Torah · HolidaysHolidaysLaws for After Pesach (2014)Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysRabbi Uri Nahum · April 23, 2014−15Play+30Position0:001:02:16Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome here to JRoot Radio. We are on live on JRootRadio.com, and this is the Halacha Hour0:09on Wednesday afternoon, live at 2 to 3 p.m. And then, be'ezrat Hashem, this show will be on again0:17tonight at 11 to 12 p.m. The Halacha Hour, just a little background: here on the Halacha Hour, we0:22talk about halachot. Usually we learn from the book, the Ben Ish Chai, and we work off of the Ben0:28Ish Chai. However, in the last couple weeks, let's say two months actually, from a little bit before Purim0:34until now, we've been talking about the halachot of the holidays. First we started with0:39the halachot of Purim, then we went on to the halachot of Chodesh0:43Nissan, then afterwards we went on to the halachot of Pesach, and today also we will not continue0:48in the Ben Ish Chai just yet. We still have a few halachot of after Pesach, of what to do after0:53Pesach, and that's what we'll be doing today, be'ezrat Hashem, all the things that one needs to know for the days1:00after Pesach, immediate days after Pesach. And hopefully once we get covered with that, we'll1:04go on to the halachot of Sefirat HaOmer, the minhagim of Sefirat HaOmer, as well as the counting1:09Sefirat HaOmer, and from then we'll go back to our regular schedule of the halachot of the Ben1:14Ish Chai. Today's class is dedicated anonymously,1:21le'ilui nishmat the hayeled Rafael Elisha Meir ben Devora. Also it is dedicated for zera shel kayama to a very special couple whose names—they don't want me to say their1:30names on the radio—and this class is dedicated for them, be'ezrat Hashem, they should be zocheh to have1:37zera shel kayama, children very, very soon within the year, be'ezrat Hashem. The way to listen to us now is on JRootRadio.com or on1:46the JRoot Radio Pro app. You can also watch the archives afterwards, either video or by audio, or you1:52could call in. You can listen on the phone at 718-506-9099, and you'll have to press 1 twice1:59when you get on the phone, and this way you'll hear the radio live. We're not on 97.5 so far.2:05There are some technical difficulties, whether you heard or you did not. But basically, we're not on2:10the radio, and on the radio we had access to thousands, literally tens of thousands of2:17Jews, and you could only see what happened when we went off the radio and everybody, you know, seeing the2:23effect that we don't have the station, that we could access so many Jews. And2:29like Rav Nissim said on the radio already, said off the radio or on the radio, that this is the2:36number one station of Jewish radio in the world. There's no politics here. It's all either classes2:41or some Jewish entertainments. So therefore, we've decided that we're going to make a petition. We're2:48going to make a petition that, b'ezrat Hashem, hopefully to put the radio back on, that we should be able to exit on2:5397.5. And just like we had before for the petition for that child, and Baruch Hashem so many people2:59signed up, and it had an effect that, Baruch Hashem, they were able to give him the medicine.3:04Okay, Hashem turns the circumstances in His own ways, but in any case, many people, thousands of3:09people signed up. We figured if we have also thousands of people signing this petition,3:14b'ezrat Hashem we'll be back on. What is this petition, rabotai? This petition is called the3:19Shemoneh Esrei, the Amidah. Let me tell you, Chazal tell us that there was a time when there were malshinim,3:26when there were people who would snitch on other Jews, and the Jewish people had a very difficult3:30time, especially the Rabbanim in being able to teach the kahal and running the kahal because3:36he had these mosrim, he had these people who would inform the non-Jews of the doings of the Jewish3:42people. So they decided to add a berachah. They decided to instill a berachah in the Amidah.3:46The berachah is that we say every single day,3:50Laminim v'lamalshinim al tehi tikvah. How come they instituted that berachah in the Amidah? One, they make a Yom Tefillah,3:55and answer they felt that if every Jew would pray every single day, three times a day,4:00and pray to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, at least this weakens their power. So we come and we say the same thing.4:05If we want this radio station, that we should have all the Torah, that every Jew living in the...4:12Brooklyn area or the New York area, to be able to have access to nonstop Torah, and it's really4:19nonstop Torah, nonstop help. There's so many classes over here that besides the Torah also,4:25you have so many classes that, or programs, that are dedicated for4:30refuat hanefesh as well as refuat haguf, and of course the Talmud Torah. So therefore, we ask of everybody to pray. All we4:39could do, Ein lanu ela Avinu shebashamayim. We could only pray to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, and whatever Hashem decides to do, after this. But we have to do4:45our part. Our part is that we should mention right before we finish the tefillah,4:53HaKadosh Baruch Hu, yehi ratzon that we should have the radio back on, and don't think that it's little. Don't think, Oh, I'm going5:00to pray for this. There's so many problems in the world that Maharal points out that5:06even the smallest detail HaKadosh Baruch Hu wants you to tell Him. Even the smallest detail that shows our5:10connection. We don't only pray to Hashem when big things are there. Hashem wants us to pray to Him,5:14to call out to Him. If you're driving and you don't have a parking spot, and it's erev Shabbat in5:21Borough Park or in Avenue J, and good luck finding a parking spot, right? But that's when5:26you're supposed to pray to HaKadosh Baruch Hu. According to the Ramban, Nachmanides, it is a mitzvah5:32de'oraita. Any time a person is in need and he says a tefillah, he's5:37mekayem mitzvat de'oraita. If you're looking for a parking spot and you can't find one, and you turn to Hashem, you say,5:42Hashem, please find me a parking spot, you're fulfilling a mitzvah min haTorah. It's the same thing over5:47here. If you want the station back on, if you want to have access on the radio, so turn to Hashem and5:52pray. Say, Hashem, please have the station back on the radio, and bezrat Hashem, Hashem will answer our tefillot. And this way, it's mechayeh el hachayim. We go from one mitzvah6:02to another mitzvah. We pray that the radio comes back on, and the zechut of the rabim will be6:08multiplied by thousands again, and everybody will be learning together on the radio, listening to6:13Torah classes, listening to programs that enhance our Judaism, that makes us closer as a people6:20together. And it makes us closer to HaKadosh Baruch Hu, which is really what these days we're in6:25right now are all about. We're in the days of Sefirat HaOmer. We're going to go through halachot very soon,6:30and we're in these days where Chazal tell us, on a certain level, amongst the greatest of the Jewish6:36people, on a certain level, on their level, of course, we're not to understand; these6:39were great giants, these were Tannaim kedoshim. But on their level, lo nahagu kavod zeh bazeh. There was a little bit of6:46a problem of separation between each other, didn't give each other the proper respect.6:50There's some sort of form of lack of unity. So therefore, in these days, these are the6:56days we want to be mezakeh, we want to increase Torah by all coming together for the same goal,7:00which is Shavuot. Shavuot, בלב אחד כאיש אחד, we all stood by Har Sinai for the same goal7:07of receiving the Torah, and be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully now we'll be able to spread the Torah to everybody7:12as well. The halachot that we need to know right now for Pesach, we will begin. First of all, hey, you7:19know it's a day after Pesach. Today is Isru Chag, and you survived Pesach. If you're one of the7:24ladies listening to the class, chazak u'baruch, yashar koach, you've survived. You get a special baseball hat or a T-shirt: You7:32survived Pesach. Maybe we should send you a certificate: I survived Pesach 2014,7:38תשע"ד. In any case, but the halachot of Pesach have not completed yet. We still have some halachot of Pesach7:44that will carry over to the days after Pesach and that are very, very important that we7:48need to know. Before we go on to the halachot, I would like to ask if you have a question7:52and you would like to either call or text in. Phone calls we take after three o'clock when we're7:58off the air, so this—8:00You can answer all the phone calls properly,8:02but if you have any questions through a text,8:04please text it in.8:05Also, I'm very interested to know,8:07because I use this for learning purposes8:09for next