Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Sefirat Ha’OmerBen Ish Hai – HolidaysRabbi Uri Nahum · April 30, 2014−15Play+30Position0:0059:29Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to Halacha Hour here on0:04JRootRadio.com. You can listen to us on JRootRadio.com or on the JRoot Radio Pro app.0:11Also, if you'd like to listen on the phone, you could call up0:18718-506-909. Let's give you the numbers to the station before we begin the halachot, before we begin0:22the class.0:23The numbers to the station, if you would like to call in for a question,0:27like always, we recommend that you call at the end of the class or we dedicate some0:31time afterwards.0:32Even after we finish the class, we'll be here in the station.0:34The number is0:38718-683-5858. And the text, you can text at any time you'd like. Hopefully we get to it.0:42And the text line is0:46347-927-8398. Again, the text line is0:50347-927-8398. Here in the Halacha Hour, this is the class dedicated once a week.0:55It's aired on, usually online, from 2 to 3 on Wednesday.1:01So if you're listening now on Wednesday from 2 to 3, you're listening live,1:04and it'll be on again from 11 to 12 also on Wednesday evening.1:10The Halacha Hour is for the sake of learning halachot and understanding the halachot.1:16We usually work from the Ben Ish Chai, except if it's a seasonal halacha.1:20For example, right now, today's class will be on Sefirat HaOmer, on counting the1:23Omer. So then we do not work off the Ben Ish Chai unless the Ben Ish Chai has in his sefer somewhere1:29talking about this subject.1:31Before we begin the class, just give a word to our sponsors.1:34Today's class is1:37l'ilui nishmat Yitzchak ben Tzviya, and also it is dedicated for a bracha, a blessing for Zera shel kayama to a certain couple that1:45wants to be anonymous.1:46Okay, today's class is, like we said, is on Sefirat HaOmer and the counting of the1:51Omer. Last week we discussed the halachot regarding what we need to know after Pesach.1:58And although it's not online yet, be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully after today, by today or tomorrow sometime,2:04the video will be online and you can watch the video and you can listen to the class2:08as well on2:10jrootradio.com. And over there you'll see a lot of important halachot that we need to know regarding the2:14laws after Pesach.2:15I know that we came on right after Pesach and a lot of people may have missed it, but2:19it's important to listen to that class.2:20And in that class we mentioned also the minhagim that we have during the Omer, and we mentioned2:26that the minhagim of the Omer are that we have mourning.2:30All the Jewish people are mourning the loss of the 24,000 talmidim of Rabbi Akiva.2:37We're not regular students; they were not little children. These were great Tannaim, where it2:43seems from the Gemara that the great rabbis, Rabbi Meir baal hanes, Rabbi Yehuda bar2:49Ilai, as well as Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, were amongst the smaller of the students, even though they2:56were taught later on, but it seems to be that the 24,000 were even greater than those five3:00rabbis Rabbi Akiva later taught in his life.3:02And therefore it was such a tremendous loss to the world, to the Jewish world. And3:07today—not today means, but since then—we have had the custom of mourning, and there's3:13two main things when it comes to mourning, and number one is we do not have weddings3:18in this time, and number two is that we do not take haircuts or3:23shave, and this is applicable to the men, obviously, not to the women.3:26Although some explained that even some women, some Ashkenazim hold that women also3:32may not take haircuts during the Omer. That's been discussed in last week's class.3:37Music, we mentioned that also music is brought down by the Acharonim not to listen to music,3:42music meaning not regular singing. Well, they call a cappella today just regular singing,3:47when a person is regular singing or regular hazanut, that's not included.3:51We're talking about music where it has musical instruments. So everybody's asking, so how come the radio is3:56playing music with musical instruments?3:59And the answer to that are a few.4:02Last week we mentioned some of the answers. One of the answers is that some people don't4:06begin this Sefirat HaOmer, meaning to say their minhagim of mourning, the customs of4:10mourning, until this Friday, because they begin only after Rosh Chodesh4:15Iyar. So therefore we could play for them.4:17And there's also, there are many, many different customs when it comes to4:21Sefirat HaOmer. We, as Sephardim, may know only the custom that we have. Our custom is right after Pesach,4:26we go all the way until the day after Lag BaOmer, which this year will be May 18th is4:30Lag BaOmer, so the day after is May 19th.4:33However, many Ashkenazim have many different customs. You look in the Grot Moshe,4:40chelek aleph, kuf nun tet, and there he brings all the different types of customs that people have. So therefore, as over here, as an internet station,4:45we could broadcast music with regular music4:49if you are of the opinion or of the custom that you cannot listen to songs with music4:55today, so don't listen. You feel that that's not proper for you, so you don't have to listen.5:01You could just turn it off whenever the music comes on.5:04But this is the halacha as far as from our side to broadcast.5:09From the listeners, you'll have to ask your own local rav. Over here, the radio station5:13got a psak from the rav over here that it's fine to broadcast the music with the musical5:19instruments.5:20Okay, now we'll get to the laws today. Oh, one more thing. I've been asked many times5:25this week, what about going to a wedding?5:28What about going to a wedding during Sefirat HaOmer? What does that5:31mean? We just said we don't make weddings, and the answer is— We talk about people who hold that5:38the custom of mourning only begins this Friday. So many people like to have weddings on Rosh5:42Chodesh. So actually tonight, today, right now, today is Rosh Chodesh, and tonight is Aleph Iyar,5:49and many people have weddings tonight.5:51Question is, if me as a Sefardi, or even if I'm Ashkenazi, but my custom of keeping5:57the aveil began from after Pesach, which means I'm going all the way until after6:02Lag BaOmer, so what do I do when it comes to a wedding? Am I allowed to attend the wedding and dance6:06and listen to music and all these things that we cannot do?6:10And although there are different opinions, Rav Moshe Feinstein explains, he even explains6:14those who say that they'll agree to this, that once it's permitted for the6:18chatan and kallah to get married, it's also permitted for anybody who is invited, anybody who is invited to6:25come to the wedding and attend the simcha and make the chatan and kallah happy in their wedding.6:30And he proves it's a long teshuvah. You look at it in the Igrot Moshe, chelek bet, I believe6:34it's Tzadi hei. You look at it, it's nice. It's not so long, actually. It's pretty simple,6:39the one I gave you. There's another place, but in Tzadi hei it's much simpler. You look6:42over there. But he's matir. He says that it's not a problem for a person to6:48attend the wedding as long as it's permitted for the chatan and kallah to get married. So therefore,6:53everybody else involved, not just the rabbis who are mesader kiddushin, but everybody, all the6:58people invited to the wedding are also permitted to go to the wedding and be mesameach the chatan and kallah, and there's7:04nothing wrong with it. Now we'll get to the halachot of Sefirat HaOmer. Let's begin first7:11of all with the background of the little bit of the mitzvah of Sefirat HaOmer. The mitzvah7:18of Sefirat HaOmer we find in this week's parashah, parashat Emor. The Torah tells us,7:28U'sfartem lachem mimachorat haShabbat, miyom havi'achem et omer hatenufah, sheva shabbatot temimot tihyena. It says, you—excuse me, Shabbat, Shabbatot, yes. It says in this week's parasha, you have to count for yourselves from the day after Shabbat,7:37which means, as Chazal tell us, that means the day after Pesach, which is the beginning of the second night of Pesach,7:48or second day of Pesach, which is second night. The Torah tells us that you must start to count7:56from the day you bring the Omer, you must start to count.8:00Seven weeks, and they have to be complete,8:03temimot.8:04And then the next pasuk says,8:07Tisperu chamishim yom, you have to count fifty days,8:09which Chazal interpreted8:11mean