Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRootRadio.com. This is the Halacha Hour on JRoot Radio. We are here on Wednesday afternoon at 2 o'clock live.0:09 Let me give you the numbers to the station before we begin. The numbers to call in to ask your question.0:16 We are in the middle of the halachot of Motzaei Shabbat, in the middle of halachot of0:21 Havdalah, specifically the berachot of besamim and the berachah of borei0:25 me'orei ha'esh. So if you have any questions on these specifically, you could call in to the following number:0:35 718-683-5858. Again, that's 718-683-5858. If you would like to text in your questions or comments, the number is0:47 347-927-8398. I'd like to apologize from the beginning if you send in your text, I try to get to it right away,0:51 but if I don't get to it right away, you should know we do answer all the texts that we get,0:57 either through the class or afterwards we answer, be'ezrat Hashem, after the end of the class we stay around also to answer the questions.1:07 Also, if you would like to call off the air after 3 o'clock, you call in again to1:13 718-683-5858. We have no sponsors for this week's class as of yet.1:16 If anybody would like to sponsor, you could text in1:21 347-927-8398. Text in your name and any name that you'd like to sponsor in honor of.1:27 And now we get to the class, be'ezrat Hashem.1:29 The class is—1:32 okay, we already have a question on. Let's see.1:35 Hello?1:36 Hello.1:36 Yes, you're on the Halacha Hour?1:38 Yeah.1:39 Yes.1:40 So I want to know which kind of things are acceptable to use as a smell for the1:50 besamim. Okay, very good question.1:52 The geta from your question, that you're Ashkenazi.1:56 No, I'm mixed, actually.1:57 You're mixed, okay.1:59 Baruch Hashem, that's good. You got to get the best2:01 of both. We grew up with the mint leaves,2:06 the nana, you know, the nana.2:08 Of course, of2:08 course.2:09 Okay. So now, the best thing to use for motzaei Shabbat, for the havdalah, is to use the2:16 hadasim, that they call the myrtle branch.2:19 Hello?2:20 Yes, yes.2:21 Okay, is to use the2:23 hadasim. Those are the best things to use for motzaei Shabbat for the besamim.2:27 That's only—make sure that it has a good smell.2:30 We'll talk about besamim; we can speak about it in depth a little bit later.2:33 Yes. No, just because the ones, the dried ones, I find them very2:38 off-putting. That's right,2:38 yes.2:39 So, okay, that's another point that you mentioned also,2:42 that if you don't like the smell of something, you can't use it.2:45 Right.2:45 So it has to be something that you enjoy2:47 the smell. So the nana leaves, if you pick them or if you're grabbing them in order to smell them for motzaei Shabbat2:53 and you enjoy the smell, then you make a2:55 berachah. But if you pick the nana leaves in order to cook, you know, to make tea with it2:59 or to use it for spices, then you're going to have an issue.3:02 We're going to talk about it in detail a little bit later on.3:04 So l'chatchilah, again, the best thing is3:07 hadasim. If you don't have hadasim, you take anything that has a good smell.3:12 Try to avoid fruits, because fruit's a little bit complicated.3:15 And what about perfume?3:16 Perfume, I'm going to speak3:17 about. The whole idea is to be meranen the3:21 neshamah. Yes, yes, yes.3:22 Perfume I'm going to speak about.3:23 It's not as simple.3:24 There are—but you should know, if one does use perfume, you have big, big guns to rely on.3:29 Those, Rav Ben Zion and Rav Ovadia Yosef, both of them are3:33 matir to use perfume for motzaei Shabbat.3:35 I'm going to talk about it later on also as3:36 well. Okay, great.3:37 Okay.3:38 Thank you. Thank you so much.3:39 My pleasure.3:39 Thank you.3:42 Okay, so now let's get to the class,3:45 but first we have to announce the numbers.3:47 If a person would like to listen on the phone, if you don't have internet access,3:50 the number is3:54 718-506-9099, and if that's busy, then you try3:59 712-432-4217. These are numbers to listen, jrootradio.com, as well as the JRoot Radio Pro app.4:04 And now let's get to the class.4:06 We are, like the kollel just called, we are in the middle of discussing the halachot of4:11 besamim and the halachot of the candle for Motzaei Shabbat for Havdalah.4:16 We'll begin from the beginning.4:17 I was told again to announce also that you could watch online, you could watch this live.4:23 There's a video actually live right now.4:25 You could see what's going on, if that makes a difference.4:27 If it's a class, you can listen.4:28 So let's begin.4:31 We mentioned last week that there are four blessings to the Havdalah,4:35 and they are Rashei Tevot Yavneh, Yud, Bet, Nun,4:39 Heh. Yud is yayin, Bet is besamim, Nun is ner, the candle, and Heh is the Havdalah.4:45 That's the final blessing.4:46 We're up to the second blessing, the blessing of4:48 besamim. First question we have to understand, we have to ask ourselves,4:50 why in the world are we making the blessing on a good smell on Motzaei Shabbat?4:56 What in the world does it have to do with anything?4:58 I understand Havdalah, so that's the last blessing.5:00 I understand a gefen, because every time you make a5:04 berachah, you make a mitzvah that's very chashuv, we put wine with it,5:07 like kiddush, brit milah, weddings.5:10 We mentioned this in the past.5:11 What about5:12 besamim? So we have a few answers.5:14 Let's begin with the famous one that everybody knows,5:17 and that's what the kollel just called recently5:18 about, and that's the opinion of the Tosafot.5:21 Tosafot says, you know why we make a berachah of besamim Motzaei Shabbat?5:24 That's because the neshamah yeteirah goes away.5:29 And like a relative that comes over for Shabbat,5:32 and he's leaving now after Shabbat, he's going back home,5:35 so you feel a little sadness when he leaves.5:38 So too, when the neshama yeteira goes away,5:41 so the neshama that's there already feels very sad,5:44 and therefore we want to give it something to inspire it.5:49 We want to give it something to make it feel better.5:51 And the only thing that the soul benefits from,5:55 that is, the only sense that the soul benefits from, is the sense of smell,6:00 and that's why we bring the6:02 besamim. That's the most famous answer, the answer of the Tosafot.6:04 However, we have two other answers,6:06 and actually they will make a difference in6:08 halacha. The second answer is the opinion of6:11 the Bach. The Bach, the Bait Chadash, a commentary on the6:13 Tur, he explains something very interesting.6:16 He says, you know why?6:17 The Zohar tells us that on Shabbat, Gehinam shuts off.6:21 The fire in Gehinam is off on Shabbat,6:25 and all the people who are supposed to be burned6:27 get a break over Shabbat, of course, if they kept Shabbat.6:30 Motzaei Shabbat, though, the fire comes back on.6:33 And since the fire comes back on,6:35 there's a stench that comes from the fire,6:38 and therefore we don't feel it, our bodies don't sense it,6:42 but our neshama, which is spiritual,6:44 could smell that stench that's coming from6:48 Gehinam, and therefore we give it the good smell6:50 in order to alleviate it from that stench.6:53 It's kind of like, you know, when you put on the heat6:55 for the first time in your house6:57 when it's wintertime and it makes that smell.6:59 It's the same thing over here.7:00 It's the beginning of the week.7:01 It's the first time that the smell of Gehinam is coming about.7:04 We had a break. The neshama had a break over Shabbat,7:07 and that's why we make the7:09 bracha besamim to alleviate our neshama from the smell that it senses7:14 from7:15 Gehinam. The third answer is Rabbeinu7:17 Bachye. Rabbeinu Bachye explains, based on the Gemara, of course.7:20 The Gemara says two points.7:21 Number one is, the Gemara says7:23 that a good smell