Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRoot Radio here on JRootRadio.com. This is the Halacha Hour, live on Wednesday afternoon at 2 o'clock at 20:09 p.m. The numbers to the station, before we get to introduce the class, the numbers first of all to the station are0:14 718-683-5858. The text line is0:21 347-927-8398. We are here to talk about the halacha, and we're continuing in Hilchot Shabbat from the Ben Ish Hai. And0:27 today, Baruch Hashem, we have Rav Nissim Mudas in the studio, and0:31 therefore if anybody would like to call in, even in the middle of the class,0:33 you could call in to ask your questions. And of course, if you want to ask any halacha questions off the air, you call in0:40 afterwards at 3 o'clock, be'ezrat Hashem. The best way to get your questions answered is by texting0:46 this way, on the air or off the air, we'll decide when to answer them. And the number is 347, again,0:53 347-927-8398. To listen to us,0:56 there are several ways. Number one is by going to the JRootRadio.com website, and just exactly how we spelled it,1:03 JRootRadio.com. There you can listen live. You can also watch us live. We're here with live streaming.1:10 The other way to listen is by1:13 calling in to the radio line, and that is1:22 718-506-9099. With that, we will come to the class. The Halacha Hour, we discuss halachot. We work off the Ben Ish Hai, and1:29 we make it practical for our days. We also try to clarify the source of the din, and1:36 hopefully answer the more common questions by bringing in all the other opinions throughout.1:44 In the halachot that we're up to, we're up to Parashat Vayishlach. But before we get to the1:49 parashah, I just wanted to make two announcements. Number one is, we switched the clock last week already, and therefore now we have the winter schedule, and1:58 therefore we would like to announce that if anybody is around the neighborhood on Ocean Parkway and Avenue U, we give2:05 almost the same class of the Ben Ish Chai, not the same one that we give on the radio, but the same style.2:10 There is a Ben Ish Chai halacha class. We start to give every2:13 Leil Shabbat, right after Shabbat. Now that Shabbat is very, very early, so what are you going to do home?2:18 You sit there and just wait around.2:20 So if you are one of those who has extra time and you want to spend it learning, especially learning Hilchot Shabbat,2:26 we invite you to join us in the shul on 2108 Ocean Parkway.2:31 That's Avenue U and Ocean Parkway in the basement, where we will have these halachot, the debut of the2:37 season will be this Shabbat, Parashat2:40 Vayera. The other announcement is that today's class is l'refuah shelemah of Eliyahu Chaim ben Shafika Tzofia, as well as2:47 to the people in Eretz Yisrael of the incident that happened this morning with the2:52 terrorist attack, and bezrat Hashem that this will also be a refuah to them,2:59 bichlal shear cholei am Yisrael. Back to the parashah, Parashat Vayishlach. We're up to halacha bet.3:03 Halacha bet, but halacha aleph we discussed last week. We're in the subject of3:08 dibur. Like we said last week, the pasuk says, and we say it by kiddush,3:12 Im tashiv miShabbat raglecha, asot chafatzecha byom kodshi, vekarata laShabbat oneg.3:19 You have to call Shabbat as oneg. You have to declare Shabbat as a day of pleasure.3:23 Lekdosh Hashem mechubad, to an honor of Hashem, vichibadto. You have to honor Shabbat.3:29 In which ways?3:34 Measot derachecha, mimtzo cheftzecha vdaber davar. There are three categories over here. All three, bezrat Hashem, will be discussed,3:37 but we're focusing right now in the beginning part of this parashah on the concept of3:43 vdaber davar. What one may speak on Shabbat. And we explained last week there are three parts of this.3:48 One is what you speak even to yourself amongst yourself, even if you're standing by yourself.3:53 You like to talk to yourself, you like to look in the mirror and talk to yourself.3:56 There's still certain halachot of what you're allowed to say to yourself.3:59 Number two is how you communicate to other people,4:03 and that is basically talking to your friends.4:05 What subjects could you speak about on Shabbat?4:08 And number three is what you tell the goy, what you're allowed to tell the goy on Shabbat,4:14 because that's also communicating, that's also words.4:16 Which words could you tell the goy and not?4:18 And those halachot of amira l'akum, of what one could tell the goy on Shabbat,4:23 be'ezrat Hashem, will be towards the end of the class.4:26 We're going to dedicate a special subject for them.4:28 Right now we're in4:30 Halacha Bet. Halacha Bet, in order to really understand it, we need a little bit of a background.4:34 The Gemara says as follows:4:37 Vedaber davar. The pasuk says, Your words on Shabbat cannot be like your words on a weekday.4:41 That means you're restricted about what you say.4:44 So the Gemara says, dibur asur;4:46 however, hirhur is mutar.4:48 Here's a kula, here's a leniency.4:50 There's things that you're allowed to speak about,4:53 and there's things that you're not allowed to speak about.4:55 Even that which you're not allowed to speak about,4:58 it's only when you express them, when you bring the thoughts to expression.5:02 You're speaking them; they're coming out of your mouth.5:05 However, hirhur, thinking about it, is mutar.5:09 That means to think things that maybe you're not allowed to say,5:13 that's permitted on Shabbat.5:14 But this halacha is not so simple.5:16 Bein Ish Chai brings this halacha at the end of the parasha,5:18 so therefore we're going to jump a little bit to the end of the parasha.5:21 We're going to go a little bit out of order, so if you're following us in the book,5:24 you go to the end by Halacha Yud Chet and Yud Tet.5:30 Let's get to Halacha Yud Chet and Yud Tet,5:32 and from there we'll understand what hirhur is,5:34 and this way we'll understand a little bit better5:36 for the halacha that we're going to need in5:39 Halacha Bet. Halacha Yud Chet says5:41 the Bein Ish Chai, Af al pi shehirhur ba'asakav mutar, like we just said,5:44 even though it's permitted for one to think about his business dealings,5:49 yesh5:50 hirhur d'asur midina. Not everything is mutar to think about.5:53 Kegon, there's things, for example, that even though you're not saying anything5:59 asur, you're only thinking about it, it'll still be forbidden.6:01 For example,6:02 shemehalech beShabbat besadehu o b'makom shel asek melacha she'osin sham po'alim shelo6:07 bechol. You want to walk in your field on Shabbat.6:11 And to see what the field needs.6:13 Or you want to walk—let's make it a little bit practical, a case in our days.6:17 You have somewhere, somehow, or some place that they're building for you.6:21 They're fixing maybe your house,6:23 maybe they're fixing your store,6:25 and you walk by the store. You want to see the workers working on Shabbat, on the week, on Shabbat.6:31 You want to see if they did their job either on the weekday or even they're working on Shabbat.6:35 All this is assur to be done on Shabbat.6:38 What do you mean? You're not saying anything. You're just looking.6:41 You're only thinking. We said hirhur is mutar;6:43 still, it's forbidden. We'll explain why soon.6:50 Even though you're not saying anything wrong,6:52 you're just thinking about it.6:54 This is not assur midat chasidut. It's not an extra thing.6:59 This is forbidden midin.7:01 