Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JewRadio.com. This is Halacha Hour on Wednesday afternoons from 2 to 3 p.m. live.0:09 The numbers to the station, if you'd like to call in, if you'd like to text in your question on the halachot that we're learning,0:15 and we are learning the halachot of havdalah on Motzaei Shabbat,0:20 b'ezrat Hashem we hope to finish today Parashat Vayetze and all the laws of the havdalah.0:24 The numbers are 718-683-5858. That's if you would like to call in to ask your questions live on the radio.0:34 If you want to speak off the air, then you can either tell the technician when you call in your question and he'll send it in to us,0:41 or you could call in after 3 o'clock. That's an hour after the show.0:45 The number to text in your question is 347-927-8398. Again,0:57 347-927-8398. These are the numbers to call in with your questions. If you'd like to listen to the radio, if you'd like to listen to this class,1:03 then you have a few options, either on JewRadio.com, on the JewRadio Pro app,1:09 or you can listen on the phone by calling1:16 718-506-9099. Also, you can watch this class live on JewRadio.com. We are streaming live by video as well.1:25 Today's class is sponsored l'ilui nishmat Yaakov ben Victoria, who shloshim is actually tomorrow.1:32 And let's get to the class, b'ezrat Hashem. Like we mentioned, we're in the halacha hour. We're learning the halachot of Motzaei Shabbat,1:40 specifically the laws of havdalah. Right now we're up to the laws of havdalah.1:43 Last week we got to discuss some of the busiest halachot in havdalah,1:51 the laws of besamim and the halachot of borei1:56 me'orei ha'esh, but because of the time we weren't able to finish all the halachot,1:59 so I'm going to review just very, very quickly some of the halachot of havdalah2:05 before we go on to the next halacha.2:07 Six halachot to keep in mind when it comes to brachat borei2:12 me'orei ha'esh. Specifically, the bracha borei me'orei ha'esh we're focusing on today.2:14 Hopefully we'll finish it, and we'll finish up also the2:17 parashah. Number one is that the reason for brachat borei me'orei ha'esh is because2:23 Hashem put the idea in Adam Harishon's mind on Motzaei Shabbat,2:27 the first Motzaei Shabbat in history,2:29 that he should create fire by knocking two stones together.2:34 That's why we make the bracha of borei me'orei ha'esh specifically on Motzaei Shabbat.2:38 Now, another halacha, second halacha:2:41 you cannot make brachat borei me'orei ha'esh on any fire which was lit with an issur,2:48 by committing a2:49 sin. Meaning, if a Jew lit the fire on Shabbat, you can't make a bracha borei me'orei ha'esh on that fire.2:56 Same thing would be if a goy lit the fire on Shabbat,2:58 even though a goy is not commanded in keeping the laws of Shabbat,3:01 but since if a Jew would have done the same thing, it would have been3:04 asur, so therefore you can't make a bracha on borei3:08 me'orei ha'esh. Third halacha is that it's preferable3:11 lechatchila that a person who is making the bracha borei3:14 me'orei ha'esh, he should make it on two flames, what we call an3:17 avukah, which is two flames together.3:20 If a person doesn't have that,3:22 if you find yourself with only one flame,3:24 like for example a regular candle,3:26 then you can even make it on also—one flame is also good.3:29 The halacha of having two fires is only3:32 lechatchila. Also, another halacha, very important halacha,3:35 most people don't pay attention to this:3:37 when making the bracha borei3:40 me'orei ha'esh, the fire that you're making bracha on,3:42 that fire had to have been lit for the sake of providing light.3:47 If the fire was not lit for the sake of providing light,3:50 it was lit for any other purposes,3:51 such as, for example, your3:54 stovetop. When you're putting on the gas on your stove,3:56 you're putting on usually to cook,3:58 so you can't make bracha borei me'orei ha'esh on that fire.4:00 You also can't make bracha borei me'orei ha'esh on a yahrzeit candle,4:03 because it's not lit to provide light,4:06 especially that we have electricity today.4:07 Rather, it's lit in order that we should give honor to the soul of the deceased.4:14 So in those cases, you cannot make a bracha of borei me'orei ha'esh on those fires.4:18 However, those candles that you can't make a bracha on,4:22 you could use them as a second flame. In the4:27 avukah, remember we said lechatchila it's better to make a bracha on two fires together.4:31 That's called an4:32 avukah. So if you have one flame that's lit according to halacha,4:36 on Motzaei Shabbat, in order to provide light,4:38 the second flame could be from a Yortzeit candle.4:41 It's fine.4:42 Next halacha, number4:46 five. One cannot be in a case4:51 where—excuse me—the light cannot be in a case.4:54 If you don't see the flame and the rays directly,4:58 then you cannot make the bracha of Borei5:02 Me'orei HaEsh. You have to be able to see the flame as well as the rays.5:07 For example, let's say the candle is in a box5:09 and you see the rays coming out of it,5:11 you can't make a5:12 bracha, even though you are benefiting from the light.5:13 You need to actually see the flame as well.5:16 And finally, the last halacha,5:18 we said already that you cannot make a bracha of Borei Me'orei HaEsh on electricity,5:23 on candles—excuse me—on light bulbs,5:26 even the yellow ones.5:27 Kavachomer the fluorescent lights.5:30 Everybody agrees fluorescent lights,5:31 you cannot make a bracha on it.5:32 By the way, this, for the5:35 Sefardim, is even5:36 bediavad. If you made it on electricity,5:37 even5:38 bediavad, you're not5:39 yotzei the chovah. For the Ashkenazim,5:42 they have somebody to be matir,5:46 and I'm not going to say it's5:47 mutar lechatchila, because even they don't hold 100%5:50 mutar lechatchila. If you're Ashkenazi and you're wondering,5:52 what did I do if I'm in a hospital,5:54 I'm in a hotel room,5:54 I don't have candles,5:56 what should I do?5:56 Well,5:57 Sefardim, you don't make a bracha of Borei5:59 Me'orei HaEsh. It's fine. You can make Havdalah without brachat Borei6:01 Me'orei HaEsh. But for Ashkenazim,6:03 then you should ask your local Orthodox rabbis6:06 to see what your particular rav holds6:10 about making electricity, making bracha Borei Me'orei HaEsh on electricity6:12 when there's no other choice.6:14 Let's move on now to the halachot,6:16 to continue in the halachot of fire,6:18 of Borei6:19 Me'orei HaEsh from the Ben6:22 Ish Chai, halacha tet-vav. What today we will do,6:23 because there's a lot of halachot left,6:25 I'm going to be selective in what we read inside.6:29 Even what we read,6:30 we probably will not read most of the halachot from inside,6:33 but still. We'll try to do what we can.6:37 Next halacha is looking at your6:39 fingers when making the bracha of borei6:41 me'orei ha'esh. We all know when it comes to bracha borei6:44 me'orei ha'esh, we see we do all these different kind of gestures6:46 with our fingers, with our hands,6:47 when making the6:48 bracha. Let me read you from the Ben6:50 Ish Hai how to do it properly.6:51 Okay, let's begin.6:52 Keshe mevarech al haner, when a person is making bracha borei6:59 me'orei ha'esh, yachof rashei etzba'otav heimanim el toch kapo. Take your right hand,7:01 bend your four fingers inside of your hand,7:07 veyagudam bechosetachat arba etzba'ot, and your thumb should be under the four fingers.7:10 That's the way to hold your hands7:13 when making the bracha of borei7:22 me'orei ha'esh. Velo ya'aseh keotam, veyunach bafim lifnei haner ulifnei haadam atzmo, and your hand, even though the fingers are closed,7:25 but it should be facing you.7:27 Okay?7:28 So again, if you can see this on video,7:30 you see my hand like this,7:31 and then, meaning to say it's open,7:33 then you bend your four, you put your thumb in,7:36 you bend your four fingers over your thumb,7:39 and it