Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Purim Part 1 (2016)Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 1Rabbi Uri Nahum · March 16, 2016−15Play+30Position0:0047:02Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio.0:04I didn't want to interrupt the song, but we had to go on already. It's0:072:09, and we are in the middle of Adar, Vav Adar.0:11Tomorrow is Zayin Adar, the yahrzeit of Moshe Rabbeinu, the birthday of Moshe Rabbeinu.0:15So we have a lot of halachot to speak about, of course, the halachot of Purim.0:20Ve'ezrat Hashem, this will be part one of a two-part series0:25that we're going to discuss the halachot of Purim.0:28We are not starting out the halachot the way we have them in the Shulchan Aruch,0:32but what I believe are the way people need to prepare for them the best.0:38So let's begin. Let's go straight to the halachot.0:42We'll begin with the halachot of Mishloach Manot.0:47Mishloach Manot, we have a mitzvah, like it says in the Megillah itself,0:51that they instituted at the time that the miracle took place in the times of Mordechai and Esther,0:56that we should give Mishloach Manot, ish l're'ehu, a person must give gifts to each other.1:03Simply translated, Mishloach Manot is to send gifts, ish l're'ehu, one person to his friend.1:10The question is why? Why is it that we have such a1:14takanah? Why did they feel that we should give, part of the mitzvot of Purim1:19is that we should give Mishloach Manot?1:21So we find by the Rishonim two explanations, two reasons that are brought down by the Rishonim.1:26One is brought down in the sefer known as Terumat HaDeshen, which is a book of1:33halacha. It's quoted. Constantly, always, you can find it quoted by the Beit Yosef, by the Darkei Moshe.1:41One of the reasons in the Trumat HaDeshen says,1:44the reason why we have mishloach manot is that we have to ensure that every single person,1:51every Jew, has a meal for Purim.1:53Since we can see later on that the days of Purim are1:58yemei mishteh v'simcha, these are days where we must have a simcha. It must be like a Yom Tov with a feast, with a meal.2:04So mishloach manot is the way that we can ensure everybody has one.2:07Everybody has to give someone. Eventually, we make sure that everybody gets mishloach manot.2:13That's one reason.2:14The other reason that's brought down is found in the sefer known as Manot HaLevi,2:19written by a very famous Kabbalist.2:21Even if you don't learn Kabbalah, it's still by a famous Kabbalist.2:25You know his song, the song of Lecha Dodi, Rabbi Shlomo Alkabetz, who is buried in Tzfat, as the song says.2:32So Rabbi Shlomo Alkabetz writes that the second reason for giving mishloach manot2:38is in order to increase the love between the Jewish people.2:43Remember what Haman said about the Jewish people in the Megillah2:46when he wanted to annihilate the Jewish people. He approaches Achashverosh and he2:50says,2:53Yeshno am echad mefuzar u'meforad bein ha'amim. There's one nation that's divided and spread out.2:58And the Gemara Megillah says what he meant to say is,3:01these guys don't get along with each other.3:03Don't have to worry about them. They're going to unite against you.3:06Don't worry, King Achashverosh. These guys don't get along with each other.3:08They all are attacking each other.3:10So therefore, they instituted, after we took care of Haman,3:14mishloach manot to show the love and to increase the love amongst the Jewish people.3:18These are the two reasons that are brought down for why mishloach manot should be given.3:24Now, the halachot, technically you see that, you know,3:28sometimes you'll see that one reason will apply, not the other,3:30but we try to be machmir like both reasons.3:33But you have to know, first of all, that when we speak about a lot of different details of mishloach manot,3:39which I try to cut down a lot of different3:43halachot that are not so practical. But one thing is that you have to know:3:47the pasuk says3:48ish l're'eihu, and the halacha tells us that the obligation, the minimum obligation per person,3:54is that a person has to give to one person.3:58One man gives to another man, a lady gives to another lady.4:01Should not be mixed, by the way.4:02Men should not give women, women should not give men.4:04But women do have to give. They shouldn't rely on the fact that their husbands are giving4:08and it's all considered one family.4:10No, it should be that the lady should give,4:12that she personally has to give or not, we'll talk about it later on.4:15But that's the minimum one.4:16So therefore, when we speak about all the details,4:21all the things that are required,4:24these are things that a person should try to do at least with one mishloach manot4:27to be yotzei de chovah, to fulfill the obligation,4:30and then afterwards you could do as you wish.4:33So keep that in mind as we go along.4:35All the details according to halacha which are4:39me'akev, which are a minimum, which one has to do,4:42are only for that one mishloach manot that you have to give.4:45Otherwise, you could give as you wish.4:48You could give a toy if you like, give money, whatever you like,4:50but that's not really mishloach manot. Mishloach manot is as we're going to explain.4:54Of course, a person has a minimum of giving one,4:57but if he wants to give more, even better.5:00Increases the love amongst the Jewish people, like we said5:02according to Rav5:04Shlomo Alkabetz. Or even though the people that you're giving, Baruch Hashem,5:07they have food, they have what to eat,5:10still the more you give, the better.5:12Like we said, it increases simchah amongst the Jewish people.5:16The question is now, what could a person give for mishloach manot?5:20Because the pasuk, if you think about it, just the regular translation,5:23it's a little vague.5:24Manot means a gift, a maneh.5:26So what's a gift?5:28So the halacha brings down that the gifts over here5:30must be either food or drinks.5:33You cannot give anything that's not food or drinks.5:36No clothing, no cigarettes. Even the guy is a smoker,5:40I don't know if that's a gift, a gift of what.5:42Okay, no money. Even if5:45you tell a tamid chacham to give him as hiddurei Torah,5:47you're not yotzei with such gifts.5:50Believe it or not, although that's something that should seem simple,5:54I did see brought down by some5:58Acharonim that as long as one fulfilled his obligation with one mishloach manot,6:03you could