Torah · HalachaHalachaLaws of Friday Night PrayersBen Ish HaiRabbi Uri Nahum · February 20, 2014−15Play+30Position0:0052:37Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to Wednesday afternoon Halacha Hour here on0:04JRoot Radio. You can listen to us live over here at 97.5 FM.0:09Also, you can listen online,0:13jrootradio.com. And if you want to call in and you want to listen on the phone0:15where you can't reach us by internet or by radio,0:19you can listen at0:23718-506-9099. The numbers to the studio are 347-927-8398 if you want to text,0:29which is the best way to get in touch with us.0:33The other phone number, today Baruch Hashem we have Rav David with us0:37helping us here to answer the phones,0:39and the number is0:49718-683-5858. 718-683-5858. Before we start the show, we just want to announce that we have two announcements to announce, Baruch Hashem.0:58Number one is that today's class is sponsored by Mr. Nuts.1:03That's not a person, that's a store.1:05Mr. Nuts has anything that you need for Purim.1:09He has candy, nuts, dry fruits, chocolate, whatever you got,1:11you could go and custom make your own mishloach manot,1:15and ask for Freddy, tell him you heard it here on Halacha Hour.1:18Where is the store?1:19The store is on Avenue U between 7th and 8th,1:23the second store off East 8th.1:24You can go there and ask for Freddy.1:27You heard it here on Halacha Hour.1:28The second announcement is that if anybody would like to sponsor the show1:34or to do a l'ilui nishmat in memory of someone or1:38l'fuah shelemah, text into the station and just text in your request and we'll get in touch with you.1:43Make sure you leave a phone number and we'll get in touch with you. Regarding any sponsorship.1:48Okay, with that, we come back to our regular schedule,1:51and we are learning Hilchot Shabbat from the Ben1:56Ish Chai. The Ben Ish Chai in Parashat Vayera talks about the halachot of Leil Shabbat.2:02Last week, we were discussing the mitzvah of Tosefet Shabbat.2:07The mitzvah of Tosefet Shabbat means to add on to Shabbat.2:10Like we explained last week, we have an obligation,2:13according to 90% of the poskim, there's an obligation,2:17de'oraita, this is also the opinion of the Shulchan Aruch,2:19and all the Acharonim, nobody disagrees with this.2:21There's an obligation, de'oraita, from the Torah, that a person should not come into Shabbat last minute,2:26but he has to accept Shabbat2:28earlier. What's called accepting Shabbat early?2:30We said that at least, at least two to five minutes before Shabbat comes in,2:35and Shabbat means over here, it means sunset.2:38So whenever sunset is, it's going to be on Friday night,2:40you have to accept Shabbat a few minutes beforehand, no matter where you are,2:45and you have up to about an hour beforehand to accept Shabbat.2:48Even though you didn't pray Mincha, you could always accept Shabbat for the sake of not doing any2:53melacha, and not accept Shabbat for the sake of2:55Mincha, which means you could have in your mind that I'm accepting Shabbat only to restrict myself from doing any3:02melacha, but if I still want to pray Mincha, I'm able to pray3:05Mincha. That is a mitzvah, that's an obligation.3:06Today, we're up to Parashat Vayera, Halacha Zayin,3:12and in Halacha Zayin, there's an important3:15halacha. This halacha, you should know, is a little bit complex,3:19at least if you try to look at it inside, try to learn it inside.3:22But Baruch Hashem, the Ben Ish Chai says it very, very simple, and hopefully we'll simplify it.3:27And that is, let's say one has accepted Shabbat early, that means,3:32okay, so we're assuming Shabbat is at3:345:30. You decide to accept Shabbat at 53:37o'clock. Now the question is— What about somebody else in your family, or not your family, another Jew?3:42For him, it's still a weekday. For him, it's still Friday afternoon.3:46What is permitted and what is not permitted as far as telling him to do something for you?3:52Meaning, could you ask your friend to put on the lights for you?3:56It's for you, it's Shabbat.3:57We know that in general, when Shabbat is here, you're not allowed to tell a goy to do anything4:02for you. You can't tell a Jew because a Jew also has to keep Shabbat.4:04The difference over here is that the goy—excuse me—that the Jew over here who has accepted Shabbat4:09is telling another Jew who has not accepted Shabbat.4:12Could you tell him or not?4:13So let's read the words of the Ben Ish Chai, and then we'll bring you the source and explain everything outside.4:19Now, Ben Ish Chai says as follows:4:21Mi shekibel Shabbat me'od yom,4:22one who has accepted Shabbat early,4:25yuchal lomar la-chaveiro shelo kibel Shabbat4:26adayin4:27la'asot eizeh melachah. He could tell his friend that you could do a melachah for him.4:33Meaning, let's take Reuven and Shimon.4:34Reuven accepted Shabbat at4:37five o'clock. Shabbat is 5:30. He accepted it early,4:39five o'clock. And then he comes, he realizes,4:41Oh boy, I forgot to put the food on the fire.4:44So he goes and knocks on his neighbor, Shimon.4:46He says, Shimon, I need some help. Come.4:49He brings him up. He tells him,4:51Here, I want you to put on the light, I want you to put on the fire, put on the food.4:54But it's Shabbat already for him,4:56and it doesn't make a difference.4:56Since it's not Shabbat for Shimon,4:59he's allowed to tell him.5:00That's the opinion of the Ben Ish Chai over here,5:03which is the opinion of5:05Maran. And the Ben Ish Chai concludes, he5:06says, even though you find in the Bach that he brings,5:10de'nachon lehachmir bazeh,5:12the Bach says that it's proper to be5:14stringent, says the Ben5:15Ish Chai, ve'nir'eh li de'letzorech mitzvah yesh5:19lehakel ve'lo lehachmir. He says, I hold that if you're doing it for the sake of a mitzvah,5:23let's say you're telling him to put up the food for Shabbat,5:25that's a mitzvah, right?5:26You need to eat on Shabbat.5:28You should be lenient and you should not be stringent.5:30Vechen minhag pashut, and that's5:31the minhag. One who has accepted Shabbat is allowed to inform another Jew5:35who has not accepted Shabbat yet. To do any melacha for him.5:40This is the halacha here in the Ben5:42Ish Chai. I want to go a little bit just in the background of the5:44halacha to understand it, where it comes from,5:46and also to understand all the different5:51תוצאות, all the different things that stem from this5:54halacha. Let's begin.5:55There's a Gemara that says like this.5:56There's something called techum on Shabbat.5:58What does that mean,6:00techum? On Shabbat, one is not allowed to leave the city that he's residing in on Shabbat6:05outside the city perimeters another 2,000 amot.6:07Okay, that's the6:09halacha. It's called techum Shabbat,6:102,000 amot. The distance is of about, let's say, 4,000 feet, let's say.6:15A person is not allowed to go outside of the city, outside of 2,000 amot.6:20If you're living here in Brooklyn, it's not so common.6:22But if you go up to the mountains in the summer6:25and you have these little villages and towns, so that's also a city.6:29If you want to walk from town to town or from city to city on Shabbat6:33because somebody has a simcha in the bungalow colony somewhere else,6:38so that's where it's very relevant.6:40On Shabbat, you may not leave outside of 2,000 amot.6:43However, the Chachamim made something, and they said the following:6:46You could push your 2,000—you have a really 2,000 amot radius.6:51So let's say you have to travel to the east.6:53What you could do is, by a takanah called something called6:58eruv, you could take a certain amount of food, place it near the edge of your 2,000 limit,7:05and