Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to Halacha Hour here on0:05 JRootRadio.com. Today is Yud Tet Cheshvan, and be'ezrat Hashem,0:09 we will talk about the halachot, continue the halachot from last week.0:12 Before we continue the halachot, we begin as we usually do.0:15 We give you the numbers to the station and describe a little bit what the class is about0:20 and specifically this specific class today, what we're going to talk about.0:25 The numbers to the station are as follows.0:27 If you would like to call in, and phone calls are welcome if it's on the subject in the0:33 middle of the class.0:34 If a person has a question in halacha that's not really so relevant to the subject, we0:39 ask that you call after class.0:40 We'll be around to answer those questions.0:42 The number to the station is0:47 718-683-5858. Again,0:51 718-683-5858. To text in your question on anything that we're discussing, if we're able to answer,0:55 you could text it in at1:02 347-927-8398. Also, to watch and to1:04 listen—actually today I think just1:05 to listen—to listen to this class, you could go to JRootRadio.com or listen on your JRoot Radio Pro app on your1:12 smartphone, or you could call in the following number, 718-506-9099, and welcome to our class.1:20 The Halacha Hour, we talk about the halachot.1:22 We learn the book, specifically the Ben Ish Chai, and we build from the Ben1:28 Ish Chai. We describe the sources of the halacha to clarify the dinim and to also bring up all1:34 the practical nowadays examples and how to apply the halacha with the different opinions,1:41 Sefardim, Ashkenazim,1:42 we try to bring in as much as possible, whatever.1:47 Bezrat Hashem, we're in the middle of Parashat1:50 Vayishlach. We are discussing the halachot of what could one speak about on Shabbat, what a person1:57 is permitted to speak to himself about on Shabbat, and what he's permitted to say to2:03 others on Shabbat.2:04 And we discussed a number of halachot.2:06 Even though we're up to Halacha Hey, it would sound like we just started last week2:09 at the end, but really we've had already two classes on what a person could speak2:13 about on Shabbat,2:14 and now we're up to Halacha Hey, continuing in the halachot of what a person could speak2:18 about on Shabbat.2:20 Today, Bezrat Hashem, we'll also discuss the concept of Shtarei Hedyotot, what one could read on Shabbat.2:27 I don't think we'll be able to finish it, but at least we'll start it, Bezrat Hashem, today.2:32 Before we begin, let's just award our sponsor.2:35 Today's class is sponsored,2:41 לעילוי נשמת לדור בן רחל. Lidor ben2:46 Rachel, ruach Hashem תניחנו בגן עדן. This class is in his memory.2:48 Let's begin.2:49 Halacha Hey: doing your calculations on Shabbat,2:53 speaking about calculations on Shabbat.2:55 Let's begin.2:56 It says over here, the Ben Ish Hai writes,3:02 אסור לחשוב חשבונותיו. A person is forbidden to make his calculations on Shabbat.3:06 What does that mean, his calculations on Shabbat?3:08 Meaning,3:13 בין חשבון העתיד להיות, בין חשבון שעבר כבר. Whether you're talking about calculations that already happened, things in the past,3:18 or things that you're planning to do in the future.3:25 אלא שצריך להיות לא עתה, לדעת אותו. But now he's talking about it,3:27 he's trying to discuss,3:27 he's trying to work out the mathematics. Because he needs to know it.3:32 Kegon, let's give3:33 an example. He says,3:37 kach v'kach hotzeiti habinyan ploni biskirut hapoalim. He says like this,3:39 he's3:39 talking—again, this applies3:40 even if he's talking to himself.3:42 It doesn't have to be necessarily if he's talking to other people. Kal vachomer if he's talking to other people,3:46 because now you have two people involved.3:47 But even if a person is talking to himself3:49 and he says to himself out loud,3:51 and he says,3:52 you know, this building,3:53 Baruch Hashem,3:54 we're about to make chanukat habayit on this building.3:56 We finished building it.3:57 I spent so-and-so on this building.4:00 I spent $400,000 on this building4:03 fixing it.4:05 In this case, it's forbidden.4:08 He made the4:09 calculation. He figured out,4:10 well, let's see, I hired workers for a year.4:13 I promised each worker4:16 $20,000, and I had, let's say, 20 workers.4:19 So therefore it comes out to a total of4:24 $400,000. So he still didn't work out the numbers with his workers,4:30 and he doesn't know if really they deserve each one4:33 the $20,000. He's working out the mathematics.4:35 Again, he's not writing anything.4:36 He's just talking about it,4:37 and he's not talking to anybody.4:44 Still, lachen asur. Even though it's something of the past,4:47 the building's already put up,4:48 the work4:49 is finished, they're already went on to the next site,4:50 they have nothing to do with4:51 him, the workers are4:52 gone. Doesn't make a difference.4:54 But since he's calculating something that he needs to know,4:57 he needs to know how much to pay them,4:59 it is forbidden to do so even by himself.5:04 Ve'af al pi—now, even though he says,5:11 even though now as he works out the numbers,5:13 he comes out to the conclusion that,5:15 one second, I don't owe them anything5:17 because I paid them for this,5:18 and I paid them for that,5:19 and I paid them for that.5:20 So this guy in this our example,5:22 where he hired workers to work on his building,5:24 and now he wants to see, he's calculating,5:27 he comes out at the end that he really doesn't owe them anything.5:28 So really, he spoke about something that he doesn't need5:32 because they're paid for already.5:35 Still,5:39 im kol ze, harei kodem hayah mistapek v'lo. Originally, before he started talking about it,5:41 he didn't know this.5:42 It's only now that he figured out5:43 that he doesn't owe them anything.5:59 V'chen afilu shehu lo hayah tzarich b'oto cheshbon klal, shekvar asah heshbon meihem, v'kach chozer v'choshev hahotza'ah shebinyan shasah kedei l'hodi'a la'acherim shehem tzrichim b'da'azu, shegam hem rotzim la'asot binyan kaze, u'retzonam b'zeh kamah tzrich lahem, harei zeh asur. It also applies when somebody you're talking to6:04 also feels that, or might have a need for what you're talking about.6:08 Let's give you a practical example.6:10 Let's say you have somebody coming over to your house6:12 and he says—or it doesn't have to be in your house,6:13 in your shul—he says,6:14 Wow, what a beautiful suit you have.6:17 So you say, Yeah, you know what I did?6:19 You know, usually people go to the store6:20 and they just pick up a suit and they pay for it.6:22 I was smart.6:24 I went and I bought the jacket from somewhere else,6:27 and then I went somewhere else6:28 and I bought the pants separately,6:29 and then I went and I bought—to the6:31 store—and I bought the shirt separately.6:33 In that case, when a person's talking6:35 and he's figuring out the calculation this way,6:38 so even though something that happened in the