Why?7:07 Since you're walking,7:09 you're taking action by walking to a location that you normally will not walk on Shabbat,7:16 therefore,7:20 it looks clear that you're going to do something that is not mutar on Shabbat.7:27 So basically, like the way the words of Magen Avraham, the way he explains it and the Mishnah Berurah brings it down,7:32 is that—I think7:34 b'halacha—is that the only way that this thinking is assur7:38 is when everybody could tell that you're thinking about something assur.7:42 Like we said over here, this is one example.7:44 You have a location where is not in your neighborhood,7:50 and the workers, they finished working on Friday, and now you want to walk on Shabbat just to see what they did, what they did in the last week.7:59 So now you're walking by.8:00 Place, and you're looking around. You're not saying anything. You're just looking around to see,8:04 okay, are the windows up? Did the guy do his job? Did they put up the foundation?8:09 Whatever it may be. Are you saying anything? No.8:11 Nobody knows what you're thinking, but still it's8:13 assur. Why are you walking there? If it's down the block, I understand.8:15 Listen, you walk down the block, or it's on your way to shul, out of shul,8:18 it's on your way to your friend's house,8:19 and even though you're mechaven, you're really thinking that you want to walk by8:22 because you really want to check out on the house,8:25 that's mutar. It doesn't look like you're doing anything else,8:27 so it's on your way.8:28 But when you're going out of your way, you're going out of your neighborhood8:30 in a place that you normally would not walk,8:33 it's clear that you're walking by your house to check up on the house.8:36 That type of thinking is forbidden.8:39 That's one example. Another example is as follows.8:41 Let's say here in our neighborhood, we have a few avenues8:45 which are known to be commercial avenues.8:47 Most avenues, they have houses in this little Brooklyn over here that we have.8:50 But let's say by Kings Highway Avenue,8:53 I don't know, that's already, that's as far as my neighborhood goes,8:57 Avenue M. There's stores around,8:59 and you heard there's a great sale.9:01 You heard about this before Shabbat.9:02 Now you want to know if it's really true.9:03 You want to see if the sign is still up.9:05 You know that there's a sale.9:06 So you walk out of your way by Kings Highway to look at a store.9:12 So why you stop?9:13 First of all, to stop to look at a store,9:15 clearly it shows that you want to check out the prices9:18 or you want to check out the sale.9:19 Now there's another issue of reading.9:21 We'll get to that later on,9:23 but that's already a problem.9:25 Your action shows what you're thinking,9:27 and what you're thinking about is assur, that's9:29 assur. But if you're walking down Kings Highway9:31 because that's the way you go to shul,9:32 you live on9:35 Nostrand, you live on Ocean Avenue,9:36 and you want to walk down to Ocean Parkway,9:39 and you want to go to the Mir Yeshiva on Avenue R and Ocean Parkway,9:42 so on your way, you walk down Kings Highway.9:46 As you're walking down,9:47 you happen to notice something.9:48 That's fine. It doesn't look like it.9:50 Even if you're thinking about it, that's fine,9:52 because your action doesn't show that you wanted to go look at it.9:56 That is the rule of thinking.9:59 Thinking about something forbidden on Shabbat is mutar min10:03 ha-din, and only on the condition that it's not recognized,10:06 not clear from your actions10:07 that you're thinking about it.10:10 We could skip the rest of the10:12 halacha. Basically, we gave this, we gave the idea.10:16 Here the Ben Ish Chai gives examples from their days,10:18 but, you know, the example that he uses over here is hiring a horse and carriage,10:21 which I don't think any of us are doing.10:24 So we'll get to that afterwards.10:28 Okay, so that's the one10:30 halacha. Next halacha about what you're allowed to think about on Shabbat is10:39 halacha yud-tet. Af al gav de'medina im yoshev k'mo mehareher b'asakav mutar. Even though, min halacha, if you want to sit home10:42 and you want to think about your business,10:43 you're thinking, you know, I should buy this merchandise,10:45 I should set up my store in this way,10:47 I should, you know, go after this client,10:49 I should get this account.10:51 Even though min ha-din it's mutar, like we said,10:58 dibbur is asur, hirhur is mutar. But now that's only min din, the regular11:01 halacha. But there's another aspect over here, like we said in the pasuk,11:06 V'daber davar. You have to declare Shabbat as pleasure,11:08 and a pleasure of Shabbat,11:10 mitzvah shelo yechashev bahem klal. It's a mitzvah not to think about them at all.11:15 In your eyes, you should feel as your work is already completed.11:19 It's done.11:20 It's not you're done working already,11:22 even though you know that you can go back Sunday11:24 or Motzaei Shabbat right back to work. It doesn't make a difference.11:27 When it comes to Shabbat, Shabbat already is a different world.11:30 You quit your job. Graduated, you're retired,11:35 it doesn't make a difference.11:35 You're done.11:37 Try to clear your mind from any sort of weekday business.11:45 The big machshavot b'kono. Mekubalim make a big deal out of this,11:47 but even halacha, this is a time which is made for you to think about11:50 HaKadosh Baruch Hu.11:52 As the sefarim bring down,11:54 Chazal bring down11:56 that the why we're Shabbatot and Yamim Tovim given to the Jewish people.12:00 It's not that we just eat and gain extra calories12:02 so Weight Watchers make more money.12:06 We were given the Shabbaton, Yamim Tovim12:08 because we're busy, don't know weekday.12:10 We have to fulfill the curse of Adam Harishon,12:13 b'ze'at apecha tochal lechem. We're running after things that we have to run after.12:16 Shabbat, you have none of that.12:18 Shabbat, everything is off.12:20 Now, technically you could still, you know, misuse the day.12:24 You have nothing to do,12:25 so you're thinking about what to do afterwards.12:27 That's not what Shabbat was given for.12:29 Again, you can't forbid it12:31 because the Torah says12:33 hirhur is mutar. Chazal said12:35 dibbur davar only is asur. But still, like we said last week,12:39 you take away the whole life of Shabbat from it.12:42 The purpose of Shabbat is12:46 le'orer ahavah v'yirah b'lev. It's in order to inspire and instill within us12:50 love and fear for HaKadosh Baruch Hu12:51 with a great happiness.12:58 Sometimes you think about your work13:01 and you remember how your worker13:02 messed up that account with Walmart13:05 and you just lost ten million13:06 dollars. Not a good feeling to think about.13:08 So that is for sure13:10 asur. That, even though we said13:12 machshavah is mutar, machshavah that makes you worry,13:14 machshavah that brings you to sadness13:16 is asur on Shabbat.13:20 You're not allowed to have this on Shabbat.13:25 On Shabbat, what's supposed to be for a person13:27 is to have a day of rest,13:30 of calmness, and peace of mind.13:33 That's what it really is: peace of mind.13:35 I want to read you something13:36 that the Ben Ish Chai quotes,13:37 and I believe in Halacha Dalet,13:39 but he doesn't quote it,13:40 but he says to look there.13:41 I'm going to read you something very important,13:42 because like we said, machshava is13:44 mutar. But even machshava, which