Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Okay, welcome to the Halacha Hour on Wednesday afternoon, 2 to 3 o'clock, where we learn the halachot0:06 from the sefer, from the book Ben Ish Chai. We're in the middle of halachot Kiddush in0:10 Parashat Bereishit, which is found in the Ben Ish Chai, Shana Bet, in the second year. We're0:16 up to Halacha Yud Tet. But before we get to today's shiur, today's class, I would like to just review0:20 something very quick and clarify something that had a few questions on it. The obligation0:27 of Kiddush begins for men and women a little bit differently in the daytime, but in the0:33 evening time, the obligation of Kiddush begins for everyone at the same time, and that is: whether0:39 a person is mekabel Shabbat, once the person accepts upon himself Shabbat, then already0:45 he becomes obligated in Kiddush, and he has to wait to eat or drink anything before making0:51 Kiddush. Number two is if a person was not mekabel Shabbat, Shabbat comes whether the0:58 person likes it or not, and that is from the time the sun sets. That's called sheki'ah, when1:03 bein hashmashot begins, and therefore from that point on already a person may not even1:08 have a drink of water until he makes Kiddush. This is regarding Kiddush in the evening.1:13 However, in the daytime, halacha is a little bit differently for men and women. For men,1:18 the obligation begins once they pray Shacharit for the Sefardim, and Shacharit meaning the Amidah.1:25 Once the men pray the Amidah, then they have the obligation of making Kiddush,1:30 which means anything before that time, they're allowed to have because they have no1:36 obligation of Kiddush yet, but they have to be careful and aware of the halachot of what1:42 a person can eat or drink before Shacharit. For women, it depends. If a woman regularly1:51 prays, then her obligation is exactly like that of a man, and that means that she only1:58 has the obligation after Shacharit. But if a woman doesn't regularly pray and she prays2:06 maybe Mincha in the afternoon, but she doesn't pray Shacharit in the morning, then her obligation2:11 begins immediately once she wakes up, and she has to make first Kiddush if she wants2:16 to eat, even though she didn't pray yet. I want to clarify something a few people asked.2:21 There's some people who asked me, and they said that they don't pray Shacharit. These women2:27 don't pray Shacharit on a regular day, on a regular basis, but on Shabbat they have more2:33 time, and they do pray Shacharit every single Shabbat. So the halacha is that for these2:39 women who pray Shacharit every single Shabbat, they have the law exactly like a man. Since2:43 they're careful to pray almost every single Shabbat, the obligation of Kiddush only2:48 begins after Shacharit. Like we mentioned last week, for the children, there is no obligation2:52 to wait for Kiddush to eat or drink, children meaning anybody under the age of bar mitzvah.2:59 One more point, and that is, if a person has to take medicine, and before or while taking3:05 the medicine he has to eat some food with it, or he has a heter to eat before3:11 Shacharit, then he should not make Kiddush before Shacharit, since the obligation of Kiddush only3:17 comes after Shacharit. Now that's, of course, talking about people who, either men or women,3:24 who pray every single Shabbat. However, if there are women who don't pray on Shabbat,3:30 Shacharit on Shabbat, and they have to take medicine in the morning, they should first3:35 make Kiddush, and then they can take their medicine with the food. Next, Halacha3:42 yutet is an important halacha, their own important halachot, but it's a more common halacha without3:49 us being aware of it, and that is if a person forgets and eats before making Kiddush. Okay?3:55 So let's see what the Ben Ish Chai says, a few words from the Ben Ish Chai. We're not3:59 going to go through the whole halacha. It says like this: Im4:03 shachach ve'achal kodem Kiddush. If a person forgets and eats before Kiddush,4:08 even a person ate his full meal, he had a whole4:12 full meal before remembering that he didn't make Kiddush, he has to stop immediately and4:18 make Kiddush. And he can't eat anything4:23 after he remembers that he didn't make Kiddush. He can't continue even tasting, eating anything.4:29 Now this is if he remembers, whether in the nighttime or in the daytime. If he4:36 remembers in the middle of his meal that he didn't make Kiddush, he stops, takes a cup of wine, and4:39 makes Kiddush. However, if a person completely forgot4:46 at night to make Kiddush, he was invited somewhere, he came, and the people already made Kiddush4:52 and he himself forgot to make Kiddush, and he had a full meal, and only on Shabbat day4:57 he remembered that he didn't make Kiddush. So the halacha says, yesh lo5:02 tashlumin lemachar kol hayom. He could make up the Kiddush of Leil Shabbat on Shabbat day. How does this5:09 work? What does he do?5:14 Ve'omar kol birkat haKiddush shel layla chutz miparshat vayechulu, she'ein omrah bayom. The main part of the Kiddush, although the custom is that we say Shalom5:19 aleichem, Eshet chayil, plus we say also Vayechulu and Mekadesh haShabbat, the main part of5:26 the Kiddush is two blessings, two berachot: the blessing of Borei pri hagafen. And the5:34 blessing of mekadesh haShabbat, Baruch atah Hashem, mekadesh haShabbat. If a person completely missed Kiddush on Leil Shabbat,5:42 he can make up the next day. The next day, when he makes Kiddush in the morning, he should5:47 say just the two berachot, borei pri hagafen and berachah of mekadesh haShabbat, and5:55 this Kiddush will work for the Kiddush in the daytime as well as for the Kiddush in5:59 the evening. Okay? How come he doesn't say Vayechulu? Because Vayechulu is said regarding6:05 the completion of the six days of creation, which happened on Leil Shabbat, Friday night.6:11 So a person can't say Vayechulu on Shabbat morning because the creation, or the physical6:17 part of creation which Hashem created, finished on Friday night. And Shabbat morning, when6:23 a person remembers it, it's too late to say Vayechulu, Shamayim va'aretz. Now the creation6:27 has finished creating. There's an important point, and it's going to come up a6:33 little bit again, but just to mention it, it happened actually to me one time on Shabbat day. I6:40 didn't—usually Shabbat day we make Kiddush in the shul. One time I missed Kiddush in6:45 the shul and completely forgot about it. By the time I got home, I was eating somewhere,6:49 and there were many, many people, and