past,6:40 if your conversation right now with your friend6:42 may be beneficial to him,6:44 so that's called making calculations6:46 that are necessary on Shabbat,6:48 because your friend says, Wow, what a fantastic idea.6:51 You know what?6:51 I'm going to do the same thing.6:53 Or he goes home, he tells his wife,6:54 You know, look what Moishy did.6:57 He looks fantastic.6:58 He could be on the GQ,6:59 you know, it's unbelievable.7:01 And you know how much he spent on it?7:03 He spent half the price that I would spend.7:05 Oh, he did?7:05 He shopped smart.7:07 He went to7:08 Walmart.com, he went to Amazon,7:09 and for this one he went here,7:10 and for this one he went there.7:12 I should do the same thing.7:14 So in that case,7:15 even though you already spent your money already,7:17 you already don't need7:18 it, it doesn't make a difference to you.7:19 So that conversation would be permitted and forbidden.7:23 Permitted when you're talking to yourself.7:25 You say, you know, what a smart guy I am.7:27 I bought the jacket from Walmart.7:30 I bought the shoes from Amazon,7:32 and I bought the pants from Hatbox,7:35 and I bought... You're talking to yourself.7:37 That's mutar because you already spent it already.7:40 But for you to go and tell somebody else,7:42 that's forbidden.7:43 A more common example would be like this:7:45 Did you know that Hatbox has a sale?7:48 Did you know that this store is going out of business7:51 and has a sale?7:53 That's sure forbidden,7:55 because even though you're not telling him7:56 to go buy over there,7:58 you're only thinking about it,7:59 but still when you...8:00 Talking about calculations, you're talking about the numbers. They have a sale, everything's half8:05 price. To you, you already did it, you're done. But to your friend who needs to know that information, it's forbidden.8:10 Likewise with ladies when they have conversations.8:12 Says, Oh, you spent so much on your maid, on your housekeeper. Why'd you spend so much?8:18 You know what you should do? You should hire three of them and give them separate hours.8:21 This way you pay them less, or whatever it may be.8:24 Or you should hire one person for a full week, and this way you pay her less.8:27 Whatever it may be. Even though you yourself don't need to know the information,8:32 you already know the information, but to tell your friend about it, to talk about these calculations, those are forbidden.8:38 The only time it's mutar is when your friend doesn't need to know about it,8:43 and you also don't need this calculation.8:47 I'll give you an example. Somebody tells you, What a beautiful wedding you made.8:51 You know, I personally, I don't know if I could pull off such a wedding. You know,8:55 I can't afford it, or whatever it may be. But how much did you spend on this8:59 hall? How much did you spend on this wedding? Such an example, such a case is permitted.9:05 Why? You already made the wedding,9:08 and now you're trying to figure out the... You don't remember because you paid each one separately.9:12 You paid the photographer separately. You paid the hall separately.9:15 You paid the caterer separately. You paid the music separately.9:18 You paid the drinks separately. You paid the valet separately.9:20 Now you're sitting down and you're putting all the numbers together.9:23 You already paid for it.9:25 And your friend that you're talking to doesn't have any kids that are getting married anytime soon.9:31 Or, let's say he already got all his kids married,9:33 or he's not planning to make a wedding in the same hall that you made.9:37 It's an out-of-town wedding.9:38 Such a conversation is9:40 mutar, even though you're mentioning numbers, even though you're saying, I paid $50,000 for this.9:45 I paid $10,000 for this, and I paid $5,000 for this.9:48 That's all permitted because it's9:54 heshbonot asher avar she'ein lahem tzorech. Here are the9:55 conditions. It's first of all on something that happened in the past.9:58 Number two, there's no need in my calculations right now,10:01 not for me and not for somebody else.10:03 Then it would be permitted.10:05 Okay, so again, let's repeat the case, the10:09 halacha, and when is it10:10 mutar. Anytime a person is speaking to himself about calculations regarding how much he spent10:16 or he's planning to spend on something, when there's a necessity in his speech,10:20 when there's a need for someone to know about it, whether himself or somebody else, it's forbidden.10:25 However, there's absolutely no benefit whatsoever, not to him or to others who are listening to him10:31 in this conversation. Let's say it's just for bragging rights.10:35 You know, that's not called a necessity.10:37 You know, the guy wants to show off. The guy wants to have some kavod.10:40 He wants to say, Wow.10:41 You know, some people get kavod by mentioning how much he spent, by bragging that they spent so much money on something,10:48 and some people get kavod by showing how smart they are that they're able to get it so cheap.10:54 In different communities, on different levels in society, have different reasons for why they say how much they spent.11:01 Some people say, you know, they could have spent only11:05 twenty thousand, they'll make it into11:06 a hundred thousand. And some people, they could have spent eighty thousand, but they make it that they spent only ten thousand just to show how smart they are that they didn't get ripped off.11:13 In any case, you're doing it purely for kavod purposes and all these things, and nobody is going to be able to copy you.11:19 That's mutar.11:19 It'll be the same thing if somebody comes to your house and he says, What a beautiful renovation you've done.11:24 Again, if your conversation will not be of benefit to him or to yourself, it's mutar to11:29 talk about. You're allowed to say, Oh, you know, I got the tiles for very cheap.11:33 I got them for half price.11:35 They're still going out of business.11:36 I hired some worker that I found in the street.11:39 You know, he's not licensed, but you know what?11:40 At the end of the day, I trusted him.11:42 Somebody told me he's good.11:43 He did my tiles, and I got this person to paint my house,11:46 and me and my kids are the ones who, you know, pretty much built the bathroom.11:51 That's all fine, because You already finished.11:55 You paid for it,11:56 and your friend is not planning to do the same thing as you, or at least you know, pretty much you know that he's not planning.12:03 That's all permitted.12:05 With this heter, I would like to read you the conclusion of the12:09 Ben Ish Chai, and he brings over here, he says the following:12:13 Ach tzarich lizaher shelo leharbos bidvarim eilu. Like we mentioned in the past, these halachot are a very fine line,12:17 meaning even with the heterim, you have to be careful not to talk things unless they're really divrei Torah.12:22 Like we mentioned, some people even just speak