Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to the Halacha Hour here live on0:06 JRootRadio.com. We are here live on Chaf Bet—today is Chaf Bet0:16 Cheshvan, תשפ״א—and be'ezrat Hashem we'll be continuing our halachot of0:19 מוקצה as we've been learning so far from the Ben0:22 Ish Chai. Quickly, we have to always start with the introductions as we introduce the class.0:28 The numbers to the studio are0:32 718-683-5858. This is the number if you'd like to call in, if you have any questions, you could call in.0:36 Although we prefer that you call in at the end of the show,0:40 we hope to discuss almost every question that possibly is out there on the subject,0:45 but you could call in anyway if there's some sort of0:48 unclarity, and we'll pick up your call if we can,0:51 be'ezrat Hashem. The number to text in, which is the best way to get your answers to your questions,0:55 is 347-927-8398. And to listen, you can listen through the internet,1:02 JRootRadio.com, or by calling in 718-506-9099 or1:11 712-432-4217. We are in the middle of Parashat Miketz in the Ben1:17 Ish Chai, where we discussed all the halachot of1:21 מוקצה. Really, it's not all the halachot of1:23 מוקצה, because the halachot of מוקצה are divided into two parts1:26 in Parashat Miketz and Parashat Vayigash.1:29 Also, you should know that as much as we discuss about1:33 מוקצה and we really work very hard on making it clear,1:37 you should know that the halachot of מוקצה go way above and1:42 beyond what it says over here in this book,1:43 as the Ben Ish Chai himself writes in the beginning of his introduction,1:46 he writes that— It's impossible to really discuss every detail of the halachot of1:52 muktzeh. We try to bring some of the main points of the halachot,1:55 and we also try to bring out some of the rules.2:00 And of course, it's practicality that you should know2:02 at least where there's an area for question,2:05 if, when it comes up. Hopefully you'll be able to pretty much get around on Shabbat2:11 avoiding any2:12 issur muktzeh. But in case you can't get around from it,2:15 you know, at least you'll know where there's a question.2:18 We left off discussing last week2:22 the halachot of broken vessels,2:25 and now we're up to the next halacha,2:27 halacha Yud Gimel in Parashat Miketz in2:31 Shanah Sheniyah, where we discuss now2:34 leftovers from clothing or from materials.2:37 What does one do when he has clothing or2:40 materials that have basically been broken2:44 and you have leftovers?2:45 We're not going to read the halacha inside,2:47 as I believe most of the details of this halacha2:51 are not so practical,2:52 but we have to bring it anyway2:54 because we do learn concepts and rules from these2:58 halachot. Basically, there are three rules that come out from halacha Yud Gimel.3:00 I'm going to say it all outside.3:02 Number one is a3:04 machtselet. What is a3:06 machtselet? Machtselaot, in plural,3:08 and that is mat. A mat.3:11 Mats are used basically to lie down upon it.3:15 In places in the olden days3:16 where most of the floors were either tile or dirt,3:18 people had3:19 machtselaot. They had mats all over.3:21 You couldn't move into a house without mats.3:22 It's kind of basically3:25 your floor.3:25 That's where you're sitting on.3:27 So these mats would break at times.3:29 You know, they're made out of bamboo3:31 wood or whatever it may be.3:32 What would happen now when the pieces are broken3:35 and now the mat,3:36 which was, let's say, eight feet,3:38 is now very, very small?3:40 What would you do with it?3:41 So the first halacha of a mat3:43 is that as long as it's3:47 ra'ui, as long as the broken piece3:49 or the leftover piece of the mat3:51 is fit for some sort of usage,3:53 any usage,3:54 and obviously you kept it around,3:56 then it will not become3:59 muktzeh. That's point number one.4:01 Point number two4:02 is when you have clothing4:04 and they ripped,4:06 or they're not wearable anymore,4:08 and you're not planning to fix them,4:11 because if you plan to fix them,4:12 that's a different halacha.4:13 But you're not planning to fix them,4:15 and they in turn will become shmatas, as we say.4:18 Now, the halacha is very interesting4:20 because it all depends who you are.4:22 If you're a poor person,4:23 the halacha says,4:25 and again, this is what the halacha says.4:27 We are not saying this is the practical halacha.4:30 We're just telling you what the halacha says,4:32 what the book says,4:32 what the Gemara says,4:33 and what the Shulchan Aruch says.4:34 The halacha says is that4:37 leftover clothing,4:40 if it's for a poor person,4:41 even a small size,4:43 the size of what halacha calls4:44 three by three etzbaot,4:47 which is equal to about six by six centimeters,4:50 then that's already good enough4:52 to qualify as a keli,4:56 as we defined in the past.4:57 Keli means it has a function,4:59 and therefore, because a poor person5:00 will use such a small item,5:01 even such a small little rag,5:03 it's not5:05 muktzeh if the person is a poor person.5:07 However, this size5:09 will not work for a person who is wealthy.5:12 For a wealthy person,5:13 he needs to have5:14 the leftover,5:16 whatever got ripped,5:17 whatever clothing got ripped,5:18 he needs to5:19 have three by three5:21 tefachim, which is 48 by 48 centimeters.5:24 That's the difference between5:25 poor and rich people.5:26 For the poor person,5:29 stam,5:29 we're talking about where a person has ripped clothing,5:32 a shmata,5:32 a small shmata is good enough.5:34 He could use it for,5:35 I don't know,5:35 wrapping diamonds.5:37 He doesn't have diamonds,5:37 obviously, he's a poor person,5:38 for wrapping, you know,5:39 a small little coin.5:41 But a wealthy person5:42 will get rid of such a small item5:44 and dispose of it,5:45 so therefore,5:46 in order for it not to be5:48 muktzeh, it should be used as a rag or something,5:50 it needs to be bigger,5:51 three by three5:52 tefachim. The last point that we find5:54 in this halacha,5:54 which is again also brought down,5:56 and this is perhaps5:56 the most important point,5:57 and that is5:59 when you have6:00 A poor person6:02 visiting6:04 a rich person's house6:05 on Shabbat,6:07 or vice versa,6:08 if the rich person is now6:09 in the house of a6:10 poor person on Shabbat,6:12 the halacha6:13 is going to be different.6:14 Let's say you have a ripped6:15 piece of cloth.6:16 So we said the6:17 size is different when a person is rich6:18 or when a person is poor.6:20 And obviously this is all6:21 dependent on the fact that6:23 what's commonly done6:25 in the days of the6:26 Gemara, in the days of Shulchan Aruch,6:28 usually a ripped6:29 part of a cloth6:31 is commonly6:32 what's commonly used6:33 by a poor person,6:35 even by the size of6:36 six by six centimeters,6:37 and by a rich person6:38 when it's6:39 48 by 48 centimeters.6:40 Here the third point6:42 that Shulchan Aruch6:43 brings down6:44 is that even—6:46 not even—6:47 when a person is6:48 visiting somebody else,6:50 then whoever is the6:51 owner of the house,6:52 whoever is the6:52 owner of the item,6:53 he is the one6:55 who basically6:56 the halacha depends6:57 on him.6:58 If he is careful7:00 to use it,7:01 meaning to say7:02 if he's an7:03 aniyim and he will use7:04 a smaller piece of cloth,7:07 so then7:08 the rich person7:10 who's in the7:11 poor person's house7:12 could also use it7:13 because7:14 he's in his house7:15 and it's not7:16 muktzeh for the7:17 owner, will not be7:18 muktzeh for the visitor as well.7:20 Vice versa,7:21 if the poor person7:21 is in the rich person's house7:22 and now something rips7:24 and it's smaller7:25 than7:26 48 by 48 centimeters,7:27 where it becomes7:28 muktzeh to the7:29 ashir, to the wealthy person,7:30 the poor person,7:33 although for him7:33 it's good,7:34 he could use it,7:35 since he's in7:36 the rich person's house,7:38 he already is7:39 bound7:40 to the laws of7:41 muktzeh that are decided7:42 based on7:43 