rely that the other things,6:05that if you give money or hiddurei Torah or even clothing,6:08that could technically count as mishloach manot.6:10But again, we're dealing here with that one specific mitzvah,6:13that obligation to be yotzei the6:16chovah, you need to give food or drinks.6:18Now when it comes to food,6:20food could also be in a can.6:22Think about it.6:23We all know that we could give a cake,6:25but everybody gives a cake wrapped6:27in a, what's it called,6:29in plastic.6:30So if you want to take off the plastic,6:32or if you want to remove the can,6:33either way, it doesn't make a difference,6:35as long as a person is able to access the food,6:37so that's not a problem.6:41But preferably, Mishnah Berurah says6:43you should not give raw foods.6:46On this, Hacham Ovadia says, by the way,6:48that technically you could be yotzei with raw food.6:50Let the guy, it's food,6:51so the guy has to cook it.6:52Okay, he'll put it on the grill,6:54but technically you could give raw food.6:56However, it's preferable, in order to be yotzei the6:59chovah, to not give raw foods.7:01Examples of raw7:02food, you say, raw foods, who's going to give?7:03I'm going to go out giving out pieces of steak,7:06ground beef?7:06Say, here you go,7:08one scoop of ground beef for you?7:11No.7:11But I'll tell you what some people might not realize.7:15Sometimes, you know, people like to do themes.7:16Not sometimes,7:17most people like to do themes for their mishloach manot.7:21One time we did a theme of,7:23I think we did like a coffee cake7:25with a cup of coffee,7:27and we gave those, you know,7:28those coffee samplers that they sell,7:30like Nestor's Choice.7:32So that— It's really raw food.7:34You can't eat that.7:35It needs to be cooked.7:37Okay, so that's the hot water is going to cook it.7:39It's instant, but fine.7:40But that's something like an example of raw:7:43tea bags, coffee, instant soup,7:47all these kind of things.7:48According to Chacham Ovadia, technically7:50you could be7:51yotzei de chovah. So a person is really stuck somewhere,7:53as we're going to talk about at the end,7:55you could use that.7:56But7:57lechatchila, a person should try to give food7:58that a person is able to—8:00Enjoy right away without having the need to cook it.8:03A question that usually comes up is,8:05what's considered two foods?8:07Could one use, let's say, crackers and a dip,8:11or, for example, French fries and ketchup,8:14apple and honey?8:14The real question is,8:16I understand the apple could be considered one of the manot,8:18and French fries could be.8:20So could a halah, so could the crackers.8:22But the question is the dip itself.8:25Can I use, is the hummus counted8:27as a, what's it called, as a8:29maneh? Is the ketchup or the honey?8:31So although8:33there are opinions8:34that are matir, here Chacham Ovadia does not permit using dips8:37as one of the two manot.8:40So therefore, when you're giving, again,8:42when you're giving for the sake of being8:45yotzei de chovah, don't let the hummus or the ketchup or the8:49honey or the mayonnaise8:52be your second maneh, be your second type of food.8:56Next, when do we have to fulfill the9:00mitzvah? We all know it's Purim,9:01but as the poskim bring down,9:05all these mitzvot must be fulfilled on Purim day,9:09not during the night,9:11which means that you came out of shul9:13and, or you went to shul on Leil Purim9:16and you wanted to give somebody the9:19mishloach manot because you know you're only going to see him then,9:21you could, but you're not yotzei de chovah with that.9:23You still have to give someone during the day of Purim.9:29Some random halachot, some—not random,9:32but some last few pointers regarding mishloach manot9:35is as follows.9:37The poskim bring down from the9:40pasuk—some of the poskim bring this9:43point—the pasuk says mishloach manot.9:44Mishloach means to send, like with a messenger.9:47And so the question arises:9:50do we have to send the mishloach manot9:53through somebody, through a messenger,9:55or can we give the mishloach manot directly to the person?9:59So the conclusion is that10:03technically you don't have to,10:05but if a person could be stringent at least for once,10:09for one of the mishloach manot, to send it through a messenger,10:11this way you cover even the hava aminas of certain10:15poskim. Now, when you're sending your mishloach manot, by the way,10:17it's fine to send it through any messenger.10:21Unlike other areas of halacha where the messenger10:24needs to be somebody who's qualified,10:27for example, in kiddushin,10:29halacha technically permits us to be mekadesh an isha.10:32A man can be mekadesh a woman through a messenger.10:35He could give somebody the ring or the coin,10:37and he tells him,10:38There's a lady in that town,10:40I know what she looks like.10:40You go to her10:42and you say,10:42Harei at mekudeshet leploni.10:44You could do that.10:46But over there,10:47the messenger himself has to be qualified.10:50There's halachot. Over here,10:51when it comes to10:53shluchim, to send them through anybody,10:55it's not a problem.10:56Even a child who's under the age of bar mitzvah.10:59That means you have little kids,11:00you want to send them around the neighborhood,11:02throughout the whole block, to send11:03them shluchim, even if you're being yotzei the chovah with those,11:05it's not a problem.11:06As the Chasam Sofer explains,11:08the shlichut over here is not the important thing.11:11Rather, over here,11:12it's the receiver has to know who it came from,11:14and the giver must notify him.11:17So therefore,11:19we don't need to have somebody who is a bar11:24chiyuva. Likewise, you could send your mishloach manot with a11:28non-Jew. So if you call up a store and you tell them,11:29Please make me a basket11:31and deliver it to my brother,11:33deliver it to my friend, my cousin,11:35and they'll deliver it for you,11:37of course11:38al yedei goy, that's the people who are working there,11:39it's also not a problem.11:41Goyim could deliver your mishloach manot.11:43You could have your housekeeper deliver your mishloach manot.11:45It's not a problem.11:46Let's say you had to run out of the house,11:47it's an emergency,11:49and you tell your housekeeper,11:49Whoever comes in,11:50this is the mishloach manot,11:51you give them on my behalf.11:53It's also not a problem.11:55Remember, you don't need shlichut over here11:57as long as they know.11:58In such a