Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Hanukkah Part 2Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 2Rabbi Uri Nahum · December 2, 2015−15Play+30Position0:0051:32Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to JRoot Radio. This is the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio Live,0:05broadcasting on a week before Hanukkah. We are0:10in the middle of the halachot of Hanukkah, and0:13let's give you the numbers very quickly.0:15Numbers are 718-683-5858, and a text is0:21347-927-8398. As we usually do, we learn from the Ben Ish Chai. However, this time, because of the0:26season, and that is the season of holidays, we always take a break and we cover the halachot of the holidays.0:31In last week's class, we discussed the halachot, or at least we began discussing the halachot of Hanukkah. Be'ezrat Hashem, in today's class,0:39we will0:40discuss the rest of the halachot of Hanukkah.0:42And if you have any questions or comments,0:45usually we like to take them at the end of the class,0:47unless you text and we see that it's not going to be discussed,0:50we'll bring up your question or we'll discuss it, be'ezrat Hashem, over the broadcast. Let's begin,0:58first of all, with the times, the zmanim1:01for Hanukkah. Like we said, we mentioned last week, the dates are this Sunday night, Sunday night, December 6th.1:08We already will be the first night of1:11lighting the menorah. We'll go all the way until the next week, December 13th at night. That's1:19the times of Hanukkah.1:22Okay, now what we need to know, we left off last week at the zman, the best time for a person1:29to light the menorah. When's the best time for a person to light the menorah? And we gave the different shitot, the different opinions.1:36Practically speaking, let's give you the actual times. The rule is that1:43the best time to light is really, to be yotzei all opinions, is to be able to light it about1:5010 minutes.1:52Ten minutes or even before that, ten minutes after1:55sunset, what we know as sunset, and to allow it to light for1:59maybe two hours, let's say, two, three hours, as long as you can. That would be the ideal way.2:05If you light it at that time and you keep it lit all the way till then, you cover all shitot. You're2:10doing mehadrin, mehadrin, mehadrin, mehadrin. That's why it's covered according to2:16all shitot. So2:16if a person doesn't have that option, because sometimes the men come home late, or sometimes, whatever it may be, people are stuck somewhere or whatever,2:24they cannot light. So the best zmanim will be as follows. We listed over here2:29the best times to begin lighting the menorah, to begin lighting the menorah. We listed2:35six different times based on this year's sunset being at 4:29. If you look at the calendar, throughout the whole holiday of2:43Hanukkah, sunset will be around 4:29, and maybe the last couple of days will be2:484:30. But it doesn't make a difference because it's a minute off, and chachamim, even when they gave the2:54shiur, the zman, they went exactly to the second they were talking about,2:57be'erech. So2:58here we've listed the six times. I'm going to read them in order,3:01and if you could light any time, like we've mentioned in the past, between3:084:30 and3:116, 7 o'clock, that's, you know, you pretty much have that range. You could also light all the way until alot hashachar, which is 63:17a.m., right, or 6:09 this year. But still,3:21lechatchila, we're talking about over here the best time, the most preferred time.3:25We're going to list six times in order. Why do I list the six different times?3:30You'll listen to these times, and if you find yourself that, you know what, I can make it by that time,3:35don't think it's too late.3:36For example, let's say you couldn't light at3:394:45, which is what we listed over here as the prime time to be able to light3:44nerot Hanukkah. So don't say, okay, anyway I'm not lighting 4:45, I might as well light3:48at 7, 8 o'clock. No. We give you different times. If you can make it earlier, even better. Why? The numbers are based over here on3:55which opinions you'll be covering. So let's begin. Time number, the preferred time is4:024:45 p.m. Or4:044:50 p.m. Next, if you could light, the best time is number two is if you could light before4:125:15 p.m. Again, this is talking about begin lighting.4:15Next,4:175:20, time number three, level number three is 5:26 p.m. Level number four is4:235:40 p.m. Level five is4:24around 6:10 p.m. And finally,4:29between 7 to 84:31p.m. That still, you could still cover some opinions that might consider this4:36in lechatchila. So therefore, if you know that you come home late anyway,4:40but you could squeeze yourself, you could push yourself that you could come home maybe before4:447 or 8 o'clock, then you should push yourself for that.4:47Don't think that anyway I'm coming home late, might as well light at4:499. No, no. If you come home, make it before 7 or 8 o'clock, it's still very good.4:52But of course,4:53min ha'ikar hadin, if you want to light as late as4:576:09, not you want to, if you find yourself in the situation where you must light before that time,5:036:09, then especially here in New York City or in the big cities, people are still passing by, you could light with a blessing5:11without a problem. Okay, now today's class we're going to discuss5:15much more practical than—I mean, the whole class was practical—but today we will be discussing in this class5:22the setup of the menorah,5:24exactly how to light with the berachot, and then we'll talk, be'ezrat Hashem, about the special cases that5:30often come up, the most common questions that come up on Chanukah, and some pointers that many people may overlook5:37if they're not knowledgeable with the halachot of Chanukah. Let's begin5:41with setting up the menorah. You should know, first of all, that there's a halacha. The halacha tells us the rule.5:46This is a general rule. We have mitzvot that the time—5:51To perform these mitzvot is in the daytime, daytime being lechatchila from sunrise,5:57that's called6:00zman netz hachamah, until sunset, until the nighttime. For example, tefillah,6:05although it comes earlier, but, you know, praying, we have Mincha or Arvit—I mean Mincha or6:10Shacharit. You have also, like, Brit Milah, lulav. Those mitzvot6:14are mitzvot that should be done in the daytime; they cannot be done at night.6:19Then there's mitzvot that should be done at night, like Kriat Shema in the6:23evening, you have6:25Sefirat HaOmer. So the rule is as follows: any mitzvah which has a time to be done, to be performed at night,6:31when the zman comes, when the time of night comes,6:35you're not allowed to eat or do melachah before you perform the mitzvah, like Kriat Megillah,6:44Sefirat HaOmer, hadlakat ner Chanukah in our case,6:46Kriat Shema. You're not allowed to eat6:50when the time comes. Not only when the time comes, but a half an hour before the zman, a person is forbidden in doing6:59melachah or eating. Now we have to define what does it mean to eat or to do7:04melachah before7:05performing the mitzvah. Let's take the example that's at hand, which is the7:10lighting of the menorah.7:11If you haven't lit your menorah, you cannot have a seudah. What does it7:15mean you cannot have a seudah? You cannot have a meal. You could eat, you could