Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws for After Pesach (2015)Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysRabbi Uri Nahum · April 15, 2015−15Play+30Position0:0059:41Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to the Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio.0:04We are back right after Pesach 5775, Tavshin Ayin Hey, 2015.0:10We will begin, bezrat Hashem, our Halacha series now, from now until0:16Shavuot, discussing all the halachot, all the details that we need to know0:20from now until the holiday of0:24Shavuot, bezrat Hashem. So before we get to what these subjects are,0:27let us just give you a little bit of the numbers over here to the station0:31and how to listen and what the class is about.0:33This is the Halacha Hour. We air on Wednesday afternoons from 2 to 30:38p.m. The same class is aired on again at night in the evening, 11 p.m. to 120:45p.m., to 12 a.m. If anybody has questions, usually we try to take them after the class.0:49Today maybe we'll take it for the first part of the class.0:51If you have any questions, you could call in.0:53You could even call in any time.0:55We have a technician over here who will be helping us,0:58bezrat Hashem. He'll be helping us. He'll take down your questions.1:02So if you would like to call in, the number to call in is1:09718-50— no, no, that's not the number.1:16718-683-5858. Again,1:17718-683-5858. If you would like to text in your question,1:20then that will be much easier for me1:23because I can look at the text and if it's on the subject, we'll answer.1:26If not, we'll, bezrat Hashem, reply to you by the end of the class.1:30To text in your question,1:34it's 347-927-8398. If you have questions that you would like to hear off the air,1:37then you call in at the end of the show at 31:41p.m. bezrat Hashem will be here for about 10, 15 minutes after the class.1:44Anybody has questions, we'll be more than happy to help you1:48answer you if we can.1:50Now, that's if you would like to participate, to be part of the1:53shiur, to the class over here. However,1:54if you'd like to just listen and you just want to listen,1:57so then we'll give you the ways, the address to listen to,2:00or where to listen.2:03JRootRadio.com. You go to the website, you see actually besides audio,2:06you could also watch us live.2:08You can see me talking into the mic in the beautiful library over here.2:11Also, you could listen in on your JRoot Radio Pro app2:15on the smartphones, Android or Apple.2:18They both have these beautiful apps,2:20and you could also listen in through the phone2:23by calling in2:27712-432-4217. That's a live radio,2:29and the archives at2:34718-506-9099. That is how to listen and how to participate in the class.2:37Here in the Halacha hour, we try to,2:41be'ezrat Hashem, clarify the2:43halachot, especially the ones on the season.2:44Usually it's on the2:46Bein HaShmashot, we try to do halachot of Shabbat from the2:50Bein HaShmashot, but whenever it's season time, it's holiday time,2:52we take a little bit of a break to go over the2:56halachot, even though we might have heard some of them, some of them are new,2:59and we go over them, be'ezrat Hashem, over here to talk about them.3:02In any case, the halachot today,3:06on Tu B'Shvat, like we said in the beginning,3:07will be on the specific things that we need to know3:11in this period of time, in this period of Sefirat HaOmer.3:13Some of them are connected to Pesach,3:15some of them are connected to3:17holidays of Shavuot, and some of them are connected to the actual Sefirat HaOmer.3:20We have over here about nine categories,3:24even though we could really make ten,3:25we've made nine categories of halachot that we need to know.3:28Number one, the subject of3:33chametz she'avar alav haPesach. This includes where to shop and where to avoid shopping from.3:37It's very important that we should hear this part.3:39Number two. Is berachot of leftover Pesach food.3:47We'll talk about that, be'ezrat Hashem.3:49Number three is3:52Birchat HaIlanot; we'll mention that.3:53Number four are the halachot of tefillah,3:55because we did make some changes in the3:58Amidah and some of the changes that we do in our siddur right now.4:01Number five is the minhagim of Sefirat HaOmer,4:06what we could buy, we cannot buy,4:08all these things, be'ezrat Hashem.4:09These are customs of Sefirat HaOmer.4:11Number six is the halachot of counting the4:16Omer. Number seven, we added this year also4:18the subject of Kemach Yashan.4:21We will dedicate, be'ezrat Hashem,4:22hopefully a full class on the subject of kemach yashan4:25for those who want to know it superficially4:28and for those that want to know it very, very well.4:33Be'ezrat Hashem, this is the subject4:35that I've been asked a few times to talk about it.4:38Hopefully this year we'll dedicate a4:39class to discussing the subject of kemach yashan.4:43Then we have also the halachot, minhagim,4:46whatever you want to say,4:48you know, whatever you want to call them,4:49of Pesach Sheni and Lag BaOmer.4:51That's a very interesting class.4:52And finally the halachot of Shavuot and Yom Tov,4:55which, be'ezrat Hashem, will all be in its own time.4:59Hopefully within these weeks from now5:01until Shavuot, we will cover all these subjects.5:03Let's begin, be'ezrat Hashem,5:05with the first subject of5:08halachot, which is chametz she'avar alav5:12haPesach. Before I continue, I would like to hear,5:14you know, every year Pesach, you know, we get a5:16lot—most of the questions are asked5:17usually before the holiday Pesach5:19and during the holiday Pesach.5:21And this year, as I will explain,5:22we got some interesting questions,5:25and I'm always interested to hear5:27if any interesting, you know, scenario came up to you.5:30So if you have any interesting case5:32that came up to you,5:33whether you got a psak or not,5:34please text it in5:38at 347-927-8398. So this way we can, you know, learn,5:43and perhaps if we could share it also5:44with the rest of the listeners,5:47we could always, you know... We could always grow and learn5:49from everything that everybody, you know, went through.5:51Let's begin.5:54The laws of chametz she'avar alav Pesach5:56for the year5:592015-5775. Let's give a little bit of6:01a background. Shulchan Aruch in Siman Taf Mem Chet writes6:05that chametz she'avar alav Pesach,6:09if you have chametz she'avar alav Pesach,6:11which says the Shulchan Aruch,6:14asur6:15b'hana'ah. It's forbidden even in6:18hana'ah, even in deriving benefit from it.6:20That is if it's chametz shel Yisrael,6:22if it's under the ownership of a Jew.6:25Says the Shulchan Aruch,6:26and here's the key word:6:27afilu hinlicho, shogeg or anus.6:31Even if you left it by mistake,6:35you forgot about it,6:36you forgot that you left over some chametz in your attic,6:40or even if you're anus.6:41What does it mean, anus?6:42For some reason you got sick,6:43you were hospitalized,6:45you were arrested,6:46make up whatever anus case you want.6:48It was beyond your control6:51that you weren't able to get rid of your6:53chametz. That6:57chametz, if it went through Pesach under the ownership of a Jew, the Shulchan Aruch rules6:58that it's forbidden7:01b'hana'ah. This is a halacha7:02that is7:03miderabbanan. The chachamim decreed7:04that a person shouldn't leave over his7:07chametz. People will say,7:07Yeah, you know what? I have chametz in the house.7:10Yeah, okay, you know, okay, I won't eat from it on Pesach,7:12but I'll eat it after Pesach.7:13But that's assumed7:16de'oraita. One who owns7:17chametz during the holiday of Pesach7:19is committing an7:22issur de'oraita of lo yera'eh lecha or7:25lo yimatze lecha chametz b'chol gevulecha. So therefore,7:26in order to save the people from this7:29issur, chachamim decreed you're not allowed to have any7:31chametz in your house on Pesach,7:32or not only in your house,7:33in your property,7:34even if you're not home.7:35But as long as it's under your ownership,7:37it's7:38asur. Not only is it7:40asur if it's under your ownership,7:41even if you declared it7:50ownerless, chametz שנמצא בביתך בפסח אסור אף בפשע ביטלו. Even if you7:51mevatel the chametz, if you didn't do bedikah properly, if you didn't basically try to get rid of it completely,7:54that— Chametz becomes asur after Pesach. Not only is it forbidden.8:00To eat during chametz, it's also forbidden to derive any benefit from8:05not chametz. This is a