the level7:44 of the rich person,7:45 which means7:46 for him it will be7:47 muktzeh, even though7:49 it's bigger than7:50 six by six centimeters,7:51 it doesn't make a difference.7:52 Since he's in7:52 the rich person's house,7:53 the laws will follow7:54 based on the owner.7:56 That's a very7:56 important rule,7:57 that last rule,7:57 is that7:58 we learned.8:01 Two things, that things sometimes muktzeh depends on the owner,8:03 who the person is.8:04 So in such a case where the owner is, for him8:08 it's muktzeh; it's muktzeh for anybody who's visiting him in that house.8:11 Where it's not muktzeh for the owner,8:13 even though if it would have been your house8:15 it would have been8:15 muktzeh, since now you're visiting at somebody else,8:19 then it will not be muktzeh for you either.8:22 So that's an important rule.8:24 Practically now, let's be honest,8:26 ripped clothing, what are you going to do with it?8:27 Most of us throw it out.8:28 So whether rich or poor,8:30 pretty much in these things that usually ripped out,8:33 you're going to throw it away.8:34 Unless people have sometimes,8:35 when they have things that get ripped,8:37 they'll use them for shmatas, rags8:40 to clean up, you know, the bathrooms or whatever.8:42 So it all depends, obviously, on the person.8:44 But I'll tell you one interesting halacha8:46 that I did see brought down.8:49 Piskei Teshuvot brings down in the name of Shlomo Zalman8:54 Auerbach regarding laundry.8:55 What does that mean, laundry?8:56 You take off your clothing and you have a hamper8:58 in your room, you have a hamper8:59 in the bathroom, whether you're a child,9:01 you're an adult,9:03 married,9:03 unmarried, it doesn't make a difference, right?9:05 The halacha tells us now,9:07 what the question in halacha is:9:09 what would happen to the clothing that I wore9:12 and I placed in the hamper?9:14 Could I remove them on Shabbat?9:16 I'll give you an example.9:17 You come out of the bathroom, there's no towels.9:20 You don't want to run all the way downstairs9:22 and get the towels that are in the laundry room9:24 that are folded and nicely, you know, prepared for you.9:27 You're all the way upstairs.9:28 You don't want to go all the way downstairs.9:29 One idea.9:31 So now you have a hamper right there,9:33 and you know that in the9:34 hamper you dumped your towel yesterday.9:36 Could you pick up that towel from the hamper,9:39 or do we say it's9:41 muktzeh? Why would it be9:42 muktzeh? What do you mean? It's perfectly fit.9:44 Yeah, but that's exactly where the9:46 nekudah, that's where the point is.9:47 The question now is,9:49 would you on a normal day9:51 take something out of the hamper?9:53 Would you take it out and would you wear it?9:56 Would you take it out and use it9:58 for whatever you need to use it for?10:00 So let's say you have a hamper10:00 and you have inside of it your dirty socks,10:03 your smelly other, you know, undergarments,10:05 and you have your, you know, dirty shirts10:08 and pants or whatever it is,10:09 and they're all inside of the garment, okay?10:11 Would you take any of these items out?10:14 So you tell me, some yes, some not.10:15 Okay, that's your answer.10:17 Whatever you normally would take out10:19 on a normal day and use it again,10:21 of course when it's necessary.10:23 I'm not talking about regular.10:24 Nobody wants to walk around with smelly socks.10:26 People want to wear fresh socks.10:27 But when it's necessary,10:30 when your washing machine is broken10:32 and, chas v'shalom, shut off your gas10:33 and they don't have gas in the house,10:35 and now you can't do your dryer10:37 and you can't do your cleaner,10:38 so what are you going to do now?10:39 So the only option you could do now is10:42 go back to the hamper10:43 and pull out some of these old socks10:45 and you sniff whatever, you know,10:47 people can handle.10:47 So in such a case,10:50 since you would pull it out,10:51 so it's not completely muktzeh for you.10:53 However, if you're that person that,10:54 no way, I'll go buy new socks before I have to.10:56 I'll go barefoot10:57 anyway, that's a style, no,10:58 to walk without socks.11:00 That's a new style.11:00 So I won't wear socks.11:01 I don't need it.11:02 So in such a case,11:04 then the clothing,11:06 Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach says,11:07 should be11:09 muktzeh. And therefore, if my towel is dug deep11:12 under those piles of whatever it is,11:14 so although maybe the towel I would pull out,11:16 but to get to the towel11:18 I'll have to move11:19 muktzeh, so I'll have to figure out a way11:21 to be able to move the muktzeh out of the way11:24 to get to my towel.11:25 In such a case, basically11:27 you'll have to, you11:28 know, shove it by the back of your hand,11:30 by your arms,11:31 put the things on the side,11:33 or knock down the hamper.11:34 I don't know if your mom or your wife11:36 will be so happy with that,11:37 that you knock down the11:38 hamper and you put all the clothing on the floor.11:39 But in any case,11:40 the clothing is11:41 muktzeh, although the towel,11:42 yes, you would pick it up,11:43 you wouldn't dry your hands again with it,11:45 so then the towel is not11:47 muktzeh. That's the rule, the practical rule.11:48 And who decides?11:51 Who decides? If the clothing11:53 is muktzeh or not,11:54 it's not a set rule.11:56 You decide.11:57 You could decide this11:59 halacha means to say12:00 based on what you would normally do.12:01 If you normally would take things12:03 out of the hamper,12:05 then that's a halacha for you.12:07 Maybe for your wife will be different.12:09 Maybe for your kids will be different.12:10 I don't know.12:11 Maybe for you next year12:12 will be different.12:13 You learn12:16 Mesilat Yesharim, you learn a little bit more12:16 of how hanhagat adam.12:18 You read the Rambam,12:19 and maybe perhaps a person12:20 should act a little bit more refined way,12:21 so maybe you won't touch12:22 dirty clothing again.12:23 I don't know.12:24 But basically,12:25 you decide the12:26 halacha on what you would normally do.12:28 That is halacha Yud-Gimmel, outside.12:30 Now we come to the main subject12:32 of today's class,12:34 and that is12:36 halacha Yud-Dalet and12:38 halacha Tet-Vav. I would like to finish Parashat12:42 Meketz, which has12:44 ten zayin halachot. We're up to12:45 Yud-Dalet, so it sounds like very simple.12:46 Okay, you read12:48 Yud-Dalet, Tet-Vav, and12:48 Tet-Zayin, and you're done.12:49 But as you know already from this class,12:51 we take our time.12:52 We're not in a rush.12:53 We want to understand.12:54 We want to know.12:55 We want to learn.12:56 We're not here to just finish.12:57 We're not here to make a siyum.12:58 It will be nice,12:59 but we're not here to make a siyum.13:01 So let's see how much time,13:03 how much we could do13:03 with the time that we have.13:05 Halacha Yud-Dalet and13:08 halacha Tet-Vav discuss a very, very important13:09 practical subject13:11 that comes up every single Shabbat,13:14 and that is the subject of leftover food.13:18 What could you do with leftover food?13:19 Are they13:20 muktzeh? Are they not13:21 muktzeh? When yes, when not?13:23 And if they are,13:25 when do I have13:26 heter, and how do I have heter of moving them,13:27 if I do have13:29 heter? Let's begin by reading the halacha inside13:33 and translating it just simply,13:35 and first we'll get what the Ben Ish Chai says.13:38 And you should know, pretty much13:40 the words that Ben Ish Chai brings down over here13:41 are pretty much the words of Shulchan Aruch13:43 and almost all the13:46 poskim. Obviously, the details,13:47 the full details of it13:48 based on the other13:50 Acharonim, you know, that's what we're going to speak about,13:52 and a little bit practically.13:54 Let's begin.14:01 Halacha Yud-Dalet: Mutar leha'avir me'al ha-shulchan perurin she'ein re'uyin ela libhemah va'of. Pay attention to the words.14:02 It is permitted for a person14:03 