Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRootRadio.com, here on JRootRadio.com. You're listening to Halacha Hour here on0:08 JRoot Radio. You can listen to us either by the internet, JRootRadio.com, or you can listen on the0:15 JRoot Radio Pro app, or you can listen through the phone. And the phone number to listen, if you would0:19 like to listen to us over the phone, is 718-506-9099. Okay, let's give you the numbers to the station0:28 first, and then we'll begin with our introduction to today's class. The number to the studio,0:33 if you want to call in, and today, Baruch Hashem, we have Rav David sitting with us, and therefore, if0:37 you want to call in, you can call in at any time to ask your halacha questions. The subject0:41 of today's class will be the laws, the halachot of seudah shlishit and minhag on Shabbat, and0:51 we are back to the book from the Ben Ish Chai. We'll talk about that in a second. First, let's0:56 give you the numbers. The studio number is 718-683-5858, and the text number is1:07 347-927-8398. If you have any questions or comments, you can call us or you can text us. Again,1:13 718-683-5858. The text is 347-927-8398. Today's class is sponsored by and for the hatzlacha of Shlomo1:21 Eliyahu ben Nina, as well as Maya Sima bat Paula Buliza. Hashem should give them bracha v'hatzlacha in everything that they1:30 do, bezrat Hashem. Okay, the Halacha Hour learns a duction. What we do is we learn halachot over here, and we're back to our1:37 regular schedule. We took off a little bit of a break from Purim until now, learning1:40 about the halachot regarding the moadim, the holidays. At the time we learned Purim, then1:45 we learned the halachot of Pesach, and last week we concluded our halachot on Sefirat1:50 HaOmer, and of course we did also the customs, the minhagim of the Omer the week beforehand. If you1:55 missed any of the classes and you're interested to find out, I don't know why you would want1:58 to find out about Purim or Pesach right now, but if you're interested about Sefirat HaOmer,2:02 you could go and listen to the archives or watch the videos on JRootRadio.com. What we do is2:09 we work off the Ben Ish Chai, and we read the parashiyot of the Ben Ish Chai. The halachot2:17 from Ben Ish Chai, and then we elaborate and we explain the source of the halachot, also the practicality, what opinions we go2:22 with, we don't go with, and we try to accommodate everybody, Ashkenazis, Sephardi, Chassidish,2:27 whatever it may be. And we try to bring in as much as we can, if we can. We should have2:33 siyata dishmaya, siyata dishmaya. Before we actually get to the halachot, there's a very important announcement.2:38 As the debating if I should announce this, if I should say this, I'm definitely in the shul,2:42 I definitely have an obligation to speak about it. But on the radio, it's not my style2:47 to give mussar, like the name of the class of the show, it's Halacha Hour. We're here2:51 just to give halacha. So therefore, I'm not giving any mussar, I'm giving just straight2:55 out halacha. There is a new app out there, I believe it's unique to the iPhone. I don't3:00 want to say what the name of the app is because otherwise it'll arouse people's interest3:04 and they'll want to know about it. But we're going to keep it a secret for3:08 now, that this app is a very dangerous app. It's similar to Facebook. If you know what3:14 it is, then that's good enough. If you don't know what it is, Baruch Hashem, then you don't3:17 need to listen to this. But if you know what it is, and you're a person that cares about halacha,3:21 and especially if you're a person who you're careful, de'oraita, de'rabbanan, you should know. I mean,3:28 Facebook could also be sometimes, not sometimes, a lot of times, could also be lashon hara. But in this3:32 app, where there's no busha, anybody participating, even viewing, you don't have to necessarily3:39 participate by texting, but even just viewing what people are saying on this app is3:44 asur mide'oraita. This is without exaggeration. This is like eating pig, and according to3:49 the Chafetz Chaim, it's even much more because according to Chafetz Chaim, he lists 313:52 different mitzvot. 14 issur, 14 mitzvot aseh and 17 mitzvot3:59 lo ta'aseh in lashon hara, and as well as motzi shem ra. So therefore, if you know what I'm talking4:03 about and you have it, it's a big mitzvah to delete it, to not participate at all. Even4:08 if you don't have it, or you shouldn't even hear about it, and if you know other people4:12 that have it, it's a big mitzvah to convince them, to show them, to be mochiach, to show4:18 them that this is something very, very wrong and we should not have. Unfortunately,4:23 it's caused tremendous disasters in only two weeks that's been out, and that's good enough,4:28 I think. Yishma chacham v'yosif lekach. And if you don't know, ashrecha u'ma4:33 tov lach. You're out of that world and you're out of that loop. You're wonderful if you don't know,4:36 Baruch Hashem. Okay, let's get to the halachot of Menachah on Shabbat as well as4:42 seudah shelishit. In the Ben Ish Chai, we're going off Parashat Chayei Sarah in the second year. What we usually4:47 do is we go in the order of the Ben Ish Chai, but today we're going to do a little bit4:50 of a switch. Usually it takes me a few weeks to go through a parashah in the4:55 Ben Ish Chai because there's so much to talk about. In this week's parashah, most of it will be very,4:58 very simple and straight out, and a lot of it I won't even read inside because a lot5:04 of it, you'll see, it's based on a text. A lot of it, you know, I'm going to bore you5:08 if I read it inside. So I'm going to start from the last, the second half of the5:15 parashah. There's only 14 halachot. We're going to start from halachah yud. We're going to start first5:19 with the halachot of seudah shelishit. The reason why we're starting from the second5:24 half of the parashah, for two reasons. Number one is that's the order it's brought down5:28 in the Shulchan Aruch. The laws of seudah shelishit are found in5:34 Shulchan Aruch, siman reish tzadi aleph, and the laws of Menachah are reish tzadi bet, the one afterwards. Also, there's more5:39 to talk about in seudah shelishit than the halachot the Ben Ish Chai brings by5:42 Menachah, so therefore I would like to start with that. Halachah yud, we begin talking about5:49 seudah shelishit and the significance of the seudah shelishit. We'll see, be'ezrat Hashem, as we go along, but the Ben Ish Chai begins,5:53 b'seudata mincha, and he says, kodem shetotel yadecha, before you do netilat yadayim to5:58 have your third meal on Shabbat by the afternoon. Tomar b'kol ram uv'simcha rabbah. You should6:06 say in a loud voice and with great joy the following words. Now, we're going to say what6:11 these words are. It's not going to be so familiar to some of us, and a lot of Chassidim, a lot6:19 of Ashkenazim as well, more Chassidim have any way of saying this. Atkinu seudata6:25 d'mehemnuta, shlema, chedva, dimchaka kadisha. They have this special tune: Atkinu6:30 seudasa d'mehemnusa, shlemasa, chedva dimchaka kadisha. Right, that's the tune. That's the words that come from the Arizal who wrote6:35 this. Prepare the seudah. This really comes from the Zohar. Prepare the seudah6:41 d'emunah, the emunah sheleimah, the complete emunah. This is the joy, the seudah, that's the joy6:46 of the Holy King, which is HaKadosh Baruch Hu. Atkinu seudata d'malka, prepare the meal of the King, which6:51 is Hashem. Da hi seudata d'Zeir Anpin. This is the seudah of Zeir Anpin. Zeir Anpin is a6:57 Kabbalistic term. You can find these words in the siddur. You can find them in a lot7:01 of the benches in the Birkat Hamazon. Menachem says to say this. I haven't seen too7:06 many people say this, and there's different piyutim and things, but still the idea is, like7:12 we said, according to the Mekubalim, everything that you do should always express with7:16 your mouth. That's why the Shem Yichud Kudsha Brich Hu. That's why whenever you do a mitzvah,7:20 even if you're not saying Leshem Yichud, say, I'm about to fulfill a mitzvah, because7:23 we want to get every part of you involved in the mitzvah. We know that there's7:28 three parts to the person. There is the thought of a person, there is the action, and there7:35 is the speech of a person: dibur, machshavah, maaseh. When it comes to fulfilling a mitzvah,7:40 you want to be completely involved in fulfilling the mitzvah. So not only should your body7:44 be involved—you're having seudah shelishit, that's