Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of HanukkahBen Ish Hai – HolidaysRabbi Uri Nahum · November 20, 2013−15Play+30Position0:0054:11Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to Halacha Hour on Wednesday afternoons here live at0:05JRootRadio.com, and if you're listening from the radio, it's at 97.5 FM.0:12I'll give you the number to the studio. We're discussing Hilchot Hanukkah.0:15In this Halacha Hour, we talk to understand, and we try to apply also the halachot in our days.0:22We give you questions because we're discussing Hilchot Hanukkah,0:25and there's obviously many, many practical questions,0:29and we only have this week and next week. So I'm going to give you the first numbers.0:32If you have any questions, to text in your question,0:34you text it in at0:37347-927-8398. That's probably the easiest way if you want your question to be answered.0:41There is the other number to the station,0:45718-683-5858, but I apologize from the beginning, I don't always pick up the phone for a number of reasons.0:49Number one is I'm not so sophisticated over here yet how to pick up the0:53phone. You know, it might take me a while.0:54Number two is also, if we're in the middle of a subject,0:57I will not be able to pick up the phone until we finish the inyan, we finish the subject,1:02so you might just, you know, give up and hang up.1:05So the best way is if you text in your questions,1:09347-927-8398. During the music break, that's when you have the time to call in,1:13and that will probably be the easiest time to answer any of the halacha questions.1:18A few short announcements before we begin the class.1:22Next week, be'ezrat Hashem, the class will be pushed a day earlier1:26because of the holiday.1:27Next week, Wednesday night, we know is the first night of Hanukkah,1:30so therefore, even though we have the classes usually on Wednesday afternoons, live 2 to 3,1:35next week the day before Hanukkah we'll be pushing it to Tuesday1:39between 2 to 31:41o'clock, okay? So that's just for next week, the week of Hanukkah, the week before Hanukkah,1:45sorry, the day before Hanukkah we'll be having the class instead of Wednesdays,1:49we'll have it on Tuesdays between 2 to 31:52p.m. The other announcements are, like we mentioned a little bit in the past,1:56and that is, give the halachot, usually using the book Ben2:00Ish Chai. We're learning in our shul also the halachot from the Ben2:03Ish Chai, and over there, because I'm not limited on time,2:07so therefore we discuss it a little bit more.2:11And if you like the style of the class,2:13so you're more than welcome to join us on Friday nights2:16on the shul on Avenue U and Ocean Parkway.2:19The name of the shul, of the building, is Beit Yosef,2:22although our minyan is called Sukkat David and Ohel2:24Moed. It's downstairs in the basement.2:27Shabbat, we begin tefillat Mincha, candle lighting,2:31and then afterwards we go into2:33Arvit, and then after Arvit we have this class.2:35So please join us, b'ezrat Hashem.2:38Okay, so now, another one more quick announcement, sorry.2:42We are selling raffle tickets for a big menorah.2:46It's a silver, sterling silver menorah, around2:49a thousand dollars, and the tickets are very cheap. It's only ten dollars per ticket.2:52A hundred dollars will buy you twelve tickets.2:54This is going to support the learning that we have in our shul privately.2:58And if anybody is interested in buying a3:00ticket, the drawing will be next week, Monday night.3:02If you're interested in buying a ticket, just text in your name and number,3:06and we'll call you back, b'ezrat Hashem,3:08and we'll get all your information.3:10It's goralot. Let's get to the halacha.3:11Last week we were discussing some of the halachot.3:14We went into some of the details,3:15and b'ezrat Hashem, hopefully with today's class and next week's3:18class, we'll be able to finish complete all the halachot in the sefer Ben3:23Ish Chai. And of course, if there's any questions, we'll take in any questions3:26and also discuss that.3:28Anyway, what we spoke about, just a quick review of what we spoke about last week.3:32Last week we spoke about the location of the menorah.3:40By the way, this class is l'fuat shlema of Eliyahu Chaim ben3:45Shafika Sofiya, this class, as well as all the halachot of3:49Hilchot Chanukah. Again, we're discussing the location of the menorah.3:51Where is the best place for a person to place a menorah?3:54And we said the rule that3:57the reason why we light the menorah3:59is in order to publicize the miracle that happened in the times of the Beit HaMikdash.4:03So therefore, because the rule is that we want to publicize the menorah,4:07the best location to place your menorah4:10is the place where we draw the most attention.4:13And we discussed different examples.4:15I'm just going to go over them a little bit from what we said last week.4:18Might sound a little bit repetitious.4:19There's some new cases as well that were asked over the week,4:22and we'll explain them.4:24If you live in a regular apartment over here in New York City,4:28so most probably, not always, but most probably,4:32the best location for your menorah4:34will be by the front window of your house,4:37because that's where will draw the most attention.4:39If you would light it in your house, inside your house, by the doorway,4:45not necessarily would people be able to see it over there,4:47because most places, most houses have a balcony in front of them.4:50If you're able to really light it according to the4:52halacha, where it says by the entrance to your gate coming into the front yard, the gate in front of your, in the front yard,4:57if you want to light by the entrance over there,5:02ma tov u'ma na'im, if you can do it in a way that it won't shut off,5:04that's great, that's fantastic.5:05But being that's not so practical for most people,5:08so the window will probably be the best location.5:11It draws the most attention,5:13and that's where you could publicize the miracle the most.5:15That's if you live on a first floor or a second floor in New York City.5:19Another halacha that we're going to mention later on5:22is that 20 amot is the highest that you could place your menorah.5:26We'll talk exactly what 205:28amot, it comes out to around 31 feet.5:31So being that 31 feet is measured from the street level,5:36if you live on a third floor,5:38and for sure on a fourth floor apartment,5:40so most probably if you place your menorah in