go into so much detail over here,35:35but if you have a kosher schach, but what's keeping the schach on your sukkah,35:42where without it the schach would fall off your sukkah,35:45is something that is disqualified from being a schach, from kosher35:50schach, it should be35:51pasul. What do I mean?35:52Technically, if I have a mixture of kosher schach and not kosher35:55schach, what's the halacha?35:56For example, let's say I have in my—I take36:00a schach, I put some metal pieces inside of my36:03schach. What's the halacha?36:04The halacha is we go by the majority.36:05What is the majority?36:06If the majority is kosher schach, it's great.36:09If the majority is not kosher schach, then it's no good.36:12Whatever the minority is, we say it's36:15batel b'rov. So now, this is only true when the item itself that is the minority that's36:23pasul, that's disqualified from36:25schach, is there as another ingredient or another just serving as36:28a schach. When the non-kosher schach is being used to support and to make sure36:36that the kosher schach stays in place,36:39where without it the kosher schach would not be there,36:42then it'll be pasul because of36:46davar hama'amid, according to the36:48Rama. Let me explain to you.36:49Let's take for example, I have a kosher36:53schach, and this is most commonly used by mats.36:55Let's say I have a36:56mat. You know the mats, this schach mats that they sell?36:59So once upon a time, the way they used to make them,37:01till today you still have some people make them,37:03is that they would take the string that's made out of polyester,37:09sometimes out of plastic—not hard plastic, obviously, soft37:12plastic—and they would use it to stitch up all the small pieces of the mat.37:16Now, the mat itself is made out of very, very thin slices of bamboo sticks.37:21And they're sewing it all together with this polyester string.37:27Where does polyester come from?37:28Although polyester comes from petroleum,37:32which grows in the ground, but still it's not naturally growing;37:35it's just found in the ground.37:37So therefore, polyester is37:40pasul l'schach. When I use the polyester strings now37:43to hold up the schach, according to the37:46Rama, since the polyester here is called37:49davar hama'amid, it disqualifies the whole37:52schach. And therefore my whole schach is not kosher according to the37:55Rama. According to Shulchan Aruch, however,37:57even if I'm using37:59davar hama'amid, even if I'm using something that's not kosher as38:02a schach to hold up my schach, according to Shulchan Aruch38:06it is mutar.38:07So therefore, this mat with the polyester string,38:11according to Shulchan Aruch there's no problem.38:12I can use it,38:13and I can even make a bracha on it,38:15and that's really the38:16halacha l'maaseh. And of course, what we have to tell you,38:18and that is38:20that although it's, according to Maran, it's mutar,38:22like we said beforehand,38:24you want to be yotzei according to opinions.38:26We'll talk about it a little bit more later on.38:28So let's go practically now.38:31If you're going out to buy a sukkah,38:33or if you have a sukkah,38:35you're just going out to get38:37a schach, your best option is to buy bamboo sticks.38:41The best.38:42Nobody will argue that's a38:44kosher schach. You know, I've seen Gedolei38:46Yisrael, this is what they use for38:47their schach. That's the best option.38:49The next option you can do,38:50it's also kosher l'chatchila as well,38:52is that they sell mats38:54where the material is 100% wood38:58that's kosher for39:00schach, and the strings that are being used39:02to hold up those small pieces of wood39:04is a material that also qualifies for39:08schach. It's like, basically, it's a string made out of—39:11The things that come out of the tree.39:13This is natural,39:14it's not processed,39:15it grows from the ground as well.39:18So therefore, that's also very, very good.39:20If a person is going to buy a mat39:22which is held up either by glue39:25or anything that's not39:28kosher to use itself as39:31a schach, means the main39:33part, which is made out of natural wood,39:36and that can be used as39:37schach, but what's holding it together39:38is not befitting to be39:40a schach. In that case, you enter a39:42machloket between the Shulchan Aruch and the39:46Rama. That is the laws of39:49schach. Now, the next thing when you're buying a39:52sukkah or you're making, putting up your sukkah,39:54is to look out for things39:55that you want to try to avoid.39:57Number one thing that you want to try to39:59avoid is a machloket.40:01What do I mean, a40:03machloket? We just said beforehand that Shulchan Aruch is matir something, and the Rama says it's pasul.40:09We're going to learn also more things later on where it would be mutar according to one opinion; it's assur according to another opinion.40:15Although if you hold like one of