Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio on Wednesday afternoon,0:04 here live at 2 to 3 p.m. If you0:08 would like to listen to us on the phone line,0:11 the phone number to the phone line is0:17 718-506-9099. That's0:18 if you would like to listen on the phone line. You could also hear us0:22 live as well on0:25 JRootRadio.com or on the JRoot Radio Pro app. The numbers0:29 to the station, if a person would like to call in to the Halacha Hour to ask questions0:34 regarding the subject of halacha that we're discussing, and we're in the middle0:37 of the laws of Motzaei Shabbat, the laws of the times of Motzaei Shabbat.0:42 We can talk about Havdalah, netilat yadayim today. The phone lines are0:46 open today, and the number is0:54 718-683-5858. And if you'd like to text in your question, and that's always the best,1:02 at 347-927-8398. Again, the phone numbers to call in, it's1:09 718-683-5858, and to text in your questions or comments at1:14 347-927-8398. And finally, to listen live,1:18 JRootRadio.com or1:23 718-506-9099. Today's class1:25 has been sponsored1:30 l'hatzlachat achenu Bnei Yisrael, especially the chayalim, the soldiers in Eretz Yisrael. Hashem1:34 should protect them. And regardless of what a1:38 person's political point of view is,1:41 lema'aseh, kol Eretz Yisrael is right now, as you heard1:45 throughout the broadcast on JRoot, what's going on in1:49 Eretz Yisrael. All of the Jewish people are in makom sakana. The missiles are flying1:54 everywhere, and the soldiers are going in, and these are our brothers1:58 and sisters, and these are our brothers, the soldiers going in, and right now they're2:01 in makom sakana, and therefore we dedicate this class. This chut of the2:05 Talmud Torah of this class, be'ezrat Hashem, should go to help them,2:10 to protect them, to give them siyata dishmaya and2:15 shemira. And to give them, be'ezrat Hashem, a normal life.2:17 Just a few words, maybe, to talk about what's going on in2:23 Eretz Yisrael. The Shlah brings down—the Shlah is2:25 Rabbi Horowitz from about four or five hundred years ago.2:29 He used to be the chief rabbi of Prague at one time. So the Shlah, in his book,2:34 Shnei Luchot HaBrit, he writes something very interesting. He says when it comes to the parashah,2:38 the Ashkenazim call it the sedra, sidra—we would say2:42 the Sefardim, sidra. He says, why is the parashah called the2:46 sidra? And he says an interesting point. He said because2:49 sidra is from the word seder, as we have on Leil Pesach, seder. Seder is like the2:54 word siddur, which is organized, systematic. Everything is in the system.2:58 That's why Leil Pesach, we call a seder, because we have3:02 about fifteen steps, and it's in order. First we3:06 make kiddush, then we wash our hands, and so on and so forth.3:10 Likewise, says the Shlah, that the parashah of the3:14 week is called the sidra. You know why? Because it contains3:18 in it the order of events in the world of that week.3:23 You always hear the rabbis in shuls, the rabbis of3:26 many congregations, they'll speak, they'll bring an idea from the parashah3:30 and relate it to an event, whether it's a simchah in the shul, a bar mitzvah,3:35 a bris, whatever it may be, or they'll relate it3:38 to the current events. And somehow, in some way, they always3:42 connect the parashah to the events of that week.3:46 And you wonder, is that just a coincidence? And the answer is no.3:50 If it falls out in that week's parashah, as the Shlah says, it's a3:55 sidra, it's a seder. The Torah contained in it that way. There is a way,3:59 yes, that you could see the events even before they happen from the4:02 sidra. So although we don't have the capability to be able to foresee things, at least4:06 not over here, but we could learn from the parashah4:10 things that we could take upon ourselves, things are within our hands,4:14 we have to learn. So. Once more, lasso, I'd like to point out4:18 from this week's parashah, Pinchas, and also from the end of last week's4:22 parashah, because those who know the parashah know that the parashah4:27 Pinchas, the beginning of the parashah, is really a4:30 continuation from the end of last week's parashah, Parashat Balak. In the end of last week's parashah,4:35 we find that the Jewish people were in grave danger.4:39 Many people were dying. Besides the plague4:42 that Hashem brought upon the Jewish people, or excuse me, besides the executions4:46 that Hashem brought upon the Jewish people for worshiping Baal Peor,4:50 for going with the Midian, going with the non-Jewish women, there was also4:54 the plague that took place specifically amongst the shevet of Shimon,4:58 the tribe of Shimon, because of the act of5:02 Zimri and Kozbi bat Tzur. And until Pinchas stepped up5:06 and he took action to try to put an end to the aveirah that was amongst the Jewish people,5:12 only then do we find the Torah telling us that the plague stopped.5:16 In this week's parashah, the Torah tells us5:19 that Hashem gives an award to5:23 Pinchas. You are a man of shalom, Pinchas. You brought peace between me5:27 and the Jewish people, because now I stopped. I was about to wipe out,5:31 as the Torah says, I was about to wipe out all the Jewish people, but you took5:35 an action and you stopped the aveirah, and therefore you brought5:39 an end to this plague. So what we could learn from this for ourselves5:43 is that keep in mind, we all pray for the welfare5:47 of the Jewish people all over the world, specifically in Eretz Yisrael, and we're all5:51 behind them, and we are learning in their zechut, and we're praying for them.5:55 But we have to look at what we personally can do for ourselves.6:00 Obviously, Hashem is sending a message. We shouldn't lose sight6:03 right now of why Hashem is sending the Palestinians,6:08 or why Hashem is sending these rockets flying into us.6:11 Why are these things happening? We cannot decide why this is happening to6:16 another person, but if it affects us and affects each one of us,6:20 it bothers us, we're worried, and We're not comfortable6:23 with the situation, then Hashem is also speaking to us, not just to the people in6:28 Eretz Yisrael. And the people in Eretz Yisrael have to figure out for themselves, but for ourselves,6:31 we have to look into ourselves and to see what we can fix,6:36 what we can do. And you might say, What am I? What do I have to do? I don't even live in6:40 Eretz Yisrael. I'm here, and I'm so far away, and how much could I do?6:43 In the parashah, it was one man who stopped the whole plague. You don't know who that one person may be,6:48 that one man or one woman who feels that I could do better.6:52 I could fix something. I could become close to Hashem.6:56 I could stop something that's distancing me from Hashem,7:00 whether it's an aveirah or something that's not on my level. And that person7:04 could bring an end to a lot of suffering, not just for himself,7:08 but for all the Jewish people. And that's the small idea that we could derive7:12 out of this. We shouldn't lose sight of what's going on7:17 from the ruchaniut point of view. The hashkafah, the proper hashkafah,7:20 is always to look inwards, to see what we could do, to see what Hashem7:23 is trying to relate to me, myself, not to preach to others, but to myself.7:27 How much could I do? What do I need to do in order, if Hashem is7:31 doing this and it's affecting me, what could I do about it?7:36 With that, we'll move on. But before we move on to really what we do,7:40 we want to announce that this7:44 next coming up next Tuesday, next Tuesday,7:47 I think it's the 15th of July. I'm not sure exactly on the English date, but I'll tell you what7:52 next Tuesday in the Hebrew date is. It's Yud Zayin Tammuz, which means,7:55 rabotai, we have a fast. It's going to be a Yom7:58 Ta'anit, the ta'anit...8:00 Yud Zayin B'Tammuz, that's the time when the Goyim