they were waiting for me to come, and once I came,6:54 everybody was told, Please wash, let's go, we got to wash already. So I washed, I didn't6:59 netilat yadayim, I sat down about to make hamotzi, I did not make the berachah hamotzi, and I7:04 remembered right away, hey, you know, I didn't make Kiddush today. So what do you do in that7:07 case? Is it fine to make Kiddush, to interrupt between netilat yadayim hamotzi, or do I first7:14 say hamotzi and then make Kiddush afterwards on a cup of wine? Now keep in mind this was7:20 Shabbat day. We can learn later on that a person who doesn't have wine can make Kiddush7:27 on bread, but that's only in the evening. On Shabbat day, you cannot make Kiddush on7:31 bread. So that option is out. I cannot make Kiddush on bread. But do I have to make Kiddush7:36 before Hamotzi? And the answer is yes. Between netilat yadayim to birchat hamotzi, I must7:44 go take a cup of wine, make Kiddush, and then I can go and make the7:50 bracha of Hamotzi. Why? Because it's not considered a hefsek; it's considered tzorech seudah. If a person7:55 speaks between netilat yadayim and Hamotzi for something that's necessary.8:00 For the seudah, it's not considered8:02 a hefsek. There's even more to this, but on a simple level, this is what a person should do.8:06 Again, a quick review. If a person forgot to make Kiddush in the evening or in the daytime,8:11 and he remembers, he stops whatever he's doing, even if he's in the middle of eating,8:15 and makes Kiddush right away.8:17 If a person remembers in the daytime before making the bracha of hamotzi8:25 and after the bracha of netilat yadayim, then he could pause, make Kiddush on a cup of wine,8:32 and then have the bread and make birkat hamotzi.8:36 This is something that many people may not be aware of.8:40 We just learned that if a person makes—I mean, misses Kiddush in the evening, he can make it up in the daytime.8:49 Many times, you may have people over you that may not be religious8:56 and have not made Kiddush in the evening,8:58 and they're coming to your house on Shabbat day, and they missed Kiddush on Leil Shabbat.9:04 These people have an obligation to make Kiddush from the one that they missed on Leil Shabbat.9:10 Just because they don't keep Shabbat or they don't know so much about9:15 Shabbat, you know, they're trying to become maybe a little bit more, and they're unaware that they have to make Kiddush,9:19 doesn't exempt them from their obligation.9:22 So therefore, if you have such guests over and you know pretty much who's coming over,9:27 and you know that these people have not made Kiddush the night before,9:31 ask them, Did you make Kiddush the night before?9:33 If not, then they should make the Kiddush, like we said, hagafen and the bracha of9:41 mekadesh haShabbat. If these people that you're inviting over did not make Kiddush on Leil Shabbat.9:46 And they don't know how to make kiddush. They don't know how to read.9:49 They don't know what to say, even though it's a9:52 short beracha. Then even though you made kiddush with them the night before, you can make kiddush with them the next day.9:58 This is something that we learned10:00 when it comes to birchat hamitzvot. A person may make a blessing for another Jew10:05 even though he was yotzei already.10:06 Just like on Leil Shabbat, if a person made kiddush already and had his meal,10:11 and he wants to go to somebody's house and make kiddush for them10:15 where they don't know how to say the10:17 beracha, so too over here, since they missed it the night before,10:20 you can make and should make kiddush with them the next day10:24 because these people have an obligation to say kiddush.10:26 In fact, this kiddush, according to almost everybody's de'ot, especially those people who don't pray,10:32 so it's for sure it's an obligation10:36 min haTorah for them to hear the full kiddush that we say on Friday night,10:40 for you to say it for them on Shabbat day.10:43 Now, for those who have missed kiddush on Leil Shabbat,10:47 which could happen to a person also,10:49 even a regular person who shomer Shabbat and makes sure to make kiddush,10:54 sometimes a person can be very, very sick10:56 and he cannot make kiddush on Leil Shabbat.11:00 So since he's not allowed to eat before or drink before making kiddush,11:07 so on Shabbat morning, although this person may be a man who prays every single Shabbat and every single day,11:12 and his obligation comes after tefillah,11:16 since he did not make kiddush from the night before,11:18 the Kaf HaChaim points out that he's not allowed to eat or drink anything until he makes kiddush,11:22 because although the kiddush of the daytime did not kick in yet,11:27 did not start till after Shacharit, will not start till after11:30 Shacharit, the kiddush that he has to make from the night before is still Forbidding him11:36 and restricting him from drinking or eating until he makes that kiddush.11:42 Okay?11:43 The next part of the Ben Ish Chai in this halacha is very big and complicated.11:47 I'll just summarize it in a few words,11:49 and that is: if a person completely forgot kiddush on Leil Shabbat11:54 and didn't make kiddush and didn't say it on Shabbat day,11:57 he didn't know that you have to say the blessing of Baruch Atah Hashem Mekadesh HaShabbat,12:01 and he only remembered after sunset but before tzeit hakochavim,12:10 what we call12:12 bein hashmashot. So what do you do in that case?12:13 So the halacha, after back and forth with the Ben Ish Chai and Chacham Ovadia and12:20 the Acharonim, we said the following:12:22 it depends if a person prayed or not.12:25 If a person prayed, then he should not make kiddush12:29 because, like we mentioned, praying, according to many opinions,12:35 when a person prays and he says the blessing Baruch Atah Hashem Mekadesh HaShabbat in his12:39 Amidah, it's considered that he made kiddush min haTorah.12:43 The Chachamim are still obligated to make kiddush on a cup of wine,12:46 but now that's12:48 bein hashmashot, and bein hashmashot, the Chachamim say it's safek if it's considered the day or the following night.12:54 So he has a safek on an obligation which is only rabbinical.12:58 That's called13:00 safek deRabbanan, and the rule is whenever it's13:03 safek deRabbanan, we say safek deRabbanan lekula; we're lenient.13:05 He doesn't have to make kiddush.13:06 However, if a person did not pray at all,13:09 he was sick the whole Shabbat,13:11 he wasn't even able to pray on Leil Shabbat or Shabbat morning,13:14 he didn't make kiddush, didn't eat anything,13:15 and now it's after sunset