Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Okay, welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio. We're here live on0:05 Gimel Shvat, Wednesday afternoon, January 13th, and0:10 we are back on video live. If you'd like to watch this video on JRootRadio.com, you could watch us.0:15 You could see us right now0:17 filming live.0:18 Okay, we are not gonna, you know, we were told that the introductions are too long,0:24 so we're just gonna give you the text number,0:26 347-927-8398. If you have any text, any0:30 questions through text, we'll be able to answer, be'ezrat Hashem, in the middle of the class, of course, if it's pertaining to the class.0:36 And all other inquiries and comments and speeches and whatever that may be, would like to hear your feedback,0:42 please call in at the end of the class. We'll give you the numbers again.0:45 We are in the halachot of Shabbat, the halachot of muktzeh. I believe we have done0:52 15, perhaps this is the 16th class on muktzeh, and there will be still more. We are going very slow.1:00 We're trying to elaborate on the subject that's very, very difficult,1:04 and Baruch Hashem, I think we're doing good so far. We've done, we covered a lot.1:07 We've covered most of the halachot of muktzeh, and certainly most of the practical cases.1:12 We still have a few more to finish up. And1:15 speaking of finishing up, we want to finish up the halachot that we spoke about last week,1:20 graf shel re'i, and1:23 continue into the halachot of this week.1:25 So if you're listening now, keep, stay tuned, because we'll be discussing something that's very, very important.1:31 We hope that, be'ezrat Hashem, to give a clarity on this1:35 halacha, exactly what the opinions are and how to go about it, the halacha and the subject of1:42 toys and1:43 balls like soccer balls and footballs and basketballs and golf balls and, you know, all the different types of sports.1:49 What is the din? What is the1:52 halacha? What does the halacha tell us when it comes to those items1:55 regarding muktzeh and everything else that has to do with it,1:58 be'ezrat Hashem. That will be the subject of today after we finish up the laws of graf2:04 shel re'i. So let's review a little bit, not so much, but a little bit of what we discussed last week.2:09 Of course, you have to go to last week's archives to, you know, to hear the whole discussion in full.2:13 We discussed last week the halacha of graf shel rei, which is a din that's found in the Gemara. In general,2:18 mukzeh machmat gufo,2:21 anything that is mukzeh because in2:24 itself is not a utensil, it has no function,2:27 it's not used for anything, like dirt, rocks, stones, or all these kind of things. The rule is that it's2:33 mukzeh and it's forbidden to be2:38 handled completely, not l'tzorech gufo, not l'tzorech mekomo. And like all other2:44 mukzeh, anything that's forbidden to move around, it's permitted to move it in an indirect way, meaning to say in an abnormal way.2:52 Let's say if something is normally handled by your hands, which is most items, you could kick it,2:57 a stone, usually people move it with their hands. So if you want to kick it to the side, it's fine.3:02 That's mukzeh machmat gufo.3:03 There is a heter that's found in the Gemara regarding mukzeh machmat gufo.3:08 That means although something could be completely forbidden, it has no function, yet3:12 we still find there are ways that you would be able to3:17 move it on Shabbat, and that is if it falls into the category known as graf3:24 shel rei. What is graf shel rei? Literally means3:28 it's a potty. That's pretty much how it translates nowadays. That's a potty. It's something that's made to3:34 hold the waste of animals. So basically, the category of graf shel rei, as we explained last week, is3:40 anything that is3:44 disgusting to the person. It's repulsive.3:46 So the halacha tells us that although something is mukzeh machmat gufo and3:52 under normal circumstances I would not be able to handle it, I would not be able to move it in a normal way.3:59 If it's in the category of graf shel rei, meaning to say if it's repulsive, I may pick it up in my own bare hands.4:06 I don't need to move it with the side of my foot to kick it to the side.4:11 I could actually pick it up with my own hands. Some of the examples that we explained last week of4:16 graf shel rei are a dead rodent. You see a dead rat,4:21 you could pick it up with your hands if you're brave enough, right? Okay, but you could pick it up with your own bare hands.4:27 You don't need to sweep it up. You don't need to kick it to the side. You could actually pick it up.4:33 That is an example. Another common example would be when the kids make—forgive me to use the mashal again,4:41 but it's graf shel rei. It has something disgusting, so I have to use something that's disgusting as a mashal.4:45 So if the kids make, they make number one, number two, and the dirty diapers, all those fall under the category of graf4:52 shel rei. Most people bothers them. Like we said last week, graf shel rei does not have to be4:57 something so repulsive that you can't stand it. It could be already something that icks you and bothers you.5:03 You can't be in the same room with it.5:05 So therefore, another halacha that we find in graf shel rei is that it has to be, in order for you to have the5:12 heter to remove muktzeh mechamat gufo, which falls under the category of graf5:16 shel rei, it has to be also in the place that you commonly use on Shabbat.5:22 If you commonly use it, but not on Shabbat, it does not fall in the category of graf5:25 shel rei. So we gave the example with the attic. If you happen to walk into the attic,5:29 or you happen to walk into one of the storage rooms in your basement to5:32 pick up a bottle of soda, and then you notice over there a dead rodent,5:37 you have no heter to remove it. Although it's disgusting and repulsive, but still,5:42 it's not a room that you use, that you commonly use. Even though,5:46 yes, I walk in and out of it, but it's not a room that you sit on and you, you know...5:52 We basically use on a regular basis.5:56 Going in and out of a room just to get something, that's not6:01 qualified to be a room6:03 that is called6:05 commonly used. Commonly used should not be misunderstood that, yeah, I walk in there, of course, when I need a6:10 seudah, I walk in there. No. Commonly used refers to over here that I actually use it to sit on on Shabbat,6:16 whether I relax, I eat, whatever it may be, not just something that, like a closet where I walk in and out of it.6:21 However, we did give another heter. When you find a graf shel rei in an area which you don't commonly use,6:28 the heter is only with the following two conditions. Number one, it has to be something that may cause you financial loss.6:36 Number two is that in order to be able to consider, let's say, this attic as a6:44 graf shel rei, even though you don't normally use it, you have to actually use it. Sit down, bring your chair,6:49 sit down over there for a few minutes, and then feel the6:54 disgusting thing that's next to you, that eeks you, and then you can have the permission to pick it up.6:59 These are some of the halachot that we spoke about last week regarding graf shel rei. We also mentioned at the end that7:06 only something that is physically repulsive is7:10 qualifies for a graf shel rei, but something that's spiritually repulsive, that doesn't qualify for7:15 graf shel rei. Meaning, we