Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRoot Radio here on—not Halacha Hour, sorry, let's start again.0:08 Welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio. This is the Halacha Hour airing live on Wednesday afternoon.0:15 I believe it is Chaf Hei Bet Tevet, it is Chaf Hei Bet Tevet, and it's January 6th.0:23 We're airing live at 2 o'clock, be'ezrat Hashem. Let's give you the phone numbers before we actually start.0:29 This is the Halacha Hour. We're discussing the halachot of Shabbat.0:33 If you'd like to call in for any questions regarding the halachot of Shabbat or muktzeh or halachot in general,0:39 please call in after the show at 3 o'clock. The number to the studio is0:44 718-683-5858. We'll give it to you again at the end of the show.0:47 To text in your question, which is usually the best way, we get to see it,0:51 we see if it's something that's shayach, that's relevant to the subject that we're speaking about,0:56 we'll bring it up. If you have a question on what we're saying, you text in your question,0:59 be'ezrat Hashem, we'll bring it up in the middle of the show. The text number is1:07 347-927-8398. Before we get to our class, we'd like to wish a big mazal tov, mabruk, for the simcha tonight of the man behind this radio station,1:19 Rav Nissim Lazari. We all know what he does for the station.1:23 The whole thing is mamash, as they say, tzaddik yesod olam. For over1:27 here, Nissim is the yesod of the whole station. The whole thing stands on him,1:31 and we should have a lot of simcha, be'ezrat Hashem, the engagement of his daughter tonight, Hila, to Yehuda Cohen,1:37 who happened to be living down the block from me.1:39 So, baruch Hashem, it's a big simcha,1:41 and be'ezrat Hashem should help them to get married b'sha'ah tovah and to1:49 be boneh beit ne'eman b'Yisrael, with many children and many1:55 simchot, be'ezrat Hashem, Torah and osher b'beit echad, be'ezrat Hashem. And if you're listening to this, it's going to be on tonight again also at 102:01 o'clock. Don't forget, you're probably, if you're, you know, at the engagement, a lot of people sometimes may forget,2:04 you know, they're on the way back from house. So maybe I figured this could serve as a reminder,2:08 if not for the people, maybe for myself as well.2:11 In any case, we come back to the halacha. In the halacha, we talk about the halachot of Shabbat2:17 specifically from the book, the Ben Ish Chai, we're in Parashat Vayigash,2:22 and we began to discuss a very important subject.2:26 The subject is the halachot of transforming muktzeh into kli shemelachto leheter.2:34 We mentioned in the past that the most severe category of muktzeh, that is muktzeh machmat gufo.2:45 This form of category is as its name is, muktzeh. It's completely muktzeh because of itself.2:52 Itself is nothing. It has no usage. You can't use it for anything:2:56 stones, pebbles, sand, dirt. These kind of things don't have a3:00 use. They're not a keli, and being that they're not a keli, being they're not a utensil, they don't serve for anything,3:05 they have the strongest level of muktzeh machmat gufo.3:08 We mentioned last week this parashah primarily deals with the subject of muktzeh machmat gufo,3:14 which happens to be in3:16 Hilchot Muktzeh. These are the most complicated halachot when we're dealing with muktzeh machmat gufo.3:20 It's not as relevant in our days as it was in those days.3:24 Like we mentioned last week, in our days, whatever you want, you can go to the 99-cent store,3:30 you go to any of those, you know, those kind of stores, and you can find whatever you want.3:35 There's something that they make for it.3:36 Once upon a time, the Gemara talks about, for example, they used to have this big log of wood in order to lock up the door.3:42 No one uses logs of wood to lock up the door.3:45 We'll talk about what we do use3:47 in our days. In any case, but you don't use a log of wood to lock a door. You know what you use? A lock,3:51 right? And a lock has—it's a3:53 keli. You want to hold up the door, you want to keep the door open,3:55 you don't use a stone to hold the door open.3:58 You know what you use? A door stopper.4:00 You have all different types of door stoppers as well:4:03 ones that attach to the door, one of those rubber things that you put on the bottom.4:06 There's so many things that we have in our days to— Do what we need to do,4:12 that really these kind of halachot seem to be a little bit outdated,4:16 but they're really not, because they do come up.4:19 And because they do come up, and because it's also part of4:22 Hilchot Muktzeh, the rules are still relevant.4:26 They do come up, and when they do come up, we have to know how to deal with it and what should we do.4:31 We spoke a lot about it last week.4:33 We are not going to go through the halacha inside, even though we didn't go through halacha inside also last week.4:37 We'll just review a little bit of the rules that we mentioned last week,4:41 and then go on to the things, the areas of this halacha that we have not spoken.4:47 So again, the rule is over here, what we're trying to discuss, the rule of transforming,4:54 taking something which is muktzeh machmat gufo,4:56 where it would be forbidden to move it in any which way,4:58 not l'tzorech gufo, not5:01 l'tzorech mekomo. Of course, ikar ha-din is always mutar for anything that's5:04 muktzeh, because the whole gezeirah of muktzeh, a lot of people get mixed up with this,5:08 the whole gezeirah of muktzeh is for you to move it in a normal way.5:12 Once you're moving it in an abnormal way, not the normal way that people would move it,5:17 then it's not subject to the laws of5:21 muktzeh. Laws of muktzeh, the restriction of muktzeh is only moving something in a normal way.5:24 Let me give you two examples.5:27 Most common, let's take a dollar.5:29 You have a dollar on your kitchen table.5:32 You want to pick it up, you want to move it.5:33 So a dollar is muktzeh machmat gufo,5:35 so you cannot pick up the dollar with your hand.5:38 However, if you are a little bit skilled, you'll take off your shoe, you take off your sock,5:43 and with your toes you'll grab onto the dollar and change it.5:48 Now, probably a dollar is not going to be worth your effort.5:50 You know, just keep the dollar there, and who cares if somebody takes it and gets lost.5:53 But let's say it's a hundred-dollar bill, right?5:55 A hundred-dollar bill.5:56 Some people might even use their own hands,5:58 chas v'shalom. But a hundred-dollar bill, that calls for some maneuvering to do.6:03 You take off your shoe, you take off your sock, you want to move it with your toes.6:07 It's mutar,6:08 even though you're moving muktzeh with the intention of moving it to—it's fine.6:12 You're not carrying outside.6:13 You're just picking up with your toes, and you want to put it wherever you want to put it.6:16 That's fine.6:17 Muktzeh does not kick in.6:20 However, in a case where you have, let's say, a soccer ball,6:22 we did not get to balls and toys,6:25 bezrat Hashem, we hope to get to it either this class or in the next class coming up.6:29 We will talk about toys in general.6:31 So let's say you have a soccer ball or a basketball.6:33 You have them lying around in the house.6:35 The kids didn't put them away,6:36 and now you want to move the soccer ball.6:38 You want to put it away.6:39 You want to put it in the attic, in the basement, in the closet, whatever it is.6:43 It shouldn't be there.6:44 So you obviously can't pick it up with your hands.6:47 According to the opinions that hold that balls6:49 are muktzeh, and to kick it also is not mutar.6:51 Why?6:51 Because that's the normal way of moving a soccer ball, which is kicking it.6:56 So when we say that you're allowed to move something with your foot,7:00 it doesn't always mean with your