Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio. This is the Halacha Hour live on Wednesday.0:07 I don't know what the date is. I think it's July 1st today, and we are here live in the studio. Let0:14 me give you the numbers, how to listen and how to call in. Baruch Hashem, today we have a technician0:18 here live. So if anybody would like to call in, you'll be able to call in in the middle of0:24 the show. You don't have to wait till the end. But of course, if you want to be off the air, you'll0:28 have to call in at the end. Let's go to the websites, the numbers. Here we go. JRootRadio.com. That's0:35 where you could call—not call, but you could go on, you could watch on the internet live. You could0:40 watch a video and you can listen also online. You could also listen on the JRoot Radio Pro app, and0:46 you could call in and listen live. The number is 712-432-4217 or 718-506-9099. For those who are0:58 listening at 11 o'clock, this is not live. This is at 2 o'clock. We're live, so therefore do not call in the1:05 following numbers or text in any questions. We won't be able to see it. At least me personally, I1:09 won't be able to see it till next week, and by next week it's already from all the messages, we won't1:13 have it here. The numbers to call in to the station if you'd like to call in regarding any question on1:19 muktzeh, specifically what we're discussing, because we are talking about the halachot of1:25 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, as we will explain. The number is 718-683-5858. Again, 718-683-5858. And today we have somebody1:35 who is answering our phone calls, and you could text in, which is always the best way,1:44 347-927-8398. Again, 347-927-8398. Today's class is l'refuah shlemah of Chaya Malka bat Batsheva and Yitzchak ben Berta,1:57 and it's also for hatzlachah and siyata dishmaya for someone who wants to remain anonymous. Okay.2:04 We're in our halachot. We're learning from the Ben Ish Chai the halachot of muktzeh. We're in2:15 Parashat Vayigash. We're up to halacha hei. Before we move on to halacha hei, which is keli, or muktzeh that is machmat chisaron kis. Before we move on to that halacha, somebody2:22 saw me last week, and he had a good question on the class that we had last week. Last week2:29 we discussed kli shemelachto l'issur, and he asked a certain question, and I believe2:35 maybe I did not clarify all the way, so therefore we will, bezrat Hashem, clarify it right now.2:41 We said last week that in order to move a kli shemelachto l'issur, you need a heter, a reason to2:51 move it, meaning either you want to use the item itself, even though it's usually2:55 a kli shemelachto l'issur, but you want to move it because to use it for something like a hammer to crack a coconut,3:03 or you need the makom. It's on your chair and you want to sit down, so therefore you want to sit3:09 down, it's in your place, you can move it. To move something away, to move a3:14 kli shemelachto l'issur away because you don't want it to be there, not because you need it, because you don't3:19 want it to be there. Last week we said that it's asur. So somebody saw me, a person, a3:25 chacham learning in Israel, he saw me, he told me that, I have a question. You know, I saw3:31 in poskim says otherwise, and he's referring to the Or Letzion in Chelek Bet, siman3:37 chavav, ot gimmel. The Or Letzion says over there that if a person wants to move, let's say he's talking about a3:43 kedeira, let's talk about a pot, an empty pot. We already established that a pot is considered3:47 kli shemelachto l'issur, and therefore when the pot is completely empty... You cannot move it3:53 unless it's called—unless you need the pot, you want to use it for something, or you need the place where3:58 the pot is. To move it away because it doesn't look nice, we said is a problem. However,4:03 the Or Letzion says, no, you can move it, because I want that spot. That's also4:09 called I want it. I want that spot to be empty. That's called l'tzorech mekomo. That's what4:14 he says, kibud Shabbat. However, Rav Moshe Feinstein, in Igrot Moshe, in Chelek C, siman4:21 chaf-bet, lamed aleph, where most of the questions of muktzeh are there in very, very short, you know, short4:26 question and answers, over there he says to move a kli שמלאכתו לאיסור because you want4:33 the place to look nicer, he says that it's asur. And he says even though you want to do it because4:40 it's kavod Shabbat, he says the real honor of Shabbat is when we listen and we follow the laws4:45 of Shabbat. He talks about the example we gave last week when we had pens on the table, or you4:52 had a pencil case on the table, and you wanted away from the table. It's not Shabbosdik. It4:55 doesn't make a difference. Since you don't have a purpose for the place where the pencil case is,5:00 that's not called tzorech mekomo, and therefore it's forbidden to move it, as in the words of5:06 Rav Moshe Feinstein. And by the way, this is—Rav Moshe says this elsewhere. Other people had5:13 ideas about having a minyan where you bring in the young non-affiliated Jews, and they're5:19 going to come to this minyan, they're going to daven, they're going to pray on Shabbat. However,5:24 passably and likely they'll drive there. So he said, you know, the person asking the question, they said,5:28 we want to make such a minyan in order to encourage or train them in keeping Shabbat.5:34 So he says, if you want to train them to keep Shabbat— Don't make that minyan, because if you5:39 make the minyan, you know they're going to drive, and therefore you're causing them to drive5:43 on Shabbat. You want to be mechanech them? You want to train them in religion? Train them that they shouldn't be mechalel Shabbat.5:50 That's a chinuch. They should know that you one cannot drive on Shabbat, and that's why we're not making this minyan.5:53 So he's consistent over here. He says also, that's kavod Shabbat. Kavod Shabbat is not what we think5:58 is the honor of Shabbat. Kavod Shabbat means that we follow what it says in the6:03 halacha, what the chachamim prescribed to us, and they told us already what it means, kavod Shabbat.6:08 That's the opinion of Rav Moshe Feinstein. And this person calls me to look further, and I6:14 upon further investigation, there's a new book that just hit the market, one of my favorite books.6:18 He came out with a new chelek now, Piskei Teshuvot on Hilchot Shabbat,6:24 second chelek, part. And over there he brings down that this is really, already he opens up,6:29 he says this is really an old machloket. You find already that6:35 Tehillah LeDavid was one of the Acharonim from about 150 years ago, 200 years ago. He's medayek from the6:41 Rashba and Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchata as well, and you see clearly from the Biur Halacha, as I'll show you in a6:46 second, that they all hold that l'tzorech mekomo means I need the place. I can't just move it6:55 because I don't want my item there. I need to use the place in order to be qualified7:00 l'tzorech mekomo. Where do we see this in the Biur Halacha? The Biur Halacha talks about7:05 having the same exact case, where you have a pot and it's empty, and now you want to move it.7:09 He says you're allowed to move it. You know why? Because it's graf shel7:13 re'i. What does it mean, graf shel re'i? It's now a subject right now; we'll get to it eventually.7:17 Graf shel re'i means when something is very disgusting and comparable to, let's say,7:22 you know, the potty, the toilet training that the kids, the kiddie potty. So it's disgusting.7:28 You don't want it there. You can move it, even though it's muktzeh, you're allowed to move it7:32 if it's disgusting. Same thing, if you have a table—I mean, not table—if you have a pot7:35 and it's on the table and it's all dirty and things, even though there's no contents inside of7:39 it, I'm allowed to move it because of graf shel re'i. How come the Biur Halacha didn't say7:43 I'm allowed to move it because it's called l'tzorech mekomo? I don't want it to be there.7:47 See, clearly he's matir it only because it's a graf shel re'i and not because that's called7:53 tzorech mekomo. That is a diyuk from the Biur Halacha. Shmiras