infiltrated the city of Yerushalayim,8:07 and they broke through the walls of Yerushalayim, the times of the Second Beit HaMikdash,8:11 and therefore we have a fast. The halachot of the fast,8:16 Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll put on the recordings from last year. In a few weeks coming up, we'll8:21 talk about all the halachot pertaining to Yud Zayin B'Tammuz — not necessarily8:26 Yud Zayin B'Tammuz, but the three weeks, Rosh Chodesh Av, Shavua shechal bo, as well as8:31 Tisha B'Av — that will all be discussed, Be'ezrat Hashem, later on. But for now, what we have to know is8:35 there's a fast this Tuesday morning, this Tuesday beginning from the morning.8:38 4:09 a.m. is the latest time. Some people have earlier times; you look in your own calendar8:45 for the Sefaradim. This is the way we follow over here. 4:09 a.m. is the beginning of the fast,8:51 and the fast finishes at around 9 o'clock to 9:15. You'll decide for yourselves.8:58 If you heard the class from last week where we discussed sheki'ah and9:03 seta kochavim, you get an idea exactly how to figure it out. Sheki'ah, sunset, is at 8:25 on Tuesday,9:10 which means about 35 minutes to nearly maybe 50 — some people want to do 50 minutes,9:17 whatever they like — is the conclusion of the fast. So from 9 to 9:15, it's good enough9:25 already for a person to be fasting until then, and it begins the three-week period,9:29 the weeks known as Bein HaMetzarim, which means no more music. No more music means to say no more music with instruments,9:38 no more parties, no more dancing. For these three weeks, we don't have any of those9:44 because we are mourning the destruction of Yerushalayim and the Beit HaMikdash.9:50 And as is brought down by Sefarim, although some say from the beginning of Rosh Chodesh Tammuz,9:54 but certainly from the time of Shiva Asar B'Tammuz, a person must be very, very careful,10:00 as the Sefarim, the poskim bring it down, that there's— Things are, we need extra protection from ourselves. We don't10:07 have so much shemirah in that time, and therefore one should take a lot of caution doing whatever10:12 activities he wants or he/she wants to do in these three weeks. Laws, that's just a small10:18 announcement about the fast next week. We come back now to the halachot that we're discussing.10:23 Here we're up to the parashah in Bein HaMetzarim. This is a class mainly on the10:30 Bein HaMetzarim, and the parashah that we're learning right now is the parashah of Vayetze, and the halachot are10:35 like the name Vayetze, which means to go out. The Bein HaMetzarim talks about10:40 motzaei Shabbat. The laws of when Shabbat is yotzei, when Shabbat leaves us. And last week we spent pretty much10:46 the whole class talking about one point, and that is what time is Shabbat over. And we discussed the10:53 opinions of how to calculate what time is nighttime, what's the different opinions, how to relate10:59 it to ourselves, what's the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam, how people are holding11:04 and they're saying this is Rabbeinu Tam, and so on and so forth. We discussed all of that last11:08 week. We're not going to go through it again, but there were questions that I wasn't able to get to,11:13 some through a text line, some people called in, and also there were some points that myself,11:18 that I had in my notes that I wasn't able to get to because the class was over. We just ran out of11:22 time. So let's go back over a few points and let's begin. The first point we mentioned last11:28 week, that in times of emergencies, we mentioned the case of Onen, a person is allowed to11:34 pray Arvit before shekiah. This is only applicable to Sefardim, not to Ashkenazim, but to11:41 Sefardim, because Ashkenazim never pray Arvit before shekiah. But even then, the halacha says that Arvit is11:46 supposed to be, you could only pray, motzaei Shabbat is supposed to pray Arvit very late,11:50 even though technically throughout the week you pray Arvit after shekiah, after sunset.11:55 When it comes to Shabbat, you're supposed to delay until the time that you're ready to finish Shabbat12:00 or close to it. That's lechatchila, that's when you're supposed to pray Arvit. If it's very, very important,12:06 even Ashkenazim could pray from the beginning already, right after Shekiah, they could pray if12:10 it's very, very necessary. Sefaradim could even pray from plag hamincha. Now, this is a very important12:15 point that we didn't mention and have to point it out, and that is the old law: a person could12:20 pray Arvit, and technically he could even do havdalah when it's necessary, as we gave the12:25 examples last week. Shabbat is not over. You could say havdalah and you could pray Arvit, but that's12:31 for the mitzvah of Arvit and the mitzvah of havdalah. But it doesn't mean Shabbat is over, which means12:35 you cannot go and do any melacha that you want. There is a time when Shabbat is over. Whatever you12:41 hold, if you hold that Shabbat is over 40 minutes or 50 minutes after shekiah, after sunset,12:48 then although you prayed Arvit earlier, you still cannot do any melacha or even12:57 nissur derabbanan until the time that Shabbat is over, which is 40 or 50 minutes, or Rabbeinu Tam, 7213:04 minutes, whatever you hold. This happened to us one time. It wasn't a case of onen, but if you remember,13:09 before Hurricane Sandy, there was a hurricane before that, the year before that,13:13 that was called Hurricane Irene. And at the time, we didn't know, nobody knew what was going to happen,13:18 and everybody was scared that things, you know, a lot of problems, flooding and things. And at the time13:23 we were praying in the shul that was closer to the beach, and we were worried that if, you know,13:27 the storm was supposed to hit, I think it was supposed to hit by Shabbat afternoon, going13:32 into Motzaei Shabbat, and we were worried that if we have Mincha Arvit regular time, it might be too late,13:37 it might be too windy, it might be too dangerous. So therefore, we announced that we're going to pray13:42 an early Arvit. We're going to pray Mincha and right away have Arvit right afterwards, and everybody13:47 go home afterwards. At least you prayed with a minyan. It was an emergency situation, but we13:53 announce, and like we're saying right now, Shabbat is not over until the time is over, rabotai. If you hold14:00 40 minutes, 50 minutes, or 72 minutes, whenever you hold Shabbat is over, you have to wait until14:04 that time to be able to do any melacha or even an issur derabbanan. Another point to keep in mind,14:11 and this is applicable all the time, especially for men, not especially, only for men,14:16 and that is Kriat Shema. Kriat Shema, sometimes even if you have to pray earlier, this is now14:23 a rule for Shabbat, but it's really a rule also for Shabbat and even throughout the weekdays,14:27 especially in the summer. A person who is praying Arvit before set hakochavim, and again,14:32 set hakochavim is defined, whatever your rabbi or your community holds that set hakochavim is. If you pray14:38 Arvit earlier, most people do that in the weekday, or even Friday night, even Ashkenazim Friday night14:44 pray Arvit early, you have to keep in mind that you still did not fulfill the obligation of14:49 Kriat Shema. Kriat Shema is a mitzvah de'oraita, and according to 99% of the poskim, a person is obligated to14:57 say Kriat Shema after set hakochavim, and that's a psak in Shulchan Aruch, and Banah doesn't bring15:02 any arguments in Shulchan Aruch. So therefore, even though you prayed earlier Kriat Shema,15:07 even though you said Kriat Shema in shul, if you prayed Arvit earlier and therefore you said15:13 Kriat Shema before set hakochavim, you have to keep in mind that you still have to repeat Kriat Shema when you get home.15:19 This is for Friday night, this is for Motzaei Shabbat, this