to take off the table,14:05 to remove from your Shabbat table,14:06 peirurin means crumbs14:09 that are not fit14:13 for animal or bird consumption.14:17 Crumbs over here referring to14:20 bread crumbs, okay?14:21 Bread crumbs that are not fit14:23 for animals or birds,14:27 then you're allowed to remove them.14:29 What does it mean you're allowed to remove them?14:29 You pick them up with your hands,14:31 okay.14:36 Vechen, mutar lahbir atzmo klepein haruyin lehema. It's also permitted to remove from the table14:41 bones and shells of food,14:43 that is,14:44 that are fitting for animal consumption.14:48 However,14:52 aval, kelipei egozin ushkedim kayotze, not shells14:55 which14:57 sheein reuyin lehema, which are not fit for animal consumption.14:59 That means animals cannot eat them.15:00 For example,15:02 eggshells, right?15:03 Eggshells cannot eat them,15:04 as Ben Ish Hai talks about in the next15:07 halacha. Or let's say certain15:09 nutshells that are not edible15:11 even by animals.15:13 Then the halacha says,15:19 asur lahbiram ultaltam byadav o al yade kli. It's forbidden for a person to remove them,15:21 to pick them up with his hand.15:24 Why?15:24 They are15:26 muktzeh. Even to pick them up,15:27 to move them through a15:29 keli, it's also15:31 asur. You can't just move15:33 muktzeh through something else,15:34 as we'll learn soon,15:39 veasur. Vegam asur ltaltel shulhan beodam alav, so you can say,15:40 okay, let me pick up the whole table.15:41 Let's say you're eating on one of those15:43 lifetime tables,15:45 eight foot, of course, you know,15:46 Shabbat table.15:46 So you're eating on those lifetime tables15:48 and you want to pick it up,15:49 you don't have such a heavy table,15:50 so you tell me15:51 I can't pick up the bones and everything,15:54 fine,15:54 let me pick up the table15:55 and throw out the stuff.15:56 No, it's also15:57 asur. Which, by the way,15:58 in those days—16:00 They did have movable tables.16:02 In our days, we would call that our tablecloth.16:06 According to the Ben Ish Chai, what he's saying over here,16:07 if you have16:11 muktzeh leftovers—what are muktzeh leftovers?16:12 Anything that is not fit for animal consumption,16:16 okay? That is considered16:18 muktzeh. You cannot pick it up with your hands.16:19 You can't even pick it up with a tablecloth16:22 under normal circumstances.16:25 So now the question is, what are you going to do?16:27 You want to have a dirty table Friday night16:29 and eat on top of it on Shabbat morning,16:31 and then when my guests come16:32 and the in-laws come in16:33 and you want them to see my house like this?16:36 Oh, it's going to be16:37 a ... Okay, let me explain to you.16:38 It doesn't have to be16:39 ... I'll explain to you how to do it.16:42 Says the Ben Ish Chai, okay, so what should you do?16:48 Again, in those days, we didn't have movable tables,16:51 not like today. We have big dining room tables16:52 that are pretty much stable.16:54 You only move them for special occasions.16:56 So if you have this table,16:57 or like what we said,16:58 if you have a tablecloth17:00 which has muktzeh leftovers, bones17:03 that are not edible by animals,17:05 eggshells that are on it,17:06 so what should you do?17:08 Put a piece of bread on it,17:09 or if there is already a piece of bread on it,17:11 pick it up with the piece of bread.17:13 Why?17:17 Since the tablecloth,17:19 in our case,17:20 or the table in the case of17:21 Ben Ish Chai, since the tablecloth is holding the17:25 muktzeh, which are the bones,17:27 and the piece of bread,17:30 so since it's holding both of them,17:31 it becomes a basis to17:36 davar ha-asur u'mutar, and since the bread is still on it,17:37 they become17:39 batel. They become secondary to the bread.17:41 Obviously, the bread is more important to you17:43 than the pieces17:44 of—than the bones and the eggshells.17:46 So although you're not planning to eat the bread,17:49 but still the bread, as long as it's on it,17:51 it's not17:53 muktzeh. So therefore you could pick it up.17:55 It's not a problem.17:58 Good. V'im hu tzarich l'mkomo, shulchan. I'll give you another heter, says the18:00 Ben Ish Chai. If you need the place where the table is,18:03 like in our case,18:04 you want to remove the tablecloth18:07 so you could put the new tablecloth18:09 and bring out the fruit,18:10 or you want to use it, obviously, for Shabbat day.18:14 So if you want to take off the stuff,18:17 then,18:20 then you don't need the heter of having bread on it.18:24 Why?18:24 Because you need the location of the stuff,18:30 you need the other items on it.18:31 So the tablecloth in itself is not18:33 muktzeh. It's only muktzeh because it has the bones on it.18:35 So in such a case, you could remove it.18:37 Now, if you followed me so far,18:40 you are unbelievable. That's great.18:42 If you're able to follow just by listening,18:44 that's very good.18:45 But I'll tell you,18:46 we're going to18:47 clarify. Even if you followed me,18:49 you should only know what to do,18:51 but you should basically18:52 not understand why we do what we do18:54 unless you learn these halachot, obviously.18:55 So let's explain.18:59 Basically, there are two types of leftover foods.19:02 We could at least categorize them that way.19:05 Foods that are fit for human or animal consumption,19:10 they're fit. They could be eaten by animals,19:13 as you see the cats running through your garbage, right?19:15 Or squirrels.19:16 Or type number two19:18 is when it's not fit for human or animal consumption.19:23 In a case where it's not fit for human or animal consumption,19:27 the moment they become leftovers,19:30 like for example,19:31 you have an egg,19:32 and now you want to take off the shells of the egg.19:34 You want to, you know, take it off,19:38 peel the egg. That's the word I'm looking for.19:39 Now you want to peel the eggs.19:41 The shells of the egg, the moment they're placed down,19:44 or let's say you're eating...19:45 And we're going to talk about pits afterwards,19:47 but let's say you're eating olives,19:49 and now you have pits,19:50 and the pit is, you know,19:52 you sucked out every part of the olive that we're talking about,19:54 and now you only have the pit.19:56 So now, pits, olives,19:59 shells—I mean, not olives, excuse20:01 me—olive pits,20:04 eggshells, nutshells that are not fit for human consumption or animal consumption20:09 become20:10 muktzeh. Chut HaShani says, when do they become20:13 muktzeh? It's only after the meal.20:14 As long as I'm still part of eating it20:16 and I have leftover food,20:18 it's not 100%20:19 muktzeh. I don't have the problem yet.20:22 In the middle of my food,20:23 I don't have to worry if I'm biting on a chicken bone20:26 and now I finish the bone,20:27 I have to drop the chicken bone from my hand20:29 because I finished all the meat on it.20:31 It's besides the fact that, by the way,20:33 those bones anyway are fit for animal consumption.20:35 I don't have to just drop it off from my hands.20:37 Once I'm finished, I'm done with my plate,20:40 or let's say I'm done with the meal,20:42 then already we come into the laws of20:46 muktzeh, okay?20:47 So now, when it comes to leftover foods,20:51 the rule is as follows:20:53 when you have something that is going to be thrown out,20:57 you're going to throw it out in the garbage,20:59 like bones or food and crumbs,21:01 all these things, they become21:03 muktzeh. You could only move them off the table21:07 if they qualify for one of those four reasons.21:10 I'm going to give you now four ways,21:13 four possibilities21:14 that you could actually pick up the bones21:16 with your own hands,21:19 okay? Now, excuse me, not with your own21:20 hands—four ways.21:21 Back,21:24 delete, rewind. One more time.21:24 You could clean your table in one of four ways.21:27 How could you clean your table in one of21:28 four—what are these four ways?21:30 Number one is21:31 if the leftovers are either