Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive.
Transcript
Welcome to Halacha Hour on Wednesday afternoons here at JRoot Radio. Let me give you the numbers before we begin. The numbers to the studio are 718-683-5858. To text in your questions, which probably today I don't have a technician, will probably be the best option. We'll take phone calls only in the end. To text in your questions, it's 347-927-8398. Again, the numbers are 718-683-5858. That's if you call if you have a question to call in, and to text in your question, it's 347-927-8398. Today's class is sponsored, l'refuah shleimah, of Dan ben Olga, may Hashem give him a speedy recovery, l'refuah shleimah b'ezrat Hashem b'mheirah. And anybody who would like to sponsor a class, you could text into the station, you could call into the station a little bit later, and b'ezrat Hashem we'll take your, I don't say orders, but we'll take your request. Today's halacha, we're continuing from last week. We began last week talking about Kabbalat Shabbat. We spoke a little bit about coming into Shabbat already. We started with halachot of candle lighting erev Shabbat. Now already we're up to Leil Shabbat, to the night of Shabbat, all the halachot pertaining to the night of Shabbat. And b'ezrat Hashem today we will cover a very, very important subject, and that is the subject of Kabbalat Shabbat. In the past, we got a few questions regarding the subject of Kabbalat Shabbat. A lot of people were asking what would be in this and that, whatever it may be. And then today, b'ezrat Hashem... We will have, hopefully, we'll discuss it as much as we can and bring out all the practical halachot, im yirtzeh Hashem, from it. But before that, we're up to halacha gimmel. If you're following with us in the book, we are learning from the book, the Ben Ish Chai, in Parashat Vayera, in the second year, halacha gimmel. Here the Ben Ish Chai brings something al pi Kabbalah, a very interesting and nice thing al pi Kabbalah. We mentioned in the past, maybe we'll discuss it a little bit more now. The Torah says, Ki bayom hashvi'i Shabbat vayinafash. On the seventh day, Hashem rested, and vayinafash really seems like He took a breath of calmness and He relaxed. I think it's this week's parasha as well, Parashat Ki Tisa. So the Gemara says, Vai nefesh, woe to the soul. The word vayinafash could be read, woe to the soul. And the Gemara explains, what does it mean, woe to the soul? To that, the Gemara answers, woe to the soul that has departed us on motzaei Shabbat when Shabbat leaves. Because when Shabbat comes in, we all have that extra neshama, that extra soul that comes with us, and that is what gives the flavor of Shabbat, to the point the Gemara says that that's a spice that Hashem brings to us, and we all feel it. We all know that when Shabbat comes, there's a special feeling that we cannot describe. If somebody would videotape Jews on Shabbat, living Shabbat, eating the meals on Shabbat, it's just not the same. The food and the atmosphere, the whole environment of Shabbat is completely different because of that extra neshama. The Mekubalim, we said this in the past, the Mekubalim explain that this soul is actually contained of many different parts, three at least, and these three parts come at different times of the evening. We discussed this in the past. We said that a person has to prepare himself. Now the Ben Ish Chai tells us exactly when these three parts of the soul come to the person, and these three parts of the soul are called nefesh, ruach, and neshama. We know that neshama is the soul, and a lot of people translate nefesh as a soul, but the Kabbalists explain that there's three parts: nefesh, ruach, and neshama. And when do they come to the person? They come to the person during the tefilah of Arvit. And depending on the person, when he prays and he's supposed to prepare himself, and here the Ben Ish Chai explains that it just doesn't come by itself. You have to sit there and prepare yourself that these things should come. So I'm going to read from inside, and the parts that I could skip, I'll try to skip. He says like this: B'leil Shabbat yesh l'adam shlosha minei tosefet Shabbat. On the evening of Shabbat, you have three additional souls, or not souls, or three additional parts of the soul that come to you besides your regular neshama that's with you all the time. Ha'echad, the first one, tosefet nefesh. That's called the nefesh that we just said before him. And when does it come? V'zeh na'aseh b'et Kabbalat Shabbat, v'nohagu kallah. This comes when a person accepts Shabbat. When does a person accept Shabbat? If you're praying regular and you're praying before Shekiyah, so then you're accepting Shabbat early. And by Kabbalat Shabbat, when we say Lecha Dodi at the end, we say a line that comes from the Gemara, and the line says, Bo'i kallah. We're inviting the bride to come in. That is Shabbat Malka, the queen of Shabbat, who's the bride. When you say that, you get that nefesh. Ha'sheni, the second part that comes to a person, this is only in the evening, by the way, tosefet ruach, which is the ruach, the second part of the soul. When does it come in? V'zeh na'aseh b'Etcha omrim Bar'chu kodem Arvit. That comes in when the chazzan says Bar'chu et Hashem hamevorach and the whole kahal responds, Baruch Hashem hamevorach le'olam va'ed. At that time, we get the ruach, the second part of the soul. Veha'shelishi, and the third part of the soul, when does it come in? That's the neshama, that tosefet neshama. When does it come in? V'zeh na'aseh b'Etcha omrim, u'fros aleinu v'al Yerushalayim sukkat shlomecha. Right before we stand up to the Amidah, we have a blessing called Hashkiveinu. According to the Sefardic custom, we have it a little different during the weekday than on Shabbat. And on Friday night, on Leil Shabbat, we say over there, u'fros... Alenu, etzukat shelomecha, and right then we get that force means Hashem spread upon us. What when we say those words, spread upon us, we get the sukkat rachamim v'shalom, we get that extra soul that's called the neshama. And this is when it comes in in the evening. So he explains over here, Ben Ish Chai, that these three parts come in the evening, and the other three parts also come in the daytime, and that's why a person should be standing up when you're receiving these three parts of the soul. Nefesh, ruach, neshama. Again, let's just review outside. Nefesh comes when a person accepts Shabbat, and that comes usually, like we said in the past, according to the Arizal, we accept Shabbat when we say Bo'i Kallah. So when we mekabel Shabbat, and saying Bo'i Kallah, the nefesh comes. When after Kiddush, before we begin our meal, then we get the ruach, which is by Bar'chu, Hashem mevorach, and finally we get the neshama right before we stand up for the Amidah when we say Ufros alenu. And a person should try to stand