drink, you could even eat bread up to two ounces,7:21but that's only up to two ounces. Less than that,7:24more than two ounces, it's forbidden. That's what it means to have a7:28seudah. Chachamim were scared that you might get carried away with your seudah and forget yourself.7:32So therefore, if a husband—and this applies only on the person who has the obligation of lighting.7:37So by the Sefardim, where only the man has the obligation of lighting, the man of the house,7:42so if he comes home late from work, he comes home—even not late from work—he comes home 6, 77:47p.m., he says, Honey, I'm exhausted. What a day I had. Please let me have the shawarma sandwich. Shawarma sandwich,7:53that's with bread, that's more than a kebeitzah, that's more than two ounces. In that case,7:57he cannot have the sandwich, but he could give—8:00From rice, give him some fruits, give him some water to drink, no problem, even some coke.8:04That's not a problem. The only problem is to have a seudah with bread, which is two ounces.8:09Also, melacha, when we said a person cannot do any melacha before lighting the menorah,8:14we're referring to here melachot that take time,8:17not melachot of Shabbat. Melachot of Shabbat include putting on a light, lighting a cigarette, and such.8:23Melachot that are forbidden before performing a mitzvah whose time is at night8:30means melachot that take time, like laundry, building, other things like that.8:36The husband comes home, he sees that the front gate of his house has fallen,8:40and he wants to go now and fix it. He says, Hold on, it's menorah, it's time for8:46Chanukah. You have to light the menorah, and then you can do your melacha.8:48Melachot that take time are forbidden.8:51And again, this only applies to the person who has the obligation to light.8:54So kids that come home from yeshiva, and they're waiting for their father to get home,8:59and they're home at six o'clock, and their father is not going to come home till9:03seven, they're allowed to eat. They're allowed to eat seudah with bread. Why?9:06Because it's not their obligation to light; it's the obligation of the father.9:10He's the baal habayit. The child is סמוך על שולחן אביו. He is completely taken care of by his father,9:16and he doesn't have to worry about such a thing.9:19Okay, that's an important, I guess, introduction to setting up for the menorah.9:26Now, setting up for the menorah, we already explained,9:29you have to place your menorah lechatchila by the front door of your house,9:34or the front of the entrance of your house, which could be the front of your yard,9:38or as some put it in the window.9:40In both cases, where do you actually place the menorah?9:43So in the window, it's very simple.9:45You take the menorah, you put it in the window facing the street that you want it to... So you want to view it that people should see it from there,9:55and that's it. You put it in the window, and pretty simple.9:58And afterwards you put the candles and you light.10:01When it comes to putting a menorah in the door, it's a little bit more complicated.10:04The halacha should be as follows.10:06First of all, face your house with your back towards the street and look at your front door.10:10Next, I guess, like virtually divide the door in half,10:17and then the left side of the door, assuming that you have a mezuzah on the right side of the door,10:23the left half of the door, in that half is where you're supposed to set up your menorah.10:28There's a machloket over here exactly where you place it in this half,10:33but the minhag and most opinions hold that you take the menorah and you place it,10:38the whole entire menorah, you place it all the way to the edge by the left corner.10:45I mean to say by the left side of the doorpost. That's where the menorah is supposed to be.10:49However, when it comes to setting up the actual candles,10:53you start setting it from the most right stick of the menorah,11:00the branches of the menorah that are in front of you. You begin to light from the extreme right.11:06Even though the menorah itself is set up in the left part of the doorway,11:12the lighting begins from the extreme right, or at least the setting up for the candles.11:17Now this is all for the first night.11:18You set up by placing the first candle all the way on the extreme right of the menorah.11:24By the way, the same thing will be if your menorah is facing the street,11:28but it's placed in front of your window,11:31and therefore you're standing facing the street to light your menorah11:34also. You're going to always set up the candle, at least on the first night,11:38in the extreme right of the menorah.11:41And of course, on the first night you come, you should bring your whole family together.11:46Me'ikar hadin, as long as the husband or the leader of the household,11:50or if the leader appointed somebody, as long as they light that in the house,11:56nobody has to be there technically.11:58But of course, lechatchila, preferable is to get the whole family together,12:02bring the kids, bring the wife, bring everybody out. Bring your maid12:08even—no, I'm12:09kidding—but bring everybody and let them come to light or to observe the lighting of the menorah.12:16How do you light the menorah? Very simple.12:18You make the three berachot, which are,12:21Asher kideshanu b'mitzvotav v'tzivanu l'hadlik ner12:26Chanukah. Ashkenazim have a little bit of a different text over here.12:28They say, l'hadlik ner shel12:30Chanukah. We say, l'hadlik ner Chanukah, only three words, l'hadlik ner12:34Chanukah. That's the first blessing.12:35Second berachah is,12:37Baruch atah Hashem Elokeinu melech ha'olam, she'asah nisim la'avoteinu bayamim hahem bazman hazeh.12:41And finally, the third berachah is, on the first night that is,12:44Shehecheyanu v'kiyemanu v'higianu lazman hazeh, the famous berachah of12:48Shehecheyanu, which is going to be recited on the first time that you're lighting the menorah.12:52Clear? Good.12:54So that's how we're going to light on the first night.12:56That's pretty simple.12:58It becomes complicated now in the setup, at least13:01in the setup, on the second night or on the third night.13:05What do you do then?13:06So the halachah is going to be the same,13:07whether you're lighting with your menorah facing the street,13:10which means you're placing it by the window,13:12or whether you're placing the menorah outside of your house.13:16Either way—by the way, those who are lighting outside their house,13:20your back should be towards the street13:22and you should be facing your house,13:24and that's how you should light menorah.13:25Not that you're standing inside the house and lighting,13:28unless, unless you have a— Door,13:32it's, you know, the glass door. Sometimes in front of the front door,13:35they have another screen door,13:37and sometimes it's made out of glass,13:39so you want to put it in the glass.13:40So it's like a big window, basically.13:42Then you're obviously lighting from the inside of your house.13:44In any case where you are lighting outside the house,13:48where the actual menorah is physically outside of your house,13:51outside your door, that is,13:52you'll be facing the house,13:54but you'll always set up, like we said, to your extreme right.13:58The next night, the second night,14:00and the same will be for every single