Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to Halacha Hour on Wednesday afternoon here on JRoot Radio.0:06 To listen to us on the radio, it's 97.5 FM,0:09 and online it's at0:13 jrootradio.com. To call into the studio, the numbers are0:19 718-683-5858. That's the number if you want to call into the station.0:21 And the text is0:26 347-927-8398. We're here. We have the Halacha show where we talk about,0:30 guess what, Halacha,0:31 and we're learning the halachot of nerot Shabbat,0:35 candle lighting on Shabbat.0:37 And be'ezrat Hashem, we will be taking questions, but just a little bit later on,0:40 not right away. We're going to be taking questions a little bit later on,0:44 and so if you want to text it in, you can text it in from now,0:47 but we will not answer it till afterwards,0:50 okay? Also, if you want to call in, I apologize,0:52 I'll probably not be picking up the phones0:54 until a little bit later on in the show.0:55 So first let's get through some of the halachot that we want to talk about,1:00 and then we'll take questions on any of the halachot that we said today1:04 or in the previous classes,1:06 and be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully we'll be able to answer them,1:09 okay? Just a little bit of a quick reminder:1:11 we're learning the halachot of hadlakat nerot.1:13 We're working off the sefer, the Ben1:16 Ish Chai. It's in Parashat1:18 Noach. I believe the halacha that we're up to1:21 is halacha chet.1:22 Before we got to halacha chet1:24 last week, we left off for the last few minutes1:29 to—we were talking about a little bit of a very important subject,1:32 and that is:1:33 must a person accept Shabbat1:35 by candle lighting or not?1:37 And that's a very, very important subject,1:39 very important halacha.1:41 Unfortunately, because of the time,1:43 I did not have the chance...1:47 To explain it fully,1:49 so, mazrat Hashem, we'll try to do it again1:51 one more time, this time,1:52 and hopefully to give a full explanation1:54 of this halacha1:57 of accepting.1:58 The question is, should we accept Shabbat or not?2:01 Okay, so let's begin,2:02 mazrat Hashem,2:04 with the first step first.2:08 We said last week there's an opinion called the Bahag.2:11 The Bahag is one of the Rishonim2:12 who lived over a thousand years ago.2:15 He's known for his2:16 book, the Halachot Gedolot. And this holy rabbi said2:19 that when Shabbat Friday afternoon2:22 is on2:23 Hanukkah, Hanukkah and Shabbat come on the same time,2:26 and now Friday afternoon you want to light2:28 candle, you want to light2:30 for2:32 Hanukkah, meaning you want to light for Shabbat.2:33 Obviously we can't light Hanukkah candles on Shabbat;2:35 that's2:37 issur d'oraita. So says the Bahag, in such a case,2:39 don't light first the halachot nerot of Shabbat.2:43 Don't light the candle lights,2:44 the candles of Shabbat first,2:45 and then afterwards come to light the menorah.2:47 Do not do that,2:49 because once you light the2:51 menorah—excuse me—once you light the candles for Shabbat,2:54 then you've accepted Shabbat2:55 and you won't be able to light the menorah for2:58 Hanukkah. That's the opinion of the Bahag.3:00 That's the opinion of him. Clearly from the Bahag it comes out3:02 that one who lights the candles3:04 on Friday afternoon3:06 accepts Shabbat,3:08 okay? That's the opinion of the Bahag,3:09 and many Rishonim went with the Bahag.3:11 There's the Ran, the3:13 Or Zarua, and Beit Yosef, name of the3:15 Mordechi. A few opinions went with the Bahag,3:16 okay? So that explains also the minhag3:19 why some women have—the Beit Yosef brings3:21 down—there's a custom that some women would have3:23 that after lighting the candles,3:24 they would throw away the candle.3:26 Usually you shut off the3:27 candle, but being that kibui is one of the3:31 melachot from the Torah, it's3:32 an issur d'oraita to shut off a candle,3:34 so therefore the women would just throw away the3:38 candle and let it fall to the3:39 ground because they already accepted Shabbat3:41 by lighting candles.3:41 This is one approach to accepting Shabbat3:45 on Friday afternoon,3:47 that it happens by candle lighting.3:50 However,3:50 you have another group of Rishonim,3:53 led by the Ramban,3:54 and then you have the Rashba, the Rosh,3:56 the Tur, and the Tosafot,3:58 also big Rishonim, and they disagree with the Bahag.4:01 They say, no, there is no obligation4:04 for a person to accept Shabbat4:06 while lighting candles.4:07 You want to, kol hakavod, you could,4:09 but you can't tell me that4:11 a person is obligated to accept Shabbat4:13 by candle lighting.4:13 This is basically the two main opinions.4:15 They hold that accepting Shabbat comes4:17 when a person begins the4:20 tefillah Arvit, which begins with the words4:22 Baruchu, Hashem mevorach. Good? So let's review very quickly4:24 the two opinions are:4:25 you have the Bahag, the Rishonim led by the Bahag4:28 on one opinion, on one side,4:30 and they hold that a person accepts Shabbat4:32 when lighting candles.4:33 And then you have the other opinion,4:36 led by the Ramban,4:37 you have the Rashba and Tosafot,4:39 and they hold that you do not have to4:42 accept Shabbat by lighting candles; rather,4:44 you accept Shabbat when you begin4:45 the tefillah of4:47 Arvit. Now, in the opinion of the Bahag,4:49 there is another disagreement of how to understand the Bahag.4:52 Does the Bahag mean4:53 that when you light candles,4:55 you must accept Shabbat,4:58 and by all means5:00 you can't get out of it?5:01 That's it, you're stuck. You lit the candles,5:03 you're stuck, and therefore5:04 you have to accept Shabbat. Or maybe5:08 the normal custom is to accept Shabbat,5:10 but if a person doesn't want to5:12 accept Shabbat, you can't force him to accept Shabbat5:13 against his will, meaning can a person make a5:15 condition to say, I'm lighting5:17 candles and I don't want to accept Shabbat.5:19 Could he do such a thing or not?5:21 That's also machloket Rishonim.5:23 The Mordechi, and the5:25 Hagahot Maimoniyot holds that when the5:27 Bahag said you have to accept Shabbat, it5:29 means if you didn't think about it, then you accepted Shabbat.5:31 But if you want to make a condition,5:33 it works. You have, on the other hand,5:35 the Tashbetz, and the Tashbetz says5:37 no. If you5:39 had kavanah, if you had intention,5:41 and you made a condition, I do not want to accept5:43 Shabbat by lighting candles,5:44 according to the Bahag, sorry, it doesn't work.5:47 You must accept Shabbat5:49 by candles; no condition would work.5:51 That's the5:53 machloket rishonim, the opinions before the5:54 Shulchan Aruch came to write his book,5:56 the Psak Halacha. Now, we follow the opinions of5:59 the Shulchan Aruch, but I'm showing you6:00 where the Shulchan Aruch gets, where he's coming from.6:02 There's a whole, you know, rabbis6:04 who've discussed this for