Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio,0:04 live on Wednesday afternoon.0:06 I believe0:07 today—no, I believe it is the 10th of0:09 Shevat, Tav Shin Ayin Vav,0:11 and we are here0:14 filming and airing0:15 on live. So if you'd like to watch us0:17 also, you can go on0:19 jrootradio.com, where over there you have the video0:21 to watch this live.0:23 And of course, you have the archives0:25 after this, so you can always go back0:27 to jrootradio.com and you can watch0:29 the videos of this class0:31 and all the other classes0:33 on here that are aired on0:36 jrootradio.com. Quick,0:37 just one phone number.0:38 If you'd like to text in a question0:41 or0:42 comment, the text-in number to text in0:44 the number is0:47 347-927-8398. We'll give you the number to call in0:49 after the class if you have a question0:51 regarding the subject today.0:53 The subject that we're discussing today,0:57 we're still in the Halachot of Muktzeh, and we usually work off the0:59 Ben Ish Chai. The subject today1:01 is the subject of toys,1:04 playing with1:06 ball,1:07 basketball, all the different types of sports,1:09 and what's their status1:12 as far as Muktzeh is concerned,1:13 and other things.1:15 We spoke about it, I know, last week a little bit,1:17 but because of the time we didn't have the chance1:19 to really elaborate.1:20 But, Hashem, today we hope to elaborate on it,1:22 and we'll also speak about pets,1:25 animals, and all the other goodies,1:26 b'ezrat Hashem, in1:29 the Halachot of Muktzeh. If we have time,1:30 no promise or anything, but if we do have time,1:33 b'ezrat Hashem,1:34 we would like to also maybe1:37 bring in a few Halachot1:39 of Berachot.1:40 As you know, next Sunday night1:42 is Tu1:44 B'Shvat, the 15th of Shevat. We don't say1:46 Ana, we don't say Tachanun on Monday,1:48 and even on Sunday afternoon Mincha.1:51 But besides that, the Gemara tells us,1:52 the Mishnah says in Rosh1:54 Hashanah that Tu B'Shvat is1:56 Chag Ha'Ilan. It's the holiday of the ilan,1:58 and we hold like Beit Hillel on the 15th of2:01 Shevat. That's when it's really Rosh2:04 Hashanah of all the trees,2:05 not the Chag, but the Rosh2:06 Hashanah, the song, I believe, is2:08 Chag Ha'Ilanot. Okay, let's get back to our subject.2:10 Our subject is2:12 toys and balls specifically.2:14 So let's begin from the beginning, from the source.2:16 We'll begin from the Shulchan Aruch2:18 in siman Shin Chet,2:22 se'if mem-hei. Over there, the Shulchan Aruch2:23 writes the following words.2:25 I'll read and then translate.2:27 Asur lesachek beShabbat v'Yom Tov2:29 bekadur. It is forbidden to play2:31 on Shabbat and Yom Tov with a ball.2:34 Now, you can't tell me2:35 Maran over here2:37 means—no, it just means you can't play, but it doesn't mean it's2:39 muktzeh. You can't say that, because Shin Chet2:42 is the siman that deals2:43 with the halachot of2:46 muktzeh. So why is Maran2:47 bringing it here? Clearly2:48 it's—and anyway, if you look in the Beit Yosef, you'll see clearly that's what he holds.2:51 That's the way everybody explains2:53 him. Maran holds balls2:55 on Shabbat and Yom Tov2:58 are forbidden.2:59 Rama comes in and3:01 says, Vyesh matirin, there are those who3:03 permit it, vנהגו להקל, and they were3:05 noheg to be lenient.3:08 So it seems like3:09 over here, a classic3:11 machloket between the Shulchan Aruch and the3:13 Rama. Or as it would be3:15 translated more, it would be3:17 a machloket between the Sefardim and the Ashkenazim.3:19 According to Maran,3:21 whom the Sefardim follow,3:23 it is forbidden to play3:25 with a ball on Shabbat, and therefore3:27 it's muktzeh. According to the3:43 Rama, no, נהגו להקל, the minhag is to be lenient. The balls are therefore not muktzeh. We want to understand now why. Why is there a machloket? Why does the Shulchan Aruch hold what he holds, and why does the Rama hold what he holds? So if you look in Maran, you really3:45 need to understand the reasons of Maran, you have to go back3:47 to the source. Where's the source?3:50 All of the words of the Shulchan Aruch,3:51 if you want to know what the reasons are,3:53 you have to go back to the Beit Yosef.3:55 In the Beit Yosef, Maran brings3:57 the opinion of one of the Rishonim4:00 known as the Shibolei HaLeket.4:02 In the sefer Shibolei HaLeket,4:03 he writes over there that the balls4:06 are disgusting and dirty,4:07 and therefore they're not even4:09 ra'ui. They can't even be used for anything4:12 else. You can't even use them4:14 to cover your pots and your dishes with.4:15 They're all so dirty, they're full of mud.4:18 So usually4:19 the classic rule is—4:21 Something, as long as it has some sort of function,4:24 then we could4:25 use it for that function,4:27 although that's not its main function.4:29 Lemashal, we saw by a4:31 hammer. A hammer is not made for something to be4:34 done on Shabbat. A hammer is made4:36 to nail in4:38 nails into the wall. That's what a4:39 hammer is made for, building. Building is asur on Shabbat.4:42 However, being that I could4:44 use the hammer to crack a4:46 coconut, to crack walnuts, so then4:48 I could use it for something that's mutar,4:50 so it doesn't become 100%4:52 fully muktzeh. As opposed to4:53 now over here, the Shvut HaLeket says balls,4:55 the very dirty, disgusting—what are you going to use it for?4:57 To cover your pot with it? What are you going to use it for?4:59 You can't. It's disgusting. You won't use it.5:01 That's one reason that's brought5:04 down in Shvut HaLeket. Shvut HaLeket quotes5:05 a Midrash, which is also found5:08 in Yerushalmi, which we'll talk about5:10 more at length later on.5:11 The Midrash says that there was an area5:14 in5:15 Yerushalayim, in Eretz Yisrael,5:17 known as Tur Shimon,5:19 which is probably the heart of Shimon, whatever it5:22 was. So that area was destroyed.5:24 Says the Midrash, why was it destroyed?5:26 Do you think it was5:28 destroyed because of zenut,5:30 of adultery,5:32 because of kind of things like that?5:33 No. The Midrash says there was5:36 one girl, and they kicked her out of the place.5:37 So they were very5:40 careful in zenut. So why was it destroyed? Says the5:42 Midrash, you know why? Because5:44 they played with5:46 ball on Shabbat. So from these two5:48 reasons in the Beit Yosef,5:50 Maran rules in his Shulchan Aruch5:52 that balls are5:54 forbidden. You're not