up for all these three parts. Now, in the first part, which is by Bo'i Kallah, anyway everybody's standing. Even Ashkenazim have a custom when they say Lecha Dodi, they're sitting down, they stand up at the end and they turn around to the back, which is facing the west, and that's when they say Bo'i Kallah, Bo'i Kallah. Sefardim anyway stand up the whole Lecha Dodi, and some, you see sometimes different shuls, maybe by Ashkenazim also you find a few yachidim standing up also. They might be Sefardim, I don't know, but they'll stand up. So you're standing up anyway for the nefesh. For the neshama, you're standing up to say the Amidah, so a person should first stand up and then say those words of Ufros alenu sukkat shelomecha. So this way you're receiving neshama standing up. The other part, which is the ruach, so here it's a little complicated. Ashkenazim have a custom that whenever Kaddish is recited in the shul, they all stand up. For the Sefardim, our custom is not to stand up. The only time we stand up by Kaddish for the Sefardim is if Kaddish caught us in the middle of standing. Meaning, if the chazzan already began Kaddish, then we must remain standing until the chazzan says the Ve'imru Amen right after the fifth Amen. You know, there's five Amenim that we answer to the Kaddish. Once he finishes Ve'imru Amen, then afterwards for the Yehei Shlama or Al Yisrael. Already sit down. But if already we got caught in the middle of saying, of the chazzan saying Kaddish, our custom is that we stand up. Otherwise, if we were sitting down, we would not stand up. So here, technically, you're supposed to get the ruach standing up. So by Baruch Hu, although normally you don't have to stand up by Baruch Hu, and certainly according to Sefardim, we don't bow down by Baruch Hu, one should stand up by Baruch Hu to receive the ruach. In some places they have a beautiful minhag where everybody stands up by the Kaddish, even Sefardim, I'm talking about. Ashkenazim anywhere are standing up. I'm talking about the Ashkenazi. I'm talking about the Sefardim, that they'll stand up—oh, sorry, again, I'm talking about the Sefardim. The Sefardim will stand up when it comes to the Kaddish right before Baruch Hu. So this way they're standing for Kaddish and they'll stand up for the Baruch Hu to receive the ruach. In any case, I'll tell you like this. This is very important. There's a Chida that says—I have to see this Chida inside more—but the Chida says that if you're in the kahal, if you're in the congregation where everybody's sitting down by Kaddish and Baruch Hu, and you're the only one standing, and especially that the rabbi is also sitting down, it's very disrespectful, and he uses very harsh words to speak about the person who's standing up, as if you know better than the rabbi, as if you're treating better than the rabbi. If the custom of the shul that you're going to, that everybody's sitting down and you're standing up, it looks a little bit of a yohara, like it looks like as if you're better. So in that case, either do one of the following things: either go up to the rabbi and ask permission, Is it okay, rabbi, that I stand up when the Kaddish right before Baruch Hu on Leil Shabbat because I see everybody sitting down? If you get permission from the rabbi, fantastic. And if you're too embarrassed, you don't want to go up to the rabbi, or you feel the rabbi isn't—don't pray there. Either sit down or don't pray there, because you shouldn't stick out and you shouldn't appear to the kahal or to anybody else that you're, כאילו, חס ושלום, like you're acting better than the rabbi. I'm not saying that you don't know better; you might actually know better than the rabbi, but still, you shouldn't stick out that way. It's his shul, it's his congregation, and get permission from him. That's brought down in the poskim. A person has to be careful. Get permission, that's not a big deal. Go up to the person, go up to the rabbi and say, Listen, I read in Ben Ish Chai to stand up by Baruch Hu, and see what he tells you. If he says no problem, no problem. That is. The halacha, and that is just to go about it. I had a question. I'm not sure of it yet. I have to ask some mekubalim from Eretz Yisrael, is what about a woman who doesn't pray Arvit, and she doesn't pray Kabbalat Shabbat? So I understand when a person is accepting Shabbat, right when you accept Shabbat, you get the nefesh anyway. But what about a woman who's not praying Arvit? When does she get the ruach and the neshama? Because if in הלכה, as he says in the next halacha, in halacha dalet, I'm not going to read it inside, he says that if a person did not have in mind that he's receiving the parts of the so-called the ruach and the neshama when he's praying, let's say b'vad echad, he's completely spaced out, or he fell asleep during the chazan singing of the Kaddish, and he missed out. He didn't think that, oh, the ruach is coming now, so he loses it out. When could you get it back? You have one more chance, because the sefaradim say right before Aleinu לשבח, we say not the Bar'chu. So over there you have another chance to make it up. But it sounds like over here you have to have kavanah for it, and it doesn't just come by itself. So what about the ladies who don't pray on Leil Shabbat? When do they get—do they have to think, I'm getting the ruach, I'm getting the neshama, even if they're not praying? I'm not sure, but be'ezrat Hashem, hopefully next week I'll have an answer. If not next week, I don't know, but I'll try to get you an answer as soon as possible. That's halacha gimel and dalet. Also we said outside that you can have kavanah for the Bar'chu before Aleinu in case you miss the ruach, in case you miss your chance of preparing yourself to receive the ruach and the neshama. We move on to halacha dalet. So halacha dalet, he brings down over here simple things. He says even though the Lecha Dodi was not mentioned anywhere in the Arizal, it's actually written by somebody who lived around the time of the Arizal, also in sefer Rav Shlomo Alkabetz. And he, Rav Shlomo Alkabetz, if you look at the Lecha Dodi, you see the roshei teivot actually of his name over there right in the beginning of each stanza. It's, I think, Shlomo haLevi, you'll see it over there. In any case, the custom amongst all the Jewish communities, certainly the ones that I know about and certainly the, you know, what we see, the custom is that they all say the Lecha Dodi when we accept Shabbat on Friday night, and it's a beautiful, beautiful custom and has, of course, many things al pi Kabbalah. But even if a person doesn't have a siddur, let's say he's stuck somewhere and you don't have a siddur, you should be careful to say Bo'i Kallah. And he brings down over here, even though we say Bo'i Kallah at the end, a lot of times you're praying after bein hashmashot, which we're going to discuss soon, that really