to say forty-nine days up to fifty days,8:13and that is the mitzvah in the Torah.8:16Torah tells us we have to count forty-nine days8:17from the day after Pesach all the way until Shavuot,8:20which is exactly seven weeks and seven days8:23in each week. That comes out to forty-nine days until Shavuot.8:27Now I'm going to go a little bit,8:29not on a tangent,8:31but an important point.8:32Some people may not feel it's important,8:33but it's really important,8:35and that is the question8:37that's already from the time of the Gemara:8:40Is the mitzvah in our days8:41to count the Omer8:44mide'oraita or8:46miderabanan? Is it a Torah obligation,8:47or is it a rabbinic obligation to count the Omer?8:52Why should we say it's rabbinic?8:54It says it clearly in the Torah,8:55U'sfartem lachem8:58mimachorat haShabbat. Why in the world would we think it's rabbinic?9:00And the answer is,9:01although the pasuk is mentioned in the Torah,9:04but still, since the Torah also says9:07from the day that you bring9:09the Omer—the Omer was a special,9:10basically it was a special9:12korban—what they did is that they harvested,9:14the first of the harvest that they took9:17in Eretz Yisrael was brought to the Beit HaMikdash,9:19so that was brought as a korban.9:20The Torah will detail the korban;9:22if you look in this week's parashah,9:23you see the korban.9:25So since the Torah says that you have to count9:27when you bring the korban,9:29so maybe you would say that,9:30you know what,9:31today that we don't have a Beit HaMikdash9:33and we're not bringing the korban,9:34the counting is not9:36mide'oraita because it seems like the Torah depended on that.9:38Or you could say,9:39no, bottom line,9:40the Torah gives a mitzvah.9:41It happens to be it mentions it next to the korban,9:43and just because we don't have the9:44korban doesn't mean the mitzvah is not around.9:46We still have the mitzvah9:47mide'oraita to count.9:48This is whatever answer you answer,9:50you are correct,9:51because this is a machloket.9:52It's a machloket from the Gemara.9:53It's a machloket also in the Rishonim.9:55Let's go from9:57the Gemara,9:58and then go through the whole Gemara.9:59The Gemara is found in Masechet Menachot,10:00daf samech vav amud aleph, 66a.10:04If you have10:05art scroll. Anyway, so the Gemara says that10:08there was a machloket already10:09between Rabbanan d'bei Rab Ashi and10:13a memar, and whatever they did10:14basically comes out like this,10:15that according to the rabbis10:16in the yeshiva of10:18Rab Ashi, some say,10:20is that they10:22counted—the way they counted,10:24they understood that the10:25counting is an obligation10:27min haTorah. And a memar, the way he counted,10:29he understood that it's really,10:30it's only a10:31zecher, in memory of the Beit HaMikdash,10:33in commemoration of the10:34Temple that we had once upon a time.10:36So therefore it's only a10:37zecher to remember Beit HaMikdash,10:39just like we shake the lulav10:41on seven days of the holiday,10:43even on10:44mide'oraita, you all have to do10:46u'kachtem lachem bayom harishon. Why do we do it for seven days?10:47To remember what was done in Beit HaMikdash.10:49We do so also over here.10:52We count the10:52omer in order to remember the Beit HaMikdash.10:55Those are the two opinions in the Gemara.10:57And the machloket extended10:58even to the Rishonim,10:59the rabbis of before the11:03Shulchan Aruch, from seven, eight hundred years ago already,11:05nine hundred,11:06you could go even—the Rif, the Rambam,11:08as well as the11:09Chinuch, all of them hold11:10that the counting that we do today,11:12the counting of the omer that we do today,11:13is also11:15mide'oraita. It's a Torah obligation.11:16However, there's others who disagree:11:19the Rosh,11:20the Rashba, Tur, the Raza,11:21and of course11:22there's many others on each side as well.11:24They hold that the mitzvah is11:29miderabbanan. The mitzvah is miderabbanan. You're probably wondering,11:31who cares if it's11:34de'oraita or derabbanan? You'll see that you must know this.11:36It's very important to know11:37if it's11:38de'oraita or derabbanan in order that you'll understand11:40many things in the rest of the class.11:43In any case, we want to know.11:44Bottom line,11:45we hold like11:46Shulchan Aruch. Even Ashkenazim,11:47if the Rama doesn't disagree,11:49we hold like Maran,11:50the11:51Shulchan Aruch, the Mechaber. So what is the opinion of the11:53Mechaber? What is the opinion of Maran Beit Yosef?11:54Is counting the Omer in our days11:57mideoraita or12:00miderabbanan? So Maran in the Beit Yosef,12:03not in the12:04Shulchan Aruch, in the Beit Yosef,12:05seems to imply that12:07counting in our days is12:08derabbanan. There he brings a certain law,12:10a certain12:11din, and he disagrees on the12:13rabbi who said the din. He says12:15because in our days,12:16like the Ran says,12:17the majority of Rishonim hold12:19that the counting in our days12:21is only12:22derabbanan. Therefore, you can be lenient12:22in certain12:23cases, whatever the case may be.12:24In the12:25Shulchan Aruch, though, he doesn't write12:26if it's deoraita or12:27derabbanan. And usually, if Maran doesn't write in12:30Shulchan Aruch, just because he may say something12:31in Beit Yosef,12:32not always does he agree12:34when it comes to12:36Shulchan Aruch. Not always will he continue12:37in the same ruling12:38when it comes to12:39Shulchan Aruch. Ninety-five percent of the time, yes,12:41but not always.12:42So therefore,12:42Maran doesn't say his opinion in12:46Shulchan Aruch. But there are proofs12:47that you can bring12:48from the12:50Shulchan Aruch that Maran,12:51the Beit Yosef,12:52the Mechaber, holds12:53that counting Sefirat HaOmer,12:55counting the Omer in our days,12:57is12:58miderabbanan. We'll bring you two quick proofs.13:01And first of all,13:02as follows.13:02First of all, Maran holds13:05that when there is a need,13:07a person could count13:09the Omer in bein hashmashot.13:11What is bein hashmashot?13:13Bein hashmashot is the period13:14between sunset and13:16tzeit hakochavim. According to13:17halacha, any time before sunset13:20is considered daytime,13:22and any time after13:25tzeit hakochavim, when the stars come out,13:26is considered13:28nighttime. The time in between,13:29I believe in English, is called twilight.13:31The time in between is a question.13:33The time in between is called bein hashmashot,13:36and we discussed this in Chol Shabbat,13:38and we discussed it at length.13:39You should13:40listen to the classes we had on bein hashmashot.13:43There we discussed it at13:44length. In any case,13:45in between time13:46is called bein hashmashot.13:47The Gemara in Masechet Shabbat explains13:49that the time in between13:51is safek yom, safek13:53layla, safek yom13:55valayla. We're not sure if it's really a day.13:57We're not sure if it's really part of the night.13:59We're not sure if it's a mixture of day and night.14:01So therefore,14:02we're always stringent14:04when it comes to laws14:06that are14:07mideoraita, for example, Shabbat.14:08We accept Shabbat by sunset.14:11So once sunset comes,14:12that's it, it's already Shabbat.14:14Even though it's technically,14:16it's a safek, still14:17safek14:18de'oraita l'chumra. When it comes to the laws of14:20derabanan, we're more lenient over there14:21when it comes to laws of14:22derabanan in bein hashmashot.14:24And here you see14:27where the Shulchan Aruch says14:28that a person could count in bein hashmashot.14:31So it comes out that really14:34he's holding that safek14:35derabanan. How could you make a blessing14:37and count14:39over here Sefirat HaOmer in bein hashmashot14:40if you really hold14:42that it's de'oraita, safek14:43de'oraita l'chumra? Obviously, the fact that Maran says14:46that you could count14:48Sefirat HaOmer during bein hashmashot,14:49he holds that it is14:51derabanan. That's one proof.14:51Another proof14:53is a little bit more complicated,14:56and just to go quickly,14:59basically, I'm looking at the time.15:01I don't think I'm going to have so much time15:03if I go through the whole proof.15:04But basically,15:05Maran Shulchan Aruch15:06in Orach Chaim taf-pei-tet se'if vav,15:09over here in Birkat Halacha, he says that if a person15:11does not know the day15:12when he made the blessing,15:14he was thinking the wrong day.15:16L'mashal, he was thinking,15:17let's say tonight is the 16th,15:18okay,15:19and when the person was making the15:21beracha, he thought it was the 17th.15:23And then afterwards15:25he realized at the end of the15:26beracha that he realized that it's really15:28not the