Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript
We are here live in the studio for the Halacha hour, learning the halachot of, right now we're focusing on halachot Shabbat, specifically from the Ben Ish Chai. We're in Parashat Bereishit. We're up to Halacha Yud Gimel. I just want to review very quickly what we learned last week. The Ben Ish Chai pointed out, we learned—actually, let's start with this. We learned that every adult male and female, Jewish adult that is, has an obligation to make Kiddush, and this obligation is an obligation from the Torah. What's considered an adult male or female? That is girls from the age of 12 and higher, and men from what we call bar mitzvah, from the age of 13 and higher. Another point we learned is that children, their obligation in Kiddush is only miderabanan; it's a lower level, and therefore children cannot make Kiddush not only for adult men, but they cannot even make Kiddush for adult women. Somebody gave me a good idea to mention, and if you would have—we mentioned last week a case of twins. If you have twins, a boy and a girl, when the twins are the age of 12, the boy's obligation is still miderabanan, while the girl's obligation is from the Torah. Therefore, in that case, the boy will not be able to make Kiddush for his sister, the twin who is 12 years old. However, the girl, who is a bat mitzvah, could make Kiddush for herself and for her brother as well as for the rest of the family if it's necessary. And now we'll begin today's class, Halacha Yud Gimel. The Ben Ish Chai discusses Kiddush before nightfall. Okay, before sunset, let's focus a little bit more on this point. A little bit of a background to the halacha. There's a mitzvah called Tosefet Shabbat, to add on to Shabbat. The mitzvah, the Gemara explains, really comes from what the Torah tells us regarding Yom Kippur. Regarding Yom Kippur, there's no argument on this. The Gemara says this, and everybody agrees on this Gemara. There's an obligation from the Torah that a person should not accept Yom Kippur when the sun sets and the new day begins. Rather, a person has to add from Erev Yom Kippur, from the day before Kippur, onto Yom Kippur. So let's give an example. Let's say the sun sets at 8 o'clock on Yom Kippur. A person should not wait till 8 o'clock to accept upon himself all the laws of Yom Kippur. He must add from the hours before 8 o'clock, either minutes or whatever he wants, some sort of time he must add to the Yom Kippur. And for example, let's say he should accept it 7:50. This way he added 10 minutes from Erev Yom Kippur to Yom Kippur. This is called a mitzvah of Tosefet mechol al hakodesh, adding from the weekday upon kodesh. On Yom Kippur, everybody agrees this is an obligation from the Torah. However, the question is, does the same law apply to Shabbat? Meaning, do we have an obligation to add from the weekday to Shabbat? We're talking about now an obligation, not if you could. You could, for sure you could. The question is, do you have an obligation to add from the regular on Friday to onto Shabbat? We would say about 90% of the poskim hold that there's an obligation from the Torah, just like Yom Kippur, to add from Friday onto Shabbat. That means you must accept Shabbat earlier than when the time sets. If the sun is setting at 8 o'clock, a person must accept Shabbat a few minutes beforehand at least. Some hold even up to 24 minutes beforehand. Some even go a little bit more. However, there are some opinions who hold that the obligation is only miderabanan, and some hold that there is no obligation at all. The opinion of the Shulchan Aruch, that there is a mitzvah to add from Friday onto Shabbat. That means to make part of Friday kadosh, holy, like the kedusha of Shabbat. With that background, we'll get to Halacha Yud Gimel. Let's read a little bit from the Ben Ish Chai. Af al gav de kaimar lan kiddush Shabbat de'oraita, even though we learned up till now that making kiddush on Shabbat is an obligation from the Torah, mutar lechatchila lehitpalel ulekadesh me'od yom. Still, one would be able to pray earlier, that means before Shabbat comes in. Why? דסמכינן להלכה כמאן דאמר תוספת שבת דאורייתא, because we rely on the opinions that hold that Tosefet Shabbat, adding from the weekday onto Shabbat, is an obligation from the Torah, and therefore, since the mitzvah is from the Torah, a person could also make kiddush, which is also a Torah obligation, in that time. To give a little bit of an example, let's say the sun is setting, like we said, 8 o'clock. Now a person wants to accept Shabbat earlier at 7:30 or even 7 o'clock. He could make Kiddush right afterwards. He doesn't have to wait till eight o'clock to make Kiddush. Even though technically the day of Shabbat has not come till eight o'clock, still, since there is a mitzvah from the Torah to accept Shabbat earlier, so therefore he can make Kiddush then. Now the question is, what about according to the other opinions? The Rambam, for example, holds that the obligation is not from the Torah. The obligation, according to some—some explain the Rambam—the obligation is miderabanan. So how could a person accept Shabbat at seven o'clock and make Kiddush at seven? Obligation has not come into play yet till eight o'clock. For that, says the Ben Ish Chai, even though there's a Rambam who disagrees and he holds that the mitzvah is not min haTorah, it's only miderabanan, still the Magen Avraham explains that even though tosefet Shabbat is derabanan, yotzei b'Kiddush zeh, keivan d'bsha'ah d'mekadesh yavo achar kach lidei chiyuv d'oraita. Since it will eventually lead into de'oraita, meaning when a person