fit for animals,21:36 and what kind of animals?21:37 Those are animals that are found.21:38 We're going to discuss, by the way,21:39 every single one of those four ways in detail.21:44 Just right now, get the concepts first.21:46 How could you clean your table?21:47 Either if they're fit,21:48 if the leftovers are fit for commonly found animals.21:52 Number two.21:53 If they're removed through heter in21:56 Hilchot Muktzeh. Number three,21:57 if they're what's called in21:59 halacha, they categorize in22:00 halacha what's called graf shel22:03 re'i, literally meaning a pot of waste,22:07 that's made for waste.22:09 Number four22:10 is if they're fit for human consumption.22:14 That's my own addition22:15 at the end. We'll explain all this.22:17 We said the first way that you could remove muktzeh off the table22:20 is if they're fit for commonly found animals.22:23 This detail, this way of how to clean your table22:26 is going to be discussed,22:28 בעזרת השם, in22:30 Halacha tet-vav. So I don't want to get into it right now.22:31 We'll talk about it in full detail later on.22:34 Second way we said,22:35 if you want to clean your22:36 table where you have muktzeh on it,22:39 is if they're removed through a heter in22:42 Hilchot Muktzeh, meaning to say22:43 I actually have things that are really,22:45 really not fit for animal consumption.22:46 I have no22:47 heter right now to move it;22:48 they are22:49 muktzeh. How can I clean my table?22:51 Number one is something called22:53 tiltul min hatzad.22:54 In22:56 סעיף ח' in22:58 סימן שיא, Maran brings down over there22:59 a concept called tiltul min hatzad,23:01 and it's a very important concept.23:02 I think it's discussed in Parashat23:04 Vayigash. We'll talk about it very quickly right now.23:06 Listen to this case.23:08 You have a23:11 tzenon. Maran brings down,23:11 you have like a,23:13 what do you call it,23:15 a23:16 tzenon—help me out,23:18 Daniel—a radish.23:18 You have a radish,23:20 and it's in dirt.23:21 And obviously,23:22 you know, it's not growing in dirt;23:23 he just stuffed it in dirt. In those days,23:25 that was their refrigerators.23:27 So you have it stuffed in dirt.23:28 Dirt is, afar is muktzeh machmat gufo.23:31 So radish is a food.23:33 Food is not23:33 muktzeh, but it's wrapped completely;23:35 it's inside the dirt,23:37 and it's23:38 not—it didn't take root.23:39 Obviously, they have a problem of23:41 tolesh. So now I want to come on Shabbat,23:43 I want to pull out the radish,23:44 and I have a few leaves sticking out of the radish.23:46 So the radish is not23:48 muktzeh, but what would happen now23:49 if I would move the radish?23:51 Automatically,23:51 I'm also moving the dirt,23:54 which is23:56 muktzeh. And you can't say it's moving on its own.23:58 No, I'm causing it to move, because—24:00 I want the dirt to move out of the way so I can get my radish.24:03 So I can't touch the dirt with my direct hands because the dirt is muktzeh machmat gufo.24:07 But the radish, the radish I could touch.24:10 So what's the halacha?24:11 The halacha is you could pull out the radish even though the dirt will move.24:14 This is what's known, tiltul min24:16 hatzad. Tiltul min hatzad means I'm using something that's mutar on Shabbat, that's not24:22 muktzeh on Shabbat, to move something that's24:27 muktzeh. This is only permitted when it's for the sake of something that's permitted,24:33 meaning to say, why am I moving the dirt in the case of the radish?24:37 First of all, how am I moving the dirt?24:38 Through the radish.24:40 It's not directly through my hands.24:41 I'm pulling out the radish, and the dirt is moving on its own.24:44 Why would it be permitted?24:46 Because the radish is—I want the radish. I want to eat the radish.24:50 So I'm doing it for something that's mutar.24:52 If I want to move the dirt because I don't like the way it looks over there, so I'm using24:56 the radish now to push away the dirt, that's asur, because I'm moving it for the sake of25:00 the dirt.25:01 So in our case over here, if I have now the muktzeh on the table, the leftover food which25:06 is categorized as muktzeh on my table, it's not fit for animal consumption. So now I25:12 could move it through tiltul min25:13 hatzad. How is that so?25:15 First of all, I need the location.25:17 It has to be—I need the location of the item.25:22 That's what we said right now over here in the25:24 Ben Ish Chai. If I need the location of the muktzeh, meaning to say it's on a tablecloth, and I need to25:31 move the tablecloth so I can put another tablecloth,25:33 I need to move away the dirty muktzeh stuff because I want to set up something else on25:39 the table.25:40 Even if it's not setting up for me, I want to set up the flowers or whatever. I want25:43 it to look nice.25:44 So then I can move it through either a napkin. Or some people threw a smata, clean the25:49 table through a smata or napkin, or with a25:51 knife. Another way is when I have the tablecloth, I can pick up the whole tablecloth together26:00 with the garbage on top of it, which we call the leftover food, which has become26:06 muktzeh, and pick it up all in one shot, because the tablecloth is kli she'machto l'heter, and the26:11 leftover bones, which are not fit for animal consumption, is26:15 muktzeh. I'm moving out the tablecloth with the dirty stuff on it because I want the location of26:22 the tablecloth, so that's fine, that's mutar. I can pick it up that way and throw it in the garbage.26:27 That's another26:29 heter. Third way that we can find a heter is when you have the leftovers and they're considered26:34 graf26:36 shel re'i. What does it mean, graf26:38 shel re'i? Sometimes you have food that's left over and it's just purely disgusting.26:44 Yeah, somebody ate. He has a leftover tahineh combined with the chicken, combined with the rice,26:49 and it's, you know, some people are so disgusted that they wouldn't even pick it up,26:53 right? To the point that they wouldn't pick it up, but they ask, Okay, kids, come on, let's practice26:57 what we trained.26:58 Time to clean up Shabbat table. Okay, you get that guy's plate, you know, you get daddy's27:02 plate. I'm not touching it.27:03 So this is a graf27:05 shel rei. When a person is repulsed by something, this is what we find in halacha, something called graf27:10 shel rei. Graf shel rei, like we said, literally is a pot. In those days, before the invention27:15 of, Baruch Hashem, the bathrooms, so the bathrooms would have to be either out of the house,27:20 sometimes in the field, and it was very inconvenient.27:22 So they have what we call today, basically, a potty, right?27:26 A traveling potty, like they have for the kids, they have it for adults.27:29 So they have this potty that the family members would, you know, allocate a certain room,27:33 and they would use it for waste.27:35 So now, if this is called a graf shel rei, if you have graf shel rei around, the halacha says,27:41 let's say they had it in the backyard. Now it's a beautiful sunny day in the middle of November.27:47 I want to sit outside and, you know, enjoy before the freezing cold weather comes, and27:52 you're sitting outside and you see, boom, the graf shel rei right there.27:55 You see the number two over there.27:57 You are allowed to remove it out of your way because it's disgusting.28:00 You want to be there;28:01 it's disgusting,28:02 so you could remove it out of your place, out of your way.28:05 Same thing if I'm eating and now the leftover food is on my plate or it's on the table28:10 and it's disgusting for me that it should be there in front of me, I'm repulsed by it,28:13 I'm allowed to pick it up and move it,28:15 even though it's 100% muktzeh, by the way.28:17 I have eggshells; I'm not fit for animals.28:18 According to all she told, it's 100%28:21 muktzeh. I can still move it because of the heter of graf28:24 shel rei. You got to remember those words,28:25 graf28:31 shel rei. The halacha is found