should be facing you in such a way.7:41 That's the proper way to do it7:43 and to look at your,7:45 basically, between your skin and your fingernail.7:52 Velo ya'aseh ketam, venohagim lesakek be'achorei etzba'ot veyotam peshutim betikefufim, and don't do the following.7:54 Don't look at your fingers.7:55 Don't put out your hand7:57 open, the back of your hand.7:59 Don't keep your hand...8:00 Open and look at the back of your hand in front of the light.8:05 Also, don't open up your hand, even though you're looking on the inside of your hand against the light.8:15 Rather, always keep them first closed them and then put it next to the light.8:19 Also, like we said, basically, don't do it any other way.8:29 Just keep it this way. That is, says, bend your four fingers over your thumb and look over there,8:35 okay? And then he talks about what the best candle to use for Havdalah,8:40 and he says that the best one to use is wax candles.8:44 Now, we want to understand what's the pshat, what's the whole idea of bending your fingers, bending your hand?8:49 We don't find this by any other thing.8:50 If you're supposed to say other brachot, you don't see. We do all different types of8:55 gestures. So let me tell you, let's begin with the first pashut pshat, the simple reason for bending the fingers, really.9:04 The Gemara explains and says the following words, which I brought down in halacha:9:12 אין מברכין על האור עד שיהא עותו לאורו. You cannot make a bracha on fire until you benefit from the fire.9:18 Yeh'oto means coming close to it to be able to benefit from the9:21 fire. So now, the fire that you're making bracha on has to be strong enough,9:26 means that when you're making the bracha, the fire has to be strong enough that you're able to have benefit from it.9:32 What is light? What is a fire? What kind of benefit to get from the light?9:36 We said fire, in this case, has to be in order to provide light,9:39 not for heat, not for any other reason, to provide light.9:42 And therefore, the light is used to be able to discern between two items.9:47 When it's completely dark, everything looks the same. You can't see any difference.9:52 Light gives us the ability to distinguish between two items.9:57 So therefore, when you're close enough, says the Gemara, to be able to tell the difference between two coins,10:01 if you're holding a penny and a dime. When it's dark, you can't really tell which one is which,10:07 right, when you reach in your pocket.10:08 But when you're holding it next to the light, you can see which one is a dime and which one is a10:15 penny. So when you have enough light, where you're close enough to the light that you're able to tell the difference,10:20 then you can make the10:21 beracha. For the same thing, if you want to be able to tell the difference between your nail and your skin,10:27 you shut the lights in your house and it's completely dark, you can't see the difference.10:31 Only when you're close enough to the fire that you can see the difference between your fingernail and your skin,10:36 that's when you could make the beracha of borei10:38 me'orei ha'esh. And that's why, the simple reason why we bend our fingers when it comes to beracha of borei10:43 me'orei ha'esh. That's the simple reason.10:46 Now, there are kabbalistic reasons. There's a lot of kabbalistic reasons.10:49 There's a lot of different segulot to it. We'll give you just one.10:53 Because you're looking at your fingers to see the difference between your skin and your nail,10:58 the nail is a reminder of the sin of Adam Harishon.11:03 Because Chazal tell us, before Adam Harishon ate from the11:06 etz hadaat, his whole body was covered with nails.11:08 After he ate from etz hadaat, the nail shrunk to the size that we see today,11:16 that it's only at the edge of the person's body, at the extreme edges, by one's feet, by one's fingers as well.11:24 Okay? So that's the simple and a little bit not so simple explanation.11:29 Now, let's get back to11:31 halacha. There's a very important concept over here.11:34 Chazal tell us,11:38 Ein mevarchin al ha'or ad sheyotzi le'oro. Like we said, you have to benefit first,11:41 which means you have to look at the fire first, benefit from it, and then you make the11:49 beracha. Why? Let me tell you a very important concept.11:53 In berachot, when we make berachot, there are three categories of11:58 berachot. All berachot fall into three categories.12:00 Category number one are berachot which are known as12:05 birchot hanehenin. These are blessings we make when we give thanks to HaKadosh Baruch Hu12:09 before we partake in any benefit in this world.12:12 For example, the berachot that we make on eating and drinking,12:16 like shehakol, mezonot, or12:19 borei pri ha'etz. All these berachot are called12:22 birchot hanehenin. The second category of berachot are berachot that we make on mitzvot.12:27 For example, the berachah that we make on hadlakat nerot,12:31 the berachah that we make on lulav, on sukkah, on tefillin.12:38 And the third category of berachot are12:43 birchot hashevach. Those are berachot that we make praising HaKadosh Baruch Hu for what He has given us.12:48 For example, birchat levanah, birchat hammah, Yotzer hame'orot in the morning.12:53 All these are called12:54 birchat hashevach. Now, there's a very important difference between birchot hanehenin and12:59 birchat hashevach. We're not talking about birchat mitzvot right now,13:01 and people make a mistake in this.13:03 Birchot hanehenin, Chazal tell us,13:05 אסור ליהנות מעולם הזה קודם ש... בלי ברכה. Excuse me,13:12 אסור ליהנות מעולם הזה בלי ברכה. You're not allowed to benefit from this world without13:15 a berachah. Okay? So therefore, you can't eat and then make13:19 a berachah. You can't drink your water and then make shehakol.13:21 Rather, you make shehakol, and then you could eat, and then you could drink.13:28 Okay? So therefore, you first make the blessing, and then you partake in the benefit.13:34 However, by birchat hashevach, it's the exact opposite.13:37 First you benefit, and then you praise Hashem for it.13:40 For example, birchat levanah. And if you remember,13:44 Chatam Sofer, first you're supposed to look at the moon and then make the13:48 beracha, okay? Why? Because you're praising Hashem.13:51 First see it and then praise it.13:53 So when it comes now to the beracha of Borei Me'orei HaEsh,13:57 the fire that we make Motzaei Shabbat, you have to know,14:00 although there is a machloket on this14:04 beracha if it's birchat hanehenin or14:06 birchat hashevach, majority of opinions rule that the beracha of Borei Me'orei HaEsh is14:11 birchat hashevach, which means first you're supposed to benefit from the fire on Motzaei Shabbat,14:15 and only then do you make the beracha of Borei Me'orei HaEsh.14:20 That's very, very important.14:22 It's not like14:23 birchat hanehenin, okay? So therefore, when we tell you to look at your fingers,14:26 bend your fingers and look at your14:29 hands to tell the difference between your fingers and your nails,14:31 you're supposed to first look at your fingers and then make the14:35 beracha. That's the way it's supposed to be done.14:38 Now, I have to point out, though, that there are opinions that say otherwise.14:42 There are opinions that say, no, do it the other way.14:45 But still, there are people who make a compromise,14:49 me'ikar hadin, you're supposed to do it like the way we said,14:52 which is bend your fingers and then make the14:55 beracha. That's the proper way to do it.14:57 However, there are those who make a compromise and they say,15:00 now first look at the light.15:01 You don't need, by the way, to look at your fingers.15:04 It's good, but it's not an obligation,15:07 meaning to say, for some reason, let's say you're tied down,15:09 you cannot—your hands, you cannot pick up your hands and you make a beracha of15:14 havdalah. As long as you're able to