Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Kemach Yashan Part 2Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 2Rabbi Uri Nahum · May 6, 2015−15Play+30Position0:0057:00Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio. This is the Halacha Hour live on Wednesday afternoon.0:08Today is Erev Lag BaOmer, the 32nd day of the Omer. Tonight will be, be'ezrat Hashem, Lag0:14BaOmer, and we're going to have a special class today.0:16We're going to finish up last week's class about our discussion of kemach yashan, and,0:22be'ezrat Hashem, we'll also speak, as much time as time allows us, about0:28Lag BaOmer, about the simchot Lag BaOmer, some of the halachot as well,0:31be'ezrat Hashem, we'll speak about that right towards the end of this class.0:36Let's first give you the numbers, the introductions that we do on a weekly basis.0:41Let's begin. To listen to this class online,0:44you could go to0:46jrootradio.com. There you could also watch us live.0:48You could also listen through your phone by calling the number0:57712-432-4217. You could also listen by Radio JRoot Radio Pro app. That is only on the smartphone,1:05or if you have an iPad or whatever of such, you can listen in such a way as well,1:09the JRoot Radio Pro app.1:12To call into the studio, the numbers are1:18718-683-5858. The other way to be interactive in the class is by texting in,1:22which we always recommend is the best way to get your questions answered,1:28and that's by dialing or texting to the number1:35347-927-8398. Again, it's1:40347-927-8398. Here in the Halacha Hour, we usually discuss the halachot that are practical.1:46We try to make them practical, explain the background.1:48And of course, try to understand how they apply in our situation.1:54Usually we work from the Ben1:56Ish Chai. However, in the holiday season, we take a little bit of a break1:59and we speak about anything that is connected to the holiday.2:04And of course, usually it's the halachot of the holiday.2:06In what we're up to right now, we are in between the days of Pesach and Shavuot,2:13and now different halachot that come up at this time,2:15halachot that are directly connected to the times,2:19like we spoke about in the past,2:20which are the laws and the customs of2:23Sefirat HaOmer, as we're going to speak about today,2:25the laws of—not the laws, but really the customs2:28and the reasons of the customs of2:32Lag BaOmer. However, we are in the middle of discussing Kemah Yashan.2:34The question is, what in the world does that have to do with2:39Sefirat HaOmer? And the answer is, not much,2:42because really this halacha seems to be a little bit isolated.2:46In our days, you could have spoken about this halacha any time of the year.2:50But being that when we count2:54LaOmer, Sefirat HaOmer, there is a halacha that becomes permitted, as we explained last week,2:57and that is that once we start counting the3:01Omer, then the new produce—or excuse me,3:04the produce from last year—becomes permitted to3:07eat. Therefore, it is brought down in the halachot of3:12Sefirat HaOmer, Maran3:14in Orach Chaim, siman taf-peh-tet, the last halacha, se'if yud. Over there3:17he brings the halacha that the halachot of Kemah Chadash apply as well in our days.3:26In order that we should come in and to start talking about the subject of Kemah Yashan,3:30we need to go back a little bit from last week,3:32a little bit of review, recap what we said last week,3:36and then take it from there.3:38Let's begin like this.3:40What is Kemah Yashan?3:41What is Kemah3:42Chadash? It's something that seems to be mysterious to a lot of people,3:45the subject of Kemah Yashan, Kemah3:47Chadash. And the answer is as follows.3:49Maran writes in Shulchan Aruch. That,3:52like we just said beforehand,3:55the halacha in3:57siman taf-pei-tet, the Shulchan Aruch writes,4:06Asur le'echol chadash af bizman hazeh. Maran tells us there's something called4:09chadash, something that's called4:10new, but we're going to use the terminology that's used in4:14halacha. Chadash is forbidden4:16even in our days that we don't have a Beit HaMikdash,4:19and it doesn't make a difference in which form it is,4:22whether it's roasted,4:24whether it's ground and made into bread,4:26made into cookies,4:27whether it's cooked,4:28it doesn't make a difference.4:30It's4:35asur ad techilat leil yud-chet b'Nisan, u'be'eretz Yisrael ad techilat leil yud-zayin b'Nisan. It's asur until the first night of4:37Chol HaMoed, whether you're in Eretz Yisrael or in4:40chutz la'aretz. In Eretz Yisrael,4:42already the second night of the holiday of Pesach4:44is already4:46Chol HaMoed, and all the produce which is in the category of chadash is4:50asur. What is4:52chadash? What in the world is Maran talking about that is4:54chadash? And the answer is as follows:4:55anything that took root after the 16th of the Nisan,5:01that is called5:03chadash. Now, this doesn't apply to all types of produce.5:06It doesn't apply to corn,5:07it doesn't apply to apples,5:08which are trees.5:09It doesn't apply to cucumbers.5:10It doesn't apply to all these things.5:12It only applies to the five grains5:16which we would make hamotzi on them5:18had they been turned into bread.5:20The five grains are known in5:22halacha as the5:25chamisha minim, and we will name them for you right now in English.5:28They are wheat, barley, oats, rye, and spelt.5:33These five grains are the only grains5:38that are subject to the laws of5:43chadash. Nothing else,5:44not corn, not anything else.5:45So when we say produce,5:47we're referring specifically to these five grains.5:50That's number one.5:51Number two, these five grains are asur5:56when they're planted5:58if they took root after Pesach.6:00Now the way this works is as follows:6:02you dig up the ground,6:04you put a seed in the ground,6:06and then you wait for the seed to take root.6:08Once the seed takes root,6:10and then already it6:11starts, just like it starts to take root on the bottom6:13of going under the ground,6:14it starts to go up the ground.6:16Eventually it gets to the stage6:18when it's fully developed6:19and it's ready for6:21harvest. Not necessarily is it harvested right away.6:24Here the halacha tells us,6:25in order for something to be considered6:27chadash, it's something of the new produce,6:29it has to take root after the 16th of Nisan.6:32I don't care when it was planted.6:35I don't care when it was harvested.6:36What we care about is when it took root.6:40So had it taken root after the 16th of Nisan,6:43it's in the category of6:44chadash, which means it's a produce of this year,6:46which will not be permitted to eat6:48until the next 16th of Nisan.6:52Let's give a mashal over here.6:53We are in the year6:55תשע״ה. We're going to use English numbers6:56because people are familiar with it6:57and it's easier.6:58We're in the year 2015.7:00We just had Pesach a month and something ago,7:03a month and change.7:04So now what happened is as follows.7:07We came after Pesach,7:10after holiday was over,7:11and we harvested some things.7:12Now in order to harvest the produce,7:15it had to have been in the ground7:17for at least a7:17month, because remember,7:19you're putting it in,7:20it takes a while till it takes root,7:21and then it starts to grow, to grow,7:23and you want it to grow7:24until it gets to a stage of full development.7:27So at least a month, if not more.7:29So this is what we did.7:30We came, we harvested7:31right after Pesach, we came,7:32we harvested the produce.7:33Is this considered7:35chadash or is this considered yashan?7:37If it's7:38chadash, if it's part of the new produce,7:40then it's subject to this7:42issur that we're talking about.7:42It will not