allowed to play with ball on Shabbat5:55 and Yom Tov. Two reasons.6:00 Rama, his reason for permitting6:02 balls on Shabbat, you look also6:04 in the Beit Yosef. The Beit Yosef also quotes6:06 the opinion of the Tosafot.6:09 Tosafot sounds6:10 like they're saying that6:12 it's mutar. Over there,6:14 the subject is not, you know, for our6:16 discussion. It's a bigger subject than our discussion.6:17 Over there, it's talking about carrying a child6:21 on Yom Tov.6:22 Is it only permitted to6:24 carry the child on Yom Tov6:25 for the sake of a mitzvah? You want to take him for a6:27 brit milah. How can you take a baby out also for a stroll?6:30 Over there, Tosafot says, Yeah, of course you can6:32 take a baby out for a stroll, just like they take out6:34 bulls. It's like the bulls they take them out6:36 in the6:37 shut harabim, and now you can't tell me a bull is taken out for a mitzvah,6:40 so therefore it's6:41 fine to take out the baby. That's the words of Tosafot.6:44 You understand from the words of6:45 Tosafot that they were taking out,6:47 they had whatever bulls they had back then, they were taking them out6:50 in reshut harabim on Yom Tov.6:51 And we know when it comes to the laws of6:54 muktzeh, Yom Tov is not6:56 any less stringent in6:57 muktzeh than Shabbat is. In some areas, Yom Tov is6:59 even more strict.7:01 It's even more strict in muktzeh than7:03 Shabbat. So therefore, if something is not muktzeh for Yom Tov,7:06 it's not going to be muktzeh for Shabbat7:08 either. So that's the opinion of7:10 Tosafot, and the Rama says,7:11 nahagu, and7:13 the minhag was already to be lenient7:16 to,7:17 it says, yesh matirin, to,7:19 I guess, to play or to have a7:22 ball on Shabbat, to move it. It's not considered7:24 muktzeh. So the question7:25 that everybody wants to7:27 know—one second, one second, hold7:29 on—this is a7:31 ball that Maran is7:35 oser. That's only in their days, not in our days.7:37 That's usually the classic7:39 defense, right? In their days,7:41 the ball, as Maran himself7:43 quotes in Shulchan Aruch, it was disgusting, full of mud.7:45 In our days, the balls,7:47 they're made for such a thing. They're7:48 clean and beautiful, right?7:51 So maybe the law changes.7:53 So really the question is like this:7:55 according to the ruling of Shulchan Aruch, Maran.7:57 What7:59 would8:00 The status of bulls in our days be.8:04 They're made for playing.8:05 They're cleaner than they were in the olden days.8:08 So what would be the status as far as muktzeh is concerned?8:12 So believe it or not, it's a8:15 machloket. Surprise, it's a machloket. Yes, it is.8:18 Machloket is amongst the Acharonim, obviously, who live in our days8:20 that see what the bull is all about.8:22 If you look in Shemirat8:23 Shabbat Kehilchata, he quotes in the name of Rav Shlomo Zalman8:26 Auerbach that bulls in our days are not8:28 muktzeh. Why? They're made for this purpose.8:31 You find also Shelmei Yehuda and8:33 Nishmat Yitzchak, both of them quoting Rav Elyashiv that say8:36 bulls in our days are not8:38 muktzeh. Why? They're made for that purpose.8:40 They're clean.8:42 Shevet HaLevi also writes the same thing.8:43 In our days, that the bulls are made for that purpose,8:47 they're not8:48 muktzeh. And if you look in Chazon Ovadia on top,8:50 he also writes over the same.8:52 He brings the words of Rav Elyashiv and the Shevet8:56 HaLevi that says in our days,8:57 being that the bulls are made for that purpose,9:00 they're not9:03 muktzeh. Okay.9:04 Now that's the people who are9:06 matir. You have Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, Rav9:09 Elyashiv, Rav Shmuel9:11 Wosner, and9:14 Chacham Ovadia zecher tzaddik livrachah. On the other side, on the flip side,9:16 you have Acharonim in our days9:19 that are oser. Who are the9:20 Acharonim that are oser? Well, first one already,9:23 Minchat Aharon, Minchat Aharon, Rav Moshe Levi9:26 writes at length9:27 that bulls in our days are still9:29 muktzeh, even though in our days9:30 they're made for that purpose,9:32 still9:33 muktzeh. Why?9:34 Why?9:36 He says because,9:37 let's look in this Shibolei HaLeket.9:39 Remember,9:41 Shulchan Aruch, his words come from Shibolei HaLeket.9:43 In the Beit Yosef,9:45 he quotes why bulls are asur9:46 because of Shibolei HaLeket.9:47 So he says, look in Shibolei HaLeket,9:49 open it up and see what he writes about9:51 bulls yourself, and you'll understand9:53 why bulls are still9:55 muktzeh. I want to read to you now9:56 the words of Shibolei HaLeket,9:57 and I would like to elaborate and explain it.9:59 Shibolei HaLeket writes like this.10:02 He says,10:08 אבל אלו הכדורים שלנו, אפילו כלי לא חשיבי. True, the words of10:09 Shmuel, like, are about 600 years old,10:11 if not 650 perhaps.10:13 But he writes like this:10:14 the balls in his days,10:16 they're not considered a keli.10:18 Remember, we defined in10:19 Hilchot Muktzeh the definition of a keli is10:22 anything that has a purpose.10:23 He says balls do not have a purpose.10:25 They don't have the status of a keli,10:27 a utensil on Shabbat.10:28 Again, of course it's a keli;10:29 it has a purpose to play with.10:31 But according to Baal HaLeket,10:32 he says they don't.10:33 You know why?10:34 Because they're made for playing.10:41 ומחשבת השחוק שיחשב לשחק בו לא משוי ליה כלי. And the fact that you thought about playing with it,10:44 the fact that you're using it to play,10:46 that's not good enough to qualify it10:49 as a ball,10:51 as a keli—excuse me, as a keli.10:52 One more time.10:53 Shmuel HaLeket is saying, basically,10:55 the fact that a person had intention10:58 or has the purpose of playing with a ball,11:02 that playing is not good enough11:04 to qualify it as a keli.11:05 Kind of like, we want to compare it to something else.11:08 Let's give you11:10 a mashal. Basically, Shmuel HaLeket is saying like this:11:11 just because you thought about playing with it on Shabbat,11:14 that thinking doesn't qualify it to be a keli.11:16 Kind of like forbidden material to read on Shabbat.11:20 There are things that you're not allowed to read on Shabbat.11:22 We learned it in the past11:24 in Parashat11:26 Vayishlach, the Ben Ish Hai, regarding the halachot of what a person is allowed to read on Shabbat11:29 and what he's not allowed to read on Shabbat.11:31 So over there, we spoke about11:35 shtarei hedyotot, documents