case11:58where you have your housekeeper giving it,12:00sometimes, you know, little kids come to the door,12:02they knock, they give you one,12:04and then you give them back.12:06So when they know,12:07you know who's giving,12:08who's receiving,12:09you should write down on the mishloach manot12:12your name12:13and give it to others.12:15So this way people receiving know who it came from.12:17By the way, as a side point,12:19you should know12:20that recycling in mishloach manot12:22is 100% mutar.12:23What does it mean, recycling?12:24We all do it,12:25and it's not a problem.12:26You take12:28somebody—somebody gives you mishloach manot.12:29What are you going to do with 700 mishloach manot12:30and Pesach is right around the corner?12:32So what we all do is12:33we take the sticker,12:35we slowly— Slowly, slowly12:36rip off the sticker in a way12:37that doesn't mess everything up.12:39We put another sticker with our name on it12:41and give it.12:41That is 100% mutar.12:43There's no problem.12:45The ikar is to receive it.12:47There is a12:48machloket between the Rama and12:50Chatam Sofer. If I give my mishloach manot to someone,12:53and that someone says12:54here, let's make a name,12:55Michael, okay?12:55So if I give my mishloach manot to Michael,12:57Michael says,12:58I'm mochel. Okay,12:59I got it.13:00Don't worry about it.13:01I don't want to bother you.13:02I'm not burdening you.13:03Keep it.13:04Consider it like it was accepted.13:07So in such a case,13:08according to the13:09Rama, technically, if that was my only mishloach manot,13:11according to13:11the13:13Rama, yatza yedei chovah. The13:13Chatam Sofer in a pri chadash disagrees over there.13:16But in another case,13:17but if I did receive it,13:19I don't have to eat it on Purim.13:20I don't have to eat it after Purim.13:21I can do whatever I want with it.13:22I can recycle13:24and use it for the next person13:24to give it as mishloach manot.13:26That's absolutely not a problem,13:27and we all do it.13:28The best is when you get yours back13:30from somebody else.13:30That's like, you know,13:31right?13:32See, you made it round.13:34Anyway,13:36so13:37recycling mishloach manot13:38is also not a13:39problem. Technically, also,13:41if a person chipped in13:43with a group13:44to buy a mishloach manot,13:46let's say for a rabbi of the shul13:48or for the rebbi of the class.13:51So this could happen by13:52bachurim in yeshivot13:53that don't have so much money,13:55and especially baalei13:56teshuvah that are learning13:57and they don't have so much income,13:58and they're learning full time,14:00and14:00they don't have14:01enough to give everybody,14:02and that's something14:03mechubad. They could chip in with others14:05and buy one big mishloach manot for the rabbi,14:08and14:08they're yotzei dei chovah. The whole group could be14:11yotzei dei chovah, even if that's the only mishloach manot14:12that they're giving.14:13And like we said beforehand,14:14women have to make sure14:16that mishloach manot14:17is being sent from them also.14:19They don't have to actually physically give,14:21but14:22they shouldn't rely on the fact that14:24the family is giving.14:25So let's say the Cohen family is giving14:2720 mishloach manot from the14:29Cohens. It has to be that one of them,14:31the husband has in mind14:33that the woman also is fulfilling her14:34chiyuv, not just for himself.14:36So that's an important thing to keep in mind,14:39that ladies are also chayav in mishloach manot,14:41and14:42if they're not going to deliver it to their friends14:45or to their cousins14:46or to their family members,14:47then they should either write their names14:49or that it came from them,14:50and that the husband should have in mind14:52in one of the mishloach manot14:53that's for her sake as well.14:56Okay.14:59Next.15:01Manot, by the way,15:02is plural, not singular.15:03Okay, let's continue.15:07The next thing is,15:08I'm going to give you a list over here15:10of15:12hidurim, meaning to say15:13that most of our mishloach manot that we give,15:17we're giving it out of kavod,15:18out of, you know, respect.15:20People give us,15:22so,15:22Oh yeah, of course,15:23have mishloach manot.15:23Please wait by the door.15:24We run upstairs,15:25quick, quick, quick, quick.15:26Give me one15:27mishloach, cross out the name,15:27put this name.15:28Okay, here we go.15:29Oh, I was waiting for you to come.15:31Here, give him mishloach manot, right?15:32A lot of our mishloach manot are that way,15:34or15:34we know from ahead of time15:35who we're going to give,15:36but we're not doing it15:37because of the reasons that were said beforehand.15:39So, like we said,15:41you know, you could do whatever.15:42You could give anything.15:43You could give whatever you like,15:44a piece of candy, technically.15:46But there are other hidurim that we mentioned,15:49or we didn't mention yet,15:50and a person should try15:51at least one mishloach manot15:53to do it in a way that covers all opinions.15:55I'm going to give you over here15:58seven different hidurim.16:00Now, a person should keep in mind16:02when giving at least one mishloach manot, try to do this one mishloach manot that way, and then do whatever you like with the rest.16:07This way, your yotzei the chovah, your chovah of kavod and,16:14you know, basically things because you live in a society, you have to give everybody mishloach manot.16:18Let's go through the seven. Number one is it has to be given on Purim day, right? Obviously, that's a16:24din. Number two, it should be according to your standard and the receiver's standard.16:29So if you are a wealthy person and you have so many people coming to you and giving you mishloach manot,16:34and you really, you know, you're not so wealthy, you're not a billionaire, but, you know, you're fine, you're pretty okay, you're good,16:42but you can't just buy a fancy thing for every single person is going to knock on your door.16:46You expecting to give 200 mishloach manot. You want to spend now $20 on each one?16:50It's $4,000. You know, you're not in the mood to spend that, and you know that everybody's going to throw it out afterwards.16:54So what you could do is16:56at least one of them, you should give something very, very chashuv, very good according to your standards, whatever those standards are. And17:04even if you're not on such a high standard,17:07the receiver, whoever you're giving it to, let's say you're giving it to a wealthy person