halacha; it's Shulchan Aruch.8:07There are no questions on this halacha.8:09It's not debatable.8:10Maybe the applications may be debatable,8:12but in itself, this halacha8:15is a halacha8:16mi'deRabbanan. It's a gezeirah from the8:18Chachamim. Chametz she'avar alav Pesach is asur in eating and in benefiting from.8:22This is why, when it comes to Pesach,8:25many people sell their8:27chametz. Certainly, if you have a store that sells8:31chametz, grocery supermarkets,8:31you have to sell your chametz before Pesach to a goy.8:35So even though it's in your property,8:37the problem is not if it's in your property or not.8:39Like we said, if you're the owner of the8:42chametz, that's when it's a problem.8:43Even if you're in Florida and your chametz is in Brooklyn,8:46your chametz is8:47asur. But if you're in Brooklyn and your chametz is in your house,8:50it's in your basement, it's in your closet,8:51but it doesn't belong to you, it belongs to a8:54non-Jew, that chametz is permitted in hana'ah after Pesach.8:57Of course, you have to buy it from him,8:59and it's mutar.9:00So therefore, if you want motzaei Pesach,9:03you want to go to a non-Jewish store9:06and buy from them chametz, it's not a problem,9:09even though he had it during Pesach.9:11It's only forbidden for the Jew to have it during Pesach,9:13not for the goy.9:15And that's why, like we said, we sell our9:17chametz. Now, this year, I had four very, very interesting cases.9:21I never had these cases ever before.9:23You know, like we say, you live and learn.9:25Let me tell you the four cases,9:26and then we'll tell you what the din was by each one of them.9:30I get a text from one of the guys.9:33He tells me, a young man, he tells me,9:36I walked into a Dunkin' Donuts this morning.9:38This is Chol Hamoed Pesach, by the way.9:40I walked into a Dunkin' Donuts this morning,9:42and I bought a donut.9:44And Baruch Hashem, I realized right before I ate it9:48that it's Pesach, and I just threw it away.9:51Okay, so I said, okay, what do you want me to do?9:53He's like, okay, did I commit a sin?9:54Did I do an9:56aveirah? I said, yeah.9:57He's like, but it was an accident.9:58I said, okay, so it's a sin by accident.10:00You know, he's like, what am I,10:01am I get karet?10:03And I says, no.10:04Karet is only if you eat chametz on Pesach.10:06If you own chametz on Pesach, it's10:09asur. It's a big10:09issur. It's issur of10:10lav. It's a lo ta'aseh, but it's not karet.10:13So he says, what do I do now?10:14I said, okay, do teshuvah.10:15Never do this again.10:17Don't go into Dunkin' Donuts.10:18That's your first problem.10:18Why are you walking into Dunkin' Donuts?10:19It doesn't have hashgacha. How are you walking buying donuts in the first place?10:23Okay,10:23but that's case number one.10:25A person bought Dunkin' Donuts, a donut from Dunkin' Donuts10:29on Chol Hamoed. Yes, you are committing an10:31issur. In fact, this is an10:33issur. Had you done it on purpose, you would have gotten lashes for it,10:37because you're active.10:37You went and bought on Pesach10:39chametz. It's more than10:41the kebeitzah, for sure yechayav on this.10:43Case number two.10:44A person walked into a non-Jewish supermarket,10:49big supermarket,10:51and they went in, and they have a kosher section,10:53and they went to the kosher section.10:55They saw where the matzah section is,10:56and they bought a box of matzah.10:58They wanted, they purchased it,10:59they paid for it,10:59they went home.11:00They come to eat the matzah,11:01and they realize, oh my gosh,11:03it says not kosher for Passover.11:05You're not allowed to eat this matzah for Passover.11:07Those who don't know, matzah is actually, which we'll discuss later on,11:11matzah, some people eat matzah all year round,11:14and the companies that produce these matzot are not there to make it kasher11:17l'Pesach. They want to make the sale for people to eat it throughout the year.11:20It's a cracker.11:21It tastes good.11:21People like it.11:21It's delicious.11:22They like the, you know, the other ones.11:25So it's kasher, but not kasher11:27l'Pesach. It's pure11:29chametz. So it says on it, not kosher for Passover.11:31They went home now.11:32What do you do now?11:34Did they commit an11:36aveirah? Could they give it back,11:37or do we say that's deriving benefit from the11:39chametz? Must they burn it?11:40What should they do?11:41That's case number two.11:42Case number three:11:43a person walked into a Jewish supermarket11:47where they had the chametz all closed off,11:50completely closed off.11:51Don't touch11:53chametz. Don't walk in, you know, with the big black garbage bags and everything.11:56They ask one of the workers, a non-Jewish worker,11:58they say, Excuse me, where's the matzah?11:59I need to buy some matzah.12:00He points to a certain aisle.12:02He goes over there and he sees all different types of matzahs.12:04He goes and he takes some matzah crackers.12:08He gets to work.12:09He's about to open the box of12:11matzah, and what does he see?12:14Do not eat. Not kosher for Passover.12:17Again, the same story,12:17but this time it was from a Jewish supermarket.12:20And again, the question:12:21what do you do with the12:23chametz? Question number four.12:26This is a really interesting question.12:28I got a call from an owner of a Jewish grocery store12:32where he also sold this chametz according to12:36dat v'din. He closed it off,12:37and he has non-Jewish workers in the store, and he stepped out.12:40He comes back, and his non-Jewish worker tells him that,12:44you know, right beforehand,12:46there's somebody who walked in,12:47and he asked me to get something from behind this section,12:51you know, with the closed-off section.12:52He says, What'd you do?12:53He says, I sold it to12:54him. So you're not allowed to sell it to him.12:55So what could I do?12:56The guy, he kept on nagging me, and he said he wants it,12:59and I told him, No, my boss don't let.13:01He says, No, I don't care. Go get it for me.13:02And it turned out that the person who bought it,13:05the buyer, was also Jewish.13:07So what do you do in such a case?13:08Well, I don't know if there is something to do.13:10In any case, let's go through all the cases to see what the halacha is.13:14What is the halacha in all these cases?13:15What could you do? What could you not do?13:17In the first case of the guy who bought Dunkin' Donuts,13:20yes, it was13:22a aveirah. He did a bishogeg, but he wanted that donut.13:24He just forgot that's13:26chametz. So therefore, that donut is asur.13:31It's asur b'achilah for sure,13:32there's no question.13:33Even if it's not your donut, you're not allowed to eat it.13:35But you can't even give it back to the store13:37because you wanted that donut,13:38you made a final sale.13:40Now even though the store may take it back for you,13:41but you're selling it back to the store,13:43even though you forgot that space, but you wanted the donut.13:46So therefore, you cannot return it.13:47You have to burn that13:50chametz, which this person already threw it out.13:53There's nothing to do.13:53The only thing to do is teshuvah and13:57ma'asim tovim. That's it.13:57As far as halacha is concerned, there's not much to do.14:00Aveirah was done by accident.14:02In case number two, where the person went to a non-Jewish store,14:05over there it's a little bit more interesting,14:06because the person never wanted to buy14:10chametz. He went to the kosher section14:11and he saw that there should be kasher l'Pesach merchandise,14:15and somehow or another,14:18the matzah, which was not really14:20kasher l'Pesach, was mixed in there.14:21Whether it was done on purpose or not,14:24it was clearly14:26a mekach ta'ut. Mekach ta'ut means it was a sale that the person did not want.14:30It was a sale that was done by accident.14:32He wanted kasher l'Pesach matzah,14:34and something else came in its place.14:37It was placed there, you know, beyond his knowledge.14:39So in that case, after consulting with the14:42posek, he ruled that it was a14:44mekach ta'ut, and therefore it can be given back,14:47because in halacha, mekach ta'ut is not really considered a sale.14:50It's not a sale and then you're selling it again.14:52It was never yours.14:53You never wanted to buy such an item.14:55You could return,14:56and you should return the chametz as soon as possible.14:59Now what about in a case where you went to the Jewish supermarket?15:01And