date that he was thinking about.15:30There's a question15:31based on the Gemara15:32Masechet Berachot if that works or not.15:34Maran was lenient whichever way it is.15:36As long as you counted,15:38even though you thought the wrong date,15:39it still works.15:40That's the opinion of Shulchan Aruch,15:42and over there15:43the Acharonim bring,15:44look, over here clearly15:45he's ruling15:48safek derabanan lekula. I know it's not so clear15:50the way I said it,15:51and the reason is because15:52to really explain it15:53will take another ten minutes,15:54and we don't have that time15:55to get through all the things.15:56Okay,15:57now let's get to our original question.16:00What is the difference if Sefirat HaOmer, for me, today? What's the difference16:04if it's the right day? Bottom line, I have to do it, right?16:06So what is the difference?16:08Well, we already told you the rule.16:10There's a rule that we have when it comes to psak halacha,16:14when we come to rule halacha.16:16We, maybe most of us,16:19maybe we'll just open up the book and see whatever the rabbis rule,16:22and that's it. We will go and follow whatever our rabbis tell us to do.16:26Whether they tell us, when they tell us to jump, we jump as high as they want us to jump,16:30or whatever they tell us, we follow what our rabbis tell us.16:32And if it's the right or the derabanan, if they're lenient, if they want to be machmir, that's what we follow.16:36But as far as a person who wants to understand the reasoning of the psak halacha,16:41the rule is as follows.16:44Whenever you have a doubt in a matter that is min16:47haTorah, that matter that is an obligation16:50min haTorah, which is called safek, a doubt,16:54de'oraita, on a subject from the Torah,16:56the rule is lechumra. We're always stringent.16:59However, if you have a doubt17:01when the subject is one which is rabbinical,17:05let's say there's a law that's only rabbinic,17:07Chazal made it establish a certain law that's only rabbinic,17:10the rule is17:14safek derabanan lekula. Since it's a doubt in a law that's17:16derabanan, that's only rabbinical, we will be lenient.17:19Who is we? We doesn't mean you.17:22We means the poskim,17:24the poskim who are coming, the rabbis who are studying the laws,17:28studying the Torah the whole time,17:29and they have to decide on a certain law.17:31This is the rules that they'll work with.17:34For me and you, we can't just pick and say,17:36okay, this is safek, and this is17:38derabanan, so it must be safek, I'm going to be lenient,17:40and this is de'oraita, safek, I'm going to be stringent.17:42We can't do that.17:43We have to listen to what our rabbis tell us to do.17:46If we want to understand how to learn,17:47we understand the laws that we're learning,17:50it's important to know this rule.17:51This rule is for those who are learning psak17:54halacha—excuse me—those who are learning the dinim from the sources,17:57and they have the obligation of giving us a psak18:01halacha. So therefore, they're going to have to know this rule,18:05and that's what they work with.18:07Let's get to another explanation in the mitzvah of counting Omer.18:11We mentioned the pasuk. The verse says,18:13Sheva Shabbatot, when you count, you count seven weeks,18:18temimot18:20tihyena. The weeks also have to be complete.18:24Temim, tamim means shalem, like from the word shalem, a complete whole.18:27You have to count seven whole weeks.18:29And here we have a difference of opinion.18:35We have a different way of understanding what temimot means.18:39Mainly, we have three shitot, two, but three shitot that comes out18:42how to explain the obligation of temimot.18:46According to the Bahag and Rabbi Yehudai Gaon, they write the following.18:51They say that if a person forgot one of the days of the Omer,18:54we have 49 days. Let's say a person forgot to count one of the days,18:57that's it, you lost it. You cannot continue to count anymore.19:01If you count, it means nothing.19:03Let's say, for example, a person has been counting19:06one day, two days, three days. He got up to day number 24.19:10Now, the 25th day he forgot about it.19:13Whatever the reason may be, it doesn't make a difference.19:15He forgot. He did not on purpose. He was anus.19:17At the end of the day, he didn't count.19:19He gets to day number 26, and he remembers that,19:25wow, I did not count the whole day, the whole 25th day.19:29According to the Bahag, don't bother counting 26, 27, 28, according to him. Why?19:33Because you already lost it.19:37The Torah says you have to be complete. You already broke it.19:39You don't have complete. You didn't count all the 49 days.19:43So if you continue counting, it absolutely means nothing19:46because you already broke the count19:48and you don't have the complete mitzvah.19:53As some explain it, temimot means19:56that the whole mitzvah, the whole 49 days, is considered one big mitzvah,20:00and once you cut it, you already broke it.20:04However, most Rishonim do not agree with the20:08Bahag and Rabbi Yehuda. Most Rishonim disagree with this interpretation.20:12Most Rishonim hold that when the Torah says20:16temimot, this doesn't mean that if you missed one day, you can't continue counting.20:20Most Rishonim hold that every single day is a separate mitzvah.20:24Every day that I count is another mitzvah.20:26I counted yesterday, last night's20:29Omer, I counted last night, I was the 15th of the20:32Omer. Today, when I count the 16th, it's another mitzvah.20:34That means at the end of Tavshin Ayin20:39Daled, if I counted all 49 days in Shamayim, I'll have 49 mitzvot.20:43According to the Bahag, if I counted all 49 days,20:46I only have one mitzvah.20:49Therefore, the meaning of temimot, according to the Bahag, means20:52that the whole 49 days have to be complete,20:56otherwise I broke the mitzvah.20:58According to the other Rishonim, the majority of the other Rishonim,21:01the meaning of temimot means21:03that each day, I have to make sure that each day is shalem.21:07I have to make sure that I count each day.21:08And even though I missed one of the days, I can still continue,21:10even with a blessing, according to the other Rishonim.21:12Why? Because21:16each day is not connected to the other one.21:18I still am fulfilling another mitzvah,21:21so I didn't do one of the days.21:22I missed one of the days,21:23so I won't have 49 mitzvot.21:25I'll have only 48 or 47.21:27But still, each day is a separate mitzvah.21:29That's the opinion of the majority of the other Rishonim.21:31There's a third opinion that's not so famous,21:33the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam.21:34The way some explain it,21:36Rabbeinu Tam holds that21:39in order to be out of the loop,21:41in order to be out of the,21:43basically, of counting the21:45Omer, in order to break counting the21:47Omer, you have to miss the night.21:50If you miss the night21:51only, that already you can't continue the next day.21:53You lost it.21:54We know that the Tanna and Omer were counting for the whole day,21:57and the day begins with the night22:00and then we go to the day.22:01According to Rabbeinu Tam,22:02if you miss counting at night,22:04it already doesn't make a difference if you count in the day;22:06you lost it.22:07Does he hold that it's 49 separate mitzvot22:10or only one big mitzvah?22:12It's not clear from the words of Rabbeinu Tam,22:14but this is what he says regarding the22:16nighttime, that you only count at night but not in the daytime.22:19Well, that's the way at least some Rishonim explain22:22him. In any case,22:23remember what we said as a rule:22:29Isfekta d'Omri d'Rabbanan de'oraita. Counting with Omer is22:29deRabbanan, so therefore,22:32lehalacha, in general,22:33we're going to see the full details later on,22:36we hold22:38lekula. Since the counting with Omer is22:41deRabbanan, so we're lenient22:42to go with22:43most opinions. Who's the most lenient opinion?22:44The opinion that says that if you miss the counting,22:46so therefore you can continue counting afterwards22:48because you still have another chance to make it up later on.22:51So therefore, we're going to be22:52lenient when it comes to counting22:54Omer, since counting Omer is22:56anyway deRabbanan, safek deRabbanan lekula, and besides the fact that we have the majority of the Rishonim,22:59we're going to say count anyway, continue counting anyway.23:02However,23:03the blessing that we make on the mitzvah23:05is23:06de'oraita. Since the blessing is23:08de'oraita, so we come back to the23:11safek de'oraita lechumra. When we have a doubt in the law23:12that's23:14min