your body, that's7:48 just eating—you have to think and understand that Hashem is sitting with you. At the same time also,7:53 in seudah shelishit, lemashal, for example, also express it with your mouth, dibur. Speak7:59 about the mitzvah.8:00 This is not only by seudah shlishit; this is by every mitzvah they want to do.8:03 Ladies who want to light the candles on Erev Shabbat, say, I'm about to fulfill the mitzvah of lighting the candles,8:09 mitzvat derabbanan of lighting the candles. You said it with your mouth. Obviously you're thinking about it,8:13 and lemaaseh, when you actually light the candles, you fulfill it with your actions.8:17 That is the reason for saying this line.8:22 I want to read you from the Zohar. I'm going to try to read very, very quick.8:25 The Zohar, what he writes regarding seudah shlishit. Listen to this.8:29 He says like this:8:33 Kol birkan de'ila v'tata b'yoma sheviaa talyan. All the blessings are found in the world above, in the spiritual world, and here down here in the physical world8:39 are all dependent on the seventh day, which is Shabbat.8:45 V'tanina was taught: Ama lo eshtekach mana b'yoma sheviaa. When the Jewish people were in the desert, how come the man did not fall on Shabbat?8:49 Says the Zohar,8:54 you know why? Mishum dehu yoma mitbarchan minei kol shitin yomin d'lain, because all the six days of the week,8:59 all the six days get their source, get their blessings from Shabbat.9:06 V'chol chad v'chad yahiv mezonei l'tata, and each day produces the food, the parnassah that you need for that day.9:13 Kol chad b'yomoi mehiv birchan min Shabbat. They all get it from the9:15 Shabbat. Meaning to say, Shabbat is the supplier,9:18 and the six days of the week are the ones who are receiving the supply of blessings,9:23 and that's given by Shabbat. A person who is a supplier,9:26 you know, if you work, let's say, bring it down to our level,9:29 if you're a person who makes shoes, you don't need shoes. You are the one giving to everybody,9:34 so yourself you don't need to take for yourself. That's the mashal.9:37 Over here, Shabbat itself is the source of9:40 blessings, and therefore it doesn't need the man, but every one of the six days of the week,9:46 they get the man from the blessing of Shabbat.9:48 And therefore, says the Zohar, a few paragraphs down,9:53 And that's why a person has the obligation9:57 to take pleasure three times.10:00 And these three times means to say, to participate, to make a meal three times on Shabbat.10:06 The complete emunah for a person depends on10:15 his seudot. And look what he says over here: You must take pleasure by eating,10:18 and you must rejoice also by eating.10:20 That means don't be grumpy when it comes to eating a meal.10:22 Oh, come on, I have to wash my nutritionist and the things.10:35 You have to take joy. So then eat whole wheat if your nutritionist doesn't let you eat bread. But you should not be grumpy when it comes to the meals. Listen to the words of the Zohar.10:37 And if a person misses any one of the meals on Shabbat,10:43 then it appears, what he is missing appears up there in10:49 Shamayim. And harsh words, listen to the following words,10:52 and his punishment is great.10:56 And that's why10:59 he has to prepare his table,11:01 means to say he has to have a seudah three times on Shabbat.11:04 One is11:05 mikadai Shabbat, when Shabbat enters, which is what we call the Friday night meal,11:09 and never keep your table empty, like we said in the name of11:12 the Arizal. Even if a person finishes his meal,11:14 he always keeps some crumbs or something of bread on the table.11:18 Why?11:19 Because Zohar says,11:21 When your table is not empty,11:23 it represents the shulchan in the Mishkan,11:25 in the11:26 Beit HaMikdash, which was never empty,11:27 and therefore you could bring down the blessings.11:31 For all the rest of the days of the week,11:34 and especially in our economy,11:35 rabotai, we all need that11:37 segulah leparnassah. Keeping bread on our table throughout the whole Shabbat11:43 brings parnassah, brings11:44 berachah. If you tell me, what if bugs?11:46 So put it in a plastic bag.11:48 Just keep some sort of bread.11:49 But like the Arizal says,11:50 make sure it's not a whole bread;11:52 it's a broken piece of bread,11:54 because otherwise you might have issues with11:57 derech haGoyim. And then it concludes, the Zohar says,12:04 Uvahai milah, achzei v'tallei mehem emunah. With this, through the meals,12:05 a person will have complete12:08 emunah. This is what the Zohar speaks about12:10 seudah shlishit. The Gemara says it's an obligation,12:12 according to the12:13 Levush. This is an obligation12:14 mideoraita to have three meals.12:15 Where do we learn it from?12:16 So the pasuk that the poskim bring down12:19 is brought down in the Torah.12:20 It says like this:12:21 Moshe tells the Jewish people12:23 in Parashat Beshalach12:24 regarding the man,12:25 he tells them like this:12:30 Ichluhu hayom. Ki Shabbat hayom laShem; hayom lo timtza'uhu basadeh. Eat the man today,12:32 because today is Shabbat.12:34 Today you won't find it in the field.12:36 So why does G-d keep on saying the12:37 word12:38 hayom, hayom, hayom? The Gemara says from here,12:39 three times we find in this pasuk12:40 the word12:41 hayom to teach us that a person needs12:43 three meals on Shabbat,12:45 and that's the three meals that we have.12:47 And therefore,12:49 halacha lemaaseh, practically,12:49 if a person for some reason12:51 missed one of the meals,12:53 he has to make it up.12:54 L'mashal, let's say Friday night,12:55 for whatever reason12:55 he did not have12:57 a seudah, he did not have a meal.12:58 Lo aleinu, he was sick, he was in the hospital,13:00 whatever it was,13:01 whatever the reason may be.13:03 You know, sometimes, you know, when Purim falls13:04 on Friday afternoon,13:06 a lot of people end up13:07 missing the Friday night meal13:09 because, you know, the seudat Purim,13:11 you know, you finish eating13:12 but the wine doesn't let you continue.13:14 In any case,13:15 so if a person missed the13:17 seudah of Leil Shabbat,13:19 then the poskim bring down13:20 that he should have three meals13:21 on Shabbat day.13:22 Now we know there's a meal in the morning,13:24 the meal by13:25 seudah shlishit, but being that this person13:26 missed the meal from the night beforehand,13:28 he has to13:30 say—he has to have a third meal.13:31 And being that he missed the meal,13:33 if he didn't make kiddush the night before,13:35 he also has an obligation13:36 when he comes to eat that first meal13:38 to say kiddush,13:40 which is13:42 Baruch atah Hashem mekadesh haShabbat, but he should just skip13:44 vayechulu. That is13:45 if a person missed his meal13:46 on Friday night.13:48 I just want to emphasize13:50 a little bit more13:51 on the importance of13:52 seudah shlishit, and the reason why we're emphasizing13:53 on seudah shlishit more than other meals,13:55 because Friday night you're hungry,13:56 you're starving,13:57 and Friday night meal is the best,13:58 so easy.14:00 Shabbat day,14:01 you know,14:01 if the rabbi's derashah was too long,14:02 or the chazzan was too long,14:04 or too stretchy,14:05 you come home,14:06 you're still pretty hungry,14:07 and the smell of cholent14:09 anyways, mesmerizing the whole Friday night,14:11 that you want to eat anyway.14:12 It's easy to eat.14:13 Seudah shlishit is very difficult to14:15 eat, we all know that.14:15 So therefore,14:17 I want to tell you a few stories,14:18 just very, very quick stories,14:20 to bring the point home.14:21 The14:22 Chatam Sofer, when he used to have14:23 seudah shlishit, he used to have it with his talmidim,14:25 and he would extend his meal14:28 all the way through the late... Hours of the night.14:31 The meal would run all the way14:33 to the late hours of the night,14:34 and it's brought down14:35 that he would say the Divrei Torah,14:37 and his face was like fire,14:39 and people would just sit around14:40 in that lengthy14:42 seudah shlishit. They loved it.14:42 All his students were all around him.14:44 This was his minhag,14:45 a custom every single Shabbat.14:47 The beautiful story with the Baal Shem Tov,14:50 where a regular simple innkeeper14:52 told him a14:53 pshat, an explanation,14:54 which he loved.14:55 So the Baal Shem Tov also emphasized14:57 and stressed that you should have14:59 seudah shlishit with people;14:59 you shouldn't have it alone.15:01 And one time Baal Shem Tov was invited15:02 to a certain hotel or hostel,15:04 whatever you want to call it,15:05 and the owner was Jewish.15:06 