hundreds of years.6:06 Now, when it comes to6:09 the Psak Halacha, the Shulchan Aruch rules as follows.6:10 He says like this.6:12 Shulchan Aruch writes, he brings6:14 the opinions of everybody. He brings the opinions of the Bahag.6:16 He brings the opinions of,6:18 as well as the Tosafot6:20 and the Ramban, who disagree, and they say that6:22 Kabbalat Shabbat is by6:23 Barechu. But from the style that he6:25 writes it, it comes out that it seems to be6:27 that according to Shulchan Aruch,6:29 he doesn't go with the opinion of the Bahag,6:31 which means he goes with the other opinion,6:33 that accepting Shabbat6:35 happens when a person6:37 prays6:39 Arvit. Now, according to the Shulchan Aruch, when a person says6:41 Mizmor shir leyom haShabbat, once he says that6:43 in the Kabbalat Shabbat, he accepts the Shabbat.6:45 But beforehand, if he lights the6:47 candles beforehand, he does not have the6:49 obligation of accepting Shabbat.6:50 That seems to be the6:52 consensus of opinions6:54 explained in Shulchan Aruch.6:56 Okay, this is found in6:58 siman reish samech7:00 gimel. That's where you find these halachot, samech7:02 gimel, I believe, halacha yud. Okay, the discussion7:04 of all this.7:06 Now, the7:09 Rama, who7:11 the Ashkenazim follow,7:12 he writes that the minhag7:14 is that the women do accept7:16 Shabbat by lighting, unless they make a condition.7:19 Okay, so here7:20 you have Shulchan Aruch going like one opinion,7:22 the Bahag, and he says—I mean, not like the7:24 Bahag, you don't have to accept Shabbat.7:26 And the Rama says that the minhag is, the custom7:28 by the Ashkenazim is that they do accept Shabbat unless7:30 they make a condition.7:32 So even the Rama, who went with the Bahag,7:34 that you have to accept Shabbat, he also went with7:36 the opinion that says you could make a7:38 condition not to accept Shabbat. Good?7:40 Now, even though the Rama says7:42 you could make a condition,7:44 the Acharonim of the Ashkenazim,7:46 the rabbis of the Ashkenazim that came after the Rama,7:48 they explain, like the Mishnah7:50 Berurah, Magen Avraham, they all wrote down that7:52 women shouldn't just make conditions7:54 every time.7:55 She should only make a condition not to accept7:58 Shabbat by candle lighting.8:00 It's necessary. If it's not necessary, then she should accept Shabbat by candle lighting.8:07 Clear? I hope this is clear. This is what the rulings of the Shulchan Aruch and the8:14 Rama. Here we have the customs of the Sefardim and the Ashkenazim. According to the Sefardim who follow the ruling of the Shulchan Aruch,8:21 the woman does not have to accept Shabbat by candle lighting. According to the8:26 Rama, she should accept Shabbat by candle lighting. She has to accept it by candle lighting unless she makes a condition otherwise.8:34 Now, one more thing, a few more things, just a clarification on this halacha.8:39 You should know because now we're in the month of Kislev, and be'ezrat Hashem, probably next week we'll start talking about the halachot of Chanukah.8:45 There is a halacha by Chanukah that Shulchan Aruch brings down. Now, based on what I just told you,8:50 what do we say? The whole halacha of accepting Shabbat by candle lighting comes from the Bahag,8:56 and he says this halacha of accepting Shabbat by the laws of Chanukah.9:03 So technically, if we go with the ruling of Shulchan Aruch, when we come on Chanukah9:08 and we come in to light the candles on Friday afternoon for Shabbat and for Chanukah,9:13 technically we can light whatever one we want first. If we want to light Shabbat candles, we can light it,9:20 not accept Shabbat, and then light the menorah. However, you look at Shulchan Aruch in Hilchot Chanukah. He rules over there like the Bahag,9:26 meaning he says when it comes to Friday afternoon a person is lighting candles and he has two sets of candles to light,9:31 he has to light the candles of Chanukah and he has to light the candles of Shabbat.9:35 What should he do first? Says the Shulchan Aruch, first he should light the candles of Chanukah,9:43 and then afterwards he should light the candles of Shabbat.9:46 So now that brings up a big question.9:50 Here in siman reish samech gimmel, in Hilchot of Shabbat candles,9:57 Shulchan Aruch seems to rule not like the minhag, that you don't have to accept Shabbat.10:01 Yet if you turn to halachot of Chanukah on Friday afternoon, when you're lighting right before Shabbat,10:08 it seems like the Shulchan Aruch is ruling like the minhag, who says that first you light the candles of Chanukah10:14 and then the candles of Shabbat. So what's going on?10:17 So the explanation is, how do you reconcile the two opinions, the two different statements or contradicting statements from Shulchan Aruch?10:23 The answer is that lechatchila, it is always preferable, even according to the10:29 Sefardim, that a woman should accept Shabbat by lighting candles on Friday afternoon.10:35 It's preferable. She doesn't have to, but it's preferable.10:39 And the proof is, look, Shulchan Aruch ruled that way when it comes to Chanukah.10:43 This doesn't mean to say that we dismiss the opinion of the10:46 minhag. No, it's preferable. We just are not obligated to.10:50 Where according to the Ashkenazim, they seem to be more obligated to accept Shabbat unless they make a condition.10:56 Okay? With that, we'll go on now to the next step, and that is a little bit of a clarification on this halacha that we said.11:03 When we said that a woman should accept Shabbat lechatchila to the11:06 Sefardim, and according to the Ashkenazim, who say that a woman who's lighting the candles has to accept Shabbat,11:13 this only refers to women.11:16 Even Ashkenazim don't have a custom that when the man lights Shabbat candles, that he has to accept Shabbat.11:22 That's very important.11:24 For let's say a single guy is living by himself, he's eating at home, or he's sleeping at home, as we're going to learn.11:31 If he lights candles in the house, he doesn't have to accept Shabbat.11:34 He can light the Shabbat candles on Friday afternoon and then get into the car and drive to Shabbat afterwards.11:39 There is no custom, even for Ashkenazim, that a man has to accept Shabbat when lighting the candles.11:46 Now. The other thing that we want to clarify is that if a woman is accepting Shabbat by candles,11:56 and this now doesn't make a difference if you ask Ashkenazi or11:58 Sefardi, if a woman decides to accept Shabbat by candle lighting, this doesn't obligate anybody else in her house,12:05 not her husband, not her kids.12:07 She wants to accept Shabbat, and let's say the husband's running a little bit late.12:10 Now she's standing there, she's accepting Shabbat, and she says,12:13 Oh, holy Shabbos, and she's lighting the candles, and now she says, I accepted Shabbat.12:18 The husband could still get into his car and drive to shul.12:21 