year, any interesting questions8:12that came up over Pesach.8:13Even if you got a psak halacha,8:15not interested in—even if you're not interested in knowing8:17what my opinion, our opinion is in the halacha8:19regarding halacha—but I would like to know8:21scenarios that come up on Pesach.8:23If you could please text in8:25some of the most common or complicated8:28questions that came over Pesach,8:30we would love to hear them. And if you'd like them to be answered,8:32mention, please answer those questions.8:35Okay, let's get to some8:36halachot that we need to know regarding Pesach.8:39First category of halachot8:41that we need to know for8:42after Pesach is8:45regarding the din that's brought down8:46in Shulchan Aruch in8:48Siman Taf Mem Chet. Here I will be reading from Maran8:50in סעיף ג'. Maran writes,8:53and this is a halacha, it's a din8:54from the Gemara, from the Gemara. The Gemara says,8:56and it's brought down in Shulchan Aruch,8:58chametz shel Yisrael9:01she'avar alav haPesach. If you have9:02chametz belonging to the Jew,9:05meaning it's under the ownership of a Jew,9:06doesn't have to be necessarily in the house; it could even be9:09in somewhere else, but it's under9:10the ownership of a Jew,9:12she'avar alav haPesach, which9:14went through the holiday of Pesach9:16under the ownership of the Jew. That means9:18in the holiday of Pesach it was considered9:20the ownership; it was considered9:22owned by a Jew, says the9:24halacha, and no argument on this,9:26not Ashkenazim, not Sefardim, there's no9:28exceptions over here,9:30asur b'hana'ah. It is forbidden in any benefit.9:32Not only that,9:43afilu hiniacho shogeg or anus. Even if the9:43chametz was left by accident—what does mean b'shogeg? It means the person9:44didn't realize he had the9:46chametz. He didn't realize that this was a9:49chametz, or he didn't realize that it was forbidden9:50to keep chametz in his house9:52without selling it to a goy9:54or without getting rid of it. He didn't realize it.9:56Or even anus, even if he9:58realized it but he couldn't get to it. He got10:00stuck in traffic, he was10:02jailed, you know, something happened.10:04He was sick in the hospital10:06and completely didn't think about his10:08chametz that he had. The halacha says10:10it is forbidden to have10:12any benefit from that chametz after10:14Pesach. Not only could you not eat it,10:16you may not even have benefit from it. You cannot10:18sell it, you cannot give it to your10:21animal, you cannot give it as a present even to a goy. It's10:23forbidden to have any sort of benefit from10:25this chametz. That is the halacha.10:28Not only that,10:29Maran writes later on,10:33Hametz nimtza b'beit Yisrael achar Pesach, asur af afilu b'tilo. If you have10:35chametz in your house, even if you declared10:37it ownerless, we all said10:39bitul, which means,10:45kal chamira d'ika birshuti, d'chazitei v'da'chazitei, d'lo chazitei v'da'lo chazitei, right? We all declared that on Erev Pesach.10:47We all declared that the night of10:49bedikat chametz. We said, We don't want this10:52chametz. But if you said that10:53and you kept the chametz in your house, it's still10:55forbidden b'hana'ah. Maybe10:57you saved yourself from other issurim, but bottom line,10:59if you have that11:02chametz, it's in your ownership,11:03it's in your house, and you didn't get11:05rid of it or you didn't sell it,11:07that chametz is forbidden11:09b'hana'ah. Why am I saying this? Well, first of all, let me11:11tell you a story that happened.11:13I get a phone call on Erev Pesach11:16from11:17a young man11:19who's living with his parents, and he11:21has a question. He says, Rabbi... I need11:23to sell my chametz, and this11:25was maybe about11:27an hour before—not an hour,11:29it was less than an hour. It was within an hour that11:31you can't eat chametz anymore. So I said, I'm sorry, I already11:33gave in the contracts already to11:35the other rabbis who were selling11:37it. I already, I cannot sell it. Go find, go11:39try this rabbi and this rabbi. After11:41trying, I guess, he called a few rabbis.11:43He calls me back now two hours11:45later. This was exactly11:47five minutes before11:49the issur of owning11:51chametz in your house. That means he had another11:53five minutes to get rid of your11:55chametz, either to sell it or to give it away11:57to a goy. He goes, Rabbi, what do I do?11:59I have all this chametz and I did12:01not sell it. So I said, You12:03got to sell it right now or give it to a goy.12:05I'm sorry, I can't help you.12:07So I don't know what to tell you otherwise.12:08So he calls me up and he tells me this is the story.12:11I usually sell the chametz for my12:13parents every single year, and this year I completely forgot about it12:15and just remembered this morning. And this is12:17Erev Pesach already. So, okay, you got a few minutes. He's like,12:19Okay, I know. So what12:21can I do? I said, There's nothing to do.12:23You have to get rid of the12:25chametz. You're not allowed to have chametz in your house.12:27It's an issur of12:28bal yera'eh u'bal yimatzei. It's an issur lav. Although it's not12:31chayav karet, but still it's12:33an issur lav. It's an issur12:35lo ta'aseh. You cannot have chametz in your house. You got to get rid of it.12:37So he tells me, I want12:39to get rid of it, but it's not my chametz. It's my parents'12:41chametz, and they don't care. They're not religious. They don't care.12:42They're keeping the chametz. I said,12:45Hold on. Let's see, is it12:47really chametz? It's not chametz. You know, before we12:49jump the gun, a lot of times people12:50think everything is chametz. So I said, What do you have12:53in the house? He tells me, Okay, we got some12:54meats. Well, meat is not chametz. Just because it's not12:56kosher l'Pesach doesn't mean it's12:58chametz. Vegetables—vegetables are also not13:00chametz. So then he tells me, No, no, but we got some pizza,13:03some pizza dough.13:04We got also some13:07borekas. We got some this, and13:09names a whole list, which is13:11100% pure13:13chametz. There's nothing to talk about.13:15So I said, Okay, you have to explain to your13:17parents that it's forbidden to keep it by your house.13:19Calls me back a few minutes later,13:21half an hour later. They don't want13:23to hear it. They don't care. They don't want to get13:25rid of the chametz. What do I do? I'm getting very nervous.13:27You know, it's issur. I know it's a13:29big issur, but I can't convince13:31my parents otherwise. So after a whole13:33back and forth, what could you do?13:34I told them, Listen, at the end of the day, it's their13:37chametz, not your chametz. You're only13:38living by your parents. It's not your13:40chametz. What you have to do is take a good look.13:43At the chametz that you have in your house,13:45whether it's in your freezer or in your closet,13:46and just make sure that you do13:49not eat from that chametz or benefit from13:51it after the holiday. They're not going to eat13:52on the holiday. These, his parents13:55know better than to eat chametz on Pesach,13:57Baruch Hashem, but they don't want to13:59get rid of their chametz. They feel14:00they don't want to get14:02rid of it. It's two, three hundred dollars. They don't want to get rid of it. They're keeping it there.14:04They're not using it, so they don't understand14:06the importance of getting rid of14:08chametz. They don't understand this halacha. So14:10what could you do? The only thing you could do is,14:12you yourself, who do understand the halacha,14:15you are not allowed to have any14:16benefit from that chametz. Keep in mind14:18which of the stuff is right now14:20in your house before Pesach. After14:22Pesach, make sure you don't eat from that stuff. If there's14:24no dinner, come, I'll give you dinner or I'll14:26pay for your dinner, or you go out and you eat something14:28from a restaurant. Do not eat from14:30that chametz. That is the halacha.14:32Now, that's a very far-out story.14:35It's a unique14:36story. I never got such a question in my life14:39like this. Is it14:41possible? It's possible. First of all,14:42if you know people who14:44are like that, you got to be careful when to eat by their14:46house. You have to wait a few times. But really, the14:48bigger problem14:50is really in the supermarkets,14:53because there are a lot of14:54Jews out there. At least these parents knew14:56what Pesach is all about. There are a lot of14:58Jews that don't know what Pesach is all about, but it doesn't take15:00them out of the category of being Jewish.15:02Although they might be mechalel Shabbat15:06b'farhesya, they do not keep any of the15:08mitzvot. They don't put on tefillin. They might15:10even be married to a goya.15:12Perhaps they're intermarried as well. But as long as they're15:14Jewish and they are the owners15:16of a store that sells15:18chametz, so therefore the15:20chametz that they had is forbidden15:22after Pesach unless they sold