strengthens a person.7:25 In fact, a lot of smells, still today,7:27 if a person is fainting, they give him something good to smell,7:30 and it revives a person.7:32 That's one point.7:33 The other point that the Gemara says7:35 is that a person on the third day...7:37 Of anything is usually weaker.7:40 What does that mean?7:41 Well, we find in Parashat7:44 Vayera that Abraham Avinu had a brit milah,7:46 and on the third day of his brit milah,7:48 he was visited by7:50 malachim and he was in tremendous pain.7:51 Usually the third day after surgery,7:53 the third day after something,7:54 a person usually feels weaker.7:56 This is why the Gemara says7:58 that we don't fast, and that once—8:00 Panim, they used to fast all week in order that the korbanot should be accepted in the Beit HaMikdash.8:04 They never fasted, though, on Sunday. Why not?8:07 So one of the answers that the mefarshim bring, based on the Gemara, is8:11 that the third day is Sunday, the third day of creation.8:16 Adam was created on a Friday, so Friday is the first day, Shabbat is the second day, and the third day is Sunday.8:21 Usually on the third day a person is usually weaker.8:23 And says Rabbeinu Bachya, based on that, we give the besamim.8:27 By the way, you can find it, Rabbeinu Bachya in Parashat8:31 Vayishlach. Based on that, we give the besamim. We smell the besamim on Motzaei Shabbat because it's really Sunday,8:38 and where the body is, where the neshama, and the whole body is naturally weaker.8:42 So that's why we give the smell, in order we smell the besamim, or to revive ourselves, to strengthen ourselves.8:49 Those are the three reasons are brought down.8:50 Now that we're talking about these reasons, I'm going to go a little bit into it,8:54 something very, very interesting, and just to clarify, because that's the purpose8:59 over here. We want to clarify this point about the9:02 neshama yetera. We all speak about the neshama yetera, again, an9:05 exosoul. What does that mean? You'll be surprised if you look into the Rishonim, how they explain9:11 neshama yetera. It's not as simple. We are used to understanding the way the Zohar explains.9:15 The Zohar says that you really, you get a9:19 neshama yetera. It's as simple as that. We all have one soul on Shabbat.9:23 We have an extra soul that comes from Gan Eden.9:25 These are the souls of other tzaddikim that are already in Gan Eden.9:29 They come down to this world to partake in the pleasures of this world on Shabbat,9:33 and each one who is planning to keep Shabbat gets that neshama of one of those tzaddikim from Gan Eden.9:39 That's the way the Zohar explains it. That's the way we usually understand it. However,9:43 The Rishonim don't explain it really that way.9:46 The Rashi brings down, Rashi says, you know what neshama yeteira is?9:49 Neshama yeteira gives a person an appetite.9:51 It means that a person on Shabbat has an appetite to eat and enjoy his food without feeling bad.9:56 You ever overeat? You know that feeling when you overeat,9:59 it hurts and it kills you. You can't eat so much.10:03 And although you're enjoying the moment when the food is going down your throat,10:06 but afterwards you get this horrible feeling that you overate.10:10 On Shabbat, a person has an appetite.10:12 You see all the delicious food that we eat, and we eat so much of it.10:15 We have a seudah in the evening, seudah in the daytime,10:18 and we eat a lot, and we're still enjoying it.10:21 We don't have a bad feeling or a heavy feeling after eating it.10:24 That, according to the Rashi, is called the10:27 neshama yeteira. Once Shabbat leaves, we don't have that neshama yeteira anymore.10:30 We don't have that feeling anymore.10:31 Ibn Ezra brings and he says the neshama yeteira gives us the ability to understand spiritual matters better.10:40 That's the meaning of10:41 neshama yeteira. What might be difficult throughout the week to understand,10:46 I mean to say, like let's say Torah or spiritual concepts,10:50 we have it easier on Shabbat because of this neshama yeteira, the Gemara tells us that we have.10:54 And I believe the father of the Shlah explains that really these two answers of the Rashi and Ibn Ezra fit together.11:00 It means that because we have the ability to enjoy food11:05 and to not feel bad after eating,11:08 therefore we're able to concentrate and focus on our spirituality and understand spiritual matters more.11:14 That is the concept of11:16 neshama yeteira. In any case, whatever explanation you want to go with,11:19 which most of us are used to, the Kabbalah one, the Mekubalim,11:23 we lose it already motzaei Shabbat.11:26 Now the other answer we said is11:28 the Bach. The Bach says that the smell of11:32 Gehenna. According to the Bach, not everybody agrees with this,11:34 but according to the Bach, not only does Gehenna shut off on Shabbat,11:38 but it also shuts off on Yom Tov.11:41 Which means, which means that since the Gehinam shuts off on Shabbat and Yom Tov,11:49 right? So that means whenever Motzaei Shabbat is Yom Tov,11:54 we will not make the bracha of11:56 besamim, because in order to make the bracha of besamim, you need both answers.11:59 The answer of Rabbeinu Bachya you always have,12:01 but you'll need all the opinions in order to make the12:05 bracha, and this makes it much more simpler.12:06 Let's give you examples.12:08 We just gave an example:12:09 Motzaei Shabbat is Yom Tov.12:11 We don't make the bracha of besamim then.12:12 Why?12:13 Although the neshama yeteira does leave us,12:15 we don't have a neshama yeteira except for Shabbat.12:18 On Yom Tov, we do not have a neshama12:20 yeteira. Still, we will not make a bracha of besamim on a good smell,12:26 because, why?12:28 Because Gehinam is also shut off according to12:30 the Bach. Another example:12:31 What about Motzaei Yom Tov,12:34 when the holidays finish?12:36 Let's say the holiday is on Monday and Tuesday,12:38 so Tuesday night we're making Havdalah.12:42 How come we don't make a bracha of12:43 besamim? And the answer is the same thing,12:45 because we don't have a neshama12:48 yeteira, because neshama yeteira only comes on Shabbat.12:50 Although Gehinam is coming back on,12:53 but we don't have the neshama12:54 yeteira, and therefore we will not make the bracha of12:59 besamim. This will be true also on Motzaei Shabbat,13:02 which is Tisha13:04 B'Av. Whenever Tisha B'Av falls on Motzaei Shabbat,13:07 so Gehinam is back on13:10 and the neshama yeteira leaves us.13:12 However, in this case over here,13:13 we don't want to feel better13:15 because it's13:17 Churban Bayit, we're mourning the Beit HaMikdash,13:18 and therefore,13:19 even though we should have technically made the13:21 besamim, but we don't want to feel better on this sad day of Tisha13:23 B'Av, and therefore we won't make a13:26 bracha. Now, just to point out a very quick halacha.13:31 Although we said on Tisha13:32 B'Av we don't put on, we don't make the bracha of13:35 besamim because we don't want the person to, we don't want to feel better13:38 when we're mourning the Beit HaMikdash.13:39 This is not true to a regular mourner,13:42 lo aleinu. A person who is an avel,13:44 a person who is mourning,13:45 does make the bracha of besamim, motzei Shabbat,13:48 like the regular berachot that he does13:50 throughout his mourning period.13:52 The only thing is only by Tisha13:54 B'Av, which is a public mourning,13:55 it's a universal mourning on all of us,13:57 that's why we don't make a beracha of13:59 besamim. But you should know,14:00 even though we just finished Tisha14:02 B'Av, even on Tisha14:03 B'Av, if a person wants to make the beracha of14:05 besamim, not in order to feel better,14:07 but because he wants to have an extra blessing,14:10 you could make a bracha on14:12 besamim. Let's get to now to the Ben14:15 Ish Chai, because this is, after