Just because his wife accepted Shabbat, it doesn't obligate the husband.12:24 And not only that, it doesn't even obligate the kids in the house.12:27 If the kids are in the house and they don't want to accept Shabbat yet, they don't have to.12:32 Only the custom is only by the woman who's lighting the candles only.12:37 Again, it's a woman, and she's the one who's lighting the candles.12:39 Even her own daughters don't have to accept Shabbat.12:42 And again, unless they decide if they want to accept Shabbat, they could,12:45 but they don't have to. Just because the mother accepts Shabbat, they don't have to.12:49 Okay?12:50 Now, another thing that we have to keep in mind: which candles are we talking about?12:55 Which candles are we talking about that a woman has to accept Shabbat?12:58 And the answer is the candles that she's going to light last.13:03 And usually we said in the past that the candles that she should light last are the ones that she's going to make a blessing on,13:08 and that's the one that is lit where a person is going to have his seudah on Leil Shabbat.13:13 If you eat your meal on Friday night in the dining room, so that should be the last candles that you light,13:20 and over there you should make the blessing and light the13:23 candles, and that one over there is what we talk about that a woman should accept Shabbat.13:27 But if she is lighting the lights in the house,13:29 she's lighting the lights in the kitchen, in the bedroom, and everywhere else,13:32 and now she hasn't lit the candles on... In the dining room yet,13:37 she doesn't have to accept Shabbat yet.13:40 Another important point to point out, even though we're far away from the next holiday, especially in this leap year,13:47 the custom of accepting Shabbat is only when you light Friday afternoon.13:52 If you're lighting erev Yom Tov, let's say the holiday is on Monday night,13:59 okay? So now Monday afternoon, right before candle lighting time comes, when lights14:04 again, there is no custom that a woman should accept Shabbat, should accept the holiday earlier.14:10 There is no such minhag to the Ashkenazim,14:13 again to the Sefardim also.14:14 Sefardim never have to accept Shabbat,14:17 but there is no custom. Since there is no custom, when a woman lights candles on erev Yom Tov, Ashkenazi or14:25 Sefardi, she does not have to accept the holiday of Yom Tov yet.14:28 If she still wants to do whatever melacha that's forbidden to do on Yom Tov, she could.14:32 The custom is only on Friday afternoon, the candles of Shabbat,14:37 and only the woman who is lighting it and not the man if he is lighting.14:43 Only that there is a custom that she should accept Shabbat to the14:48 Sefardim, and according to the Ashkenazim, she must accept Shabbat by candle lighting unless she makes a condition.14:53 I hope that halacha is clear.14:56 This, believe it or not, is only an introduction to the next point,14:59 okay? The next point that we're going to come speak about is a very, very important subject.15:04 There's a famous question everybody asks, Sefardi, Ashkenazi, everybody has the same question,15:11 and be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully today we'll clarify this point,15:14 and that is: when you come to light candles, Ashkenazim or Sefardim, men or15:20 women, when you come to light candles on Shabbat, on Friday afternoon.15:24 Okay, do you make the beracha before you light the candles, or do you make the beracha after you light the candles?15:30 Meaning, there's two famous customs that are known.15:33 Custom number one is you make the blessing,15:36 you make the beracha, Baruch Atah Hashem,15:43 Elokeinu Melech HaOlam, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu l'hadlik ner shel Shabbat. After you say that, then you light the candles, and that's it, you're done.15:49 Right? The other custom is first they light the candles,15:53 and after finishing, after they lit whatever they lit, they have to light,15:57 then they make the beracha, Baruch...16:04 Okay, that's the second minhagim. So now we know the minhagim.16:08 The question is why, and what should a person do16:13 if the Sefardi or Ashkenazi, what should they do?16:14 So in order to explain the two different minhagim, the two different explanations,16:18 I have to take a little bit more time to explain the background to each one, what they say.16:24 Let's start with the opinion of the first minhag,16:27 and that is making the blessing first and then lighting the candles.16:31 Where does this come from?16:32 Now you should know this is the ruling of16:34 Shulchan Aruch in siman רסג, halacha ה. Maran, Klally writes that a woman who is16:40 lighting—doesn't woman, but whoever is lighting the candles—should first make the blessing on the candles16:44 and then afterwards to light.16:46 Okay? Now even though you can tell me, Why?16:48 I'm Sefardi, I don't do that. We'll talk about that in the second.16:51 Just give me time a little bit.16:53 So first, where does this halacha come from?16:55 Pretty simple, I'll tell you. You16:57 know, you look in the Gemara Pesachim. The Gemara is also found in several places17:01 in Masechet Sukkah and everyone, and in a few other places in Shas.17:05 There's a rule that the Gemara brings down.17:07 The rule is as follows. Let me read it to you.17:14 כל המצוות מברכין עליהן עובר לעשייתן חוץ מן הטבילה. The Gemara says all the mitzvot, we make a blessing on them,17:20 עובר לעשייתן. עובר לעשייתן, says the Gemara, what does עובר mean?17:22 It means לפני, beforehand.17:24 Before you make the mitzvah,17:27 with the exception of17:29 tevilah. Which tevilah are we talking about?17:31 Dipping in the mikveh. We're talking about the dipping of a convert.17:34 How could a convert, if a convert wants,17:35 you know, one of the steps that the convert has to take,17:38 you know, if we're talking about a man,17:39 is he has to dip in the mikveh17:41 in order to convert to become Jewish.17:42 So how do you expect the convert to dip in the mikveh,17:46 excuse me, to make the blessing before dipping in the mikveh?17:48 He's not Jewish yet.17:49 It's only after he dips in the mikveh that he becomes Jewish.17:51 So he can't say before dipping in the mikveh,17:53 Baruch Atah Hashem...17:57 asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu. The convert cannot say that Hashem has commanded me.17:59 He's not a convert yet.18:01 We're talking about he's still a goy,18:01 so before dipping he can't make the18:03 bracha. So that's the exception.18:05 We say let him dip first,18:07 and then after dipping he can make the blessing.18:09 Otherwise, the Gemara seems to say18:11 all mitzvot you make a blessing beforehand.18:14 I'll give you just a few examples, quick examples.18:17 We make a blessing on putting on tefillin, right?18:21 So you put on the tefillin,18:23 you put the box on your arm,18:25 