foot.7:02 Kelachar yad doesn't always mean something in the back of your hand.7:05 Kelachar yad, when the halacha brings down, you're allowed to move7:09 muktzeh, 100%7:10 muktzeh. Muktzeh has no heter to move it.7:12 When you're allowed to move it, kelachar yad, it means in an abnormal way,7:16 not in the normal way that's usually moved.7:18 So the soccer ball, since nobody would usually pick it up with their elbows,7:22 you're allowed to pick it up with your elbows.7:24 That's not the way to carry a soccer ball,7:26 right?7:27 Or a football is usually kicked,7:29 right?7:30 It's not people throw the football and people also kick the7:34 football. So in that case, you'll have to move it with your elbows7:37 if you want to get rid of and move it out of the way.7:40 Here we're discussing7:41 our halachot now. We come to muktzeh machmat gufo,7:44 that you want to make it into7:47 kli shemelachto l'heter, basically transform it.7:49 You now use it for a certain function.7:51 So we have to know certain rules.7:53 Number one is that whatever status the item comes into Shabbat,7:59 that's the way.8:01 It remains throughout the whole Shabbat. Meaning, if something came into Shabbat categorized according to halacha as muktzeh machmat gufo, or let's say muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, whatever it is, that's the way it remains throughout Shabbat.8:13 And even if you change your mind on it and you want to now use it for something else, it doesn't make a difference.8:20 It remains the same status as the way it came into Shabbat.8:24 Otherwise, you could throw out all the halachot of8:28 muktzeh. L'mashal, a guy has a shechita knife, a knife that's only used for shechita, and he's careful with it.8:36 It costs $135 wholesale, and he's careful that it shouldn't be used for anything except for shechita, to slice the neck of the animal in a kosher way.8:49 He's scared that it shouldn't get ruined, and it's not like a regular kitchen knife that you use to cut your boxes that you get from your grocery.8:55 So now, in such a case where a guy is using a shechita knife—excuse me—he has a shechita knife in the house,9:01 and all of a sudden on Shabbat it occurs to him that his knives are all dairy. He doesn't have any meat knives,9:08 and now he decides, you know what? I have a shechita knife. Let me use it to cut my steak.9:13 Even then he says, Oh, it's going to ruin your shechita knife. He doesn't care.9:16 You know what? He's getting a new shipment of shechita knives. He doesn't care anymore about it.9:21 It doesn't make a difference, since it will remain muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, since that's the way it came into Shabbat. That's the way it remains.9:30 In order to transform the status of any muktzeh from one category to another, it must be done before Shabbat comes in.9:41 Again, it must transform the status of anything that's muktzeh into a status of kli she'melachto l'heter, where you want to move it, be able to use it on Shabbat.9:52 It must be done before Shabbat comes in.9:58 Okay, next. We saw last week that there are three ways to transform something from muktzeh into kli shemelachto l'heter, of course, before Shabbat.10:08 Number one, which is, I'm going in the list, there's three ways.10:12 The three ways, I'm listing first what we call most aggressive way, which is basically the most machmir, and then we're going lighter and lighter.10:21 Number one is designation through action. You actually have to do some sort of action before Shabbat that shows you want to use this for,10:29 or you want to basically transform this muktzeh machmat gufo into10:35 a kli shemelachto l'heter. We're going to use a mashal of the following.10:38 A person is making an extension in his backyard, and part of his extension, he's putting bricks around that extension,10:46 okay? So now the bricks are made to put in the building.10:50 Those, you know, I'm talking about those small little bricks on the outside, they're nice.10:53 So those bricks normally have the status of muktzeh machmat gufo, since they're made for building.11:00 Now it comes on Shabbat and he says, you know, it's going to be a chaday. I still didn't install my ACs, and I would like to have some air inside.11:08 So he decides to take a brick, and he decides to put it as a door stopper,11:16 okay? If you're going to do this on Shabbat, it's a problem, like we said.11:19 You can't decide to change your mind about the brick on Shabbat. You have to do it before Shabbat.11:23 So there are three ways to do this before Shabbat.11:26 We're going to list what the three possibilities are, and then we're going to tell you what lemaaseh today, what we need to do.11:32 The three ways are: number one is designating it with action.11:36 Actually, you have to come on Friday or any day beforehand, take the brick and do something,11:42 put it on the side. Maybe some say even chip it, but do something to the brick that shows that you're going to place it as a...11:54 as a doorstopper, make it into a11:56 doorstopper. The other way is, the other way is thinking about it.12:01 What does that mean, thinking about it?12:03 That means you think that before Shabbat comes in on Friday, you look at your bricks in the backyard and you say,12:11 Oh, that stone, I want to use it as a12:15 doorstopper. So here we have a machloket between the Mishnah Berurah and Ben Ish Chai in this form of designation.12:20 According to the Mishnah Berurah, just thinking that you want to use the brick as a doorstopper allows you to use it as a12:29 doorstopper. However, according to the Ben Ish Chai, thinking alone doesn't help.12:33 You actually have to speak it out.12:38 You have to say, I want to use this brick here tomorrow to use it as a12:44 doorstopper. That's the second form.12:45 Third way is like this:12:48 Shabbat comes in,12:49 you forgot to designate anything,12:51 but then happens to be that on the previous Wednesday, by accident,12:55 you used a brick that you see right in front of you.12:59 You used a specific brick as a13:02 doorstopper. The fact that you used it, according to certain categories of13:08 muktzeh, the fact that you used it alone allows you to use it now on Shabbat,13:13 even though you didn't think about it, you didn't plan on using this brick on Shabbat,13:17 even though you didn't designate it, actually you didn't prepare it.13:22 Just the mere fact that you used it beforehand, it's good enough.13:26 Those are the opinions that are brought down,13:29 and we saw last week that it all depends what kind of things you're using,13:33 if it's common for it or not.13:36 Lemaskana, bottom line, halacha lemaaseh, practically speaking,13:41 whenever you want to use anything that's13:44 muktzeh machmat gufo, that you want to change it into a13:48 kli shemelachto l'heter, being that today, like we mentioned, this is not so common,13:51 but if it does come up that you see pieces of wood or, you know, to balance the table,13:57 to balance your chair, to balance a bookcase,13:59 or if you have bricks that you have for building14:02 and now all of a sudden you want to use it for holding the door open,14:06 in all these cases what you have to do is the following:14:09 you should be machmir like designating it with an action,14:13 which means preparing the brick, the piece of wood that you want to use.14:17 And you have to have in mind that you're using this for all time.14:22 You're using this as a doorstopper until you don't need it anymore.14:27 It shouldn't be just for one Shabbat, meaning14:29 you shouldn't have in mind that I'm going to use the brick as a doorstopper this Shabbat,14:33 and then when Shabbat is over, I'm going to take the brick,14:36 put it back in the pile to use it in the building.14:38 In that case, we have to be14:41 machmir. You