explained forbidden magazines.7:18 Don't go too far with the word forbidden. Forbidden means, like we explained, things that you're not allowed to read on Shabbat, things that have7:25 commercials and advertisements. The other ones, has v'shalom, that there should be in your house or in your proximity.7:31 Yekef Hashem won't bring in your way. In any case,7:34 for magazines that you're not allowed to read on Shabbat because they have advertisements, they have subjects that are not for Shabbat to be read,7:40 those, although spiritually damaging, it's not supposed to be there, you might look at it,7:45 you don't have the permission to handle it with your hand.7:48 Anything that doesn't qualify for graf shel re'i and it's muktzeh machmat gufo, although you can't handle it with your hands,7:53 we come back again, we stress the rule: you could move it in an abnormal way. Between your elbows, you could.8:00 Pick it, you can pick it up with your foot. Do what you like to be able to remove it.8:04 Those are some of the halachot of graf shel rei. We will continue this week, be'ezrat Hashem, in the same subject.8:10 Halacha dalet in the Ben Ish Chai, Parashat Vayigash.8:14 The halacha speaks about over here the actual graf8:19 shel rei. You should know the word graf and abit are pretty much what we would call a8:24 potty. But in those days, just to take you back a little bit in time and give you a little bit of appreciation of the lifestyle that we live in.8:32 In the olden days, if a person wants to go to the bathroom, you don't go pick a room in the house8:38 and, you know, you do what you got to do and then everything is clean. You spray Lysol and you're good enough to go.8:43 No, it doesn't work that way. There was no, you know, sewer system that we have today.8:50 Today, if, Hashem, ends up in Staten Island, let them worry about it. You're fine over here in8:53 Brooklyn. Over there, back then, the only way to do it is either to actually physically go out of the house,9:00 go to a certain designated area in your backyard, in the forest, in the woods, or I don't want to say neighbor's house, but, you know, it could possibly be,9:09 and over there, you know, answer your nature call over there.9:14 That's one way that was done. Another way, which is if a person was a little bit wealthier,9:19 you go sometimes to some of these big mansions or those castles from the, you know, olden days, pre-sewer system days,9:25 and you see they would have a designated room where they'd use as a bathroom, but they wouldn't just keep the waste on the floor.9:32 They'd have a special bucket to use it. And of course, if it's days which are cold in the winter and everything else,9:38 of course they had to use a special bucket even in the small house because it was too cold to keep on going outside every time somebody needs a9:43 bathroom. So, like we said, identical to what the children today use, what we know. As9:51 patis. So therefore, what did they do in those days with those patis after they get filled up?9:56 They would take them and they would empty them out.10:00 And this is where the whole concept of grasharai comes in,10:03 that when it's full and you need to, you know, get rid of it, you have to pick it up.10:10 Ah, it's muktzeh. Yes, it's muktzeh, but something disgusting because you need to use it again,10:14 so you have to pick it up and throw it out.10:15 Now, in the case the halacha tells us, when a person took the bucket that's full,10:19 he went outside, he threw it out where he threw it out, where it's, you know, out of harm's way,10:23 and then he wants to bring it back. Why did they have to bring it back?10:26 The part that you're using of, or the patis, is disgusting. It's all full of waste.10:32 So in order to be able to bring it back, the halacha tells us that you have to fill it up with water,10:36 and since that water could technically be given to animals to drink,10:41 so therefore they allowed it over here in the combination with water and the bucket together10:46 to bring it back to your house, and you don't have the problem mukzeh of picking up and handling the bucket.10:54 This is how the halacha is brought down.10:57 However, the Acharonim point out that this halacha, if you're reading it in11:02 Shulchan Aruch, if you heard about it, it should not only apply when the bucket itself was either made out of earthenware,11:09 not like the china that we have today. China we have today is even fancier,11:12 or if it was made out of wood, where we all know things that get dirty like that11:17 and they commonly use, it's very hard to clean them.11:19 Although you may flush them with water a little, but they get stuck on them and it's very, very disgusting.11:24 The Acharonim already discussed in their days, if a person has a, let's call it—not call it a11:29 patis—but basically he has a bucket which he uses for waste in those days,11:32 and it was made out of glass, or if it was made out of metal. Those things can be cleaned very easily.11:40 You just put some water on it, and that's it.11:42 It gets cleansed, and you have no problem bringing it back.11:46 It's not disgusting anymore. It's only disgusting when you can't really clean it thoroughly.11:51 So therefore, as part of this, we come back to our halacha case.11:57 So practically speaking, you have a potty. The kid's made in it. You know, he's been potty trained,12:03 and now it's full, so you want to empty it out.12:05 So you take out the insert from the potty, and you empty it out.12:08 The question is, could you bring it back?12:10 Isn't this a case of graf shel rei, where halacha tells us you have to fill it up with water before you bring it back?12:14 And the answer is, it is, but it's not.12:18 It is a graf shel rei. It is a bucket that's made for waste.12:21 But unlike the case of the Mishnah, or excuse me, the Gemara, or the halacha, where you actually have to fill it up with water and bring it back,12:29 over here you don't have that problem.12:30 You know why? Number one is it's cleaner.12:34 Most of the potties, I don't know if any other way, they're made out of plastic.12:39 The reason why I say most, I always try to protect myself.12:41 I don't like to say something and people,12:43 okay. Most of the things of the potties out there are made out of plastic.12:51 Plastic, rabotai, is very, very easily cleaned.12:55 It doesn't stick. Things don't stick on it.12:57 It's not like wood. It's not like earthenware, where things get stuck on it.13:00 So therefore, in such a case where your potty is made out of plastic and you empty it out,13:05 you give it a run under the faucet, you wash it a little bit, and it's clean.13:09 There's nothing there. So you're not—although it's made to put something13:13 in this, but it's not disgusting in itself now,13:15 and therefore you can bring it back, and even if you don't put any water inside of it.13:20 Besides that, besides that, you have another heter to be able to bring it back.13:26 What is that heter?13:28 The answer is, the heter is something called kavod13:35 habriyot. Gadol kavod habriyot shedoche lo13:40 ta'aseh. Says the Gemara that kavod habriyot, the respect for people, is so great13:48 that it can even push a lo13:50 ta'aseh. What does it mean, lo ta'aseh, over here?13:51 Not a de'oraita, but it's a derabbanan. Meaning, like this.13:55 There's such a concept that we find.13:57 You got to be careful. You got to be careful how you interpret my words over here.14:00 I'm