all,14:16 a class from the Ben14:18 Ish Chai in Halachah Tet. What to use for14:20 besamim, and this is what the person just called to ask.14:23 We're going to start from the14:24 Ben Ish Chai, Be'inyan Atzei14:26 Besamim, meforash b'divrei Rabbeinu14:29 HaAri zal b'Shaar HaKavanot. The Ari zal explains14:30 what should a person use for the14:33 besamim. I'm not going to read it inside,14:33 but he says14:35 you should use the14:36 hadasim. If you remember14:37 when we spoke about kiddush,14:38 halachot of kiddush,14:39 we mentioned that a person14:41 should take the atzei14:44 besamim and walk around the table with it14:46 before making kiddush,14:48 and then make a beracha on it,14:50 borei atzei14:51 besamim. And it's not any random14:54 hadasim; you're supposed to take two bundles,14:56 right,14:57 of these two bundles of14:59 besamim, with three branches on each one.15:01 That's15:02 a chatchila, what you're supposed to use on Friday night15:04 before you begin your kiddush,15:05 and you make the blessing of atzei besamim on it.15:08 Says the15:09 Ari zal those same branches of15:10 hadasim are the ones that you're supposed to use also15:13 for motzaei Shabbat15:14 for Havdalah as well.15:15 And not only that,15:16 there's a special way to smell them.15:18 How do you sniff them?15:19 I'm going to read it to you inside.15:29 Kesheyariach, yimshoch veyisha'ef hareach bechotmo shlosha hamshachot u'she'ibot, v'zo achar zo, keneged nefesh, ruach, u'neshamah. When you sniff them,15:31 you should sniff them in the following way:15:33 three sniffs after each other,15:34 not just,15:34 you know, when you smell,15:35 you just take one sniff.15:37 And that's it.15:38 When you're making the bracha, borei atzei15:39 besamim motzei Shabbat,15:41 you should sniff three times,15:44 like that.15:44 I don't know if you're able to hear it;15:46 I heard myself.15:46 But you take three sniffs from the15:49 hadasim. When you make the bracha of borei atzei15:52 besamim, why?15:52 Corresponding to three parts of the soul:15:55 nefesh, ruach, and neshama.15:58 That is what Arizal brings down.16:00 It's based on the Zohar. The Zohar says the chetelah is supposed to use16:04 hadasim. And not only that, even the Rishonim bring down, the Tur brings down from the name of the Rishonim16:08 that you're supposed to use hadasim. Why?16:11 The Zohar explains the souls in Gan Eden come from a place which has hadasim all around,16:17 and therefore your neshama, which is benefiting over here, should smell the smell of16:22 hadasim. However, this is very important to keep in mind,16:24 and I try myself personally to be makpid to try to always also bring besamim,16:28 try to buy them ערב שבת, if, you know, it ends up working out. Sometimes, you know, they just don't have them.16:35 But when I do have them, and a lot of times they do last more than a week. You keep them in water, they do last.16:41 But sometimes they don't have a smell.16:42 You have to be careful with hadasim because at the end of the day you have to have a smell, a good smell from it.16:48 And if it doesn't have a strong smell, it doesn't have a good smell, you can't make16:53 a bracha עצי בשמים. A lot of times people will tell me, No, this has a smell. Here, smell.16:56 And I'll smell it, it'll smell like grass. It won't smell like17:00 hadasim. Hadasim have a special smell different from all other types of greens.17:04 You know, greens have a special smell like a tree.17:07 That's not a fragrance. It has to be a fragrant smell.17:10 And sometimes, I'll tell you even more, you could buy fresh hadasim and they may not have any smell.17:16 So before you come to have הבדלה, when you're taking the hadasim, or whatever you're taking to make havdalah on,17:23 make sure you sample it. You're allowed to sample it without making a bracha, just like food.17:28 If you want to taste the food to see if it tastes good or not, you don't want to eat, you just want to taste it,17:34 to take a little bite or to drink a little bit just to see what it tastes like, if you want to eat it or not,17:39 you don't have to make a bracha. Same thing by smell.17:41 If you want to smell, you want to sniff something to see if it has a smell or if it has a pleasant smell that you enjoy,17:47 then you could smell beforehand, before making a17:49 bracha. And I do that all the time. Every time I'm making הבדלה, I personally make the havdalah most of the time in the shul,17:55 and before I make the havdalah, I sample the hadasim. Not always do they have a smell,17:59 even if they're fresh. Kavachomer if they're not fresh. You have to make sure it has a good smell.18:05 Okay. Now, the next point that we want to talk about is the berachah to make on Motzaei Shabbat on the besamim.18:12 You should know there's a difference between Ashkenazim and18:16 Sefardim. Ashkenazim have a minhag that no matter what you use on Motzaei Shabbat for the berachah of besamim, for the havdalah,18:25 you will always make the berachah of minei besamim.18:28 That's the rule by Ashkenazim. No matter what you use, you will always say minei besamim.18:33 Even though the next day, or how about this, a few hours later when they're having melaveh malka,18:38 if they want to take a smell from something that smells good18:41 to make the proper berachah, they might make atzei besamim or asvei besamim.18:46 When it comes to havdalah, that's the standard, they'll always say minei besamim.18:50 However, for the Sefardim, our minhag is not that way.18:53 Our minhag is to make the correct berachah, the proper berachah by havdalah. It makes no difference for us.18:59 So therefore, we've composed a list of items that people commonly use for besamim19:06 and what the berachah on it is.19:09 To really discuss the berachot of besamim, the halachot of what berachah to make on besamim19:15 will take us a full class by itself, at least, if not more.19:19 It's in Siman Reish Tet Zayin, Siman Reish Yud Zayin in Shulchan Aruch.19:22 This is not our main subject, but because it comes up a lot, we have to know certain19:27 halachot. So let's begin.19:28 We said the top thing is, the best thing to use is19:31 hadasim. So following the list, I keep in mind this is only for the Sefardim on Motzaei Shabbat for havdalah,19:36 and if Ashkenazim want to use this list for the rest of the year, or I mean the rest of the week,19:42 then they also could follow the following list.19:44 Hadasim, the berachah of hadasim is atzei besamim. Okay, atzei besamim.19:49 The general rule is if the item that you have comes from a bark, a branch,19:58 then the berachah will be atzei besamim.19:59 If it has the roots of it—not the roots, but the stem—is hard, then the berachah will be20:05 atzei. If the stem is soft, the berachah will be20:08 asvei. So let's give an example.20:10 Mint leaves that the person just called about.20:13 Mint leaves are asvei besamim.20:15 Because mint leaves grow, it doesn't make a difference if they grow on the ground or on a tree.20:19 It makes a difference if their stem is hard or if it's soft.20:26 So therefore, mint leaves will be atzei besamim.20:30 People use also cinnamon sticks.20:33 That's atzei besamim.20:35 Cinnamon powder, that's also atzei besamim,20:39 because really cinnamon sticks are hard.20:41 If you grind it, it makes no difference.20:42 It should still be atzei besamim.20:45 But this is important to keep in mind.20:48 For cinnamon powder or cinnamon sticks, things that are usually used for food,20:53 things that we usually use for food, like the kola just called about mint leaves or whatever it may be,21:05 things that people usually use for food, you have to know21:08 you can't make a bracha of minei besamim on it if it's usually made for food,21:12 unless you take it specifically for the use of smelling.21:19 That means, let's say you're cooking and you