is13:46 mutamna din, it's important to see13:50 the mekubalim say about machshava on Shabbat.13:52 And this is from Rav Chaim Palachi.13:55 Rav Chaim Palachi was a rav, is a Sefardi from Turkey13:59 about 150 years ago,14:00 and he says something amazing.14:02 The Ben Ish Chai here quotes it.14:04 Again, he doesn't quote it,14:04 but he says to look there.14:05 I want to read a few inside.14:07 Rav Chaim Palachi writes14:09 in Sefer14:12 Kaf HaChaim, the perek—I did not record right now,14:14 we'll look at it later14:15 on—but he says the following:14:21 אמרו בגמרא, ודבר דבר, שלא יהא דיבורך של שבת כדיבורך של חול. On Shabbat, your words have to be different from the weekday.14:27 דאסור לומר דבר פלוני אעשה למחר, because the way Chazal expressed it14:29 is that you're not allowed to speak about14:31 what you're going to do tomorrow.14:32 We'll speak about these details a little bit later on.14:37 But he says over here, בקבלה בידינו—listen to14:38 this—we have a tradition,14:42 דמי שאומר בשבת איזה דבר לעשות, a person who says,14:43 I'm going to do something on Shabbat,14:46 even though in a case that's mutar,14:50 לא מסמנא ליה מילתא, it's not a good siman,14:52 which means14:53 it's not going to work out so well.14:56 והיינו טעמא—what's the reason?14:57 He says,15:01 כמו שכתבתי בשם הזוהר, כי בשבת שולט מזל שבתאי. On Shabbat, there's a special constellation that's there.15:11 וכן כתב אברהם בן עזרא על התורה, פרשת יתרו, פסוק זכור את יום השבת לקדשו. He writes the same thing,15:12 that what?15:17 כי בשבת שולט מזל שבתאי, ולא יצלח בשום מלאכה, בשום דבר. He says15:18 you're not going to be successful with any15:21 melacha, anything that a person does on Shabbat.15:22 We're not talking about only the people15:24 who mechalel Shabbat,15:24 that's for sure.15:25 We're talking about15:27 even—even dibur,15:28 even speaking about something.15:30 He says,15:33 ולא בעי בדיבור, כי בלאו הכי אסור. And not only speaking about your work,15:34 which in most cases15:36 could be a problem.15:37 Here, listen to these words:15:43 אלא אפילו מחשבה, דקיימא לן דיבור אסור והרהור מותר. Even thinking,15:45 which we just explained,15:46 according to the din,15:46 according to15:47 halacha, it's mutar.15:53 אם כל זה, מי שחושב על מלאכה ביום שבת קודש לעשותה בחול. Anybody who thinks about15:54 what he wants to do on Shabbat.15:58 Means to say,15:58 [unclear] is thinking what he wants to do.16:00 After Shabbat, ein ha-mitbarechet. There's no blessing in that machshavah, kivan shechashav aleha b'Shabbat, because you thought about it on Shabbat.16:09 Because now, you might say, okay, Sefardi, we want to listen to him.16:13 First of all, he's a mekubal. Number two is, you know where he gets this from?16:19 Kach matzati katuv b'sefer ketav yad miMeharsha. This is in the name of the Maharshal. The Maharshal is in the back of every Gemara.16:24 The Maharshal is one of the greatest16:27 Acharonim, and we could go on and on to speak about the praises of the Maharshal, but everybody knows the16:33 Maharshal. If you don't know the Maharshal, then Reb Chaim Palagi is good enough already.16:36 You know that mekubalim already means a lot.16:39 Even that which you're allowed to think about, you should not think about it on Shabbat16:43 because it doesn't have a blessing16:45 within. Maybe we could explain that's a Gemara.16:46 The Gemara says one time there's a chasid echad, there's a certain rabbi who was known as a16:51 chasid, meaning to say he always did things more than16:53 halacha. One time he was walking by his field, not because he was checking on his field;16:56 he needed some air. He wanted to air out a little bit on Shabbat.16:58 He's walking by his field, he sees that he had a fence and part of the fence was broken down,17:03 and he thought, you know, I want to fix it up.17:06 That's what he thought in his mind. According to halacha, he did nothing that's asur.17:10 But then he called himself and said, What am I doing? On17:12 Shabbat I'm thinking about what I'm going to do?17:14 In halacha, again, he did nothing forbidden,17:16 but still he decided, since I thought about it on Shabbat, I don't want to do it.17:20 And the Gemara says that afterwards there was a miracle that happened to him,17:23 that what happened is, it'slaf echad, it's a type of plant that grew over there and sealed up the fence.17:30 And the Arizal explains that this rabbi was really gilgul of17:33 Slofchad, and there's a whole big lot of things going on over there in17:36 Kabbalah. But the point that we're showing you over here,17:39 that hold on, if it's mutar, what's the problem? Do it.17:42 So this is a big rule: not everything that's mutar is recommended.17:45 That's a very, very important rule in all of these17:48 halachot. Like we said in the beginning,17:51 these halachot are a little bit dangerous to speak about17:53 because a person could technically keep the halachot of17:57 Shulchan Aruch and still remove the kedushah, the holiness of Shabbat.18:00 So that's why we said, and we're going to repeat it again and again,18:03 with every single case, even when we find a18:06 heter, I'm only going to quote what the poskim bring down,18:08 and that is a person has to be careful when using the18:14 heter and only use it when it's very, very necessary.18:17 Only to be lamed zechut on18:19 other zerizut, but for you, as far as yourself, to use it only when it's very necessary,18:23 and to be careful not to get, you know, carried away that might lead to other18:28 issurim. And with all that, we saw already in Mekubalim down18:31 that there's no blessing, there's no siman berachah, and all these things.18:34 And by us, we all know, we all run to gedolim to get18:37 berachot. We're always trying to do segulot for18:39 berachot. So why would you want to think about something that's not going to have a18:44 berachah? Lo shaveh. So what should you do18:46 in order for your mind not to wander?18:48 You're right, you know, what are we supposed to think about, you know?18:50 So the answer is, like Chazal tell us,18:53 the days of Shabbat and Yom Tov were given for the Jewish people18:56 in order to learn Torah and get closer to Hashem.18:58 Find yourself a class. Find yourself a book to read,19:01 a halacha book or Torah book, that means,19:03 and to read on Shabbat. Keep your mind occupied19:06 and you won't come to think about those things,19:08 and this way you'll have blessing in whatever you do.19:10 Let's go back now to Halacha Bet.19:12 Halacha Bet, Ben Ish Chai talks about something19:14 where seems to be very, you know,19:17 if you would ask a normal guy who may not be so learned in these19:21 halachot, sounds like a big19:22 issur, but it'll be mutar based on the rules that we said.19:24 Let's read the case and the19:26 halacha, and then we'll explain the rules of how to do the19:29 halacha and why this halacha is the way it is.19:32 Says Ben Ish Chai in Halacha Bet,19:37 Im tzarich lachavero le'eizeh goy lesocharo motzaei Shabbat le'eizeh melachah. Let's say you need your friend,19:41 or a goy that is not your friend.19:43 You need somebody to come to your house.19:44 You need to hire them for some job to do for you.19:50 Asur lomar lo b'Shabbat bo etzli la'erev. You can't tell him, Come to my house tonight.19:55 Even though you're not saying anything about money,19:57 even though you're not saying anything about work,19:59 you can't go up to your friend who's a plumber and say,20:01 you know, Come to my