Shabbos... or Shemirat Shabbat...8:00 Rav Ta says it straight out,8:02 and like we said, it's meduyak already from the Rashba.8:04 However, I do have to say,8:06 he brings down the8:08 matirim, like we saw already on Mishnat8:11 Yaakov and Machzeh Eliyahu, which is Rav Falk from England,8:15 and the Medayek from the words of the Levush and the8:18 Gras. However, I saw8:21 in Chut Shani, that is Rav Nissim Karelitz,8:24 sheyichyeh, le'arichim tovim,8:26 he quotes straight out the Rashba and the8:29 Meiri that explain that tzorech mekomo means8:32 I need to use the item there.8:34 I need to use the place where the item is.8:36 And therefore, that is the way,8:39 like we said last week, and that's what we're continuing this week.8:41 In order to move8:45 mukzeh, that's kli shemelachto8:48 l'isur, I need it to be8:50 mukzeh. I need to have a reason for it,8:54 like tzorech gufo or tzorech mekomo.8:57 I need to use the item.8:59 I need a reason that I need to use the item,9:01 or I need the place of item to use.9:04 If I just want it to be away from me,9:07 that's not called l'tzorech mekomo.9:10 That is how we're going to rule the halacha.9:14 You should know, though, there are cases,9:17 even though I want the item outside of the room,9:19 I don't want to use the item itself,9:21 I don't want to use the exact place,9:23 sometimes it would still be permitted9:25 because it's called l'tzorech mekomo.9:26 Let's say there's an item that's9:29 mukzeh, and it's obviously kli shemelachto9:32 l'isur, and it's preventing me or someone else9:35 from being in that room,9:37 and I will not, or that person will not, walk into the9:40 room unless the item is outside of the room.9:44 So even though I'm not technically using9:46 the actual physical spot where this item is,9:48 but being I can't use the9:51 room unless the item is out of the room,9:52 then it would be qualified9:55 l'tzorech mekomo.9:56 I'll give you two examples.9:58 Number one is—9:59 In a room where husband and wife are,10:01 and there is a bag of tefillin.10:03 According to those10:04 shitos that hold tefillin is10:07 muktzeh because it is kli shemelachto10:11 l'issur, since the husband and wife cannot be in the10:13 room unless they take out the tefillin bag,10:15 so therefore the tefillin bag10:17 could be taken out of the room.10:19 I'm not using necessarily the counter10:23 or not the counter,10:24 but let's say I have a small little wardrobe10:27 where I have this tefillin on it.10:29 I'm not going to use that spot.10:31 It doesn't make a difference.10:33 Since the room itself cannot be used10:35 without the tefillin out,10:36 removing tefillin is called l'tzorech mekomo.10:38 Another example:10:39 you forget your alarm clock10:41 and it's ringing now,10:42 and you can't go to sleep.10:43 The kids played with it.10:44 You can't go to sleep.10:46 It's ringing now,10:46 let's say on Shabbat afternoon,10:47 you want to take a nap.10:48 It doesn't have to be at night,10:49 for sure at night,10:49 but even it's about afternoon.10:50 I have now the alarm clock ringing at10:55 4 p.m. and I need my nap.10:56 I need, you know, it's oneg Shabbat,10:57 or whatever reason it is,10:59 I want to sleep on Shabbat.10:59 I have to sleep11:00 at noon. I can't sleep in the living room11:01 where all the guests are.11:03 So in that case,11:05 to remove the alarm clock,11:06 of course, we're not talking about an alarm clock11:08 that's plugged into the wall.11:09 We're talking about an alarm clock11:10 that could be moved,11:12 since it's ringing11:12 and I can't stay in the room,11:13 I can't use the11:15 room unless the alarm clock is out,11:16 that will also be considered11:20 l'tzorech mekomo. Again, if I need to use the room11:23 and the item that's kli shemelachto l'issur is preventing me from using it,11:27 moving it or removing it from the room11:29 is also in the category of11:33 tzorech mekomo. That is just a clarification from last week.11:35 We move on now to today's discussion.11:40 Today's discussion is11:44 on muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Let's read the Ben Ish Chai from inside.11:47 And after we go through the Ben11:50 Ish Chai, then we will bring out a lot of points11:53 regarding11:55 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, and there's a lot.11:55 Really, this is where it gets exciting.11:57 You know, if you already followed us till now,11:58 you followed, you learned with us12:04 the halachot of kli שמלאכתו להיתר, the halachot of kli שמלאכתו לאיסור, this makes12:07 kli שמלאכתו muktzeh machmat chisaron kis will now be very, very interesting and exciting.12:10 Let's begin.12:16 סכין של שחיטה, או של מילה, או איזמל של ספרים. If you have a knife12:18 that's made just for12:21 shechita, that's the shochet's knife,12:24 or של מילה, or the mohel's knife,12:26 that's the one that's used for doing circumcision,12:29 or איזמל של ספרים, or they used to have these special knives12:32 that they still have it today.12:34 It's kind of like the razors12:35 where they would sharpen the12:38 קולמוס. You know, when you're writing a Sefer Torah12:40 or tefillin,12:41 the קולמוס, which is the pen that you use,12:43 has to be in a certain size.12:45 You know, you want to write small or big,12:47 it has to be in a certain way.12:48 So they used to have a special knife12:50 that was made to sharpen that pen.12:55 וסכין של סופרים. Sorry, sorry, sorry, I missed one.12:57 סכין של ספרים is a knife,12:59 or what we would call today like a razor13:01 or a shaver13:02 or something that the barbers use,13:03 a trimmer.13:04 סכין של סופרים is this thing13:06 that's made to use for13:09 a13:13 kolmus. שמיוחדת לקולמוסים, כיוון שמקפידין שלא לעשות בהם תשמיש אחר. Since normally,13:14 people, owners of such items,13:16 are very, very careful13:17 not to use them for any other uses,13:24 אסור לטלטלם אפילו לצורך גופם ומקומם. So now the halacha becomes13:26 that you can't move these items13:28 even if you want to use it for something else.13:31 Let's say you have a shechita knife13:32 and all knives in the13:34 house are missing or broken or13:36 dirty, and now you want to use a shechita knife13:38 to cut your steak.13:39 Today you decide to change your mind.13:41 You quit. You don't want to be a shochet anymore.13:42 You gave up on it,13:43 or you don't want to be a mohel anymore.13:45 You want to use now13:47 the milah knife for that,13:48 or you want to show somebody your shechita knife.13:51 You found a big rav that came to your house13:54 and you want to show him your shechita knife.13:55 It doesn't make a difference.13:56 They're considered muktzeh machmat chisaron kis,13:58 and you can't move them,14:00 even for the item itself,14:01 even if it happens to be14:02 you forgot the item on your chair14:06 and now you want to sit in that location.14:08 You cannot pick them up in a normal fashion14:09 and move them.14:16 ואפילו תחובים בין הדנים שעשה קינים, אסור לטלטלם, אף על פי שאין בסיס לאיסור ומותר. Even if they're stuck into,14:19 let's say you have a place14:20 where you stick all the knives.14:22 So even if they're there,14:25 and you're going to say,14:25 okay, there's some knives that are,14:28 you know, that I use all the time.14:29 I use them to cut my steak.14:31 I use them to cut my fruits.14:32 And then I have also my shechitah knife14:34 also inside over there.14:36 My knife rack,14:36 it doesn't make a difference.14:38 Since it's there holding muktzeh machmat chisaron kis,14:40 and it's very valuable to me,14:42 I cannot move it.14:45 V'hu hadin, this not only applies to these knives,14:46 also applies to kunas shel basamim14:50 shemakpidim shelo yitlaklech. These have these special types of hammers14:54 or cleavers, basically,14:55 whatever they used to use14:57 for making spices,14:59 making, or something,15:01 you know, fragrances,15:01 and they would not use these types of15:04 cleavers for anything else.15:06 Also, it'll be asur to use them on Shabbat15:09 or to move them even on Shabbat.15:12 Why?15:12 Because usually you're careful15:14 from using them for any other purpose15:16 except for what it's made for.15:23 However,15:23 if for some reason, somehow,15:25 before Shabbat comes in,15:27 you decided that I'm going to use these items15:29 