and before you tighten the strap you say,18:27 Baruch Atah Hashem...18:31 להניח תפילין, and then you make it tight.18:33 First the blessing, and then you do it.18:34 Talit is the same thing.18:36 First you make the blessing, and then you put on the18:38 talit. Other mitzvot, like bedikat18:40 chametz, you make the blessing18:42 על ביעור חמץ, and then you go search for the18:44 chametz. It's not done backwards.18:45 Why? Because of the18:47 rule. The rule says,18:53 כל המצוות מברכין עליהן עובר לעשייתן. So we come now to the mitzvah of lighting candles.18:56 The mitzvah of lighting candles is not different from any other mitzvah.18:59 You make the blessing first,19:00 and then you light the candles,19:02 exactly like we do by19:06 הדלקת נרות חנוכה. By Chanukah, what do we do?19:07 First we make the blessings.19:09 We make19:14 אשר קידשנו במצוותיו וציוונו להדליק נר חנוכה, then שעשה ניסים לאבותינו, and only afterwards do we light the candles.19:17 So the mitzvah of lighting candles on Friday afternoon19:18 should be no different from this mitzvah as well.19:21 Good?19:22 Now. As a rule,19:25 you should know, as a rule,19:25 the some mitzvot that are done in one second.19:29 And these mitzvot,19:31 once you do them,19:31 that's it, it's over.19:32 The mitzvah is done.19:33 You can't do anything more about it.19:34 There's some mitzvot that take a little bit of a longer time,19:37 and therefore, although you missed making the blessing beforehand,19:40 you still have a chance as long as you're involved in the mitzvah.19:42 Let me give you two examples.19:44 A mitzvah,19:45 like now, remember,19:46 this is a rule by all mitzvot.19:48 All mitzvot, you make the blessing first,19:49 and then you fulfill the mitzvah.19:52 So let's take a mitzvah of19:54 shechitah. Torah commands us that we have to do19:56 shechitah. We have to slaughter the animal in accordance to20:00 halacha, and in order for us to be able to eat it,20:03 you have to slaughter first.20:04 It's a mitzvah.20:05 The20:06 shochetim, wherever they work,20:07 when they come to do20:08 shechitah, they make a20:09 berachah. They make a blessing before slaughtering the20:11 animal, whether they're slaughtering many animals20:13 or one animal,20:14 you make a blessing,20:17 asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu al ha-shechitah, and then afterwards20:19 you fulfill the mitzvah of20:21 shechitah. Good?20:21 Let's say a person came,20:24 he took an animal,20:25 he slaughtered it20:26 without making the blessing,20:27 and then he remembered,20:28 whoa, I forgot to make the blessing.20:30 So now, according to this,20:31 what we learned,20:32 according to right now what we learned,20:33 that's it, the mitzvah is done.20:35 You did shechitah, shechitah is done.20:36 The shechitah takes about two seconds,20:37 and therefore once you did the20:39 shechitah, you're20:39 done. That's the opinion of20:43 the Shulchan Aruch. Another example20:45 where you didn't lose the berachah completely,20:48 let's say, for example,20:50 bedikat chametz. This is a mitzvah that takes much more than two seconds.20:52 It takes a long time.20:54 A proper way of doing20:55 bedikat chametz, to search under your bed,20:57 to search under the couches20:58 and in the kids' rooms20:59 and the kids' bags,21:00 that could take a good hour or two.21:03 I know some people take some four hours.21:05 So here comes the man,21:06 he wants to make the berachah of checking for21:08 chametz. The blessing is,21:10 Baruch atah Hashem Elokeinu melech ha'olam, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu al21:14 bi'ur chametz. He forgets.21:15 He starts searching.21:16 In the middle of his searching,21:18 he's looking in this candle under the couch,21:21 under the bed,21:22 and everywhere in the house.21:23 He remembers,21:24 Whoa, I didn't make a21:26 beracha. So what does he do in that case?21:27 Since he's still involved in the mitzvah,21:30 he can make a blessing21:32 because he hasn't completed the mitzvah yet.21:35 Okay?21:35 So therefore,21:36 in the middle of21:37 bedikat chametz, he remembers he didn't make a blessing,21:39 he'll say on the spot,21:40 Baruch Atah Hashem, Elokeinu Melech Haolam, asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu al21:45 biur chametz. That's the rule when coming to light21:48 the— excuse me,21:49 that's the rule when coming to fulfill any mitzvah.21:51 You must make the blessing beforehand,21:53 and if you didn't make the blessing beforehand,21:56 if you're still involved in the mitzvah,21:58 you're still fulfilling the mitzvah,21:59 you can always make the22:02 beracha as long as you're still involved in the mitzvah.22:03 Once you completed the mitzvah,22:05 then you cannot make a22:06 beracha. In fact, according to the Rambam,22:08 if a person finished the mitzvah,22:10 that's it, he's done. He finished the mitzvah.22:12 Let's take the example of22:14 shechitah. Okay, a person slaughtered the animal, he's done,22:16 and then he remembered, I didn't make the22:17 beracha. According to the Rambam,22:19 not only can you not make it,22:19 if you do make a blessing then,22:23 you've committed an22:26 issur de'oraita, beracha levatala. It's assur. That's it.22:28 The mitzvah is gone. You can't make a blessing. You lost it.22:31 Only if he's still involved in the mitzvah22:32 could you still make a22:33 beracha. Okay?22:35 So that's the opinion,22:36 the first opinion of the Shulchan Aruch.22:38 The word is, v'hacha, he says you make a blessing22:40 before lighting candles,22:42 because the rule of the Gemara is,22:47 kol hamitzvot, mevarchin aleihen over la'asiyatan. You have to make the blessing on the mitzvot22:49 before you fulfill them.22:51 And over here,22:52 you're lighting the candles,22:53 so before you fulfill the mitzvah,22:54 you have to light.22:56 If for some reason22:57 you forgot to make the22:58 beracha before you lit—23:00 And you're still in the middle of lighting.23:01 Let's say you have a custom of lighting23:03 two candles,23:05 זכרון ושמור. You lit candle number one,23:06 and then you remembered,23:07 wow, I forgot to make the blessing.23:09 So then, it's not over yet.23:11 You still have a second candle to light.23:13 You could still make the blessing,23:15 since you're still in the middle of lighting.23:18 However,23:19 if your minhag,23:20 if your custom is to light only two candles,23:22 and you already lit the two candles,23:24 and you're done,23:25 and then you remembered23:26 and did not make a blessing,23:27 according to the Rambam,23:29 it's asur for you to23:30 make—it's forbidden for you to make a23:32 blessing. It's over.23:33 That's it.23:34 What happens in the23:35 mitzvah? You fulfilled the23:36 mitzvah; you just didn't fulfill the23:39 beracha. Okay?23:39 That's the opinion of the Shulchan Aruch.23:42 That's the first way of explaining23:45 the custom of the first reason.23:47 