here, before I get to the15:03halacha, I really have to point this out.15:04Besides this case, you should know,15:06I had a few other cases where it didn't call me for it,15:09but I found out about it,15:11where people walked into a supermarket,15:14a Jewish supermarket,15:15where we tell you, you know,15:16go in, they have15:17a hashgacha, and I personally shop there,15:18I would eat there.15:20And we tell you usually,15:21you know, listen, it's a Jewish market.15:22They have a very good15:23hechsher. You can buy whatever you want.15:24But you have to be careful,15:26rabotai. In big supermarkets especially,15:27people, you know, when you think about it,15:30last time you went shopping for anything,15:31grocery, food, or clothing,15:32it doesn't make a difference,15:33and you had things in your cart,15:36and then you decided, you know what,15:37I don't want to buy this.15:38Do you go all the way back15:40to where you got the item from?15:41Let's say you're in the vegetable section,15:45and you realize, you know,15:46I don't want to take this soda.15:48I don't need to drink Coke.15:49I don't like Coke.15:50Do you go all the way back to the drink section15:52and put the Coke where it's supposed to be,15:53next to the Coke and not next to the Pepsi?15:55If you do,15:57ashrecha v'tov lach. That's the right thing to do.15:58Chazak u'baruch.16:00Most people don't. Most people are not as good as you are.16:03Most people will just take the bottles and just dump it next to the apples.16:06Let the worker pick it up, you know, that's what they're here for.16:10Derech eretz is not right now our subject, but that's what happens.16:13So therefore, people, a few cases where people picked up chametz stuff in the Pesach,16:19in the kosher for Pesach aisle. You can't blame the store for that.16:22You can't blame the supermarket that should have better hashgacha. It's not their fault.16:26A customer right before you that walked down the aisle took out the cereal boxes and put it on the Pesach section.16:32So therefore, rabotai, you have to be very careful.16:34Ladies especially who are shopping, it doesn't make a difference,16:36whoever is shopping, whether you're shopping before Pesach or on Pesach,16:41don't assume that something is kasher lePesach unless you see that it says on it,16:45even if it's in the Pesach section.16:47Even if you see everybody's crowded, even if you see everybody who's religious taking it,16:50and everybody's taking the same from the same shelf,16:53don't assume16:56that's kasher lePesach. Make sure you check every single box that you take.16:58Not because, chas v'shalom, the owners of the market are doing anything harmful on purpose,17:04but it happens. People make mistakes. People drop things off by accident.17:09So therefore, check your boxes.17:11Now let's go back to our case over here.17:13The person over here bought chametz, right?17:16This is the not kosher crackers in the Jewish supermarket, and he went home.17:21Could you do it? Could you give it back or not?17:25So again, I consulted the same posek, and he told me that first of all,17:30that's not his chametz to sell.17:31The Jewish supermarket has no right to sell you that17:35chametz. Why? Because that chametz belongs to the goy that they sold it to.17:40So therefore, you must give back the17:43chametz. You're not even allowed to take it. He wasn't allowed to sell it to you.17:45That's gezel. You give it back to the store,17:48and they should give you back, should refund you with your money.17:50It's for sure mekach ta'ut. That's not a question.17:53But more than that, the store, the Jewish store, had no right to sell it to you.17:58Finally, the last case, you know, where the worker took18:03chametz, the non-Jewish worker took chametz from the chametz section and sold it to another Jew.18:07So you have to contact the Jew and you have to tell him,18:09Listen, it's not my chametz. I can't sell it to you. It's not even mine.18:12He told me that the person who bought it really doesn't care.18:14He doesn't want to hear it.18:16So in that case, what could you do?18:17It's technically you stole from the goy, right?18:19So now you owe the goy money.18:20So when he sells it back to you on Motzaei Pesach, so it comes back to you.18:24So then you get into halachot gezel,18:25not gezel. It's already beyond the scope of Pesach.18:29But, like we said, the real warning that we come out of all this,18:33what I learned is definitely check every box that you buy.18:37Even if it's, even if on Pesach where everything is closed off,18:40you must check the boxes or whatever you're buying,18:43the merchandise that you're buying, to make sure it says18:46kasher l'Pesach. Whatever hashgacha you follow, that's already your own issue.18:48But as far as just being in regular, decent18:51kasher l'Pesach, it shouldn't be18:53chametz. In any case, we come back to our subject over here.18:57Chametz after Pesach.18:59Chametz after Pesach has a problem.19:01Most of us don't have this issue.19:03We either get rid of our chametz by eating it before Pesach,19:06by throwing it out, giving it away,19:08or by selling it to the goy.19:10So even though we have chametz in the house,19:12if we sold real chametz, we sold it to the goy.19:15After Pesach, we're told by the19:17rabbi, you can assume by this time, 9:30, 10 o'clock, whatever it is,19:22that the goy already purchased his19:24chametz—excuse me, he sold back the19:26chametz. You could go back, I'll be your messenger.19:28You could take this chametz and eat it yourself,19:31not a problem at all.19:33However, not every Jew is as good as we are,19:36as you are,19:38right? Unfortunately, a lot of Jews, now 100% Jewish,19:41and they don't keep this halacha. Why?19:44They don't keep Pesach19:47bichlal. Pesach for them is like, you know, the national anthem.19:50They'll sing it if they have to,19:52if they're on TV and they have to19:53to put up the show. They couldn't care less.19:56Now, not every person who is not observant19:59doesn't sell his20:01chametz. There's some people who sell their chametz because, listen,20:04the community that he serves is an Orthodox community.20:06They will not buy from him after Pesach20:08if he doesn't sell their20:10chametz. So don't assume that every person who's not religious20:12and he owns a supermarket didn't sell his20:14chametz. No, some people do sell their20:16chametz. However, in cases where we know20:18that the person did not sell his20:20chametz, then that chametz that he has in the store becomes a problem.20:24Even though it's his problem, it's not my problem,20:26don't make it your problem.20:27You're not allowed to go into his store and buy that20:30chametz. You are not allowed to have benefit from it.20:32Even if you paid for it,20:33you cannot derive any benefit from that20:35chametz that was left over after Pesach.20:37Why? Because throughout the holiday of Pesach,20:40it went under Jewish ownership.20:42So therefore, we have to know20:44which— Supermarkets which grocery stores20:48are selling the chametz and which are not.20:51So first thing you have to know is20:52if the supermarket—you have really two issues here.20:54It's not just a supermarket you should know.20:56The Star-K points out most of the things I'm telling you right now,20:59I've taken it from the Star-K or the OU,21:01and these are people who have really done their research.21:03A small guy like me is not going to be able to really21:06do as thorough of a research as they have done.21:09And really, if you have bigger questions on this,21:11you should contact the Star-K or the OU,21:12and they're pretty reliable,21:15very, very reliable actually,21:16in all this information,21:17and they're very, very open about all this information.21:20You can ask them whatever you like,21:21or you can download their PDF from their websites.21:24In any case, there are two issues with21:27chametz on Pesach when you're dealing with businesses.21:30Number one is if the owner of the supermarket himself is Jewish.21:34Again, even though he's not observant,21:35he might even be married to a goya,21:36it doesn't make a difference.21:37He's still a Jew,21:39l'chumra. Meaning to say, when we consider a person who is not observant,21:43who is mechalel Shabbat21:45b'farhesya, as a goy, as the halacha says in21:48Shulchan Aruch, this is only l'chumra, not21:52l'kula. That means if you need your lights on on Shabbat21:54and