have to say, you have to have in mind that you plan to use this brick always as a doorstopper,14:46 since today nobody usually uses a brick as a doorstopper.14:50 Let me give you another example that really it would work,14:55 even without designating forever.14:57 I'll tell you why you'll see in a second.14:58 You know they have these glass sliding doors,15:02 like most people have them going out to the balcony.15:05 So sometimes people have these sliding doors in the backyard,15:09 and they want to lock it up at night.15:10 Besides the regular lock, even if somebody breaks the lock,15:13 they don't want them to be able to break the lock and go into the house.15:16 So what they do is they take a piece of wood,15:18 it can be a two by four, it can be just a regular stick15:21 that's the same size as the door that's not being15:25 open, and they place it in between the doorpost and on the inside of the door.15:33 So this way, when the piece of wood is there, it kind of blocks the door to open.15:38 You can't open it.15:38 Even if you break the lock or the lock is not working,15:41 you can't get the door open because this piece of wood is there.15:44 You find this also sometimes in hotels.15:46 They have it with a piece of metal. It's the same idea.15:49 So let's say you go to Home Depot,15:51 I'm not advertising anybody,15:52 whatever, you go, you go to a local wood store and you ask them to cut a piece of wood with the size of your door.16:00 That's good enough. Even though a piece of wood is really muktzeh machmat gufo,16:04 but since you wanted the saw and you bought it special for that, you cut it for that,16:08 then automatically it turns into kli16:10 shemelachto l'heter. You're allowed to move this piece of wood for whatever need you have,16:13 not only just to lock the door, but even if you want to move this piece of wood16:17 because it doesn't look nice over there, you want to put it somewhere else,16:19 it has a status of kli16:24 shemelachto l'heter. This is a regular example.16:27 Now, let's say, let's say it's the other way.16:30 Let's say you have a piece of wood lying around in the backyard16:33 because, you know, you're planning to fix something,16:36 you're planning to put up your sukkah or whatever it is,16:38 and now you decide that, you know what, let me use that piece of wood.16:42 It's a two by four. Hey, it looks like it's big enough,16:45 I could squeeze it in to hold my door locked.16:49 In such a case, you'll have to do this designation that we spoke about before Shabbat.16:54 You can't decide on Shabbat, you can take a two by four that you happen to have in your garage,16:59 and now I'm going to use it to block or to lock my sliding glass door.17:03 It has to be all prepared from before Shabbat.17:06 Okay, so now the question becomes like this.17:10 If we're talking about transforming things that17:14 are muktzeh machmat gufo into kli shemelachto l'heter, could we do this also with money?17:19 Meaning, can I take money, regular money,17:23 which we all hold as muktzeh machmat gufo, has no actual use,17:27 and somehow figure out something to use it for?17:30 Let's say I want to use it for a decoration.17:33 Can I use whatever it is?17:35 Or let's say I want to use it as—listen, let's say I want to decorate my table with dollar bills.17:43 I'm having somebody coming over, and I want to take now fifty-dollar crisp fifty-dollar bills17:49 and decorate, you know, there's a special way you fold it, or maybe, I don't know,17:53 and you want to decorate the plates with it.17:57 Technically, you should say yes. Why?18:00 It's a $50 bill, true, but you know what?18:02 I'm using it now as a napkin, or I'm using it now as a decoration.18:06 How is this different from a regular napkin, which used to be a piece of leaf,18:12 and all of a sudden I turn it into a napkin to use to wipe, to clean my hands,18:16 to wipe my fingers, or to use it as a decoration in a cup?18:20 So I want to use the same thing.18:21 I want to put the $50 bill in a cup that makes it look very nice.18:26 Can I do that or not on Shabbat?18:28 Of course, preparation, like we learned, has to be done before Shabbat.18:33 Can I do this before Shabbat so that the $50 bill becomes18:37 kli shemelachto l'heter? So in short, can we turn money into18:42 a kli shemelachto l'heter by designating it in whichever form to be used as a18:48 kli shemelachto l'heter? So the answer is as follows.18:50 This is one of those answers that, you know, you have to mix halacha together with a little bit of musar, basically,18:58 and those are not my words, but the words from the poskim.19:02 Technically, you're right, it could work.19:05 Why? Because we said you can turn anything you want that's19:10 muktzeh into kli shemelachto l'heter. You just have to know the steps, like we learned beforehand,19:13 either designation through action by planning to use it, that's called thinking about it,19:18 or having used it once before.19:21 However, by money, although it could technically work, a person should not do it.19:25 Poskim really not should not do it. Why?19:27 There are three reasons that I listed here why a person should not use money19:35 or designate money to be a19:37 kli shemelachto l'heter. Number one is Hacham Ovadia brings an old minhag that used to be in Turkey,19:43 when a person, on Shabbat chatan, when he gets the aliyah,19:47 in the middle of the whole shul, they would give the chatan a certain coin.19:51 And there was a minhag like that in Turkey, in old Turkey, obviously not today.19:55 In old Turkey, they used to give the coin on Shabbat to the20:01 chatan. So the poskim then dealt with it, and they said, This minhag, I don't know,20:06 but this coin basically is not to serve as money.20:09 They're not giving him money to go and buy new shoes or a new hat.20:13 They're giving him a coin like a gift.20:16 It'll be like nothing different from giving a person flowers.20:20 So the poskim broke down over there that they should make a hole in the coin.20:24 Why?20:25 So this way, people see that it's not being used. It's not regular money.20:30 It would not look good.20:32 That's one reason why we see over here that it's not so pashut to use money for20:39 keli she'melachto l'heter. People don't understand, don't know this20:42 halacha, and they'll think that money is fine.20:44 Another thing is, we're worried that a person might end up using that money later on in the future for money.20:54 In order to turn something that's muktzeh machmat gufo into20:58 keli she'melachto l'heter, it has to be turned into keli she'melachto l'heter forever.21:03 Like the brick.21:04 The brick that you want to use as a21:07 doorstopper, we said it has to be placed and used as a doorstopper forever.21:12 You can't plan to use it for once about as a21:14 doorstopper and then afterwards put it back with the other bricks and put it back into the building.21:18 It has to be permanently changed into21:23 a keli she'melachto l'heter. So you ever see some21:24 people—Sefardim are more into21:26 this—they have, you go into their store,21:28 they have like dollar bills, five-dollar bills, one-dollar bills,21:32 all like, you know, in their store behind the register.21:36 You see it says mazel tov, hatzlacha, and all these kind of things.21:40 Sometimes you walk into people's cars,21:41 they have these like dollar bills and whatever hanging in the car.21:44 So clearly they're using these dollar bills as decoration.21:48 Or, or sometimes you see people have a dollar bill hung up in their house,21:53 and you ask them, Where'd you get it from?21:54 They tell you, I got it from a certain rebbe, and he gave it to me21:58 as a segulah. So technically these kind of bills are there for show, right,22:01 for display,22:03 but— The reality is that some people, when they're