Torah · HolidaysHolidaysCustoms of the Omer and Kemach Yashan Part 1Ben Ish Hai – HolidaysPart 1Rabbi Uri Nahum · April 29, 2015−15Play+30Position0:0057:24Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches holiday halacha in the Ben Ish Hai archive.Transcript0:00Welcome to Halacha Hour here on JRoot Radio on Wednesday afternoons, live at0:052 o'clock. Of course, with our customary0:08Sefardi timing, it's 2:05 right now. We are beginning now the Halacha Hour, where today, bezrat Hashem, we'll be talking about0:16an interesting subject. We'll begin with the0:20minhagim of0:21Sefirat HaOmer.0:22Even though we have a little bit of short time left,0:24but we'll begin with the minhagim of Sefirat HaOmer and jump to the subject of Kemach Hashem. First, we'd like to say we're dedicating this0:29class to0:31Iran and0:32Jacob and Baazrat Hashem, as well as the whole JRoot Radio staff. This is in their honor.0:37I believe it's already—we're up to year three, Baruch0:41Hashem. We've completed two full years here with the JRoot Radio,0:45and we owe them a lot of hakarat hatov personally. And I believe all of us0:49who are listening once, twice, all the time that we always listen to them, and0:53we'd just like to express our gratitude and tell them that we appreciate their avodat hakodesh,0:59and they should be, bezrat Hashem, zocheh liskulot mitzvot and yizku lehagdil Torah ulehadirah, bezrat Hashem.1:06Today, usually, let's just—we have to give you the numbers and the background usually before we begin,1:10so let's begin. First of all, the numbers to the studio:1:13718-683-5858. Remember, if you're calling, you'll be on live.1:17I don't know if I'll pick up the phone calls or not,1:19but in case you call between 2 to 31:23o'clock, that means you will be on air. If you'd like to ask questions off the air, then1:27call—please call in1:28718-683-5858, the same number, but call after 3, bezrat Hashem.1:32We'll try to stick around a little bit to answer any questions off the air.1:36To text in your questions, which is, like we say every week, it's the best idea.1:41Here it's כתוב ומפורש. It's written down over here.1:45We won't lose it, and this way we'll be able to answer you1:49in case we get to it, or if we will try to get to it.1:52The text line is1:55347-927-8398. This is how you could be interactive with the show, with the class. In order for a person to listen,2:03then there's a different2:05way to listen. You have different ways, that is jewradio.com, the website, and you could also2:12download it, or if you have it on your phone, Jew Radio Pro app, and you could also watch us on2:20jewradio.com live. To listen in through the phone, it's 712-432-4217 or2:30718-506-9099. With our regular introduction, we'll come back now to our class at hand. In the weeks between Pesach and2:35Shavuot, we've dedicated these weeks to discuss all the different halachot that pertain to these weeks.2:41We spoke about different subjects last week. We spoke about the halachot of how and when to count the Omer, with all the different2:50scenarios that come up.2:52We will be speaking, be'ezrat Hashem, now about the minhagim of2:56the Omer, or as they call them, the minhagim on the Sefirah. Some are familiar,3:00some are not familiar. With that, before we jump to the subject of3:05Kemahaya Shan, let's begin.3:06In these days between Pesach and Shavuot, the Gemara tells us in Masechet Yevamot that the great Tanna Rabbi Akiva,3:16Rabbi Akiva, which all the Mishnayot, Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, who was born actually on the day that Rabbi Akiva passed away,3:22all the Mishnayot Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi tried to model it after the teachings of Rabbi Akiva.3:28The Gemara tells us Rabbi Akiva had3:3024,000 students. As the Gemara points out elsewhere, it was really3:3512,000 pairs of students. That means 12,000 sets of chavrutot, and all these students died. They passed away.3:44Between the days of Pesach until3:49pros Atzeret. Pesach until pros Atzeret. That's what the Gemara says. What does it mean, pros Atzeret? Literally, pros means halfway.3:55We will see what that means in a second.3:58Tragedy, it was a big tragedy. I don't personally, I don't believe that it took place all in one year.4:06The Gemara doesn't say that it took place in one year.4:09I didn't see any commentaries that said that it took place in one year.4:12Perhaps these 24,000 students died throughout the years,4:15but the time that they died was in between Pesach and Shavuot. In any case, it was a big tragedy.4:20Can you imagine? Here it was the greatest rabbi of the generation with all these thousands of students.4:26You know, the biggest yeshiva today is around, I don't know, six, eight thousand people. That's not even a quarter4:34of the students of Rabbi Akiva, who were all4:37greatest of the greatest of the Jewish people in those times. That means they were Tannaim, and they passed away.4:42It was horrible. It was something really, really tragic. And the Gemara tells us,4:47al shelo nahagu kavod zeh bazeh, they were not4:51respectful to each other.4:53Whatever that means, again, many, many different explanations. Obviously, it was on their level.4:58They were expected to be on a very high level, and they didn't live up to it.5:03The Arizal explains5:05that maybe the sin was not so, so bad, their sin,5:10but he explains, al pi Kabbalah, that in this time between Pesach and Shavuot is5:16the time that you'll notice is when everything starts to grow.5:19Everything starts