it.15:24Now, if you have any suspicion15:26of any store15:28that is owned by a Jew15:30who does not sell his15:32chametz, so then you have to know what to do.15:34What are we to do?15:36So the answer is as follows.15:39If it's a supermarket.15:40And it goes, let me just pull it up.15:43Okay, I'm reading to you15:44from the15:46Star-K. If it's a supermarket,15:48and it's one of a bigger supermarket where things15:50move, so according to the15:52Star-K, they hold, they say in their pamphlet,15:54that a person should wait two weeks15:56after Pesach from buying from that specific supermarket. So...16:00Let's say, you know, I'm completely making up a name right here. You know, let's say16:04it's—I don't want to make a name. I don't want people to think that,16:07you know, maybe it's some store out there. I'm not even going to make up a name.16:09But let's say it's, you have a supermarket in your neighborhood.16:12You know that's owned by a Jew, and you know that the Jew does not sell his16:15chametz. You want to buy from that supermarket anything that's chametz. You could buy anything,16:19but chametz products such as breads or whatever it is,16:22other things that, you know, that are for sure chametz that you had,16:26you have to wait at least two16:27weeks. So this way you know that it moved, that this way the old chametz already came out.16:34What if maybe there's still some16:37leftover? In bigger supermarkets, you don't have to worry about it.16:39If there was, it's probably16:41batel b'rov. Two weeks, you're safe after Pesach to wait.16:45There's another issue also regarding16:49chametz she'avar alav haPesach, and that is distributors.16:50A lot of distributors, meaning there's a lot of stores that will buy16:53chametz not directly from the company. They're not buying directly from Kellogg's.16:56They're not buying directly from the big names, Coca-Cola and all these people.17:02They're buying it from distributors.17:04These are individuals who go to the big companies and they buy a certain amount,17:09and then for a little bit more price they come and they sell to the smaller stores.17:13So these distributors, a lot of them are Jewish,17:16and unfortunately some of them do not sell17:19their chametz, and they own it throughout Pesach.17:21So that's chametz she'avar alav haPesach also,17:23and it's in his warehouse. He has access. It's his.17:26So in that case, if there are supermarkets are buying from distributors that are Jewish,17:33that means even if the supermarket is owned by a goy, it's owned by a17:37non-Jew, but they're buying from distributors that are Jewish, but they do not sell their17:42chametz, over there a person should wait at least a month,17:44four weeks after Pesach, around May 21st,17:49until he could safely buy the chametz from that store.17:52Now, this is only regarding supermarkets.17:56If it's liquor, liquors don't move that much.17:58By the way, we're talking about big liquor stores.18:00In big liquor stores that move merchandise,18:02in whiskey, it's pure18:04chametz. There's even vodka can be18:06chametz. There's a lot of things that can be 100%18:09chametz. So therefore, when it comes to liquors, one should wait a little bit more.18:13Wait till after Shavuot from buying liquors from stores18:15that are either owned by Jews that do not sell the18:19chametz, or even they're owned by goyim,18:22but they purchase from distributors that are Jewish who do not sell the18:28chametz. This is what you have to know regarding these big supermarkets.18:32Otherwise, you have your local shops18:34over here in Brooklyn or in Monsey or in Lakewood,18:37where you have these regular small stores18:39that are not big chains, they're not big supermarkets,18:42and most of them probably have18:44a hechsher. Most of them are probably owned by ehrliche Yidden, good Jews,18:49and even though they're some simple Jews,18:52still most of them pretty much sell18:54their chametz. If you're not sure if the store has a18:57hechsher, most probably they sold the18:58chametz. But if you're not confident in restaurants or other places,19:02you don't trust it so much,19:03so go to the Rav Hamachshir, call them up.19:05Every store that has a hechsher must provide you with the number of the Rav19:10Hamachshir. Call them up and find out,19:11Excuse me, is your—this place that's under your19:14hashgacha, did you sell their chametz or not?19:16And you'll find out from them exactly.19:18Sometimes, although a place may have a19:20hechsher, they may only have a hechsher on a specific part of the store.19:23They don't have a hechsher on anything else.19:25L'maaseh, some places have a hechsher only on the meat,19:28and the Rav Hamachshir only takes care of the meat.19:30He has nothing to do with the rest of the store.19:32So you have to find out if the hechsher is on the store or on the Rav19:36Hamachshir. But that's again, if you suspect that the person did not sell his19:39chametz, if there's any reason to suspect him.19:40But if you know the guy's a good guy19:41and you could trust him when you ask him directly,19:43if he tells you, I sold my19:46chametz, you could go ahead and trust.19:47If you don't trust him, then you'll have to do a little bit more research.19:50Now, there is the big chain stores,19:53the big stores that people buy from,19:56and there's always questions:19:57can we buy from them? How long do we have to wait?19:59So the Star-K also came out with a list of big national stores.20:03These are stores throughout the country,20:05very big, and everybody buys from them either online or directly.20:08And they said that from this list guaranteed you could buy from them,20:12either they're owned by non-Jews. Or even their owned by Jews,20:18they sold it according to20:20halacha. Now, I want to point out,20:22this list is not limited to the names.20:24I'm about to tell you the list of20:25here, but it's not limited to these names only.20:27You can have many other stores.20:28This is just a small list that the Sakei came up with.20:32There could be many other stores,20:33but some of them are the most famous ones.20:35Here we go. Let's go through the list very quickly.20:37These are the stores that you can buy from them20:40chametz right after Pesach.20:42You have no problem worrying about20:44chametz she'avar alav haPesach. What are they? BJ's, Costco, Kmart, Petco, Rite Aid,20:49Sam's Discount Warehouse, Save-A-Lot, Walmart, Wegmans,20:54Winn-Dixie, Walgreens, Trader Joe's,20:57Shoppers Food Warehouse, Royal Farms, PetSmart,21:00Mars Food Lion, and CVS.21:02Again, it's not limited to this list.21:04This is just the research of the21:06Sakei. It could include many other stores,21:08but for these stores, for sure you don't have to worry about.21:11You can buy from them without a problem. Okay.21:14The good news from all of this,21:16I'll tell you one thing, is that21:18you don't have to worry about kemach yashan.21:19I'm not going to go into the halachot of kemach yashan21:21because the time doesn't allow us.21:24But regarding the din of kemach yashan,21:28right now whatever is available in the market21:30has no issues of kemach yashan.21:32Everything is considered kemach yashan21:34from now until at least July.21:37Everything is b'chezkat kemach yashan,21:40and you don't have to even ask about it.21:43Everything is fine to eat as far as flour.21:47Let's go to the next21:48halachot. The next category of halachot that happened21:51after the holiday of Pesach21:53is that, if you noticed, if you were in shul,21:56and even if you were not in shul,21:57hopefully you got news of it by now,21:59that we made a change in our tefillah.22:02We made one change in the tefillot22:04on the holiday of Yom Tov,22:06and then once we got to22:08Chol Hamoed, we made a second change.22:09What is that change?22:10We switched from the winter amidah22:15to the summer amidah.22:17We have basically one small difference22:20between the amidah that we say in the summer22:23than to the one that we say in the winter.22:24In the summer, Which began on the first day of Pesach,22:28we switch from22:32Mashiv haruach umorid hageshem, and we start saying22:34Morid hatal. That's in the second blessing of the Amidah.22:37Over there, we22:38mention—this is called a22:40hazkarah—we mention over there that God brings rain22:43and God brings dew.22:45Ashkenazim don't mention22:47Morid hatal. Ashkenazim just mention in the winter22:49that God brings rain,22:51but they don't mention anything about tal.22:53Let's just go, they continue.22:55The custom, the minhag of the22:58Sefardim is that we do mention22:59Morid hatal, Hashem brings the dew down as well.23:01That is23:02hazkarah. The second difference,23:04the second switch that we did,23:05and that started in23:08Chol Hamoed, is that we stopped asking for rain.23:12Remember, in the beginning of23:13the Amidah, we're only mentioning that God brings rain.23:15Over here now,23:18we