And when the Baal15:07 Shem Tov was sitting with his students,15:09 this owner of the hotel15:10 also came with a few friends,15:11 and they sat down15:12 to have seudah shlishit all together.15:14 So the Baal Shem Tov said,15:15 You know, how come this man is doing15:16 this? It's not brought down15:17 in the halacha, in the poskim, that you should have it15:18 with a group of people.15:19 So he went over to this person15:20 and said, How come15:22 you're having the meal together15:23 with a whole group of people?15:25 He says, I do this every Shabbat.15:26 You know why?15:27 Because it's brought down15:28 that we get an extra soul on Shabbat,15:31 and the neshama15:33 yeteira leaves on Motzaei Shabbat,15:35 and that's pretty much15:35 by the time we finish15:37 seudah shlishit, and therefore15:38 it's a form of death,15:39 because the neshama is leaving the body,15:41 and I want to15:42 die amongst the Jewish people.15:43 I want my soul to leave15:44 amongst the Jewish people.15:45 Baal Shem Tov loved this,15:47 and that's brought down.15:48 Obviously he said it over,15:49 and that's what's brought down.15:50 There's some Admorim15:51 till today,15:52 there's some Hasidim15:53 who sit around in the15:55 seudah shlishit tish,15:56 or whatever they call it,15:57 and they sit around15:58 and they go to the late hours.16:00 Hours of the night. You could be driving, and you could be done with your melaveh malka, and they're sitting16:05 around still in seudah shelishit. I remember personally—not remember, but I try to go16:10 once a year in the summer to a getaway. It's not a getaway; it's like a kiruv organization16:15 where they work with, you know, baalei teshuvah and everything. And the last Shabbat of the program,16:20 they sit and they have seudah shelishit. I'm not kidding. They start an hour earlier16:26 before everybody, because it's up in the mountains anyway, but they start an hour earlier,16:30 and seudah shelishit finishes by 10 o'clock. That's about two hours after shkiah, by the way,16:35 and it's beautiful. And even though these are people that most of them probably never kept16:40 Shabbat before, never kept a real Shabbat, still it's such an enjoyment. Everybody's all together,16:46 and seudah shelishit has a kedushah because the neshamah is leaving at that time.16:51 It has a very, very special kedushah, and it should be treated in such a way. You don't have to extend16:56 your meal. I'm just showing that, look how the tzaddikim who felt it a little bit more didn't want it to finish.17:02 So the question that's asked: How come the Ashkenazim call it shalosh17:07 seudos? I'll translate that in Sefardic: shalosh seudot. You speak to Ashkenazi, he tells you,17:13 You're coming over for shalosh seudos. You're staying for shalosh seudos, which is shalosh17:17 seudot. Really, in Hebrew, and even they'll admit it, the real word for the third meal is17:23 seudah shelishit, and that's what's brought down everywhere, seudah shelishit. But everybody calls it shalosh17:28 seudos, and that's a question really a lot of their rabbis also ask. So I'll give you two answers.17:34 One answer is brought down—I forgot from which rabbi—I saw in Taamei HaMinhagim. He brings down like this.17:40 He says, Why is the third meal called... Three meals. We're only having one meal.17:46 It's the third meal, man; that's not three meals. That's the translation of Shalosh Seudot, three meals.17:51 And the answer is as follows: Friday night and Shabbat day, when a person's eating,17:55 you can't prove really that a person's eating it l'shem Shamayim because God commanded to do so.17:59 Because Friday night, like we said, a person's hungry. Shabbat morning also, a person, you know,18:03 he's in the mood to eat. It's the first meal of the day. You wake up at18:07 seven, eight o'clock. By the time you come home, it's twelve, twelve-thirty. By the time you have the seudah, you're hungry. You didn't have breakfast.18:12 This is your first meal. So it's not really a proof that you're eating18:16 l'shem Shamayim. But when you come to the third meal, especially, especially in the winter, it's not easy to have a meal,18:22 and so hard. But you still wash and you plan to have a meal, that shows that you're eating18:29 l'shem Shamayim. And if that third meal is l'shem Shamayim, then we know for sure that the first two meals that you had on Friday night18:35 and the one on Shabbat morning was also done for the honor of Hashem because Hashem commanded to do so.18:42 So therefore, in this third meal, your Shalosh Seudot have shown that all your three meals on Shabbat were done l'shem Shamayim in honor of Hashem18:52 because Hashem commanded to do so. That's one answer from18:58 Taamei HaMinhagim. The Shem Mishmuel brings from the name of his father, if you want to see it, it's in the year Taf-Reish Ayin.19:03 He explains as follows. He says the three meals correspond to the three Avot:19:08 Abraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov. The first meal corresponds to Abraham because, whatever, I'm not going to go into it right now.19:14 The second meal corresponds to Yitzchak, and the third meal corresponds to Yaakov.19:18 Al pi Kabbalah, the sefarim bring down that Abraham, Yitzchak, and Yaakov represented different kochot, different powers of the soul.19:27 Abraham represented the trait of kindness, of chesed and rachamim. He always went and bring guests.19:31 Yitzchak represents the trait of gevurah, midat ha-din. He's the one who asked Hashem to bring yissurim, to bring inflictions on a person in his lifetime.19:40 He's the one who was ready to sacrifice himself, to be a korban himself. He represents19:46 midat ha-din. And Yaakov was a combination of rachamim and din. He was a combination of kindness as well as din,19:53 and that's why he's called Tiferet. According to Kabbalah, Tiferet is a combination of chesed and din.19:58 And being that Yaakov is the third of the Avot, the seudah shlishit represents the Yaakov Avinu, which is also the—it's the third meal.20:10 And just like Yaakov Avinu, who is inclusive not only of himself, he's inclusive of Abraham and Yitzchak, so too the third meal,20:18 seudah shlishit, by the Ashkenazim they call it shalosh seudot, because it's inclusive of the powers, of the spiritual powers of the first two meals,20:28 of the meal on Friday night and Shabbat day. This is what we could say regarding seudah shlishit and the names,20:35 and we'll just conclude with the following, and then we'll come back to practical halachot.20:39 The Kaf HaChaim brings down in Reish Tzadik Aleph, Chav Zayin, the following words. He says,20:44 אדם הרגיל לאכול ג' סעודות שבת למצוה. A person who accustomed himself to make sure to always eat three meals on Shabbat for the sake of the mitzvah,20:57 ונתארח אצל בני אדם שאינם מחזיקים באותה מצוה. Now he's a guest by somebody's house who didn't grab this mitzvah. Now it's too much, too heavy, we can't.21:05 So now he says, אל יניח המצוה מפני הבושה. Don't let go of your mitzvah of eating the third meal because you're21:13 embarrassed. Oh, how am I going to eat the meal? I'm invited by this person's house and they don't eat21:16 meal. I'm going to sit here and eat the meal myself? I'm embarrassed. So he says, don't let go of the mitzvah just out of embarrassment.21:22 You know why? He says, כי אוי לה לאותה בושה. Woe to the embarrassment in the next world21:27 if a person comes to Shamayim and Hashem shows him every Shabbat he had a chance to have a complete21:33 emunah, and what have you done? You left it because somebody said something to you.21:37 And Chazal tell us, one who has three meals on Shabbat is zocheh to be saved from three things:21:45 chevlei Mashiach, the pain that comes before Mashiach comes;21:49 din Gehennam, the judgment of Gehennam; and milchemet Gog uMagog, the war of Gog21:53 uMagog. Rabotai, you got all the benefits for having three meals.21:56 Chazal were not exaggerating. They're not just trying to convince you to have three meals.21:59 Chazal are telling us metziut, reality. Three meals are important.22:05 The first two meals are easy to talk about.22:08 This meal of Shabbat, the meal of seudah shlishit, is the harder one,22:14 and therefore we're putting a lot of emphasis on this.22:16 Let's get to the next halacha.22:18 Halacha yud aleph, Ben Ish Chai talks about kiddush.22:21 How come we don't make kiddush on22:23 seudah shlishit? Friday night we make kiddush before we begin the meal.22:25 Shabbat day we also make kiddush.22:26 What about Shabbat afternoon by22:29 seudah shlishit? How come we don't have