that are not Torah.11:37 They're not11:40 Torah-oriented documents, have nothing to do with your health.11:43 Let's give you an example:11:44 a paper that has advertisements.11:46 Are you allowed to read advertisements on Shabbat?11:48 No,11:49 not allowed to read what's on sale.11:52 Why?11:52 Because that's called11:55 sharei hedyotot. Those are darkim; it's a chazal, a forbidden.11:57 So now, if a person now has a paper12:01 and he's written something on it,12:03 does that make the paper into keli?12:05 It's not a keli.12:06 That's mutar on Shabbat.12:06 You're not allowed to read those kind of things on Shabbat.12:09 So just like over there12:10 it turns into12:12 kelim melachto l'isur because you're not allowed to read it,12:13 here's12:15 where the halacha goes a little further.12:15 He says12:16 playing in itself does not render something into keli,12:19 and therefore12:21 the Muchta Haba holds, even12:22 though nowadays the balls are made for the sake of playing,12:25 maybe in olden days12:26 they were made for something else12:27 and then they convert it to playing.12:28 But he says12:29 in our days12:30 they are made from the beginning for the sake of playing.12:31 Even though it's clean,12:33 but it doesn't make a difference.12:34 The sake of playing,12:36 it's not good enough to qualify it as a ball.12:38 And this is also the ruling of12:42 Chut Shani, l'ibadel l'chaim tovim. The12:44 Chut Shani,12:46 who is Rav12:47 Nissim Karelitz, one of the biggest poskim today,12:49 alive,12:50 Hashem should keep him well and alive,12:51 he lives in Bnei Brak.12:53 He also rules in the sefer12:55 that balls in our days,12:56 according to the12:57 Sefardim, it should be forbidden.12:58 And it seems to be that way13:00 from the hanhagot of13:03 Ish Matzliach, because he quotes13:04 Muchta Haba. The Or Letzion also forbids the balls in our days13:08 for a different reason.13:09 He says13:10 if you look in the Beit Yosef,13:12 we just quoted to you the Beit Yosef,13:14 and he says13:14 there are two reasons why balls are13:16 muktzeh. Number one is because they're disgusting.13:19 Given, in our days they're not disgusting;13:20 they're very clean.13:21 But number two,13:23 it says over there13:23 Maran brings the Midrash,13:26 which is quoted in13:28 Shibolei HaLeket, that the place called13:30 Tushman was destroyed because they played ball.13:31 So for that reason alone,13:33 the fact that it's such a severe thing13:36 to play ball on Shabbat,13:37 it turns the ball into something forbidden,13:39 and therefore it remains13:42 muktzeh. So these two reasons,13:45 the Acharonim that we just listed,13:46 I'll repeat them:13:47 the13:50 Or Letzion and Chatahaba, Chut Shani, and seems to be Ish Matzliach as well.13:52 For the reasons that13:54 the ball was the reason for destroying13:57 two shemon, and therefore it seems to be a special gezeirah on it13:59 that the ball remains muktzeh even in our days.14:02 And14:03 according to the second reason,14:05 being that it's made for playing,14:07 the act of playing itself14:08 does not render something14:11 into a keli,14:13 into a utensil,14:14 to remove it from the status of14:18 muktzeh. Now this last reason,14:19 don't take it lightly,14:20 because it's also the reason14:22 of the14:25 Magen Avraham, Mishnah Berurah. Magen Avraham, Mishnah Berurah, both of them say that14:27 the14:30 balls—of course, when they come to explain Maran,14:32 you know, their own opinion it doesn't14:34 bring—but again, in the explanation of Maran,14:37 they mention,14:38 and14:39 they mention the Shibolei HaLeket basically,14:42 but they explain14:43 that being that the ball is made for playing,14:45 the act of playing does not render it into a keli.14:48 So14:49 you can throw on the list in our days also14:52 the14:53 Mishnah Berurah and the Magen Avraham. They'll hold also14:54 that balls in our days should also remain14:58 muktzeh. Now,14:59 question is15:01 as follows:15:02 if telling the act of playing itself15:04 does not make something into a keli,15:06 does not transform it to something that's mutar,15:09 we learned in the past15:11 that if I take15:13 something muktzeh, even the worst level15:15 of muktzeh, in the categories of15:16 muktzeh, muktzeh machmat gufo15:18 is the most severe form of15:21 muktzeh: stone, dirt,15:24 a scrap piece of wood.15:25 All those, we15:27 learned that they are15:28 muktzeh machmat gufo.15:29 If they come into Shabbat as15:32 muktzeh, there's nothing for you to do.15:33 You can't pick it up,15:34 you can't move it.15:35 The only thing you can do15:36 is perhaps kick it15:37 or do some other things.15:38 So now,15:39 question is,15:40 we learned15:41 that if I would like to convert a brick15:43 into a15:45 doorstopper. I could do that before Shabbat.15:47 How do I do before Shabbat?15:49 Come before Shabbat15:51 and15:52 use it as a15:54 doorstopper, or say,15:55 I am going to use this as a15:58 doorstopper. So the question is,15:59 why15:59 if I want to—16:00 Remove the ball from being muktzeh. Why can I do this? Why can I take it from before Shabbat16:04 and then designate it or use it for something that's mutar?16:08 You want to know what something's mutar? Take a soccer ball, which these Acharonim are holding that's16:14 muktzeh, and use it to cover your negel vasser cup. You know what a negel vasser is, right?16:19 I'll say it in Sefardi: your netilat yadayim cup.16:22 You want to use the ball as a cover to your netilat yadayim. Look, I found a purpose for it.16:26 It's not disgusting. Two, I'm not using it for, you know, it's going to be muktzeh when it's made for playing.16:32 I'm not using it for playing. I'm using it to cover the netilat yadayim cup. Why can I do that?16:36 The answer to that is based on a halacha that we learned also in the past.16:40 In order to transform muktzeh machmat gufo into16:45 kli she'meachto l'heter, in order to transform, for example, the stone into a16:48 doorstopper, in our days, the fact that people don't usually use such an item16:54 for the purpose that you want to use it, you need to designate it for that purpose forever.16:59 You need to convert the brick into a doorstopper forever.17:01 You can't put it back into the pile of bricks to be placed in the building after Shabbat.17:06 So we come back to the ball. If you want to take the ball out of the status of17:10 