you're supposed to try to—you're supposed to accept Shabbat before sunset. Many times you're praying Kabbalat Shabbat after sunset. Certainly also some— Communities, some shuls have a custom of saying Shir HaShirim between Mincha and Kabbalat Shabbat. Although the preferable thing to do is to pray Mincha, then to say Kabbalat Shabbat, that's where you accept Shabbat earlier, right before sunset, and then afterwards to say Shir HaShirim. That's preferable. But, you know, people are not ready to change their minhagim or what they believe is a strong minhag. Okay, fine, you don't want to change, you don't want to think, beseder gamur. But in any case, a person should accept Shabbat in any case earlier. If you see that you're not going to be able to accept Shabbat before sunset because you're only going to be able to say Lecha Dodi after sunset, so then accept Shabbat on your own. Say Bo'i Kallah, Bo'i Kallah, Shabbat Malketa, and this way you accepted Shabbat before sunset, and then afterwards you can say Lecha Dodi, not a problem. You should know when you say Bo'i Kallah, that's when you're receiving the nefesh part of the soul for Friday night. With that, we'll move on to Halacha Vav. Halacha Vav is a very, very important halacha. I am not exaggerating when I tell you that I've spent literally hours preparing for this halacha, even though it's something that we discussed in the past, but I wanted, bezrat Hashem, hopefully, bsiata dishmaya, to elaborate and to discuss it at length, hopefully clarifying every issue. So if you're listening and you have any questions, please text in your questions. Anything that I have not clarified, please make sure you text it in. By the way, I really appreciate all the comments, all the questions, and even people who see me in the street, I really appreciate it. Thank you very much, and please keep them coming. If you believe I made a certain mistake, please let me know where I should look to correct myself, and bezrat Hashem, if we did make a mistake, we're here to get the emet. We're not here to have someone to say I'm right. So if you believe there's anything that needs correction, please, I appreciate your comments and any remarks or questions, bezrat Hashem. The subject that we're going to discuss now is an important subject called— Tosefet Shabbat. Adding on to Shabbat. We'll begin with a quick halacha, then we'll go to the sources, discuss it at length, and then come back and see what the Ben Ish Chai writes about it. The halacha, in simple form, is that Shabbat, usually we know by sunset we accept Shabbat, but a person has to accept Shabbat before Shabbat comes in. It's kind of, mashal, imagine you have your parents who live outside of America. Imagine they're coming to visit you, or somebody that's very chashuv is coming to visit you, somebody that you honor and respect. It's more respectful that you go pick them at the airport and bring them home than for you to wait for them to come home and to knock on your door, right? That's the more mechubad. Shabbat also, you have to be mekabel Shabbat. You shouldn't wait for Shabbat to come in, last moment Shabbat comes in, oh, it's here, now we're bound to the laws of Shabbat. You have to go out of your way and to bring Shabbat, to bring it home. Also, when you leave Shabbat, when you're done with Shabbat, you shouldn't just finish Shabbat on exactly the moment that Shabbat finishes. You should add a few more minutes to the Shabbat. That's a mitzvah, tosefet Shabbat, adding on to the Shabbat from Friday on to Shabbat and from Saturday night motzaei Shabbat. That, which is really ליל ראשון, to Shabbat Kodesh. That's the ikar mitzvah of Tosefet Shabbat. Where does it come from, and what's the opinions, and what's the whole thing about it? Let's begin with the Gemara Masechet Rosh Hashanah. The Gemara is also found in Masechet Yoma, I believe also in Moed Katan. They bring the same Gemara. There's a pasuk that says as follows. Pay attention to the pasuk. The pasuk says, וְעִנִּיתֶם אֶת נַפְשֹׁתֵיכֶם בְּתִשְׁעָה לַחֹדֶשׁ בָּעֶרֶב. Excuse me, בָּעֶרֶב, מֵעֶרֶב עַד עֶרֶב תִּשְׁבְּתוּ שַׁבַּתְּכֶם. That's the pasuk. Pasuk is talking about Yom Kippur. When it comes to Yom Kippur, we know Yom Kippur is on the tenth of the seventh month, which is what we call the tenth of Tishrei. So now that you know that the fast is on the tenth, on Yom Kippur we refrain from eating in the five עינויים, plus it has the same halachot as Shabbat, which means we refrain from all the melachot of Shabbat, deRabbanan or deOraita. And the Torah says over there regarding eating, it says וְעִנִּיתֶם, which is regarding fasting. It says you have to inflict your souls בְּתִשְׁעָה לַחֹדֶשׁ, on the ninth of the month, בָּעֶרֶב, in the evening. That's very complicated, right? We just explained that Yom Kippur comes on the tenth. So why in the world is the pasuk telling me that I must inflict myself, which means I must begin fasting on the ninth? It's supposed to be on the tenth, and then you tell me, no, in the evening. So that's exactly the question of the Gemara. The Gemara says, יָכוֹל בְּתִשְׁעָה מִתְעַנֶּה? You can tell me now I'm going to fast on the ninth of the month? Doesn't make sense. It says in the pasuk, בָּעֶרֶב. When the ninth comes, it says in the evening, which means in the tenth. So why in the world is the pasuk saying בְּתִשְׁעָה? So the Gemara answers, מַתְחִיל וּמִתְעַנֶּה מִבְּעוֹד יוֹם, כְּדֵי לְהוֹסִיף מֵחוֹל עַל הַקֹּדֶשׁ. You must begin. To fast when it's still daytime, pay attention to the words, min ha'ayon, which means when it's still daytime, in order that you should add from the weekday onto the holy day, which is referring to Yom Kippur. So let's say Yom Kippur is on Wednesday evening, which means Yom Kippur will be on a Thursday, Wednesday evening and on the Thursday. Wednesday you're eating, and let's say sunset is at six o'clock. The pasuk here tells us that don't wait till six o'clock to begin fasting, but what you have to do is before six o'clock. How much before, we're going to discuss in a second, but before six o'clock, I don't know, 5:30, 5:45, 5:50, whatever it is, before that you should come and you should start fasting and go into Yom Kippur at six o'clock already that you began fasting. Okay? That is the Gemara. That's a source in the Gemara. Now the Gemara obviously is talking about what? It's talking about Yom Kippur, okay? But even though it's talking about Yom Kippur, you notice in the pasuk it says, Tishbetu Shabbattechem. This is what you shall do regarding Shabbat, anything that's called Shabbat. And we know as a rule, Shabbat is called Shabbat, Yom Kippur is called Shabbat. Also to a certain extent, the holidays are also called Shabbat, as the Gemara points out many, many times. So therefore the pasuk is telling us over here that this law of adding on to Yom Kippur applies to anything that's called