the window,5:43it will be too high.5:44It will be considered above 205:46amot. So in that case, the best location would be5:49to go to the next option,5:50and that is to publicize the miracle5:53to your family members inside the house,5:56and that's also something we'll discuss a little bit later on.5:59So again, if you're living in an apartment building6:02where your apartment is within 31 feet,6:06you want to be even more meikil within.6:10What's it called?6:12Within 38 feet from street level,6:14then you can light by the6:17window. If it's above that,6:18for sure if you're on the fourth floor or6:20higher, then because your apartment is higher than 37 feet,6:23then you should do it in a location6:25that will be more public inside the house.6:29Another question I got asked,6:30and it was a very nice question,6:32is if a person living in the basement.6:35In the basement, you have no window. The window,6:38the only window which is facing the street6:41is really not even facing the street;6:43it's facing the driveway6:45where nobody walks in.6:46Or let's say you have one of those apartments6:48where you don't have a front window6:51because your apartment is the second half of the floor6:56facing the backyard,6:57and over there there's nobody in the backyard.6:59There's nobody walking in your backyard.7:01The only person who would go to the backyard is you,7:03maybe if you want to go out for a little bit7:04to get some fresh air or whatever.7:06And in the front of your7:09apartment is another apartment,7:09so nobody's seeing into the7:11backyard. So if you're putting it by the7:12window, nobody could see it,7:13especially if your house is attached on both sides,7:15so nobody could see it.7:15So in that case,7:16then you go to the next option.7:20You publicize the miracle now7:21instead for the people walking in the street,7:23you publicize it for the people inside of your house.7:26That would be the same in the7:28basement. If you live in the basement7:29where the windows are so high up7:31that you, either it's not practical to light by the7:33window because the window is so tiny,7:36or nobody's going to see it by the7:37window. Let's be7:38honest, by the window over there nobody's going to see it.7:39It might not even be three7:42tefachim. So therefore, in that case,7:44you would have to light inside the apartment,7:48and the location will become the most public.7:51And there actually,7:53we'll talk about in the next halacha a little bit more,7:56that some, al pi Kabbalah7:58especially, to place it by the door.8:00On the entrance coming into the house would probably be the best location, of course, in a way that people will not knock it down, okay?8:04Last week we ended off the class.8:10Okay, I have a good question also coming in.8:13How come we don't light outside like we do in8:16Israel? This is a very good question. I'll take it just very quickly right now.8:20The answer is as follows:8:22How come we don't light like we do light outside?8:24Really, we should be lighting outside.8:26The halacha says—let's start from the beginning,8:29okay? Start all the way at the beginning.8:30The Gemara says, the Gemara says that you light your menorah on the outside of your house.8:36And we explained in the times of the Gemara, all houses were like the way we have our stores today.8:41They're street level, what we would call today a8:44walk-in. In America here, especially in New York, houses, you have to go up a few steps in order to get to the first floor.8:51Not so in the houses once upon a time.8:53Every house was street level, like a storefront.8:55So therefore, if your house was right on the street, that's where everybody would see it.9:00So by the entrance to your house, that's where you place the menorah, between three to ten tefachim from the ground.9:05That's how you should light.9:07If you had a front yard, or if your house was in a chatzer, was in the courtyard where many houses were there,9:13so according to Shulchan Aruch, that's what we follow according to9:16these Rishonim, then you should light your menorah on the door to the courtyard,9:22because that's where it will be publicized the most.9:24The front of the courtyard, people will walk by because the courtyard is facing the street,9:29and you have to go into the courtyard and then go into the houses.9:31So the courtyard is what's facing the street.9:33You put it by the entrance to the courtyard. That's where you place your menorah.9:36That's how the halacha is in Shulchan Aruch,9:38and that's how it was. That's how halacha is written in the Gemara.9:41The Rishonim bring down, especially the Ashkenazi9:44Rishonim, they say, you know, this is all true.9:47Well, the Gemara—let's go back again. The Gemara says actually,9:49in times of sakanah, then you don't light it outside; you light it in your house.9:55What does that mean, in times of9:57sakanah? Well, if the goyim would know that you're Jewish, or even if they know that you're Jewish,10:00they know that this is a Jewish neighborhood, but there's animosity.10:04How dare you celebrate Yom Ha'atzmaut in our non-Jewish country?10:08And trust me, most of Jewish history was filled with such problems,10:13when the Jews were not able to light because of such a thing.10:18So therefore— In these cases, everybody lit inside,10:23and that's how most of the Ashkenazi throughout their history lit,10:26because they lived in Christian countries. They couldn't light outside,10:28so they were always lighting inside.10:30What happened to publicizing the miracle?10:32Then you're left with the other option: you have to publicize the miracle to the people in the house.10:37So this is where the minhag of some people till today, that they light inside.10:42But really, Baruch Hashem, today, in most countries—most countries,10:45I don't know, I can't tell you about every country.10:48If somebody wants to buy me a ticket, fly me all over the world so I could observe every country,10:52I'll tell you. But what I know from most countries I know about,10:54which is limited to three, four, whatever,10:56most people could light by the window or could light by the front of the house,11:03because we don't have the animosity anymore.11:05You're lighting your candles, they're putting their tree,11:08and the other guy is putting on another imam, whatever it is.11:11Everybody is quote-unquote respectful of other religions,11:16so we don't have such an animosity. And the question is a valid question:11:18why