accepted Shabbat at seven o'clock, in a few more minutes, in an hour or so, it will be already Shabbat from the Torah, and his obligation will be from the Torah, so therefore he may also make Kiddush at seven o'clock, even according to the Rambam, because it will eventually lead into de'oraita. We're going to skip the next part and go on to the end of the halacha, and the Ben Ish Chai says, V'al kein nahagu ha'olam bazeh bechamah mekomot lekadesh me'od yom. Therefore you see that the custom is to make Kiddush even before the sun sets, especially in the summer. You see many, many people who pray very early, because if you're going to pray after sunset, by the time you finish praying, by the time you get home, it's already close to nine o'clock. Another week or two it will be exactly nine o'clock, 9:15 when people get home. So people don't like to eat so late, especially if you live in countries like England, where shkia is around 8:30, 9 o'clock sometimes. So by the time a person gets home, it's close to 10 o'clock. So it's very difficult to wait till sunset to make Kiddush. That's why the minhag by most of the Jewish world is in the summertime they pray earlier and they accept Shabbat earlier. אך המחמיר לקדש בוודאי לילה, תבוא עליו ברכה. If a person wants to be machmir to wait to make Kiddush till the evening, till that means making sure that for sure night, then תבוא עליו ברכה. He should get an extra blessing. He gets a blessing from the Ben Ish Chai. However, one thing a person has to be careful if he's waiting. If you want to make kiddush till it's for sure night, and you don't want to make kiddush early, this way you want to cover yourself according to all opinions, so don't pray early and then wait, because in that case, kabbalistically it's not lechatchila, or not even kabbalistically; halachically, it's not so good for a person to come and wait for making kiddush. The words of Shulchan Aruch imply that a person should make kiddush immediately when he comes home. So what is suggested, if you want to pray a little bit earlier, he says pray only a little bit earlier and then go home. And if you look in the siddurim, there's certain parts from the Zohar, and some people have some pizmonim and certain prayers that a person says before kiddush. You could say all that until the sun sets, until it's nighttime, and then you can make your kiddush. So let's review. Let's cap it up very quickly. If a person wants to accept Shabbat earlier and then pray earlier and then make kiddush even before the sun sets, he has permission to do so. And if a person could wait till it's for sure nighttime, then it's better. However, even if you do it earlier, it's not a problem. Even lechatchila, a person could do it. I would like to add a point that's not connected so much to Hilchot Shabbat, but it's connected to this case. There is a halacha that's brought down, sourced from the Gemara, and it's brought down in Shulchan Aruch as well, that for the men at least, that there's an issur for a person to begin— Meal with bread, meaning a meal with bread, a half an hour before the time of Kriat Shema. Now, Kriat Shema is about 40 minutes after sunset. So that means about 10 minutes right after sunset, even a little bit by sunset, a person is not allowed to begin a meal with bread. Most of the time it's not a problem. The problem really comes on Friday night, Leil Shabbat. If a person has prayed not so late, just a little bit earlier, that by the time he gets home, you see that it's already within the half an hour of Kriat Shema. Le'mashal, let's say sunset is at 8 o'clock, and Kriat Shema must be said at 8:40. From 8:10, a person is not allowed to begin a meal with bread. So what does a person do in such a case? So first thing is to try to avoid it to the best of your capabilities. Try to pray and get home to begin your meal before that half an hour begins. Once you begin your meal, you can already continue. Just make sure you repeat Kriat Shema later on. If, however, a person prayed already and he gets home and it's within that half an hour, and it's too much of a tircha, too much of a burden on himself or the rest of the family to make everybody wait until 8:40 till he says Kriat Shema, so then he could rely on the opinions of the Taz, the Kaf HaChaim brings it also, and the Magen Avraham also, that since you already prayed and said Kriat Shema, although it's not the right time for Kriat Shema, but still there are opinions that say b'diavad a person could be yotzei dei chovah with Kriat Shema that he reads. After plag hamincha, therefore you could begin your meal. That's a halacha that's brought down by the Kaf HaChaim. A person could rely on such an opinion. If, however, a person could be machmir, it's better because there are those who are stringent. If a person cannot be machmir, then you could even begin your meal, and just remember to say Kriat Shema later on, in the middle of the meal. Okay, with that we'll move on to halacha yud dalet. Halacha yud dalet talks about a boy becoming bar mitzvah leil Shabbat. That means he only turns 13 afterwards. However, they prayed early. Eight o'clock is Shabbat. The father and son went to shul and they prayed earlier, and they're home already at 7:15. And now, being that already the boy is considered bar mitzvah because he accepted Shabbat, he wants to make a kiddush for the rest of the family. Regarding this, says the Ben Ish Chai in halacha yud dalet, Katan shegdiven asah ben shalosh esreh shanah vyom echad bleil Shabbat kodesh, yamtin bakiddush ad layla vadai. He should wait to make kiddush until it's for sure night. Even though we say