muktzeh by using it as a netilat yadayim cup cover,17:13 you must turn it into a netilat yadayim cup cover forever,17:18 and you're not going to do that,17:20 because otherwise why would you buy a twenty-dollar soccer ball or basketball17:24 in order that you should use it as a netilat yadayim cover?17:26 Obviously you're not going to use it back as a basketball or a soccer ball.17:30 So for that reason, Rav Nissim Karelitz says, in our days,17:35 according to the ones who hold, which is Maran Shulchan Aruch and these17:39 Acharonim that hold that balls in our days are still17:41 muktzeh, you can't really convert the ball into17:46 kli she'meachto l'heter; it remains17:49 muktzeh. Okay,17:50 now we've discussed balls. Nowadays, according to17:56 our Sefi Shulchan Aruch, because remember, according to the Rama, it's not muktzeh anyway.17:58 According to the Rama, the minhag, that they permit it.18:01 So I want to focus a little bit now on the Rama, just to go back to the Rama now,18:05 who permits, or who says18:07 nohagin l'hakel, the minhag is to be lenient with playing ball on Shabbat.18:10 I would like to discuss a few points regarding playing ball on Shabbat18:14 that people should be aware of.18:16 Even the Rama, who is matir, who permits playing ball on Shabbat,18:19 he himself will tell you that the following is also something to look out for.18:24 Number one is, if when we permitted playing ball on Shabbat for the Ashkenazim,18:31 it's only permitted on something concrete or some place that's18:38 tiled. Basically, you cannot play on grass, you cannot play on something that's dirt.18:41 The Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchata, he says even more.18:47 He says you can only play with a ball indoors.18:49 Outdoors, you cannot play with it.18:51 You know why?18:52 Because when you play outdoors, although there's concrete,18:55 but there's also dirt all around,18:57 so we're skirting to play on dirt.18:59 Now the question is, what's the big deal to play with a ball on dirt?19:03 What's the problem?19:04 And the answer is what we call asvuyei gumot.19:08 You're creating holes in the19:09 ground, although your intention is not to create holes in the ground,19:12 and you couldn't care less,19:14 but lemaaseh you are.19:16 The fact is that when you do play on dirt19:21 and you're running, you're digging up holes,19:24 and that is a problem of a toldah of19:27 zorea. Although again, it's not your intention, but it's a19:30 psik reisha. You can't do something that's permitted on Shabbat19:35 while— Automatically causing something asur immediately to happen,19:38 even though your intention is only, of course, for the19:41 heter. The classic case of psik reisha is,19:44 I want to open up the fridge to take out a can of soda.19:47 Mutar or not? Mutar, what's the problem?19:49 But if there's a light on, and I open the fridge and the light goes on,19:52 that's forbidden.19:53 Even though my intention is not for the light,19:55 I could care less for the light. It doesn't make a difference.19:57 The fact that the light is going on,19:59 it's called a psik reisha when I open the door.20:01 So, the halacha tells us when I do something that's permitted on Shabbat20:04 and it automatically causes something forbidden to happen,20:07 it's known as a psik reisha, it's forbidden.20:09 So to play with a ball, according to the20:12 Rama, is forbidden to play outdoors,20:15 according to the Shmirat Shabbat20:17 Kehilchata, even on concrete outdoors if there's dirt around.20:19 You can only play in a place where there's no dirt around,20:22 like indoors and whatever else.20:24 So that kind of limits your playing to indoors.20:26 You can't do it outside.20:27 Number two, when playing with a ball,20:30 it's very common that happens.20:32 If a person is playing, the ball sometimes deflates.20:34 You can't inflate it on Shabbat.20:38 So that's also something to keep in mind.20:39 You cannot inflate a ball on Shabbat,20:41 although that's debatable,20:43 but still it's something to keep in mind.20:46 You shouldn't inflate the ball on Shabbat.20:49 Now, if the ball pops,20:53 then it becomes back to20:55 muktzeh. Why? Because you can't use it for anything.20:57 It's completely destroyed.20:59 You can't put air back into it.21:01 It's not made for anything else at all,21:03 and therefore it remains, it becomes21:07 muktzeh. So although, let's go with the people who noheg21:09 like the21:10 Rama to permit playing ball on Shabbat,21:12 or to permit, let's say that ball is not muktzeh on Shabbat,21:15 moving it after it's deflated is forbidden21:18 because once it pops,21:20 there's no use for it whatsoever.21:23 Next, another thing to keep in mind,21:26 and this Shmirat Shabbat brings down,21:29 there is an issur on Shabbat to use a tree.21:35 What does it mean to use a tree?21:36 You can't use a tree for anything.21:37 You can't lean on the tree.21:38 You can't take your jacket21:39 and hang it on a nail that's on the tree.21:41 You can't hang it on a tree.21:42 You can't climb up the tree.21:44 All this is forbidden on Shabbat.21:46 Why? Because we're scared they're going to pull off a branch.21:49 Who's we? Not me.21:51 Not the rabbis in our generation,21:52 not the rabbis of the last generation,21:53 the rabbis of the Gemara,21:55 Chazal. It's like any21:56 gezeirah d'rabbanan. We are forbidden to use a tree on Shabbat21:59 out of fear that you might come to break off a branch.22:02 And even if you're such a22:04 chacham, and you're so smart,22:05 and you're going to be careful,22:06 you're not going to break anything,22:07 it doesn't make a difference.22:08 It's a22:09 gezeirah d'rabbanan. We may not climb up a tree.22:13 We cannot use a tree22:17 because of this22:20 gezeirah. So therefore, if children are playing with a22:23 ball, and the ball finds itself on top of a tree,22:28 you can't climb up the tree to bring it.22:30 You can't bring it down from the tree22:31 because you're using the ilan.22:34 Now I'll go even further.22:35 The Shmirat Shabbat22:36 K'hilchata says another very important point to keep in mind.22:39 If a person is playing ball and he's playing soccer, or he's playing football,22:42 and on Friday the ball gets stuck in the tree,22:46 so you come into Shabbat where the ball is on the tree.22:50 Says the Shmirat Shabbat K'hilchata, it is22:53 