see the light and benefit from the light15:17 or close enough to the light, then you can make the15:20 beracha. You don't even have to, by the way, to shut off the lights.15:22 As long as you're in close proximity of the fire of the havdalah candle15:26 and that you know that if the lights have been shut off,15:29 you could benefit from that light,15:30 that's good enough to make the15:31 beracha. You don't need to shut off the light.15:32 And same thing, you don't need to pick up your fingers either.15:35 So therefore, look at the light, benefit from it,15:38 make the beracha Borei Me'orei HaEsh,15:40 and then afterwards look at your fingers.15:42 Okay,15:42 this way you kind of make a compromise between all the15:48 shitos, and basically you make a compromise.15:50 That's what it is.15:51 One more point about Birchat Borei Me'orei HaEsh,15:55 and that is the latest time for a person to be able to make.16:00 Brachah borei ha'esh. Keep in mind, you don't have to make brachah on the fire if you don't have it.16:05 So if you're in a hospital where they don't let you put on the candle and you have to make havdalah,16:10 or you're in a hotel and, again, you don't have havdalah candle or they don't let you make a brachah havdalah,16:15 or even if you're in your own house and you don't have any fire in the house,16:19 then what you do is you make the havdalah without the16:23 brachah borei me'orei ha'esh. If you come across fire that is providing light16:28 after you made havdalah and you want to make a brachah borei me'orei ha'esh, you should,16:33 but the latest time to do that, according to the16:38 Ish L'Avraham, is after alot hashachar. Some say even up to sunrise,16:42 according to Chacham Ovadia, and some say up to Mishayakir,16:44 which is basically between dawn, alot hashachar, and sunrise.16:49 But everybody agrees even past alot hashachar you can make a brachah of16:56 borei me'orei ha'esh. That is it for the halachot of17:02 borei me'orei ha'esh. I just want to conclude with the following:17:05 a practical guide of what a person should use lechatchilah as a candle for17:11 borei me'orei ha'esh. If you have the luxury of doing it, if you're able to do it, this is what's17:16 lechatchilah. And then we're going to tell you all the way to the17:19 bediavad. Bediavad, with the last, you know, the last thing on the list.17:23 And why are we telling you these? Because lechatchilah, in your own house,17:26 now that you listened to the class, whenever you listen to this class,17:28 go ahead and buy this lechatchilah, especially we're coming up to days of Elul17:32 and we're supposed to enhance our performance17:35 of mitzvot, so this is what you're supposed to do.17:36 But bediavad, you find yourselves in situations,17:39 bediavad, you find yourselves sometimes away on vacation, sometimes in other people's houses,17:43 sometimes in the hospital, lo aleinu, or17:45 Baruch Hashem you had a baby mazel tov and you're there on Motzaei Shabbos17:48 and you have to make a brachah borei me'orei ha'esh and you want to know what to use.17:52 Okay, let's start with the best things that you could use.17:55 The best, best thing is, you know those candles that they sell that's called havdalah candle,18:00 which basically it's a wax candle and everything is intertwined.18:03 Basically many candles are intertwined together18:06 that when you put on the candle, many flames are touching each other.18:09 Besides that the intertwined, the body of the candle itself is intertwined.18:14 Those are really the best candles to use for havdalah.18:19 This is according to all opinions. Everybody would agree that's the best one.18:24 If you don't have such a candle, you could still make it on another.18:27 Remember, you can even make it on one little flame.18:29 You could take two candles, regular two wax candles,18:33 put them next to each other, the flames are touching each other,18:38 and then make a18:40 bracha over me'orei ha'esh. The other option, if you don't have it, then you could also take two matches.18:45 It doesn't have to be a candle.18:47 As long as you know that the matches are going to be able to last18:50 by the time you make the bracha and look at it.18:51 So if you're one of those people that says such a long18:55 beracha and the candle is going to shut off by the end of the18:57 beracha, you're right. I mean, excuse me, not the candle.19:00 The match is going to shut off, so maybe it's not good for you to make it on a match.19:03 But technically, on match, even on a lighter, two lighters,19:06 put the flames next to each other. If you're lighting for the sake of providing light,19:09 you can make a bracha on it as well.19:10 If you don't have those options, then go back on the list:19:15 wax candles or matches, even if you have only one.19:19 Like a hatalah is supposed to have an abukah, remember, like a double flame.19:22 But even if you have one, it's also good enough.19:24 And when you're stuck and you really have nothing else,19:27 then you go to your stove.19:29 You shut off the stove, make sure it's off at least,19:31 and then put on your stove, for the sake of providing light.19:34 Now, even though we don't need so much light,19:36 but you don't need so much light even in the candle.19:37 So if you put on your stove for the sake of providing light,19:41 because you want to benefit from the light of the stove,19:44 then you can make a bracha also on the stove.19:48 Okay?19:49 And like we mentioned beforehand, whenever you make a bracha on the fire19:53 on Motzaei Shabbat, you don't need to shut off the candles,19:56 as long as you benefit from it.19:58 And what's called benefiting from it?20:00 You don't have to actually physically benefit,20:01 but as long as you're in close proximity20:04 that you know you can benefit from it,20:06 that is also good enough.20:08 Ad kan is the laws, all the laws of20:12 בורא מאורי האש. There's one more detail which we're going to discuss later on,20:15 and that is women and the20:18 bracha בורא מאורי האש. We'll talk about that, be'ezrat Hashem, when we get to the halachot of20:22 women. Halacha tet zayin, and now we move a little bit quicker in the Ben20:27 Ish Chai. When making havdalah in the shul,20:32 he says,20:34 כל אותם השליח ציבור מוציאם ידי חובתם, יתכוונו עיניהם בכוס בשעת הברכה. If you're in a shul20:36 and you're making havdalah in the shul,20:38 which most people do,20:40 okay,20:41 you listen to the havdalah in the shul20:42 and20:43 you yotzei the chovah with havdalah in the shul,20:44 then you have to pay attention.20:46 Not just pay attention.20:48 Everybody's eyes should focus on the cup of wine,20:50 even the one making the havdalah should look at the wine.20:55 And don't just get up, pick up yourself and move around20:59 until the chazzan finishes the whole21:04 havdalah, including, and of course, the last21:06 beracha, which is the main21:07 beracha, which is21:14 ברוך המבדיל בין קודש לחול. ולא כאותם הבורים שדקם לשמט אנה ואנה, דפונים לכאן ולצאת. And not like those fools, basically,21:18 that are walking around,21:20 they can't wait to leave.21:21 Oh, Shabbos has been so long,21:22 Shabbat has been so long and draining,21:24 we got to get out already,21:25 finish the havdalah already.21:27 No, don't be like those people.21:30 I have these guys going to put on their shoes,21:32 this guy's looking for his son21:34 or his friend to walk home with,21:36 and21:39 somebody's saying, And it turns out that they're missing out21:41 the main part of the21:42 havdalah. And really,21:43 we see this many times in the shuls.21:45 People making havdalah in the shul,21:47 they're listening to either the chazzan or the21:48 rabbi making21:50 havdalah, and they're not paying proper attention.21:52 And you should know,21:53 people most of the time pay attention21:55 to the first three21:59 berachot, הגפן, בשמים, בורא מאורי האש. When it comes to the22:00 havdalah, the yetzer