Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws of Counting the Omer (May 11)Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysRabbi Uri Nahum · March 18, 2019−15Play+30Position0:0059:01Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio, live on Wednesday afternoon.0:06Bezrat Hashem, today's class, we will have a special class today.0:11Like we said in the past, today's classes, or the classes in between Pesach and0:16Shavuot, are a little bit different from our regular classes,0:19meaning to say we usually speak about the halachot of Shabbat specifically from the0:24Ben Ish Hai. Today's class will obviously bring—it's halacha still, we're not veering off of0:30that—but we're still in the halachot of the seasonal halachot,0:34and therefore we're discussing a lot of halachot that deal with this special period that we're going to speak about today,0:39the period known as Sefirat HaOmer.0:41So before we continue into the class, just to give you very quickly a little bit of the regular, you know, beginnings,0:47and it is as follows.0:49The number to the studio is0:53718-683-5858. As we usually do, we try to only take questions towards the end.0:57The reason for that is people asked, how come?0:59The answer is because there's a lot of material that we try to cover,1:03try to condense it, and we try to, you know, because especially these seasonal halachot,1:07we want to get it out before, you know, the season's over.1:10So therefore, we only take questions off the air.1:12At the end, we will stay around to answer any of your questions.1:17However, you could text us 347-927-8398, and that is encouraged.1:22We like that.1:23If you text in your questions, comments, this way throughout the class,1:27if I see there's something perhaps I missed or we didn't clarify,1:32Bezrat Hashem, we'll bring it up and we'll discuss it as well.1:35The other way to just listen in is jrootradio.com or on the JRoot Radio app,1:42and the phone number to listen in in case you're running out of your car and you don't want to miss,1:46because you don't want to miss some halacha and the Torah wherever you go and JRoot on the go,1:50so 712-432-4217. You can listen to all the classes over there, or2:00718-506-9099. Like we said, these are seasonal halachot between Pesach and2:03Shavuot, and the subject that we will be speaking about today is, or are, the laws of the Omer.2:12Now, today's class is about the laws of Omer. Even though these halachot usually should be learned really before Pesach,2:21but before Pesach we're busy learning about the halachot of the holiday of Pesach.2:25Nobody's even thinking.2:26You know, a lot of times it hits you, like the second night of Pesach, and you're like,2:30Whoa, Sefirat HaOmer tonight. We have to count the Omer and all the minhagim.2:33So we kind of like jump into it.2:35But still, there's a lot of questions and there's a lot of details that we need to know.2:39And even if we know the basics, there's still a lot of things that do come up.2:44As an introduction to the laws of Sefirat HaOmer, I would like to first point out and bring out what the sefarim bring down2:53about these days in between Pesach and Shavuot.2:55Let's start with the basics, and then we'll build up a little bit more before the halacha.3:02So we look in the Torah, and the Torah says that there's a mitzvah to count the Omer.3:08There's a mitzvah to count basically 49 days, or the Torah puts it 50 days3:14to get to the 50th day between Pesach and Shavuot.3:16Sefarim point out that it doesn't say the date of the holiday of Shavuot like the way the Torah says it by the other holidays.3:26For example, by Pesach, Torah says it's on the 15th of the first month.3:30That's what we know as the 15th of Nisan.3:32By Yom Kippur it says the 10th of the seventh month.3:35Rosh Hashanah, the first of the seventh month.3:37It's Sukkot, the 15th of the seventh month.3:40But when it comes to the holiday of Shavuot, it does not mention a3:44date. The holiday of Shavuot has no date.3:46Rather, it's dependent on the counting.3:49You count your days, you count 49 days, or 50 days as the Torah puts it, seven weeks,3:56and after you count, you reach the holiday of Shavuot.3:58And Sefarim point out. How come?4:01How come there's no date by Shavuot?4:02And it's very important that it's really because the holiday of Shavuot is not just a holiday where we commemorate the giving of the4:09Torah, but the holiday of Shavuot is where we receive the Torah,4:12and each person receives the amount of Torah that he's going to be4:17zocheh, that he's going to merit to learn and to gain throughout the next year.4:20How much Torah will you learn?4:22It all depends on how you prepare for it.4:25So therefore, in anticipation for the holiday of the giving of the Torah,4:29Torah says, I want you to count.4:31Like when a person's excited, as the chinuch says, when a person's excited for something,4:34he's waiting for that day to come.4:36Ahatan, waiting for that day to get married.4:39Little kids waiting for their birthday.4:40You ever ask a little kid, How old are you?4:42And he'll say, I am four years old and in seven days and four hours and 254:48seconds—oh wait, 24 seconds,4:5023 seconds—right? He'll tell you, That's when my birthday.4:52He's anticipating, he's excited for it.4:54When you wait for something, you count.4:58So instead of counting down, says the chinuch, we count up.5:03Why do we count up?5:04Because we don't want to feel so long in the beginning.5:06Imagine you start 50 days—oh, 50 days from now.5:09Now you're telling me to get excited 50 days?5:10And now when I say one, it's5:12nisht gefehrlach, it's not such a big deal.5:14And once we start counting one, two, three, four, so that's it.5:16We're going to continue all the way until we get to the final days.5:20So this is really the basics.5:22This is why we count, based on the chinuch and the sefarim bring down,5:25we count the Omer in anticipation to receiving the Torah.5:28However, the mekubalim, the Rishonim that were5:32mekubalim, and the later mekubalim point out that these days are very, very special.5:36The Ramban says that the days in between Pesach and Shavuot are like a5:42Chol Hamoed, with Pesach being the first part of the holiday5:44and Shavuot being the final part of the holiday.5:45It's all one big connection.5:47It's not two separate holidays.5:48It's actually one big— As lashon naas, ginormous holiday.5:54This is what the holiday of5:56Shavuot—this is this big holiday that starts with coming out of Egypt,6:00coming out of Mitzrayim, and receiving the Torah.6:03Why? Because really they go hand in hand.6:07What does it mean that we came out of Mitzrayim?6:09What are we celebrating, that we came out of Egypt,6:11that we became a nation?6:12We are not a nation without a Torah.6:14A Jew is defined by his Torah.6:16That's how we are.6:17We're not defined by land.6:18We're not defined by anything.6:20We're not even by time.6:21There's no holiday.6:22There's no date for the holiday of Shavuot,6:24because the Jews as a people are only a people of6:28Torah. Wherever we went throughout our Jewish history,6:30and most of the time it was not in the land of Israel,6:32most of the time it was elsewhere,6:34we were defined only by the people of the book.6:36We are the people of the book.6:37A Jew could live anywhere in the world.6:39The greatest—you know,6:40think about6:41it—the greatest of the greats,6:42the greatest of the greats of the Jewish people6:44never stepped foot in6:47Eretz Yisrael, like Moshe Rabbeinu,6:49like Aharon HaKohen,6:51like even go back to the6:53tzaddikim before the founding of the State of Israel.6:56People didn't go there.6:58It just, you know, it wasn't easy.6:59The Gra, ah, the Gra wanted to go to7:01Eretz Yisrael, and he saw that he couldn't make it.7:03People—of course, there's a great mitzvah to live in7:06Eretz Yisrael, but they weren't zocheh to go to7:08Eretz Yisrael. It's a big zechut to go to7:09Eretz Yisrael. Baruch Hashem, we have such an opportunity, a privilege today.7:12But a lot of tzaddikim were not7:15zocheh. What, they're not Jewish?7:15Of course they're Jewish.7:16They're the ones who teach us,7:17who tell us everything about our religion.7:20Ela