to grow. You'll look at the trees, they're starting to blossom.5:23That's why we say birkat ha'ilanot usually this time. You'll look at the produce in the fields.5:27Everything starts to grow, this season.5:30Well, even if it grows different times of the year, the5:34time of the year where things grow the most is at this time. And as a rule, when things grow,5:40it means it's a sign of blessing. And the rule is like this: whenever there's a sign of blessing,5:47there is also judgment.5:49The judgment is there to see if we deserve that blessing.5:53So being that everything, there's blessing in the world, everything is starting to grow,5:58this signifies that there's also judgment. It's6:02yemei din; we're being judged, and therefore everybody has to be on special, special guard.6:07Everybody has to take extra care that he should be on his best behavior. Says the Arizal, the reason why6:13midat hadin was able to get the students of Rabbi Akiva, even though they were holy people,6:18they had obviously so many zechuyot that perhaps if we combine all of our6:22zechuyot and our days, we can't, you know, compare to even one person.6:27Still,6:29they were caught in the zeh; they were caught even on small little things because it's6:34yemei din. Why? Because it's a time of growth, and time of growth means there's blessing in the world, and we are going to be6:40persecuted if we are not so, so careful in those days. So because of that, this6:48event that took place in Jewish history has ramifications in our days today in halacha. The6:58hachamim have—or really it's not the hachamim, it's a minhag. If it would have been hachamim, that means it would have been really7:05a gezeirah deRabbanan, but it's not. It's actually a custom that the Jewish people have accepted.7:09The Jewish people have accepted everywhere the customs that are known as the minhagim of Sefirat HaOmer.7:16The two that are spoken about in Shulchan Aruch are is that we don't make weddings in these days.7:22We don't make weddings. We don't make7:26engagements with music in these days. Also, because really, you know, our engagements today pretty much were like a wedding back then, you know.7:33And also what's brought down in halacha is that no haircuts and shaving. These are7:39minhagei aveilut, customs of mourning. Like if you see a mourner who goes through stages when somebody, one of his relatives passed away,7:46the stages are seven, the first seven days, then the first thirty days, and then the first year.7:52You'll notice that the minhagim of the omer are what every mourner goes through for the first thirty days, between the Shavuah.8:01And the shloshim, the mourner cannot shave. We also don't shave.8:05Mourner cannot take haircuts; we don't take haircuts.8:07A mourner cannot attend parties, even for a sibling in that first month.8:11Also, we don't make parties in this time.8:15That is a national ramification of what took place many years ago from the students of Rabbi Akiva.8:23Another question is, when is exactly the time?8:27Because the Gemara says, from Pesach until8:32pros Atzeret. That means the Gemara is not really explaining to me, telling me exactly what the time is.8:36We know they started dying from Pesach, I mean to say after Pesach,8:40or excuse me, from beginning of Pesach, but until when?8:44So for this, we have a big8:47machloket. We have actually two sets of8:49machloket. The first machloket is between the Shulchan Aruch8:52Rama. Shulchan Aruch, which is followed by the8:56Sefardim, and the Rama is followed by the8:59Ashkenazim. Pros Atzeret means half of a month. Half of a month is usually 15 days.9:03So if it's a half way through till Shavuot, half a month until9:09Shavuot, it should be 15 days before9:13Shavuot. Plus you have to— now that's plus you take away the three days of9:17shloshet yemei hagbalah. So it comes— excuse me— you take away half a month, which is 15 days from 49 days,9:22that comes out to a total of 34 days.9:26According to Shulchan Aruch, they passed away for 30— they died within a period of 34 days.9:31So therefore, we mourn for 33 days,9:34and on the 34th day, we apply the usual rule, which we apply by avelut,9:40miktsat hayom kechulo. You ever notice when people sit shiva, it's not really actually seven days?9:44They get up on the seventh day because once they sat part of the day,9:49which happens in the morning until they pray9:52Shacharit, then already it's considered like they sat the whole day.9:54That's the rule called miktsat hayom9:58kechulo. On the 34th day, which is the final day when the students of Rabbi Akiva passed away,10:02we get up. We complete our period of mourning,10:07and that's why Sefardim who want to take a haircut or technically shave,10:11you have until—you have to wait until the day after10:16Lag BaOmer, not on Lag BaOmer, but the day after10:19Lag BaOmer. However, the Ashkenazim hold, or the Rama really, which the Ashkenazim follow,10:24that really, you're right, people did die also on the 34th day,10:29but really mainly they died until the 33rd day.10:33And Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, who happened to be of the new students,10:36he also passed away then, and there's reason to celebrate on10:39Lag BaOmer, which everybody agrees to.10:42So therefore, the 33rd day is really the final day where the majority of the students died,10:47and although some did also die on the 34th,10:49but it's not important enough to make it a day of mourning,10:53and the 33rd day, we consider that, according to the Ashkenazim,10:58miktzat