Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Purim Part 2 (2014)Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 2Rabbi Uri Nahum · March 12, 2014−15Play+30Position0:0059:43Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio on Wednesday afternoons, and where we talk about halacha.0:06In this hour, we will discuss, b'ezrat Hashem, the halachot of Purim.0:09Last week we started with the halachot of Purim already, so this will be really part two.0:13And b'ezrat Hashem, we hope to cover today all the halachot, and already tomorrow, Taanit Esther,0:18which means we have a lot to do, and we're going to work off the Ben0:22Ish Chai. Usually we would read from the Ben0:24Ish Chai, but today we probably will read only some parts from the Ben Ish Chai inside,0:29in order that we should cover what we need to know for the holiday of Pesach—of, not Pesach,0:35too early—for the holiday of Purim, which we'll start, b'ezrat Hashem, will be this Motzaei Shabbat.0:41Just quickly, even though we mentioned it last week, but before that we want to make an announcement.0:44If anybody would like to sponsor this class,0:47this class could be sponsored by either texting the station or getting in touch with the station through email,0:53whatever you like. Or any of the classes, really,0:55you could call and sponsor, and you have the zechut of all the Torah that comes out of this class or any other class.1:02To listen to us, you could listen on your FM dial at 97.5 FM,1:07or you could download the app,1:11and you could also listen in on the following phone number, 718-506-9099, or on1:20JRootRadio.com. This video, this class is being videoed, so you can now start watching these classes.1:24Not only listen, you can also watch them online on1:29JRootRadio.com. In order to call in for your questions, I apologize,1:33but we will only designate the last 15, 20 minutes of the class,1:37so only at 2:45 we'll begin to take phone calls.1:40We have a lot to cover, and we want to get through the main1:43halachot, and don't be shy to call in, because a lot of questions that we get are very important.1:48I believe sometimes I may skip a point that I don't mention, and everybody should know about it.1:51So call in at 2:45 with your questions,1:54and if you're shy and you don't want to call when we're on the air,1:57you can call when we're off the air when we finish the class at around 3,2:013:10. The text, which is the best way to reach us in order for your questions to come on the air,2:06or even off the air, is2:11347-927-8398. And I believe we finished with all the introductions.2:13Let's get to the2:14halachot. Last week we spoke about the halachot of ta'anit Esther,2:19mishloach manot, and matanot2:23la'evyonim. This week, today, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll speak about the halachot of reading the Megillah,2:28which comprise most of the halachot of Purim,2:31and reading and listening to Megillah, that is.2:34And also we'll speak about the seudat Purim,2:39which also takes place on Purim itself.2:43And just to mention just quickly, because tomorrow is2:46the fast, just to review from last week,2:47tomorrow is ta'anit Esther, which means the2:51fast. We will fast tomorrow beginning from alot2:54hashachar. What time is alot2:55hashachar? There are a few different opinions, you'll ask your local rabbi,2:58but I saw times from 5:12 a.m., even saw3:034:57 a.m., and up3:06till 5:59 a.m. So we follow, by us the Sefardim, we follow Hacham Yosef's calendar,3:10which is 5:59 a.m. is alot3:13hashachar, and the fast will go up until about 40 minutes after3:18sheki'ah, which is around3:207:40. Somebody wants to be lenient3:22should ask his local rabbi if there's a reason to be lenient.3:27That's tomorrow, Thursday.3:29On Shabbat we have Parashat3:32Zachor. This Shabbat we'll take out a second Sefer Torah,3:35we'll read from the Sefer Torah3:37from Parashat Ki Teitzei, which speaks about Amalek.3:39This is an obligation3:41mide'oraita, and there's a safek if women are also obligated,3:44so everybody should make an effort, men for sure have to go.3:48Women should try to go if they can, if it's available,3:51and if you're listening and you're the rabbi of a shul,3:54or if you're listening and you're the president of a shul,3:56try to make some sort of arrangement3:58to make it easier for women to hear Parashat4:00Zachor, whether on Purim itself or even on Shabbat Parashat4:04Zachor, some time when the men don't have to be in shul,4:07they could watch the kids for a while4:08until the women come and listen to Parashat4:10Zachor. Let's get to the halachot. Halacha Aleph.4:13Halacha Aleph, we will speak about... Who is obligated4:17in reading and listening to the Megillah?4:20Let's read first this4:22halacha. Says the Ben Ish Chai, Parashat Tetzaveh,4:28Hakol chayavin b'mikra Megillah, anashim v'nashim. Everyone is obligated to read the Megillah,4:30men and women alike.4:34Ach hanashim, af al pi she'odim likrot, yishme'u min ha'anashim. However, being that it's a4:37machloket if women could read for other people4:39or should read,4:40the best thing is that women,4:41even though if they know how to read the Megillah,4:43the best is that women should listen to the Megillah4:45from others who read it for them.4:47And therefore, says the Ben4:53Ish Chai, v'lachen kol adam, af al pi shekara Megillah beit haknesset, yikraena b'veito bishvil ishto. Every person should make sure that his wife hears the Megillah.4:56If you personally know how to read the Megillah,4:58so you go home and you read it for your wife,5:02shelo shamaa beit haknesset, who didn't hear in the shul. And not only your wife,5:05uvishvil haבתולות, uvishvil hanashim shebatim habayit. Every woman that's above the age of5:07twelve, and according to others even5:10chinuch, you have to answer them,5:13and you have to make sure that they hear5:17the Megillat Esther on Purim.5:20This applies in the evening5:22and in the daytime as well.5:26Now, I want to point out something important.5:28Because women also have the obligation5:30to read the Megillah,5:32so most shuls will be packed with women5:34this Motzaei Shabbat5:37in order to hear the Megillah.5:39And because of that,5:39who's going to watch the kids?5:40So one of two things happens:5:42either they get a babysitter5:43and they keep them at home,5:44or the second thing is5:45they bring the kids to the shul.5:46And this, I have to mention,5:48rabotai, it's very, very important to know.5:50Baruch Hashem, there's so many minyanim today in our neighborhood,5:52over here in Brooklyn,5:54that have different times for reading,5:57and you can literally find any time that you want.6:00When you bring your children to the shul,6:02you have to know,6:02it's you as a6:04parent, it's your obligation to make sure6:05that the children do not disturb.6:07We're going to soon learn that6:08if you don't hear one word of the Megillah,6:10you are not yotzei the6:12chovah. And sometimes6:13the women think that6:14I'm going to bring the kids to the shul,6:14I'm coming to do a mitzvah,6:16and they pick up worse aveirot than the mitzvah itself.6:19You don't end up hearing it6:20because the child disturbs you,6:22and then it disturbs other people6:23and they don't end up hearing some words.6:25So a person,6:26chacham einav b'rosho. The pasuk says6:28that you have to be a little bit clever.6:30You know your children,6:31you know if they act up or not.6:32Don't say, Oh no, no,6:33this time they're not going to act up.6:34You don't want to put yourself in a whole thing.6:36Just you wait at home,6:37ladies, wait at home.6:39Let the men hear it in shul,6:40and then afterwards6:41go to a special reading6:43in the shul for the ladies,6:44and they have it all over.6:46I know that in Rabbi Landau's shul6:48on Avenue L and East 9th, I believe they have every half an hour6:50they have a reading for the ladies.6:52And the same thing you could find6:53by the shul Bnei Yosef.6:55It's not only Bnei Yosef.6:56Many, many shuls6:57ask your husband to ask around6:59in the shul that he prays or he davens at,7:01and they have a special reading for the men.7:04Now you tell me,7:04what about b'rov am hadrat melech?7:06We have a7:07halacha when it comes to the reading the Megillah7:08that you're supposed to hear it7:10with a big crowd.7:10You're not supposed to hear it in a small crowd.7:12The poskim bring down7:14that the concept of b'rov am hadrat melech,7:16that means to hear the Megillah7:17with many, many people,7:19this only applies to men,7:20not to women.7:21So therefore,7:22women don't have to hear7:23it. In fact, it's better that they hear it in the house,7:25me personally.7:26I read the Megillah in the house,7:27and my wife calls a little bit of the neighbors,7:30whoever needs to come.7:32A few family members also come,7:34and yes, children come,7:35but it's more controlled.7:35When it's in the house,7:37the children are a little bit under control,7:38and it's not such a big place.7:40In the shul,7:41you can't designate somebody7:42to be over the kids,7:43because whoever you're