being very careful to say what I'm saying,14:01 and I'm giving a warning that whatever I say is what I meant.14:06 Do not derive out of my words anything that I did not say.14:09 If you're unsure or if you're hearing something in my name,14:13 make sure you double-check it.14:16 What that kavod habriyot means, that out of respect for people's dignity,14:22 there are certain times when we may do an14:27 issur derabbanan to avoid disrespecting a person's dignity.14:30 Okay, let's give you a very good example, which is our subject.14:36 You have a case of elderly people cannot go to the bathroom,14:41 Hashem yishmor, right? They get to an age they can't get up,14:43 or people are very, very sick and they can't get up,14:45 and they can't walk all the way to the bathroom,14:47 and, you know, it's very, very common.14:48 It doesn't have to be only in a hospital; it could be sometimes in the house.14:51 And therefore they have a special bucket which they use, you know, to go to the bathroom.14:54 It just makes it easier for them from the bed,14:56 or they just have to slide off the bed a little bit.14:58 It sounds, you know, they don't have to travel so far.15:01 So let's say you have such a bucket.15:03 So now it's filled up. Obviously you're not going to keep it in the room;15:05 you're going to throw it out.15:07 So could you bring it back?15:08 And the answer is yes, even without filling it up with water.15:10 You know why?15:12 Mishum kavod15:14 habriyot. Because out of the person's dignity.15:16 No, you have to wait now till the guy has to go very bad.15:20 What if he has to go very bad and he can't wait,15:21 and then he's gonna, chas v'shalom, make on himself and create a disgusting situation?15:27 Same thing will be applicable for kids.15:29 If you don't have the bucket ready at all times,15:32 and let's say you couldn't find whatever it is,15:34 if you don't have it ready at all times,15:35 what's gonna be with that kid who has to make15:38 and he's being potty trained, he's not wearing any diapers?15:41 You know what's gonna be?15:42 It's gonna be all over your living room.15:44 That's right, all over.15:46 He might step on it, take it to the backyard,15:48 take it to the front yard, take it to shul,15:51 take it to your neighbor's house.15:52 It's gonna go all over, whether you realize it or not.15:55 So therefore, where's the dignity of the person or the people in there?16:00 So because of that, hachamim allowed you to do, or they put on the side temporarily16:07 the issur derabanan of muktzeh over here. So out of kavod habriyot, we find sometimes16:13 this is one example where this halacha is, and many other places,16:17 but this is one example. We got to be careful how to apply this din, as you can see,16:22 it's very, very scary. You know, when hachamim speak about a person's dignity,16:27 sometimes, you know, it's pretty much custom-made. For somebody who's very, very16:33 hashuv, maybe for him, yeah, we might allow goyim to do things for them that otherwise would be asur for another person.16:39 So it's not something that we regular people could go ahead and decide,16:43 yes, it's kavod habriyot, not kavod habriyot. This is something that the poskim, people who are into halacha16:47 and they know the whole spectrum of the Shulchan Aruch and they know how to apply,16:50 they could use that. They could apply and tell us when to apply this din of kavod habriyot.16:56 In our case, the poskim permit the bringing of the potty back, even without water, out of kavod habriyot,17:05 that the kids or the elderly people should not make a mess all around the house.17:11 That is halacha daled. Halacha hei, one more thing regarding graf shel rei, and we're done, I promise you.17:16 That's it. We're not going to go back to this specific halacha.17:20 Halacha tells us that in graf shel rei, I'm not going to read it inside,17:23 in graf shel rei, it's forbidden to create a situation which will cause it to become a graf17:31 shel rei and then afterwards have the heter to do17:34 it. Meaning to say, you can go ahead and, you know, pile up dirt so this way now becomes repulsive to you,17:43 and now you have the heter to bring it and throw it into the garbage.17:46 Remember, graf shel rei, anything that falls in the category of graf17:48 shel rei, it's automatically mutar for you to handle in the normal way.17:52 It's not muktzeh. The halachot muktzeh are removed, pushed to the side to allow you to remove graf17:59 shel rei. Right? Now, when over here, to create a situation which is going to be a grama shedei, that is asur.18:07 So the Gemara talks about, for example, a person piling up dirt,18:11 or if a person is sitting down next to a drip to create a18:15 grama shedei, all different types of cases the Gemara brings down about the issur of creating18:20 grama shedei. Rav Nissim Karelitz, shlita, in Chut Shani, he explains that this is only talking about things that are not done on a regular basis.18:30 Meaning to say, if a person is doing something absolutely normal, which is eating,18:35 and as a result of eating he's having, you know, shells and pits,18:40 and he has peels and all these different things, that when they pile up, they will be disgusting,18:46 that's not an issur of creating grama shedei. You don't have to actually peel. For example,18:50 let's give you an example. Eggshell. If a person is, you know, shelling an egg,18:55 so a few pieces are not a big deal, but when you keep on shelling an egg, what's going to happen?18:59 The pieces that pile up is going to be disgusting. It's all dirty and doesn't look good.19:04 So do you have to remove the eggshells and directly throw it into the garbage?19:08 Because if you keep it next to you, it's going to pile up, it's going to look disgusting.19:11 Then afterwards, in order to clean it up, you have to pick it up with your hands.19:15 So you just told me I cannot create a situation of19:18 grama shedei. So Rav Nissim Karelitz explains this is only talking about when a person is creating something that is not normally done,19:28 meaning eating, which is a person normally eats,19:31 and therefore when you're eating and the way you eat is by shelling and putting the shells right next to you,19:35 so even though it's going to create a grama shedei, it's not the issur that the Chachamim were talking about.19:43 Oh, you're gonna ask me, the Gemara brings a case of19:47 Rabba She. Rabba She in those days, okay, not nowadays, not19:50 to be confused with our nowadays. He was eating what seemed to be olives, and then he would spit out the pits behind him.19:57 The Gemara says why he didn't want to pile up pits in front of him,20:00 because if he piles up pits in front of him, it'll become disgusting,20:02 and eventually when he cleans up, what's he gonna do?20:05 He's gonna pick it up with his hands, and20:07 it's gonna be muktzah because graf shel rei. Yeah, but who told you to create graf shel rei from the beginning?20:11 So therefore he decided to spit it behind him.20:13 Poskim bring down that that story of Rabba She was20:17 a chumra. Rabba She was20:18 machmir. Also, such a thing that a person has to spit it behind him, it's not applicable today.20:23 It's not like those days, you know, yeah, the guy would actually chuck things behind him and it wouldn't be a big deal.20:27 The rabbi who had, he would spit behind him, it's not a big deal that things should pile up over there.20:32 And nowadays, if it's not a graf shel rei in front of you on