stopped asking for rain23:20in the summer23:22tefilot. What is that?23:23For the23:24Sefardim, we switched from Barech Aleinu,23:26which is the longer blessing,23:29to the shorter blessing in the summer23:30called23:33Barecheinu. The Ashkenazim have the same blessing;23:36they just omitted a few words.23:37What are those words?23:42Veten tal umatar livrachah. In the ninth berachah of the Amidah,23:43we ask Hashem to give us rain in the winter.23:46And the Ashkenazim say23:49Veten tal umatar livrachah, very, very short.23:50By us, we have a whole long prayer,23:51but the same idea:23:52we ask for rain.23:54Now in the summer,23:55we don't ask for rain.23:56How come?23:57Rain in the summer is not good23:59because now—24:00It's not meant for rain. The rain already fell in the winter, and therefore we want the weather to be nicer now. It's a little bit better now.24:06As you see, you know, it's still cold, so maybe somebody's still making a mistake out there.24:11Make sure you say the proper things.24:13If one forgets to say it, he must go back and repeat Amidah. Why?24:17Because the Gemara says, and that's halacha as well,24:19that a person who mentions rain in the summer, it's considered24:25siman kelalah. It's not the season for it.24:26So therefore, this is considered that you did not pray the proper tefillah, and you must repeat the Amidah.24:34This is halacha if a person mentions morid hageshem, if he mentions that God brings the rain,24:41or kal vachomer if he asks for the rain.24:44Even mentioning that God brings the rain considers the Amidah invalid, and we have to repeat it.24:50Kal vachomer if one requests v'ten tal u'matar, he has to also repeat the Amidah.24:56Now what happens if a person is praying Amidah and he's not sure if he said25:02morid hatal, he's not sure if he mentioned25:05mashiv haruach u'morid hageshem, he's not sure if he asked for rain or even mentioned rain.25:08So the halacha says that we go by the hergel lashon.25:13What does it mean, hergel lashon?25:14It means that what he's used to saying.25:17We say, the Yerushalmi brings down, that in the first 30 days after the switch,25:23which means until Pesach Sheni. Pesach Sheni is on25:28Yud-Daled Iyar, the day after, so about 30, that's almost exactly 30 days.25:31If a person is not sure. That means any time between he finishes the Amidah25:36and he says, you know, I don't remember, did I say25:40Mashiv Haruach U'morid Hageshem or did I not? Did I skip it?25:41I think I asked for rain. I'm not sure. Maybe I did, maybe I didn't.25:44If you're not sure, you're mesupak,25:46the halacha is you must repeat the Amidah if you're within the first 30 days.25:51Why? Because most probably you just said what you're used to,25:55what you're accustomed to, and therefore you have to repeat it.25:58If, however, your safek came after 30 days,26:03you're not sure if you mentioned the wrong prayer,26:06you're not sure if you said26:08Mashiv Haruach U'morid Hageshem after 30 days, then the halacha says26:11that since it's after 30 days already,26:13you got used to saying Mashiv Haruach, you got used to skipping26:17Mashiv Haruach U'morid Hageshem, you got used to skipping V'ten Tal26:19U'Matar, and therefore you do not have to repeat the Amidah.26:21That is the halacha regarding26:25Mashiv Haruach U'morid Hageshem if a person is in26:26safek. Therefore, one of the great Rishonim,26:29who was the rabbi of the Rabbeinu Asher, the Rosh,26:33the rabbi of Rabbeinu Asher, who is known as the Maharam26:36of Rottenberg, came up with a genius idea. He says,26:38listen, if the whole thing is about getting your mouth used to it,26:42so therefore, very simple. You know what you do?26:44Just say26:45the beginning of the26:55bracha, Atah gibor l'olam Adonai, mechayeh meitim atah, rav lehoshia, morid hatal, if it's Sefardi, and if you're Ashkenazi, say rav lehoshia, mechayeh hachayim b'chesed. Skip Mashiv Haruach U'morid Hageshem. Say that 90 times. Around 90 times.26:58Why? 30 days, an average of three prayer per day,27:02so if you say it 90 times,27:04very good, you are already considered that you've said it, you're already considered that you're used to it,27:11and you don't have to worry about27:13a safek. If you come to doubt, even within the first 30 days,27:16you could continue with the Amidah, you don't have to repeat it27:18because you know that. Listen,27:20you probably repeated what you're used to,27:22and you're used to, you already trained yourself within these 30 days.27:26You said it 90 times, you're good enough.27:27The Hatam Sofer says say it 101 times.27:29Okay, it doesn't hurt a few more times,27:3190, 101 times, it's not a big deal.27:32But basically the idea is you got to get your mouth used to saying the Amidah27:37or that part of the Amidah27:40without the27:42Mashiv haruach umorid hageshem. Make sure you don't say the blessing.27:44You don't say Baruch Atah Hashem,27:46mechayeh hameitim. You just say, all you have to do is27:47make sure that you're saying Rab27:50lehoshia. If you Sefardi, you say27:53Morid hatal, mechayeh hameitim bachesed. And if you're Ashkenazi, you say Rab27:55lehoshia, and just go straight to27:57mechayeh hameitim bachesed. And this way you train yourself27:59and you save yourself28:01in case you're not sure,28:02you know that already I trained myself already28:04and I don't have to repeat the Amidah.28:06That is the suggestion28:08that's quoted by the28:10Maram Rothenburg, and Maran28:11Shulchan Aruch is posek halacha that way.28:13In28:17siman קי״ד, סעיף ט׳, Maran brings the28:19Maram Rothenburg that goes with that28:21psak halacha, that if you train yourself,28:23that's also good enough28:24if you say it 90 times.28:26Those are the dinim that we have to know28:28regarding Morid hatal and28:30Barechenu. However, when one does make a mistake,28:34for sure you know that you made a mistake,28:35or in the case where you do have to repeat the Amidah,28:38so we have to know a little bit of details,28:40and that is, let's give you a little bit of background.28:41The Amidah is basically divided into three parts,28:43although we call it Shemoneh Esrei,28:45the Amidah,28:46it really has more than 18 blessings.28:48It has 19 blessings.28:49Like we mentioned at the beginning of the class,28:50there was an additional28:52beracha that was added to the Amidah28:54in order to counter the Mosrim,28:58the people who informed,28:59the informers amongst the Jewish people,29:00the people who tattled tale on the Jewish people.29:03It was added, so made it to29:0519 berachot. But still, nonetheless, the name never got lost from the Amidah.29:08It's called the Shemoneh Esrei,29:09or Shemoneh Esrei according to the Ashkenazim.29:12So there are three parts29:14to the Amidah.29:16What are these three parts?29:17The first part of the Amidah are the first three blessings,29:21which is from the beginning of the Amidah29:23until the conclusion of29:25Atah Kadosh, Baruch Atah Hashem,29:27HaKel HaKadosh.29:28That's the first part of the Amidah.29:29The second part of the Amidah begins from29:31Atah29:34Chonen until29:36Shomea Tefillah, the end of the berachah of29:38Shomea Tefillah, Baruch Atah Hashem,29:40Shomea Tefillah. The third part of the Amidah29:41is from Retzeh,29:45which is the last three blessings29:48until the end of the Amidah.29:49Why am I telling you these three categories,29:51these three parts of the Amidah?29:53Because halachah makes a big difference29:54where a person made a mistake.29:56These three parts of the Amidah29:58are all separate parts,30:00meaning if a person makes a mistake30:02in any part, you go back to that part.30:05In the first three30:07berachot, if a person makes a30:08mistake in any of these three30:10berachot, it's not good enough to go back30:12to that specific berachah and fix yourself.30:15For example,30:16let's take over here what we're talking about30:18in Mashiv Haruach U'Morid HaGeshem.30:19By mistake, a person in the summer said Mashiv Haruach U'Morid HaGeshem.30:22He cannot just go back to the second30:24berachah, Atah Gibor30:26Le'olam Adonai, and begin from there30:28to say the30:30berachah. If he made a mistake30:33after he finished30:34HaKel HaKadosh and he remembered,30:35Oh, I made a mistake in the second blessing of the Amidah,30:38you must go back to the beginning of the Amidah.30:40Why?30:41Because once you pass30:44HaKel HaKadosh, you already finished one part of the Amidah.30:46It's all one category;30:48they all come in one package.30:49It's a one-package deal.30:50And therefore, any mistake30:53in one of the first three blessings of the Amidah,30:56you must repeat the whole package.30:58You must go back to the beginning of the Amidah.31:00In the middle, in the second part of the Amidah,31:03which is the berachot of Atah31:06Chonen, of31:08Barech Aleinu, Barecheinu, whatever it may be,31:10all these blessings are, in this case,31:12they're not considered one