kiddush?22:31 So Ben Ish Chai says, al pi Kabbalah, why kiddush should not be there.22:34 But really, the poskim already deal with it. How come there's no kiddush?22:38 Listen to the Rambam, writes.22:39 Rambam says,22:44 וצריך לגבוע כל סעודה משלושתם על היין. All of the three meals that a person is having on Shabbat,22:49 he has to set it on wine,22:51 ולפצוע שתי ככרות, and also to make hamotzi on two loaves of22:54 bread. So it sounds like from the Rambam22:57 that what's the wine that he's talking about over here?22:59 The simple meaning of the Rambam,23:00 just like we know Friday night and Shabbat morning,23:02 when do we have wine?23:04 We have it by kiddush.23:05 Sounds like you need to have kiddush before you have23:10 seudah shlishit, and that's really most of the Rishonim understood the Rambam that way.23:13 They didn't agree with the Rambam.23:15 They did not agree with the Rambam.23:16 Most Rishonim argued on the Rambam,23:18 but they understood that the Rambam requires23:20 that a person should have kiddush before23:23 seudah shlishit, which means you just take a cup of wine or grape juice23:25 and say23:27 borei pri hagafen, and then you have your meal.23:28 That's how most Rishonim brought the Rambam.23:31 They understood him,23:32 but they argued on him.23:33 However, the Beit Yosef says,23:34 no, you could explain the Rambam to23:39 mean, לגבוע על היין means that you must have wine in the meal,23:42 not before the meal necessarily,23:43 but in the meal,23:44 and therefore you could explain23:45 that there's no machloket between all the Rishonim.23:48 Everybody will agree that there's no obligation to have kiddush23:50 as you had it once in the morning.23:52 All you need to do is drink in the middle of your meal23:55 a cup of wine or grape juice.23:57 In fact, the Arizal, the Arizal himself brings the same.24:00 Thing, he says that in the middle of Kiddush, a person should have a cup—no, excuse me, I messed up. In the middle of seudah shlishit, the Riza says a person should have a cup of wine or a cup of grape juice.24:10 Why? Because, al pi Kabbalah, explains what he explains.24:13 And even Shulchan Aruch brings the same thing.24:16 Shulchan Aruch says that a person should drink wine in the middle of24:23 seudah shlishit. Al pi Kabbalah and al pi pshat, it's very good to have wine in the middle of24:27 seudah shlishit. If you don't have, you're still24:29 yotzei dei chovah, but it's a good idea.24:31 One is to be yotzei according to the24:32 Rambam. Number two is, al pi Kabbalah,24:35 spiritual things are happening,24:37 holy things are happening.24:38 However, if a person sees that he only has one—what do you call it?—one cup of wine,24:47 all he has is only one cup of24:50 wine, and the question is, is he going to use it now for the—what do you call it?—is he going to use it now for having the Kiddush in the middle,25:04 or is he going to use it for seudah shlishit in the middle of the meal,25:07 or is he going to use it for, let's say he has zimun with three people25:11 and he's going to use it for later on in the middle of—not in the middle,25:15 afterward, after seudah shlishit he's going to use it for the sake of zimun?25:18 That's—the halacha says, and here Ben Ish Chai goes through back and25:22 forth—he says a person should drink, keep the cup of wine for birkat hamazon, to make zimun on it.25:28 It's better to have the cup of wine for birkat hamazon than to have it in the middle of25:36 seudah shlishit. Now the question comes up:25:37 if you ever saw when people are eating seudah shlishit together,25:41 you see when it comes to zimun, a lot of people will say zimun on a cup of wine,25:48 and the way that the zimun works on a cup of wine is as follows:25:51 you pick up a cup of wine and you say,25:53 B'rshut morai v'rabotai, or B'rshutchem, Sefardi, Ashkenazi, whatever you say,25:57 but at the end of the day you say, with your permission, and you invite everybody to bless Hashem.26:01 That's called zimun. You're inviting everybody to bless Hashem,26:05 okay? So now the question is— How come, when it comes to26:12 seudah shelishit, when they make zimun, the halacha says that after you finish Birkat Hamazon,26:16 then you make the bracha of hagafen and you drink the cup of wine or cup of grape juice.26:20 How come when it comes to seudah shelishit, you make zimun holding the cup of wine,26:23 when it comes to then you see a lot of people, they don't drink the cup of wine.26:26 The question is, is that what you're supposed to do?26:28 And if yes, how come that's so?26:32 How come every time we drink it, and over here we don't drink it?26:35 The answer is as follows.26:37 There are three opinions when it comes to making zimun with a cup of wine.26:41 According to one opinion, this is Shulchan Aruch, by the way, brings this in the Chot of Zimun.26:46 According to one opinion, when you make zimun, you're supposed to make it on a cup of wine,26:52 even—excuse me—when you're saying Birkat Hamazon. Sorry, let's start again.26:56 When it comes to making Birkat Hamazon, since you're fulfilling27:00 a mitzvah d'oraita, you're saying Birkat Hamazon, it's very special to say Birkat Hamazon,27:04 so therefore it requires a cup of wine, just like Kiddush requires a cup of27:07 wine, Brit Milah requires a cup of wine,27:08 Eitam, we have an important mitzvah requires a cup of wine.27:12 The second opinion says, no, you only need a cup of wine when you're making zimun.27:16 If you're not making zimun, you don't need a cup of wine.27:19 That's the second opinion.27:20 Third opinion says, no, even if you have zimun or you don't have zimun,27:23 Birkat Hamazon, you don't need a cup of wine.27:27 Okay? Halacha lemaaseh, when a person is making zimun, lechatchila he should have a cup of wine.27:32 This is the way the Shulchan Aruch brings it down in Hilchot Zimun.27:36 Okay, that is the27:39 halacha. Now, when it comes to Shabbat, so we're making zimun over here,27:42 and we have a cup of wine. Why don't we drink it?27:44 And the answer is, says the27:47 Magen Avraham, because there's an additional factor to take into consideration.27:50 We're going to talk about this really in Hilchot of27:53 Havdalah. The halacha says that once— I am, once the shekiah comes on Shabbat,27:59 going into motzaei Shabbat,28:01 I'm not allowed to eat or drink anything until I make28:03 havdalah, and that's called28:06 bein hashmashot. When we begin bein hashmashot, which is after sunset,28:08 until I make havdalah, I'm not allowed to eat or drink anything.28:11 The only thing I'm allowed to drink is water, technically, according to28:15 halacha. So now, says the28:18 Magen Avraham, throughout the year, how come people don't make zimun on a cup of wine?28:23 The halacha brings down that you're supposed to make zimun28:25 whenever you have three Jews, at least three men, that is,28:29 eating together bread, and they're making zimun,28:31 you're supposed to make it on a cup of28:32 wine. How come people don't do it?28:34 He says, and the answer is because they're relying on the opinion that says28:37 that even when making zimun, you don't need a cup of wine.28:40 So being that so,28:42 here when it comes to motzaei Shabbat,28:45 or really bein hashmashot of Shabbat going into Saturday night,28:49 since you usually rely on the opinion that says you don't need a cup of wine,28:52 so over here you can't drink the cup of wine because28:54 you don't usually drink a cup of28:55 wine, and therefore you considered eating or drinking before the making of havdalah,29:03 and that's why you shouldn't drink that cup of wine.29:05 And that's the opinion also of the29:07 Mishnah Berurah, and that's why many people, I hope they know this,29:09 that when they make zimun on Shabbat afternoon,29:14 I mean to say on29:16 seudah shlishit, even though they may start with a cup of wine,29:17 they don't drink it, they leave it for havdalah.29:19 That is the reason why people do what they do.29:22 However, you have to know29:25 that the Ben29:28 Ish Chai, as well as Chacham Ben Tzion, as well as29:30 the Kaf HaChaim, the Sefardim pretty much went with the Zohar.29:31 The Zohar says that a person who is making birkat hamazon29:35 should not hold a cup of wine unless he has a zimun of three people.29:39 Three people.29:40 Whenever you have a zimun of three people,29:41 you make zimun with a cup of wine.29:44 It's an obligation. It's a chov. It's not optional.29:47 We don't go with the opinion that says you don't need a cup of wine.29:49 We don't go with the opinion that says that29:51 when you make birkat hamazon by