very stuck22:07 and they need that dollar or those five dollars,22:10 they'll take it and they'll use it for money.22:14 So they've reverted it back to muktzeh machmat gufo.22:19 Because of this fear,22:20 some of the Acharonim, I believe it's the Chazon Ish, the22:26 Chazon Ish, I think Chacham Ovadia brings a little bit, he hints to it as well,22:28 that it's not proper to use money as a22:35 kli שמלאכתו לאיסור. So therefore, if you want to use your fifty-dollar bills as a napkin,22:39 it's not recommended you do so,22:40 because although using it as a napkin, and really you're a עשיר, you're wealthy, you don't care,22:44 sometimes, you know what, afterwards you might say,22:46 you know, חבל, fifty dollars, why should I let it go to waste?22:50 You might end up using it as money, which probably you will,22:53 if we're talking about fifty dollars.22:54 Not only that, a few dollars,22:56 sometimes, you know, it happened to me personally,22:58 and I know people tell me the same story,23:01 sometimes people come into your new car and they tie like a dollar bill around.23:05 I was, you know, I needed some gasoline.23:07 I needed a few dollars, not nothing major,23:10 but just to get by. I was stuck somewhere,23:12 so I took those dollars and I used it.23:15 Of course, you're going to use it when you're stuck23:17 and you end up using it.23:18 So for that reason, you should not make money into a23:22 kli שמלאכתו לאיסור. And finally, finally, the third reason that's listed, all the poskim bring it, is23:30 זילותא דשבת. It does not look good.23:33 People will see—not people—Shabbat will be lower in people's eyes.23:37 You're moving money, and you say, What do you mean? I23:40 designated. Technically, you're right.23:41 You know, according to halacha, you're right, right?23:43 But what are you trying to be?23:45 Trying to be cool?23:45 You're trying to impress people,23:46 Look, I know how to turn a dollar into a23:49 kli שמלאכתו לאיסור. People are going to see you interacting and using money around,23:52 and, Oh, it's23:54 mutar, mutar. So it's a problem to do that.23:56 You should not do that.23:56 So therefore, מסקנה of the poskim, the consensus is—24:00 That although the halacha has room to turn money into24:05 kli shemachto l'heter, you should not do it. It doesn't look good, and you have other problems that could perhaps24:10 make the whole transformation null and void; that doesn't work. So therefore,24:16 one should not turn money into kli shemachto l'heter. Now, the next question is:24:22 what about other forms of, or other categories of muktzeh? Like, for example,24:31 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, or kli shemachto l'isur. Could we also transform them into kli shemachto l'heter, or do we say this24:37 only by muktzeh machmat gufo? Muktzeh machmat gufo, like a stone or rock or money, these are things24:44 that did not have any usage before you did something to them. So you kind of created a24:53 keli. It was nothing; you turned to something. But a kli shemachto l'isur, or24:58 muktzeh machmat chisaron kis, which had a function before, maybe you can't transform it. Maybe25:03 it stays the way it is. And the answer is no, you could transform it. This halacha applies25:09 by all categories of muktzeh. So I'll give you a few examples. Let's say a person has a menorah25:14 that he uses to light candles. So a menorah that's used to light candles has a status of25:21 kli shemachto l'isur. It's made to put candles on it. Now, one week he decides, you know what, I don't want25:27 to use these candlesticks for lighting anymore. I'm just going to put them in a bowl, whatever it25:31 is you decide, and now I want to use these candlesticks only for display, only for display.25:37 I'm not going to use it for lighting anymore. So you could do that. You could now take them and put25:42 them in your, you know, those armoires, I think they call it, but these basically these closets with glass25:46 doors, and let them, and put them on display. They turn into kli shemelachto l'heter, which can be moved even to25:54 protect the item itself. Or let's say, for example, once you turn your candlesticks into26:00 a kli shemelachto l'heter, you could take it with you from room to room. So if you're sitting in the dining room and26:05 your future son-in-law is there and you want to impress him that you got some money, you're able to26:09 support him, so you put your silver candlesticks. And then you want to show him that you have so many26:13 candlesticks without him knowing, you go and you put it also when he's not looking. You put it in26:17 the living room when he comes to sit there. He says, Wow, these people have good money. Okay,26:20 you know, I'll marry into them. They could support me. Whatever reason you have, you could do that.26:25 You could transform it. Same thing, I'll give you another example. We said in the past that an26:30 expensive phone that you're careful that people shouldn't, not anybody should handle it,26:36 has a status of muktzeh machmat chisaron kis. Let's say you want to transform that into a26:42 toy now for your kid. You want the kids, you know, they have something. Now, of course, without a26:47 battery we're talking about. So you want to take your phone 6S and you want to now let the kids26:53 play with it. Of course, you take out the battery or it's dead. It's just, you know, walking around26:56 there cool, you know, they think they're holding on to a phone. So that's technically mutar.27:00 We're not dealing with the subject of toys yet, but technically you've transformed27:06 the phone into a kli shemelachto l'heter, which is a toy to keep little kids quiet. Now, there is a point27:14 that you have to know. One point that the poskim bring down is that if the muktzeh still looks like27:23 muktzeh, so then it could be a problem, like this iPhone. If it's clear that it turned into a toy.27:30 Well, how, I don't know, maybe you took out the case, it looks all scratched up.27:34 So then everybody will tell you, fine, you transformed it into a toy. For little kids,27:41 it's kli shemachto l'heter. However, if you see that the item still looks like muktzeh, nothing changed. It still looks like27:47 the way it was before and should, so then in that case, poskim say it doesn't lose that status so much of27:55 kli shemachto l'isur or whatever it is, because it still looks like muktzeh. You have to do some sort of physical28:01 change to it that people should see that it's not muktzeh anymore; it's rather28:10 a kli shemachto l'heter. Now, before we move on to the next halacha, just one last thing, and that is28:15 that when you come to designate an item, it's simple, but I have to point it out,28:21 you can only designate an item that's yours. Meaning to say, if you have bricks in the backyard,28:26 but those bricks don't belong to you, they belong to your upstairs neighbor who is making his own28:30 extension, and now you want to use one of those bricks to hold your door open. Now your28:36 neighbor doesn't care, you want to use it for the back, he doesn't care about a few bricks, you28:39 know, especially he's not losing them, you're putting them back. And now you say, I'm going to use those28:43 bricks, I'm going to turn them into a doorstopper. It's asur, it's not yours, it's still28:48 the owner, unless you get permission from him that it becomes yours. So you cannot designate something28:55 for somebody else. Or let's say you know your neighbor is going to have so many people coming28:59 over on Shabbat, and he's going to eventually need a doorstopper. Without him knowing, you go take29:04 one of those bricks and you designate it into a doorstopper. It doesn't work. Why? Since the owner29:14 himself never— Gave you permission for that. It's his item. You can go ahead and transform