hara starts working,22:01 and everybody starts talking, walking,22:03 Shavua tov. They get up.22:04 The berachah didn't even finish,22:05 I'm not even talking about the person drinking it.22:07 You're supposed to wait till the person22:08 who's making22:09 havdalah finishes drinking the cup of wine,22:11 but I'm not even talking about that.22:13 People are already saying Shavua tov22:14 before the person finishes22:15 the berachah of22:17 hamavdil, and that's the main part of22:19 havdalah. If you miss that22:20 berachah and you spoke in that22:22 berachah, you didn't do anything.22:23 It's ridiculous.22:25 People just get up and they walk.22:28 Therefore, hamazir22:31 vehenezhar. Right,22:31 a person has to be careful22:32 and has to warn other people.22:34 You have to make sure you wait22:35 till the whole22:36 havdalah. Don't let yetzer hara get you.22:38 And it's very, very important22:39 that people should know about this22:41 halacha, and people don't know about it,22:42 and they don't realize it.22:43 They just, you22:44 know, they're not thinking.22:45 So therefore,22:46 rabotai, make sure that if you're making22:49 havdalah, either in the shul, anywhere else,22:50 and you're listening to somebody else,22:51 you wait till you hear the whole thing,22:53 and you don't speak,22:55 interrupt in any way22:56 until the end of the person23:00 drinking from the23:02 havdalah. I want to point out something.23:04 In some kehillot,23:05 in some congregations,23:06 when they say23:09 Birkat Hagefen after the23:10 chazzan or the person making the23:11 havdalah says the23:13 bracha Hagefen, everybody starts to laugh.23:14 You know, I've seen somebody23:16 who wasn't familiar with the minhag,23:18 and he came and he was sitting there23:20 Motzaei Shabbat and listening to the havdalah from the23:23 chazzan, and all of a sudden23:23 the chazzan says23:25 Hagefen, everybody starts to burst out in laughter.23:27 He didn't know this was a custom,23:28 so he thought he missed the joke.23:30 He missed the joke.23:30 He was looking around,23:31 What did I miss?23:32 What happened?23:32 Who did what?23:33 I also want to laugh, right?23:35 So the question is,23:36 how come everybody laughs?23:38 And there's no source for the laughing.23:40 I have not seen any source for the laughing.23:43 And even the communities that do it,23:45 they never did it in the old country,23:47 okay?23:47 They never did it in the old country.23:49 They never laughed.23:49 It was all something that was made up here in America.23:52 How come they laugh?23:53 And the answer why they laugh is,23:55 they say that it's a good siman.23:58 You're beginning the week right now.24:00 Right, Havdalah is the beginning of the week, of the new week. It's Motzaei Shabbat,24:03 which is the first night of the week,24:05 and therefore in the beginning of the week, you want to start off the week with laughter.24:09 Okay, makes sense. It's not a problem of interruption; you're not saying any words.24:14 But, but, and you have to be very careful,24:17 because unfortunately, a lot of problems do extend from this custom of laughing.24:24 You're not going to be able to break them in hag of laughing.24:26 It's good, why not? Laugh, laugh all you like.24:28 The problem is, is when the laughing goes to the next level24:33 and people already start interrupting by talking.24:37 I've seen places where after making brachat hagefen,24:40 one guy actually announces it, Everybody laugh!24:44 And everybody laughs. But you're not supposed to talk.24:47 You're listening to Havdalah; it's like you're making Havdalah. You're not supposed to interrupt.24:50 Rav Akiva Eiger, quoted by Biur Halacha, says24:52 if the person making Havdalah speaks between brachat hagefen and25:01 brachat hamavdil, it's a bracha levatala. Excuse me, no. Not only does he speak,25:04 he says even if you make the wrong bracha, let's say by mistake, yeah,25:08 let's say by mistake you made a bracha on something that's25:11 atzei besamim, which doesn't have a smell.25:13 You thought it had a smell, but it doesn't have a smell,25:15 so it's a bracha levatala. It's called an interruption.25:17 You made a hefsek; you have to go back and say hagefen again.25:20 Kavachomer, the guy is saying, Laugh.25:23 That laugh has nothing to do with Havdalah.25:24 Don't tell me it's part of the Havdalah; it's nothing to do with Havdalah.25:27 There's no source for it. Again, you want to laugh, it's fine, but be careful.25:30 Other times I've seen where already extended that when people come to the25:36 beis hamim and everybody goes, Ahh. Okay,25:38 again, you're not saying any words; it's not a problem.25:41 But when people say, Wow, this smells great,25:46 when they're talking about atzei besamim, this is ridiculous.25:49 Who cares about your comment? You want to post a comment,25:53 go to any website where they leave you a place where you can put comments25:55 and write what you want.25:57 I think Yeshiva World News, go right over there on every Motzaei Shabbat,26:01 Today's beisamim smelled good.26:02 What do you have to tell everybody in the shul?26:04 It's an interruption,26:05 and when you do it, it causes everybody else to do it.26:08 And sometimes there's a26:10 machloket: no, it smells good; no, it doesn't smell good.26:12 So, rabotai, besides, you know, if you want to do all your minhagim,26:16 make sure that you keep that ikar26:18 halacha: do not speak. To interrupt from the beginning of the havdalah,26:23 from the beginning of the26:25 Birkat HaGefen, until the person making the havdalah finishes drinking from the havdalah.26:29 These are important things to not just do for ourselves, to keep in mind,26:33 but we also have to warn others in order that they should be yotzei the chovat havdalah,26:38 like the way26:40 Chazal were metaken it. Keep in mind, if you don't do havdalah, you can't eat,26:43 which leads us to now the next halacha, okay?26:47 Next halacha is talking about a26:49 person—I'm not going to read it inside because we're running out of26:52 time—but the Ben Ish Chai says if a person is hard of hearing26:55 and he's sitting in the shul and he cannot make havdalah26:57 on his, but he wants to make it in the shul,26:59 it's a very unique case.27:01 Says the Ben Ish Chai, you know what you should do?27:03 Look at the cup of wine that the chazzan or the rabbi has in front of him,27:08 and you make your own berachah along with him.27:12 Meaning, he's holding a cup of wine,27:13 even though you don't have a cup of wine with you,27:15 but you could see the cup of wine,27:17 make the berachah of hagafen along with him.27:19 Then you have your own besamim, you make atzei besamim.27:22 You're close enough to the light,27:23 then you put out your hand, you make a berachah of27:26 borei me'orei ha'esh, and then you look at your hand, and then you make27:31 a berachah borei me'orei ha'esh. And then you make the berachah of hamavdil while looking at the cup of wine,27:34 and then when he drinks from it, that's fine.27:36 Now, is that lechatchilah? No.27:38 Lechatchilah, you're supposed to hear it from the person making the havdalah.27:42 But because you're stuck in a situation which is27:45 b'diavad, you're sitting all the way in the back,27:46 you can't hear the27:48 chazzan, you can't move up to hear the chazzan for whatever reason,27:51 so this is what you have to do.27:53 I want to point out that if you are listening to havdalah through a microphone28:01 and you cannot hear without the microphone,28:03 then you're not yotzei the chovah either.28:05 Same thing, you cannot be yotzei dechovah by listening to havdalah on the radio,28:12 even, believe it or not, yeah, even if it's live streaming.28:16 There's no second difference.28:18 It's yashar.28:19 It doesn't make a difference.28:21 A person who cannot hear with his own ears,28:25 the sound of the person making havdalah,28:28 is not yotzei dechovah of