in12:26 lashon hakodesh. Why? Because your words on Shabbat have to be different.12:28 So he says even though it's permitted to speak about such things,12:31 you have to be careful not to talk too much about it.12:34 Okay, you're excited, you got a new house,12:35 you renovated a house,12:36 you got new suit,12:38 you got new things.12:39 Don't talk about it all about the money.12:41 Talk about other aspects of it.12:42 Talk about how much you learned in the house.12:53 Vekatav b'gaon Chida, b'Moreh Etzba, ot kuf nun alef. He quotes Chida. Listen to this Chida: Hagam d'yesh matirim b'cheshbonot she'avru, yesh osrim. Even though we said regarding calculations that happened already,12:57 it's mutar, he says there are those who still are forbidding.13:01 They forbid any cheshbonot of the past.13:06 Ve'shomer nafsho yirchak mehen. And a person who is sensitive and he cares about his neshama more,13:12 distance yourself away from these cheshbonot even though they happened already.13:17 Vehen lu yehi d'sharei, mizeh yavo ledvarim na'imatid. Why? Even if it's 100% permitted,13:20 we all know when you talk, your conversation, especially nowadays,13:24 there's no restrictions in our conversations,13:29 and even when we're allowed to speak about certain things,13:32 our conversation may lead us to things that are forbidden.13:36 Al ken yistom petach v'tov lo. That's why the best is try to be quiet as much as possible,13:39 even when it's permitted.13:40 So again, mutar min hadin, 100%.13:42 But the rule is as follows:13:44 you got to be careful in these13:45 halachot. These are very13:47 borderline halachot. It's kind of like a person... Who is told by a doctor that this plant,13:53 you should go, you know, you go into a forest,13:56 and he said, no, almost every leaf in the forest is poisonous.13:59 But he said, no, there's two types of leaves that are not poisonous,14:02 those you're allowed to touch.14:04 The only thing is, you got to be careful.14:06 You know, they're surrounded by a lot of poisonous plants.14:11 Now, I can't tell you they're all poisonous.14:12 That one is not poisonous.14:14 Just be careful14:14 when you're touching it, only touch the ones that are not poisonous.14:17 So, you know, you're allowed to,14:19 but how much time are you going to spend over there around the non-poisonous plants?14:22 You have poisonous plants all around you.14:25 Same thing over here.14:25 Even though it's permitted to talk about certain things,14:27 it always, almost always leads to forbidden conversation,14:31 and a person has to stay away from them.14:33 We move on now,14:35 halacha vav. Halacha vav, the Mishnah talks about speaking about money that you spent,14:41 pretty much very similar to what we said,14:44 and it's really included, but we'll just do an inside.14:48 He says like this:14:55 אסור לומר לחבירו, בכך וכך קניתי חפץ זה או כלי זה, אם יודע בחבירו שרוצה גם הוא לקנות ממנו. Similar to what we said again,14:57 a person is not allowed to say14:59 over here, you're not figuring out anything.15:01 In the previous15:02 halacha, you're trying to figure out how much you spent totally.15:06 You know, sometimes you go to a few different stores,15:09 and now you're putting all the numbers together.15:11 That's called15:13 cheshbonot. The next halacha, well, you know the numbers,15:15 you know how much you spent,15:16 and you want to say now, you know,15:17 your wife comes home and she tells you,15:19 you know, this week I spent $300 at the grocery,15:25 $400 at the supermarket,15:27 $200 only on meat.15:29 These are15:30 cheshbonot she'avar, these are not15:31 cheshbonot. Really, you're just telling your husband15:33 of things that you spent already.15:35 Now your husband needs to know why.15:37 Stop.15:38 He wants to know where his money is going.15:40 So literally, there's no real need for it.15:42 Your husband's not going to go and spend over there.15:44 But if you're talking to your friend,15:46 a man or a woman is talking to his friend,15:48 and they're saying, You know,15:50 I spent this week $200 on meat.15:52 $200 on meat? Wow.15:54 Well, what'd you buy, a whole cow?15:55 Yeah, it was actually on sale.15:57 So you know that your friend, there's still more.16:00 The sale is not over. When's the sale over? Next week. He needs it? That's asur.16:04 If you know that he needs it, but if your friend is a vegetarian16:07 and he tells you how much you spent on meat, no problem.16:10 Only a problem when you know he needs it.16:18 That's why stresses.16:20 It's very common that people brag about how much money they spent and how much they saved.16:26 All Jews love each other and friends, especially when they care about each other.16:31 It's a known thing. When you find something very good on sale and you bought for yourself already,16:35 you want to share that information.16:36 How many times you get a phone call from your mother or your mother-in-law and says,16:40 Run, run, run! This store has a sale, big sale on something that you want.16:44 This store is going out of business. Remember those, the cutlery set that you wanted?16:50 You're getting it now for 70% off.16:52 Everybody likes to share that information.16:54 It's great. It's fantastic. You got to be careful not to do it on Shabbat.16:57 It's17:03 asur. However, if there's absolutely no need for your friend to know,17:07 you have people that are coming to your house on Shabbat17:10 and they're not married, they're not planning to buy anything for the household things.17:14 They're yeshiva bachurim especially. They couldn't care less how much money you spent on meat.17:18 They're getting the food free from the yeshiva on Shabbat. They're coming to eat by you.17:21 So what point? There's no necessity for you. They don't care how much you spent money,17:26 and it's not going to help them at all.17:28 So then,17:30 then you could say, This is how much I spent, even by a wedding.17:34 This is how much I spent for this building. This is how much I spent in the hall,17:39 whatever it is. This is how much I spent in the supermarket on meat.17:42 All this is17:43 mutar. Again, the rule is making calculations or speaking about how much money you spent17:48 is permitted. On a condition that you or the person that you're speaking to17:54 has no need for that information.17:59 Good? That is the general rule.18:01 And it's still, in all, be careful not to overdo it, not to talk too much about it either.18:07 The Ben Ish Chai concludes with another18:09 halacha. It's just a one-liner, small18:11 one-liner. Didn't come by itself, but it's an important18:17 halacha. אסור לדבר דבר שזכר לו צערו. It's forbidden on Shabbat for a person to speak about something that will cause him pain.18:25 Or even if the pain is in the past, you cannot speak about it18:30 if it's going to remind you or the other person about the pain.18:34 Give you a mashal of things that we may be familiar with18:39 and some things that