tosefet Shabbat is de'oraita, in such a case, he says, for him to exempt other people, it's better that he should wait. Vkein raui lharot bdin zeh lchatchilah, dein bzeh lo tircha vlo hefsed, because it's not a burden. It's true he has to wait another 45 minutes, but it's not a big burden, it's not a big loss. They might have seen him until night. What does he lose if he waits till the night? So he won't make kiddush tonight. Let him make kiddush tomorrow morning, and then he can exempt other people. But regarding now tonight, because it's de'oraita, we don't say that we should be lenient to allow the boy who— Just became bar mitzvah or is becoming bar mitzvah that night to make Kiddush earlier. Regarding this halacha, there's a point we can bring out, and that is that when a person is making Kiddush for other people, he has to be able to hear the Kiddush. And the poskim bring down that two people should not make Kiddush at the same time. What does that mean? When is this applicable? In some Chassidisha houses, I think I've seen in the Chassidisha houses, that everybody, every adult person makes Kiddush. The father makes Kiddush, the children make Kiddush if they're over bar mitzvah. Each one makes his own Kiddush. So in that case, if one person is saying Kiddush for the others, then he cannot say Kiddush at the same time that somebody else is saying Kiddush, because the person listening has to be able to focus on the words of the Kiddush. This could also happen if there's some sort of Shabbaton or a place where many families are eating together, and they're all sitting on separate tables, and one person in each table is making Kiddush for that table. They have to be careful that those who are listening to be able to hear every word, and because of that, the person making Kiddush should make sure that there's nobody, nothing disturbing them at that same time, that two people should not be making Kiddush at the same time, so not to disturb the people who are listening to the Kiddush. That's a point that the poskim bring out, that two people making Kiddush at the same time should not be done, so that people could focus on the words of the person making Kiddush. Let's move on to Halacha Yud-Vav. Let's say you find yourself in a place where you're listening to Kiddush from someone. But the person making the kiddush is either mumbling, or it's such a big place you're barely able to hear, and he is the only one who's got the cup. So let's give you a little bit of a background before we get to this halacha, and that is that the Shulchan Aruch writes, when it comes to all blessings, all berachot, let's say a person wants to eat an apple. So Maran writes in Siman Reish Vav, Halacha Dalet, Kol davar shemevarech alav le'ochlo, anything that a person is making a blessing on or to eat it, o lariach bo, or even to smell it, and you're making a blessing on it, tzarich le'ochzo bimino keshehu mevarech. A person must hold it in his right hand when he's making the beracha. So let's go back to our apple case. If you want to eat an apple and it's in front of you, don't make the blessing and then pick up the apple to eat it. Pick up the apple first, hold it in your right hand, even if you're a lefty, hold it in your right hand, and then make the blessing, and afterwards enjoy your apple. This is true also over here when we're making Kiddush. We're going to drink that cup of wine. So since you're saying hagafen, the bracha of the blessing of hagafen, you must hold the cup of wine in your right hand when you're making Kiddush, okay? An important point to keep in mind, that all of what we just said right now is lechatchila. This is the preferable way of fulfilling this mitzvah of making blessings: hold it in your right hand. B'diavad, if a person, however, made the blessing already without holding the item in his hand, b'diavad, it works. It doesn't have to repeat the bracha. Not only it doesn't have to, he should not repeat the bracha. It works, even if it was right in front of him and he made the blessing on the apple that's in front of him without picking it up, it works, and he may pick up the apple to eat it. So with that, we get to halacha tet-vav. The people who are listening to the Kiddush from the father or whoever is the leader of the household have to pay attention, like we just said, to hear the words of the Kiddush. And let's say a person has a hearing disability, not completely disabled, but he has a hard time hearing, or the leader of the household who's making the Kiddush, he's not clear, whether he's older or he cannot pronounce the words properly. And for whatever reason, the people listening to kiddush cannot make their own kiddush. Maybe the leader of the household will get insulted, or people will think that you're too frum for them, you're too religious for them. Whatever the reason may be, so what should you do in such a case? You can't hear the words, and you can't make your own kiddush, so how are you supposed to fulfill the mitzvah of kiddush? Says the Ben Ish Chai, he gives advice. He says this is what you do: Yiten einav b'kos sheb'yad baal habayit u'mekadesh alav. Look at the cup that the leader of the household has in his hand, v'yomar b'lahash birkat ha-kiddush kulah b'sha'ah shebaal habayit mekadesh, and then just say the last berachah, what we call Mekadesh HaShabbat, as he's making kiddush. You can't hear him, but say the words and look at that cup, and this way it's considered that you made kiddush. How does this work? You're not holding the cup in your hand. And the answer is, like we said, you're only obligated to hold the item in your hand lechatchilah; bediavad