the opinions, it should be mutar, you don't want to do something where it's mutar according to some and assur according to others.40:23Why do you want to put yourself in a machloket when you could avoid the40:28machloket? If you can't avoid it, you're somewhere, you're stuck somewhere in the Midwest, and you have no sukkah, you can't order a sukkah that's going to be delivered to you.40:37I don't know if that's possible today with Amazon, but let's say for some reason Amazon doesn't want to deliver to there.40:42It says, you know, it's a war zone, whatever it is.40:44You want to build yourself a sukkah, and then you have to be somech on40:50shitah d'matir, although the matir even l'chatchilah. Okay, fine, b'seder. But if you're living in Brooklyn, New York, you're living in Lakewood, you're living in40:56Monsey, you have a thousand stores that are selling sukkah just outside your house. You don't even have to walk so far to get it.41:02So yes, it's going to cost you a little bit more money.41:04Still, a little bit more money is worth it to do a mitzvah according to all opinions.41:10Imagine—it's the best way to imagine—imagine make a sukkah according to Shulchan Aruch, it's 100% kosher, okay?41:16You go to shul, and, you know, you want to invite somebody for your house for your sukkah, and who do you see in shul?41:22The rabbi comes over, the shul comes over to you, he says, Listen, we have a special guest here today.41:27Who's the guest? None other than Rav Moshe41:30Isserles, the Rama himself, mitechiyat hameitim. He came out of techiyat hameitim. He came to shul today, and he needs a place to sleep.41:38I would love to take him to my sukkah, but I'm eating by my in-laws, and it's not nice to invite another guest.41:42Listen, would you like to have him over to your house?41:44Imagine you bring the Rama to your house,41:46with the Rama sitting in your sukkah.41:49You say, Listen, I came out of techiyat hameitim so I could do mitzvot.41:52You're putting me in a sukkah where I hold it's pasul.41:54So why do you want to put yourself in a machloket, avoid a machloket, right?41:58You want to make a sukkah that's kosher according to all opinions.42:01It's kosher according to the Rama, it's kosher according to the Mishnah Berurah, it's kosher according to the Chazon Ish,42:04it's kosher according to the opinions.42:05Don't just say, Maran, Maran, Maran.42:07Yes, Maran is42:07matir it, the Chacham Ovadia is42:09matir it, but lechatchila, preferably you should try to make, try to do42:14almost what, and specifically the mitzvah of sukkot, right after Yom Kippur,42:18in a way that's not a machloket according to any opinion.42:21That is our take on that point.42:26The other thing you want to avoid when buying, purchasing a sukkah, or putting up a sukkah,42:31or, you know, getting a sukkah from a friend or whatever it is,42:34is that you want to get a sukkah that should be, that would make the mitzvah easy to do every year.42:41A lot of times, out of excitement, people buy certain things, certain mitzvot,42:47that are hard to maintain, hard to keep up to do that mitzvah.42:52Let's take, for example, the example of a sukkah.42:54Let's say you're buying a sukkah,42:55and you're buying the sukkah, and it's beautiful and everything,42:58and you're buying it in a year where Sukkot falls out earlier in the year,43:02and the weather is nice and beautiful and sunny and it's hot.43:06So by you sitting in the sukkah, it's, you know, might be a little bit chilly outside,43:10but it's not so bad because pretty nice weather.43:13But the next year we're going to have a leap year,43:15and all of a sudden we have a leap year, Sukkot will be in October,43:19the weather will be a little bit colder,43:21and it's going to make it very hard to sit in the sukkah.43:23Everybody will be shivering in your sukkah.43:25So you don't want to get a sukkah that one year you're comfortable in,43:29one year you're not.43:30You want to put in the heater, you want to put in the AC,43:32that's up to you, fine, that's great.43:34But basically, you want to get a sukkah which makes it easy to put up,43:39makes it easy to use,43:42and also you want to make it easy to put away for storage.43:46Because you don't want to look, you don't want to dread the time of, you know, Sukkot coming43:51because, oh boy, I have to build my sukkah.43:53Baruch Hashem, in general, there's such a happy atmosphere after Yom Kippur.43:56Everybody's excited to go and do the mitzvot of sukkah, Baruch Hashem.44:01So you also want to look forward to building the sukkah.44:03You don't want sukkah to be something like a burden44:06where everybody has to fight: you do it, get your brother to do it,44:08get this one to do it, then you have to go hire a goy to do it.44:12You want to make it, again, as easy as possible,44:14easy to store, easy to put up, and easy to use as well.44:18Next thing when