Shabbat, which is even on Shabbat and Yom Tov, and that's really the opinion of many Rishonim. What do the Rishonim say? So everybody agrees that this pasuk, which is from the Torah, it's a biblical obligation, it's a chiyuv mide'oraita, that a person, when it comes to Yom Kippur, must begin fasting earlier. There's no doubt, there's no question. Everybody agrees on this. There's no machloket on this. Good? Hard to find no machloket, but we found there is no machloket regarding this. But the pasuk—I was very careful to quote the pasuk very carefully—and the pasuk doesn't say anything regarding melacha. All it says is, Ve'innitem et nafshoteichem, which is referring to fasting. So what about melacha? What about not working? So on Shabbat we know we don't fast, so obviously that's not going to apply on Shabbat. But what about melacha? Do we say that pesukim is referring to melacha as well? So the majority of the Rishonim hold that yes, the pasuk is referring not only to fasting, which is refraining from eating. Eating is forbidden on Shabbat, on Yom Kippur, not only to eating, but all the things that are forbidden on Yom Kippur a person must begin beforehand. And when does he begin? He begins on before Yom Kippur comes in. Also melacha, yenala te'lu before it comes in. So that means it applies to all Shabbatot. Every Shabbat, no matter when it is, this week I believe maybe 5:13 is candle lighting, so that means whenever Shabbat will be, let's say it's 5:30, 5:40, whatever it might be, you have to come into Shabbat earlier. You can't stop working only at 5:40. You have to do it a little bit earlier. That is the opinion of the majority of the Rishonim. However, if you open up the Rambam, when it comes to the laws of Shabbat, he doesn't mention anything about this halacha. He doesn't quote this Gemara. He doesn't bring this halacha at all. And the question is, how come the Rambam doesn't bring this halacha? So therefore, we have two opinions to explain the Rambam. According to the Beit Yosef, this is the Shulchan Aruch and this commentary on the Tur, the Beit Yosef in the Chida writes, you see from the Rambam that really there's no obligation, according to the Rambam, to add from the weekday onto Shabbat. When is there an obligation? There's an obligation only when it comes to fasting. When you're fasting on Yom Kippur, so then add before Yom Kippur, Thursday is Yom Kippur, so add on Wednesday. Add from Wednesday onto Thursday. That is the opinions of the Beit Yosef and how to understand the Rambam. Not everybody understands the Rambam that way. The Gra, the Maggid Mishneh, which is before the Beit Yosef, he says that the reason why the Rambam skipped it is because he doesn't hold it's an obligation min haTorah. He holds that's only an obligation miderabanan. On Yom Kippur it's an obligation min haTorah. But on regular Shabbat, there's an obligation to refrain from any melacha before Shabbat comes in, but the obligation is only rabbinical; it's a chiyuv miderabanan. So it comes out that there's a machloket between the Rishonim. According to the majority of the Rishonim, there is an obligation mideOraita for a person to add on to Shabbat. According to the Rambam, he doesn't bring it down, and there's two ways to explain it. Some say there's no obligation at all to add, and others say no. According to the Rambam, there's only an obligation miderabanan. That is the machloket between the Rambam and the other Rishonim. So what does Shulchan Aruch hold? We go, Kabbalan hu le'ot Maran; we accepted the whole laws of Shulchan Aruch. If you look at Shulchan Aruch, I'll read you the words Shulchan Aruch writes. In siman ... he says, יש אומרים שצריך להוסיף מחול על הקודש. That's all he brings. And this yesh omrim, all the commentaries explain, this yesh omrim is just a polite way of not disagreeing completely with the Rambam. But basically, Beit Yosef went with all the other Rishonim. There's an obligation min haTorah; it's a mitzvat aseh that a person must accept Shabbat earlier. You can't come into Shabbat just like that. You have to accept Shabbat a little bit earlier. And this is the psak halacha according to all the Acharonim. All the Acharonim go with the Shulchan Aruch; nobody disagrees with Shulchan Aruch. There is an obligation mideOraita for a person to come into Shabbat earlier than when Shabbat comes in. If Shabbat comes in by sunset, then you have to come into Shabbat earlier than that. You have to stop; you have to accept Shabbat earlier. That's a mitzvat aseh of Kabbalat Shabbat, Tosefet Shabbat. Okay, so we explained that. Now the question is, when can you begin? To add onto Shabbat. So there's, we said this in the past. Let me just tell you in halacha, this is going to make a lot of ramifications. And the day is divided into three parts. The pasuk says, Vaya'erev vayevoker yom echad. And every time when it comes to the creation of the day, the Torah tells us the definition of a day. The day begins how? Vaya'erev, first the evening came, and then vayevoker, and then the daytime came. That's one day. We know our days begin in the evening, as every holiday and every Shabbat always begins in the evening. A person becomes bar mitzvah, one, in the evening, not the next day when you make the party. In that evening, that's the first night when a person becomes chayav b'mitzvot, because the day begins from the evening. But day and night is not so simple. Although the pasuk says, Hashem called the light of the day, which is when the sunlight, Hashem calls it yom, as it says in the pasuk, Vayikra la'or yom, and it says, V'lachoshech kara layla, and to the evening, to the night, Hashem called night. Okay? That's the evening, very nice. To the darkness, Hashem called evening. So we know for sure something is for sure. Whenever you see the sun, the ball of the sun on the earth, that is daytime. Very nice. That's simple. Vayikra la'or yom. And when you see three stars in the evening, that's a sign of night, then you know for sure it's night. Very good. The question is, it doesn't happen that way. You don't see the stars immediately when the sun sets. There's that time between called twilight in English, and that's what we call in halacha, bein hashmashot. Bein hashmashot means that twilight. It's the time after the sun sets until the stars come out. That time, Gemara explains, that's called bein hashmashot. When does bein hashmashot begin is a big, huge subject that I really don't want to get into, because we're going to confuse everybody, including the person giving the speech, the class, okay? It's going to be very, very confusing and complicated. But just to say in simple, simple terms, okay, we're going to go with the simplest terms in the halacha, whatever it is, that once sunset comes, sheki'ah, once sets, which means that the whole ball of the sky goes under the horizon, you can't see it anymore, then bein