on Shabbat for something that's mutar.15:30 You took your shechitah knife,15:31 you looked at it, you said,15:32 you know, I'm planning to get a brand15:34 new—I'm getting a package,15:36 a dozen of brand new shechitah knives.15:38 I don't need this one anymore.15:39 Or maybe I'll use it for15:41 shechitah, but I'm going to use it also15:43 for cutting my steak on Shabbat,15:46 then it will be mutar to use it.15:48 V'chen, now Ben Ish Chai brings another case,15:51 niyar15:51 חלק. We're going to discuss every point,15:53 be'ezrat Hashem,15:54 as we go a little bit later.15:55 We're just reading right now.15:57 Niyar15:57 חלק, if you have15:59 a blank piece of paper.16:01 Im hu chashuv me'od, shu meyuchad lichtov bo igrot davka. If it's a very, very important piece of paper that you're careful,16:05 you only use it to write letters on them,16:09 ve'ein mishtamshim bo tashmish acher lichtov bo eizeh davar. You don't use it for wrapping other things,16:14 דינו ככלים הנזכרים ואסור לטלטלו. Then it has the status of16:18 kli שמלאכתו לאיסור, or muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, and therefore you cannot move it on Shabbat for any reason.16:25 That is the halacha about16:27 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Let's review and define first of all muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.16:32 Even though we've done it in the past, we're going to stress it, we're going to focus on this today.16:36 Muktzeh machmat chisaron kis is a category of16:40 muktzeh where the items in this category are ones that people are very, very careful from using them16:46 for anything besides what it's made for.16:50 Why?16:51 Because out of fear of ruining it, or depreciating its value.16:59 That's the definition of muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.17:01 You will not use them except for what they're intended for,17:05 out of fear that you'll depreciate its value or you're going to ruin it.17:10 That is the definition of muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.17:12 Now, there's a big question in the poskim.17:16 The examples are given in Shulchan Aruch17:18 — you see, Ben Ish Chai is pretty much copying the Shulchan Aruch, the17:21 Acharonim — the examples are given usually for muktzeh machmat chisaron kis17:25 happen to be things that are17:32 melachtam le'issur. Things are usually that the main purpose of it is something that's forbidden on Shabbat.17:36 Let's, if you recall, let's go review the examples are given:17:41 sakin shel shechitah, a butcher's knife17:43 — not a butcher, but really a shochet's knife.17:45 Sakin17:49 shel mohalim. זמן של מילה, that is,17:50 a mohel's knife, which is made to cut the orlah of the baby,17:55 or17:58 סכין של ספרים או של סופרים, the barber's scissors,18:00 the barber's razor,18:02 or the sofer's special knife.18:05 All these items are made,18:09 כלי שמלאכתם לאיסור. So the question arises between the poskim:18:11 in order for something to qualify as18:16 מוקצה מחמת חסרון כיס, does it also have to be18:20 כלי שמלאכתו לאיסור, or do we say no?18:22 Even an item that's כלי שמלאכתו להיתר, if it's very, very expensive18:26 and you're very careful from using it for any other purpose,18:29 then it should be also18:34 מוקצה מחמת חסרון כיס. For example, diamond ring.18:36 Would you ever use your diamond ring for anything else?18:38 Would you ever use your diamond ring to hold up a window?18:41 Would you ever use it as a18:42 paperweight? Would you ever use your diamond ring to pull out a nail from a box?18:49 No way.18:50 Ah, but it's hard, you know, it's gold.18:51 No way. You will never use it because it's going to depreciate in value.18:54 But a diamond ring is a18:57 כלי שמלאכתו להיתר. It's made so somebody should wear it, so show it to people.18:59 It's not19:02 כלי שמלאכתו לאיסור, and that's really what the question is.19:03 Do diamond rings or crystal vases, anything that's made19:08 להיתר, do they qualify as19:12 מוקצה מחמת חסרון כיס because people are very, very careful with them?19:15 And the answer that pretty much the majority of the poskim bring down19:20 is what the Tosefes Shabbat says in early19:24 Acharon. He says it's in19:27 siman שי״ד, סעיף קטן י״ג. Says the Tosefes Shabbat that only19:33 כלי שמלאכתו לאיסור could become19:36 מוקצה מחמת חסרון כיס. If it's kli she'melachto l'heter, it does not become muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.19:41 And he explains why.19:42 Meaning, only the item has to be designated for something that you cannot use on Shabbat,19:47 and it has to be something that you're so careful that you'll never use it for any other purpose,19:51 then it will qualify for muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.19:54 If it's a kli she'melachto l'heter, it does not become muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.19:59 Not your diamond ring, not your crystal vase, not your whatever it may be,20:03 you know, special cups, whatever it may be.20:06 And he explains why.20:08 Muktzeh machmat chisaron kis has to be a kli she'melachto l'isur first.20:13 Why?20:14 Well, a kli she'melachto l'isur, a regular kli she'melachto l'isur, a hammer,20:18 it's made to bang in nails into the wall, and that's asur on Shabbat.20:22 We20:23 said you're allowed to move20:25 it. Why? L'tzorech gufo and l'tzorech mekomo, if it's in a certain place that you need to use,20:27 or if it's for any other purpose, like cracking a coconut.20:34 However, in this case, that you have, let's say, this knife that's made for20:41 shechita. Shechita is asur on Shabbat, right?20:43 But it's made for20:44 shechita. Would you use this knife for anything else?20:46 Would you use it20:48 l'tzorech gufo? And the answer is no, of course not. I wouldn't use it20:51 l'tzorech gufo. And because you wouldn't use it20:53 l'tzorech gufo, so you have no other usage for this knife except for doing20:58 shechita, and shechita is asur on Shabbat.21:00 So technically, you have no uses for this knife on Shabbat,21:03 and that's why it's21:05 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Because it's so precious, it's so expensive.21:09 Again, expensive doesn't have to be literal; it's to you.21:12 It's so precious to you that you won't use it for anything else21:16 except for what it's made for.21:17 And what it's made for is forbidden on Shabbat.21:19 So it comes out that this item has no usage on Shabbat whatsoever,21:24 and that's why it becomes21:25 muktzeh. That is the opinion of Tosafot Shabbat,21:28 as well as the Gra, which is Hagaon Rav Zalman,21:31 which is21:34 Shulchan Aruch HaRav, Baal HaTanya. One of the main21:35 Acharonim, and it seems to be the opinion of the majority of the21:39 Acharonim. They all bring this.21:40 However, if you look in the21:43 Acharonim, you'll find a few contradictions to this rule.21:46 Remember, we said that21:48 kli shemelachto l'issur only will become muktzeh machmat chesron kis.21:53 However, I'm going to bring you a few examples21:55 where you see Acharonim, some of the main Acharonim, who,21:57 a lot of them do go with this rule,21:59 and they seem to contradict themselves.22:01 They say that kli shemelachto l'heter does not become muktzeh machmat chesron kis.22:05 So let's go through some examples.22:07 You look in the Mishnah Berurah in siman22:10 shin-chet, se'if katan kuf22:12 samech-chet. He brings over there a wall clock.22:14 It's not his own, you know,22:17 chiddush over here. He brings it from the Acharonim who say22:19 you have a wall clock,22:20 which means a clock that you hang up on the wall,22:23 says22:25 the Mishnah Berurah that you cannot move it on Shabbat.22:30 He holds—well, right now we're assuming that a clock is kli22:36 shemelachto l'heter. Just work with me on this.22:37 We didn't get to that.22:38 We'll talk about that later on.22:39 A clock cannot be moved on Shabbat,22:41 even though it's made to tell time.22:43 Telling time on Shabbat, it's kli22:46 shemelachto l'heter. That's22:47 assur. The Chazon Ish also reiterates the same point.22:50 Rav Nissim Karelitz in Chut Shani,22:52 he goes a step further.22:54 Him and the Or Letzion both say22:56 that if you have a picture22:58 frame—what's a picture frame made for?23:00 