Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Hanukkah Part 3Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 3Rabbi Uri Nahum · November 26, 2013−15Play+30Position0:0056:42Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Okay, we have a lot to cover, so we'll get straight to the halachot0:03without any introductions or anything else. Just one small thing, and that is we are0:08dedicating this class l'refuah shelemah of Eliyahu0:13Chaim ben Shafika Sofia, as well as refuah shelemah for Lizet bat Salcha and Rachel and Rula bat Latife. Let's begin.0:23Last week we mentioned the times that a person should light. Just to quickly review that,0:29the best time for a person to light nerot Chanukah this year, 5774, 2013,0:38is there's basically four grades. Grade number one, which is A, meaning to say the top, A, B, C,0:43D. The top is between 4:50 and 6:10 p.m. The earlier you light, the closer to 4:50, the better,0:51so that's grade A. If you light between 4:50 and 6:10, that's the top, and the earlier0:56you get, more of a plus. It'll be A plus. Grade B will be from 6 o'clock until 81:04o'clock, and from 8 till about 10:30, 11, that's grade C. And if a person still hasn't lit the menorah by1:1110:30 or 11, you have up till 5:25 a.m. to light the menorah. That's when alot hashachar is, and1:20it's still, according to halacha, yotzei dei chovah, but of course, like we said, it's grade D. But1:25again, the times are, the best time is 4:50 until 6:10. That's the prime time a person should try1:32to light at those times. Okay, we don't have time to explain most of the halachot. We have to get1:38to the main halachot. Be'ezrat Hashem, we're working on a video together with the Jew Radio of showing how1:44to light and giving the primary halachot. Today we'll be working off the Ben Ish Chai, and we're up1:50to halacha zayin. Where we spoke about times of lighting, and a lot of the stuff today I may not1:58read inside because of the time. So therefore, we'll begin with this halacha. The Ben Ish Chai says,2:03and that's a halacha that's also brought down by all the poskim, that the person who is lighting,2:08once the time has come to light, which is 4:30, let's say officially, then a person should not2:14have a meal. What does he mean by a meal over here? A meal means eating with bread that's2:19over a kebeitzah, like we find by other mitzvot. We're worried that a person may be nimshach2:23achar se'udato. He may forget himself with his meal, and therefore he may not be able to light.2:30So therefore, that's the halacha: when the time comes, the person is not allowed to have a meal.2:34It's also brought down a person is not allowed to have a shiur; he's not allowed to begin2:37learning at that time, because he has to go and light at that time. And again, we're worried also,2:41especially in learning, a person might forget himself in learning and may not be able to2:47light. However, there's a few points over here, and that is: number one is, a lot of times the kids in2:53the family ask the following question. According to the Sefardi custom, where we only light,2:58one person only lights, and it's usually the father who's lighting. The father sometimes3:02comes home at eight, nine o'clock, and the kid is home from school or yeshiva, let's say even3:074:30, 5 o'clock, even 6, and he's home and he wants to know, can I have a meal right now?3:13He's above the age of bar mitzvah. Could he have a meal? Does he have to wait till his father3:16lights because the time has come? Is he allowed to have bread? To have other foods, for sure3:21there's not a problem. He wants to eat other foods that are not bread, that's not a problem,3:25even the person who has to light. The question is, could he have other foods like—could he have3:30bread, a sandwich that's more than a kebeitzah, or does he have to wait till he sees candle lighting?3:35The answer is that he does not have to wait. The obligation of lighting is on him. The3:39obligation of lighting is on his father, and therefore the child could have—I don't call him a child,3:43but even he could be a person who's older than a child. He could be 18, 19, as long as he's being3:48supported by his father, and his father is the one who takes care of all the bills. Therefore,3:53it's the father who has the obligation, and he's the one who has to wait, not the child.3:57The son does not have to. The other point we mentioned: a person should not begin learning.4:01If the time of lighting has come. However, you have to know, if there's a person who has a shiur4:08kavua, he has a set time for learning, and that's his time that he learns a day. And usually it's4:13common by people who go to work and they dedicate time to learn. If his time of learning is the time4:19of lighting, and if you would have to cancel or delay the class, you may not be able to have that4:25time of learning that day, then you do not cancel the class and you learn. I'll give you an example.4:30Motzaei Shabbat. This Motzaei Shabbat we light the menorah. So when is the best time to light?4:35Immediately when your Shabbat is over. Whenever your Shabbat is over, you go home4:38and you're supposed to light. That's the prime time, because it's right after4:42Seudat Shlishit. However, Baruch Hashem, it's a beautiful custom in many shuls that there's learning right after4:48Havdalah. In that case, Chacham Ovadia brings down, and you see also many hold this way, it's also4:54מסתבר that way, makes sense that way. In that case, if you would cancel the class,5:00or even if you delay the class, you say, Okay, rabotai, everybody go home,5:03light and come back. If there's a chashash, if there's a doubt, maybe somebody will not come back.5:11You have twenty people in your class or twenty people in the shul that are going home to light.5:16Maybe fifteen will come back, maybe. So, right, and it's not a hundred percent that everybody will come back,5:21then the halacha says, no, תמות תורה זו. You continue5:25your shiur kavua and you light afterwards. Lighting on time is preferred. Lighting at that time between5:314:50 to 6:10, that's the ideal time. But to push away learning of Torah, or even5:36a safek that we might not be able to learn. And between me and you, most people who go home to light5:40do not come back to the shul. They're already home, the wife and the kids,5:44and there's things, all of a sudden things come up. So therefore, in that case,5:48a person should not interrupt his learning schedule. Learn and then go home afterwards5:52and light. In fact, Chacham Ovadia, as well as his children, have said many, many times5:57that when they had times when they had a shiur kavua, they continued6:02the shiur kavua, and then afterwards they went home. This as well, you see from big talmidei chachamim in our6:06community as well. Over here in Brooklyn, you see that they have a6:10shiur kavua with other baalei batim. They keep the shiur and they only light afterwards.6:15Halacha chet. Halacha chet, the Ben Ish Chai discusses the length of time that the menorah6:22has to stay lit for, and the halacha says, Tzarich sheyiten bah shemen6:29sheyidlak levachot chatzi shaah. You have to put enough oil in your menorah that it should be able to light for at6:41least a half an hour. V'im lo haya bah shemen shiur hadlakah chatzi shaah, afilu mosif bah shemen achar hadlakah lo yatza yedei chovato. But for the time that you come to light it, you lit the menorah with the blessing,6:47and then you realize, whoa, I forgot to put enough oil. I have oil, but it's not enough. It's only6:52enough oil that's going to last for 10, 15 minutes. It doesn't help right now that you just add the6:57oil. Like we mentioned last week, when you light the menorah, it has to be able—you have to be able to fulfill the7:04mitzvah completely at the time of lighting it. If you realize it's not enough oil,7:08do not add other oil. Shut off the menorah, then add the oil, and then afterwards light again.7:13Just don't make another berachah. Why? Because when you light it, it has to be able—you have to place it