yourself, you have a cup of wine.29:54 Only with three people or more29:56 do you make zimun. With a cup of wine.29:59 And therefore, the Acharonim bring down30:01 that there's an obligation every single time30:03 that three men are eating and they're making zimun30:05 to make it on a cup of wine or grape juice.30:07 And even though you may not do it throughout the week,30:12 you're really, you're not holding like Sefardi poskim.30:15 When it comes to30:18 seudah shelishit, still, Bacham Ben Tzion brings it down and he says30:21 it doesn't exempt you from the obligation30:23 of making zimun on a cup of wine.30:26 Therefore, even though you may not do it throughout the week,30:27 so don't mess up also on Shabbat.30:29 On Shabbat, you can make zimun30:31 with a cup of wine and drink it as well,30:33 even though you're drinking it30:35 way after shekiyah, way into30:38 bein hashmashot before making Havdalah. Why?30:39 Because we Sefardim have an30:42 obligation to make zimun on a cup of wine throughout the year.30:45 If a person doesn't want to do his30:48 obligation throughout the week,30:49 just because on Shabbat30:51 he's making, it doesn't mean he should put it down.30:54 So that's really according to the30:55 Sefardim. Sefardim, if you're making zimun30:58 on31:00 seudah shelishit, which finished after31:03 shekiyah, which means in31:05 bein hashmashot, not only do you make zimun on a cup of wine,31:07 but you must also drink from the cup of31:10 wine, and there's no31:11 issur. Look at it in the31:13 Or Letzion. Ben Ish Chai also brings this31:15 halacha. Let's move on now to31:17 Halacha Yud Bet. Halacha Yud Bet, the Ben31:19 Ish Chai talks about some customs to do31:21 in the middle of31:23 seudah shelishit. If you recall,31:25 al pi Kabbalah, it's very, very31:27 chashuv for a person to smell31:29 hadasim by the meals of Friday night31:33 as well as Shabbat day.31:34 It's very, very31:35 chashuv. We find already in the Gemara,31:37 which talks about31:39 Lag BaOmer, and mentions also about Jews31:42 bringing hadasim for the honor of Shabbat.31:44 So therefore, the Ben Ish Chai says also,31:46 if you can, especially a lot of31:48 shuls for Havdalah, they give out31:50 hadasim. If you can, bring31:53 hadasim and make a bracha atzei besamim31:55 in the middle of31:57 seudah shelishit, and before making the31:59 bracha you should say the words.32:01 Zachor v'shamor b'dibur echad ne'emru, and then afterwards say the bracha of atzei vesamim, and then smell the32:06 hadasim. Of course, make sure the hadasim have a smell.32:09 According to halacha, bread during seudah shelishit is an obligation.32:14 That's a psak of Maran Shulchan Aruch,32:17 that a person must have bread.32:19 Lechatchila, a person must have32:23 kebeitzah. Kebeitzah is about two ounces of bread during32:27 seudah shelishit. If a person cannot, then he could have a kezayit of bread.32:33 That's according to halacha.32:34 According to the mekubalim, a32:37 person—Ben Ish Hai brought this also in the other32:40 meals—in every one of the three meals, a person should have his table set up32:44 like the way it was set up in the Mishkan or the Beit HaMikdash.32:47 Just like the Shulchan, the Beit HaMikdash had twelve loaves of bread,32:49 so too when a person is eating or coming to eat his meal on Shabbat,32:54 for all the three meals he should preferably have twelve loaves of32:57 bread. It's hard to do when you're eating seudah shelishit in the shul,33:00 especially in a lot of shuls, you're lucky if you get one piece of bread.33:03 And for lechem mishneh, it's the same piece of bread that's going from each person,33:07 the same challah, the same pita that's going around from each person to person,33:10 and everybody's using for lechem mishneh.33:12 Okay, it's a little harder, I agree,33:14 but if you can, if you have the luxury to do it,33:17 then you should try to set up twelve loaves of bread when you're eating.33:20 If not, then four loaves of33:22 bread. If not, at least two. You also should try to have lechem mishneh.33:27 But of course, if a person doesn't have lechem mishneh,33:28 you don't have to eat the two pieces of bread.33:30 You have to eat at least a kebeitzah or kezayit, at the very least.33:34 But to make the bracha hamotzi on two breads or four breads or twelve breads,33:40 that is a preferable mitzvah.33:44 Since there is an obligation to have bread during the meal,33:49 so the poskim already, the Tur, and even earlier the Rishonim already are bringing33:53 and they explain that since you have the obligation to eat bread,33:56 then make sure that you have— That in mind,34:02 that you know that you're going to come to eat bread in34:04 seudah shlishit, especially in the days where, in the winter days when it's very, very short34:07 and you have34:08 seudah shlishit, make sure that you don't overeat in your Shabbat morning meal.34:14 Don't eat so much that when it comes to seudah shlishit, you can't eat.34:17 And if a person cannot eat34:20 and he's stuffing the bread down his mouth,34:22 that's called34:23 achilah gasah. Achilah gasah is not called34:25 achilah. It's not called that you ate it.34:26 It's not called that you fulfilled the mitzvah.34:28 So therefore,34:30 chacham einav b'rosho. A wise man always looks ahead34:33 and he sees,34:34 listen, I'm going to have to have three meals.34:36 So34:37 if you're going to stuff yourself on Shabbat morning,34:39 even though the food is delicious,34:40 so ask them for a doggy bag34:41 and pick it up motzaei Shabbat.34:43 If you're going to see that you're going to eat so much34:45 you can't eat34:45 seudah shlishit, so cut down on what you're eating Shabbat morning,34:49 because there's a special mitzvah, like we said,34:51 to eat34:52 seudah shlishit. If, in case, a person stuffed himself34:55 and he can't eat bread,34:56 he really, he forgot himself,34:58 he lost himself,34:59 he's too stuffed,34:59 he can't eat bread35:01 in seudah shlishit, then at least,35:02 at35:03 least go with the following list.35:05 Since there's other Rishonim that bring different opinions35:07 what a person could eat35:08 during35:09 seudah shlishit, so you can rely on those opinions35:11 when it's very, very necessary.35:13 Because remember,35:15 achilah gasah lav shemei achilah; it's not called35:16 achilah. So what should you do?35:17 So you have the following list.35:19 If you cannot eat bread.35:21 Then try to eat something that's mezonot,35:23 either cakes or cookies.35:25 Try to eat that,35:26 especially the mezonot,35:27 which is35:28 safek if it's hamotzi35:30 or if it's35:31 safek if it's mezonot.35:32 That's a different35:33 sugya. Try to have that.35:34 If you cannot have that,35:35 then at least try to have meat or fish,35:37 a lot of35:38 shuls, for example,35:39 put out tuna fish.35:39 It's very, very good to have fish35:41 on all the three meals of Shabbat.35:43 But if you cannot have cakes,35:45 then at least try to have fish or meat,35:47 which is considered very, very35:49 chashuv. Chicken also.35:49 And if you cannot have meat or fish35:52 or all these things,35:53 it's too heavy,35:54 everybody has room for fruits,35:55 everybody has room for desserts,35:56 pineapple, watermelon, cherries,35:59 or anything,35:59 or oranges.36:01 Then what could you do36:02 if you're stuck36:03 and you can't eat anything else?36:04 Then at least have some fruits,36:05 preferably from the pomegranates36:07 and the grapes36:07 and the five special fruits of Eretz Yisrael.36:10 And if you can't have that,36:11 then even regular fruits will suffice36:13 if a person is stuck.36:15 Now, there's a question:36:16 can a person say Divrei Torah36:17 instead of eating?36:18 I always heard that when I was young.36:20 Oh, you know,36:21 you can be36:22 yotzei dei chovah seudah shlishit by just saying Divrei Torah.36:24 Now, you should know,36:26 no poskim bring this down.36:27 Nobody brings this down.36:28 Where is the source of this?36:29 So I saw brought down36:30 in36:33 Sefer Ta'amei Minhagim, in the name of the36:34 Shlah. The Shlah brings36:35 from the Zohar36:37 that Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai,36:39 when used to say Divrei Torah36:42 on Shabbat36:44 minchah, which means36:46 seudah shlishit, whenever Shabbat was erev Pesach.36:49 When erev Pesach falls on Shabbat,36:50 since you can't have36:51 chametz, you can't have bread,36:52 you can't have also matzah36:54 on Shabbat afternoon,36:56 so the Shlah brings down36:57 that the shebi, that Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai36:59 used to say Divrei Torah.37:00 