mai, it's not7:21תלוי in that. We're defined by the book,7:22and therefore this big holiday,7:23it's really one long holiday,7:26and these days are like a7:28Chol Hamoed, a big days of celebration.7:30Nar Israel says,7:32you see how the trees are growing,7:34just like in the physical world,7:36as the Maharal points out.7:37When you see things happening in the physical world,7:40it's only a7:45remez. It's alluding to what's happening in the spiritual world.7:48And because we're not so in tune with our spirituality,7:52so therefore Hashem shows us what's going on in the physical world7:54to let us realize what's going on in our spiritual world.7:58So in the physical, we see that the—8:00The time for the harvest to grow the most is at this time.8:03This is, think about it, this tree started budding in Nisan,8:07and he said, Ah, I have time.8:09They said, Rebbe Chayim, no, there's plenty of time.8:10By now already, you see how fast they're growing?8:12That's it. After Shavuot, pretty much the trees are almost fully developed.8:17Most of the growth that we see on the tree happens now. Likewise,8:21most of the spiritual growth that a person could gain throughout the whole year,8:25believe it or not, is in these days,8:26in the days between Pesach and Shavuot, in days of8:32Sefirat HaOmer. But unfortunately, also these days of Sefirat HaOmer were also known as days of tragedy.8:37And we know, as the Gemara tells us in8:40Yevamot, that Rabbi Akiva had 12,000 pairs of students. That's how the Gemara calls them,8:4524,000 students, and they all died in this period.8:50Whether they died in one year or throughout the years,8:53but they happened to just always die between Pesach and8:56Shavuot is not clear from the Gemara. My understanding is of the latter,8:59that they died throughout the years, but it happens to be that they always died in between Pesach and Shavuot.9:04So you see, it's also a time of din. It's a time of tragedy,9:07and we have customs also of commemorating the tragedies that took place in this period of time.9:13In fact, the Arizal says these days between Pesach and Shavuot are a time of din.9:17It's not a contradiction. How can there be such special days and it's also a time of din?9:22Because anybody who knows how the system works in Shamayim,9:27whenever something great is going to come towards a person or towards a community9:31or towards a people or the world, it always comes, first of all, has to go through customs.9:40And the customs in Shamayim are the Satan and the midat hadin.9:44They have to see if the people receiving these blessings are are fit for it.9:50If the people receiving these blessings are worthy of the blessings Hashem wants to bestow upon them.9:56So therefore, being that we see that the world is growing9:59and we're going to benefit,10:02lehanot bahem bnei adam, we're going to have so much benefit from the plantation, from the world that Hashem has given us:10:06beautiful trees, food, fruits, beautiful weather, everything is nice.10:10So the world goes through a zman of din,10:13and in the spiritual world we're also going to go through menasiyah. Therefore we're10:17upfront. We have to see, in Shamayim they have to see if we deserve it or not.10:21And because the din is at its height, people are judged very strictly in this time10:26because of the specialness of the time, because of what we could gain.10:29Therefore, unfortunately, the students of Rabbi Akiva, as great as they10:33were—and we shouldn't, chas v'shalom, put them down;10:35we were nothing compared to the smallest toenail that they threw out even from their bodies.10:42We were nothing compared to them.10:44They were huge giants, huge giants.10:47We, chas v'shalom, we should say any criticism about them.10:51What Chazal tell us is only for us to learn for ourselves, not to put them down,10:55chas v'shalom. And still, because of their greatness, because of their stature, because they were so great,11:00and because the time of growth was so great coming,11:06so therefore they were judged on such a strict level,11:09and unfortunately 24,000 students of his died.11:12And unfortunately people don't realize what a tragedy it is.11:15We live so far away from them. Nobody knew them. We don't know anything about them.11:19The Gemara doesn't really mention their names or anything else.11:22So, but Chazal told us that, you know, it's a big tragedy,11:25and whether you realize or not, there are customs that, in order to remind us what a tragedy it is.11:30The tragedy perhaps is that we don't realize what we really lost.11:34In any case, that is. What the period, what this period is, the period of11:40Sefirat HaOmer. On one hand, it's a wonderful period where it's a time of growth and closeness,11:47and it's a time of preparation for receiving the Torah.11:51At the same time, it's also a time of tragedy.11:54But they all come, all these things come with halachic obligations.11:57The Torah tells us, u'sfartem lachem, you have to count.12:01And therefore, the counting, the mitzvah of counting the Omer, is something that's essential.12:07We're going to speak about it right now, if it's relevant to who is it relevant,12:10men, women, everything else,12:14b'ezrat Hashem. And the laws also, where we commemorate the national tragedy that happened in this period of time,12:20which is the passing away of the students of Rabbi Akiva.12:23Now, because the laws sometimes feel dry a little bit, so therefore,12:26and usually this class is going to be aired when,12:29in the middle of Sefirat HaOmer, when people are already counting and they already know the basics.12:32So therefore, we try to cut down on the12:34basics, and we try to focus more on the situations that come up in these12:40halachot. And there's going to be four parts to the class,12:42whether we cover it all in one class or two classes, only time will tell.12:45The four parts of the class is like this:12:47number one is the basic laws of counting the12:51Omer. Part two will be questions and answers on the halachot of counting the12:57Omer. Part three of the class will be the basic laws of the customs in the13:01Omer, minhagei haOmer, which is the customs of mourning.13:03And finally, number four will be the questions and answers,13:06the question-and-answer part of the situations that come up regarding the13:13minhagei haOmer. Let's begin with the basic laws of counting the13:16Omer. Very, very simple.13:18Torah, open up the Chumash, Parashat Emor.13:20Those who like the English chapter and verse is chapter 23, verse 15, okay?13:29Perek chaf-gimel, pasuk tet-vav. Torah says, we read this on almost all the holidays,13:35u'sfartem lachem mimachorat haShabbat. You should count for yourselves from the day after Shabbat,13:37and here Shabbat means, about, it means the day of Pesach, the first day of Pesach.13:49Miyom havi'achem et omer hatenufah, from the day that you bring the korban haOmer, sheva Shabbatot temimot tihyena. Count for yourselves seven. Weeks,13:53and the Torah says they should be complete.13:55This word temimot is very key over here.13:57It should be complete full weeks.14:00Later on, the Torah says, In the end of the14:04pasuk, Tisperu chamishim yom, I want you to count fifty days.14:07Here the Torah is telling us two things:14:09count for yourself seven weeks, and count for yourself also fifty days.14:12Chazal come and teach us the meaning of the words,14:16as we don't know what it means.14:17We didn't get a mitzvah from Moshe Rabbeinu.14:18Chazal, who have a tradition, rabbi from rabbi,14:21all the way back to Moshe Rabbeinu,14:22teach us that the word14:24Shabbat here doesn't mean a regular Shabbat of the week,14:27but Shabbat refers to the day of Pesach.14:30Likewise, when it says chamishim yom,14:32it means count forty-nine days up to the fiftieth day.14:36Good.14:37Now, since this pasuk is found in Parashat Emor,14:39we should assume that this mitzvah is really a mitzvah14:45mideoraita, like anything that's found in the Torah.14:50Uk'shartem lachem, uk'shartem otam l'ot al yedchem, you should tie it on your hand,14:52that's referring to the mitzvah14:53of tefillin; tefillin is14:55deoraita. Likewise, we should assume that counting Omer is14:58mideoraita. However, notice