you're buying your sukkot or putting up the sukkah is44:22decorations. Decorations—in fact, there's halachot about decorations.44:24It's brought down in Shulchan Aruch, it's a Gemara,44:26that there's a special mitzvah to decorate your sukkah.44:31Why?44:31Ze44:33Eli v'anvehu. The Gemara tells us whenever we do mitzvot,44:35we shouldn't do just the minimum possible.44:36We want to do mitzvot in the best way that we can.44:40We want to beautify the mitzvah.44:42So you're buying a sukkah, you're putting up a sukkah,44:46don't make it dry and boring.44:49Decorate it.44:50What should you decorate it with?44:52The best thing you can decorate it with is pictures of gedolim,44:56pictures of rabbis that inspire you,45:00that you look up to. Perhaps maybe you learn45:03their sefarim. That should be your ideal pictures to put up in your sukkah,45:06pictures of great rabbis. That should be a place of holiness.45:11Also, what's good to do is you can put up even pictures of your little kids45:13that they make in school for Sukkot.45:15It's good to do that for the children,45:17that they feel part of the sukkah.45:19Sometimes they're so young and they want to help in45:21the sukkah, and you know that the best way that your kids could help45:23is by staying away.45:25You know, let them stay on the side and let me do my work.45:27Don't come in my way. That's how you45:29can help. And they want to partake in it,45:31so let them hang up their pictures from sukkah.45:33And sometimes it's very silly,45:34and you work so hard to make everything so perfect,45:36and now they come with their little, you know,45:39unmatching and uneven picture frame and things.45:43Who cares?45:44Let them put it up. Let them feel that they're also part of the sukkah,45:47even though it's only a picture of them.45:49So put it right next to the great rabbis and say,45:50one day, that's going to be you.45:52That's what Rav Gifter used to do in his room in the yeshiva.45:56Put up pictures of the kids. Let them feel part of it.45:59Now here I have to stick something very, very important.46:02And that is,46:03although the halacha tells us, b'sukkot teshvu shivat yamim, and Chazal tell us,46:08teshvu k'ein taduru, we have to live in the sukkah as we live in our house.46:11In our house, we have plenty of pictures of our children,46:13and we have pictures of older, we have pictures of your children46:17and grandchildren when they're married even.46:20And sometimes people are not careful in their own house,46:23and they put up pictures of relatives46:25where the ladies are not dressed properly.46:28Well, in the sukkah you cannot do that.46:30In sukkah, although it has to be treated like your house,46:32at the same time, a sukkah has to be treated like a shul.46:36And therefore, you have to maintain the holiness of the sukkah.46:40It's a place where the Shechinah dwells,46:43and one has to be careful not to bring down the kedushah of sukkah in any which way.46:47You cannot, cannot—the sukkah, it cannot be a place46:51where you put up pictures that are inappropriate46:53that you would not put up in the shul or in the yeshiva classroom.46:56You would not put up pictures of your relative47:00who's not just b'tzniut there;47:02you should not put up in your sukkah.47:04It's eight days, nobody will get offended.47:06If that means you have to take away all pictures,47:09even your ... pictures, fine, take that away.47:11Better not to decorate the sukkah than to put up things47:13that will lower the kedushah of the sukkah.47:16So that's something very important to keep in mind.47:18Decorations are beautiful and recommended47:20as long as they enhance the kedushah of the sukkah.47:24Once they do the opposite,47:27they take away from the47:28kedushah, it's assur to put it up in the sukkah.47:31Next thing we have to keep in mind also47:32as a halacha: every sukkah needs lights47:34because you use the sukkah in the evening.47:36And therefore, when you're putting up the lights,47:38there are some47:39halachot. What is47:40the halacha? If something is coming down,47:43hanging down from the sukkah,47:46so if it's the size of four tefachim wide,47:51It could be potentially a problem.47:53When is it a problem?47:55If it's coming down from the schach, or...48:00If it was being held, put up in the sukkah,48:03it's four tefachim wide and it's far from the48:06s'chach a distance of48:08four tefachim. How much is48:10four tefachim? Again, we're going with the shiur of48:12Rav Chaim Naeh, which is the shiur of the48:14Sefardim. This is the more stringent shiur in this halacha.48:19The shiur of four tefachim over here is 32 centimeters,48:22which is about a foot,48:2512.5 inches, okay? It's about a48:26foot. So therefore, if you have the lights hanging down from the48:33s'chach, where they're hanging, or you put it up in the sukkah,48:35where they're far from the48:37s'chach a distance of48:39four