you have a heter, like we're learning in21:57Hilchot ..., in cases where you're allowed to tell a goy to turn on the light,21:59let's say you have a22:02choleh she'ein bo sakanah and you want to tell a goy to turn on the light,22:03you can call your non-observant neighbor,22:06say, Hey, anyways, mechalel Shabbat, let him open the light for me.22:09Oh, but didn't you say that he has a din of a22:11goy? You made me buy the reshut from him in22:14eruvin. That's only l'chumra, but not22:17l'kula. Same thing will be over here. If the Jew,22:19even though he's not observant,22:20if he has chametz ... on Pesach,22:23even though he's a22:24mumar, that chametz is still forbidden.22:25So number one is we have to see if the owner of the supermarket22:29is a goy or is he a Jew.22:31If he's a goy, there's nothing to worry about.22:33If he's a Jew, already flags should go up.22:35The second concern is—22:38Even though the owner may be not Jewish,22:41you might say, okay, it's great, he's not Jewish.22:43But sometimes the distributors,22:47that means, what is the distributor?22:49These are the middlemen that deal with the big companies,22:52and they come to the supermarkets,22:54or they come to the stores and they sell it to them.22:56The store itself is not going to sit there and deal with every company.22:59This distributor goes and buys from all these different big factories,23:02these big companies,23:04l'mashal. Let's say there's a distributor, he'll deal with23:07Coca-Cola, he'll deal with Pepsi, he'll deal with Sprite,23:09he'll go and deal with, you know, all the different types of foods23:12that doesn't have only drinks,23:13you know, with Cheerios and Nature Valley, I23:16don't know, all these different places, he'll deal with them,23:18he'll buy from them,23:20and then for a few extra pennies per item,23:22he'll come and sell it to the supermarket.23:25That's a middleman, the distributor.23:26A lot of times these distributors are Jewish,23:29and they are not selling their chametz on Pesach.23:33So then you have another issue,23:34because that chametz that they own, that they sold to the supermarkets,23:39is also23:41chametz she'avar alav haPesach. So how in the world are you supposed to know?23:43So if you have a rabbi that you trust and you can ask him,23:45let him tell you.23:48What I would like to tell you, though,23:50is that the Star-K does have a little bit of a list,23:54and I only picked places from the list23:57that we, you know, over here in the Brooklyn area.24:00We know about things that are beyond Brooklyn,24:02even though there might be some of these stores24:04outside of Brooklyn, but only the big places in Brooklyn.24:07Then those that are not24:09mentioned, you know, maybe I'm not so familiar with them,24:11but those who would like to know other places,24:13call up the OU or go and call up the24:17Star-K, and they'll tell you all the rest of information.24:20So another point to keep in mind before we go to the list24:23is that there are over 35,000 supermarkets in America,24:2935,000 big supermarkets in America.24:31There's no way on this class,24:33where I'm only going to spend an extra minute on this,24:35we're going to find out all of these,24:37all the stores and which names and which not.24:39So keep that in mind as well.24:41The major supermarkets where one is permitted to shop from:24:46ShopRite here on Avenue U and Avenue I.24:49Avenue I ShopRite is, according to the OU,24:52is not a problem. You could shop from there.24:54Whether it's not a problem because they sold it24:56or didn't sell it, whatever it is, ShopRite is fine.24:59Also, the Star-K puts the following, and they said Walmart,25:02Costco, BJ's, CVS, Rite Aid, and Kmart.25:09I thought Kmart is a lev shalom,25:10but anyway, Kmart as well.25:12All these stores, they are fine for this year, 2015.25:17They have no problem with25:19chametz she'avar alav haPesach. Why? I'm not sure.25:21Maybe it's their own by25:23a goy. Maybe it's a non-Jewish distributor.25:24Maybe they sold25:24the chametz. Whatever the case may be,25:26this is the list for the Star-K for the year 2015.25:31Now, there are some stores that one has to avoid.25:34What are these places that one has to avoid?25:36So there is a big distributor who is,25:39according to the Star-K, is Jewish,25:41and he doesn't, for all they know,25:43he does not sell his chametz on Pesach.25:45So therefore, this person distributes25:47to some local stores that we know about25:49and people shop from.25:51What are these stores?25:52Stop & Shop. And Target.25:56These two stores buy from a major distributor25:58whose Jewish, who does not sell his chametz on Pesach,26:01and one should avoid shopping from them.26:03For how long?26:04You don't have to avoid for the rest of your life.26:07Usually things in the supermarket move so quickly26:09that by two weeks already,26:13two weeks already, things either moved out off the shelf,26:16or at least the majority moved off the26:19shelf. And according to the26:20poskim, once the majority of the items that are in the store,26:23or in that section really,26:25are not a problem of26:27chametz she'avar alav haPesach, then you can assume that26:30ruba26:32deparish, kol deparish meruba parish. Whatever was poreish, probably came from the majority,26:35which was mutar.26:36So therefore, if a store itself is owned by a26:40non-Jew, then the store should not buy26:45chametz, specifically chametz from that store26:47until two weeks after Pesach,26:49which is around April26:5126. That's the date that the26:53store begins. If they have a Jewish distributor,26:57so then that means they're getting their merchandise26:58after Pesach, which is assur, or even during Pesach,27:01then one should avoid shopping from there27:03until four weeks after Pesach,27:05that is May 10th. Okay?27:09Target and Stop & Shop,27:10they're buying from a Jewish distributor,27:13and therefore one should avoid buying27:15chametz from them until May 10th.27:18Liquor, though, is a little different.27:19Liquor takes longer to move,27:21and even major liquor stores,27:23you have to be careful, really.27:24A lot of these liquor stores are really owned by Jews,27:27and again, they're Jews.27:28Somebody told me they're just Jews by name.27:30No, they're Jews by soul.27:32If they're Jews by name,27:33it means they're really27:34goyim, their mother is not Jewish.27:35If their mother is Jewish, that means they're Jews,27:37and therefore it's a problem.27:39In such liquor stores where things move,27:41but they don't move as slow as fast,27:43you have to avoid shopping from them27:45until after Shavuot,27:46where we can assume already27:47that the majority of the stuff27:49is not27:51chametz she'avar alav haPesach. If one accidentally27:52already now is listening to this class27:53and he says, Oh my gosh,27:55I already bought from Stop & Shop,27:57I already bought from Target,27:58I already bought from places27:59that you told me you shouldn't buy.28:00So we called up the OU,28:01we called up the28:02Star-K, and they said that I guess28:05b'diavad there is what to be28:07somech on. That you don't have to return the item.28:08Of course, you want to be28:09machmir, you want to return the item to the store28:11and get your money back.28:13You could, but you don't have to really,28:16because there is what to rely on28:17that maybe it came28:19from—remember, he did not only28:20buy from one distributor;28:21he bought from different distributors,28:22and there is enough what to be28:24somech on. But28:25l'chatchila, one should avoid buying from them28:26from two to four weeks after Pesach.28:29Now, I know I'm getting a lot of texts in,28:31and some of them are longer than others.28:33I don't have time to really go over all the texts.28:38I see one quick text28:39I can answer very quickly,28:40and that is tonight's class will be repeated28:41at 11 to 12. That I can answer.28:44The rest I can't answer, I'm sorry.28:46In any case, yeah, we'll answer all the texts,28:48b'ezrat Hashem. We'll try to keep a few minutes28:50by the end of the show to answer all the texts.28:53Let's now go on to the second part of the class:28:57Berachot of leftover food from Pesach.29:01The food that's pretty much29:02you're going to have leftover from Pesach29:04is matzah or the Pesach cakes29:08or the Pesach pasta, the Pesach bread,29:10whatever it may be.29:12So let's begin. Matzah.29:13So matzah during the holiday