hayom11:00kechulo. Once the 33rd day comes in the morning,11:02after that we say that they could go ahead and take haircuts and shave.11:07This is not only the minhag of the Ashkenazim.11:08There are some Sephardic groups that also have such a minhag.11:17I believe the Egyptians as well also follow this minhag of the Ashkenazim,11:22that on the 33rd day, on Lag BaOmer, after praying11:27Shacharit, they already could take haircuts and they could shave,11:30and parties anywhere beginning on11:32Lag BaOmer, because Lag BaOmer in itself, we'll speak about it next week,11:35is a reason to11:36celebrate. So already parties could begin then, anyway.11:39But really, me'ikar hadin, the Sefardim is supposed to push over,11:42not make the celebration right away;11:44it's supposed to make the celebrations on11:48lamed-daled BaOmer. There's yet another machloket that's brought down in11:50halacha. Sefardim do not follow this at all.11:53Some Ashkenazim follow this minhag.11:55What is the minhag?11:57Some explain that when the Gemara says that they died between Pesach and Shavuot,12:04and remember it says,12:07there are 15 days when the students of Rabbi Akiva did not die.12:14These 15 days didn't take place right away.12:17This actually happened to be,12:20from the 49 days, there were 15 days where they did not die.12:22Which are they?12:23Well, you have, first of all, seven days of12:27Pesach, any times basically that we don't say12:33Tachanun, where we say Tzaddikim say Hishem. Basically, the seven days of12:35Pesach, six Shabbatot,12:37two days of Rosh Chodesh Iyar,12:39one day of Rosh Chodesh Sivan,12:42that totals up to what?12:44That totals up to the days when they didn't pass away,12:47minus that from 49 days, you come to 33 days.12:49So therefore, they hold that really as long as you mourn for 33 days12:55from the beginning of12:57Pesach, from right after12:58Pesach, second day of Pesach until Shavuot, that's good enough.13:01So therefore, they begin really from Rosh Chodesh Iyar.13:05They could shave, they stop shaving from Rosh Chodesh Iyar,13:09but they go all the way until13:12Shavuot. Now, although they don't really stop by13:15Shavuot, because they hold that three days before13:18Shavuot began what the Torah describes as shloshet yemei hagbalah,13:21when the Jews prepared themselves for the accepting of the13:24Torah. So they will wait until three days before13:27Shavuot until they take haircuts or whatever they have to do.13:30There's a chumrah in this,13:32is that although we're all taking haircuts and parties are beginning for us13:36from Lag BaOmer onwards,13:38they will celebrate on13:40Lag BaOmer. Some of them will even take haircuts on Lag BaOmer itself,13:43but after Lag BaOmer they resume their mourning period13:46until three days before13:49Shavuot. Halacha brings down, as Maran Shulchan Aruch says.13:53It is forbidden for a person to follow the leniencies of both customs.13:59You have to have one of the customs.14:02Sefardim, like I said, usually don't follow the second custom at all.14:05Sefardim will go until the 34th day, some to the 33rd day,14:09till Lag BaOmer, and they will not take haircuts and not make parties until the 34th day.14:14Ashkenazim will do it till the 33rd day.14:17But those who want to do from Rosh Chodesh Iyar until three days before14:22Shavuot cannot do both, cannot shave and make parties until Rosh Chodesh Iyar,14:25and then again after14:28Lag BaOmer take the other leniency and say from Lag BaOmer and onwards14:30I could also be lenient and make parties and shave and take haircuts then.14:33No. You have to choose one custom.14:36These are basically the different customs14:39al pi halacha. However, the Arizal, like we said above,14:41says that these days between Pesach and Shavuot are days of judgment, days of14:47din, and therefore he holds that haircuts—forget the parties,14:51the semachot, I agree, you want to mourn the students of Rabbi Akiva,14:54you're right, up to the 34th day if you're Sefardi and 33rd day14:58if you're Ashkenazi. But as far as shaving and haircutting,15:01the Arizal holds that nobody should take a haircut from Pesach until15:07Shavuot, not even the three days before,15:09and even in areas where the halacha permitted haircuts.15:12Lemashal, if a person is an avi haben, he had a baby boy,15:16and now the brit milah is taking place in the middle of the days of the Omer,15:20according to the Arizal, you can take a haircut.15:23You're getting married, you can15:26take—excuse me, not according to the Arizal; according to halacha, you can take a haircut.15:29According to halacha, if it's your wedding day, of course you can take a haircut.15:32However, if it's Lag BaOmer, of course halacha permits haircuts.15:35According to Arizal, no.15:37You have no excuse, not no excuse.15:40If you want to do the custom of the Arizal, no haircuts whatsoever.15:42It's zman of din. The hair cannot be cut until mamash erev Shavuot, the day before15:49Shavuot. That's the minhag of the Arizal, which a lot of mekubalim follow. A lot of mekubalim bring down.15:55Those who want to be mekubal, always we say the rule is we have to follow what the halacha says.16:00If a person now wants to be stringent, be machmir, follow mekubalim, chazak u'baruch, why not? If you can do it, fantastical,16:11but it doesn't obligate us.16:14So that's the minhag of the Arizal.16:15The only thing is, the Arizal never mentioned anything about shaving.16:17He only spoke about hair cutting.16:19What about shaving? The shaving16:21also, do I have to wait