be permitted7:44until next year Pesach 2016,7:47and not the first day of Pesach,7:48but rather the second day of Pesach7:50in Eretz Yisrael7:51and in7:52Chutz Laaretz the third day of Pesach.7:53Remember, the target date7:55is usually 16th of Nisan in Israel. In America, you always—8:01If so, you add another day. However, if you tell me that this produce belongs to last year's produce,8:06this whatever I harvested after Pesach 2015 really is part of last year's produce,8:12so then it's called yashan, old, and yashan has become mutar after the first day of Chol Hamoed Pesach.8:23This, however, would have been asur before Pesach.8:27So what's the halacha? The answer is that the halacha is: when did it take root?8:34If it took root beforehand, before Pesach, then once Pesach comes in,8:39even though I harvested it much after, even if I harvested it a month, two months later,8:42I don't go by the harvest. We go by when it took root.8:47That is the definition of kemach chadash as opposed to yashan.8:51Chadash means the produce of the five grains took root after Pesach,8:56and therefore it becomes asur until the next year Pesach.9:03If it took root before Pesach, then it's already mutar because I'm already past Pesach,9:10and that's called kemach yashan.9:12Now, is this halacha a minhag? Is this something that's only for black hats or for those extra,9:19or as they call them in the non-Jewish world, ultra-ultra Orthodox?9:23Where do we fit into this category? Where is the source of this halacha?9:30The answer is the halacha is9:33mideoraita. This is a pasuk in Parashat Emor, which is read actually the Shabbat.9:38We will read about, the Torah will talk about9:41Sefirat HaOmer, talk about all the holidays, and there we'll mention the pasuk9:44where it says clearly the following.9:47It says—9:56V'lechem v'kali v'karmel lo tochelu ad etzem hayom hazeh, ad havi'achem et korban Eloheichem, chukat olam l'doroteichem b'chol moshvoteichem. You cannot eat nor bread, nor roasted or semi-roasted kernels until this day,10:05referring to the 16th of Nisan, until you bring the korban,10:09which produces the Torah tokef. That's what we call10:15chadash. Chadash is asur until the 16th of Nisan, and then after the 16th of Nisan,10:20it is known as kemach yashan already.10:22This is10:24min haTorah. If it's min haTorah, question is, is this just one opinion? Is there an argument?10:29And the answer is nine Rishonim. Amongst them, the Rambam, the Rif, and the Rosh.10:37Those are the three giants in halacha of the Rishonim.10:40This is what the Shulchan Aruch bases his rulings in Shulchan Aruch upon these three opinions:10:46the Rambam, the Rif, and10:50Rashi, plus many others. I just gave you a partial list, not only these three,10:54but there are nine at least that the Mishnah Berurah, Biur Halacha points out.10:59They all hold that the issur of eating from the new produce is forbidden11:07min haTorah. Question that now hits everybody is, what's the psak halacha?11:12Okay, you tell me now these opinions. What about11:14Shulchan Aruch? And we said the Shulchan Aruch already beforehand.11:16Shulchan Aruch rules without any compromise.11:19Shulchan Aruch says the issur of chadash is asur afilu b'zman hazeh.11:24Even nowadays, it's11:26asur mid'Oraita. In Yoreh Deah, Maran talks more explicitly.11:29He says it's asur whether it's in Israel, whether it's outside of11:33Israel. It's asur whether it's the ownership, whether the produce is under the ownership of a Jew or the goy.11:39That means you can't just go to a goy and buy his produce and say it doesn't apply to him.11:43No. The issur is on the item itself.11:46Anything that took root after Pesach, you cannot eat it this whole year until the next year Pesach.11:53Practically, until the next year 2016, you cannot eat the new produce, what is12:00chadash. The question that confronts every rabbi. I'm not talking about in our days only.12:05I'm talking about in the days already from the Rishonim,12:09is we see the severity of this issur.12:12We rule12:14that it's asur min haTorah. The question is, how in the world is it that the majority of Jews were not keeping it?12:19This is not a new thing.12:20If you never heard of kemah yashan, or if you never kept it really12:23and you're feeling a little bit guilty, not guilty, I don't know,12:25and you say, How could everybody do it?12:27You should know that's a big question12:30in halacha. Every posek in the world, when they came across this subject,12:34had to answer this question:12:35What's going on over here?12:36It clearly says in the Torah12:39it's asur. It clearly says in Shulchan Aruch12:41that it's asur min haTorah. How is everybody eating from the new produce?12:45And therefore, we started to explain last week12:48that although the majority of the Rishonim hold12:52that it's asur min haTorah, there are opinions, however, that hold otherwise.12:56Although they're not even close to the majority,13:00they're considered almost a13:02daat yachid. It's only very few opinions,13:04but still there are other opinions.13:06Now, who are the other opinions?13:07The other opinions are led by the Bahag, Baal Halachot Gedolot,13:10as well as Rabbeinu Baruch, Sefer HaTerumah,13:13which is brought down by the Rosh as well.13:15They hold like this.13:18They hold that the issur of chadash is only rabbinical;13:23it's13:25miderabbanan. But the Torah13:26says—what do you mean?13:27There's a pasuk in the Torah. How could you hold it's13:29derabbanan? And the answer is based on a Gemara13:32in the Yerushalmi.13:33I'm not going to go into the details on that;13:34it's going to be very confusing.13:35But basically, even in the Gemara13:37we find a machloket about it.13:38There are opinions in the Gemara that hold that it's asur,13:41but it's not clear what level of issur it is,13:44and they hold it's13:46asur miderabbanan. Once you tell me it's13:49asur miderabbanan, the question is—13:50If the rabbis are the ones who decreed upon this,13:53for example, shemitah.13:55We all know of shemitah.13:57It says in the Torah, in Parashat Behar,13:58it says that you're not allowed to work the field on the seventh year.14:02And we all know in Israel,14:03the religious people,14:04people who want to keep14:06halacha, they keep shemitah.14:07However, Gemara Masechet Gittin14:09and throughout other places,14:10Masechet14:11Shevi'it, which is dedicated for shemitah,14:13explains that our shemitah in our days,14:16now that we're living today,14:17the way our society is living today,14:20shemitah is only14:21asur miderabbanan. It's not14:23asur midoraita. Yet we know, okay, shemitah,14:25but still it's14:27derabbanan, even though Torah talks about it as a full parashah on it,14:29it's14:31derabbanan. So it says Rabbeinu Baruch, likewise,14:33the issur of14:34chadash, even though there's a pasuk that says it14:35mefurash,14:36still the issur is only rabbinical.14:38The rabbis are the ones who made it.14:40Now, where did the rabbis decree14:43that there is an issur of14:44chadash? And the answer is,14:47in chutz14:49la'aretz, only in the parts that are around14:53Eretz Yisrael, only in the countries right around14:54Eretz Yisrael. For example,14:57Eretz Mitzrayim, Eretz Bavel, which we would know as the Middle East,14:59right there, right around15:01Eretz Yisrael, that's what the rabbis made15:02a gezeirah because it's too close to home,15:04it's too close to15:05Eretz Yisrael. However, other countries,15:07other lands that are further beyond15:10Eretz Yisrael, according to these Rishonim,15:12it's only15:13asur—it's not even asur.15:14Since the whole issur is only15:16derabbanan, they were not gozer on such far countries,15:17and therefore