in a place,7:20and you have to have enough oil that's able to last for a half an hour, which is the minimum.7:25If you look in the Mishnah Berurah, he says something interesting. He says,7:28you should know, after half an hour, there is no mitzvah with the menorah being lit.7:32The whole mitzvah is only half an hour, so therefore you could shut it off. In fact,7:36even if you keep it on, he says there's no mitzvah whatsoever if you keep it lit after7:40half an hour. However, the question is, when does that half an hour begin? Like we mentioned last7:46week in much more in detail, there are different opinions exactly when the Gemara means,7:52let me just give you a little background. We mentioned last week the7:56Gemara says, when is the time to light the menorah? So the Gemara says—8:00Mishte tiska hachamah, ad shetechle regel min hashuk, until that people stop walking in the market.8:08That's a simple explanation.8:10When that time is that people stop walking, now many different interpretations about it.8:15So the simple explanation, the Gemara says, why do you have to know this time for?8:18The Gemara says because that's how long you have to keep it lit for.8:22So now, the Rambam writes like this.8:30The Rambam writes that time that the Chachamim said, techle regel min hashuk, is kechatzi shaah or yoter. It's around a half an hour. It's a little bit more than a half an hour,8:3330, 35 minutes. That's how long the Gemara means that it has to be lit for.8:40But being that there's a big discussion, when exactly does the time begin to light?8:46When is the earliest time?8:47What is called shekiat hachamah? We mentioned last week8:48there's different opinions.8:50Some say it's the beginning of the sun setting.8:52Some say it's at the end, what we call8:54tzeit hakochavim. And tzeit hakochavim itself is a big discussion.8:57When does it exactly begin?8:59So technically, this half an hour really,9:03even according to the Mishnah Berurah, if you want to follow all the opinions,9:06that could last even more so,9:08that even more than half an hour that you lit.9:11That means let's say you lit your menorah at the ideal time at9:154:50, so half an hour later would be9:185:20. However, if it stays lit more than9:215:20, it's still a mitzvah because there's other opinions that say9:24that the mitzvah only begins at 6 or later on.9:28And some say that9:30techle regel min hashuk, in fact they say in the name of the9:32Bisker Rav, as long as there's somebody walking the street.9:34Nowadays there are people walking the street even later,9:36so there's still a mitzvah to keep it on after that time.9:41So therefore, if it doesn't hurt,9:43a person should keep his menorah on9:45as long as he believes there's still people walking around in that neighborhood.9:48So this way he could publicize the miracle.9:51The Gemara, which says a half an hour,9:53and the Mishnah Berurah, which says a half an hour,9:55is referring to times when people did not walk the street past the half an hour,9:57so of course there's no mitzvah.9:58Or in a time when a person is lighting like the way10:01the Ashkenazim used to light,10:03or most of the Jewish people used to light in the olden days,10:05which is only on the inside,10:07where it wasn't into the view of the people on the outside.10:10So in that case, since the people in the household have seen it for half an hour10:14and nobody else sees it,10:15so that's it.10:16There's no mitzvah afterwards.10:18However, nowadays there's people outside.10:20We can't force you. To keep it on for more than half an hour,10:24but certainly there is an ענין and there is a mitzvah10:28to keep it lit as long as there's people walking around in the street.10:32Again,10:34non-obligation, but it is certainly something very recommended,10:38very nice to do.10:40Move on now to10:42Halacha Tet. Halacha Tet, the halacha says,10:44important10:47halacha. We said that the hadlakah, lighting the menorah,10:50if you light it appropriately,10:51that creates a mitzvah.10:53So therefore, the Gemara says,10:54and here the10:58Bein Ish Chai brings the halacha, Im hidlikah vichibah haruach. If a person lit the menorah11:00and was shut off by the wind,11:03then, im nicham makom shel haruach, it all depends.11:07Does he have to relight it or not?11:08It all depends on the person.11:10If he put it in a place11:13where it was going to shut off because of the wind,11:17lemashal, he lit it outdoors without a glass covering,11:20so of course it's going to shut off.11:21What do you think?11:22You light it outdoors,11:23you can't even light a match outdoors.11:24Here you lit your candles outside,11:28and then you left it outdoors without any protection.11:31Of course, with the wind,11:32if it doesn't even knock down the menorah,11:35right, it's for sure going to blow away the candle.11:38So in that case,11:39it was his negligence11:41that why the candles have shut off.11:44Therefore he has the obligation to light it again.11:48However, he should do it without a11:51berachah. However,11:54if the person did what he has to do,11:57he put it, let's say, by his window inside of the house.12:00There's no windows are open,12:01there's no wind coming inside.12:03He put it by the window,12:04and it was lit,12:05and then he left it alone, and by mistake12:07or something happened,12:09the kids bumped into it12:10or whatever it was,12:12the candles just shut off.12:13Sometimes they shut off on their own.12:15If they shut off on their own.12:17Then, according to12:18halacha, min hadin, you have no obligation to relight it again.12:23If a person wants to relight it,12:26tabo alav bracha, that's an extra thing,12:28and Chazak u'Baruch, certainly it's recommended,12:30and you get a blessing.12:32But if it's shut off,12:33min hadin, you don't have to.12:34Now, what's the difference?12:35Any more people are going to see it lit.12:37They're going to say,12:38Chaval on the oil.12:39Anyway, you put it on.12:41We put in the oil.12:42We're not going to reuse it.12:43Might as well put it on.12:44That is true,12:46but the difference will be12:48if anybody is planning to light his menorah12:50and leave the house.12:51If you're planning to light your menorah12:52and you invite to eat somewhere else,12:54and your menorah has to light for half an hour,12:55you have no obligation of staying next to the menorah12:58and making sure that it stays lit for half an hour.13:00As long as you put enough oil,13:03and of course you left it in a place that's safe13:05and it's not going to, chas v'shalom, make a fire, right?13:07You don't want a bigger flame than13:09it is. So you left it in a safe place,13:11you put on enough oil,13:12and you left the house,13:13you don't have to make sure that it stays on for half an hour.13:16If you left the house13:17and you're already on the corner13:18and you turned the block13:20and you get a phone call from your neighbor,13:21Hey, neighbor,13:22you know, I'm being a good neighbor.13:23I'm just telling you that your candle shut off.13:26I'm looking out my windows.13:27My menorah looks beautiful,13:28but your menorah,13:29the candle shut off already.13:30You don't have to come back.13:31You did the obligation.13:32You can continue going.13:33If you don't want to come back,13:34you don't have to.13:34If you want to,13:36tabo alav bracha. Certainly it's very recommended,13:39very nice if you do come back,13:41but you don't have to come back.13:43The big question, though,13:45is as follows.13:46We're going to learn,13:48be'ezrat Hashem, towards the end of the class,13:50that on Erev Shabbat,13:51on Friday afternoon,13:52this Friday afternoon,13:53the time to light the menorah13:55is after13:57plag hamincha. Plag hamincha, there are two opinions.13:59One is the opinion of the14:01Gra, based on the14:02Gra's calculation, which will be14:043:30, and based on the Magen Avraham's calculation14:06of14:07one plag hamincha, it's at14:094 p.m. So let's say,14:10so now14:11obviously on Friday afternoon,14:12when you're lighting for Shabbat,14:14the menorah,14:15the candles of14:16Chanukah, you can't light