house tonight.20:03 Especially if you say, We had a big flood in our house.20:06 You know, make sure you come over tonight.20:07 That's a problem.20:08 He can't go up to a person who works by taxi,20:11 says, Come to my house tonight.20:12 You're not telling him to come by his car,20:14 but he knows to come by car.20:16 Even though you're not expressing it clearly, it's still asur.20:20 Because that's what you really want him to come over for.20:22 You're not inviting the plumber because you want to give him a piece of the cake that your wife made.20:26 You're inviting the plumber because you want him to fix the flood.20:31 You're inviting your friend who's a taxi driver because you need a ride to the airport.20:36 That's asur.20:37 And also, there are two reasons why it's asur.20:41 Number one is because your intention is because you want to hire him.20:44 Number two is,20:48 You're commanding him, telling him, Come to my house,20:51 and you're kavanah is that he should come to work.20:53 That's a problem.20:55 However,20:57 if you don't tell him, Come to my house,21:02 אלא בדרך שאלה, you're just questioning,21:04 in a way, kind of like this:21:09 אומר לו, הנראה בעיניך שתבוא אצלי בערב? You think he'd come over tonight? As a question,21:14 mutar. Even though the guy knows.21:16 You go to the guy who's a taxi driver;21:17 you always use this guy to go to the airport,21:20 and now you tell him,21:22 Hey, David, what do you think about tonight?21:24 You think you'd come by tonight?21:25 And he knows21:26 the only time you use him is for car service.21:30 Mutar, even though that's your kavanah.21:32 But since you said it,21:34 why?21:34 There's two conditions over here.21:35 Number one is21:36 you didn't mention anything about21:38 melachah. You didn't tell him, Come with your car.21:40 You didn't tell him, Bring your equipment,21:42 that he should understand.21:44 You didn't mention anything about21:45 melachah. You didn't tell him about driving.21:46 You didn't say a word about21:47 melachah. That's condition number one.21:49 Condition number two,21:50 it has to be done in a question form.21:52 You think you'd come to my house tonight?21:54 That case, in that way,21:56 it would be mutar to do such a thing.21:58 Like we said the story last week,21:59 but we got to be careful with this,22:00 right?22:01 Not to abuse it.22:02 And especially when sometimes you deal with people who are not learned.22:06 Let's say the taxi driver doesn't know22:08 halachot, and now you start22:09 telling him, You think you come tonight?22:10 Oh, you mean to pick you up to take you to the airport?22:13 That already ruins it,22:14 so then you can't get into the discussion.22:16 Only when both of you are learned of the22:18 halacha, you could ask him by not mentioning any22:22 melacha. You could come to my house tonight.22:24 Do you think you could come by tonight?22:26 Then it would be22:28 mutar. Why?22:29 And the answer is based on all the rules that we said.22:31 The words that you speak on Shabbat are restricted.22:35 The Chazal told us what you're allowed to speak about22:36 and what you're not allowed to speak about.22:37 You are not allowed to speak about things that are forbidden,22:41 like a22:42 melacha. But hirhur,22:44 but machshava is22:46 mutar. And here, what did you say?22:47 You didn't say anything about22:49 melacha. You asked the guy to come over.22:51 That's fine,22:52 even though you're thinking about a22:55 melacha. That is halacha bet,22:57 and now we'll move on to23:10 halacha gimel. Halacha gimel. Halacha gimel. Here, another heter23:12 of what a person is allowed to speak about on Shabbat23:14 and what he's not allowed to speak about.23:15 But before we get to the heter,23:16 we first need a little bit of a background23:19 just to clarify this23:23 halacha. The background is23:24 we need to explain first23:26 a concept called techum Shabbat,23:28 a little bit of halachot techum Shabbat.23:30 Techum Shabbat is, I don't know,23:32 maybe23:34 ten, twenty—not twenty, but about ten, fifteen simanim in Shulchan Aruch23:38 of eruv, techumin, and all these things.23:40 So we're obviously not going to do everything in one shot.23:42 We're just going to give a few little,23:44 just the simple23:45 halachot, just we need for23:46 small details that we need for the following23:48 halacha. Number one is23:49 there is an issur min haTorah for a person to travel23:52 a certain distance outside the city.23:55 The Torah restricts a person,23:57 and according to some it's23:58 de'oraita, according to some it's derabanan.24:00 Everybody agrees it's based on the pasuk,24:02 but the Chinuch brings it that it's a nisur de'oraita, even the Rambam.24:06 It's a nisur min24:08 haTorah. That means whichever area you're there on Shabbat,24:10 whether it be the city or, let's say, you're in the desert by yourself on Shabbat,24:14 min24:16 haTorah, only mid'oraita, Torah forbids a person to travel three24:21 parsa. Three parsa, we're going to define what these measurements mean.24:23 Parsa is a certain measurement; it's a certain distance.24:26 You're not allowed to travel three parsa outside of your area.24:28 Again, your area could be the city that you live in,24:32 which means outside your city,24:35 beyond your city, you're not allowed to travel another three24:39 parsaot. And if it's your area, that means if you're in the desert,24:42 there's no city. From where you are, you're four amot,24:45 you're not allowed to travel three parsaot min24:48 haTorah. What is a parsa? What are three24:51 parsaot? Each parsa, parsa is like saying basically yards and feet and inches, right?24:57 In order to have one foot, you need 12 inches. Make up a foot.25:00 Three feet make a yard, and so on and so forth.25:03 So same thing with25:05 measurement. Parsa is—one parsa equals four mil, okay?25:11 Each mil, how much is each25:14 mil? Each mil is a distance of 2,000 amah.25:19 Amot are measurements that Chazal use left and right,25:23 and we spoke about them a25:25 lot because they have obviously—they're very connected.25:28 So amot are 2,000 amot.25:30 How much is an amah?25:31 We said already once upon a time that there's a25:35 machloket between the Acharonim, between the Chazon Ish and Rav Chaim Naeh, of how big an amah is.25:41 To make things very simple, I'm going to use the measurement25:44 that's closer to the Chazon Ish, just for mathematical reasons,25:48 not because that's a halacha, but just to make it easier to calculate.25:51 Let's say that each amah is about two feet.25:54 So that means you're not allowed to travel three parsot outside the city26:00 mideoraita. It means that you're not allowed to travel 48,000 feet outside the city.26:05 So wherever your city finishes, so let's say you live in New York City,26:11 wherever New York City finishes,26:14 min haTorah, you can walk outside New York City up to 48,000 feet.26:17 You know how much 48,000 feet is?26:19 Nine miles.26:20 So up to min haTorah, up to nine miles,26:22 you're allowed to. But Chachamim came and said, No, no, no, hold on.26:25 You're allowed the guy to walk a little bit. He's going to walk a little bit more,26:28 and he's going to do26:30 an issur d'oraita. Chazal, like always, the Torah commended us,26:33 commended the Chachamim to make sure that we don't come to do26:36 issurei d'oraita. So Chachamim came and made a26:41 gezeirah deRabbanan, and they said, No, no, you can't travel outside the