don't we light like the way we do outside?11:20And the answer is that it's not practical,11:23because most people have silver menorah,11:26and they're nervous if you leave it outside, it will get taken away.11:30Also, it might shut off.11:32If it might shut off, so what have you accomplished?11:34You lit it and then it shuts off.11:36We're going to learn later on,11:37you can't light it even in a location where the lights are going to shut off11:40because of the wind.11:42But for this, you have a solution.11:43So you buy these glass cases, which could protect it from not being lit.11:48So that's another—that's perhaps a solution. But still, how come people don't do it?11:52The answer is some people do do it, and others do it, place it by the window.11:56In fact, I know of great talmidei chachamim, real, real stuff,12:00some of the biggest rabbis in America, who light it in the window.12:03Why?12:04Because it's more mefursam. It's more publicized in the window12:09than by the front of their house.12:10Like we said beforehand, most houses have a balcony,12:12and the balcony has a fence,12:14and if you put it there, especially with the glass cases12:17that they don't make it so accommodating for large12:20menorot, you can't see it as well as if when you put it in the front window.12:25So that's the reason why they don't light here12:27in Israel, where I guess it's more practical.12:29It's more, I guess the housing conditions are a little bit different.12:32They do light it outdoors for that reason,12:36because it's more publicized that way.12:37In our days, I told you it's more publicized in the window,12:39where most people are living here in our neighborhood12:42in one- or two-apartment houses.12:46Got another question over here. How about a hotel?12:48What would you do when coming to a hotel?12:51That's an excellent question.12:52I had it on my notes to talk about.12:56Sorry, I'm not feeling so well, so take me a little while.13:03We are going to speak about it later on,13:06but we'll just bring it in the kitzur right now.13:08Somebody was going to,13:09I believe somebody was telling me that he was going to Israel,13:12and since he was going to Israel,13:14so he was going to stay in a hotel with his family in Israel.13:18So right now, let's assume that everybody in the family is going to Israel.13:23In such a case where everybody is going to13:25Israel, or the whole family is going away together,13:28nobody is left home in the house to light.13:31So in such a case, that's where the question is right now.13:33I'm not talking about where the family is divided,13:35only the husband is away and the wife is still at home.13:37Let's talk about right now where everybody is away13:40and they're all in the hotel.13:41So where are you supposed to light right now?13:43You can't light in the room.13:44Why not?13:45Because most hotels, I believe, they have a policy: no fire in the room.13:49It makes a lot of sense, right?13:50Because even though you're careful, you never know.13:52Somebody else might come in who's not so careful,13:54so you're not going to be able to light in the room.13:56In fact, it might be a crime to light in the room.13:59Not just it'll kick you out of the hotel;14:01it might even be a crime in some countries,14:02for sure it's a crime,14:03because you could set the whole building on fire14:06and endangering everybody else.14:07So if it's Israel, for example,14:08I believe that most hotels which are owned by Jews14:11or where the religious Jews stay,14:13they will give you a place to light in the entrance,14:16like let's say the entrance or wherever it is.14:19There's a special table that's set up where everybody could light.14:21In that case, it might even be better to light in the hallway14:24or when you come in,14:26because— Most probably, if you're in a hotel,14:28you might be—most probably, it's not 100%,14:31but most probably you might have an apartment that's higher up,14:34meaning to say it's more than 20 amot above ground level.14:39So anyway, you can't light in the window.14:40So you light inside.14:42Who are you publicizing the miracle to?14:43Besides that, in a hotel, in my opinion,14:45most people who go to hotels14:48don't stay in the hotels except for sleeping.14:50You're going at night; you're lighting and sleeping.14:51It's not like the house where you're more relaxed.14:54You come home, you want to enjoy yourself,14:55you just sit in the house.14:56If you're going away, you buy a hotel.14:58You come to the hotel, you get what you need,15:00and you leave the hotel room.15:01You spend the night out somewhere.15:03You visit relatives, you visit15:05rabbanim, I don't know. You go to different places.15:06You just come home to sleep.15:08So therefore, even when you light,15:11which is—we're going to talk about what time to15:13light—most probably you're going away from the hotel,15:14so it's probably much more beneficial to light in the front if they let you.15:19In case they don't let you,15:20that will be the discussion later on,15:23if they don't let you light even in the front.15:26So then we're going to talk a little bit maybe about electricity a little bit later on.15:30I'm not saying electric works15:32100%. I'm not saying it doesn't work either.15:33We'll talk about it, be'ezrat Hashem, later on.15:35I guess we'll keep you excited to follow the class.15:38Let's continue in the15:39halachot. Last week we left off,15:41we read inside the15:44halacha, Halacha Dalet, and as many people could testify,15:47Halacha Dalet in the Ben Ish Chai is the most complicated15:49halacha in the whole parashah over here in Hilchot Hanukkah.15:53So that's why we read inside to explain it.15:55We divide the halacha into half.15:57Now we're up to the second half of the halacha.16:00Where the Ben Ish Hai discusses how a person should light the menorah.16:05What does it mean, how?16:06It means to say in the order of the lights.16:08I'm not going to read it inside because we don't have so much time to go through this last point inside,16:13but we'll just explain like this.16:15When you want to set up your menorah,16:17let's assume right now you're setting it up by the window,16:20okay? So you have your menorah by the window,16:22and you have four sticks coming out from the right, four sticks coming out from the left,16:27or whatever design in your menorah you have, it doesn't make a difference.16:29You have basically the places where you can place the light.16:32Well, the