Okay.23:48 Now we have the other custom,23:51 and everybody knows the custom23:52 that the Ashkenazim do,23:54 and that is the23:56 Rama. The Rama gets it23:57 not from23:58 his own; the Rama gets it from Mahari Weil.24:00 Mahari Vayil, he says a different way. He says like this: the Rama writes24:07 that the minhag is that they first light the candles, and then after lighting the candles,24:12 they throw away the candle from their hand, and then they make the blessing.24:17 Okay? That's the second custom.24:19 Now really, if we were following until now, we were following the class till now, I wasn't too confusing,24:24 so you should have a question right away.24:26 What is the question?24:27 The question is, how can you make the bracha after you lit the candles?24:31 Isn't it a24:33 bracha levatala? It's a bracha levatala. You already lit the candles,24:36 you fulfilled this mitzvah. How could you go ahead and light it?24:38 And you can't tell me it's a custom.24:40 The Gemara says,24:44 kol ha-berachos, what? Mevarchin alehem over la'asiyatan. And we just said, according to the Rambam, it's a24:48 bracha levatala. And the answer is that it's not a bracha levatala according to their minhagim.24:55 Why? Because the Rama writes—listen to this24:59 halacha—the Rama writes when it comes to25:01 shechitah, let's say you come to an animal,25:02 and the animal, you're not sure if it's kosher on the inside.25:06 You're not sure of the lungs—25:07 we're not talking about Beit Yosef now,25:09 we're talking about kasher and not kasher.25:10 You're not sure if it's kasher or treifah or not.25:13 So the Rama says if you make a bracha, it can be25:16 bracha levatala; you're doing shechitah, but the animal is not able to eat it.25:18 So what should you do? says the25:21 Rama, do25:22 shechitah. Afterwards check it.25:23 If you see that the animal is kosher,25:26 then you can make a25:27 bracha. So clearly, according to the25:29 Rama, he goes with the Rishonim named the Hagahot Asheri and others,25:32 who say that even though a person finished the mitzvah,25:36 he could also make the bracha afterwards.25:39 Not only it's not a25:40 bracha levatala, you could even make a25:41 bracha. Ah, what are you going to do with the Gemara?25:42 The Gemara says you have to make the blessing before you do the mitzvah.25:46 According to these Rishonim, and the Rama included,25:49 the Gemara is only talking25:52 lechatchila. The Gemara is telling you the preferable way of making blessings on mitzvot.25:56 The preferable25:58 thing, lechatchila, is supposed to make the blessing beforehand.26:00 However, if you did not make the blessing beforehand,26:03 you still have the chance to do it afterwards,26:05 and it's not a problem.26:06 It's not going to be a26:08 bracha levatala. Okay, that's the opinion of the26:10 Rama. Now the question is,26:12 if the Gemara is telling you that26:14 lechatchila it's preferable to make the blessing beforehand,26:16 so why are you making the blessing after you light the candles?26:21 So to that, the answer is26:23 that the Rama, who is going with the26:26 Maharival, he said it's based on the Bahag.26:28 Remember we just said beforehand, the Bahag,26:30 according to the Bahag,26:31 if a person lights candles, he accepts Shabbat.26:35 They understood the Bahag to mean26:37 that once you make the blessing,26:40 you accept the Shabbat.26:41 So if you said the words,26:45 Asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu lehadlik ner shel Shabbat, you accept the Shabbat.26:47 And if you accept Shabbat by the blessing,26:49 how could you light the candles afterwards?26:51 So therefore, in order to avoid this problem,26:54 light the candles,26:56 and after lighting the candles,26:58 then you can make the blessing,26:59 and you will be fine.27:00 Why? Because this way27:02 you haven't accepted Shabbat until you finish the blessing.27:04 That's how they understood the Bahag.27:05 If you make the blessing before lighting the candles,27:08 we're scared that you accepted the Shabbat by the27:10 bracha, by the27:11 blessing, and therefore make the bracha only after lighting candles.27:15 That's the reasoning of the27:18 Rama, why you make the bracha afterwards.27:19 Now, in order to try to fit in with the Gemara,27:23 which says27:25 that you're supposed to make the27:28 bracha before the fulfillment of the mitzvah,27:30 so they say the following:27:32 since the whole purpose of lighting candles27:34 is that you should benefit from their light,27:36 do the following:27:38 light the27:39 candles, and then cover the candles,27:42 that you shouldn't get any hana'ah from them.27:44 When your hands are above the candles27:45 and you don't get any benefit from the light,27:48 make the blessing,27:49 and after you make the blessing,27:51 boom,27:52 voilà, take out your hands27:53 and you'll see the light27:54 and then you'll benefit.27:54 So it comes out27:55 that you made a blessing27:57 and you have not had27:59 hana'ah, benefit from the lights28:00 until after you made the28:02 bracha. Others say also28:03 cover your eyes.28:04 The same idea.28:05 You cover your eyes,28:06 you make the28:07 blessing, and you open up your eyes28:09 and boom, right there28:09 you see the candles.28:10 So you made the blessing technically28:12 before the benefit of the lights.28:14 That's the reasoning of the28:16 Rama. Those are the two opinions.28:17 We have28:18 the—let's summarize again.28:19 We have the28:21 Sefardim, according to Shulchan Aruch,28:22 you make a blessing28:23 before lighting the candles.28:25 Why?28:25 Because that's what the Gemara says28:26 on every mitzvah.28:27 First you make the blessing28:28 and then you do the mitzvah.28:30 And according to the Ashkenazim,28:31 first you light the candles,28:32 and then,28:33 in order that it should be consistent with the Gemara,28:35 that28:37 you should have the28:38 bracha before the candles,28:39 so cover the candles,28:40 make the blessing,28:42 move your hands away,28:43 and then you benefit from it.28:44 Why do they do that?28:46 In order to28:48 not except Shabbat by the blessing.28:50 If you're saying the blessing by itself,28:51 then maybe perhaps28:52 you accept Shabbat.28:53 These are the two opinions.28:55 Now, we want to know,28:57 you know,28:58 obviously if you have your minhag,28:59 you have your minhag.29:00 You're Sefardi, you do with Shulchan Aruch.29:02 You're Ashkenazi, you do the other way.29:03 I'm not going to try to convince you now29:04 if29:05 you're Ashkenazi to do it the other way.29:05 I'm not going to convince you either one.29:08 I'm not going to tell you which one makes sense.29:09 You be the judge.29:11 You decide which one makes more sense to you.29:13 You look up this again,29:14 you decide.29:15 The question is now for the29:17 Sefardim. We know that many people have a29:21 minhag—it's brought down at