hashmashot begins. How long is bein hashmashot? For our sake, just for now, there's two opinions: there's 13 and a half minutes or 18 minutes, ad kan. That's what it says over here. So now, we explained you have to add on to Shabbat. When do you have to add on to Shabbat? Comes the Rosh and says, you can't tell me you have to add on to Shabbat when it's already Shabbat, when it's already three stars. That doesn't make sense. Why are you adding on? You can't begin to add when it's already nighttime. It's already Shabbat, right? So you have to add on to it. You can't tell me also you have to add on to the part called twilight, bein hashmashot, because then it's a safek. How can a person do melacha? Even though the Gemara says that bein hashmashot, the twilight, is considered safek. We're not sure if it's part of the day or part of the evening, but it's still a safek de'oraita. And the rule is whenever it comes, we have a doubt where something is from the Torah, we say safek de'oraita lechumra. So it's absolutely forbidden for a person to do anything that's assur during bein hashmashot. So what remains? It remains the daytime, the third part of the day, which is yom, Friday day, when the ball of the sun is still out and you can see it. That's when you have a mitzvah to add. At that time, a person can add on to Shabbat. So therefore, you have to look at your calendar. Whenever Friday, when you look at every calendar, Friday night, when is sunset? When is sheki'ah? If sunset is 5:30, for example, then you must add on from before 5:30. You must add on to Shabbat from before 5:30. You can't wait till 18 minutes after sunset to add on to Shabbat. That's already Shabbat, or at least safek Shabbat. So for sure everything is forbidden then. You have to do it only beforehand. How much time could you add? Well, could you add on to Shabbat from Wednesday, today? Could you say to somebody—it doesn't make sense if a person says, You know, today is Wednesday. ... I want to add on to Shabbat from now on, from today, from Wednesday already I'm keeping Shabbat Wednesday, Thursday, Friday. I can't do any melacha. No, that's ridiculous. You can't do that. Could you add on Thursday, Friday? Okay, Thursday, Friday also you can add on. Friday is Friday; it's not Shabbat. So which point could you add on and the poskim bring down? You can begin adding on to Shabbat already from a time called plag hamincha. Plag hamincha, in simple terms, it's hard to explain on the radio because there's two things over here. It's not a set time every time. Plag, first of all, there's a question when plag hamincha begins. Some say it begins an hour and 15 minutes before sunset, and some say it begins an hour and 15 minutes before the three stars come out. The time before the three stars come out also, question is when the three stars come out, and also the hour and 15 minutes are always shaot zmaniyot, not the regular 60 minutes an hour, not the 60 minutes that we know, because it's very, very complicated to explain. So how are you going to figure out when plag hamincha is? One of two ways. If you have a smartphone, iPhone or an Android, if you have an Android, you go to the Google Store or whatever the thing where you download the app, and you download a very important app called Zmanim. Zmanim gives you the times according to all the opinions, whatever custom they have give you the time, and this way you'll know when plag hamincha is. The other app, I think from the Apple Store, you can get also. It's also, I think it's also called Zmanim. I like the one from the Android; it looked much better, it was much more thorough. Doesn't make a difference. In any case, you download any calendar, or you, guess what, you can buy a calendar or just get a calendar, they give them out all the time. Find out what time plag hamincha is. Whenever that plag hamincha is, which usually is around an hour and 15 minutes shaot zmaniyot before, let's say, sheki'ah or sunset, then you could already from that time only begin to add on to Shabbat. I'll give you an example. I took three weeks. I took the times of three weeks. To show you, one is the early time to add. This week, this Shabbat, 5:29 p.m. is shekiah. If you go to plag hamincha, there's two different opinions exactly when plag hamincha is. We'll go with the early opinion. That's the opinion of the Gra, who holds that you do an hour and 15 minutes before shekiah, and he says that the time is 4:23. Plag hamincha according to the Gra is 4:23, which means at 4:20, if you want to accept Shabbat early, you're not obligated to. You could say it's Shabbat, but it doesn't obligate you. So therefore, at 4:23, you can only begin, according to the Gra, to accept Shabbat this Friday. Give you another example. Let's say in the summer, which is more shayach in the summer, this is more practical in the summer. We took the week of June 13th, Parshat Korach. This year, June 13th will be 8:29. It's not only this year; every year June 13th will be 8:29 p.m. will be sunset. You know what time, how early you can accept Shabbat? About an hour and a half beforehand. You want to talk about an hour? Yeah, about an hour and a half beforehand. At 6:55, a person could already begin to accept Shabbat. That's a very long time beforehand. Sometimes you only have like a half an hour, an hour. Like, for example, in December, where sunset is 4:29, so then the earliest time you accept Shabbat is 3:31. You only have an hour. Sometimes you have much more, let's say an hour and 45 minutes, and sometimes you'll have only an hour, sometimes even half an hour, according to the different opinions. In any case, you have to look at the calendar and see when plag hamincha is. Whenever plag hamincha is, even though there's two times you'll see in the calendar, you could go with the earlier time and accept Shabbat that early. That's the earliest you could. Before that time, it doesn't obligate you, which means if you want to refrain from melachah, you don't want to do any melachah, it's fine. It's fantastic. There's a lot of tzaddikim who used to be careful that they wouldn't do melachah from, let's say, chatzot, from midday on Friday, but it's not an obligation. Halachah says clearly, the Rama brings it down, that only from plag hamincha could a person begin to add. But we want to know not the maximum amount of time to wait. We want to know what is the minimum amount to wait. Maximum, okay, beseder, I'll begin from plag hamincha. That's not a big deal. I want to know how much. Much time do I have to add? So really, meikar hadin, this is brought down by a lot of Acharonim as well. It's based obviously on Rishonim, the Eretz Tzvi, Rav Moshe Feinstein, Chacham Ovadia. Minimum, minimum time, according to them, is two minutes. That means, what time is shekiah? You'll have to look at the calendar. What time is shekiah this week? It's 5:29. You can't come into