group.31:14Although it's a second category of the Amidah,31:16rather, each blessing by itself,31:18it's fine if you31:21go back to just the31:22moment where you made the mistake.31:23Meaning, if a person in31:25Barech Aleinu made a mistake,31:27he said Barech Aleinu, he said he asked for rain,31:30and then afterwards he gets up to31:32Retzei and he realizes,31:34whoa, you know, by mistake I said the prayer31:36that's supposed to be said in the winter.31:38I said it now in the summer.31:39I'm supposed to go back.31:40Where do you go back to?31:41You can just go back to that blessing,31:45Barecheinu, or Barech Aleinu. You don't have to actually go back to Atah31:48Chonen. In that case, the halacha says31:49that each blessing is by itself;31:51they're not connected to each other.31:52It's not one package.31:53And you can go back just to that blessing31:56and go continue from then onwards. You can't just fix yourself and say—32:00Baruchenu, and then jump back to Retzeh.32:03You must start from Baruchenu and continue in the same order of the Amidah,32:07and that will be the same thing.32:09We come now to the last category of the Amidah in Retzeh.32:12It's also considered like the first part of the Amidah;32:14it's all one package.32:15Therefore, if a person makes a mistake in any of the last three berachot of the Amidah,32:20which he is obligated to go back to,32:23he must go back to the whole category.32:25Lemashal, let's say a person forgot to say32:27Ya'aleh Veyavo. Ya'aleh Veyavo is said in the berachah of Retzeh.32:31In that case, if a person remembers32:34in Sim Shalom,32:35Oh, I forgot to say32:36Ya'aleh Veyavo, then you go back to the beginning of that blessing, to Retzeh,32:40and you continue from then onwards.32:42Okay, that's important to keep in mind if a person makes a mistake.32:45If a person makes a mistake within the same32:47berachah, he could just fix yourself,32:49start just from that32:50berachah, and continue.32:51Meaning, in the second blessing of the Amidah,32:53if a person said32:54Mashiv haruach u'morid hageshem, and then right before saying32:57Baruch Atah Hashem, mechayeh hameitim, he remembers,32:58Oh, I made a mistake,32:59then you just go back to the beginning of that blessing.33:01You don't have to go back to the beginning of the Amidah.33:02You just go back to33:04Atah Gibor and continue from then onwards.33:05Same thing, if a person said33:07Baruch aleinu, and before he concluded the blessing,33:09he said,33:10Oh wow, I asked for rain,33:12so go back to the beginning of that blessing33:15and repeat it in the right way without asking for rain.33:19Those are the halachot that we need to know33:21regarding Morid Hatal and33:23Baruchenu. If you have any questions,33:23you could text it in to the number over here at the station33:27to text in, we forgot to say,33:28is33:32347-927-8398. And if you would like to call in,33:34although we prefer that you call at the end of the show,33:37the end of the halachah hour,33:38and that's at 333:40o'clock, the number is33:43718-683-5858. Again, the number to text in is33:48347-927-8398. And if you'd like to call in with your questions,33:51preferably after 333:52o'clock, the number to the studio is33:56718-683-5858. To listen to us,33:57you can listen on33:59JRootRadio.com, that's with two O's, not34:05O-U-T-E, J-R-O-O-T Radio.com. And you can also listen on the JRoot app Pro.34:09You can get it on your smartphone,34:10either Android or iPhone.34:12And to listen live on the phone,34:14you can call in 718-506. 9099.34:18Again,34:22718-506-9099. Let's come back, continue in our34:25halachot. Other things that we have to know right now after34:28Pesach is that because this Pesach season,34:32I don't know what you want to call it,34:32this Nissan, this month of34:34Nissan, has not been the warmest.34:35Even though we had a double Adar,34:38we had a leap year,34:39and technically it should have been very, very warm34:41in the month of34:42Nissan, which would have made the trees already start to grow34:45and would have made it much easier to say34:47birchat ilanot. The reality is that it wasn't.34:49It was actually pretty cold,34:51colder than usual.34:52We barely hit some warm temperatures,34:55and therefore a lot of people did not say34:58birchat ilanot, and therefore we're just reminding everybody.35:00We already spoke about the35:01halachot of birchat ilanot, that according to the35:05Chida, the Ben35:06Ish Chai, Rav Chaim Palachi,35:07the35:09Kaf HaChaim. Sofer,35:10all of them hold that you should say it specifically in35:13Nissan. Even the Chacham Badian Mishnah Berurah say that really you could say35:16birchat ilanot even after the month of35:18Nissan, but35:19lechatchila a person should try to push himself35:20to do according to the35:22Magen Avraham poskim, like the Or Letzion brings down.35:24Let's say a lot of the Acharonim held that you could only say it in35:27Nissan, so therefore35:28try to push yourself to go say35:30birchat ilanot and try to find basically two trees,35:33preferably,35:35that are supposed to be fruit trees35:36that already started to bud,35:38started to35:40sprout. And if you want,35:41where I said35:42birchat ilanot, and over there we checked that35:43it's fine already,35:44you can say bracha over there35:45on East 9th in Brooklyn35:47between Avenue R and S.35:48There's a little side street called First Court.35:51In that corner35:52there's trees,35:52and the blessing is on the tree.35:54If35:55you're Sefardi, a lot of Sefardim get very nervous35:57because the35:59birchat ilanot, if you open it up,35:59it's like a whole big seven pages.36:03Birchat ilanot, rabotai, is one blessing.36:04It's one short blessing.36:05That's all it is.36:06It's one simple blessing,36:08and that's all you need to say.36:10If you want,36:11if you're in a rush,36:11go to the tree.36:13Once you see the tree,36:15say the blessing,36:15then all the36:16yehi ratzons and the petichat Eliyahu36:18and the tefillot that you want to say,36:20you can say them afterwards.36:20You can even say it in the house.36:21You don't have to say it next to the tree.36:23You can go home and say it.36:24The36:25birachah, you have to say next to the tree36:25once you see it.36:26But otherwise,36:28you could say the36:29yehi ratzons any way you want,36:30from inside the car,36:31inside the house.36:32It doesn't make a difference.36:33Even if you don't say it,36:34it's all minhag anyway.36:35But the blessing,36:36one is obligated to say the blessing,36:38and36:38lechatchila try to say it now36:40within the month of36:42Nissan. The next thing we're going to speak about,36:44the next category of halachot36:45that we need to learn after Pesach,36:47is the birachah on matzah after Pesach.36:51This is a big subject.36:53It's a very important subject,36:55and although36:56it really has—36:57to really understand it36:59and to really go into it properly,37:01we'll have to spend a whole class on it.37:03We'll just tell you very, very quickly37:05what the halachah should be.37:09Shulchan Aruch brings down37:12in the Beit37:13Yosef—actually, not the Shulchan Aruch,37:14let's start from the Beit37:16Yosef—there is something known in the Gemara37:19as pat37:21haba b'kisnin. The Gemara establishes37:23that this thing called pat37:26haba b'kisnin is37:27mezonot, not like regular bread,37:29which is37:31hamotzi, and the37:32bracha acharona would be37:33birkat hamazon. Pat37:35haba b'kisnin has the blessing of37:36mezonot, and the after blessing37:38will be the blessing of37:41al hamichya. Now, what is pat37:42haba b'kisnin? The Gemara doesn't tell us37:43what pat haba b'kisnin is.37:45To that, we have37:46basically three different opinions37:48in the Rishonim.37:49Some Rishonim explain37:50that pat haba b'kisnin means37:53anything that is crunchy,37:57like37:58koses. Koses is when a37:59person eats something raw.38:01A person is38:04koses et ha'orez. Orez, rice, usually38:05cooked, is very mushy,38:06but when you eat it38:07raw, it's very crunchy.38:08So some explain38:10that pat haba b'kisnin means38:11I took regular dough,38:12flour and water,38:13and I baked it to the point38:15that it became crunchy.38:15From the beginning,38:16I wanted it to be crunchy.38:17It's not that I forgot in the38:18oven; I wanted it to be crunchy.38:20That38:23makes the dough now38:26turn from hamotzi to mezonot.38:29It was dough;38:30I baked it.38:31If I would have baked it to be soft,38:33it would have been hamotzi.38:34Now that I baked it to be crunchy,38:37it turns into mezonot.38:39That's one opinion38:40of the definition of pat38:42haba b'kisnin. There are two other opinions.38:43The other two opinions,38:44one says38:45that's got to be like a38:46kis, like a pocket,38:47and the other opinion says38:48it's basically something38:50that has additives38:51in the mixture of making the dough.38:53You put juices in there,38:55you put honey,38:56you put sweets38:56to the point that you