then what you could do is you could take the7:072,000—basically these are 2,000 amot that you're allowed to leave from the7:11west—you could transfer that towards the east,7:13this way giving you, from your city, 4,000 amot to the east.7:18But at the same time, now you can't leave the city from the western side at all.7:24You're stuck by the edge of the city.7:26You're not even allowed to leave a little bit.7:27Whatever you take from one side, you could transfer to the other side,7:31but you lose it on the other side.7:32That's the concept of7:33techumim. So the Gemara says if a person has a techum on Shabbat7:37where he's allowed to go to, where his friend is not allowed to go to.7:40One could ask from his friend that wherever he's going there,7:43to the other techum where he's, let's say, let's take Abraham and7:46Yitzchak. So Abraham is not allowed to travel west,7:50and Yitzchak is not allowed to travel east,7:52because they both did eruvim in two opposite sides of the city.7:54So now Abraham could tell7:56Yitzchak, listen, I know that you have a field over here,7:58and I'm going to guard it for you over Shabbat.8:00But on the condition that you guard for me my field on the other side, on the western side.8:04So each one could guard for somebody else,8:07and even though they each may not go to the other person's techum, to the other person's area,8:13they could still guard for each other.8:15Says the Rashba—this is the8:16Gemara—says the Rashba from this Gemara, you see from here8:19that even though it's forbidden for one person to do something,8:22if it's mutar, if it's permitted for another Jew to do it,8:25then you could ask of him to do it.8:27And from there he learns that this is the halacha when it comes to Eruv Shabbat.8:31This is very practical on every Friday afternoon.8:34Here there's a Jew who has accepted Shabbat.8:37Let's say Reuven accepted Shabbat early,8:39five o'clock. His friend, his neighbor Shimon, has not accepted Shabbat yet.8:43So for Reuven it's Shabbat; for Shimon it's not Shabbat.8:46For Reuven to turn on the light, it's forbidden because he already accepted Shabbat.8:49He could go to his friend Shimon and ask him,8:51Put on the light for me. Even though it's forbidden for8:54Reuven, but since for Shimon it's8:56mutar, it would be permitted for Reuven to ask of Shimon.9:00That's where the source of the halacha.9:02Although the Ran disagrees, and Maran brings that in the Beit Yosef,9:06bottom line, the Suchan Aruch writes,9:13יש אומרים שמי שקיבל עליו שבת קודם חשיכה, מותר לומר לישראל חברו לעשות לו מלאכה. That's the bottom line of Maran, that the halacha is like the9:17Rashba. One who has accepted Shabbat earlier, before sunset,9:20could tell his friend to do melacha for him.9:24Again, it has to be before sunset.9:26We're only talking about over here if you accepted Shabbat before sunset,9:31okay?9:32The chidush over here, which we're going to talk about in a second,9:34is that even though Reuven, who has accepted Shabbat,9:37has accepted it with a minyan,9:39meaning it was—we explained in the past9:42that there's two ways a person can accept Shabbat.9:44There's a person can either accept Shabbat alone.9:47All together with minyan.9:49We're going to learn some of the halachot in a second.9:51When a person accepts Shabbat with the minyan,9:54the laws are more binding; they're more strict.9:56The chiddush over here is that Reuven, who has accepted Shabbat early,10:00he could tell Shimon to do melacha for him.10:03He could tell another Jew to do melacha for him,10:05to do something forbidden for him,10:06even though he has accepted it with a minyan.10:11And with that, let's talk about a little bit10:13some of the halachot, also important halachot,10:14about accepting Shabbat with10:18a tzibur, accepting it with a minyan.10:19These are very, very important practical halachot10:22that happen very, very often, especially in the summer.10:25In the summer, now it's the winter,10:27people are rushing last minute to get to shul.10:29You know, it's hard to even—you have to figure out a time10:32to squeeze in the mitzvah of tosefet Shabbat.10:34When we said two to five minutes, it sounds like it's nothing,10:37but it's really very difficult for a lot of people10:39to actually accept Shabbat a little earlier.10:40In the summer, it's very easy.10:42In the summer, you want to accept Shabbat even before that.10:45You want to accept Shabbat already much earlier10:47than even the time allows it.10:48So this is very relevant in the summer,10:51where a person will accept Shabbat much earlier.10:53We gave an example last week.10:55You know, sometimes you'll have shkiah, sunset, around10:588:30. If you wait to accept Shabbat till11:008:30, that means you're praying in the shul at11:038:30 Arvit, let's say, let's put it nicely.11:04You're going to be done a quarter to nine.11:06By the time you get home, it's going to be 5, 10 to11:089. All the kids are sleeping.11:09It's very hard.11:09And if you're already older,11:11and your kids are out of the house11:12and they're married out of the house,11:13so it's even harder.11:14You can't even eat that late.11:15It's very hard to eat at this older age;11:17it's harder to eat a late meal.11:19So when are you accepting Shabbat?11:21So most people would like to accept Shabbat very early.11:23It's still daytime outside.11:25So in that case, you accept Shabbat11:26and you see others have not accepted Shabbat.11:28What is11:29the halacha? What could you do?11:30What could you not do?11:32First, we have to learn some11:34halachot regarding accepting Shabbat.11:36Number one is—11:37When a person accepts Shabbat by himself,11:40what does that mean?11:41It means, I'm going to give a time right now.11:43Let's say Shabbat is at six11:45o'clock, sunset is at six11:46o'clock. A person wants to accept it at11:495:30. He, at 5:30, decides on his own to say,11:52I accept upon myself11:54tosefet Shabbat, the mitzvah of adding on to Shabbat.11:56Then the halacha becomes that12:01he becomes—he turns into Shabbat mode12:0399% of the way,12:05which means12:06he's forbidden with 99% of the things12:09that anybody else would be forbidden with on Shabbat.12:12He can't do anything that he can on Shabbat.12:14The only things that are permissible,12:17that are permitted to do12:18when one accepts Shabbat early,12:20is an issur12:23miderabanan for the sake of a mitzvah,12:25or an issur12:27derabanan if you really, really need it,12:29although it may not be a mitzvah.12:30What does that mean?12:31An issur12:33derabanan is something like, let's say,12:35muktzeh, or let's say amirah12:37l'akum, telling a goy to do something for you.12:39That's forbidden12:41miderabanan. If you accepted Shabbat at five12:43o'clock, or 5:30 in our case over here,12:45you12:46accepted 5:30, Shabbat is not here till six12:48o'clock. You cannot put on a light,12:49you cannot drive to shul,12:50you cannot do any of those things.12:52But let's say you need the light to be on,12:54you could call a goy and ask him to put it on.12:57On Shabbat, you can't just tell a goy to put on the light for you.13:01We learn those halachot, be'ezrat Hashem, on its own time,13:03but it's forbidden to tell a goy13:04anything that you can't do.13:05You can't tell a goy to do on Shabbat.13:06However, before Shabbat,13:09we're more lenient.13:10We hold that you could tell a goy to do things for you,13:14even though you're in Shabbat mode.13:15You're only in Shabbat mode 99% of the way.13:17That 1%, which is an13:19issur derabanan, anything forbidden by the rabbis13:22for the sake of a mitzvah,13:23that would be permitted.13:25That's one way of accepting Shabbat.13:27The