maybe we haven't paid attention to.18:42 First, someone went through a very, very horrible time.18:46 You know, let's say, you know, he lost a relative that was very close to him.18:51 It could be a child, it could be a parent.18:53 You can't remind him about this on Shabbat.18:54 Now, why would somebody remind him?18:56 You say, Hey, how are you feeling?18:57 Is it all, you know, you got over it?18:59 Somebody was engaged, and now he broke up with his fiancée.19:05 It didn't work out,19:05 or she broke up with him, really.19:08 Right? It was a week before the wedding.19:09 It was very tragic,19:11 and, you know, the girl called it off.19:13 Very heartbreaking.19:15 You go over to the guy,19:16 you know that he broke off his engagement.19:18 You go over to him,19:19 Oh, you know what I heard?19:21 I heard that your fiancée, your ex-fiancée, excuse me, she's getting into somebody else.19:27 That hurts.19:28 That's very painful.19:29 You can't talk about that on Shabbat.19:31 It's asur.19:32 It's conversation.19:33 I'm not talking about money.19:34 I'm not talking about anything.19:35 Shabbat is a day of oneg, of pleasure,19:36 and there are certain halachot that tell us what we could talk about and what we cannot talk about19:40 so we could keep that day enjoyable.19:43 When you talk about things that are hurtful, it's asur.19:45 Now, there's no issur in your words as far as lashon hara, as far as money is considered,19:50 but since you're causing pain to somebody else, that's asur.19:53 You know what?19:53 If you're doing it on purpose just to cause him pain, then you might be עובר another issur19:58 min haTorah, which is20:00 לא תונו איש את עמיתו. In this case over here, even if you're doing it very innocently,20:03 if you know that it causes him pain, it's asur to talk about it.20:06 Another example.20:08 Oh, you know who bought that building?20:10 This person,20:11 and you know that is going to irritate him.20:13 You know that this person, you know, it's going to bother him because he wanted to buy the same building.20:17 And again, you're just making conversation.20:20 That is forbidden.20:21 So, you have to be careful with this.20:23 You have to think.20:24 Yes, we have to think before we speak.20:26 In general, we have to do it,20:27 but on Shabbat even more so.20:29 On Shabbat, we have to keep the environment enjoyable.20:32 Don't speak about things that cause pain.20:33 Give you something that maybe people will not mention.20:36 It is true that we have much more time for conversation on Shabbat,20:40 especially husband and wife.20:41 If there is an issue that is very pressing, that's very important to be discussed,20:47 but you know it's going to cause pain to your spouse,20:49 husband to wife or wife to husband,20:51 and you know it's going to get all agitated,20:53 he's going to get all excited about it,20:54 or she's going to get so upset about it,20:56 don't talk about it on Shabbat.20:58 If it's so, make an appointment to speak about it on Motzaei Shabbat.21:01 Anything that causes pain is forbidden.21:02 Don't tell your husband that his mother hurt your feelings again.21:09 You know how upset he gets21:10 when he sees that there's friction in the family between you and his mother,21:15 so don't talk about it on Shabbat.21:16 Ah, when am I going to talk about it?21:17 Try to talk about it after Shabbat.21:19 If you're planning to go to their house on Shabbat,21:23 your in-laws' house on Shabbat,21:23 and you know that there's some friction between you and your21:28 mother-in-law, and it's a pressing issue21:29 and you have to talk about it now21:30 because otherwise it's going to become worse,21:31 okay, fine.21:33 But otherwise, if it's not going to become any worse,21:35 you're just causing pain on Shabbat,21:37 you're not allowed to speak about it,21:38 and this applies with everything.21:40 And I'll tell you something else people don't realize.21:45 A lot of people are not,21:46 you know, today, yes, most people are,21:49 you know, have access to the internet21:50 and they know what's going on in every part of the world.21:53 But those who don't know so much what's going on in the news,21:56 if you know that certain information will hurt them,21:58 you know, in the news22:01 will give them pain,22:02 you're not allowed to talk about it.22:03 L'mashal, a person who doesn't know about the news22:04 that's going on in22:06 Eretz Yisrael. For you to tell him22:08 there has been three stabbings22:10 in Eretz Yisrael this week22:11 on Shabbat,22:13 where22:14 he has—he can't do anything about it.22:15 It's just going to make him feel bad.22:16 You can't tell him on Shabbat.22:17 You can tell him before or after Shabbat,22:19 but not on Shabbat.22:20 It just causes him pain.22:21 I remember when the whole thing happened with22:24 Leiby Kletzky, it really,22:26 it hurt so much.22:27 I had to—I took off a week22:29 that Shabbat from shul.22:31 Right on the spot,22:31 I told my rabbi, we have to go away for Shabbat.22:33 I can't,22:34 this whole thing.22:35 And from then I decided not to listen to the radio22:37 because it was just crazy.22:39 It just—you keep on hearing these things,22:41 it kills you after a while.22:43 It wears—it's very heavy.22:45 It makes a person depressed.22:47 You can't talk about these conversations on Shabbat.22:49 It happened.22:50 There's nothing to do about it anymore.22:53 Ah, the rav sometimes brings up the news22:55 that's very, very painful.22:56 A rav in his speech22:58 on Shavuah Shlishit or Shabbat morning22:59 sometimes brings up the news,23:01 and he speaks about things that are painful.23:02 In that case,23:04 there's something to do about it.23:05 He wants to stir the people to do23:07 teshuvah. From the23:08 tzaar, he's going to bring them to do23:09 teshuvah. He's going to bring them closer to23:10 HaKadosh Baruch Hu. But stam to give people tzaar on Shabbat,23:13 it is forbidden.23:14 And we're going to learn soon23:16 regarding reading material23:17 that causes a person23:19 tzaar, that's also forbidden.23:20 The idea is23:21 talking23:22 in conversation,23:23 no matter what the conversation is.23:24 If that person is going to get tzaar from it,23:27 or you are going to get tzaar from it,23:29 it's forbidden to talk about on Shabbat.23:30 It falls under the forbidden speech on Shabbat.23:33 With this,23:34 we move on to halacha zayin,23:37 and now we are entering23:38 a whole new subject over here.23:41 In zayin and chet,23:43 although they look like two short23:44 halachot in the Ben23:46 Ish Chai, they actually contain so much.23:48 And really23:49 there's a lot of halachot over here23:50 that's so practical,23:51 that's so applicable.23:53 On a regular Shabbat basis,23:55 you'll see23:55 you'll be shocked about these23:58 halachot because you say,23:58 But everybody does it.24:00 And there's a rule that doesn't make a difference what everybody does, because we learn already, you