designating7:44has to be old enough7:45to be able to take care of them.7:47And if they're old enough to take care of them,7:48they also have to be old enough7:49to hear the Megillah.7:50So it doesn't work out so well.7:52A person should make sure7:54that he should hear the Megillah reading,7:56or she should hear the Megillah reading,7:57but at the same time,7:58they should make sure that the children...8:00do not disturb anybody else and prevent them from hearing the Megillah.8:05The last thing the Ben Ish Chai says in this halacha, and this is actually a machloket, I'm saying this8:10because the person who picks up the Ben Ish Chai should know8:14why the halacha wouldn't act on this halacha.8:16It says the Ben Ish Chai at the end,8:19if a person was already8:22yotzei their chovah, he already fulfilled his obligation of hearing the Megillah,8:25and now he's going back and reading it for the woman,8:32lo yevarech bishvilah, v'gam hem lo berchu. The person who is reading the Megillah, the baal koreh,8:34and the woman should not make a8:37beracha. This is what the Ben Ish Chai brings over here,8:39and this comes from a few Acharonim. One of them is the8:42Chesed LaAlafim, who brings down that since women do not know Hebrew,8:45they don't know how to follow,8:46so you're making beracha for them,8:48but they're going to space out, they're going to miss a few words,8:51so they're not yotzei the chovah, technically.8:54So how can you make a8:55beracha? And even8:57safek, safek berachot. That's what the Chesed LaAlafim brings down,8:59and that's the Ben Ish Chai goes with this as well.9:02However, not everybody agrees.9:04Even the Chesed LaAlafim, once upon a time.9:05First of all, we have the9:07Chida. The Chida says you can't make gezeirot that Chazal didn't make.9:10If Chazal said that women have the obligation to read,9:13and we have to make a beracha when we read the Megillah,9:16so that's it.9:17You make the9:18beracha. If Chazal weren't scared that women may space out and may not follow,9:21so we also shouldn't come ahead9:23and start making our own new9:26gezeirot. And HaKamovadia brings this reason9:28and brings another reason9:29why you should make a beracha for the ladies,9:31and the reason is9:32because, Baruch Hashem, in our days,9:35most ladies do know Hebrew.9:36Most ladies do know how to read and follow.9:38Most ladies did go to yeshiva or9:41Batei Yaakov, and they did learn the Hebrew,9:43especially in Eretz Yisrael.9:45So because of that,9:46since they could follow,9:47a lot of times you have9:49Chumashim, even they don't have9:49Chumashim, they're listening in,9:51so therefore there is no problem.9:52And I believe,9:53my own personal opinion,9:54if the Ben Ish Chai was around in our days9:55and he sees the education in our days9:57that the ladies have,9:59he'll also agree that you should make a10:00beracha, and therefore,10:01halacha lemaaseh, even if you're reading for the ladies,10:04you should make a10:05beracha. Now, we're talking about reading Megillah for the ladies.10:09Whoever is reading should pay attention to the following things.10:12When you read for the ladies,10:14you're going to make three10:16berachot like you usually do.10:17What are the three10:18berachot? The first beracha is10:19Baruch Atah Hashem...10:21asher10:24kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu likro Megillah,10:25not lishmoa Megillah.10:27Lishmoa Megillah,10:28even though there's a machloket with this,10:30the Ashkenazim, I believe,10:31say lishmoa Megillah.10:31For the10:32Sefardim, we say the same thing.10:34The machloket is based because,10:35like we said10:36beforehand, some say10:37that ladies only have to hear the Megillah10:38but not to read the Megillah.10:39So therefore,10:40the text for the Ashkenazim,10:41some will change the text to lishmoa Megillah.10:44Here we hold that even10:47better the ladies should listen to it,10:49still we say10:51likro Megillah. Next,10:52when you're reading for the ladies,10:53you have to keep the following point in mind,10:55and that is,10:56in the shul10:57we have a10:58bracha acharona. As we're going to soon learn,11:00the bracha acharona can only be said11:02when you have a minyan of people.11:04Minyan means ten.11:05Ten could include the reader himself,11:09and even if it's ten mixed with men and women,11:12you still make the11:14beracha. So therefore,11:14when you're reading for the ladies,11:15sometimes it's a small group,11:16it's about six, seven ladies11:18and the11:19baal koreh, that's only nine.11:20You need to make sure11:21that you have ten in order to make the11:23bracha acharona. If you don't have ten,11:24if you just have nine,11:26you cannot make the11:28bracha acharona. Some say11:28you could even include some of the children who understand,11:30even though they're under the age of bar mitzvah11:32or bat mitzvah.11:34You have to know who's there11:35and if they're listening the whole time,11:37they're sitting and they're attentively listening.11:38I know my niece,11:39when she comes, ten, eleven years old,11:41she listens very well from beginning to the end.11:44She doesn't run around.11:47Technically, you could also include her,11:49even though she's not of the age of mitzvah,11:50you can include her for the last11:52beracha. And the reason for that is11:53that the last beracha is made in order to publicize the miracle.11:56You can only publicize it11:57when you have a minimum amount of people,11:58and that is the number ten.12:00When you have ten people,12:02then you can make the12:03bracha acharona. And special attention has to be made12:05when you're reading for the ladies.12:07Sometimes it's a smaller group.12:09That there should be ten people.12:10Let's move on now to12:13Halacha Bet. Halacha Bet, I'm not going to read it inside,12:16but basically the halacha is as follows.12:17V'halachot do come out from here.12:19The halacha is that when listening to the Megillah,12:22you have to hear it from somebody12:25who himself is obligated to read.12:29Meaning, the rule is always by all mitzvot12:32is that the following three people are exempt from mitzvot.12:35Who are they?12:36A12:41cheresh, shoteh, and12:43v'katan. רשי, what chashu. Cheresh, shoteh, v'katan. Cheresh is, usually the definition of cheresh means12:46any person who is12:49deaf-mute, cannot hear and cannot speak.12:51That person is12:52patur; he's exempt from all mitzvot in the Torah.12:55Being that he's exempt,12:56even though he may have learned the skill of speaking,13:00doesn't make a difference.13:01Since he's not obligated,13:04he cannot exempt others who are listening to him.13:06The other case, which is more practical,13:09the katan.13:11Shoteh, by the way, is a person13:14who—I don't say a13:15fool—but shoteh is a person who lacks the ability to comprehend things.13:21That's a different category by itself.13:23Katan is a person under the age of bar mitzvah13:26or bat mitzvah.13:27Katan usually are exempt from all mitzvot in the Torah.13:29When they do mitzvot,13:31it's only because we are training them.13:33When it comes to the mitzvot of mitzvah of Kriat Megillah,13:36although there's a13:37machloket, still a person should not listen to a katan who is reading the Megillah.13:42Make sure that the child is above the age of bar mitzvah.13:44Unless you're stuck somewhere13:46and there's nobody around,13:48and the only one who knows how to read the Megillah13:50is this katan who went to yeshiva13:52and he learned very, very well how to read,13:54and he has a kosher Megillah,13:55so then okay, you can rely on the opinions that say13:58once the child is above the age of seven,14:00since he understands and he knows how to read,14:02you can rely on that opinion.14:04But lechatchila, you should not listen to the Megillah from a child that's reading,14:09and child means anybody under the age of bar mitzvah.14:12With that, we'll go on to a very practical halachot in our days.14:16Listening also, like we said,14:17has to be for someone who is obligated,14:19and although it might seem simple to a lot of people,14:21but it's important to know:14:23you cannot be yotzei dechovah. You cannot exempt yourself from the obligation of hearing the Megillah14:28from a pre-recorded Megillah reading.14:31Here on JRoot Radio, on Purim,14:33you'll hear the Megillah reading played.14:36They're going to play it a few times in the day.14:38They're going to play it in all the14:40nusachot and all different versions of the reading the Megillah.14:43Even if you're listening from the beginning till the end,14:46you're not14:46yotzei dechovah. Even if you rewind it14:47and you make sure you heard every single word,14:49a person who hears from a pre-recorded reading14:54is not14:55yotzei dechovah. Not only that, it goes even further.14:57Even if you're listening in on the phone,14:59you go to shul and your wife is home15:02and you put her on the phone15:03and she's listening live from the phone,15:05she's not15:07yotzei dechovah. You have to hear the person's voice directly,15:09which leads us to the following:15:12what about if I'm