It's made to show you a picture.23:02 If you have a beautiful picture frame23:04 that you set it on a wall23:06 and you won't move it from there,23:07 you set it on the wall, you nailed it in,23:09 that's it. That's its makom.23:11 Let's say, for example,23:12 you have a painting of the Kotel,23:14 you have a painting of your whole family,23:17 whatever it is,23:17 it's a big nice picture that you won't take off.23:20 If you set it on the wall,23:21 that becomes muktzeh machmat chesron kis.23:24 Which means,23:25 if it would fall on Shabbat,23:27 you cannot move it.23:29 You can't pick it up.23:30 Now, even though a picture frame is made23:33 to show, to display,23:34 and that's23:35 mutar. A lot of look at that picture on Shabbat.23:37 You're looking at the kotel,23:38 what's wrong?23:38 Some people, you know, when they pray,23:39 it's great. They're praying by the kotel,23:41 all right? So what's the problem here?23:43 And the answer is23:45 that since you set it,23:47 you designated it,23:48 it becomes muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.23:51 That's what the Or Letzion says,23:53 Rav Nissim Karelitz as well.23:55 Two more cases, two more examples.23:57 By the way, we have explanations for all this.23:59 Just work with—24:00 Another example, Rav Moshe Feinstein in Chelek Hei, siman chaf alef, ot zayin.24:07 He talks about tablecloth, fancy tablecloth that one will only use for a special, special guest.24:15 You know, if I come over. Now, if somebody will only use it only if a special guest will come over,24:19 then they'll take out this fancy tablecloth. Rav Moshe says, nah, since it's only made for a special, very, very important guest,24:25 you cannot move it on Shabbat for somebody who is not so important.24:31 To just regularly move it, to use it, you cannot use it. That's another example: tablecloth.24:36 What in the world is wrong with a tablecloth? A tablecloth. Tablecloth is made to cover the table.24:40 That's kli shemelachto l'heter. How are you making this now muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, seemingly?24:46 Finally, we have the Rama himself. The Rama brings down that if a person, let's say, I'll give you an example,24:54 modern-day example, let's say a person has in his basement, he has a store. He sells over there shirts, pants, whatever it is,25:00 but he sells them and he will never ever use them. He's very careful that he won't use them.25:05 They don't have to be expensive, but he's very careful that he won't use them.25:08 His kids need a shirt, say, Okay, we'll go buy it somewhere else. This is for sale, not for you.25:13 Or buy it. You know, that's how he is. He's very makpid. He's very careful with his merchandise.25:17 He has shirts and pants. Shirts, rabotai, is a shirt, kli shemelachto l'heter or l'isur? What's a shirt made for? To wear.25:25 Could you wear a shirt on Shabbat? Yeah. So it's a kli shemelachto l'heter. However, says the Rama, being that you have shirts that are made l'schorah, which are made25:33 to sell, he says even if they're made to be given as a present, you know, you have somebody's25:41 wedding and it's coming up in a month and you bought him this beautiful forty, fifty, I don't know, maybe a hundred-dollar shirt,25:49 you know, in the box, and it doesn't have to be gift-wrapped, but you have it there.25:54 You want to move it, you want to try it on, but you're designated to give to this guy as a gift,25:58 to this chatan as a gift. Since it's designated to be as a gift, says Menuchat HaAba, it becomes like these shirts in this person's26:06 basement that are made to sell and becomes muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. And this seems to contradict the rule26:14 that we said. In order to be muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, we said it has to be26:19 kli shemelachto l'isur. How in the world are you telling me now that, no, this is going to be muktzeh machmat chisaron kis anyway,26:26 even though it's a kli shemelachto l'heter? And the answer, the Chut HaShani answers a phenomenal answer,26:32 and this explains really the three examples, the first three examples that we gave:26:39 the case of the clock, the case of the picture frame—well, that's it, the two26:46 cases—the case of the clock and the case of the picture frame. And it matches also with the other ones,26:49 but he says it by these two cases. Says Rav Nissim Karelitz, in a case where I take an26:57 item and I don't care what the item is, if it's kli shemelachto l'heter or l'isur, if I designate it in a certain spot27:07 where I'm never going to use it, I took it out of all purposes, all uses, then—I mean all uses that is27:16 forever—then that's like a separate category, where it becomes like a separate category of muktzeh that I cannot use it at all.27:26 It's not like a kli shemelachto l'heter. No, it has nothing to do with kli shemelachto l'heter or27:31 kli shemelachto l'isur. It says, I took the picture frame and I put it on the wall, and I have in my head I will never ever use this.27:37 In my mind, I'm never going to take that picture frame off. I have a beautiful painting. Why would I take it off?27:42 It's not made to go and display to people. Already it does get on the wall. You want to watch it?27:46 Look from afar. Right? You can't use them. You just look at it.27:51 It's not made for anybody to touch. It's not made for anybody to see. It's not made for anybody to pick up and move.27:56 It's not like a small little picture frame that I'm putting on my piano, on my bookcase.28:00 I'm putting it on the wall that nobody is supposed to touch it.28:04 Likewise with the wall clock. Therefore, says the Chut Shani, therefore it makes it automatically.28:12 A separate category, it becomes like a muktzeh me'da'at. This is such a concept in28:17 halacha, where I put it completely out of my mind and I make it asur now for anybody to use,28:23 not for me, for anybody else. Therefore, if the item falls, I have no permission to move it,28:26 because in my mind, when Shabbat came in, this item is not for touching. This item is not for handling.28:31 It's made to be on the wall and just on the wall.28:34 That is also the opinion of the28:38 Minchat Shlomo, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach. He also goes with this opinion. If you kovea makom for it, it becomes28:43 muktzeh. And that explains why the Mishnah Berurah says if you put a clock on the wall, or the28:51 Chazon Ish, or the—what do we say?—or let's say yon, you put a picture frame, it becomes28:56 muktzeh. Why? Because it's not like I'm using it. It's not like29:00 kli shemelachto l'heter. Happens to be it is a kli shemelachto l'heter, but once I put it on the wall, I set it out of my mind.29:06 Nobody's going to touch it. It's no man's land.29:08 When it falls on Shabbat, you have to leave it there. You cannot move it.29:11 However, not everybody agrees on this.29:14 Hacham Ovadia brings a list of Acharonim that disagree with this rule,29:17 where they specifically point out if there is something— That is nikba29:24 makom, that you designate a place for it. It does not make it muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.29:29 And just to quote you a few Acharonim, some of the big names:29:32 Pnei Yehoshua, the Rosh Yosef, which happens to be the Pri Megadim,29:37 his peirush on Shas; the Chida in Shibolei Yosef, siman tzadi-zayin, ot chet, the last piece over there;29:43 and Rav Moshe Feinstein as well.29:45 Rav Moshe Feinstein says anything that's set on the wall for beauty29:49 and, you know, it's made to—of course, you hang up things on the wall,29:52 you don't plan to use it again—he said that does not make it into29:57 muktzeh. So therefore, although we said that there are those who explain30:02 that it could be that something that kli she'melachto l'heter will become muktzeh machmat chisaron kis30:06 when I designate a place for it,30:08 others disagree. Chacham Ovadia disagrees, and as well as Rav Moshe Feinstein,30:13 the Chida as well. The Chida actually says in strong words.30:16 The Chida says, regarding the wall clock, he says a wall clock that a person put up on the wall,30:21 he brings down the Acharonim that forbid