the29:22 muktzeh of somebody else into a kli shemelachto l'heter without his clear consent. Okay? You have to be29:30 either the owner or allow somebody else. One more point, and that is that a katan, any child under29:36 the age of bar mitzvah, also cannot designate. Even though he's the owner of the item, he cannot29:42 transform muktzeh into a kli shemelachto l'heter. With this, we finish the subject of transforming29:49 muktzeh machmat gufo into kli shemelachto l'heter. We're going to move on now to the next subject29:54 in the Ben Ish Hai. This takes up the halacha gimmel, tet-vav, gimmel, dalet, hey, vav in the Ben30:01 Ish Hai. Discusses a subject that is very, very, very common. Also another subject that's under the category of30:08 muktzeh machmat gufo. We did discuss it a little bit in the past, but now, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll talk about it30:14 more and elaborate much more on it, bringing all the practical cases. I hope we have enough time.30:19 Be'ezrat Hashem, I hope we have enough time. Maybe we'll do it without going inside.30:24 Before we speak about the subject, let me just tell you a little bit outside some30:30 simple things and a warning. The subject we're about to speak about is not the most pleasant30:35 subject to speak about when thinking about it, but it's a realistic subject. The subject is30:41 graf shel re'i, literally meaning what we would call today a potty. It's a bucket that's used for30:49 waste. So technically, if you think about it, let's say a dirty diaper with number two.30:57 Forgive me again for giving such an extreme example, but, you know, that's the subject we're31:01 dealing with, and we all know how practical that is. So let's say number two, the kid made. He's being31:06 potty trained, and he had an accident in the living room. So technically, according to halacha, what would that31:13 be called? It's not a kli, so technically it's muktzeh machmat gufo. And therefore, if it's31:20 muktzeh machmat gufo, you should technically not be able to move it in a normal way. And also, you can't31:26 sweep it up also, technically, if you hold it's muktzeh machmat gufo. However, in halacha we find,31:32 the Gemara tells us that there are certain things that are muktzeh machmat gufo. However,31:38 they become so repulsive that they fall under the category of graf shel rei. This is a category31:46 called graf shel rei, and once something is called a graf shel rei, the rabbis removed31:52 the issur of muktzeh, removed the stringency, the restrictions of muktzeh, and allowed—32:00 You to handle it, to move it, even in a normal way.32:04 So let's go back to the extreme case that we gave.32:07 Your two-year-old comes and says,32:08 Mommy, I had an accident,32:10 and all the kids are yelling,32:12 Ah! Ah! The baby had an accident!32:13 The baby had an accident! Right?32:15 And the alarm goes on.32:17 Okay, the whole house is going crazy.32:19 The two-year-old had an accident.32:20 Okay, okay, okay.32:21 You see it right there,32:23 it's stuck on the carpet, okay?32:24 If you're gonna brush it off, forget about it.32:27 It's gonna smear all over the carpet.32:29 It's gonna be much worse.32:30 That's right.32:31 The only option you have is32:33 go take out those plastic gloves,32:34 you know, the ones that the doctor uses in the hospital,32:37 put them on,32:38 or convince your husband to do it,32:39 if your husband is foolish enough,32:41 whatever it is.32:42 So you go, you put on your gloves,32:43 and you gotta pick it up with your bare hands.32:47 According to halacha,32:49 since that, you know,32:50 forgive me, that the feces,32:52 the waste,32:53 the number two is disgusting,32:55 so therefore it would be permitted to move it32:58 directly with your own hands.33:00 You don't have to use a33:02 shinui, even though it's33:03 muktzeh machmat gufo, but since it's repulsive,33:05 it's disgusting,33:06 you're allowed to pick it up in a normal way.33:08 Now this does not only apply to this case,33:10 although if you look in the Shulchan Aruch,33:12 he33:13 says—I'm gonna read you the words of the33:16 Ben Ish Chai, which are pretty much the words of the33:18 Shulchan Aruch.33:19 He says like this:33:22 Kol davar metunaf, everything that's dirty,33:24 kegon ki, for example,33:29 vomit. Otzoa, or the waste of a human being,33:33 ben shel adam, whether it's of a human being,33:35 ben shel tanegolim, or whether if it's animals.33:38 Let's say you have a dog as a pet33:40 and he makes in the living room.33:42 In those days they had a lot of chickens going around33:44 and they make.33:45 Or if you live in a neighborhood in Brooklyn33:47 where it has a lot of33:49 cats and they go on your property33:50 and they make,33:51 right?33:52 In all these cases,33:57 im hem bemakom sheyoshev sham, if they are in the place where you are sitting there,34:02 or bchatzer shenichnas veyotzei ba oto makom, or they're in an area34:05 like a courtyard34:06 which you commonly use,34:13 then mutar lefanotam lehotziam leashpaah, o leveit hakisei afilu beyad mamash. Then the Chachamim removed the restrictions of34:17 muktzeh and told you you're allowed to pick it up with your own bare hands34:21 and to remove it to wherever you want to remove it.34:23 You want to pick it up and throw it in the toilet,34:25 you want to pick it up and throw it in the garbage,34:26 it's fine.34:27 You don't have to think about it.34:29 Just pick it up.34:30 There's no muktzeh right here.34:35 Vzehu hanikra bedivrei Chazal, bechom makom graf shel rei. This is what's called a graf shel34:40 rei. Now, what I just read34:41 was only the first part of Halacha gimmel in the34:44 Ben Ish Chai. There's still much more to talk about in this34:48 halacha, but before we get to the other points,34:50 let's discuss this over here.34:52 Poskim, all of them agree34:54 that the examples are given here,34:56 which are vomit34:57 or of an animal or a human being,35:01 is not the only thing that's under the category of graf shel35:06 rei. When Chazal, when the rabbis told you that graf shel35:08 rei, you're allowed to pick it up with your own hands,35:10 it could be anything that's disgusting.35:12 The question is,35:13 how disgusting does it have to be?35:16 So let me give you a few cases that are found in the Gemara,35:20 Nidah Rishonim, and you'll see that repulsive over here is not a requirement.35:25 It could be even anything that causes an extreme discomfort,35:29 that for a person to be there in the same room.35:32 Let's give you an example.35:33 Number one, the Gemara talks about pits of fruits.35:38 People are eating olives,35:39 and the pits themselves,35:40 when they're piled up,35:42 can create a graf shel35:45 re'i. Another example in the Gemara,35:47 the Gemara talks about inviting a goy over to your house,35:51 which could cause a problem.35:53 Why?35:53 If you serve them wine,35:55 in those days35:56 the cup of wine they used to drink from,35:57 they'd also dip their bread35:58 to give it a little bit of flavor.35:59 They want the juice, basically, in their bread.36:02 The bread was too dry,36:03 so they'd dip their bread into the wine.36:06 Says the Gemara,36:06 what would you do now if you invite a goy over?36:08 That cup of wine would become36:11 muktzeh. Why?36:12 Wine is36:13 yayin nesekh, so you can't use it for anything,36:15 and the pieces of bread inside of it36:17 now become36:18 muktzeh, even though the goy drank his whole wine,36:20 but those pieces of bread are muktzeh now36:23 since there's nothing to do.36:24 You can't give it to an animal36:26 because you're getting36:28 hana'ah. Yayin nesekh is forbidden36:29 not only in drinking,36:30 but it's also forbidden in36:31 hana'ah, so it's not used for anything.36:33 Says the Gemara,36:34 yeah, but that case is a case of36:37 graf shel36:39 re'i. It's