first night is very simple.16:34First night, Wednesday night, you're going to light one candle.16:36That's a chiyuv, one night.16:38So therefore, the first night, you put the candle, you make the blessing,16:44the three blessings, three16:50berachot, להדליק נר חנוכה, שעשה ניסים לאבותינו, and שהחיינו, and then afterwards you light the candle.16:53That's very nice.16:53After you light the main candle, then you have something called the shamash.16:57The shamash is the extra candle that we light17:00that once upon a time was used to show us that there's a heker for the mitzvah of the menorah.17:11However, the second night becomes a little more problematic.17:14How do you set up the lights for the second night?17:17So the rule of thumb is as follows:17:19you always set up beginning from the right,17:23and then you place, from the right side,17:28you place the amount of candles that you need for that day.17:31So let's say it's the fourth night for a second,17:34okay? So I have my menorah in front of the window.17:37I go to the extreme right of the sticks of the menorah,17:41and then I set up four candles, or four cups, whatever you want to use.17:46So I've set up the four cups.17:48The one on the extreme left for that day,17:51that means in this night, which is the fourth night,17:53the one on the extreme left is going to be the last one I set up from the right, right?17:57So then the one on the extreme left, which is number four,18:01I place it the fourth one,18:03I will use that one. To light first.18:07When I make my blessings, which is18:11להדליק נר חנוכה and שעשה ניסים לאבותינו, I will light the one on the left first, which is considered the new candle,18:16and then I will continue lighting the other candles,18:20which are considered the הידור candles,18:22going to the right,18:23like the way you write English.18:24How do you write English?18:25You begin from the left hand to the right.18:28I want to go to school.18:29How do you write?18:30You write I, then18:32W-A-N-T. You're writing from the left to the right.18:34That's how you should light the menorah candles as well.18:37You set it up from right to left,18:40but when you light, you begin lighting from the left18:44and you go to the right.18:46Okay?18:46That's very important to keep in mind.18:48Sounds a little complicated, but it's not.18:49Let's go to the next night, the fifth night.18:51How do you light the candles on the fifth night?18:52You set it up on the right,18:54which means you put four,18:56and today is the fifth night,18:57you put an extra candle that's a new candle,18:59extreme left,19:00not extreme all the way, but just next to,19:02they all placed next to each other,19:04and then that candle, the new one,19:05is what you're going to make the bracha on.19:07You're going to make the19:08bracha and you're going to light that candle19:10and continue lighting all the way to the right.19:13This is the way you should light your menorah.19:18It doesn't make a difference if you're putting it in the window,19:20it doesn't make a difference if you're putting it outside.19:22That's how you set it up.19:24You always begin from the right to set up,19:27but when you light, the way you write English,19:29that's how you do it.19:30You start lighting from the left to the right,19:33okay?19:33That is the conclusion of Halacha Dalet.19:38We move on to Halacha Hey.19:40Says the Ben Ish Chai in Halacha Hey,19:47מניחה למעלה משלושה טפחים. How high up from the ground do you place the menorah?19:50So we mentioned this very,19:53just by the way,19:54but now we'll discuss it in detail.19:57Three tefachim from the floor.19:57If you're lighting outside of your house,20:00like in Israel,20:01or if you want to get this glass box20:03and you want to light even in America20:04outside your house,20:05very good.20:06So what you do is, from street level,20:07you light three tefachim up,20:15and mitzvah lehanicha lematah me'asarah tefachim. But preferably, preferably20:17the mitzvah lechatchila, if you want to do it the best way,20:20you light it between three to ten20:23tefachim. The Mekubalim explain20:25that if you light between three to ten,20:28the best place is, if you can, if you can,20:31that the flame should be by seven20:37tefachim, okay?20:38Now I know20:39three20:39tefachim and ten20:40tefachim and seven20:41tefachim, you're not going to find it on your measuring tape.20:44There's no tefachim on your measuring tape.20:46I have a measuring tape in my house that says20:48tefach, but they don't sell that in the stores.20:49So you have to know what a tefach is.20:51Now this makes it a little complicated20:53because tefach is a machloket.20:54There are two main opinions.20:56The20:57Minhag Sefardim is to follow the opinion of20:59Rav Chaim Na'eh, and a lot of the21:00Ashkenazim follow the opinion of the21:02Chazon Ish of how big a tefach is.21:04Now we mentioned these21:06halachot when it came to halachot Sukkot,21:08because we need to know how big a wall should be of the sukkah.21:11Now we need to know how big does,21:13or how high could you light the21:15menorah, so we need to know what a tefach is21:16and what is an21:17amah. We should just know21:19that for every21:20amah, in every21:21amah you have six21:24tefachim, okay?21:25Every amah has six21:27tefachim. Once we know what is,21:29how big a tefach is,21:30we will know how big the amah is,21:32and then we'll be able to explain21:34all the halacha properly.21:36A21:37tefach, according to the Minhag21:39Sefardim, in centimeters is eight centimeters;21:41in inches it's 3.15 inches,21:44okay?21:45That's how big one tefach is.21:47Remember, an amah is six21:49tefachim, so that would mean21:51one21:52amah, according to21:53Rav Chaim Na'eh, which is the minhag of the21:55Sefardim. will be 48 centimeters,21:57and it will be 18.9 inches,21:59which is one foot and 6.9 inches,22:02about one foot and seven inches.22:05That's how big one amah would be,22:09according to the22:10Sefaradim. The Chazon Ish's measurement22:11is a little bit larger,22:14and he says that each tefach is 9.6 centimeters,22:17around 3.78 inches,22:20which makes an22:21amah, which is six22:23tefachim, 57.6 centimeters,22:25or you could say in inches,22:28one foot 10.68 inches.22:30Okay?22:32Hard numbers, I know,22:33and I don't expect you,22:34if you're driving and you're doing a carpool right now,22:35to remember all these numbers.22:36But I have to say them22:38in case you want to go back and hear them,22:39that