it works. So in this case, you're in this situation, which is bediavad, where you can't hear the words. So what are you supposed to do? Not be yotzei with the berachah? So just look at the cup, say the berachah of Mekadesh HaShabbat, and then even though you will not drink from the cup of wine, the kiddush still works. Because as we're going to learn later on, when a person makes kiddush, someone—it doesn't make a difference who—someone from the people listening to kiddush has to drink melo lugmav, which is 1.6 ounces of the wine. And in this case, this older person, the leader of the household, is the one who's going to drink from the cup of wine. So from your blessing, it's like he listened—not listened, but he made his own kiddush also, and he could drink from that cup of wine to cover you for the kiddush. Okay. Now, before a person jumps to making his own kiddush in such a manner, he has to know what the minimum amount a person needs to hear from the blessing of Mekadesh HaShabbat to be considered that he made kiddush. Meaning, you don't have to hear every single word bediavad. Lechatchila, you're supposed to hear every single word. However, there's certain parts of the blessing, of the last blessing of kiddush, that a person must hear. If he didn't hear it, then even bediavad it doesn't work. What's the minimum? The minimum is the beginning of the beracha and the end. And that is, you have to hear the following words: Baruch Atah Hashem, Elokeinu Melech HaOlam. That you have to hear for sure, and you must also hear the end: Baruch Atah Hashem, Mekadesh HaShabbat. These words are the minimum. If you're able to make out the beginning and the end of the blessing, then you could rely on that to be yotzei yedei chovat, to consider your obligation fulfilled. However, if you can't even hear that, then you should do what the Ben Ish Chai says: look at the cup and make your own kiddush in such a way. Now, what about drinking from the cup of wine? Like we mentioned, drinking from the cup of wine could be done by any person in that room. And since this person who is making the kiddush is going to drink from it, so that could work for you as well when you make your own silent kiddush. If a person could also hear, try to make out the words of Yetziat Mitzrayim in that beracha, it's preferable, because according to some opinions, that's a necessary ingredient. But when one is stuck, you can rely on this, that you could hear just the beginning and the end of the last blessing of kiddush in order to cover yourself for the kiddush on Leil Shabbat. One more halacha before we take a quick break. Halacha tet zayin. Who can make kiddush for you? Who is, besides the fact that the person has to be Jewish and an adult, but even amongst Jews, there are certain people that may not qualify to make a kiddush. Ben Ish Chai begins in Halacha tet zayin. He says, Suma, a blind person, yuchal lekadesh ulhotzi ishto uvnei beito yedei chovat kiddush, can make kiddush for his family. Why? Dechol haposkim chalku al Rabbeinu Yerucham bedin hasuma. There is an opinion called Rabbeinu Yerucham. He is one of the Rishonim. He is a student of the Rabbeinu Asher, the Rosh, and he says that a blind person should not make kiddush for other people, since we find in the Gemara that blind people may be exempt from mitzvot, he should not make a beracha. However, all rabbis disagreed with this opinion, and they ruled that a blind person can make kiddush. If there are people present who are not blind, and the blind person, who happens to be the leader of the household, doesn't mind if somebody else makes kiddush, then tov shekadesh zeh hafikeach. It's better to cover all opinions, including Rabbeinu Yerucham, and to make kiddush to allow the person who is not blind to make kiddush. Since it's possible, why not do according to all opinions? So again, a blind person can make kiddush, although it's preferable, if the blind person doesn't mind, that someone who is not blind should make kiddush for other people. Now we're on the subject: who else may be disqualified from making kiddush? What about a person who is mechalel Shabbat? He doesn't keep Shabbat. How could he do kiddush for you? He himself doesn't keep Shabbat. He says, Baruch atah Hashem mekadesh haShabbat, meanwhile he himself puts on a TV, drives. Could a mechalel Shabbat cover other people with kiddush? So the poskim bring down there's two types of mechalel Shabbat. There's a mechalel Shabbat who, although he doesn't keep the halachot of Shabbat, he knows, or maybe he doesn't know some halachot, or even the halachot he doesn't know. He'll put on a television, he knows that, in aspos poran TV. He'll change the channel, he'll put on the lights. He may smoke in his backyard, but he won't do it in front of people, or even if he does it in front of some people, he won't do it in front of— A person that he respects. If he would see the rabbi of his shul walk down the block, he'll hide his chilul Shabbat. So this person obviously knows what he's doing is wrong, and he's not doing it against. He has a taavah, and he's not doing it lehach'is. So since he's embarrassed to be mechalel Shabbat in front of someone that he respects, such a person can make kiddush for other people. However, there's other people that are mechalel Shabbat, and they don't care. They're not embarrassed in front of anyone. It's a little harsh to say, but it's not my words. These are the words of the Gemara and the Shulchan Aruch, that a person who's mechalel Shabbat befarhesya, in public, meaning to say he's not embarrassed of anyone, even the rabbi of his shul. I don't know if