night,14:02you'll add, you'll put the candle again in the extreme right,14:07and you'll always add an additional candle to the left of that.14:11Meaning to say, on the second night,14:13you're going to set up two candles:14:15the one that you set up from last night,14:18which is on the extreme right,14:19and then the new additional candle for the second night14:22you're going to place right next to it.14:24So therefore, you'll be lighting two candles for the second night.14:30Where do you begin from?14:31You begin from the new one that you just added that night,14:35which is from the left.14:36You're going to light from the left and go towards the right.14:38In general, that's the direction we want to take14:43in performing14:45mitzvot. You begin from the left and you go towards the right,14:47as Gemara tells us in14:48Yoma, Kol pinos she'ata poneh lo yihyu ela derech yamin.14:51You should always turn towards the right.14:54So you begin from the left and go towards the right,14:55like the way we write English.14:57How would you write in English?14:58Thank you very much.15:00You begin the T on the left15:01and you write the H to the right of it,15:04and the A to the...15:05That's the same way you're going to light on every single night.15:07You're going to begin all the way with the one on the left15:10that you set up new for that night,15:12and after the15:15berachot, you'll... Light, the one on the extreme left,15:18wherever it may be set up,15:20and then you go towards the right.15:22Here the poskim bring a point15:23that you should stand next to the candle15:26that you're planning to light first.15:28Don't stand far from it,15:29so this way you avoid another problem in15:31halacha known as in15:33ma'avirin al hamitzvot. Fine.15:35This is how a person lechatchila is supposed to light,15:38whether he's standing on the outside15:40lighting his menorah,15:42standing outside his door,15:44or whether he has his menorah in the front of his window.15:47You're always going to start with the15:48left and go towards the right.15:54Now, sometimes15:56what could happen is15:57that a person may forget to say the berachot.16:01Remember, on the first night you're making16:02two berachot; the rest of the holiday you're only making two16:04berachot. You're skipping Shehecheyanu because you already made it.16:07What would happen if a person forgot to say the16:10berachot and he remembered in the middle of16:12lighting? So we have a few possibilities.16:15We have three situations, basically, that a person could find himself in.16:19Number one is that in the middle of his lighting,16:22he remembers that he didn't make the16:23berachot, which means before completing all the candles.16:28All the candles, by the way,16:29what I'm referring to over here is not the16:32shamash. The candles I'm referring to over here,16:34the candles that one is going to light with the16:37hidur that's for that night.16:38Meaning to say, on the third night where you're lighting three candles,16:41you're really going to light four16:43because it's an additional candle known as a16:45shamash. The shamash we're not dealing with right now.16:46We're dealing specifically with the candles that are for the holiday,16:52which are the three candles.16:53If a person started lighting16:56and before, let's say on the third night,16:58before lighting the third candle,17:00he remembers,17:01Oy, I forgot to make a17:03berachah. What do you do in such a case?17:05In such a case,17:06since you're still in the middle of lighting the candles,17:09so you can even make all the blessings.17:11You can make the berachah of17:15lehadlik ner Chanukah, as well as17:17she'asa nisim la'avoteinu. Why? Because you're still involved in the lighting,17:19even though you already lit the ikar.17:21We already mentioned17:22the main mitzvah,17:23the main part of the mitzvah17:24is one candle.17:25Technically, you can be17:27yotzei yedei chovah even lighting one candle.17:29Still, the hidur is considered part of the mitzvah,17:31and you can still make the blessing of17:36lehadlik ner Chanukah. However, if a person already completed lighting all the three candles,17:42even though he did not light the shamash yet,17:44it's then too late to say the first17:46berachah, which is17:49lehadlik ner Chanukah. According to the Rama, you could.17:50According to Ashkenazim, you have what to rely on.17:52However, by the17:53Sefardim, we're very machmir on that.17:55We hold that once you finish lighting,17:57you cannot say the bracha of17:58lehadlik ner Chanukah; you're already finished lighting.18:01And therefore,18:02you could not say the bracha of18:05lehadlik, but you could say the other blessing,18:07which is,18:12שעשה ניסים לאבותינו בימים ההם בזמן הזה, as long—here's a18:14condition—as long as it's within a half an hour of18:17lighting. Meaning, let's say you began lighting at 518:22p.m. You lit your menorah at 518:24p.m., and you remembered at18:265:05, five minutes after you finished complete lighting,18:28you're already18:30saying Ma'oz Tzur, Yehotzi, and then you're looking at your18:32video—you know, today, im lo18:35tzalem lo yatza. Every single event that we do,18:36we have to take a selfie,18:37we have to take a video of ourselves18:38and post it somewhere.18:40So you're doing chazarah on your video18:42that you just lit your menorah,18:44and then you realize,18:45Oh, I did not make a18:47bracha. You rewind again, you do a replay again,18:49you bring the referees, and you see,18:51I did not make a18:52bracha. So in that case,18:54since you're within a half an hour of the mitzvah,18:58meaning to say within a half an hour of when you lit,19:00you could still make the bracha of19:03שעשה ניסים לאבותינו. It's an important halacha to keep in mind.19:05It's not too late to say the bracha of19:08שעשה ניסים לאבותינו as long as you're within the half an hour.19:10Of course, it goes without saying19:12that's only if a person forgot.19:13If a person didn't forget,19:15if a guy said it19:16and he just wants to say it again,19:17even on somebody else's candles,19:18it doesn't work.19:19How come a person could say the bracha of19:24שעשה ניסים לאבותינו בימים ההם בזמן הזה after he lit?19:25And the answer is because this blessing19:28is going on the lights of the menorah.19:30It's not going on the mitzvah of taking action.19:33Like, for example,19:33להדליק נר חנוכה, you're saying,19:36אשר קדשנו במצוותיו וציוונו. He commanded us to light.19:38Once you finish lighting,19:39you can't make the bracha anymore.19:40But— The beracha of19:44she'asah nissim la'avoteinu is going on the nerot of19:47Chanukah, and since the nerot of19:50Chanukah are a mitzvah only within a half an hour,19:52so therefore I'm only given that first half an hour19:54to make a beracha in case I forgot.19:57By the way, this also applies19:59on the first night if a person forgot to say his blessings.20:02He can even say20:04Shehecheyanu as long as he's saying the20:08berachot within the 30 minutes20:09that he himself lit.20:12I mean to say,20:13he started—I'll give you an example.20:15He lit at 520:16o'clock. At 5:15 he realized he didn't say any of the20:19berachot, Lehadlik ner Chanukah he can't say.20:21However,20:23she'asah nissim la'avoteinu or Shehecheyanu you could say.20:24Even if you said20:26Lehadlik, you forgot to say the other two20:28berachot, you could still say