in Siman Shin Chet, Halacha Lamed Daled, anything that's disgusting on Shabbat, even though it's28:34 muktzeh, I have a heter to move it if I'm disgusted by it when it's in front of me.28:40 So, practically, like we said, if you want to clean up your table28:43 and you see, you know, those things that are just disgusting to be left over on the table,28:47 you can pick it up and move it out of the way.28:49 Even though it's muktzeh, you're even allowed to pick it up with your own hands.28:51 Besides the fact that you probably wouldn't even touch it with your own hands,28:54 even if you're wearing gloves, because that's how you discuss it,28:57 you're probably just pick it up, like we said, either with a napkin, a shmata, put it on a plate.29:01 Anyway, the plate is not muktzeh, so you're picking all of it up.29:05 That would be mutar.29:06 And you should keep in mind, I said the fourth heter is when it's fit for human consumption.29:10 You should keep in mind that, by the way, a lot of times you have food that you're going to throw out29:15 not because it's disgusting, not because, you know, people ate from it.29:20 No. Sometimes you have very, very good food. Just so you know,29:24 you have no room in your fridge for leftovers that are going to be stored for another week.29:28 That's, you know, caterers do this all the time.29:31 They have a lot of very good food, but nobody's picking it up afterwards.29:35 No, they're not going to store it. They have another party afterwards, and they're going to throw it out.29:38 Is it unfortunate? Yeah, it is. But what are you going to do?29:41 At the end of the day, they have another party to take care of.29:46 So therefore, over here, in your house, the same thing.29:50 How much challent could you save already? The kids are not eating leftover29:54 challent. So you have very good challent. It's still in the serving bowl, and you want to throw it out.29:59 That's not muktzeh. It's even fit for human consumption.30:03 We're talking about muktzeh that's not fit for human consumption,30:07 either because people ate from it, it's disgusting, people are going to throw it out.30:11 And then also, as we'll discuss later, בעזרת השם, it's also not fit for animal consumption as well.30:18 Okay. Now, as a side point, cleaning up, by the way, for סעודת שלישית is a different story.30:24 Cleaning up for סעודת שלישית means to say, you had30:26 סעודת שלישית, the ladies had סעודת שלישית in the house, and now they're done eating and they want to clean up.30:31 That's not so simple, because over there, if it's garbage, like we said, it's disgusting in front of you,30:36 you're allowed to take it out.30:37 But bezat Hashem, it's just a few leftover plates and a few crumbs on the table.30:41 That's not—you're not disgusted by it.30:43 You might not like it.30:44 You know, ladies and certain men like to have their house very tip-top, you know, clean and shiny,30:50 but it's not disgusting for you. So therefore, you don't have30:55 the heter of גרף של רעי. It'll be nicer, of course, if somebody's coming over, you would like to clean up,30:59 but it's not31:01 גרף של רעי. גרף של רעי, like we said, you're disgusted by it.31:03 So in that case, to clean up, you don't have31:06 the heter of גרף של רעי. Besides that, you have another problem of preparing from31:11 Shabbat, מוצאי שבת. Why are you preparing? Why do you want the table clean?31:13 So you can set up the next meal on it. But when's the next meal?31:16 It's going to be after Shabbat.31:17 So you're preparing on Shabbat for after Shabbat.31:19 So that's why by סעודה שלישית, to clean up is not so pashut.31:23 In the shul, where it's a small shul and they eat סעודה שלישית in the same place where they pray,31:29 so in that case they could clean up because it's mamash in front of them.31:33 They can't pray, they can't use the tables.31:35 So in that case, then you have the other heterim,31:37 and it's not called hachanah because you're using the tables now,31:40 as opposed to cleaning up סעודה שלישית in your house,31:43 when you're going to use the table only after Shabbat.31:46 Okay, now with that introduction, let's come back to our case.31:49 Leftovers. Let's look at the leftovers on our tables.31:52 What do we have leftovers usually? Bread.31:54 Leftover bread, actually, we said over here31:57 that you could pick it up with your own hands because they're not—32:00 Okay, even if they're not fit for animals,32:02 Maran doesn't bring that they have to be fit for animals,32:04 okay? So you could pick it up and remove it,32:07 but it has to be32:11 what we're talking about only.32:13 They're only a question when32:15 they are smaller than a kezayit.32:16 Bigger than a kezayit, people usually eat or they save.32:19 And if you definitely want to eat from that bread,32:22 there's no question that's not32:23 muktzeh. So, but if you have these little crumbs around,32:26 then those pieces of bread,32:28 what's the heter that you could pick it up and move it?32:31 And the answer is32:32 because you could give it to birds,32:34 you give to cats, they'll eat the bread.32:37 So you have a heter to remove them also for that reason.32:42 As a side point, I want to mention32:45 that you should be careful in how you throw out bread.32:49 I know a lot of people are32:51 machmir, some people may not know the halacha,32:54 that you're allowed to throw out bread32:56 as long as it's smaller than a kezayit.33:00 Kezayit means about an ounce.33:01 So if you have bread that's less than an ounce,33:02 you're allowed to throw it out.33:03 I'm talking about weekday also,33:04 you're allowed to throw it out.33:06 However, Maran writes words,33:07 he says,33:12 Even though you're allowed to get rid of33:14 pieces of bread that don't have a kezayit,33:16 but it's33:18 kasheh la'aniyut. It's not good because it could cause33:20 paverdy. When is that so?33:21 It's only if you throw it out in a way that's disrespectful.33:23 You throw it out in the street33:25 where people are going to step on it.33:27 If a person is taking the33:28 bread and throwing it out in a special bag,33:30 and therefore keeping the respect of the bread,33:33 then that's not a problem.33:34 Again, that's only if there's smaller than a kezayit.33:36 A big piece that's bigger than a kezayit,33:39 you cannot throw it out like that.33:40 Some say you could rip it apart,33:42 make it smaller than a kezayit and throw it33:43 out. You could rely on those opinions.33:45 But to take regular bread and throw it out,33:47 you should not do so.33:48 So what should you do with all the bread33:50 if it's bigger than a kezayit?33:51 You have the pizza crust,33:52 which is for sure bigger than a kezayit. In general,33:54 I'm talking about the weekday.33:55 So in that case,33:56 either break it up into small pieces and throw it out,33:58 or put it in the bag,33:59 keep it on the side for about a week or two,34:02 and you'll see once it gets a little bit moldy,34:04 then already it's not fit for human consumption.34:07 You could throw it out.34:08 The best, if you could find a way34:10 to give it to the birds or whatever it is,34:12 you could do so,34:13 although New York City doesn't like me to say that34:15 because I think the sign says,34:18 Feed a bird,34:20 you know, breed a rat or something like that.34:21 You know, you bring a rat in.34:22 So in any case,34:24 you'll figure out what you want to do34:25 with feeding it to the animals,34:26 but that would be the best possibility.34:27 If not,34:28 you keep it on the side34:29 till it gets a little bit moldy.34:30 Once you see that bacteria on it,34:32 you could get rid of it.34:33 Come back to our case now.34:35 This whole problem, when we said that34:37 the pieces of bread that are less than a kezayit34:39 become at least in the subject or question of34:42 muktzeh, that's only,34:44 rabotai, that's only if they're smaller than a kezayit.34:45 Bigger than a kezayit, they're not a problem34:47 of