the table, it's a graf shel rei behind the couch.20:37 Besides the fact that there's bugs and everything, so it doesn't make a difference either way.20:41 No, you do not have to eat your cherries and spit out the pits in the garbage directly.20:46 No, you do not have to go out of your way to throw out the peels so you shouldn't avoid creating graf20:53 shel rei. Says Rav Nissim Karelitz, if you're eating in a normal fashion and as a result a graf shel rei is created,20:58 it's not the issur of creating graf21:00 shel rei. And in all cases, even if a person has created a graf shel rei which is21:08 asur according to all opinions, even in such a situation, everybody permits it to be picked up afterwards and to be thrown out.21:16 So now, here's a common case which usually happens.21:19 You have, let's say, seven people eating on the Shabbat table.21:23 Yeah, you know, seven is the number of Shabbat, that's why I picked seven.21:25 Okay, so you have seven people eating on the Shabbat table.21:30 They're done.21:31 So the plates have to be picked up, right?21:33 You ever see how the ladies pick up the plates, or even the guys pick up the plates?21:36 This does not mean that only ladies pick up the plates.21:38 Even men, it's a mitzvah that they should pick up the plates.21:40 In my house, I also get up and I pick up the plates.21:42 I'm proud to say that.21:44 It does not take away from your manhood.21:46 Men, listen up.21:47 Ladies, you can tell your men to listen to the halacha hour and they'll learn a little bit.21:50 Anyway, so now you ever see how people clean up the Shabbat table, the plates?21:56 You have leftovers on each guy's plate,21:59 so it's a big tircha now.22:01 It's a big burden.22:03 Pick up one plate at a time and take it to the kitchen.22:04 So what do they do to make it easier for themselves?22:06 They take all the plates,22:09 they pile up all the leftovers on one plate,22:12 and then they stack up the plates22:14 and they put that plate on top of22:16 them and they carry it over to the kitchen to be thrown out.22:19 Question is, is it mutar to do such a thing?22:23 Because what am I doing?22:24 I'm creating a disgusting situation.22:26 I'm picking up all the leftovers from each person's plate22:29 and I'm piling it up,22:30 and now I'm creating something what seems to be a graf22:33 shel rei, when I could easily avoid it by just picking up each plate and going to the kitchen with it.22:37 Why should I make a whole big pile?22:40 And especially that the heter of graf shel rei is that once I have to get rid of it,22:45 I have to, you know, it's not a clear heter.22:46 I have to try to get rid of it as soon as I can.22:50 Why should I increase over here the graf22:53 shel rei pile up, pick it up first of all,22:55 and then pile it up somewhere else,22:56 and then pick it up from there and throw it out again?22:59 So again, Rav Nissim Karelitz comes and answers,23:01 and he says that is fine to do.23:04 You don't have to be23:05 machmir and you have to pick up each plate and take it to the kitchen,23:09 because either way you're picking up the same amount of23:12 muktzeh. So if you, like, pause for a second to pile it all up23:15 just to make it easier for you to carry,23:17 it is not a problem to do so on Shabbat.23:21 Even, again, to pile up all the leftovers on one plate23:25 and to carry it all together to the kitchen on one plate,23:28 it's mutar to be done.23:31 Now, there is a23:35 midat chasidut. Up to now we spoke about23:40 din, halacha. Midat chasidut? Yes, there is such a concept.23:41 Don't think that it's nothing.23:42 If a person wants to be23:44 machmir. I got a guy who, he said,23:47 Rabbi, can I text you for halacha questions?23:49 I said, Yeah, no problem.23:50 A lot of people text me.23:51 So he said, How do you answer people?23:53 I said, Listen, it's a quick yes, no, maybe.23:55 You know, I don't have time to sit and explain.23:57 You want to sit and explain,23:58 you got to sit down with me and I got to—24:00 I don't have time. Yes, no, quickly.24:02 Mutar, asur.24:03 So he says, do me a favor then.24:05 When I text you, give me the most stringent opinion.24:08 So there are people out there that love to do24:12 chumrot, and ashechem Yisrael. And like we said before, just make sure the chumrot are your24:14 chumrot; don't throw your chumrot on other people.24:16 In any case, there are people who like to be machmir, and you should know24:19 there is such a concept and there's such an24:22 inyan, and tabo alav berachah for a person who wants to be machmir in this area.24:25 What could you do?24:25 There is such a thing of not even putting in front of you any pits of fruits.24:30 Like we said of ashe, would spit the pits behind him.24:33 So that means there is such a concept: if you want to peel an egg,24:36 or you want to peel seven eggs, to actually peel directly into the garbage pail.24:41 It's much better, 100 percent it's better.24:43 Do you have to? No, you can do it in your normal way.24:46 But is there an24:48 inyan? Ladies, if you're in the kitchen and they're four ladies,24:50 you know, they're schmoozing, they're talking.24:51 One lady is preparing the eggshell and she's cracking the eggs,24:53 and the other one is peeling the fruits and everything else.24:56 And you see one lady going over and she's cutting up the oranges24:59 and she's putting the peels directly into the garbage.25:02 Don't look at her as a25:03 meshugana. No, she's not25:05 a— no, she's doing25:07 lechatchilah. She's doing25:09 lefi kol hade'ot. There is a25:10 midat chassidut. It's definitely praiseworthy to do such a thing.25:14 Okay, we will stop over here when it comes to the subject of graf25:17 shel rei. We'll move on now to the next halachah in the Ben Ish Chai, in Halachah Vav.25:25 Halachah Vav might seem to be a very insignificant25:29 halachah because it doesn't apply in our days, as you'll see in a second.25:32 But you should know there are a lot of halachot that will come out of this.25:36 Let's begin.25:39 Halachah Vav says—it's a Shulchan Aruch really25:42 mefurash—it says about a person... Let's just give you a background a little bit.25:46 In those days, in their days, we didn't have, you know, you walk into anybody's house today,25:51 you have three types of floors:25:52 either it's marble, either it's wood, you want to call it parquet,25:56 whatever you want to call it, or it is carpet, pretty much.26:00 Yeah, some combinations, of course, but pretty much that's what it is.26:03 It's either tiles, you want to call it marble, you want to put plastic,26:06 whatever it is,26:07 it's either tiles, it's either wood, or it's carpet.26:11 In those days, in olden days, it was very rare to find houses26:15 which were tiles.26:19 You see, most houses were not tiled, were not marble,26:23 and certainly not wood or anything else, definitely not carpet,26:26 but they actually had dirt.26:28 The floor was dirt, kind of like your backyard, right,26:31 when you have grass and dirt. Maybe it didn't have grass,26:33 but they have dirt all over.26:35 So now, a lot of times when there's waste, it's very hard to clean it.26:39 There's a whole Shulchan Aruch on how to clean those type of floors,26:43 if you can, on Shabbat.26:44 In any case, a person sometimes will have dirt and everything else,26:47 so instead of cleaning it, you do what the little kids do26:51 today when they make a mess, right?26:53 I remember, how do we clean up our rooms when we were younger?26:56 We