forbidden to bring the ball down on Shabbat,22:56 which we learned already.22:57 But not only that,22:59 even if the ball falls out on Shabbat by itself,23:01 it when comes and blows the ball down on Shabbat,23:03 that ball remains23:05 asur. Why?23:05 It entered Shabbat on the tree.23:07 Since during the entering of Shabbat,23:10 which we know23:12 as bein hashmashot, you were not allowed to bring the ball down.23:16 So the ball comes into Shabbat as23:20 muktzeh machmat issur. It's kind of like the fruits we discussed in the past.23:23 If you have a fruit on a tree23:24 that's still hanging on the tree,23:26 connected to the tree,23:28 and you didn't pick it before Shabbat,23:29 when Shabbat comes and a windstorm comes23:32 and blows the fruits down,23:33 they remain23:33 muktzeh because they came into Shabbat23:36 connected to the tree,23:37 and you weren't able to pull it out23:39 because it'll be23:41 an issur tolesh. So therefore, they remain in their muktzeh status23:43 throughout the whole Shabbat.23:43 This is the same thing with the ball, by the way.23:45 If the ball comes into Shabbat on the tree,23:47 now Shabbat is23:49 now, since I couldn't get it23:50 and I still can't get it on Shabbat23:52 because it's on the tree,23:53 even if the wind blows it down,23:55 it still remains23:56 muktzeh. But this is only true if the ball was there before Shabbat. If the ball ended—24:00 Up on the tree on Shabbat, and the wind blew it down. Although I can go up, but the wind blew it down, then it would be permitted, will not be24:10 asur. Up till now, we spoke about the laws of mukzeh regarding24:15 balls, what we said according to the Rama, who permits ball on Shabbat, and according to Maran, who forbids ball playing on Shabbat,24:24 and we saw that there's a machloket Acharonim as well regarding the balls in our days.24:28 I would like to point out something very, very important,24:32 and that is, up till now we only spoke about the technicalities of the status of24:40 mukzeh. I was careful, or maybe I missed, maybe I didn't catch myself all the time, but I was trying to avoid the word playing with the ball on Shabbat.24:49 Why? Because playing with the ball on Shabbat and the ball being mukzeh are two different categories.24:56 They're two different worlds.24:58 I would like to quote to you now sefarim inside.25:01 I usually don't do this. You know, I speak a lot of things outside.25:04 If I'll quote, I'll quote the Ben Ish Hai inside or Maran.25:06 But here, I have to, because of the severity of the subject, as you yourself will see,25:12 and you'll judge it for yourself, you'll see there's something very severe.25:15 It's not such a simple thing to just go ahead and play ball on Shabbat.25:19 Let's look at some of the Acharonim and the early Acharonim and the late25:25 Acharonim, what they speak about when they speak about playing ball on Shabbat and what they speak about it.25:30 Before we get to this halacha, I would like to give you a little bit of an introduction.25:34 There's a concept out there, there's something known out there that is—not known,25:38 but what I see unfortunately sometimes out there is something known as the abuse of25:44 halacha, which means although halacha permits something.25:47 But people, you know, people abuse the heter of the25:53 halacha, and they take it to an extreme, and I guarantee that's not what the halacha meant when they said it's mutar.25:59 I'm going to give you an example.26:05 We all know that in order to pray in a minyan, you need ten men.26:11 That's a fact, right? If you have nine men, it doesn't work.26:14 You need ten men to pray with a minyan.26:16 And the halacha tells us when it comes to chazarat hashatz, when it comes to saying26:20 chazara, Maran says if you don't have nine people answering26:24 the26:26 chazara, karov lihyot berachah levatalah. It's very close to the berachah of the person, the chazzan saying it, is26:31 berachah levatalah. So therefore, you got to make sure that before you start the chazara, you have people who are answering.26:34 You have a minyan of people that are answering you.26:36 Nine people. Some say even the chazzan can be counted as part of the nine.26:38 Fine, okay, they're26:41 matir it. So now, what would you say in the following case?26:45 You have a shul that has a regular minyan at26:49 seven o'clock, and, you know, they have to finish, they have to pray at seven because they have to finish by 7:45, 826:53 o'clock, so people rush out to work. You know, they have to go to work.26:55 And now it's vacation time, it's the summer, people are away,27:01 and they, you know, the regular minyan of 30 people has dwindled down to about, you know, 10, 12 people.27:08 That particular, one particular day, eight people show up to minyan.27:13 So eight people is no minyan.27:15 So they're calling up people, Come on, you coming, you coming, you coming.27:17 It's already 7:10. Finally two guys roll into the shul. It's already 7:10, okay?27:23 So now the people are in a rush, they have to rush to work.27:26 So people who roll into the shul, they go, instead of coming and praying right away,27:30 catching up to the minyan, no. They go get a cup of27:33 coffee because you're allowed to drink before, right? You're allowed to drink before tefillah, no?27:38 So they want to drink a cup of coffee.27:41 Okay, they're not doing anything asur, fine.27:43 Now they want to put on the talit and tefillin.27:46 They take their time, very slowly.27:48 All of a sudden they have the greatest27:49 kavanot. They're already 10, 15 minutes late, right?27:51 And the whole minyan is waiting for them.27:53 Now, instead of catching up to the27:56 tzibur, they realize that everybody needs them,27:58 so they decide all of a sudden to start from beginning with28:01 Pesukei dZimra. They want to start from the beginning of Korbanot.28:05 So now the tzibur has to wait an extra 20 minutes28:08 because these guys are late. We started at 7,28:10 now we can't even continue until these guys catch up to us.28:14 Now, are they doing technically—the two people came28:16 late—are they doing anything against28:18 halacha? What do you want for that?28:19 They're drinking coffee before tefillah, Shulchan Aruch says28:21 if a person needs to drink something, he needs it,28:23 then the Acharonim permit it, okay.28:25 So you don't like