haTorah, we have to be stringent.23:15So over here, although we may continue counting,23:18we can't make the23:20blessing because when it comes to the blessing,23:22we have to be stringent and say23:25that we23:26safek de'oraita lechumra and not make23:27a berachah. That's23:29the halachah lemaaseh. If a person forgets to count23:32one full night and one full day,23:34he does not continue to count23:36with the blessing.23:37He should continue to count anyway,23:39but without a blessing.23:40Let's give an example.23:41Tonight will be, I believe, the 16th of the23:43Omer. Let me just check over here.23:45Yet tonight is the 16th of the23:50Omer, which means, which means23:51that if a person forgets to23:52count tonight, the 16th of the23:55Omer, so therefore what should he do?23:56What he should do is23:57count the 17th and—24:00Onwards, every day onwards, but without a24:03beracha. Why? Because according to the Rishonim, that's a mitzvah, so you're doing according to those Rishonim,24:07according to the other ones, according to the Rishonim, according to the Bahag, who says that you broke it.24:12Okay, so I won't make a beracha. I won't lose if I make a beracha, if I count without a24:16beracha. That is a halacha l'maaseh. Another halacha l'maaseh, based on these other Rishonim,24:20the primary time to count with a blessing is at24:24nighttime. We're going to see later on that it runs all the way until24:26alot hashachar. If a person, if a person forgot to count at night,24:33then in the daytime for the next day you could still count,24:37but make sure you count without a blessing. Why?24:40So you can be yotzei de'ah, according to Rabbeinu Tam. Remember, Rabbeinu Tam holds that the next day you can't count; you already lost it.24:46So therefore, we count the next day, but without a blessing.24:49This is a background to the mitzvah of Sefirat HaOmer.24:55It is, I agree, it is a little bit more complicated,24:58especially for one who is not used to studying inside,25:00but one who is listening and paying attention, wants to know the source of the25:04din, it will be very, very helpful to understand many of the halachot later on.25:08And now we'll get to practical:25:09how to count, when to count, what time to count, who should count,25:13mazat Hashem. We now will get to the practical part of the halachot of Sefirat HaOmer.25:19Let's begin, first of all, who is obligated to count25:22the Omer? Well, like any mitzvah, men that are from the ages of bar mitzvah and onwards,25:28which is thirteen years old and one day and up,25:31all men are obligated in the counting of the25:34Omer. What about women? Are women obligated to count the25:38Omer? So technically, women are exempt.25:41Why? We have the rule. What's the rule?25:43Rule is,25:47mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama, nashim peturot. The Mishnah Masechet Kiddushin says25:50any commandment... That is25:54a mitzvat aseh, which is—what does it mean,25:55mitzvat aseh? That means it's a positive commandment.25:56We have in our Torah mitzvot that we are obligated to do,25:59where the Torah commands us to be active and go ahead and do them.26:03And then we have mitzvot where the Torah commands us to be passive and not to do them.26:06It restricts us from keeping them.26:08The ones where the Torah commands us to keep, that's called26:12mitzvat aseh. The ones where the Torah forbids us from keeping,26:15restricts us, and tells us not to26:18do, that's called mitzvot26:20lo ta'aseh. So therefore, the mitzvot26:24aseh, if it comes in a specific time,26:27in general women are exempt.26:29There are exceptions, but in general women are exempt,26:31unless you have a special exemption26:33like Shabbat and Megillat Esther, whatever.26:37There are times when we have a special exemption from this26:41rule. But otherwise, as a general rule,26:44mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama, women are exempt.26:45So therefore,26:49Seferat HaOmer, is it a mitzvat aseh or lo ta'aseh? Well, what's the command?26:51U'sfartem lachem. Torah says you must count, so it's26:54mitzvat aseh. And when does the mitzvah begin?26:57When does it come?26:58It comes between Pesach to Shavuot.27:00That's a specific time.27:02So therefore, it's called27:05mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama. And like we said,27:08mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama, the Mishnah says that women are exempt.27:11So therefore, that's a simple explanation27:13why women do not count27:15the Omer. They're exempt from counting27:16the Omer because27:18it's mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama, and that is the way the Rambam brings it as well.27:21So what about if a woman wants to count?27:25She wants to count,27:26even though she's exempt, she wants to count.27:28So here we come to a27:30machloket between Sefardim and Ashkenazim.27:32According to the Ashkenazim,27:34they hold that if a woman—27:38In this case, it's a woman.27:39A person who is exempt from a mitzvah27:42and wants to fulfill the mitzvah anyway,27:45he could still make a blessing on the mitzvah.27:48Baruch Atah Hashem27:50asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu. Why? Hashem didn't command us.27:52Still, since you're coming27:53and obligating yourself to do the mitzvah,27:55you could still make a bracha on it.27:56That's the way the Ashkenazim rule,27:58which, if you've seen during Sukkot,28:00Chabad and many Lubavitchers28:03will give the lulav and etrog to28:05women and make them make a28:06bracha, because according to the Ashkenazim,28:08you can make a blessing on mitzvot28:10aseh shehazman gerama to28:11women. Sefardim hold no.28:13We hold that if you're exempt from the mitzvah,28:15if you want to keep the mitzvah,28:17chazak u'baruch, kol hakavod,28:18we'll give you28:20a yishar koach. However, you cannot make a blessing on the mitzvah.28:23How can you say,28:25asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu? Hashem didn't command us.28:26So therefore,28:28it's Sefardiya that wants to fulfill28:32a mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama, where she's exempt,28:35she can do so, but she cannot make a blessing on it.28:37For example,28:38if she wants to shake lulav and etrog on Sukkot,28:41kol hakavod,28:42chazak28:42u'baruch, shake it,28:43but don't make a blessing on it,28:45okay?28:46That is true by almost every single28:50mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama. However, when it comes to counting the28:52Omer, there's an additional factor that we have to consider,28:55and that is based on the Zohar.28:59The Zohar says,29:00obviously Kabbalistic,29:01it's not only the Zohar,29:02it's also the Arizal,29:04the Ben Ish Chai brings it down,29:06or Litzion also quotes them,29:07but this is all based on the Kabbalah.29:09Don't ask me to explain it.29:10This is not my area for sure.29:14But the Zohar says that29:16women have no place to count29:19Sefirat HaOmer, and therefore Kaf HaChaim also brings it down29:21that women should not count29:23Omer. Even though in general we say29:26mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama, where women are29:27exempt, if she wants to do it,29:28why not? Kol hakavod, let her do it.29:29When it comes to counting29:30Omer, women should not count29:32Omer al pi Kabbalah.29:33Okay,29:33this is for Sefardim, it's binding.29:36For Ashkenazim,29:37some have a minhag where women count29:39and not let them count with a blessing.29:42Asobrodan, Piskei Teshuvot brings down in the name of29:45Chut HaShani that in the house of the29:47Steipler, that's the father of29:50Rav Chaim Kanievsky, the ladies used to count with a blessing.29:55Okay, but again, that's only pertaining to Ashkenazim.29:57For29:58Sefardim, women should not count,30:00certainly without a30:02berachah, and even without a30:04berachah lechatchilah they shouldn't count at all.30:06Let's now move on to the next people30:09who are obligated or not obligated:30:11children. Children means any children30:13who are under the age of bar mitzvah or bat mitzvah.30:16Well, bat mitzvah, like30:17we said, girls anyway shouldn't count30:19Sefardim, but even according to Ashkenazim,30:20under bar or bat mitzvah,30:22they are exempt like30:24they're exempt from all the other mitzvot in the Torah.30:26However, we do have, as30:29parents, the obligation to train them,30:31and baruch Hashem we send them to yeshivot,30:33and we send them to places30:35where they're going to learn Torah,30:36we get them tutors,30:37and therefore they teach them30:38that they