in the pasuk that it says,15:00From the day that you bring the korban haOmer,15:03Omer15:05hatenufah, the special15:05korban—we don't have time to talk about it15:07yet—but this special korban that was brought together,15:09the Torah connects it together.15:10So therefore, based on that,15:12we find a machloket in the Gemara15:14how to understand the mitzvah in our days,15:16that we don't have a Beit HaMikdash15:18and we don't have the mitzvah of bringing the korban haOmer.15:23Is the counting a separate mitzvah from the korban,15:29and therefore I have two separate mitzvot15:31mideoraita: to count and to bring the korban?15:34Or is the counting and the korban go hand in hand?15:37That means if I'm able to bring the korban,15:40then I also count—that is15:42min haTorah. This, guess what?15:43The answer is a15:45machloket, Masechet Menachot,15:46daf samech vav amud alef,15:49between Rabbanan15:52and Rabbi Ashe versus a15:53meimar. The machloket is exactly as we said.15:56Now, this machloket is not only in the Gemara,15:58but extends also to the—16:00Rishonim. And we have a few Rishonim that understand that this counting of the Omer is completely separate from the mitzvah of bringing the korban,16:09and therefore, even though we don't have a Beit HaMikdash today and we're not bringing the korban, the counting is a separate mitzvah,16:17and the mitzvah is min16:19haTorah. Who are some of these Rishonim?16:21The famous ones: Rif, Rambam — Rambam, that is, as we say — and16:26Chinuch. However, on the other hand, we find other Rishonim that say, no, they go16:31hand in hand. And therefore, the fact that we can't bring a korban today, counting is also non-obligatory from the Torah.16:35Ah, but we count. Yeah,16:36it's miderabbanan. The rabbis instituted it,16:39so this way we don't forget the mitzvah.16:42If we think that over time we're going to completely forget it,16:43korbanot we can't bring,16:45b'seder. But the counting, the anticipation for receiving the Torah, we should still do it,16:50but it's going to be only16:52miderabbanan. Some of the Rishonim on this side of the fence who hold that counting Omer is16:58miderabbanan are the Rosh, the Rashba, the Ran, as well as the Raza.17:04Maran in Beit Yosef says that the majority of Rishonim hold that the mitzvah of counting the Omer in our days,17:11that we don't have a Beit HaMikdash, is17:13miderabbanan, although it doesn't say anything in Shulchan Aruch clearly which way it is,17:17but many poskim treat it as only17:21derabbanan, and they point out a few proofs that even Maran holds that it's17:26derabbanan, like the way he mentioned in the Beit Yosef.17:29Now you're going to ask me, whoa, who cares?17:32Rabbi, do I have to count or not?17:34Yeah, you have to count.17:35So if I have to count, so what's the difference, deraita or17:37derabbanan? Then I have to count.17:39Ah, you want to know what the difference is?17:41Because we hold, like the way the Beit Yosef says,17:44because the majority of opinions hold that counting Omer in our days is17:49miderabbanan, so therefore we're going to be a little bit more lenient in certain areas,17:54as we'll see in our cases that we're going to bring up in the questions and answers section,17:57we will be a little bit more lenient.18:00For example, for example. Counting,18:03if, you know, unlike Kriat Shema, which is18:06mid'Oraita, the time to say Kriat Shema, we tell you to be machmir to be18:11yotzei according to all opinions, whereas opposed to counting the Sefirat HaOmer, which is only18:16mid'Rabbanan, we'll be lenient to allow you to count earlier.18:19Also, whenever we have safekot, whenever we have doubts,18:22we can be a little bit more lenient, being that this is a mitzvah only18:28mid'Rabbanan. We will see, b'ezrat Hashem, some of these halachot18:31will try to highlight why it's important if it's d'Rabbanan or18:34d'Oraita. We just want to give that as a basic introduction.18:36Now, simple basic halachot in the application of the mitzvah.18:41Number one is, okay, I count. How do you count?18:43The answer is, the Torah says, Count for yourselves the shiv'ah shavuot and fifty days,18:50like we said, forty-nine days.18:52So there the Torah commands me, and by18:54the Chachamim instituted in the same style, in the same theme as the Torah.18:58So the Torah commands me to count weeks and also to count days,19:03and this is the chiyuv. When a person is counting the Omer,19:05we're counting these days from now until19:08Shavuot, you must count the weeks and you must count the days as well.19:12You can't just count one of them.19:14L'mashal, I'll give you an example.19:16Let's say19:18Lag BaOmer. Ah, Lag BaOmer, that's the thirty-third day of the Omer.19:20When we count the thirty-third day of the Omer,19:22it's not enough to say that today is the thirty-third day of the Omer.19:25Rather, we have to say, Today is the thirty-third day of the Omer,19:29which are also four weeks and five days.19:33Do the math, thirty-three divided by seven, by the way.19:35Okay, anyway,19:37thirty-three days, which are four weeks and19:40chamishah yamim. Of course, if you understand Hebrew, you're supposed to say it in Hebrew:19:48Hayom shloshah v'shloshim yom laOmer, shehem arba'ah shavuot v'chamishah yamim. This is the way you count.19:50Every single day you're supposed to count.19:51When do you count? At night,19:52because that's the beginning of the day.19:54That's when we started the harvest of the19:57Omer. We're counting the days, right?19:59So the day begins at night.20:02Vayehi erev vayehi boker. And just like any mitzvah,20:04whether it's20:06de'oraita or de'rabbanan, we make a blessing before we perform the mitzvah,20:09right? Ladies light the candles for Shabbat.20:13It's20:13mid'rabbanan. Shlomo HaMelech is the one who instituted it.20:15And what do they do?20:16They make a blessing before they perform the mitzvah20:18of lighting the candles.20:20Okay, so, fine, we already discussed that once in the past.20:23Another case is lighting the menorah of20:26Chanukah. We make the blessing,20:27and then we light the menorah of20:29Chanukah. Likewise over here,20:30when coming to perform the mitzvah of counting the Omer,20:33we must make a blessing,20:34and then we count.20:36The Gemara points out that the20:38counting has to be done also standing up.20:40It's learned from certain words in the pasuk.20:45And what's customary,20:47what the minhag is, that after counting,20:50a lot of people do what the Arizal says to do,20:51which is they read the20:53mizmor Lamnatzeach b'Neginot in the image of a menorah.20:57And also a lot of people say,20:58as the Sefardim do,20:59they say the21:01Ana Bekoach, the 42 words,21:03which have very deep Kabbalistic meaning21:05and very big connection to the days of Sefirat21:09HaOmer. Preferable that a person should count this mitzvah with a minyan,21:13as anything that's done with a minyan21:15has advantage of b'rov am hadrat melech.21:17And this is how a person fulfills the mitzvah,21:19very, very basic.21:20There's also a time when to21:22count, like we said, has to be in the evening,21:24because that's when the day starts.21:26The range of time that a person has21:28to count the mitzvah of the Omer21:31is all the21:32way—with a beracha, so it depends.21:33If you count with a beracha or without21:37beracha. With a21:39beracha, if you want to count the Omer with saying the blessing,21:42you could count from any time,21:45from shekiah, sunset,21:47all the way until alot21:49hashachar, which is dawn.21:50That's with21:51the beracha. However, if you forgot21:54or something happened and you weren't able to count21:57all the way until alot21:58hashachar, you remembered the next day that you forgot to22:00count the night before,22:02so you can still count.22:02We follow the22:04opinion—we were lenient because, again,22:05it's derabanan, right?22:06So we're lenient like22:08some of the Rishonim, Rabbeinu Tam, who says22:09that you can also count in the day with22:11the beracha. Now, we don't count with the beracha in the daytime.22:14We don't hold like22:15Rabbeinu Tam that you should say a22:17beracha on counting the Omer in the daytime,22:19but we do hold like him22:20that you're allowed