pick up your cinnamon and you want to put cinnamon in your food,21:25 and now you smell the cinnamon. It smells good.21:27 You want to make a bracha on it. You want to smell it and make a bracha on it.21:29 You don't make a bracha on it,21:31 even if it smells terrific and you love the smell of cinnamon. It doesn't make a difference.21:34 You only make a bracha on it if you went lechatchila and brought it for the sake of smell.21:38 That's why if you're a person that will sometimes, or especially every week,21:44 have havdalah on cinnamon in your house, you should buy a special box of cinnamon21:49 just for the sake of havdalah or besamim,21:54 and designate that only for the sake of besamim.21:56 And again, the bracha is atzei besamim.21:58 The same thing will be by cloves.22:01 The clothes, the bracha should be lechatchila really atzei besamim.22:04 But some people have a minhag of making minei besamim.22:07 HaChametzion says you could stick with the minhag,22:12 excuse me, HaChacham Ovadia says that. And if a person wants to stick with the minhag,22:14 yikol, but lechatchila, clothes are also atzei besamim.22:17 Even though it's going to seem make minei, lechatchila it comes from a stem22:21 and it's supposed to be atzei besamim.22:23 Next, flowers, roses,22:26 if they have a natural smell, the bracha is atzei besamim.22:29 The same thing will be by rose water.22:31 Rose water is they basically take the roses and they cook them in liquid and water,22:36 and that's what you have.22:37 That will be also atzei besamim.22:39 All these cases, rabotai, make sure you do the proper22:44 beracha. And like we mentioned, make sure that you're taking it for the sake of smell,22:48 things that you usually use for food, like cinnamon, sometimes cloves or mint leaves,22:53 make sure you're taking it specifically for the sake of smell,22:56 otherwise you cannot make a beracha on it.22:58 Another point to keep in mind,22:59 if you ever have a doubt what beracha to make on the besamim,23:05 on something that smells good, if it's supposed to be asbei or23:09 atzei, you say the bracha of minei besamim.23:11 Minei besamim is like shehakol on food.23:16 Just like when you say shehakol on any food,23:18 yotzei, bediavad, if you don't know what it is,23:21 so too minei besamim, when you're in doubt what beracha to make,23:25 you make the bracha of minei besamim.23:27 Okay, that is halacha tet.23:32 Halacha yod.23:33 Now I know I didn't get to the beracha of colognes and perfumes.23:38 I'm going to talk about them, be'ezrat Hashem, when we get to halacha yud aleph, I believe.23:42 Yeah, halacha yod. ייזהר שיטול הידיים בשעת ברכה ויריח בו כדרך גדילתו, וצריך שיאחזהו בימין, וכשהוא בעצמו מברך על הכוס, לאחוז ההדס בשמאלו. צריך שבשעת ברכה שההדס יאחז הכוס בשמאלו וההדס בימינו.24:00 Okay, the Ben Ish Hai is telling us now simple halachot, but we still have to know.24:05 Whenever you make a berachah during the havdalah,24:10 whatever you make a berachah on something, it should be in your right hand,24:16 okay? So therefore, if you're beginning the havdalah and you're beginning with24:19 hagafen, so the cup of wine should be in your right hand when you're saying24:22 hagafen. When you come up to the hadasim, put the cup of wine in your left hand24:28 and then take the besamim in your right hand.24:31 You should not put the cup on the table; keep it in your left hand24:34 to show that everything is because of the havdalah.24:37 Everything is coming because of the havdalah.24:39 But when you make the berachah of besamim, the besamim should be in your right hand.24:42 When you're done with the berachah of besamim, put down the besamim24:46 and then use your right hand in order to, you know, to look at your fingers when you do the24:54 berachah borei me'orei ha'esh. And then finally, when you're up to the last berachah of havdalah,24:57 you put the cup of wine back in your right hand.25:00 That's a simple25:02 halachah. Let's get to halachah yud aleph, a very important25:05 halachah. We spoke about which types of besamim that you should use.25:08 Now you should know, not every besamim is mutar.25:11 There's a lot of things that smell good, but not only could you not use it for havdalah,25:16 you can't even make a berachah on it, even throughout the whole year, throughout the whole week even.25:21 What is that?25:22 Halachah yud aleph, he tells us:25:24 Im ein lo hadasim, yevarech al she'ar minei besamim sheyesh bahem25:27 reiach tov. It says, if you don't have hadasim,25:29 then anything that smells good, you can make a25:32 berachah. However, the following you cannot make a25:34 berachah. What is that?25:44 תכשיט של זהובין שתולין הנשים בצווארן, הדדין, ומניחין בו בשמים שקורין קרנפול, אסור לברך עליו, דזה נקרא בשמים של ערווה. If a person has besamim that women used to25:47 wear, women used to wear before, I guess, deodorants before. Sprays and everything,25:53 women would have like this kind of like,25:55 basically like a keli, a vessel, a small little cup or a little jar,25:59 that they would put besamim inside of it,26:01 and then they'd wear it as a chain,26:03 and they would keep it on them, and that smells.26:05 That you're not allowed to make a bracha on it.26:07 Even if she takes it off, you're not allowed to make a bracha on it.26:09 That's called besamim shel26:13 aravah, which Shulchan Aruch talks about. That's asur to make a bracha on it.26:16 We'll discuss this in detail a little bit in just a minute.26:20 And he says,26:23 even if berach alav b'motzaei Shabbat, even if one goes ahead and does it by mistake,26:26 lo yatza yedei chovato, v'tzarich lachzor ulevarech al besamim26:29 kesharim. You're not yotzei yedei chovah, and you have to come back26:31 and make sure you find the proper besamim to make a bracha on.26:35 There are certain things that we're not allowed to make a bracha on it.26:38 Like we just saw, something called besamim shel26:41 aravah. What is besamim shel26:43 aravah? So like we said, Shulchan Aruch talks about besamim shel aravah, it's a Gemara,26:47 that you're not allowed to make a bracha on it.26:48 Why not? Says the Shulchan Aruch, you know why?26:51 Shema yavo lidei hirhur neshikah o kiruv basar.26:54 A person might come to kiss or come in contact,27:00 in physical contact with the woman.27:01 Meaning to say, if she's wearing something on her,27:04 she's wearing this jar that has a good smell,27:05 and now she's extending it to this man to smell it,27:09 he's making27:10 a bracha. He might come to grab her hand, he might come to touch her.27:14 So therefore, because of those reasons, it is forbidden.27:17 Even if one knows for sure that he's tied up and he's not going to do it,27:19 still, it's gezeirat hachachamim, it's forbidden for a person to make a bracha on those fragrances,27:26 okay? Other opinions27:29 explain, the Acharonim explain, there's another reason why besamim shel aravah is asur,27:33 because it might get the person to think about the27:35 ervah. Now this applies, by the way, this applies to any woman which is forbidden on the person,27:39 which means— Even any woman that's not a person's wife,27:46 even his wife in the time that she's27:48 nidah, because she's forbidden on a person,27:50 any fragrance that a woman is wearing,27:52 a person cannot make a bracha on it.27:54 Let's give a practical example.27:56 A person, the man is making havdalah motzaei Shabbat,27:59 and a woman—we'll talk about perfumes28:01 later—but let's say she has rose water.28:02 We all agree on rose water, you can make a28:04 bracha. A woman has rose water and she's28:06 nidah, but she has the rose water in the palm of her hand,28:09 or she's holding up the jar and she extends it to her husband to make a bracha on it,28:13 it's forbidden.28:14 Why?28:14 Because since his wife is28:17 nidah, the halacha says that that's called besamim shel28:20 