of Pesach,29:15everybody makes berachah of hamotzi,29:17unless it's egg matzah29:18and you're a person who has a custom of eating egg matzah,29:22or in the Sefard where you could eat egg matzah.29:24So egg matzah is really29:26mezonot. So what's the berachah of matzah after Pesach?29:29Ashkenazim, it's very simple.29:30For Ashkenazim, this is bread.29:32It doesn't make a difference if it's crunchy or not crunchy.29:34Who cares what the texture of the bread is?29:37This is bread, and therefore29:38they make hamotzi on Pesach29:40and hamotzi on matzah even after Pesach.29:43That's only—I have to point this29:46out—only if you're having the hard crunchy matzah.29:49We find that there's two different matzot in the market.29:51There's soft matzah,29:52which a lot of Sefardim eat in29:54Eretz Yisrael and some also over here,29:56and there's also a hard crunchy matzah,29:58which is the regular29:59people—you know, when people understand that's matzah.30:01The soft matzah, you don't go by the name of it,30:03just like breadsticks are not hamotzi, right?30:05The crunchy breadsticks are30:07mezonot. So too, soft matzah is hamotzi throughout the year.30:11Even though it's called matzah, it doesn't make a difference.30:13We go by the texture; we don't go by the name.30:15Now, our question is, what would be with the matzah?30:18I have leftover matzot,30:19and they're good. I can have them as crackers.30:20Instead of buying30:21Melba toast, I can have matzot from all the leftover matzahs I have,30:26and great, I'm doing a matzah shemurah.30:28I'm having a real good diet over here.30:30What is the berachah on matzah for the Sefardim? After Pesach.30:35So to explain this very quickly30:36is hard, and you're not going to understand the30:39halacha, and it's going to be very confusing.30:40So I'm going to spend a little bit of time30:42to clarify the subject.30:45In Shulchan Aruch, in Siman Kuf30:48Samech Chet, סעיף ז', Maran brings where if I have dough and I bake it,30:54so sometimes, depending what I do to the dough,30:58the dough will not be hamotzi after it's baked;31:02rather it will be31:04mezonot. In a case where it will be hamotzi,31:06it means I have regular flour and water,31:09and I bake it and I have beautiful soft bread.31:11That's called, that's regular bread.31:13That becomes hamotzi. There's no question about that.31:15Even a little tiny piece, it's hamotzi.31:18But there are three scenarios where I could take that31:22dough and turn it into mezonot before baking it,31:25that after baking it will become31:27mezonot. What are these three cases?31:28Number one is if I take the31:30dough and I stuff it with sweets and then I bake it.31:35So now I have stuffed sweets.31:36So even though it's only flour and water,31:39that after being baked, since it's stuffed with sweets,31:42it becomes31:44mezonot. Case number two is where in the dough itself,31:47when I'm making the dough, I add enough inside31:51where I could taste it after it's being baked.31:54I add enough additives, sorry, ingredients31:56besides flour and water, like milk or apple.32:00Juice or orange juice. Not that it says it on the bag. What it says on the bag is noriskeit. It's nonsense. It means nothing.32:07What it says on the bag is nothing. Don't look at the ingredients. Taste it.32:10If you're a Sephardi, you have to taste it. If you could taste it, you could say, Ah, there's a,32:15I could taste over here apple juice or orange juice or honey, then it becomes mezonot.32:22According to the Ashkenazim, the Rama is a little bit more32:25machmir. They need not to just taste it, but it has to taste very, very strong.32:29You know, the taste has to be very, very much like apple juice or whatever the additives are,32:34and then they'll make mezonot. Third condition, that's what we're going to speak about,32:38is the opinion of the Aruch, b'shem32:42Rav Hai Gaon, and he says that if I take regular flour and water and I bake it to the point that it comes out crunchy,32:48kind of like a cracker or a Melba toast, then the bracha would be mezonot.32:54What's the reason why all of a sudden this dough that was yesterday, you know, that was, you know,33:00that I took this dough, I divided it to one I baked for bread,33:04and the other one I left in the oven a little bit longer because I wanted to be crunchy.33:07Why should the crunchy one be mezonot, and why should the soft one be33:12hamotzi? And the answer is, says the Beit Yosef, because when it's crunchy, people don't eat it as a33:18meal. They only eat it as a snack, so that's why snacks are mezonot.33:23The other one, which is made soft, that's made to have a bread.33:25I don't care if you decide to eat it as a snack; it's made to be as a bread, as a meal.33:29For that, you make a bracha of hamotzi. That's the main difference,33:32as the Beit Yosef's reason, that's what he brings, why one is mezonot, one is33:37hamotzi. Hamotzi is when it's made to be eaten as a meal.33:40The other one, which is made to be eaten as a snack, it becomes mezonot.33:44So now people will say, Okay, so that means matzah. It's crunchy, it should be mezonot.33:50However, if you go with the reason of the Beit Yosef, that if it's made to be eaten as a snack, it'll be mezonot,33:57but if it's made to be eaten as a meal, it should not be mezonot, it should be34:01hamotzi, we have a big problem making mezonot on matzah after Pesach.34:05Because, like we said, there are matzot that are sold throughout the year;34:09they're not even kasher l'Pesach, they're chametz, pure34:12chametz. And people, why do they buy them? Because people like to have them as a meal,34:17whether it's for health reasons or it's because they taste better, it doesn't make a difference.34:21People are having them as a meal. So because of that, it really puts a big question:34:26how are we to make the bracha of hamotzi—I'm excuse me—how are we making the bracha of mezonot, as Sefardim, on matzah after Pesach?34:35It was made, first of all, to be eaten as a meal in the holiday of Pesach. Now you have34:39the leftover, so how are you making bracha of mezonot on it?34:41Because of this, Chacham Ben Tzion and Chacham Ovadia both said,34:45really lechatchila, if a person wants to follow the best way according to34:50halacha, he should not have matzah by itself and make mezonot.34:52You should wash for regular bread and have matzah34:57betoch hase'udah. Don't eat it by itself and make mezonot,35:01lechatchila. However, if a person is going to have to eat it, he's not going to wash, he's going to have to eat the matzah,35:05in that case, both Chacham Ben Tzion and Chacham Ovadia hold that the minhag is,35:11as the Chida and other Acharonim brought down,35:14the minhag is that the Sefardim will make bracha of mezonot on matzah,35:18the hard crunchy matzah, after Pesach.35:21Why? Because that's how they've been doing it.35:24But really, lechatchila, like they said, like these poskim brought down,35:27one should avoid having it by itself.35:29So it's really not so simple to say, Oh, I'm Sefardi, I'm going to eat matzah,35:33it's going to be mezonot. Not so pashut.35:35If it's egg matzah, then for sure you have—that's because of the second condition:35:38you added additives to the dough, and that's why it's mezonot.35:42But otherwise, for— Regular matzah, plain flour and water,35:47that is not so simple to make a bracha of mezonot.35:51Lechatchila, one should wash first on regular bread35:53and then eat the mezonot in the middle of35:56seudah. Even to make hamotzi on the matzah is not so simple either,35:59because like we said, the minhag is mezonot.36:01So therefore, one should have it in the middle of36:04b'toch haseudah. Even if you plan to say mezonot on the matzah,36:07you have to be aware of something else.36:10In the Mishnah Berurah, Ish Matzliach, Rav Mazuz in the back36:15brings down an idea, a very important idea really,36:18that really when we say a kezayit is about 27 grams, or let's say 28.8 grams,36:25that's really the weight of an item.36:28All the halacha, the Rishonim and36:31Acharonim, really when they discuss, and the Gemara talks about36:34kezayit, it's talking about in volume.36:36So in general, things, the way they weigh36:39and the way they are in volume,36:40the size of the volume and the size of the way they weigh,36:42in general you could assume that if you have the weight,36:45it's pretty much the same size in volume.36:48However, when