also until all the way until Shavuot that I shouldn't shave?16:26So because the Arizal never spoke about it, because according to the Arizal, in general you're not allowed to shave.16:32If the Arizal never allowed to shave,16:33so therefore Chacham Ben Tzion comes and he says,16:36chidush, and he says that really the Arizal only meant hair cutting.16:41But if you normally trim your beard or shave your beard,16:45so the Arizal doesn't apply to you because you are not in the—it's not applicable to you.16:52You anyway don't follow the Arizal throughout the year; you trim your16:54beard. The Arizal didn't never spoke about the beard.16:57That's what's brought down by Chacham Ben17:00Tzion. However, I have to tell you is that I've seen many17:05Sefardim—I'm talking about gedolim, rabbis—who follow the Arizal,17:09yet I never saw them trim their beard either by17:13Lag BaOmer. And we're talking about gedolim or rabbis that do usually trim their17:17beards; they'll wait until Erev17:19Shavuot. But the Chacham Ben Tzion says what he says, you can't take it away,17:22and it's also mistaber the way he explains it.17:25So those who want to follow the minhag of the Arizal,17:28not take haircuts until Erev Shavuot and want to trim their beard,17:31it's not a contradiction whatsoever.17:34Now there are other minhagim that are brought down by the17:37Acharonim. Shulchan Aruch only brings the issue with haircuts and weddings.17:42However, Acharonim bring other issues.17:44For example, no dancing, even without music we're talking about,17:47just, you know, regular dancing, hip hip hooray. No, you cannot do that.17:51No music also, not listening to music.17:54And Rav Chaim Palachi, although a lot of Acharonim disagree,17:57the Kaf HaChaim disagrees with this, but Rav Chaim Palachi also says18:00you should not make the blessing Shehecheyanu in the days of the Omer.18:03A lot of people mix up the days of Sefirat18:07HaOmer with the three weeks between Shiva Asar b'Tammuz and Tisha18:13B'Av. These are not the same,18:15rabotai. We're much more stringent over there18:17because of the churban Beit HaMikdash. Over here,18:19it's a custom; over there,18:20it's a din min haGemara.18:22Some of them are minhagim, but a lot of them are dinim min haGemara.18:26So therefore, some of the leniencies that people mix up are as follows.18:30First of all, if a person wants to make an engagement without any music,18:34what they call the meeting of the family or the18:36l'chaim, as long as it's without any music or dancing,18:38even in the days of Sefirat HaOmer, it's mutar.18:41Dating, for sure it's mutar, especially if a person has to get married,18:43especially if he's never got married18:46before. And even those who were married previously, it's still a mitzvah.18:50It's close to18:51an aveirah; if not, it's an aveirah to remain single.18:54Also, buying new clothing really is not a problem.18:57Even if you want to be stringent like Rav Chaim Palachi and not make19:01shehecheyanu, so then although buying clothing, it's mutar even without a sale.19:04So don't make19:05shehecheyanu. Don't wear it that you have to make19:06a shehecheyanu, or buy clothing that's not obligated in the bracha of19:12shehecheyanu. Haircuts, we mentioned already, is asur.19:13But the question comes up: what about haircuts for women?19:17If a woman wants to cut her hair, what is the19:20din? So remember what we said in the beginning,19:22that the minhagim in Sefirat HaOmer are19:26minhagei aveilut. So we have to revert back to the laws of19:29aveilut. What is the din when it comes to haircuts?19:33If a person is a mourner in the shloshim,19:36the Sefardim hold that after seven days, a woman can take a haircut.19:41Men are forbidden haircuts and shaving until the shloshim are over.19:45However, women do take19:48a haircut. So therefore, Sefirat HaOmer, which is only a minhag,19:51the minhag in these days of the Omer, it's only a custom.19:54It's not going to be more stringent,19:56according to us Sefardim. Women can take haircuts in these days,20:01no problem.20:02However, the Ashkenazim... Hold that women don't take haircuts in the shloshim20:08when it comes to avelut, in mourning, in the real mourning period.20:13In Sefirat HaOmer, the Grot Moshe, Rav Moshe Feinstein writes that the minhag is not to.20:18Minhag is that women do not take haircuts,20:20Ashkenazi women do not take haircuts in the days of the Omer.20:23However, if it's really necessary, there is definitely room to be lenient.20:29And now we come to children.20:31What about the20:32children? Again, we come back to the Shulchan Aruch or to the halacha20:36when it comes to children in the shloshim.20:39The only people chayav in avelut,20:42in minhagei avelut or avelut, even when a person passes away,20:46are people who are above the age of bar mitzvah,20:48not ketanim, not children under the age of bar mitzvah.20:51Usually we tell you a mitzvah is an obligation on adults,20:58and for children we obligate them because we train them.21:01We don't train children in avelut.21:05We don't want that the person should be repeating avelut,21:09right? So that's not something that we're mechanech our children with.21:12If a child becomes an avel since he's under the age of bar mitzvah,21:17the laws of avelut don't apply to him.21:18Some things will do just so because it doesn't look nice21:22or to, you know, stir up some feelings about the person who passed away,21:25but not because it's an obligation.21:27So therefore, for the Sefardim, again, we go straight.21:29The halacha