these opinions hold15:20this is why the people are eating15:24chadash and they're not concerned if it's chadash or yashan.15:27How can they not be concerned with the15:29halacha? How can they not be concerned with15:31an issur midoraita? It's something that's mefurash in the Torah,15:33and the answer is15:35because they are of the opinion15:38that chadash... In the countries far from15:42Eretz Yisrael is not forbidden.15:44However, like we said,15:47that's not the opinion of the majority of poskim.15:50That's certainly not the opinion of the15:53Shulchan Aruch. And now the question is,15:55how does this opinion play into15:57halacha? Do we say that, listen,16:00You know, what are you going to do? There are people who matir, and therefore don't speak about it.16:05Let the people do as they wish. They have an option.16:08Or just listen to the Shulchan Aruch, and we have to know about it, and we have to stop.16:11What do we do in such a case?16:13So if you look in the poskim, poskim were hesitant to preach about this subject.16:20They don't want to go out and tell everybody, Asur, asur, it's asur min haTorah. Why not?16:25So the Rosh, already, who is quoted by the Beit Yosef, he says, and he's not the first one; there's other opinions as well,16:32he says like this: If the people are not keeping it, and you know by preaching to them they're not going to keep it,16:39so then what's going to happen is it's going to make it worse, because they're going to end up doing the16:45aveirah b'mezid. Since this is something that's very difficult for people to really keep,16:50so therefore if you tell them, they're not going to listen to you anyway. So what did you gain?16:54Nothing. If anything, you made it worse for the people who are doing it, because now they're committing a bigger16:59aveirah. But the Rosh adds, however, and especially he says that the majority, anyway, of the produce in his17:05time—the Rosh, by the way, lived about 700 years ago, a little bit more, but it's around 700 years17:12ago—so the Rosh writes, besides the fact that the majority of the produce in his time was anyway17:20came from last year's, was anyway from last year's produce, so we're not sure exactly where it came from.17:26Therefore, we could use something called a sfek-sfeka: the majority anyway came from there,17:31and you're not sure where this produce came. You don't have to worry about it. You could allow them to eat it.17:35But certainly, if a person could be machmir on himself, he should be17:40machmir. The Rosh was one of the first ones to bring this up. The Rama follows in his tracks,17:45and you have a lot of the Acharonim as well that follow in their17:48tracks. But a lot of the Acharonim are not so happy with this sfek-sfeka, because according to the rules of17:54halacha, you can't just make up a sfek-sfeka without following the rules of17:58sfek-sfeka. Sfek-sfeka is really a very complicated subject.18:03The Shach in Yoreh De'ah, siman kuf yud, he brings over there all the dinim of18:08sfek-sfeka, but even him, not everybody necessarily agrees with all those rules. It's a big, big... Complicated list,18:15and therefore, but still, there are rules that everybody has to abide by.18:21You can't just make up ספק ספקא as the way you feel. It has to be a real safek that we consider it as a18:26safek. So a lot of poskim, Rav Akiva Eiger, I believe he quotes also from Mutzal Me'esh, it's a sefer,18:34and he asks on the ספק ספקא that doesn't fit according to the rules.18:37So the leniency of the Rama is really not such a big leniency.18:43The next person who, the next posek that brought another leniency, a major leniency, was the18:48Bach. The Bach ruled that קמח ישן, although you're right, it says in the Torah that it's18:56assur, but who's it assur? Who produces assur? Only the produce under the ownership of a Jew.19:04Had the produce been under the ownership of a goy, says the19:08Bach, this is not in the category of issur, and he is very strong about his opinion.19:13He says, I brought it to all the rabbis of my generation, including the Maharshal, including Rav Shachna,19:18and they all agreed with me. Nobody disagreed with me, and he holds very strongly.19:23You are not even allowed to be stringent.19:26Why? Because this is the halacha. The halacha is that only produce19:36that's under the ownership of a Jew is forbidden, not the produce that's under the ownership of a goy.19:41And therefore, for living outside Eretz Yisrael, and our produce, the five grains that means,19:46are coming from non-Jews, that's fine according to the19:51Bach. However, this Bach is not a green light, because all the Acharonim, kim'at all of the19:58Acharonim, went against the Bach, and they all disagreed with him, starting with his son-in-law, the Taz,20:03and the Shach also knocks him out, and then the Gra on top of it writes the following.20:11He says,20:17Everybody disagreed. They all knocked out the Bach, and— Already, they held that it was a mistake,20:27that what he wrote, we do not follow it.20:29But there is such an opinion out there. There is such a leniency out20:32there. There's another great rabbi that came to try to bring a leniency,20:36and that rabbi is known as the Pnei20:38Yehoshua. Pnei Yehoshua is one of the greatest commentaries of the rabbis after Shulchan Aruch, the Acharonim on Shas.20:45And he writes a pamphlet, I guess maybe a 15-page pamphlet, on the subject of20:52chadash, the subject of what is mutar, what isn't mutar, not mutar. And over there he proves, or according to him20:59he holds, that really the issur of chadash should really not be21:05asur min haTorah. However, at the end he writes, he says, However,21:07although I concluded that chadash should really not be forbidden21:14min haTorah, he writes, you know, but I have standing in front of me the opinions of the three giants,21:19the Rif, the Rambam, and the Rosh.21:22These rishonim held that it is21:26asur min haTorah. So he says, Who am I to not disagree with them?21:29Yes, I could prove to you that really it should not be21:33asur min haTorah, but really, he says, I don't believe there's one person in our generation21:37that could even match one of them.21:40Kal vachomer when you have all these three rabbis together ruling21:45that's asur min haTorah. So therefore he concludes, My words are nothing,21:48so why'd you write a whole pamphlet for21:50and tell me that's not21:51asur min haTorah? And he says, My words are only there21:53to be melamed zechut, that those who are doing it and they cannot stop,21:57then they have what to rely on.22:00Why? Because you could say it's a22:03safek de'oraita. He says they have what to rely on.22:05But certainly, if they can and they have to stop,22:08if they could stop from eating22:11chadash, they must stop from eating22:13chadash. That is the opinion of the22:15Pnei Yehoshua. The Taz himself comes and he says,22:17again, remember, everybody's bothered with this question.22:20Everybody's bothered with this: how could people do it?22:23We come, you know, a person who's learning22:25halacha... The real way to learn22:26halacha is not just to pick up, you know, like an English book and say,22:30Okay, what's the bottom line?22:31Okay, let me just do it.22:33Certainly, if a person wants to know what to do in22:35halacha, of course, these English books are fantastic. You should know,22:38they're so clear.22:39All the books have been, Baruch Hashem,22:41published by ArtScroll, Feldheim, and other such companies,22:45not only just English. Even in Hebrew,22:47the ones that give you22:48piskei halacha written by known rabbis,22:50they're very beautiful.22:52Really a lot of work went into them.22:55But