something is crunchy like melba toast or a matzah,36:53really it's much smaller.36:55According to Rav Mazuz, he said he's done a test.36:56Now this is not only the opinion of Rav Mazuz,36:58it's also the opinion of many37:00Acharonim. Chacham Ovadia has a whole thing in37:02Chelek Gimmel, you see in the beginning he talks about it.37:03In any case, over here, in the matzah itself,37:07this is why I wanted to bring Rav Mazuz.37:09He says that the machine-made matzah,37:11he's tested all different types of machine-made matzah37:13and he saw that the maximum,37:17the maximum weight of a matzah to be kezayit is 13 grams.37:22That means if you're only having 13 grams of matzah,37:24that's already a kezayit; it requires a bracha37:27acharona. So on Pesach, if you had 13 grams of37:30machine-made matzah—I'm talking about machine-made, not37:32handmade—if you had 13 grams of machine-made matzah,37:35then the bracha acharona would already be37:38birkat hamazon. So now, based on this,37:41each loaf or each, you know, square matzah is 33 grams,37:47which is about37:49three kezaytot. Most people have two, three squares of matzah when they're having their meal.37:53Some even have more.37:55You know, it goes very quickly.37:57So if you're having three squares of matzah,38:00that means you're having already how many38:04kezaytot? You're having already38:10eight kezaytot. Eight kezayit of mezonot is hamotzi.38:14If you're having cake, or if you're having cookies,38:18things that you normally make birkat mezonot on them,38:20if you're having eight kezayit of them,38:24you are required to wash your hands38:26and make a birkat hamotzi38:27and do birkat hamazon afterwards.38:29So if you're having three square matzah,38:32then for sure you have to wash your hands38:35and netilat yadayim and birkat hamazon afterwards.38:36So even according to the38:38minhag, and you want to make mezonot anyway,38:40you have to be careful.38:41You should limit one eating to two squares of matzah38:46and don't go beyond that.38:47That is the halacha of matzah after Pesach.38:52The other scenario is potato starch cakes.38:56Potato starch cakes is very simple.38:57Shehakol.38:58Why?38:58They take potato, they grind it38:59because you can't use any flour.39:01They turn it to flour,39:02and now it works. Well, it works exactly like regular flour from regular wheat,39:08and they make all types of cakes.39:11Some people claim that even the taste of the Pesach cake39:14is even better than throughout the year.39:16You know, like some people say,39:19you can't even feel Pesach.39:20Of course not.39:21You're in Hawaii39:22and you're on a cruise,39:22on a vacation.39:23Of course you're not going to feel Pesach.39:24But the Pesach cakes even make it more so,39:26you can't tell.39:28Now the problem is after Pesach.39:30What happens now after Pesach?39:32After Pesach, nothing should change.39:34The bracha of niskech should be shehakol.39:36So therefore, you have to be careful.39:38You have to know that39:41before you come to eat any cakes,39:44especially people that usually pull out,39:45you know, the leftovers from Pesach,39:47ask them,39:47was this leftover from Pesach?39:48If it's leftover from Pesach,39:49it's pretty much shehakol.39:51You know,39:51it's probably going to be shehakol,39:53the bracha rishona,39:55and bracha acharona is going to be borei nefashot.39:57In a case where a person by accident—40:00Incident, already made a bracha of mezonot on the cake, and in the middle of eating, somebody told him, you know, you're eating a Pesach cake.40:09So we hold that mezonot b'diavad covers all foods except for water, salt, and any of the, you know, like the sweeteners, like NutraSweet and Splenda and all these things.40:22If you make a mezonot on any other food besides water, salt, and the sweeteners, yotzei even sugar.40:28Notice there's a difference between sweetener and sugar. Not now to go into why not.40:32Mezonot pretty much covers all types of food. So if you made mezonot by accident on a Pesach cake, yotzei b'diavad, you can continue eating.40:39However, bracha acharona will be borei nefashot. Don't make al hamichya on it.40:43Even though you started with mezonot, you're going to make the bracha acharona of40:47borei nefashot. Now here it gets a little bit more complicated. A guy picked up a Pesach cake, he made mezonot, he ate two, three pieces.40:53Ah, this is a great cake, and then he made a bracha acharona of40:57al hamichya. What's the din then? The halacha says that al hamichya does not cover41:05borei nefashot. Al hamichya does not cover borei nefashot. Therefore, if a person said al hamichya on these Pesach cakes, he must go back and say borei nefashot again.41:14If, however, here's a little bit more complicated, let's say a person had real cake and he also had some Pesach cake along the way.41:24Or let's say he was having some fruits. Let's do it this way. He was having some fruits from41:29shivat haminim. He ate grapes and the Pesach cake. By accident, he made a mezonot on the Pesach cake, and of course he made a ha'etz on the Pesach fruits. Not Pesach fruits, even weekday fruits,41:38right? So now he made al hamichya and al haperot on everything all together.41:43So in that case, it could be a little bit more complicated. Because you're making the beracha of al ha'etz anyway, which you're obligated to say,41:53and you included in it also something which you said41:58atah notan, so according to some opinions, it's probably going to cover the potato starch cakes.42:03So in such a scenario, the best thing to do is take a cup of water or a drink, make shehakol, drink it again, and make borei nefashot, having in mind the pesach cakes.42:13If you don't have a cup of water, then42:17bediavad you can be yotzei, but that's only if you said the beracha of al ha'perot as well. Then you have what to rely on.42:22But otherwise, you should go ahead and make beracha borei nefashot, in the case we made on a pesach cake.42:31Next subject:42:33Birkat Ha'ilanot. Birkat Ha'ilanot, we spoke about it really before the holiday of Pesach, right in the beginning on Rosh Chodesh42:38Nissan, but we have to mention it always after Pesach because the Shulchan Aruch brings down,42:45hayotzei bimei Nissan, a person who walks out in the days of Nissan, and according to many, many42:50Acharonim, who are the Chida, the Ben Ish Chai, Rav Chaim Palachi, the Kaf HaChaim, Sofer, Shut Halachot Ketanot,42:57all of these poskim, they hold that one could only say Birkat Ha'ilanot in the month of43:03Nissan. You cannot say Birkat Ha'ilanot after Nissan or before43:06Nissan. You can't say in Adar, you can't say in Iyar.43:08Once it's already Aleph Iyar, one cannot say Birkat Ha'ilanot anymore.43:13So therefore, if a person has not said Birkat Ha'ilanot, make sure you go out and you say it.43:17According to the Mishnah Berurah and Chacham Ovadia, they hold that you could even say it after43:24Nissan. Nissan is lav davka; it just happens to be that's when things grow.43:27But really the beracha is on the tree, whatever it starts to bud, whenever the flowers of the tree start to come out,43:34you have to go and make the beracha on Birkat Ha'ilanot, even if it's in Iyar.43:38So because of this machloket. Rambam Tzion says, say it without Shem Hashem,43:43say it without Shem43:44u'malchut, because really it's not so pashut to say it after43:47Nissan. And therefore, we'll tell you after Pesach, if you did not say Birchat Ilanot, make sure you go out, you look for the trees.43:53What are you looking for?43:54You're looking for lechatchila two fruit trees.43:57Has to be fruit trees, by the way. This is not43:59lechatchila, but two is44:01lechatchila. The fruit trees mean to say any fruit. It doesn't have to produce a thousand fruits.44:05As long as it produces any fruit, and be surprised how many are in the neighborhood.44:09I had in front of my house for the whole time, for the last ten years,44:12I had a cherry tree in front of my house, and I completely did not notice it.44:16And every year you walk by and you see dirt on the floor, you don't even realize to look up.44:19And I had two cherry trees in front of my house.44:21So you could have them even in your backyard. It's not one specific location.44:25What are you looking for?44:26You're looking for the following.44:27Usually the way the tree grows is like this.44:30The rain falls in the winter. When it comes to the