listening in the shul,15:15I can see the baal15:17koreh, but I'm listening from him speaking on the microphone,15:19so I'm not really hearing the baal15:21koreh, I'm not hearing the person's reading it,15:22but I'm hearing the sound from the15:26microphone. So in this case,15:27all the halacha should be the same.15:29As long as you're not hearing the sound of the baal15:31koreh, you're not15:33yotzei dechovah. You have to hear the voice himself.15:35If you could still hear the voice of the baal15:37koreh, of the person who's reading the Megillah,15:39but the mic is just enhancing it,15:41which means if you shut off the mic for a second15:43or ten seconds,15:44you would be able to hear the words from the baal15:47koreh. So what's the mic doing?15:49Just making the sound a little bit louder.15:51So in that case,15:54you're yotzei dechovah. You can be15:55yotzei dechovah. That's the ruling of15:57Chacham Ovadia, and that's the psak.16:00We're going to give that a person who's listening in from a microphone,16:06it's asur unless you could hear the person's voice himself.16:11Now, does that mean this is a halacha and nobody disagrees?16:14There are those who disagree.16:16There's a Tzitz Eliezer. There's others who say that listening through a microphone,16:19if you're in the same room, could be16:22yotzei dei chovah. But the ruling of Chacham Ovadia Yosef is that,16:26I believe Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach as well,16:27in order to be yotzei with a microphone,16:30you have to be able to hear the person reading as well,16:33and just that the mic is enhancing it, it's fine.16:36Next, we get to the following halacha.16:38We said that cheresh, a person who is deaf-mute, is not16:41yotzei dei chovah. Poskim bring down that a person who could speak,16:46he's only deaf, but he's not mute,16:48technically he's not in the category of16:50cheresh. So could a person be yotzei dei chovah from listening to such a person?16:54You can ask me, when is this possible?16:57This is possible when a person could only hear with a hearing aid.17:00He cannot hear without a hearing aid.17:02He knows how to read Megillah beautifully.17:03Something happened, he got older,17:05and now he needs to wear a hearing aid in order to hear,17:08and he's reading the Megillah for you.17:09Could be yotzei dei chovah or not?17:11So the rule is also pretty much the same.17:13If the only way this person could hear is through the hearing aid,17:17which means without the hearing aid he cannot hear anything,17:20so then better not to listen from such a baal17:24koreh. But if the person could hear,17:27but the hearing aid is just enhancing his hearing,17:30then it's fine.17:31He's17:32yotzei dei chovah. Even a person who's listening that way in the shul,17:34not only is he yotzei dei chovah by hearing through the hearing aid17:36because it's just enhancing,17:38it's making the volume a little bit louder for him,17:40but also you could be yotzei dei chovah by listening to the Megillah from such a person.17:47Halacha gimel.17:48Again, if you have any questions, please text in your questions.17:52Do not call the station till at least17:552:45. By then we'll have the technician17:56over here, we'll answer the phone calls.17:58But till then, we won't take any questions.18:00If you have any questions, text it in,18:01and the text number is18:07347-927-8398. Halacha gimel.18:08Halacha gimel. Isn't important halacha to keep in mind.18:12Although maybe it depends on your age;18:15you'll decide how applicable it is to you.18:18Halacha says,18:22If the reader is dozing off while reading the18:25Megillah, since he may truthfully read every word,18:27he's18:28yotzei the chovah. Don't worry,18:28not the reader in the shul.18:30No shul is going to allow the baal koreh to doze off.18:32This happens probably a person is tired,18:34he comes home late,18:37maybe not necessarily18:38Motzaei Shabbat, whatever it is,18:39he's picking up the18:40Megillah and he has to18:40read, and he's very tired,18:41and he has to read the Megillah to himself.18:43He's dozing off.18:43As long as he knows that he read every word,18:45it's fine.18:46But a person who is listening to the baal18:52koreh, if he's dozing off,18:54even though he may say,18:54No, I really heard every word,18:56he's not18:57yotzei the chovah. Why?18:58Because the halacha is18:59you must hear every single word of the19:02Megillah. You cannot miss any word.19:04So if you're dozing off,19:05mistama you missed a word or two,19:07and that's it.19:08One word already disqualifies you,19:09and you have to hear the Megillah again,19:12and therefore19:13a person is not19:14yotzei the chovah if he's dozing off.19:15If you see somebody dozing off,19:16you have to make sure you keep him alert.19:18Take a five-hour energy drink19:19or whatever you may have to take19:21to keep yourself up,19:22and this way19:24you can hear the Megillah from beginning to end.19:25This applies again in the evening and daytime.19:28A lot of people19:28we see are makpid in the19:30evening to make sure to hear the19:31Megillah, and in the daytime19:32sometimes,19:33okay, it's only the daytime reading.19:35You should know the halacha says19:38both are necessary,19:39but it's more important19:41to hear the Megillah in the daytime.19:42So a person has to make sure19:43that he hears the Megillah in the daytime as well,19:46and that he should hear the whole thing as well.19:48And don't say,19:49Listen, I heard it already last night.19:50You know, I know the story.19:51It doesn't make a difference.19:51The19:52obligation is you have to hear it again,19:53all the words from beginning until the end.19:56Let's move on to halacha dalet,19:57the berachot of the20:00Megillah.20:02הקורא את המגילה צריך לברך הברכות מעומד. When reading the Megillah,20:05although the halacha is that20:07you don't have to stand up20:09when you read the Megillah,20:10unless you're reading in shul,20:11then that's a different reason20:12why you have to stand up,20:13because of the honor of the20:14tzibur you have to stand up.20:15But technically you can read the20:16Megillah even sitting down.20:17When I read it in the house for my wife,20:19I sit down when I read the Megillah.20:21How come?20:21Because halacha is20:22you could stand or sit down,20:23whatever you like when you read the Megillah.20:25Only in shul do we stand up20:26in the honor of the whole kahal20:28that's in the shul.20:30However,20:32דברכות, whether the beracha rishona or the end,20:37אפילו קורא יחיד בביתו, even if you're reading it by yourself in the house,20:38you must stand up20:40during the20:44berachot. The other thing that we have to keep in mind20:46regarding the20:48berachot when standing up20:48is that there's a custom,20:50there's different customs on standing up20:52when you read the20:56Megillah—excuse me, there's a minhag,20:57sorry—there's a minhag of standing up20:59when listening to the21:01berachot and some sit down.21:03Meaning,21:04when the person who's reading the21:05berachot has to stand up,21:06but the people listening to the21:07berachot, some have a minhag21:09where the whole tzibur stands up21:10and after the end of the21:12berachot they all sit down,21:13and that's what I believe the Iraqi minhag is,21:15the way Ben Ish Hai brings it down.21:17And others don't have such a minhag.21:19I know the Syrian minhag is21:20not that way.21:21Only the person who's reading the Megillah21:23is standing up;21:24he says the berachot standing up,21:25while everybody else is sitting down21:27during the21:28berachot. Either way,21:28both minhagim are brought down21:30and it's fine to do either one.21:32I'll tell you one thing, though:21:33if the whole tzibur is standing,21:35don't be sitting down.21:35If the whole tzibur is sitting down,21:37don't stand up to stick out,21:39because that's a separate class by itself.21:42A person should not stick out from the21:44tzibur. Both are fine21:45and both have their sources.21:47Another thing the Ben Ish Chai brings down over here,21:48when you read the Megillah,21:49he says,21:52צריך להיות פושט אותה כולה ואחר כך מברך ברכות מעומד. When coming to read the Megillah,21:55you have to open up the whole Megillah first,21:58and then you make the21:59berachot. How come we open up the whole Megillah?22:00Because we find in22:03the Megillat Esther that the Megillah itself22:05is referred to as a geret, a letter.22:07If you ever see those pictures of the,22:10you know, letters are sent by the king,22:13Hear ye, hear ye, and they open up these big letters.22:14They unroll the whole letter first,22:16and then they read it.22:17That's how you do it.22:17You get a letter today in the mail,22:18you open up the whole envelope22:19and then you read it.22:20You don't slowly take out the paper from the envelope;22:23you take out the whole thing,22:23you open it up.22:24So since the Megillah is called a letter,22:27a geret, so therefore we open up the whole Megillah first22:28and then we read it.22:30That's the22:31lechatchila. That's the minhag that most people do.22:32But you should know,22:33it's not