or you're giving it to a17:13rabbi with17:15respect, a rav of the shul, a rosh yeshiva, should also be given with,17:21you know, according to their standard.17:23So at least give that one mishloach manot, make it nice and fancy and give it to them, at least one of them. And17:29if you don't want to give to such a person, you want to give somebody on a lower17:32standard, so fine, so you don't have to make it so fancy,17:33but it should be according to your standard and the receiver's standard. Next, number three,17:38it should be, like we said, two different types of food or a food and a drink.17:43Number four,17:45to be yotzei all opinions, there is an opinion of the Toras Manas quoted in the17:50Ben Ish Chai, some say it's the same, where each food that you're giving should be in a separate container by itself, because17:57the Toras Man holds that if you put both containers in one big container,18:02so they become all as one. So therefore make18:06the two foods in two separate containers. So,18:09lemashal, I'll just give you an example18:11we're going to use this later on. Give a challah and a bottle of wine,18:15like that. The challah is obviously put in a nice plate and the bottle of wine by itself.18:20These are two separate containers. It should be given as such.18:24Next.18:25Number five,18:27try to give something that could be eaten as part of the meal,18:30not just junk food. Most of the mishloach manot are being distributed as junk food, which is fine.18:34But remember, it's supposed to be—the idea of it, according to some of the opinions,18:38is that it's supposed to be something that you use for the meal.18:40Most of that junk food that you're giving are not being used as a meal. The best, maybe they'll snack on it on Purim or18:45maybe later. If not, they're going to drop it off by the yeshiva the next day or two.18:49So therefore, give something that could be eaten by the meal.18:52Of course, you have to make sure it's according to the standards of18:56kashrut of the person who's receiving it.19:01Number six,19:02send it with a messenger, at least one, like we mentioned before.19:06Make sure you send it with a messenger.19:07And by the way, the messenger could be right in front of you. Sometimes I have a few people that are in my house.19:12They all came at the same time, so let's say I'll have19:15Michael and19:16Yosef. So I'll say,19:19Yosef, take my mishloach manot. You're going to be my messenger to deliver it to Michael right here in front of me.19:23And then, Michael, take my mishloach manot. You're going to be my19:26delivery boy. You're going to deliver it to Yosef. And then they'll do the same thing back. At least for one19:32mishloach manot, try to do it this way to be yotzei all shitot. And19:36try, number seven, try to give it to a person who's going to receive it as well,19:41so this way you're yotzei according to all opinions. The example that we gave before, we're going to repeat it again:19:47challah and wine. Try to give it to one person. It could even be to your parents.19:50It could even be, let's say, invited to somebody's house for a meal.19:53Then, you know, one time we did this also with my siblings, where we all got together19:59and we decided that each one, you know, so it shouldn't be too hard on one person, each person is going to cook a dish.20:05So that's what we did.20:07We came, let's say I came with the sesame chicken, and my sister came with the lo mein, and this one20:13came—whatever it was—and then the rice. So let's say we came with the sesame chicken and a bottle of20:16wine. I gave it to one of my siblings and I said, Okay, now you give it to my other sibling. And then we all rotated.20:23We all made each other shaliach to give each other food, and then we all shared together in the food.20:27It's fine. I don't have to eat my whole thing by myself. I could share with everybody.20:31So try to do that as well.20:32Try to make it something that could be in also in the meal, and the people should accept it and eat it.20:39Now, before we move on to the next point in the Mishloach Manot, is20:45that I want to mention something very important, and that is, like we said before,20:50most of our Mishloach Manot, we're giving it not because, you know, of the reasons that are really, that20:55we're metaken. Remember the reasons that they instituted Mishloach Manot is in order that we want to increase love amongst the Jewish people,21:02and we want to ensure that somebody21:06has Mishloach Manot. So therefore, it's highly recommended that a person21:10should be on the lookout from now to make a list to give to people who fit in that criteria.21:17Number one,21:18give it to someone that you probably, that you have a fight with, whether you had a fight with him this year, last week,21:24seven years ago.21:26Try to break your21:28yetzer hara. Try to overcome your yetzer hara and go and give that person a Mishloach Manot. And it's better if you go in person. And21:36trust me, it does a lot. Don't think that, oh, you know, he's going to make fun, he's going to reject it. Not at all,21:41unless the guy is really cruel. Nah, I don't think so.21:43Am Purim, hard to find. Break your yetzer hara and go to the person's house and deliver a21:50Mishloach Manot. You'll see how much that breaks, how much of the ice that breaks.21:52Another thing is,21:54give it to needy people. And what I mean over here, needy people are two types of needy people.21:59Number one is socially needy. You know, there's always that guy that you know is not going to get so much22:06Mishloach Manot. There's that neighbor that you know not too many people are going to knock on their door.22:09So therefore, you make sure to give them Mishloach Manot. It does so much.22:15You don't know how much that means, especially if you're the popular person on the block,22:19you're the popular person in the group, and you're a person people respect.22:23It means so much, a kavod, if you do it with you personally.22:27Remember, we want to increase love. We want to bring simcha to people that need it. And22:32on this day, where everybody's getting hundreds or tens of Mishloach Manot, and this poor22:37person is getting bekoshi two or three, only because people just exchange with him because he gave them first,22:42you initiate and you go out of your way to that person's house and give them22:47Mishloach Manot. Another person who's needy is financially needy. You