to22:22count and22:26you're still considered like you didn't miss from the counting,22:28and you can continue counting with a blessing22:30every single day.22:31So therefore, in summary,22:33if a person is counting the Omer,22:36to count it with a blessing,22:38you have only the22:39nighttime. The range is between22:41shekiah all the way until alot22:43hashachar. However, in the daytime22:44you can still count,22:45but without a22:47beracha, and that goes all the way until the following night,22:52tzeit hakochavim. However,22:53this is the range.22:55The best preferable time to count,22:57Maran says,23:02siman taf-pei-tet, se'if bet, vehamedakdekim—those are very careful with23:08mitzvot—sofrim mitzeit hakochavim. They only count from23:10tzeit hakochavim, when the stars come out,23:12v'chen raui la'asot, and this is what's proper as well.23:15So therefore,23:16a lot of people, Baruch Hashem,23:17when it comes to this23:18mitzvah, they want to fulfill23:21it b'hiddur, beautify the23:22mitzvah, and they try to count as soon as the time comes,23:26but specifically by23:28tzeit hakochavim. Even though you can count23:29earlier, like we learned in Chol HaMoed Shabbat,23:32before23:32tzeit hakochavim you have23:34shekiah; between shekiah and23:35tzeit hakochavim you have something known as23:37bein hashmashot. Technically you could count23:38then, but it's not the preferable time.23:40The preferable time is between.23:41is right after23:45seta kochavim. Now it's best also to count.23:47Don't wait till way after23:49seta kochavim, because the Torah does say23:50temimot; you should have full days.23:52It means count the day as soon as it comes in.23:55If you delay it,23:56it's going to be too late.23:57So therefore, try to count immediately23:59when seta kochavim.24:00The question is, what is the time of24:03Sefirat HaOmer? This is a whole shiur to give on24:06what is Sefirat HaOmer and reasons,24:08which is going to give you the times in simple.24:11Keep in mind, a lot of poskim, most poskim, hold that24:14counting na'omer nowadays is only24:16miderabbanan. So therefore, a lot of poskim are lenient in the times.24:19Even Hacham Ovadia in general tells you24:22that Shabbat should not be over until Rabbeinu Tam's time,24:25which is 72 minutes.24:26When it comes to counting24:29the Omer, he says 13 and a half minutes24:32after sunset, a person could already count24:35the Omer. It's only derabbanan; you could be lenient.24:37Going up the list, Hacham Ben Sion says24:40no, 13 and a half minutes is not the preferable time.24:42The preferable time is about 25 to 27 minutes.24:44And I saw recently in the book24:47Mekabtziel, which is a sefer written by the Ben24:50Ish Hai, and he says to count the Omer around 30 minutes,24:53between 25 to 30 minutes.24:54But he says almost 30 minutes after shekiah.24:59Rabbi Ribiat brings down that25:01by the Ashkenazim, they noheg between 50 to 72 minutes,25:05and he says somebody who wants to be25:06lenient as early as 45 minutes could also be lenient.25:10That's by the Ashkenazim.25:11Now, should one wait Rabbeinu Tam, like any other25:15halachot? No, because you want to do it as early as possible.25:18But of course after25:20Sefirat HaOmer, and because derabbanan, you could be25:21lenient. However, one is very careful25:23that everything that he does,25:25he does like Rabbeinu Tam.25:27Whether it's derabbanan, de'oraita, is very25:29machmir, or sometimes be lenient, whatever.25:31But he does everything like Rabbeinu Tam,25:32then you're right.25:33But by counting25:36Sefirat HaOmer, you could also wait 72 minutes after shekiah25:38to count25:40Sefirat HaOmer. This is the basic of how to perform the mitzvah25:43of counting25:45Sefirat HaOmer. There's something that's rabbinic,25:48miderabanan, that surrounds the halacha of25:52Sefirat HaOmer, and that is a general rabbinic decree25:56of any mitzvah that takes place in a specific time.26:00We know that the rabbis have the obligation,26:02as we saw in Parashat Acharei Mot,26:03that they have the obligation to make sure26:06that we keep the Torah.26:08So therefore the Chachamim made that26:09whenever there's a mitzvah that comes in a specific time,26:12that you shouldn't forget to do mitzvah,26:14when the zman of the mitzvah comes,26:15you're not allowed to26:17do—you're not allowed to involve yourself26:19in certain things that might make you forget.26:23So therefore, that translates in the following:26:26when there's a mitzvah to be performed at night,26:29let's say Kriat Shema,26:31reciting the Shema26:32is a mitzvah mide'oraita that takes place every single night.26:35When is the zman to read Kriat Shema?26:37We hold the26:39halacha, tzeit hakochavim. So therefore the rabbis instituted,26:41as the Gemara says in Masechet Berachot,26:42that when the mitzvah comes,26:44you're not allowed to involve yourself26:46in having a meal26:49or certain26:51melachot until the mitzvah is performed.26:53So likewise over here,26:54there's a mitzvah to count the Omer at night,26:57and like any mitzvah that takes place at night,26:59which27:01is de'oraita, derabanan, chachamim made27:03a gezeirah, like lighting the candles for menorah27:05or bedikat27:06chametz, for those who hold27:08that's miderabanan. So once the zman,27:10the time comes for a person to count,27:14he's not allowed to have a meal27:17or involve himself in a27:19melachah. However, Mishnah Berurah points out27:20that this is not only when the time comes27:23to perform the mitzvah,27:24but even 30 minutes prior,27:26like we find by Kriat Shema,27:28even 30 minutes prior to the zman,27:30to the time that we have—27:32To perform the mitzvah,27:34you're not allowed to27:36... in the meal or in27:38melachot. Now, the definition of a meal,27:40rabotai, definition of a meal means27:42that it's a meal that when you eat27:45at least a kebeitzah of bread.27:48That means two ounces of bread or more.27:50If you're eating less than two ounces,27:52rabbis do not restrict you.27:54Then that's like a little bit of a light meal,27:57although you're making27:57hamotzi and birkat hamazon, they're not scared that you're going to forget about it27:59in such a case.28:01The question is that,28:02now you just told me that28:03there's so many different times28:04of when counting the28:06Omer is. When does the 30 minutes take effect?28:09And the answer is28:10there's a28:12machloket. Believe it or not,28:13there's a machloket between the28:17Acharonim on when do the 30 minutes begin,28:20meaning to say,28:20when is the time to count?28:24Do we look at the earliest time28:26that one can count,28:28when the mitzvah can be performed,28:30or do we look at the time28:31when Maran says28:32one should count at that time,28:34the preferable time?28:35This is a28:39machloket. Chacham Ovadia, and it's not only28:40Chacham Ovadia, it's also28:41Kaf HaChaim also brings it down,28:43Shulchan Aruch Harav also brings it down.28:45They're a little bit more stringent.28:47They hold28:48that if a person has not counted Sefirat HaOmer yet,28:51then when the time comes28:52that he's able to count,28:53which, like we said, is sunset,28:55once shekiah comes,28:58that's when you're able to count.28:59So therefore, 30 minutes before29:01shekiah, a person cannot begin a meal.29:03That's the opinion of29:04Chacham Ovadia, Kaf HaChaim, and Shulchan Aruch Harav.29:08However,29:09Mishnah Berurah and ... point out that29:10no,29:11the 30 minutes begin29:13before the best time to count,29:15which means, like29:15Maran says,29:16tzet hakochavim. Whatever time you hold29:19tzet hakochavim is, whether you hold like the29:20Ben Ish Chai, 30 minutes,29:20or you hold 13 and a half minutes29:22like29:23Chacham Ovadia, or you hold29:24Rabbeinu29:25Tam, 72 minutes,29:26whatever that zman that you count.29:29Thirty minutes before that29:31is when the restriction applies.29:33Not when it's possible to count,29:35but when it's the best time to count.29:38Thirty minutes before29:40tzeit hakochavim. That's the way Mishnah Berurah holds.29:42So what do we do,29:44halacha lemaaseh? Really try to be29:45machmir. We're going to tell you what to do,29:47halacha lemaaseh, when it's applicable.29:49But29:49you can always keep that in the back of your