an obligation.22:34It's not necessary.22:36Why do I say that?22:38Because first of all,22:39according to Shulchan Aruch,22:40if you want to know22:41the din of Shulchan Aruch,22:41he holds that22:43the only thing you have to do22:44is22:46not to open up first22:47and then make the22:48berachot. He says22:49make the22:50berachot even though it's closed,22:51and as you're reading,22:52just don't fold it back.22:53Just keep on reading22:55and don't fold it back.22:56That's the opinion of Shulchan Aruch,22:58me'din. Like I said, the minhag is not that way.22:59The minhag is that people open up the whole thing.23:01But you should keep this in mind23:04when you're reading somewhere23:05and you don't have a table23:06necessarily in front of you.23:08Let's say you're reading23:09someplace by somebody's house23:10and they don't have a23:11table to provide you to sit down23:12to read the Megillah or to stand up,23:13and you have to hold the Megillah.23:15So if you open up the whole thing,23:17it might drag on the23:17floor, and then it's disrespectful to the Megillah.23:19In that case,23:20they can follow what Maran says:23:23just don't roll it back23:25as you're reading throughout the Megillah.23:28And even if you do roll it back23:29and you hold it like a Sefer Torah,23:30you just open up the page23:32that you need to23:32read, even then it's fine.23:34This is only a custom that's brought down,23:37and it's not an obligation.23:38So therefore,23:39even the listeners should know23:41that the kahal who is listening to the Megillah23:43don't necessarily have to open up23:44their whole Megillah.23:45It's only the person who's reading.23:47But if they want to open up,23:48that's fine. It's great. Why not?23:50Lechatchila, if possible, they should do it.23:52But if you're sitting in a shul23:53where it's very crowded,23:55and by opening up the whole Megillah again23:56it might drag on the floor,23:58and especially if everybody on your23:59row also has a—24:00Megillah, how you can be able to control it,24:01and you know how the pages roll back.24:03So then, that's called a case that's not possible,24:06and it's fine.24:08And even if you don't have a kosher megillah,24:09you have a chumash,24:10there's nothing not any different.24:12You have a chumash anyway in front of you,24:14and you're following.24:15Then, just like there,24:16it's not a big deal if you,24:18obviously, since you can't do it in any other way24:20to go through the24:21pages without opening up the whole megillah,24:23so too when you have your own private megillah,24:24you don't have to open up the whole megillah.24:26Let's go to Halacha24:28Hei. Halacha Hei talks about24:30Shehecheyanu. We said that one of the24:32berachot—I don't know if we mentioned24:32it—there's three berachot that we make for megillah,24:35and they are:24:36Asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu likro megillah.24:38The second is24:40She'asa nisim la'avoteinu bayamim hahem bazman hazeh,24:43and the third berachah is24:46Shehecheyanu. This is an important halacha.24:49Shehecheyanu, there's a machloket between Ashkenazim and24:52Sefardim. According to the24:55Sefardim, Shehecheyanu is only said24:57for the reading of the megillah at night,25:00which means25:00that when we say Shehecheyanu this Motzaei Shabbat,25:03when reading the megillah for the first time,25:04we don't go back to say Shehecheyanu again25:07on Sunday morning25:08because we've already yotzei the chovah with the25:10Shehecheyanu. However, according to the Ashkenazim,25:12they follow the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam in this.25:15They will say Shehecheyanu Motzaei Shabbat,25:17and they will say it again when reading the megillah25:20on Purim day in the morning,25:22which will be this Sunday morning.25:24Okay,25:24that's a very important machloket to keep in mind.25:27Sefardim only say Shehecheyanu one time.25:30Ashkenazim will say it in the evening25:32and in the daytime as well.25:34But even according to the25:36Sefardim, in the past we've explained that the25:37Shehecheyanu usually goes on the holiday.25:39Here, the Shehecheyanu is going on the reading of megillah.25:42But25:45since we have other mitzvot in the day of Purim,25:49such as Mishloach Manot, Matanot25:51La'evyonim, and the seudah itself,25:52we don't make a separate Shehecheyanu for those25:56mitzvot because these mitzvot are nothing special25:59that are out of the ordinary.26:00It's not like eating matzah,26:01shaking26:02a lulav, which is not usually done throughout the whole year.26:04Here, we have a mitzvah to give presents.26:08We always give presents,26:08to give tzedakah. We always give26:10tzedakah. To have a26:11fes of mi, we always have a26:12fes of mi, so we don't make a Shehecheyanu on those specific26:14mitzvot, but still the poskim bring down,26:16when you say the26:18Shehecheyanu, or the baal koreh is saying the26:19Shehecheyanu, have in mind that the Shehecheyanu will also cover26:22the mitzvot of Purim themselves,26:24which are mishloach manot, matanot26:26la'evyonim, and the reading of the Megillah.26:29That is what the kavanah for Shehecheyanu is supposed to be26:32when listening to the Megillah,26:33or the baal koreh who is reading the Megillah.26:35It's good, if you're reading the Megillah in shul,26:37to make the announcement beforehand26:38when people are listening to your reading,26:41right before you start reading, say,26:42I'm going to make the bracha of26:44Shehecheyanu. I'm going to have in mind also for this,26:46and also you should have in mind with me.26:48The other thing that you have to know is,26:51if Shehecheyanu was somehow omitted, it was skipped,26:53the person forgot to say26:54Shehecheyanu—I'm talking about26:56Sephardim now—the person forgot to say26:57Shehecheyanu, you could still say26:59Shehecheyanu as long as you're in the middle of reading the Megillah.27:03Once you get up to the ten names of Haman,27:06you're allowed to say Shehecheyanu right in the middle.27:07What does that mean?27:08That means you get up to27:09about Ish Yehudi hayah...27:11and then you27:12remember, wow, I forgot to say27:13Shehecheyanu. You could stop right there,27:15make Shehecheyanu out loud,27:16and continue.27:17That's not a hefsek. It's not considered an interruption27:19because it's done for the sake of the reading.27:22If you got up to the ten names of Haman already,27:24read the ten names of Haman,27:26and now you27:27remember that you didn't say27:28Shehecheyanu, according to the27:29Ben Ish Chai, it's too late already.27:30Then you'll have to say your27:32Shehecheyanu for the following day27:34in the morning27:34when you're reading the Megillah in the morning.27:36You cannot say it27:38if you're not reading the Megillah,27:40either before reading the Megillah27:42or in the middle of reading the Megillah.27:43Once the Megillah has been read already,27:44it's too late for27:48Shehecheyanu. Halacha vav.27:50Halacha vav I'm going to skip.27:51It just says that27:53if a person skips any words,27:54he's not27:55yotzei dei chovah when listening to the Megillah.27:58You have to be careful.28:00Unfortunately,28:01not every person who reads the Megillah28:03is knowledgeable28:05and knows the28:07halachot, and just because he knows how to read the Megillah28:09doesn't make him the big28:10chacham, doesn't make him the big rabbi.28:11So a lot of times,28:12people who28:15read—I've heard of very, very crazy stories28:18and sad stories,28:19but whatever, we won't go into it now.28:21In any case,28:22just make sure28:22that when you're listening to the Megillah,28:24that you're hearing every word.28:26And if you see28:27that the person reading the Megillah28:29skipped a few words,28:31whether it's his fault or your fault,28:33then you should fill it in.28:35What does that mean, fill it in?28:36So let's say,28:38achar ha-devarim ha-eleh, you heard the baal koreh say,28:40achar ha-eleh. He missed the28:41words28:42ha-devarim, so you say the words28:43ha-devarim. Now when you're saying the28:45words ha-devarim, he's saying28:46ha-eleh, so you'll have to read ahead of them,28:48ahead of the baal28:50koreh, until he catches up to you,28:52because you have to make sure28:53you hear every word from him.28:54And you're allowed to read from your own Megillah,28:58and just make sure29:00that whatever part you're reading,29:04you continue to read to the place29:06where he's going to catch up to you.29:08Meaning,29:09if you said29:11achar ha-devarim ha-eleh, and by you saying29:12ha-devarim he's saying29:13ha-eleh, so you missed the word29:14ha-eleh, so you have to go ahead of the29:16chazzan and then wait29:17and then listen to him from the next pasuk.29:21This is important to know,29:24even if you spaced out29:25or you had to, let's say,29:26somebody—something fell29:28and you weren't able to hear,29:29so instead of making the baal koreh go back,29:31you could just read yourself that pasuk.29:34And catch up to the chazzan himself,29:36or if a person had to step out,29:38it's the same29:39halacha. Keep in mind that when reading the