tefachim, if the lights themselves are four tefachim wide,48:41you cannot sit under that part of the sukkah.48:43It's48:44pasul. However, if your lights are very wide,48:46they're more than48:48four tefachim, but they're hung up on the s'chach itself,48:52or they're basically within four tefachim of the48:56s'chach, then in that case it's considered part of the48:59s'chach and it's not a problem. You could even sit under it.49:01Like some people in their sukkah, they make beautiful sukkot49:03and they like to put these beautiful chandeliers.49:07Sometimes you have huge chandeliers49:09like the way you have by the49:10Chassidim. Ever go to49:12a Chassidish sukkah? It's so worth it.49:13It's in our backyard right here in49:15Borough Park. Go there and see some of the most beautiful sukkot49:18that they build in the shuls by the49:21Chassidim. They have this magnificent chandelier of many fruits,49:24many different things.49:25It's larger than even49:2940 tefachim, you know what I'm saying?49:29It's huge.49:30It's not a problem to sit under49:31because why?49:32It's within four tefachim to the ceiling,49:35at least the upper part of it.49:36Even if it's hanging down from there,49:37it's fine.49:38As long as it starts within four tefachim to the ceiling,49:40whatever is hanging down,49:42it's fine.49:43Okay,49:43that is the halachot that we need to know for lights.49:48Now,49:48very quick49:51halachot regarding building the sukkah,49:52and the rest, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll leave for next week.49:55Building the sukkah.49:56Before we come to talk about building the49:58sukkah, we have to give an introduction.49:59When it comes to the halacha of sukkot,50:02you have to know your measurements.50:03You have to know what a tefach is,50:05what an amah is,50:06how they measure in centimeters,50:08how they measure in inches,50:09how they measure in feet.50:11And you have to be very, very skilled in this.50:14You have to have these measurements ready and at hand,50:16because everything is basically according to50:19measurements. You need to know what's the minimum,50:20and you want to go as large as possible.50:23According to halacha, you could.50:24Let's begin.50:25There are two measurements that are used50:28when it comes to making the building of a sukkah.50:32One is called a50:34tefach, one is called an50:35amah. Those are the names in Hebrew.50:37Each amah has six50:41tefachim. That means the amah itself is made up of six different50:44tefachim. So when you know the measurement of a50:47tefach, you multiply it by six, and you know the measurement of an50:51amah. Most of the time, the measurement that will be used is a50:55tefach. That's the most common measurement that we use,50:58or we need for halacha, is a51:00tefach. Sometimes we'll have51:01amah, but in general, you need to know what a tefach is.51:03So how much is a51:05tefach? Tefach literally means a51:07fist, the size of a51:08fist. But that's defined in51:10halacha, because obviously, you look at your51:13two-year-old's fist, and you look at your fist,51:15especially if you're about six, seven feet tall,51:17the fists are going to be two different, completely two different sizes.51:20So what's the definition of a51:23tefach? How much is a fist?51:24This is a debatable,51:26this is a51:27machloket, and we're going to use the two main shitot that people follow,51:30the opinion of the51:33Chazon Ish and that... of51:36Rav Chaim Naeh. According to the51:38Chazon Ish, each tefach measures 9.6 centimeters.51:429.6 centimeters is 3.78 inches,51:48around 3.8 inches.51:50That's the opinion of the51:52Chazon Ish. According to51:54Rav Chaim Naeh, no, each tefach is 8 centimeters,51:56which makes it 3.15 inches,52:013 inches and around 3.2 inches52:04about, let's say 3.2 inches.52:06So there's a discrepancy of 1.6 centimeters52:09between the52:10Chazon Ish, who's larger,52:12and Rav Chaim Naeh, which is shorter.52:13It doesn't seem such a big deal,52:151.6 centimeters,52:17but when you add it52:18and you multiply it,52:19for example, when you need 1052:21tefachim, when you need 20 amot,52:23that's going to make a huge difference.52:26The halacha for the52:28Sefardim, the minhag of the52:30Sefardim, the way the Chacham Ovadia brings it down52:32and Chacham Ben Sion as well,52:33I don't believe any Sefardi will disagree52:36that this is the minhag of the52:38Sefardim, is that we follow the opinion of52:41Rav Chaim Naeh. Not because we follow52:42Rav Chaim Naeh, but that is the minhag of the52:45Sefardim throughout all the generations.52:46Rav Chaim Naeh was within the last 50 years.52:48The Sefardim throughout all the hundreds of years52:52in our history,52:53we've always followed the shittah52:54that is consistent with52:56Rav Chaim Naeh, and that is52:57that a tefach is the size of 8 centimeters.52:59That's the53:00Sefardim. It's pretty simple,53:01you