Shabbat. You can't do melacha. I mean, it's not that you can't; you mevatel a mitzvat aseh if you do melacha at 5:28. At 5:27 already, you must stop. You must add on to Shabbat. That's a mitzvat aseh min de'oraita. You have an obligation from the Torah, a biblical obligation, to add at least at 5:27, at least. You want to do more, chazak u'baruch, we told you, you can do up to plag hamincha, but the minimum is two minutes. But there's other Acharonim, like Ollet Zion, Chacham Ovadia, Menuchat Ahavah, Rav Moshe Levi, also Lev Avraham, also ... they hold about five minutes. They say a person should accept at least five minutes before. Okay, so you have between two to five minutes minimum a person has to accept Shabbat. Meaning, 5:29 is Shabbat, shekiah. Before Shabbat, two to five minutes, a person must already accept Shabbat. What's recommended, though? What's recommended, we have a few opinions. We'll tell you the Ben Ish Chai and the Mishnah Berurah, and then what seems to be the minhag according to the women to the men. What's recommended is the Ben Ish Chai in this week's parashah, and I'll read it for you. He says like this: Hayav adam lehosif me'chol al kodesh, like we just learned. A person has to add from the weekday until Shabbat. Uzman tosefet zeh yesh bo kamah safekot. How much time to add? There's many different opinions, like we just told you. We have from two minutes until an hour and a half. V'anachnu, us... Who should we follow? Ein lanu ela divrei haArizal. We should follow what the Arizal says and he says, zman kabalat Shabbat u'semuch l'skiat hachamah. It's closer shekar b'anu kavato, what it means to say, keshechamah b'rosho, in other, dehainu shlish sha'ah kodem kriat hamugrab. In the Arab countries, if you go visit Turkey, or even if you're close enough to the Arab neighborhoods in Israel, in Yerushalayim, you'll hear always throughout the day, about five times a day, you'll hear them on the loud mics. They have this person yelling out, you know, their prayer, and he sings it in a whole different makom. So this is done. This was done also during the time what they call the mugrab, which is what they call sunset, but it really wasn't sunset. Really what it was, it was seven and a half minutes after sunset in the lands of the Bnei Yisrael, which is in Baghdad about 150 years ago. So therefore he brings 20 minutes before the mugrab, which comes out to be 12 and a half minutes. So according to the Bnei Yisrael, he writes 12 and a half minutes. Other places write 30 minutes. About 13 minutes before sunset, according to the Bnei Yisrael, a person should accept Shabbat. According to the Mishnah Berurah, he says, again, he also says there's a minimum of about two minutes, but it would be wonderful if a person could do 16 and a half minutes before sunset, which is about a minute and a half after candle lighting. That's when a person should accept Shabbat. This is talking to men as well as women. Again, min haTorah, there is an obligation to add. You don't have to add that much. You can add as much as you want, but what's highly recommended, the Bnei Yisrael says about 13 minutes, and the Mishnah Berurah says about 16 and a half minutes, which is about 17 minutes, let's say. However, the Mishnah Berurah himself brings down that it's really, really highly recommended if you could do 20 to 30 minutes beforehand. This way you cover all the opinions, because there's an opinion that holds that really Ben HaShmashot begins even before shekiah; that's the Ra'em. In any case, I don't want to get into it right now, but the Mishnah Berurah says if you could do 30 minutes, unbelievable, that's great. And that's, I believe, the minhag in Bnei Brak. Maybe 30 minutes, maybe they changed it now to 40 minutes. Minhag in Bnei Brak is 30 minutes beforehand; the nashim can lighting. Again, it doesn't obligate you, but it's really, really highly recommended that a person should accept Shabbat earlier than that. So let's summarize. In short, there's an obligation מן התורה, according to all the Acharonim, on top of them Shulchan Aruch, that a person must accept Shabbat before Shabbat comes in. Before Shabbat comes in means to say before shekiah. How much time before shekiah? Minimum two minutes to between two and five minutes, maximum up to plag hamincha. What's highly recommended is between 12 to 18 minutes beforehand. So the ladies are lighting candles. Even though we said in the past, according to the Sefardim, ladies do not have the obligation of accepting Shabbat by candle lighting. But since candle lighting is around 18 minutes, it's highly, highly recommended that a lady should have everything done in the house, so this way when she comes to candle lighting, she should accept Shabbat by that time. We stress that a lady, a Sefardi lady, does not have the obligation to accept Shabbat, but it doesn't mean that she shouldn't. Why not? If she could, that is the best thing that she could do. She could accept Shabbat earlier. Not only that, even the men. If the men accept Shabbat that early, which means obviously they can't drive to shul, that's it, it's Shabbat for them. They accepted Shabbat. Once you accept Shabbat earlier, it's Shabbat for you. You can't do any issurim; it's completely Shabbat. You walk without any keys, without carrying, without driving. You can't put on the lights anymore. So if you're not up to it, if you feel that you're one of those late people and you're always rushing into Shabbat, you don't have to. You have no obligation. It's interesting, there's—just to tell you. This is a teshuvah in Chelek Aleph, in Chelek Aleph of Igrot Moshe. It seems from the reply of Rav Moshe Feinstein was that one time he got into the car after candle lighting and he was driving to shul. And according to the teshuvah, it was about a two-minute drive, literally, it wasn't longer than that. But it seems like some rabbi wrote him a letter rebuking Rav Moshe Feinstein. Imagine, rebuking Rav Moshe Feinstein: how can he get into the car after candle lighting time? People will think that you're allowed to drive to shul. So he explains, really, there's no obligation for a person to accept Shabbat that early. But he says, I'll accept your rebuke, shows you the humility of Rav Moshe Feinstein. He says, I'll accept your rebuke, and therefore I'm going to give you my word: from now on, by candle lighting, I will not get into the car, I will not drive, I will not get into the car at all, because, you know, maybe you're saying that people will learn from me. I'll take it, I'll accept it. Shows you the gadlut of Moshe Feinstein. But you also see from there, he explains, two minutes, he says over there, really the obligation of adding on to Shabbat is two minutes before Shabbat. But you want to add on more, that's great. If you could do it, why not? And you have to see yourself. If you could do, start slowly. Start