know, there's people,22:51yeah, they'll give you tzedakah, and you could tell the tzedakah was, you know,22:55was squeezing themselves out. So give them a nice platter of food.23:00It's tzedakah. Pretend it's23:02tzedakah, but like we said, it's the way that you give them a nice platter that they're going to eat.23:06I guarantee they're not going to give it out. They're not going to recycle yours. They're going to use it for23:10their seudah. I don't know how good of a seudah they'll have. So now you're not going to find these people on Purim,23:15but they are around on Purim. You know why you're not going to find them? Because23:18you're not thinking about them. Purim is so busy, Baruch Hashem, we have so many mitzvot on that day.23:23So therefore, from today, make a list of the people23:27that—anyway, you're making a list of people you're going to give—don't forget to include these three people.23:31Number one, a person that you had a fight with,23:33somebody that you're able to enhance your relationship with them.23:37Number two, a person who is socially needy. Number three is a person who's financially needy. And by the on Purim, a lot of people from23:43Israel that go around collecting. You know, I happen to know personally a few of these people that go around. Some of them are23:50rabbanim. I'm not telling you there's fakers. There's no fakers. There's some fakers, but a lot of them are23:56legitimate good people, and this is, you know, unfortunately, this is how they have to spend.24:00Their Purim, while we're enjoying, they're going around from house to house trying to get a little bit of a few dollars.24:04Even if you don't have so much to give them financially, when they come into your house,24:07offer them something to eat. You should make some sort of, like, you know, food, some drinks, so they should come in.24:13It's like a little bit of a mishloach manot. And of course, they're tired, they're hungry.24:18They're not going to say it, but they're walking around collecting all day.24:21They don't have really the time to eat.24:24But so when they come in anyway, invite them for a little bit of l'chaim, a little bit of a drink.24:27Give them, offer them, don't just from the door, give them something and, you know, goodbye.24:31This is a day that you want to increase simcha to everybody. Don't forget anyone.24:38Okay, the last point now is regarding the mourner's obligation, an aveil's obligation with matanot la'evyonim and mishloach manot.24:49The mourner's obligation is as follows, okay,24:53to give or to receive in mishloach manot, the halacha differs.24:58So let's start like this. To give mishloach manot, a mourner is25:03chayav. By the way, a mourner means anybody within the mourning stage,25:06whether it's betoch shivah, shloshim, or betoch shanah. A mourner is chayav to give mishloach manot.25:17However, he should limit it to just one person.25:22Maran in Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah, siman taf aleph, halacha25:26zayin. I'll read it for you:25:40מת לו מת קודם פורים, ופגע בו פורים, אינו מפסיק אבלות. Avelut continues,25:44מקום מקום אין אבלות נוהג בו, לא ביוד ולא בט״ו. However, there is no external signs of mourning,25:51אלא דברים שבצנעא נוהג. And Maran says,25:56וחייב לשלוח מנות. He is chayav, he is obligated to send manot. He is not exempt from mishloach manot.26:00So a mourner is obligated to give mishloach manot,26:03at least one person. That's the minimum. Let him do that.26:07Receiving, on the other end, is a little bit more complicated, let's say that.26:12It's a machloket in Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah, siman shin26:17peh hei, halacha gimel, between Maran and the26:19Rama. It depends on the din of she'elat shalom, if it's noheg during Shabbat and Yamim26:26Tovim. So, according to Maran, that during the days of Shabbat and Yamim26:30Tovim, noten shalom lechol adam26:35b'Shabbat, shemiklal devarim shebefarhesya. You're allowed to ask shalom26:36of avelim, you're allowed to say shalom to the avelim, and they could answer back,26:40because otherwise it would be like publicizing his mourning.26:44However, the Rama writes, no, asur lishloach manot because you're not allowed to ask26:50b'shlomo. So the halacha, there's a machloket on Shabbat if you could say shalom to a mourner or not.26:56The Rama connects that also to mishloach manot.27:00That means if you're allowed to give shalom to a mourner,27:05you're allowed to also give him mishloach manot,27:07and that's the opinion of Shulchan Aruch.27:09And according to the Rama, it's forbidden.27:12You're not allowed to say shalom to an avel on Shabbat.27:16So too, mishloach manot on Purim is also, the mourner is not allowed to receive.27:20It's like a form of receiving shalom; it's receiving a gift.27:24And that is, we would say, a machloket that then we should technically say27:28it's a machloket between Sefardim and Ashkenazim regarding a mourner:27:32could he receive gifts or not?27:34Sounds like according to Sefardim, not a problem, you could receive gifts.27:37According to Ashkenazim, a mourner cannot receive gifts.27:42However, you should know the Ben Ish Chai is machmir like the27:45Rama. Ben Ish Chai says that a mourner should not receive gifts.27:49However, he disagrees because Maran, Maran Shulchan Aruch rules that you could receive.27:53So therefore, if you're a Ben Ish Chainik and you follow everything with the Ben27:58Ish Chai, so don't give it to the mourner. Or if you're the mourner yourself,28:01but what you could do is, what everybody agrees on,28:04is that you could give it to a family who is not a mourner.28:06So let's say the father of the family, let's go back to28:11Mishpachat Cohen. So the father, Father Cohen, Dad Cohen, is a mourner.28:16So don't give it to Dad; give it to Mom.28:18Give it to son Cohen, Sonny Cohen, right?28:22Give it to him. Let him be the receiver,28:25which is, understand again, you're giving it out of respect.28:28But when you give it to Sonny Cohen, right, Daddy Cohen knows that it's going to him, really,28:34but which means you're doing it out of respect.28:37You showed your respect that you're giving him the mishloach manot.28:39Another thing that everybody agrees on:28:41if the mourner himself fits into the category of an ani, of a poor person,28:48then everybody agrees you could give him mishloach manot,28:51and he could receive mishloach manot.28:53There already it becomes more