says that for Sefardi children under the age of bar mitzvah,21:33they could take haircuts during any time21:36in Sefirat HaOmer. They don't have to wait till21:37Lag BaOmer. So if a kid really wants to take a haircut,21:40they could take a haircut.21:41That's21:43me'ikar hadin. Ashkenazim, however, hold that the minhag is not21:46to. Just like adults don't take haircuts in21:48the Omer, they also don't take haircuts in the days of21:53Sefirat—excuse me—yeah, also the children don't take haircuts also in21:56Sefirat HaOmer. And if you look around, really,21:57you'll notice that. Although, meikar hadin, according to Sephardim, children could take haircuts,22:01most people who are keeping Omer will apply it also to their children,22:05and they won't let them take haircuts either.22:08But really, in upsharing, which is when a kid turns22:11three, according to all22:12shitot, there's absolutely no problem with a child who turns three and you want to cut his hair.22:17There's no problem, even for a Jewish person cutting his hair.22:19It's not a problem to be done during these days of22:23Sefirat HaOmer. I'm talking about even before22:25Lag BaOmer. This, in short, are the halachot, or really the minhagim, that are done during the22:35Omer. And if anybody has a question, you could text in,22:38you could call in to the station right now.22:40We'll take the questions.22:41If not, we will move on.22:43You could call in later on, like we said, at22:45three o'clock. We are now going to move on to our next subject, which is a big subject.22:48I really hope we get through the main parts of this very, very important discussion,22:55which is Kemahiashan, marzat Hashem, before the end of this class.23:02Kemahiashan. I want to begin this class with a story that happened to me personally.23:06It was right after my first son was born,23:10and I was, you know, my wife gave birth in23:13Maayanot, and on my way back from the hospital, I was in Borough Park.23:15You know, we all know Maayanot is in Borough Park.23:17So I decided, you know what, it's Motzaei Shabbat,23:19let me pick up some pizza and I'll drive back home.23:22Now it was at the time, it was in the days of Selichot, in Elul,23:28and I pulled over the car in front of a pizza shop and I walk in.23:32Nobody was in the pizza shop.23:33I look behind the counter, nobody's there.23:35There's one person sitting by one of the tables in the restaurant,23:39and I turn to him, I say, Excuse me, do you know where's the23:42mashgiach? So the guy answers me with an Israeli accent,23:43so I started talking to him in Hebrew.23:46So I asked him,23:49Ata mashgiach? Amar li, Ken. Ani po, ani yodea, yachol lishol oti. You could ask me.23:51I'm just going to turn the conversation back to English, translate.23:54So I told him, Can I ask you a question?23:56He said, Sure.23:57Is your pizza kemach yashan?24:00So he tells me, Ma pitom? What are you talking about?24:04Everything is fresh.24:06I said,24:08Okay. I realized, okay, maybe he misunderstood me.24:10Now I said, No, no, no. I'm sure your pizza is fresh.24:13Now I just want to know, the kemach, the flour.24:15Now I'm talking to him in Hebrew,24:17Hakemach shelcha,24:18ze yashan o chadash?24:20Tells me, Ma pitom yashan? What are you talking about? It's old.24:22It's all fresh.24:23Everything we have here is fresh.24:24I said, No, no, you misunderstand me.24:26You know, in halacha, there's something for the doughs,24:31anything that's baked has to be kemach yashan.24:34Is your pizza kemach yashan?24:37So he says, No, everything is fresh.24:40So I said, Okay, you know what?24:42Thank you very much.24:43Have a good week.24:44And I started walking out of the store.24:45He's like, Eifo ata holech? Where are you going?24:46I'm telling you, I promise you, everything is fresh.24:49I said, No, you know what? It's24:50okay. I realized clearly that this guy has no clue what he's talking about.24:54Kemach yashan, the guy's clueless.24:57He never heard of kemach yashan.24:58So I get back into the car.24:59There are a few people with me in the car.25:01I said, Hey, where's the pizza? We're hungry.25:03I said, No, it's not kemach yashan.25:04I can't buy from here.25:06Right before I drove away, I looked up to see the name of the store,25:08and guess what?25:08I see a big sign with the name of the pizza store that says,25:12Pizza, fries, falafel, and25:16halavi... And guess what?25:17On the sign it says, Kemach yashan.25:20You know, I realized, wow,25:23okay, I don't know what to tell you.25:24The sign seems to know more than this person in the store who's supposed to be the25:28mashgiach. I don't know.25:29Definitely, I'm not going to take the sign.25:32I'm not going to eat it.25:33If the mashgiach himself doesn't know what kemach yashan is,25:35how do I know what he's checking for?25:36So therefore, it's been always on my mind to always speak about the subject kemach yashan in full detail.25:42What is it?25:43What are we talking about?25:45What in the world is this kemach yashan?25:46Why are people putting it up?25:48How stringent is it?25:49And if it's really so stringent, why are people not following this25:55halacha? And why? How come, more importantly,25:58how could hashgachot, if something is not kosher,25:59how could a hashgacha write kosher on it and sell it to everybody?26:03What in the world is going on over here?26:05So let me tell you.26:07To give this class has its pros and cons.26:10The pros are obviously we want people to be educated.26:13We want to create some awareness.26:15And let me tell