is for any time of the week that15:23 you pray Arvit earlier than set hakochavim. Now here's a question. We mentioned last week the15:29 different times, and we explained where the 72 minutes come from. That's the opinion of Rabbeinu15:34 Tam. Question is, somebody asked, we find also that there's times like 96 minutes, and we mentioned15:40 that as well, that Rav Moshe Feinstein says that those who want to wait and want to be machmir up to 9615:46 minutes, where do we get 96 minutes from? We explained that the Gemara explains from15:53 sheki'ah until set hakochavim, from sunset until the stars come out, according to the longest opinion, the—16:00 Most stringent opinion, it says that there is a distance of four milin,16:04 and the Gemara explains that four milin,16:07 and according to Shulchan Aruch, it takes a person about 18 minutes,16:12 exactly 18 minutes, to walk one mil. And four times 18 is 72 minutes.16:18 So where in the world did we get 96 minutes from?16:21 And the answer is, although we mentioned that a mil is only 18 minutes,16:26 there are opinions like the Rambam or the Gra who hold that a mil is 24 minutes,16:32 and that's based on the calculation of how do you count the day.16:37 When is considered the beginning of the day, and when is it considered the end of the day?16:41 Is the beginning of the day from the time that sun rises until the sun sets,16:45 which means zerichah, netz hachamah until shekiah?16:49 Or is the beginning of the day really from alot16:52 hashachar, which is earlier than netz hachamah, which is dawn,16:56 until set hakochavim, which is after shekiah?17:00 If you hold that the beginning of the day is from sunrise until sunset,17:05 then it comes out that each mil will be 24 minutes,17:09 not 18, will be 24 minutes.17:11 So according to this opinion, which is the Rambam, the17:15 Gra, that the mil is really 24 minutes, so now if you do 24 times 4,17:20 because remember the Gemara says four mil, it doesn't tell me a time,17:24 it just tells me a distance.17:26 And according to those opinions that hold17:29 that it takes an average person to walk one mil,17:36 it takes him 24 minutes to walk one mil,17:38 so it comes out that four milin from the sunset until17:43 set hakochavim, according to them, will be 96 minutes.17:47 Another question that was asked. And that is,17:51 we find that the concept of time in halacha is always17:56 shaot zmaniyot. For example, we mentioned this in the past,17:59 Kriat Shema in the morning.18:00 One has to read Kriat Shema within three hours of the morning.18:03 What does that mean, the morning?18:05 And we said the morning is, like we said right now,18:07 the morning, let's say according to the opinion that says18:09 from the time of sunrise.18:11 Now, how do you calculate these three hours?18:13 It's not regular three hours that we know of 60 minutes,18:16 where each minute is 60 seconds.18:18 No.18:19 The three hours that the Gemara talks on,18:21 the halacha talks about,18:22 is referring to18:26 shaot zmaniyot, which varies. The hours will be shorter in the winter18:31 and longer in the summer.18:32 That's called18:34 shaot zmaniyot, or what I'd like to call halachic hours.18:37 So the question is, when we say that a person has to wait18:41 motzaei Shabbat 72 minutes for Rabbeinu Tam,18:44 does that have to be shaot zmaniyot or not?18:46 Because Rabbeinu Tam was talking about18:48 four milin, and four milin we just explained18:50 equals 72 minutes. But is that shaot zmaniyot or not?18:52 And the answer to that question is18:54 the Biur Halacha brings a machloket18:56 between the Minchat Kohen and the Pri Megadim.18:59 According to the Pri Megadim,19:02 72 minutes after shkia is the time of Rabbeinu Tam.19:05 And these 72 minutes are regular 72 minutes of 60 seconds each.19:10 According to the Minchat Kohen, he says no.19:12 These 72 minutes are only in the times of the spring or the fall,19:18 around Tishrei and Nisan,19:20 where the hour that we know of 60 minutes and 60 seconds per minute19:25 is equal to the halachic hour, is equal to19:27 shaot zmaniyot. That's what we call19:30 shaot shavot. But in the summer, the 72 minutes will be longer,19:34 and in the winter will be shorter.19:36 That's according to the opinion of the Minchat Kohen.19:38 And the Biur Halacha says that that's the opinion also of the19:41 Magen Avraham and the Gra as well, that you do it shaot zmaniyot, you have to wait.19:45 However, the Biur Halacha himself,19:46 which is the Chafetz Chaim, the19:48 Mishnah Berurah, concludes that you're going to have to be so19:50 machmir. You want to be machmir 72 minutes,19:52 but you don't have to be so machmir to do it19:54 shaot zmaniyot. 72 minutes by itself is good enough.19:57 And however, if you look in20:00 Chacham Ovadia, in Shut Yabia Omer, chelek bet,20:02 as well as in the20:04 Siddur Havei Da'at, he quotes him that way as well.20:05 As well, in other places20:06 you find that Chacham Ovadia seems to say,20:09 or he says it,20:10 that20:11 shaot zmaniyot, that 72 minutes will be longer in the summer.20:14 Even those who want to wait Rabbeinu Tam in the summer20:16 should wait 72 minutes20:19 shaot zmaniyot. And that's the way I always understood it.20:21 Just recently, I saw20:23 there's a Mishnah Berurah called Ish20:27 Matzliach Mishnah Berurah, which is the notes from the yeshiva of20:31 Kisei Rachamim, which is headed by a huge talmid chacham in our days.20:33 His name is Rabbi Meir20:35 Mazuz shlita, a big, big20:38 talmid chacham. That's beyond that we could explain.20:41 There's no question,20:41 he's a big, big talmid chacham and a big posek.20:44 Chacham Ovadia also held of him very, very, very highly.20:47 He has in that20:48 Mishnah Berurah, the Ish20:50 Matzliach, in the back he has a20:51 kuntres that he personally wrote.20:53 It's called20:56 Kuntres Bein Hashemashot, and over there towards the end20:57 he writes that he was speaking to somebody21:00 who was very close to21:02 Chacham Ovadia, and he writes that Chacham Ovadia says21:04 that it's okay if a person doesn't want to be21:07 machmir to wait the 72 minutes21:10 sha'ot zmaniyot. If a person wants to wait just regular 72 minutes,21:12 it's fine.21:13 That's what it says over there.21:14 So although Chacham Ovadia writes it21:16 in Yabia21:16 Omer that you have to wait21:18 sha'ot zmaniyot, the 72 minutes you have to wait,21:21 sha'ot zmaniyot, but Meir Mazuz says that21:23 somebody who spoke to Chacham Ovadia, Chacham Ovadia says21:25 it's okay if a person is not so21:27 makpid, is not so careful to wait21:29 sha'ot zmaniyot, 72 minutes is still good enough.21:31 Okay,21:31 another question we got through the text,21:34 and that is:21:35 could you connect what was said to the calendar?21:38 Basically, I'm assuming21:39 that the person who's asking this question21:41 wants to know21:42 all the things that we spoke about,21:44 sunset and Rabbeinu Tam and all these things,21:47 can I connect it to the calendar?21:49 Meaning to say,21:50 look at the calendar and show us21:52 how exactly,21:53 what do these times mean on the calendar?21:55 So really, the calendar itself,21:58 to be able to tell the zmanim on the calendar,22:00 be'ezrat Hashem we hope to work on a video22:02 and a full class on it22:04 to explain every detail on the calendar,22:05 because it can be very confusing22:06 for a person who doesn't know,22:08 especially ladies,22:09 you know, they look at the22:10 calendar and they don't understand22:11 what does it mean22:12 sof zman, who decided this should be the time22:13 and why is it,22:14 and what does it mean22:16 alot hashachar and22:18 plag hamincha? It can be very complicated,22:19 but we'll just explain very quickly.22:20 If you look at the calendar,22:22 most calendars will have a—22:23 not most calendars,22:24 every single calendar will tell you22:26 when sunset is for every single day,22:28 okay?22:29 