havdalah.28:30 You have to hear it directly,28:34 okay? Halacha yud chet. Halacha yud chet, like we just said28:38 beforehand—oh, sorry,28:39 I missed one point.28:39 One point,28:41 halacha zayin, about, and that is there is a28:43 segulah, you know, whenever everyone runs after the havdalah,28:45 everybody runs to take from the grape juice or from the wine,28:48 and they put it over their eyes.28:48 Actually, that's brought down.28:50 That's brought down, I think the Drisha or the Pri... the Drisha brings down28:54 to take from the wine that they used to shut off the candle28:57 and put it on your eyes.28:59 Some people put it on their heads,29:00 they put it in their pockets for siman tov.29:02 Okay, on the eyes it's brought down to show the chibuv of29:05 the mitzvah, the love of29:06 the mitzvah, and some say that29:08 since there was a cup that you made the berachah on it,29:10 you made the mitzvah with it,29:12 so therefore,29:15 sheyireh mitzvot are me'akevina pur'anut, which means they can prevent bad things from happening.29:19 Some people take showers in the havdalah,29:21 fine, you can do whatever you like, it's not a problem.29:23 But certainly to put it over your eyes,29:25 even a little bit on the forehead,29:27 that's recorded, that's brought down,29:28 and one who does so is great.29:30 Also another segulah that's brought down29:31 is to smell the candle once it was shut off.29:34 I always used to—I don't remember29:37 where—I remember hearing it or seeing it a very long time ago,29:40 that when you smell the candle on motzaei Shabbat,29:43 it's good for memory,29:44 and you're supposed to say the29:47 pasuk, Zichru Torat Moshe avdi, and then take a sniff from the candle.29:49 I looked for the source, I couldn't find it.29:51 There's one more book that I need to look at,29:53 which I don't have right now with me.29:55 It's going to take me a few weeks29:56 till I get that book, hold of that book.29:58 But otherwise, I didn't see it anywhere,30:01 but I remember seeing it maybe somewhere30:03 a long time, unless my memory is failing me.30:06 The other thing that's brought down30:07 as a segulah to smell the candle,30:09 it's brought down that it also saves one from fires.30:12 There's many, many segulot30:13 besides the one that I just mentioned.30:15 There's many, many segulot30:16 also smelling the candle30:17 and the grape juice that's left afterwards30:19 from when a person shut off the candle with it30:22 on motzaei Shabbat.30:25 Halacha yud chet. Here are important30:27 halachot. Eating and drinking before making Havdalah.30:30 Remember, we just mentioned,30:31 you cannot eat or drink before you make Havdalah.30:36 I see we're running a little bit short on time.30:39 I'm going to start reading probably outside.30:41 Maybe I'll select a few things, okay?30:44 So let's begin.30:45 The Gemara says in30:47 Masechet Pesachim the following words.30:48 It's a little scary, these words,30:50 but the Gemara says them; we have to know it.30:52 The Gemara says,30:52 Kol ha-to'em klum kodem sheyavdil, mitato30:57 b'askara. Anybody who tastes, or eats basically any food,31:02 before he makes Havdalah,31:05 his death is through askara.31:06 Askara was a sickness31:07 that Rashi explains,31:09 which causes one to basically choke, okay?31:12 Begins from the stomach,31:13 it goes up to the throat31:15 and causes one to choke.31:16 That's the death that the Gemara attributes31:19 to the students of Rabbi Akiva,31:21 the 24,000 students who died31:23 from Rabbi Akiva's students.31:24 They died in the midat askara,31:26 okay? Now,31:28 what's the31:28 halacha? Halacha says,31:29 Shulchan Aruch brings it down,31:33 asur le'echol mishtetachshach ad sheyavdil. One cannot eat31:34 once it gets dark31:35 until he does Havdalah.31:37 What does it mean when it gets dark?31:39 Simple meaning,31:41 mishtetachshach, I would say,31:43 means31:43 motzaei Shabbat.31:44 Comes the31:45 Magen Avraham, says no.31:46 Mishtetachshach means31:48 even safek31:50 hashecha, which we call31:51 ben hashmashot. In English,31:52 that's called sunrise,31:53 sunset.31:54 Once the sun sets31:56 and ben hashmashot begins, according to31:58 Magen Avraham, you cannot eat.32:00 That is not only the opinion of Magen Avraham; that's also the Ben Ish Chai, and that's the opinion of many Acharonim that say that once the sun sets on Shabbat afternoon, if you didn't make Havdalah yet, you cannot make Havdalah. Excuse me, you cannot eat until you make Havdalah.32:18 You cannot eat, by the way, and you cannot drink either until you make Havdalah.32:22 However, there is a Taz. The Taz explains that when Maran says, אסור לאכול משתחשך, it means you're not allowed to eat or drink when it gets dark. It means motzaei Shabbat, which means when Shabbat is completely over, which is32:38 set by kohavim. And therefore, according to the Taz, ben hashmashot, the person is allowed to eat, but most Acharonim did not go with the Taz.32:43 So therefore, now we have a question: what do you do if a person now prayed Mincha and he didn't have seudah shelishit yet, and he looks at his watch, it's already32:52 shkia? Of course, he's supposed to begin seudah shelishit before shkia, before sunset on Shabbat afternoon. But let's say a person didn't.32:58 What do you do? You miss out? You miss out on seudah shelishit? Or you say, No, listen, I'm not allowed to eat?33:05 Or you say, No, it's a mitzvah, and therefore it's a mitzvah, and the one goes in such an area.33:09 The answer is as follows. After bringing many reasons, we're going to tell you why,33:15 the consensus of this many of the poskim, Chacham Ovadia, Chacham Ben Zion, is that you could start seudah shelishit 15 minutes after sunset.33:27 After 15 minutes after sunset, you could even start.33:30 Lechatchila, again, you're supposed to start before shkia, before sunset. But if it's already sunset, you have up to 15 minutes to begin your33:37 seudah shelishit. And once you begin seudah shelishit, you could continue eating.33:40 And certainly, if you began seudah shelishit before sunset, for sure you could continue eating after sunset as well, going into the night.33:49 Okay? What's the reason that we're making? We just told you.33:52 Most Acharonim rule like the Magen Avraham that safek hashecha, you can't eat or drink.33:57 So why now you're telling me33:59 the halacha? So number one is, first of all, you have the Taz, so already it creates a safek, safek34:05 d'Rabbanan lekula. Besides that, if you really think about it, remember we spoke at length in a few different classes about the whole concept of34:14 bein hashmashot, and we explained that Shulchan Aruch rules like Rabbeinu Tam,34:19 which means that really the real bein hashmashot, according to Maran, doesn't begin until 58 and a half minutes after what we know as34:28 sunset. So really, when a person is eating within those 15 minutes, technically, according to Maran, it's considered daytime.34:34 So certainly according to Maran, you can eat then, and there's no problem.34:37 So that's another reason to be matir only for seudat mitzvah, not for anything else but only34:42 seudat mitzvah. Two more reasons. Number three is that there is a concept—not a concept, but basically over here we're in bein hashmashot, which is safek,34:55 right? There's a safek now if you're obligated to keep or to eat35:03 seudah shlishit, and there's a safek if you're also now if you're allowed to eat or not.35:08 So therefore we say, safek aseh d'Rabbanan docheh safek35:13 issur d'Rabbanan. The safek of the mitzvah d'Rabbanan of making seudah shlishit will come and push away the safek if you're allowed to eat or not.35:22 And the last reason why we matir this halacha to eat within 15 minutes after sunset, to eat seudah shlishit, that is, it's because that's the minhag.35:31 Minhag is that even after sunset, you have 15 minutes, people do wash and they eat after sunset.35:36 So