you should know.22:40This22:41is—now let's focus right now22:42specifically on the22:43tefach. Each22:44tefach, we either22:45have—we're going to work with22:47inches—either it's 3.15 inches,22:49or according to the22:51Chazon Ish, it's a little bit larger,22:523.78 inches.22:54Okay, so now you have to light it.22:56If you want to light it from the ground level,22:58so then you have to light it higher than23:02three tefachim, three tefachim and higher.23:04B'diavad, if a person places it lower than23:05three tefachim, you should know,23:06he's23:07yotzei b'diavad. There's no question.23:08So just the23:10lechatchila, preferable is to light it above23:13three tefachim. Okay?23:14How much is23:16three tefachim in inches,23:16according to the23:18Sefaradim? The minhag is 9.45 inches,23:20which is about nine and a half inches from the ground.23:23The Ashkenazim hold23:2411—or not all Ashkenazim,23:25but the Chazon Ish's measurement is23:2711.34 inches,23:30almost one foot.23:31That's considered three tefachim up.23:33And these measurements,23:35depending what the subject is,23:37you could be23:38meikil, because the whole concept of lighting23:40menorat Chanukah is all23:41derabbanan, and we have a rule,23:43safek d'rabbanan lekula. So whenever you have these measurements,23:47whatever is more befitting23:48or it's more lenient for you,23:49you could use it.23:50That's the way the Steipler explains.23:52Now23:53let's jump to ten tefachim for a23:55second. We said you have to light between three to23:58ten tefachim. Ten tefachim, according to the Sefaradim, is—24:0131.5 inches,24:03okay? According to the Chazon Ish, 37.8 inches. So therefore, let's translate the halacha now in inches instead of24:12tefachim. The halacha says you have to light between 3 to 10 tefachim, which means you have to light between 9.5 inches24:19to 31.5 inches. That's how you should light it. Preferably, it should be exactly24:257 tefachim, which is 26.5 inches, which is about 2 feet and24:30a half, okay? That's how a person should light it, lechatchila according to the Sefardim. According to the opinion of the Chazon Ish,24:37preferably it should be by 7 tefachim, which is24:4126.5 inches, which is about 2 feet and a half,24:45okay? But really, the 3 to 10 tefachim will be between 11.5 inches until24:5237.8 inches. That's the opinion of the Chazon Ish, okay? This24:58is only25:00lechatchila, even if you're not lighting outside.25:02But for whatever reason, you have to light inside, like the case we gave in the basement25:08of a person is not in the basement, a person is in an apartment where he cannot light outside. For whatever reason25:14he cannot light outside,25:15so in that case,25:16the Sefarim bring down that you should light by the doorway coming in, and obviously put it away from the door that when you open25:22the door it shouldn't get knocked down, right?25:25Just a little sicha. So when you put it there,25:27also you're putting it on the floor, and you measure from your floor in the apartment,25:31since you're lighting for the people on the inside, you're publicizing the miracle for the people on the inside. Even if you're living alone by yourself,25:36even if you're single and you're living by yourself in a basement or in a place where you have to light it by yourself,25:41so then also you measure from the floor25:443 to 1025:45tefachim. So that's why these measurements are important for you as well,25:48and you go back, you go online and hear these measurements again.25:51If anybody would like, you could ask us and we could send you an email with all these measurements, okay, now.25:58One thing we do have to know, and we mentioned in the past,26:01im minicha lemaalah me'asarah, yatza yedei chovah. The26:03Mishnah says, and that's halacha in the Gemara, coming all the way from the26:08Gemara. The Gemara says, any26:10ner Chanukah that's above26:13twenty amah, you are not yotzei yedei chovah. If you place it, let's say you have a house,26:18which is your private house, it begins from the floor, and you're placing it for some reason, you're placing it above26:25twenty amah, even though I pick up my26:27hand, I'm going to clearly see it, it doesn't make a difference. Even if my26:30menorah is so large, to be yotzei yedei chovah, if it's above twenty amot, I'm not26:35yotzei yedei chovah. How much is twenty amot? It's, according to26:39the Sefardim, 378 inches. How much is that? 31 and a half feet. That's Kena'zim, it's26:46453.6 inches, which is26:4837.8 feet. So we're talking about 38 feet around. Okay, so between 31 to 38 feet,26:56that's from the floor, from the ground level,26:59that's twenty amot. You cannot light it higher than that. And27:02the halacha says if you did light it higher than that, it doesn't work. You have to shut it off and27:08bring the menorah to the proper27:11location, and then light it again. Lo berachah, but you cannot27:15just take it the way it is as a slit and bring it down.27:19The halacha says, and that's leading us27:22into halacha vav, halacha says that the flames of the menorah doesn't go by the base or whatever style of menorah you have; it goes by the27:29base—I mean by the flames. The flames of the menorah27:32have to be under twenty amot. If the flame of the menorah is under twenty amot, then it works.27:37And if it's not, even though the base of it is under twenty amot, it doesn't work,27:41and therefore you have to shut it off and then light it in the place where it's going to work.27:45And that's the next halacha. The halacha says,27:48Tzarich lehadlikah bimkom hanachatah. The Gemara comes out after27:51discussion, the Gemara comes out that the lighting of the menorah is what makes the mitzvah.27:57It's not the placing it; it's the lighting. The Gemara says, What do you mean?28:01Give me an example. An example would be as follows: imagine28:03I take a menorah, I light it in my hands,28:04and then I place it right outside between three to ten tefachim, most beautiful location.28:09I put it in this beautiful glass that everybody could see it. It's a magnificent28:16three-foot menorah, gorgeous.28:18I did not fulfill the mitzvah, because when I lit in my hand, that's not a proper case for it. It has to be placed.28:23First you place it, and then you light it. And therefore, if I lit it in a location where it's not proper, when I light it, it28:29has to be in a location which is proper for it. If I lit it in a location28:32which is not proper,28:32I have to