So if you look at Shabbat, for Saturday,22:32 on Shabbat on the calendar22:33 you'll find whatever time it says.22:34 Let's go with last week's calendar.22:36 It's been the same time22:37 for about a few weeks in the summer.22:39 The latest sunset that we get here in New York...22:43 Is22:45 8:30 p.m. That is sunset, that is22:48 sheki'ah. From that point,22:49 right after,22:49 right when it gets to22:52 8:30, according to the opinions that hold22:55 that Ben HaShmashot begins right away,22:57 which is the Gra and the23:00 Geonim, so that is when Ben HaShmashot begins.23:03 How much time after is Shabbat over?23:04 So according to those opinions,23:06 they hold 13 and a half minutes.23:07 And again, where is it applicable?23:09 Like we said,23:10 nobody does 13 and a half minutes;23:11 they do even longer than that.23:12 But that's when Ben HaShmashot begins23:14 until23:16 tzeit hakochavim, whatever time you want to define later on.23:17 But if you hold like Rabbeinu Tam,23:20 so then motzaei Shabbat will be23:23 around—not around,23:24 it will be 72 minutes later.23:25 Which means,23:26 if 8:30 was sheki'ah, sunset,23:29 it means that for you23:31 motzaei Shabbat,23:32 if you want to go like Rabbeinu Tam,23:33 it will be23:37 9:42. 8:30 sunset,23:38 it means that23:40 9:42 will be motzaei Shabbat23:41 according to Rabbeinu Tam.23:43 That's the way you can figure out23:44 from the calendar.23:45 Now sometimes you'll see in the calendar23:46 they write motzaei Shabbat at a different time,23:48 and you'll figure out.23:49 You just do the math backwards.23:51 See when sunset is,23:52 and see how many minutes they added,23:54 and you'll know.23:54 Whoever set up the calendar,23:56 you'll know how they decided23:57 when Shabbat will be over:23:58 40 minutes, 50 minutes, some...24:02 All right, a little bit more than that. Each one has its own ways, so you'll have to figure it out on your own.24:06 Sometimes the calendar will say three stars,24:09 seta kochavim. That's not necessarily Rabbeinu Tam.24:11 Again, that's the time that whoever wrote the calendar decided when24:16 seta kochavim is for every day and for Motzaei Shabbat as well.24:20 So you'll have to see if it's something of your custom,24:22 if your community follows such a thing.24:25 L'mashal, most Chassidim in America, here in America, will go like Rabbeinu Tam,24:29 which means they will not finish Shabbat until 72 minutes later.24:34 However, in Eretz Yisrael, many, many24:37 Chassidim—I'm not talking about individuals, I'm talking about communities,24:39 talking about24:42 Belz, I'm talking about also the Ger24:44 Chassidim. These are the biggest Chassidim in Eretz Yisrael.24:47 Ger Chassidim, all of them, none of them hold like Rabbeinu Tam.24:49 They don't finish Shabbat 72 minutes afterwards.24:53 They finish early. I forgot exactly what the24:54 time—I know Belz is 50.24:55 Ger could be 40 to 50 minutes as well.24:58 I'm not sure exactly,24:59 but the idea is that each community, depends what your community follows,25:03 you'll follow by that.25:05 So here's the question now.25:06 The question is for the Sefardim now,25:09 somebody asked, well, this is not our minhag.25:12 Is this our minhag to follow 72 minutes ago with 72 minutes of Rabbeinu Tam?25:16 So let me explain something very, very important.25:20 Rabbeinu Tam's opinion is the way to explain the Gemara.25:23 Shulchan Aruch also went with Rabbeinu Tam as well.25:28 He also explained that motzaei Shabbat is like the way Rabbeinu Tam says,25:32 which is 72 minutes later.25:34 True, we said yes last week that the minhag of the25:39 Sefardim, like the way the Chida brings down,25:41 like the way the Ben Ish Chai brings down, and like the way others bring down,25:43 is not to go with Rabbeinu Tam.25:45 That's the way they were noheg.25:47 But it doesn't mean that whoever wants to be noheg like Rabbeinu Tam25:51 is doing anything, chas v'shalom, like he's considered baal25:55 gaavah or is doing yohara.25:56 It's—he's out of place.25:58 And chas v'shalom that you should say,26:00 Oh, he's too stringent, he's too much.26:02 No. A person wants to keep Rabbeinu Tam,26:04 he's going like the psak of26:06 Shulchan Aruch and like the psak of many, many Rishonim.26:09 As well as Hacham Ovadia himself,26:12 the gadol hador from the last generation,26:15 the posek for most people followed,26:17 he also holds 72 minutes as well.26:19 And if you'd like to see,26:21 it's even Gadol looking at Biur Halacha where he brings down26:24 that even Rabbanim26:27 like the26:28 Rabban Fandri, who used to be the chief rabbi of Turkey26:31 as well in Izmir, I believe,26:33 also Rabbi Lanyado from Aleppo in Syria,26:36 also they tried to institute through a cherem even26:40 that people should go and wait 72 minutes and sit in darkness.26:44 Remember, back then there was no electricity.26:46 They sit in darkness until 72 minutes later26:48 when Shabbat is over.26:51 So many, many gedolim throughout the generations26:53 tried to do this, tried to institute26:55 that their kehillot should follow Rabbeinu Tam.26:56 True, the minhag was not accepted that way by the people;26:59 perhaps it was too much for them.27:01 But don't be27:02 an am haaretz when you see somebody holding like Rabbeinu Tam27:04 and yell at him and say,27:05 Ah, you're too machmir, you're too stringent.27:08 What are you doing? It's not our way.27:09 If you say that, then you're going to sound really ridiculous.27:12 So make sure you don't say that.27:14 Make sure that you follow what we said27:16 and you understand that Rabbeinu Tam's opinion27:18 is really27:20 lechatchila. Everybody will tell you27:21 lechatchila, if you can, 100 percent, you should follow Rabbeinu Tam27:24 and not the other way.27:25 And it's not a yohara27:28 if you're going with the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam.27:30 One last question before we come into last27:34 halacha, and that is: how does a person jump into Rabbeinu Tam?27:37 How do you go onto Rabbeinu Tam?27:38 It's very hard. Seventy-two minutes is very hard.27:40 So I saw someone, I know a person27:43 who learned the27:44 sugya, who learned the opinions,27:45 and he saw the importance of waiting longer,27:48 and therefore I saw that what he's doing so far,27:50 he waits.27:51 Meaning, you have to kind of,27:53 you know, just recently I had a meeting... For Tu B'Shvat in the yeshiva,28:00 and basically everybody knows the story.28:02 Every year Tu B'Shvat goes up,28:04 Baruch Hashem, they're educating our children.28:06 And I sat down in the meeting,28:08 and he showed me the number that they're asking.28:10 He showed me the number that I was paying this past year.28:12 He said, Our goal is to get as much as we can28:15 from what you're paying last year28:18 to what we're asking for.28:20 How much could you do?28:21 And that's what he told you, the same thing.28:22 How long do you wait till Shabbat is over?28:25 Forty minutes, thirty-five minutes,28:27 whatever you wait.28:27 If you wait forty-five minutes,28:29 let's say you wait forty minutes,28:31 and you would like to keep seventy-two minutes,28:32 or you have between forty and seventy-two minutes,28:35 try to keep as much as you can past forty minutes.28:38 You could do forty-two minutes,28:40 hazaku baruch, do forty-two minutes.28:41 And year by year, slowly, slowly,28:44 even every once in a while,28:46 every few years if you'd like,28:47 add a few minutes,28:48 add another two minutes,28:49 another two minutes.28:50 You'll see, it just takes time to get used to.28:53 It's really not difficult at all.28:55 Besides, anyway, by the time28:56 anyway you most probably28:58 will end up shul28:59 anyway, you'll end up finishing from shul that late.29:02 So take it slowly, a few minutes,29:05 add a few minutes once in a few years,29:08 and be'ezrat Hashem you'll see you might even,29:09 you don't have to go past