Megillah,29:42you have to hear every single word of the Megillah in order,29:45which means if a person had to step out29:46from listening to the Megillah29:47and by the time he comes back29:48he sees that he missed seven29:50pesukim, you can't say,29:51Okay, let's wait till the end of the Megillah,29:52I'll go back and read these seven29:54pesukim. It doesn't work that way.29:55It's not like you're reading Tehillim29:56and you just make up the perek of yesterday.29:58You have to hear them in order.30:00So if you're reading,30:01then you have to read all these seven30:02pesukim. Now, of course, when you're30:03reading these seven pesukim that you missed,30:04you're going to miss the next couple of pesukim as well.30:07So you're allowed to read from your own Megillah30:10up till where the chazzan is.30:12But this is important to keep in mind.30:14If you have a kosher Megillah in front of you,30:16you're allowed to read the Megillah from the Megillah30:18all the way through,30:19even if you don't know the30:21ta'amim. As long as you know the30:23nekudot, you know how to pronounce the words,30:24that's fine.30:24Even if you don't know how to pronounce the30:27ta'amim or sing the30:28ta'amim. If you don't have a kosher Megillah30:30and you're listening to30:33Megillat Esther from a Chumash, so then it's a little bit more complicated.30:38It's harder30:38because you're only allowed to read up to 49%.30:42The other 51% you have to hear from the30:45chazzan. So if you stepped out for about a minute,30:48it's not a big deal.30:49You could read what you missed30:50and catch up to the30:51chazzan and still be in the 49%.30:54But if you miss more than that,30:56then it's going to be a little bit of a problem.30:58So if you really miss more than that,31:01you're going to have a big issue.31:02You might have to hear the Megillah again.31:05Halacha zayin.31:06Not reading inside.31:08Halacha zayin.31:08There are four pesukim31:09that we all, the kahal, says out loud.31:12The first one is a famous one:31:13Ish Yehudi31:18hayah b'Shushan habirah, u'shmo Mordechai, ben Ya'ir, ben31:20Shimei, ben Kish, ish Yemini.31:21This pasuk and the other four that are said31:24are known as the four pesukim of31:27Geulah, where the whole kahal says it together.31:30After the kahal says it,31:31the baal koreh has to keep in31:33mind that he should go back and read these pesukim31:35for the31:37kahal, because that's the pesukim.31:40Lechatchila, you have to hear the Megillah from a kosher Megillah.31:42Not everybody has a kosher Megillah.31:43Even though we just said31:44that you're allowed to read up to 4931:47percent from a non-kosher Megillah,31:48that's only31:49b'diavad. The guy stepped out.31:50He has to come back and catch up to what he missed.31:53But31:54lechatchila, you're supposed to hear every single word31:56from a kosher Megillah. Halacha tet.32:02The Ben Ish Chai brings, skip the halacha, halacha chet. The reading of the ten names of Haman, we know there's a famous halacha, everybody32:10knows this, that Chazal tell us when they hung the ten children of Haman, they hung32:16them all in one shot. What that means is, let's say they had the chair under them. Before32:21they hung them, they pulled the chair all together, all in one shot they32:25were hung. So because of that, we have to read these ten names in Megillah in one breath. So the32:32Baal Koreh takes a deep breath right beforehand and he says these ten names. The Sefarim bring32:37down also, the poskim, that means that you should read not only the ten names of Haman32:42in one breath, but even from the beginning of that pasuk where it says, Hamesh32:47me'ot ish ve'et, right, and all the ten names, and then also aseret, that all should be said in one32:53breath, together with the nekudot. I mean, obviously you have to say it properly, plus also32:58the ta'amim, that all has to be done in one breath. A lot of people think that this is33:02crazy to do, it's really not so hard. Just take a deep breath, slow down, take a deep breath33:06and say it, and you can do it. Keep in mind that this is only lechatchila. If a33:14person said the ten names of Haman, he had to take a breath in the middle, something got caught33:16up and he had to cough, it's fine. It's not a big deal. You could continue. This is only33:22lechatchila. And certainly, you shouldn't make the mistake which Rabbeinu Chaim points out in Halacha Tet, that when you're33:28reading the ten names of Haman, because if you notice on the Megillat Esther, you'll see the ten33:33names of Haman will have the names on one side and the word ve'et ten times on the33:37left side. The ve'et has to be read. There's a halacha that when you read the33:42Megillat Esther, you cannot read it בעל פה. You cannot read it without looking inside. Even if you33:47know the pasuk by heart, it doesn't make a difference. You have to read the word from33:50inside. So it's very hard when it comes to ten names. Personally, when I read the33:54Megillah, I have the hardest time with these ten names of reading it inside, not because of the33:58one breath. One breath is not a big deal. The big deal is that when you read the34:03ve'et, you have to look inside and read the ve'et from the Megillah. And I know that it34:07says ve'et, and it's all the way on the other side, the names all the way on the other side.34:11So make sure, whoever is reading the Megillah, if you're listening to this, make sure that34:15you put your finger and you read—not just remember that there's a word34:19ve'et, but you read the actual word ve'et from the inside of the Megillah as you read the ten34:24names of Haman. And if you're not a person who reads, you probably didn't understand34:27what I just said, but this was halacha for people who34:32are reading the Megillah. Halacha Yud. Oh, Halacha Yud, Rabbeinu Chaim talks about over here about34:39the Yaabetz. The Yaabetz is Rabbi Yaakov ben Tzvi, who talks about his father. His father34:44was a great rabbi. He's called the Chacham Tzvi, the famous book Kav HaYashar, which is34:48Kav of the gematria of Tzvi. That's the Chacham Tzvi. He says that he had a minhag, shehaya makeh b'raglo v'tofeach b'sandalkoesh, hamazkir shem Haman b'kriat haMegillah, that he used to make the noise34:59of—not make the noise—he used to hit the floor with his foot when the name of35:04Haman would come up. Okay, so hitting Haman became famous for hitting Haman, or making noise35:10during the name of Haman, has a source, and not only has a source over here. If you look35:15in Darkei Moshe, he brings from Rishonim also that making noise about Haman, or35:20doing different things for when the name of Haman comes up, has many, many sources in35:28halacha. And therefore the Rama writes that since all these minhagim have their sources35:35b'harei kodesh, right, they're very good sources for these things, they're written by Rishonim,35:40a person should not cancel out any minhag. But I'll tell you what the poskim bring35:44down, that unfortunately sometimes people get carried away, and the yetzer hara plays a35:51big game on them, and he makes it a kar tafel and tafel ikar. Hitting Haman, okay, it has35:57a source, it's a nice minhag, but people get carried away with it sometimes, and I've seen36:02places which were ridiculous when it comes to hitting Haman. You cannot hear the Megillah36:06at all. You know, we said that if you miss even one word of the Megillah, you're36:14not yotzei chovah. Forget one word. People make so much noise when it comes to Haman, and even later on, that you cannot hear.36:20Sometimes, honestly, I've been in a place when I was much younger, and I know the36:23halacha, half the Megillah you couldn't hear because of the noise of Haman, or people made noise36:27on Haman. So therefore, what we started to do in our shul, and Baruch Hashem we've done36:32it, and the kehal, it's really dependent on the kehal, is what the beinish chai brings down,36:37a beautiful minhag, and what is that? Make noise by the first Haman as much as you want, and36:42the last Haman, and that's it. Don't worry, Haman will get beat up. You can kill Haman,36:47go home and yell as much as you want on Haman. Take, and you know, in fact it's even brought36:51down, take a piece of paper, write on it Haman Amalek, step on it, yell at it,36:56play your blasting music on it, whatever you like. In the shul. Make sure you don't37:01disturb others. Make noise on the first time, not the second time. Besides that, you should know,37:05making the noise on Haman, it might be a hefsek because some say you're supposed to read it37:09as a negeret, nonstop. If you've noticed, I've seen gedolim, Hacham Baruch Haba Shalom,37:14lhavdil, Hacham Yosef Rafu, when they read the Megillah, they go very37:19fast when they read the Megillah, because there's shitot that bring down that it should37:22be like a get, like a letter. You read it quick. So therefore, the interruption in37:26itself is not so simple according to halacha, but still, since the minhag is brought down,37:30we do it, but don't get carried away. One Haman