have to know what the halacha is.24:07 And you have to know, even when everybody is doing it, you can't just dismiss them and knock them.24:14 There's a rule that I learned from a very big talmid chacham, he's now the Manchester24:19 Rav, and he says whenever you see something that looks like, you know, whenever you see frum people, talking about religious people,24:26 not talking about non-religious, when you see religious people are doing something and you see that, you know what, it doesn't make sense in halacha how they're doing such a thing,24:33 you can't go around shooting down religious people. If they're doing it, especially when there's rabbanim, they're not opening their mouth, they're not doing anything, as we're going to see soon,24:42 you can't just go and shoot. There's something there. You have to first of all learn the halacha24:46 and see what is the halacha. If the halacha, maybe you don't know the24:50 halacha, maybe you heard the halacha from somebody and you think that's assur, and then you open up and you realize that, hey, it's really mutar.24:58 Whoever told me this halacha was going with this stringent opinion.25:01 I remember when, you know, before I started learning real halacha, when I was in yeshiva.25:07 So in yeshiva you don't learn real halacha, you open up a Kitzur Shulchan Aruch, you open up Yalkut Yosef, Ben Ish Hai, you open up,25:12 you know, something very quick, or you hear halachot from just random people, and that's as far as your halacha is.25:18 And I remember a certain halacha that I read in Yalkut Yosef that he says it's forbidden to do such a thing.25:23 And then I went to a certain place and I saw that the rav of the place was doing it, gets what it says in Yalkut Yosef,25:28 and I said, I can't believe this,25:30 you know. And Yalkut Yosef spoke very, very strongly against this halacha,25:34 and I said, how could this person do such a thing? The guy must be an am haaretz, this rabbi.25:38 Later on, I started learning, I came across the same halacha, but now I'm learning it from the source,25:44 Tur, Beit Yosef, Shulchan Aruch. And all the25:48 mefarshim, so hey, it's not so simple.25:51 There's matirim and there's osrim.25:52 So the rabbi is going with the opinion that's25:54 matir. In fact, the matir was a Ben25:56 Ish Chai. So why am I going crazy?25:58 Okay, Yalkut Yosef is oser, but it's a machloket at the end of the day,26:01 and he has every right to go with the Ben26:04 Ish Chai, especially if the rabbi himself is Iraqi, of course.26:07 So therefore, you have to be careful.26:10 When you learn a halacha and you see that it's forbidden,26:12 and you look around and you see people are not doing it,26:15 first you have to know what the real halacha is.26:17 Once you discover the halacha is really assur, why are people doing it?26:20 Then you have to search,26:22 search a little bit more, and find out why are people doing such a thing26:25 when it seems like it's26:27 assur. Then you have to speak to prominent26:30 rabbanim, talmidei chachamim, poskim, and ask them.26:31 Don't just go around shooting.26:32 If you still see that there's really no26:35 heter, okay, there's no26:37 heter, then you have every right to say, Hey, these people are doing wrong.26:40 But if you see that they have a26:43 heter, and sometimes the heter may be26:47 that mutav sheyihyu shogegim v'al yihyu mezidin. What does that mean,26:50 mutav sheyihyu shogegim v'al yihyu mezidin? That sometimes halacha says26:52 that people could do something,26:55 and we know that they're doing something wrong,26:58 and we warn them,26:59 but sometimes the warning, we know, will go on deaf ears.27:02 They'll know that's wrong, but they're so attached to this27:06 issur, and therefore if you tell them,27:08 they're going to do the issur anyway,27:11 and this time the issur will become worse,27:13 because by you telling them the27:17 issur, they're not going to stop.27:18 So therefore27:19 it becomes that they're mezid,27:22 they're doing an aveirah on purpose,27:24 as opposed to doing it by mistake.27:26 Till now they're doing it by mistake.27:28 They don't know 100%. They think it's mutar.27:30 The aveirah is on a lower level.27:33 But if they, but once they know27:35 and they're not going to stop anyway,27:37 they're going to be mezidin.27:38 In that case, keep27:40 him out. There's a lot of details to this27:42 halacha. This halacha is brought down in the27:44 poskim many, many times.27:46 In fact,27:47 to go into it a little bit,27:49 the halachot of27:52 tochacha. There are halachot of when a person27:54 could open his mouth about27:56 halacha or to tell people off that they're doing something wrong.27:59 And one, you have to be smart28:01 because on one hand,28:02 if you tell people what they're doing something wrong28:05 and they listen to you,28:06 they stop the issur that they're doing,28:08 that's great.28:10 You mezakeh harabim, you stop them. But on the other hand,28:12 you have to be smart also.28:13 If you know that certain people will not listen,28:17 will never listen to you,28:19 and you tell them anyway,28:21 so then in that case28:22 you made their aveirah worse.28:24 You took them from a28:27 shogeg to a mezid.28:28 Till now they were doing28:30 the aveirah because they didn't know any better.28:32 Now that you told them28:33 that you guys are doing28:35 aveirah and they're continuing to do28:37 the aveirah and they're not stopping,28:39 so now you made their28:41 aveirah b'mezid, and their punishment is going to be worse.28:43 So you came in order to save,28:45 but you ended up messing up more.28:47 You came to try to lighten up their28:50 issur. You're trying to save them28:51 from doing things that are forbidden,28:52 but now you're telling them it's28:55 assur and they're doing it anyway.28:57 Now you made them have a bigger29:00 aveirah. So what does that mean?29:01 So you never open your mouth.29:02 What happened to the pasuk,29:06 Hocheach tochiach et amitecha, v'lo tisa alav chet? There's a pasuk that says29:08 you have to reprove,29:09 you have to correct your friend.29:11 Hocheach means not to bash him29:13 and to knock him.29:14 Hocheach means clarify for him,29:16 like in this week's parashah.29:17 It says Eliezer was praying for29:20 a wife for29:21 Yitzchak, and he says that the woman29:23 that will offer water to my camels,29:27 otah hochachta. But he says birarta. You have to clarify.29:30 You have to clarify for your friend29:32 what he's doing wrong in order to correct him.29:35 And if you have the29:36 ability to stop him from doing29:37 an aveirah and you don't stop him,29:39 You are responsible for his29:43 aveirah. So then,29:44 how do you balance this out?29:46 So there's halachot. There's a29:47 Shulchan Aruch. Shulchan Aruch tells us exactly29:49 what we're allowed to tell29:51 and what we're not allowed to tell.29:52 And these are important29:53 halachot, because you're never patur