muktzeh. Also, this is only true by bread. Any other food says the Chut Shani, any other bread34:51 that—I mean, excuse me, any other food that's smaller than a kezayit34:56 does not have this problem.34:58 Only bread,34:58 when it's smaller than a kezayit,35:00 it loses its35:01 chashivut, loses its importance.35:02 So therefore,35:03 then you have to find35:04 heterim to be able to pick it up.35:05 But other foods are not.35:08 Now,35:08 other things that you have on the table,35:11 leftovers from meat,35:13 or even bones and all these things.35:16 So the rule is,35:17 if they're soft bones, like chicken bones,35:19 or if they're bones that have a piece of meat on them,35:23 or even the leftover meat,35:25 since it could be technically eaten by animals,35:30 so then35:31 they're not muktzeh either.35:33 And I'm talking about when I say they're not35:35 muktzeh, you could pick it up with your own hands.35:38 If they're, however,35:39 when they're not fit for human consumption,35:42 animal consumption,35:43 like we said before about the eggshells,35:45 or unsalted35:48 nutshells. You know, sometimes you have the salted35:50 nutshells; people will suck on it.35:51 So the nutshells are35:52 ra'ui. I mean, people won't do it,35:53 but they are35:54 ra'ui, they are fit.35:55 So in those cases then,35:58 when they're 100%36:00 muktzeh, then we need to go back to the heter that we said beforehand,36:02 either pick it up with a tablecloth,36:04 move it through a napkin,36:06 clean up with, sweep it with a napkin.36:08 You can't use your bare hands to pick it up.36:12 Good?36:12 Okay.36:13 Now we move on to the next36:14 halacha. We've been saying over and over,36:17 if the food is fit for animal consumption,36:20 then it's fine.36:21 So this36:23 heter of the fact that it's fit for animal consumption36:25 is not a36:27 blanket heter, meaning to say,36:28 it's not a blanket heter that I can just go ahead and say,36:32 okay, I think an elephant could eat this.36:34 Okay,36:34 so it's not36:36 muktzeh. And here, you know,36:37 I've heard,36:38 I've seen once on the animal show,36:40 and they showed this,36:41 you36:41 know, alligators will eat such a36:42 thing. It doesn't work that way.36:44 What does it mean that you are allowed to remove36:48 bones or food that's fit for animal consumption?36:53 Let's see36:56 halacha tet-vav. Ha'atzamot, the bones that we just mentioned36:57 that you're allowed to move them,37:00 even though we told you you're allowed to move them37:02 because they're fit for animal consumption,37:04 when do we say that?37:09 That's only in a place where there are dogs,37:13 not just there are dogs,37:14 that's common to have dogs.37:19 But if you're in a place on Shabbat37:21 where there are no dogs around,37:23 for example,37:26 you're on a ship or something.37:29 Or37:31 b'shayara bamidbar, or you're traveling,37:32 you37:33 know, in the desert.37:34 In those days,37:35 they used to travel;37:35 it took them weeks to travel some37:37 places, in the desert somewhere.37:40 Asur letaltelam. In such a case,37:41 you're not allowed to move them.37:42 There are no dogs around you.37:44 This is the reason why we permit you37:48 to move food that's fit for animal consumption.37:50 Not because technically it's fit.37:52 It's technically fit,37:53 but also you have to have animals around you.37:56 That's a halacha in37:58 Shulchan Aruch, which the Ben Ish Chai brings down.37:59 This is not something that people argue on.38:01 The argument is only in the definition38:04 of what's called commonly around.38:07 And here we have already a few different ways38:11 of explaining it.38:12 The word that was used in38:14 Shulchan Aruch was that the animals have to be38:17 matzui. What does it mean,38:17 matzui? It literally means found.38:19 So Mishnah Berurah says that38:21 most people will have such an animal.38:25 Most people will have such an animal.38:26 This doesn't mean that38:28 you have to take a survey38:29 and find out that there's 51% of people38:32 who have the animal and38:33 49%—no. It means it's very, very common to see38:36 people walk with such animals.38:38 If you're walking in the street38:39 and you see people walking their dog,38:40 yeah, okay, a lot of people have dogs.38:42 Some people have seven, eight dogs, right?38:44 But if you walk one day in the street38:46 and you see a guy walking with a chain38:48 and he's walking a tiger,38:50 that's not normal,38:51 right? What's this guy doing?38:53 Okay, so that's not normal.38:54 That's not called commonly around.38:56 So that's the definition of Mishnah38:58 Berurah. Chazon B'tzion says a major39:00 chiddush. Chazon B'tzion says39:02 if you have a39:04 city—now over here the halacha says,39:06 matzui b'oto ir, in that city that's commonly found.39:08 He says if, let's say, you live in a city39:10 where once—it's a big39:12 city—one side of the city,39:14 the neighborhood over there in that city,39:16 there are no dogs.39:17 The other neighborhood has dogs,39:18 but where you live on Shabbat,39:20 people don't have dogs.39:22 There are no dogs roaming around the street.39:23 There are no animals roaming around the street.39:26 Lemashal, you live in Manhattan.39:27 I highly doubt that in39:30 Manhattan—I am not there, I'm not a resident of Manhattan,39:32 I try to avoid Manhattan as much as I can,39:34 Baruch Hashem—but I highly doubt that in Manhattan39:37 there are many, many dogs roaming around.39:40 Perhaps maybe people do own a lot of dogs,39:44 and they'll be39:46 able—a lot of people do have dogs,39:48 so maybe it will qualify.39:50 But let's assume people don't have dogs in Manhattan for a second,39:52 okay? So no animals roaming in the street,39:53 and there's no such a thing.39:54 So in such a case, according to,39:56 let's say part of Manhattan has a lot of dogs,39:58 and the other part where you live doesn't.40:00 have dogs, that's called matzui. That's called40:04 commonly found, and therefore, says the Chacham Ben Tzion, you don't have such a heter.40:08 If your food is fit for animals, for those dogs40:11 that are on the other side of the city, that's called40:15 food that's fit for animals. Your food will remain muktzeh; you don't have animals around your neighborhood.40:21 However, Chacham Ovadia and Chazon Ovadia and40:23 Rav Nissim Karelitz and Chut Shani disagree. They write anywhere in the40:28 city. Chacham Ovadia speaks clearly against Chacham Ben Tzion, and he says that's true.40:32 He brings the Ben Ish Chai as a great proof. Says40:36 Chacham Ovadia, what did the Ben Ish Chai give as an example? If you're around a place40:40 where there are no animals, what does he say? If you're on a ship.40:44 If you're on a ship, yeah, on a ship people don't have animals.40:47 Why didn't the Ben Ish Chai say if you're in part of the city that doesn't have animals?40:51 We all know the upscale cities, especially in those days, didn't have dogs.40:57 Today, penei a dog, penei a geleb, but those days didn't have dogs.41:00 So therefore, if—Ben Ish Chai could have given a very simple41:03 example: if you live in an upscale neighborhood where there are no dogs, you don't need the dogs to41:07 guard your place because you have the Israeli Mossad guarding your41:11 property. So then, in that case, you could have said, in that case41:15 it would have been muktzeh. He didn't say that, because as long as it's in your city,41:19 you qualify for the heter. If you're on a ship where there41:23 are absolutely no animals, no dogs, then you don't qualify for the heter.41:27 That's the opinion of Chacham Ovadia, according to Chacham Ben Tzion. So again,41:31 let's come back. What is called commonly found? It means that it's around you.41:35 So in Brooklyn, New York, where there are squirrels all over the place,41:39 and there are cats all over the place, and there are dogs all over the place,41:43 that's called we commonly find that we have these types of41:47 animals, and therefore