like a tzedakah,28:56and he's allowed to receive it as well.28:58One final question, and that is: what would a person do,29:02if, no aleinu, they're stuck in the hospital29:06and they don't have anybody around them?29:09They're stuck in the hospital and they don't have anybody around them to give.29:11So if your roommate—let's answer that very29:14quickly—if your roommate in the hospital is a Jew,29:17even if he's not religious, you can give them mishloach manot.29:20It can be29:21yotzei de chovah. Now, what does mishloach manot mean?29:23Well, everybody gives you food, so take any food as long as it's kosher,29:26and one food, one drink, and give it to29:31the guy next to you in the hospital,29:34as long as he is not a kofeir, a person who29:37says he's an atheist, he doesn't believe.29:40He has to be a Jew, even if he's not religious.29:42As long as he's not a kofeir, you could be29:45yotzei de chovah by giving to another Jew.29:46Also, if there's a nurse, or if there is a doctor in the29:51hospital—even though we said men should not give to women29:53and women should not give to29:54men—over here, when you're stuck, you could give it with,29:58of course, explaining that this is a hiyuv if they're Jewish.30:01Even if they're not religious, as long as they're Jewish,30:04you explain to them that, you know,30:06it's Purim, we have to give another gift,30:07and you could give it to the nurses or to the doctors.30:11When a person, no aleinu, is really, really stuck,30:14then they could just appoint a30:16shliach. They could call someone,30:17please deliver two types of food to Mr.30:21so-and-so, and that's how they could be30:25yotzei de chovah the mitzvah of mishloach manot.30:27Now, let me tell the listeners right now:30:30if you know any such people,30:32it's a big mitzvah to visit them on Purim,30:35to bring them something30:37that they're able to give other people as well,30:39that should be mekayem the mitzvah of mishloach manot.30:41Give them, and this way they're able to give others as well,30:44and sometimes they might be able to give you.30:45It's a big, big mitzvah30:47if you're able to find some sort of time to squeeze30:50to be able to visit such people30:51that unfortunately have to spend Purim in the hospital.30:55We move on now to the next subject,30:59and that is matanot31:02la'evyonim. Now, matanot31:04la'evyonim, the halacha says it's supposed to be given31:05right after Shacharit on the daytime,31:09and technically we should talk about it later,31:10but I'm speaking about it now31:12because of the way we give matanot la'evyonim in our days.31:15A little bit of a background.31:16Matanot la'evyonim is also found in the pasuk,31:23u'matanot la'evyonim. That's what the pasuk says.31:25What's the reason they instituted matanot31:27la'evyonim? The answer is, like we said,31:29we want to ensure everybody has what to eat.31:31Everybody should celebrate on this day,31:33so therefore they instituted that31:38everybody should give money31:39to at least31:41evyonim. Evyon is a poor person,31:43but evyonim in Hebrew, it's plural,31:45minimum of two people.31:47What could you give them?31:49You don't have to give them necessarily money.31:50You could give them either money or food,31:53because remember the idea is that31:54you should provide them with the ability to have a31:57seudah, so that could come in money or food. The problem—32:00The problem is that we don't find, as Mishnah Berurah points out, we don't find in halacha a clear definition of how much to give for32:08matanot32:09la'evyonim. It says give them gifts,32:11matanah. How much gifts do I have to give them?32:14So here we find what we basically categorize as three categories.32:21The Mishnah Berurah quotes the Ritva, one of the Rishonim.32:23The Ritva says two prutot. Shtei prutot,32:30you can be yotzei de chovah. Now, shtei prutot, rabotai, that equals to something around five cents a nickel, maybe.32:35I'm being very nice and generous when I say five cents.32:38So to give an ani five cents, to give two aniyim, oh, with ten cents I'm32:43yotzei de chovah? Well, technically, right?32:45It's a minimum.32:46But the Acharonim bring down that that's32:50ridiculous. Two prutot? Maybe prutot were more worth back then.32:53Two prutot in our days, based on the price that we have, is nothing.32:57What can a person buy with it?32:58No. So the Acharonim bring down, no.33:00It should be given—you should give something that a person is able to buy with it a good33:05amount of food.33:06The Acharonim bring down, like the Minchat Chinuch and others, they should be able to buy33:11shlosha beitzim of bread.33:12That shlosha beitzim of bread is six kezayitot, about around six ounces of33:18bread. So basically a pack of pita, around33:24$1.75, $2. That is what a person should give, preferably, but that's only bread.33:30The minhag is that people give enough for a little bit of a meal.33:33People always grew up with the notion that you give them enough for two slices of pizza and33:37a French fries. This way it's like a mishloach manot that you give them.33:41So we always price it between $2 to $7. I'll tell you what the— With a better33:46way of thinking, if you want to know how to figure out how much to give an ani, I'll33:51tell you. You can figure out in the following.33:54Let's flip tables for a second,33:56chas v'shalom. If, chas v'shalom, you were the evyon, if, chas v'shalom, you were the one on the receiving34:02end, and you don't have what to eat on Purim, and you want people to give you a seudah, not34:07from everybody, but from someone that should be able to give you a seudah, how much would34:10you want to receive?34:12Two prutot, a nickel? Two dollars? Seven dollars? How much would you want to give? How much would34:19you want somebody to give you?34:21And that's how much you should give to somebody else.34:24And that's how you can figure out. Now, do you have to give every single ani that comes34:29to you that way?34:29No, no, no, no, no. But at least two34:33aniyim. So therefore, whatever amount that you feel is respectable and honorable, give it to two34:40aniyim. So if you feel, you know what, $25, I'll be happy, so take34:43$50 for two aniyim and give it,34:47and that's the amount that you should give.34:48But you decide how much an ani should give.34:52You want to know what the greatest level, the third category, the best, best thing to34:56do is what the Rambam writes.34:58I'm