he goes to shul, but even if he goes, he's not embarrassed to be mechalel Shabbat. He'll drive, he'll smoke in front of other people. The words of the Shulchan Aruch are, Dino ke'akum lechol davar. This Jew, although he's a Jew, but since he's mechalel Shabbat befarhesya, he's considered like a non-Jew when it comes to halacha, which means, we said only Jews could cover you in kiddush. Such a person, even though he may be honored to make kiddush, somebody does him kavod and make kiddush, since he doesn't care about doing chilul Shabbat in front of other people, so he cannot cover you for kiddush. A person has to be careful in such a case. If you have no choice but to listen to him, so you have to do what the Ben Ish Chai says beforehand: say your own words of kiddush, or try to make your own kiddush. We'll take a little bit of a break right now. We'll come back and continue with halacha yud-zayin. ״ה׳ וישמרך. יאר ה׳ פניו אליך ויחונך. ה׳ ישמרך. יאר ה׳ פניו אליך ויכונך. ישא ה׳ פניו אליך. ישא ה׳ פניו אליך. וישם לך, וישם לך, שלום. יברכך ה׳ וישמרך. יאר ה׳ פניו אליך. יברכך ה׳ וישמרך. יאר ה׳ פניו אליך. During the break, somebody pointed out to us an important thing that we should mention. Let's connect a little bit to kiddush, but it's important. We mentioned that there's two types of mechalel Shabbat. There's a mechalel Shabbat who cares. What does it mean he cares? It means that he's embarrassed. He knows that it's wrong. He has a big yetzer hara, he can't control himself, but he's embarrassed in front of people that he knows or he respects as Torah authority, and he will not be mechalel Shabbat in front of them. That type of person, although what he's doing is not good, but he could make kiddush for you. The other type is a person who doesn't care, is mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya, publicly, doesn't care about anyone or anything. Such a person has a din like a goy and cannot make kiddush for you. Now, you have to be careful. And another point regarding a person who's mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya, and this could happen to anybody. In fact, it happened to me. I'll tell you a story in a second, where such people, when they're invited over, and let's say we're inviting them over, we want to be mekarev them, we want to bring them closer to Judaism, or even they're relatives and we have to invite them, a person has to be careful that there's a halacha, there's a whole section of halachot regarding yayin nesech, wine that's touched by a non-Jew. Wine that's touched by a non-Jew. What does it mean, touched? It means physically touched. The actual wine was touched, or the bottle of wine was used to pour. A goy who touches the wine or pours from the bottle of wine for you or pours a cup for you, that wine becomes forbidden to drink miderabanan. Not only it's forbidden to drink, you can't even drink that cup of wine. You can't even benefit from that cup of wine. It has to be thrown away. That's a special gezeirah that chachamim made. Which is yayin stam yeinam, the one that's been touched by goy. This only applies to wine that's not mevushal, that's not cooked. If you look at your bottles of wine in the house, you'll see it'll say mevushal or not mevushal. Every single kosher wine is guaranteed that it has not been touched by a goy unless it's mevushal, once it's cooked. So then it's not a problem if the goy would touch it or pour it for you, and you don't have to worry about it. If, in case you have bottles of wine which are not mevushal, and you have people over you who are mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya, who publicly desecrate the Shabbat, then a person has to be careful not to allow them to touch your cup of wine. Let them drink their own cup of wine, but not your cup of wine or anybody else in that room that keeps the halachot of Shabbat. I'll tell you a story. One time we had somebody over where we didn't know, but he was a person who was mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya. How do I know? Well, he came, he parked his car right outside. He didn't care less. We didn't know he was such a person. And we had other guests in the house who are religious, and they came over and they brought us wine before Shabbat, but the wine was not mevushal wine. Now, we had to put the wine on the table because it's not nice, you know, they brought us a gift and we put it on the table. But at the same time, we had this guest who was mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya. So if he would touch the wine, it would create a problem. So I took the bottle of wine. I said, you know, I'm going to serve everybody today wine. I wanted to make sure that nobody gets a cup of wine. And mazel, look at what happened. I tried to open the bottle of wine, and I don't think it ever happened to me, but the bottle opener broke. And the metal piece got stuck in the cork, and I couldn't open it. So guess what? Our friend who's mechalel Shabbat happened to be an expert at opening wine bottles, even if you don't have the right tools. I don't know what he did. He took a fork, and he insisted that he's going to open it. He took a fork, and he pulled out the cork. He says, Ha, you see? I have opened the bottle of wine. Here, have some wine. And right after he poured me, I had to make up a lie, but I had to. I told him, I'm sorry, I don't drink. You know, I don't drink alcohol because, you know, it gets me dizzy, I get sleepy. You don't mean fall asleep on the table. It's not nice. I don't drink wine. And I had to somehow camouflage it or make sure that he only drinks from that bottle and nobody else. So