much of our leftovers... will be considered41:51 ra'ui lema'achal behemah. It's fit for animal consumption41:55 and should not be muktzeh; we should be able to move them. Of course, we're always going to have the41:59 actuals that are not fit for animal consumption, right? Okay. Now, I mentioned42:03 that our cats and squirrels and dogs going around. So now we know42:07 most of the dogs that are roaming around our streets are owned by42:11 people. However, cats, majority42:15 of cats are hefker, are ownerless. And certainly42:19 nobody—I guess, I don't know—people own. The only time that people own squirrels are when42:23 they're planning to get rid of them. You know, they catch them and,42:27 you know, they're gone. That's it. They're not using the squirrels as pets. So the question42:32 is, that's interesting: do42:35 the animals are mentioned here, when we say that the animals around, could42:39 you—do the animals, excuse me, do the animals have to be owned?42:44 Could they have—do they have to have an owner to42:47 qualify as animals roaming the streets so I could rely on the heter42:50 that my food should not be muktzeh? Shalmei Yehuda, there's a great42:55 book on Hilchot Muktzeh. It's an old book, but it's a very, very excellent42:58 book on Hilchot Muktzeh. The whole book is on Hilchot Muktzeh. It's called Shalmei Yehuda. He brings43:02 the name of Eliyashiv that yes, the animals43:07 must have an owner for the heter to work.43:10 We'll explain why in a second. With the exception of a43:14 dog, even dogs that are not—that don't have an owner,43:19 with the exception of dogs, all animals, in order to qualify for43:22 this heter that your food should not become muktzeh, they must43:26 have an owner. However, Rav Steinberg, in the same book, in the back, he has a whole43:31 section where he disagrees. Hacham Ovadia also disagrees, as we'll43:35 explain their reasons now. Rav Eliyashiv says that43:38 when you have cats around and you have squirrels around, since they don't have any43:43 owners, so then you don't have the heter that43:47 your food should not be muktzeh because it's fit for animals.43:51 Because the halacha tells us that you43:55 cannot feed any animal which is43:59 not your responsibility.44:03 In ma'achalan alav, you cannot feed an animal which is not your responsibility. Since these animals are ownerless,44:07 cats don't have an owner, squirrels don't have44:11 an owner, birds don't have any owners, and I don't think44:15 you're feeding mice, but anyway, so you don't—since they don't have an owner, you don't have44:19 responsibility to feed them. So what if they're roaming in your backyard, in your front yard, and on your44:23 roof? Who cares? You don't. Since you cannot feed44:27 them on Shabbat, therefore what's the heter of being able to move the food?44:31 You cannot feed them. That's the opinion of Rabbi Eliezer. However,44:35 like we said, Rabbi Shimon disagrees. He brings a few arguments.44:39 I'll give you two. He says, number one, first of all, Rabbi Shimon says, no, you don't need44:43 the animals to have an owner. First of all, there's no posek before Rabbi Eliezer that ever mentioned44:47 this. We don't find anybody mentioning that you need the44:51 animals to be owned by somebody. And also, even if you want to tell me that44:55 I'm not allowed to feed animals that are not mine,44:59 why? Because halacha says,45:04 Kol she'ein mezonotav alecha. He says that's not what45:05 it means. Ein mezonotav alecha, when the halacha tells me I can't feed animals that are not my responsibility,45:10 it doesn't mean if I own them or not. My responsibility45:15 means that animals that come to me to eat.45:17 For example, a lot of people feed cats even though they don't own cats. You know, there's cats roaming all over the streets,45:22 and the cats are cute. They're not like the dogs are ferocious and45:25 scary. Cats, people like the kittens, and they put food for them.45:29 Are they the owners of the cats? No. The cat eats, says Birkat Hamazon, and goes away. That's it.45:33 So if the cat comes to your house and you feed it anyway, even if it's not yours,45:38 the halacha permits you to feed it on Shabbat.45:41 Ein mezonotav alecha means that they usually don't come to you, and since cats do come45:45 to people's houses and they do get fed, and certainly if they get fed45:49 by somebody on the block, even if it's not you, you, you, but since45:53 it's—they're around and people do feed them, that's already considered,45:57 that at least qualifies you for the heter of that46:01 the food should be ra'ui for ma'achal behemah.46:05 Another heter HaRav Ovadia brings down, he says,46:09 I don't even need this whole heter that you have to46:13 own the animals. Why? Because46:18 this whole thing, this whole halacha of46:21 mukzeh has nothing to do if you're going to actually feed them or not. The halachot of46:26 mukzeh depend on if the food is fit46:29 for animal consumption or not. He brings this in the name of Me'or HaShabbat, in the name of46:33 Yisrael Fisher. Food, in order for it not to be46:37 mukzeh, just has to be fit for food. It doesn't actually—you don't46:41 actually have to feed the animals. As long as it's fit for it, that already46:45 takes it out of the category of mukzeh. Another heter, based on46:49 the Mishnah Berurah, even the animals that we said you're not allowed to feed on Shabbat or Yom Tov,46:55 if you place the food outside46:57 and the animals come and eat it on their own, that's mutar. So47:00 if I'm going to my leftover food on the table and I want to pick it up47:04 and I want to place it in my backyard, even though47:08 you want to tell me, let's assume that I'm not allowed to feed the cats, let's assume47:13 I'm not allowed to feed the cats means I'm not allowed to put the food right in front of them. But if I leave it in my47:17 backyard and the animals come whenever they want, they eat it, they47:20 could—that's mutar according to halacha. So since that way is mutar,47:24 so I could do the same thing now on Shabbat. I could technically pick up the food and feed it to the animals.47:29 Would I do it? No, no, no, no. New York City told me I'm going to bring rats, so therefore I'm not going to47:32 feed the animals. I'm not going to feed the squirrels. I'm not going to feed the birds. I'm not going to feed the cats.47:36 But since I could, so therefore at least it saves my food47:40 from being mukzeh. Now, keep in mind,47:44 rabotai, the other heterim that I brought also for a person who wants to pick up food47:48 that's fit for animal consumption, but I think that's good enough for now.47:53 Keep in mind, though, that if you are a person47:56 that does own an animal, then as long as any of your—48:00 Leftovers are fit for your animal. Even if you do not actually feed them from your leftovers,48:06 you don't need any of these heterim. Your food does not become48:08 muktzeh. Any of your leftover food, once it's fit for your animal,48:12 so then already it's not muktzeh for your animal,48:16 for you at least, that means, because you could technically give it to your animal.48:19 Of course, you reserve some nice good food for your animal. It doesn't make a difference.48:24 Somebody has a question now.48:27 What's the question?48:28 We always mentioned that when it comes to muktzeh, it depends on the person,48:31 like we mentioned beginning of the class.48:33 You decide if something is going to be muktzeh or not, because it depends on your standards,48:37 like we mentioned by the case of the laundry. Would you pick it up or would you not pick it up?48:40 If that's so, so how can you tell me that our leftover food is not48:44 muktzeh? Of course it should be48:46 muktzeh. Why should it be muktzeh? Because nobody here feeds animals.48:49 At least most of the people don't feed animals. If you have a pet, beseder, I48:53 understand. Oh, you're one of those people that loves animals and you always give them