therefore, yes, lechatchilah, when you're making the schedule for the shul, you're supposed to make it that you're supposed to have enough time before sunset to35:44 have seudah shlishit. But even if a person was delayed and he finds himself after sunset, as long as you're within the first 15 minutes, you could35:54 have dalah. Okay, next, halacha, halacha yud tet is pretty similar.35:58 And halacha yud chet, we discussed eating before Havdalah, and yud tet talks about drinking before Havdalah.36:03 So says the Ben Ish Chai over here, the halacha is that one should not drink anything before making Havdalah, either once the sun sets.36:13 Of course, we're talking about over here that you're not in the middle of36:16 seudah shlishit. If you're in the middle of the seudah shlishit, so we told you you're allowed to continue seudah shlishit, allowed to continue even drinking36:22 in the middle of seudah shlishit. We're talking about a person who is not in the middle of36:25 seudah shlishit. He had seudah shlishit earlier, and now he wants to drink.36:29 You cannot drink after sunset.36:32 The only thing that you're allowed to drink is what?36:36 Water,36:37 plain simple water.36:38 Water you're allowed to drink before making Havdalah.36:40 There we're not גוזר on water, according to most opinions.36:44 However, however, even though technically you're allowed to drink water in בין השמשות before making Havdalah,36:51 still, Ben Ish Chai brings over here, and brought down also by the36:55 Rama, that many people refrain from drinking water by36:57 בין השמשות. You know why?36:58 Because it's brought down by the Rishonim, I think it's the Rokeach,37:02 that if a person drinks water by בין השמשות, it's like he's stealing from his relatives who are dead.37:08 A lot of people explain that to37:11 me in מוצאי שבת. What does that mean?37:12 It means that a person who drinks water by37:15 בין השמשות, so this is very spiritual and Kabbalistic. It's beyond us to understand,37:20 but basically the souls in Gehenna are burning,37:24 right?37:24 One is Gehenna shut off, shuts off on Shabbat.37:26 One is to go back on37:28 מוצאי שבת. So when the fires turn back on on37:32 מוצאי שבת, the souls that go into Gehenna, they burn.37:33 Sometimes they get a little bit of a break to go wash themselves in water,37:36 to cool themselves off in the water.37:37 When you drink water at that time, it's like you're taking away from their water.37:41 Again, this is Kabbalistic. It's not a37:45 din, but one who could be machmir not to drink even water before making37:50 Havdalah, תבוא עליו ברכה. Now to summarize everything. Let's put everything, let's make everything clear.37:55 Number one is, one cannot eat or drink after sunset until making38:02 Havdalah. Number two, one could only drink water38:05 min hadin, although some are machmir like we just mentioned,38:07 but still, min hadin, you could drink water before making Havdalah after sunset.38:11 Hacham Ben Zion says that even tea and coffee without sugar at all38:18 could be permitted for those who are sick or those who are elderly.38:22 Number three, halacha number three38:24 is that one could begin seudah shlishit after sunset,38:29 provided that's only within the first 15 minutes.38:31 Number four, if a person was already eating or drinking before sunset,38:37 he must stop his eating or drinking once sunset comes,38:40 even though he started eating beforehand.38:42 Remember, the only exception is38:44 seudah shlishit, but if he's eating regular snacks, he's eating fruits,38:46 he's eating potato chips, he's drinking wine,38:49 he has to stop once the sun sets.38:51 However, if it's38:56 pat haba'ah b'kisnin, Hacham Ben Zion, Hacham Ovadia both are matir. If it's something that you would normally make a39:02 bracha of, you normally make a mezonot, but if you'd eat a lot of it, you'd make birkat hamotzi,39:05 since that's like a little bit of a39:07 safek, you could eat it up to 15 minutes,39:09 up to bein hashmashot, basically39:10 up to 13 and a half minutes after sunset.39:13 With that, we move on now to39:15 halacha chaf. Halacha chaf, the Ben Ish Chai talks about39:21 birchat hamazon. This is important.39:22 We mentioned this in the past; we'll do it quickly now.39:24 Birchat hamazon after, on39:28 seudah shlishit. If you're making birchat hamazon on39:30 seudah shlishit, so most of the time people finish39:32 their seudah shlishit already into the night.39:33 So there's a mitzvah, whenever you have people eating together39:36 or even by himself, there's opinions in39:39 halacha that you're supposed to make birchat hamazon on a cup of wine,39:41 just like you make kiddush on a cup of wine,39:43 you make a wedding, a chuppah on a cup of wine,39:45 brit milah on a cup of wine.39:46 Birchat hamazon is so39:48 chashuv that it requires a cup of wine.39:49 There's a few opinions.39:51 There's three opinions in Shulchan Aruch,39:53 in Siman Kuf Peh Bet, I believe,39:56 yeah, Kuf Peh Bet or Kuf Peh Dalet.39:58 You'll check it out.39:59 Anyway, over there.40:00 Here, the opinions are as follows. One opinion says that whenever you make birchat hamazon, even if you're eating40:06 by yourself. The third opinion says, no, you don't need wine on birchat hamazon at all,40:10 okay? So now, when it comes now to seudah shlishit, you finished seudah shlishit, now you want to make birchat hamazon.40:16 Could you make a birchat hamazon on a cup of wine? Remember, if you make a birchat hamazon on a cup of wine,40:20 you have to say havdalah afterwards and drinking it. We just said you can't drink before making40:24 havdalah. And if you're going to drink it already, it's going to be either in between seudah or after seudah, and you already finished your meal.40:31 So could you drink or not? Do you say that this cup of wine is connected to birchat hamazon and therefore you could drink,40:36 or do you say, no, you finished birchat hamazon and now you haven't made havdalah, so you can't make a bracha on a cup of wine?40:42 So Magen Avraham points out, and many acharonim go with this Magen40:46 Avraham, but Magen Avraham says if you're a person who never makes birchat hamazon on a cup of wine,40:51 then you can't make birchat hamazon now on a cup of wine on seudah shlishit. Why?40:56 The fact that you don't make birchat hamazon on a cup of wine means you're holding, like the opinion says, birchat hamazon really doesn't require wine.41:03 So why are you making it? So you can't drink anymore. So this cup of wine is not—you can't do it now.41:07 You can't make birchat hamazon now, seudah shlishit, on a cup of wine. That's Magen Avraham; many acharonim bring him.41:13 The Mekubalim point out, and the Chametzion goes with this as well, is that since, al pi Zohar, there's an obligation to say birchat hamazon on a cup of wine,41:28 okay, only when you have three, not when you're doing it by yourself41:32 and you're not patur, only when you have three, there's an obligation at all times.41:35 So the fact that you don't make birchat hamazon on a cup of wine all the time doesn't exempt you on seudah shlishit or any other time.41:44 You're supposed to always make birchat hamazon when you have three men eating together on a cup of wine.41:50 So therefore, if you're having seudah shlishit and you finished, according to the Chametzion, you always make it on a cup of wine,41:56 regardless if you regularly or you don't regularly make birchat hamazon on a cup of42:01 wine. You must always make it on a cup of wine and drink from it.42:05 Many people I know, the Ashkenazim or not makpid on making birchat hamazon on wine,42:08 so they'll hold the cup of wine, but then they won't drink it; they'll leave it for42:12 havdalah. According to the Chametzion, you're supposed to also drink from it.42:15 Okay? Ben Ish Chai explains. He says that when we say you make Birkat Hamazon regularly on a cup of wine,42:21 it means even if you only