city.26:44 What the shiur of the Torah is,26:45 we're going to make an issur deRabbanan: you can't travel outside the city26:48 2,000 amah.26:49 That's 4,000 feet.26:51 That's being very gracious.26:53 That's according to all the, you know, that's very mekil, 4,000 feet.26:58 It's about three-quarters of a mile.27:01 You can go outside of the city about three-quarters of a mile.27:05 That means wherever your city finishes,27:07 you can walk outside of it 4,000 feet.27:10 Fine? That's the Chachamim's takanah, gezeirah of techum Shabbat.27:16 So most of us barely can walk to the end of the city27:19 when we talk about where it's practical.27:22 But if, in case you have a city, let's say you go to the mountains,27:25 and over there in the mountains in the summer27:27 you do have your bungalow colony over there27:30 that's considered like a city because it has more than three houses.27:33 So outside of your bungalow colony,27:35 if you want to go to the other neighbor's house,27:37 if it's more than a mile, you have an issue.27:39 How to get around that, that's already you need to learn27:43 Hilchot Eruv Techumin. That's not for us for now.27:44 We just want to know about the measurements.27:47 Now. Once we got the halachot, very simple again,27:51 min de'oraita, you're allowed up to nine miles,27:53 up to 24,000 amah, that's27:58 three parsot. Miderabbanan, you're only allowed to walk up to28:01 2,000 amot. That means you have to stop by28:04 2,000. Let me tell you two more halachot that we need to know28:06 in order to get to understand the28:09 Ben28:11 Ish Chai. The Shulchan Aruch brings down28:14 in siman shin tzadi chet, he says,28:20 Kol beit dira shehu yotzem meha'ir. Let's say you have a city,28:21 let's make bungalow colony A,28:24 and let's say you have a house where people live in it28:29 that's outside of the city.28:32 How far does it have to be in order to be considered part of the city,28:36 that you could say this is still part of the28:39 city and I start measuring my 2,000 amot from that house?28:45 The answer is,28:51 im haya beno bein ha'ir shiv'im amah u'shnei shlishim. If there was a distance of 70 amot and28:55 two-thirds, 70 amot and two-thirds, it comes out again,28:58 being very, with the more lenient opinion,29:00 with the opinion of the29:01 Chazon Ish, that's about 140 feet, which is 47 yards.29:06 It's less than half of—not even half a football field.29:08 I'm not counting the touchdowns over here,29:10 but that's 47 yards.29:12 If you have between that house and the city less than 47 yards,29:17 then, or less than that,29:19 then you could say,29:29 mitztaref la'ir, this house will be considered part of the city, v'nechshav mimena, u'k'shemodedin la'alpayim amah lechol ruach, modedin chutz mi'beit dira zeh. And therefore this house allows me to extend my29:34 2,000 amot, that I begin counting from that house onwards.29:37 So therefore, if I have, let's say, my bungalow colony, it's called A.29:42 In my bungalow colony, they have one house outside of it within 40 yards.29:49 That's great.29:50 That house now extends my 2,000 amot; that makes me29:53 closer if I want to go in that direction another29:57 2,000 amot, which is three-quarters of a mile.29:59 I can still do it because that house basically, you know, is part of the city.30:04 That's one30:05 halacha. Another halacha I need to know,30:08 and that is as follows:30:09 How many houses are you allowed to have like this?30:12 How many houses that are not really part of the city,30:14 but they're within close proximity of the city that we could have30:18 that we could still consider part of the city?30:20 Says30:25 the Shulchan Aruch in halacha vav, the next halacha in Siman Tzadi Chet, he says30:26 if you have such so many houses along the way,30:29 the distance30:32 ad mahalach kama yamim, you could have thousands of miles,30:35 but you have all the houses along these miles,30:38 one after another within 47 yards of each other.30:44 He says the halacha, hakol ke'ir achat. It's all considered like one big city,30:47 and when you want to measure the30:50 2,000 amot, you begin from that last house.30:52 So long as you have a house,30:55 and the definition of a house is any place that a person could sleep in it30:59 within 47 yards to your city,31:02 then you could go on forever like this.31:05 These are the two halachot that are in31:08 Shulchan Aruch. Another halacha that I didn't quote over here,31:10 but you should know about it:31:11 this house doesn't have to be made out of brick.31:15 It doesn't have to be that last house that the big bad wolf couldn't blow down.31:17 This house could be even from the one that was,31:20 you know, from that first little pig that you could blow down,31:22 which means it has to be as long as it's a little hut,31:24 but it's usable for a person to sleep in it,31:27 like a sukkah kind of.31:29 It's technically considered a house,31:31 and, you know, we all know a sukkah you can put up in two seconds.31:34 It depends what sukkah,31:35 but you can pretty much put it up very quickly,31:37 and that would be considered a house as far as the halachot of techum Shabbat,31:41 which means if it's outside the city,31:43 within 47 yards, it's part of the city,31:46 and it extends my techum Shabbat31:49 that I could begin counting from that house and onwards.31:52 These are the two halachot that we needed31:54 to understand the following31:57 halacha. Let's come back to halachot Shabbat31:59 of what to speak about.32:01 On Shabbat, we said you're not allowed to speak about things on Shabbat which you cannot do on Shabbat.32:08 Even if you want to speak about something that you're going to do on Sunday, or Monday, or Tuesday, anything later on in the week, it's not a problem of hachana.32:15 You're allowed to speak about what you're going to do on Sunday, Monday, as long as you don't speak about something that's assur to do on Sunday or Monday.32:21 You can't say that on Monday I'm going to buy a new pair of shoes. That's32:28 assur. But you're allowed to say, on Monday I'm going to visit my grandma, if your grandma is within, you know, where you live.32:36 Here, listen to this halacha. The halacha says as follows.32:39 The halacha says, Mutar lomar la-chavero, a person is allowed to tell his friend, Lekrach peloni ani holech lemachar. I'm planning to go to a certain city tomorrow.32:50 You're allowed to say that.32:54 V'chein mutar lomar lo, not only that, you're allowed to tell him, I want you to come with me tomorrow. I'm going to a certain city.32:57 Let's make it a little bit more, you know, with better examples.33:01 Let's say here we're living here in New York City, in Brooklyn.33:03 You're allowed to say, I'm going to Florida tomorrow.33:07 You want to come with me to Florida tomorrow?33:08 That you're allowed to say.33:10 Florida? How in the world are you going to get to Florida? There's no way you can get to Florida. You're not walking to Florida.33:14 So what are you going to do? You're going to fly. To fly to Florida,33:17 that's assur on Shabbat.33:18 Yeah, but I didn't mention anything about flying. It's mutar.33:22 So what do you think? People are going to walk to Florida? There's no way people are going to walk to Florida.33:25 You're right.33:27 But since technically it's possible to walk to Florida on Shabbat,33:32 the rule is that any time I could do it b'heter, any time I could do what I'm talking about in a permitted