were told, you know, make sure your bedroom is clean.26:58 So of course, we took our pajamas. Instead of folding it,26:59 we just tucked it under the bed.27:01 We had a problem, we tucked it under the mattress.27:03 We had a bigger problem, we tucked it under the bed.27:05 As long as you don't see.27:06 Well, you don't see, it doesn't hurt you.27:07 We kind of lived that way as little children, cleaning up our27:10 rooms. And Baruch Hashem,27:13 minhag avoteinu beyadeinu, our kids follow the same thing.27:15 I tell my kids, clean up your rooms,27:16 and sometimes you see, you know,27:19 you didn't really clean up, you just tucked it,27:20 you threw it into the closet, you threw it under.27:22 So in those days, if they had some dirt,27:24 dirt meaning to say waste,27:26 let's say somebody threw up, or let's say somebody,27:28 the kids, you know, who were being potty trained had an accident,27:31 so what they would do is they would actually have27:34 a pile of dirt that they would use to cover up those things.27:38 I don't know if it was temporary or it27:40 was permanent, but that's what they would do.27:42 So halacha tells us in those days,27:43 a person is bringing now dirt27:46 as a side point—not a side point, but this is a27:48 halacha—dirt, what's the status of dirt on Shabbat27:50 as far as muktzeh is concerned?27:51 Where would it fall in?27:52 Kli shemelachto l'heter, l'isur? What is it?27:55 And the answer is, dirt is27:59 muktzeh machmat gufo; it has no purpose, it has no use by itself.28:01 So in those days, they would take dirt28:04 and they want to use it on Shabbat.28:06 You can't just use dirt on Shabbat; you have to designate it.28:08 You have to take it before Shabbat28:11 and put it in a certain spot28:12 or pile it up in a certain corner of the house28:14 with the kavanah that you want to use it28:17 for whatever you want to use it on Shabbat,28:19 and then it will be mutar.28:20 Then what happens is what we were learning about28:23 in the last few weeks, and that is28:25 you transform the28:28 muktzeh machmat gufo into28:30 a kli shemelachto l'heter. Why? Because you did it before Shabbat,28:33 and now it's not dirt anymore.28:34 Now it's used as a cover,28:36 and that's mutar to be done on28:40 Shabbat—excuse me, that's mutar to be done for Shabbat28:43 if it's done before Shabbat.28:46 Now, there's a question.28:48 We have dirt in our houses.28:50 You know where?28:51 Not only outside in the backyard.28:54 Anyways, that's for sure;28:56 nobody's using it for anything,28:57 and there's nothing I could think of28:59 that you would want to use it on Shabbat.29:01 But you know where we have dirt?29:02 We have29:03 flower pots. You know those flower pots with dirt in it,29:06 especially that the kids bring on29:08 Shavuot. So could you move those flower pots on Shabbat,29:12 or do we say, no, it's dirt, it's29:14 muktzeh, and muktzeh, wherever it's in,29:16 the item that's holding it has the same status.29:19 So that's our question:29:20 could you move a flower pot on Shabbat or not?29:24 So the halacha is as follows.29:26 Let's think about it.29:27 It's a flower pot, right?29:28 What's in it besides dirt?29:29 There's flowers.29:31 What is the purpose of the29:33 flower pot? And the answer is,29:34 it's there for display.29:38 I have flowers on me; it looks good.29:40 It gives a different feeling to the room.29:43 So if I'm using the29:45 dirt—excuse me, if I have the29:46 flower pot, which is there for display,29:49 it's not something that my kids brought in29:50 and it's, you know, just sitting there, just,29:52 Oh wow, it looks beautiful,29:53 and it really doesn't, you29:54 know. It's really there for display and it looks good.29:57 And I'm using it to beautify my30:00 house, so it has a function which is permitted.30:04 It's there for display.30:05 It's no different from your china,30:06 more expensive, but it's no different.30:08 It's there for display,30:09 so it has the status of30:11 kli shemelachto l'heter. So to move a flower pot on Shabbat,30:14 when the flower pot is being used30:17 for decoration or for display,30:19 it's mutar.30:21 However, you must be aware of the following four things.30:26 Number one,30:28 if the dirt falls out of it,30:32 then the dirt is muktzeh machmat gufo,30:36 because the dirt itself30:37 you're not using to beautify your house.30:39 You're not using it for decoration.30:40 So it comes back to being30:42 graf—excuse me—it comes back to being a muktzeh machmat gufo.30:46 Could you pick it up?30:48 Could you clean it?30:49 Yeah. When?30:50 What's a graf30:51 shel rei? So when it's a little bit of dirt,30:53 which is not so bad,30:54 you can't pick it up30:56 with your hand. You may be able to,30:57 you know, with the broom,30:58 you may be able to dust it away with the broom,31:00 but to pick it up with your hands,31:02 you're not allowed to,31:03 unless a significant amount of dirt that fell,31:05 which is clearly disgusting on your floor,31:09 then you can even pick it up with your own bare hands.31:12 Another important halacha,31:13 very, very important halacha.31:14 We're not aware of it so much31:16 because, you know, we don't think that way.31:18 There's an issur d'Oraita of zorea, planting.31:20 Planting includes even to allow anything to grow.31:23 So if you have a31:25 flower pot, poskim bring down,31:26 and it's outdoors,31:29 moving it outdoors,31:30 whether it's moving it from your backyard into your house31:32 or moving around in the backyard,31:35 you are running into problems of31:37 zorea. So therefore, in such cases31:39 where you have a flower pot with real flowers,31:41 with things that are actually real growing from there,31:44 and it's in the place which has dirt,31:46 whether it's your front yard, backyard,31:47 it doesn't make a difference, on your balcony,31:49 you cannot move it.31:51 This can only31:52 move—the flower pots can only be moved31:54 on floors that are tiled.31:57 Carpet, or something, it's not going to be able to nourish31:59 from the ground.32:00 I cannot go into more detail on this. It's too long to explain,32:03 but just keep the halacha in mind.32:05 When the flower pot is outdoors32:07 on a non-cemented or not wood floor, like a dirt floor,32:13 it's asur to move it.32:14 Next,32:16 another thing that you should know32:18 about—it's not really to be aware32:20 of—but this halacha only pertains to,32:22 the issur that means that we just said,32:24 only pertains to real flowers.32:26 If you have fake flowers, that's fine.32:30 They're not growing.32:32 Oh, but there's dirt.32:32 Dirt is part of the look.32:33 It's all part of the same look,32:34 you know,32:36 olam hazeh, hakol hevel. So you have the flower pot with dirt in it,32:39 and it's fake flowers.32:40 It's fine to move it even outdoors.32:43 And one last thing that people should know about:32:47 flowers, we find the halacha tells us,32:50 the32:53 Rama in Siman Shin Lamed Vav, there's an issur to put flowers in water,32:57 according to the32:58 Rama. Although some disagree,33:00 Chacham Ovadia, for example,33:01 brings poskim this way, that way,33:03 and he comes out that33:04 lechatchila, of course,33:05 a person should not put flowers in water.33:09 However, when they're completely open,33:11 although lechatchila you should avoid it,33:13 still, if it's33:15 completely—when the flower, you know,33:16 has completely opened33:18 up—then those who put it in water33:19 have what to rely on.33:21 So therefore, a flower vase33:23 with