and he feels better13:18 and he wakes up,13:19 and now what should he do13:21 in that case? Since he didn't pray at all,13:24 the obligation is from the Torah,13:26 and although it's safek because13:29 bein hashmashot it's a doubt whether it's daytime or the following night,13:32 but it's a safek, it's a doubt in an obligation which is from the Torah.13:38 So this falls into the category of13:42 safek de'oraita, and the rule is,13:45 safek de'oraita lechumra. Whenever you have a doubt in a law that's from the Torah,13:49 that's an obligation from the Torah,13:51 then we are stringent, we're13:53 machmir, and therefore a person should make kiddush,13:55 kiddush meaning two blessings,13:57 hagafen and the beracha of mekadesh haShabbat.14:02 Okay, we move on now to14:07 halacha hei. Halacha hei, a little bit connected to kiddush,14:11 but not to the making kiddush.14:14 We speak about the famous,14:15 what everybody knows,14:17 we cover the bread on Shabbat when we make kiddush.14:21 What's the reason why we cover bread on Shabbat when we're making kiddush?14:26 So Ben Ish Chai here gives three reasons.14:28 Number one, he explains,14:30 Tzarich sheyeh aleh14:36 shulchan mapa, tachat hapat, umapa lemaalah. He has to have two covers,14:38 not just a cover above the bread,14:40 but a cover under it.14:42 The cover under it could be anything besides the actual table,14:45 which means if you have a tablecloth,14:48 a napkin, a plate,14:49 or some people have a special challah plate,14:52 either one will serve as a cover under,14:54 and of course a cover on top.14:57 And the reason why we have to have it covered in such a way,15:01 number one is15:03 zecher laman. This is a reminder of the man,15:05 the man, the way it fell,15:06 the Torah says15:08 that first tal would fall,15:13 and it would be like a layer,15:15 that the man, when it falls on it,15:17 shouldn't get dirty.15:18 And then afterwards the man would fall,15:20 and another spray of tal would come on top,15:23 and it would become like a frost,15:25 like a cover on top of it.15:27 So when the Jews woke up in the morning,15:29 they found the man covered from the bottom,15:31 from the top.15:33 And therefore, on Shabbat, the bread,15:35 which is a symbol for the man15:37 that fell for the Jewish people in the desert,15:39 we have to cover it in such a way.15:41 Hasheni, the second reason,15:46 detete seudata de Shabbata bikara, that the meal of Shabbat should be presented with honor.15:50 You ever saw those pictures15:52 of all the cartoons,15:54 when a person, this Italian waiter,15:56 this big mustache,15:57 and he's holding a silver platter and—16:00 He's opening the cover for it, right?16:02 Something that's chashuv, when you go to a wedding,16:04 the food is not just placed on the table like that.16:07 It's placed in a very nice cover.16:10 So too, the food, the main part of the seudah, which is the bread,16:13 should be placed in a nice package,16:15 in a cover on the bottom and a cover on top.16:18 There are עוד יש טעם שלישי, and there's a third reason,16:21 משום בושת הפת, that the bread should not be embarrassed.16:24 What does that mean, the bread should not be embarrassed?16:26 It means like this:16:28 in Hilchot Berachot, we have rules,16:32 and the rules are that there's a din of16:36 kedimah. That means if a person is planning to eat different types of foods,16:41 he has to make certain berachot before others.16:46 There's a certain order.16:47 This is not a class on Hilchot Berachot, but we'll go very quickly.16:50 If a person has a cup of wine,16:52 where the blessing is16:55 Borei Pri Hagafen, and he has also a slice of bread,16:58 where the blessing is Hamotzi,17:00 to make the berachah, he's supposed to make a berachah on bread,17:04 which is Hamotzi, before he makes a berachah on the wine,17:07 which is17:08 Hagafen. That's the order how things are supposed to go.17:11 When a person is coming and making kiddush on Shabbat,17:14 the bread has to be on the table,17:16 like we explained kabbalistically,17:18 right? It represents the shulchan.17:20 And when the bread is on the17:22 table, you're picking up the cup of wine17:24 and making the kiddush on the cup of wine17:27 before you make the berachah of Hamotzi on the bread.17:29 You're changing the order.17:31 So in a way, Chachamim say that's called embarrassing the bread.17:35 So therefore, we cover the bread17:36 as if the bread is not there, you cannot see,17:39 and we don't have bread anymore.17:40 We know it's there, but it's covered,17:42 and we're not planning to eat it yet.17:45 So therefore, we could pick up the cup of17:47 wine and make the17:50 kiddush with the blessing of hagafen on the cup of wine,17:53 and then once we're done, we could uncover the bread.17:55 Similar to when a person goes to a wedding17:58 and they have the appetizers,18:00 and the main food is on a table.18:03 Let's say there's a buffet style,18:04 it's on a buffet table,18:06 but it's covered, which means nobody's allowed to have it yet.18:08 It's there, but nobody's allowed to have it yet.18:09 So then the only other food that you have is the appetizers.18:12 Likewise over here, we're going to have the bread, but not now.18:15 So we cover it and we make kiddush on a cup of wine,18:18 and then we make the18:20 bracha hamotzi. Those are the three reasons that are brought down18:23 why we cover the bread.18:25 Now we know that we cover it in the evening,18:28 and on Shabbat day when we're having the meal in the house,18:31 also we cover the bread.18:33 The Kaf HaChaim points out that you should cover it also18:35 during18:38 seudah shelishit, because the idea of boshet hapat,18:43 meaning that we should have the cup of wine only after18:48 hamotzi, therefore we cover the bread to have the cup of wine.18:50 Although it's only relevant to Shabbat morning and Shabbat evening,18:54 you have the other reasons,18:57 zecher laman, and also the reason of the seudah of Shabbat should come19:02 and be presented in a nice way.19:04 So although people are not so careful in this,19:06 I haven't seen anybody in seudah shelishit that covers his bread,19:09 but if a person can do it,19:11 just take a napkin19:12 and put the lechem mishneh on a plate,19:15 and then put the napkin over it for two seconds19:17 and then uncover it,19:18 it will be a very good idea.19:20 Also, what kind of cover should a person use?19:24 The poskim bring down19:26 if a person could use a white cover,19:29 it's very good,19:30 because19:32 zecher laman. However, even a clear cover,19:34 even though you could see the bread,19:36 but it