after sunset.14:19Because after sunset14:20is already Shabbat,14:20that's asur.14:22So therefore,14:22we have to light it before sunset.14:24How much before are you allowed to light it?14:26Up to14:27plag, from plag onwards,14:28you could light it.14:29We'll learn more about that,14:30bezrat Hashem, a little bit later on.14:31So let's say 414:33o'clock, you lit your menorah.14:35After you lit menorah at 414:37o'clock, at14:384:15, you have not accepted Shabbat yet,14:40not accepted Shabbat,14:41and therefore you have the ability to light if you want.14:444:15, the candles shut off.14:45Now the halacha says,14:47although we give you permission to light the menorah14:50earlier than sunset,14:51you have to make sure that there's enough oil to last14:55a half an hour14:57after set14:58hakochavim, half an hour after the stars come out.15:02So it's not enough just that you light the menorah earlier15:05and15:06your yotzei chovah with just a half an hour;15:07it has to stay lit a half an hour15:09after set15:11hakochavim. So in this case,15:12at15:134:15, it's not even shkiyah yet,15:14it's not even sunset yet.15:15We haven't even began set15:17hakochavim, to begin the half an hour,15:19but your candles shut off.15:20Do you have to go back and light it,15:22or do you say,15:23Look, I did my15:24mitzvah, I lit it,15:25and just like if it shut off within the half an hour,15:27I have to go relight the menorah,15:29also over here15:29I don't have to relight it.15:32Hacham Ovadia has a15:33chiddush, and he says,15:34although15:35he said, No, it's a big discussion in the15:37poskim, Hacham Ovadia rules15:38that since you lit it in the time15:41when this is the time for menorah,15:44even though you did not accept Shabbat,15:45min15:47hadin, you don't have to do anything.15:48It's shut off15:49not because of its own fault,15:50it's shut off on its own,15:52and therefore15:53you fulfilled the obligation by lighting it.15:54So at15:554:15 it's shut off,15:56you lit it at15:584:10, and everything was fine.16:00Enough oil, the wicks were fine, so you did the obligation. Technically, you don't have to relight it again.16:06But of course, if you relight it again, tabo16:10alav beracha. I do have to point out that it's known already, you know, they sell these easy-light candles in the stores,16:19and most people find that much easier. It's easy light, right?16:22Okay, so they buy, they go to any Judaica or any store, groceries, Jewish groceries, and they buy this box which has basically cups and oil and wicks all prepared.16:34All you have to do is take off the cover and light it.16:38It's very known that many of these candles, unfortunately, when you light them, they don't stay lit, not even for half an hour.16:46It's not that there's not enough oil. Of course there's enough oil.16:49Something, I don't know exactly what's wrong. Maybe it's old merchandise, maybe it's not stored properly, maybe the wick is not placed properly,16:57but it's a fact that people could testify that they light it and you see—I'm not saying all the brands, but certain brands don't stay lit for half an hour.17:08You can't say, Look, there's enough oil, there's enough—I have a wick. I did my obligation. It's not my fault, it's the company's fault.17:13You know that this company, you see, first night, second night, third night, every time you light, 15 minutes later they're shutting off.17:19There's something wrong. There's something wrong with the candles, obviously.17:24So therefore, a person just has to be aware of that.17:27I personally switched from, a few years ago, I switched from these easy candles to regular oil and wicks,17:34and the reason is because I saw that they keep on getting shut off, and therefore, you know, you can't say, I don't know about it.17:47You do now. You see. You do know, and therefore a person has to be careful.17:51Another reason why I switched is because— You're involved more when you put the oil yourself and you wick yourself and you have to wash the cups yourself.18:00It gets you more involved.18:01It's not an obligation, but it's nicer.18:03But in any case, as far as halacha is concerned, a person has to be careful when buying the easy-light candles, or any candles really,18:09to make sure that you set it up in a way that you'll be able to light a half an hour after18:16tzeit hakochavim. Move on now to halacha yod.18:20Okay, important halacha over here.18:25The Ben Ish Hai talks about if a person forgot to make the18:28beracha. We discussed this a little bit in the past, but now we'll go into it in detail.18:32He says like this:18:36Hidlik ner Chanukah v'shachach v'lo berach. Let's say you lit the menorah and you remembered and you didn't make a18:41beracha. Somebody asks, How in the world did you forget to make a18:44beracha? What do you mean, how often are you lighting menorah?18:46Well, the person who's asking the question is certainly a person who doesn't have little kids in the18:50house. When you have little kids in the house and this one is crying, this one is pulling you,18:54and the other one is pulling his sister's hair, and he is yelling, and18:59everybody's yelling, and your wife is rushing you, Let's go, let's go, come on, the latkes are burning and the donuts are burning,19:03and everybody's yelling, you go out of sync. You can't think so well, and you just light the menorah,19:09and you realize only afterwards, Whoops, I forgot to light with the19:13beracha. In any case, you forgot. You lit, but you didn't make a19:18beracha. What is the din? Do you make a blessing or not?19:21Is this like nerot Shabbat, the Ashkenazim, you can make a beracha afterwards or not?19:24And the answer is no.19:26If you finish lighting, you finish lighting completely, you don't make a beracha. It's over.19:31Oh, what do you mean? But I didn't light, I didn't make a blessing.19:34Okay, so the beracha works.19:36It's not like you're not yotzei the chovah. The mitzvah you did. The blessing you didn't make.19:41The blessing is not me'akev. It does not prevent the mitzvah from being fulfilled.19:45The blessing is nice, but it's not19:50me'akev. Now, as far as, as far as the, what's it called,19:57is a person who did not, who forgot to make a bracha before lighting,20:03but he remembered middle of his lighting.20:06Meaning, in the middle of lighting the menorah, let's say it's the fifth night,20:10and he's lighting three candles, he remembers, Whoa, I forgot to make the blessing.20:17In that case, then you could still make the bracha of20:23lehadlik ner Chanukah. I do have to point out, and that is the blessings of20:31Shehecheyanu and She'asa nisim la'avoteinu. Let's say a person forgets on the first night.20:33The first night, tomorrow night, we're going to make three blessings.20:35Number one is20:40lehadlik ner Chanukah. The second blessing is20:45She'asa nisim la'avoteinu bayamim hahem bazman hazeh, and the third blessing is20:49Shehecheyanu. If a person forgot and he lit the menorah and he didn't make any blessings,20:53the only blessing that he does not repeat is the first21:00bracha, lehadlik ner Chanukah. However, the other two blessings,21:04She'asa nisim and Shehecheyanu, as long as the menorah is still lit in front of him, he could still make the blessing.21:09That's important to keep in mind.21:11Only lehadlik you can't make anymore, because how could you say,21:17Asher kid'shanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu lehadlik, who commanded us to light? You're finished lighting already, so you can't make a21:20bracha. If you're in the middle of lighting the menorah,21:22so technically, since you're in the middle, you could still say21:26lehadlik. However, the other blessings of21:29She'asa nisim and Shehecheyanu, these blessings, since the Chachamim instituted21:34that a person, even who is not lighting at all and nobody's lighting for him,21:37if he sees the candles of the menorah lit,21:41he can make these blessings even though he himself is not lighting.21:44So therefore, he can make these blessings even after he finished lighting,21:48as long as the