way,33:40 I'm allowed to speak about it, even though my intention is not to do it in a permitted way.33:44 Let's give this case of Florida.33:45 I want to go to Florida. During the week,33:49 I have tickets already reserved, and I'm taking already my airplane.33:52 I'm going to Florida. There's no question, I'm going by airplane.33:55 I'm not even driving there.33:57 Going by airplane, that's assur to do on Shabbat.34:00 I can't tell you that I'm flying to Florida.34:02 I can't tell you I'm traveling to Florida.34:04 Traveling means I'm traveling either by car, by train, by bus, or by airplane, or by ship.34:10 Some people still do that.34:11 That you can't say.34:13 You can say, I'm going to Florida, because technically you could walk to Florida.34:16 Ah, you're going to ask me in one second,34:18 we just learned the halacha.34:19 You're not allowed to walk outside the city 2,000 amot.34:23 Florida is way further than 2,000 amot.34:25 So how in the world are you going to get to Florida?34:27 Even on Shabbat, you can't walk to Florida.34:28 Once you go outside of New York City, in fact we're going to learn soon,34:32 possibly even outside of going on the Brooklyn Bridge even, for sure the Verrazano Bridge, right?34:37 Once you walk there, it's going to be a problem.34:39 How in the world are you going to walk?34:40 It's not physically possible to walk to Florida.34:44 Meaning the same from a halacha point of view.34:46 And the answer is, there is a possibility.34:49 You know how?34:50 Let's say we would set up huts along the way from New York City all the way to Florida.34:55 We'd set up these little huts all the way, each one within 47 yards of each other.35:00 What do we say beforehand?35:02 As long as I have a hut, as long as I have a35:06 burgan—Chazal call this a burganin, like a35:08 sukkah—as long as I have a place where somebody could sleep there,35:11 even though it's not there now, but since it's possible to be done,35:15 then I could speak about on Shabbat, again35:18 on the condition that I'm not saying anything that's forbidden.35:22 I can't say I'm traveling, I can't say I'm flying, I can't say I'm driving.35:27 I have to say I'm going.35:28 Going can mean any which way.35:30 And therefore I could tell also my friend, You want to come with me to Florida?35:33 Because technically it could have been done on Shabbat.35:37 That is the rule. That's the halacha over here.35:39 That's not the halacha of the Mishnah; that's only, that's the halacha of Shulchan Aruch.35:43 It's a Gemara even, the Gemara talks about this.35:47 Lech imi leKrach Ploni, you could come with me to the city.35:51 But again, the conditions are: I have to be able to do it in a mutar way, in a permitted way,35:56 and I cannot speak about anything forbidden.35:59 Even though we both understand that we're going to fly on Shabbat, we're going to fly after Shabbat.36:05 Everybody knows I have a private jet. I'm like the President of the United States. I have Air Force36:09 Two. So therefore, I'm allowed to speak about it on Shabbat as long as I don't mention anything about the jet,36:13 I don't mention anything about the plane or about traveling.36:17 But in a case where it's impossible to be done,36:21 למשל, I can't say I'm going to Israel.36:23 Why not?36:25 Because how else can you get to36:26 Israel? Swimming? You can't swim on Shabbat.36:28 Even though swimming on Shabbat is asur36:33 miderabbanan, it's forbidden to speak about anything that you can't do even miderabbanan on Shabbat.36:37 Even something that's asur miderabbanan, you cannot speak about on Shabbat.36:41 So I can't say I'm going to Israel on Monday.36:44 You want to come with me to Israel on Monday?36:46 Even though I'm speaking to myself, I can't say to myself,36:48 Oh yes, I'm going to Israel on Monday.36:49 I'm speaking to myself. Nobody's listening to me.36:51 I'm talking to my mirror, my best friend, right?36:54 The only person who doesn't argue with me.36:55 So I'm talking to myself. It doesn't make a difference.36:58 You can walk to Israel on Shabbat.37:01 The only way you can get to Israel is by doing something asur, either swimming,37:05 traveling by ship, traveling by airplane, which is what you're probably going to do,37:09 or I don't know how you can travel by car, right?37:11 So therefore, you can't speak about it,37:13 even though you're not speaking to anybody else, you're speaking to yourself. It is forbidden.37:18 Why? Because you technically cannot do it on Shabbat.37:21 But if it can be done on Shabbat, for example, I'm going to Florida, I'm going to California,37:24 even though they're very far,37:25 kavachomer if you say, I'm going to Jersey, that is permitted to be spoken about on Shabbat,37:31 even telling your friend to come with you as long as you don't mention any halacha.37:34 Question?37:35 Okay.37:36 Here brings, we have, we just hinted to a certain halacha37:40 that somebody maybe we should be aware of it a little bit more,37:46 and that is, let me just give the numbers actually one more time.37:50 If anybody would like to call in, it's37:54 718-683-5858. That's the number if you would want to call in if you have any question in halacha37:58 or what we talk about or38:02 what to call, even if we're not what we're talking about, we suggest that or we recommend that you do it after the class.38:07 347-927-8398 is the number to text in any question that you have.38:13 Question comes up is, and this question really bothered me a few years ago.38:17 I thought I found a38:19 heter, and just recently I came up to a sefer that brings not so pashut.38:24 Could a person travel to Manhattan from Brooklyn on Shabbat?38:30 How?38:30 Not by driving, of course. We're talking about walking.38:33 Could you walk from Brooklyn to Manhattan on Shabbat38:35 by walking on, you know, you could walk on the Brooklyn Bridge,38:38 or vice versa. Could you walk from Manhattan to Brooklyn?38:40 I'll tell you a story that happened with us.38:42 We were in yeshiva one time,38:43 and one of the rabbeim in yeshiva was having a shalom zachar.38:46 Shalom zachar is basically they get together on Leil Shabbat,38:50 the Ashkenazim, when they have a baby boy,38:52 and they, you know, I don't know if they have lechaim, but they have the chickpeas, that I remember.38:55 Okay, so we went to a shalom zachar by one of our39:01 rabbeim, and one of our friends was clearly missing,39:03 and he lives right there in the neighborhood.39:05 And we're there for, you know, you go to the shalom zachar way after the meal.39:08 We're already maybe four hours into Shabbat.39:10 It was a long Friday night. It was one in the winter,39:13 and all of a sudden our friend walks in39:15 wearing a baseball cap39:18 and wearing his weekday clothing.39:20 And what happened to him?39:21 He says he was driving, he got stuck in the city39:23 erev Shabbat,39:24 and the only option was,39:26 in order not to be mechalel Shabbat,39:28 he remembered he had a friend living in the city.39:30 He pulled over,39:32 and he went to their house.39:33 He dropped off the car.39:35 Of course, he parked it. He gave them the keys.39:36 They gave him a baseball.39:37 He was scared to walk with the kippah for some reason,39:39 and he decided to walk.39:40 He knew the streets of Brooklyn,39:41 and he walked all the way,39:43 I think from like 40th or 50th Street in the city,39:46 all the way to Brooklyn.39:47 All the way to Flatbush, that is.39:50 