still serves as a cover.19:40 Another thing,19:41 covering mezonot.19:43 What about covering mezonot?19:45 In Hilchot Berachot,19:46 if a person has in front of him19:47 something where the beracha is mezonot,19:49 let's say a cookie,19:50 and he has a cup of wine.19:52 Now, halacha says that you have to make the beracha of mezonot19:54 before the beracha of wine.19:57 So therefore, when a person is making kiddush in the morning,20:00 you have mezonot right in front of you20:01 and you have a cup of wine.20:02 Do you have to cover the mezonot or not?20:05 There are different opinions20:07 amongst the poskim20:08 if a person has to cover the mezonot or not.20:11 I'm just going to say the opinion of20:14 Hacham Ovadia. In20:15 Hazon Ovadia, Shabbat, chelek aleph, he says20:17 that a person must cover even the mezonot,20:20 and not only the person making kiddush,20:23 but even20:24 those who are listening to the kiddush,20:26 since we have a rule,20:29 shomea k'oneh, that when a person is listening to kiddush,20:30 it's as if he is saying it,20:32 so the mezonot that's in front of the listeners20:35 also has to be covered.20:37 This is what Hacham Ovadia rules.20:38 There are different opinions,20:41 so a person should ask20:42 his local rav. But preferably,20:44 certainly to be20:46 yotzei according to all opinions,20:47 one should cover even the mezonot20:51 on Shabbat,20:52 whether it's in the daytime kiddush20:54 or whenever he's making kiddush20:55 when he's picking up the cup of wine.20:58 I want to point out a small lesson21:00 when Chazal said,21:02 Boshet hapat.21:03 Once heard from a rav,21:05 forget who the rav was,21:06 but it was a very important lesson.21:10 Chazal tell us that we cover the21:12 bread in order not to embarrass the bread,21:14 meaning that we're making21:15 the beracha of wine21:17 before the beracha of bread,21:20 so don't embarrass the bread,21:22 cover it.21:23 Sometimes a man may come home,21:25 and the kids have thrown the house upside down.21:28 The bread is not ready,21:30 the table is not ready,21:32 and he sees the challot, the bread is uncovered,21:35 and he starts yelling,21:36 What's going on?21:37 Why aren't you covering the bread?21:39 You have to cover the bread. Don't you know?21:40 Boshet hapat. The bread is going to be embarrassed,21:42 and you have to cover it.21:44 So a person has to learn from the bread.21:47 We cover the bread that we shouldn't embarrass it,21:49 kavod hachomer. The bread, you should know,21:50 is not going to get any embarrassed.21:52 The bread is not going to turn red.21:53 It's not going to become crispier21:55 if you sees you pick up the cup of wine.21:57 But we should learn from it21:59 that if we're22:01 sensitive even to something that has no feelings,22:04 to the bread that it shouldn't see,22:06 it shouldn't get embarrassed22:06 by making a blessing over wine over it,22:09 a person also has to be sensitive22:12 to everyone in the family,22:13 to his wife and his children.22:15 Because, like the Ben Ish Chai points out22:17 in22:19 Leidah Parashiyot, there's a big yetzer hara that tries to confuse the house,22:21 that tries to make trouble in the house,22:24 especially on Shabbat,22:25 and especially in the areas22:27 where people could fight for it religiously22:30 and say, You know, I'm not doing it for me,22:32 I'm doing it for the honor of Shabbat.22:33 Be careful not to embarrass the family members22:36 and to yell at them.22:37 Like Chachamim say,22:41 Divrei chachamim benahat nishma'u. They're heard22:45 benahat, when said softly and kindly.22:47 We'll take a small break,22:48 and then we'll come back to the rest of the halachot,23:45 be'ezrat Hashem. So23:46 easy, so easy to23:52 see. Besugayim wakuru. Kibezvune, kibezvuneo, besencho, besencho. Sois, sois. Besugay.31:05 בזמננו לשמוח, בשמחה. ברוך אתה ה'. משמח ציון, ציוני. משמח ציון,31:26 ציוני. בבוניהו, בבוניהו. משמח ציוני, בבוניהו. ... ... ... ... כי בזמננו, כי בזמננו לשמוח, בשמחה. ... ... ... ... כי בזמננו, כי בזמננו לשמוח, בשמחה. ברוך אתה ה'. משמח... We're back. I just want to say the phone numbers for anybody would like to call in or text in a question. Or a comment, preferably a question. The telephone number over here to the station to call in to ask a question is 718-683-5858. One more time, 718-683-5858. To text in a question, you can text it in at 347-927-TEXT, T-E-X-T, 8398. I don't think we have those phones anymore. But anyway, the phone number is 347-927-8398. This is to text in a question. I want to point out another thing, and that is there's a little bit of a change of schedule. We're on live on Wednesdays at 2 to 3 o'clock. However, the rerun has been pushed from 10 to 11 o'clock on Tuesday nights. So again, the halacha hour is on Tuesday night as a rerun from the show that's live on Wednesday, on Tuesday night from 10 till 11 o'clock. If anybody has a question also, when you hear the rerun, you can just text it in and we'll hope to get back to it. From now, the next few halachot from Halacha Aleph to Chaf Gimel, the Ben Ish Chai talks about the halachot regarding the cup of the kiddush. And here we're going to talk about which cups qualify and what a person needs to do when he has the cup. Let's begin with Halacha Chaf Aleph. Kos ha-kiddush, the cup that a person is making kiddush on, afilu hu imhu naki, tzarich hadacha bifnim u'shtifah bachutz. Even if it's clean, a person should rinse it with water from the inside and from the outside. Now this is only al pi Kabbalah. This is only kabbalistically. The Zohar says a person should rinse it even if it's clean. However, According to halacha, if you know it's clean, you washed it and you put it in the cabinet, you can just take it out. But since it's not so hard, we all have sinks, Baruch Hashem, so if a person has a sink, he should rinse it from the inside and the outside before31:29 making kiddush. Also, u'maaleh al kol gedevotav, when you fill it up, it should be filled to the top. If you're worried that when you fill it up, it's going to overflow and make yourself dirty and make the people around you dirty or the tablecloth dirty, so you don't have to go all the way to the top. I believe the Taz says even a little bit right before the edges is also fine. The next thing a person has to be careful in the cup of wine that he's using for kiddush, v'lo yihyeh pagum. It should not be pagum. What is pagum? Shem shata mimenu pegamo. Pagum means a trune. Any time that a person takes a sip from the cup of wine, it doesn't make a difference who the person is, whether it's a person making the kiddush or if it's