a person has to be careful. Make sure you only get yayin mevushal if you have such people over. It's not a problem to have such people over, especially if you can bring them closer to Torah and they'll see a Torah family. It's great. But just make sure you take all the precautions to avoid any issues. At the same time, a person has to be careful that if such a situation happens to you and you have a person in your house, make sure that you don't embarrass the person either in front of everybody. Not just because you might distance him from the Torah, but it's an issur. There's an issur to be מלבין פני חברו ברבים, and this could have an everlasting effect. So כל חכם יעשה בחכמה. A person has to do it wisely. Try to do it in a very nonchalant way, in a way that they shouldn't figure out what you're doing and that the wine that they touched might be a problem, because people are very sensitive to these issues and a person has to take their sensitivity into consideration. Okay, let's move on to Halacha Yud Zayin. Halacha Yud Zayin talks about eating before one makes Kiddush. Says the Ben Ish Chai, asur lit'om afilu mayim kodem Kiddush. One may not even taste water before making Kiddush. When? Mishehigia zeman haKiddush, dehainu bein hashmashot, afilu shelo hitpalelu Arvit ad hain. A person is not allowed to even taste water when the time of Kiddush comes. When does the time of Kiddush come in? Well, it could come in one of two ways: either if you accepted Shabbat, or even if you didn't accept Shabbat, but Shabbat came in, that means sunset already, then since there's an obligation to make Kiddush, a person is not allowed to drink even water. How much? What about mihu im hu betaanit vhu mutalah diyach piv kodem Kiddush. However, if a person is fasting, he just wants to rinse his mouth without swallowing any water, then a person could do so. The Poskim discuss this point regarding a person who is very thirsty and he wants to drink and he didn't make Kiddush yet. So, one thing everybody agrees on, that there is an issur for a person to taste anything, not only food, but even water, which has no taste at all. One may not drink it once the obligation of making Kiddush comes in. However, Chacham Ovadia Shlita brings that if a person is very, very, very thirsty, then he could be lenient to drink only water up to thirteen and a half minutes after shekiah. So that's only if it's very, very necessary. A person sees his throat is very, very dry and he cannot do anything about it and he really needs to drink, then he could drink. We're not talking about a person who is dehydrating, chas v'shalom, who went to the Sakana, that even after twenty minutes of shekiah and a person didn't make Kiddush, he couldn't. We're not talking about a person who's going to put himself in danger or anything. We're talking about just a person who's very thirsty and he's not comfortable. So, uncomfortable. Says the Chacham Ovadia, only up to 13 and a half minutes if it's really necessary and he can't wait till Kiddush. What about a person who has to take medicine and he didn't make Kiddush yet? What is the din then? And the Acharonim bring down, based on this halacha of rinsing your mouth before Kiddush, that's mutar. If a person has to take medicine before Kiddush and he needs a little bit of water to swallow the pill, one medicine is mutar on Shabbat. He may also take medicine even though he has to drink a little bit of water, since he's doing it really not for hana'ah, he's not doing it for any hana'ah, he's doing it just so the pill could be swallowed. He could drink a little bit of water to swallow the pill. Question: What about children? Could children taste or eat anything before Kiddush? And this answer is very important. All parents must hear this answer and make sure to spread it to tell all your friends. There is no gezeirah, there's no decree that forbids the children to eat before Kiddush. I've seen many times when the children are very hungry and thirsty and Daddy didn't come home yet, Abba's not home yet. Can we eat? We're hungry, we're starving. No, you have to wait. You have to make Kiddush. There's no such a gezeirah on children. Anybody under bar mitzvah could drink and eat before Kiddush. The issur of not eating or drinking before Kiddush is rabbinical. It's made by the Chachamim, and when the Chachamim made the decree, they only made it for adults. I will tell you the words of the Magen Avraham that the Mishnah Berurah also brings down: Asur le'annoto. It's forbidden to make the child... Fast and suffer to wait to make kiddush. And this applies to any child under 13, although it's good to train them when they get close to the age of 13. In a few months they're going to be bar or bat mitzvah, talking about boys 13 and girls 12. But otherwise, children who are younger, certainly if they're under six, there's no reason. And it's not only no reason. It's very problematic when you make them wait to make kiddush in order that they should eat. Sometimes they could grow up resenting the whole concept of making kiddush, because their memories of kiddush is one of suffering and painful and have to wait and so dragging and sloppy. So therefore, a person has to remember the halacha: there is no issur for children to drink or eat before kiddush. And the words of the Magen Avraham, asur l'hanotot, it's forbidden to make a child suffer and wait till kiddush happens. If the child on his own wants to do it, zaku baruch, give him an extra blessing and a kiss if he does it. But otherwise, do not force upon children something where the chachamim do not force. Next halacha, halacha yud-chet. When is