first shut it off, and then place it in a location where it's proper for it, and then light it. Now this28:38has many ramifications, many examples to it. We mentioned beforehand28:43that you have to light the menorah in the place where it's going to be lit and stay lit also for a while.28:49We're going to learn later on that it has to be lit for at least a half an hour. If I placed in the menorah enough oil to28:56last me only 20 minutes, not a half an hour, or my candles are so small that they won't even last a half an hour,29:03let's say, then if I lit it and29:07then I added on29:09wax or I added on oil to the cup where it's going to last now more than a half an hour,29:14it doesn't work. When I light it, the candles have to be able to29:21fulfill the mitzvah, since the mitzvah of the candles, the minimum amount that they light has to be half an hour.29:27So when I light it,29:29everything, all the conditions have to be there. It has to be in a location that's proper.29:32It also has to have the amount of oil to be able to last a half an29:37hour. Even though I may add the oil, if I add it on29:41later, even if I add the oil later on, I will have it lit for half an hour,29:45it doesn't make a difference. It has to be that way before I start lighting it.29:49So in that case, if I'm coming to add oil,29:51I must first shut off the candles, add the oil, and then once I see that I have enough oil29:57that can last me half an hour, then I might light it.30:00Why? Because hadlakah osah mitzvah, bimkom hanachah. It has to be in its place and then light it. Same another example.30:07Let's say a person is not feeling well, and, you know, it's the father of the family, and,30:12lo aleinu, he got sick this year, and, you know, he's the father of the family.30:16He is the one the whole family gets together to watch the father light it. But this time he's very sick,30:20he can't get out of bed. You can't take the menorah to him in his room,30:23allow him to make the berachot and light, and then carry it to the front, to its location.30:31Hanachah. Hadlakah is asah mitzvah b'mkom hanachatah. You have30:34to place it where it has to be, and then you light it.30:38You can't light it in one place and then move it to somewhere else.30:42Same thing, there's another halacha. If you light it in a place where it's not going to last for half an30:47hour, even though you have oil, but it's not going to last for half an30:49hour. For example, you light it in a place where the windows open. Now you know the wind is going to blow, and it's going to shut it off.30:56So even though, chazak baruch, you lit it for two seconds,30:59but it's going to shut off right away because the wind is going to blow it. In that case31:03also, you are not yotzei the chovah if you light it that way. So if you're placing right by the open window,31:11it's going to shut off any second now. So it doesn't work now that you cover it31:14afterwards, you shut the window, you have to shut off the candles, shut the window, and then light it.31:19We're talking about a case where it's for sure going to shut off from the wind.31:23But if it's not, you're not 100% sure, there's a window open in the room,31:26you're not 100% sure31:28that the window is going to be able to bring in the wind to blow off the candle, in that case31:33you don't have to shut it off. Just shut the window and that's fine.31:35Only if you place it directly next to the wind where it's going to for sure shut off,31:40since you lit it in a way that it's not going to be able to last half an hour,31:44you must first shut off the candles and then31:48light it in the proper location. That is halacha vav. We're going to take a small musical break right now31:56till I figure out how to take the break, okay, and then just tell you.32:00If you have any questions, you could call in to your questions right now. And if you call32:06in your questions, we'll answer, be'ezrat Hashem, over the phone, or we'll answer any text that32:13we get, be'ezrat Hashem, about the halachot.32:15The numbers, again, to the station are 347-927-8398. Okay, that's the number to the station. And the32:25numbers to call in: 718-683-5858.40:15We're back in discussing the halachot of40:20Hanukkah. Numbers to the station are 347-927-8398. Studio is40:26718-683-5858. If you call in now, we could take your questions. If you text in, also we're taking your questions. And40:32that we are selling raffle tickets for Menorah, sterling silver menorah, 21 inches, $10 a ticket,40:4012 tickets for $100. Anybody who's interested, please text in your name and your phone number,40:45and we'll contact you. The money is going to support learning Torah and kiruv40:53rechokim, so whoever could help, tizku l'mitzvot. Let's come now to the next halacha, Halacha Zayin. Now we will be talking about the time that a person should light.41:00This is a very important subject. What time is a person allowed to light?41:04So we're going to discuss basically two main things. Number one is the preferred time that a person is allowed to light,41:12and number two is the latest time that a person could light. This is going to be the subject right now.41:18One is the preferred time, which will be called lechatchilah, and one is a person allowed to light according to halacha,41:25me'ikar hadin, up to which point is he allowed to light. Let's begin with the background from the41:30Gemara. Listen to the words of the Gemara, and then you'll understand where the different opinions fall into place,41:35and we'll give you the exact times also for New York City for 5774 this year, be'ezrat Hashem.41:41Says in the Gemara as follows:41:48זמנה משתשקע החמה עד שתכלה רגל מן השוק. Says the Gemara, when is the time of lighting the menorah? The time of lighting the menorah is when the sun sets until תכלה רגל מן השוק. Until literally means that there's people not walking in the42:03market anymore. Now the Gemara says, what do I need to learn, what do I need to tell this halacha for?42:07So Gemara gives two reasons why I have to tell you this time.42:13De'i lo adlik, madlik. I have to tell you this time from the time that the sun sets until tichleh regel min ha'shuk, to teach you two halachot.42:19Number one is that if a person does not light at this time, he should not light afterwards.42:29אי נמי, לשיעורא. Or the other way to explain, says Gemara, the other reason is to tell you the amount.42:32Now this Gemara needs explanations.42:35There are two main