it. He says you can't make up30:24 new—where do we find such a case? Where do we find such30:27 an issur in Chazal? Where do we find such an issur in Shulchan Aruch? We can't make up new30:31 issurim. Not only that, a lot of Acharonim question the source of this30:37 issur, keviut makom, that you should take something and designate a place for it.30:40 A lot of Acharonim question, where's the source for it? Where do we find30:42 in Shulchan Aruch that it talks that you designate a place for it?30:45 Designating a place for it does not make something30:49 muktzeh, according to these other30:51 Acharonim. Now, the only thing we didn't discuss yet—what do you mean, there's a Rama30:54 who says something that's made for selling,30:57 that everybody agrees, even if it's31:00 kli she'melachto l'heter, like we said, the example of the shirt. The person has shirts in his basement that he sells.31:05 We said everybody agrees that that's—what's the name.31:10 That's the Rama. The Rama says that becomes31:13 muktzeh even though it's31:15 kli she'melachto l'heter. And there, nobody disagrees. Everybody agrees that becomes muktzeh. How come?31:20 So the Menuchat Ahavah puts it in these words.31:22 He says, when it comes to items where a person should be Shabbat31:30 maktzehu mikoach she'mushba olam. On Shabbat, you set it aside that nobody is allowed to use it.31:36 In such a case, says the31:38 Menuchat Ahavah, that's why the shirts in this guy's basement become31:42 muktzeh. He designated that nobody should use it.31:45 Nobody is allowed to use it for any usage whatsoever.31:49 This only applies, by the way, to items that a person is selling,31:54 not to food that a person is selling.31:55 Let's say a person has in his basement a grocery store.31:58 On Shabbat, obviously he's not selling, but—32:00 Even though you have in your grocery store chips and food and all these other foods that you're planning to sell,32:04 if you want to go to your store and pick up some food to eat on Shabbat, that does not become32:10 muktzeh. Food does not become muktzeh. Like we said in the first class, food is not32:14 muktzeh. The only time food will become muktzeh is if you turn the food into merchandise,32:20 into items that are not for eating. For example, an etrog that you plan to sell32:25 for people to do the mitzvah of Arbaat Minim, you know, on Sukkot.32:30 People are not planning to eat it on Sukkot; they're planning to use it for a mitzvah.32:33 So now you turn the etrog, which is a food, into an item, an item for sale, and it's a very expensive lemon, right?32:39 So that is when the food could turn into muktzeh machmat chisaron kis because it's made for sale.32:46 Another example is matzah shemurah on Erev32:50 Pesach. Erev Pesach, you can't eat matzah until the night of the seder,32:53 and there also the matzah turns into a mitzvah.32:57 It's not a food anymore because I cannot eat it. I can only eat it that night,33:02 and it's also something that I'm very careful with,33:04 especially those, you know, you spend a lot of money on matzah. It doesn't have to be the money,33:07 but I'm very careful with my matzah shemurah that I will only use it for one purpose,33:12 and that is to eat it on the night of the seder.33:13 So that makes it also muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, even though it's a food.33:17 But again, I turn it into a merchandise, and I'm very careful from using it for any sort of usage.33:22 This is the explanation of the criteria for33:31 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. It has to be kli shemelachto l'isur first.33:33 If it's kli shemelachto l'heter, it does not become33:37 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. However, there's a machloket if I designate a place for it.33:42 There are some who hold that it becomes muktzeh even though it's a33:46 kli shemelachto l'heter, and those who disagree and they hold no, as long as kli shemelachto l'heter, it does not.33:51 But when it comes to items that are for sale,33:53 everybody agrees that it becomes33:57 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Personally, I have two questions on what we just said.34:00 If I was listening to myself, I would ask two questions.34:02 Question number one: according to those who permit it,34:05 according to those who say like Hacham Ovadia and the ones who are34:09 matir in the case where, let's say, the case where I took a picture frame and I put it on the wall,34:14 why are the people34:17 osrim? Because I designate a place for34:18 it, and they're hold designating a spot for it, even though I don't want to use it anymore,34:22 it doesn't make it34:24 muktzeh. What's the difference between a picture frame that I put up on the wall that I don't plan to use at all,34:29 and between the merchandise I have in my basement, I have shirts I want to sell,34:33 and I don't plan on using them at all, and I don't let anybody use them,34:37 even though on Shabbat now, let's say I give you a good example,34:40 I sell raincoats.34:41 It's the summer, okay, so they're on sale a little bit, but still I sell raincoats,34:45 and they're expensive, nice Calvin Klein, Gucci and Armani, and I got nice stuff in my basement.34:50 All of a sudden it rains. Summer rains, what kind of crazy weather is34:53 it? Okay, it is. That's what it is. It is what it is.34:56 You're gonna wear it or not, you wear it.34:57 So now I changed my mind. You know what?34:59 I'm gonna take for myself a nice Armani raincoat, and I'm gonna wear it to go to shul.35:05 Mutar or not mutar? Everybody will agree that's35:08 asur, because I have the raincoats in my basement for sale, and I don't plan on using them.35:12 I never plan on using them. I keep them just for sale.35:14 Now that it rained, all of a sudden I changed my mind, that item remains muktzeh. Why?35:18 Because in my mind when Shabbat came in, I designated it.35:23 Not designated, I made it in a way that nobody is supposed to use it.35:27 Why is this any different from the case of the picture frame on the wall?35:31 Same thing when I put up the picture frame on the wall.35:33 When Shabbat came in, in my mind that picture frame is not for use at all.35:37 What's the difference between this and that?35:39 That's question number one that I have,35:41 but no answer for these two questions.35:43 I'm saying the question out loud. If you have the same question, I agree with you. Don't ask it.35:47 Okay, if you have an answer for me, please call me after the show. I'd love to hear it.35:50 Question number two is the case of Rav Moshe Feinstein35:53 in chelek hei. I don't understand it.35:55 He says a tablecloth that's very, very, very chashuv, very, very important,35:59 that you only use when you have an important guest.36:03 It becomes muktzeh on Shabbat when you don't have that important guest.36:07 Why?36:08 I will use it if the important guest does come,36:10 so it's a36:13 kli she'melachto l'heter. And it's not even something that I'm36:15 kovea makom; he himself agrees that kviut makom, designating or putting it aside, does not make36:21 it muktzeh. Why is this muktzeh now all of a sudden?36:23 I did not understand. I was not zocheh to understand this case over here by Rav Moshe.36:28 If somebody could explain to me,36:30 also I'd appreciate it.36:32 You could call in at three36:35 o'clock, be'ezrat Hashem, I'll be here.36:35 Okay, let's get to the next point now36:39 in the halachot of muktzeh machmat chisaron kis.36:43 Although, even according to those that are oser the picture frame36:47 because you designated it on the wall,36:50 you have to know there's a difference between designating an item36:55 or if something is so precious that you'll keep it in this special spot.36:59 For example, let's say you have a crystal vase in your—37:04 you have a crystal vase,37:05 okay? A crystal vase is very, very expensive.37:07 You bought it, let's say, I don't know, you got it as a gift,37:10 whatever it is, it cost a thousand dollars.37:12 Baruch Hashem, your little kids37:14 are now— they graduated from being little babies, toddlers,37:17 and now they're jumping on the table,37:19 dancing, making a whole rikud on the table,37:21 Baruch Hashem. Mazal, great.37:22 