food,48:56 okay. But most, the majority of the people here, Israel, people that live in big cities, that is,49:02 they don't own animals, they don't feed animals, they don't want to feed animals.49:07 So how could you be matir them to pick up the food since it's fit for animal consumption?49:14 So the answer to your question is that this is actually a49:17 machloket. Piskei Teshuvot brings the name of Migdanot Eliyahu49:20 that all these heterim that we just mentioned before, a person shouldn't rely on them.49:25 Why? Based on the question.49:27 Since we do not feed animals in our days, we don't commonly feed animals49:32 in our days, so therefore the food should technically become49:36 muktzeh, our leftover food, even if it's fit for animal consumption,49:39 should technically become muktzeh since we don't normally feed animals.49:42 However, and that seems to be the opinion also of Rav49:47 Elyashiv, Shlomo Yehuda brings down Rav Elyashiv that this whole heter of the food that's fit for animal consumption49:53 doesn't really apply in our days because we don't feed animals in our days49:57 and people don't own these animals.50:00 However, other poskim, even modern poskim,50:06 Huchani, Chacham Ovadia, Minchat Ahava, I mean all the poskim that I pretty much looked at, nobody mentioned this point.50:09 And they all lived in big cities.50:12 They seem to understand the halacha in its simplest sense, that as long as it's fit for animal consumption50:18 and the animals are around me, even though I don't normally feed the animals,50:23 it would be good enough to qualify me for the heter that my food should not become50:31 muktzeh. So practically, if I have leftover food that is fit for common animals,50:39 common animals are dogs, because a lot of people do own dogs in our neighborhoods,50:44 cats, because cats do roam our streets, and certainly if you live in Yerushalayim,50:48 and also for squirrels, all these types of foods will not become muktzeh. However,50:54 food which is certainly not edible for animals,51:01 then everybody agrees that's going to be51:04 muktzeh. So how do you clean the51:06 table? Like we mentioned before, you have to either pick it up with a tablecloth, or if it's graf51:11 shel rei, where it's disgusting, it's in front of you and disgusting,51:14 then you're going to have to pick it all up and take it all to the garbage in such a way.51:18 We're pretty much done with these two51:20 halachot. I'm not going to finish reading the other part of the halacha of Tet Vav.51:27 We're nearing the end of our class.51:28 I just want to jump to the next51:30 halacha. I want to finish the51:32 parasha. It's not fair, probably, that we don't give it the proper attention and time,51:36 but I'm going to have to squeeze in the last51:38 few halachot so we can start fresh, be'ezrat Hashem, in the next51:43 parasha. Next halacha deals with a very important concept known as—51:49 מבטל כלי מהיכנו. Mevatel kli mehechano is a very interesting51:52 halacha. Let's first see the application of this51:57 halacha, and then we'll explain the reason of the52:01 halacha. Whoever is calling, we ask you that please hold on,52:04 and we'll get to your phone call in a second,52:09 because we have a few minutes left.52:13 We want to cover what we have to cover.52:14 Let's get to the52:20 halacha. כל דבר שאסור לטלטלו. Anything which is in the category of52:22 muktzeh, which makes us forbidden from moving it,52:26 אסור לטלטלו בתוך כלי. You're not allowed to place it52:28 in a keli, in a utensil, which is a regular utensil.52:32 Why?52:34 משום דהוי מבטל כלי מהיכנו. Because now that you place it in the keli,52:36 now that you place it, let's say, on a plate.52:39 Plate is כלי שמלאכתו להיתר. You're allowed to move a plate.52:42 And you want to take now something that's52:44 muktzeh, let's say the eggshell. You want to crack the eggs,52:47 you want to open them on top of the plate.52:51 What's going to happen when you put the eggshells on the52:54 plate? You now cannot move the plate because the eggshells are on it.52:58 It's now holding up the eggshells.53:01 So what's the problem?53:02 That's called53:05 מבטל כלי מהיכנו. Basically, it's a rabbinic law.53:07 You've made the plate now unmovable,53:10 so it's identical to, some explain,53:12 it's identical to53:14 סותר. It's like you broke the keli.53:15 Again, it's not de'oraita, it's53:17 derabbanan, but it's like you broke the keli because now you can't move the plate.53:20 And some say it's like53:22 boneh. It's like you basically cemented the plate in the ground53:26 because now you can't move it from that spot.53:28 So it's like53:30 boneh. Again, it's not de'oraita, it's53:32 derabbanan, but that's the source of this53:33 halacha. It's called53:35 מבטל כלי מהיכנו. Therefore, he says over here,53:38 practical case, like we just example, like we just said,53:41 ולכן אסור להניח כלי על השולחן כדי להניח בו קליפי ביצים או קליפי אגוזים וכיוצא. You're not allowed to place on, let's say, a bowl or a53:51 plate. Any shells of nuts or eggs53:55 that ein re'uyim l'achilat adam, that are not fit for human consumption53:58 or animal consumption, like we said before.54:03 V'davka kli zehu rekan. But when does this apply?54:05 That's only if the utensil that you're placing,54:07 let's say the plate or the54:08 bowl, is completely empty,54:11 she'ein bo davar ha'ra'ui l'maachal adam, and doesn't have also food54:13 or anything that's fit for human consumption.54:15 So let's give you an example.54:18 Eating your cherries.54:19 After you're done eating your cherries,54:21 you have the pits.54:22 The pits are not fit for animal consumption,54:25 certainly not for human consumption.54:26 If you place it in an open bowl or a cup,54:29 then you mean the cup not fit to carry anymore,54:33 so it becomes54:35 mevatel kli meheichano. So what should you do?54:35 Put a few good cherries inside beforehand,54:38 and then put the pits on top of that plate.54:42 This way, the keli now,54:44 which is your cup or your bowl or your plate,54:47 is carrying both the heter,54:50 which is the cherry,54:51 and the54:53 issur, which is the cherry pits.54:54 Now, if you want to pick it up,54:55 you're picking them up both together,54:59 with the plate together with the pits and the cherries,55:02 and the pits become55:03 batel to the cherries.55:04 The best is if you would put bread.55:07 The Ben Ish Chai says that55:08 we only say the muktzeh leftovers,55:11 like pits and whatever,55:13 we only say they become batel55:15 to another food when it's bread.55:16 If it's not bread, they do not become,55:19 what's it called,55:19 they do not become batel to it;55:21 they become secondary to it.55:22 So therefore, it's best55:23 if you're eating, let's say, seeds55:25 and you want to spit out your seeds or shells,55:28 although there's a discussion in the poskim,55:30 Shulchan Aruch brings it down,55:31 if you're allowed to spit them out in front of you,55:33 many of the modern poskim55:34 like Shlomo55:36 Zalman Orbach, they are55:37 matir that a person should, you know,55:39 when he's eating seeds or whatever it is,55:41 or nuts, to take out the55:42 shells and place them in front of him.55:44 So before you place them on an empty vessel,55:46 an empty plate,55:47 make sure you first fill,55:49 you put a piece of bread,55:50 and then you put shells55:53 or your sunflower seed shells55:55 or your nut shells,55:56 you put them all afterwards.55:58 So this way, you—56:00 Don't transgress the issur of56:03 mevatel kli meichano. Out of time,56:04 this class will be aired on again, be'ezrat Hashem, tonight.56:06 If you have any questions, you can call in the studio right now,56:10 718-683-5858, or you can text in at56:14 347-927-8398. Be'ezrat Hashem, we hope to continue next week with next parashah, Parashat Vayigash,56:20 also subject of muktzeh, but a different category of56:24 muktzeh. Thank you for listening.56:26 We'll see you next week. Shabbat shalom.