menorah is still lit, he can make the blessing.21:50You know, I'll tell you a better case.21:52Let's say a person lit his menorah in his house and he left the21:55house. And now he's driving down,21:58and he remembers, in the middle of his driving,22:01I forgot to make the blessing of22:05she'asah nisim la'avoteinu and/or shehecheyanu. In that case, as long as you see somebody's menorah22:11and you see their candles,22:12you can make the blessing22:16she'asah nisim la'avoteinu and shehecheyanu, because that's the institution, the Chachamim instituted,22:19that when you see the miracle of22:21Chanukah, the miracle of the candles, you commemorate the22:23candles, you could still say that blessing.22:27Important halacha that's brought down in Mishnah22:31Berurah, but those argue on him,22:34okay? If a person is not lighting on the first night,22:37let's say the first night he says,22:39You know, I won't be from Mincha, I want to light on time the first night.22:42I'm not going to get home till 1022:43o'clock. It's going to be before Thanksgiving, before Black Friday,22:46and I'm going to be very busy at work.22:49So therefore, he calls into the house22:51and he tells his wife, You light for me.22:52So therefore, tomorrow night the wife will light22:55by herself with her kids,22:57and she'll make three blessings.23:00She'll make the blessing of23:04lehadlik ner Chanukah, she'asah nisim, and then she'll also make23:06shehecheyanu. The husband, who's still at work,23:08doesn't have to light at work,23:10and he doesn't have to light when he gets home.23:11Why?23:12Because his wife has lit for him.23:15The question is, what happens now on Thursday night?23:18Thursday night is Thanksgiving.23:19He doesn't have work. He comes home,23:21and now he wants to light.23:23He makes, of course, the first two23:26berachot, which are23:27lehadlik ner Chanukah and23:28she'asah nisim. The question is, does he say23:29shehecheyanu or not?23:30So here the Mishnah Berurah says,23:32No,23:34ishto kegufo. His wife is like himself.23:36She made23:37shehecheyanu; it's considered like he made23:38shehecheyanu, and he does not have to repeat23:40the berachah of23:42shehecheyanu. However,23:43Chacham Ovadia and both Rav Elyashiv hold—23:46Not so.23:47If they did not make a beracha of23:51Shehecheyanu the first night,23:52the next time that they light,23:55it could be the second and third night,23:56whenever they're coming to light,23:58they would still recite.24:00The blessing of24:02Shehecheyanu. What happens to24:04safek brachot lehakel? You know, it's not so simple of safek brachot lehakel and Shehecheyanu and other things,24:08but there's many factors involved over here.24:11The Chacham Badiyah brings24:13a safek sfeika. Probably it could even be a safek24:15sfeik sfeika of a person that he should make the24:19bracha Shehecheyanu if he himself has not made the bracha Shehecheyanu on the first night.24:23Even though his wife made it, he can still make the bracha Shehecheyanu later on.24:29Okay, halacha yud24:31aleph. We're skipping around. I'm sorry, I apologize to those who are following with a book.24:35The reason why I'm jumping around is because24:36we have to try to be able to cover all the halachot with the last half an hour that we have over here.24:40Halacha yud aleph, I'm not going to read it inside.24:43I'm going to say it outside and support halacha.24:45We know that we light the menorah in shul.24:47The reason why we light the menorah in shul, once upon a time,24:51the Jewish people weren't able to light outside, so they couldn't publicize the miracle of the menorah24:55to the people in the public, the people in the streets,24:58and everybody had to light in their houses inside.25:01So who did you publicize it to? To the people in the family. That's it,25:04bifnim. But in the shul, everybody gets together.25:07Since everybody gets together, it's a great place to publicize the25:10miracle when a lot of people are there together.25:11So therefore, they instituted that we light the menorah in the shul to publicize the miracle.25:17However, the Beit Yosef, Shulchan Aruch,25:20they explain that25:22a person who is lighting in the shul is not yotzei yedei25:26chovah. It does not fulfill his obligation25:28with the menorah that's being lit in the shul,25:31because the halacha says,25:33ner ish u'veito. Candle has to be with the person's household.25:36The shul, even though you may spend most of your day in shul,25:39or you're learning there, it doesn't make a difference.25:41That's not your household where you sleep. Therefore, you're not yotzei at all.25:44Even if you're the one making the blessings, you're not yotzei yedei chovah at all.25:49And we still make the blessings in the shul.25:51So therefore, tomorrow night, if you're praying anywhere,25:54we're going to have25:56Mincha Arvit. So therefore, we'll pray Mincha first, and then afterwards,25:58when we get up to Arvit, probably after26:01Shekiah, we light the menorah between Mincha and Arvit with a blessing,26:07okay? We already spoke about the location in the shul.26:09We said that it should be in the front.26:10We're going to make tomorrow night three blessings.26:12What are the three blessings? The three blessings26:20are Lehadlik Ner Chanukah, number two is She'asah Nisim, and Shehecheyanu. Whoever is lighting the menorah in shul26:22is going to go home and also light it in the house26:25because, like we said, he's not26:28yotzei dei chovah. Even the people who are listening in the shul26:30and people who are, or even the person himself who is lighting.26:33But here is an important point to keep in mind.26:36If the person in the shul who is lighting the menorah26:40has a family that he's going home and light for them,26:43so he goes back and he repeats all the blessings.26:47He says all three blessings when he gets home,26:49all three26:51berachot. If, however, the person who is lighting in shul26:53is a single person who is living by himself,26:56he's being supported by himself,26:57and he's the one who happened to make the blessings in the shul,27:01then when he goes home and he lights the menorah like he has to,27:04he only makes the first27:08berachah, Lehadlik Ner Chanukah. That's an important halachah to keep in mind.27:11Why is that so?27:13Because we mentioned in the past27:16that the berachah of27:18She'asah Nisim and the berachah of27:20Shehecheyanu, there's a27:22machloket if these blessings were instituted27:24regarding the holiday itself,27:27the holiday of27:28Chanukah. That's why we say the berachah of27:30She'asah Nisim or Shehecheyanu is going on the holiday,27:32or is it going on the mitzvah of lighting?27:36Okay?27:37So because of that, because of this27:40machloket, so if you said the beracha in shul,27:44since according to the opinions that say it's going on the holiday,27:48one blessing per day and you're done.27:50One blessing of Shehecheyanu, you're done,27:52because it's going on the holiday.27:54It doesn't make a difference if you made it in shul27:55or if you make it in the house.27:57So therefore, when you go home,27:59if you have a family, like a wife and kids,28:01so they also have to hear the blessings.28:03You're allowed to make a blessing for them.28:04That's fine.28:04But if you don't have a family,28:07you're living by yourself,28:08you're not lighting for anybody else,28:11so since according to those opinions,28:14Shehecheyanu already covered you for the holiday,28:17even though now you're lighting your candles that are obligated,28:21you're exempt from the blessing of28:26Shehecheyanu, or at least we say28:27safek berachot lehakel, and therefore you do not make the blessing in the house.28:30Now another point to keep in mind28:35about skipping Shehecheyanu and28:36She'asa Nissim: there are times in the shul28:38where you will not make the beracha of She'asa Nissim or28:41Shehecheyanu if it's the first day.28:42When is that so?28:43That's when everybody in the shul attending that moment,28:47that minyan,28:48has already said these blessings.28:52Lemashal, let's take Friday