ervah, and therefore you do not make a bracha on it while she's holding it.28:25 If she puts it down, here is a little bit of28:30 machloket. If she puts it down, so here it makes the following:28:33 everybody will agree if it's something that's not hers,28:35 that she's not usually wearing.28:36 For example, if she has a bottle of rose water28:38 and she puts it down,28:40 so everybody agrees that you could pick it up and make a bracha on it,28:42 Ashkenazim and28:44 Sefaradim. What about something that she usually wears on herself?28:47 Your wife is nidah now.28:49 While she's wearing it, she's holding it,28:50 you can't make a bracha on it.28:51 What about if she usually has it on her,28:53 but now she puts it down?28:54 Could you make a bracha on it?28:56 So according to the Ashkenazim, no.29:00 Since she's nidah, it might get you to think about it.29:02 Even if she's not holding it,29:03 you still can't make a29:04 bracha. However, according to the29:07 Sefaradim, you could make a bracha on it.29:08 You could still make a bracha on these besamim29:10 as long as she's not holding it.29:12 Even though she's nidah, it doesn't make a difference; it's mutar.29:14 By the way, this issur also applies to one's own daughter,29:18 because she's forbidden.29:19 If his daughter is holding also the besamim,29:23 also you have to be careful.29:24 So therefore, when you have your daughter holding up the besamim,29:26 make sure you take it from her29:28 in your hand to make the bracha on it,29:30 okay?29:31 That is one subject.29:33 From that, let's go on to another question29:36 that everybody asks,29:37 like we had the caller ask before:29:39 could a person make a bracha on perfumes?29:42 Or, you know what, let's use colognes,29:44 because perfumes,29:45 you come back to the same machloket, Ashkenazim,29:47 Sefardim. But let's use colognes.29:48 Colognes made for men29:49 has a very good smell.29:50 Can you make a bracha on it or not?29:53 Let's tell you,29:54 because we can't go into detail with this,29:56 we'll tell you in just very short.29:59 If the perfume,30:00 if you know that the cologne 100%30:02 is a cologne that's made from fragrances30:05 that usually smell very well,30:06 they just mix it all together,30:08 that means they took certain types of30:09 flowers and they didn't add anything else,30:12 then everybody agrees you can make a bracha on it,30:13 and the bracha will be minei besamim,30:16 okay?30:17 Since you don't know which things they put in it.30:18 However, most perfumes and most colognes are not that way.30:21 Most colognes have to go through a30:23 process where they mix many different things,30:25 some of them are chemicals,30:26 and sometimes these chemicals really smell bad,30:30 but because they do something to them,30:31 then it ends up smelling good.30:33 For that reason,30:35 Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and Rav30:36 Elyashiv hold that you cannot make a bracha on perfumes,30:41 even minei besamim,30:43 anytime. We're not talking about just for Havdalah.30:44 Anytime you can't make a30:45 bracha, even though it smells good,30:46 you can't make a bracha on it.30:47 That's the opinion of Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and Rav30:50 Elyashiv. However, Hacham Ovadia and Hacham Ben Zion both hold30:53 that you can, you could make a bracha on perfumes or on colognes.30:59 What will be the31:01 bracha? The bracha will be minei besamim,31:02 even if you know for a fact that they used a bad smell.31:08 That means they had something in the mixture of this cologne.31:11 You look at the ingredients31:12 and you see that one of the ingredients is something that smells horrible,31:15 but it went through a whole process,31:17 through chemical reaction or whatever it is,31:19 and now it smells very good.31:20 It doesn't make a difference.31:22 Hacham Ovadia explains why,31:24 and Hacham Ben Zion also pretty much says the same thing,31:26 and they hold that you could make a bracha of minei besamim on it.31:30 Now you should know,31:31 Hacham Ovadia, in a book, you might see it,31:34 Hacham Ovadia once upon a time used to hold31:36 that you cannot make a bracha on regular perfumes,31:39 like Rav Shlomo31:41 Zalman Auerbach. However, he retracted31:43 that halacha, and in his book31:44 Hazon Ovadia on31:47 Hilchot Berachot, he writes that one can, one could make a bracha on perfumes.31:51 But I just want to mention a small point,31:53 that his son Hacham David Yosef has a book, Halacha Berurah,31:57 where he rules, Hacham David rules,31:59 that one...32:00 He did not make a bracha on perfumes, on colognes.32:03 He cannot make a bracha,32:06 ... He says, Safek brachot lehakel, and he says that my father also agreed to me.32:08 So I don't know how to explain it.32:11 Did the Chacham Ovadia again retract? I don't know,32:13 but that's what he brings down.32:14 In any case, this is the halacha.32:17 Chacham Ben Tzion, Chacham Ovadia both write32:19 that you could make a bracha on colognes.32:22 You could make a bracha on it.32:24 You can make the bracha of minei besamim,32:26 the Ashkenazim, Rav32:27 Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, Rav Elyashiv, hold that you cannot make a bracha on it.32:31 Keep in mind, though, the following two points.32:35 Number one, in order to make a bracha on perfumes, on colognes,32:40 the Taz brings down that you have to be able to see it.32:43 If you spray yourself with cologne32:45 and then you rub your hands together,32:48 and then you look at your hands, you can't see anything.32:51 You can't see any liquid.32:52 Even though you might smell it and it smells very good and very strong,32:56 you do not make a bracha.32:58 That's called rei'ach she'ein lo shoresh.33:00 You must have some33:01 solid. The same will apply if you have an empty bottle of cologne33:05 and now you look inside, there's no more liquid,33:07 but it smells great.33:09 Or sometimes, you know, the cap of the perfume bottle,33:12 of the cologne bottle, smells very good,33:14 but there's nothing there.33:16 That's called rei'ach she'ein lo shoresh,33:18 and you cannot make a bracha on it33:19 according to all opinions, even33:21 Chacham Ovadia. You must be able to see something tangible.33:24 Same thing would be by rose water.33:25 If you have rose water in the palm of your hand,33:28 if you could see the rose water, you can make a bracha.33:30 If you cannot see the rose water33:31 because it was absorbed by your hands,33:34 then you cannot make a bracha according to all opinions.33:38 Another point to keep in mind33:40 is that in order to make a bracha on fragrances,33:43 on anything that smells good,33:47 it has to be a fragrance that's made in order to give off a good smell,33:52 as opposed to a fragrance that's made33:54 to get rid of a bad smell.33:56 I'll give you an example:33:57 Lysol. That's an air freshener.34:00 An air freshener smells good.34:02 You can get whatever smell you like.34:03 You can get, I don't know, vanilla,34:05 and they have whatever, I don't know,34:07 they have good smells, okay?34:09 So you have all these air fresheners,34:11 and they smell fantastic.34:12 They smell like lemon.34:13 It smells great.34:14 But they're not made in order to give off a good smell.34:17 They're made in order to get rid of bad smell.34:19 You use it in the bathroom,34:20 you use it in the kitchen,34:21 you use it when the kids make in the middle of the living room.34:24 That's what you use it for,34:26 to get rid of bad smell.34:27 So therefore, you don't make a bracha on air fresheners.34:29 The same thing will be by, you34:32 know, those fragrances that they put in bathrooms,34:33 like they put them in these bottles34:35 in order that the bathroom should smell good.34:38 So they smell very good.34:38 You cannot take that out and make a bracha on it34:40 because