second option,13:28the second way a person can accept Shabbat13:30is— When he accepts Shabbat with the minyan.13:33Now here it gets a little bit13:35complicated. Let's take the following example.13:37Let's say you're praying with your shul,13:40and you're there,13:41you know, it's a13:43summertime, eight o'clock is sunset,13:44and you want to accept Shabbat early.13:45So you go to shul at13:48seven o'clock. Seven o'clock they pray13:50Mincha. If13:50you're Ashkenazi, they daven13:51Mincha, and at 7:15 they're finished.13:54Now 7:15 they begin Kabbalat Shabbat.13:56Two, three minutes13:57and already you're up to14:00Bo'i Kallah, Mizmor Shir LeYom HaShabbat, where according to the14:02Mekubalim as well as the14:03Pashtanim, you already accepted Shabbat at that time14:04with the14:06tzibur. Now the laws of Shabbat are more binding.14:09You added on to Shabbat an extra hour.14:11Shabbat doesn't come till14:12eight o'clock, but since you accepted Shabbat14:14by Bo'i Kallah with the14:17tzibur, with the minyan,14:18then you're bound to all the laws of Shabbat.14:20There's no difference between now to later on.14:24You already accepted Shabbat all the way.14:27You even14:28issur d'rabbanan l'tzorech mitzvah you may not do,14:30since you accepted it with the14:32tzibur. That's the second way of accepting Shabbat early,14:37when you accept it either by yourself,14:39where you're allowed to do14:41an issur d'rabbanan l'tzorech mitzvah, and when you accept it with the14:43tzibur, where you become14:45asur in everything,14:46you're not to do on Shabbat.14:47There's a point that I want to point out over here,14:50and although this is not so common nowadays14:53because the way the poskim bring it14:55out, sometimes you may find yourself in such a situation.14:57The halacha brings down14:58that even though you may not be in the shul15:01when Shabbat was being accepted by the kahal,15:04you could be bound to the kahal15:07even though you're not there.15:09What do I mean?15:10Let's say you live in a town.15:12Let's go with something that everybody agrees on,15:15okay? Let's say you live in a town.15:18Where there's only one shul.15:20That's it.15:20There's no nothing else.15:21In that city or in that town,15:22there's only one shul.15:23So this usually happens when you go away in the summer,15:26you go to these colonies,15:28or whatever you are,15:30you may be going away to a hotel in a city15:32where you are the shul.15:34There's nobody else around you.15:35So in that case,15:37even though you may not be present15:39at the time when that Shabbat minyan is taking place,15:43Friday night,15:44once they say15:45Boi Kalah, you accept the Shabbat with them.15:47Meaning,15:48you go away to Shabbaton15:50in some deserted island.15:52I don't know where it is,15:52okay? So you're standing out on Shabbat,15:55and you look at your schedule on Friday15:56and you see that Friday night15:57the prayers will begin at seven o'clock Mincha.16:007:15, we will have Kabbalat Shabbat. At 7:30, Arvit Shabbat, Arvit of Shabbat. So you know between16:067:15, 7:30, they're already accepted Shabbat. Even though you're not praying with them, once16:117:30 comes, even though Shabbat sunset is not until 8, you must accept Shabbat at 7:15 or 7:30, whenever16:19they accept Shabbat together, even though you're not present with them. That's halacha obliges you to16:23it, since there's no other shul in the town. The Graz, which is Rav Zalman Mlyadi, which is16:30the Shulchan Aruch HaRav, the Baal HaTanya, he brings down that if there's many shuls in the city, then you're not16:35bound to it. And that's how a lot of the poskim bring it down. Mishnah Berurah brings it down,16:40Chacham Ovadia brings it down, Chacham Ben Tzion Abba Shaul, they also bring it down. They all bring these halachot.16:46They all bring this halacha that if there's more than one shul, even though you yourself16:51pray in that specific shul, and they're praying early, they're praying at 716:55o'clock, and you don't want to accept Shabbat, that particular Shabbat till later on, till 816:59o'clock or till 7:45, then in that case you're not bound to them, even though they accepted Shabbat,17:04because you have other shuls. Some are machmir that if your shul accepted Shabbat, then you're17:09bound to your shul, even though other shuls are still available, or other shuls have not accepted17:13Shabbat yet. Minchat Ahavah, Moshe Levi, alav hashalom, he is machmir. But in general, most of the17:20Acharonim, especially the Sefardim, hold that as long as there's some shul that has not accepted17:26Shabbat yet, assuming again before shekiah, you're not bound by them, okay? Now, in the17:33tzibur, when you are though around the minyan, it doesn't help to make a condition that I don't want to17:38accept Shabbat. Meaning, let's say you prayed at 7 o'clock and your wife told you, listen,17:42I understand you have to catch mincha, but I need some help preparing, I need some help to17:46get some things ready for Shabbat. So go, pray mincha, and come back and help me with some17:50things. I need you to, let's say, put on the fire and do some melachot to prepare for Shabbat.17:57If you were with the minyan and you heard them say, Bar'chu es Hashem hamevorach, and you answered18:01with them, then you accepted Shabbat. Sorry, even if you make a condition, I don't want to accept18:06Shabbat, it doesn't help, according to a lot of the poskim. There are some who say that it does help.18:11The Kaf HaChaim, I believe Rav Moshe Feinstein also says that you could make a condition, but18:16pashut pshat of Maran, and according to Chacham Ovadia, that if you said, you answered with the18:22tzibbur, you answered with the minyan, Bar'chu es Hashem hamevorach, you're bound by the minyan18:27and you have accepted Shabbat with them. Even there's other shuls, but since you were in that18:31minyan and you answered with them, Bar'chu es Hashem hamevorach, you also must accept Shabbat with them.18:39So now with that, let's come back now to talk about a very practical case. Here we are in the18:45summer. The husband goes to shul. He prays by the earliest minyan possible on Friday night.18:50He's praying at six o'clock, or 6:30, let's say. Shabbat doesn't come in for another two hours.18:55By the time he finishes shul at 7:15, he already prayed Mincha, he prayed Kabbalat Shabbat,19:00he prayed Arvit, and he already accepted Shabbat all the way. He comes home, and his wife and19:05kids have not accepted Shabbat yet. Question is, must the wife and the children also accept Shabbat19:12when the baal habayit, when the father, the husband, also accepts Shabbat? Are they bound to him?19:17What about the other way? Baruch Hashem, there's a very nice minhag that a lot of the ladies19:22accept Shabbat by candle lighting. Like we said, it's beautiful. Even though it's not an obligation,19:27but it's beautiful. According to the Sefardim, although you're not obligated, but it's beautiful19:30for a woman to get herself ready by Shabbat candles, to accept Shabbat. It's wonderful. It's19:35great. So let's say here you have a woman who has accepted Shabbat earlier, and now her husband sees19:39that she accepted Shabbat by candle lighting. Is he bound to her? Could he still drive to shul?19:44What about the children, the little kids? We're not talking about the adults above bar mitzvah.19:48Maybe you could say they're different. But what about the little children? Are they bound? What's the difference?19:52The difference will be is, let's take the first case that we gave. A guy, a husband comes19:58back home in the summer, he comes back home. He sees that his wife has not accepted