the person of anybody else, like the children, the cup of wine is considered pagum and it should not be used for kiddush. Next, v'yehei shalem b'sfato ha-basis shelo, and the cup should be complete in the base and by the edge where the mouth goes. V'sedek afilu b'lo chisaron posel. A crack, even if nothing is missing from the cup, just a crack in the cup, then that's going to become pasul. A crack meaning, let's say over here, a split in the cup. Okay? We should point out, all these things that we mentioned over here are only31:32 lechatchila, meaning preferable.31:34 If you don't have these things, let's say somebody drank from the cup of wine,31:38 but you have enough, you have a shiur of revi'it, you have the amount of revi'it in the cup of wine,31:43 then you can make kiddush on it,31:46 bediavad. Preferably, a person should have a cup that's31:51 not pagum. But again, these are lechatchila and not31:53 b'diavad. Next,31:58 v'tzarich sheyiten oto adam acher b'stei yadav. When a person is—32:00 Picking up the cup of wine, there's a certain manner, kabbalistically, of how to pick up the cup.32:04 If you have another person with you, the other person should pick it up with two hands32:09 and hand it over to you with two hands.32:12 V'zeh hamekadesh, who is making the kiddush,32:18 yekablenu mimenu b'shtei yadav. He should also receive it with two hands,32:20 b'tzad semolo, keneged hazeh.32:22 He should hold it to the left side by his chest, by his heart,32:26 and then,32:27 v'achar kach yochaz bo b'yad yamin32:29 bilvad. After picking up with two hands,32:31 you should only hold it with one hand,32:36 v'igbihen ma'alah al shulchan tefach lefachot, and should be higher than the table at least32:38 a tefach, which is around eight centimeters,32:43 v'yiten einav bo shelo יסיח דעתו ממנו, and you should look at the cup32:45 in order that your mind shouldn't wander around.32:48 So let's review very quickly in the matter of how to pick it up.32:51 Number one is32:52 pick it up with two hands32:54 if you're by yourself.32:56 If somebody is with you, you should give it to you with two32:58 hands. I want to point out33:00 that a person's wife could also give it to him33:03 as long as his wife is not33:04 niddah. If his wife is not33:06 niddah, then she should not give him the cup of wine.33:08 He should pick up the cup of wine by himself.33:11 When you receive it,33:12 if somebody is giving it to you,33:13 you should receive it with two hands33:14 and then only hold it with the right hand.33:16 The Mekubalim explain that the left hand shouldn't assist33:19 holding the cup of wine33:21 because the left represents33:23 din, and you don't want to give any support to the33:26 din. Again, this is all kabbalistically.33:27 If you want to hold the cup of wine whenever you want,33:30 as long as you're holding it,33:31 preferably in the right hand,33:32 then a person is also33:35 yotzei de chovah. Now that we're talking about the cups of wine,33:36 I want to talk about something important33:38 before I get to the question that we just got in:33:41 plastic cups.33:43 Can a person make kiddush on plastic disposable cups?33:47 There's two types of plastic cups.33:49 There's plastic cups that we use one time;33:51 those are disposable,33:52 the ones that you buy, you know,33:54 like a hundred for 99 cents.33:55 And then there are those cups33:57 which are hard plastic that people keep.34:00 The second type we're not talking about.34:01 Those are regular cups34:02 that are no different from any other cup.34:04 The plastic cups are disposable,34:06 spoken about in the34:08 poskim, and after much give and take,34:10 the bottom line is that everybody will agree34:12 that if a person has another option34:15 besides the plastic disposable cup,34:18 then they should use the other cups.34:20 What's the best cup to use?34:23 The Mekubalim bring down silver.34:24 A silver cup is the best.34:27 If a person doesn't have silver,34:29 glass or hard plastic,34:30 anything that a person usually uses,34:33 that qualifies also34:35 to use it for kiddush.34:36 If a person, however,34:37 doesn't have anything besides plastic cups,34:41 then you can use a plastic cup for kiddush.34:46 Better if you would use that cup again.34:49 Now, I've always seen34:51 that when people have plastic disposable cups,34:52 they put two cups together.34:55 They put one cup inside the other cup.34:57 I have not found any source for that.35:01 When you learn the sugyot35:02 and you learn the35:04 halacha, you don't find really any logic to it so much,35:07 why you should put two cups.35:09 It doesn't make it any more35:10 chashuv, this two cups, two disposable cups.35:12 It's either a nice fancy cup,35:15 even if it's plastic,35:16 and you're going to use it again and again,35:18 or it's not.35:20 What does two cups do?35:21 It doesn't make it more important.35:25 And I've seen also35:27 that in the book35:29 Piskei Teshuvot, he says the same thing,35:29 that he has not found any source for the double cup,35:32 and there's no meaning to it.35:34 Although I would like to say35:36 that I came across a picture35:39 where there was an important Rosh35:42 Yeshiva who was making kiddush on a double cup.35:44 And the story on the bottom,35:47 when it's speaking about this picture,35:48 it says that there was a certain gadol.35:49 I don't want to say his name35:51 because maybe I quoted him wrong,35:53 that a certain gadol told him35:55 to put two cups together.35:56 Again, the reasoning I don't understand,35:59 but, and there is no source,36:01 but there is such a thing.36:02 Does it make a difference?36:04 In my opinion,36:05 I don't know why it should make a difference36:07 if you put two cups together.36:10 If a person has another cup,36:11 then you could use it.36:12 If you don't have another36:14 cup—excuse me—if a person has another cup,36:15 then you should use the other cup.36:17 And if you don't have another cup,36:18 then you can use the plastic cup.36:21 Come to a question over here.36:23 Let me see.36:24 What do you do36:26 if you started kiddush36:28 and then you did hamotzi,36:30 and you forgot the second challah in the oven36:33 and you have only the covered one?36:36 I'm not sure if I exactly understand this question,36:38 if you could call back,36:39 but I'm assuming, let me—I'm assuming like this:36:43 you uncovered,36:44 you made kiddush on a cup of36:46 wine. You uncovered the cover of the challah,36:52 and you find only one,36:53 and you made hamotzi on it,36:54 and then you remembered,36:55 I don't have lechem36:56 mishneh, I need the second