questions that we first have to understand from this42:38Gemara, and then we'll go to put everything else in place.42:41Number one is, the Gemara mentioned42:44mishתשקע החמה. What does it mean,42:46תשקע החמה? What does it mean,42:49שקיעה over here in this case? Number two is, it says over here,42:53תכלה רגל מן השוק. The Gemara didn't give me a time like it does by other places,42:57three stars, or over on Masechet Berachot, in the beginning, where the Gemara gives different times.43:04Over here it says,43:05תכלה רגל מן השוק. What is that time exactly,43:07תכלה רגל מן השוק? Is it to be taken literally? Is it for their time only, or is it forever?43:11Those are two questions we're going to discuss.43:12So let's get to שקיעה first of all.43:15שקיעה, the simple meaning of שקיעה usually means the sun setting.43:18What does it mean, the sun setting, by the way?43:20It doesn't mean what most people, what the non-Jewish term of sun setting.43:27Sun setting, most people, you know, the ball, the sky looks like a ball.43:30So when that ball completely goes underground, that's called sunset.43:34That's called43:35שקיעה. The whole ball has to be underground. Not when it begins.43:38When the whole ball is under, that's usually the meaning of43:42שקיעה. However, in this case we have different opinions.43:46Some say that when the Gemara says שקיעה, it means the beginning of43:51שקיעה. What does it mean, the beginning of43:52שקיעה? It means what we just told you, sunset.43:54When the whole ball of the sun went under the horizon,43:59that's called44:00שקיעה, what we normally call a sunset. If you open up every calendar,44:03what time is sunset? You'll see what time sunset is.44:05That's what the Gemara means.44:06That's when you could begin lighting it.44:08That's one way of the Rishonim explaining the word44:11שקיעה. Another way the Rishonim explain שקיעה is it doesn't mean when the sun sets.44:17It means when the sun has completely set, and it's for sure nighttime already,44:22when the three stars have come out.44:23How long is that?44:25So for the three stars to come out is a big discussion that's called bein hashmashot is over.44:29When bein hashmashot is over and three stars coming out,44:31that is a big44:33machloket. Let's just say it's between 13 and a half minutes to 18 minutes.44:36So between 13 and a half minutes to 18 minutes after sunset,44:40that is called44:43sof השקיעה. And according to many Rishonim,44:45when the Gemara says that you have to light the lights of the menorah44:49when the sun sets, it means the end of the44:52שקיעה, which is three stars, about, let's say, 18 minutes after the sun sets.44:59Okay, these are the two main explanations of what does it mean, the sunset.45:03Now what's the purpose of knowing exactly what time it is?45:08Why is the Gemara establishing that the time to light the menorah is at that time?45:12And the answer is, just like placing the menorah in the right place45:17should be placed in the place where it could draw the most amount of attention,45:21because we want to publicize the miracle,45:22we also want to light the menorah in the time where we could publicize the miracle the most.45:29And if you light it before the sun sets, it's still completely daytime.45:32The sun is out, there's light in the streets,45:35and being that there's light and everybody can see,45:39your little candle is not going to make such a big difference.45:42You're not going to be able to see so much.45:44The candles are being lit, and you have not been able to publicize the miracle properly.45:48Like the words of the Gemara are,45:51שרגא בטיהרא מאי אהני. If you light a candle in the middle of the day, what benefit do you get?45:55It doesn't help you. You can't see the candle.45:57So we want to light it when it's dark,45:59and that's why you have to wait46:01until the sun sets.46:02And here you just have the machloket between the two opinions.46:06When does the sun set?46:07What is the meaning of the Gemara when it says the sun sets?46:09Does it mean the beginning of the46:12שקיעה, or does it mean the end of the46:16שקיעה? Okay?46:17That is the two ways of understanding the Gemara.46:21The Shulchan Aruch, listen to his words.46:23He writes as follows.46:25The Shulchan Aruch says,46:28like this:46:34Ein madlikin ner Chanukah kodem shetishka hachamah. You don't light the ner Chanukah before the sun sets.46:42Ella im sof sheki'atah. You must light at the end of the46:46sheki'ah. Lo me'acher v'lo makdimin. You shouldn't light later than that,46:48and you shouldn't light earlier than that.46:49According to the Shulchan Aruch, he's saying very clearly.46:52He's going with the Rishonim that46:54explain that sheki'ah here means not in the beginning of the46:57sheki'ah, but rather means at the end of the46:59sheki'ah, after the sun has set,47:00and it's already after the stars have come out,47:05after the47:06bein hashmashos, which is the 13 and a half to 18 minutes after47:08sheki'ah. Now, the only thing is, you have to know,47:11there's a famous47:12machloket of when the sun actually sets.47:16It's a big, big machloket between47:17Rishonim. It's really not our subject,47:19but you have to know47:20just because to understand the cases that are going on,47:22to understand the times.47:24There's, most Rishonim say that47:27sheki'ah, all the time that we discuss sheki'ah in the Gemara,47:29it means when we see that ball of the sun47:32go below the horizon.47:33So that means all the calendars in the world,47:36Jewish and47:36non-Jewish, would say47:38sheki'ah. That's what the meaning of the sheki'ah as well.47:40That's when the sun has set.47:41There's an opinion called the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam,47:44and he's not the only opinion, you should know.47:46There are many Rishonim who follow Rabbeinu Tam as well.47:48In any case, Rabbeinu Tam,47:50based on different47:52Gemarot, he explains that the sheki'ah that we see47:56is actually 58 and a half minutes47:58before the real sheki'ah that the Gemara...48:01is referring to. So according to Ben, the real sunset that the Gemara always refers to is really 58 and a half minutes after the sunset on our calendars.48:10That's the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam,48:12okay? Now, in general, we know that Maran follows the opinion of Rabbeinu Tam.48:17So when Maran writes over here,48:24Im madlikin ner Chanukah קודם שתשקע החמה אלא עם סוף שקיעתה, he says that the time to light candles is