Shabbat,20:02and he already accepted Shabbat. Could he tell her, Poran the AC, shut off the AC? Most of the time20:07it would probably be shut off the AC because the husband is paying for the bill, unless it's the other20:11way, so he'll tell Poran. Okay, in any case, now he comes home, he sees certain things that need20:15to be done in the house. Could he tell his wife do it? Could he tell his children who have not20:19accepted Shabbat? Again, I want to stress, this is only before sunset. Once it's sunset, or if you're20:28in a town, in a village, or in a colony, or you're away where there's only one shul and everybody20:33in the shul already accepted Shabbat, there's nothing to talk about. Everybody's bound to it.20:37If you're only here, we're talking about, let's say you live in Brooklyn where you can't get away from20:41a shul. There's a shul on every single block, on every corner, and there's people who have20:46shtiebels everywhere. Here is a person who has accepted Shabbat early. Could he tell his wife20:52or do something for him? Are his kids bound to him or not? That is the question. So the halacha,20:57let's begin with things that there's no machloket on, and then we'll talk about when it gets a21:02little complicated. If a woman accepts Shabbat early, let's say she accepts Shabbat by21:09candlelighting, the children and her husband are not bound to her Kabbalat Shabbat. Meaning, although she may not21:15do anything on Shabbat, meaning to say, let's do it like this: candlelighting is at 5:30, which means that21:24Shabbat comes in at 5:48. Sunset comes at 5:48 is sunset, that's when Shabbat comes in. So here's a21:30woman who accepted Shabbat by 5:30. There's another 18 minutes till sunset. The children and her21:36husband do not have to accept Shabbat at 5:30 with her. They can each go ahead and do whatever they21:42need to do for Shabbat. And not only that, the halacha says, like we just learned, That the21:47woman could ask from her husband or her children to do for her. She could ask her,21:54please put on—the, excuse me, the wife could ask the children, please put on the light, I forgot to put on the21:58light in the bathroom. Please lower the AC. Please higher the heat, whatever it may be.22:04Since the other people have not accepted Shabbat, she could ask from them to do whatever they need.22:09Why? Because you're not bound by the woman's Kabbalat Shabbat. That everybody agrees on.22:15Question is the other way. When you have the husband accepting Shabbat, since he's the22:22baal habayit, since we, in general, people in the house are tafel to the husband, to the man of the house,22:30in that case you have a few opinions. There are machmirim and there are22:34mekilim. Tell you what the modern, what the poskim from our generation speak about. Rav Moshe Feinstein22:38writes something interesting. He says, really, a woman does not have to accept Shabbat when her22:44husband accepts Shabbat, but still, as a chumra, he writes it as a chumra, not as a din, as a22:51stringency, she shouldn't do any melacha that's specific for him. For example, let's say he has a study,22:59and over there he has a light that he likes to sit by, that light, and he likes to read,23:03he likes to learn Torah over there by the light on Friday night. So she could, if he accepts Shabbat early23:10at seven o'clock in the shul, she doesn't have to accept it at seven o'clock either. Shabbat23:14doesn't come until eight. She's not bound to him. But as a stringency, she should not put on the23:20light that's for him that he needs. She should put on the AC in that study for him. Why? As a23:26chumra. That's the Rav Moshe Feinstein. HaRav Ovadia goes with the din, and he says straight on, he says—23:33Neither a husband nor a wife or the parent could force, could bind any of the family23:41household members into Shabbat. If anybody chooses to accept Shabbat earlier, then Shabbat23:47is earlier for them only, and everybody else in the house could do whatever. They don't have to23:54accept Shabbat. They're still not in the Shabbat mode until they personally accept Shabbat, which means23:59if a husband comes—24:01From Shul in the summer, and it's already Shabbat for him, he can't do any24:05melacha. He sees his wife was not accepted Shabbat yet. He could ask her to put on whichever lights he wants her to put on.24:10Even the light in his own private study, according to Chacham Ovadia, there is no problem.24:14The Piskei Teshuvot, I saw, he brings a very nice proof. He says, if you learn the Shulchan Aruch, if you learn the24:21mefarshim, it doesn't—when Maran says that a person who accepted Shabbat could ask from another Jew to do melacha for him,24:27he doesn't bring anything regarding—he doesn't bring any distinction when it comes to husband or wife.24:33It seems very simple, straight halacha. You accepted Shabbat, you're allowed to tell somebody else who has not accepted Shabbat24:38to do whatever you need for him. And he concludes with the following words. Piskei Teshuvot says,24:42although one should try to be as machmir as he can, that if your husband accepted Shabbat,24:47you should try to accept Shabbat at the same time as him, the minhag is clearly not that way,24:51as we see many people in the summer. Men go to pray early, and the women still have not accepted Shabbat.24:56There's no problem. Definitely, like we brought, majority of the poskim, a lot of the poskim say that there's no problem with it.25:02That is halacha zayin. Let's just review very quickly. One who has accepted Shabbat could ask from another Jew25:08who has not accepted Shabbat to do melacha for him. The question is, some people want to know,25:13how come this is not a problem like amirah l'akum? We know on Shabbat you're not allowed to tell a goy to do work for you.25:20Why? Because even though the goy doesn't have the mitzvah of Shabbat, still, when you come to tell the goy,25:28Shabbat will be lowered in your eyes. Chachamim did not make such a gezeirah when it comes to tosefet Shabbat,25:35before Shabbat. And the answer is because we're not worried that you might come to do melacha yourself on Shabbat.25:41This is all before Shabbat. To tell another Jew who has no obligation over here,25:46he has no—excuse me—he has no issur of Shabbat, Chachamim did not need to make a gezeirah over here of the fears that they had when you would tell a goy.25:54By a goy, you might say there's a shliach lidvar aveirah, some chumrot, or some say that really because Shabbat will be lowered in your eyes.26:01This is only tosefet Shabbat. This is before Shabbat. You're just adding on to the Shabbat.26:06They didn't need to make a gezeirah in such a case. That is halacha zayin.26:10With that, we move on now to the next halachot from halacha chet until halacha—let me see over here. Yud26:21Aleph. All these halachot speak about halachot in the shul. So a lot of the ladies might be listening.26:26Most women do not go to shul on Friday night. If they are in shul, it'll probably be like either they're away on a Shabbaton or some sort of getaway,26:35and then they happen to be in shul. But otherwise, most of the time the ladies are not home.26:38So therefore, they're more relevant to the men. But still, it's nice to hear and nice to know,26:44especially if a lady prays at home, it's good to know some of these halachot.26:47Halacha talks about saying Vayechulu. No, sorry, mistaken Amidah.26:52Im ta'ah, says the Ben Ish Chai, im ta'ah b'Arvit de Shabbat26:57v'hitchil Tefilat Chol, nizkar b'emtza haberachah, gomer otah berachah v'chozer lomar shel Shabbat.26:58A person praying Friday night, and he made a mistake in