still, at the end of the day,22:57when a person wants to know just quickly what to do,22:59that's what you look at.23:00You look at the English books.23:02However, when you want to study the subject in depth23:05and you want to understand the source of the23:09halacha, the real way to do it is you start from the Torah.23:11You go on to the Gemara, Mishnayot, Gemara Rishonim,23:15go to Tur, Beit Yosef.23:16You go to look at all the23:18poskim and you get a full picture of exactly what it is.23:20And therefore all these rabbis were confronted.23:22Listen, I looked at everything,23:24and at the end of the day,23:26it should be23:27asur min haTorah. Why in the world are people not following it?23:30And therefore the Taz comes with another23:32heter. He says,23:33Because we live in a time which is23:37sha'at hadchak. Sha'at hadchak means it's very necessary.23:40And so what?23:41If it's very necessary, we're going to eat23:43taref, we're going to eat non-kosher food?23:45What does that mean?23:45We live in sha'at hadchak, so let's go.23:47Get me a hot dog from Nathan's.23:50How do you do such a thing?23:52And the answer is, says the Taz, no.23:55Sha'at hadchak allows me to rely on a daat yachid.24:01What does it mean, daat yachid? There's a machloket, like we just mentioned before, between the Rishonim, between the24:08nine big rabbis that we mentioned beforehand, and the other three big rabbis, the Bahag24:14and the Sefer Terumah, Rabbeinu Baruch, and they held, I mean, say the later Rishonim held, that24:22this is a24:23issur of chadash does not apply in chutz24:26la'aretz. So being that it doesn't apply in chutz24:29la'aretz, now of course there's no question that halacha we have to follow the majority.24:33Not only are they the majority, the majority forbid it, but that's also the ruling of24:37the Shulchan Aruch.24:38However, the Taz says, b'sha'at hadchak, when it's like sort of like an emergency state situation,24:46we can rely on24:48daat yachid. We can rely on the very minimal opinions in this halacha.24:53That's how the Taz explains the reason of why people are lenient with the subject of,25:00with the eating of25:03chadash. Is25:03this—now this in itself is debatable.25:05Meaning to say, if something is assum min haTorah, according to majority of opinions, according25:10to the Shulchan Aruch, according to the majority of opinions, everybody holds it's25:13assum min haTorah. There are a few that hold that it's not assum min haTorah; it's even25:17mutar. Now, in halacha, of course, like I said, you can't follow the minority. You always25:20have to follow the25:21majority. The question is, b'sha'at hadchak, can I rely on these opinions or not?25:25This in itself is debatable when the subject is25:28assum min haTorah. If it's assum d'rabbanan, okay, this is what to rely on.25:31But if it's assum min haTorah, although the Taz is of the opinion that25:37b'sha'at hadchak b'issur d'oraita, you could rely on the minority of opinions.25:41However, not all the Acharonim agree with this.25:44Yabia Omer in chelek yud, Yoreh De'ah siman mem-gimel brings a whole bunch of25:50Acharonim that disagree with this.25:51You look it up over there.25:54Yet we do find, in the subject of yashan, and the subject meaning to say of26:01chadash, we know, okay, even those who hold that chadash is assur, we do find some opinions that are26:07lenient in certain cases,26:09meaning to say in subcategories of26:12chadash. So up to now, we brought you the opinions of the majority of the poskim, the26:16rulings, Shulchan Aruch, that's assur, and a few people that are matir.26:21And according to Maran, there's no question.26:24You treat chadash like the way you treat non-kosher meat.26:29Non-kosher meat, if you cook it, you have to dispose of it, you have to kasher your26:34pots, according to Shulchan Aruch. If you cook chadash in your pots, then you have to take that26:42pot and do hagalah on it.26:42You have to kasher your26:44pots. Or what you could do is hold on to the pots, don't use them until Pesach comes along, and26:50wait till after Pesach to use them. Then26:51the flavor that's in the walls becomes yashan,26:54right,26:55becomes last year's flavors, and therefore it will be mutar.26:57This is the opinion of Shulchan Aruch.27:00However, there are those who are a little bit more lenient.27:02In beli'ot, in the flavor that's absorbed into the walls, if that flavor came from27:09chadash, there are some leniencies.27:12The first one to introduce a leniency is the Rama in his teshuvot, in the name, I believe,27:19of27:20Terumat HaDeshen. He explains that being that according to some poskim, it's not even assur, so it's a27:28safek.27:30It's a safek27:31d'rabbanan. Why?27:31It's a safek if it's27:33assur d'rabbanan. It's not27:34assur d'rabbanan. So the Rama holds27:35you don't have to be so machmir in the flavor.27:37That means if somebody cooked not yashan food in the pots and you want to use them27:43now to cook again, according to the Rama, you could be lenient.27:47Why?27:47Because he says, mida'oraita... Really, the flavor is batel27:54b'rov. And since it's batel b'rov, and the whole subject of chadash in itself is debatable,28:00you have what to rely on.28:02Not everybody. Again, this is a leniency in the flavors in the28:05pot. That means if I have somebody tells me, Listen, I made you pasta.28:10Don't worry about it.28:10It's 100% kemach yashan.28:13It's from last year's produce.28:14It's not28:15chadash. Okay,28:16I may not be able to eat it right away.28:18I have to know,28:18does this person in general cook pasta in this pot?28:22What does he use it for?28:23Imagine somebody comes to you and he brings you a plate of pasta,28:26and it's a28:28non-Jew. He tells you, 'No, this pasta is 100% kosher.28:32I bought it from the most kosher supermarket,28:37the kosher supermarket,28:39and it's, you know, this brand and this brand. It's 100% kosher.28:42There's nothing in it.28:42It's just pasta and tomato sauce that has all the hechsherim in the world.28:48Could you eat it?'28:49And it says, 'No, because what about the pots that he cooked with it?'28:52So according to Shulchan Aruch, the pots that were used to cook with it, something that's not yashan,28:57is also asur.28:58The Rama, however, is29:00matir it because he holds any of the subject of chadash is debatable.29:04And although we're always stringent to hold that you need 60 times the heter more than the29:13issur, in this case, according to the Rama, being that min haTorah it's29:18batel b'rov, you could already have the food that's cooked in the pots.29:22You don't have to worry about the29:23beli'ot. But again, really when you analyze this heter, you see that's not such a simple heter.29:30The Magen Avraham already knocks out this Rama.29:34He says this only applies if you're cooking the same food.29:37But once you had— Min b'she'eino mino. Once you cook a different type of food,29:41that means if you're not cooking raw pasta, just straight pasta in the pot,29:45you're cooking something else,29:46so the flavor goes into it.29:48Even min haTorah, you need shishim to be29:51mevatel. And therefore, he disagrees with the Rama,29:54or at least he limits the heter of the Rama to specific cases.29:58The Mishnah Berurah, however, in Mishnah Berurah in Shaar HaTziyun over there,30:02he writes that you could be lenient, though, if it's30:07sha'at ha-dchak, you have to rely on,30:08if you wait 24 hours. That means had somebody who really cooked30:13chadash. Let's say somebody took something that's for sure chadash and he cooked it in the pot,30:16therefore making the pots now asur.30:19The Mishnah Berurah says you could be lenient and wait