the other20:32berachot as long as you're within 30 minutes of when you lit.20:36Now we're on the subject.20:37I'll tell you another interesting20:38halacha that's connected to this 30 minutes.20:41As we all know, the candles have to last20:42for at least 30 minutes of when you lit.20:46That's the mitzvah.20:48That's the way the Gemara is interpreted20:50by the Rosh, the Rif, and the Rambam.20:53There's a halacha that tells us,20:56a very interesting20:57halacha—we don't find this halacha by other20:59mitzvot—is that let's say a person is away.21:02He's not lighting.21:04Even though he's not lighting,21:05he could still make the21:08berachot of21:09she'asah nissim la'avoteinu, and if it's the first night,21:10he could even say21:13Shehecheyanu. However, this halacha, this21:16din, only applies if you have21:18all of the following four conditions.21:20You need four conditions,21:22and you need all of them.21:23If you don't have one of these conditions,21:25it doesn't apply.21:26What are the four conditions21:28in order to make the21:29beracha of21:31she'asah nissim la'avoteinu? And shehecheyanu on the first night,21:32but if it's the rest of the21:33holiday, you can mix Shehecheyanu and Nes nesim21:37la'avoteinu. Condition number one is21:38that you have not lit yet.21:40You have not lit21:40and you have not heard the21:42berachot from anybody yet.21:43That's condition number one.21:44Which means if you are in a shul,21:46this doesn't apply, right?21:47We're talking about that21:48you didn't light yet21:49and you did not hear the21:53berachot from anybody.21:54Condition number two:21:55you're not planning to light,21:57which means you left work21:58at around six22:00o'clock, you're driving on the highway,22:01you look over22:01and you see all the buildings22:03with the menorah over there.22:04You haven't lit yet.22:06Nobody has lit for you either,22:08and you see the22:10menorah. It doesn't make a difference.22:10You don't make a22:11berachah. Why?22:12Because you're going to be home soon22:13and you're planning to light.22:15So therefore, in that case22:17also, the condition22:19in order to make the22:20berachah has to be that you have not lit22:23and you're not planning to light.22:24For example, you're stuck in traffic.22:27They made an announcement,22:29Ladies and gentlemen,22:30we apologize. On the highway,22:31we're closing the highway.22:31You're going to be here all night.22:32Prepare, you know, your sleeping hours,22:34whatever it is.22:35You're going to be stuck on the highway.22:36Only in that case.22:37Number three, condition number three:22:39nobody's going to light for you.22:40If you have a wife at home,22:42if you have somebody22:43who you're appointing22:44to light for you in the house,22:46this halachah also doesn't apply.22:48You need to not have lit.22:50You need to plan22:52that you're not going to light that night,22:54and also nobody's lighting for you.22:56Condition number three,22:57in order to make the22:58berachah, shehecheyanu, by seeing other people's candles,23:01is that you must make the23:04blessing within 30 minutes of when they lit.23:07Meaning, let's say you're a person23:09who doesn't, you know,23:10you don't have a house,23:11you're wandering around,23:13you're not living anywhere.23:14And I'll just give you an example.23:16I don't know,23:16you came from a different city.23:18You're not anywhere.23:19Your parents are not lighting for you23:21because you're23:23self-supported. You pay for your own bills for everything.23:25Your parents don't give you a penny,23:27and nobody's lighting for you in the house.23:29That's condition number one.23:29You have not lit yet.23:31You have not been in shul.23:32That's condition number two.23:34Number three is23:35you're not planning to23:35light because you have no home to light in it.23:37That's condition number three.23:38If you want to make the23:38berachah by seeing other people's23:40nerot, make sure that it's within 30 minutes23:42of when they lit.23:43So if you know that guy just lit,23:45so you can make a23:46berachah. If you don't know,23:47safek, maybe.23:48Or how about this?23:49If you're within a half an hour of23:51shkiah, so you know for sure23:53that these people obviously23:55must have lit it within a half an hour,23:57and then and only then,23:58with all these four conditions.24:00You can make the bracha of she'asah nissim la'avoteinu on the rest of the nights,24:06and if it's on the first night, you can also make the bracha of24:11shehecheyanu. Now, here's an important point.24:13If for some reason, all of a sudden, your mazal changes and all of a sudden24:18you find yourself that you have the ability to light that night after you made these24:23brachot, when you come to light that night, you do not make a blessing of she'asah nissim la'avoteinu anymore24:28because you already made it.24:29But you will make the blessing of lehadlik ner Chanukah because you're coming to light it right now,24:35and that's the blessing that you make when you're coming to perform the mitzvah of lighting.24:40Fine?24:41Okay.24:42Now, on this point, we want to clarify a little bit.24:46There's a machloket amongst the24:48Acharonim if the bracha of she'asah nissim la'avoteinu and shehecheyanu is going on the holiday24:55or is it going on the mitzvah of lighting.24:58In general, the Gemara tells us a bracha of zman, which is the bracha of25:03shehecheyanu, is when we say it on a holiday, it's going on the holiday.25:06For example, Sukkot, we make the bracha of shehecheyanu on kiddush.25:10Pesach, we make the bracha of shehecheyanu on kiddush.25:13What else do we have?25:14Rosh Hashanah, we make the bracha of shehecheyanu on kiddush.25:18Yom Kippur, we make the bracha of shehecheyanu by Kol Nidre.25:24So when it comes to the holiday of Chanukah, we also make a shehecheyanu. The25:28question is, what are we making shehecheyanu on?25:30Are we making it on the holiday of25:33Chanukah, or no? Do we make the bracha of shehecheyanu on the mitzvah of lighting the menorah?25:38Like, for example, any mitzvah that a person does once a year,25:41we know the rule: you make a bracha of shehecheyanu on it.25:43So there's a machloket in the Acharonim where it's going on,25:45so we... Take this25:48halacha lechumra. So, in the case where a person already made the bracha of25:53Shehecheyanu, in the case where a person already made the bracha of25:57Shehecheyanu or25:59שעשה ניסים לאבותינו, if he finds himself in a situation again where he's gonna light,26:04then you don't make a bracha of שעשה ניסים לאבותינו or26:07Shehecheyanu. We just gave one example.26:09A person was not planning to light, he has not lit,26:12he didn't have in mind that he's gonna light,26:13so in that case he already made Shehecheyanu or26:16שעשה ניסים, then we tell him not to make it when he's lighting again.26:19Here's another situation,26:20and this is very important for people to keep in mind.26:22The minhag of lighting in the shul,26:24we said as long as there's a tefillah of26:25Arvit. Sometimes you have26:27night seder, and people come to learn at night,26:29let's say from eight to nine, nine to ten, whatever it may be,26:32and afterwards they have Arvit, they have26:34Maariv, and then they're gonna light again,26:35as the minhag is to light in the shul when you're praying.26:37When you're coming to light again,26:39if