his Amidah.27:02Friday night, we know we have a special prayer for Friday night, which begins with the words27:08Atah kidashta. And if a person by mistake began, after saying27:13Baruch Atah Hashem, HaKel HaKadosh, he began to say Atah27:17chonen l'adam da'at, and then he realized, oh-oh, that's not Shabbat.27:20The halacha is that you finish that particular berachah that you remembered,27:23even though it's a berachah that you say during the weekday prayer,27:27you still finish that specific27:29berachah. And once you finish that berachah with the conclusion,27:32which is whatever it is, Baruch Atah Hashem27:34chonen hada'at, whatever that berachah you may be in,27:36then you go back and you begin the part, the section that has to do with Shabbat,27:40which is Atah27:42kidashta. Why is this so?27:44The Gemara in Berachot explains that really we were supposed to pray the regular weekday tefilah27:48every single day, including Shabbat,27:50which is three berachot in the beginning, three berachot at the end,27:53and in the middle we have twelve, thirteen berachot.27:56At the time it was twelve, now it's thirteen berachot.27:58The only thing is the Chachamim felt that, you know what, Shabbat,28:01we want to enjoy Shabbat, relax a little bit,28:03have more time to go home. And in Yom Shabbat,28:06so therefore they made the Amidah shorter.28:08Instead of thirteen berachot in the middle, they cut it down to just one.28:12So now the Amidah has only seven berachot:28:15the three first ones and the three last ones,28:17and the one in the middle, which concludes with the28:19words Baruch Atah Hashem,28:21Mekadesh HaShabbat. If one by accident began a different28:24words, he started saying the blessings of the weekday Amidah,28:28he doesn't have to interrupt because28:30anyway we're trying to do this28:32takanah. Chachamim were making this28:33takanah; they made the Amidah shorter for you,28:35to try to make it shorter for you.28:36The fact that you went ahead and started saying it,28:39you've not done anything wrong. You can finish it.28:40It's not a28:42berachah levatalah. Finish the berachah, and then once you finish the28:44berachah, then afterwards you could come back and continue your Amidah28:47from the Amidah of Shabbat, that is.28:50These halachot, there's a lot of28:52the details of these28:54halachot, but when we talk about in28:55Parashat Toldot, that's where Ben Ish Chai talks about it more at length.28:58We're just saying it in short. If you make a mistake,29:01you're allowed to finish the29:03berachah. Not you're allowed to; you must finish the29:04berachah, and then afterwards only come back to it.29:07The next part of this halachah, Ben Ish Chai says,29:11there is a part, if you notice in your Amidah29:16on Friday, on Shabbat, in29:18Minchah—now let's start like this:29:20on Friday night, Leil Shabbat,29:22and Shabbat morning, and Shabbat afternoon,29:26Minchah, that means Arvit, Shacharit, and Minchah, even Musaf,29:29we conclude right before we say the words of Baruch Atah Hashem,29:33Mekadesh HaShabbat, we say29:36Vayanuchu bah, right? And over there we say,29:38we let the Jewish people rest in Shabbat.29:42And over there, if you notice on Friday night,29:43we say29:44Vayanuchu bah, and Shabbat morning we say29:46Vayanuchu bo, and Shabbat afternoon in the29:51Minchah, some minhagim, some customs have this,29:54they say29:54Vayanuchu bo, just like you said Shabbat morning,29:56and some say29:58Vayanuchu bam. And there's really difference of opinion,30:01really it all depends on the minhag.30:03Even amongst the30:04Sefardim, we find a split in the minhagim.30:06Hacham Ovadia says30:06you should say30:07bo in the morning and afternoon.30:09Ben Ish Hai brings30:10al pi mekubalim, you should say30:12bo in Shacharit and bam by30:14Mincha. And there are reasons are brought down,30:15very nice reasons are brought down over here.30:17The Knesset HaGedolah says30:19that the whole Shabbat is,30:20we know we say right in the beginning,30:22boi kallah, Shabbat Malketa. Shabbat is like a bride,30:24you're getting married.30:25And the process of a person getting married,30:28first you go to the girl's house.30:30You know, till today there's some communities30:32that still have this custom30:33that even though the guy and the girl already,30:35you know, they decide to get married,30:37they'll go to the girl's house and ask for her hand.30:39It's just a ceremonial thing,30:41you know, already they30:42accepted, they already30:43wanted. But that's how it is.30:44You first go to the girl's house,30:45you meet her parents,30:46the family meets her family,30:48and that's how30:49it's done. So therefore, in the evening30:50we begin, we say30:51on Friday night,30:52we say30:54ve'nuchu bah, speaking about Shabbat in the feminine.30:57Now this is representing,30:58says the Knesset30:59HaGedolah, when you go to the girl's house.31:01Then in the morning31:02we already say31:05ve'nuchu bo. Ve'nuchu bo says31:07over here31:07why are we referring to Shabbat in the masculine?31:11Because, melashon zachar, because31:12in the morning31:13that represents the daytime.31:15That's the next step of the wedding process31:17already.31:17The chatan brings the kallah home31:20to his house31:21for her to meet her31:23in-laws, for her to meet his parents.31:25And then by31:26Mincha you say31:28ve'nuchu bam. Ve'nuchu bam already,31:29that's when the chatan and kallah are living alone by themselves,31:33ve'hayu le-basar echad already31:34when they have the union by themselves.31:36This is how31:39the Knesset31:40HaGedolah, the great Rabbi Ben31:41Nishti from Turkey31:44from about 500 years ago,31:45explains the difference in the text.31:47Other,31:50nishti. Okay.31:51Others have different explanations,31:53different remazim31:54and everything.31:55There's a lot of beautiful stuff on this concept,31:57but the idea is that the Shabbat,31:58basically,31:58a person has...32:00Many wedding every single Shabbat,32:02you're getting married, as the Midrash brings32:04down, beautiful Midrash. Midrash says that32:06when Hashem was pairing—everything Hashem created32:08in the world, He created in pairs.32:10When Hashem was pairing up the days,32:12Sunday had Monday, Tuesday had Wednesday, Thursday32:14had Friday. Shabbat didn't32:16have anybody. So Shabbat comes to Hashem and says, Hashem,32:18everybody has a pair. I'm the32:20only single one. You know, You didn't even give me32:22somebody to be paired up with.32:24So Hashem says, Shabbat, don't worry,32:25you're not going to be single.32:27Knesset Yisrael,32:28the Jewish people, will be your match,32:30will be your zivug, will be your partner.32:32And you see the concept32:34of a marriage, the concept of a pair,32:36and like in anything in marriage, we know that32:39the woman completes the person.32:41Everything that's in32:43pair—you know, if you have one sock and you're missing32:44the other sock,32:46it's not a pair anymore. You can't wear it.32:48Then they're not matching anymore. The matching socks32:50makes it a full unit. It completes it.32:53That is the same32:54when it comes to marriage. A woman completes32:56a person. As the Gemara says, a person who's not married32:58is considered an incomplete33:00person. Shabbat completes33:02the Jew. A Jew without Shabbat33:05is incomplete. It's the same backwards.33:06Shabbat without the Jew is also33:08incomplete. But a Jew without Shabbat is33:10an incomplete person. Our match33:12is made through Shabbat, so that's why we refer to Shabbat33:15as the bride.33:18Halacha tet, a little bit connected, the same idea.33:21Halacha tet speaks about saying33:27Vayechulu. It says, After Arvit, we