springtime, they start to sprout.44:35How does it start to44:36sprout? There's, you see on the tree already like flowers start to come out.44:40Every tree, like a flower starts to come out.44:42From these flowers, then the fruit also comes out of there.44:46Now you have to be careful.44:47Some of them produce flowers, sometimes the leaves come out.44:50In the case where the flowers are coming out of the tree,44:53that already you can make a bracha, Birchat Ilanot.44:55But if the leaves are only coming out of the tree,44:58the tree is not ready to make the bracha of Birchat Ilanot.45:00The earliest time one can make the bracha of Birchat Ilanot45:04is when the tree produces already a flower.45:07That flower where the fruit eventually will come out.45:09Now when the fruit starts to grow, that flower slowly will fall off.45:13Once that flower falls off, according to most opinions,45:16you cannot make the bracha of Birchat Ilanot. It's already too late.45:19So that's what you're looking out for.45:21You're looking out for a tree where the flowers grew on the tree,45:25and the flower did not fall off the tree yet, because otherwise it will be too late.45:31Lechatchila, if one could say it outside the city,45:34let's say you're going on a trip outside the city,45:36great. If you could say it over there, it's better,45:38but it's not45:39me'akev. Also, you don't have to say it in the minyan.45:41You could say it even45:43beyachid. Sometimes if you catch a tree and you're by yourself,45:46say it right away. Don't wait for a minyan.45:48It might be too late by the time you catch a minyan.45:51And also— Preferably, preferably,45:54it should not be a tree that has been planted within the last three years,45:58or a la tree.46:00But if it is an orla tree,46:02you have the Ben Ish Chai and Chacham Ovadia to rely on,46:04that you could still say the bracha on it,46:06although others argue.46:08What about women?46:09Are women obligated in this46:10beracha? Now, this beracha is not a mitzvat aseh shehazman gerama.46:13It's not based on time;46:14it's based on the tree.46:16It just happens to be that the time is in the days of46:18Nissan. So based on that, really, women should say the46:22beracha. The only thing is, and the Sefardim, that's how they bring,46:25Sefardim, the poskim bring down,46:27women should go and make46:29birkat ha'ilanot. However, I did see, Piskei Teshuvot brings in the name of46:32Teshuvot Hanhagot, and he writes that they don't have to run after the46:35mitzvah. Women don't have to go drive themselves nuts to look for a tree.46:37If they happen to come across a tree,46:39then they can make the46:41beracha. But it's a mitzvah, it's a beracha that comes once a year,46:44and it's limited on time,46:46and usually those mitzvot are46:49chavivot. They're very beloved because they come in a special moment.46:51It's definitely not כדאי to lose out on this46:59beracha. Next subject of halachot, and we'll conclude with this,47:03are the halachot of tefillah.47:06The halachot of tefillah,47:09we made a few changes in the holiday of Pesach.47:13We basically switched from the—excuse me—we switched the Amidah from the winter Amidah to the summer47:25Amidah. What is the winter Amidah? What is the summer47:27Amidah? In the winter, we ask for rain,47:29and in the summer, we don't ask for rain.47:33In the Amidah, there are two places where we mention rain.47:36One is where we mention that God brings rain.47:38That's right in the beginning of the47:41Amidah, in the second beracha, where we say47:44Mashiv haruach u'morid hageshem. We mention that God brings rain.47:47And in the middle of the47:51Amidah, the beracha of Barech Aleinu, over there, in the ninth47:54beracha, we say— Ask Hashem for rain,47:58v'ten tal u'matar livracha. The Sefardim say a whole...48:06And the Ashkenazim will say just that line, v'ten tal u'matar livrachah. In this summer, rain is not good. It's not seasonal. This is not the time for rain,48:13and therefore we cannot ask for rain in Barech Aleinu, and also we should not mention that God brings down the rain.48:21If a person makes such a mistake, if he asks for rain, or if he mentions that God brings rain,48:27that means if you said48:29Mashiv haruach u'morid hageshem, or if you ask48:32v'ten tal u'matar livrachah, then you said the wrong Amidah. You must repeat it.48:36But there's a difference, though.48:38The difference is as follows.48:41The first time in Amidah that you mention rain is going to be in the second48:45berachah. In the second berachah, if you, by mistake, said48:50Mashiv haruach u'morid hageshem, if you caught yourself in the middle of the Amidah, or anywhere in the Amidah really,48:54after you concluded that berachah, that means if you already started48:58Attah Kadosh, then you must go back to the beginning of the Amidah.49:00Why? Because the rule is that the first three berachot of the Amidah are one package.49:11If you make any mistake in that first group, you cannot just go back to your mistake and fix it.49:17You have to go back to the beginning of the set of berachot, which is the beginning of the Amidah, and fix it.49:23Therefore, translate it like this.49:26If an Ashkenazi said49:30Mashiv haruach u'morid hageshem, as opposed to not saying anything at all49:32over the summer, he didn't say49:33morid hatal, he just said49:36Mashiv, and he mentioned Mashiv haruach u'morid hageshem in the summer Amidah,49:38both of us, we have to go back all the way to the beginning of the Amidah,49:40no matter where I catch myself, unless I catch myself within that49:43berachah before I say49:46Baruch Atah Hashem, Chayeh HaMetim. However, if I made a mistake49:49and I asked for rain,49:50which is in Barech Aleinu49:52or Barecheinu, I said49:53V'ten tal u'matar livrachah, and I caught myself.49:55If I finished the Amidah, there's nothing to do. I have to start the Amidah from the beginning.49:59But if I didn't finish the Amidah,50:01as long as I'm still in the Amidah somewhere,50:03I don't have to go back to the beginning of the Amidah.50:05I could go back just to the ninth blessing of the Amidah,50:08which is50:09Barecheinu, and continue from there and read ahead and finish the Amidah.50:13Why? Because50:16the berachot in the middle,50:18after the first three and before the last three of the Amidah,50:21those don't have a specific order.50:23There is an order, obviously, that we say it in. The Gemara Megillah talks50:25why there's such an order.50:26But even if you switch the order,50:30yotzei b'diavad. And therefore,50:31if a person made a mistake in berachah of Barech Aleinu50:34and he said50:35V'ten tal u'matar livrachah, you just go back to50:37Barecheinu and you finish the Amidah from there.50:39You don't have to go back to the beginning of the Amidah.50:43There's another halachah over here in this area,50:46and that is50:46that if a person is not sure,50:49he's in middle of the Amidah and he realizes,50:51Oh, did I say50:52Morid hatal or did I say Mashiv haruach umorid hageshem? He's not sure.50:55Now you should know, in general, most of us don't remember50:57what we did five seconds ago.50:59I'm trying to remember what I said, you know, in the beginning of the class, okay?51:01So it's normal.51:02We don't remember things,51:04you know. Our mind is always— and especially in Amidah, we like to do our best thinking51:07of our worldly things in the Amidah:51:10which business deal I want to do,51:12which date I want to go on,51:14what car I need,51:16what things I need to buy.51:17We always have that in Amidah, unfortunately.51:19That's reality, unfortunately.51:21So in general, we don't remember what we did.51:22But if you have a real uncertainty,51:25if you have a real safek because you're not sure,51:27you know, I'm used to reading51:28and I don't pay attention to the words I'm saying,51:31and I'm not sure if I said51:33Morid hatal or if I said51:35Mashiv haruach umorid hageshem. I'm not sure if I said51:38Barech Aleinu or Barecheinu. In that case, we tell you the halachah like this:51:41if it's before— Pesach sheni.51:46That means before you51:49dalet yar, then you must repeat it.51:51Meaning to say, if you caught yourself51:52that maybe you messed up by51:54Mashiv haruach umorid hageshem, you go back to beginning Amidah.51:56And if you caught yourself, you know,51:58that you messed up by51:59Barech Aleinu, you go back to over there.52:01We assume that if you had a