do it on Seudah Shlishit, you could also do it on a cup of wine by42:28 Seudah Shlishit. Meaning, let's say you never make Birkat Hamazon on a cup of wine when you have a zimun, when you have three people.42:32 But Seudah Shlishit, you makepid, or on Shabbat you makepid to use a cup of wine.42:36 That's called, that's even according to the Magen Avraham and LeGri, that you could make Birkat Hamazon on a cup of wine.42:42 By us in the shul, we always make Birkat Hamazon on a cup of wine, and we drink it afterwards.42:46 Although other shuls don't do it, I don't understand why not.42:49 You know, we have enough opinions that permit it.42:51 But, you know, certainly everyone has his, you know, has what to rely on,42:58 has the source for why they do drink or they do not drink on.43:03 They don't drink the cup of wine after Seudah Shlishit when it's already after sunset.43:11 Halacha, chaf43:14 alef. Okay, now we get into an important halacha.43:19 What is the din when making havdalah?43:21 Should one sit or should one stand?43:26 The answer: that really the Kolbo brings down, since you are saying goodbye to Shabbat,43:34 Shabbat is known as the Shabbat queen,43:36 so therefore you're escorting the queen to walk out, to leave Shabbat.43:40 So it's not respectful. It would be respectful that a person should make havdalah sitting down.43:46 You have to stand up to escort the Shabbat on its way out.43:50 And therefore, says the Kolbo, you're supposed to make havdalah standing up.43:55 That's the opinion of the43:57 Kolbo. However, the Tosafot disagree with that.43:59 The Tosafot say, What's going on?44:02 How could you make havdalah standing up?44:05 When you make havdalah standing up, you make a bracha on44:09 the gefen, and you make it on behalf of everybody.44:12 So therefore, you have the law, you have the halacha:44:15 whenever somebody is making a bracha where everybody else is also partaking of it,44:20 he's supposed to be sitting down.44:23 L'mashal, if you want me to cover you for the bracha of mezonot on a piece of cake,44:29 we're supposed to sit down, and then I'll make the bracha of mezonot on the cake.44:35 I shouldn't be standing up. L'chatchila, you have to sit down.44:38 So also here, says the Tosafot, you're supposed to really sit down when you make havdalah,44:44 because you're making a44:46 bracha on the gefen. Now obviously, this means only if you're drinking from a cup of wine.44:49 But really, if you're not drinking from a cup of wine,44:51 technically, you don't have to sit down.44:53 But Tosafot still says if you're standing up,44:56 it could also work. Why?44:59 Because you're kavua.45:01 The whole idea of sitting down means that you set yourself now45:04 to cover another person with a45:06 beracha and the bracha of a45:07 gefen. But now that we are setting ourselves to be yotzei the bracha of havdalah,45:12 which we don't have to sit down for the bracha of45:15 hamavdil, so therefore it also works for a gefen as well.45:17 So Shulchan Aruch rules that when one is making havdalah,45:20 since he's covering other people,45:22 he has to sit down because you have to be kavua,45:24 and that's the ruling of the Shulchan Aruch,45:26 and technically it should be the ruling that all Sefardim should follow.45:31 By the way, this applies not only to the kahal,45:34 but it applies to the person making the havdalah as well.45:36 He should also be sitting down.45:39 However, the Rama says that the minhag is like the45:41 kolbo, that everybody stands up in order to escort Shabbat on its way out.45:44 This is the background to this45:47 halacha. Technically, according to this45:50 halacha, when you make Havdalah by yourself for yourself,45:54 then you should be standing up.45:57 Because think about it.45:58 Even the Tosafot that Beit Yosef brought down to argue on the46:01 Kolbo, the ones who say that you're supposed to sit down46:03 is only because you want to cover another person.46:07 But if you don't want to cover another person,46:09 then you have the reason46:10 of the Kolbo. You're escorting Shabbat on its way out,46:12 and therefore you would want to say the46:16 beracha, or say the whole Havdalah standing up.46:18 This way you stand up when you escort the Shabbat out.46:21 Okay?46:23 However, there is a opinion you should know,46:25 Rav Chaim Palachi, he brings from the46:27 Kubalim, even if you make it by yourself, you should be sitting down.46:30 Although I haven't seen anybody besides him46:31 that says you sit down even when you're saying it alone.46:34 In any case, in any case,46:37 the Ashkenazim always stand up by Havdalah,46:40 and if I remember correctly, in Syria and Halab46:43 they used to stand up,46:44 if I remember correctly.46:45 Not only that, Ben Ish Chai says in Iraq46:47 they also used to stand up by Havdalah,46:49 and I've seen many kehillot46:52 where the rabbis46:54 are talmidei chachamim, where the person making Havdalah stands up only46:56 and everybody else sits down.46:58 By us in the shul,46:59 it's a smaller shul,47:01 so therefore we all sit down,47:03 including the one making the Havdalah.47:05 But again, each one does like his minhag.47:08 Preferably, according to Maran,47:10 everybody should be sitting down,47:11 even the one making the Havdalah.47:12 But if one stands up,47:14 certainly you have the47:16 Rama, you have, like the minhag was in47:18 Ben Ish Chai, in Ben Ish Chai's time.47:20 And also keep in mind47:22 that technically the Tosafot47:23 says that you're supposed to sit down47:26 only because you're covering another person,47:28 bechatan nehenin. That's only if you're drinking from it.47:29 If you're not drinking from it,47:31 then technically it shouldn't apply either.47:32 We have ten minutes left of the class.47:34 If anybody would like to call in47:36 or text in your question,47:37 get the numbers.47:41 718-718-6835-858, that's47:42 the call-in. I'm not going to take any questions47:43 until after 10 minutes,47:44 till after 347:46 o'clock. And if you want to text in your comments or questions47:48 to47:52 347-927-8398. We have a few halachot left.47:54 I'm going to go to the next47:57 halacha, halacha bet, havdalah for women, and then.48:00 We jump around or just basically summarize.48:03 I want to finish today the halachot of Motzaei Shabbat,48:06 so bezrat Hashem already next week will be Rosh Chodesh Elul,48:09 and already we have to get to the halachot of the holidays,48:12 Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Sukkot.48:13 We have plenty of halachot that we still have to cover coming up.48:17 Let's begin with this halacha, halacha48:22 chaf-bet: women making havdalah.48:24 Let's give you a little bit of a background.48:25 There is a machloket rishonim48:27 if women are obligated to make havdalah bichlal or not,48:30 if women should make havdalah or they are exempt from havdalah.48:34 What does that mean?48:35 Why, and who says what?48:37 Rabbeinu Yonah. Rabbeinu Yonah says women are obligated to make havdalah.48:40 You know why?48:41 Because it's part of the Shabbat.48:43 Even though, yes, it's already Motzaei Shabbat, but still it's part of Shabbat.48:46 Zachor v'shamor, and therefore, just like she's obligated in shamor, she's obligated in zachor.48:51 Certainly, according to the Rambam, who holds that zachor et Yom48:57 HaShabbat l'kadsho, which is the mitzvat de'oraita, includes even havdalah,49:01 so certainly women are obligated in havdalah.49:04 Now what about the ones that hold that hachamim are the ones who instituted havdalah?49:10 Even they'll agree, according to Rabbeinu Yonah,49:13 that women are obligated also in havdalah Motzaei Shabbat.49:16 It's part of Shabbat.49:18 That's the opinion of Rabbeinu Yonah.49:19 However, Beit Yosef quotes the Orchot Chaim, who says that49:24 since the havdalah on a cup of wine is being said on Motzaei Shabbat,49:29 which is a weekday already, that's beginning of the week,49:32 