However, no Acharonim brought this37:03 halachah. What could you do with this information?37:04 I don't know,37:05 but I'll tell you one thing,37:06 that a person cannot do this37:09 lechatchilah. A person cannot go ahead and say,37:11 Okay, I'm going to have the37:12 V'retorah. I'm going to say the37:13 V'retorah. I'm going to listen to the37:14 V'retorah and be37:16 yotzei the chovat seudah shelishit. Absolutely not.37:17 If you're really, really stuck somewhere,37:19 you're in a hospital,37:20 somewhere where Bikkur Cholim didn't get to you,37:22 or they don't have a Bikkur Cholim room,37:24 and you don't have any food,37:25 there's nothing for you to eat,37:27 then what could you do?37:28 You should say the37:29 V'retorah. You should know,37:30 if you read the biography of the Klausenberger Rebbe,37:33 he used to time,37:34 when he was in the concentration camps37:36 for many years37:36 and he was suffering under Nazi rule37:39 and37:40 work and forced labor,37:41 he would always time himself.37:42 He should figure out when Shabbat is,37:45 and whenever Shabbat was,37:46 he would make sure to say Divrei Torah.37:48 When the time of סעודה שלישית by37:52 bein hashmashot, he would make sure to always say37:53 some sort of Divrei Torah,37:54 something would come out of it.37:55 He's not saying it to anybody,37:56 but he would say some sort of words of Divrei Torah37:59 during that time.38:00 Maybe it's based on the Shlah and the Zohar,38:02 I don't know.38:03 But that was what's brought down in the38:05 biography of the Klausenberger Rebbe.38:07 Let's move on to the next point.38:10 סעודה שלישית, after a person is eating,38:11 he has to say Birkat Hamazon.38:12 And Birkat Hamazon,38:14 we have an obligation to say38:17 Retzei v'hachlitzenu. Even if you finish your38:18 meal way after tzeit38:20 hakochavim, like we said,38:20 you're one of those people that likes to38:22 stretch out סעודה שלישית way into the night.38:24 As long as you started your meal in the daytime,38:27 you could still say38:29 Retzei v'hachlitzenu, which is mentioning Shabbat in Birkat Hamazon.38:33 Now, the question is,38:34 what if a person forgot to say38:38 Retzei v'hachlitzenu in Birkat Hamazon38:40 of38:43 סעודה שלישית? What is the halacha?38:45 Let me give you a little bit of a background.38:47 The rule by repeating Birkat Hamazon,38:50 if you didn't mention38:52 me'ein hame'ora, what is38:53 me'ein hame'ora? Every time we say Birkat Hamazon38:54 and it's said on a special day,38:57 we have to mention that special day38:59 in our Birkat Hamazon.39:00 L'mashal, we just had Rosh Chodesh Iyar last week.39:03 And Rosh Chodesh, if you ate bread,39:05 so he said, Birchat Hamazon.39:06 When you eat bread on Rosh Chodesh,39:09 in Birchat Hamazon39:10 you must mention39:12 Ya'aleh V'Yavo, and you must mention Rosh Chodesh as in the39:15 berachah. In case a person forgot,39:16 and he remembered after he started the next39:20 berachah, does he have to39:21 repeat, or does he or she have to39:23 repeat Birchat Hamazon or not,39:25 is dependent on the following point.39:27 Whenever we have an obligation to eat bread,39:31 not a mitzvah, a preferable mitzvah,39:33 but an obligation to eat bread,39:36 then if a person forgot to mention39:38 the theme of the day,39:40 which is called39:42 me'ein hame'ora, then you have to repeat Birchat Hamazon.39:43 Let me give you an example.39:45 Leil Pesach,39:46 there's a mitzvah39:48 min haTorah ba'erev tochlu matzot.39:49 You must eat matzah.39:51 That's not preferable.39:52 That's not an option.39:54 You must eat matzah,39:55 men or women.39:55 You have an obligation to39:57 eat matzah, like we all just ate matzah.39:59 Matzah is—40:00 Bread. So therefore, if Leil Pesach a person said Birchat Hamazon, he forgot to mention40:05 Ya'aleh V'Yavo and mentioning Chag HaMatzot Hazeh in Birchat Hamazon,40:08 and he started the fourth blessing, the bracha after40:13 Ya'aleh V'Yavo, then the halacha says that you must repeat Birchat Hamazon.40:17 Okay? This is the40:19 din. However, let's take Pesach daytime.40:22 There is a mitzvah to eat bread on Yom Tov.40:26 Is an obligation to specifically have bread? There is no specific obligation.40:30 It's a big mitzvah, very important mitzvah,40:33 but if a person cannot keep it, it's not that he has—it's not as much of an obligation as eating bread on the night of Pesach.40:41 So therefore, if a person forgot to say Ya'aleh V'Yavo on Shabbat—excuse me, on Pesach day,40:47 in the meal that he's having on Pesach40:49 day—then he does not have to repeat Birchat Hamazon.40:51 The same halacha would apply to Rosh Chodesh.40:54 You're not allowed to fast on Rosh Chodesh,40:56 and there's a mitzvah to eat bread,40:58 but it's not an obligation to eat bread on Rosh Chodesh.41:00 So if a person forgot to say Ya'aleh V'Yavo on Rosh Chodesh41:05 in Birchat Hamazon, he does not have to repeat the Birchat Hamazon.41:09 When it comes to the meals on Shabbat,41:11 everyone agrees, everyone agrees that there's an obligation to eat bread on Friday night41:17 as well as Shabbat morning, the first meal.41:19 The first two meals you must have bread.41:21 And if a person didn't say Retzei V'Hachalitzenu, who did not mention Shabbat in Birchat Hamazon,41:27 then he has to repeat. He has an obligation to repeat Birchat Hamazon,41:31 to say it with41:33 Retzei V'Hachalitzenu. No argument on this,41:35 Ashkenazi and Sefardi. Question is, what about41:38 Seudah Shlishit? So if you look in Shulchan Aruch, siman kuf41:40 peh chet, Shulchan Aruch writes that Seudah Shlishit has the same halacha as Rosh Chodesh.41:44 What do we say about Rosh Chodesh?41:45 Rosh Chodesh, you do not have to repeat the Birchat Hamazon.41:48 If you forgot to say41:51 Retzei v'halitzenu, if you forgot to say41:53 Ya'aleh v'yavo, same thing, you don't have to repeat Birkat Hamazon41:55 if you forgot to say Retzei v'halitzenu by41:57 seudah shelishit. Why not?41:58 Didn't we just say that there is an obligation for a person to have bread on42:05 seudah shelishit? And the answer is, yes, we did say that,42:08 but there's other Rishonim that hold42:09 you could be yotzei the chovah with fruits as well,42:12 meaning that there's a42:14 machloket Rishonim. And Shulchan Aruch, even though he ruled that you must have an obligation to have bread,42:18 but still it's still a42:20 machloket. And therefore, if a person said Birkat Hamazon on42:23 seudah shelishit without mentioning42:25 Retzei v'halitzenu, b'diavad you're yotzei according to the other opinions,42:27 because since there's no obligation to specifically have bread in this meal.42:30 And that is the psak of Shulchan Aruch,42:32 that is the psak of the Mishnah42:35 Berurah, and as well as the42:37 Kaf HaChaim, Hacham Ovadia, and42:39 Or Letzion. However, the Ben Ish Chai in Parashat Balak brings that42:46 since seudah shelishit is an obligation42:49 al pi hasod, al pi Kabbalah, if a person forgot to say42:53 Retzei v'halitzenu in42:55 seudah shelishit, he must repeat Birkat Hamazon.42:56 That's what the Ben Ish Chai brings down.42:58 However, all the43:01 Acharonim, even43:02 the Sefardi Acharonim, Hacham Ovadia, Or Letzion, and Kaf HaChaim, disagree with him.43:04 And why?43:06 Because the Ben Ish Chai usually has a rule,43:09 and a lot of Acharonim go with this rule,43:11 is that if the Arizal says something,43:13 we don't say43:14 safek berachot lehakel against the Arizal.43:15 And he says since the Arizal says there's an obligation al pi Kabbalah to have a meal,43:20 seudah shelishit, so therefore if you didn't say Birkat Hamazon,43:22 you must repeat Birkat Hamazon.43:23 That's the43:25 Ben Ish Chai. However, the Chacham Tzion and43:27 Kaf HaChaim, both of them mention as well,43:29 Hacham Ovadia, is that since the Arizal didn't specifically speak about Birkat Hamazon,43:33 all he said is that you have an obligation to eat bread,43:36 but he didn't say that Birkat Hamazon,43:38 if you missed it, you have to repeat it.43:39 So in that case, it doesn't fit under the rule of43:42 ein omrim safek berachot lehakel neged43:44 haArizal. We don't say43:46 safek berachot lehakel against the Arizal,43:47 and therefore here all the43:49 Acharonim, the43:51 Sefardi Acharonim, disagree with the43:53 Ben Ish Chai. They all hold,43:54 if a person forgot to say43:57 Retzeh v'hachalitzenu by44:00 seudah shelishit, yatza yedei chovah b'diavad. That is the opinion of Chacham Ovadia as well,44:02 and that is44:04 halacha lemaaseh. Like we said, the Ashkenazim, anyway,44:05 don't have an issue with this,44:06 because the Ashkenazim also follow the44:09 