beginning, one Haman at the end.37:34Let your frustration out on Haman in the beginning and at the end, and that's it. And this way37:39everybody gets to hear it. And whoever is reading the Megillah has to make sure that37:42everybody is hearing. If you hear noise, you must stop. Stop everything, and don't37:46say, Okay, it's their fault. There's other people, unfortunately, that they have to hear,37:50they're coming to hear the Megillah, and you have to make sure that they hear every part.37:53So if you hear noise, you have to make sure you wait until the noise stops, and then you37:57pick up from when the noise started, and you read and make sure that everybody hears every38:01single word of the Megillah. And I'll tell you also another thing that's38:11important, that the poskim bring down. We mentioned how important it is to be b'rov am hadrat melech. That means you're38:18supposed to go to the big shul, try to go to the biggest shul as possible to hear the38:20Megillah with a lot of people. Sefardim bring down, in Mishnah Berurah, a lot of poskim, if it's rov am, rov bilbul, where you're going to hear the Megillah, there's38:29a lot of people and they make so much noise and you can't hear the Megillah, it's better38:34to go and take a small minyan. If you have a minyan of ten people, it's better to38:37hear it there than to go to a place which has twenty thousand people, but you can't hear every38:43single word. You have to know what the ikar, you have to know what the38:46tafel. Just very quickly, I want to answer a few questions that came through the text line.38:52First question is, what is the halacha for the amount of matanot la'evyonim? Matanot38:56la'evyonim, we mentioned last week, just we'll go very quickly, recommended is enough39:01money for one seudah. That's recommended. Medin, it really comes out like shtei prutot,39:06which are nothing. But recommended, a little bit seudah. How much is a basic39:11seudah? I say usually six dollars or six to ten dollars, the best, what I tell a person, chas v'shalom, a few39:17of the aniyim. And you had to get the— Money. The whole idea of Hatan Matanah is that make39:23sure that a person who is poor should have money in order to be able to buy himself a39:28seudah. What would you like to have for a seudah? A piece of pita and that's it? Or39:31would you like to have a whole nice sandwich? How much is a nice sandwich? Maybe a shawarma39:35sandwich, a steak sandwich, or, I don't know, you like cheese sandwich, whatever you like.39:40How much would you want? That's what you should give to at least two people, two separate39:45people. So I say between six to ten dollars per ani. If it's beyond your means, so then you could39:52give anywhere from two dollars to six dollars, but that's the recommended and the minimum in hadin. And of course, the more.40:02If a person gives him a matonah al menat lehachzir, it's always better. Now, the next question is, what's the time of the fast tomorrow? We mentioned this in the beginning.40:08If you're Sefardi, 5:59 a.m. But there's other shitos. Some say as early as 5:12 a.m. or40:164:57 a.m. You'll have to check with your own rabbi in your own shul exactly how they follow.40:20Let's go to Halacha Yud Aleph.40:23Speaking about eating, there's a halacha that you're not allowed to eat before the Megillah.40:27This year that the Megillah is being read on Motzaei Shabbat, it's not so bad,40:32because usually we come in from fasting, we come to hear the Megillah.40:35But we'll say the halacha anyway. In the time when there's a fast,40:38when there's a fast, you cannot eat. What we mean over here to eat,40:42lechatchilah you shouldn't eat anything.40:43But if a person has to eat a little bit, you could eat up to two ounces of bread.40:49But again, lechatchilah you shouldn't eat or drink anything until you hear the Megillah.40:53But if you need to, after a fast, you could eat or drink up to two ounces of bread, and drink,41:00of course, fruits, all these things, that's always fine to eat.41:04But lechatchilah a person should stay away from it.41:06This applies not only in the evening, but also in the daytime as well.41:09So really the ladies are praying in the house, and waiting to hear the Megillah, reading41:1411:12, should try not to have a meal with bread up to two ounces before hearing the Megillah.41:19Another thing to keep in mind also, which the Ben Ish Chai over here brings in the second part of the halacha,41:27that even though it's brought down by the Ben Ish Chai and the Chacham Ovadia also brings it down,41:31even though one could technically say the birchot of Megillah on his own.41:35That means if you're sitting in shul and the chazzan is making the41:37berachah, you want to make your own berachah, you could also do it.41:39But it's preferable to be yotzei dei chovah with the berachah of the chazzan or the baal koreh.41:44This way you're together with the whole shul together, you're just listening to him.41:47However— If you cannot hear the birachot of the41:51chazzan, or if you believe you have berachah vanot than the chazzan or the baal koreh, and you want to say your own41:56berachot, you could say it as long as you have a kosher megillah in front of you.42:00If you don't have a kosher megillah and you're just listening from a chumash,42:03then don't say your own berachah, and just exempt yourself from the berachot with somebody that's there, with the baal koreh that's there reading for you.42:14Next,42:15Halachah Yud Bet talks42:18about—Halachah Yud Bet and Yud Gimel, put it together, and we'll make it practical for this Motzaei Shabbat.42:23What's going to happen this Motzaei Shabbat?42:24What's going to happen is you're going to go to shul.42:26You're going to go42:27first—actually, let's start with Mincha on Shabbat.42:29Mincha is regular.42:30We don't say42:36Tzidkatecha. If it's seudah shlishit, you go straight into Kaddish. After that, you're going to have42:37Shalosh Seudot, or you're going to have42:41seudah shlishit. After seudah shlishit, if the rabbi's doresh or makes a speech, whatever,42:44it doesn't make a difference,42:45you're going to pray42:46Arvit. After Arvit, you're going to pray Arvit up to the Amidah.42:49In the Amidah, make sure you say42:51Al Hanisim. If you forgot to say42:54Al Hanisim in the Amidah, you don't have to go back.42:55If you want to mention it right before you step back,42:58you say Oseh Shalom,42:59you can mention it over there,42:59that's fine,43:00but it doesn't obligate you to go back on reading of the Amidah.43:05Next,43:06after the Amidah,43:08we say43:09Chatzi Kaddish, and then because it's Motzaei Shabbat,43:11so we'll say43:13Shuva Hashem, which begins with really43:17Shuva Hashem v'hinachem until V'ata Kadosh. And where we usually sit down,43:19we say43:21V'ata Kadosh yoshev tehillot Yisrael, we don't say that,43:22and we wait.43:23Then we take out the megillah,43:25and what happens is as follows.43:27So now, here is an important point.43:29There is a halachah that's brought down,43:32and some are noheg this way,43:34that one should say43:37the berachah of Borei Me'orei HaEsh before reading the megillah.43:39How come?43:40So the Beit Yosef brings the Kolbo.43:42He says43:43because since you're reading Motzaei Shabbat from the Megillah,43:45and you need the light in order to see what you're reading,43:49so therefore43:50you have to make the bracha borei me'orei ha'esh only,43:53and then read the Megillah,43:54and after you finish the Megillah43:56and you finish43:56Arvit, then you make43:58Havdalah. That's what the Kolbo brings down.43:59The Beit Yosef brings that,44:01Beit Yosef in the book44:03Beit Yosef,44:04he brings this Kolbo.44:06And this is also brought down by the other44:08Acharonim, like44:09the Chida, Chazon Ovadia also says that before you read the Megillah44:13on Motzaei Shabbat,44:14you should say the bracha borei44:15me'orei ha'esh. What does that mean?44:16Take out a candle,44:17you know, the one that you use for44:19Havdalah, put it on,44:19say the bracha borei44:22me'orei ha'esh, and then read.44:23However, others disagree,44:25and Rav Moshe,44:27Hagaon Rav44:27Moshe44:29Levingstein, he brings very good44:30sevarot. He brings two, three reasons why you shouldn't say it.44:34Number one is,44:35first of all,44:36borei44:37me'orei ha'esh, we don't say on electricity.44:40You can't.44:40Let's say a person is making44:42Havdalah, he doesn't have a candle.44:43You can't make borei me'orei ha'esh on electricity,44:45even though you tell me there are opinions that way.44:47Yeah, Havei Da'at brings down,44:49Chazon Ovadia brings down,44:49there's seven opinions who hold44:50that you could make borei me'orei ha'esh that way,44:52but still,44:53we don't make a bracha on the electricity.44:56We don't call that44:57esh; it has to be real fire,44:59and that's the opinion of the majority of the45:01poskim. It has to be real fire.45:02So why all of a sudden now45:04do we have to make a bracha borei45:05me'orei ha'esh? I'm benefiting from the electricity.45:07I'm not benefiting from the