coffee, fine, tea without sugar.28:29 And they want to pray Korbanot, what's the problem?28:32 They're praying lechatchilah, what's the problem?28:34 Obviously, even though according to halacha there is no problem,28:36 but you clearly see there's something wrong over here, right?28:40 Come on, you're abusing your rights to the28:42 halacha. The halacha allowed you to what?28:46 Allowed you to drink before, but not now28:50 when everybody's waiting for you.28:52 Although you're right, lechatchilah is supposed to pray from the beginning,28:55 so come on time or come early and pray from the beginning.28:57 Don't come late and you know that everybody needs you29:01 and schlepp the whole minyan, make everybody wait for you.29:03 There you're taking היתר and you're abusing it.29:06 This is the same with many29:10 halachot. Now things are permitted, but it's when Chazal told us,29:13 or when the Torah permits, if you abuse it29:17 then, or if you use it in the wrong way,29:19 you're abusing the rights of the halacha and it ruins the whole heter.29:22 Who's going to be29:24 kovea? Who decides what's called abusing the halacha or not?29:27 You're right. It's not given to me or anybody on my level to decide.29:33 But we all agree that there's poskim and there's gedolei hador before us29:37 who've decided, who've discussed this, who've mentioned the subject.29:40 So I'd like to begin with the words of the29:46 Maharitatz. Who's the29:47 Maharitatz? Rabbeinu Yom Tov Moreno Harav Yom Tov29:53 Sahalon. Whoa, who's that?29:54 If you notice, Maharitatz is quoted a lot29:58 by Biur Halacha, sometimes makes me wonder, early30:01 Acharonim. His fathers are Motsei Sahalon, who was one of the students of the Shulchan Aruch of Maran,30:05 Rabbi Yosef Karo, the Shulchan Aruch, lived in Tzfat.30:09 The shut Maharitatz in Siman30:12 Resh Bet, I've highlighted over here only a few parts I would like to read.30:15 He says like this:30:18 When it comes to the heter of playing ball on Shabbat, he says like this:30:22 When Rama was matir, or Tosafot was30:25 matir, it was only because30:28 me'at sichok v'rov Shabbat b'Torah,30:31 ma'asim tovim. It was only in the case where they played just a little bit,30:34 but the majority of Shabbat they spent it30:36 when they were learning Torah or doing acts of mitzvot,30:43 uv'dvarim hamutarim v'ochim lishmoa haderashot. But they were going afterwards to listen to the30:46 derashot, v'einam manichim tefillat haShabbat30:49 erev v'boker v'tzohorayim, b'elah amru. And they're going to make sure to pray,30:52 they don't miss Mincha because they're playing ball,30:54 they don't miss Shacharit, they don't cut out Shacharit because they're playing ball.30:57 This is where they allowed the case of playing ball on Shabbat.31:03 I'm going to skip a little bit.31:04 Not so, he continues to say,31:06 not so in the case in his days.31:09 People were playing ball on Shabbat,31:10 and as a result they were not coming to shul,31:13 they were doing all different types of31:15 aveirot, they're missing out on playing, and they were betting on the games,31:18 they're doing all these different things,31:19 and he says, so therefore it should be forbidden.31:21 Now you can say, one second,31:23 hold on, what are they doing? They're playing. Playing is mutar or not?31:26 You see clearly that he takes into account.31:30 Who's playing? What are they doing because of the playing?31:34 How is it affecting them? It's not the act of playing by itself.31:37 And then he says like this:31:41 Im kein, dino didan de'ika kol hani aveirot d'amran. He says, in our case,31:43 where people are playing,31:45 it's causing them to do all these other31:52 aveirot. Vadai deyesh lechol chachmei hador lekanek nat Hashem,31:56 lichtov neged osei resha'im, neged hamorim lehakem notnim yad leposhim. He says it's an obligation for all the great rabbis.32:00 The generation to write against this and to speak against the rabbis who permit the playing of the ball on Shabbat, as we see what's happening.32:10 And unfortunately, people don't understand.32:13 They don't learn from the takanot hachachamim. They only learn from when the problems happen.32:18 And then in another teshuvah, he writes something even more harsh. Rabotai, brace yourself.32:23 These are not my words. These are not Uri Nahum's words. These are the words of the Maharitatz from around 450 to 500 years ago.32:34 He writes the following:32:41 Ham'sachakim b'kadur b'Shabbat yishtachu atzmotam b'Gehinnam. Harsh words. It's not my words.32:44 The people who play ball on Shabbat, their bones should burn in Gehinnam.32:53 Gam ata kadur yitznefim tzenifal eretz acheret b'rosh golim, they'll be exiled,32:57 v'lo ya'abru ge'ulim v'duyei Hashem ki hatatam k'midah me'od. The playing ball has caused so much sin.33:10 V'haRabbanim habachurim hamorim, zekim, chitzim, u'mavet l'hachshilah me'et Hashem l'hati et haasur, lo yikarei shemam Rabbanim ki im darbanim. And those rabbis in his days who were permitting this ball playing,33:13 because they say there's a Rama, he's saying, don't call them rabbis.33:17 They're spitting out poison.33:19 They're giving them the wrong33:22 psak. Not because, again, the psak is correct, the Rama is matir. No,33:25 he's not matir in such a case.33:30 V'ata azvu atzat hazekenim v'etra'atam. The youngsters and the young rabbis were leaving the advice and the psak of the elder rabbis.33:41 V'yelchu acharei hayeladim habachurim, v'yahabu bachurim v'lo yoruhu horaah kazo. And he says, don't allow them to give such a33:44 psak. People are listening to the young rabbis who permit it,33:46 and they're not listening to the gedolei hador who forbid it.33:53 Ki kama devarim kulam mekilim, ein megalim otam hemon am. He writes, You can't just permit things. Not things,33:58 not everything that's mutar, you have the permission to go ahead and permit it.34:02 He writes, How many times do we see that the Gemara says34:06 it's mutar, but you cannot tell this to regular people?34:10 There's a lot of halachot. The Gemara is full of that.34:12 In Shulchan Aruch, there's a few examples where it's mutar,34:15 but we don't say this to the people because they don't understand.34:18 So if it's mutar, why is it written there?34:20 It's written there because the rabbis need to know how to deal with it34:26 when you have a combination of other