afternoon.28:54Friday afternoon,28:56everybody who comes to shul already has lit,28:58right?28:59It's very hard to find the people who came to shul29:01Friday afternoon29:02to pray Mincha or29:03Arvit and they have not lit in the house.29:05I'm not talking about kids,29:09sefaradim, only one person lights,29:10so the father.29:10But once the father lights,29:12that covers the child also.29:13So I'm not talking about these kids,29:16even though they can be adults themselves,29:1818, 19 years old,29:19if they're living and being supported by their father,29:22they're29:23yotzei yedei chovah with the lighting of their father.29:24So they're considered like they themselves also made the29:26blessing, even if they were not present29:28at the time that the father was lighting.29:30So let's say Friday afternoon,29:31we're lighting the29:32menorah. In that case,29:33you cannot make the bracha of29:36Shehecheyanu. And if it's the first day,29:37which is29:38Shehecheyanu, which is the first day of29:40Chanukah, which is when you have to make29:43Shehecheyanu, you're not going to make the bracha either of29:45Shehecheyanu. Why?29:45Since everybody present in the shul29:48has already said these blessings of29:51She'asa Nissim, Shehecheyanu, so therefore29:53you will skip them29:54and only make the bracha of29:57Lehadlik Ner Chanukah. Another case where this will be relevant30:01is people who have night30:04seders. Baruch Hashem,30:05it's very, very popular here in Brooklyn,30:06and many people,30:08many working people,30:09after a long hard day of work,30:11they dedicate an hour or more30:14to go to local shuls or beit midrash,30:18and they sit there and they learn.30:19And they learn for an hour,30:20and then they pray30:21Arvit. So there's a mitzvah30:23being that you're praying Arvit over there,30:24and there's a group of at least ten people there.30:26Obviously you won't have a minyan without ten people.30:30So therefore there's a mitzvah30:31to light the menorah in that shul again,30:33even though it was lit earlier by30:35Mincha and Arvit, there's still a mitzvah to light it again.30:37So in that case also,30:39before you light the30:40menorah, whoever is lighting the30:41menorah has to make sure30:43that whoever is present there30:48has—whoever is lighting the menorah in the shul30:50has to make sure that30:51those who are present,30:53there's at least one person30:54who did not make the blessing of30:59She'asa Nissim l'avoteinu. If he finds out that everybody there31:01already has already lit in their house,31:03let's say, for example,31:05the night seder is from nine to31:08ten o'clock. People come to learn from nine to31:09ten o'clock, then they pray Arvit at31:11ten o'clock. So most people already have one home31:13lit, and they come to shul.31:15So now you're about to pray31:17Arvit, so you're going to light the31:18menorah, and you ask,31:20Anybody here... Anybody here31:24who has not lit his menorah in the house yet?31:27If you see that everybody says,31:28No, we lit already,31:30so then whoever is lighting31:31only makes one blessing,31:32which is31:34lehadlik ner Chanukah. The bracha she'asa nisim is not said31:36since everybody in the house already said it.31:38Why?31:39For the same reason that we said beforehand.31:40Since31:43she'asa nisim la'avoteinu has a31:43machloket if it's going on the holiday31:45or on31:45the mitzvah, if here already everybody said it,31:48so who are you saying it for?31:50According to the opinion that31:51it's going on the holiday,31:53yatzata yedei chovah, you already fulfilled the obligation,31:54so therefore31:55don't say it.31:56Another small point to keep in mind,31:57that whenever you're lighting in the shul,32:00It's, you have to make sure that there's ten people present.32:03Even if there's not ten people present when you're lighting,32:05but you know that there's ten people are going to come,32:07you can still light the menorah with the32:09beracha. For example, Friday afternoon.32:11Let's say Friday afternoon, you're coming to light the menorah,32:14and you're going to light it before32:15Mincha because you know that by the time you finish32:17Mincha, it's going to already be32:19shekiah, but you don't have a minyan yet.32:21So you're going to start the ketoret, you're going to start,32:22so you have to light now.32:24But you know that by the time you start32:25Ashrei, people will come in,32:26and there's not enough time to wait for ten people to come in.32:28But you know for sure that there's ten people are going to come in,32:32so then you can light it.32:34And even though there's not ten people present,32:36but since you know for sure that ten people will come in,32:38that will cover you.32:41Okay, let's move on now to Halacha32:46Yud Bet. Halacha Yud Bet, Ben Ish Chai talks about the proper oil,32:50the best oil to use,32:51and here we go.32:52Ben Ish Chai says,32:54Shemen zayit mazah min hamuvchar. The preferred oil to use is shemen zayit,33:00extra virgin olive oil.33:02That's the finest and the best oil to use for the33:05menorah. Why?33:06Because that's the same type of oil that was used in the33:10Beit HaMikdash when they lit the menorah over there.33:12And since the miracle that took place in the33:16Beit HaMikdash is what we're commemorating,33:19that the menorah stayed lit for eight days,33:20so therefore we try to emulate it as much as possible.33:23That's why you have to33:25light—not you have to light,33:26but it's preferred to light with shemen zayit33:29zach, to light with extra virgin olive oil.33:32That's the preferred mitzvah.33:33Now, however, the Gemara says33:36any oil is really33:38kosher. Any oil is kosher to use for lighting a33:41menorah, as long as the oil could produce some sort of flame.33:45Any oil, any wick,33:46even though it's not olive oil,33:48doesn't make a difference.33:49Even the ones that we don't use on Shabbat,33:51you're allowed to use it for33:53Chanukah. There's an opinion of the Maharal33:57M'Prague. He writes in his book called33:59Ner Mitzvah—he has a book, beautiful book, Ner Mitzvah,34:01those who love34:03machshava—and towards the second half of the book,34:05it's a very small book,34:06he has a lot of different halachot over there,34:07he writes an interesting thing.34:09He says something that— The Rama doesn't bring that way,34:12but he says that wax candles cannot be used34:16for lighting the34:18menorah. Why?34:19Because in the Beit HaMikdash, what did we use?34:21We used oil.34:23Wax is not oil.34:24How can you light wax?34:25That has nothing to do with the miracle.34:26So he says you can't use wax.34:28The Rama, however, doesn't bring this.34:29The Rama says34:30the minhag is that people do use wax candles,34:33and therefore34:35a person could use wax candles if he has to,34:37if he needs to.34:39You can light with wax candles.34:40The real question is,34:42could you use electricity for menorah or not?34:45Let's say you have an electric34:46menorah. You know, the ones, it looks exactly like a menorah with a plug,34:50and you're plugging it in,34:51and you'll turn the bulb, exactly the number of bulbs to the number of days.34:55The second night, you'll turn two bulbs on.34:57The third night, four bulbs.34:58Could you make the blessing and turn on the bulbs35:00and light with electricity or not?35:02This is pretty much the same discussion35:04that we just mentioned beforehand.35:06There's a lot of35:10theukim from Rishonim and things35:11that the mitzvah has to be,35:14because the mitzvah is a commemoration of the miracle35:16that took place in the Beit HaMikdash.35:19So therefore, you have to light it with things that are similar35:22to the Beit HaMikdash.35:23The miracle took place with oil and wicks,35:27so too you have to light oil and wicks.35:28Electricity—you don't have oil, you don't have wicks.35:31So therefore,35:32you don't have any commemoration of the miracle.35:36Therefore, you cannot use,35:37according to those35:38shitos, you cannot use electricity to be35:42yotzei the chovah. Okay, that's one approach.35:44The other approach is,35:46no, you could use