doubt52:04whether you said the right words in Amidah52:07before Pesach sheni,52:08we assume that you probably said the wrong Amidah52:11and you must go back.52:12However, if it's after Pesach sheni,52:14again, we have a safek, we're not sure.52:16If it's after Pesach sheni, we assume that by now already52:19your mouth, your tongue already got used to saying52:22the correct Amidah,52:24and therefore you could just go ahead and continue the Amidah.52:26We assume that you said the correct Amidah;52:28you don't have to go back and repeat it.52:30Why? Because, like we said,52:32a person usually takes a full month to train his mouth52:36what to say.52:38It's good musar. In any case,52:40the Beit Yosef52:41brings from the Maharam52:43Rothenburg, who is the rabbi of the Rosh,52:46Rabbeinu Asher. He says,52:48being that this is so,52:49one could train himself.52:51One could go to the Amidah52:52and say that paragraph52:55that he needs to train his mouth in52:5790 times,52:58and this way you know for sure53:01that you've been trained.53:02The whole idea is that after a month your mouth got trained.53:04Why? Because you said it 90 times.53:06It's 30 days,53:0730 days times an average of three tefillot a day.53:10We assume that you said the correct53:12bracha. So says the Maharam53:14Rothenburg: repeat it 90 times and you'll be fine.53:16The Hatam Sofer says53:18if you say like53:22this,53:25Rab lehoshia, morid hatal, or Rab lehoshia, mechakeh chaim bchesed according to the Ashkenazim, if you say this53:2790 times according to Maharam53:29Rothenburg, according to Hatam Sofer 101 times,53:31you could assume that53:34from now on, as you're praying,53:36if you're in doubt,53:37you could assume that you probably said the correct words.53:40And by the way, I was listening to53:42these halachot.53:43I actually gave the same halachot last year,53:45and when I heard this, I said, No, it's a good idea to do it.53:47And just the next day, I got into a53:49safek if I said the right thing or not.53:51And like we said, since I trained myself,53:54I said it at least 90 times,53:56probably I said 100 times,53:57so then we assume that I said53:59the right Amidah.54:00I don't have to repeat the Amidah.54:03Final thing that we're going to mention today54:04before we go to the text and take any phone calls54:08is54:09tikun chatzot. For those who say tikun chatzot at night,54:11the time is about 1 a.m. now54:13because we changed the clock.54:14Tikun chatzot in the days of54:16Sefirat HaOmer, we don't say54:18tikun Rachel, which means we don't say54:20vidui either. We just go straight to54:22tikun Leah. And the54:24difference here is usually whenever we don't have54:26tachanun, whenever we skip54:28tikun Rachel, we also skip Lamnatzeach, David,54:31Yaancha Hashem b'yom tzarah. However,54:32in tikun Leah and54:34Sefirat HaOmer, we do mention that54:36mizmor. We just skip only54:38tikun Rachel. And of course, if the next day is Rosh Chodesh54:40or whatever, it's a day that everybody54:42doesn't say tachanun, then we'll skip54:44also the mizmor of Yaancha Hashem54:46b'yom tzarah. We'll go now to some questions54:48that we have either on text or some people.54:50You could call in, by the way. Let me give you the numbers:54:52718-683-5858. We'll54:54take any questions on the subjects that we54:56spoke about. You can also call in after the54:58show, after 3 o'clock, and over there55:00we'll take also your questions55:01off the air. You can also text in55:03at55:07347-927-8398. Okay,55:08questions like this: The trees now are not55:10budding flowers. What if it doesn't55:12bud until after the Chodesh of55:14Nissan? What is the halacha?55:16So, like we said,55:18it's a machloket. According to the55:20Mishnah55:22Berurah, according to Chacham Ovadia, even afterwards, even though55:24it's been a late spring,55:26trust me, we're all waiting for the good weather55:28and we get it here and there,55:30still you could still say it.55:32You could still say it even after the month of55:34Nissan because it goes by the tree, not by55:36the date. However,55:38Like we said, a list55:39of Sefardi Acharonim, including55:41the Ben Ish Chai, Rav Chaim Palachi,55:44and the Chida, they hold55:45that you could only say it in the month of Nisan.55:48So it's a machloket. In the case of55:49machloket, in the Berachot, usually we tell you55:51safek berachot lehakel, but unless55:53you are a person that always strictly follows55:55the Mishnah Berurah or55:57Chacham Ovadia, or your rabbi follows one of them, then55:59you...56:00to rely on, and certainly you could ask a rabbi and he'll tell you if you can make the bracha or not.56:07Next, I bought whiskey from a Jewish non-religious store56:12already. Can I use it? I'm not sure if they sold it.56:16Question is, could you go back to the store and ask them, do you sell56:20yachametz? I don't know if you could trust them, really. They're not religious. Maybe they have no56:27ne'emanut. If you know for sure that they're Jewish, it could be a big problem,56:32because over here it's not like they're buying it from different places. It could be a big problem.56:36So I would suggest very strongly that you consult your rabbi what to do,56:41but otherwise it could be a big problem, really, with that whiskey,56:43and you may have to, you know, have a ... ask your rabbi what to do with that whiskey afterwards.56:51But it seems like, to me, from my point of view over here, from the way the question is just mentioned, it seems to be a problem.57:06Okay, now here's another question from the text.57:09The question is like this:57:12somebody bought—okay, it's a case that happened a few years ago. It's a very interesting case.57:15Somebody actually went to a store and they bought matzah, and they came home,57:19they didn't realize, they started eating it, and they realized that it was not57:23kosher l'Pesach. Question is now, what should have been done?57:27Well, if it's bought from a kosher, like we said, if it's bought from a Jewish store, so you could go back and give it back.57:34But over here, you opened it and you ate from it. Obviously, you ate from it, you ate from it,57:37so you did an aveirah b'ay accident.57:40Like any aveirah b'ay accident, you do teshuvah. You do sincere teshuvah.57:46Obviously, you will never do this again. You'll obviously be much more careful the next time,57:49that's for sure.57:50Kabbalah la'atid, do you know what to do.57:52The three steps in teshuva is charata, vidui, and kabbalah57:56la'atid. You have to have the regret, which clearly you have regret that you didn't check the box.58:00You have to say confession, which you'll be58:03yotzei dechovah next time we hit the month of Elul and we're saying58:06Tachanun and we say vidui, anachnu chatanu, and you also have to say kabbalah58:12la'atid. I'm sure next time they're going to make sure they check every box58:14and they're going to tell everybody about it.58:16But in general, sefarim bring down, if, chas v'shalom, it happened to you even by mistake,58:19one should do some introspection: why did Hashem bring this aveirah about?58:24But like we said, in teshuva today, that's how teshuva is done.58:27You want to be really, really machmir, you want something very nice,58:30if you like those kind of kabbalistic things,58:32the Kaf HaChaim brings58:35down in the name of the Chida that to give, find out the price of how much does it cost for a58:41goat, which is the korban that's brought for a korban58:44chatat, and give that amount, donate it to tzedakah.58:48And there's a whole special nusach to say of, l'shem yichud, before it,58:54and to read the parashat58:56chatat, because one who commits an aveirah of eating chametz on Pesach is chayav karet.59:01If it's by accident, then it'll be59:05chayav chatat. We're running out of time, we're told we have to stop right now,59:08so we'll give the phone numbers one last time,59:10and we'll be here to answer any other question that you may have.59:14If you have it through a text, we'll text you back.59:16If you want to call in, you can call in right now at59:21718-683-5858. Text number is59:23347-927-8398. Again, this class will be aired on tonight at59:2711 p.m. here on59:30JRootRadio.com. Thank you for listening.59:31Thank you, Iran and JRoot Radio for hosting us.59:35Have a wonderful week.59:36We'll see you, be'ezrat Hashem, next week when we'll talk about the minhagim59:38and the laws of Sefirat HaOmer.