seventy-two minutes,29:10 but you'll see that in a few years already29:13 you'll be holding29:15 Rabbeinu Tam, and you'll be comfortable with it.29:16 You'll like it as well.29:18 With that, we move on now29:20 to29:21 Halacha Bet, and now we move on to halachot of havdalah.29:26 Ben Ish Chai brings down over here29:28 from Halacha Bet until29:32 Halacha Zayin the laws of havdalah during tefillah.29:35 So let's begin, first of all.29:37 Why should we begin outside?29:39 He says it right here inside.29:41 Says the29:43 Ben Ish Chai, Leharambam, according to the opinion of the Rambam,29:45 mitzvat aseh min haTorah lekadesh29:48 et Shabbat bidvarim b'bi'ato. There's a mitzvat aseh from the Torah29:51 for a person to be mekadesh29:54 Shabbat even when it comes out.29:55 We all know Kiddush when Shabbat comes in.29:57 It says in the Torah,29:57 Zachor et yom haShabbat29:59 lekadsho. We spoke about this in halachot Kiddush,30:01 that a person has to make the day of Shabbat special.30:04 How do you do so?30:05 When it comes in, you make it special.30:07 You designate it. You say, you pronounce.30:09 As Chazal tell us,30:11 the word zachor means you speak it out.30:13 You express it verbally and you say30:15 Shabbat is kodesh,30:16 and we do so on a cup of wine.30:18 That's what we know as kiddush.30:19 Motzaei Shabbat, when Shabbat is leaving,30:22 we also have to verbally express30:25 that Shabbat is leaving30:26 and the kedushah has left us.30:29 And according to the Rambam,30:30 that's a mitzvah mide'oraita as well.30:31 So that's what we do when we say Havdalah.30:34 According to the Rambam,30:35 the Havdalah that we say is30:37 de'oraita. Other poskim hold30:40 derabbanan, but according to him it's30:42 de'oraita. And how does one do so?30:44 Just by pointing out30:46 that what just happened right now,30:48 up till now was Shabbat,30:49 it was kodesh,30:51 and now from this point onwards30:53 it became30:54 chol. That is the30:57 mitzvah mide'oraita according to the Rambam.30:58 That's how he fulfills zachor et yom haShabbat31:00 when it comes in with kiddush31:01 and when Shabbat leaves, with Havdalah.31:05 However, Chazal instituted31:08 that you should do so31:10 with a cup of wine as well.31:13 And that's the famous Havdalah that we know,31:15 when we sit with a cup of wine,31:17 and those halachot will be discussed later on,31:19 not this week.31:20 But for now, the Havdalah in tefillah,31:23 Chazal instituted that in our prayer,31:26 when we're praying Arvit and Motzaei Shabbat,31:28 we should include, we should say31:30 the words of Havdalah,31:32 and that is done through a small prayer31:34 known as31:36 Atah chonantanu. And Atah chonantanu, you notice,31:38 even if you don't understand Hebrew,31:39 you'll pay attention to the translation,31:41 you'll see31:41 that Atah chonantanu means,31:43 basically you're saying,31:44 Hashem, You gave us intelligence,31:46 and You gave us the ability31:48 to be able31:53 to understand the difference,31:55 intelligence to be able to understand the difference31:57 between two different things, and that—32:00 That is the concept of havdalah, and that is placed in our tefillah. Where? In the first32:06 berachah, right? Not in the first berachah of the Amidah, but the first berachah of our request,32:11 Atah chonen l'adam da'at. Why in that berachah? And the answer is because32:17 Atah chonen l'adam da'at, we're asking HaKadosh Baruch Hu for intelligence.32:20 First we express our thanks to HaKadosh Baruch Hu that we're able to32:25 understand, and then we ask HaKadosh Baruch Hu to basically separate us also from any bad things that are happening in the world,32:33 and that's why it was instituted over there.32:35 Now, the halachah says something very, very important.32:38 You must make havdalah in tefillah. That is very, very important.32:42 Even though you're going to make havdalah later on, you still must say32:47 Atah chonen... But if a person forgot to say Atah chonen, the halachah says that you don't have to repeat the Amidah.32:54 Why not? If a person forgets Ya'aleh Veyavo, you have to repeat it.32:57 If a person forgets something that needs to be added in Amidah, you have to repeat it.33:00 How come over here, if you forget Atah chonen, you don't have to repeat it?33:03 And the answer is because we know you're going to make havdalah later on.33:06 So yes, the halachah is supposed to say Atah chonen; it's a must.33:09 But even if you didn't say Atah chonen, since you're going to make havdalah afterwards33:13 on the cup of wine, the famous havdalah that we do with the candle and the besamim,33:18 so that's good enough already to save you from having to repeat the Amidah.33:22 That's halachah bet,33:30 halachah gimel. When we said a person who made a mistake and didn't say33:35 Atah chonen, you don't even have to mention it later on in Amidah.33:37 Let's say you finish Atah chonen, you got up to33:41 Mevarech ha-shanim, and you realize you didn't say33:43 Atah chonen. You don't even have to mention it in33:45 Shomea Tefillah. So he says, when is that so?33:49 That's only if you know you're going to be able to make havdalah later on on a cup of wine.33:54 However, ha-ben miyodea she'ein lo kos afdah alav,33:57 vegam lemachar lo yehyeh lo.33:59 But if you know that you're not going to have a cup of wine,34:01 and you know that even tomorrow, the whole day Sunday until Sunday night,34:04 you're not going to be able to have a cup of wine,34:06 lemashal, you're away on vacation, and you forgot to bring extra wine for34:10 Havdalah. You had exactly enough grape juice or wine just for what you need for Shabbat, for Kiddush.34:17 You don't have beer, you don't have any alcoholic drink.34:19 How are you going to make Havdalah on the coast now?34:21 Okay, so you said Havdalah in34:25 Amidah, so that's good enough.34:26 You made Havdalah in34:27 Amidah. Yes, later on you have the other things,34:29 but at least you said Havdalah in34:31 Amidah. If you forgot to say Havdalah in34:33 Amidah, we said you don't have to go back to34:35 Amidah, but in this case, that you're away and you don't have34:38 anyone, and you don't have any store—hard to believe here in America,34:41 there's no store that sells even34:42 beer—but let's say you don't have any stores that are open around you,34:45 not Motzaei Shabbat, not Saturday night,34:47 and not the whole day later on, not the whole full day,34:51 you're not going to have wine or grape juice or any alcoholic drink34:54 until you get back home on Sunday night.34:57 So in that case, you lost it.35:00 You cannot say, okay, I'm going to make Havdalah.35:02 True, you have to make Havdalah anyway later on,35:04 but you must repeat the35:05 Amidah, and therefore you go back and repeat35:09 Amidah. However, if you remember in your35:13 Amidah, in the time when you don't have wine,35:14 you remember that you didn't say35:18 Atah honantanu, then you go and say it in Shema35:21 Koleinu. In the middle of Shema Koleinu, you mention35:24 Atah honantanu. The same paragraph that we say in35:26 Atah honen, Atah honantanu, you mention it in Shema35:30 Koleinu. You say in Shema Koleinu, Shema35:37 tefillah. Next,35:40 that is35:41 Halacha Gimel. Before we get to35:43 Halacha Dalet, there's a lot of things on35:44 Halacha Gimel that we need to point out from the35:48 poskim. The halacha brings,35:49 Maran Shulchan Aruch brings35:51 the halacha, and although Ben Ish Chai doesn't necessarily say it over here,35:53 but we have to point it out.35:54 Remember, you have to make havdalah in the35:57 amidah, and if you don't make havdalah in the35:58 amidah, it's not so bad. You don't have to repeat the36:00 amidah because you make havdalah later on, on a cup of wine.36:03 However, if a person ate something before havdalah,36:08 in the case where he did not say36:11 Atah Chonantanu, then he has to repeat the36:14 amidah, because we're going