mind,29:51that it is29:54a safek deRabbanan, and29:54it's29:55a safek because29:57machloket Acharonim in the29:58mitzvah deRabbanan, or in the restriction that's30:01deRabbanan, safek deRabbanan lekula. One could be lenient,30:03especially when it's necessary.30:05That's a basic introduction30:06to the laws of counting the30:09Omer. Let's get now to30:10some of the most common questions30:12that we have30:13when it comes to counting the30:15Omer. Question number one:30:17Is it better to count on time30:19with Arvit minyan,30:21or is it better to wait for a minyan30:23and count later in the evening?30:27For example, let's assume30:27that you follow the30:29Ben Ish Chai, that the best time to light30:30is thirty minutes after30:32shekiah. Let's assume that30:34shekiah, sunset, is at30:35eight o'clock. So according to30:35Ben Ish Chai, when's the best time to count?30:38Eight-thirty. Very good.30:38Now, eight-thirty, I'm home,30:40but I'm not going to30:41go—I'm praying Arvit at30:4410:15, and by the time we finish30:45Arvit, it'll be like30:4610:30 when we get up to the time30:47when we count the30:48Omer. So what's better now?30:50Is it better to count early,30:51or is it better to count with the minyan,30:53but at a later time?30:54This way my day is not 100% tamim,30:56it's not 100% complete.30:58There's two hours I went in the day30:59where I didn't count from then.31:01So this is a31:04machloket. The Or Letzion says,31:06since the mitzvah, the hiddur of31:08temimut is in the pasuk,31:10and the hiddur of counting with the minyan31:12is something external,31:14that's something that in general31:15we say to all mitzvot,31:16so he holds31:17it's better to be31:19yotzei de chovat temimut, which means31:20it's better for a person to count earlier,31:22even without a minyan,31:23than to wait for a minyan later on.31:25This is the opinion of the31:31Or LeTzion, Chacham Ben Tzion Abba Shaul, zecher tzaddik livrachah. However,31:32on the other side,31:33we do have cholkim, we do have those who argue.31:40Rav Moshe Feinstein, Igrot Moshe, Minchat Yitzchak, and Shevet HaLevi, all of them say31:41that no,31:43you should wait for a minyan31:44for a number of reasons.31:45Number one is31:47tadir v'she'eino tadir, tadir kodem, since you're going to pray31:49Arvit before you count31:50Omer, and you pray Arvit every single evening.31:52Arvit is31:53d'rabbanan, so is counting Omer is also31:55d'rabbanan, so therefore31:56wait till you pray31:57Arvit and count afterwards.31:59Also...32:00When you make sure that you're always counting with the minyan, this way you don't forget.32:07Besides the advantage also, when you count with the minyan, you have birkat amadat melech.32:10So for these reasons, these three Acharonim, Mikdash Moshe, Minchat Yitzchak, and the Shevet32:18HaLevi, all of them hold that you should wait for a minyan.32:21Next, question number two.32:25If one is driving during the time when he's supposed to count the32:29chatalah, so let's say he has no issue of praying right now.32:32He prayed in early Arvit, and he was done by—again, we're using the example throughout the class32:37that 8 o'clock is sunset and 8:30 is the preferable time according to the opinion of the Ben32:44Ish Chai. You'll adjust it, obviously, with whatever you hold.32:46So let's say, and this happened to me actually one time,32:49I was driving and you get, you know, the messages from 4,000 people,32:53Don't forget the Omer, Baruch Hashem, Hashem32:55yisayed. They want to remind everybody to count the32:58Omer. And now I'm driving, and I'm in the car, I have my family with me in the car.33:03Question is, what do I do now?33:05Do I count as I'm sitting in the car?33:09Now, the mitzvah, like we said, hachamim learn it in the33:12pasuk. From the pasuk, they're supposed to stand up.33:14Do I count sitting down now when it's lechatchilah, or do I wait until I get home?33:25And this was a far place, and I'm not going to get home until maybe an hour or two later33:31and count later.33:32Is it better to do temimot and count now, but I'll be sitting down,33:36or is it better to wait for later, but I'll be standing up?33:40So I asked this to my Rosh Kollel, Rabbi Meslaton,33:43and this is a real answer.33:45He says, Why don't you just pull over? What's the big deal? Pull over.33:48And really, yeah, why don't you just pull over?33:50So obviously, then I don't have the question anymore, right?33:53So if you're able to pull over, just like you would pull over if one of your kids says,33:57I need to go, I need to go, right?33:59So you pull over. Same thing over here.34:00If you're able to pull over, so pull over, stand up, and make the34:04berachah. But if you can't pull over, you're stuck, you're driving,34:07your speed, whatever it may be, you can't pull over.34:10So in that case... He came out and34:13that it's better to count then sitting down34:17than to wait later on to count standing up.34:20Because sitting down, you're counting earlier,34:23you're accomplishing the34:25temimot. It's earlier. The earlier, the better.34:27This also seems to be the theme also of Chacham Ben34:30Tzion, that any time that you have to weigh out the, you know, what's between better and best34:36when it comes to Sefirat HaOmer, temimot always34:39seems to always take precedence.34:41So over here, it'd be better to count sitting down earlier34:44than to wait later on for a chance to count Sefirat HaOmer standing up.34:47Now, this is if it's going to be like much later.34:50If we're talking about a difference of a few minutes,34:52obviously you wait till it's later.34:54We're talking about over here where it's going to be,34:56my specific example, it's going to be like an hour or two at least,35:00maybe even more, until I reach my destination.35:05Next question, I think we're up to number three.35:09When could a minyan now count?35:13Could a minyan be more lenient and count Omer any earlier?35:17Because this happens a lot on Friday nights35:19or in the summer, Sefardim, a lot of35:22Sefardim, they pray earlier.35:25They, you know, Mincha and Arvit, a lot of people come,35:27and now they finish Arvit, and it's not35:31tzeit hakochavim. For example, it's not 8:30, the preferable time.35:34It's not even according to Chacham Ovadia, 8:13 and a half.35:37It's like35:388:05. What should be35:39done? Really, lechatchila, a person should count by35:44tzeit hakochavim. And if there is a fear,35:48if there is a fear that the minyan35:51or the people of the minyan maybe will forget,35:54and most probably people will forget35:56because people forget when they go home,35:58they're already in a different zone.35:59So in that case, as a minyan,36:03they should count right then,36:06even though it's still bein hashmashot,36:07it's not tzeit hakochavim according to some of the opinions,36:09but being that it's already after36:12sheki'ah and it's bein hashmashot,36:14they should count then.36:16Now, if you're praying in that minyan36:18and you want to wait till later36:19and you know you're not going to forget,36:21fine, wait till later.36:22Just like we said before36:24that, you know, waiting for a minyan36:27or counting36:29early, we said it's better to count earlier,36:30according to36:31all leshonot, than waiting for a minyan.36:32Likewise over here,36:33it's better to count later than to count with the minyan.36:36We see that also from the Shulchan Aruch as well.36:40Question number four.36:44If a person finds himself in such a minyan36:47and he wants to count later,36:49what should he do?36:51So we tell you like this:36:53if one is sure that he's not going to forget,36:55he knows himself he's not going to forget,36:57so count later.36:59But if a person is mesupak,37:00he's worried that maybe I will forget.37:03Right now I'm in a minyan,37:04it's Friday night,37:04I don't have anything to remind me.37:06I didn't realize that the minyan is praying earlier.37:08I see we finished at37:108:10. To wait around,37:11I have to go,37:12my kids are pushing me to go already,37:14I'm supposed to go home already much earlier.37:16I'm scared I'm going to forget when I get to the house.37:18But I would like to count really with a berachah later on.37:21So Maran says you can make a condition.37:24What's