different heterim.34:29 I'll give you an example.34:31 Halacha brings down, it's a Gemara, that although it's permitted for a woman to technically get an aliyah,34:39 but you're not, ein kibud chachamim, and that's halacha Shulchan Aruch, we don't give women aliyot.34:44 The Rama says you can't give women aliyot.34:46 So who's going to go ahead now and give an aliyah to a34:48 woman? So why does halacha say it?34:50 So you have to know, the halacha says it to learn other things from it.34:53 You go ahead and say, Oh, the halacha is permitting, and you can give a woman aliyah,34:57 chas v'shalom, נגד פסק of the Rama and everybody else.35:01 So you're going to tell me, Okay, that's35:03 a meharitot. So harsh words, but back then maybe the situation is different.35:07 Let me tell you, the situation is not different.35:09 Nowadays it's worse.35:10 Somebody once told me he was once in a shul, and it was an Ashkenazi shul,35:14 a little bit modern, but still, he said the rabbi got up and he said,35:19 You know, rabotai, I have to say this, but35:22 when the Rama permitted playing ball on Shabbat,35:25 it's one thing if a person has a ball and he wants to play a little catch with his son in the backyard,35:29 okay, beseder, I understand.35:31 But to make a tournament on Shabbat, a basketball tournament on Shabbat, shema Yisrael.35:37 And that's really what we tell you. You think it's just playing ball?35:39 There are tournaments, people mistefilah, and of course you're35:43 sweaty. And because they're sweaty, they have to take showers. And when they take showers,35:47 all the issurim, they take hot showers, which is a problem of bishul, which is35:52 de'oraita. And don't forget the sechitah that comes out of it after coming out of the shower.35:56 Could you do all these things in a way that's mutar? Of course you could.35:59 But could you guarantee that people are doing it36:01 b'derech heter? And let's not forget, the people who are probably playing ball on Shabbat,36:05 they're probably not playing so clean.36:06 And forget about the words that they use.36:08 Just listen to the words that they use when they play during the week.36:11 True, we can't stop them when during the week from these words.36:14 But on Shabbat, when you give them the heter, you can't close your eyes and say,36:18 Oh, it's mutar. You have a Chacham Ovadia who says it's not36:22 muktzeh. Hold on a second. What if I just quoted to you? Chacham Ovadia himself writes.36:27 Why just said, I got it from36:29 Chacham Ovadia. You think I know how to look up36:31 Maharitatz? You think I sit there and I read the36:32 Maharitatz? Chacham Ovadia brings down.36:34 So even though he said the ball is technically not36:36 muktzeh, chas v'shalom to play with a ball on Shabbat.36:38 Now I'd like to quote to you the36:44 Badei HaShulchan. Badei HaShulchan is not Rav Feivel Cohen.36:45 The Badei HaShulchan over here that I'm quoting is the ha'arot on Kitzur HaShulchan, Rav36:52 Chaim Naeh. He brings like this. He brings the name of the Maharshal.36:55 He says,36:59 Davar tema hu lehatir sechok ha-kadur b'Yom Tov. He says it's very strange to permit playing ball on Yom Tov.37:03 He's arguing on the37:04 Rama. The Maharshal, by the way, is a cousin of the37:07 Rama. And he writes,37:12 Ela sechok shel yeladim ha-gedolim me'arba einayim minhag ra'hu. This, by the way, the permission that the Rama was matir is only for little kids,37:17 not for adults.37:18 It's a very evil minhag.37:22 V'im ayasher cheli, abatlenu. If I have the power, I will stop such a thing.37:25 And then he quotes a famous Midrash.37:28 And he says, the Midrash says,37:30 Why is it that the place called Tur Shimon was destroyed? Because they played ball on Shabbat.37:37 And he says over there, when they played ball on Shabbat,37:40 he says over there that— The Midrash says,37:44 by the way, this city, Tur Shimon, was a city of chesed.37:49 They used to give so much food to the37:52 aniyim. It was known as such a chesed city.37:56 And still, with all the zechuyot, the fact that they played ball didn't save them.38:01 Then he writes,38:03 Even those who permitted playing ball, like Tosafot,38:06 they only permitted it38:09 for tzorech. She'ein bekadur issur muktzeh, because really what they came to define that status of muktzeh of a ball.38:15 And it said there's no muktzeh when it comes to a38:17 ball.38:24 But,38:24 halilah la'asok mizeh kebi'ut lehotzi hazman hakadosh bischok shel devarim betelim, b'chas v'shalom. To waste your time,38:27 the precious time on Shabbat,38:29 with nonsense, with playing.38:32 You have no greater disgrace of Shabbat38:35 than this.38:37 And he quotes the famous words,38:39 which, we said it in the past,38:41 the Gemara says,38:41 Lo nitnu Shabbatot v'yom tov38:47 l'Yisrael ela k'dei la'asok bahem b'Torah. The Shabbatot and the holidays were given to the Jews,38:49 why?38:50 Not to play ball,38:51 but in order that they should be osek in the Torah.38:56 The whole week they're busy at work,38:58 and now is the time for them39:00 to be able to go to classes,39:01 to be able to focus a little bit more on39:03 ruchaniyut, spend time with the kids.39:12 He says, Look at Tur Shimon,39:14 because of ball,39:15 they didn't desecrate it with the39:17 melachah. They weren't driving on Shabbat,39:18 they weren't cooking on Shabbat.39:19 They were playing ball.39:20 Cause the whole city in39:22 Eretz Yisrael to be destroyed.39:30 Ki afilu yadata osrim s'chok ha-katuv b'Shabbat, ein bo ela issur muktzeh miderabbanan, v'aveirah zeh garmah churban leTur Shimon. And the sin...39:33 How playing ball39:34 caused Tushmot to happen,39:35 even though it's only39:38 issur muktzeh. So you see, it's not just a playing ball.39:41 It's—excuse me—it's not just because it's39:43 muktzeh. It's a playing ball.39:44 It completely removes the whole kedushah of Shabbat.39:49 And of course,39:50 forget all the averot that come with it.39:52 Now, I want to read to you one final line39:54 that the Badei Shulchan says: Ve'etzem ha-mischak hazeh hu minhag umot ha'olam.40:00 This whole concept of playing ball is really40:03 the—where does the custom come from? It's not a Jewish thing. It's a non-Jewish thing.40:06 Yeah, okay, I'm not telling you not to be sports-like in the weekday.40:09 Be sports-like, but he's just telling you where does it come from and