doing at least two minutes. This is an obligation. Then go up to five minutes. Then if you could do ten, you could do thirteen, according to the Arizal. And then if you could do twenty, thirty minutes, according to the Mishnah Berurah, fantastic, that's wonderful. Now I know what you're going to ask me. About a month ago, when we spoke about Kabbalat Shabbat, we said there's a huge machloket if a person accepts Shabbat, how in the world is he going to pray Mincha? Once you accept Shabbat, if you tell me I accept Shabbat earlier, you know, I would love to, but I can't because my minyan, whatever I pray in, in the shul, they're always praying, you know, what do you call it, they're praying Mincha Erev Shabbat fifteen— not fifteen minutes. Some places they pray five minutes before shekiah. So if I accept Shabbat ten minutes beforehand, I can't pray Mincha anymore. So that's a good question. I always also had that question. And the answer is, Beis Hacham Rebbe brings a Taz, beautiful Taz, the Taz, Turei Zahav. He has a beautiful commentary on the Shulchan Aruch, sometimes a little complicated. Here on siman nessa mechalef, seif gimel, he brings down the following. Listen to the halacha that he says. He says like this: If a person accepts Shabbat, Then it becomes Shabbat for him. All the melachot of Shabbat become—he becomes bound to all the melachot of Shabbat unless he makes a condition, unless he specifies, he makes a condition what he wants to accept Shabbat for. Which means, over here you see from here that you can accept Shabbat that will restrict you; you'll refrain from doing any melacha. But you could accept Shabbat, but you could also limit the acceptance of Shabbat to tefillah, which means I could accept Tosefet Shabbat, the addition of Shabbat, that I should not do any melacha, but I will still be able to pray Mincha. That is the recommendation that's given by Chacham Ovadia, and as well a lot of Acharonim: accept only Tosefet Shabbat. Make a condition, I only accept Shabbat that I should refrain from melacha. And I'm doing the mitzvah of Tosefet Shabbat, as the Torah says, don't do any melacha, like the way the Rishonim explained it. But as far as Mincha, no, I'm not accepting Shabbat for Mincha. That means if I still have to pray Mincha, then I'll pray Mincha even though I already accepted Shabbat, because my acceptance of Shabbat was only limited to the melachot, to the things that are forbidden to be done on Shabbat, but not to Mincha. That's the way Chacham Ovadia brings it down in the name of the Taz, and that's the recommendation that we give to everybody. Question over here: does one have to express or verbalize his Kabbalah? Does a person, when he accepts Shabbat, does he have to say, Ani mekabel Shabbat, or he wants to say in English or Chinese, whatever he wants? Does he have to say, I am accepting Shabbat, or not? So Mishnah Berurah brings down, beautiful diyuk from the Rama and Shulchan Aruch even: Minhagot of Teshuvah BeAhavah, he brings the following case. Let's say ... A person ate his seudah mafseket. He's done, he made birkat hamazon, and now the fast will begin in another 20 minutes. Does he have to say, Ani mekabel hataanit, I'm accepting the fast, or could he just think about it and the fast begins? Which means the difference will be as follows. Let's say there's 20 minutes left till Tisha B'Av begins, and now all of a sudden a person in his mind says, You know, I want to stop eating. I want to start fasting. Five minutes later he realizes, You know, I don't have enough liquid. I need to drink some Gatorade to put some electrolytes in my body so this way I can get some energy for Yom Kippur. So what could he do at that time? Could he eat or can he not eat? He only accepted in his mind. So from the words of Shulchan Aruch and the Rama, Siman Taf Kuf Nun Gimel, it sounds like—not sounds like, it says mefurash—if you just said it in your mind, it means absolutely nothing. You have to express it. Although some Acharonim disagree and they say no, if you said in your mind—that's, I believe, the Bach and the Gra over there—they bring, no, if you accept it in your mind also, that restricts you. But still, according to Shulchan Aruch and Rama, it sounds like no, you have to express it. So therefore the Acharonim bring the same thing over here. The Mishnah Berurah says you must express in your mouth that I have to accept Shabbat, and that's the Mishnah Berurah's opinion, and certainly according to Mekubalim. We mentioned in the past, the Mekubalim say by everything you should always speak it out, even putting on tallit. You're going to put on the tallit, you're going to wrap yourself in it, it's clear. Then when you're holding the tallit in your hand, still, Se l'shem yichud. Specify, I'm coming to do this mitzvah, we're putting on tallit. You're putting on tefillin, say, I'm putting on tefillin. You're coming to light candles of the menorah, say, L'shem yichud. Hareini ba l'kayem mitzvat aseh d'Rabbanan lehadlik nerot shel Chanukah. Always when you do a mitzvah according to the mekubalim, you should always express it. So certainly, if you're going to add on to Shabbat according to mekubalim, say it with your mouth. However, the Chacham Ben Zion, in Or LeTzion, Chelek Bet, he brings a nice proof, and he says that although it's certainly recommended that a person should accept Shabbat, he should express it and say, Ani mekabel Shabbat, for sure that's highly recommended. Still, he holds that's not an obligation. If a person chooses to and he wants to accept it only in his mind, he could. So you have what to rely on; you have to be on the lenient side. So we tell you, what you should do is, if you know you're accepting Shabbat early and you haven't prayed Mincha, try to accept it earlier just for Melacha and not for praying Mincha. And say, express it, say, Ani mekabel Shabbat. Let's say you're driving to shul, so the moment you park, you put your keys down, then say, Ani mekabel Shabbat. If not, and you only said it in your heart, you have what to rely on, but lechatchila you should express it. Okay, we're done with this halacha. We'll take a phone call right now. Anybody has questions, you can call into the station right now, and the phone number is 718-683-5858. Hello? Hello, is Nissan there? No, sorry. Call a little later. What? Sorry, you got to call a little later. Hello? Okay, so we're going to go on to the music break right now, and be'ezrat Hashem, right when we come back, if there's any questions either by text or by if somebody wants to call into the station, be'ezrat Hashem we'll answer your questions. Let me just give you the number to the station again, 718-683-5858. If you have any questions regarding Kabbalat Shabbat, anything that we haven't clarified, and also if you want to text in, 347-927-8398. We'll be back right after this short break. I will say to the Ribono