say33:28Vayechulu in a loud voice.33:30That means not silently, but we all say it out loud,33:33standing up.33:36Even one who is praying33:42ביחיד has to say it. There's a big,33:44very, very important33:48apikabbalah that a person should say Vayechulu. What's this concept?33:49Why? What's so important about34:02Vayechulu? So the Tur brings the Gemara in Masechet Shabbat. The Gemara says like this: אמר רב המנונא, כל המתפלל ואומר ויכולו, מעלה עליו הכתוב כאילו נעשה שותף לקדוש ברוך הוא במעשה בראשית. Anybody who prays on Friday night34:04and says the paragraph34:07Vayechulu, השמים והארץ וכל צבאם... Hashem considers him a partner in34:10creating the world.34:13Teneimar, Vayechulu hashamayim va'aretz. If you look at the word in the Torah, it doesn't have34:16any vowels,34:17it doesn't have any34:18nekudot. You could also read it34:21Vayechallu. Vayechallu means they have completed.34:23We know that God completed the creation of the world.34:25Why does it say in the plural,34:27they? Who is it referring to when it says they have completed?34:30It's referring to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, to34:32Hashem, as well as the person who's saying34:35Vayechulu. So when you say Vayechulu on34:37Friday night, you're considered a partner34:39with Hashem in completing the world.34:41We'll explain that concept in a second.34:44The other Gemara, the Gemara says34:58in Masechet Shabbat, Amar Rav Chisda, Amar Mar Ukva: Kol mitpalel b'erev Shabbat v'omer Vayechulu, shnei malachei hasharet melavin lo l'adam, מניחין ידיהם על ראשו ואומרים לו, וסר עוונך וחטאתך תכופר. Anybody who says34:59on Friday night35:01the words35:05Vayechulu, hashamayim va'aretz, that paragraph in the Torah, two angels escort the person35:08all the way to his house35:09from the shul, and they put his hands on his head,35:12and they declare,35:13Your sin is gone. You are forgiven35:16for all your sins.35:17It's amazing. What's this concept over here35:19that you're forgiven for your sins, you become a35:21partner with Hashem by just saying mere words of35:24Vayechulu? First of all, you see from here35:26that it's important. That's number one.35:28Before we get to the35:29halacha of it, you just see the importance of saying35:32Vayechulu. Why is it so important?35:33Because you have to know, you know, there's a concept,35:35they say if a tree falls35:37in a forest and nobody's there to hear it, does it make a noise?35:40Now, of course it makes a noise, but nobody's there to hear it,35:42so does it or not? The idea is that35:44although something can happen, if there's nobody35:46there to witness it or to take part of it,35:49then it's considered35:50as if it hasn't happened.35:52Same idea. Hashem created Shabbat.35:54If Hashem created Shabbat and nobody has kept Shabbat,35:56nobody is living the testimony.35:58When you keep Shabbat, you should know it's a36:00big statement to the world.36:01You're giving the statement to the world that there's a God in the world36:04who has created the world in six days and rested on Shabbat.36:06That's your statement by36:08just keeping Shabbat. When somebody36:10sees you and he sees that,36:12you know, a goy who doesn't understand, he'll give you something.36:14He'll say, I'm sorry, it's my Sabbath.36:16I can't touch this on Sabbath.36:19What you're saying is,36:20you know, of course he has to find out exactly36:22why keeping the Sabbath, but basically the statement is36:24that there's a God who created the world,36:26and just like He stopped from His36:28work on Shabbat, we also stop36:30on Shabbat. So therefore, by you36:32declaring on Friday night,36:34Vechullu hashamayim v'haaretz, which is when you're36:36already entering the Shabbat36:38to keep Shabbat, you are36:40partnered with Hashem. It's because36:41the creation has now come to its36:44goal; it has fulfilled its mission.36:45The creation of Shabbat36:47to show that there's a God in the world who's created the36:50world. Now by you keeping Shabbat36:52and declaring that God has done it, you're36:53the partner in Hashem. You're36:57basically confirming36:58Hashem's creation36:59of the world. The other one, the37:01Chida says a beautiful explanation. How come a person37:04says Vechullu is forgiven? He says37:06when you say Vechullu, any mitzvah that we37:07do, we know we create malachim, we37:09create angels. When you say37:11Vechullu on Friday night, you create37:13angels, and these angels are the ones that escort you37:15all the way to the house. And these37:17are the ones that you say,37:21you know, Shalom aleichem, malachei hasharet, malachei Elyon. These are the angels that you're saying37:24shalom aleichem to when you're saying Kiddush. These two37:25angels, says the Chida, he compares37:27it to a wedding, like we were saying up till now.37:29When a person gets married,37:31he also needs two witnesses.37:33These two angels are the two37:35witnesses that you are keeping Shabbat.37:37And just like we explained before, when a person,37:40our relationship37:41with Shabbat is like that of a chatan and37:43kallah, it's like that with a husband and wife,37:45because Shabbat completes us.37:47So too, we are getting married to Shabbat. We need37:49witnesses, and who are these witnesses?37:51These are the malachim that are only created37:53by us keeping Shabbat. So when we say37:55Vechullu and we are accepting upon ourselves Shabbat,37:57we're keeping Shabbat, these angels are created,37:59and they follow us all the way to the house,38:01and they declare that our sins are forgiven.38:03Why? Because we know the Gemara tells us38:05anybody who gets married, what happens when38:06a person gets married? His sins are38:09forgiven. We even learn that from myself. So that's38:11the idea over here. The reason38:13why the angels put their hands on your head and they38:15declare that you're forgiven on Shabbat,38:17because you are like38:19a chatan. You are getting married38:21now. Again,38:23every Shabbat you're getting married by accepting38:25upon yourself Shabbat, accepting upon yourself38:26that completely you take upon yourself the wife,38:28which is Shabbat. Therefore, you're38:31forgiven from all your sins, just like38:32a chatan would be forgiven. That is the38:34drashah regarding the halachah of38:37Vechulu. Now we get to38:38halachah in practice. Let's start with the background. How come we38:41say Vechulu after Amidah? In Amidah38:43we say38:44Vechulu, Hashamayim v'haaretz, and it seems like we did38:46our obligation from the Gemara.38:49It sounds like you have to say Vechulu and that's it.38:51So we said in Amidah. Why do we have to38:52repeat it again after Amidah?38:54And there's two reasons that's brought down. Number one is38:58because38:59sometimes when Yom Tov falls out39:01on39:03Shabbat—not sometimes, but39:05whenever you have a holiday,39:07Pesach, Shavuot, whatever it may be, that39:09falls out on39:10Shabbat—so the Amidah is different. And since the Amidah39:13is different, it didn't have Vechulu in the Amidah,39:15so you have to say Vechulu, so we say it39:17when we finish the Amidah.39:19Now even though technically we should have39:20only said it only when the holiday falls out on Shabbat,39:23still they made the takanah that39:25people shouldn't forget, we always say39:27Vechulu after the conclusion39:29of our Amidah. That's number one.39:31The other reason that's given why we say39:33Vechulu out loud is in order to cover39:35for those who don't know how to read.39:37Once upon a time, majority of the Jewish people39:39may not have known how39:42to read the39:43Hebrew, so they come to39:45shul, but since Vechulu is39:47so important during39:49Arvit, we have no chazanah, so