completely,29:57 and you have to know29:57 when you're not allowed to open your mouth.30:00 Rule number one:30:01 when it comes to telling other people30:04 when they're doing something wrong,30:06 the rule is as follows.30:08 If it's something that's30:09 forbidden30:11 min haTorah, and it says it clearly in the Torah that it's forbidden,30:15 you have an obligation30:16 to tell the Jew30:19 what he's doing,30:21 that he's doing something wrong,30:23 and that he has to stop it,30:25 and he has to do what it says according to30:27 halacha. Let's give an example.30:28 Here's an issur that says in the Torah. It says in the Torah30:30 you're not allowed to eat pig,30:33 right? It says it clearly.30:35 Chazir is one of the forbidden foods.30:37 Now you know this guy is eating pig.30:40 Whether he knows it's30:41 assur or he doesn't know it's30:42 assur, you have an obligation in30:44 the Torah to go up to the person and say,30:46 Stop doing what you're doing.30:47 You're doing something forbidden.30:49 Even though you know for a fact30:51 that he's not going to stop,30:52 even though that you know he's going to30:54 go and eat in McDonald's tomorrow30:56 and after it and the day afterwards.30:57 In fact, he's the owner of that McDonald's,31:00 and he wants to eat there.31:02 You have an obligation to tell him,31:03 You can't eat a cheeseburger.31:05 You can't eat ham.31:09 You can't eat all these non-kosher foods.31:12 A person who's mechalel Shabbat31:13 also says it straight in the Torah,31:15 You're not allowed to be mechalel Shabbat.31:16 You know that he puts on a fire,31:17 you know that he drives on Shabbat.31:18 You have an obligation to tell him31:20 that he's doing an31:23 issur, whether he's going to listen to you or not.31:25 You have to tell him.31:26 How long do you have to tell him for?31:28 You have to keep on reminding him.31:30 You have an obligation to keep on reminding him31:32 until the point that he is about to hit you.31:35 That's what it says in31:35 halacha. That doesn't mean he's about to really hit you,31:37 if he's gonna really hit31:39 you and have to put yourself in31:40 sakana. That's also halacha in31:42 yoreh deah. You have to tell him to the point31:44 that he's ready to hit you,31:46 when he says, Leave me alone already,31:47 and he's storming off,31:49 I don't want to listen to you anymore,31:51 and then you know that you've reached31:53 the level of31:54 tochacha. If you keep on telling him31:56 and every time he just nods his head31:57 and he just ignores you, whatever it is, so...32:00 So that means your words may have an effect.32:02 If he gets to the point when he yells at you and screams at you, or he's ready to hit you,32:07 then you're patur. You don't have to tell him anymore.32:09 You yatzata yedei chovah, and that's it. From now on, the gezeirah is on his head.32:14 He has been warned about something that's clearly said in the Torah,32:18 and you're patur. You did your job. You will not be held responsible.32:21 But so long as he doesn't do that to you, you have to keep on reminding him. You have to tell him,32:25 Didn't I tell you last week you can't eat non-kosher and now feels uncomfortable?32:30 But still, you don't know sometimes, and most of the time, your words may have an effect.32:34 If he didn't fight you off, he didn't shrug you off, he didn't yell at you, he didn't tell you, Leave me alone,32:39 obviously your words have an effect that he didn't say anything back to you.32:42 Again, it might feel uncomfortable, but that's what it says in halacha. That's your obligation.32:48 Again, it only applies to things that are asur min haTorah, and they are clearly expressed in the Torah.32:57 I'll give you an example. We said non-kosher is clearly said in the Torah. You have to eat kosher food.33:03 You're not allowed to eat non-kosher animals.33:05 Here's something that says in the Torah, but it's not clear in the Torah.33:09 It says in the Torah that a woman who's married has to cover her hair, but it's not clear.33:14 It's understood through remez. It's understood from the story of Sotah, where the Kohen uncovers the head of a married woman.33:24 From there, says the Gemara in Ketubot, we learn that married women should cover their33:28 hair, but it doesn't say straight out. So now, if you see a woman—talking about33:32 a woman, obviously—if you see a woman who is walking around without covering her hair, and you know for sure she's not going to listen to you,33:37 you don't have an obligation to tell her if you know for sure she's not going to listen to you.33:41 However, if you think that there's a possibility that she might listen to you. Or this applies, by the way,33:50 not only to mitzvot that are not clear in the Torah, but even mitzvot33:55 deRabbanan, halachot mideRabbanan. If you have a doubt that the person may listen to, you have an obligation to tell them.34:00 So let's take a woman who sees her neighbor that she's not covering her hair,34:04 and maybe she doesn't know about it, so she goes over there and says, You know, you have to cover your hair.34:09 If you see she says, Oh, thank you very much. I know, but I'm not nimus to do it. That's it.34:15 You know you did your obligation. Enough. Leave her alone from now on.34:18 You thought that maybe your words, she might hear you. But if you know this woman is anti,34:23 and she's not going to listen, and she doesn't think that there's an obligation to cover her hair,34:29 you don't have to say anything. You know that she won't accept it.34:32 Sometimes you should know that people don't want to accept what you have to say.34:36 Meaning, there's some people that just don't like you. Let's accept it.34:40 There's certain people that just, you know, as charming, as wonderful, as wonderful as you think you are,34:45 certain people don't like you. That's a fact of life. Not everybody has to like everybody.34:49 You should, but the fact of life is not everybody likes you. Accept it.34:55 If you know that somebody doesn't like you, then your words are going to go on deaf ears. Don't say anything to them,35:00 because sometimes people don't want to hear it from you.35:03 It's not that they don't want to hear the halacha; they don't want to hear it from you.35:06 And then you might put them in a position where they are mezid, so you have to be careful.35:10 So therefore, sometimes as a rav, he has the ability to influence someone where you can't.35:16 And if you know that this person will not listen to you, don't say anything to them.35:20 Why? What do you mean? I'm trying to save him. No, you might make the aveirah worse,35:24 because now you're telling him something that he could have listened, he could have done it35:30 if he heard it from the rav. When you tell him, now he wants to do it just to spite you.35:35 And we learn these halachot, rabotai, from where? From Yom Kippur.35:40 There's a mitzvah min haTorah to accept Yom Kippur