everybody already made the bracha of26:41שעשה ניסים, you don't make the bracha again.26:43Why? Because you already said it.26:45However, if there's even one person in the shul,26:48even one person in the shul,26:50who has not lit yet,26:52and therefore he has not said bracha of26:54שעשה ניסים, and nobody has lit for him,26:56then you can make the bracha of26:59שעשה ניסים, even if that person himself is not lighting.27:01As long as there's one person in the kahal27:02who has not said the bracha of27:05שעשה ניסים, or people have not said it for him,27:07meaning to say he was not yotzei with his wife lighting27:09or his parents lighting for him,27:12then whoever is27:14lighting, that is anybody who is lighting the menorah in the shul,27:17could say bracha of27:18שעשה ניסים. However, in the case where everybody already made the bracha of27:22שעשה ניסים, or if it's the first time where everybody already made the bracha of27:25Shehecheyanu, you cannot make these blessings in the shul.27:28This will apply especially on Erev Shabbat.27:30We light the menorah in shul on Erev Shabbat,27:33but whoever is coming to shul on Erev Shabbat,27:34they already prayed—excuse me—they already lit the menorah in their house,27:39so you can't make bracha of שעשה ניסים in the shul.27:42And if it's the first time that you're lighting,27:44if it's the first night of Chanukah,27:46you can't make the bracha of Shehecheyanu either,27:48because these blessings were already said by the whole congregation.27:55I want to jump a little bit to special cases.27:59Because of the time that we have left,28:01I want to go to special cases that come up on28:07Hanukkah, and here we have many, many questions28:09exactly what to do in these special cases28:11on28:14Hanukkah. And if we have extra time, we'll come back to the minhagim.28:17Erev Shabbat.28:19How do we light menorah on Erev Shabbat?28:21So we mentioned already any mitzvah that the time is supposed to be done at night,28:25you have all the way up to28:29plag hamincha. Not, you know, I mean to say you could perform the mitzvah as early as28:32plag hamincha, like28:33Arvit. Technically, according to some opinions, right?28:35You have up from28:37plag hamincha. Maran is posek, Shulchan Aruch is posek in Shulchan Aruch,28:41that you could light as early as28:45plag hamincha when it's very necessary.28:47Erev Shabbat, Friday night,28:49you can't light the menorah, right?28:52So therefore it's very necessary that we light by28:56plag hamincha. That means to say before sunset,28:58because after sunset you're going to have major problems with Shabbat.29:01So therefore, Erev Shabbat,29:02we light the menorah.29:04You could begin lighting it as early as29:08plag hamincha. That's the earliest time you could light it.29:10Here, however, the Acharonim, the poskim bring down,29:12lechatchila a person should try29:14to first pray Mincha and then to light.29:16So most people will have29:19Mincha gedolah on Erev Shabbat when it's Hanukkah.29:22This way you avoid the problem of29:25tartei de-satrei. That's the29:26lechatchila. If a person didn't pray29:27Mincha, he can still light the menorah. He can still light the menorah29:30and then after go to shul to pray29:32Mincha. But that's only29:33b'diavad. Lechatchila, he's supposed to pray Mincha beforehand.29:36Next. When coming to light,29:38you have two29:39mitzvot. You're going to light the menorah,29:40and you're going to light also Shabbat candles.29:42It's also brought down29:43lechatchila. If a person himself is lighting the Shabbat candles,29:47he should first light the menorah29:50and then light the Shabbat candles.29:52Why? Because we want to cover the opinion of the Baal HaGah who holds29:54that if you are lighting,29:56that means you as a lady,29:57she's lighting the Shabbat candles,29:59you already accepted Shabbat.30:00And if you accepted Shabbat,30:01how could you light the menorah?30:04Even though30:05lehalacha we don't hold like the30:06Baal HaGah; at least30:07the Sefardim don't hold like the30:08Baal HaGah. A lot of people could be30:09machmir. A lot of people try to be machmir like30:12Baal HaGah, which is excellent.30:13But halacha, Maran doesn't hold like the30:15Baal HaGah. But still, by30:17Nerot Chanukah lechatchila, a person should try to avoid that problem,30:19which means first30:21light the menorah30:22and then afterwards30:23light the Shabbat candles.30:24In case where it was done reverse,30:25especially if your wife is the30:26one who lit the Shabbat candles first30:28and you haven't lit the menorah yet,30:30you could still light the menorah30:32after the Shabbat candles.30:34It's not30:35lechatchila, but you could still do it.30:37Another point to keep in mind30:38when lighting30:39ערב שבת, because we're lighting early,30:40the candles must last30:42all the way30:4430 minutes after30:48tzeit hakochavim, whatever you hold that tzeit hakochavim is.30:50But make sure you put enough oil,30:52or if you're using wax candles,30:53they're big enough30:54that you should allow it to last30:56for 30 minutes30:58after31:00tzeit hakochavim. If they shut off before that time31:02for a reason that was unexpected,31:06me'ikar hadin, you don't have to put it back on.31:08But of course,31:09if it's not Shabbat yet,31:11תבוא עליו ברכה, the poskim give a blessing to a31:13person who puts back these candles,31:15puts on the candles again.31:16Now this happens a lot.31:19A person's menorah shut off,31:20meaning to say it's already Friday night,31:23the menorah candles already has been shut off,31:25and now he wants to move the menorah.31:27This happens in the shul,31:28this happens in other places.31:30Could you move it or not?31:31So here we have a machloket Ashkenazim,31:34Sefardim. Ashkenazim hold that's it.31:36Since it came in as31:37muktzeh, it remains as31:38muktzeh. According to the31:39Sefardim, Maran writes,31:41you can make it condition.31:42You can make31:43a tenai. You can make a condition that31:45when the candles shut off the menorah,31:48I want to be able31:50to move my menorah.31:51However, over here31:52some poskim point out31:54that the menorah now31:55is not mutar to just move.31:57It becomes a31:58kli שמלאכתו לאיסור because it's made to—32:00Light on it. So therefore, in such a case, if you want to move your menorah, if it's in your way and you made the condition so you could pick it up and move it.32:08If it's not in your way, stam you want to move it, so then you don't have such a32:13heter. So in that case, you'll have to do what the Ashkenazim do if they want to move their menorah, and that is put the menorah on a tray,32:20and on the same tray that you have the menorah standing, put also a loaf of32:24bread. It has to be a chashuv; it should be an important-looking piece.32:29And then you could pick up the tray together with the challah or the bread and the menorah and move it to wherever you wish.32:36Motzaei Shabbat, when we come to light candles on Motzaei Shabbat, first we do the reverse in the house.32:43First we do Havdalah, and then we light the menorah,32:45as opposed to the shul, where we first light the menorah and then we do Havdalah, because once you do Havdalah, everybody's running out,32:51right? So then we got to make sure that everybody sees the lighting of the menorah so we could publicize the miracle more.32:57For those men that go to