could taste it,38:57or according to the Ashkenazim,38:58that you added so much39:01that the majority,39:02it's more than the water.39:03We're not going to focus39:04on the second two opinions.39:05We want to focus now39:05on the first opinion.39:07The first opinion tells us39:08that if I took something that's crunchy,39:09I took dough,39:11flour and water,39:11regular flour and39:12water, no other additives,39:13and I baked it to the point39:14that it's going to be crunchy,39:16then39:17the blessing should be mezonot.39:19Beautiful.39:20The question is,39:21why in the world39:21are we making hamotzi on that39:23when it comes to39:25Pesach, right?39:25It's crunchy.39:26Why are we making hamotzi?39:27And the answer is because39:29we have another sevara, another idea39:31that's brought down.39:32Why is it39:33that we make all of a sudden39:35on these three types of things39:36mezonot?39:37Why did the Gemara establish39:38that pat haba b'kisnin should be mezonot?39:39What makes it different from bread?39:40Okay, so it has a little sweet,39:42so it's a little bit crunchy39:43or it's stuffed,39:44but who cares?39:45At the end of the day,39:46it's flour and water.39:47Why should it be different?39:49And the answer is because39:50usually people have that as a snack,39:52since they usually eat39:54crunchy things as a snack.39:55For example,39:56crackers.39:57Crackers people have usually as a snack.40:00It's regular flour and water, but it's crackers. At the end of the day, people don't eat it as a meal; they eat it as a snack.40:04So therefore, the halacha says that you should make mezonot on it because it's something that's made as a snack; it's not made as a meal.40:12So when it comes now to matzah, where it's, on Pesach we're talking about, where it's made for a meal, it's not because we have no other bread.40:21This is a poor man's bread, poor man's bread, and therefore we have no other bread. We have to eat lechem oni on Pesach,40:26so we have no other choice but this bread, and therefore the beracha is hamotzi. Makes a lot of sense why this is our bread. It's not made as a snack; it's made to be regular bread.40:35So the beracha of the matzot on Pesach, according to all opinions, Sefardi or Ashkenazi, should be and is hamotzi.40:43Fine. Question is, what about after Pesach? After Pesach, do I make the beracha of hamotzi on the matzah or not?40:50I have leftover matzah. When they bake, they clean; they bake it for the sake of having it on Pesach.40:54We're not talking about matzot that are sold throughout the year, which says, Do not eat on Pesach; these are40:59chametz. Very interesting, right? You have matzot that are chametz throughout the year.41:01That's made because a lot of people are very healthy and very whatever. We're not talking about these matzot.41:05We're talking about leftover from Pesach. What do I do in this case?41:07Should I make hamotzi because that's what they were made for,41:10or at the end of the day, right now I'm only having it as a snack; it's crunchy?41:14So this is very complicated.41:17The Ashkenazim's minhag is that they make hamotzi;41:20they wash on it, regular41:22netilat yadayim and hamotzi on the matzah.41:26Tell you, if a person really doesn't, to the halacha,41:29there's a lot of—not a lot—even according to Sefardim, technically you should make hamotzi,41:35but the minhag is not that way.41:37The minhag, the way the Acharonim bring it down,41:40the minhag is that Sefardim make mezonot on matzah.41:44Okay, that's the way Chacham Ovadia brings it down,41:45that's the way Chacham Ovadia brings it down.41:47The minhag is to make mezonot on matzah and not hamotzi.41:52So the question is, is that what we do?41:56Is that the minhag? Is that what we do,41:58lechatchila? Why do Acharonim bring it like that in such a way as a minhag?42:01The answer is because although that is a minhag, that's the way the Acharonim bring it down,42:05but it's not so simple.42:06Even Chacham Ovadia says, lechatchila, a person should try to avoid eating matzot as a42:14snack because really, especially in our days, matzah has turned into a regular meal.42:19The matzah is not made for a snack anymore.42:21Even if it's crunchy, it's made to become bread throughout the whole year.42:26Once upon a time, when they had bread and everybody was eating bread42:28and people didn't care about health and all these different things that we have today,42:31so people ate matzah as a snack only.42:33But today people are eating matzot as a42:35meal. So therefore, how can you tell me now it's still mezonot?42:38It's made as a meal.42:39So let's continue making hamotzi. Continue making hamotzi.42:43You can't go against the minhag.42:45That's what the sefarim bring down,42:46so we say mezonot.42:48But lechatchila, even those who say that the minhag is to say mezonot,42:51they'll tell you42:52lechatchila it's preferable that a person should have matzah42:57betoch seudah. That means wash on something else and then have matzah in the middle of the meal.43:01But to just have matzah to make43:03hamotzi—I mean, to make mezonot—matzah, it's not so simple.43:06If you do it, okay, you have what to rely on.43:07But lechatchila, try to say hamotzi on something else and then eat the matzah in the middle,43:12because the times have changed.43:14The matzot is not the way that it used to be,43:16and we're not talking about just in our days43:17already, from the times of the Chida already43:19this is brought as a discussion.43:22And I want to point out, if somebody does make mezonot,43:25sefaradim make mezonot on matzah, nothing to yell at him.43:28There is what to rely on.43:29But one who is stringent, tabo43:33alav berachah, to be yotzei according to all opinions.43:36This is only true regarding the hard matzah.43:40In the market today, Baruch Hashem, especially from Eretz Yisrael, and even here43:43by us in the Kollel, we in Keter Tzion,43:46we make soft matzah ourselves,43:48and that is basically, instead of the matzah the way we're used to,43:53whether it's machine or hand matzah, which is very crunchy,43:55this soft matzah is soft.43:59It's not a crunch.44:02That— Is hamotzi according to all opinions,44:05before, during Pesach, after Pesach, it makes no difference.44:08I remember we used to make the matzot in the matzah bakery.44:11We used to make our soft matzot.44:12Some people used to tag along.44:13Yeah, you need some help.44:14Not only the kollel guys could do it,44:15but you need to get help from other people.44:17And you'd see some of the people take a matzah,44:19you know, comes out fresh from the oven.44:21You have some of the matzot that turn44:23chametz. You know, we have the Rosh Kolel,44:26Tamir Hacham, sitting there checking every matzah,44:29and some of the matzot are not good,44:30so you cannot use it on Pesach.44:32So they're chametz, so he rips them off the matzah44:35and he puts them on the side.44:36So people come, they snack off of these matzot.44:39A lot of people would come and say,44:40Baruch Atah Hashem...44:42Why are you making44:44mezonot? And the answer is, yeah, because it's matzah.44:46It doesn't go by the name.44:47It goes by what the matzah is, how it's made.44:50You could call it matzah, you could call it bread,44:52call it whatever you want.44:53At the end of the day, this is soft.44:54There's nothing different between this and the pita.44:56The only thing is that this is chametz and this is not44:59chametz. If it's soft, there's no question, according to all opinions,45:03this is hamotzi, regardless when you eat it.45:06Soft matzah is hamotzi on Pesach.45:09Soft matzah is hamotzi before Pesach.45:11Soft matzah is hamotzi even after Pesach.45:13Soft matzah is hamotzi even if it's not made for Pesach.45:16Even if it's 100% chametz, it is hamotzi45:19because it's not crunchy.45:20It doesn't fit in any of the explanations of45:24pat haba'ah b'kisnin. I had to point this out because I've seen people stumble,45:27make a mistake in this area.45:29So with that, we'll go on now to,45:33with a few minutes left,45:34you have a few minutes left, to the minhagim on Omer.45:37Next week, b'ezrat Hashem, maybe we'll talk about—not maybe, b'ezrat Hashem, hopefully—we'll talk about the laws of Sefirat45:43HaOmer, of counting the Omer.45:44Today, we'll focus on just the minhagim.45:48During Sefirat45:53HaOmer. A little bit of a background.45:54Chazal tell us in the Gemara, B'livi Masechet Yevamot,45:58that Rabbi Akiva had 24,000 students.46:01These 24,000 students were not regular students.46:04These were not just, you know, a bunch of guys46:06that came to school and they started studying.46:08These students were great Tannaim.46:10These students were the leaders of the next generations.46:13These students were, to a certain extent,46:15greater than some of the famous Tannaim that we know,46:18because the Gemara tells us that Rabbi Akiva had 24,000 students,46:21and after they died,46:22he went