going to read you the words of the Rambam inside, such beautiful words, and he says35:02like this:35:10מוטב להרבות במתנות לאביונים מלהרבות בסעודתו ובשלוח מנות לרעיו. Better that a person should give more to matanot la'evyonim than the amount that he gives for35:17his meal on Purim, or the amount that he's spending on the mishloach manot that he's giving35:22to friends.35:23Why? says the Rambam, שאין שמחה גדולה ומפוארת. There's no greater happiness, and35:31there's no more honorable happiness, אלא לשמח לב עניים יתומים ואלמנות. than to make35:38people who are poor, widows and orphans, happy, ודומה לשכינה. And when you're35:45doing such a thing, you're like the Shekhinah, you're like Hashem Himself, shene'emar, Lehachayot ruach35:49shefalim, ul'hachayot lev nidka'im, to revive the spirit of those who are down and to bring35:58back the hearts of those who are downtrodden. That's what the Rambam writes.36:01So the third category is, and Baruch Hashem, it's beautiful, I see some people, you36:06know, as a rabbi in the shul, so they come to me and they give me the money, le'evyonim, and you see some people that do36:10this. It's so wonderful, so nice to see, Baruch Hashem, there's a lot of wonderful36:14people out there, is that they go to their wives, the man goes to his wife and he says,36:18How much did you spend on mishloach manot for everybody in the family, for us and the kids?36:23How much are you spending on the seudah Purim, even for invited out? Fine, well, how36:27much is the total? Two hundred dollars? Fine. Two-oh-one? Rabbi, this I want you to take,36:32two-oh-one now and give it36:35to matanot la'evyonim. That's a beautiful thing, to give more than what you're spending on yourself, to give36:39that to matanot la'evyonim. It's a beautiful thing. Obligation? No, but it's definitely36:43the best category. If you want to be mekayem the mitzvah b'hidurah, that's where you start.36:49You want to give more, of course, like the Rambam says, that's even better. You're36:54domeh to the Shekhinah.36:56Another way to do this is that you can invite them over. You can invite them over for the37:01seudah and have them come over. You can also37:07mekayem mishloach matanot la'evyonim if you're really stuck.37:09Now where could the money come from that you give to37:12matanot la'evyonim? The minimum, whatever minimum we said, like whether you call the two prutot or the two meals, two37:18dollars to each person, the minimum has to be from your own pocket. It cannot be from37:22ma'aser. But if you want to add on to that, yeah, give from ma'aser as much as you like. Why37:29not?37:29You can give it to matanot la'evyonim. That should be distributed on Purim. And,37:33rabotai, you should know, speaking to some aniyim, I don't speak to so much to them, but this is37:38the day that they all look forward to because, Baruch Hashem, they get over a lot.37:42They're able to pay a lot of bills. Usually a lot of these people are in big debts, and37:48most people have an image that an ani is like those stories that you hear or you37:52read from like a hundred years ago. The ani is this poor guy with rags and he's living37:57on... No, no, no. That's not, unfortunately, the aniyim in our days. The38:04aniyim... Are people that are sitting night next to you in shul. The aniyim could be the tutors38:09of your kids that are learning in kollel. The aniyim could be many people. You want to38:14know what's an ani in Biyur according to halacha? According to halacha, you look in Shulchan38:19Aruch, Yoreh Deah, in the halachot of, I believe, Reish Nun Chet or Reish Nun Zayin,38:26or halachot of tzedakah. Over there, the halacha clearly defines what's the definition of a38:31poor person. You know what the definition of a poor person is? It's any person whose income cannot38:40meet his expense. That means, let's say his expense throughout the whole year, whether38:46it's tuition, whether it's clothing. Yes, aniyim also have tuition. Yes, aniyim also have38:50to pay for clothing. Yes, aniyim also have holidays with their kids that they have to celebrate,38:54and they have to pay for food. Okay, so they get some benefits from the government, but38:58they also have expenses on top of that. So all that expense that they're spending throughout39:02the year, so let's say it comes out to $100,000, let's say, and his income39:07is $80,000. Now, $80,000, that's a lot of money, but you know what? His regular39:11expense—we're not talking about he's spending luxurious, not talking about he's going39:14vacationing every other day. No, no, no. He does minimum. Yes, he sends39:19his kids to camp because that's a normal standard. Yes, he'll take a weekend away to relax from39:26a stressful job, to go away to Jersey for a little bit, but that's not because he's not39:30going to the islands. No, no, no. He's functioning as a normal person. He has bills to pay, and39:38normal bills, and he cannot meet it. That's an ani. An ani is a person whose income does39:45not meet his expenses. He has to spend $100,000; he only makes $80,000. Of39:51course, if he makes even less. So technically, you should know most people learning39:55Kolel qualify as aniyim, believe it or not. Yeah, because most...40:00We call it beli make it. The wife works here, and he gets a little bit from there, and somehow miraculously they end up somehow with something.40:06But of course, if you know somebody who really needs it, people are really in debt, it's a big mitzvah to give them.40:11And by the way, the more related to you they are, the closer they are to you in blood, relatives or your wife's relatives, it's a bigger mitzvah.40:19As we find in the halachot of tzedakah, it's better to give to the people closer to you40:25than to give it to strangers or people, you know, especially from different places.40:31And even, by the way, own family members. If you have a brother who's an evyon, who's an ani, who qualifies as an ani,40:36and Baruch Hashem you're doing well, to give him matanot la'evyonim, you're yotzei dechovah, and it's even preferable.40:42One should a person give matanot la'evyonim? It has to be on Purim day itself.40:49That means the evyon has to receive it on Purim. Doesn't mean you have to give it on Purim.40:54Meaning, most people today, from what I've seen, is that they don't actually give the money themselves to the ani.41:00Rather, they give the money to the rabbi or to a person in charge of an institution, whether