therefore39:50the chazan would repeat Vechulu in order39:53to cover, in order that the people who don't know how to39:55read should listen in and be39:57yotzei their chovah, the saying of Vechulu.40:00Many reasons, like Ben Ish Chai says, are given why it's important to say Vayechulu specifically three times.40:07Some compare it to Parah Adumah, like the Eliyah Rabbah says. Others say it's like a chazakah; you're saying it three times. In any case,40:14there's a halacha in Shulchan Aruch, very important halacha in Shulchan Aruch,40:19siman רסח, yud-bet. And Maran says over there that when the chazzan is saying Vayechulu, or when—excuse me—when the kahal is saying40:26Vayechulu, or the Birkei Yosef, which we'll talk about in the next halacha,40:30Maran says it's forbidden for a person to speak when the kahal is saying40:36Vayechulu. Even though you finished and you're done, you said Vayechulu already,40:40you can't go ahead and talk to your friend in shul on Friday night when they're saying40:44Vayechulu. And he brings a very scary story in the Beit Yosef, and the Mishnah Berurah also brings the story.40:49Story from the Sefer Chasidim. Sefer Chasidim was written about40:51seven, eight hundred years ago by Rabbi Yehuda Chasid, one of the40:54Baalei Tosafot, and he brings a story about a person who had a friend who passed away. This friend who passed away was a big41:01chasid. Chasid means a very, very big tzaddik. There's tzaddik, and there's a higher level than the tzaddik, which is a41:07chasid. So he brings a story about a chasid who passed away, and his friend sees him in his dream.41:12But he looks at him in his dream—usually we know that people in their dreams, when dead people come to us in the dream,41:16they shine—but he sees him very, very pale. His color on his face is41:22paled out, and he says, What happened to you? What, there's no sun in Gan Eden? They told us it's all sunny.41:26What's going on over there? So he says, You know why I'm pale? You know why I look like this? Because I wasn't careful41:34during41:35Vayechulu in shul, even though I had all the mitzvot in the world. But since I was talking in shul during41:41Vayechulu, I became pale. Now, if he was a really big chasid, I doubt that he was talking every Friday night,41:46and I doubt that he was talking about nonsense. He wasn't asking what was the latest41:51score in the baseball game, basketball game, or what's going on in the news. That's not what he's asking.41:57I'm sure he was talking about something else, but still.41:59You see that he became pale.42:01Therefore, Maran brings this as a halacha, asur to speak in the shul42:06when the tzibbur is saying Vayechulu and V'chameh Eshabbat. This is a halacha. This is not a42:10chumrah. This is an obligation on every single person in the shul.42:15There is a halacha that a lot of people know. A lot of times in the shul,42:18you'll see, like at the end of the Amidah—or excuse me, the end of42:21Arvit—you see a lot of people getting together and saying Vayechulu together. So there is some Acharonim that bring down42:27that since Vayechulu, you're testifying that God created the world in six days and rested on Shabbat.42:33So just like every testimony, you should stand up. The halacha is that you should stand up when you give your testimony.42:39So therefore,42:41we stand up when we say Vayechulu. Also, besides standing up when we say42:45Vayechulu, you should also say it—some say you should say it with another person, because eidut in the Torah, any testimony in the Torah42:51has to be done with two witnesses.42:54We never accept any case in the Torah, besides a very, very minor exception of42:58agunah, but otherwise we never accept the testimony of one witness. We always need a minimum of two witnesses.43:03So therefore, you need to say it with two people. A lot of the Acharonim ask on this concept,43:09because even when we have two witnesses, when each of the witnesses gives his testimony, he gives it alone.43:15So,43:16but still, since they wrote it, they say it's good that a person should say it in pairs,43:21but there's no obligation, especially if he's Sephardi. In fact, the Olat Tzion, Chacham Ovadia Tzion, brings the Chazon43:28Ish, and he says that if a person is praying the Amidah and he hears that the tzibbur is about to get up to43:33Vayechulu, he doesn't have to rush his Amidah in order that he should finish and say Vayechulu together with the tzibbur.43:38It's fine to say it on his own. And even others who say—even those who say that you have to say it with another43:44person—if you don't catch another person to say Vayechulu with, then you can always say, just don't think you're saying it as an43:50eidut. So this is the bottom line halacha. If you could, if you want,43:53you should try to say it together with the tzibbur or with another person. This way it becomes like an43:58eidut. But if you don't catch another person, you're davening with another person,44:02there's no obligation to say it with another person. You should say it anyway, like Ben Ish Chai says, you should say it three times44:08on Friday night. What does that mean?44:11You should say it one time in the Amidah, one time after the Amidah, and another third time we say it when?44:16When we say Kiddush, when we say Kiddush on Friday night, that's when we say Vayechulu on the third time,44:22and the Sefarim bring down, even those who don't pray with the minyan, like Beit Shai brings down over here,44:26you should say it. In any case, you should always say it to make sure you've completely said it three times.44:32Next44:34halacha, halacha yud. Let's see, we have—yeah, we could catch up. Halacha yud. Halacha yud, if you're praying again in the shul, you'll see that44:42there's—you have Me'ein Sheva. What is Me'ein Sheva? Me'ein Sheva is the right after Vayechulu, the chazzan starts to say44:50a beracha, beautiful words of the Vechavi, understand the Hebrew. They're always beautiful, but this is very nice,44:55and different communities have different tunes. Ashkenazis—for the idea for me,44:58I still have the tune of the Ashkenazim from yeshiva days. Very, very special. Yes, even the Ashkenazi tune.45:04Okay, so in any case, the45:10beracha Me'ein Sheva says—let me just give you a little bit of background from a little bit Kabbalah and the Gemara. What's45:15the beracha Me'ein Sheva? Beracha Me'ein Sheva, once upon a time the shuls45:19were more affordable because they were not in the main city; they were in the45:25fields. Fields—the real estate is very, very cheap over there.45:28You just go to the field, you knock down a few trees, and you build the shul. And most people had to travel out of town,45:33out of their small little village or town, in order to get to the shuls in their towns or in their cities.45:39Because of such, and there's no streetlights back then,45:43so people used to travel together to go to shul, and when they finished shul, they traveled together back to go back home.45:49And people didn't like to travel by themselves, and it was sometimes very scary to travel by yourself.45:53You could bump into animals or the wrong people.45:57So therefore, the Chachamim made it.45:59They said, what would happen on Friday night, a person comes late to shul, if it's any other time.46:04Then a person comes late to shul. You know, it's46:06deitana atzaba. At night, if you come late to shul, what's going to happen is46:09that you're coming, you're praying Amidah when everybody already finished Amidah and they're going to finish46:14Aleinu, Shir Berachot, and they're going to go home, and you're going to be left there.46:16You might have to walk