early.35:47 That means, let's say Yom Kippur begins at 6:30. If a person has to stop eating, let's say35:53 6:20, some say even as early as shkia, or 6:10, that is.35:58 This is a halacha. The Shulchan Aruch brings down that in their days, when ladies were not educated,36:04 in their days when ladies didn't go to school, didn't know how to read,36:09 so they knew about what it says in the Torah,36:11 and they knew that you have to fast on Yom Kippur,36:13 and they always know that the day begins at sunset, which is36:17 6:30. Why are you telling them now to stop at 6:10? They're not going to listen to you.36:20 So the halacha says, although they're doing something wrong, because halacha does say you have to accept it earlier,36:24 they don't want to accept it until 6:30. Halacha says don't tell them anything.36:28 Why?36:31 Mutav sheyihyu shogegin ve'al yihyu mezidin. If you tell them that's forbidden, then what's going to happen is they're going to do it anyway,36:37 and now they're doing it b'mezid. Now they're doing the aveirah on purpose instead of36:41 shogeg. Until now they think it's mutar, even though we all know the truth that it's certainly not36:45 mutar. So this is the halacha. This halacha teaches us that if something that's not clearly expressed in the36:51 Torah, like adding onto Yom Kippur, if you know for a fact that people will not listen to you, don't tell them.36:58 If you have a doubt, the possibility that maybe they'll listen to you, you tell them.37:03 However, if it's a mitzvah that's clearly expressed in the Torah and the person is not keeping it,37:10 even though you know for sure that they're not going to listen to you, you must tell them anyway.37:14 Why? Because otherwise you're not keeping what it says in Torah, hocheach tochiach, even what it says in Torah.37:22 How much you have to tell them? Until the point that they're ready to hear you.37:26 We have a phone call.37:30 Hello?37:31 Yes.37:32 Hello? Yes,37:32 hello, I don't want to be on the air.37:35 So then I recommend you call in 15 minutes.37:40 Okay. Let's come back now to what we're talking about.37:47 Now that we finished the halachot of tochacha, we will move on to the next subject.37:52 The subject is, like we said, shtarei37:57 hedyotot. Shtarei hedyotot is a very big subject. It has a lot of38:01 halachot, and we'll begin just today with an introduction: what are shtarei38:06 hedyotot, and the details of all these halachot. Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll have them next week.38:11 By next week, hopefully, we'll have them all clarified,38:14 of what is permitted to read and what is not permitted to read.38:17 Let's start with basics.38:19 I want to point out, though, that a lot of people get mixed up when learning this.38:23 Myself, I also had the same problem.38:25 When you come to learn these halachot, they're found in siman shin zayin.38:28 Now, most people learn the siman al הסדר, in order.38:32 You know, you go halacha aleph, then bet, then gimel, dalet,38:35 hei, vav. So these halachot are from, I believe, from halacha yud bet until38:40 yud chet. Many people, when they come to learn these halachot in order, it gets very confusing.38:44 I recommend, if you're learning these halachot inside, you start learning halacha yud gimel first,38:49 then you jump back to38:51 yud bet, and then you continue to, again, do again yud gimel one more time,38:56 and then yud dalet, and then continue till38:58 yud chet. That's the way to learn it, and you'll see that's much clearer that way.39:02 Let's begin with the background.39:05 Chachamim said, they made a special gezeirah—this is39:09 all derabbanan—that one cannot read shtarei hedyotot on Shabbat.39:14 What in the world is39:17 shtarei hedyotot? So, answer is, shtarei hedyotot, like the literal translation means39:23 documents that are not kodesh.39:26 Torah is kodesh.39:28 It could be written on a document, it could be written on a letter, it doesn't make a difference, but it's kodesh.39:32 Non-Torah items are called39:36 shtarei hedyotot. What exactly falls in the category of shtarei hedyotot, we'll see soon, be'ezrat Hashem. But until now,39:42 let's just get this, that there's an issur39:46 miderabbanan, it's forbidden miderabbanan for a person to read shtarei hedyotot on Shabbat.39:51 Why? We find three reasons. The Bach brings all these three reasons.39:54 According to the Rambam, the reason is you might come to erase.39:58 If you read these documents...40:00 Give me such a bat, and you see that something you don't like, you might come to erase it,40:03 you might come to cross it out. That is forbidden mideoraita, to erase something is40:08 mideoraita; it's a issur mideoraita, so therefore Chazal would go in.40:11 According to the Rashi, no, there's a different issur. This falls under the category of40:16 hotzaat hafatzecha. If you remember, we mentioned the pasuk last week.40:19 We say, Im tashiv miShabbat raglecha, asot hafatzecha40:24 byom kodshi. You're not allowed to do things40:27 on Shabbat that are your needs on Shabbat. By you reading40:32 these documents on Shabbat, you're doing your needs on Shabbat. That's forbidden,40:36 even though you're not doing an actual melacha, but that falls under the category of hotzaat hafatzecha.40:39 There's another reason that's brought down by the Rishonim, is that it might lead you40:43 to writing. When you look at these documents, you might come to write on the side,40:48 on the margins, in a different paper. Therefore,40:51 they're forbidden. The chachamim, for all these reasons combined,40:55 forbade a person to read40:59 shtarei hedyotot. When we speak about reading, you should know, reading includes41:03 two things. Reading means, like the way I read41:07 over here during the class on the radio, where I actually express it41:11 with my mouth, I actually read with my mouth. That's one type of reading.41:15 The other type of reading means even reading with your eyes.41:19 So when we say right now, you're not allowed to read shtarei hedyotot, it means41:23 either way, you're not allowed to read it by actually speaking it,41:27 or even if you just read it with your eyes, it's also forbidden. There are exceptions,41:31 and we'll point out these exceptions. But when we say from now, as we41:35 discuss shtarei hedyotot, whenever we discuss shtarei hedyotot, you're not allowed to read. For example,41:38 when we say you're not allowed to read your phone bill on Shabbat, it means even if you read it with your eyes.41:43 So I just want to point this out, and I have to repeat it again and again.41:47 What are considered shtarei hedyotot? So there is41:50 one category that everybody agrees on, they are considered41:54 shtarei hedyotot, and then there's another category that there's machloket. What everybody agrees is41:58 shtarei hedyotot are any documents that speak about business,42:02 that speak about money. For example, your bills, your