down to the south of46:25Eretz Yisrael and he taught another five students.46:27Among these five students were46:29the smallest one, who is listed at the end of the list,46:31is Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, the author of the Zohar.46:36Also Rabbi Meir Baal HaNes, Rabbi Yehuda,46:39Rabbi Elai. These were the five students that Rabbi Akiva had,46:42and the Gemara tells us that46:45Rabbi Akiva only taught these five students46:47after the first 24,000 students passed away.46:49So we could safely say46:51that the original students were obviously much greater,46:53that Rabbi Akiva felt now,46:55you know, now only the first ones passed away,46:57he went on to the next students.46:58So we're talking about very, very holy people,47:00and it's not right to just go ahead and say,47:03Oh, they hated each other,47:06chas v'shalom. Chazal tell us,47:08lo nahagu kavod zeh bazeh, on their own level,47:09obviously they were much greater tzaddikim, and Chazal tell us47:12that47:14usbivav keh, the people who are closer to47:17HaKadosh Baruch Hu, Hashem judges them much stricter,47:22kehut haseערה, usbivavnessaערה meod. The people around them,47:24Hashem judges them very, very finely.47:26So therefore, being that they were the leaders47:28and they were going to transmit the Torah to the next generation,47:31especially these were students of47:33Rabbi Akiva, Hashem was much stricter with them,47:35and Chazal tell us that they all died.47:3724,000 students all died47:39from when?47:40From Pesach until Pros Atzeret.47:43From Pesach until half of Atzeret,47:46keep those words in mind. We're going to come back to them.47:48And therefore, in this period of time,47:50we all are mourning the loss of Rabbi Akiva's students.47:54I haven't seen it anywhere,47:56although I haven't seen otherwise.47:58I don't know if the 24th...48:00Thousand students died all in the same year, or they died in multiple years.48:05That means, was it that 24,000 students died in one year between Pesach and Shavuot,48:12or was it that, no, the students of Rabbi Akiva died between Pesach and Shavuot, but over a number of years?48:19All 24,000 happened to die just between Pesach and Shavuot, and they realized, oh, this is a special time that we have to mourn them.48:24I'm not sure, but there's room definitely to say either way.48:28In any case, this is the period when they died. This is when they died, and therefore we have minhagim of aveilut. We have customs of mourning.48:38The Arizal points out that this is a time of din. This is a time when we see that the produce grows very, very fast.48:46Everything starts to grow in the trees. You see right now, this is a time of growth and development,48:51and therefore whenever we have growth and development, the rule is that there's48:55midat ha-din. There's always a prosecution. Whenever a person is getting something good,49:00we have always the prosecution that comes to a person, and they come and they tell Hashem,49:07why does this person deserve it? And a person is judged a little bit more strictly in that time.49:11That's how the Arizal explains what happened in these times.49:14But in any case, 24,000 students died, and it was a big tragedy,49:19and therefore the Jewish people have accepted minhagim, customs of mourning.49:23The two main customs of mourning that are brought down in halacha are only two.49:28What are they? No weddings and no haircuts or shaving. That's all that's brought down.49:34No weddings, no haircuts and shaving.49:36There are other things that are brought down by the Acharonim, but in halacha and Shulchan Aruch,49:41what's brought down are only these two things.49:42We don't get married in these times, and we don't— Take a haircut or shave in these days.49:48What are these days?49:50We said between Pesach and49:53Shavuot. What does it mean, pros?49:54Pros from the word perusah. Perusah means half, or when you divide something.50:00Half of Atzeret means, really means a half of a month before Atzeret.50:04So based on that calculation, if we have 49 days of Sefirat HaOmer between Pesach and Shavuot,50:10if you subtract half a month from that, which you subtract 15 days from that,50:16you come to 34 days.50:19And therefore Maran Shulchan Aruch brings down in Siman50:24Taf Tzadik Gimel that we do not take haircuts from after50:29Pesach—anyway, not taking because of the Omer, I mean, excuse me, of50:33Chol HaMoed—we don't take haircuts from Pesach all the way until when?50:41Until Lamed Daled, the 34th of the50:44Omer. Not like the Omer, the 34th of the Omer. Why?50:46Because they died until the 34th of the50:49Omer. So why can we take haircuts on Lamed50:52Daled BaOmer? We should be not taking haircuts until Lamed50:55Hei BaOmer. And the answer is because we hold mikzat hayom50:59kekulo. If you see any mourners, you see that when they get up from51:03shiva, they don't sit seven full days.51:05The seventh day comes, we say mikzat hayom51:07kekulo. Once part of the day came in already, it's considered like the full day came in.51:11So that's51:12a minhag according to Sefardim. According to the Rama, he holds no.51:14They actually finished dying on the 33rd day.51:18The 34th day already nobody died anymore.51:20So therefore, mikzat hayom51:23kekulo. Once the 33rd day comes, already from the morning they could take haircuts.51:27So that's the difference between Ashkenazim and Sefardim, mainly.51:31According to the Sefardim, the— The issur of taking haircuts begins from Pesach51:37all the way until Lamed-Daled BaOmer,51:40and includes haircuts and shaving,51:42as well as weddings,51:44according to the Ashkenazim. No, until the Lag BaOmer in the morning,51:48that's when already we don't take—according to Ashkenazim,51:51they don't take haircuts until that day.51:53There are different customs as brought down51:56regarding Sefirat HaOmer, how to calculate it.51:59The Mishnah Berurah brings down a minhag that many Ashkenazim follow till today.52:03The minhag is that the way to explain this52:07Gemara—the Gemara says, pros a Atzeret, which means half of Atzeret.52:11We explained that means 15 days.52:12Some explain that these 15 days not necessarily came in order.52:15It doesn't mean 15 days like Lamed-Daled BaOmer.52:18What it means is that there were 15 days that the talmidim of Rabbi Akiva didn't die.52:24What are these 15 days?52:25Well, they didn't die on any day that we would not say52:29Tachanun, meaning to say the seven days of Pesach, the six Shabbatot, the two days of Rosh Chodesh52:35Iyar, the first day, also one day of Rosh Chodesh Sivan.52:39That totals up all these days, comes out to about 15, 16 days52:44which the talmidim of Rabbi Akiva didn't die.52:47So therefore, as long as you mourn for 33 days,52:52it doesn't make a difference when you mourn,52:53whether you start mourning right after Pesach,52:56whether you mourn right before Shavuot,52:58it doesn't make a difference.52:58As long as you mourn for 33 days,53:00then that's good enough already to fulfill this obligation of this minhag53:07of mourning for the talmidim of53:08Rabbi Akiva. So therefore, some Ashkenazim have the custom,53:10and right now they will take haircuts.53:11They'll take haircuts all the way until next week, Rosh Chodesh Iyar,53:14and then from Rosh Chodesh Iyar—53:18From then onwards, they will not take haircuts until the three days before Shavuot,53:23which is shloshet yemei hagbalah.53:25The halacha does bring down53:26you cannot be lenient like both opinions.53:28You can't take haircuts all the way into Rosh Chodesh Iyar53:30and then afterwards from Lag53:32BaOmer also take haircuts afterwards.53:33No.53:34Either you hold up to Lag53:36BaOmer, or,53:38l'Sefardim, Lamed-Daled BaOmer, or you hold from Rosh Chodesh Iyar all the way until Shavuot.53:43But even if you hold from Rosh Chodesh Iyar until Shavuot,53:47you could, according to the Ashkenazim,53:48you could take haircuts on53:51Lamed-Gimmel BaOmer because it's a special day.53:53It's a day of the petirah of53:56Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, according to some53:58also that's when they stopped dying.53:59So there's many opinions54:02and a lot of room to be lenient at that time.54:04That is the two different minhagim of how to calculate the54:08Omer. However, there's still the Arizal.54:10The Arizal holds, like we said54:12beforehand, it's54:13Sefirat haOmer, and being that it's54:16Sefirat haOmer, therefore one should not take a haircut54:19all the way from Pesach until Shavuot.54:22Those who follow the Arizal, the mekubalim especially,54:25don't take haircuts all the way until Erev Shavuot,54:28including54:30shloshet yemei hagbalah. Hacham Ben Zion explains that this is only applicable to the hair.54:34One who usually shaves his beard,54:35who usually cuts his beard, trims his beard,54:38for him you could still trim his beard even54:41after—excuse me—once after Lag BaOmer comes,54:44you