fire.45:08I'm not using any fire to read today,45:11nowadays. Also, besides that,45:14when I'm saying borei45:16me'orei ha'esh, when I come back and say45:17Havdalah, I can't say borei me'orei ha'esh again,45:19and it's better to say the brachot of45:22Havdalah all together in one group.45:23So why should I take it out of order now45:26in order to be choshesh for that45:27shita? The other thing is also,45:29it seems like there's a machloket45:31in the Beit Yosef itself,45:33because here45:34in the Halachot of Purim,45:36the Beit Yosef brings the Kolbo;45:37he doesn't say anything about it.45:38But in45:41Siman Reish Tzadi Chet, Maran brings the Beit Yosef,45:42and over there he doesn't go with it,45:43because he says that reading Megillah is not a45:47melacha, and since it's not a45:48melacha, reading Megillah is not a45:50melacha. Therefore,45:51you don't have to say Borei Me'orei Ha'esh beforehand.45:54And because of that,45:55a lot of45:57people—or not a lot of people,45:58but some people—don't say the beracha Borei46:00Me'orei Ha'esh. I personally have a question also:46:03if the beracha Borei Me'orei Ha'esh, we hold,46:04is46:05birchat ha-shevach, it's not46:07birchat hanehenin, which means46:08we look at the candle first46:09and then we make the blessing of Borei46:12Me'orei Ha'esh, because we're praising God for the fire46:14that was created motzaei Shabbat.46:15It's not like drinking a cup of water,46:17where you have to make the blessing46:19before you drink the cup.46:20Over here,46:21we're praising God like46:23birchat lebanah. First you look, you see the moon,46:24and then you bless God.46:27You're not making46:28beracha because you're benefiting from the light of the moon.46:30You're making the blessing46:31because you're thanking God for the moon.46:33So too by Borei46:35Me'orei Ha'esh, we're blessing Hashem for the fire46:38that46:40the idea was put in the head of Adam HaRishon46:42to make on motzaei Shabbat.46:44So why are we making the beracha first?46:47Because46:48we're not using—first of all,46:48we're not using the flame;46:49we're using electricity.46:50And number two is46:53it's not birchat hanehenin, it's birchat ha-shevach. So what can I do?46:55The Acharonim bring it down,46:56but not everybody agrees with it.46:58The Piskei Teshuvot brings down46:59that the minhag of the Ashkenazim47:00is not to say the47:02beracha of Borei Me'orei Ha'esh before Megillah,47:04and I heard also47:04that Chacham Yosef47:06Shalom Elyashiv does not say the beracha of Borei47:08Me'orei Ha'esh before reading the Megillah.47:09And also, like I said,47:10also Rav Moshe Levi47:12zatzal in Tefillah47:13l'Moshe also brings47:14down that you should not say the47:15beracha of Borei47:16Me'orei Ha'esh and should only say it47:18in the end with Havdalah.47:19This applies only in the shul.47:20Even those who say47:21that you should say47:22beracha Borei47:23Me'orei Ha'esh is only in the shul.47:24When you go home, though,47:25and you have to read the47:26Megillah for your wife in the house,47:28then you make Havdalah first.47:30You make the full Havdalah,47:30that means with a cup of47:31wine and everything,47:32and then you read the Megillah47:36for your wife.47:38And that's how it's done in the house.47:39Let's go back to the shul now.47:40After, let's say whether your47:42minhag is to say borei me'orei ha'esh or not,47:43I don't think it depends on47:44minhag. You'll ask your rabbi what he wants to do.47:46If you say borei me'orei ha'esh or not,47:48in any case,47:49now what happens is47:50the baal korei stands up,47:51he opens up the whole Megillah,47:53and you should have two people,47:55one on his right,47:55one on his left,47:56when reading the Megillah,47:58and then once the Megillah is all open.48:00Up in the chatilah, this is like we said beforehand. Then you make the three48:04berachot. After you finish reading the Megillah, first you roll back the Megillah,48:09and then after you roll back the Megillah and you close it,48:12then you make the last berachah, the berachah acharonah of48:15Megillat Esther. This is what takes place in the shul. This is the order of Megillah reading in the shul.48:20The next halachot in the48:24Ben Ish Chai, al hanisim, we'll just say it outside very quickly.48:27Al hanisim, we're supposed to say, add Al Hanisim in our Amidah,48:31and we're supposed to add Al Hanisim in Birkat Hamazon.48:33In both cases, if a person forgot to say Al48:36Hanisim, he does not have to repeat neither the Amidah or the Birkat Hamazon.48:41The next halachah is matanot la'evyonim, which we discussed last week.48:44I just want to mention something I didn't mention last week,48:47and that is that there's a halachah that's brought down on Purim,48:52kol haposhet yad notnin lo. Usually, you have to make sure that your tzedakah is going to the right cause.48:56A right cause means a person is qualified to be an ani.48:58On Purim, we don't check.49:00Whoever puts out his hand, we give him.49:02On Purim, we don't have to necessarily check.49:04That's some halachah that we didn't mention last week.49:07Mishloach manot we also spoke about last week as well,49:10and now we'll move on to49:13halachah yud-zayin. Halachah yud-zayin, we won't read it inside; we don't have so much time.49:16If you have any questions, by the way, text it in now,49:18and if you want to call the station,49:22maybe you could call in another—I guess you could try to call in now.49:25We'll get the technician to come soon.49:27Halachah yud-zayin: women's obligations in Mishloach Manot,49:32Matanot La'evyonim. Ben Ish Chai—and not just49:34the Ben Ish Chai, the halachah brings down that just like men are obligated with the four mitzvot of Purim,49:41which is hearing the Megillah,49:43Mishloach Manot, Matanot La'evyonim, and the49:46seudah, women are also obligated in all those49:50four mitzvot. And even though it might seem simple,49:53but women have to make sure that when it comes to Mishloach Manot,49:56because they make it out of a49:58family—Baruch Hashem, everybody has their own theme,50:01and everybody makes specific Mishloach Manot that they give to50:04everybody—a woman should make sure that at least one of these Mishloach Manot50:07she should personally give it to another lady.50:09So this way, she's yotzei mishloach manot.50:12In the daytime this has to50:13happen. Also,50:15matanot la'evyonim, ladies should make sure to inform their husbands50:17that when he gives whatever he's giving, a donation to50:20matanot la'evyonim, he should include her.50:21Sometimes the husband just gives a donation,50:24101, 201, without thinking, without breaking it up,50:27that money is from him and also from his wife as well.50:30Just a pointer to keep in mind for the ladies.50:33Next, halacha50:35yud-chet. Halacha talks about mourners,50:38people who are50:39aveilim. The definition of a mourner over here50:41is any person who is in the period of mourning,50:44whether it's in the year of the parents,50:47or even within the seven days of mourning.50:50Here the Ben Ish Chai says that50:51although they have an obligation of giving matanot la'evyonim and mishloach manot,50:55like they have the obligation like everything else,50:56they have to hear the Megillah,50:58they have to go to50:58a seudah, they have to have a51:00seudah, they have to also send mishloach manot.51:03Still, nobody should send them mishloach manot.51:06That's the opinion of Ben51:07Ish Chai, and that really comes from the51:10Rama in Yoreh De'ah, Hilchot51:12Aveilut. Over there, however, the51:14Diuk—I don't want to go through it right51:15now—but it seems like the opinion of Shulchan Aruch is not that way.51:18And therefore, a51:21person—so according to51:23Chacham Ovadia, he says that you can even give a mourner mishloach manot.51:26It's fine, it's not a problem.51:29But the best way to do it is like this:51:31instead of giving, you know,51:32sometimes a lot of mishloach manot that we have to give,51:34we have to give it out of kavod,51:39you know, or that people shouldn't be upset with us.51:41So you could always give the mishloach manot to the person's children51:43or to his spouse,51:45and this way they know that it came from you51:48without giving it directly to the mourner.51:50Ashkenazim don't receive mishloach manot,51:51so give that to their spouses.51:53And even if you want to be machmir like the Ben51:54Ish Chai, who goes with the51:56Rama, and you want to give a mourner mishloach manot,51:58give it to one of his family members,52:01and it's understood that it's going to him,52:03but don't make them52:04shliach, but just give it to them.52:08Okay. Also, if a person's rav is a mourner,52:12that it's brought down52:13that you could give them mishloach manot,52:15because there it's coming mostly for the honor.52:18Next, Purim52:19seudah. You have to have a seudah on Purim.52:21We didn't mention this till now,52:22but a person must have a meal on Purim,52:24and it has to be a little bit more festive meal,52:26more than the common regular meal.52:27It should be more similar to like Shabbat and Yom Tov