Every time I walk in, I have to get my kids, each one, off the table.37:25 Come on, come on, one at a time.37:26 If I keep my crystal vase on the table,37:29 I am going to sit shiva for that crystal vase.37:32 It's not going to last.37:33 It's going to be gone in a second.37:35 So we'll wait. We'll keep this until the kids get married37:38 before they bring their grandchildren in the house.37:40 I take it now, and where do I place it?37:42 I place it now in a closet,37:44 away from people, from my kids touching it.37:47 I could put it maybe on display, right?37:51 But in an area, in a place like a museum,37:54 can't touch it.37:54 You can look at it; you can't touch it.37:56 Everybody agrees in that case37:58 that the crystal vase does not become38:02 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, even though I'm putting it in the spot.38:03 So it is, I'm not putting it in that spot38:06 because I— even those who38:09 will say that means I'm not putting it in that spot because I don't want anybody to use it for anything.38:11 No, of course I'll use it.38:13 I just don't have the opportunity.38:14 I'm protecting it.38:16 There's a difference between designating it in a certain spot38:19 that I'm never going to use it again,38:21 or because it's so precious,38:23 I have a special place for it.38:25 Having a special place for it to protect it38:28 does not turn an item into38:32 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Even though, rashi in the Gemara38:35 sounds like it seems like a condition.38:38 The Acharonim— Rashi in Masechet Shabbat says,38:40 he's regarding certain items, says,38:46 Hanah kapid alaihu, u'meyached lahem makom delo chazu l'melachet acheret. Certain items38:48 that are muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, says explains Rashi,38:49 because people are makpid on it,38:52 they care about it,38:53 and they designate a place for it,38:56 and therefore it's not ra'ui for a different38:59 melacha. The Acharonim explain this doesn't mean39:01 that meyached lahem makom is a condition.39:03 No, it's just a result of the fact that it's so expensive,39:06 people are careful with it.39:07 But it's not a condition in making something39:12 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, and it's not going to turn a regular item,39:14 kli she'melachto l'heter, into39:16 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Just wanted to point that point out.39:20 Next, and this is a big subject,39:21 and maybe from this39:24 we'll stop here. Right after this,39:26 let's see how long it takes us.39:27 I wanted to speak a little bit about39:29 the three weeks coming up39:30 and some of the halachot coming up.39:32 Let's start with the last question39:35 we're going to talk about today39:36 about39:37 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Next week, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll continue.39:38 We're not done with these halachot.39:41 Question is like this:39:43 electronics.39:45 What is the status of electronic devices39:49 on Shabbat?39:50 What are they?39:51 How do you categorize them?39:53 We already learned,39:54 kli she'melachto l'heter, you can move it39:55 for as long as you have a purpose for it.39:58 Kli she'melachto l'isur, you can only move it39:59 if you...40:00 You need the item itself to use it for something that's mutar, or if you need its place. And finally, we learned today about40:07 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, which means an item40:11 that's made, that's so precious, and you're careful not to use it for something else.40:15 You cannot move it for any purpose. Question is, what about electronic devices? Today40:19 it's all over. Everything, almost everything that we have in the house will be in this category. It's electronics: your phone, your40:25 CDs, your radio,40:27 your—think of everything. I don't know, next will be our belts will start buzzing. You know, they have watches, the iPhone watch,40:32 you know, everything. Regular watch, by the way, is also electronics.40:36 It has a battery. Who cares, right? It doesn't have to be iPhone. How do you categorize now40:41 electronic devices?40:43 So guess what? Whatever answer you said, you're probably right.40:46 We find in the poskim, some say that electronics are40:50 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. That's number one. Number two, some say that's kli shemelachto l'isur. And we find even opinions that say40:56 kli shemelachto l'heter. It's possible some items, some electronic devices will also be kli shemelachto l'heter. Let's explain.41:04 Muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, this is universal. Everybody will agree on this. If you have an electronic device41:09 that's made for something that you cannot do on Shabbat, and41:13 you're very careful from allowing your kids to play with it, you're careful from giving it out randomly to other people,41:20 you're very, very careful with it,41:22 so then that becomes—by the way, you might lend it to people,41:25 but you're very careful in how they use41:27 it—then that becomes muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. An example is you have a brand new laptop,41:32 and you don't let the kids watch on the laptop. You give them the old laptop to watch their Uncle Moishy and Twins from France.41:37 You don't let them watch on this new laptop. So that, your new laptop that you just got, the Note, or maybe I'm41:45 too old-fashioned, I don't know what's out there, okay, but you won't let them use it. You got a brand new iPad, right? iPad 75.41:51 So now you're not going to let anybody use it. You just bought it for $7,000. That is41:57 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Same thing, by the way, a new phone when it's first on the market, the new Samsung, the new42:02 iPhone 6, all these things, when it first comes out, people are very careful. They won't let the kids play with it42:07 till, you know, the kids take it over. But then you have something like42:12 BlackBerry, alav hashalom. You know, those old phones that nobody uses anymore. They're smartphones, but you let the kids play with it.42:18 You know, it's like a dummy phone almost, but you paid for it,42:21 so chaval, let the kids use it. In any case.42:24 Those types of phones where people are very, very careful from letting their kids play with it, or,42:29 you know, obviously not going to use it for something else.42:31 You're not going to use your cell phone, even a BlackBerry, to hold up your window,42:36 or if your table's shaking, you're not going to put your BlackBerry under it, obviously. That's not going to make42:40 it muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Muktzeh machmat chisaron kis is that you're careful, very, very careful, from42:45 using it in a way that might get it ruined. If a special case on it, you take care of it,42:52 that is muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. This is universal. All the poskim will agree on this.42:57 Now, here's where it gets a little complicated.42:59 If it's made—oh, now you know what? The next case, the next case:43:04 kli shemelachto l'isur. The next category we find, if something is made for issur, like a cell phone,43:10 even if it's not hashubi, but a cell phone is made that you should dial on and talk on it.43:14 That's asur on Shabbat. Or a regular house phone, the Panasonic or the Sony, whatever it is, those phones,43:19 they're not muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Haraayah, and the proof is, people throw it all around.43:24 You sometimes have to look for the phone and you find it under the couch, in between this, that. It's all over the place.43:30 It might even be in the toilet bowl sometimes, right? It's all over the place. You're not makpid on it. You're not careful with it43:37 that the kids should not use it, that somebody should only use it in a specific way. You don't have to be, you know,43:44 a crazy man and go into the bathtub with it, obviously. Nobody wants any item to get ruined.43:50 You wouldn't jump with your suit into a pool. That doesn't make43:56 your suit muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. So just because you