it's made in order to get rid of a bad smell.34:44 Another example will be deodorants.34:45 A lot of deodorants smell fantastic.34:47 They smell wonderful.34:48 They smell great.34:49 But deodorants are made in order to get rid of a bad smell.34:53 Since they're made to get rid of a bad smell,34:55 also these cannot be used34:59 on—these, you cannot use it to make a bracha on it.35:02 And for sure, obviously,35:03 you cannot use it for havdalah or motzaei Shabbat.35:06 So therefore, if you're stuck and you don't have anything,35:09 you don't have hadassim,35:11 you don't have cinnamon,35:11 you don't have35:12 rosewater, you don't have perfumes if you're35:14 Sefardi, you don't have anything to make a bracha35:15 besamim, what should you do?35:17 The answer is,35:18 you don't use deodorants,35:20 you don't use air fresheners,35:21 you just don't make a bracha besamim.35:23 Why not?35:23 What do you mean?35:24 It's part of the havdalah.35:25 Although besamim is part of the havdalah,35:27 but it's not35:28 me'akev, which means the havdalah still works35:30 even without using besamim.35:32 And just later on in the evening,35:34 whenever you find besamim,35:36 you make a bracha besamim.35:37 You could still go ahead with the bracha of35:41 besamim—I mean, you could still go ahead with the whole havdalah35:43 if you're not besamim.35:44 This happens, by the way, in shuls.35:46 I know this happened to us a few times35:49 until we decide to become smart about it35:51 and do something about it.35:52 But basically, we had a35:53 person that used to donate every single Motzaei Shabbat.35:56 He would bring before Shabbat, obviously,35:57 he would bring the35:59 hadasim, and that was his thing,36:00 that was his mitzvah.36:00 He would sponsor the hadasim for the shul36:02 Motzaei Shabbat. Everybody,36:03 you know, he goes and cuts it,36:05 everybody gets a branch from the36:07 hadasim, and that's how we'd make the havdalah.36:08 It happens sometimes,36:09 you know, especially in the winter,36:10 he was in a rush,36:11 he forgot about it completely,36:13 or there was no36:15 hadasim, so now the shul didn't have any36:16 hadasim. So what do we do?36:17 In that case,36:18 since we have nothing to make Atzei Besamim on,36:21 so therefore36:22 we don't make a bracha of Atzei Besamim.36:23 We continue,36:24 we go ahead with the havdalah.36:25 I would say the bracha of gefen,36:27 bracha on the light, on the fire,36:29 and then the bracha of havdalah,36:30 and then when you go home,36:31 you make your own bracha of besamim36:32 on cinnamon or whatever,36:34 something else that smells good.36:35 And that's important to keep in mind,36:37 that if you don't have besamim,36:38 you just don't make it.36:39 Don't go ahead and make the wrong bracha,36:40 but you will make it later on in the evening,36:42 but you only have Motzaei Shabbat36:43 to make a bracha on it.36:45 Once Motzaei Shabbat is over,36:46 you lost it.36:47 What does that mean,36:48 you lost it?36:49 It doesn't mean36:49 you could still make36:50 bracha on other binei besamim,36:52 but as far as the mitzvah of havdalah36:54 that you need it for Motzaei Shabbat,36:55 technically it only works on Motzaei Shabbat.36:58 That is up till now37:00 the halachot of besamim.37:02 I believe we covered it in full,37:04 and now we'll get37:06 to the halachot of havdalah,37:08 the fire for havdalah.37:10 That is halacha37:13 yud-bet until halacha37:16 tet-vav. I hope with the short amount of time that we have,37:17 we'll be able to cover it.37:18 So therefore,37:19 if you have any questions37:21 and you'd like to call in,37:22 the number is37:25 718-683-5858, although we recommend you call in37:27 after 337:28 o'clock. And if you have any comments37:30 you want to text in,37:31 you could text in at37:36 347-927-8398. Okay, let's get to Halacha37:40 Yud Bet. You know what?37:40 I'm not going to read it inside,37:42 and we say everything outside37:43 in order that we should cover37:45 everything that we need.37:46 The Gemara says37:47 that we make one of the37:49 berachot is Borei37:51 Me'orei Ha'esh. How come?37:51 So the Gemara says in Masechet Pesachim37:54 that Adam HaRishon37:55 had this fantastic idea on Motzaei Shabbat.37:57 What happened?37:57 Keep in mind,37:58 Adam HaRishon was the only one in the world,37:59 right? Him and38:01 Chava. And when he sinned on Erev Shabbat,38:03 Hashem felt bad for him,38:04 so He38:06 let—because Shabbat was38:08 coming—He allowed the sun to stay on38:11 throughout the whole duration of Shabbat,38:12 so there was no darkness38:13 throughout all of Shabbat.38:14 Once Shabbat was finishing,38:16 the sun was setting,38:18 all of a sudden38:18 it started to get darker38:19 and darker and38:19 darker till there was no light at all.38:21 Nothing.38:22 No, nothing.38:22 Can you imagine? The world was completely with darkness.38:24 Adam HaRishon thought,38:26 Oy, this is what Hashem meant38:28 when He told me,38:29 Don't eat from the tree,38:29 because the day you eat from it,38:31 you're going to die.38:32 I see the world has shut down,38:33 and now I'm going to die next.38:36 And then all of a sudden,38:37 Adam HaRishon got this wonderful idea.38:38 The Gemara tells us38:39 that Hashem put it in his head38:41 to take two stones38:42 and to knock them against each other,38:44 creating a fire.38:45 And that's how Adam HaRishon38:47 came to create fire.38:49 He didn't create fire;38:50 Hashem gave him the idea38:52 of bringing out fire38:53 by knocking two stones.38:54 When did that happen?38:55 Motzaei Shabbat.38:56 And therefore,38:57 in commemoration of the fire39:00 that was created on Motzaei Shabbat,39:02 every Motzaei Shabbat39:03 we come and we make a39:06 beracha on the fire.39:08 Now, this39:11 beracha—we'll talk about it more later39:13 on—this beracha is a39:15 beracha, there's a discussion39:16 if it's39:17 berachat ha-shevach or39:18 berachat ha-nehenin. You're not really making a beracha over here39:20 because the benefit of39:22 fire—it's not like the beracha you would make39:24 when a person is smelling something good.39:26 When you smell something good,39:27 anytime you smell something good,39:27 you make a beracha on it,39:29 just like eating.39:30 When you come to eat something,39:31 you make a blessing on it.39:32 It's not the same thing39:33 over here by the fire,39:34 because technically,39:35 if you're making a beracha on fire39:36 because you're benefiting from the fire,39:38 so anytime you see fire,39:39 anytime you benefit39:41 from the light of the fire...39:43 You should technically make39:45 it beracha. However,39:46 that's not the reason why we make it.39:47 We make it only in commemoration39:51 of this miracle,39:52 or not this miracle,39:53 but this idea that Hashem39:55 put in Adam Harishon's head,39:57 omatza eish Shabbat.39:58 Keep that in mind;39:58 it's going to be needed for later on.40:00 Before we come to talk about all what the fires need, what we need for the fire,40:04 you have to know that there are certain—not every fire is going to be mutar to make a bracha on it.40:11 Just because you see a flame doesn't mean you can just go ahead and make a bracha,40:16 borei me'orei ha'esh. Why? First of all, the fire itself cannot be fire that was lit40:22 b'issur. Any time the fire was lit b'issur, you cannot make a bracha on it.40:26 Let's give you a few examples. Let's say a Jew on Shabbat puts on a fire.40:31 He lights a candle. Why? Whatever, he puts it on because he wants to see better,40:36 and that candle stays lit till motzaei Shabbat. You cannot make a bracha on it now on motzaei Shabbat.40:41 Why? Since it was lit by a Jew on Shabbat, and that's asur.40:45 Another example is a goy who lights a candle even to give him light,40:52 but in order to celebrate his festivals, which are avodah zarah.40:55 For example, let's say on Xmas