really the end of48:26sheki'ah. Technically, Maran means you have to light it after bein hashmashot of Rabbeinu Tam.48:32So that means 72 minutes after what we call sunset is really the beginning of the time when a person should light according to the48:43Shulchan Aruch. However, however, even though that's the opinion of Shulchan Aruch, the minhag is not that way.48:48The minhag is that we don't light right at the48:50beginning. You look at all the Acharonim, especially you'll see48:54even Hacham Ovadia, who usually takes Maran all the way, and especially when it comes to Motzaei Shabbat,48:59in this case he doesn't say that.49:01In this case, we will hold that the sheki'ah over here, like the opinions of the Geonim,49:07and that the sunset is what we call sunset, when the sun actually sets,49:10and therefore we will say that sof sheki'ah, the end of the sheki'ah, which is when bein hashmashot comes out, is about 18 minutes after what we call sunset,49:21okay?49:21Now, so why did I bother telling you all the different opinions and explaining the Gemarot?49:25I'll tell you why.49:27Because we want to be able to light the candles, the chatilah, in the best, in the most preferred time.49:35So the halacha says that if you don't light in the most preferred time, according to Shulchan Aruch, you have up till alot49:42hashachar. Alot hashachar is about 549:46o'clock, 5:30, 5:30 a.m. So actually a little beforehand, I think 4:30, 549:50a.m. So then— If you have, if you're able to light up to then, so why don't you just light it that late?49:55And it says, no, you want to do it in the best time.49:57Lechatchila, when's the best time to do it?50:00And this is why I'm telling you all these opinions.50:02It comes out, based on the calendar for this year, for the year 5774 here in New York City,50:09sheki'ah during the holiday of Chanukah, which begins next week, Wednesday night,50:13until the following Tuesday evening, which is going to be the last time we light,50:18it comes out that 4:30 to 4:28 is sheki'ah. Working backwards,50:22Wednesday night will be 4:30. I believe the next night will also be 4:30, and then 4:29, and so on and so forth.50:28So that's when the beginning of the sun50:31setting. So therefore, the best preferred time that a person could light and should light50:36is about 20 minutes after that time.50:40Why?50:40This is considered sof sheki'ah according to the Geonim,50:43which hold that bein hashmashot is about 13 and a half minutes till 20 minutes.50:47Now, you should try to really light it at that time.50:49I'll tell you why.50:50Because the opinion of the Rambam, the Gemara says,50:55ad shetichleh regel min ha-shuk, and all the Rishonim explain that you have a half an hour to light the menorah.51:00Since you have a half an hour to light the menorah,51:03the question is, what happens after that half an hour?51:06Do you say that you can't light anymore,51:08or no? The half an hour is a preferred time.51:11That's when everybody's walking in the street.51:13But if it's already past that time, you can still light it till the morning.51:17That's a machloket Rishonim.51:18Shulchan Aruch rules that you can light it all the way until alot51:23hashachar. However, the shittah of the Rambam is51:27that if you don't light within that half an hour, you can't light anymore.51:30It's like you're doing nothing afterwards.51:31So that's why it's preferred that a person should try to be yotzei51:35according to all opinions.51:36And therefore, if you want to be yotzei according to all opinions,51:39the best time to light throughout the holiday of51:42Chanukah for this year, 5774,51:45is from51:494:50 p.m. That's the best time to light it then51:51and let it last at least half an hour.51:53And if you light up till51:576:10, up to 6:10, you could still squeeze in51:59the chatzilah. It's considered still52:01the chatzilah according to Rabbeinu Tam,52:05the way Shulchan Aruch explains it,52:07which is Rabbeinu Tam.52:08That is, if you want to be yotzei52:11lechatchilah. Now somebody pointed out something very interesting.52:14This year, the way the calendar works out,52:15I know a lot of people are usually at work52:17and they can't make it that time.52:19You should know, the way it works out this year,52:22you could pretty much make it home in the preferred time52:26almost all the time.52:27Why?52:28Wednesday is the first night.52:29Wednesday is erev Thanksgiving, right?52:32A lot of people get off earlier at work.52:35And even if you don't get off early,52:36if you take off a little bit earlier that day,52:39you come home just that day early.52:42Thanksgiving, most people are not working.52:44And even if you are working, for sure you're home, okay?52:46You get home in time to light the candles.52:48That's already, that we cover for Wednesday, Thursday.52:51Friday anyway, you have to be home52:53because when you light candles,52:54it's going to be before Shabbat.52:56Motzaei Shabbat, Saturday night,52:58you're going to light also on time.52:59And Sunday most people are not working,53:00so that's five out of the eight days of Hanukkah.53:03If a person just plans his days a little bit right,53:06you can be home53:07anyway without doing anything necessarily extra.53:10So the other three days,53:11lechatchilah, if you can, if you can53:14somehow convince your wife53:15and your wife will be also convinced53:17and you're also ready to give it up,53:18if you're at work and you're not going to come home53:21until maybe nine o'clock, eight, nine53:23o'clock, it's better to light your wife too light.53:26That's better53:28meikar hadin, halacha. If you should actually do it or not,53:30that's a separate question.53:32If you believe that your children should see you lighting and everything,53:36so that's something that you have to ask your own personal rabbi53:39and see how you should apply the53:45halacha. I know of, whatever. Okay, if anybody has a question,53:47you can call me about that.53:48But anyway, time is up.53:49We have to stop over here.53:51Bezrat Hashem, next week, Tuesday.53:52Again, the class will be on Tuesday next week53:55at two to three,53:56and over there we'll discuss more of the times.53:57If you have any questions,53:58you should text it in.54:00Even if you listen to this on Tuesday evenings,54:01you should text in your question.54:02Bezrat Hashem, we'll try to answer whatever we can.54:05Until then, have a wonderful week.54:07Thank you for listening,54:08and Shabbat Shalom.