don't jump into the pool with a regular phone doesn't mean it's going to become44:02 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. What it means is that44:06 I'm careful to only use it in a specific way. A house phone, people are not so careful with it.44:11 They let it fall on the floor, they let it go. They don't like it, but if it happens, they don't go crazy.44:16 So therefore, a house phone,44:19 according—should be kli shemelachto l'isur, but here we have a little bit of a disagreement.44:25 It is a kli shemelachto l'isur according to the majority of44:29 the Acharonim. The Grot Moshe,44:31 Rav Elyashiv, Shemirat Shabbat Kehilchata, Chacham Ovadia, Chut HaShani, Chut Shani. All of them hold44:38 it's a kli שמלאכתו לאיסור. However,44:40 last week you mentioned, in a case where you have a44:45 kli שמלאכתו לאיסור, where you have no heter for it, you can't use it for anything that's44:50 mutar, does it automatically make it44:54 asur to move it, מחמה גופו? Let's take, for example, you have a Blackberry or a house phone.44:59 What could you use a house phone for? To call.45:02 So it's a kli שמלאכתו לאיסור. Is there any reason why you would be able to use a house phone on Shabbat45:08 להיתר? Could you think of any way? He says, no. What do you use a phone for? Just to call.45:13 It's not made in a way that I can use it for anything else.45:16 So we said that there was a machloket between Rishonim as well as Acharonim. If45:21 this item becomes now like a regular45:26 kli שמלאכתו לאיסור, although I don't have a צורך גופו, but I have a צורך מקומו, I can move it if it's on45:30 my chair, or does it become now a more stringent level of45:36 מוקצה, which makes it מוקצה מחמת חסרון כיס? That's what we mentioned last week, and45:42 the same will apply here.45:44 Those who forbid,45:46 like Be'er Moshe, says since electronic devices don't have any other uses except for that which is45:53 asur, so it becomes like מוקצה מחמת חסרון כיס. You can't even move it45:57 לצורך מקומו. However, we mentioned last week, Chacham Ovadia, and it's the opinion also of the Rashba and Ritva, that such an46:04 item, like a house phone,46:05 it's just a kli שמלאכתו לאיסור. If you come to sit on your chair or on the couch and you find that the phone46:11 is there and you need to sit in that spot, you could pick it up and move it out of the way, no problem.46:16 Here, the next case, the next opinion, which is46:20 electronic devices to be kli שמלאכתו להיתר, this already is a little bit more shaky.46:26 Chut HaShani brings, and a lot of other Acharonim also bring this way.46:30 They hold that46:33 electronic devices, since they're made46:36 in a way that they only function through electricity, whether you plug it into the wall or they're operating through a battery,46:44 so then it becomes46:46 kli shemelachto l'isur. Even though its main function might be46:51 l'heter. Classic case is, I have a clock. I have a clock,46:56 okay? It doesn't have to be a wall clock. Let's not make a wall clock where I leave it on the wall.46:59 But you know those alarms, what do you call it, a desk clock, I think they call it. Help me out over here,47:05 okay? So they have like a regular thing, you know, it tells me time. It's made to tell time. That's what it's made for.47:11 It's a digital clock that I put on my desk. It's made to tell me time. It tells me three o'clock, two47:16 o'clock. Beautiful. It's plugged into the wall.47:18 So according to47:22 Chut Shani, Rav Nissim Karelitz, and a few other47:25 Acharonim, since—even though, no, sorry—even though it's made to tell me time,47:30 it doesn't make a difference. Since it only operates through electricity, and that is assur to be done on Shabbat, so therefore makes it47:39 muktzeh that's in the category of47:42 kli shemelachto l'isur. However, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach disagrees. In Minchat Shlomo he writes,47:46 no, we don't look on the item of how it functions. We look at it of why. What's its purpose?47:54 What is the purpose of this clock? To tell me time. Am I allowed to look at time on Shabbat?48:00 Yes, so that's mutar.48:02 It's a48:04 kli she'melachto l'heter. I just have to be careful when I move electronic devices48:06 that I shouldn't do48:07 issur, for example, plugging it out of the wall,48:10 pressing the wrong button, or if lights turn on.48:12 But it's not going to make48:15 it kli she'melachto l'issur just because it works through electricity,48:17 and that is also the opinion of Rav Moshe Feinstein.48:19 I know I'm running a little bit short on time,48:22 but I have to read this for you.48:24 It's a48:26 teshuva in Chelek He, siman chav gimmel, because I saw a very, very good book48:28 that I look at it and it's very good.48:30 It's a book written in English.48:31 I believe he was also a very close student of Rav Moshe Feinstein,48:34 but he quoted Rav Moshe Feinstein48:36 in a way that's against this48:39 teshuva. Therefore, I want to read this48:40 teshuva and to clarify what it says in48:45 the great Moshe, the opinion of Rav Moshe Feinstein.48:47 He says like this,48:48 in this teshuva, by the way, is in48:53 Orach Chaim, Chelek He, siman chav gimmel, a very short48:54 teshuva. He48:54 says, Hinei katavti kama pe'amim b'inyan zeh. I already wrote about this subject,49:01 v'chen pirsamti daati ba'al peh l'ma'aseh b'inyan zeh. And I also publicized my49:03 opinion verbally about this item, this idea.49:08 Ukvar hem devarim mefursamim v'yedu'im, and everybody knows about it.49:12 Aval, me'achar she'ra'inu she'kin ra'ah yesh kein mevuchah b'shitati. He says49:13 some people pointed out49:15 that there's a little bit of confusion49:16 of my opinion, like the way I wrote it.49:19 He brings the sources in49:26 Chelek Gimmel and Chelek Daled. Al ken, bikashti sheyaatiku devarim elu b'zeh halashon kedei lefarsem daati b'sifri haba. Therefore, I requested that they write down,49:30 record down my exact opinion49:32 regarding electronical devices.49:34 And here I quote Rav Moshe Feinstein's words.49:36 He says,49:41 Hinei keli hashmal, hagam shepo'alim al yedei hashmal. Electronic devices,49:42 even though they operate49:43 through electricity,49:47 umchubarim lahashmal, and they're connected to49:48 electricity, afilu meratz hashmal, even a lamp with a light,49:56 lema'aseh einam mukseh bShabbat. However, at the end of the day,49:58 they're not considered mukseh, umutar l'taltelam. You're allowed to move them,50:04 ela im ken hem kelim she'osim bahem melachah, unless they are utensils50:07 that are made to do a melachah with them.50:13 Aval, im pe'ulatam eina melekhet Shabbat. However,50:14 if they're made for not50:17 a melachah on Shabbat,50:19 which means they're not made to do50:20 melachah with them on Shabbat,50:27 ein hachshivan kimlechto l'isur, mehachamat shemekablim kocham al yedei davar ha'asui kemo chashmal. You can't consider them50:29 a kli shemelachto l'isur just because they are energized50:32 through electricity,50:33 which is asur.50:35 The davar shemelachto l'isur, because when we say50:37 in50:41 halachah davar shemelachto l'isur, פירושו דבר שעושים בו איסור. The meaning is50:42 it's an item that you do50:44 an issur with it,50:48 ולא דבר שנעשה על ידי איסור. It's not an item50:49 that works50:50 through something that's asur.50:54 ורק צריך להיזהר שלא להפרידם מחיבורם לחשמל. The only thing is50:55 one has to be careful,50:58 when you move them,50:59 not to disconnect them51:01 from where they're plugged in,51:02 from the electricity.51:05 ומי שרוצה להחמיר על עצמו יותר, he says51:06 if a person wants to be more51:07 machmir on himself,51:08 he says,51:11 הגם שאני בעצמי איני נוהג כן, even though personally,51:12 he says, Moshe,51:13 I don't do it,51:14 הרשות בידו, of course you can be51:19 machmir. אך יש לדעת שלכל הפחות מותר לטלטל גם כלי חשמל לצורך גופו ומקומו. However, you should know,51:23 but it shouldn't be any worse51:24 than51:25 kli shemelachto l'isur, and therefore51:26 it should be able to move it,51:29 even a lamp,51:32 לצורך גופו ומקומו. אבל עיין לעיל סימן כב. However, in51:33 parentheses I bring over here51:35 that it seems to be that he says51:37 when it comes to a light,51:39 a lamp, something else, we'll talk about that a different