it's Kupat Ha'ir or Vaad Harabbanim, whatever it is,41:08and then they give it. Then the rabbis or people in charge of the tzedakah fund, they'll give it out to whoever they feel is41:19needy, and the rabbi gives it out, obviously, on Purim day.41:23So as such, I make the announcement every single year. I really hope that people listen.41:27You'll always have one or two people that will knock on your door last second, five minutes before Purim is over,41:32and ask you, Oh, by the way, I didn't give matanot la'evyonim, Rabbi. Here, take twenty dollars and I'm41:39yotzei dechovah. Please, if you're not giving the money to the ani directly and you're giving it to somebody to give it for you on your behalf,41:46give them enough time to be able to allocate the money in the right way.41:51Especially if you—I know, for example, if I'm giving out matanot la'evyonim and I know how much I'm giving out already from before,41:57from three days before Purim, I could divide it in envelopes.42:01It could be something mechubad. When I give it to a person who needs it, it comes in a nice envelope.42:06And sometimes you get money—even those who want to give it on Purim day itself,42:10rabotai, the mitzvah is not that you should give it to the rabbi on Purim.42:13The mitzvah is that the ani should receive it on Purim.42:15So make sure you give the money to the rabbi or whoever you want to give it to who's going to deliver it for you42:22before Purim, enough time. You can already give it from now, and he'll deliver it for you on Purim.42:30Next.42:34The rabbis who are giving out the matanot42:40la'evyonim, the halacha brings down that they should give it preferably immediately after Shacharit. Before they do anything else, they should give it then.42:47Who's obligated in the mitzvah? Well, obviously all men. Also,42:54all women also have to be, the chiyuv also to give.42:59So that means men, if you're giving money, give it also on behalf of your wife as well.43:03Also, any boys or girls above the age of bar mitzvah or bat mitzvah,43:10the parents should, you know, if they have their own income or they get some allowance, they also have to give.43:16And even children under, parents should train these kids to give.43:21Question: could you give a check to an ani?43:23This is a machloket between the43:28Acharonim. The following poskim are matir:43:30Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, Rav Elyashiv, Rav Wosner, Rav Chaim Kanievsky. They all say you could give it, you could give a check,43:36and you could be yotzei the mitzvah of matanot43:38la'evyonim. So if you want to give, let's say, to two evyonim, you want to give them a check, twenty dollars each, you could do that,43:44even if it's43:45postdated. Even if it's postdated, that's a major43:48chiddush. However, Rav Nissim Karelitz said although you could give a check,43:51but it has to be that he's able to cash it that day,43:54so you can't give him a postdated check.43:55Also, you can't give it to him when Purim is on Sunday when the banks are closed,43:59unless, I guess, he has that, you know, the app and he could, you know, deposit the check from the phone.44:03Okay, fine. Yes, aniyim also have smartphones.44:08Okay. Anyway, so, but checks could also be given,44:10and of course if you're giving the rabbi the check and he's gonna cash it in and give the ani, of course you could do that as well.44:17Now one last point about— Matanot44:21la'evyonim. Before we conclude this class,44:24and that is, the halacha says,44:26Kol ha-poshet yado litol, notnim lo.44:31Whoever sticks out his hand, you give it to him.44:35What does that mean? We don't examine, we don't check if the guy is needy or not. Purim, you give it to him.44:41Now, the Tur, when he quotes this44:44halacha, he quotes from the name of the Ramban and the Nimukei Yosef.44:47He adds in at the end, and he says,44:49Echad Yisrael v'echad goy, whether it's a Jew or a44:52goy. So it sounds like even goyim, even if a goy sticks out his hand on Purim, you could give to44:58them. However, the Beit Yosef quotes45:00the Hagahot Maimoniyot in the name of the Maharzor Vitri,45:04who was one of the students of Rashi, who wrote a book of45:09halachot, and he quotes Rashi in there, and he says that Rashi used to get so bothered45:12when he would see people on Purim giving to goyim.45:16He says, You're taking away two problems.45:19Number one is you're taking away that money that you could have given to a Jew, you're giving it now to a45:24non-Jew. Number two is you're also making it like45:27this holiday is for everybody, no difference Jew or non-Jew alike.45:30So it used to bother him a lot.45:32So Maran concludes in his halacha when he brings it, he says like this:45:37Ein medakdekin im ha'aniim Purim. We don't check out the guy when we're coming to give him money on Purim if he sticks out his hand. Kol ha-poshet yado notnim lo. Whoever sticks out his hand,45:43we give him anything, a dollar, a quarter, whatever it is.45:45It's a good idea, by the way, to have a roll of dollars or quarters and to give it out.45:50Makom45:51shenahagu liten afilu la'akum, notnim. Maran concludes, only if there's a minhag in your area where you live45:56that they also give goyim, you could continue.45:58But if there's no such a minhag, you should not give it to46:02non-Jews. Not today. You want to give to non-Jews, give it a different day.46:04Today is a day for the Jewish people to increase simcha amongst the Jewish people.46:08We're going to have to stop here.46:09Just keep in mind, that this Shabbat is Parashat Zachor.46:13Men are obligated here; it's46:15a mitzvat de'oraita. Women should preferably also46:18hear. And next week we'll finish up the46:20halacha. We'll talk about46:23taanit Esther. But the— oh, I forgot.46:24Next week the class will be on Tuesday,46:26and it'll be aired on again as a repeat on Wednesday at the same time.46:30So look out for that class next week.46:32It's going to again be on Tuesday46:34next week; it's a change of schedule.46:36So we'll talk about46:38Tanit Esther. We'll talk about Purim day itself,46:41the laws of Megillah, and the party drinking.46:43Make sure you listen to that class next week.46:46And this class will be aired on again tonight at 1046:50p.m. Thank you, Eran. Thank you, J Root, for hosting us.46:53We'll see you next week.46:54Anybody has a question, call in right now,46:57718-683-5858, or text in at 347-927-8398.