should count,30:40and they could count even with a blessing,30:41even if they missed a day or two or three.30:44The children could count with a30:46blessing because30:47they're doing it for training purposes,30:49and therefore you could train the30:50children to count with a blessing,30:52and it's a very good training, why not?30:54And give maybe special prizes30:55if the children are able to count the whole thing.30:57The question, though, is as follows.31:00This is a very interesting question,31:01and technically it happened to me, I guess,31:04because this applied to me when I was a little child.31:07What if a person becomes bar mitzvah,31:09if a child becomes bar mitzvah31:11in between the days of Pesach and Shavuot,31:13he becomes bar mitzvah in the days of Omer.31:15Should he now continue as an adult now,31:18in halachah he's considered an31:19adult after becoming bar mitzvah,31:21should he continue counting the Omer with a blessing or not?31:24To count without a blessing, you never lose, like we said,31:27because according to the shittot that hold that31:29each day is a separate mitzvah,31:30so you're fulfilling a mitzvah.31:32But to count with a blessing is the question.31:35Now, this is a big, big machloket.31:39It's a big machloket.31:40For sure you could say almost,31:41almost between Ashkenazim,31:43Sefardim, but even amongst the Sefardim we find a machloket.31:45Let's begin with the opinion of Hacham Ovadia zatzal.31:49Hacham Ovadia, when I say Hacham31:50Ovadia, you should know, usually comes from many, many other31:54Acharonim. There's not only the opinion of Hacham31:56Ovadia. The following is also the opinion of the31:58Pri HaAretz, the Hidda, the Chaim Palachi, and even—32:00Even from Neshek Nazim, we find the Chidushei Harim.32:02Chidushei Harim, Rabbi Yitzchak Meir of Gur, the first Ger32:08Rebbe, they all hold that a child, even though he's been counting.32:11So let's say a person becomes bar mitzvah32:14lag ba'omer. So he's been counting from after Pesach,32:17he's been counting every single day with the blessing as a child.32:20Now, lag ba'omer he becomes bar mitzvah.32:23What should he do? Should he count now with a blessing or not?32:25According to them, he may not continue to count with a32:29blessing. Why not? Because if he counts with a blessing32:33now—excuse me, why not? Because up till now, the counting that he did means nothing.32:38It was all done mitzad chinuch, for training purposes,32:41and it's considered as if he became—not as32:45if—since he becomes obligated by32:48lag ba'omer, now his obligation begins.32:49So it's considered that he missed already all the first 33 days of Sefirat HaOmer.32:54So the counting that he's doing now, he's coming in the32:57middle. They're not considered temimot, they're not considered complete according to the33:00Bach. So how can he make a blessing?33:01That's the opinion of33:04Chacham Ovadia, that a child who becomes bar mitzvah in the middle of the Sefirat HaOmer33:08cannot count with a blessing from now on.33:11He should count, but without a blessing.33:13However, not everybody agrees with this.33:16Like we said, the Olat Tzion, even amongst the33:19Sefardim, the Olat Tzion and33:21Kaf HaChaim, Chacham Ben Tzion Abba Shaul zatzal and Kaf HaChaim Sofer,33:24both of them say that the child who becomes bar mitzvah in Sefirat HaOmer33:29and he has been counting till now,33:32he didn't break the chain of counting,33:35he may continue counting with a blessing.33:38Why?33:39Because they bring33:41from—the Olat Tzion really explains in33:44chelek alef, it's also brought down in33:45chelek gimel—he explains as follows,33:47that really since the child... Has counted,33:50so really there was still a counting,33:52even though he did it when he was not obligated.33:54But still, at the end of the day,33:55he can't say that he broke the chain.33:57He has temimot.33:59He still has his weeks complete in the counting.34:02And even if you want to tell me that it doesn't work,34:05still we find Acharonim like the34:08Chartzvi, which is Rav Tzvi Pesach Frank,34:10who explained it this way.34:13Other later34:14Acharonim, but even earlier Acharonim who went this way.34:15So let it be, it's a34:16safek. I believe even Minchat Chinuch also goes this way,34:19so it's a34:20safek. When it comes to Sefirat HaOmer,34:21we're going to learn later on,34:22when you have a34:23sfeik sfeika, you could still count.34:25So therefore, according to Chacham Ben34:26Tzion, a child who becomes bar mitzvah34:28in the middle of Sefirat HaOmer34:29could continue with a blessing.34:31So you have a machloket here:34:35Chacham Ovadia, Chida, Rav Chaim Palachi,34:37Pri HaAretz on one side,34:37versus the34:39Olat Yitzchak, on the other side.34:40What do you do?34:41So we usually revert back to our rule,34:44which is34:46safek berachot lehakel, unless you have a rabbi that tells you otherwise,34:49and you ask otherwise34:51and you get a different34:52psak, and you go like the Olat Tzion all the time,34:54okay?34:54So you could go like the34:56Olat Tzion and the Kaf HaChaim. But otherwise,34:57we have a machloket over here between the35:00Acharonim. When it comes to35:01berachot, safek berachot lehakel. Anyway,35:02a person makes35:03counts without the35:05berachah, the mitzvah you did,35:06so the35:07berachah, okay, you35:08won't. So there's a safek on the35:10berachah. You say35:12safek berachot lehakel in general.35:13However,35:13this is only for the35:15Sefardim. The Ashkenazim,35:16many, many later35:17Acharonim Ashkenazim35:19hold that you could count with a blessing.35:21The child who becomes bar mitzvah in the middle of the35:24Omer could continue counting with a blessing,35:26to the point that there's some who say35:28that even if he didn't count with a blessing,35:29now he could count with a blessing.35:31But bottom line,35:32the minhag is like the opinion that we mentioned in the beginning,35:35that they count.35:36The Ashkenazim,35:37they have a minhag35:38that the child becomes bar mitzvah in the middle of35:40Sefirat HaOmer, he may continue counting with a35:43berachah as long as he started counting from the beginning35:50with— He started counting meaning without missing any of the days.35:52However, one important point for the Ashkenazim,35:55that sometimes35:56if a person missed one of the days of counting the36:01Omer, so since he can't continue counting36:03with a bracha, he can listen to somebody else's blessing36:05and be yotzei with it.36:06Try to avoid having such a katan,36:09meaning to say36:09this child who became bar mitzvah in36:12Sefirat HaOmer, try to avoid having him cover you for the blessing,36:15because there's a36:16safek if he himself should make a bracha or not.36:19The minhag is that the Ashkenazim36:21hold that he could continue counting with a blessing.36:23Still, try to avoid having him be motzi you for the36:28bracha. That is who is obligated.36:31Next we have to discuss,36:33we have to explain,36:34is when to count.36:35What is the best time to count the36:38Omer? And let's begin.36:39The36:40day—remember, it's a mitzvah on the days,36:41you're counting36:42days—and when does the day begin36:44according to halacha? Look in the Torah,36:45the first page:36:48Vayehi erev vayehi boker, yom echad. The day begins from the erev, from the evening.36:51Our day begins from36:53nighttime; that's why Shabbat begins Friday night,36:55and Motzaei Shabbat—Shabbat finishes also Motzaei Shabbat,36:57Saturday36:58night—because our day begins in the37:00nighttime. So therefore, we're counting the days37:02over here, we must count it when? When the night comes.37:06When is the best time to count?37:07Obviously,37:08because either you want to say37:10zrizim makdimin lamitzvot, or because of the reason37:14temimot tihyena. What does mean temimot? Remember, the Torah commands37:16that they have to be complete,37:18and many Rishonim explain37:20each day has to be complete.37:22How do you consider that you counted the day complete?37:24At the earliest time37:26that the day begins,37:27and the day begins in37:31halacha at tzeit hakochavim. And therefore, Maran brings down Shulchan37:33Aruch—even though37:34he doesn't say those words,37:35even37:36though—but he says37:40that the best time, medakdekim, sofrim b'tzeit hakochavim. The best time to count is37:41tzeit hakochavim. What it means is37:44that Shulchan Aruch is telling us37:45that even though this is37:47mitzvah derabbanan, and technically because it's37:48derabbanan we could have been lenient to count37:50at any time that37:51would fit in according