follow53:02Rav Chaim Naeh. What about the Ashkenazim?53:04So for the Ashkenazim,53:05the Piskei Teshuvot I53:06saw, he brings down53:06that when it comes53:08to the mitzvah of sukkah,53:10most of the53:12dinim, most of the laws53:13dealing in sukkah53:14are53:15mideoraita, are biblical,53:15and therefore53:17we have the rule,53:18safek53:19deoraita lechumra. You always want to use the measurement53:22where you'll be53:24yotzei even in the stringent way.53:25What does that mean?53:27It means as follows.53:28Let's say53:29the halacha requires53:30a certain amount of height minimum.53:33For example,53:34the height of a wall.53:36The halacha says53:37that the minimum height of a53:39wall has to be53:40ten tefachim. That's going to be a huge difference53:42between Rabbi53:43Chaim Naeh and Chazon Ish.53:45According to Rabbi53:48Chaim Naeh, the size of53:50ten tefachim is two feet eight inches.53:51I'm rounding it off,53:53two feet eight inches.53:54According to Chazon Ish,53:55two feet eight inches is not enough.53:57You need to go another four inches,53:59and that is three feet two inches.54:01So if I have a wall54:03of54:04ten tefachim, according to Rabbi54:05Chaim Naeh, which is two feet eight inches,54:07according to Chazon Ish,54:08it's pasul.54:09It's not a wall yet.54:10It needs another few more54:12inches until it's three feet two inches.54:13So therefore,54:14according to54:15the poskim, they say54:16whenever you have54:17a machloket like this,54:18you should go with the machmir opinion54:19over here,54:20to be like the Chazon Ish.54:22However, sometimes54:24I'll have to be54:25machmir by following the54:26opinion of Rabbi54:27Chaim Naeh. How is that so?54:29For example,54:30you're allowed to sleep in the sukkah.54:31Excuse me,54:32when sleeping in the sukkah,54:34you're allowed to cover yourself54:35with something54:36as long as the cover54:37is not a distance54:39of54:40ten tefachim from the ground.54:41How much is54:42ten tefachim from the ground54:43going up?54:44So it's going to be a difference.54:45According to54:47the Chazon Ish,54:48I could sleep under something54:50that's up to three feet two inches tall.54:53According to Rabbi54:54Chaim Naeh, no.54:55If something is54:57above two feet eight inches,54:58let's make it two feet seven inches,55:00it's going to be a problem.55:02So therefore,55:03in such a case,55:04the poskim says,55:05even according to55:06the55:06Ashkenazim, you should be55:08machmir, because over here55:09the maximum allowed height55:11is debatable,55:12and it's a55:14safek d'oraita, so use55:15a more stringent measurement,55:16which is the measurement55:17of Rabbi55:18Chaim Naeh. And if you're55:19sleeping under something in the sukkah,55:20it should not be—55:23Higher,55:23taller55:24than two feet eight inches.55:26So that's the general.55:28You'll always55:28have to look55:29wherever it's a bigger55:30chumrah, the more55:31chumrah, and you'll go with that55:32shittah. For our sake,55:33for this class,55:34not to make it so confusing55:35for everybody,55:36we will be using55:38the measurements55:38in general,55:40the measurement55:41of55:42Rav Chaim Naeh. I guess the smaller size55:44of55:44a tefach, which is55:45eight centimeter or 3.15 inches55:48per55:49tefach. We will mention sometimes55:51a chazon ish,55:52you know,55:52because we'll explain55:53why, why we have to mention it.55:55But in general,55:55whenever we say55:56tefach or I give a measurement,55:57I'm usually going55:58with the measurement55:59of Rav...56:02I'm noeh the minhag of the Sefardim, and sometimes it comes out also more l'chumra that way, more than the Chazon Ish.56:06So we'll leave it at that.56:09We'll leave it just to know the judgments of Tefach and Amot,56:13and be'ezrat Hashem we'll continue the rest of the halachot of Sukkah56:17partially next week, and also the week all the way afterwards after Yom Kippur,56:23the week of Sukkot, that will be on Tuesday.56:25And again, a reminder, next week, be'ezrat Hashem, the halacha hour will be on Tuesday,56:30not Wednesday; it will be on Tuesday at 256:33o'clock. And this halacha itself will56:35be—oh, excuse me—this class itself will be repeated on the air again tonight56:40at 11 o'clock here on56:43JRootRadio.com. And that's it for the class.56:44We just want to give you the numbers again if you would like to call or text in56:47to call into the station if you have any questions off the air.56:50It's56:53718-683-5858. If you want to text in anything for the next 10-15 minutes, we'll be here,57:02347-927-8398. Until next week on Tuesday, we will see you.57:04We will wish you a wonderful end of the year.57:07It's the last week of the year, everybody, use it well.57:10And we want to give again a big thank you to Iran BSD Productions,57:14the whole JRoot Radio staff, David Levine, Rav Nissim, Lazari, and everybody else.57:20Have a wonderful week and Shabbat shalom.