something disgusting.36:40 So you see that someone's leftovers36:43 are also considered36:45 graf shel36:47 re'i. Now obviously, leftovers we're talking about over here,36:49 something that's disgusting,36:51 you know, like36:52 the tahineh and the hummus36:53 and smeared together with the36:55 matbucha and the bread inside of it,36:57 and you have the sauce of the chicken,36:58 you know, that kind of thing.37:00 But when a person leaves over37:02 a half a slice of bread that he didn't eat,37:04 it's not really so disgusting.37:07 Leftover food, you see, could also be37:09 under the category of graf shel37:11 re'i. Another example,37:12 the Gemara talks about37:14 removing pots37:16 after they've been emptied.37:18 So you have a37:19 pot that you cooked food inside of it,37:20 you emptied out the contents,37:22 and the Gemara says,37:23 what are you going to do with the pots now?37:24 How are you going to move it?37:25 It's37:25 kli she'melachto l'isur because it's made to cook in it.37:27 Gemara says,37:28 yeah, but since you have all these37:29 leftover foods,37:30 it's disgusting,37:31 kind of like the cholent pot.37:33 Listen, cholent is37:34 gishmak. When we make37:34 cholent, we're not saying37:36 hashs, anything against37:36 cholent. I love37:38 cholent. But we all have to admit37:40 that when you have those stuff37:41 that are stuck in the37:42 cholent because you didn't put the oil,37:43 trying to be healthy,37:44 and you have all the barley kernels37:48 with the potatoes37:49 and the things stuck in the cholent pot,37:51 it does not look good.37:53 So therefore,37:54 it's not that it just doesn't look good;37:56 it looks disgusting.37:57 To move it,37:59 leftovers or pots38:00 that are not 100% clean,38:01 that have these burnt stuff inside of them38:03 that look disgusting,38:06 are also considered graf38:09 shel re'i. So practically speaking,38:11 let's give you a few examples38:12 which are graf38:13 shel re'i, which could properly happen,38:16 and therefore,38:16 being that they're graf38:18 shel re'i, you're allowed to move them38:19 in a normal way.38:20 You want to put on38:21 gloves and move them,38:22 go ahead.38:23 You want to move them38:23 with your own bare hands,38:24 okay, you could do that also.38:27 The restrictions of38:29 muktzeh are removed from anything38:31 that's graf38:32 shel re'i. A few examples.38:33 Let's give you a few examples.38:35 Number one is dirty diapers,38:37 right?38:37 You clean your kid,38:39 and now the diaper's there,38:41 whether it's ketanim or gedolim,38:43 number one or number two,38:44 right? It's there.38:45 It's disgusting.38:47 You're allowed to pick it up38:47 with your own regular hands.38:48 You don't have to pick it up38:49 in your38:50 shinui, with your elbow38:51 or with your toes38:52 or kick it.38:53 You're allowed to pick up38:54 the dirty diaper38:55 and dump it out38:56 where you have to dump it.38:58 Number two,39:00 lo aleinu, if we find a dead animal39:02 in the house,39:03 a dead mouse,39:04 a dead rat,39:06 even dead bugs39:07 that are disgusting.39:08 I'm not talking about39:08 those little fruit flies39:09 that you can't even notice,39:11 or dead ants.39:12 No, I'm talking about39:12 really, like, you know,39:14 a dead cockroach.39:15 It's disgusting.39:16 When there's a cockroach39:17 that ate from the poison39:19 and now you see it,39:20 it's disgusting.39:21 Again.39:23 As the poskim bring down,39:25 in the words of Rav Moshe Feinstein,39:28 the heter of graf39:30 shel rei is39:32 custom-made. It's based on you.39:34 So if you have ladies,39:36 they'll be more disgusted39:37 by something39:38 than a few yeshiva guys39:40 that, you know,39:41 they've done for a couple years39:43 and they've already seen39:44 what's out. You know,39:45 they've been exposed39:46 to many different things.39:47 So there's a difference39:49 in levels of graf39:52 shel rei. It depends on you.39:53 If you're disgusted by it,39:55 fine.39:55 If it doesn't bother you,39:56 it's not a graf39:58 shel rei. Here, however, we have a question.40:00 Question now. What if I have two people in the room, and for one person it is a graf shel rei. For the other person, nah, it doesn't bother him.40:11 Question is, for the person that it doesn't bother him, could he pick it up, or do we say no?40:16 Him it doesn't bother him, so it's not a graf shel rei, so he has no heter to move it.40:19 The other person that is a graf shel rei, they have to pick it up.40:22 I'll give you an example: wife, right? Certain things that disgust the wife, especially, especially if she's pregnant, and there's a lot of things that bother her40:33 much more, eek, why? I don't know. Kacha, the baby thinks that way, so now she is convinced by the baby that it's disgusting.40:40 And now she tells her husband, Ach, please remove it. Take this thing out of the fridge. Take this thing out of the kitchen. Take it out of the house.40:46 I don't want to see it. It's disgusting,40:49 repulsive. And the husband says, What are you talking about? We're planning to have this for lunch. It's nothing.40:54 Let's say it's even מוקצה מחמת גופו. Could the husband now pick it up for his wife?40:59 Sorry, husbands, but the answer is yes. You can't get away from this. You can't tell your wife, No, no, no, you have to pick it up.41:06 No. I mean, you could tell her whatever you want, but you want to know the41:09 halacha? Halacha is that if something is disgusting for one person because of a graf shel rei, then it becomes mutar for anybody in the room to remove it for them.41:21 So if the mother comes into the room and says, Ach, disgusting. Why are these things here? Why is the dirt all over? Pick it up. Take it away from here.41:30 Even though for the husband and the kids it's not a graf shel rei, since it's disgusting for her and she's using that place, then it becomes mutar for anybody in the room to remove it.41:43 There are some important rules, though, we have to know about graf41:47 shel rei. We mentioned it a little bit here, and the Ben Ish Chai continues later on, and he talks about it more.41:52 Again, the words, they're almost the words of the Shulchan Aruch, so we're just going to say it outside.41:58 In order for something to be also graf shel rei, it depends on the location.42:02 It has to be in a location that one is using, or one commonly uses, even though he's not using right now.42:08 I'll give you an example.42:10 A living room, a dining room, those are places that people are using on Shabbat.42:13 But if you have an attic, they don't go up to the attic so much.42:16 When do you go up? Once in a blue moon.42:18 So if you happen to go up to the attic, and you happen to see in the attic something disgusting—forgive me for this example—you go up to the42:26 attic, you want to take from there a bottle of wine.42:29 Why is it in the attic? I don't know, just whatever it is.42:31 You're taking from there a bottle of wine.42:33 The attic is not a place where people sleep.42:35 It's just there. You put some things you store over there.42:37 After you pick up the bottle of wine, you see a dead mouse over there.42:41 Ew, disgusting, right?42:43 The rabbi said, dead mouse,42:45 dead mouse is a graf42:48 shel rei. No. Although a dead mouse is a graf shel rei, but being that it's in a location where it doesn't—you're not using,42:57 you're not using it, so therefore it doesn't make it a graf43:01 shel rei. Meaning to say, because it's—you're not using that place.43:05 We just tell you, if it's bothering you, get out of the room.43:09 You're not using it anyway.43:10 But if, let's say, the same thing happens and you find it downstairs in your basement, in the area where you play, or you use to relax,43:19 or you find it in the front yard on the balcony.43:22 So although you're not sitting there all day, but