least in the29:22 books—that some women,29:23 even though they're29:25 Sefardim, first they light the candles29:26 and then make the blessing.29:26 What we just said right now,29:28 according to the Rambam,29:29 it's29:30 bracha levatalah, and Shulchan Aruch clearly ruled29:32 that you have to make the blessing first29:34 and then you light the candles.29:36 Could a woman who's been noheg,29:38 who has had a custom29:40 of first lighting the candles29:41 and then making a29:42 bracha, could she switch over?29:44 Even better,29:44 does she have to switch over?29:46 Is that the same?29:46 We're going to answer this question29:47 right after this musical break,29:50 and we'll be right back. בָּנִים, וְנֵבוֹנִים, חֲכָמִים וִנְבוֹנִים. אַהֲבֵי ה׳ יְדֵי אֱלֹקִים, אנשי אמת, זֶרַע קֹדֶשׁ בה׳ דְּבֵקִים.32:00 מכרוב מעשים טובים, ובכל מלאכת עבודת ... ומעשים טובים. מכרוב מעשים טובים, ובכל מלאכת עבודת ... ומעשים טובים. מכרוב מעשים טובים, ובכל מלאכת עבודת ... ויזהר ... ... חכמים ונבונים. ... ... ... ומכרוב מעשים טובים. Okay, we are back here on JRoot in the Halacha Hour. Let me give you the number. It's a seudah. If anybody has a question, you could call in in five minutes. Let me—we have just the halacha to go over, and then, bezrat Hashem, we'll take any questions on the phone or in text. The numbers are 718-683-5858. The text number is 347-927-8398. You know, I think everybody has a phone today, a cell phone. You could just store this on your phone. You should know the JRoot number for any program that they have over here. The text number is 347-927-8398, and the studio number is 718-683-5858. Okay, just two quick announcements, bezrat Hashem, before we get back to the halacha. Number one is that probably beginning next week, we will be talking about halachot Hanukkah. I apologize that we have to cut it in the middle, but, you know, Hanukkah is coming up, and this is a halacha hour, and bezrat Hashem we'll cover the halachot from the Ben Ish Chai, and I hope that by the time Hanukkah comes, we should cover the halachot of Hanukkah and all the practical different situations that come up on Hanukkah. If you're a guest and you're going somewhere else, and all the different, bezrat Hashem, the halachot, we hope to cover them beginning next week until Hanukkah comes, and hopefully we'll be done before it comes. The second announcement we want to make is that, bezrat Hashem, now that the clock has moved back, our shul will be starting to give our yearly Ben Ish Chai class on halachot, and the same halachot that you're hearing here on the radio, we give pretty much the same style of halachot on Friday night after tefillah. So you ladies are listening, or the men are listening, ladies should push your husbands. It's a very important, in my opinion, obviously, right? So it's a32:03 halacha class where we learn the halachot, all the practical halachot. Also, we try to explain also the roots and the sources of the halachot. The shiur will take place on Friday nights in the shul by us on Avenue U and Ocean Parkway. The shul is called Beit Yosef, but we're in the basement downstairs, and that's where we're giving the classes. Mincha is usually at candle lighting time, and then we have the tefillah, and after Arvit, that's when we sit and we learn the halachot. It takes about 45 minutes. The whole class is about 45 minutes. It's very interactive. You can ask your questions, and you can hear other people's questions, and— We'll see you there, ברוכים הבאים, whoever wants to come. Let's get back to our class. We mentioned that there's two main opinions, machlokes between the Shulchan Aruch and the Rama. One, does a person have to make the blessing on lighting candles? According to the Shulchan Aruch, he writes clearly in Reish Ayin Gimel, halacha hei, that first a person must make the blessing and then light the candles, right, for the simple reason because that's what the Gemara says. You make the blessing before you fulfill any mitzvah. And the Rama writes, no, first you light the candles and then you make the blessing. Okay, we asked the question beforehand, before the musical break, and we'll come back to the question in a second. First, let's learn the halacha inside the Ben Ish Chai and see what the ruling of the Ben Ish Chai is. Now, you can tell me, Ben Ish Chai is Sephardi, so mistama he should follow the opinion of Shulchan Aruch, but you'll be surprised. Listen to the words of the Ben Ish Chai in Parashat Noach, halacha chet: Ha'isha, the woman, lo chala aleha kabbalat Shabbat behadlakat nerot Shabbat, ela ad shetesayem...40:02 Kol hanerot asher madleket. She doesn't have the obligation of accepting Shabbat until she concludes all the candles that she lights, where,40:12 b'makom hashulchan shesham tihyeh berachah shelah, in the place where she's lighting by the table where her blessing is going to take place.40:17 And says the Ben Ish Chai, what should a woman do?40:19 Ve'achar shetesayem kol hanerot, after a woman concludes lighting all the candles,40:29 techef umiyad tizrok miyadah et hapetilah shemadleket ba et hanerot. Immediately she should dispose of the, get rid of the candle that she's using to light all the candles, or the match.40:39 Vetaniach yadah aleiha, she should then cover her eyes.40:43 Vetaatzom eineha, not only just cover her eyes, but she should also close her eyes, uvarech techef, and make a blessing right away.40:53 Veshtamah piha, and there's a Kabbalistic reason why she should close her eyes at that moment.40:57 So what do you see from here?40:59 You see from the Ben Ish Chai, what does he rule?41:02 He rules clearly like the41:05 Rama. He tells you, but it's a little interesting because what does he say first?41:08 He says that she only accepts Shabbat after lighting candles,41:14 right? She only accepts it after lighting candles.41:17 And then, but he says after lighting candles, then she should close her eyes and make a blessing,41:23 exactly like the Rama says.41:24 And then he says,41:26 ve'achar sheyuma berachah, after she concludes her41:33 berachah, tiftach eineha vetireh et zerichat or hanerot, vitpashtut oram bmakomahu. She finishes the berachah, she should open her eyes and see the radiance of the light from that place.41:40 Okay?41:41 Now, as far as throwing away the candle, the Ben Ish Chai says,41:48 ve'im hamakom hahu paruz bo sedin al hakarka, and if that place is— has some sheets on the floor,41:55 v'eina yochalah lizrok hapitah ba'aretz, and she's scared to throw the chashashon, there could be a fire, let's say she has carpet, whatever, she can't throw the match away on the floor or the candle on the floor.42:06 Ta'amid echad אצלה k'dei shetechaf miyad b'siyum hadlakah, yikach hapitah miyadah v'yichabehna. Somebody should stand next to her,42:08 that when she finishes lighting, she should hand over the candle and they should shut it off.42:13 And he says