Obviously, how did he get here?39:51 He walked over the bridge.39:52 Question is,39:54 ... Why not?39:56 Well, the city, the definition of a city39:59 is not what we—40:00 Would call a city if it's on the map, it's called a city. If the mayor decides to call it one city, it's one of the boroughs of the city.40:06 A city is defined, like we said beforehand, by the way the houses are situated.40:10 If you have a house that's more than 47 yards away, that's not part of the city anymore.40:16 It's definitely more than 47 yards between Brooklyn and Manhattan.40:19 And how long is a bridge? Is a bridge 2,000 amot or more?40:25 Is it more than three-quarters of a mile? I think so,40:28 for sure the Verrazano, but the Brooklyn Bridge also is more than three-quarters of a mile.40:33 So how are we walking from Brooklyn to Manhattan and from Manhattan to Brooklyn on Shabbat?40:39 We're walking outside the city, which is, let's say, from Manhattan to Brooklyn,40:42 we're walking outside Manhattan more than 2,000 amot,40:45 and I don't think anybody is putting up a eruv techumin over there.40:48 So what's the heter? Is there a heter or not?40:52 Originally, I saw a heter that's brought down by40:57 Mishneh Halachot. Mishneh Halachot is the Ungvar Rav zatzal,41:01 Rabbi Nashe Klein,41:03 zecher tzaddik livrachah. He used to live here in Brooklyn, in Borough Park,41:04 and then he moved to Eretz Yisrael in the last years of his life.41:07 Anybody who is familiar with Hacham Ovadia's sefarim, you see that he quotes him a lot.41:12 If you're familiar with halachah, you'll know how important Mishneh Halachot is,41:15 one of the great poskim of our generation.41:17 He passed away not so long ago, I think about five, six years ago, on Rosh Hashanah.41:22 So the Mishneh Halachot, I don't remember where it was,41:25 I remember seeing it clearly.41:26 He says it's mutar for the following reason.41:29 He said that they told him, and it's true,41:31 when you drive in the tunnel, you ever see those booths in the tunnel?41:34 So the booth in the tunnel over there is where people are supposed to be41:38 there technically, or it allows people to be there.41:40 He says since people could technically be there on Shabbat,41:43 so that's considered like a burgan,41:45 that's considered like the little hut that connects it to the city.41:49 And since there's many of these booths along the way of the tunnel,41:52 that is a heter why people could even use the bridge,41:55 because the city of Manhattan and the city of Brooklyn are connected to each other.41:59 It's all considered part of one city,42:01 and therefore even though you're walking above the water and the tunnel is inside the water,42:05 that is permitted to be done on Shabbat.42:08 That is the opinion of the42:10 Mishneh Halachot. That's how he is melamed zechut for people walking from Brooklyn to Manhattan and vice versa.42:16 Why? Because the tunnel, with the boots in the tunnel connects them.42:20 Now, again, time before we said it's possible to put42:23 boots. This is only—when we said it's possible, that's only to talk about on Shabbat.42:27 When it's possible to be done42:29 b'heter, you're allowed to speak about it on Shabbat as long as42:31 you're not doing melacha. But to actually physically walk from Brooklyn to Manhattan,42:34 it's only mutar if there's actually real boots over there and there's people there.42:38 According to Mishnah Berurah, as long as people can be there, it's mutar.42:43 However, recently I came across Shut Shevet HaLevi,42:47 also one of the great poskim of our generation,42:49 Rav Shmuel HaLevi Wosner from42:52 Bnei Brak. Also, Shevet HaLevi is, I think, 11, 12 volumes on42:56 halacha, again, always quoted by the poskim, Shevet HaLevi.43:00 And I saw something very interesting.43:03 He gets the question from one rabbi in America43:06 who asked him this question about the Brooklyn-Manhattan bridge,43:10 and the rabbi who writes in the question says he wants to be matir43:13 it. However, Shevet HaLevi didn't like the proofs that this rabbi brings,43:18 and he himself said, You know what? I don't like what you bring.43:21 I don't feel that I can be matir based on the proofs that you bring.43:25 But at the same time, he says, I don't want to be oser. Why?43:27 Because I don't live in America,43:29 and you have rabbis in America. Let the rabbis deal with it.43:33 So therefore, he said, Don't put me on the side of the poskim that say43:37 mutar, and don't put me on the side of the poskim that say43:39 asur. If I was living there, I could give a psak. It seems like it's43:42 asur, but I don't live there, so therefore ask the rabbis that are in America.43:46 They live in the place. They know the area better.43:49 I'm staying out of it.43:51 You learn a lot from the Shevet HaLevi.43:53 Number one is—by the way, keep in mind, Shevet HaLevi43:58 is—there's a teshuva in Yabia Omer where she quotes Shevet HaLevi44:01 of a book from about 75 years ago.44:05 That's how already, he was already being quoted in halacha from 75 years ago.44:10 So that is for sure one of the biggest poskim.44:12 And still, he said, You have rabbis,44:15 they know the area. I'm not in the city.44:16 I'm not in the area. I'm staying out of it.44:19 Let the gedolim in your area deal with it.44:21 Even though he could have given psak halacha very easily and permitted or be44:25 oser, he said he's not there. He doesn't want to get himself involved in it.44:31 This is basically the issue:44:33 could you walk or could you not walk?44:35 There is heterim. At the same time, there are people who are44:38 osrim. If a person has a situation where he has to walk and he has to cross a bridge,44:43 just make sure you ask your rav and see what your rav holds.44:47 There are ways this way and there's ways that way.44:49 You should ask your local44:51 rav. You should ask him what the psak halacha of what your, let's say,44:56 minhag is, but what your rav is going to be posek in that area. One more small little detail before we get to the next halacha on Shabbat.45:01 The Chesed LaAlafim, who is the author of Pele45:06 Yoetz, Rabbi Eliezer Papo, he says that there's a minhag amongst people that they say,45:10 which is done really45:12 b'amei ha'aretz, and he says that there's no heter for it in45:13 halacha. We're just pointing it out because some maybe may not be familiar with it.45:18 He says people come, they talk about things that are forbidden to be done on Shabbat,45:20 but they add the words,45:23 Bli amirat Shabbat, without talking about Shabbat,45:24 and then they go on and they talk about all the things that are forbidden on Shabbat.45:27 He says that's complete nonsense.45:29 That's minhag of burim45:32 and amei ha'aretz. What does it mean, bli amirat Shabbat?45:33 What do you think, you can just declare,45:35 I'm not going to be mechalel Shabbat and get into a car?45:37 That's silly.45:38 You think you can just say,45:39 I'm not going to talk about things forbidden on45:41 Shabbat and then talk about things that are forbidden on Shabbat?45:43 There's a term even that's famous, everybody knows it,45:45 Nish45:46 Shabbes geredt. It means nothing, nish45:48 Shabbes geredt, and then you go on and talk about something45:50 that's assur. If it's assur, you can't talk about it.45:51 It doesn't make a difference what introduction you give45:53 before you speak about it or after you speak about it.45:56 So we just wanted to