piece of bread.36:58 What do you do in that case?37:00 So if you37:00 said b'chat hamotzi already,37:02 then you eat from the piece of bread that you made,37:05 and the lechem37:06 mishneh, I guess you didn't have it,37:09 but it's not37:10 me'akev. This is only37:11 l'chatchilah. It's preferable that a person who makes the bracha of hamotzi37:14 should have two pieces of37:15 bread. But over here,37:16 that you made the blessing already,37:19 then eat from the bread that shouldn't be37:21 hefsek. Once you already made the blessing,37:23 it's not going to help so much37:24 if you bring the other piece of bread.37:27 Now, if this was not the question,37:29 if I misunderstood the question,37:30 please call back and let us know.37:32 Another point37:34 when we're speaking about making Kiddush,37:37 there's a din in the Gemara37:40 that mentions something called37:42 a ituf, and different ways of explaining what ituf is.37:44 But the poskim point out that37:46 if a person is making Kiddush,37:49 he should be dressed properly37:51 when he's making Kiddush.37:52 Meaning, if you're a person that usually wears a hat37:55 in important events,37:57 like when you go to a wedding37:59 or when you go to shul on Shabbat,38:03 then when it comes to Kiddush,38:04 you should also have your hat on,38:05 at least when you make the bracha of Kiddush.38:07 If you usually wear a suit or a jacket,38:10 even though it's a hot summer day38:11 and the AC is not working so well,38:15 still, just for the sake of Kiddush,38:18 you should dress as when you dress38:21 when you go to an important event,38:22 and that's how you38:23 mekayem the mitzvah of38:24 ituf that's mentioned in the Gemara.38:25 Again, this is all preferable.38:27 It's not38:29 me'akev. If a person just made the blessing,38:30 then that's good enough.38:35 Halacha Chaf Bet, Ben Ish Chai speaks about38:36 this concept of pagum,38:38 and he speaks a little bit more in depth about it.38:40 And he says,38:41 Im ein lo ela kos38:44 yayin echad. Let's say you want to wait for Shabbat,38:47 and you realize that you only have enough wine,38:49 or you bought maybe a big bottle of grape juice,38:52 and the kids drank from it,38:53 and all you have left38:55 is just enough for one cup.38:57 You have exactly three ounces of wine39:00 that's good enough only for one cup,39:02 okay?39:03 So what do you do with it?39:05 So Ben Ish Chai says,39:11 Mekadesh bo balayla, veshofech mimenu kos acher veshoteh. You make the Kiddush with it in the evening,39:14 and then what's left over,39:15 you put in another cup.39:16 So I want to correct myself,39:17 I'm sorry.39:18 Over here we're not talking about that you just have three ounces.39:21 We're talking about you just have one cup,39:22 but more than three ounces.39:24 You have, let's say maybe39:25 you have a 10-ounce cup,39:27 and that's how much wine you have.39:28 So you fill up the cup of39:30 wine with the 10 ounces of wine,39:32 and then you make kiddush on it in the39:34 evening. And then, in order to avoid the problem of39:39 pogem, because we mentioned39:40 if you drink from the cup of wine,39:41 you make it pagum.39:42 So what do you do?39:43 You pour from the cup of wine that you made kiddush on39:46 into another cup,39:48 and you drink from that other cup.39:50 Why?39:51 She'im yishteh min hakos atzmo,39:54 harei ze na'aseh pagum.39:55 If you drink from the cup that you make kiddush on,39:59 it becomes pagum.40:01 Yachol lekadesh al hamachar, and then you can't use it for the next day. You have nothing; you have a kos pagum,40:07 and although if you have nothing else you could use it, but lechatchila you have to try to avoid it.40:12 Therefore, the advice is,40:17 shofech mimenu lekos sheni, veshoteh mikos hasheni. You should pour, after making the kiddush in the cup of wine, you should pour into a separate cup40:23 and drink from that separate cup, leaving the leftover wine,40:26 which is more than three ounces, for the following day.40:34 Now, vhenish'ar bekos rishon, yosif alav mayim lemachar vekadesh alav. What's left over, if it's strong enough wine,40:39 then you can add a little bit of water without taking away from the strength of the wine.40:43 If you have grape juice, it's very dangerous to add water to it,40:46 because then you lose the40:49 beracha. So a person could add to it a little bit of water to make the cup appear full; he should do so.40:55 If not,41:03 vim lo nitzarech lehosif, im yosif alav mayim lesimol berachah, lo yishteh botam yayin shelo yuchal levarech alav borei pri hagafen. If you cannot add water, because if you add water to it,41:06 it will take away from the strength of the wine, which will not make it hagafen anymore,41:11 then41:14 harei zeh shotehhu kulo balayla. So then you have no other choice;41:16 you drink the whole thing in the night.41:17 When are we talking about?41:19 That's only,41:22 bameh devarim amurim, yesh lo kos acher lehavdalah. That's only if you have enough wine in the bottle41:26 that you can use also on motzaei Shabbat41:32 for havdalah. Aval im ein lo kos acher lehavdalah, harei zeh meniach kos zeh lehavdalah. But if you went away for Shabbat41:34 and all you have is one cup of wine, that's it,41:35 and we're talking about only three ounces,41:38 then what you do is the following:41:40 in the evening you make kiddush on bread.41:43 In the daytime, since you have also, you have no wine,41:46 if you have beer, if you have any other alcoholic drink, vodka or whiskey.41:51 You can make Kiddush on it.41:53 If not, you can make Kiddush on bread.41:54 Also in the daytime, since you have no other choice,41:57 and that cup of wine you'll use it for havdalah on Motzaei Shabbat.42:01 Why?42:02 Because Kiddush in the evening, you can make it on bread.42:05 In the daytime, although you can make Kiddush on bread,42:08 but if you have no other choice, that's what you have to do.42:11 But for havdalah, there's nothing else.42:13 Either you make it on wine or beer or alcoholic drink.42:17 If not, then you can't make it.42:19 Those halachot of havdalah we'll talk about,42:21 be'ezrat Hashem, in upcoming parashiyot.42:24 But what we did discuss in this42:28 halacha is the concept of pagum.42:29 Pagum means when a person drinks from it.42:31 How does a person fix pagum?42:33 Very simple.42:35 Either you add a drop of wine or a drop of42:38 water. And what makes something pagum42:41 is not only when a person drinks from it with his mouth.42:44 Even if a person puts a straw and he drinks from it,42:47 that also makes it pagum.42:54 Okay. Somebody sent in a comment.42:56 He said that