so therefore it has nothing to do with Shabbat.49:33 Why should women be49:35 chayav? That's a49:37 machloket. What is the psak halacha?49:39 Well, we have Shulchan Aruch.49:40 Maran writes, women are obligated in making havdalah on Motzaei Shabbat.49:47 However, v'yesh cholkim, there are those who argue.49:49 But clearly, according to Maran,49:51 he's going with the opinion of Rabbeinu Yonah and many others, of course,49:54 that women are obligated to make Havdalah Motzaei Shabbat.49:56 The Rama writes, because there's a machloket, he says,50:00 better for the women not to make Havdalah on their own;50:02 better that they should hear from men the Havdalah,50:07 okay?50:08 And therefore, with that, we'll go to the next step.50:11 For the Sefaradim, majority of the opinions hold50:15 that women can make Havdalah; they're obligated just like men are.50:18 Women make Havdalah on their own, and not only that,50:21 but even men can make Havdalah for the women50:23 if they were yotzei their chovah already,50:26 since women themselves are obligated.50:28 There's no difference between men and women,50:30 okay?50:32 However, however, if women do know how to make their own50:36 berachot, they know how to read berachah on their own,50:38 then yes, they have to say it on their own.50:40 They should say the whole Havdalah,50:42 because Maran rules that when it comes to all these50:45 berachot like Kiddush and anything else,50:47 if a person knows how to read it himself,50:49 he has to be yotzei the chovah by himself50:50 and not have somebody else cover him.50:53 So likewise, we say the same thing.50:54 If a woman knows how to make Havdalah, she should make Havdalah on her own50:59 and not have somebody who already made Havdalah make it for her,51:04 okay?51:05 The Ashkenazim, remember, according to51:07 Rama, Rama says,51:10 don't make it on your own; try to listen to another man making it,51:14 which is the best way.51:15 If a husband comes home, he hasn't made Havdalah yet,51:18 according to the Sefaradim, the best thing is the husband should make Havdalah.51:21 This is, according to all opinions, is the best thing.51:23 If the husband doesn't make Havdalah in the shul,51:25 or if he has intention that he doesn't want to make Havdalah in shul,51:28 he could come home and make Havdalah for his wife.51:31 He should do that,51:32 okay?51:33 For the Ashkenazim, the Bach brings down,51:35 even if you want to go with the opinion that says51:38 that women are exempt from Havdalah,51:39 if the women want to accept it upon themselves, they can do so.51:42 Certainly they can do so.51:43 However, it's still preferable for them to hear it51:46 from the men who have not yet made havdalah.51:49 So, so far at this stage, just to summarize very quickly,51:52 a woman in Sefaradia could make her own havdalah,51:57 lechatchila, without a problem.51:59 If the husband hasn't made havdalah,52:01 of course you listen to the husband's havdalah.52:02 For Ashkenazim, a woman should try to hear52:06 lechatchila from the man making it.52:08 If there's nobody around to make havdalah for her,52:10 no men around to make havdalah for her,52:12 then she could also make her own havdalah.52:18 Okay,52:18 the question is, what about a man who already made havdalah?52:23 A guy made havdalah already, now he is coming home,52:25 and his wife knows how to make havdalah.52:27 So we said for the Sefaradim, wife should make her own havdalah.52:30 For the Ashkenazim, for the Ashkenazim,52:34 so really in this case also there's a question.52:37 On one hand, if you hold that women are obligated,52:41 so then you can make havdalah for them,52:44 and you can be motzi them,52:45 and you don't have the problem if they know how to read already,52:47 because you have the opinion of the Rama52:51 who says even people know how to make52:52 a bracha, you can be motzi them anyway.52:55 But if you hold that they really are52:57 exempt, how could you make a bracha for them?52:59 You're already exempt.53:01 So therefore there's a whole big discussion with this,53:04 okay?53:05 And it comes out that53:08 if a person wants to make havdalah for his wife,53:10 he could, even though he made havdalah already, for Ashkenazim.53:13 And the only thing is, even for the53:16 Sefaradim, if a woman knows how to make the bracha of Borei Me'orei HaEsh alone,53:19 she should make it on her own.53:20 That's the opinion also of Ben53:21 Ish Chai. If you made havdalah in the shul53:23 and you're coming home to make havdalah only for your wife or your daughters,53:27 then in that case,53:29 let her make the bracha of Borei53:31 Me'orei HaEsh. That's lechatchila, let her make it.53:33 But if you make even, but if you want to make even Borei53:36 Meorei HaEsh, Chacham Ovadia is also53:37 matir it. But Lechatchila, Chacham Ben Tzion and Rav Ben Ish Chai hold53:42 that a woman should make the bracha Borei53:45 Meorei HaEsh when her husband already made it.53:46 I want to point out something very important,53:49 and that is,53:50 if you have children above the age of six or53:52 seven who understand the concept of Shabbat,53:53 there is a mitzvah miderabbanan to train them in making Havdalah,53:59 that they also have to hear Havdalah.54:01 And therefore, listen to this:54:03 if you are Sefardi or Ashkenazi,54:05 it doesn't make a difference,54:05 and you made Havdalah in the shul already,54:08 and you come home now,54:10 and your children who are above, boys,54:12 your boys, children who are above the age of six or54:16 seven, that they understand what Shabbat is,54:18 you could also make Havdalah for them54:21 Lechatchila, if they don't know how to make their own54:22 Havdalah, which most children do not know how to make,54:25 okay? And once you're making Havdalah for them,54:27 women could also be yotzei with the Havdalah54:30 from her husband,54:31 even according to54:33 Sefardim, even the berachah of Borei54:37 Meorei HaEsh, okay?54:38 So we have a question over here:54:39 if you're making Havdalah with Ashkenazim,54:41 do they have to stand up with them,54:43 or could they be yotzei sitting down?54:46 Well, like we said beforehand,54:48 the reason for standing up for Havdalah54:50 is to escort the queen.54:53 So Lechatchila, really they should be standing up.54:56 If they do sit down,54:57 again, this is all54:59 the din Lechatchila. Preferably, yeah, they should be standing up55:01 when making Havdalah,55:03 just like you would stand up55:04 by making Kiddush also in the evening,55:06 so too over here they should be standing up.55:08 Although I haven't seen it written down,55:10 but just from the reasons,55:11 that's what I'm talking from,55:13 okay?55:13 Now we have exactly a few seconds left,55:17 minute maybe.55:18 I'm just gonna—55:20 Boy, what to do over here.55:23 You know what?55:23 Maybe next week.55:25 Yeah, we're gonna have to stop over here.55:27 It's already running out of time.55:28 If you have any questions or comments,55:31 let me give you the phone number to the station.55:32 You can call on.55:33 I'm here for a few more minutes.55:35 Next week,55:35 Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll just finish up the last few halachot,55:38 and then after that,55:41 Be'ezrat Hashem, after those halachot next week,55:42 we'll also go on to the halachot of Elul,55:45 as well as Rosh Hashanah,55:47 and all the holidays55:47 we'll explain,55:49 Be'ezrat Hashem, next week.55:50 Numbers to the station are55:53 718-683-5858. You can text in at55:58 347-927-8398. We're here in the station.56:00 Answer your questions, and thank you for listening. Thank you to Iran and Jew Radio for hosting us.56:06 Until next week, have a wonderful week, and also a Chodesh Tov.56:10 Next week we'll meet again on Wednesday afternoon, be'ezrat Hashem,56:13 and then it will already be Rosh Chodesh Elul,56:16 and we're preparing ourselves, be'ezrat Hashem, for yemei ha-rachamim veha-selichot.