to learn soon36:16 that there's a—hachamim said36:19 that one is not allowed to36:22 taste—I should say, one is not allowed to eat anything before havdalah.36:25 Once already Benas Mashiach comes36:28 and you didn't make havdalah,36:29 you cannot eat anything.36:32 That is the halacha. So therefore, if a person didn't say havdalah in the36:37 amidah, we said you don't have to because you can go and eat36:39 and you can go make havdalah, excuse me.36:40 But if you ate before havdalah,36:42 so then you went against the takanah of the36:45 hachamim, and therefore the amidah that you said,36:47 you never made havdalah in it,36:49 and you ate also, you go back36:51 and you repeat the36:53 amidah. The question is, how much you have to eat36:55 in order to be chayav to go to repeat the36:58 amidah? The halacha says that you're not allowed to eat anything.37:02 You're not allowed to eat anything.37:03 You're not allowed to taste anything before the37:05 amidah. So therefore,37:08 the Shulchan Aruch Harav brings it down,37:10 he says it. Anything.37:11 If you ate even a little bit of a piece37:14 of whatever food,37:15 as long as it wasn't water. We're going to learn37:17 that water, you're allowed to drink water before Havdalah.37:19 Water is fine. There weren't gezeirah on water.37:21 Water, a person wants to drink before Havdalah,37:23 even though he didn't make Havdalah, you're allowed to drink water.37:25 The only thing you're not allowed to do is—not the only37:27 thing—everything else you're not allowed to eat or drink.37:30 Not wine, not grape juice, not juice,37:31 even regular juices, apple juice, orange juice,37:34 sodas even, anything with sugar,37:35 all those things you cannot drink37:37 until you make Havdalah. So if you ate37:39 or drank anything according to37:41 Shulchan Aruch HaRav, even a little sip of37:44 soda before you said37:45 the Havdalah, in the case37:47 where you also forgot37:50 Ata Chonantanu, then you go back and you repeat37:52 the37:53 Amidah. That's halacha. The Alter Rebbe has a big37:55 chiddush. No, I haven't seen it by anybody else,37:57 and he says in order to obligate37:59 a person to repeat the Amidah in the case38:01 where you forgot Ata Chonantanu and ate38:03 before Havdalah, he has38:05 to eat a kezayit or38:07 revi'it. That's a chiddush of38:09 Chacham Ben Tzion that I haven't seen anybody38:11 else bring it down. Everybody else,38:13 and the pashut pshat of38:15 Maran Shulchan Aruch, is38:17 ta'am—tasted. He tasted anything, it sounds like.38:22 Now here is a38:23 question. The question38:26 is,38:27 what if a person38:29 did the following? Let's say a38:31 person prayed Amidah on Motzaei Shabbat.38:33 He did not say38:36 Ata Chonantanu, and then38:38 even though he didn't say38:40 Ata Chonantanu, he ate afterwards38:41 by mistake. Of course, he ate by mistake,38:43 which is the halacha is he's supposed to repeat the38:45 Amidah. But before he came to ask,38:47 or before he realized, he said38:49 Havdalah on a cup of wine, the regular Havdalah38:51 Motzaei Shabbat. He didn't know the38:53 halacha. You know, a lot of times in the summer people are rushing out, they want to38:55 go back and they want to run home,38:57 or a lot of people do Havdalah in the house.38:59 So you go back home to do Havdalah for your wife,39:02 and all of a sudden39:03 your wife is busy, she's not ready yet39:05 for Havdalah, the kids are not ready,39:07 and he's sitting there, whatever it is, you forget yourself,39:09 you get a phone call, and then you forget yourself39:11 and you eat something.39:13 You didn't make Havdalah in the39:15 Amidah. You didn't make Havdalah yet, and you ate.39:17 Halacha is you have to repeat the Amidah, but you didn't realize,39:19 and then you made Havdalah afterwards.39:20 Do you still have to repeat the Amidah or not?39:23 So the Biur Halacha brings two opinions:39:25 the Pri Megadim and the39:28 Derech HaChaim. According to the Pri Megadim...39:29 No, the whole point is39:31 that you're supposed to say havdalah39:35 before you eat.39:36 True, you ate,39:37 but now at the end of the day, you39:39 did the havdalah, so why do you have to repeat the Amidah to say39:40 Atah Chonantanu? You already did the havdalah.39:43 It's good enough. Therefore, he says,39:45 according to the Pri Megadim, you do not have39:47 to repeat the Amidah if you already said havdalah.39:49 Even though you ate before the havdalah,39:50 but since you didn't realize it afterwards,39:52 you don't have to. According to the39:56 Derech HaChayim, however, he says39:57 no, it's a knas.39:58 Chachamim made a knas.40:00 Basically made a punishment on the person who forgets40:04 Atah honantanu in Amidah and eats before Havdalah, that he has to repeat the Amidah.40:08 And I don't care if he made Havdalah later on; it's a knas, and therefore you have to repeat it.40:12 The Kaf HaChaim says, the halacha is like the Pri Megadim,40:16 that you don't have to repeat the Amidah. However, Hacham Ovadia brings40:19 that he himself, he rules this way, and he brings from40:24 shut Divrei Shalom, Mizrahi, and the big40:27 also Sephardi poskim, right around the time Hacham Ovadia as well. And they say40:31 the halacha is like the... that if you ate before Havdalah in the case where you forgot40:35 Atah honantanu, even if you said Havdalah afterwards,40:39 you have to repeat the Amidah. However, they point out you should repeat it40:43 with a condition, and this is what we'll tell you, halacha lemaaseh. Make a condition.40:47 Say like this: if the halacha is like the Pri Megadim that I don't have to repeat the Amidah,40:51 so I'm praying a tefilat nedavah. This is like a voluntary Amidah.40:54 But if the halacha is that it's like the40:58 Derech HaChaim, that I have to repeat the Amidah because I ate before Havdalah, then this will be41:03 the Amidah that I'm saying as my obligation.41:06 That's called tefilah with a condition,41:10 al tenai. Next.41:14 Next halacha that we want to talk about, we want to give you a little bit of a background. We discussed a little bit,41:18 but now let's give you the full background. Chazal, although41:22 Havdalah motzaei Shabbat is, like we just mentioned,41:26 you just have to point out that yesterday was Shabbat and today is already motzaei Shabbat,41:30 Chachamim made a takanah that a person has to make41:34 Havdalah, like we said, on a kos, with a cup of wine, and over there41:38 we say also the blessing of borei41:42 me'orei ha'esh, as well as besamim. Chazal also made it41:46 forbidden for a person to do any melachah. Or41:50 to eat anything before making havdalah.41:54 Which havdalah are we talking about over here? Well, the41:58 havdalah that you do on a cup of wine, the Chachamim said you cannot eat until42:02 you make the havdalah on a cup of wine. You cannot eat or drink, that is,42:06 okay? The melachah, however, the42:09 melachah, they were not as machmir. The melachah, it works even if you said havdalah42:14 in tefillah. Even if you said Atah chonantanu, that's42:17 what's Atah chonantanu. You're making havdalah. So that's considered already havdalah, which allows you42:22 to do melachah. What if a person did not say42:25 Atah chonantanu, or hasn't prayed Arvit yet, and now it's already, the time is over,42:30 Shabbat is over, and he wants already to go ahead and to do42:33 melachah. Could you do melachah without making first havdalah, without praying Arvit? And the answer42:38 is yes, but with a condition. You have to say first,42:42 Baruch hamavdil bein kodesh lechol. Just like we would say the berachah by42:45 the havdalah, Baruch atah Hashem,42:50 Elokeinu melech haolam, hamavdil bein kodesh lechol, bein or lechoshech, bein Yisrael la'amim. Here, you don't have to say the whole thing, and in fact, you don't even42:53 say it with the name of Hashem. All you say is, Baruch42:58 hamavdil bein kodesh lechol. This is the opinion of Shulchan