the time in the day when the kiddush kicks in, when there's an obligation for a person to make kiddush? Now, in this halacha we're going to discuss the two types of kiddush: the kiddush on Leil Shabbat and the kiddush in the daytime. Let's begin. Kiddush halayla eino talui b'tefillat Arvit. Most people are unaware of this halacha. The kiddush in the evening is not connected to Arvit; it's not dependent on Arvit. Meaning, sheim yirtzeh lekabel Shabbat me'od yom, ulekadesh v'le'echol uletpalel tefillat Arvit בלילה, reshai. If a person wants to accept Shabbat early, and before praying Arvit he wants to make kiddush, he wants to have a seudah, and only later to pray Arvit, he's permitted to do so. Verak tzarich sheyatchil le'echol chatzi shaah קודם זמן קריאת שמע. The only thing is he has to be careful to begin his meal, like we mentioned beforehand, half an hour before the time of reading Kriat Shema. Because, like we mentioned, a seudah, in this case, you have not said Shema at all, not even in tefillah, so nobody will permit it to have a seudah within a half an hour of reciting Kriat Shema. Now, even though technically a person can make Kiddush and have his meal before Arvit, the Arizal, Mekubalim, explain that there's a special Kabbalistic order that—exactly how it works, you have to speak to a Kabbalist—but a person should first pray, then make Kiddush, and then have his seudah. Again, this is Kabbalistically. Min ha-din, if a person wants to make Kiddush and eat before praying Arvit, it's mutar. So therefore, one necessary, a person could first pray Mincha, let's say earlier in the afternoon. When the time of plag ha-mincha comes, he could accept Shabbat early, have his meal, and then later on go to pray Arvit. Two examples. For example, let's say a person has older parents in his house, or eating by him, and the only minyan in his neighborhood is a late minyan that's praying, let's say, at 8:30, and by the time the person goes to shul to pray Mincha and Arvit, by the time he gets home and makes Kiddush, it's too late for his elderly parents or for his young children to stay up. So in that case, he could pray Mincha earlier in the day, and then when plag ha-mincha comes, he has to check the calendar when plag ha-mincha is, he could accept Shabbat, make Kiddush, have the meal with his family, say Birkat Hamazon, and later on go to pray in shul. Another example, and this could happen to people who are invited somewhere. Let's say a person is invited to someone's house, and he missed the earlier minyan, and now the people are praying early and they're starting the meal early. But they have, let's say, within a close distance to the house where he's going to eat by the host, he has a place where he could pray Arvit a little later. He could go earlier, except, again, he has to pray Mincha early. Then he could accept Shabbat early, sit with the family, make Kiddush, have his meal. In the middle of the meal, he could take a 15-minute break, go outside, go to the shul, pray Arvit, and then come back home and continue his meal, assuming that the people are still in the middle of their meal. So these are two scenarios where a person needs to rely on such an opinion. He could rely on an opinion, and that is to make Kiddush and have a seudah before praying Arvit. One is not dependent on the other, unless you want to be stringent like the Mekubalim. This is regarding Kiddush in the evening. Regarding Kiddush in the daytime, says the Ben Ish Chai, Kiddush hayom talui b'tefillah. Kiddush in the daytime is connected to tefillah. The Kol Zeman shelo hitpalel Shacharit, lo chal alav chovat Kiddush. This halacha is specifically to men; we're going to talk about women soon. But regarding men, as long as a person has not prayed Shacharit, then he has no obligation of Kiddush yet. Praying Shacharit, meaning over here the Amidah of Shacharit. Before a person gets up to stand up to say the Amidah on Shabbat morning, he has no obligation to make Kiddush yet. ולכן, ביום שבת בבוקר יוכל לשתות מים קודם תפילה, מפני שכיוון שלא התפלל, לא חל עליו חובת קידוש. Meaning that a person has not, or does not have, the obligation of Kiddush until he prays. So before prayer, he could have a drink. He could have anything that he's allowed to have throughout the week before he prays. Okay, so let's review very quickly. In the daytime, for the men, the obligation to make Kiddush only begins after Shacharit, which means if he wants to eat beforehand, not only does he not say Kiddush, he doesn't have to, but he's not allowed to because there's no obligation of Kiddush yet. Now, there's a very important point that I want to bring out. There is a machloket—I don't know if we're going to get to it or not—there is a machloket between the Rishonim of when the obligation of Kiddush kicks in. Is it after Shacharit or is it after Musaf? We go with the ruling of Shulchan Aruch that the obligation begins after Shacharit, immediately after Shacharit, and not after Musaf. So why am I saying this? Unfortunately, sometimes you see some people who are very lax in this halacha, and they'll eat after Shacharit in shul. They'll eat, like, candies, or they'll eat some things before making Kiddush. And when the sefer Torah is out, right before Musaf, because they say, Hey, listen, we didn't pray Musaf, we didn't finish praying, so we don't have the obligation of Kiddush. And that's not correct, because we hold that the obligation of Kiddush begins right after Shacharit. Now, I was once somewhere, and I saw people who were eating candies by Kriat HaTorah after praying the Amidah of Shacharit, but before Musaf. And when I told them, You