point that out.45:57 You can't speak about something that's forbidden46:00 by introducing that it's forbidden.46:02 The only way it's mutar, like we said,46:04 is by not mentioning any46:07 melacha, and also by not commanding somebody to do something that's forbidden.46:11 These are, up to now, we did two halachot, Halacha Bet and Gimel.46:15 Move on now to46:17 Halacha Daled. Halacha Daled is pretty quick.46:20 Says the Ben Ish Chai in46:25 Halacha Daled, Even talk about things that have nothing to do with something forbidden on Shabbat,46:31 asur46:32 leharbos b'Shabbat. He can't talk too much about it on Shabbat.46:34 Why?46:39 Because your words on Shabbat46:43 should not be like the way you speak during the weekday.46:45 We mentioned this last week's class,46:48 that Chazal didn't say, Talk about this and talk about that.46:51 It says,46:57 Diburcha b'chol lo yehei kediburcha b'Shabbat kediburcha b'chol. Don't let your words on Shabbat be47:02 like the way you speak during the weekday.47:06 So therefore, even though you're not talking about any47:10 melachot, it's still, you cannot speak about things that are not Shabbat talk.47:24 And people who enjoy talking about the news,47:26 and again, they're not talking about47:27 melachot, they enjoy talking about the news,47:28 they enjoy talking about stories and things that develop in the world.47:33 They enjoy it,47:34 and they're not talking about anything that's forbidden.47:36 Of course, we're not talking about47:37 lashon hara. We're talking about regular, kosher, basically kosher weekday talk,47:41 and we're not mentioning any47:43 melacha. The Ben Ish Chai brings over here the heter of the47:46 Rama, that you're allowed to speak about it, but you can't speak too much about it.47:49 This, however— is debated.47:51 A lot of poskim don't like this opinion of the47:53 Rama. A lot of Acharonim argue on the Rama in this47:57 halacha, and they say, no, it's not. Just because you enjoy it.48:00 It's not so simple that you could talk about it.48:02 The Rama even goes further, and Ben Ish Chai doesn't bring here.48:04 The Rama says that if you don't enjoy, but somebody else enjoys it, you're allowed to speak about it.48:10 And again, Acharonim don't like it so much.48:12 So therefore, we tell you, like we say with almost all these things,48:16 that if you don't enjoy it, for sure you shouldn't speak about it.48:19 If somebody else enjoys it and you feel that's going to give me a little bit of oneg Shabbat48:22 just to get them into the Shabbat, you know, atmosphere,48:25 it could be maybe you're dealing with somebody who's newly observant,48:28 or some guests just, you know, make you feel comfortable in the house,48:31 whatever it may be, fine.48:32 But in general, if it's nothing to do with spirituality on Shabbat, try to avoid it.48:39 Again, even though it's mutar, but try to avoid it.48:41 The Zohar brings down that when Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai's mother would talk about something on Shabbat,48:49 even though it's permitted but wasn't spirituality,48:52 the Zohar would tell48:53 her, Ima, Shabbat hayom, and right away, Shabbat hayom, she would stop right away.48:58 This ad kan we spoke about the heterim.48:59 I want to read you now something from the49:02 Shlah. This is very, very sharp, the words of the49:05 Shlah. He says, you know, I don't know if it should—let me just read a few lines.49:10 Let's read the very sharp.49:11 If you want to see the Shlah, the Shlah is in49:14 Parshat Vayakhel—excuse me, not the Shlah, sorry.49:16 This is the Alshich. Moshe Alshich, who lived in the time of the Beit Yosef,49:21 who lived in the time of the Arizal.49:23 This is in Tzfat over there.49:25 If you go to the cemetery in Tzfat, you see the49:28 Alshich's kever. The Alshich was a darshan, was known as the, basically, the pulpit rabbi,49:34 but of course he was a huge talmid chacham in the times of Maran Beit Yosef.49:39 And he writes in this פירוש on Parshat Vayakhel the following.49:41 He says,49:51 ובכלל הדבר הזה תגדל אשמת המשתעשעים ביום השבת לקרוא בספרי סיפורי מלחים ומלחמותיהם ביום השבת, מתענים לו מר כי הוא עונג שבת. He's criticizing, basically, those who talk about the news49:55 and all the different things and the wars and everything that's going on49:58 on the weekdays, and they talk about it on Shabbat and they say,50:00 Listen, I enjoy on Shabbat.50:02 He says,50:09 ואוי להם, כי היו כמבזית הקודש בשיחתם להם, ואת קדוש ישראל ניאצו, כי עשוו בהבליהם. He says, Woe to them.50:10 They're angering Hashem with all this.50:16 והם, במה הם מעלים? כי בין קודש לחול לא הבדילו. They're not distinguishing between the weekday and the Shabbat.50:25 והיא להם שומר שבת מחללו, כפועל בטל עבד לו שכר בעמלו. And they think that Shabbat is as long as you sit and you don't go to work,50:29 and that's good.50:35 כי חפץ ה' בשמירת שבת, לנחמנו ממעשינו ומעצבוננו, בצאתנו מעשה. People think, or the people in this time,50:37 that Shabbat is that Hashem wants to give us a break.50:41 Hashem feels bad for us.50:42 We're working too hard.50:43 Hashem says, You know what?50:44 Take Shabbat off.50:49 ויצוונו לעשות יום השבת קיבול נוחו, יגיע כוחו, וזאת מנוחה וזאת מרגוע לחומר, העושה כל מלאכה. So basically, Hashem, give us a break from our physical labor on Shabbat.50:59 אכן אמרו, אמור, אין כספי פיזי, וחולו בימים ויכולו שבוע, ודשן לדשן עצם. Great if it's made for my pleasure,51:02 if Shabbat is made for me to enjoy. Guess what?51:04 I enjoy talking about these51:05 things. I enjoy talking about those things, or the news that's going on.51:23 He says afterwards, ולא זאת המנוחה, ... כי ... יצר ... ותחסם אותו, כי מלחלך השם הוא קנא נפש אדם, כי תקרא ביום השבת, אלוקים אשר נתנה ויתן לה מתת נפש יתרה. So that's not the idea of51:30 menuchah. Think about it, rabotai.51:31 When we said that God created the world in six days,51:33 and then He rested on Shabbat,51:37 a simple question:51:38 How did God create the world?51:40 Did He take a screwdriver?51:43 Did He take a drill and some nails?51:45 How did He create the world?51:46 Hashem, you know how He created the world?51:47 With His words.51:50 ויאמר ה', ויאמר ה'. And from those words, what does it say in the Torah?51:55 וביום השביעי שבת מנפש. On Shabbat He took a break.51:56 From what?51:57 What did You do that's asur?51:59 You just spoke.52:00 That's52:01 exactly—it's not an idea of working or not working.52:03 You can have the easiest job52:04 and still, it's52:06 still—that's, you're not allowed to do.52:07 The idea of Shabbat is, like here,52:10 and all52:11 the sefarim bring down like that, the shiur brings down, it's a day for the soul.52:14 It's a day where you put away the weekday things52:16 in order that your soul should connect to52:19 HaKadosh Baruch Hu. That's the purpose of it.52:20 So it's not just what you enjoy;52:22 it's what your neshama enjoys.52:23 Your neshama enjoys spirituality, Torah, and mitzvot.52:27 And this will stop over here,52:28 but, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll continue next week,52:31 Wednesday, live.52:32 If anybody has a question, you can call into the station.52:34 We're here for another five, ten minutes,52:38 718-683-5858. We'd like to give thanks to Rav Nissim and J-Root Radio52:40 and the whole J-Root Radio staff.52:43 This show will be on again tonight52:45 on52:46 JRootRadio.com at 11 p.m. to 1252:49 a.m. We'll see you again next week.52:50 Till then, have a wonderful week and Shabbat shalom.