you plan to sit after the meal to sit outside,43:28 so you're allowed to move43:29 it. You don't have to wait till you actually sit on the balcony to remove it. In that case,43:33 you pick it up and remove it, since the balcony is an area which you use on a regular basis on Shabbat.43:41 Okay, that's very, very important to know.43:45 Next, another thing in the case, let's go back43:50 again. I'm sorry, like my introduction,43:52 these halachot are a little bit disgusting, but we have to talk about them because they happen.43:56 Let's say in the case of the attic, you see the dead bat and you smell it.44:00 It's44:00 horrible. Now, the smell is not going to reach downstairs in your first floor and not even in the second floor.44:07 But you know what? You're worried that it's going to attract bugs,44:11 and bugs come in, it's going to be a problem for you because you're going to have to get an exterminator44:15 and, ugh, it's going to be a whole problem.44:17 But at the same time, you're not using the attic,44:20 so what's the halacha now? What could I do?44:21 So halacha tells us what the Ben Ish Chai brings over here in44:28 Halacha ה. He says that if a person wants—if a, excuse me, it's not the Ben Ish Chai only, it's the Shulchan Aruch as44:35 well—in the case where there is a financial loss or some sort of thing that could, you know, cause you financial loss,44:42 you're allowed to create that room as your sitting place. Meaning,44:48 the attic is not a place that you use, right?44:51 So what you could do is take a chair and sit there and relax, you know, hang out in the attic for a few minutes.44:59 Once you hang out over there and it's disgusting to sit there with the rat,45:03 then you could go take a glove, pick up the rat and throw it out in the garbage.45:06 Don't flush it down the toilet, it's not a good idea.45:08 You could have45:09 a sewer backup. Okay, you could throw it out in the garbage, and then afterwards remain in the room for a few more minutes,45:15 and then pick up your chair and go back and sit in the dining room.45:19 So basically, when there's a financial loss, you see, you know,45:23 the Gemara brings an example where there's a drip, there's something leaking, and the leak,45:28 the water is coming down, it's all dirty and disgusting, and it's falling into a bucket,45:32 but you're not using that room.45:34 So you're worried, though, that if you don't take out the bucket, it's going to overflow45:37 and have another flood in the basement.45:39 So then, in that case, the Gemara says you could take your, basically your chair,45:44 hang out over there and make it your permanent place.45:46 But you can't just happen to walk into the room and say, Oh, I'm here, it's disgusting, and pick it up.45:50 No. It has to be either a room that you use, or when there's a financial loss,45:55 you could create that room to be your place of hanging out by bringing a46:00 chair and sitting there for a few minutes before you pick up the graf46:03 shel re'i and after you pick up the graf46:09 shel re'i. Also, halacha brings, the Acharim bring down that when we give you the permission to move graf46:14 shel rei, you could pick it up in any way.46:17 It's a normal way.46:17 You don't have to try to avoid picking up the graf,46:21 and that means in the case of the dead mouse, you don't have to kick it.46:24 You could actually pick it up in the hands.46:25 You don't have to try to kick it or do anything else,46:29 right?46:30 This is the opinion of46:34 Chacham Ovadia, Yabia Omer, Rav Nissim Karelitz, as well as an early46:37 Acharon, the Halale David, the Obring the Tehillah LeDavid from 150 years ago, that permits46:41 this. However, I did see this, Aruch HaShulchan says46:45 that when it comes to graf shel rei, it's not a46:47 heter gamur. If you have a way to avoid handling with your hands the graf46:53 shel rei, you should do so.46:55 For example, if you have a goy, if you have a dead mouse,46:57 I think if you have a housekeeper, anyway, you're going to ask her to move the dead mouse.47:00 But let's say you have a goy around and he'll move it for you.47:02 It's better that he moves it than you move it.47:05 And I saw in Rabbi Barnes' book on muktzeh, in the back,47:08 he has two sections in the back in Hebrew47:11 where he has questions from Gedolei Yisrael in the last generation, from Moshe Feinstein47:15 and Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, zichronam livrachah. Over there in the section, he's speaking to Rav Moshe Feinstein.47:21 Rav Moshe Feinstein says a person l'chatchilah should try to be machmir like this47:26 Aruch HaShulchan. However, minhag is not that way.47:27 Whenever we have a permission to move graf47:30 shel rei, whether it's a dirty diaper and everything else,47:33 the minhag is like the simple understanding of47:36 Maran Shulchan Aruch and like the poskim recorded before,47:39 is that people handle it in a normal way,47:43 and whoever can be47:47 machmir, תבוא עליו ברכה. Another important halacha in graf47:50 shel rei is that even a bad smell could create a graf47:56 shel rei. We spoke about something disgusting.47:57 You see a dead mouse.48:00 Dead animal, you see vomit or waste, all that is disgusting. We all agree, yeah, that's48:09 for sure graf shel rei. But even if there's an unpleasant smell and there's something48:13 that you could do to remove that smell, you could also, that also becomes a graf48:18 shel rei. So let's say you have dead flowers that you forgot to throw out. So let's say they don't48:24 look so bad, doesn't look repulsive, but you know what? It has a horrible, horrible48:30 smell, right? They're just sitting around and giving off a horrible smell. That's also48:35 considered graf shel rei. If it makes the sitting in that room unpleasant, you could pick it48:41 up and throw it out. And by the way, like we said before, we're48:45 restressing it, whenever you have the graf shel rei, you've picked it up, you don't have48:50 to drop it off in the nearest location that can be dropped off. Let's say you have48:54 two garbages. You have one right outside your house in the backyard, and there's one49:00 by the end of the backyard. You don't have to drop it off at the nearest garbage can.49:05 You can take it to the other garbage can that's further out in your backyard and drop it off49:09 over there. When it comes to graf shel rei, the rabbis removed the restriction of49:15 muktzeh and allowed you to get rid of the unpleasantness of whether it's the smell or the look of what49:21 we categorize as graf shel rei. Here's an important question based on what49:27 we just said. We mentioned that something can be a graf shel rei on a condition that49:32 you are using that room. What if you ate your meal, but you're planning to leave right after49:40 your meal? You're planning to leave after your meal, and you know when you finish eating49:43 your meal, you have a lot of garbage on the table. We discussed leftover foods and all49:48 these type of things that are left over after we eat. We explained in the past that some49:53 of them could fit the fact that can be muktzeh machmat gufo. Could you pick it up?49:58 It says you're not planning to use the room anymore. So the halacha is like this: if you50:02 are planning to come back on Shabbat, so anyway, either way you have to, when you come back,50:08 let's say for example, you finish eating at two o'clock, you're planning to leave the50:10 house and come back by five o'clock. So when you come back by five o'clock, the leftovers50:14 are for sure going to be disgusting, right? Because it's גרף של רעי. You're50:19 leaving now at two, but you come back at five. So either way you're going to pick it up. So50:22 it doesn't make a difference if you clean up at two or five, since either way it's going50:26 to