classes on Motzaei Shabbat, which is highly recommended and they should do it all the time,33:03even on Motzaei Shabbat, if you have a class, even on Motzaei Shabbat Chanukah, you should not interrupt your regular learning.33:13That is, if you have a fear that you're not going to come back.33:16Sometimes some shuls, what they'll do is they'll tell everybody, Go home and come back.33:19If there's a fear that the guys, once they get home—you know how it is when you get33:23home—this one wants this one, and you're going to run to do this, and33:25before you know it, you completely forgot yourself and you didn't light the menorah.33:35You're already stuck in the house; you're not going to come back to class.33:38So in that case, we tell you, don't leave the shul before your class.33:42It's okay, you can light later. It's okay anyway you're lighting later33:45because it's Motzaei Shabbat. Stay by your class; that's shiur tamud Torah33:51is kavua, and then you could go to the house to finish lighting your menorah.33:56Okay, now we have three categories that we want to speak about.34:02Category number one is kids and lighting.34:05Kids and lighting. All the halachot are pertaining to children and lighting.34:09By the Ashkenazim, the children light themselves.34:13At what age? I could train them as young as they want,34:16but usually when they get to the age of chinuch, each child lights with34:20a beracha. The question is, what could we do34:22about Sefardim? What would you say if the children now want to light their own menorah?34:27So Abba is lighting a menorah, Daddy is lighting a menorah,34:29and now the children also want to light their own menorah.34:32Could they do it, and could they do it with a blessing or not?34:35So let's go through all the cases.34:37If the children, whoever that child that wants to light,34:40is under the age of chinuch, which is around the five or six,34:43he's under the age of five or six,34:45then you can let him. Chacham Ovadia says you can let him light even with the34:50beracha. Sefardim, yeah, it's not hurting anybody. He's too young.34:53It's okay, he can light with the beracha. If he's excited, he came home from playgroup or34:56pre-1A and he has this menorah, he's excited, you can let him light even with the beracha. It's fine.35:01If the children are above the age of chinuch, when they already understand,35:04they're above the age of five or six,35:07then you can let them light. There's no problem to let them light,35:09but you should tell them not to make a35:13beracha. If the children, however, are going to make the beracha anyway,35:16don't make a fuss about it. Don't make a big fight about it.35:18The poskim that permit the children to make their own35:22beracha, being that they're ketanim, even though they're35:25Sefardim, we don't do it, it's fine if they are very insistent on it.35:29You can let them light and even make a beracha if they're very insistent on it.35:32Lechatchilah, you should tell them not to light.35:34If they don't understand, even if they light with the beracha, that's fine.35:38Above the age of bar mitzvah, you should really not tell— you should tell them they shouldn't light,35:43because our minhag is that we each light our own. You know, we light one menorah per family.35:48But if they still want to light, then they cannot make a35:52beracha. And if they want to light also,35:55their menorah has to be standing in a place which is completely recognizable35:58that it's not part of your menorah.36:00So if they want to light in a different part of the house, it's fine,36:04but they should not make a blessing.36:06Preferably, again, nobody should have only one menorah,36:09but if they want to light, it's fine. It doesn't hurt anybody,36:12even above the age of bar mitzvah, as long as they don't make a36:16beracha. Next, a lot of families, as we did also growing up,36:21what happens is, and we do it the same without children,36:24is that let's say it's the fourth night.36:26So you have five candles set up:36:29four for the nerot of Chanukah and one for the36:31shamash. So a lot of families would do the following.36:34That's the Sefardim, of course. Ashkenazim, you know, they have their own way.36:36The Sefardim will come. The father will make the berachah, all the36:40berachot. He'll light the first candle,36:42and after he lights the first candle, he gives it over to his wife to light the second.36:46And then you have, what is it, fourth night, you have three candles left.36:49You have two candles from the mitzvah of Chanukah36:52and then one which is the36:54shamash. So the kids also want to participate. They also want to light.36:57Here you have to be careful.36:58The Ben Ish Chai light says that if you want to let the children under the age of bar mitzvah37:03or bat mitzvah light or participate in the lighting of the menorah,37:08if they're under age, they can only light the37:12shamash. They cannot light any of the other candles.37:14That means on the fourth night, all four candles must be lit by an adult,37:18whether the adult is your son, your daughter, it doesn't make a difference.37:21It has to be done by an adult.37:23So what do you do when the kids really want to light,37:25and it's not like you have only one kid that you can let him light the37:28shamash. You have, bli ayin hara, six, seven kids, and they all want to light,37:31and you don't have enough candles.37:32So first of all, lechatchilah they should not light.37:37Like we said, Ben Ish Chai and many other37:39Acharonim are oser. Even seems to be the Chacham Ovadia held this way as well.37:42But what you could do is you could hold on to their hands,37:47put the candle in their hand that they're planning to light with it,37:50and hold on to their hands and together light the37:54menorah. So this way, the ikar, the main part of the lighting is really taking place by you.38:00If the children are very insistent and they're going to make a whole big ruckus in the house38:04and they're going to really, really flip out38:06and there's no way to calm them down,38:08so you don't have to ruin your holiday.38:10Yesh al mi lismoch. You have Rav Chaim Palachi.38:13Rav Chaim Palachi says if the children light the ner that's hidur mitzvah,38:18not the first candle that the father is making a berachah on,38:22but the other candles, he's38:24matir it. Lechatchilah, Ben Ish Chai is oser and other Acharonim are38:27oser, but if one is somech on Rav Chaim Palachi, especially if he's Turkish,38:31yesh lahem al ma38:34lismoch. Now, a common question that's also asked are,38:37must the kids be around during the time of lighting38:41menorah? We just mentioned, bring your kids, it's very nice.38:43The question is, is it an obligation or not?38:46So the answer is, I mean, the question really has part of it also,38:50is that it ruins the kids' bedtime.38:52Sometimes the father comes home late.38:54He comes home at38:57eight, nine o'clock. So now, if the kids stay up, they used to sleeping at39:01seven, seven-thirty. So if the father's coming home at39:03seven o'clock, nu, nisht geferlach, it's fine,39:05b'seder. But here, the father's coming home so late,39:08if we keep the kids up, it's going to ruin their sleep time.39:11It's going to ruin their schedule. They're going to miss the bus.39:13They're going to have all these problems throughout