Aruch, although some43:01 Rishonim hold you have to say Shem Hashem. The halachah is like Shulchan Aruch, by just43:06 saying Baruch43:09 hamavdil bein kodesh lechol on motzaei Shabbat, whenever Shabbat is over, that is good enough for havdalah.43:13 Already you could do melachah with not a problem,43:18 okay? In a case where you prayed Amidah, you don't even have to43:22 say Baruch hamavdil bein kodesh lechol, because in the Amidah, you said Atah43:25 chonantanu, the havdalah was said when you prayed the regular43:29 Amidah of motzaei Shabbat. The question is as follows: What if a person43:33 forgot Atah chonantanu in the Amidah? He prayed already Arvit motzaei Shabbat.43:37 He said the Amidah, he did not say Atah chonantanu in the Amidah, so he didn't make havdalah.43:42 Now, this is a little bit slightly different from43:45 beforehand. What happened over here, he did not say Baruch43:50 Hamavdil bein kodesh l'chol, and now43:53 he wants—he did a melacha already. Remember, he didn't make Havdalah on Amidah.43:57 He didn't make Havdalah on a cup of wine, so he's really still Shabbat for him.44:02 Even though the time is over, it's still Shabbat for him. Shabbat is not over44:05 until the person says the words of Havdalah.44:09 And what happened? The guy did a melacha. Do we44:13 say that just as a person who ate before making the Havdalah on a cup of wine44:17 has to repeat the Amidah in the case where he forgot tachanun ta'anu, so too this44:21 person who did melacha before making the Havdalah on a cup, before making44:25 Havdalah on a cup of wine, has to repeat the Amidah? Or44:28 do we say, no, the only word gozer by eating44:33 before Havdalah on a cup, but they're not gozer by melacha44:36 before making Havdalah on a cup? That is the question.44:40 So I could give you the answer right away and tell you it's machloket, but of course44:44 we want to understand why there's a machloket. So let's begin44:48 with the Rishonim. There's an opinion, the Rashba,44:51 Rabbi Shlomo ben Aderet, one of the greatest Rishonim. The Rashba writes the following words.44:56 Of course, the opinion of Rishonim is all based on Gemara.45:00 It's not like they're, you know, just making up things, okay? So now he's saying like this.45:04 The Rashba writes that if a person forgets45:07 a tachanun ta'anu in Amidah, and he eats,45:12 or if he does melacha before making Havdalah on a45:16 cup of wine on the kos, then he has to repeat the Amidah.45:19 That's the Rashba's words. It's not only the Rashba; it's45:23 also—Hacham Ovadia brings a list—the Tosfot HaRosh, Ritva, Nimukei Yosef, Orchot Chaim, and45:27 Ohr HaMoed as well. All of them say that a person45:31 who forgets a tachanun ta'anu... And45:36 eat or does melacha before havdalah must repeat the amidah.45:41 The Rambam, however, if you look in the halachot of the Rambam, it doesn't mention a word45:44 not about eating and not about melacha. In either case,45:47 which means he doesn't hold of it. He doesn't hold of this halacha. If he holds, he should have brought it down.45:52 However, although Rambam doesn't mention anything about it,45:56 the other poskim hold if you eat45:59 before havdalah, when you forgot atah chonantanu, you have to repeat the amidah.46:03 But they don't talk, other Rishonim don't mention anything about doing46:07 melacha before havdalah. And the Shulchan Aruch himself46:11 writes,46:17 Simple understanding of Maran is that if you46:19 ate anything before havdalah, on the cup of wine, if you forgot, of course, atah46:25 chonantanu, you have to go back and repeat the amidah.46:27 That's if you ate. It mentions again nothing about doing melacha.46:32 However, Rav Akiva Eiger and the Eliyah Rabbah, Biur Halacha brings them down,46:35 they hold that you have to repeat the amidah. Even melacha, they go46:39 with the Rashba and they say, they understood that the Maran is not arguing on the Rashba.46:43 They understood Maran like that, that if you do melacha when you forgot atah46:47 chonantanu before making havdalah on the kos, you have to repeat the amidah.46:51 And the Biur Halacha himself, however, says you don't have to be machmir like Rav Akiva Eiger46:55 and the Eliyah Rabbah. You can rely as well on the Rambam. Also other Rishonim47:00 that say that if you did melacha before havdalah, you don't have to repeat the amidah.47:05 Here we come to the Acharonim now. Okay, so Ashkenazim,47:08 like the Biur Halacha hold, you don't have to repeat the amidah. In fact, a few other47:12 poskim, Acharonim, went with the Mishnah Berurah from the Ashkenazim. They say,47:16 according to the Ashkenazim, if you forgot atah chonantanu and47:19 you did melacha before saying Baruch hamavdil bein kodesh lechol, before havdalah.47:24 You don't have to repeat Amidah. There's no knas. The knas is only47:28 when a person eats before the havdalah.47:32 What about the Sefardim? Here we have a machloket between the Chacham Ben Tzion and47:36 Chacham Ovadia. Most people are used to what the Chacham Ben Tzion is going to be47:40 machmir, and Chacham Ovadia—excuse me—yeah, Chacham Ben Tzion is going to be machmir, and Chacham Ovadia is going to be47:44 lenient. In these halachot, it's interesting that it's really the opposite. In a few cases,47:48 as we'll see, Chacham Ovadia is machmir, and Chacham Ben Tzion is mekil.47:51 Chacham Ben Tzion, he has a very nice teshuvah in Chelek Aleph,47:55 and he proves that the halacha is that you don't have to repeat the Amidah if you—48:00 Forgot to say, ... and he did a melacha before making havdalah48:06 on a kos. That's according to Chacham Ben Zion. According to Chacham Ovadia, yes, you do have to repeat.48:10 He brings Rav Shalom Mizrahi again, and he says also you have to repeat the amidah if you48:15 forgot ... any did a melacha before saying, before saying hamavdil48:22 between kodesh l'chol. Therefore, what do you do?48:23 Well, you follow your rabbi, you ask him what to do.48:26 If a person doesn't want to repeat the amidah, he has what to rely on. But even if you want48:30 to go with Chacham Ovadia, he says you should only repeat the amidah al tenai, with a condition.48:36 And therefore, you ask your local rabbi and you see what you do in this halacha. Even if, again,48:40 you want to repeat the amidah according to Chacham Ovadia, you have to do it only with a condition.48:53 Okay, we got a question in the text line. Trying to understand, basically the question48:59 is: what determines when Shabbat begins or ends?49:05 Okay, and the question is basically, is it when you verbalize that Shabbat is here or49:10 it's over, or is it when the time comes?49:13 And the answer is both. But you have to know in which case. We're stringent in both areas,49:19 which means for Shabbat to come in, we're stringent that once one of the conditions49:26 is there, which is the time, once the time comes in, that's it, Shabbat is here,49:31 and that time is sunset.49:32 Whenever sunset is here, Shabbat is here.49:36 Motzaei Shabbat, in order for Shabbat to be over, then we need two conditions.49:41 You need to wait the actual time, and you also need to verbalize it. You need to express49:47 it. You need to say that Shabbat is over as well.49:51 So we're stringent,49:52 but there's two conditions which determines when Shabbat comes in and when it comes out.49:57 That is time, whatever that time is, and the— To express it, to verbalize it.50:05 When we're stringent for the entrance of Shabbat and exit of Shabbat,50:09 for the entrance of Shabbat we're stringent only one thing:50:11 if a person expresses it or the time comes, Shabbat is here.50:16 For motzaei Shabbat, if a person wants Shabbat to be over, he has to not only express it,50:23 but he also has to wait that the time of Shabbat is over, which is seta kochavim, the three stars,50:27 and then express and say, verbalize, Shabbat is over, Baruch hamavdil bein kodesh50:32 lechol, and