it's better to use two plastic cups42:59 because it's showing that it's not a weekday thing.43:01 If you don't have another option,43:04 then it's better to use two cups as far as honor.43:08 Perhaps, but as far as the cup of Kiddush,43:12 we're talking about that the cup has to be qualified for Kiddush.43:15 So if it's qualified, it's qualified.43:17 And if you use your regular glass cup during the weekday,43:19 nobody puts two glass cups together.43:22 So I'm still, you know, not sure exactly, you know, why not.43:27 What's the difference between a glass cup that I use during the weekday43:29 if I'm using for Kiddush or a plastic cup?43:33 Next we have another question.43:35 What happens if you leave the challah on the oven and you make Kiddush?43:40 Oh, okay, the question is corrected over here.43:46 It's still not. Yes, okay.43:47 The question is like this:43:50 What if a person makes kiddush without the bread on the table?43:53 Is he still yotzei kiddush?43:55 And the answer is yes.43:56 You're yotzei kiddush even without the bread on the table.43:58 It's preferable that the bread should be on the table while you're making kiddush.44:02 However, even if it's not there,44:04 since you're planning to have the seudah immediately in the place that you make kiddush,44:09 you're still44:09 yotzei, even if the bread is not on the table.44:11 Again, even if the bread is not on the table, you could be44:14 yotzei; you fulfilled the obligation of kiddush.44:18 Let's move on now to44:23 halacha chav gimmel. Drinking from the cup of wine.44:25 This is an important halacha that's mentioned in the Gemara as well as Shulchan Aruch.44:29 How much does a person have to drink from the cup of wine?44:32 Lechatchila, tzarich sheyit'am hamkadesh melo lugmav.44:38 Preferable, the person should drink, when he's making kiddush, melo lugmav.44:44 Melo lugmav means—let's give a measurement for it44:50 first—1.6 ounces of wine,44:53 not a lot.44:53 1.6 ounces of wine is considered melo lugmav.44:57 Some say even45:00 1.7. However, if a person's mouth—it really means, lugmav means a cheekful,45:05 not both cheeks.45:06 That means if you take liquid and you put it in your mouth45:08 and you push it over to one side of the mouth45:10 and you fill up only one part of your cheek, that's called melo lugmav.45:14 If a person's mouth is different size than 1.7, it goes by that person's mouth.45:21 Okay, so melo lugmav is by the person himself.45:23 How much is one cheekful of the person?45:26 Preferably, when a person makes kiddush, he should drink that much after making kiddush.45:34 U'mitzvah min hamuvchar lishtot revi'it. But it's better if a person who is making kiddush should drink45:37 revi'it, not because of seudah, but because of kiddush.45:42 Seudah is a separate thing.45:49 U'vdi'avad, im lo ta'am hamkadesh v'ta'am hamubharim melo lugmav, yatzu kulam yedei chovatam. However, if a person—we're talking about Leil Shabbat right45:52 now—if a person cannot drink for whatever reason,45:55 and somebody else has to drink, then it also works.45:59 As long as one other person drank melo lugmav from the cup of wine,46:05 then it would also work.46:09 However, it's preferable that everybody should drink from the cup.46:13 As we see, many people, they try to run after the cup of wine,46:16 or they want to drink from that cup of wine.46:18 Some people in their families, after a person makes Kiddush,46:21 they pass the cup of wine to everybody to drink.46:24 Now, I want to point out something important here.46:27 Number one is that it is not a must to drink from the cup of Kiddush.46:33 It's very good;46:35 it's a mitzvah min hamuvchar, but it's not a must.46:38 Why am I saying this?46:40 Because you could sometimes fall into a few problems.46:43 Number one, if a person feels that he has to drink from that cup of wine,46:47 otherwise he's not yotzei the46:49 chovah, it could create, in my opinion, two issues that I've seen.46:52 Number one is if a person is not planning to have a seudah over46:55 there—we mentioned this in the46:56 past—a person who is not planning to have a46:58 seudah, let's say he's listening to Kiddush in the shul47:00 and he's planning to go home and have a47:02 seudah, so the Kiddush in the shul is worthless to47:05 him, because Kiddush has to be in the place of47:08 seudah. But some people think,47:09 Oh, if I drink from the cup of wine, it's a47:11 mitzvah. I have to drink from the cup of wine,47:12 and this way I'll be47:14 yotzei. And the answer is no.47:15 If you're not planning to have a47:17 seudah, then you should not be drinking anything from that cup of wine.47:20 The second that could happen47:23 is if a person is invited with his wife somewhere,47:27 and, you know, the47:29 family—I guess it's family, it's cousins, whatever it47:31 is—the person makes a Kiddush on this cup of wine,47:33 and they pass it around for everybody to drink.47:35 It happens that your wife gets it right before you,47:39 but the person's wife is47:41 niddah. The halacha says that a person is not allowed to eat from the leftovers47:44 or drink from the leftovers of his wife when she's47:47 niddah. So in that case, a person has to know the47:51 halacha. There's no obligation to drink from that cup of wine.47:54 And you can't tell me, Oh, it's my minhag.47:56 It's very nice to have a minhag,47:58 but not when it's going against.48:00 That's the halacha. You cannot have the leftovers of something that your wife, which is nidah, has had.48:08 So whether it's a cup of wine or any leftover food.48:11 If you're embarrassed that everybody's drinking and your wife just drank before you,48:15 so then you could put the cup to your mouth and pretend that you're drinking.48:18 And this way you pass it around from one to one,48:21 and nobody will know the difference if you drank or not.48:23 Anyway, everybody's taking a sip.48:26 Next,48:28 the Ben Ish Chai points out when those who do drink from the same cup that the person is making kiddush,48:33 he says,48:37 People do drink from each other's cup, even though the Gemara says a person shouldn't,48:41 because maybe a person is sick and he has germs that will go into the cup and he gets sick from him.48:50 Since they know the person who's making kiddush doesn't look sick, he's fine, he's clean, he fits your hygienic level,48:59 so then it will be fine to drink from his cup of wine.49:03 However, I do point out that there's some people who do get disgusted and they're very germy from drinking other people's cups,49:11 especially guests.49:12 They're not used to,49:13 they're not from