electricity.35:48Why?35:49Because there's a Shut Bet Yitzchak, he brings down,35:51he says that35:53the reason why electricity doesn't work35:55is because it's not recognized.35:56If I put on the light in the house—35:58So since that electricity is giving me light,36:00it's not clear that I'm lighting this for the sake of the menorah.36:04Even if I have a chandelier with all different bulbs,36:07still that chandelier is usually used throughout the year36:09to give me light of the house,36:11and it's not recognized36:12I'm doing it for the sake of Hanukkah.36:14And we know that in Hanukkah,36:16it has to be36:18l'otam bilvad. You can only see them;36:19you're not allowed to benefit from them.36:21So therefore you cannot use it.36:22So Rav Elyashiv writes36:24that if you would use them,36:28if you would, if you, excuse me,36:30if you would have some sort of electric candles36:34that are recognized36:35that they are for the sake of the menorah,36:38that they are for the sake of the mitzvah of Hanukkah,36:42therefore you could use it36:44to be36:47yotzei dei chovah the mitzvah of36:49candlighting. That's the opinion of Rav36:51Elyashiv, and he's not the only one.36:52There's a lot of other big poskim also that hold36:55that you can use electricity for lighting the menorah.36:58However, Chacham Ovadia does not hold that way.37:01Chacham Ovadia says,37:02Chavei brachah l'akel, you should not use it.37:04You should not use electricity,37:06even if you don't have a flame.37:06Not everyone will agree.37:07If you have candles,37:08of course it's better to use candles.37:10And of course, like we said,37:10oil is preferred.37:13And even though the Maharal doesn't like wax candles,37:15but still the37:16minhag is you can still use wax candles,37:18because at least in wax37:20it melts,37:20and then that part which melts,37:22it's very similar to the oil.37:25Electricity, however,37:26even those who hold37:27you can use electricity37:27should be only a last resort.37:29Chacham Ovadia says37:30if you have to use electricity,37:31for example,37:32last week somebody asked a question about a37:34hotel. In a case where you cannot light anywhere in the hotel,37:37and the only place you can light37:38is in the room,37:39but only with electricity,37:41so then use electricity,37:42but without— A37:44beracha, without a blessing,37:46okay?37:46And like we said before,37:47a blessing is not37:49me'akev, so be cautious with the blessing,37:52light without the blessing.37:55The real practical case of this is going to happen,37:59and I'll tell you where this happens.38:00Imagine you're on the plane,38:02you're on an airplane,38:03and you're going to,38:05I don't know,38:05Israel, China,38:06wherever you want38:06to, choose any destination you want.38:08But bottom line is38:09you're flying in the time that it's night38:13and you're unable to light.38:14You can't light in the plane.38:15I guarantee they're not going to let you put flames on the plane,38:18okay?38:18If you somehow try to do it,38:20be careful,38:20you might get arrested38:21and cause a whole big balagan on the news.38:23Anyway, don't do it.38:25So what do you do?38:26In that case,38:27you should take a flashlight with you.38:30I don't know if the one on the phone will work exactly,38:32but it has to be recognized.38:33Take a flashlight38:34and have kavanah that this flashlight38:36should be for the sake of38:40nerot Chanukah. Do not make a blessing,38:42according to38:43Sefardim, you cannot make a blessing.38:43According to38:44Ashkenazim, you can make a blessing,38:45but for us,38:46we hold that you cannot make a blessing.38:47Just put it on for the sake of38:49nerot Chanukah. Now you tell me,38:50what do you mean?38:50It's the fifth night.38:52I'm only lighting one,38:53and we mentioned already38:54the mitzvah of Chanukah is38:56ner ish u'beito. All you need is minimum is one.38:58In such a situation38:59where you're on the plane,39:00I don't think it's so convenient39:01that you're going to carry seven or six,39:04whatever, flashlights,39:05and if you put them on,39:06you might create a whole commotion.39:08So therefore,39:08it's enough to take one flashlight,39:10put it on,39:10and have in mind that that's going to be used39:13for the sake of lighting39:16the mitzvah of39:22Chanukah. Halacha Yud-Gimmel we're going to skip because of the time,39:23and we're going to move on39:25to39:26Halacha Yud-Daled. Halacha Yud-Daled is very simple.39:28The halacha is39:29you're not allowed to use—39:32The candles of the menorah,39:34the flames of the candles,39:35to benefit from them.39:37This is why we light the shamash.39:39The shamash is the extra candle.39:41We have eight nights,39:42and in the menorah39:44they have an extra candle39:45that sticks out39:46that seems to be different.39:48So that's called the shamash.39:50The39:51Shamish, they call it the39:52Ashkenazim. So that candle,39:53let me tell you the background of it.39:55You know, even though technically39:57you don't have to light it39:58according to the real reason.40:00This reason is al pi Kabbalah, but even besides Kabbalah, the minhag also is to light with it.40:06But technically, the Gemara says like this:40:09in a time when you're lighting menorot Chanukah outside, you really don't need a shamash,40:14because the menorah is anyway being lit outside; you have your lights on the inside.40:17However, in a time when you have to light the menorah on the inside, for example, it's scary to light outside,40:21the Gemara says you can light on your table.40:25But in that case, since most people on their tables, that's where they had the chandeliers,40:31and that's where they lit before electricity, that's what they used for light.40:35They used to use the flame. So it doesn't look like you're lighting for the sake of40:39Chanukah. You have to light an additional candle that you could benefit from,40:43and this way everybody will see that the other candles are the candles for the sake of the40:48mitzvah. Okay, that's what the halacha says.40:49That's where the shemosh came from, that since I'm not allowed to benefit from the lights of the40:54menorah, so therefore the shamash is placed there that I should, if I need to benefit, I benefit from the shamash.40:59In our days that we have electricity, our light is coming from electricity.41:04There's no way that we're benefiting from the candles of the41:08menorah. Why? Because the light is coming from electricity.41:11So therefore, technically, we don't need to light a shamash.41:13Somebody told me, what do you mean? What if a guy needs to light a cigarette?41:16A guy needs to light a cigarette; he's not going to use the menorah of41:19Chanukah. What do you do throughout the year? You have your lighter.41:21You go to the gas, you go to the stovetop. You're not going to use the menorah.41:26But in any case, we still light the shamash,41:28whether you want to hold because the reason is Kabbalah or that's the minhag, it doesn't make a difference.41:32We light the shamash, and we should light the shamash, and that's where it comes from, and that's the minhag.41:39When you are setting up the menorah, you'll notice that the stick of the shamash, where the shamash is supposed to be,41:46it sticks out a little bit. It's not exactly aligned with the other candles, most of the41:53menorot. That stick— That shamash should be facing you.41:55The whole idea is that the shamash is coming to serve you, like the word leshamesh, to use.42:00It's coming to service you. So therefore, the shamash, when you're setting up the menorah,42:04should be facing you, not facing the people on the outside.42:07So if you're lighting in your window, the shamash should be in your direction42:12and not to the direction of the people on the outside,42:14because the purpose of the shamash is that it should be serving you.42:18Okay? Halacha tet-zayin, very quickly. People who are blind, let's say the man is blind,42:23his wife should light, and she could light with a beracha, because like we said, women also have the obligation.42:28If he doesn't have a wife and