to37:53halacha, still,37:54if you want to be precise,37:55if you want to be one of those people37:57who are careful to do the37:58mitzvot properly37:59and medakdek, so you should count by38:02tzeit hakochavim. But you probably are saying,38:04okay, that doesn't solve the issue,38:06Rabbi. What in the world is38:08tzeta kochavim? Tzeta kochavim is vague.38:10What does it mean that the stars come out?38:11Today we work with minutes38:13and time.38:14So therefore,38:14you should know38:15tzeta kochavim is a big38:16machloket. We also spoke about this38:17in our halachot Shabbat classes.38:19You look over there,38:20many, many different opinions38:21what is called38:23tzeta kochavim. We'll just bring you a few38:24different opinions,38:26three shittot that you keep in mind.38:29According to Hacham Ben Zion, tzeta kochavim means38:30between 25 to 27 minutes38:31after38:32shekia. So let's say38:34shekia is,38:34I believe tonight,38:367:50. So therefore,38:3825 minutes afterwards38:39will be around38:428:15. That is the opinion of38:43Hacham38:44Ben Zion. Wait till38:45about 25,38:4527 minutes38:46after38:47shekia to make a blessing.38:48According to Hacham38:50Ovadia, we find that the earliest time,38:52the earliest calculation38:53you can make38:53according to the Geonim38:54of38:55tzeta kochavim is 13 and a half minutes.38:57So therefore,38:58since counting38:58always there38:59miderabbanan, so we could take39:01the most lenient opinion,39:02and therefore39:02you could count as early39:03as 13 and a half minutes39:05after39:06shekia. That's according to39:07Hacham39:07Ovadia. That's called39:08tzeta kochavim already,39:09because keep in mind39:09this is only39:11derabbanan. What about if a person39:12keeps Rabbeinu Tam?39:13We all know39:14Rabbeinu Tam's opinion.39:14Rabbeinu Tam holds that39:18sunset—tzeta kochavim, excuse me,39:18not39:20sunset—tzeta kochavim, the three stars come out39:2172 minutes after sunset.39:22That's a famous opinion39:23of Rabbeinu Tam.39:24So what should a person do39:25when it comes to39:26Sefirat HaOmer?39:26On one hand,39:27if I wait39:2972 minutes39:30till I count39:31Sefirat HaOmer,39:32so39:32I'm not really39:34keeping what it says,39:35temimot.39:35Remember,39:36temimot here means39:36it should be all complete.39:38On the other hand,39:39if I count a little earlier,39:40according to Rabbeinu Tam,39:41it's not really39:42tzeta. I want to be one of39:42the39:43medakdekim. So the consensus39:44of the39:45poskim is as follows.39:46Now,39:47most people39:47don't hold Rabbeinu Tam39:48all the way.39:49They don't hold39:50everything like Rabbeinu Tam.39:52Most people,39:53most people39:53are stringent39:54like Rabbeinu Tam39:55when it comes to39:57subjects that are39:59mideoraita or subjects.40:00sects that are more stringent, like,40:03let's say,40:04Motzaei Shabbat or Motzaei Yom Kippur.40:06Most people are that way.40:08So therefore,40:11if—however, when it comes to40:12dinim which are mederabbanan, let's say Motzaei Yom Tov40:14HaSheni or at the end of a fast,40:16a regular fast day,40:19so most people are not going to be40:21stringent like the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam.40:23So therefore, if you're such a40:24person, that you only follow Rabbeinu Tam's opinion40:27in times where40:30it's deoraita, like Motzaei Shabbat or Motzaei Yom Kippur,40:32Motzaei Hagim40:33even to some extent,40:35then—but otherwise you won't follow the opinion of Rabbeinu40:38Tam—so then you should count in the earlier times40:40that we mentioned.40:41Don't wait till Rabbeinu Tam to count the40:42Omer. But if you're of the opinions that hold40:45like Rabbeinu Tam in everything,40:47even if the subject is40:49derabbanan, you'll still wait till Rabbeinu Tam.40:51You're machmir to hold like Rabbeinu Tam in every area,40:53in every aspect of halacha.40:55So in that case,40:57you're right,40:57then you should wait until Rabbeinu Tam,41:00because for you that's called41:02safek kochavim. That's how you've conducted your life.41:06That's how you41:09follow every halacha,41:10like Rabbeinu Tam.41:11So you can wait 72 minutes until after41:14shekiah in order for you to count the Sfirat41:17HaOmer. However,41:18me'ikar hadin, you have to know41:20that41:21technically—this right now we explained41:22according to Shulchan Aruch,41:25hamedakdekim, if you want to be precise in your halacha.41:28But me'ikar hadin, technically41:33a person can be yotzei dei chovah bein hashmashot. Bein hashmashot means after41:35shekiah. And where is this practical?41:38It's practical in two areas.41:39Number one, if you're praying with a minyan41:41and they finish Arvit right after sunset,41:44even though it's before41:47set hakochavim, the41:48tzibur could count.41:49Not only they count, they should count.41:50The tzibur should count. Somebody should count.41:53Not everybody has to count,41:55but the minyan itself, as a minyan, should41:57count, because why? Because most people don't remember to count.41:59Let's be honest, most people forget.42:02Most people have many things on their mind,42:03like their BlackBerrys and their iPhones42:05and their text messages,42:06and Baruch Hashem people have good things on their42:08mind also, their family and their other things and their work.42:10So therefore people forget to42:13count. So therefore, as a tzibur, as a minyan,42:14they should count in the minyan.42:17If you yourself don't want to count,42:18we'll talk about you afterwards.42:20The other practicality of knowing this42:23din, that technically a person42:25could be yotzei42:26dei chovah when counting after sunset,42:28even during the time of bein hashmashot,42:30is the following halacha.42:32You have to be careful when somebody42:34is not to mention to anybody42:36what day it is before you yourself42:39count it, because there is a42:41machloket if mitzvot42:42need kavanah or not.42:44What does that mean?42:44It means that if I am counting,42:47or if I'm fulfilling a mitzvah,42:49must I have intention42:51that I'm fulfilling the mitzvah,42:52or if I fulfill the mitzvah by accident,42:55it counts anyway?42:56That's a machloket. It's found in42:58Hilchot Kriat Shema, I believe siman samech aleph,43:01if mitzvot tzrichot kavanah or not.43:03Samech or samech aleph, if you look over there,43:05if mitzvot tzrichot kavanah or not.43:06And therefore, although the psak halacha43:08is that mitzvot tzrichot kavanah,43:10over here that we're dealing with a berachah,43:13so we want to be stringent43:14even according to the opinion that says mitzvot43:16ein tzrichot kavanah. And therefore,43:18when a person is being asked43:21after sunset,43:22what day is it? Let's say tonight,43:24after sunset, after43:267:50, somebody asks you, By the way,43:28what day is it tonight?43:30What day is tonight? And you didn't count yet,43:32you shouldn't tell him, Today43:34is the 16th of the Omer,43:36hayom shishah asar laOmer. Why shouldn't you tell him this?43:38Because maybe, even though43:40you didn't think about counting,43:41but you might be yotzei according to the opinion that says mitzvot43:44ein tzrichot kavanah. However,43:46you could say either yesterday's date,43:49or what you could do43:50is have in mind that you don't want43:52to be yotzei with what you said.43:54When you have negative kavanah,43:57then nobody is going to hold that43:58you're going to be considered that44:00you counted. So therefore, if you're saying in your mind44:02that you don't want to count, you could tell the person,44:04Tonight is the 16th.44:06Because you don't want to count it,44:07but you have to have that44:10kavana intentionally that you don't want to count.44:11Otherwise, if you don't have that44:12kavana, it might be considered that you counted. Therefore,44:14you can resume counting for that day44:17without a44:18beracha, and the following days afterwards you already can continue counting with a44:22beracha. Now let's get back to this person44:24who wants to keep the words of44:26the Shulchan Aruch. He wants to be one of the44:28medakdekim. He wants to count exactly on time,44:31and he's praying with the44:32minyan where they finish before time.44:34It's not seta kochavim yet, according to him,44:36but the minyan, like we said,44:38should count any time44:40after—during bein hashmashot, the minyan should44:42count. It's not too early for the minyan,44:43but he himself wants to wait.44:46So the halacha is, you don't have to wait.44:48You don't have to count with the minyan.44:49You can wait till later on and count later on.44:52The only thing is, sometimes people are44:54scared that they might forget. If