you a big secret in kashrut.26:17You know how kashrut works?26:19You know how the standards of kashrut are elevated?26:23It's by you, the customer, not by me, the rabbi, speaking about it,26:27by you, the customer, demanding it.26:30Then the store owners will ask the vendors.26:34The vendors will make sure you have it.26:36That's the only way it happens.26:38If you don't demand it,26:40then it doesn't make a difference how much speeches rabbis give,26:43how much they speak about it,26:44how much the owners will learn about it.26:47At the end of the day,26:48nobody's opening up a restaurant, you know, for chesed.26:52They don't want to feed you because you're hungry.26:53They're opening up a restaurant to make money,26:55and whoever's buying, they're happy.26:57If nobody cares about any certain standard of kashrut,27:01so why would the store owners spend more money27:04to get to put themselves on that higher standard?27:06Do you see McDonald's getting a27:09hechsher? No. Only in Israel, where they want to attract the customers there, which are kosher.27:14That's the way it works.27:16If you don't demand it,27:17if you walk into a store and you demand something from kashrut,27:19let's say here, kemah yashan,27:20you say, Excuse me, is this yashan?27:22And the store owner, who is, let's say, an honest person, will tell you,27:25I don't know. I'm not sure. It's not.27:27You say, Okay, I can't buy it. Guess what's going to happen?27:30Next time you walk by, he's going to tell you,27:32Hold on, I got this item for you. It's kemah yashan.27:34And if it's done by two, three people, ten people,27:38then they'll have it.27:39I remember when I started keeping yashan,27:41it was very hard to find.27:43And now, Baruch Hashem, it's much more common.27:47Kedei begins, of course there can be games,27:48but it's much more available because of the awareness,27:51because people are demanding it,27:53and that's the rule in kashrut.27:54Ask anybody who's in kashrut, they'll tell you that's the rule.27:57If the customers demand it,28:00you, the listeners, are demanding it,28:03you will have it.28:05We make sure you'll have it,28:06and it doesn't have to be, by the way, so many people.28:08As long as even a few group of people, you'll get it.28:12It's like a vote,28:13you know, when they see you voting for a certain thing,28:15they'll make sure you have what you like.28:16So that's the advantage of giving such a class.28:19The disadvantage is that I'm scared of two things.28:24Number one is sometimes if you lay out everything on a table28:29and everybody sees that, you know, when it's a real,28:32you know, let's say something is really problematic28:34and people are doing it,28:35and they see that it's28:37assur and they continue to do the28:40issur, so then they will be judged on a higher level,28:44meaning to say that they're on a stricter level.28:46Up till now they were doing the28:47aveirah, they were not aware of the28:49aveirah. They were28:51shogegim. They did it by mistake.28:52They weren't sure,28:54although it's there for, they didn't learn.28:55True, but they're still doing aveirah, but28:58shogegim. Now that they know28:59and they're still going ahead and doing29:01aveirah, so become29:02mezidin. So therefore you see a lot of the poskim will say,29:05Be careful how you say it, who you say it to,29:08because then if people still are not going to listen to you,29:11they're going to go ahead and do the aveirah anyway,29:14and now you made them do an aveirah on a higher level.29:18That's one thing I'm worried about.29:20The other thing is29:21I'm worried that people will misuse the information here,29:24because I will bring a lot of different information.29:27I'm worried that people who will have listened to this class29:29will take parts, bits and pieces of the class,29:33and to a person who hasn't listened to the full class,29:37they'll— Present it in a way29:39that either they're keeping the29:41halacha or that they find kulot.29:43So listen, at the end of the day,29:44I decided to give the class anyway.29:46I saw29:49Chacham Ovadia in Teshuvot Yabia Omer, he writes,29:50you know, one time there was a certain thing29:52that people were not keeping.29:53It was a minhag, but it was a wrong minhag,29:56and he taught it in public29:57and he kept on speaking about it, speaking about it, speaking about it,29:59and Baruch Hashem, he says,30:01many years later already,30:02his words took fruit30:04and people already are starting to keep this thing,30:07and Baruch Hashem,30:09they've highered their standards of observance.30:12And that's what we say also over here.30:13Be'ezrat Hashem, we30:14hope—we're trying to do this30:16l'shem shamayim. We hope that people should learn from this30:18and that people should take these words30:20and, you know, improve themselves30:21in kashrut, improve themselves,30:23especially in this area of kemach hayashan,30:24as we'll see,30:25is something that is30:28mamash min haTorah, as we'll begin right now.30:30Let's go straight to the class at hand.30:34Torah in Parashat Emor30:36says the following.30:37The pasuk says,30:41Daber el bnei Yisrael ve'amarta alehem. Hashem is telling Moshe,30:42go tell the Jewish people30:43and tell them,30:47Ki tavou el haaretz asher ani noten lachem, when you come into Eretz Yisrael30:49that I'm giving to you,30:52uktzartem et ketzirah, you have to harvest all the produce,30:57vehevetem et omer reshit ketzirchem el hakohen, and whatever you harvest first,30:59you pile it up31:00and you bring it to the kohen.31:02This is