after 24 hours30:25and use those pots again without having to kosher it.30:27This is the leniency of the30:29Mishnah Berurah. Again, this does not mean Maran agrees with this.30:32This is the leniency of the Mishnah Berurah based on the Rama, who holds what he holds by30:38yashan. But according to the strict explanation of Shulchan Aruch, it would be a problem30:44because, like we said, chadash, according to Shulchan Aruch, is no different from non-kosher meat.30:48The other leniency that's brought down is a leniency in alcoholic drinks.30:54Being that our drinks today, in those days, you should know, they only had water, wine, or beer.30:59This is it. That's all they had.31:01They didn't have Coca-Cola, they didn't have Sprite.31:02And, Baruch Hashem, now we have Coca-Cola and Sprite,31:05because people don't have to come, you know, for like—wine was too expensive, water was too plain,31:10so beer. A lot of people drank beer.31:11In fact, the majority of their drinks were shechar, were beer,31:15as you see, as all the poskim speak about it.31:17So therefore, they had to find a heter for the beer31:20because it was very difficult for people not to have it.31:23It was not like, you know, it was a staple food.31:25They had to have it.31:26So therefore, they had to find heterim for them.31:28Nowadays, Baruch Hashem, majority of our drinks are junk, maybe,31:33Cokes and sodas and whatever,31:35but at least we don't have the issue of yashan in them,31:38and we're not there running out and drinking beer.31:41In fact, the season of when beer becomes31:45chadash also starts a little bit later than most of the other produce.31:48In any case, there is leniency from the Pnei Yehoshua and other31:52Acharonim when it comes to alcoholic drinks that are made from new produce.31:57If it's the heavy alcohol—32:00To say, like, you know, they call hard liquor, like whiskeys or certain vodkas and those32:06things. Anyway, it takes so long to make and to store in order to get the real flavor,32:11so מסתמא it's always going to be32:14ישן. So you don't have real issues over there.32:15The only real issue is when it comes to beer; those you have to look out for.32:20Okay, now that we explained the background of this halacha, it comes out right now32:24that in our days, how would we, you know, how would we apply this in our days?32:28Let's first give you the seasons. Let's tell you how things grow in America.32:33In America, there are two seasons. I mean to say, the crops every year come from two32:40types of harvest.32:42There's the winter crops and there are the spring crops.32:44The winter crops, they are planted in the fall, and when do they harvest them?32:49Now, early summer, May, June.32:51This is right now; they're working very hard on harvesting all this produce.32:54So anything that's being harvested now, guess what?32:58It's32:59ישן. You know why?33:00Because, like we explained, in order for something to be חדש, it has to take root after Pesach.33:07If they're being harvested now, when were they planted?33:09They were planted in the fall, in November.33:11Oh, wait, November, even earlier, October, November.33:15It takes two weeks for something to take root.33:18So that means for sure these things, although they stayed in the ground and they're not33:22being harvested now, we don't go after harvest;33:23we go after they took root, and therefore the produce that's being right now33:27harvested in America, that is all considered33:32קמח ישן. You don't have to worry about it.33:34However, there's another problem.33:36There's another type of crop, and that is the spring crops.33:39Those are usually planted after Pesach.33:42Oh, they're planted after Pesach, so by the time they take root, by the time they start33:47to grow and develop, you know when they get harvested?33:50They're going to get harvested by— June, July—excuse me, July to August,33:56that's when they get harvested. But after they get harvested, they're not put in the34:01store right away.34:02After they get harvested, then already they have to take them and they have to grind them,34:07mill them to turn them to flour, and then they're shipped out to the wholesalers, and34:10the wholesalers will ship them out to the manufacturers, and they'll make their, you know, their products34:16as they, you know, they have to.34:17This is how the seasons work in America.34:21Once upon a time, we used to have an abundance in America of old produce34:27before America became the bikkur cholim of the world and they started distributing to all34:31the rest of the world. Now, the way the harvesting season, the harvesting is done in America,34:37it's done this way for the five grains.34:40Is it all the five grains?34:41Not 100%.34:42We'll talk about them in detail later on. But what we're trying to point out to you34:45is that we do have, we could have an issue of yashan, of eating produce that is chadash, even in America.34:55Those people who claim that everything is yashan in America is not correct.34:59It's not a fact.35:00Everything is not yashan in America.35:02It all depends what the things are.35:04This is not my facts.35:05Go look it up.35:06You can see it yourself.35:07There is Rabbi Yosef Herman here in Brooklyn that puts out a guide to chadash every single35:12year, and he has all these facts, all these details right in the beginning of his book.35:17And you can go there and you can research even further.35:20Don't take his word.35:21Go research even further and see for yourself how everything is produced in America.35:26So now the question to us is as follows:35:29What do we do in our case?35:31We have a problem here.35:33Do we just—do we look? Do we ask, okay, mah yashan?35:36Do we have to?35:37Well, we just35:38sow. According to all the opinions, all the Rishonim—majority, excuse me—according to 90% of35:43the Rishonim, the... The produce, excuse me, Chadash is a sumna Torah.35:50Ninety percent of the poskim, Rishonim, hold Chadash is a sumna Torah,35:53maran on top of them.35:55Even the heterim, notice the language how the heterim are brought.36:00Oh, the question is, how are people doing it?36:02Let's go36:04b'makom mitzvah, and it's36:05sha'at ha-dchak. It's very necessary. We want people to do,36:07to starve,36:07there's nothing else,36:08so there is what to rely on.36:10I don't believe the situation is like that nowadays.36:14I'll agree with you.36:15You know, when I started keeping Yashan, when I learned about this, I didn't know about36:18all this in detail.36:19Oh, I was told—I was a very simple Jew—I was told this is assur, you can't do it, it's36:25assur min haTorah. Okay,36:25it was told to me by a good source.36:27I started keeping it.36:29It was not easy.36:30I was not living in Brooklyn.36:32I was in yeshiva.36:32I was in an Ashkenazi yeshiva, even more so,36:35outside of Brooklyn.36:38So there, I had a big problem36:40because the Ashkenazim, they have more of their poskim permitting36:47Chadash. So then people were not as careful with Chadash, and I had a very big—you know, I had a very36:51difficult time.36:52Baruch Hashem, I had wonderful staff in the yeshiva, and they tried to be very accommodating.36:56I remember eating by a rebbe's house, and one rebbe would say, This is yashan, this37:01is37:01Chadash, this is not for you, and this is for you.37:03Even the cook already got used to me.37:05He would tell me, Today you can have this, this, and that.37:07Don't touch that.37:08That's not yashan.37:09So it was much harder, though.37:11It was still not everything was yashan.37:12Today, Baruch Hashem, because there's a demand for it, there's much more availability for37:20yashan,37:21meaning to say less is produce.37:22And