real flowers and water33:25 is not33:27 muktzeh because it was there from before Shabbat.33:28 And what do we use flowers today33:31 in the vase for?33:33 For decorating the house,33:35 to make the house look better,33:36 so it's33:37 a kli shemelachto leheter. A flower vase with33:39 flowers could be moved on Shabbat.33:40 A flower33:42 vase—excuse me, a flower bouquet,33:45 or whatever it is,33:46 anything that's being used for decoration,33:49 it's mutar inside the house, like we said.33:54 Okay.33:56 Now that we spoke about dirt,33:58 in the olden days,33:59 you have to know in order to understand the next halacha,34:01 or understand what's in the connection,34:04 besides dirt, they would also have34:06 other things that they use to cover up the floor,34:08 and that is sand.34:10 Sand, you know, the ones that you see on the beach?34:12 Yeah, the same one they would take34:13 and they'd use it to cover up the floor.34:15 So now, sand is really34:17 muktzeh machmat gufo; it has no purpose in itself.34:19 But since before Shabbat34:20 you're using it in order to cover up the dirt in the house,34:24 or you designated that in case there is dirt,34:26 you'll use it to cover up the dirt,34:28 then34:30 it has a din of34:33 kli she'melachto l'heter. So that brings us to the following question:34:36 Could a person use a sandbox on Shabbat?34:39 Is a sandbox,34:42 sandbox mutar on Shabbat34:44 because it's34:46 a kli she'melachto l'heter, or is it not?34:48 Maybe it's sand; it cannot be used.34:50 So now, before I come to, you know,34:53 get to the halacha, let me explain what a sandbox is.34:56 It's a box, usually made out of plastic.34:59 If you're עשיר, you make it out of something more sturdy,35:01 or you buy it that way.35:03 And inside of it, there's a lot of sand.35:05 It's not a beach, but it's a lot of sand,35:07 and the kids use it for all different types of playing.35:10 They make castles out of it.35:11 They make all different types of things.35:13 Some just like the whole feeling of it,35:15 that you sit in and you feel like you're cool,35:17 you're on the beach or whatever.35:18 It's 40 degrees outside, but still,35:19 you know, they like playing with it.35:22 So what's the35:24 halacha? Is it mutar or not?35:26 So there's actually a machloket on this35:29 amongst the two big Ashkenazi poskim.35:32 Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchata brings down the following words.35:36 I'm saying it exactly in his words,35:38 and then we'll understand what he means.35:40 He says,35:48 אין למחות בילדים המשחקים בחול הדק והיבש שהוכן לצורך זה מבעוד יום. That's all he says.35:50 You do not have to stop the children who play in sand,35:54 which is dry and it's very fine,35:57 that was prepared from before Shabbat for this purpose.36:01 From the words of the Shemirat Shabbat36:03 Kehilchata, I quoted in Hebrew on purpose,36:05 so we should understand36:07 that—oh, you know, I don't want to say,36:09 Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchata is matir.36:10 No, no, he doesn't say that.36:12 Listen to the words again:36:14 Ein limchot b'yeladim. We learn three things, the way he worded his36:18 halacha. Number one is that36:22 it was huchan l'tzorech zeh me'od yom. It was something that was prepared for this purpose,36:24 of playing with it, from before Shabbat.36:26 And therefore, if you bought a sandbox,36:28 obviously you wanted to use it for,36:30 you know, you want to use it for a game, obviously.36:32 Nobody buys a sandbox for that purpose.36:37 As opposed to sand on the beach.36:40 Sand on the beach is not prepared for that purpose.36:42 People play with it, but sand on the beach is there,36:44 whatever the government decided to put it there.36:46 So if you're going to the36:48 beach—of course kosher beach,36:49 I'm not talking about the other ones,36:50 that's36:51 not—you're going to a kosher beach,36:52 nobody's there where you have no forbidden looks.36:54 In any case, you're going to the beach,36:56 sand is36:57 muktzeh. Does that mean you can't walk on sand?36:59 Sand is muktzeh means you can't pick up sand,37:01 you can't play with sand on Shabbat,37:04 even children, even children.37:07 Why? Because you have a37:08 chiyuv to train your children in37:10 halachot, right? If your children pick up a phone on Shabbat,37:13 you tell them,37:13 Ah,37:16 Shabbos, put down the phone.37:16 So same thing, they pick up sand.37:18 We're not talking about babies,37:19 we're talking about kids that understand.37:20 So you got to tell them it's37:22 muktzeh, like anything else that you teach them.37:23 It's halacha, it's asur.37:25 So you got to keep that in mind.37:26 Number two,37:29 the words from the words of the37:31 Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchata, when he says,37:34 Ein limchot, it doesn't sound like it's37:35 lechatchila. It doesn't sound like it's the best thing.37:37 It's as if you see kids playing in the sandbox37:39 in your backyard, fine,37:41 right?37:42 As opposed to the beach where you have to stop them.37:43 Over here in your backyard,37:44 listen, it's made for a toy.37:46 Yes,37:46 it's fine.37:48 Also, it says37:50 b'yeladim. Adults can't sit there and play together with the kids,37:53 because really— Why would it be a problem?37:56 Why would it be a problem?37:56 Because the Chutani explains that really,37:59 it's not a38:01 heter to a sandbox is38:02 mutar. According to Chutani, he disagrees. He holds it's asur.38:05 Why does he hold it's asur?38:06 Because what do you do with sand?38:08 Talking about the toy sand,38:09 what do you do with it?38:09 You build with it.38:10 How do you build with it?38:12 You put water,38:13 mix it with water,38:13 you form it,38:14 you make a castle out of it.38:16 Sand by itself doesn't do anything.38:18 So therefore, since the main function of38:20 sand is really something that's asur on Shabbat,38:21 which is what?38:22 When you combine water with sand,38:25 that is a problem of38:27 lash. Lash is kneading.38:30 Kneading is not only limited to flour and water,38:33 which is how you make dough.38:35 Lash is also anything that mixes together38:38 and makes many different units into one.38:41 That's also lash.38:42 Over here, you take water,38:43 you pour it on top of the sand,38:45 and what happens?38:46 It mixes all together.38:47 Now, of course it's asur to do that on Shabbat.38:49 It's asur to put water.38:50 But the Rav Nissim Karelitz explains38:52 that since the main function of a sandbox38:54 is for the purpose of forming things,38:58 so therefore a sandbox becomes asur,39:01 even on Shabbat, even for children,39:03 and he is oser it.39:05 So those who have a39:06 sandbox and their kids are playing with it,39:07 if they're very, very young,39:09 anyway they're too young,39:10 you don't have to, you know, under five,39:11 and that's fine.39:12 Anyway,39:13 you don't have the chiyuv to train them.39:14 But if they're a little bit older,39:17 lechatchila, it's not the best thing.39:18 If you can find something else for them to do, fine.39:20 If you can't, really, really can't find39:21 something else for them to do on Shabbat,39:24 yesh al ma lismoch. You don't have to stop the children on their own,39:27 but of course for the sand39:29 or the sandbox to be handled by an adult,39:32 that is asur.39:35 That seems to be39:39 lechol hade'ot. Now we're talking about playing in sandbox.39:41 We're going to a very, very touchy subject.39:44 And that is the subject of balls and toys on