know, what you're doing is wrong, so they told me, What are you talking about? We've seen great rabbis where their congregation, you know, they give out candy during Kriat HaTorah. I said, Really? So tell me. They said, No, no, no, no, no. I said, Why? It's not lashon hara. If the rabbi does this publicly, so tell me. They said, Okay, this and this rabbi. Now, the rabbi that they mentioned happens to be a big talmid chacham. So it's beautiful, you know, guess what? Today it happens to be, was that day was Shabbat. I have a brit milah, and I think that rabbi will be in the same place, in the same brit milah. I'm going to go ask the rabbi. He said, Okay, ask him. I get to the brit milah, he wasn't there, but I did catch him later on, Baruch Hashem. When I saw the rabbi later on, I said, Rabbi, can I ask you a question? He says, Sure. I said, Is it true that in your congregation that you permit people to have candy by Kriat HaTorah before Musaf? He says, Chas v'shalom. He says, If— yes, people... You do it in my congregation, but they're like little kids. I've told them countless times that's asur. I've yelled about it. I spoke about it in public, and I said it so many times, it's asur, rabotai, you have to stop. But what could you do? There's some adults who are more immature than children. As many times as you tell them, they don't listen. So how much can a person get up every week and tell them, Rabotai, it's asur to eat candy before Musaf. It's asur to eat candy before Kiddush, and they don't listen. So I almost gave up on them. Now, the reason why I like this story is that you can never know without asking. He may be present in that rabbi's shul, and see the rabbi didn't say anything. This doesn't mean that he never said anything about it. He said in the past, but he said it so many times. You only came there after all those years the rabbi speaking about it. So make sure you ask and verify beforehand. Regardless what that rabbi, you know, let's say even that rabbi would have said yes, we have a Shulchan Aruch, we have Maran, and it's forbidden for a person to eat or drink anything when the time of Kiddush comes in. On Shabbat morning for the men, the time of Kiddush is after praying Shacharit. Now, one last thing, and that is regarding the obligation of women. Ben Ish Hai says, This is only applicable to men, but hanashim... regarding women... Women who don't usually pray every single day, sometimes they pray, sometimes they won't pray. Their obligation of Kiddush kicks in right in the morning. Only the men who pray every single day have an obligation of Kiddush only after praying Shacharit. But women who don't usually pray, their obligation of Kiddush begins right when they wake up in the morning after alot hashachar, after dawn. So therefore, for women who doesn't usually pray every day, wants to eat in the morning, she must first make Kiddush. However, a woman who prays regularly every Shabbat morning or every single day, her obligation of Kiddush is like the obligation for men, and that is only after she prays Musaf—I mean, after she prays Shacharit. So if she prays Shacharit, then afterwards she has the obligation. Before praying Shacharit, she may drink and eat whatever is allowed for her to eat before Shacharit without making Kiddush. One last point, and that is regarding people who are sick, people who don't feel well. What about them? What if the doctor says that a person has to eat or drink in the morning? So what is the halacha for them? Does he first make Kiddush? Talk about men whose obligation only comes after Shacharit. What do they do when it comes to Kiddush in the morning? They have to eat before tefillah. This is what they do every single day. So we ruled, the Sephardi poskim ruled, that they do not make Kiddush in the morning. Since they have a heter, they are permitted to eat before Shacharit, the obligation did not come in till after they pray Shacharit. So even though they're going to eat a whole meal or whatever they have to eat in order to take their medicine, whatever they have to do, they're allowed to eat it without making Kiddush, and it's not correct to make Kiddush in the morning. If you're making a hagafen, drinking a hagafen, so it's not such a big deal, but they still have the obligation of making Kiddush after Shacharit. And with that, we'll finish and just summarize what we learned today. Quickly, we learned that the obligation of making Kiddush begins when one immediately accepts Shabbat, and it's not dependent on tefillah. And even though a person accepted Shabbat early, he could make Kiddush. We also learned that a bar mitzvah boy should wait till the evening to make Kiddush. So for sure, if he's becoming bar mitzvah that Friday night, that Leil Shabbat, he should wait till it's for sure evening to make Kiddush. When a person cannot hear the Kiddush from someone else, he could recite the last berachah on his own silently. And we also learned that a person has to be careful that a person who is making Kiddush for him is someone who is qualified. A person who is mechalel Shabbat b'farhesya is not qualified to make Kiddush for him, and it has to be a person who is mechalel Shabbat without any embarrassment. Eating and making Kiddush before tefillah is permitted as long as it's not done within the half an hour of Kriat Shema. And we'll finish off with a Shabbat shalom. We'll be on over here live next week on Wednesday, 2 to 3 o'clock, and you can hear this class again on the rerun on Tuesday evening. Hopefully the system will work this time on Tuesday evenings from 9 to 10 o'clock. Shabbat shalom. Thank you, Rabbi Shmuel.