therefore, although Chadash is still around, and you'll find it by most of the things that37:29are baked by non-Jewish companies,37:32but still, the Jewish companies are becoming more aware—more, not just more aware, but there's37:37a bigger demand for it, and therefore they're supplying it.37:40They are supplying much more yashan than they have been in the past.37:44And like we said last week, this is all due to you, the consumer.37:47When you demand it, they'll make sure to produce it.37:50And because of the larger demand, there's more availability of yashan.37:55I don't believe in our days it is a37:58sha'at ha-dchak. Tell me if you're living somewhere in the Midwest, maybe in America. Even that I don't38:03know, maybe.38:04But if you're living here in New York. New Jersey here, Lakewood, I don't think it's38:10shaatnez dahak.38:11I don't know.38:11I would like to see any major posek that disagrees with this, that holds that in our38:15days we're still considered shaatnez dahak, and therefore we can rely on the leniencies.38:20Today, in our days, you don't have to be a baal nefesh. You don't have to be a38:25machmir person to keep yashan.38:27You have to be a normal person to keep yashan.38:29Every one of us has to keep yashan, even Ashkenazim alike.38:32Go read the Mishnah38:34Berurah, siman taf-pei-tet. He says when we know this produce is chadash, how can we eat it?38:37You have to stay away from it.38:40And therefore, really, it's an obligation for everyone, Sefardim and Ashkenazim alike,38:45to keep yashan, which means they cannot eat chadash in our days.38:50So now, again, tell me there are matirim, but again, read the matirim.38:54The matirim were only matir those who permitted it, permitted in very, very pressing circumstances.39:00We don't have that in our days.39:02It is not a pressing circumstance for you to go down, for you to, you know, put your arms to the39:07other shelf and get something that's yashan instead of the one that's in front of you.39:11It's not a pressing circumstance when you can get this baked product, which is39:17chadash, and you have to settle for the quality of food which is a little bit less.39:22It's not a big deal,39:23so it's a little bit in the flavor.39:24We're not talking about that there's no food on the table.39:25There's food and there's plenty of food.39:27So this bakery may have it and this bakery may not have it,39:29but it's a big deal.39:31It's a little bit of a taste.39:31It's not called a pressing circumstance.39:33Certainly, to eat something that's asur min haTorah, it's not a safek, just a regular39:38safek. This is—can you imagine?39:39You have nine Rishonim are telling you this is equivalent to eating non-kosher meat.39:44You know, today, with the, Baruch Hashem, with the people, the awareness of kashrut is so39:48great,39:48people are so careful with a little bit of a minute thing that maybe it's not kosher,39:53maybe—oh no, not39:54kosher—maybe you have a flavor that's there and forget it. Every time we hear another thing about,39:59you know, what's going...40:00Going on in the kosher world and people are stringent, you heard about this, and people stay away from even the small safek, a small doubt of an issur.40:08Hadash, where it says straight out, Shulchan Aruch and the Rishonim, it's a pasuk in the Torah, that's40:14asur מן התורה. How come people are so lenient in it? And the answer is awareness. People don't know about it.40:18We know about it, we have to preach it, we have to press it, we have to demand it.40:22It'll be much easier to keep, it'll be much more available,40:26and, ezrat Hashem, people will, at the end of the day, the tachlit is that we keep what it says in the Torah.40:31And you should know, in the market today, if you find things that are made in Israel, any of the five grains,40:37means, say, cookies, wafers, or breads, whatever, if they come from Israel and they have a reliable hashgacha from Israel,40:43they're always yashan. Because in Israel, even those who wanted to be lenient were only lenient in countries far away from40:50Israel. But in Israel itself, even those people who are lenient did agree that's asur and allowed them to agree that's even40:56asur d'oraita. Not only that, in Israel, most of the time it's owned by a Jew,41:01so you really don't even have the heter of the bach. So therefore, in Israel they're very strict about it,41:05and the majority, I can't say everybody, but the majority of the hechsherim of Israel will always be yashan.41:13Also, when shopping, you should know, you have to be careful.41:16A lot of times you'll take a package and it'll say on it, Yashan.41:21Okay, so you say, Oh, beautiful, it says kemach yashan,41:23and then you see a very reliable hechsher right next to it,41:25so you assume that the hechsher is telling you that this is yashan.41:29That is not always the case.41:31You should know, the hechsher on products doesn't mean the person gives a hechsher on everything that says on the package.41:41A lot of times the owners will put certain things on the package,41:43and really you're trusting the owner who's telling you if it's yashan, or if it's birchato mezonot, or shehakol, whatever.41:50That's not necessarily coming from the41:52hashgacha. So therefore, even when you have a hashgacha and it says yashan on the package,41:58you have to make sure that the hashgacha is giving you the certification of yashan.42:05They're the ones who are taking responsibility that the product that you're buying is kemach yashan.42:10If it's not, then you're really trusting the42:12owner. I'm not telling you that the owner is not trustworthy.42:15I'm just telling you, I don't know if it's trustworthy,42:17but if you look for hechsher, because you don't trust the owner,42:22so then you should look also for the hechsher for the yashan.42:24What's the difference? Why are you drawing the line over here?42:26You're looking for hechsher to tell you that the ingredients are not42:29tareif, so you should look also that if you're keeping yashan, that the hashgacha is also verifying that it's also yashan.42:36Rabotai, make sure you're on top of that.42:38This applies to restaurants as well.42:39Just because you go into a restaurant and it says kemach yashan on it,42:42this doesn't mean that the hashgacha is responsible for the yashan.42:46Many times I've called up the kashrut agency responsible for certain restaurants42:53and I ask them, Are your stuff yashan?42:54They say, We don't give certification for that.42:57Does that mean chadash? No, I'm not saying it's chadash. I just don't know.43:00But according to our standards, we don't hold that you need yashan.43:03So therefore, if the owner wants to bring yashan or not, I don't know.43:06If he tells you yashan, you want to trust him? Yeah, you could trust him.43:08So therefore, you have to be aware of that.43:11Again, this doesn't mean the owner cannot be trusted.43:13I'm just telling you that if you're trusting the43:17hashgacha, then you have to make sure the hashgacha is responsible for the restaurant43:21to make sure it's yashan or not.43:24The real hard area of keeping yashan really is in a person's house.43:29Excuse me, it is outside the person's house.43:31In your house, you may be in control of it,43:33if you're married, that is, and your wife listens to you.43:36Or, you know, if you're the wife, so you're buying everything43:39and automatically your husband is going to listen to you, hopefully.43:42Anyway, when you go to eat by others, especially when your parents don't keep it,43:47your in-laws don't keep it, your sisters,43:51sister-in-laws, they're not keeping yashan,43:52they don't know about it,43:52or they