I don't count right now44:56with my— I might forget. So Shulchan Aruch comes and tells us44:58an idea, a very good idea: you can count45:00with a condition, as follows.45:01Let's give a practical45:03halacha. Tonight, 7:50 is shekiyah. You go to pray with the minyan.45:05They finish Arvit at45:08845:09o'clock. That's 10 minutes after45:11shekiyah. That's not seta kochavim yet,45:13according to almost all opinions.45:15So therefore, what you want to do,45:17you want to count later on. You want to45:19count by 20, 25 minutes later on, or,45:21l'chatchila, 13, 15 minutes later on45:23after shekiyah. So what do you do?45:26So in that case, what you can do45:27is as follows. If you're worried that you might forget,45:29either put on your alarm clock, and that will remind you,45:32and then when your alarm rings45:33and it's next to you, you can remember. Or if you forget45:35that even that's not going to help you,45:36what you can do is you can count with a condition.45:38You can count with the tzibbur without a blessing.45:40For example, they're going to say,45:43Hayom shishah asar yom la'omer. So you can also say,45:45Hayom shishah asar la'omer, but before that have in mind the following condition:45:48that I'm counting right now45:49with the tzibbur, but I really want to45:51count in the proper time at45:538:20, at 8:15, with a45:55minyan—excuse me, with a blessing. That's the real45:57counting. If I do remember46:00after46:018:15 to count, I'm going to count then with a blessing46:03because my counting that I did46:05with the minyan... Is really,46:07I'm not saying it46:09yotzei dei chovah, but in case I do forget to count later on,46:12then let my counting46:14that I'm doing right now with the minyan46:16work as46:17if I've really counted46:19the Omer. That's a condition a person could make46:21when he's counting when he's with46:23a tzibur, and he really wants to count in the proper time later on46:25with the blessing. He can make that condition46:27even if he forgets later on that evening to count.46:29It's considered that he's46:31yotzei dei chovah since he counted with the46:33tzibur, because that's the condition he made. And if he remembers later on,46:35it's great. He could count with the46:37berachah because the condition was46:39that if he remembers, then the original counting46:41should not work for him.46:44Okay,46:45let's move on now.46:48Before that, actually,46:49there's a question that comes up in the poskim:46:51is it better for a46:53person to count earlier46:55without a minyan, or to wait46:57for a minyan and count later than the time?47:00Meaning, let's say a person is praying47:01Arvit at 1047:03o'clock, and the time to count, the best time, like we said,47:05is let's say between 8:15 and47:078:30. So what should a person do?47:09Should he count at 8:30 without a minyan,47:11or should he wait to pray Arvit at 1047:12and then till they finish Arvit at 10:15 count over there with the minyan?47:16So this is a47:17machloket. The47:19Olat Shlomo Chacham Ovadia says there's an obligation47:21here that47:23tehei moti hena, so therefore count earlier.47:25When the time comes, count right away.47:27You don't need a minyan.47:27Not only that, the Biur Halachah says also47:29that there is no need to count with a minyan.47:32A person doesn't have to be with a minyan in order to count.47:35Also, a person doesn't have to pray Arvit before he47:37counts. You can count even before praying47:39Arvit. That's according to the47:41Olat Shlomo. However, the Ashkenazi47:43Acharonim, the Gra, Moshe, the47:45Minchat Yitzchak, the Shevet47:47HaLevi, Rav Wosner, and47:49Eretz Yisrael, they all hold that you should47:51wait for a minyan. They bring different reasons47:53why a person should wait for a minyan,47:55even though he's going to pray later on,47:56he's going to pray at 1047:58o'clock. Still, he should wait for a minyan.48:00To count together with the minyan, with the48:03tzibur. That's the opinions when it comes to this question.48:06Another few quick halachot we want to mention about counting the Omer48:10before we get to the next subject, and that is48:13regarding the certain halachot that, just very, very quickly,48:17when it comes to counting the Omer, the Gemara learns that a person should be standing48:21when it comes to counting the Omer. It learns it from a pasuk,48:26me'ahel chereish bakamah. When you start to plow on the kamah, it means the standing up,48:31and the Gemara says that you have to stand up when you count the Omer.48:33So therefore, that's important to keep in mind.48:35When you come to count the Omer, you have to stand up,48:38whether you're making the blessing or you're not making the blessing.48:40The mitzvah of counting the Omer has to be done standing up.48:43Pay attention, because sometimes people don't pay attention.48:47You know, in many minyanim, the Sephardim, in the morning, they'll count in Shacharit the Omer again.48:52Why? In case somebody forgot it last night.48:54So if you're one of those people that are counting in the daytime48:56because you're not sure if you counted or not,48:58so you have to stand up also in the daytime.48:59Remember, the mitzvah of counting has to be done standing up.49:02So let's say you forgot last night and you're counting49:04in the day, of course you're going to count without a49:06berachah. But pay attention to the detail, and that is that you must stand up when counting the Omer.49:10So if in the daytime, in Shacharit, you're counting with the49:12tzibur because in case you didn't count it last night,49:15so you should stand up when you're counting the Omer.49:21Also, lechatchilah, lechatchilah, this is all lechatchilah, a person before counting and before making the blessing, really, of counting the Omer,49:28should know which day it is.49:29Let's say tonight,49:31first you should know that it's the 16th, and then say the blessing and count afterwards.49:37Don't say the berachah and then start to ask, start to wonder,49:41wait, wait, what day is it today, and try to figure out what day it is today.49:43First find out what the day is, and then make the49:48blessing. This is only lechatchilah, if a person made the blessing first49:51and then he's— Then he realized that he doesn't know which day it is,49:54but עדיין he's still yotzei the49:57berachah. Let's move on to the next subject,50:00and that is eating before counting the Omer.50:04This presents really the main problem for this is really on Friday night.50:08Let's explain.50:09The Rambam brings down that when the time comes to counting the Omer,50:13which is whatever time you hold is counting the Omer,50:17one may not begin a meal over there.50:21What is called a meal?50:22A meal means if you're washing and you're having bread of about two ounces or more.50:29If a person is planning to have two ounces or more of bread,50:32he cannot begin his meal when the time comes to counting the Omer.50:35The Mishnah Berurah points out two things.50:38Number one is that this doesn't only apply to eating.50:41This also applies to any50:44melachot. Any melachot that are mentioned also, like in Hilchot Kriat Shema,50:48that once the mitzvah comes,50:50a mitzvah that has its time right now in the evening,50:52since you cannot begin other50:53melachot, we're scared that through your meal or through the other50:57melachot, you may forget about the mitzvah51:02and lose yourself in your meal or in the51:06melachah. So therefore, you cannot begin the51:08meal. L'mashal, we just had before Pesach.51:10We all knew this halachah before Pesach.51:12We had bedikat51:14chametz, and we all knew when the time comes to bedikat51:16chametz, you're not allowed to begin a meal.51:18A lot of people know that51:20halachah. Also Kriat Shema, which is a mitzvah de'oraita even more so,51:23a mitzvah also that has to be done in the evening.51:27A person may not begin a meal with bread before reading Kriat Shema.51:31And Mishnah Berurah points out the second thing,51:33and that is that just like by Kriat Shema,51:36the Rabbeinu Yonah brings down that the51:39chiyuv, the obligation, the issur really,51:42the issur of beginning a meal...51:45Isn't just when the time of the mitzvah comes,51:46but even a half an hour before the mitzvah comes.51:49For example, everybody agrees51:51it has to be51:52by tzeit hakochavim. Let's say tzeit hakochavim is at51:548:15, for argument's sake. Let's say it's51:568:15. So according to51:58halacha, from 7:45 already, you're not allowed to begin a meal.52:02Why? Because you haven't read Kriat Shema.52:03We're worried that you might lose