the whole holiday.39:15So the first night it's fine, but the rest of the holiday is going to be all messed up.39:18Must they be up?39:19The answer is, there's halacha and there is hashkafa,39:23or what we call39:27chinuch. מצד הלכה, מצד הדין, as long as somebody is lighting and he's covering everybody,39:30technically nobody has to be there,39:32מעיקר הדין nobody has to be there.39:33If the father comes and he wants to light it,39:35and as long as there's people who are going to see it on the outside,39:37and he's going to perform the39:39פרסומי ניסא, he's going to publicize the miracle by people seeing it on the outside,39:41nobody from the house, not the wife, not the kids, has to be there.39:45However, for chinuch reasons,39:47it's very, very important that you get the kids to participate.39:51So now, how do you want to figure it out39:52with your husband coming home late?39:54You're going to have to speak to the rabbi.39:56We'll speak maybe if we have time, we'll speak more about this later on.39:58However, one thing is for—40:00Sure, you got to be careful.40:01The mother cannot make a beracha for the children40:04to light the menorah at, let's say,40:08five o'clock, and then when the husband comes home,40:10he's going to light again with the40:11beracha. That cannot be done.40:13If the husband wants to light without a40:16beracha when he comes home late at40:17nine o'clock, and the mother wants to light with the beracha at40:21five o'clock, matov u'manaim. That's really the preferable way40:24to avoid lighting it so late at40:26nine o'clock. But again, the husband has to be a very understanding husband40:33who cares about halacha to allow his wife to light on time,40:38and even though he's going to miss lighting with the40:42beracha. Next, another question.40:46This is pretty much the same question.40:48Should the wife light early without her husband40:51or wait for the husband to come home?40:53But this time, the kids are for sure going to be sleeping.40:55So again, me'ikar hadin, like we said,40:58the best way to do it,40:59the best way is that the wife should light on time,41:03but that's41:05me'halacha. However, there's many variables over here41:08when you ask such a question,41:10because there's so many things they have to take in mind.41:12For example, how old are the kids are we talking about? Little,41:15young, older.41:17Also, zeh shalom bayit issue.41:19Sometimes a question can come, by the way,41:21rabbis, you have to be careful.41:22A woman may ask you an instant question41:23and you answer her41:24halacha. Sometimes it's a shalom bayit issue.41:26She just wants to get her husband.41:27She wants to light that he missed it.41:29You got to be careful.41:30Are there shalom bayit issues?41:31How late is the husband coming home anyway?41:33You know, she wants to light at41:35five o'clock because she heard this class41:36and it's better to light at41:38five o'clock, but the husband's coming home at41:395:30. So I don't know if you have to be so41:42machmir. You have already, she taught what to rely on.41:44Also, how often is he doing it?41:46Is it only one night he's missing?41:48Is he missing the whole holiday?41:50All these things must be taken into account,41:53and then the family itself should go ask the rabbi,41:55What should we do?41:56Again, me'ikar hadin, of course,41:58to light on time is the best thing,42:00but you have to know that we're not just robots.42:03We have other things that are going on in our lives42:05that sometimes will affect the halacha as well.42:08Next.42:10Okay, next group of questions,42:13we're skipping because of the time that we have,42:16is what do you do when you're going away for Hanukkah,42:20and this makes it very complicated.42:22In your house,42:24b'seder, ata ha-melech, you're the king of the house,42:25you light whatever you like.42:26But what do you do when you have to,42:30you know, you have other cause,42:31you're going away?42:32Okay, so this, as an introduction,42:34let me just tell you,42:35this is only for42:38Sefardim. Ashkenazim have a little bit of different halachot.42:40I would love to go and explain and elaborate42:42on what Sefardim and Ashkenazim do,42:44but because of the time,42:44I'm going to only speak about what the Sefardim should do,42:48because their halachot are a little bit more complicated.42:50So let's begin.42:52Halacha says, like we mentioned in the past,42:56one lighting per account,42:58per bank account.43:00As long, if you're a43:02Sefardi and you're being supported by the father,43:05let's say, of the house,43:06somebody supporting in the house,43:07as long as anybody who is being43:09supported by that father, by the person in charge of the house,43:13when the candles are being lit,43:15everybody is covered, automatically covered. Okay?43:19So we sometimes have a little bit of complications now.43:24What would happen now if the father is traveling?43:26Let's say the father is going to China,43:28or he's going to California, he's going to Florida,43:30he's not home in New York,43:31but the wife is staying home with the kids.43:33What do you do in such a case?43:34So the halacha is like this:43:36the wife lights in the house43:39when the time comes to light the menorah,43:41and the husband, no matter where he is in the world,43:42even if he's in China43:43where the holiday is coming 12 hours earlier,43:46or if he is in California43:49where the holiday is coming in later,43:51it doesn't make a difference.43:53He's covered by the lighting that's taking place43:55in his house that day.43:58He doesn't have to be43:59mishtatef. Not only that, if he says,44:01I don't want to be yotzei de chovah with my family44:04for the44:05sefaradim, we have to be machmir like the Beit Yosef brings down.44:08Lav kol kaminei. He can't just decide,44:10I don't want to be yotzei with my wife's lighting.44:12He's yotzei de chovah with the44:14lighting that his wife does in the house.44:17That's scenario number one.44:19Scenario number two is,44:21let's say sometimes what would happen is44:23when the husband travels,44:24that means the father of the house is going away.44:26He's away for44:28Pesach—I mean, excuse me,44:29he's away for44:30Chanukah. The wife decides to pick up herself and the44:33kids and to go to her parents' house.44:35So now nobody's in the house.44:36What do you do in such a case?44:38So in such a case,44:39the husband is not being44:41yotzei de chovah with the lighting44:43with anybody.44:43Nobody's lighting in the house.44:45So therefore the husband must light wherever he is.44:47If he's in China,44:48he must light. Wherever44:50he may be, he has to light,44:51whatever the halachot are,44:52wherever he is.44:54The wife, by being in her parents' house,44:57automatically she's44:58yotzei de chovah because her parents are hosting her,45:00they're feeding her,45:00they're giving her to drink.45:02She's automatically being45:03yotzei de chovah. In that case, though,45:04it would be better that45:06she tells her parents,45:07Please have me in mind when you light.45:08And this way the husband is45:11yotzei de chovah and the wife is45:13yotzei de chovah wherever they are in the world.45:15Now sometimes what would happen is45:17that both parents go away45:18and they leave their teenage children in the house.45:20What would be the din then?45:22The halachah then it should