Shabbat.39:49 What is the39:51 din? Let's begin very, very simple,39:53 and we'll try to clarify as much as we can.39:56 I hope we have enough time.39:59 Begin.40:00 With the words of Shulchan Aruch in Siman Shin Chet, Halacha40:05 Mem-Heh. Listen to the words of Shulchan Aruch. He writes like this, very simple:40:08 Asur lesachek b'Shabbat v'Yom Tov b'kadur. That's all he tells us.40:12 It's forbidden to play on Shabbat and Yom Tov with a ball.40:15 Comes the Rama and says,40:17 V'yesh matirin v'nahagu l'hakel. But there are those who permit it,40:21 and the minhag, nahagu, people have accustomed themselves40:25 to be lenient to play with a ball on Shabbat and Yom40:29 Tov. Now, most people understand, and that's the way we grew up,40:33 it's40:35 a machloket Sefardim and Ashkenazim. The Sefardim are looking on to how the Ashkenazim are playing ball on Shabbat,40:38 and the Sefardi children are saying,40:41 Ah, I wish I could be Ashkenazi just for that.40:43 Wait, Pesach's coming around. Maybe it's not worth it.40:45 Anyway, but that's not what most people understand.40:48 It's40:49 machloket Ashkenazim, Sefardim. According to the Ashkenazim, you can play ball on Shabbat.40:52 According to Sefardim, it's asur to play ball on Shabbat.40:55 The question is why? What's going on?40:57 Why is Maran oser? Why is Maran forbid playing ball on Shabbat,41:02 and why is the Rama matir?41:04 And also, is this an issur across the board?41:09 Can we find an exception even according to41:12 the Sefardim? And also, when the Rama is matir, is this something also that he's matir in all times?41:16 That's what we're going to delve into.41:19 Maran is oser, like we just said,41:22 asur lesachek. He doesn't tell us the reason, Shulchan Aruch, but in Beit Yosef,41:24 he quotes one of the Rishonim known as Shibolei HaLeket,41:30 who quotes from his brother, and he brings down the words41:32 and he says two reasons why ball is asur on Shabbat.41:36 Number one is the balls are dirty and disgusting.41:40 They're always in the mud, and therefore41:42 it doesn't have any sort of function, doesn't have any sort of use.41:45 You can't use it back in the olden days, right?41:49 They didn't have covers for pots, or maybe they did,41:52 but the covers break. So like we said,41:55 there were— They would use anything, you know, to41:58 make—there was no such thing as broken items.41:59 Broken items were transformed into something else.42:02 So he says, you can't even use the bowl to cover up your pot.42:05 You can't use it to cover up things because it's disgusting,42:08 so it has no function at all, and that's why it's42:11 muktzeh. That's one reason that he brings.42:13 Another reason, which most people neglect42:15 and they don't look at that reason,42:17 Beit Yosef tells us a second reason why bowls are42:21 asur. He says, you know why?42:22 There's a midrash in42:24 Eicha, and midrash is found in other places as well.42:26 It says there was a place in Eretz Yisrael known as Tur Shimon,42:30 and it was destroyed.42:31 The midrash says, why did it get destroyed?42:34 Do you think because of zenut?42:35 Nah, it wasn't because of zenut, says the midrash.42:38 You know why Tur Shimon, the mountain of Shimon,42:40 got destroyed, says the midrash?42:43 Amazing. Look what the line the midrash says:42:45 because they played ball on Shabbat.42:48 And this is found also in Yerushalmi, the same midrash.42:52 So therefore, what seems to be from the Beit Yosef,42:54 you have two reasons to be42:56 oser, two reasons why a ball is forbidden on Shabbat.42:58 Number one is it's disgusting; it cannot be used for anything.43:02 Number two is because that's how Tur Shimon was destroyed.43:07 It was due to ball playing on Shabbat.43:10 The Rama—where's the Rama coming from?43:11 And the answer is the Rama, who follows Tosafot,43:14 he goes with the opinion of Tosafot,43:16 who allow the carrying of a ball on Yom Tov in the street.43:22 That's fine; you can even carry on Yom Tov.43:24 There was a discussion over there in the Gemara:43:26 is it mutar to take a child into the street, to carry him?43:31 Was it, you know, for the sake of a mitzvah, to take him for a43:34 milah? And Tosafot says, no, you can even carry him,43:36 even just to walk around.43:38 If you want to stroll around on Yom Tov,43:40 when there's no problem of carrying in the street with your child,43:43 it's mutar, just like balls also, we carry them in the street.43:46 So it seems like from the Tosafot that balls are permitted on Shabbat,43:49 and that's the opinion of the Rama.43:51 He says especially43:53 people are meikel, people lean it already like the opinion of the Tosafot.43:57 So this is the reasons why it's asur and44:00 mutar. So it comes out that the only reason why bowls are asur44:03 is only according to the44:07 Sefaradim, only according to Maran, not the Rama.44:10 So now we want to know,44:11 within the opinion of Maran,44:13 what would you say to bowls in our days?44:16 Today, our bowls are very clean.44:19 You look at the bowls, a soccer ball,44:20 things, although they play with it, but in general it's pretty clean,44:22 especially when it comes fresh from Walmart or whatever sports stores, right?44:28 And you look at the bowl, it's fresh, it's clean,44:31 especially, let's say, bowls that are used indoors,44:33 like a ping pong ball, right?44:35 They're not dirty,44:36 and not only they're not dirty, they're made for the sake of playing.44:40 Would the halacha change?44:42 Would the status of bowls change?44:43 Would Maran say in our days bowls are fine, they're not44:47 mukseh? And the answer to that is, you guessed it,44:53 machloket. It's a machloket between the44:55 Acharonim. It's not a Sefardi-Ashkenazi thing.44:57 The question right now is, what would Maran say,45:01 based on the reasons that Maran has given us,45:03 what would he say about bowls in our days that are clean?45:06 So you have on the side, on the people who are matir,45:10 I'm going to tell you first their opinions, and I'm going to tell you their reasons.45:13 The side that's matir, that say that even Shulchan Aruch would agree in our days,45:18 it's Sefaradim, even then bowls should not be mukseh in our days45:21 because they are clean and they could technically be used for covers.45:25 Ashmiat Shabalkirchata in the name of Rav Shlomo Zalman Orbach,45:28 Shibut Yitzchak in the name of45:30 Eliyashiv, Shevet HaLevi brings it down himself,45:33 and Hacham Ovadia and Chazon Ovadia quotes the Shibut Yitzchak in the name of45:39 Eliyashiv. He just quotes it, which seems like from the style of—45:44 Chacham Ovadia, if he's quoting it, sounds like he's going with it.45:46 Those are people who are matir.45:48 The people who are oser, people who still hold it's forbidden,45:52 is the Or Letzion, Chacham Ben Tzion45:55 Abba Shaul, Rav Moshe Levin,45:57 Menuchat Ahava, the Chut Shani of45:59 Nissim Karelitz, and it seems to be also from the hagahot of the Ish46:03 Matzliach that he is also46:04 oser. So the question is, why is there machloket nowadays as well?46:08 So the ones who permit it hold46:10 that since they're factory-made for that purpose,46:12 the balls in their days were like, you know, when we were younger,46:15 we used to play with the pits of the fruits.46:17 We used to use it for46:18 balls. It wasn't made to be a ball; we had to make it into a46:21 ball. And because the dusting was all over the dirt,46:23 in our days that they make balls specifically for this46:27 and