the condition?37:25Make a condition as follows:37:27I'm going to count right now with the minyan37:29without a37:31berachah, just counting the day.37:33When I get home37:34and I remember after37:37tzet hakochavim to count,37:38I'm going to count then with37:39a berachah, and whatever I counted now,37:40even though I said the day,37:42this is just words37:44and it's not the mitzvah of counting,37:47and it should be nullified,37:48and therefore later on37:50I'm going to be able to count with a37:52blessing. And it will work to your advantage in both ways.37:57If you remember, so you count with the37:59beracha, the day that's supposed to be.38:01If you don't remember at home,38:03then what you said in the shul38:05with the kahal,38:06with the38:08tzibur, will count for you as you counted,38:09and it's not considered like you forgot.38:12This is if a person is worried that he's going to forget.38:14You make such a condition.38:16But if you're the person who is obligated38:19to lead the kahal with the blessing,38:20for example, you're the rabbi.38:21It happens a lot in shul.38:23The rabbi himself prefers to count later,38:26but the tzibur prays at a certain time,38:28and he's the one who has to lead the38:30tzibur. This is38:31kavod ha-tzibur when the rabbi is the one who leads the38:33tzibur in counting the38:34Omer. And what is he supposed to do?38:36He can't make this condition38:37and give it to somebody else.38:38It's not38:39kavod ha-tzibur. You take some average person,38:41okay, go ahead.38:41The tzibur wants the rabbi to lead them.38:43If the rabbi is not doing it,38:44well, we're doing38:45an aveirah, why aren't you also doing it?38:46So then, in that case,38:47he has really no option.38:49Then he's going to count earlier38:50out of38:52kavod ha-tzibur, out of a few factors over here.38:54Even though it's not the preferred time38:55of counting the38:56Omer, but you have other reasons38:58where will outweigh counting39:01on the preferred time.39:03You're going to have to39:04count with a beracha also.39:06You should know,39:07when you do count in the39:08tzibur and there's a lot of people,39:08there's a lot, a lot of people39:10who otherwise will probably not count.39:12If you don't count in the shul,39:12they'll probably not count.39:13Forget about, you know,39:15with the39:16beracha, they're probably not counting at all.39:17So therefore,39:19yes, like we said earlier,39:20if a tzibur finishes even before39:24set ha-kochavim, as long as it's after39:25shekiah, it's in the time39:26bein hashmashot, they should count with a blessing.39:30And for those,39:31like we said39:31with the advice of39:33Maran, for those39:35who want to be the39:37medakdekim and want to do it in the preferred time,39:38you can make that condition,39:39or you could just make sure39:41that you count it later on.39:43Next,39:44we find that people doing39:47Sefirat HaOmer pray early.39:49How come on Friday39:52night—excuse me—on Friday night,39:52a lot of people are39:53makpid to pray early Friday night.39:55What's the reason39:56why people are careful39:57to pray early on Friday nights?39:59So this...40:00Down a lot more by the40:01Sefardim. Number one, I could tell you it's probably the summer and they want to eat early.40:04You know, they don't want the kids to go to sleep.40:05They want to enjoy the meal.40:07But anyway, let's put that on the side.40:08But Sefirat HaOmer, specifically people are makpid to pray earlier40:11because of the problem we mentioned earlier.40:14There's a40:18gezeirah miderabanan that when this man comes to making40:20the counting the40:21Omer, which is a mitzvah,40:23since you have not fulfilled the mitzvah yet,40:2530 minutes before this man comes,40:2630 minutes before the time comes,40:29one is not allowed to begin a meal.40:31What kind of meal?40:33A meal that is what?40:35The meal that you're eating a kebeitzah or more.40:38And since on Shabbat40:39there's a mitzvah to eat40:40by all three seudot a kebeitzah or more,40:43minimum kezayit, but it's a mitzvah to eat a kebeitzah or more,40:45and Friday night probably going to eat a lot more than a40:48kebeitzah because you're hungry and starving40:49and, ah, Shabbos food,40:51nothing like it.40:52So therefore, you're40:54gonna probably, you know, you're gonna have an issue.40:56So therefore, a lot of people pray40:58Friday night earlier,41:00that by the time they get home, it's before41:03this man. Now sometimes41:05you might fall into a problem41:07because sometimes when you come back home41:08from shul on Friday night,41:10even though you prayed earlier,41:12you could be either in41:14bein hashmashot or within the half an hour41:16before this man of counting,41:18according to Chacham Ovadia for sure, right?41:20So what do you do then?41:22You're stuck. You have to wait.41:24So what could you do?41:25So first of all, if you're able41:27to start the meal,41:29because that's a halacha. Halacha is once you start the meal,41:32we don't bother you to41:33interrupt in the middle, able to count.41:36There's an opinion that says41:37you should interrupt your meal in the middle,41:40אבל זה לא מוכרח, because41:41really, pashut pshat is once a person starts41:43b'heter, you have no chiyuv to stop. In any case.41:45What's called starting the meal?41:48So,41:50if you look in Maran,41:51it's in41:53Orach Chaim siman רלב se'if bet, he says starting the meal means41:55when you wash your hands,41:56netilat yadayim, for the meal.41:59Pashut pshat is that42:01I'm saying Kiddush and42:03Eshet Chayil and everything else. Until I wash my hands,42:05it's not considered I started the meal. That's a42:07pashut pshat. However, if you look in the Mishnah Berurah over there,42:10you'll see42:10that he says the following. He says,42:16Umi she-ragil lehatir ezoro b'sha'at achilah. A person who usually before eats,42:19he undoes his belt.42:20You know, that's how they used to eat,42:22to open up the stomach so this way he could eat.42:24He says that's42:26mekreiat challal. Loosening up your belt, as the Tur brings the name of the Gemara,42:28loosening up your belt, that's called starting the meal.42:31So therefore,42:33whatever you are accustomed to usually do42:34before you eat the meal, that's also called starting the meal.42:37And42:39HaCham Yosef Raful Shlita has been saying this for years42:40also, that that's a Kiddush of Friday night.42:42Before we eat, we always have Kiddush beforehand.42:44And recently I saw that the42:46Ben Ish Chai, Mikabtzel, says the same thing,42:48that the beginning of the meal means42:50on Friday night is when you started42:52Kiddush. How do you start Kiddush?42:54You start with42:56Vayechulu Shamayim, you start Kiddush with42:58Shalom Aleichem,42:59even though you have this long dragged-out song,43:02it doesn't make a difference.43:03Shalom Aleichem is the beginning of Kiddush. That's called you started your meal,43:05because you usually make Kiddush and jump into it.43:08Now let's say a person already,43:10and that's called you started. If you start before43:12the zman of the zerah, you're fine.43:14But let's say a person really doesn't make it.43:16He comes in, by the time he comes home,43:18he sees he wants to be43:19machmir like Chacham Ovadia, or like the43:22Kaf HaChaim, that half an hour before43:24shkiah he can't begin your meal, not he's there, half an hour,43:25he can't count yet because he wants to count43:28by 8:30. He's already home at43:307:40, so what is he supposed to do?43:33Wait almost an43:34hour till he starts his meal?43:36So here we could give you43:38two ways out of it.43:40Number one is43:41there's something called43:43kriat ha-shamash, and in those days used to have somebody to go around to remind everybody43:45to count the43:48Omer. So if you have something to remind you,43:50like an alarm clock,43:51where you're going to set it at the zman of counting,43:54so here we don't have the fear43:55anymore that you're going to43:58be dragged43:59into your meal, you're going to forget about counting,44:01you're going to forget about the44:03mitzvah. You have the reminder, but on condition that this reminder,44:06as soon as it gives you a reminder,44:07you do it right away.44:09It doesn't make sense that you put a sign to count