be is as follows:45:24the parents should appoint45:26and tell the children,45:27You're going to be responsible45:29for lighting the menorah this year,45:30and you will be our45:32sheluchim, you will be our shliach, our messengers.45:34And when the children light in the house,45:37the parents are covered wherever they may be.45:39If the parents are in Florida,45:40the parents are covered by the kids45:41lighting in the house45:43because they appointed them as messengers.45:47Okay, what about when the entire family goes away?45:51They all pick up and they decide to go away.45:53So where are they going?45:54If they're going to their parents45:57and they plan to sleep,45:59they're not planning to come back home.46:00They plan to sleep at their parents.46:01They're going from Brooklyn to Lakewood46:03to stay by their parents' house,46:04by their grandparents' house.46:05So in that case,46:07they'll be obligated to light in the new house.46:10And over there they have the din of a guest.46:13And as a guest,46:14when the whole family is a guest by their parents' house,46:16since, again, the grandparents are feeding them,46:18they're giving them whatever they need,46:21the yotzei dei chovah with the46:22lighting that the grandparents do in the house,46:24it'll be preferable to notify46:27or to let your parents or46:30parents-in-law have you in mind to cover you46:32for the lighting of46:35the menorah. If, however, the family goes away46:38by themselves to a46:39hotel, or they rent out a house,46:41it doesn't make a difference.46:41Basically, they pick up their residence46:43from wherever it may be,46:44from New York,46:45and they travel now all together to Pennsylvania.46:48So in that case,46:49where you're in the hotel,46:51your hotel now, or your hotel room,46:53becomes your new house,46:55and the obligation should be really46:58in that hotel room to light.47:00If you're going to light,47:02obviously you're thinking the same thing47:04that we have over here in our notes,47:06and that is47:07hotels don't let you light, put on fire in the room,47:09right? You didn't take a smoking room,47:12and even if you did,47:13sometimes they have rules against it.47:15So if you want to light in your room,47:16you cannot light47:17unless you get permission from the hotel.47:20And don't say,47:20No, you know what?47:22Better not to ask.47:22If you don't ask,47:23you don't get rejected.47:24No, no, no, no.47:25When you sign that contract47:26before you come into the room,47:28they give you this whole long contract47:29that nobody reads.47:30So that contract says47:31over there you're not allowed to put on a fire in the room.47:33So it's illegal.47:34It's asur.47:34You took the room with that condition.47:36It's asur to be over al47:38daat baal habayit. You're not allowed to go47:39against the wishes of the owner of the hotel.47:42So therefore,47:42if you want to light in your room,47:44you should call up the front desk47:45and ask them for permission.47:46By the way,47:46it's very simple.47:48It's very easy to get permission.47:51You just have to ask them.47:53And very nicely,47:54and tell them,47:55listen, I'm observing Jew,47:56and make sure you point this out.47:58I want a light47:59if you can.48:00Those in the room, and I am staying next to them. I'm only keeping them on for 30 minutes,48:05and I'm going to shut them right off, and I'm not leaving their sight.48:08In the hotel, it's okay that you're going to leave them alone in the fire could catch.48:11But if you're watching them, you're sitting next to them,48:13and all you have to do is a minimum of 30 minutes.48:15Let's say you do 30 minutes, you shut them off afterwards,48:18and you could do the mitzvah lechatchila without a problem.48:21But again, like we said, you must get their permission.48:24And if the hotel says, Get on the list. There's 25 families over here.48:29They're all Jews. They all want the light in the room. We cannot take the risk,48:32but we've given you the lobby to light.48:34So in that case, you can light in the lobby.48:38Regarding the beracha, you should ask your local rav to see what he says,48:42if he allows you to make the beracha over there or not.48:44In the case where the hotel doesn't let you light at all, not in the room and not in the lobby,48:48so in that case what you got to do is either, what's preferable,48:53appoint somebody to go to your house and to light them in your house48:57and let him be your shaliach, and this way you're covered.49:00But if you can't find the shaliach or you don't trust anybody to go into your house49:03or you don't leave any keys over,49:05so in such a case you have no other option but to use an electric menorah.49:11Electric menorah means you take a flashlight even,49:14or if it's a fifth night, you take five flashlights, whatever it may be.49:17But in that case, when you're using electric, according to the49:20Sefardim, even if it's battery operated, because of the many opinions on the subject,49:25we say, Safek berachot lehakel. Do not make a blessing if you're lighting with an electric menorah.49:34Here's some more important points very quickly.49:37Sometimes families go away for Shabbat. They go to their parents or their49:41in-laws, but sometimes their parents or their in-laws are local. They're a drive away.49:45So if your house is local, that means it's like a five-minute drive,49:48even though you plan to sleep by your parents on Shabbat.49:51You should light first in your house after plag haMincha and then go away.49:56In that case, you have to let the candles just light by themselves49:59and then shut off by themselves.50:00Make sure you have enough that they should go all the way till 30 minutes after50:05tzeit hakochavim. If you're planning to come back home,50:10then you don't light in your parents' house,50:12but you light in your home when you're planning to get there.50:15Here, in this case, however, you have to keep two points in mind.50:18Number one is, if it's motzaei Shabbat Chanukah, don't go home so late.50:22Don't go home at 1, 250:24a.m. It's once a year. Go home right away and light.50:28Go, meaning to say, go to your house and light right when Shabbat is over,50:33and then come back to your parents' house.50:34Anyway, it's local.50:36Number two is, sometimes people stay in their parents' house motzaei Shabbat50:39because they were there the whole Shabbat50:40till they pack everything, they go back home.50:42So the parents light with a berachah, and the kids even participate in it.50:46In such a case, since you're chayav, your obligation is to light in your house,50:51you're not yotzei yedei chovah with your parents.50:55You must go home and light then with a berachah.50:59I'm sure there are many cases that we missed and we didn't have time,51:02but we have to go. We have to sign out right now.51:04So therefore, anybody who has any questions51:07will be here for the next couple of minutes to answer your questions.51:09Call in at51:12718-683-5858, or you could text at51:16347-927-8398. Perhaps for the last couple of cases, we'll come back next week.51:19We'll give a very short class on the laws of Chanukah51:22and whatever we missed.51:24Thank you for joining us.51:25This has been the Halacha Hour.51:26The same class will be on tonight at 1051:28p.m. We'll see you, be'ezrat Hashem, next time with Hilchot of Muktzeh.