where did it start from.40:15 They started this—the whole act of sports is really to prepare themselves for war.40:19 It's a battle. Every game is a competition.40:22 Listen, I play ball, but he's just telling you the source of it.40:25 The whole thing is a competition. Why? Because they want to go and fight.40:28 And that's where the people, the lightheaded people in our generation went, ended it. So40:34 we have more to say, obviously. There's plenty more, but I'm not going to go through everything.40:39 I think we said enough that we should understand that playing ball is not discussed in the halacha.40:48 Playing ball, all the Acharonim of our days write very, very severe things.40:52 It seems to be something very, very forbidden, very, very problematic when it comes to playing ball.40:56 Why? It's not if it's muktzeh or not,40:59 about that. Don't get thrown away with the muktzeh, not41:02 muktzeh. Don't get lost in that technical thing.41:04 Yes, there are people in our days that hold that balls are41:07 muktzeh, like we said, Rav Nissim Karelitz, and the Or Letzion, zichrono livracha, and Minchat Aharon, others hold that41:15 even today in our days the balls are41:18 muktzeh. There are poskim who say in our days balls are not muktzeh. But everybody, everybody agrees41:22 playing ball is not only forbidden on Shabbat, but it's very, very chamur, very, very severe.41:29 So therefore, lemaaseh, so if you're telling me it's assur to play with it and it's not muktzeh, so make up your mind.41:34 Can I move a ball or not move a ball on41:36 Shabbat? So I hope by now you're convinced you can't play ball on41:39 Shabbat, and certainly to make tournaments and to go, that's for sure forbidden.41:43 So don't make it like it's a Sefardi, Ashkenazi thing.41:45 Ah, if it's Sefardi, you can't play ball on Shabbat, but Ashkenazi, you could play.41:49 No, no. Even Ashkenazi cannot play ball.41:50 Who could play ball? Children,41:53 under the age of bar mitzvah.41:54 You can, fine, you can let them play ball.41:56 They're not, you know, they're not up to the age of chiyuv, if that's what they want,41:59 and they want to play a little bit, fine. Don't let them get lost in it.42:02 That there are some42:04 matirim. Certainly little kids who don't understand at all,42:08 for them a ball sometimes would be, it's not even muktzeh for them.42:11 You know why? Because it's made to make them quiet.42:14 You know those little, like puffy balls, they feel like a pillow almost,42:19 and little kids hold them, you know, keep them quiet.42:22 It's not muktzeh even according to the Sefardim, even according to the machmirim. Why?42:25 Because that type of ball is made to keep the kid quiet.42:29 You have a two-year-old, a toddler, when he holds onto this ball, he bites on it,42:33 it keeps him quiet. You're allowed to pick it up and give it to him.42:36 That's not muktzeh, even if you're not giving it to him.42:38 It's not muktzeh. Why? Because it's made, it's like a pacifier,42:42 keeps the kid quiet.42:45 And that applies, by the way, to other toys as well. Other toys as well,42:47 other toys as well, if it's made just to keep kids quiet,42:53 even those who are machmir will admit, will agree over here42:58 that these type of toys will not become43:01 muktzeh. But other types of games, let's say Monopoly and other things,43:04 there the Ohr L'Tzion has a chiddush, and he says43:07 that since we find that the Midrash was very machmir when it comes to playing ball,43:12 perhaps there was something special about the ball. But other ball,43:13 but other toys, although adult men cannot play with it because of bitul Torah,43:20 but still, we're not make it43:22 muktzeh. Women, even Sefardi women, he says, and children can play with board games and other things on Shabbat.43:30 However, however, that's only the opinion of the43:33 Ohr L'Tzion. From the list we mentioned before,43:35 Minchat Aharon, Chut Shani, both of them say that it should be asur because it's a game.43:40 And like we saw also from, it seems to me that would be the opinion of Magen Avraham, Mishnah43:45 Berurah, that being that it's made to be a game, will be asur to the osrim.43:49 To the matirim, so they have43:51 a three line. So bottom line. What do we do with other toys?43:55 Balls we already learned.43:56 It's machloket if it's muktzeh or not,43:59 and it's forbidden to play with it for adults, for sure.44:02 Little kids, if they play with it, they have what to rely on, as long as they don't get lost with it.44:06 The other toys, also there seems to be a little bit of a dispute in44:11 machloket, but certainly there's more to rely on over there that's not44:14 muktzeh. And if ladies and younger kids who don't have anything better to do with their time on Shabbat,44:20 of course they should be able to read books and, you know, engage in more spiritual things.44:23 But if they want to play these things without getting lost with it, you have44:29 matirim. One last item over here regarding this halachot, and that is inflating a balloon.44:35 A balloon also,44:36 to inflate on Shabbat, it's also44:38 machloket. You should ask your local rav.44:40 Some matir and some forbid it.44:42 Even those who matir, if it's blown once before, then they're44:46 matir it. So you have to ask your rabbi when it comes to these kind of44:49 halachot. Seems to be that we're out of time.44:52 We'll give you the phone number if you'd like to call in.44:53 We have another few minutes here.44:55 If you call and catch us before 3, 3:05, we'll take your question off the air.45:00 Otherwise, you can send a text to45:04 347-927-8398, or you can call in45:09 718-683-5858. Be'ezrat Hashem, next week we'll meet again.45:10 We'll continue the halachot of45:12 muktzeh, and this class will be aired on again tonight at 1045:16 o'clock. Also, don't forget this Sunday night is Tu45:21 B'Shvat. Sunday night, Monday is the holiday of Tu45:25 B'Shvat, and be'ezrat Hashem, this is Tu B'Shvat is a sign of all the holidays coming up.45:28 Be'ezrat Hashem, these should be the holidays that we should spend in45:32 Eretz Yisrael. We should only hear besorot tovot, be'ezrat Hashem, amongst all45:35 Klal Yisrael. Thank you for listening.45:37 Thank you, JRoot, for hosting us,45:39 and we'll see you again next week.45:41 Until then, have a wonderful week and a Shabbat shalom.