Mishnah Berurah, which is what Maran Shulchan Aruch brings in44:11 kuf peh chet, that you don't have to repeat44:15 b'chatimah, if you forgot to say44:18 Retzeh v'hachalitzenu. Let's move on now to halacha44:20 yud gimmel. But they are told,44:22 if anybody wants to text in any question44:24 or call,44:26 we have the technician with us over here,44:27 the number to call in44:28 if you have any questions44:29 on what we said44:30 or the subject that we speak about,44:31 it's44:34 718-683-5858. And to text in your questions,44:35 it's44:40 347-927-8398. You're listening to Halacha Hour44:42 here on44:45 JRadio.com. We're up to halacha44:47 yud gimmel in the Ben44:49 Ish Chai. Very quick halacha:44:53 the44:55 seudah shelishit is an obligation,44:57 echad45:00 ha'ish v'echad ha'ishah chayavim l'kayem seudah shelishit. It's an obligation45:01 on men and women,45:03 b'pat, with bread also.45:05 There's no difference.45:06 This is not halacha just for men.45:07 Last week we spoke45:08 about sefirat45:10 ha'omer, and you're right,45:11 that was45:12 mostly—not mostly,45:13 almost every45:14 halacha that we spoke last week45:15 is only applicable to men,45:16 because according to Kabbalah,45:17 women should not count at all.45:19 But today's halachot,45:22 seudah shelishit is an obligation for men45:23 and women as well.45:25 And not only that,45:25 the Gemara says45:26 that if there's an45:32 ani—Masechet Bava Batra, daf tet amud aleph, amud bet—okay, in either case,45:34 the Gemara says over there45:35 that if an ani,45:36 if a poor person45:37 comes from town to town45:40 and there is a45:41 tzedakah that has to supply him with food,45:43 they must give him45:45 minimum45:47 the—45:48 Three meals45:49 to eat on Shabbat.45:50 Three meals,45:50 you see from here,45:52 Mishnah Berurah brings this down.45:53 It's a halacha,45:55 yoreh de'ah siman reish nun, that from the laws of45:57 tzedakah, since the minimum45:59 that we have to give an ani46:00 is three meals,46:01 you see46:01 all three meals46:02 are an obligation,46:02 there's no exception.46:03 Not only that,46:04 to the point46:04 where Chazal said,46:05 levu alai v'ani porea,46:07 when a person has to buy46:07 the basics of46:09 סעודה שלישית, where halacha says46:10 they can even borrow money46:11 to buy,46:12 you can even borrow it46:13 to buy46:14 for46:15 סעודה שלישית. In fact,46:15 if you ever go to—46:17 you have to be in a hospital46:19 on the Shabbat,46:19 hopefully46:20 it's only for46:21 simchot, when there's a baby,46:22 new baby,46:22 but you see46:23 when the Bikur Cholim comes around46:24 and they supply everybody46:26 with food for Shabbat,46:28 they always give enough also46:30 for meals46:31 as well as46:32 סעודה שלישית. Even if they're very,46:34 very tight on money,46:35 they'll give46:36 for all three meals:46:37 Friday night,46:37 Shabbat day,46:38 and Shabbat afternoon.46:39 Shabbat afternoon meal46:40 is not any less46:41 than all the other meals,46:42 for men46:43 and women46:44 as well.46:45 And all the halachot that we said46:46 from now,46:47 till now,46:48 excuse me, apply to men and women46:50 as well.46:51 Last halacha46:52 regarding46:53 סעודה שלישית in the Ben Ish Chai is the time46:55 when to have46:57 סעודה שלישית. The47:00 Ben Ish Chai says, זמן סעודה שלישית אחר תפילת המנחה. The time to47:02 have סעודה שלישית is47:03 after praying Mincha on Shabbat.47:07 If for some reason47:09 you had to eat47:11 your סעודה שלישית before47:18 Mincha, יצא בדיעבד, יצאת ידי חובה, יוצא בדיעבד. ובלבד שלא יעשנה קודם שש שעות ומחצה. Asi b'chalasharit, on a condition47:20 you didn't have your meal47:22 before47:24 six and a half hours47:24 from the morning,47:25 which means47:26 half an hour47:26 before chatzot.47:28 Okay,47:28 that's very, very important.47:29 You didn't have it before chatzot. If you had it47:31 before chatzot,47:32 that's not called47:34 סעודה שלישית, it's called47:35 bichlal shacharit, it's considered47:38 סעודה של שחרית. This is all47:39 al pi halacha.47:40 But47:40 the Ben Ish Chai brings down over here,47:41 however,47:47 ולפי הסוד גילה רבינו האריזל, על פי קבלה, אם עשה קודם תפלת מנחה, לא יצא ידי חובה גם בדיעבד. According to the Arizal,47:50 סעודה שלישית must only take place47:52 after47:52 Mincha. That's according to Kabbalah.47:53 But halacha,47:54 if a person has47:56 סעודה שלישית any time47:57 after47:57 a half an hour after chatzot,47:59 then—48:00 It's considered seudah shelishit as long, of course, as he had a meal beforehand.48:04 Now here we got a question in the text.48:06 What if a person made kiddush in the shul,48:09 and then48:10 he had48:12 mezonot? And like we mentioned in the past,48:15 the pasuk says,48:17 V'karata laShabbat oneg, which means48:18 wherever you're making kiddush, you must have a48:20 seudah. And we said seudah doesn't have to be48:22 necessarily a big meal.48:24 Seudah to be yotzei dei chovat kiddush48:26 is what? It's only48:27 to have either a kezayit of48:30 mezonot or to have a48:32 revi'it of wine or grape juice.48:33 So this person had a seudah of48:36 such a type in the shul.48:37 He had at least a kezayit of mezonot in the shul,48:39 and now he goes home, and by the time he got home already,48:42 it's after chatzot,48:44 right? And it's way48:46 after chatzot. It's after48:48 six and a half hours from the morning.48:50 Could that be considered48:52 as seudah shelishit or not? So first of all,48:53 according to the Arizal, for sure not, because48:55 seudah shelishit has to be afterwards.48:58 And also, it's brought down in the49:00 poskim that the mezonot that we told you49:01 is only regarding49:03 seudah shelishit, if a person cannot eat. In such a case,49:05 if you're obviously having bread, the first meal49:07 does not count as a regular meal,49:09 and therefore this meal is not considered49:11 seudah rishonah. But if you want to be49:13 yotzei dei chovah, what you could do is in the shul49:15 have a kezayit of bread, and that will be seudah in the morning.49:17 By the time you come home, you could have49:19 already the second meal,49:21 but that's again all b'diavad, because even49:23 according to the49:25 Pashtanim, even not according to Kabbalah,49:27 lechatchilah, the Rama brings this down,49:30 and all the Acharonim bring this down as well,49:32 lechatchilah it's preferable for a person49:33 to first49:35 pray Mincha and then to have49:38 seudah shelishit afterwards. However, when it's49:39 very, very necessary and a person needs to have49:42 seudah shelishit before49:43 Mincha, for example, let's say49:45 he's going to a place where49:48 at the time of seudah shelishit there will not49:49 be bread. Sometimes you go to a49:51 shul, and the shul doesn't have enough bread,49:53 or they may have enough bread, but49:55 the little kids come and they take, and you49:57 don't usually get bread.49:59 So in such a case, so what are you supposed to do without bread?50:01 So then you should have50:03 seudah shelishit before you pray Mincha. Personally,50:05 I remember one year I had to spend the summer.50:07 Giving classes in50:10 seudah shelishit, and50:11 the place where I had to go to, I wouldn't50:13 have time to be able to give the class50:15 and have seudah shelishit as well. So I50:17 used to have seudah shelishit before I prayed50:19 Mincha, because otherwise I wouldn't be able to have50:21 seudah shelishit afterwards. Whatever the circumstances may be,50:23 if you know that you're not going to have50:25 seudah shelishit later on, or you're not going to have50:27 breakfast seudah shelishit, then you can have50:29 seudah shelishit before Mincha. But preferably,50:31 it should be after50:33 Mincha. I want to point out something50:35 that a lot of people don't talk about, but it's brought down.50:37 It's brought down in the Rama. It's brought down in50:39 the Darkei Moshe.50:41 It's also brought down in50:43 Kaf HaChaim. If you open up almost every halacha sefer50:45 on Shulchan Aruch, they all speak about this.50:47 And what is that?50:48 There's a midrash the Rishonim bring.50:50 Already from the early Rishonim, they bring the following midrash.50:53 It's found in Shochar Tov.50:54 It says like this:51:00 Kol ha-shoteh mayim b'Shabbat bein hashmashot, ke'ilu gozel ha-metim. And the words, I think51:03 the way the Rama brings it is,51:07 Ke'ilu gozel mi-kerovav ha-metim. Whoever drinks water51:10 on Shabbat51:11 bein hashmashot, it's like51:12 he's stealing from his relatives who are dead.51:14 First of all, what is the idea of this?51:17 So it's brought down that51:19 the dead people,51:22 some of51:23 them get tried in Gehenna, right?51:24 