hold it's not our minhag because they're not so very of it,43:55they've now, you know, shrunk it to a level of minhag,43:58that's when it really becomes very, very hard.44:01So you should just know that in America,44:03you don't have a problem of eating chadash until about July and August,44:09and it all depends what type of things there are.44:13What Rabbi Herman brings in his book, he says that—44:18Rye and spelt made in the U.S. are usually always yashan.44:23They're always coming from the winter crops,44:26which means they've been planted in the fall.44:28So for rye and spelt, okay, I know it's not the most common ingredient,44:32but you get something.44:34Also, yashan doesn't have an issue until about July, August.44:38Number three is a lot of times it could be yashan.44:40You just have to make it, you know, make other people aware of it.44:43Explain to them when you're being invited.44:45If you're being invited for the holidays, usually by Sukkot or Rosh Hashanah,44:49that's when the real problems come up.44:51You're going to go eat over other people.44:52So I'm keeping it till now.44:54I don't know how other people are going to do44:55when they say, What happened to you? You44:56know, we're all doing it. Why we're not religious?44:59If it's good enough for the Rosh Yeshiva, it's good enough for you.45:01Everybody has his own45:03ta'anos. At the end of the day, this is what you keep.45:05Imagine you had a diet.45:06Imagine you were on a strict diet.45:08You cannot have any fried food,45:09and this family is known.45:11They are the frying distributors of the whole Brooklyn, okay?45:16And this is, you know, each one, you know, they make a lot of fried food,45:21and you go to their house and you tell them, I can't have fried food.45:24Would they get offended? No,45:24they understand. You had a heart attack recently, clogged arteries.45:27Okay, fine.45:29So they respect it.45:30So tell them the same thing over here.45:32Please, you know, I don't mean to offend anybody,45:33but it's a, you know, if they don't understand you,45:36so don't say it's a yesod or right, and therefore I don't want to keep it.45:39So say it like this: It's my custom.45:41We've picked up a new thing this year, Baruch Hashem.45:43We're trying to keep yashan.45:44You think it's possible that the ingredients you get for, you know, the invitation,45:50the time they're inviting us, for the meal they're inviting us to, could be yashan?45:53It makes it much easier if you do it from beforehand.45:56Don't wait till you get there and you start asking people, Is this yashan?45:59It's not yashan,45:59and they don't know how to answer,46:01and you get all nervous,46:01and then you don't eat,46:02and they all get offended.46:04Don't do that.46:04From beforehand, prepare yourself.46:06You know these people are not aware of yashan.46:08Ask them,46:09and you solve much of the problem.46:12So now, bottom line, how are we going to conclude?46:15We conclude in the following.46:16If a person wants to start keeping Yashan, you learned already the severity of the item,46:21of the subject,46:23so, and it's hard, but you want to do it in steps,46:25so you can do it also in steps.46:26Don't think it's all or nothing.46:28Although you're right,46:30you know, in some cases you're going to have big problems,46:32but still, at least work in steps,46:33like in everything in Judaism. You have to know what to do,46:37and then that's what Shulchan Aruch will tell you what to do,46:40and then you open up your own46:41Shulchan Aruch. What does it mean, your own46:42Shulchan Aruch? It means your own plan.46:44You have to make yourself a plan of how to get there.46:47You have to know that it's a very big trick.46:49And when you know what the halacha is and it's very difficult for you,46:51you can't just ignore the halacha and say, I'm going to hell anyway,46:54let me go.46:54No.46:54You have to pick up your—46:56you have to figure out how to get to the level of keeping the halacha in full.47:00So the Biur Halacha actually says the same thing.47:02Those who have a hard time in keeping Yashan, do it gradually,47:06do it in steps,47:07and avoid at least the things that you know47:08for a fact is47:10chadash, which means get yourself, first of all, on the email list of this guide to Yashan,47:16to47:17chadash, which is put out by Rabbi Yosef Herman.47:18You get a free email as the guide gets updated.47:21He calls up the companies.47:23He knows when the new produce is out.47:25He knows when they have already problems of chadash or not,47:28and he has a system exactly how to look for what's chadash and what's yashan,47:33and that's the best way to avoid it.47:35And the way to subscribe,47:37you email to the following:47:43chodosh, C-H-O-D-O-S-H, chodosh, C-H-O-D-O-S-H, at47:46sefer.org. Sefer is S-E-F-E-R dot org.47:49Very simple.47:50You email them.47:51You say, I would like to subscribe to you,47:53and you get a free email like everybody you put on the list,47:55like everybody else,47:56and then you follow the guide exactly how to shop. Very.48:00Very convenient, very, very important. Also, since the problems really start by48:07July-August, so therefore, this is what you have to do. You have to go and, by the time the season starts48:14by July-August, stock up. Stock up on many of the things that you know you need.48:19You're a pasta guy, you like noodles, you like penne, whatever it is,48:23stock up on them. Go and buy them in bulk and store them.48:27This way, you know these things don't have a problem. These are from last year's produce.48:31You don't have a problem with the yashan. You're stored up on the things that you know you're going to need48:36for the rest of the year. And believe it or not, there are many, many stores, many supermarkets,48:41because of the great demand, that already supply with yashan,48:46that have a whole line of yashan that will tell you this is yashan and this is not yashan.48:50And therefore, you shop at these supermarkets. And especially if you make a demand from now,48:55you start telling the manager, if you're close to the manager or everything else,48:59they'll make sure that you'll have it by that season.49:01Now, some people are worried. They say, Yeah, but you know what? If you keep yashan,49:06you're going to have a problem with bugs, worms, because you know what happens when you store things.49:12What happens is the bugs come in, and you're going to have other problems,49:16so you solve the problem of hadas by eating bugs. Bugs is49:19five issurim. And that ta'ana is ridiculous for the following point.49:23Number one is because, first of all, the flour that you use for everything that you cook,49:28we always sift it. So anyway, you're sifting from bugs.49:31But it's going to be full of bugs; you can't even sift them.49:33Okay, let me ask you: if you had flour in your house, you have flour, you bought,49:39you went to Costco, you bought yourself two 50-pound bags of flour, okay?49:44Happens to be it was stored in your house for three months.49:47You're not going to use it and throw it right away, or you're going to try to use it right away.49:50Well, how come you're not worried about bugs?49:52And the answer is, you know yourself that really the likeliness of bugs is not so much on how old it is;49:58it's how you store it. If you store it well, if you put it in a cool place, you won't have such a problem.50:03And the same thing will be here.50:05All those companies that supply merchandise, that supply food that is yashan,50:12they store the flour in a place that won't have a problem of bugs and worms,50:17and that's why you don't have such an issue.50:20Besides that, because again, like we