home by yourself. If you walk home by yourself, one of two problems can happen.46:19Number one is that you might be attacked on the way home because it's very dark, and you might hurt yourself or46:24somebody might hurt you. Number two is you might reach home safely, but you'll be terrified, you'll be scared.46:30You may not come back again out of fear that something wrong may happen the next time. So therefore the Chachamim said,46:35we want to prolong46:39the kahal in the shul just in case somebody came late.46:42So they instituted a berachah called Berachah Me'ein Sheva right after the Amidah, that the chazzan should say in case somebody came late.46:48Then what you have to do is, then this way46:52he could catch up to the rest of the kahal, and this way he could walk home together from the fields.46:57That's the reason that's given for Berachah Me'ein Sheva, which47:00technically should only apply if the shuls were outside in our days,47:04that we have streetlights and everything. Technically it shouldn't apply, but still that's the way it was instituted.47:09Nobody took away this takanah, and therefore we must continue to do the47:14Berachah Me'ein Sheva. The Arizal says no. I mean, besides that—not no,47:19excuse me, you can't argue on the Arizal. The Arizal says besides what the Gemara says, of course,47:22but he said no, there's a deeper reason why we say47:24Berachah Me'ein Sheva: al pi Kabbalah. It's in place of the Chazarah, and if you want to know how important the Chazarah is,47:29go read what the Arizal writes about the Chazarah, how important it is, very, very important47:34berachah, al pi Chazarah. So therefore, as such,47:36it comes out that we're going to have a major machloket when it comes to47:41the following47:43halachah. Maran brings down in the Shulchan Aruch that if you have a minyan that's gathering together in somebody's house,47:49let's say in the time where a brit chatanim, a person got married and they're having the sheva berachot meal,47:54so they have already twenty, thirty people invited to the meal,47:57so they said, you know, let's make our own minyan over here, and they're praying in the house.48:00Or, no, I'll explain the opposite way, where you have a beit avel, where the mourner is, they're praying in the mourner's house on Friday night, and they're making a minyan.48:08In that case, says Maran, you don't have the reason like the way it says it in the Gemara, which is what?48:12Which is that we don't have the houses in the field. So says Maran, Shulchan Aruch, a person who is praying in beit hatanim,48:19basically if you're praying in a private house, you should not say the bracha of48:26Me'en Sheva, because the reason of the takanah of Me'en Sheva doesn't apply. This is not the words of Maran alone;48:31these are the words of the Rishonim that come before him.48:34That's according to the reason, based on the reason that it's in order to protect the person.48:40On the other reason, according to the Kabbalah, since it's very, very important to pray the48:47bracha Me'en Sheva, so therefore, according to the Arizal, you have the Rashash, and you have also the Ben Ish Chai going that way,48:53and a lot of Mekubalim, even the poskim who go with derech Kabbalah, they'll say that if you're praying in somebody's house,49:01you'll always say bracha Me'en Sheva, even if you're not in a shul,49:05even if you don't have a set minyan. It just happens to be you made a minyan, you'll still have to say the49:11bracha Me'en Sheva. And Ben Ish Chai brings that that's the Rashash's opinion, and that's the way he made it in Yerushalayim as well.49:16So therefore, what do we do? If you're making your own private minyan on Friday night, what49:21is the din? So if it's a minyan that's kavua, that every single week, even though it's only for the summer,49:26but every single week you meet together on Friday night in somebody's house, that became like a mini shul,49:31and therefore you will say the bracha Me'en Sheva, then there's no problem.49:36If you're not a set minyan, it just happens to be you made a minyan, then in that case, according to Shulchan Aruch,49:43which Chacham Ovadia also says, it's assur to say; he holds it's forbidden to say49:48bracha Me'en Sheva, it's bracha levatalah. According to Bnei Sefard, you must say it. So the Ohr Letzion makes a little bit of a compromise,49:53and he says like this: In Yerushalayim, the minhag is like the way the Ben Ish Chai brings down from the Rashash,49:58that the minhag in Yerushalayim, even in private houses, that they say Mincha regardless if it's in the shul or outside the shul.50:04However, if it's outside of Yerushalayim, outside of Eretz Yisrael certainly,50:09if a person is praying on Friday night with a private minyan, then it depends on your minhag.50:14If you already have a minhag of saying Bechad Min Sheva, you could continue.50:16If not, you should not say Bechad Min Sheva and go with the psak of the Shulchan Aruch,50:25because really, even though we say50:28Ein omrim Sabal neged haArizal, in this case, since the Arizal didn't say it clearly, it's just under the sefarim's words,50:33therefore, he says the Chacham Bension, you don't have to. Therefore, you shouldn't say50:41Bechad Min Sheva. Some quick halachot about Min Sheva, and then we'll finish. We'll continue, be'ezrat Hashem, next week.50:45Hopefully next week we'll finish the50:47halachot. Min Sheva: if one prayed the wrong Amidah on Friday night,50:54meaning, let's say he didn't say Ya'aleh v'Yavo, he didn't say Mashiv haruach — really, Ya'aleh v'Yavo you don't have to repeat — but let's say he didn't say50:59Mashiv haruach, in any case that person would have to repeat the51:03Amidah. But Ramban brings down that if you listen to the Birkat Me'ein Sheva from the chazzan from beginning to end,51:07you could be yotzei dei51:10chovah. Other halacha that's brought down also: preferably, a person should not bow down51:14— the chazzan should not bow down when he says Baruch Atah Hashem,51:17Elokeinu v'Elokei Avoteinu, in the beginning of51:19Bechad Min Sheva. But if one does already, if you see minhag in the shul that they do already,51:23there is what to rely on. If you want to look, look in51:28Rappeh Alim, chelek gimmel, siman chaf gimmel, and you'll see what he brings down over here.51:30So that's the halacha. That's the last halacha that we're doing for today. That's halacha yud.51:36Just before we finish off, let's just give another word from our sponsors,51:40Mr. Nuts on East 8th and Avenue U. It really is on Avenue between East 7th and 8th,51:46and they have all types of candy and nuts, and especially they're specializing in Purim baskets.51:51They have a big sale now, especially for Yom Mishloach Manot.51:54Go and ask for Freddy, and when you see Freddy, tell him,51:57I heard on the radio from Halacha Hour that I should come to you,52:00and be'ezrat Hashem we'll give you a good price.52:02Also, we want to announce that, meanwhile, temporarily, we're not sure when the second class will be repeated.52:09Usually we're on over here from Wednesday from 2 to 3, and it used to be on Tuesday nights from 10 to 11.52:14I'm not sure exactly; we're going to switch the time a little bit,52:17so be'ezrat Hashem we'll let you know in the next class exactly when the time will be.52:22Until then, thank you for listening. Thank you, Dave, for taking care of the calls.52:25And if you have any questions, I'll still be in the station here for another 10, 15 minutes.52:28If you have any questions in halacha or on what we learned on or something else, you could call in.52:34Until then, have a wonderful week and Shabbat shalom.