And Gehenna, Chazal tell us, it's a place of fire.51:27 So the water51:28 cools them off, and if you drink water51:30 from that time, you take away from their water.51:33 That is the explanation of this.51:34 It's very, very Kabbalistic,51:36 very, very mystical.51:38 You could have a million and one questions on this.51:41 Yes, you're right. A lot of people have questions51:42 on this midrash and the explanation,51:44 but that's what it's brought down. It's not something that anybody made up.51:47 It's a midrash that's brought down, whatever it means.51:49 There have been a few interpretations51:51 to this midrash. Some say51:53 that when it says in the midrash51:54 that whoever drinks bein hashmashot, it's referring to51:57 Friday night,51:58 since you're not allowed to drink anything before52:00 making Kiddush, that's what it's talking about over here.52:02 How it fits with stealing from metim, I don't know,52:04 but that's how some explain it. Some say, no,52:06 it's talking about drinking52:09 on52:11 bein hashmashot. Of motzei Shabbat,52:13 of Shabbat going into52:14 Saturday night, and since it's brought down52:16 that the dead people52:18 rest on Shabbat from52:20 Gehinnom, and now here's the time that they're coming back to52:22 Gehinnom, so therefore,52:24 if you take from their water,52:26 it's like you're stealing from them. You don't give them the water52:28 to cool off. And some say,52:30 since it says,52:32 kelovav hameitim, his relatives who are dead,52:34 so it's only talking about specific people. Who is that?52:36 That's talking about52:38 a person in his first52:40 year of mourning, a person whose52:42 parents have passed away and he's in the first year of52:44 mourning. Since Chazal tell us that52:46 mishpat resha'im b'Gehinnom is52:48 12 months, and just in case,52:49 chas v'shalom, a person may be52:52 in Gehinnom for that52:54 first year, he might want to52:56 cool off, he might need that water to cool off, and you're52:58 drinking from it. Okay?52:59 Again, this is all Kabbalistic.53:01 And some say that this is only53:04 applicable to waters from a53:05 river. If you took waters from a river,53:08 that's one. But to take regular water from a53:09 faucet, it's not applicable. All these53:11 are different opinions, not necessarily do they agree with each other.53:13 By the Ashkenazim,53:15 I saw—I don't know53:17 Ashkenazim—but I saw brought down53:19 that a lot of people have53:21 accustomed to be very, very machmir when it comes to53:23 bein hashmashot, that they don't drink any water. By the way,53:25 this only applies to water. It doesn't53:27 apply to sodas. It doesn't53:29 mean to say like Coke, or it doesn't apply to53:31 wine or orange juice.53:33 It only applies to water. But you could53:35 also53:37 mix up—mix in, excuse me—mix water with other things53:39 also that doesn't apply to it. That53:41 is, a lot of people53:43 have explained it.53:45 Sefardim, Kaf HaChaim brings down, the Ben Ish Chai says53:47 that this is only a problem,53:50 the bein hashmashot from Shabbat53:51 going into Motzei Shabbat,53:53 when a person is drinking53:55 without—53:57 Without eating the meal of53:59 seudah shlishit, meaning,54:01 if you're in the middle of54:02 seudah shlishit, there's no problem to drink54:04 water, even though it's54:06 during54:09 bein hashmashot. That's according to the54:10 Rishon. But if you're not in54:12 bein hashmashot—excuse me—if you're not in the middle of54:15 seudah shlishit and you want to drink water, even according to54:16 halacha it's mutar, but based54:18 on the Midrash, the Rishon says a person should not54:20 drink water at that time.54:22 Wanted to point it out. It's brought54:24 down a person should try to be careful.54:26 And here is the final question, because we're running54:28 out of time. We're not going to be able to talk today54:30 regarding the halachot of54:32 Shabbat mincha, but54:34 we're up to the final question,54:36 and we're going to talk about it next week,54:38 be'ezrat Hashem. And the final question when it comes to seudah shlishit is54:40 as follows: When is54:42 the latest time for a54:44 person to have54:46 seudah shlishit? What does that mean? When is the latest time for a54:48 person to begin eating54:50 seudah shlishit? Like we said, if you began54:52 seudah shlishit in the right time and you want to go all54:54 the way into the evening,54:58 hazak u'baruch, ashrecha, and how fortunate are the people with55:00 you, the patient with you.55:01 That's a great, unbelievable thing.55:03 But to begin55:04 seudah shlishit, when could a person start already washing his hands?55:07 Now, why is there such a question?55:08 And the answer is, we mentioned beforehand55:12 that a person55:15 cannot eat or drink55:17 after the sun sets55:19 on Shabbat afternoon55:21 until he makes55:22 havdalah. Once bein hashmashot comes, you cannot eat or drink55:24 until you make havdalah. That's gezerat chachamim, which we'll talk about55:26 when it comes to55:28 hilchot havdalah. So now that already55:30 it's sheki'ah, how could you go ahead and do netilat55:32 yadayim and eat a meal? It's already—you're not55:34 allowed to eat until you make55:36 havdalah. So that is the question.55:39 So therefore, based on this55:41 halacha, obviously55:43 lechatchilah. Lechatchila, a person55:45 should make sure55:47 to wash before55:48 shekia. Lechatchila, according to all55:50 opinions, make sure to wash before.55:52 However, because55:54 seudah shlishit is a mitzvah,55:56 so therefore the55:58 ol letzion brings down.56:00 In siman chaf alef—excuse me, yeah, in perek56:06 chaf alef, se'if chet, he brings down that if a person is stuck,56:09 he could be lenient to wash after56:14 sheki'ah, as long as it's within thirteen and a half minutes from56:19 sheki'ah. Which means, let's say sheki'ah is at56:23 seven o'clock, so thirteen and a half minutes sha'ot zmaniyot is around, let's say, 7:15, let's say now in the summer.56:27 So a person within the first thirteen and a half minutes,56:31 you could still wash your hands and have56:36 seudah shelishit. But if it's past thirteen and a half minutes already, it's too late.56:39 It's already considered nighttime according to the Geonim,56:41 and it's too late for a person to wash his hands for56:44 seudah shelishit. So let's repeat the halacha.56:45 Lechatchilah, a person should start56:48 seudah shelishit—it means he should begin to wash his hands and have seudah shelishit before56:53 sheki'ah. If a person sees that he ran late,56:56 but it's still within thirteen and a half minutes after56:59 sheki'ah, he could still wash his hands and begin57:02 his seudah shelishit. But if it's after thirteen and a half minutes,57:04 since already that's considered safek according to some opinions,57:07 therefore you should not wash your hands57:10 and, let's say, you lost on57:12 seudah shelishit. And by the way, if you can't wash your hands57:14 and you can't have seudah shelishit with bread,57:16 you can't have it with anything else.57:17 Remember, food you can't eat,57:20 any wine and any other drinks you cannot drink57:23 wine because already you have to make57:25 havdalah. You have to wait till you make57:27 havdalah. Also, water, although according to halacha you're allowed to drink,57:30 like we said, there's a midrash that says a person should try not to drink.57:33 According to these, a person should not drink water57:36 if it's not in the middle of57:38 seudah shelishit of the bein hashmashot from Shabbat going into Saturday night.57:41 This is the end of today's class.57:44 Next week, b'ezrat Hashem, we'll continue with the Ben57:46 Ish Chai. We'll do the halachot of Shabbat,57:48 which will be very, very quick,57:49 and b'ezrat Hashem hopefully we'll move on also to57:51 Parashat Toldot, which speaks about the halachot of aliyot laTorah on Shabbat day.57:58 And we'd like to thank—right before we58:00 conclude—we'd like to thank our sponsors.58:02 This class was sponsored l'hatzlachat Shlomo Eliyahu ben Nina,58:07 as well as Maya Sima bat Pola Boliza.58:10 I would like to thank Rabbi David Levine58:12 and the JRoot Radio staff for hosting us.58:16 And b'ezrat Hashem, if anybody would like to call in58:19 or text in any questions, I'll be here for the next ten, fifteen minutes.58:22 The numbers to the station are58:25 718-683-5858. To text in your question is58:29 347-927-8398. And b'ezrat Hashem, this same class will be aired on again tonight58:32 on JRootRadio.com from 11 to 1258:36 o'clock, wherever you can hear JRoot Radio.58:38 Until then, have a wonderful week and Shabbat shalom.