the Omer in front of you,44:13or some people say,44:14Yeah, I'm going to change my wristwatch44:17instead of putting on my left hand, put on my right hand.44:18It's going to remind me later on.44:20Yeah, but why don't you just say, Okay, today is44:23Omer, and remind myself of the44:25Omer. The44:27Chachamim obviously didn't saw that once a person's eating,44:30unless something reminds him,44:31when the zman comes,44:33he's going to forget about it.44:34So therefore,44:36a person needs to make himself a reminder44:39that when the reminder comes in,44:40he's able to do it.44:41Today with alarm clock on your phone, on your whatever it is,44:44once you have a reminder,44:47you could,44:48what's it called,44:49you could start right away,44:52go do your reminder. Meaning to say,44:53let's say you want to count at44:558:30, and you're starting your meal at44:577:45. Once 8:30, the alarm clock rings,44:59you stop your meal, you get up,45:01and you count,45:02and this way you avoid the problem of45:06forgetting about counting the45:07Omer. The other way you could do,45:08as Rabbeinu Shai says45:10to do in Mikavzei El, is that since the problem of45:14having a meal45:15in the45:16seudah, the problem of having a meal45:19in the seudah before counting the Omer is45:21that you're going to eat a kebeitzah of bread.45:24So Rabbeinu Shai says45:25a piece of...45:26Like he explains in45:29Sefer Ben Ish Chai, when the guy comes Friday night,45:31he's supposed to make Kiddush right away.45:32It's not supposed to drag it out.45:33Everybody's waiting for you, malachim, haShechinah, everybody's waiting for you.45:36You shouldn't wait. So therefore, begin right away.45:39Make Kiddush.45:41You want to sing longer, sing longer, fine.45:42Do whatever you have to do.45:43And start your meal also immediately,45:46because אין קידוש אלא במקום סעודה, you're not supposed to have such a45:48hefsek between Kiddush and45:52seudah. So what do you mean by asur? So fine, don't have a45:54kebeitza. Eat a45:55kezayit and wait until this man comes,45:57the able to count,45:58count sefirat46:00haOmer, and then eat the rest of your food,46:03eat the kebeitza of bread,46:05and this way you're not over on the46:07issur of starting the meal46:09in the forbidden time.46:11This is the advice of46:13Ben Ish Chai: you wash and you don't eat a46:16kebeitza. Okay,46:17now let's go on to a few more things.46:20Question:46:22should women count the Omer or not?46:24So in46:25general, we know that46:27when it comes to women performing46:29mitzvot aseh shehazman gerama,46:31these are mitzvot that come in a specific time,46:34the rule is46:37that46:38women are exempt46:39from it. If a woman still46:41wants to perform the mitzvah,46:43she can do it,46:45but there's machloket between Sefardim and Ashkenazim46:47if she's allowed to make a blessing on it.46:49According to Sefardim, we follow the opinion of the Rosh,46:51you cannot make a46:54berachah, a woman, excuse me, a woman cannot make a berachah on mitzvot aseh shehazman gerama.46:58So if a woman wants to46:59shake lulav and etrog, kol hakavod, do it,47:01but don't make a berachah on it.47:02The Ashkenazim follow47:04Rabbeinu Tam, and they hold that47:06although she's exempt from it, she wants to fulfill the47:09mitzvah, so make a berachah on it.47:10So the Ashkenazim, if they're going to shake, a woman is going to47:13shake lulav and etrog on Sukkot,47:15she's going to make a berachah on it.47:17So we would probably think that this47:19should extend also to mitzvot47:23sefirat haOmer. Sefaradim and Ashkenazim. If a woman wants to count,47:24she doesn't have to, but if she wants to count, let her count.47:27Sefaradim will say count without a47:29beracha. Ashkenazim will say count,47:30but you could even count with a47:32beracha, like the same rules as the men.47:34However, the47:37Mekubalim, Ben Ish Chai, Kaf HaChaim bring down,47:39the Mekubalim say47:41a woman should not count47:43Sefirat HaOmer even without a47:45beracha. This is something connected to47:47sod, to Kabbalah. It's beyond my realm,47:49beyond my discussion.47:50I'm not going to get into it.47:51This is the area of the47:53Mekubalim. Ben Ish Chai said it. It's good enough for me.47:55So therefore, those who follow the47:58Mekubalim, Ben Ish Chai and the Kaf HaChaim.48:00They say women should not count Omer, even without48:04a beracha. However, a lot of the Ashkenazim are noheg that women do count, and they do count with48:08a beracha. Rabbi Ribiat, in his new book on Pesach, writes that the minhag by the Ashkenazim is that ladies count Omer with48:16a beracha. And I saw that that was also brought down in Piskei Teshuvot in the name of48:22Orchot Rabbeinu, that the women in the household of the Steipler were noheg to count with48:29a beracha. I believe also I saw that in the Igrot Moshe as well, that's talui on the minhag. And since that seems to be minhag,48:36it seems like ladies, Ashkenazi women, could count Sefirat HaOmer with a beracha, of course,48:39if they never miss a day, like the same thing as a man. In any case,48:44those who are not sure what to do,48:46ladies as Ashkenazim should ask a rabbi. For Sefardi women,48:49they should not even count. For those who lean more towards48:54Sod, for those who go strictly with48:58halacha, yes, lemaaseh the ladies want to count, but again, cannot be with49:04a beracha. Question now:49:07What about a child that turns bar mitzvah in the middle of the Omer?49:13Now this child,49:15let's say he was counting from the beginning. Let's say he becomes bar mitzvah49:19in Lag BaOmer. So up to Lag BaOmer, he counted 32 days49:24of the Omer. Now on the 33rd day, he becomes bar mitzvah.49:27Should he continue counting with a beracha like he was up till now?49:31Children don't have a chiyuv. It's good to train your children,49:34but now do we say that since till now, it's like he's like a new creature, he's like a new person.49:38He never counted till now with the chiyuv. All he did was49:42miderabanan. Now it's still derabanan, but still now he's a gadol.49:45It's like a different49:47chiyuv. It's like he's a new person, and all the counting that he did is dropped, or do we say no,49:50he can still count. He did it till now. Why should it get interrupted? He never missed out on the mitzvah.49:55This is also a49:59machloket. Chacham Ovadia brings from50:00the Chida, who brings in the name of the Pri HaAretz,50:03Rav Chaim Palachi. I saw that even Chidushei Harim as well.50:06They're all machmir. The kid wants to count, let him count.50:10Even though he never missed a day with Baruchah, but once he turns bar mitzvah,50:12he has a new chiyuv. It's like a new person now. It's like he just woke up.50:17And therefore,50:18his obligation as a katan, as a youngster, does not overflow to the days that he's a gadol, as an adult, a Jewish adult.50:25And therefore, if he wants to continue counting, he counts without a berachah. However, the50:31Kaf HaChaim and the Or LeTzion as well goes with it as well.50:34Based on a sfeik sfeika, they rule that a child who's been counting as a youngster50:40from beginning, he never missed a day, and now he reached his bar mitzvah50:45on Lag BaOmer, he is allowed to continue counting with a50:50berachah. This50:51is also what seems to be the minhag by the Ashkenazim,50:56as the50:57sefarim bring down from the Ashkenazim, the poskim, the Chortzvi, Rav Tzvi Pesach Frank, the Tzitz Eliezer, LeRod Natan.51:05I saw, I believe, also in Rabbi Ribiat that this is a custom also by Ashkenazim, that51:09a child who never missed a day of counting, if he turns bar mitzvah in the middle of51:13Sefirat HaOmer, could continue counting with a berachah. In any case, whether you hold that the child should count with a berachah or not, lechatchilah a person should not51:22be yotzei de chovah, and sometimes a person who missed out a day, he wants to hear the berachah from somebody who's51:27chayav. Lechatchilah a person should not hear the berachah from such a51:29person. We shouldn't have such a katan on that year, when he turns bar mitzvah,51:34we shouldn't have him say the berachah to51:37be motzi other people. Try to avoid it when it's possible. If it's not possible,51:41so that's where you're going to