he's living with other people, people who take care of him and they're Jewish also,42:33they should partner up, and in that case the other person should light.42:40If a person is living by himself, he's blind and he knows how to take care of himself,42:44and he's lighting the menorah, he could light but without a blessing.42:50Halacha tet-zayin, and this is a very important42:53halacha. If we just get to this halacha at least, and the next one hopefully,42:57then I'm going to feel very, very relieved. At least we covered the main43:01halachot. Halacha tet-zayin talks about who has to light, okay? Who has to light the menorah.43:09Let's read it inside.43:10The Ben Ish Hai, in his book that was,43:16A child who's living in his parents' house, even though he may be above the age of 13, 18,43:23sometimes, you know, a lot of people live with their parents even much older.43:26As long as they're being supported by their parents, he should not light.43:30It says, Father who lights,43:32okay? That's a very important43:34halacha. Anybody who's single and being supported by his family, by his parents,43:38he's yotzei de chovah with his parents.43:41He does not have the obligation to light, even if he doesn't see his parents lighting it.43:46Preferably, he should stand there during the time that they're lighting.43:49But if the child is not home, the child over here could be, again,43:52anywhere from the age of 13 and above, even if he's 25, 26.43:56If he does not see his parents lighting, it doesn't make a difference.44:02It covers him.44:03His parents' lighting automatically covers him,44:05like the minhag of the Sefardim. It's only one lighting per household,44:11and since this child belongs to this household,44:13he's covered with the lighting of his father, of his parents.44:18However, if a person got married,44:22then he should light in his own room.44:30However, he should not make a bracha. He should just listen and go to his room to light.44:35This is very relevant44:37nowadays. I'll tell you a few cases.44:38First of all, let's start with kids who are growing up in their parents' house.44:44We just mentioned any44:46child—I don't want to use the term44:48child—anybody who's being supported by his parents,44:51okay, even if he's not seeing his parents light,44:56he is yotzei dei chovah. Chacham Ovadia and Rav Shlomo45:00Zalman Auerbach, they both explain that according to the Sefardim minhag,45:04even if the child is not home, he's learning45:07in yeshiva, even if he's many hours away,45:11he does not have the obligation of lighting the menorah,45:15and therefore he's45:17yotzei dei chovah. So, for example, let's say your son is in Israel45:20and he's learning overseas in45:23yeshiva, and over there, you know, tomorrow afternoon45:26when it's, I don't know... Eleven o'clock, 10:30, 1145:30o'clock, everybody's lighting in Israel.45:32So even though you're going to light six hours later,45:35or seven hours later—I think they changed the time also,45:37right?—seven hours later, you're going to light over here in America,45:41the child is yotzei yedei chovah. He does not have to light.45:43He doesn't have to partner up with anybody.45:45In fact, if he doesn't want to watch anybody lighting,45:48he doesn't have to,45:49because since his tuition is being paid for by the parents,45:54he's supported by his parents,45:57he is yotzei yedei chovah. However, the Chacham would yet does point out46:00that if he wants to light on his own,46:02and he doesn't want to be yotzei with his parents' lighting,46:05since he's six, seven hours ahead,46:08what he could do is as follows:46:10if he's in Israel, he can do like this.46:11He can come when it's nighttime for them,46:14which is still daytime for us.46:16For sure his parents haven't lit yet,46:18and he can say, I don't want to be yotzei yedei chovah with my parents,46:20and then he can light even with the blessing over there.46:24However, if your son is learning in yeshiva somewhere here in America,46:27local, or even not so local,46:29even if it's a few hours away from where you live,46:33he cannot do that, because by the time he comes to light,46:36maybe you're also lighting,46:37and therefore he's46:38yotzei yedei chovah. So in such a case, if he wants to light,46:42he can light, but without a blessing,46:43because he's technically covered by his parents.46:46Okay?46:48Another thing,46:51here's a case that happened yesterday.46:53Somebody came up and he asked me a very good question from yesterday.46:57Let's say a person is47:01living—you have a case like47:02this—a person is living with his parents.47:04His mother is47:05in almanah, and she's living with him,47:09but not in his house.47:10He has a house, two floors.47:13He gave one floor to his mother,47:15and he took the main floor.47:17So in such a case, what do you do?47:18How many blessings?47:19So the question is like this:47:21who's supporting the mother?47:23In this case particularly, what happened is,47:26is that the child himself,47:28who's married with his own family,47:30he's supporting his mother.47:32Since he's supporting his mother,47:33even though she has her own house upstairs,47:35he should light his menorah first47:39with a47:40beracha, and have in mind that he's going to cover also her lighting upstairs,47:44and then go upstairs and light for her upstairs47:47without a blessing.47:49Why? Because he's technically supporting her.47:50It's technically one household,47:51because it goes after who's supporting who.47:54So that will be the rule over there.47:56The halacha, the question is,47:58is what happens when...48:00People visit other people for Shabbat.48:03They're going to other people's houses, they're eating and sleeping there.48:07So in such a case, let's take a regular scenario.48:12You have a family. You have the whole family, father, mother, kids, all of them.48:17They're picking up, they're going to, let's say, their parents, their grandparents' house over Shabbat.48:20In such a case also over there, since they're being supported for that whole Shabbat,48:25food and sleeping arrangements, everything is being supported by the host,48:30whoever they're hosting them is, in this case the grandparents.48:33So therefore, technically, you don't even have to partner up with them,48:36because since they're providing them with all their food and shelter and everything else,48:40so obviously they're providing them also with the oil.48:42If you want to be mechaven, if you want to tell them,48:45please have me in mind, give me a matana, or to be mishtatef, you can do that,48:50but an obligation. But min hadin, you don't have the obligation.48:53If you go into your parents' house and they're going to light,48:56yotzei dechovah with your parents' house, even though you're married.48:59But since you're being supported for that Shabbat at least,49:02you're eating and sleeping there,49:03so therefore you don't have the obligation of lighting the menorah.49:08You can be yotzei dechovah with them.49:10If, however, you have a case like this:49:13you're eating by your parents for Shabbat, but you're going back home to sleep.49:17So in such a case, you should make sure to leave your house49:21after plag, light in your house49:25after49:26plag hamincha, and then afterwards walk over and eat your meal by your parents and come back home.49:31Since you're sleeping in the house, in that case you're not exempt.49:34You have to make the bracha even in the house.49:37Okay.49:39Next case.49:45Okay.49:46Here's a good question.49:48We have a question like this.49:51The parents are going away.49:52Up to now, we've spoken about maybe kids coming to visit their parents.49:56Now you have a case:49:58the parents are going away,49:59and they're going away to whatever, they're going on vacation,50:02and their children are still in the house,50:05are staying in the house.50:06And the children over here, we're talking about obviously adults.50:07Nobody's going to leave their little kids in the house by themselves.50:09We're talking about kids who are adults.50:10But of course, the parents