phone bill,42:07 your electric bill, that's shtarei hedyotot. You get a letter from,42:11 you get a letter, let's say, and you see on your42:14 table, even if it's open already, but you see your, what do you call it,42:18 the credit card bill, and you want to see how much was spent. It's done already.42:22 That's asur on Shabbat. That's called42:25 shtarei hedyotot. This is not debatable. Everybody agrees on this. Also included in this category,42:30 letters that have to do with money, such as letters from the IRS.42:34 Let's say you see a letter from the IRS, and they're telling you,42:37 Oh, what do they want from me now? That's called shtarei hedyotot. A letter from the DMV,42:43 and it doesn't talk about money over there. They may tell you42:46 that your license has been brought back; it's not in42:51 suspension anymore. Shtarei hedyotot. All this is42:54 shtarei hedyotot. These are documents dealing whether with money or dealing with business.42:58 Even if it's not your direct business, that's forbidden on Shabbat. Even though43:02 it's talking about things that happened in the past. L'mashal, you already know43:06 that your license has been suspended. You got a letter already;43:10 now they're sending you a second letter to confirm it, and you know how the process works.43:14 This letter is forbidden to read on Shabbat. It's done already, and you know about it.43:18 That's still called shtarei hedyotot; you're not allowed to read it.43:22 Category number two of what's called shtarei hedyotot, we have a machloket between43:26 Rashi and Tosafot: letters.43:30 Letters that people write to each other. And this letter, by the way,43:34 just means any kind of letter. It means to say, let's say43:37 I write a letter. I want to write a letter to my friend, and I'm writing to him,43:41 and I say, It's been a long time. We've been in yeshiva together. I just want to check up43:45 on you. How is everybody doing? Contained in the letter, you'll see a picture of my43:50 family. How is your family? How many kids are you up to?43:53 What are they doing? How's your business going?43:56 I can, you know, it's just a nice way of talking. That's a letter. That letter,44:01 according to Rashi, ... Why? It doesn't contain Torah.44:05 I'm not writing him to tell him44:08 a chiddush on Parshat Chayei Sarah. I'm not writing to tell him44:11 a chiddush in Hilchot Shabbat. Even if it's not a chiddush, I'm not telling him an idea, a Torah idea. That's called44:15 ... according to Rashi, forbidden to read it on Shabbat.44:20 Tosafot say, no, this letter, it's not a problem.44:24 Tosafot have an issue because they see that people read letters on Shabbat.44:27 They say, What's going on? How come you're reading letters on Shabbat? So according to Tosafot, letters that people write44:31 to each other are mutar. You know why? Because when you open up the44:35 letter, you might see things that pertain to pikuach nefesh.44:39 Once upon a time, if you wanted to communicate to someone, you could have done it in one of two ways,44:44 or three ways, but the second way and the third way is very similar.44:47 One way is to go personally to the person and tell him what you want to communicate to him.44:51 The second way is that if you can't go all the way to the other place,44:55 let's say you're living in Yerushalayim and you want to send a letter to your friend44:59 who's living in America. So either you travel to America and you tell him what you want to tell him.45:03 The other way was to send him either a messenger or a letter.45:07 So if you send a letter to your friend in America, you're telling him basically45:11 something that might be pertaining to him. You might tell him, Listen, there is a person45:14 who is coming after you. I'm sending you this letter because I know it's going to take him45:19 four weeks to get to you, and I know this letter will reach you before him.45:23 So take care. Make sure you're protecting yourself from this person, or this person's45:27 dishonest. He's coming to rob you. Be careful. So that's why it says45:31 to us, you could read letters on Shabbat because they might contain information45:36 that could be pikuach nefesh, that could save your life. However,45:39 the psak halacha is not that way. Listen to the words of Shulchan Aruch45:44 in siman shin45:48 zayin. He writes the following. He says,45:51 Shtarei hedyotot, dehainu—what are shtarei hedyotot, says45:57 Maran? Shtrei chovot vecheshbonot, which we all agree on. These are documents46:00 that speak about different types of calculations or things,46:04 monies that you owe. Also says Maran, what is also called46:11 shtarei hedyotot? Ve'igrot shel she'elat shalom, even letters which people are writing just to say hello or,46:15 you know, checking up on other people,46:19 asur likrotam. It's forbidden to read them on Shabbat.46:26 Ve'afilu le'ayin bahem, belo kri'ah, asur. Even46:27 if you are not reading them46:30 with your mouth, just to read them with your eyes, like we said, that's also forbidden46:35 on Shabbat. This is the opinion. This is the psak halacha of46:39 Shulchan Aruch.46:42 Now, that is a background, really, to46:47 shtarei hedyotot, why Chachamim were gozer on shtarei hedyotot. What are46:50 shtarei hedyotot again? These are documents that deal with money, even things that46:54 you don't need for the future, but things of the past, that's still called46:59 shtarei hedyotot. It's also in the category47:02 of shtarei hedyotot are also the,47:07 according to Shulchan Aruch, is the opinion—what Rashi says, the opinion47:10 of Rashi—and that is anything that, even letters from one to another,47:15 is also called shtarei hedyotot. See, I have only four minutes.47:19 I can't go into the Bein Ish Chai now because there's so much contained in these words,47:22 but בזה השם we're going to keep it to next week. If anybody has a question, you can call in right now.47:27 If not, we'll just basically summarize47:30 and just conclude over here by giving you the numbers to the station47:35 again,47:39 718-683-5858. This is the call-in. We'll be signing off soon, so if you'd like to call in47:42 and ask any questions off the air, you can call in now. Text in your question. You can call47:46 or text at47:50 347-927-8398. This class today on Wednesday will be repeated again tonight47:54 on JRadio.com at 11 p.m. till 12 a.m.48:02 And this, next week we'll continue with these halachot of what one could read and what one cannot, what a person could and cannot read on Shabbat.48:10 Very, very practical halachot. We'll talk about reading invitations, magazines, novels, books, which kind of the Torah you're allowed to read,48:19 and there's many, many different cases, that will all be next week. Make sure you join us on Wednesday at 2 to 348:26 p.m. Till then, have a wonderful week and Shabbat Shalom. Thank you to Iran and the whole J-Radio staff. Thank you very much. Shabbat Shalom.