have to rely on. You're going to rely on the enough poskim that say that the child could count with51:49the berachah. A similar question, a little bit on the flip side, is brought, is51:53what about51:55if a person51:57is gonna52:00go—he's gonna count the Omer, right? But he has a scheduled52:04surgery to take place in the middle of Sefirat52:08HaOmer, where he's gonna be out for at least a day, and for sure he's gonna miss out52:12on the berachah. Let's give a52:14mashal. He has a schedule that on the 20th day of the Omer he's gonna go into surgery,52:19and the 20th day of the Omer he's gonna go into surgery, and what's the problem? Well,52:24on the 21st, when he wakes up from the52:26surgery, he missed one full day. Because he missed one full day,52:31he's not gonna be able to continue counting Omer with the berachah. And according to some Rishonim,52:37he interrupted the mitzvah, and52:40the whole thing is down the drain according to some Rishonim. We tell the guy, okay,52:45keep on counting without a berachah, according to the other Rishonim who say that each day is a separate mitzvah.52:49But this person, what should he do now?52:52Should he start counting the Omer from the beginning with52:56the berachah, or do we say, no, since you're planning to interrupt it, okay, it's not your choice,53:00you have to go into surgery, Hashem should give you refuah53:03shelemah, b'seder, but you know it's gonna interrupt it, so maybe don't say the berachot right now.53:07There's a53:08Chida—it's brought down in Sefer Avodat HaKodesh. The Chida says that if a person misses one day of counting Omer with53:15the berachah, he missed a whole full day, all the blessings that he said until now become a53:20berachah levatalah. Very harsh statement from the Chida. So what do we tell this person to do?53:24So now you should know, most Acharonim do not go with this53:28Chida. Most Acharonim don't hold that's a berachah levatalah, and I have a good proof from the53:33Ritva. I'm gonna say in a second. The Or Letzion says that if a person—53:39is53:41finds himself in such a case where he knows he's going to go into surgery53:46and he's going to miss out on one full day, all the siyum says it's fine. You could count up to the 20th day,53:52and on the 20th day when you have to go into surgery, okay, Hashem should give you a refuah53:55shleimah. Even though you're not going to be able to continue with the53:58berachah, you should still count the beginning of the days with a blessing. It brings a beautiful proof from the54:04Ritva. Let's say a person is going to wash and he's going to eat bread.54:07The halacha tells us if you plan to eat two ounces of bread or more,54:10so you make a blessing on netilat yadayim. If you're not planning to have two ounces of bread,54:14you're only planning to have54:15less than two ounces of bread, you're not allowed to make a blessing on netilat yadayim. You do netilah, but without a blessing.54:20Let's say a person was planning to have at least two ounces of bread.54:24He washes, he makes a berachah, he sits down to eat, he eats a kezayit. Oh,54:28stomach is full, he can't move. It's like eating,54:31you know, whatever. But he's stuffed.54:35So now54:36what do you do? Does he have to stuff himself with the other kezayit? It's already54:40achilah gasah. So the Dvar says since the kavanah that you had was to be able to eat two54:44kezayitot, for some reason you can't eat now two kezayitot, your berachah is not called54:48a berachah levatalah. When the time that you made the54:50berachah, you did it with the proper intention and you had the plan, you were able to eat two54:55kezayitot. Now that you can't do it,54:57it doesn't mess you over.55:00Two last questions. We'll try to finish them, squeeze them in with the few minutes that we have.55:04What if a person counts the wrong day?55:06Let's say a person, instead of counting the 20th day of the Omer, by mistake he says,55:11Hayom echad ve'arba'im yom. He counts the next day to a 21st day.55:15What's the din? The answer is like this.55:17If he counts the wrong day, it's like he didn't count at all. It's zero.55:22So therefore, if he remembers later on at night, later on, way later on, by the time he asks the question,55:28He realized that I counted the wrong day. He must count again with a55:32beracha. If he remembers the following day, so which means it's still the same day, it's still the 20th of the55:40Omer, so he could still count the 20th of the Omer, of course without a beracha because it's daytime.55:44And if he remembered already the next day that the day he counted last night,55:49he thought last night was a 21, but really last night was55:5220. Today, when everybody's counting 21, he realized that he already counted the wrong55:57day. So in that case, unfortunately, that person is out.56:00Out of it, he cannot continue counting with a56:04beracha. There's one more last case, and it's so important, this case.56:08It really deserves much more time. Unfortunately, we don't have the time.56:12Maybe, maybe we'll do, we'll fix it up a little bit later on.56:15In any case, we'll just say very quickly. A lot of people travel to China.56:20What's in China? Chinese food, of course. No, I'm kidding. What's in China? They go on a business in China.56:24So a lot of people travel to China during the days of the56:26Omer. The problem is, when you travel to China,56:30so the plane is taking off from New York, let's say,56:34and it's heading westbound.56:37So when you're going westbound, which means you're going through California and the other way,56:42and it's coming to China that way. So what's happening when you're heading westbound?56:46You're crossing the 180-degree line on the Earth,56:51on the globe, and that line is known as the International Date Line.56:54Once you cross that line, you automatically gain 24 hours.56:58That means two minutes ago it was Tuesday. Once you cross that line,57:02when the plane crosses that line, you're already Wednesday. All of a sudden, you gain 24 full hours.57:08And on the way back, it happens the same way.57:10You lost a full day. When you come back from China, you're going east.57:14You're going back around the other way. You're going through California, from California, and come back to New York.57:19So you're also going to cross that 180-degree line.57:21So you're traveling on, let's say, on a Thursday,57:26and as you're crossing it back, all of a sudden,57:31you're losing 24 hours.57:34So that means you're back a day. So how do you do it with57:38Sefirat HaOmer? There's a big discussion amongst the57:41poskim. The easiest way to get out of it, the easiest way to do it is, of course, ask your rabbi what to do,57:46but what we'll recommend is— That when you get there, you count.57:50That means you're going to China from New York, you count with a57:54beracha. You count that day with a57:57beracha. And if you're still in the count, that means you didn't miss a full day.58:01You still could catch, let's say your flight is at a time when you're able to still be in it.58:05You want, let's say on the 20th, then you count the 21 when you got there, although without a58:09beracha. Then you can continue counting with the beracha. But if you miss a full 24 hours, that means58:13by the time you got there, you already completely missed it, then you're going to have to count the rest of the58:17Sefirat HaOmer without a beracha, even when you come back to New York and everything comes back to normal.58:22Of course, double check with your rabbi. This is the easiest way they could get out of it.58:25And we have to stop here. We thank you for joining us.58:29Next week, bezrat Hashem, we'll talk about some of the halachot of the customs in the Omer, as well as perhaps58:33Lag BaOmer and Yud Daled Iyar. This show will be aired on again58:38tonight at 10 o'clock. You could reach us58:42now by calling 718-683-5858. We'll hear, we'll answer your phone calls58:46off the air, or text at58:49347-927-8398. Of course, you could always email us at58:54halachahour@gmail.com. Thank you for joining us. Thank you, Eran. Thank you, Rav Nissim. Thank you, Jay Root. We'll see you next week.58:58Until then, have a wonderful week and Shabbat shalom.