meals.52:32On Purim itself,52:34the seudah that we're talking about,52:35there's a52:36machloket in the poskim if you need bread or not.52:37Lechatchila, everybody agrees that it should be with bread,52:39because the definition of seudah is bread.52:42So therefore,52:44lechatchila, a person should try to make sure that they have a52:46seudah, and this seudah must take place in the day on Sunday52:48before sunset.52:49You could start it off before52:52and let it run into the night,52:53that's fine,52:53but make sure you have the main part of the52:56seudah in the daytime of Purim.52:58Also, mourners are obligated in the53:01seudah. Even a person who is mourning,53:02a person who is53:04an avel for his parents or whatever it may be,53:05he's also obligated in the53:06seudah. The only thing is53:07that he should not go to a seudah which has music.53:12He should go to a seudah which has no music.53:14And if he's making his own seudah in his house,53:16that's fine, he can have friends,53:17but he shouldn't have music in the53:20seudah. Next, Halacha chaf, skipping.53:22Halacha chaf aleph, working on Purim.53:25A person, really technically, on Purim53:27should not go to work.53:28But if a person has to go to work53:30because he can't get out of work,53:32then they could go to work,53:35but it's brought down53:36that there is no blessing with any money that's made53:39from working on Purim.53:42And somebody told me something very nice,53:44a name, Hacham Baruch, he told me53:46that, you know, a lot of people go to rabbis to get blessings53:50for... Their53:51parnasa, and they do a lot of different53:54segulot in order they should have a good53:56parnasa. And meanwhile, when it comes to Purim,53:58or times when Chazal told us53:59that there is no berachah, the money that you make on that day,54:02they go to work.54:03I don't understand. You want blessing,54:04you don't want blessing.54:05A person really wants blessing,54:07then the real way is to follow what Chazal tell us.54:10You can't just get a berachah, get the rabbi's hand on your head54:13and get a blessing,54:14and you think that's going to make it that way.54:16Chazal tell us if you go to work on Purim54:18and you make money on Purim,54:19there's no blessing in that money.54:20It will go somewhere.54:21So therefore, a person should try,54:23if you want the best54:25segulot, follow what Chazal tell us.54:26That's the best54:27segulah. Halachah kaf bet,54:29Ben Ish Chai brings down that Purim,54:31as the pasuk says,54:35ליהודים היתה אורה ושמחה וששון ויקר, Chazal tells us this became yamim54:37tovim, became a holiday.54:38So therefore, a person should make sure54:40to dress appropriately.54:42Anyway, Motzaei Shabbat,54:42you can be wearing Yom Shabbat clothing,54:44so keep Yom Shabbat clothing54:45for Motzaei Shabbat54:48and Purim day.54:50A person has to keep in mind54:51it's a holiday,54:51and you should wear something nice.54:53Men should wear suits,54:53ladies should dress properly.54:55So what about wearing costumes?54:57So I got a question last week,54:59right at the end of the show,55:00a good question:55:01What about, is wearing costumes mutar?55:03Is it recommended?55:04Is there a difference55:05for Ashkenazi?55:06And we'll finish the class with this55:08halachah. There are55:09different—the wearing the costumes,55:10the Rama brings down in the55:14halachah, and it also has sources.55:15It has old sources55:17from Rishonim55:18about wearing costumes.55:19Different reasons are given55:20why a person wears a costume.55:22Some say that,55:23being that we're giving a lot of55:24tzedakah, everybody has to give matanot55:26la'evyonim, so55:26everybody puts on a costume.55:27This way,55:29nobody can tell who's really ani,55:30who's really rich,55:31who's really poor,55:31who's really not poor,55:33because we're all wearing costumes.55:34Even the person who's poor,55:35it looks like55:36he's—you know,55:36you can't tell if he's getting55:38mishloach manot or matanot55:39la'evyonim. That is one reason that's brought down.55:41There's other reasons are brought down.55:43Esther, from the word of hiding,55:45she hid herself,55:46modechai put on the clothing of the king.55:48That's brought down.55:49It goes so far55:50that the Rama says such an important custom.55:52He says even if you're wearing kilayim deRabbanan—it means shatnez, which is only55:56asur miderabbanan. Very complicated to explain55:57what's exactly55:58deRabbanan, deOraita right now—but even if you...56:00Wearing shatnez, which is56:02deRabbanan, because it's Purim, they would noheg that way, it's fine.56:05To the point that the Rama says,56:07even if you're cross-dressing—what does that mean?56:08Even a man wears the clothing of a woman,56:10since it's done for the simcha of Purim,56:12that's fine for a man to put on a skirt.56:14However, if you're56:17Sefardi, first of all, all our poskim bring down that's asur.56:20We cannot wear the clothing of56:23women—that means if you're a man, you cannot wear a dress,56:25you cannot wear a skirt,56:26and women are not allowed to wear the clothing of men on Purim.56:31That's56:31Sefardim. And even according to the Ashkenazim,56:33even what tells me there's a56:34Rama, the Mishnah Berurah brings down from the Taz and the56:37Bach, and a lot of Ashkenazim, great Ashkenazim,56:39they all said that this is a terrible minhag and one has to stop it.56:44So cross-dressing is not recommended by the56:47poskim. When they were noheg a long, long time ago,56:49okay, there's such a minhag, we can't take it away, that's what it was.56:52But in our days, a lot of the Acharonim said,56:55no, don't follow this minhag, it should be stopped,56:58and therefore a person—it's not recommended.57:01Even for children, it's not recommended.57:03The Chazon Ish was makpid that even little children should not wear.57:06Others bring down that if it's under the age of five,57:09that's already fine.57:10In any case, in all these things, a person should be careful.57:14Although it's a time of simcha, a time of happiness,57:16a person should not get carried away and take57:19his simcha, and know that the simcha should lead into57:21issurim, and one should take the proper caution also during the57:27seudah. Although the halacha brings57:27down—everybody knows the halacha about drinking on57:29Purim—still, drinking on Purim does not permit one to transgress all57:34aveirot. Which means, even the poskim who bring down that you have to drink on Purim,57:37they don't tell you that you have to get wasted.57:39If you cannot say57:41Birkat Hamazon, if you cannot read, if you cannot pray Arvit afterwards,57:46then you should not drink.57:47If you're a person that gets affected by alcohol,57:49or the amount of alcohol that you take, then don't drink.57:52It's definitely, I guarantee. If you go and ask57:55Chazal what is better,57:56that should skip Birkat Hamazon deOraita or drink on Purim,58:00there's no question, there's no doubt what they'll tell you.58:02They'll tell you that do not drink on Purim.58:05Also, and a lot of Gedolim nowadays tell us58:08that anybody who drinks— Make sure that you don't drive.58:12You designate a driver.58:13And if you see somebody who drank58:14and is getting behind the wheels of a car,58:16take away their keys.58:17This is a58:18halacha. You take away their keys. You don't allow them to drive.58:20And even if they're not going to listen to you,58:22they're going to58:23fight, they're getting behind the wheels58:24when they're drunk, you call the cops on them.58:27It's not58:28called a moser. What you're doing is you're saving his life58:30and the lives of the other people on the road.58:31And this great caution has to be taken care of,58:34rabotai. Drinking is a mitzvah,58:36but shouldn't push away other mitzvot58:38like hillul Hashem and other things.58:39We have to be careful with our drinking.58:41It's a day,58:44laYehudim hayta orah v'simchah v'sason vyikar, like it was for them,58:45it should be, be'ezrat Hashem, also for us.58:46And by doing the58:48halachot the way the hachamim told us to do,58:50be'ezrat Hashem we'll see the58:52yeshuot, the salvation that the Jewish people had once upon a time,58:54we'll see them also nowadays,58:56be'ezrat Hashem, with the geulah ha'achronah and the rebuilding of the Beit HaMikdash.58:59We're signing off right now.59:01We're going to give you the number to the studio59:02if you have any phone call,59:03any questions you want to ask off the air,59:05we'll be here for the next ten minutes.59:06The number to the studio is59:11718-683-5858. Again,59:13718-683-5858. If you want to text us your question59:15for the next ten minutes,59:19347-927-8398. Again, this class will be aired on again tonight59:22at 1159:24o'clock, 11 p.m. until 1259:26a.m. And until then, we'll see you.59:28Have a wonderful Purim,59:30a freilichen Purim,59:32and be'ezrat Hashem we'll see you next week59:34with Hilchot Pesach already.59:35We're going to start, be'ezrat Hashem,59:37next week Hilchot Pesach59:38until the holiday of Pesach.59:40Thank you, Adan, and thank you, JRoot. Bye-bye.