he has candles that are lit in his house41:00 because in honor of his holiday of Xmas or New41:03 Year's—that's clearly avodah zarah according to41:06 most Rishonim. Christianity is avodah zarah.41:07 So you are now—it happens to be Saturday night, motzaei Shabbat, and you need a light.41:11 You can't take that light from the41:14 goy. Why? Because that light was lit for the sake of avodah zarah, in honor of avodah zarah,41:20 and that's called the light that's lit41:23 b'issur. I'll tell you even more. Halacha brings down that if a goy on Shabbat lights a candle for himself,41:28 not for another Jew, for himself, he needs light, he puts on the candle,41:32 you cannot use that same light on motzaei Shabbat, since if you would have lit it on Shabbat,41:38 it would have been asur.41:39 You know what is mutar? If he lights it when halacha permits him to light it.41:45 For example, let's say you need a light, and, you know, we have electricity41:50 today, but let's say you don't have electricity and you need a light to be put on,41:54 and you ask the goy to put it on for a sick person or for children when it's mutar,41:59 whenever it's mutar. In that case, since the light was lit with permission.42:05 Then you can use it for the bracha on motzaei Shabbat.42:09 Okay, that is which lights you could use.42:11 Another point to keep in mind, and this is very important,42:15 because today we have electricity, and so this halacha in one way becomes42:19 easier, in one way becomes more difficult.42:22 You have to know that the light that you put on has to be for the purpose of providing light.42:29 Fire provides heat, and it provides also light.42:33 Even when it provides light, sometimes the light is not made to provide light;42:38 it's made just out of honor.42:39 I'll give you an example: a yahrzeit candle.42:42 Why do you light a yahrzeit candle?42:44 You think that because the soul of the dead is going to walk around42:48 and it's going to see better when you light the yahrzeit candle?42:50 Obviously not,42:51 but rather you're lighting the yahrzeit candle in honor of the deceased.42:55 So the yahrzeit candle is not coming to light up the night;42:58 it's coming for what? Just in honor.43:00 Another example: the nerot Chanukah, the lights that we light on43:05 Chanukah. You know, when we light the Chanukah, what do we say?43:07 We say,43:11 Ein lanu reshut lehishtamesh bahen, ela lirotan bilvad. We have no permission to have benefit from the lights of the menorah.43:16 We're just there to see. They're not made to light;43:18 they're just made for the sake of the mitzvah.43:20 Which would mean that on motzaei Shabbat,43:23 if a person wants to make a bracha on fire,43:27 which is bracha43:29 borei me'orei ha'esh, he can't just use any fire.43:30 You cannot use43:32 nerot Chanukah. You cannot use the candles of43:33 Chanukah. You cannot use a yahrzeit candle either,43:35 because a yahrzeit candle is made for an honor,43:37 and the nerot Chanukah are made for what?43:39 They're made for the sake of an honor,43:44 to honor the deceased.43:45 So therefore, those are out of the question.43:48 You cannot use it for the blessing of borei me'orei ha'esh on motzaei Shabbat.43:54 Another thing to keep in mind also,43:56 if the fire was lit not for the sake of providing light,44:00 but for the sake of what?44:03 For the sake of warming up.44:08 We all have stoves in our house.44:09 We all put on our stoves in order to cook.44:11 So you have your blech on,44:13 which is that metal sheet that's covering the44:16 stovetop, and now you want to go over to the blech,44:19 you want to look under,44:21 and you want to use the fire on the stove for the44:25 berachah of borei me'orei ha'esh. That is forbidden.44:27 Why?44:28 Because the fire that was lit on the stove44:30 was lit for the purpose of what?44:32 It was lit for the purpose of providing heat to cook.44:37 It was not lit in order to provide light.44:39 However, if you want, if you have no other choice, let's say,44:43 and you want to use the44:45 stovetop, you want to use your stove, the fire on the stove,44:47 for the sake of the44:51 berachah borei me'orei ha'esh, and you're lighting it now for that sake,44:53 that's mutar. That's fine.44:55 Good?44:56 The same thing would be, rabotai.44:58 Now this is going to be simple,45:00 but a fireplace,45:01 or let's say you're making a bonfire.45:03 You're away now in the mountains,45:04 it's45:05 summertime, and motzaei Shabbat they're making this big bonfire,45:08 and you miss45:09 havdalah. And when you made havdalah there was no candle,45:11 and now you see this big huge bonfire.45:14 And the bonfire, by the way, is usually made45:16 not to provide light.45:17 It's made so it can give a little bit of warmth.45:19 It makes a very nice mood around,45:22 or a fireplace in the winter,45:24 which is made to provide heat45:25 or to give a nice look in the house.45:28 All these, you cannot make a berachah on it,45:30 which is pashut to say now.45:32 Also cigarettes.45:33 If you see the fire on top of a cigarette,45:35 also you cannot make a berachah on a lit cigarette,45:40 even though it could provide you light,45:41 but the person who is lighting a cigarette45:44 is lighting in order to cut down on his life45:46 so he can smoke a little bit.45:47 That's why cigarettes are being lit.45:48 You should know,45:49 if a person does make a berachah on everything that we said45:51 where you cannot make a45:53 berachah, the berachah is not45:56 yotzei even45:57 b'diavad. Don't think that, oh, b'diavad it works.45:59 No, even b'diavad, the bracha doesn't work,46:04 okay? Now, everybody knows the following halacha. Halacha says46:07 that you need to have46:09 avukah. Avukah means a flame.46:11 You shouldn't, for46:13 borei me'orei ha'esh, you should—because we're saying46:15 me'orei, which is46:16 plural—you should have more than one flame.46:18 So although what we just told you above,46:20 you cannot use them for the bracha of46:23 borei me'orei ha'esh, but they can be used46:25 when you have a kosher candle46:27 and you want to just add this other candle.46:28 Let's say you have a yahrzeit candle46:29 and you have a regular candle.46:31 So you light your regular candle,46:32 now you want to join it together with the yahrzeit candle46:34 to make this double flame.46:36 That is mutar.46:37 We'll talk about the double flame soon anyway.46:39 That is46:40 halacha yud-vav. Let's go to46:41 halacha yud-gimel. And again, we're not going to go inside46:44 in46:45 halacha yud-gimel. In46:46 halacha yud-gimel, the Ben Ish Chai talks about cases46:48 where a person46:50 is—it's not so relevant in our46:52 days—but cases where46:54 lechatchilah you're not supposed to make a bracha on it.46:56 On a case somebody made a bracha on it,46:57 it will be mutar47:00 b'diavad. What is that?47:00 Let me just tell you very quickly.47:03 So today we have electricity47:03 that is not so common,47:04 but once upon a time, let's say,47:06 you know, the only light that you had is47:08 from these type of lights,47:09 you know, the ones that people lit in their own houses.47:12 So we said that a goy47:14 who lights on Shabbat,47:16 you cannot take from him,47:18 you cannot take the flame from him.47:20 But if you lit from his flame,47:22 mutar47:24 lechatchilah. However, if a goy goes and lights his candle47:27 from another goy,47:29 then you cannot use the second goy's light,47:34 even though it was lit only on Motzaei Shabbat.47:36 Why? It's47:36 gezeirah, you might come to use the first goy's light.47:38 A little complicated,47:39 and it's not so practical,47:40 so I'm not going to get into it,47:42 be'ezrat Hashem. You look at it in47:44 halacha yud-gimel. It's also brought down in47:46 Shulchan Aruch. Halacha yud-daled, very, very important.47:48 Halacha yud-daled. Talks about a very