said, there is a big demand for yashan.50:25Therefore, what has been happening in the last couple of years is that a lot of the wheat is not milled,50:35that means it's not ground up into flour until it's ready to be shipped,50:39which means they don't harvest everything and then they grind it to flour and then they store it.50:44No, they store the wheat kernels. Wheat kernels are not going to have a problem of bugs,50:49and then afterwards they mill them, they grind them, and then they turn them to flour.50:52So you're getting freshly milled flour to whatever these factories are getting them,50:58and they don't have a problem of worms at all.51:01It's no different than the hadash, which has been harvested just in the same time,51:05except this one took root before51:08Pesach. So that's the problem with bugs. That's how it's solved. It's not even an51:12issue. Again, if you want to worry about it, you'll have to, you know, be fair. You have to be consistent in your worry.51:22Now I want to repeat now the email again to this guy, to51:30Chadash. It's C-H-O-D-O-S-H at51:35sefer.org. Chadash, C-H-O-D-O-S-H at51:40sefer.org. Okay, next. Another thing a person is seeing that's hard for him.51:43Okay, let's say you want to start in your house.51:45So in your house you're keeping everything,51:48hazak u'baruch, great, wonderful.51:50Now when you go out to shop, so if you store it up, it's great.51:53If you go out to shop... If you have this guide, it will show you exactly what to look for and what to avoid.52:00Restaurants, we mentioned already the issue.52:02Again, there's a demand.52:04So therefore, when you go to a restaurant, you should know,52:06you have to be aware of foods that may contain inside them wheat flour.52:11A lot of people, for example, don't52:13realize—now, I'm not talking about restaurants for a52:14second—you know, Twizzlers have to be yashan.52:17Most of the candies have wheat flour inside of them in order to hold the, what's it called, to hold the sugar together.52:24Sugar doesn't stick together, so you need to put flour to hold it together.52:27That also has to be yashan.52:28Even though you're not making it as an, it still has to be—the flour itself52:32that's what you're putting in your body has to be yashan.52:34Another issue to look for also sometimes in potato chips.52:37Like, for example, I know for a fact Wise potato chips, the barbecue flavor, have wheat flour in it.52:42Somehow, a lot of barbecue flavors, they put wheat flour.52:45Also, that has to be yashan.52:46The book will tell you if the issues of chadash apply and therefore you should avoid them,52:52or which chips you should, or which, you know, products to avoid or to keep,52:57or that you don't have to avoid, you can have.53:00You'll find that all in the book, but you have to be on the lookout for it.53:02Also, when you go to restaurants,53:04when you go to restaurants, again, if you trust the owner, you can ask him straightforward,53:08Is this yashan or not yashan?53:10If he doesn't know what you're talking about, then I don't believe then that it's yashan53:14if he doesn't know what he's talking about.53:16Or you call up the53:17hashgacha. You call up the, you know, the kosher certification, whoever's certifying the restaurant,53:23if you trust them, and you ask them, Is everything yashan?53:26Make sure that it's everything.53:28It's not just the breads,53:29because there's other things, you know, they mix together with it.53:33Also, even though people may tell you certain ingredients are yashan, certain things are not yashan,53:38if people use the same fryer to cook in it things that are yashan, things that are not yashan,53:44then it doesn't help to just buy the food that is yashan,53:47lemashal. You know, they have regular fries and they have the spicy fries,53:52which are known as—name skips my mind,53:56obviously I don't buy them.53:57So anyway, the spicy fries,53:59the spicy fries, that spice that's on the fries,54:02they first dip the potatoes. Inside of flour, wheat flour mixed together with these spices,54:09and then they get stuck on them. That's how they fry them.54:11A lot of times this wheat flour, kejen fries, that's what they're called,54:14a lot of times the kejen fries may not be yashan.54:16So you go to a pizza store and54:18you say, Is your kejen fries, are your kejen fries yashan?54:20He tells you, No, they're not.54:22Oh, what about—okay, so then you know what? Let me have the regular fries.54:24And he's putting in the same fry; it doesn't help you,54:26because in that fryer you have54:29chadash, and it's going on you.54:30It's going on the fries, meaning to say that you're going to have.54:33So although we said54:36in beli'ot it can be lenient, but that's beli'ot in the pots, in the walls.54:39In the fryer you have54:41mamashut. You have actual substance.54:43You have the actual food in the54:45fryer, and therefore that is going to be an issue,54:48and you have to be aware of it.54:50Another thing to keep in mind also is when you go away.54:53This is when it really, really becomes hard,54:55when you're traveling outside of the Jewish community of New York55:00and you're going to Florida, you're going to California,55:03and you're going, of course, in the winter months,55:05and that's going to be really an issue.55:07So again, like we said, you have to do it gradually.55:10If you're not on the level of keeping yet and you're starting,55:13so maybe you want to accept upon yourself,55:15at least in New York I'll keep it.55:16When I go outside of New York, maybe I have what to rely on.55:19I have the Taz and Shach, perhaps.55:22Yeah, maybe.55:23But again, you do it gradually.55:25If you really want to keep this halacha all the way,55:27so chazak ubaruch if you could keep it all the way.55:30If you cannot keep it all the way, don't drop everything55:32just because you can't keep it in California and you're going to California only once a year.55:35If you find a good deal on dense deals,55:37you understand?55:38So it's not the way to think.55:39That's not the way to live life.55:40You do whatever you try to do.55:42You don't do everything all or nothing.55:44A person's looking for a job and he wants a certain amount of salary,55:48and nobody's giving him jobs,55:49and he finds somebody who's offering him a little bit less from what he's looking for,55:53he's not going to drop it.55:54You take it for now,55:55because you have nothing else.55:57Same thing,55:57you want to keep55:58yashan, don't worry about the once—56:00In the lifetime chance that maybe you'll leave New York.56:03If you could keep it in New York, keep it, wonderful.56:06Even if New York, if you could keep it in your house, at least keep it at least in your house.56:09And then, be'ezrat Hashem, you'll be able to keep it fully.56:12This is our class on Gemara. Unfortunately, we didn't have time to go56:16and speak about the subject of tonight of56:21Lag BaOmer. You know, hava loke, be'ezrat Hashem, maybe next year we'll talk about it a little bit more.56:26Until, okay, we'll keep it for that.56:28We'll here in the studio, if anybody has questions or comments, you could call us in at56:34718-683-5858, or you could text in at56:37347-927-8398. This class will be repeated again tonight on JRootRadio.com at 1156:43p.m. We'll see you, be'ezrat Hashem, next week. We'll continue in our halachot between Pesach and56:48Shavuot. Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll start talking about the halachot of Shavuot and preparing for the holiday of56:52Shavuot. That will be all next week. Until then, have a wonderful week.56:55We'd like to say thank you to Iran and the JRoot staff for all their wonderful work.