could trim your beard.54:45The only reason the Arizal didn't mention the54:47beard is because according to the Arizal,54:48you're never even allowed to touch your54:49beard. Your beard is not supposed to cut it,54:52you're not supposed to touch it.54:53That's why he never mentioned it.54:54But those who have the custom anyway of trimming or shaving their beard,54:57they could trim it after55:00Lag BaOmer, that Lag BaOmer according to the55:04halacha, according to55:06Hacham Ben Zion. However, I'll tell you the truth.55:08Even though that's what the Arizal,55:09the Chacham Tzion does bring down,55:11I see many gedolim.55:13I don't know if they did it on purpose or not,55:15but they keep their beard also going.55:16They keep it anyway they have a beard.55:20So maybe they're just keeping it anyway to take a haircut55:22and not shaving until55:25Aseres Yemei Teshuvah. Maybe, yeah, maybe not. I'm not sure.55:27But Chacham Tzion, Ben Tzion says what he says.55:29I haven't seen anybody who says otherwise.55:32Next, there are some leniencies regarding hair cutting and weddings as well.55:39First of all, regarding women.55:42Could women take a haircut during Sefirat55:44HaOmer? The answer is depends.55:47If you're55:48Sefardi, if you're Sefardi, there's no question that you could take a haircut.55:51A lady could take a haircut in Sefirat55:54HaOmer. Why?55:55Because Maran brings down an55:57aveilut that,55:57lo aleinu, a woman who is sitting, who is mourning,55:59who's sitting shivah.56:01She cannot have a woman who's saying sheva, she cannot take a haircut during the seven days of mourning.56:09After the seven days of mourning, a woman could take haircuts.56:12The Rama over there is stringent. The Rama says no.56:15The minhag of the Ashkenazim, that for the first 30 days of mourning, they don't take haircuts.56:20That's according to the56:22Rama. Over here, so according to Sefardim, there's no question.56:26This is Sefirat HaOmer is not going to be more stringent than the56:30shloshim. So therefore, there's no question, a woman could take haircuts according to the56:33Sefardim. According to the Ashkenazim, HaChacham Ben Tzion wants to say that even according to the Rama, it should be mutar.56:37But that's not the way the Ashkenazim bring it down.56:40The Gra Moshe says that no,56:42Ashkenazi women should not take haircuts unless it's necessary.56:45What's called necessary?56:47Well, for sure if she has to go to the mikveh, there's no question she could take a haircut.56:52And whatever she feels is very, very necessary,56:56an Ashkenazi woman, let's say it's a56:59simchan, there's a57:00kavod chatan, if there's a brit milah57:01also, even all Ashkenazim will agree.57:02Even men,57:03even men,57:04if there's a brit milah, the father of the baby boy, the sandak, as well as the mohel could take haircuts, and shave as well.57:11And women, I guess if it's very necessary for them to take haircuts, even though they're supposed to be covered, I don't know.57:15But we're talking about obviously girls that are single,57:18if they want to take haircuts,57:20the Ashkenazia, if they feel it's necessary, they could also take it in this time.57:23What about children?57:25Again, same thing,57:26Sefardim, children could take haircuts.57:28There's no problem.57:29The Ashkenazim are machmir on children,57:31but everybody will agree that children under the age of three,57:34especially the ones who do it for the upshering and lag baOmer, and even beforehand they go to the Ariza, there's no question,57:40according to all opinions,57:42they could take haircuts in these times.57:43We mentioned no weddings,57:46but it is mutar, and it's a mitzvah for a person who's single to date, to go on57:52shidduchim, and even to make an engagement,57:54not a party, but an engagement.57:56What does it mean, engagement?57:57Engagement means an agreement to get married.57:59And even if you invite what they call today a l'chaim, meaning of the family,58:03that's also permitted during the days of Sefirat HaOmer.58:07And another leniency is that people mix up,58:11a lot of times, the days of the Omer, they mix it up with the days of bein hametzarim.58:18And therefore, we get a lot of questions:58:20Are you allowed to buy clothing?58:21Are you allowed to buy new clothing?58:24There is an opinion of Rav Chaim Palachi and some Acharonim bring him down,58:29not to say Shehecheyanu on days of the58:30Omer. But really, me'ikar hadin, Hacham Ben Sion, as well as Hacham Ovadia, both agree58:34you could say Shehecheyanu during Sefirat HaOmer.58:38If you want to be a little bit more stringent, then you can say Shehecheyanu on Shabbatot.58:44If you want to save something for Shabbat, to say Shehecheyanu, there's no problem to say58:47Shehecheyanu. Even Mishnah Berurah brings down you can say58:48Shehecheyanu, even Ashkenazim can say Shehecheyanu during Sefirat HaOmer.58:51If you want to be machmir like some of these Acharonim, so save it for Shabbat, that's for sure,58:55then you could say Shehecheyanu then.58:57So therefore, if you have a new clothing, the only safek maybe that you'll have is59:00that if such a chashuv new item, that you might have to say Shehecheyanu on it.59:04But if it's a clothing that you don't necessarily say Shehecheyanu on it, do you say Shehecheyanu on a new shirt?59:08Not necessarily.59:09Maybe some people say on a suit.59:11Personally, I don't say Shehecheyanu even on a suit.59:13I don't know,59:13maybe I'm not such an excited person about suits.59:16If you are a person who gets very excited when you buy something very important59:19and you say59:21Shehecheyanu, so even then you're allowed to buy it.59:23To wear it, to say Shehecheyanu, maybe wear it only the first time on Shabbat, say59:28Shehecheyanu, that's it.59:29In any case, that's the din of buying new clothing59:33during the days of the Omer, there is no problem.59:35The subject I haven't discussed, and that's everybody's waiting for, is music,59:40right? What about music?59:41First of all, as a side point, dancing even without music is assur during59:46Sefirat HaOmer. Okay, during the days of the Omer, we don't have weddings.59:49We don't have also dancing is also brought down.59:51Regarding music, it's a big subject,59:54but the minhag amongst all the Jewish people, even those who are lenient to listen to music throughout the year,1:00:01on the days, during the days of Sefirat HaOmer, the minhag is people don't listen to music in these days.1:00:06I mean, the radio is playing music.1:00:08There are exceptions.1:00:10There are times where people could listen to music,1:00:14and what type of music, it's also very technical.1:00:16I'm running out of time.1:00:17I'm not going to go into it right now.1:00:19Maybe next week I'll discuss it just a little bit.1:00:21But in general, in general, if a person is very down, he's very depressed,1:00:26and he needs music as a medicine, that's mutar,1:00:30no problem to listen to music,1:00:32even during the Omer, even during the three weeks of Bein HaMetzarim, between Tisha B'Av and1:00:38Shiva Asar B'Tammuz. If a person needs it like a medicine, it's mutar.1:00:41But in general, a person should try to be machmir in general,1:00:45and in these days of the Omer, the minhag is not to listen to them.1:00:50Again, we're talking about regular average people who could do a little bit, a few weeks without1:00:55Omer as a sign of mourning for the students of Rabbi1:01:00Akiva. And this issur of not listening to music, you should know, is brought down by most of the1:01:04Acharonim: the Gra, Moshe, Chacham Ovadia, and Minchat Yitzchak, and of Aharon Epstein.1:01:09A lot of people bring this issur of listening to music.1:01:12What kind of music?1:01:13So there's a cappella and there's other things.1:01:15Some call it Sefira music.1:01:17Check with your local1:01:18rav. It's not a simple subject1:01:20to just say everything is mutar or everything is assur either.1:01:22So you have to know also the fact that the radio station plays music1:01:28during the days. Let's say during these days, happens to be during these days,1:01:31according to a lot of people, they didn't start this Sefirat HaOmer, meaning the minhagim of the Omer of mourning.1:01:39Like we said, some start on Rosh Chodesh Iyar,1:01:42and some finish right after1:01:44Lag BaOmer. So to play music on the radio... is mutar from our point of view.1:01:50But to listen, you have to know what your minhag is,1:01:53when do you hold1:01:54of it, and if you hear a song here and there, you know, it's not the, what's it called,1:01:58you have to try to be machmir if you don't need it.1:02:01If a person needs it, he can, you know, he really needs,1:02:04he's very down, he needs a little bit of a lift,1:02:06so then you could be meikil to listen to it.1:02:09But again, with COVID, keep in mind1:02:11these are days when we're all mourning for the loss of these great tzaddikim.