important47:52 halacha, and that is47:53 if the47:54 flame—it's wrote down really from the Yerushalmi,47:56 Maran Shulchan Aruch brings it down in סעיף ט״ו.48:00 If the flame is in a vessel, like in a lantern, you can't make the bracha on the48:05 borei me'orei ha'esh while it's inside the vessel, while it's in the lantern.48:09 You have to take it out.48:11 You need two conditions in order to be able to make a bracha on fire.48:16 Number one is that you must be able to see the fire directly without anything stopping48:23 in between.48:24 Number two is you need to be able to benefit from the light, the rays.48:30 You know, in fire there's also rays.48:32 Sometimes you don't see the sun.48:34 For example, we benefit from the sun, not directly, necessarily from directly from the sun,48:38 from the rays of the sun. It provides light.48:40 Let's say you're sitting in your house and you see that the sun is shining through your window.48:44 That's the rays of the sun coming in.48:46 Same thing by a flame.48:48 When you have a flame and you're just benefiting from the rays of the flame, that's not enough.48:53 You have to be able to see the flame as well as benefit from its rays.48:58 If you don't have these two conditions, you cannot make a bracha on it.49:00 So therefore, if you have something in a box, if you have a flame inside of a box and you49:05 only see the radiance, the light out of it, you cannot make a bracha.49:10 Same thing would be in the shul. The Ben Ish Chai brings down,49:12 let's say you're making bracha in shul, and now you're lighting the bracha in—excuse me,49:20 let's start again.49:20 Let's say you're in shul, and now that you're in shul, the person has the candle, the49:26 Havdalah candle, and you're sitting far enough that you're able to benefit from the rays, but you49:30 can't see the flame itself.49:32 There are too many people ahead of you.49:34 You're sitting in the back row and there's so many people in front of you, you can't49:36 see the person with the flame, but you see the rays of the—let's say they shut off the49:41 candles in shul, even though you don't have to, but let's say they shut off the lights49:43 in shul, and from the Havdalah candle you get the rays, you still cannot make a bracha.49:49 Even though it's there and you know it's there, but you don't see it.49:51 You have to be able to see the flame and benefit from the light.49:56 That is a very important halacha to keep in mind, which brings us now to electricity.50:02 Can a person make a bracha on electricity?50:05 Now, it's a known thing that two great Ashkenazi gedolim, at least two, used to make a bracha50:13 on electricity50:15 lechatchila. Who are these two great gedolim?50:17 Rav Chaim Ozer Grodzensky and Rav Chaim Soloveitchik, right, the Brisker Rav's father,50:24 Rav Chaim Brisk. They used to make a bracha on electricity, the bracha borei me'orei ha'esh. This way50:28 they wanted to make a point to show everybody that don't think electricity is mutar;50:35 it's asur de'oraita, it's regular fire.50:38 However, when we get to halacha lemaaseh, though, making bracha of borei me'orei ha'esh on50:44 electricity has a few problems with it.50:46 First of all, what's the problem?50:47 Number one is electricity is in a glass, right?50:50 That's how you're able to look at any electricity.50:52 The light is in a glass.50:54 So therefore, it's like we said beforehand. Since it's in the glass, it's covered.50:59 You don't see the flame directly.51:01 That should be a problem.51:02 Also, according to others, the fire that we have, the fire that we have in electricity51:08 is not 100% fire, although it's fire because of hav'arah, but the fire that we make on51:15 borei ha'esh is something that consumes. And maybe with the Chazal metaken, Chazal institute that we have to make a bracha on fire, it has to51:20 be fire like the meaning of fire, which means a fire that consumes, and electricity doesn't51:24 consume.51:25 Another problem is, like Rav Matzion explains, is that although when you initially51:32 start putting on the fire, you're putting your mav'ir, but the way the fire can—excuse me—the way the51:38 electricity continues to burn is by a new current coming every single moment afterwards.51:44 So maybe that doesn't work either.51:46 Also, the reason a lot of opinions explain that the bracha borei me'orei ha'esh, the lights of fire,51:54 is because fire has many different shades, many different colors.51:58 You look at the fire, sometimes there's a blue, there's a red, there's a yellow, there's52:02 orange. Not so when it comes to electricity; there's only one color.52:06 So because of all these reasons, a lot of poskim say do not make a bracha on52:12 electricity.52:13 In fact, if you're Sefardim, then it's assur to make a bracha on electricity52:17 or borei me'orei ha'esh, because we hold we're more machmir on safek brachot lehakel, and52:21 that's the opinion of52:22 Hacham Ovadia. You cannot make a bracha of borei me'orei ha'esh on motzaei Shabbat on electricity.52:27 That is52:28 halacha. If you have nothing else, you cannot make it on electricity.52:31 However, in the Ashkenazim, I saw Piskei Teshuvot, he brings a few opinions, some obviously some people52:37 more recent, the Machzeh Avraham, Safnat Paneach, the Rogatchover Rebbe. They hold that if there's52:43 nothing, nothing else, then relying on what we said above, meaning the opinion of52:48 Rav Chaim Ozer and Rav Chaim Soloveitchik, you could make a bracha on electricity when you have52:54 nothing else.52:55 Ah, you're telling me the problem, it's covered up in the case.52:57 So there are opinions who are matir if it's a clear case. But just make sure, though, that53:04 even those who are matir electricity for the Ashkenazim, only when there's no other choice,53:08 you need to make sure that it's not a fluorescent light. Also that the glass that's53:13 covering the electricity should be clear glass, like they have by light bulbs.53:16 Sometimes they have certain light bulbs where the electricity—excuse me—where the glass53:21 is, you know, it's white, it's not clear, like they have, you know, by the energy saver53:27 bulbs. It has to be clear glass.53:30 If it's not clear glass, even Ashkenazim do not permit this. So make sure it's only53:34 a clear glass, okay?53:37 Now, somebody wants to know, what about a person wearing glasses?53:42 Does a person wearing glasses have to take it off?53:45 And the answer is no, because glasses is not covering the fire. The fire is exposed. Your eyes are53:52 covered by the glasses, and not only that, if anything, the glasses enhance the way you53:57 see the fire. Without it, you might not be able to see so well.53:59 So therefore, for this and a few other reasons, it's brought down that you don't have to take54:03 off your glasses when you make the bracha of Boreh Me'orei HaEsh. Okay?54:09 This is an important halacha, and we ran out of time. I'm sorry, we don't have enough time54:13 to go over. We still have a few more halachot of how to look at your fingers when it comes54:18 to Birkat Boreh Me'orei HaEsh, but I believe we covered good enough54:23 for Zat Hashem. Anybody who has a question, you can call into the radio station right now. I'll54:27 be here for the next 15 minutes to answer any questions that you have, or you can text54:30 it in. The number to call in is 718-683-5858. Again, 718-683-5858. And if you want to54:40 text in any question or comment, the text line is54:47 347-927-8398. Until then, we'll see you next week, be'ezrat Hashem. We'll continue. Hopefully, we'll try to finish halachot54:51 by next week, halachot of Havdalah, before we get to Elul in two weeks away,54:56 be'ezrat Hashem. Have a wonderful week and a wonderful Shabbat. I'd like to give a thank you to J Radio55:00 and Iran for hosting us.55:03 Have a wonderful day.