be cleaned up on Shabbat, you could clean up even at two o'clock. It's a50:30 גרף של רעי, you could pick it up. Question is, when you're leaving at two o'clock and you're not coming50:35 back till the end of Shabbat, you finish your meal, what are you cleaning up for? You're50:40 leaving the house anyway. Oh, it's disgusting, but you're not planning to stay. So in that case, you could50:45 create a גרף של רעי by staying, hang around. Don't leave at two o'clock right away. Wait50:51 a few minutes till about two or five, whatever it is, and once you're sitting there, so it's50:56 not pleasant to sit with all these leftovers all over the tablecloth, with the sauce spilled51:01 on the tablecloth and the breadcrumbs and all the other things are, you know,51:09 מוקצה, completely מוקצה. So in that case, since it's now disgusting, you pick it up. It's51:14 גרף של רעי, and you can take it and put it away in the garbage. One—not one—a few51:22 more points on גרף של רעי. Spiritual discomfort is not in the category of גרף של רעי. That51:30 means if you have something that is not repulsive, not disgusting, doesn't have a bad51:35 smell, but it's not according to your spiritual level. It could be even asur. Still, it does51:45 not make it a graf shel rei that gives you permission to remove it, give you two51:50 proofs from the Gemara. The Gemara talks about in Beit HaMikdash, they used to have a special51:55 kli called pesachtar. This is Masechet Eruvin. What's this pesachtar? It was basically this big pot, that if there was ever a52:05 dead rodent that was found in Beit HaMikdash, which would qualify as a sheretz, since the Kohanim who were around might come to touch it, they would take this52:12 pesachtar, this big pot basically, and cover the dead rodent. So let's say you have a dead52:21 rat in the Beit HaMikdash, you don't want the Kohanim to touch it,52:24 to become tamei, you take this big pot and cover it up. One second, a dead animal is disgusting.52:29 A dead rodent? Ugh. Why don't they just move it? And the answer is that it wasn't ugh,52:36 because it was Beit HaMikdash, it was a big place. It wasn't necessarily just—there was a problem, maybe they'd touch52:40 it, so they covered the kli. But even though, what do you mean, it's spiritually disgusting, you're52:45 gonna touch it and become tamei. It doesn't make a difference. You see, they didn't allow you52:50 to pick it up because it's spiritually disgusting. Same thing, we have a halacha on Pesach, proof52:56 number two. On Pesach we have a halacha: if a person finds chametz on Pesach, you have53:01 to burn it. Now, is chametz disgusting? It could be a nice Danish. Is it disgusting? Not at53:05 all. Does it smell bad? No. So, but you're a religious person. On Pesach you're53:11 gonna faint? It's disgusting. Still, it's disgusting only spiritually. It's not really physically53:20 disgusting. That's not in the category of graf shel rei. In fact, the halacha on Pesach53:23 is that if you find something on Shabbat or Yom Tov, on Pesach—not on Chol Hamoed. On53:28 Chol Hamoed, of course, you take it and burn it. But when you find something like that on Shabbat,53:32 Yom Tov, you take a pot or a dish and you turn it over, you cover the chametz, so this53:39 way people will know to avoid it. And only after the holiday, meaning to say after Yom53:43 Tov or after Shabbat, during Chol Hamoed, you could take the chametz and burn it or flush it53:47 down the toilet. But you cannot pick it up and remove it. Why not? And that is because spiritual53:54 discomfort. Does not create a situation of graf shel re'i. So we'll give you one practical halacha.54:00 We've learned in the past in Parashat Vayishlach, in the Ben Ish Chai, that there are certain magazines54:07 and newspapers that we are forbidden to read. And let's say a person finds such a54:12 newspaper in his house. You know, sometimes they put these advertisements from those leaflets that54:17 they throw in people's, what's it called, all these advertisements they throw on your property,54:20 so your kids take it in, and they open up to one of those stores, and they have54:25 over there disgusting pictures, right? It's asur to look at these pictures, but it's also54:32 muktzeh to read them. All these things, advertisements, all these things are muktzeh. They are not54:37 allowed to be read on Shabbat. So in such a case, to pick it up with your own hands54:42 will be asur because it's not a graf shel re'i. So what can you do? What's asur? Fine. So54:46 either, like we said, kick it, move it in a different way. If you need the location,54:51 you can sweep it away, or take something to cover it. As disgusting as it is, and I54:56 agree, it's disgusting and it shouldn't be there, but to pick it up with your own hands, it's55:00 still muktzeh, and it doesn't fall into the category of graf shel re'i that allows you to55:04 pick it up with your own hands and to remove it. You have to figure out a different way55:07 to move it. There's a question here. What if something is usually not graf shel re'i, but55:15 certain circumstances create that it should be a graf shel re'i, where people are disgusted55:22 by it, are embarrassed by it? For example, normally a hammer lying around in your house,55:31 normally a hammer that's lying around in the house, we said it's55:35 a kli שמלאכתו לאיסור. It's not something that's disgusting, so you have no heter to remove it unless you want55:39 to sit in that location, you want to use that location. But now, all of a sudden, you're getting55:44 guests, and very important guests. You're getting your future son-in-law's parents are coming.55:51 Oh, and they're going to discuss, you know, this is going to be the deciding factor if he should55:56 continue dating your daughter or not. And oh boy.56:00 You tell your husband, how many times do I tell you, when you finish using the tools, please put them away.56:04 You have your screwdriver around, you have the hammer around. Och, it's so embarrassing,56:09 and it's not an location that you need to, you know, that you could use that spot.56:13 Here, you have a heter. It's not a simple thing; other people argue. But56:18 Rabbanan brings from Rav Shlomo56:21 Zalman Auerbach, that one of the questions he asked him, he says, if it causes the wife56:24 or anybody in the family a certain discomfort that he can't, it's an a lot of embarrassment,56:31 there is room to say that you could pick it up with your regular hands and move it aside.56:37 So those who rely on such a heter, b'seder. Don't forget that we mentioned in the past,56:42 Rav Moshe Feinstein saying that if you have pencils on a dining room table56:48 and lichvod Shabbat you want to move it, that he says, no, you have no heter to move it.56:52 That's not called derech mekomo. That's not called kibbud Shabbat. Kibbud Shabbat is when you follow the halachot of Shabbat.56:57 But those who do rely on Rav Shlomo57:00 Zalman Auerbach, who want to rely on Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach when you have guests coming over57:03 and it's really, really embarrassing, and those things might be considered57:08 graf shel re'i, b'seder, you have what to rely on.57:12 But of course it would be preferable if you have a non-Jew move it,57:16 or if you can move it in a not normal way, what we call57:21 derech shinui, to avoid the problem of57:23 muktzeh. We're going to stop here.57:24 We still have a few halachot of graf shel re'i, b'ezrat Hashem we'll get to them next week.57:28 Until then, you should have a wonderful week.57:32 Bracha v'hatzlacha again, mazel tov to Rav Nissim, and we want to give thank you to JRoot and the whole staff.57:37 This show will be aired on again tonight at 1057:41 o'clock. We'll see you here again next week,57:44 b'ezrat Hashem. Lehitraot. Thank you for listening.