Shel Olam, Father dear, don't hide from me. My life is not complete without you. Don't hide from me. I need to see you more than ever now. Okay, we're back. We have a few minutes left of the class. Be'ezrat Hashem, we'll summarize, but we will not be able to go on to Halacha Zayin, because Halacha Zayin, although very important, make sure you listen next week, Halacha Zayin talks about when a person accepts Shabbat earlier and other people have not accepted Shabbat yet. What could you tell them? What could you not tell them? That will be, be'ezrat Hashem, next week's class. There's a lot to talk about, and in a few minutes we won't do it justice, so make sure you listen next week. I want to bring up one question that came on the text, and the person wants to know, isn't the time on the calendar anyway a time that includes in it adding on to Shabbat? You have to know, on the calendar, if it says, for example, sunset on the calendar, that has nothing to do with Tosefet Shabbat. That's exactly when sunset comes in. If you refer time on the calendar that says candle lighting, you're right, candle lighting in America is usually 18 minutes before sunset. So from that time, if a person, man or woman, want to add, want to accept Shabbat, that's great, that's fantastic. Really, that's highly recommended according to many, many of the opinions. If you accept Shabbat at 18 minutes before Shabbat, you're covering almost all opinions of mitzvat Tosefet Shabbat, as well as some other opinions, which is more stringent. In any case, that is, if a person wants to accept then, great. If you want to accept more also, you could do more. But 18 minutes is highly, highly recommended for men and women as well. But the time of sunset? No. Time of sunset is the time when Shabbat comes in, and although it's only bein hashmashot, but still it's a safek of Shabbat. It means a safek of issur karet, and chas v'shalom, a person should not do any melacha then. Once again, I repeat, sunset, whenever sunset comes in, that is Shabbat all the way, even if you didn't want to accept it. It doesn't make a difference. Sunset is fully Shabbat. It's forbidden to do any melacha during that time. That is the question for that. There is one more halacha maybe we'll get to, and anybody has questions, I'll be here at the station another five, ten minutes afterwards. If you want to call off the air, you can call in afterwards. The number is— 718-683-5858. The text is 347-927-8398. This class will be repeated again, hopefully, this Sunday, if everything is working out fine, will be repeated again on Tuesday evenings at 10 o'clock, from 10 to 11. And be'ezrat Hashem, next week it's usually aired live on Wednesdays between 2 to 3 p.m. Last halacha for today. Although the main discussion of this halacha will be in Parashat Toledot, where the Ben Ish Chai talks about it at length over there, the halacha tells us that if a person is praying on Friday night and he makes a mistake in the Amidah—let's say Friday night you're coming to pray, you start the Amidah. Of course, we all know it's very, very tiring Friday night, and a person began his Amidah and the words begin Attah kiddashta, and a person completely forgot himself. Right after Hakel HaKadosh, where he's supposed to begin Attah kiddashta for the fourth berachah, he began saying the blessing of the weekday, Attah chonen l'adam da'at, and all of a sudden he realized, uh-oh, I'm in the middle of the Amidah of Shabbat. What am I doing? What is the halacha? The halacha is, if you made a mistake, then you finish that berachah that you started, and once you finish the berachah with its blessing, then you go back. Meaning, let's say you made a mistake, Attah chonen, and then you caught yourself, whoa, what did I say? Attah chonen? It's supposed to be Shabbat. So you finish the whole berachah, say Baruch Attah Hashem with Shem Hashem, full berachah, regular the way that you would say it during the weekday, and then say Baruch Attah Hashem chonen hada'at, and then continue Attah kiddashta. Not only in the first berachah. Even if you remembered all the way by Shema Koleinu, you're almost done with the Amidah. I don't know how you didn't realize, everybody, unless you're really speed-reading, but you didn't realize that everybody around you finished the Amidah and you're still in Shema Koleinu, and you're saying Shema Koleinu, Hashem Elokeinu, and then you realize it's Shabbat. What am I doing? So in that case— Finish the bracha Shema kolenu, say Baruch Atah Hashem shomea tefila, and then you begin Atah kidashta. Why is it so? So the Gemara explains. Really, we're supposed to—we have in our Amidah 19 blessings. Originally it was 18, that's why Shemoneh Esrei, but in any case we have 19 blessings. The first three and the last three are the standard blessings of every single Amidah that we pray in our lives on every single day, the first three and the last three. The middle, we have a standard text during the weekday, which is of 12, 13 blessings in the middle, and on Shabbat we change it to one beracha. Instead of the 12, we change it to one. Why? The Gemara says that the Chachamim wanted us to relax a little bit on Shabbat and not to say such a long Amidah and not to spend so much time. They want us to spend a little bit more time on oneg Shabbat. So therefore they shortened the Amidah. Instead of saying 13 blessings in the middle, they only made it one beracha. But really, you're supposed to have prayed Amidah, but we made it easier for you. Just pray only and say only one blessing. But if you already started on your own the other blessing, so you're not really doing anything against the Chachamim. We just remade the takanah for you to make it easier for you. But if you started already, you seem to have not minded, so therefore finish that blessing. This is only true by the three out of the four prayers, meaning to say the three out of the four amidot that we pray on Shabbat, which is Shacharit, Mincha, and Arvit of Leil Shabbat. However, by Musaf, Musaf, we don't say Musaf every single day, so therefore if a person made a mistake by Musaf and he started the wrong berachah, he started saying Atah Honen, then you stop, you cut yourself right in the middle, and you begin to count the Shabbat. You begin from the beginning of the amidah, not the beginning all the way, but I mean to say the beginning of the blessings of the amidah of Musaf. This is an important halacha. We'll discuss the second part of this halacha, be'ezrat Hashem, next week. Until then, we want to say thank you to J Radio and to all the listeners. Again, if a person wants to call in with the questions, I'll give you another five, ten minutes. We'll answer your questions off the air. The number is 718-683-5858, 347-927-8398 if you want to text in your question. And have a wonderful week and a wonderful Shabbat, be'ezrat Hashem. Shabbat shalom.