time.51:48 ונוגע למנשק להבת טל לצורך מקומו, אז שגם אם צריך שהמקום שעליו הולך האור כעת יהיה חשוך, נמי מקרי צורך מקומו. Also included in what's51:51 called the tzorech mekomo, if you need that place to be dark,51:54 that's also51:55 called the51:56 tzorech mekomo. That's the end of the51:58 teshuva. I wanted to read this to stress52:00 that Moshe's opinion is52:02 that if something is electronic,52:05 but it's made52:06 leheter, which means it's made that52:09 people—something that's mutar on Shabbat.52:11 The classic case is a clock.52:13 It's digital,52:15 it's electricity,52:16 it operates through plugging it in,52:18 but it's made for something that's mutar.52:19 It's mutar to move it on Shabbat,52:22 like kli shemelachto leheter. However, one has to be careful.52:24 When we give these heterim, you have to be careful52:26 that you have to know your audience,52:28 you have to know who's around you.52:29 If by moving this clock,52:32 people might be52:33 mezalzel more, people don't understand the reason why you're doing it,52:35 and they might come to be matir more things,52:37 they might come52:39 to move things that really asur, then you should be52:42 machmir. We're giving over here52:43 a kulah halacha, but you have to be smart52:45 and wise in how you apply the52:48 halacha, that it shouldn't cause,52:50 chas v'shalom, people to do issurim52:51 based on the halacha that you're doing.52:53 We're going to have to stop here.52:55 We have a few minutes left. I have to speak about52:57 what's coming up.53:00 This Shabbat is53:01 the 17th of53:04 Tammuz, which means we're beginning53:06 the three weeks known as bein hametzarim.53:08 So there's going to be a fast.53:10 It's supposed to be really53:11 Yud-Zayin b'Tammuz. We're supposed to have a taanit of the53:13 17th of Tammuz on Shabbat.53:15 Of course, we can't fast on Shabbat.53:17 The only time we fast on Shabbat is53:19 Yom Kippur, and therefore53:21 the fast will be pushed off53:24 until the following day on Sunday.53:26 Also,53:27 Tish'a B'Av will fall on Shabbat, and again,53:29 we won't fast on Shabbat. It will be pushed off until53:31 Sunday. Let me give you quickly the times53:34 and a few quick53:35 halachot. Next week we'll talk more about the halachot of the three weeks,53:38 and in two weeks' time, I guess we'll53:39 talk about all the other halachot of53:41 Rosh Chodesh Av, as well as53:43 the—this year we don't have53:46 Shavuah shechal bo, according to most opinions we don't have it.53:47 We'll talk about all the other halachot later on.53:50 Tell you first,53:52 Sunday, July 5th,53:54 fast begins53:56 at alot hashachar. The calendar I follow,53:57 it says alot hashachar is 454:00 a.m. If you have a different calendar,54:02 hazaku baruch, follow the calendar that you have or your rav has.54:04 But the calendar that I have, Hacham Yosef's calendar,54:06 is 454:08 a.m. Fast finishes around 40 minutes,54:10 around 40 minutes after54:12 shkia, which is around54:14 9:10 p.m. Shkia is at54:17 8:29. Everybody is obligated to54:18 fast. Means to say everybody54:20 that's healthy and above the age of bar mitzvah.54:22 This goes for men and women.54:24 The people exempt from fasting54:26 are women who are pregnant54:29 or women that are54:31 actively nursing.54:32 Means not that they could nurse, but they're actively nursing.54:35 They're actually nursing their kids.54:37 Doesn't mean that you have to54:38 nurse the child on the54:40 day of the fast. It just means that you normally54:42 nurse your child, even a little bit.54:44 Even if you nurse and you also54:46 give him a bottle, you'll be exempt from the fast.54:49 There are other opinions54:50 that hold that54:52 as long as a woman has given birth54:55 within two years,54:57 then even though she's54:59 not actively nursing, the kid is not nursing anymore55:00 or the kid is taking bottles all the time,55:03 since the body is weaker,55:05 she's exempt from fasting.55:06 Hacham Ovadia used to hold that way.55:08 However, later on he changed his opinion,55:11 was chozer. He rules that55:13 the woman has to be actively nursing.55:14 But there are still opinions out there.55:16 There are big rabbis that hold that a woman55:18 has given birth within the last two years,55:20 she's exempt from fasting. Ask55:22 your local rav what you follow.55:25 Just remember, Hacham Ovadia was55:26 chozer. Next, usually55:28 a person who got married, let's say this week,55:31 when it comes to Sunday,55:32 he should be obligated in fasting.55:34 He's obligated to fast on55:35 Yud-Zayin B'Tammuz. But being that this year the fast really55:38 falls on Shabbat, but we just55:40 pushed it to Sunday,55:42 it's called nidcha. In that case,55:45 that gives55:46 chatanim an exemption.55:48 And chatanim, that means, what is the definition of55:50 a chatan? A chatan means anybody within his seven days of55:54 sheva brachot, and of course the kallah as well,55:56 they're exempt from fasting this year55:58 because it's55:59 a fast.56:01 That's nidcha. Other people that are exempt from the fast are people who are sick.56:04 Sick means to say he's bedridden.56:06 He has to be in bed,56:08 choleh she'ein bo sakana. Examples are people who have a high fever,56:11 people who are on antibiotics,56:13 especially if the doctor tells you don't fast, you don't fast.56:15 It's important to know that even though you might qualify to be on the list,56:19 it's always good to check with your rav or your rabbi to decide if you're exempt or not.56:26 Don't just jump the gun and say, I'm56:28 exempt. And by the way, it goes the other way as well.56:30 You might be exempt, and don't be too machmir on yourself either.56:34 You want to be machmir, that's Yom Kippur, Tisha B'Av, okay.56:38 But on these kind of fasts, before you're machmir—not that you can't56:42 be—but before you're machmir, call up your rabbi and double check with him,56:46 because if it's a health situation, it's something that you could,56:50 chas v'shalom, risk a danger to your health, then it's not worth it.56:54 Beginning from Motzaei Shabbat, that is, we're beginning from already Motzaei Shabbat,57:00 we cannot listen to music anymore.57:02 We don't make—what's it called?—we don't make weddings,57:07 even though this is a minhag that's really brought down by the57:11 Rama. According to Shulchan Aruch, you can have weddings up to Rosh Chodesh Av.57:14 But most of the Sefardi Acharonim have already discussed it,57:19 and they said that our minhag is like the57:21 Rama, and therefore we don't make any weddings or music in these three weeks57:27 beginning Motzaei Shabbat.57:28 We'll discuss this a little bit more in the future.57:30 One last point I want to point out:57:32 Maran does bring the following words. He says,57:34 Tzarich lehizaher miyud zayin b'Tammuz57:36 ad Tisha B'Av shelo lehachyedim arba57:41 sha'ot ad tesha sha'ot, v'lo yekol tabinim mimahem. You have to be careful coming up,57:43 in the, mean to say, in these three weeks,57:46 not to do dangerous activities,57:48 because there's a certain demon called Keteb Meriri,57:52 and therefore one has to be careful not to hit the children too hard.57:54 In those back days, when they used to hit the kids to train them.57:57 Nowadays, we have to tell the kids,57:58 don't hit your parents too hard, you know what I'm saying?58:00 But in any case, be careful.58:02 Personally, I don't recommend swimming.58:04 I personally don't like to go swimming.58:06 The kids do go swimming in camp; there's no problem.58:08 According to halacha, there's no problem to go swimming whatsoever.58:12 But again, it has nothing to do with58:14 halacha, but out of dangerous activities,58:16 one should try to be very, very careful in these weeks.58:19 We'll stop here,58:20 b'ezrat Hashem. We'll see you next week on Wednesday afternoon,58:23 b'ezrat Hashem. We'll continue58:25 Hilchot Muktzeh and the laws of the three weeks.58:27 I want to give thanks to Iran, Nissim, and Yossi,58:34 who—good enough,58:36 okay—who is here helping us in the studio.58:37 If you have any questions, you could call in right now,58:42 718-683-5858, and we'd love to hear from you58:44 and answer any questions that you have.58:46 Till then, have a wonderful week, and Shabbat shalom.