known as31:03korban omer, which is when we count the omer31:04and we say,31:07Hayom asrim yom laomer. It's 20 days since we brought the31:10korban omer. What's this31:11korban omer? It's the first harvest of the year31:13has to be brought to the Beit HaMikdash.31:16The Torah, a few pesukim down,31:18the Torah says, however,31:24Velechem vekali vecharmel lo tochelu ad etzem hayom hazeh. All types of bread,31:26kali is even if the grains are dried in the sun,31:32karmel, or if they are roasted in an oven,31:36although not fully,31:38you're not allowed to eat it31:39until that day31:40that you have to bring the omer,31:44ad haviachem et korban Elokeichem, until you bring the offering31:46that God commanded you.31:50Chukat olam l'doroteichem. This is a law.31:51This is a rule31:53for all your generations,31:56bchol moshvoteichem, wherever you live.31:58Clearly the Torah says over here.32:00That you have to bring a korban,32:02and so long as you don't bring the korban,32:04you cannot eat whatever you cannot eat,32:06which we'll talk about soon,32:08until you bring that korban,32:09and the Torah says,32:11l'doroteichem. This is not a one-time thing.32:13This is not only when you enter32:14Eretz Yisrael. This is forever.32:16And here the Torah concludes,32:18b'chol moshvoteichem, wherever you live.32:19Like it says in the Torah,32:23lo teva'aru esh b'chol moshvoteichem b'yom haShabbat. Do not burn the fire32:25wherever you live on Yom HaShabbat.32:26This doesn't mean that you32:28don't burn the fire only in Eretz Yisrael on Shabbat.32:31Even outside of Eretz Yisrael,32:33do not burn the fire on Yom HaShabbat.32:35Okay, that is the pesukim.32:37You should just know,32:38to clarify what's going on over here,32:40the halacha says that32:42the Torah is talking about over here32:44only things that you can make bread out of it,32:47which the Torah describes as bread,32:48which are the five types of grain32:52where if it's baked32:53with flour,32:55if the ingredients are flour and water32:57and then baked, would create a33:00hamotzi. What are these five grains?33:01In English they're translated as wheat,33:03barley,33:05oats, rye, and spelt.33:07These five grains, the Torah tells us33:09over here, that33:11they cannot be eaten until you bring a korban.33:14What does that33:14mean? We don't have a korban today.33:17We don't have a korban today. You're telling me I can never eat it?33:19And also, when is this korban brought?33:22And the answer to33:23this question is as follows.33:25This is the way it works.33:29Anything—let's start like this.33:31The korban is brought on the second day of33:33Pesach, which means on tet-zayin Nisan.33:37Anything33:38that took33:39root from the year beforehand,33:42from before,33:43mean to say before tet-zayin Nisan already33:45was planted and it took root already,33:47then33:49that makes it last year's33:51produce. When Tezayin Nisan33:53comes, when we had a33:55Beit HaMikdash and we offered the korban,33:58then all the produce33:59that we took root already from before34:02Tezayin Nisan,34:03laws become permitted. However,34:05if you started planting something from these five34:08grains after Tezayin Nisan,34:09or even34:11if you planted it before Tezayin Nisan but didn't34:13take root yet, according to halacha it takes about34:15two weeks for something, for34:18a seed to take root. So let's say34:19you planted it34:21Erev Pesach and it didn't take root until34:24after Pesach, which usually doesn't.34:26So then, even34:28though it grew after a34:30month, it doesn't make a difference. That34:32produce becomes next year's34:34stuff, and it's forbidden34:36to eat until the next34:38Tezayin Nisan, until the next34:40Pesach comes and we34:42bring the korban. This is in the times of34:44Beit HaMikdash. So again, let's34:46review just very quickly.34:47Any produce of last34:50year becomes34:51permitted once the second day of Pesach comes34:53because we brought a korban.34:56Anything34:57of the next year, anything that34:59has been planted or taken root35:01really after35:03Pesach or after the second day of35:05Pesach, is considered35:07the produce of the following year, and thus35:09the name chadash and yashan.35:11Yashan is produce from last year.35:13Chadash is anything from this year.35:15Last year's stuff35:17becomes mutar on the second35:19day of Pesach. Even though today we don't have a35:21Beit HaMikdash, still,35:23because we don't have a35:25Beit HaMikdash, you don't have to actually bring the korban to make it35:27mutar. You just have to wait that full day in35:29Eretz Yisrael, outside35:31Eretz Yisrael, because you have to wait until the first day of35:34Chol HaMoed. So35:36let's quote to you35:37the Rambam. He says,35:39and who summarizes everything in short:35:50A chadash, ketzad? Kol echad me-chamishah minei tevuah bilvad, asur le'echol me-chadash shelo, kodem sheyikra ba'omer b'tet-zayin b'Nisan. All the produce35:51from the five grains only35:53that we listed, you cannot eat35:55from the new crops35:58until the omer was brought35:59on Tet-Zayin Nisan.36:04V'chol ha'ochel kezayit chadash kodem hakravat ha'omer, and if you do eat it beforehand,36:07lokeh min haTorah, you get lashes36:09from the Torah.36:15Ela shebizman she'Beit HaMikdash, misheyikrav ha'omer hutar ha'chadash biYerushalayim. The only difference36:16is that when36:18in the times we had36:20Beit HaMikdash and the korban was offered on the 16th of Nisan,36:23everything becomes mutar immediately36:24if you live in Yerushalayim and you knew36:25that the korban already was