over, Shabbat to be over.50:33 And this is very important.50:34 A person, ladies who don't pray Arvit motzaei Shabbat and they want to do some sort of50:39 melacha, they have to be careful that they cannot do any melacha, even lighting the50:44 candle for Havdalah, until they say Baruch hamavdil bein kodesh50:46 lechol. A lot of ladies want to do Havdalah. Let's say they do Havdalah in the house and they50:50 want to bring the candle and, you know, make their own Havdalah, which is fine, no problem, you50:55 could do it.50:56 Only we'll talk about the machloket later on.50:59 But even if you want to do that, since you're not praying Arvit motzaei Shabbat, ladies, you51:03 have to make sure you say Baruch hamavdil bein kodesh51:05 lechol. You want to put on the AC, shut off the AC, shut off the blech, whatever you want to do51:09 motzaei Shabbat, you can, even though you're planning to say Havdalah and the time has51:14 come. If you didn't say Baruch hamavdil bein kodesh lechol, you cannot do any51:19 melacha. Men, you have to teach your wives, and ladies, you have to teach other ladies and let them51:24 know this.51:24 A lot of ladies don't know this51:27 halacha. They think that, oh, 72 minutes, I wait51:29 Rabbeinu Tam. Even the very, very frum ones and very stringent ones, they say, We're waiting51:33 Rabbeinu Tam, 72 minutes, now I can do51:35 melacha. No.51:36 72 minutes and then you have to express it, you have to verbalize it, Baruch51:41 hamavdil bein kodesh51:41 lechol. One more point on this halacha, and that is if a person misses Mincha of Shabbat,51:49 the halacha is that you have to repeat Amidah by Arvit, right?51:53 This is halacha by anything.51:54 The general rule is that there's something called tefilat tashlumin.51:58 What's tefilat tashlumin?51:58 Tashlumin is a52:01 makeup. Chazal established that we pray Amidah three times a day in general, right? Mincha. Let's52:07 start like this: Shacharit, Mincha, and52:09 Arvit. If a person, for whatever reason, couldn't pray one of the prayers, as long as he didn't52:16 do it on purpose, he couldn't pray any of the prayers, so the next day, the next52:21 tefillah, he can make up the tefillah that he missed.52:23 How does one make it up?52:25 Well, he does the52:26 following. First, he prays the tefillah that he has to pray for that time. Let's give a mashal.52:33 A person misses Mincha, so he has to pray now Arvit two times.52:37 First he prays the first Amidah. It means over here, when we say Arvit two times, it52:41 means the Amidah two times.52:42 First he prays the Amidah of Arvit, and then he prays a second Amidah right away for making52:50 up the Mincha that he missed.52:52 This is true for every single day.52:55 The only thing it gets confusing, that what happens when it's Shabbat, that the person53:00 forgot the Amidah, and now motzaei Shabbat Arvit, he wants to make it up, but how do53:07 you do so?53:08 Do you say the make-up Amidah? Do you say the Amidah of Shabbat, or do you53:13 say motzaei Shabbat?53:13 And the rule is, you always pray the Amidah, even the make-up Amidah, where you're standing53:20 right then,53:20 the same Amidah as where you are right then.53:22 Meaning, if you forgot the Amidah of Shabbat Mincha, so Arvit, when you come to53:27 Arvit and you have to repeat the Amidah, then you repeat the Arvit of motzaei Shabbat.53:33 You say the Arvit of motzaei Shabbat twice: the first time for the sake of Arvit, and53:37 the second Amidah is for the make-up for the tefillah of53:41 Mincha. That is53:42 the halacha. Now, what about53:44 a Tachanun Taanit? When do you mention53:46 Tachanun Taanit? So the rule is, remember, the second one is the53:48 make-up; the first one is for the regular tefillah of53:51 Arvit. So if a person is going to pray motzaei Shabbat the two Amidot, the first Amidah he prays53:57 for Arvit, motzaei Shabbat, and that's when you say54:02 Atah Chonantanu. In the second Amidah, you don't say Atah Chonantanu because the second Amidah is not meant54:06 for makeup. The second Amidah is meant for a makeup, excuse me, of Shabbat day, and over there you54:11 don't need to say54:13 Atah Chonantanu. If, however, a person made a mistake, if a person made a mistake and he said54:19 Atah Chonantanu in the second Amidah, then we come into problems,54:23 because according to Shulchan Aruch, the Gemara and the Shulchan Aruch rules that since he said54:27 Atah Chonantanu in the second Amidah, so it shows that you prayed the second Amidah for54:32 the sake of Arvit, and the first Amidah you prayed it as a tashlumin, as a makeup for54:36 the54:37 Mincha, which means that you were not yotzei the chovah, the first Amidah, and you have to say54:41 again a third54:43 Amidah. However, the Acharonim point out that only if you thought that the first Amidah is for54:50 the sake of makeup and the second Amidah is for the sake of54:56 Arvit. If you knew that the first Amidah is to make up for—excuse me—if you knew that the first Amidah is for the sake of Arvit and the second one is for55:03 makeup, so in that case, even though you got mixed up and you said Atah Chonantanu by the second55:07 Amidah, it's still fine; you don't have to repeat it.55:10 Kaf HaChaim makes a compromise, and the Chachamim says the same thing. However, if a person was not55:14 thinking, he prayed two Amidot, he said Atah Chonantanu by the second one, in that case55:18 he should repeat Amidah a third time, but this time with a condition, like we55:22 mentioned before.55:23 So ad kan is the laws of havdalah in Amidah. The next halacha, which is halacha dalet,55:30 anyway we're going to skip, brings a Zohar, and the Ben Ish Chai brings a Zohar and explains the Zohar, like we said, our rule is that we don't go55:37 through the Zohar, and we have another maybe few seconds. Let's just say one more55:42 halacha, halacha hei, and that is—we'll summarize it outside. The Ben Ish Chai says— That in places where people55:48 are am haaretz, meaning to say people don't know how to read. If you're in a shul and even55:52 one member doesn't know how to read from a siddur and he's standing up in prayer, you55:57 should say, Atah chonantanu.56:00 Not to say it out loud, so this way people could follow or could listen to it.56:03 So this way at least the havdalah.56:05 So they don't hear the full amidah, but at least the havdalah they should know56:09 that, or they should hear it and have in mind that they should do at least havdalah by verbally expressing it.56:14 And it's a good idea in general, and that's a lot of people are noheg that way56:17 Motzaei Shabbat, they call out just the words56:21 Atah honantanu out loud. This way is a reminder for everybody in the shul not to forget56:25 Atah honantanu. That we learned, havdalah in tefillah is instituted by the chachamim. It's very important.56:29 A person shouldn't forget it, because if he does forget it, it could lead to perhaps repeating the56:35 amidah. That's the class for now.56:37 Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll meet again next week.56:39 Just a reminder again that the Shavuasa, the festival of Shavuasa b'Tammuz, is coming up this Tuesday,56:45 and like the times that we mentioned, it starts from 4:09 a.m. until about 956:52 o'clock, 9:15 p.m., which we'll have, be'ezrat Hashem, a meaningful fast,56:54 and Hashem should turn these days—it's atzarah l'Yaakov, but the pasuk continues56:59 and says,57:01 u'mena yivashea. Be'ezrat Hashem, we should see these days,57:03 the Chazal told us that ben hametzarim will turn to be one big holiday,57:06 as the Arizal says, will turn from three weeks of mourning to three weeks of celebrations and Yom Tov57:14 with the coming of Mashiach Tzidkeinu bimheirah b'yameinu, amen.57:17 Thank you to Iran and to JRoot Radio for hosting us,57:20 and have a wonderful week and wonderful Shabbat.57:22 We'll meet again next week, be'ezrat Hashem.