they're much cleaner,46:29 technically you use it as a cover, right?46:31 So it's fine. Balls are not46:32 muktzeh. However, the ones who are oser, they say, one second,46:35 hold on a second.46:36 You're only looking at one reason why Maran was46:41 oser the balls, because they were disgusting.46:43 Read the second reason.46:44 What's the second reason?46:45 Chacham Ben Tzion says46:46 there's another reason why Maran was46:48 oser. What is that?46:49 Tur Shulchan was destroyed because of46:51 balls. Sounds like Maran holds that46:54 even if it's clean, it's going to be asur.46:56 Why?46:58 Because it caused the Tur Shulchan, caused a big city to be destroyed on Shabbat.47:02 Must be there's a chumrah, there's a severity47:04 with playing ball on Shabbat,47:05 and therefore, since you can't play ball on Shabbat,47:07 it's going to become47:10 muktzeh. More than that,47:11 if you look into the source of Maran's words,47:14 which the Menuchat Ahava does,47:16 and that is Shibolei HaLeket.47:17 I want to read to you the words of Shibolei HaLeket.47:19 Shibolei HaLeket says like this.47:22 He says, my brother Rabbi Yehuda explains47:25 that the47:29 balls, אבל אלו הכדורים שלנו, our47:33 balls, אפילו כלי לא חשיבי. It's not even called a kli.47:35 It's not called as a function.47:37 Why?47:38 He says,47:44 Machshevet ha-sichok shechishev lesachek bo lo mashvi lei kli. The fact that you thought about playing with it47:47 doesn't make it into a kli.47:49 So it comes out that47:51 according to the Bolei HaLeke, which is the source47:53 where Maran brings47:55 that it's asur to play balls on Shabbat,47:58 what does he say about balls on Shabbat?48:00 He says balls are asur because playing is not called a function.48:07 Usually we say, What's this used for?48:09 In Muktzeh, we always said you have to look at an item and say, What is it being used for?48:14 To say that a ball is being used to play, playing in itself is not called a function.48:18 That does not turn something halachically into a48:22 kli. You're right, it's a utensil, it's an item that's used,48:25 but to use for playing, for Shabbat, does not turn it into a48:28 kli. In fact, this is exactly what the Magen Avraham and Mishnah Berurah bring down in the words of Maran.48:33 When Maran says,48:35 אסור לשחק בשבת ביום טוב בכדור, you're not allowed to play with a ball on Shabbat, Mishnah Berurah and Magen Avraham explain why.48:40 Because the fact that you want to play with it doesn't make it into a48:45 kli. So, in summary, the reasons why the balls are forbidden even in our days, when they are clean,48:51 it's because they're not considered a48:53 kli. The act of playing is not something that makes an item into a49:00 kli. However, that's because it's playing.49:02 But when an item is made just to keep kids quiet,49:06 let's say you have those small balls, people don't play with49:08 them, but kids use it and when they take it, they get quiet. They're crying or whatever, they get wild.49:13 You give it to little children, very, very little children,49:15 they're not playing with it, but they're just, you know, little babies I'm talking about, toddlers, infants.49:19 So when they have this ball in their hand, that's not called—49:21 that's already like a pacifier.49:24 That's something that you give to the children to be quiet. That kind of ball is fine.49:29 But the balls are made for, let's say, basketball or like baseball,49:32 catching with it or kicking it or all these things,49:36 that form is to play with it. That's not going to be able to make it into a49:41 kli. Okay, so what do you want to tell me now?49:43 According to the people who... According to Shulchan Aruch,49:48 based on the Or LeTzion and the second people that are posek even bols in our days,49:52 I have a question.49:54 To the bowls in their days, we're discussing, you couldn't use it to cover even your pots.49:59 But in our days that the bowls are not disgusting,50:01 why can't we say that we're going to designate it to be used for something permitted on Shabbat,50:06 and therefore we're going to transform it from muktzeh machmat gufo50:10 into kli שמלאכתו לאיסור? For example, I have a netilat yadayim cup, right?50:13 And, you know, the netilah is supposed to cover it,50:15 so I want to use my soccer ball now to cover the water that's in my netilat yadayim cup.50:21 I can do that, no?50:23 So why can't I say I'm going to designate before Shabbat the soccer ball50:26 in order that I should use it to cover my netilat yadayim cup,50:29 and in that case my soccer ball now transforms into a cover,50:33 and it becomes mutar on Shabbat,50:36 and this way the ball will not be50:38 muktzeh. So why are you saying it's50:40 muktzeh? Let it be like any other stone, which when I specify,50:44 okay, I designate it for a case that's going to be mutar,50:47 it's going to remain mutar.50:48 I'm not talking about that you designate it for playing. Playing,50:50 okay, I understand you.50:52 Playing, you're telling me it's not good enough to qualify50:55 as a kli, but I'm going to designate it for a cover.50:57 And the answer is, we also learn in order for you to transform something that's muktzeh machmat gufo51:01 into51:03 kli שמלאכתו לאיסור, it depends if it's commonly used that way or not.51:06 If it's not commonly used that way,51:08 and now you want to transform it that way,51:09 you have to be51:11 meyached it le'olam. You have to give it a permanent designation.51:13 So if you want to say that your soccer ball will not be as a cover to your netilat yadayim cup,51:18 you have to make the soccer ball into a netilat yadayim cup cover forever.51:24 It doesn't work that it's going to be just done for the Shabbat.51:27 If you want to do it forever, fine,51:30 but in that case the soccer ball must always be used as a cover.51:33 You cannot use it for a cover one Shabbat and then go back to using it as a soccer ball during the week.51:38 So therefore, really, it doesn't solve much in your designation,51:43 because why would somebody want to buy a soccer ball to use as a cover,51:46 and then it's going to remain as a cover?51:48 So obviously, it's ridiculous. It's not going to51:51 work. And therefore, we come back and we remain that the soccer ball would still be,51:55 or other balls would remain muktzeh according to those who are forbidden.52:00 Are they matirim? Of course there are52:01 matirim. Regarding those who are52:03 matirim, we have a lot to say,52:05 and we don't have the time to say it because we're running out of time.52:10 We have only a minute or two left.52:13 Mazal Hashem. Next class, we will discuss the balls again.52:18 We'll review what we just said,52:19 and then, mazal Hashem, we'll elaborate on those who are matir balls because of muktzeh on Shabbat.52:26 We'll elaborate what their true intention means,52:29 of course quoting books and everything else.52:31 And till then, we'll see you next week.52:33 If anybody has a question and you would like to call into the station,52:36 you could call in now off the air at52:41 718-683-5858. The text in your question or comment is52:45 347-927-8398. This class will be aired on again tonight at52:50 10 p.m. We want to give a thank you to Iran, Rav Nissim, and the whole JRoot Radio staff52:55 for your great work.52:57 Continue it, and Hashem should bless everybody.52:59 Have a wonderful week.53:00 Shabbat shalom.53:01 We'll see you next week,53:02 mazal Hashem,53:03 Wednesday afternoon here on Halacha Hour on JRoot Radio.