are supporting them.50:12So you have kids like 18, 19 years old staying in the50:15house, and the parents are going away on vacation for Chanukah vacation.50:19Who lights and who has to light,50:20and who doesn't have to light?50:22In such a case, the children become the messengers,50:25the shliach of the parents,50:28and from the children lighting,50:31they exempt the parents from the obligation of lighting the menorah.50:34Wherever they are, the parents do not have to light.50:36The kids light for50:38them, and they exempt them.50:40Okay?50:40I see some phone calls.50:42I just want to tell you that I don't have anybody with me here in the station.50:46I have five more minutes.50:46I just want to finish a few points over here,50:49and call right after we finish the program.50:52Five minutes,50:53call afterwards, and I'll answer all your questions.50:55Honestly, I don't even know how to pick up the phone.50:57I know how to pick up the phone,50:58but I don't know if you'll be able to hear me or I'll be able to hear you.51:00So let me just finish off a few51:02halachot, five minutes,51:03okay?51:05Halacha yud-zayin, and then we'll finish the class,51:09be'ezrat Hashem, with this halacha. Next week, just to make an announcement,51:10we'll be back to our regular schedule of Wednesday51:14at 2 o'clock. Halacha hour will be at Wednesday 251:17o'clock, and I won't be so rushed.51:18I'll be a little bit more relaxed.51:19And because next week is still Chanukah,51:22it's the last day of Chanukah,51:23or it's not going to be the last day,51:25but right before the last day.51:27So,51:28be'ezrat Hashem, next week maybe we'll have a special for Chanukah.51:30We'll talk about all the halachot of donuts,51:33whether it's berachot and warming up donuts,51:35and many different interesting subjects, be'ezrat Hashem, next week.51:38Or if you have any questions regarding Chanukah,51:40any questions that you hear over Chanukah,51:42we'll discuss them in detail,51:44be'ezrat Hashem, next week. We'll have a special class.51:46We already should know all the halachot from the classes.51:48Last halacha for today,51:50last halacha technically.51:53Halacha yud-zayin. Important51:53halacha. This din comes from the Maggid Mishneh51:56on the Rambam51:57in Hilchot Chanukah,51:59perek daled, halacha daled. Shnayim o shlosha she-shavu alei batim she-ochlin kol echad bifnei atzmo52:03vedalim yachad. Let's say you have a few people,52:05each one supporting himself,52:07each one's paying for his own foods,52:09but they're sleeping in the same quarters,52:10they're sleeping in the same house.52:13Yishtatef, what should be the din?52:14How, who lights?52:15I'll give you an example.52:16Let's say you have people who are going away52:18and they're renting a hotel room.52:20Each person himself is not married,52:23each one is a single person,52:25and they're supporting themselves,52:27they're not being supported by their parents,52:28they live on their own,52:29and so they're not being52:31yotzei yedei chovah with anybody back home.52:32Now they all happen to fly together,52:34they all go to Israel together,52:35and they're renting a house together.52:38You have three, four people, to make a difference.52:40They're all sharing the house together.52:42What's the din?52:43Who lights according to the52:45Sefardim? So the Beit Yosef says,52:48Yishtatefu befritah. What can they do?52:49What should they do?52:50They should partner up,52:51put their money together,52:52go buy52:54menorah, candles and wicks and oil,52:55whatever you need,52:56and then they should all light it.52:59Kedin haksanai, like the din of a regular53:01haksanai that's brought down in53:04halacha. Vediko echad lelehad beyadav, and each night53:05they should take turns.53:06Not that each person's lighting for himself each night,53:11no.53:11One person's lighting for everybody.53:14Just they should take turns in lighting.53:19That's a din,53:20that's a53:21halacha when you have many people sharing the same quarters.53:23The same thing would be53:27if you have people who are53:31not necessarily also with,53:33what's it called,53:34with single people,53:35but even families.53:36Families are traveling together53:38and they're going away for Chanukah.53:39It doesn't have to be over Shabbat.53:41It could be over Shabbat,53:41it could be anywhere else.53:42They're all coming to share one place.53:43Let's say53:44four siblings,53:45they're all coming with all their families.53:47They're going away for Hanukkah somewhere,53:50and in the place where they're going,53:52they're sharing the same house,53:53so they're sharing the living quarters together.53:55In that case,53:56they make the53:58berachah only one per household,53:59for the54:00Sephardim only one per household,54:01and they should join in together.54:04If they don't want to join together,54:06if each person wants to light on his own,54:09technically they can do so.54:10Technically they can also light each one on his own,54:13his own menorah54:14and his own things.54:14It'll be better if they are mishtatef.54:17Once they're mishtatef, though,54:19one lighting and one54:21berachah, and that's it,54:22okay?54:23You know what?54:24I have two more minutes.54:25Let me just go with the last54:26halachah, squeeze in one last54:29halachah. Halachah yud chet, important halachah also.54:38טוב לתן לאחד מבני הבית הקטנים להדליק בידם נר הנוסף, כדי לחנכם במצוות, שגם בזה הנר הנוסף יש קצת מצוה. Let's say you have children under the bar mitzvah.54:41Children under bar mitzvah54:41don't have the obligation at all to light. And you come in to light your sefaradi, you come in to light and you put your menorah by the window, and you want to light your menorah. If you have little children, of course little children always want to get involved, they want to be involved with everything, and it's fine, you want to let them light,54:56no problem. But you can't let them light any of the lights54:58that they have55:00a chiyuv. You can only allow the children under bar mitzvah55:02to light the candle which is the55:06shamash. All the other candles55:08they may not light since they're under age.55:10Under age55:11means, not because they can cause a fire.55:12That's a different issue.55:13Even the55:14shamash, if they can cause a fire, you can't do.55:15The problem is,55:16because they're not under bar mitzvah,55:18they should not light any of those candles.55:21So the regular question everybody asks:55:23why everybody's going to fight.55:24Everybody's going to fight.55:25You have one candle, everybody's going to fight.55:26Everybody wants to light that candle, the55:28shamash. So then you can do what I do.55:30I hold the candle.55:31I hold my kids' hands,55:32and together we hold the candle together.55:33They say, Come, we're going to hold it together.55:35We're going to light together,55:36and that's55:38it. One, each candle, you could share the candle together:55:41you, the adult, and another child.55:43This is only true for children under bar mitzvah.55:45If you have any children above the age of bar mitzvah,55:48then they can light any of the candles.55:49In fact, they can even light the55:51hayuva. They can make the55:52blessings if you appoint them as a55:53shliach. It's only relevant for the children under bar mitzvah.55:57And with that, we finish today's class.56:00I'm sorry, I rushed a little bit, but we had to cover all the halachot I believe we had to cover.56:04If there's any questions, you could call into the station right now. I'll be staying here for a little bit more,56:08and I'll answer any questions that you have. I don't know if the text is working or not.56:12You can also send any text. Let me give you the56:17number: 718-683-5858. And you can text in your question at56:22347-927-8398. Tonight at 10 o'clock, you'll have the class on again, but that's going to be from last week,56:26and this class will be aired on next week on Tuesday at 1056:33o'clock. And be'ezrat Hashem, we'll see you next week, Wednesday, right before Zos Chanukah.56:38Until then, have a very wonderful day and happy Chanukah.