yourself.52:06This is a din that started from the Gemara.52:09Rabbeinu Yonah adds a half an hour,52:10and the Shulchan Aruch brings52:13this psak halacha. This is also true when it comes to counting the52:15Omer. You may not begin a meal52:17if you're having bread, more than52:20a kebeitzah, a half an hour before this man of counting the52:23Omer. The question is,52:25what's called the time?52:27What's called the half an hour before?52:30So according to52:32Mishnah Berurah, since Maran says,52:35Hamedakdekim sofrim b'tzeit hakochavim, so the half an hour begins52:38before52:40tzeit hakochavim. That means,52:41let's say tzeit hakochavim is52:438:15, so half an hour before, you can't begin a meal,52:45which is52:467:45. That's the opinion of52:48the Mishnah Berurah. However, the Kaf HaChayim brings from52:52the Shulchan Aruch Harav,52:53which is Rabbi Zalman,52:57a Graz, and Chazon Ovadia also goes with this52:59opinion. They hold that since technically53:01a person could begin counting53:03by53:05sheki'ah, so really the half an hour begins before53:07sheki'ah, which means that a half an hour before53:09sheki'ah, a person may not begin a meal.53:11So this presents a problem53:14on Friday nights,53:15Leil Shabbat. Why?53:17Because if you're praying in the minyan,53:19if you're praying in the minyan that's very, very late,53:21and they're counting,53:24you finish53:26Arvit, and it's already53:27tzeit hakochavim, and they're counting in shul, so anyway you have no issue.53:30But usually, Sefirat HaOmer falls out53:31during the spring days and during the summer days almost,53:33where the nights...53:35Begin very, very late,53:37which means it's eight o'clock already,53:39and people like to daven earlier. People like to pray earlier.53:41They want to come home. They want the53:43kids to be up a little bit.53:44They don't want to have such a meal at such a late time.53:47They don't want to have a heavy Shabbos meal at such a late time.53:50So a lot of people like to pray earlier.53:52The only thing is, if you're praying early,53:54how could you begin your meal53:56a half an hour before?53:57It's too early to count, we all agree,53:59but at the same time, how are you beginning the54:02meal before you count? So this presents a big dilemma.54:04So what could a person do,54:05and what should a person do?54:07So either you daven very, very early,54:09you pray very, very early, and you could rely on the54:12Mishnah Berurah. Remember, it's a machloket in54:15derabanan. So since it's a machloket only in54:17derabanan, so you could rely on the54:19Mishnah Berurah, and as long as you begin your meal54:23a half an hour54:24before54:28set hakochavim, that's fine.54:30And that is doable. If you pray with the54:32earliest minyan by plag hamincha, that's doable.54:34You finish, you come home, you begin your54:36meal right away. That's good.54:39The other thing you could do is54:40pray later and eat later.54:42For some people it's not optional.54:44So then what you could do is the following.54:46Mishnah Berurah brings down that just like54:48we have earlier something called54:50Kriat Shema Shema, Kriat Shema means, or54:52Shemosh, that depends how you want to say it.54:53There used to be in their days a person would walk around the54:56houses and remind everybody54:58that it is time for whatever it is.55:00It's time for55:02Kriat Shema. Somebody specially hired in the55:04community would go around to people's houses reminding them.55:06So therefore you could also set yourself a reminder.55:08What is that reminder?55:10An alarm clock.55:11We all have cell phones. They all have an alarm.55:13Although some alarms are a little bit more annoying, they don't shut off,55:15so you have to get yourself an alarm55:17that will ring at the time that you have to.55:20Count55:23Omer, and therefore if you start within—before that, if you start within the half an hour,55:25this only works, by the way,55:27within the half an hour.55:28That means, let's say the time is really55:318:15, and now it's already 855:33o'clock and you want to begin your meal right away,55:35so fine. So you can begin your meal right away55:37and put your alarm to remind you.55:39This works for the weekday as well as55:41for Leil Shabbat.55:42If you put the alarm, obviously before Shabbat, to remind you55:44when to count55:46Omer. But if it's already55:488:15, so don't begin the meal. You have to count,55:50and then you can begin your meal.55:51So that's the halacha.55:53Either pray very, very early on Leil Shabbat, on Friday night.55:56This way you come home before the half an hour before55:58tzeit, and you're fine.56:00Or you can pray very late and count and then begin your meal,56:03or put yourself an alarm to remind you when the time comes.56:07The only thing is, when the alarm rings, you must stop and you must count right away.56:11Otherwise, if the alarm rings and you technically snooze it,56:15meaning to say you just ignore it, so whether it was a purposeful alarm,56:17it didn't remind you of anything, and that will not work.56:20We are pretty much done with the basic main halachot of Sefirat HaOmer.56:25We do have special cases that come up,56:28and one case that many, many people have been asking:56:31usually there's a show in China during Sefirat HaOmer.56:34I don't know why; somebody told me it's like they always like to make it during Sefirat HaOmer.56:38So what? So now it presents a big problem,56:40because what's happening is that people are flying out to China.56:43The way it works, people flying out from New York,56:45the plane travels towards the west,56:49and they go out in the direction towards California,56:51and from there they go to the other side.56:53They keep on going west until they come to the east.56:56If you look at the map, you'll see that the map is spread out in front of you,57:01the map of the world I'm talking about.57:02You'll see that Asia, which includes China and Russia, is all the way on the east,57:07and you have the United States with California all the way on the west,57:11Alaska being the most western part.57:14So there's something called the IDL, the International Date Line,57:18which I don't know who established it. It was done in 1884;57:22we know who established it.57:22In any case, they hold that once you cross that line,57:26you're going from west to east.57:28So basically what happened is that you already skipped a day.57:31You're already on the next day.57:32And if you're coming back the other way,57:34you're going back a day.57:36So it presents a big complication in57:41halacha in kavod ha'omer, and to explain it really takes a lot of a long time,57:44but we'll tell you just very, very short.57:45If you're planning to travel57:47and you're crossing the international57:48dateline, which means you most practically you're going from America to China,57:53and therefore you're crossing the international57:55dateline, and by the time you come to China,57:56you've already lost a full day of 24 hours.58:00The poskim bring down is that you should count the day that you've been counting till now58:05and the day that they're up to without a blessing58:07for your duration in China.58:10And when you come back to the States,58:13then58:15you can continue counting on your old count,58:17which is the count that we're counting here in the States,58:19with a blessing,58:21as long as you didn't lose it.58:22So again, if you're flying out to China58:25and you get to China so that you lost 24 hours,58:28you should continue counting your old count58:31and their count without a blessing, without a58:34beracha. And when you come back to America,58:36you could, as long as you didn't lose any of the days,58:39you could go back to the counting that they did here in America,58:42that they do here in America,58:43and continue with a58:45beracha. Time has come that we have to stop the class,58:48and just to make one more quick announcement,58:51the class will be aired on tonight again58:54on58:55jrootradio.com and on the JRoot Pro app58:57at 11 to 1258:59p.m. Also, bezrat Hashem, we hope to get the videos up as well.59:01If you have any questions59:02that you want to call into the studio59:04regarding Sefirat HaOmer or the customs of the Omer59:05or any other questions,59:07I'll be in the studio for the next 15 minutes.59:08The number is59:12718-683-5858. If you have any questions by text,59:14we'll answer you also.59:15The number is59:19347-927-8398. Until then, we want to thank59:22Eran and the JRoot Radio staff.59:24Thank you very much for listening.59:26And have a wonderful day59:27and Chodesh Tov.