the49:13 family. So if you want to give the guests, you want to offer them,49:17 maybe before the person is making kiddush, before drinking,49:22 he should pour a little bit in a separate cup and pass it over to the guest,49:26 and he and his family could drink from their regular cup.49:29 Let's move on to the last halacha of the day,49:33 halacha chaf-daled, and we hope that next week,49:36 be'ezrat Hashem, we will finish all these halachot on halachot Shabbat of kiddush,49:42 excuse me, and then we'll move on to the halachot of the three weeks and Tisha49:47 B'Av, and we'll begin the holiday series talking about selichot, Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Sukkot, and49:55 Hoshanah Rabbah. Those are a lot of halachot to cover.49:57 We hope to cover them,49:58 be'ezrat Hashem. So,50:00 halacha chaf-daled: what about if a person interrupted between kiddush and drinking?50:04 What is the50:06 halacha? Menuchat says,50:10 Kiddesh v'kodem shetaam, nispach hakos. First makes a kiddush on a cup of wine,50:12 and right before he drinks, he says,50:14 Baruch Atah Hashem,50:16 mekadesh haShabbat, or borei pri hagafen in daytime.50:18 The cup falls from his hand and everything spills.50:21 What do you do now?50:23 Yaviu lo kos50:25 acher v'varech borei pri hagafen. If there's no other wine on the table,50:27 there's no grape juice, there's no wine,50:29 it's not on the table, it's in the kitchen,50:30 and he obviously didn't have in mind to continue drinking later on in the50:33 meal, so then they have to bring him another cup of wine,50:37 and he should make another50:42 berachah of hagafen. Ach, however, lo yevarech birkat kiddush,50:44 kvar berachah otah. He shouldn't make a berachah of kiddush50:47 because he's already50:49 yotzei the chovah of kiddush.50:50 He just wants to drink another cup of wine,50:52 so he makes50:57 a berachah hagafen. V'chen hu hadin im hifsik b'dibur shelo mitzorech haseudah. So too for a person interrupted with speaking51:00 before drinking from his cup of51:02 wine, meaning the person who made the kiddush51:05 spoke after saying the51:07 berachah mekadesh haShabbat, but before he drank from the cup.51:09 That's if he spoke in words that are considered an interruption,51:13 then, and he wants to continue drinking afterwards,51:16 he has to make another berachah of51:18 hagafen. Now what's called an interruption?51:21 Interruption means anything that's not necessary for the meal.51:25 Meaning, a guy makes berachah Baruch Atah Hashem,51:27 mekadesh haShabbat, and right before he drinks he says,51:29 So who won the NBA championship,51:31 the Spurs or the Heat?51:35 So that has nothing to do with the meal,51:37 so that's considered an interruption51:38 where it would require him to say another51:41 berachah. The berachah of kiddush, the second one on Friday night,51:44 is51:45 yotzei, but the first berachah he made a hefsek,51:48 it's considered an interruption.51:49 If he wants to drink, he has to make another berachah on51:53 the gefen. An interruption that's not considered an interruption,51:55 although he spoke,51:55 is if a person makes52:01 a berchat mekadesh HaShabbat, and then before he drinks, he says,52:03 Oh, rabotai, you have to sit down when you drink.52:06 So he wasn't supposed to stop,52:08 but he stopped in something that's relevant to the kiddush52:11 or to the52:12 seudah. That's not considered an interruption.52:15 The Or LeTzion,52:18 Chacham Ben Tzion Abba Shaul, alav hashalom, points out52:19 that even if the cup spilled,52:21 a person really doesn't need to make another kiddush whatsoever again,52:25 even52:27 birchat hagafen. This is only preferable.52:28 He brings it from the words of the Beit Yosef,52:32 and the Ish Matzliach follows in his footsteps,52:36 meaning the Ish Matzliach Mishnah Berurah meaning,52:38 and they say also52:39 that if the cup of wine spilled52:40 and the person doesn't want to drink more,52:41 he doesn't have to make the bracha of52:45 hagafen. What happens often52:47 is that when a person makes a kiddush,52:50 sometimes the people listening to the kiddush interrupt52:53 and they speak.52:55 So if they speak about something52:57 that's relevant to the kiddush,52:59 like, Give me, I didn't get,53:01 you know, can I please have a cup of wine?53:02 They were not supposed to,53:03 but if they do,53:05 then it's fine.53:05 They could still drink from it.53:07 However, if they interrupt53:09 in something that's not related to kiddush,53:12 so the Ben Ish Chai says,53:13 one last line, he says,53:18 The people listening to kiddush53:20 have to be very careful not to speak,53:21 even if they're not planning to drink,53:23 until the person who's making the kiddush drinks.53:25 If they are planning to drink,53:28 kal vachomer they should be careful not to speak.53:29 If they speak, however,53:32 so here pay attention53:34 because it gets a little bit complicated.53:36 In order, if the person— is listening to Kiddush,53:39 wants to drink,53:42 and he does speak53:44 from matters not relevant to the Kiddush,53:48 then it's better that he shouldn't drink53:50 because he interrupted and he spoke.53:53 But if he's still insisting on drinking,53:55 b'diavad he could still drink.53:57 He should not make another54:00 beracha. However, if a person making the Kiddush54:05 spoke and interrupted matters not relevant to the Kiddush,54:08 and the person listening54:10 also spoke about matters not relevant to the Kiddush,54:13 then if both of them interrupted,54:16 then the listener should not drink from that cup of wine.54:21 Okay?54:21 So again, let's review.54:23 If a person makes the Kiddush54:24 and he drinks from it,54:26 and another person interrupted,54:27 lechatchila they shouldn't drink,54:28 but if they want to drink afterwards,54:31 there's what to rely on.54:32 However, if the person who is making the Kiddush,54:37 as well as the listener,54:38 both interrupted in matters not relevant to the Kiddush,54:40 then they should not drink from the cup at all.54:46 And later on in the meal,54:47 if they want to drink wine,54:48 they can drink wine.54:49 Keep in mind,54:50 since the Kiddush was said54:52 and they're going to have a meal,54:53 they are considered that they have fulfilled the obligation of Kiddush.54:57 We've come to the end of the program,54:59 and we'll finish off with a Shabbat Shalom55:00 and a thank you to Iran Jacob here in the studio55:03 and to JRoot Radio.55:05 See you, be'ezrat Hashem, next week, Wednesday55:07 at 255:08 o'clock, and the rerun again will be this Tuesday evening at 1055:13 o'clock. Shabbat Shalom.