something that we said42:18 beforehand: v'davka ishah tachul aleha kabbalat Shabbat b'hadlakat hanerot shel Shabbat, and only a woman accepts Shabbat when she is lighting the Shabbat candles.42:22 Aval ha'anashim, however, as far as men are concerned,42:28 im hem madlikim nerot Shabbat b'yadam, if they're the ones who are actually fulfilling the mitzvah of42:33 hadlakat nerot, af al pi shemevarchim alehem, even though they make their own blessings,42:37 lo tachul alehem kabbalat Shabbat. They don't accept Shabbat by lighting candles.42:43 Ela k'she'omrim bo'i kallah u'mezmor שיר ליום השבת, only as we're going to explain in parashat Lech Lecha,42:46 that when they pray Arvit, when they pray Kabbalat Shabbat,42:49 that's when they accept Shabbat.42:52 V'lachen yecholim la'asot melachah, therefore the men who are lighting candles could still perform any melachah that they want after lighting candles.43:03 Mi hu tov sheyitnu b'ferush b'et hadlakah shehem mekablim Shabbat b'hadlakat nerot. However, even though the custom is that they don't accept Shabbat by lighting candles,43:07 still they should make a condition. It's better to make a condition.43:11 Why not? It's better to make a condition.43:13 Therefore, that's how the Ben Ish Chai concludes.43:16 Now, let's review very quickly.43:17 It comes out from the43:20 Ben Ish Chai that when you're lighting the candles,43:23 first you light the candles,43:24 and only then do you make the43:27 berachah. And we said that's against Shulchan Aruch.43:29 Shulchan Aruch says first you make the berachah and then you light the candles.43:32 So the Chacham Ovadia has a very long teshuvah on this.43:36 He writes this in numerous places,43:37 Chacham writes about it,43:39 and he has some very, very strong points.43:41 He says— As follows,43:44 the Chacham Bediah says as43:45 follows. Let's understand something.43:47 This whole custom of making the blessing after lighting the candles,43:53 where does it come from?43:54 It comes from the43:56 Rama. The Rama also, where does he get it from?43:57 He gets it from the44:00 Maharil Vayil. Open up the book of the44:02 Maharil Vayil and see the words that he brings.44:04 You know what he writes?44:05 He writes, the custom of some women is that after they light candles,44:11 since they're scared, since they get Shabbat, so they throw away the candles.44:16 Now, he doesn't mention anything about making the blessing.44:19 Excuse me, he does mention afterwards, sorry,44:20 he mentions afterwards, he writes,44:22 then afterwards you should make the blessing;44:24 therefore they make the blessing beforehand.44:27 Afterwards, I mean.44:28 Let's review. Sorry, I got a little confused.44:29 I got a text coming in,44:31 got a little confused. One more time.44:33 I want not to confuse everybody.44:35 The Maharil Vayil writes as follows:44:36 the custom of some women,44:38 that since they're scared of accepting Shabbat by making the blessing on the candles,44:43 they first light the candles and then they make the44:46 berachah. The Maharil Vayil seems to say that that's the custom of some of the women,44:50 but it doesn't sound like he himself is holding that way.44:53 And even if you want to say he himself is holding that way,44:56 you have a big question.44:57 The Rambam holds that after you fulfill the mitzvah,45:00 you cannot do it.45:01 You cannot make a berachah afterwards.45:02 After you fulfill the mitzvah of lighting candles,45:04 you can't make a berachah. It's too late.45:07 And especially the Rambam writes,45:08 it's a yesod de'oraita, you're making45:11 berachah levatalah. So what are you worried about?45:12 Are you worried that you're going to accept Shabbat?45:14 But the Bahag himself never said to make the blessing after lighting candles.45:19 The Bahag writes45:20 that first you make the blessing,45:22 and then you light candles, and then you accept Shabbat.45:24 In fact, the Bein Ish Chai's words are exactly the same way.45:27 He writes the same thing.45:28 She only accepts Shabbat after she lights the candles.45:32 Accepting Shabbat is a condition that you make.45:34 It's not Shabbat yet.45:36 You decide when to accept Shabbat.45:38 And especially that the Shulchan Aruch ruled not like the Bahag.45:41 Shulchan Aruch said it's preferable45:42 if you accept Shabbat by candle lighting,45:44 but you don't have to.45:46 So the worst thing is make a condition.45:48 So it comes out,45:49 really according to45:52 the45:53 Chacham Ovadia, and he makes a lot of sense.45:55 Why should,45:56 if a person is making the blessing after lighting candles,45:59 he's putting himself in a very, very46:02 big—not just46:03 machloket—he's putting himself46:04 in an issur de'oraita according to the Rambam.46:07 You're going against Shulchan Aruch.46:08 You're going almost against all the46:11 Rishonim that explain the Gemara46:12 that says you have to make the46:13 blessing before you light the candles,46:15 and even the46:16 Akuvah. So now, if you're worried about accepting Shabbat,46:19 make a condition.46:20 We mentioned already a few times46:22 that46:23 you have to accept Shabbat,46:24 and we go with the opinion that says46:25 you can make a condition.46:27 So just let the woman make her condition46:29 once a year to say,46:31 I am not accepting Shabbat46:33 until after I finish lighting.46:36 Therefore, if you say such a thing,46:38 you can make the blessing46:40 and then light the candles,46:41 and then only afterwards accept Shabbat.46:43 In fact, in the past we mentioned46:44 that a woman who is lighting candles46:46 should first shut off the electricity.46:48 This is what all the Acharonim pretty much say.46:51 That's according to46:53 Chacham Ovadia, brings the same thing.46:54 Chacham Ben Tzion, they all write the same thing.46:56 You should shut off the electricity first,46:58 light the candles,47:00 and then afterwards put on the electricity.47:02 So therefore,47:03 somebody asked,47:03 what do you mean, when you light the47:04 candles you're accepting Shabbat?47:05 And the answer is no.47:07 Accepting Shabbat is conditional.47:08 You decide. You make that condition.47:11 So therefore, have in mind47:13 that I'm not accepting Shabbat47:15 until I finish lighting my candles,47:17 or until I finish putting on the electricity47:20 in the dining room47:21 where I'm lighting with the47:23 berachah. And this way,47:24 you can be47:25 yotzei dechovah according to everybody.47:26 You made a condition.47:28 And if you can tell me47:29 some people have a custom47:30 of going like the Rama,47:32 the custom is very, very hard to accept47:35 because you're putting yourself47:37 in a place where47:39 you make it a berachah levatalah. So therefore,47:39 Chacham Ovadia writes very, very strongly,47:42 especially for a woman,47:43 that used to make the blessing47:46 after lighting candles47:47 should change her custom.47:48 It's not even a custom.47:50 She has to change her custom,47:51 and she has to rule.47:52 She has to follow what we accepted.47:53 We accepted the rulings of47:55 Shulchan Aruch. She has to first make the blessing47:58 and then light the candles.48:00 So far, he says even a woman who is Ashkenazi could also, an Ashkenazi who wants to make the blessing before lighting candles, she could do so.48:10 For the Sefardim, however, he says the difference is as follows:48:13 for the Sefardim, they don't have to do hatarat nedarim.48:15 Even though they had the custom of making the blessing after lighting candles, they don't have to do hatarat nedarim.48:19 But for Ashkenaziya, she should do hatarat nedarim.48:23 And his logic is very, very simple.48:24 How come she doesn't do hatarat nedarim?48:27 Because the ruling of Shulchan Aruch is that you make a blessing beforehand, and blessing afterwards is48:33 bracha levatalah. This is the ruling of48:35 Hacham Ovadia Yosef. However, Hacham Ben Zion, which Hacham Ovadia brings down also and he argues on, Hacham Ben Zion says,48:41 preferably, really, a woman should make the blessing before lighting candles.48:46 So that means any newlyweds, any girl that's about to get married, that should be the custom that she should follow.48:52 She should first make the blessing and only then light the48:55 candles. However, he says anybody who has had a custom in the past to first light the candles and make a blessing, they could continue.49:03 Still, Hacham Ovadia is not happy with Hacham Ben Zion's ruling, and he also argues on that.49:08 He says, no, a woman, even if she has such a custom, she should change it.49:14 Now, I believe most men do not know what their wives are doing in the house.49:18 You'll be very surprised how many men actually know what's going on in the house.49:22 You ask most men, What does your wife do?49:24 He doesn't know. Because why?49:26 Usually women are lighting the candles about 18 minutes before Shabbat comes in.49:30 By that time, the husband should be in shul.49:32 If he's not in shul, he's rushing and he's getting himself ready. He's running to shul, so he has no clue what his wife is doing,49:37 if she's making the blessing first or she's making it afterwards.49:40 So men and women, you should go and tell your wives, if you're Sefardi, first you make the blessing and then afterwards you light the49:49 candles. Why? This way you'll say the chovah according to everybody.49:52 Even the Rama will not disagree that if you're lighting, you're making the berachah first and you have a condition that you don't want to accept Shabbat,50:01 you don't have to accept Shabbat.50:02 The Rama himself writes that even though the Bach writes that you should accept Shabbat by candle lighting,50:07 and even though the Ashkenazim have a custom to accept Shabbat by candle lighting,50:10 here the Rama writes if you want to make a condition, you can make a condition.50:13 We mentioned last week a woman has to go to mikveh, she can make a condition. And not have to accept Shabbat.50:18 So everybody will agree that if you make the blessing first and then light the candles, it works.50:22 So why not do according to everybody?50:24 Why should you put yourself in the situation where it's possibly a50:28 bracha levatalah? So it's very hard for you to get your wife convinced that she should first make the bracha and then only light.50:36 So you can do the following.50:37 Tell her like this:50:38 You want to light and make bracha afterwards? Fine.50:41 Have in mind that you're not accepting Shabbat yet,50:45 and you can light the candles and then make the blessing,50:48 and have in mind that you're also lighting the electricity after you light the candles for the sake of the light in the house,50:56 because you can also use electricity50:57 if the bracha is also goer on the electricity, according to some opinions it works.51:01 So it's not the best preferable situation,51:03 but if the woman doesn't want to change and you can't convince her otherwise,51:06 you can't explain to her, and you can't let her hear this class51:09 how it's very important that she make the blessing before lighting the candles,51:13 so then you could tell her to go to do the following:51:16 light the flame candles, the regular candles,51:19 and then afterwards make the blessing51:21 and have in mind that you're lighting the electricity after the blessing also for the mitzvah of candle lighting.51:26 So this way at least you're considered in the middle of a mitzvah.51:30 Again, this is not51:31 lechatchilah, but it's definitely better to do it this way51:36 than to make the blessing after you completely lit the lights and the candles.51:40 So this is how we started and this is how we'll finish.51:42 Lechatchilah, a woman from the51:45 Sefardi, a Sefardi woman should make the blessing51:47 and then afterwards light the candles.51:49 If she has such a minhag51:51 where she lights the candles first and then makes the blessing,51:54 according to the51:55 Sefardim it's preferable that she should first make the51:58 bracha and then light the51:59 candles. In fact, Chacham Ovadia says52:02 even Ashkenazim could switch,52:04 and he brings a story of Rav Isser Zalman Meltzer.52:06 Who was the father-in-law of Rav52:10 Aharon Kotler, zecher tzaddik livrachah? When he came to Eretz Yisrael, he told his wife,52:14 first you make the blessing and then afterwards you light.52:17 So therefore, that's even Ashkenazim, he holds they could do such a thing.52:21 But in any case, we're focusing right now on the52:24 Sefardi women. Make the blessing and only then light the52:26 candles. And to be yotzei de chovah, everybody,52:29 this is what you should do.52:31 You should have in mind,52:33 or make a condition,52:35 that you're not accepting Shabbat by candle lighting.52:39 You're only accepting Shabbat after you conclude lighting all the candles.52:43 And once you do that,52:45 then according to all opinions it's fine,52:48 especially according to the52:49 Sefardim, you don't accept Shabbat until you conclude lighting the candles.52:52 The blessing doesn't make you accept Shabbat,52:55 and this condition only has to be done once a year.52:58 We'll finish with one last halachah, a small53:01 halachah. When you're lighting the candles and you have two in front of you,53:03 which one do you light first,53:04 the one on the right or the one on the left?53:06 In this case, as I brought down53:08 the Sefarim, that you always light the one on the right first.53:10 Okay,53:11 so when you're coming to make the blessing,53:13 you're coming to light the candles,53:17 first make53:19 the brachah and light the one on the right,53:21 and then afterwards light the one on the left.53:23 Shabbat shalom.53:23 If you have any questions, again,53:25 you could text it in to53:30 347-927-8398. Have a wonderful week.