brought.36:30U'kemoti hokin mutarim achar chatzot, and if you lived further36:32from Yerushalayim, away from Yerushalayim, you had to36:34wait until middle of the day36:36for you to eat the36:38produce that took36:40root before the 16th36:42of Nisan.36:45U'vizman she'ein Beit HaMikdash kayam, kulo asur min haTorah. However,36:47in36:48nowadays, the whole day becomes36:50asur min haTorah, and the next day36:52permits us to36:54eat the produce that took root before36:56Tet-Zayin Nisan.36:58This is, rabotai, what kemach yashan is.37:00Kemach yashan is37:02basically any produce37:04of these five grains37:06that took root in the ground37:08before the second day of Pesach,37:10and if it took root37:12afterwards, it becomes37:14kemach chadash, or people know37:16as chadash. This is37:18the background from the Torah.37:20The question is now37:22the application of this halacha.37:24And a lot of people are37:26wondering, one second, if it's min haTorah, you know, I know37:28pig is asur, I know horse meat is37:30asur, I know if you have a kosher animal37:32and it wasn't slaughtered properly, it's37:33asur. So how come I never knew about this?37:35Is this something that only pertains to Eretz Yisrael37:37or even outside of Eretz Yisrael?37:39So you should know, in Eretz Yisrael,37:41everybody agrees that the produce37:43that is chadash is asur.37:47Nobody denies it.37:48Nobody disagrees. Everybody agrees37:49that's asur. And about 90%37:51of the poskim hold that it's37:54asur min haTorah. The question is,37:56outside of Eretz Yisrael,37:58away from Eretz Yisrael,37:59the people, for the Jews outside of Eretz Yisrael,38:01what is the38:04din? Do we say that this halacha38:06is only something that applies in38:07Eretz Yisrael or even to the produce outside of Eretz Yisrael?38:11Guess what? There's a38:12machloket in the Gemara. There's a machloket as far back38:14as the Mishnayot.38:16The machloket depends38:18on how you explain the pasuk38:20that we quoted above that says the38:22words38:23moshvoteichem. Moshvoteichem means your dwellings.38:25There are two ways to explain this pasuk,38:27and that's the two opinions in the Mishnah38:29as well as the Gemara.38:31One way to explain it is the Torah is commanding you38:33that this issur of38:37kemach chadash is applicable38:38b'chol moshvoteichem, wherever you live.38:40So if you live in Israel, it's38:42asur. If you live in China,38:43it's also38:45asur. If you live in America, wherever you live,38:48b'chol moshvoteichem, as long as you're a Jew, it's38:51asur. The other way to explain38:53b'chol moshvoteichem, the Torah is commanding us a time.38:55After you settle in Eretz Yisrael,38:57because moshvoteichem means38:59yeshivah, which is39:02yishuv, after you settle in39:03Eretz Yisrael, which means after the 14 years where the Jews39:06went to war39:07with the non-Jewish nations in Eretz Yisrael39:09and they actually settled down39:11and they divided the land,39:14after that then becomes39:15asur, but only in Israel. Outside of Israel,39:16it's mutar. Those are the two opinions39:19that we find in the Mishnah.39:21Question is39:23having a rule of halacha.39:24So let me read you the Mishnah.39:27The Mishnah says,39:29one Mishnah says39:30that it's a39:33machloket. There's a machloket between39:34the39:38Tana Kama and Rabbi Eliezer. According to the39:40Tana Kama, chadash doesn't apply in Chutz39:42La'aretz. According to39:44Rabbi Eliezer, even Chutz La'aretz, chadash is applicable.39:47There's a second Mishnah39:49that says,39:50Hachadash asur min haTorah b'chol makom.39:53Over there it doesn't bring a39:55machloket. Over there it says clearly39:56that this chadash, kema39:59chadash, is forbidden.40:00From the Torah, everywhere.40:30That means, according to this second Mishnah, chadash, one who eats kemach chadash, is no different from eating pig. We all know pig is asur. Chadash is also asur. Both of them, as the Rambam says, one who eats pig will get malkut; a person who eats chadash also gets malkut. In fact, according to halacha, chadash may be even more strict than non-kosher meat. Why? Because if non-kosher meat accidentally gets mixed with other foods, so we come to the rules of40:33bitul. What does mean40:33bitul? It can be nullified if it's batel b'rov, or you need40:38bitul b'shishim. However, chadash, if it gets mixed up with kemach yashan, will be asur even if it's batel.40:49Even though I have majority, or sixty times the amount of kemach yashan,40:55and I have a little bit of chadash mixed in it, the whole thing becomes asur.40:58You know why?41:01Because it's davar sheyesh lo matirin.41:02What does mean davar sheyesh lo matirin?41:05Davar sheyesh lo matirin means that if something is forbidden and it got mixed in a mixture,41:11we always look to see if what is permitted in the mixture outnumbers what's forbidden.41:19In a case where the permitted ingredient outnumbers the forbidden ingredient,41:25usually we say it's mutar.41:26However, davar sheyesh lo matirin means that eventually even that which is forbidden will become mutar.41:33Even that which is forbidden will eventually become mutar.41:36So in that case, hachachamim said even though it's really batel, and really technically41:40had it been other foods you could have eaten it, still don't eat it now.41:43Wait till after the time when it becomes mutar and eat the whole mixture together.41:48So being that kemach chadash is really davar sheyesh lo matirin,41:52it becomes a little more chamur than non-kosher meat.41:55Non-kosher meat, if it got mixed up in other food, b'diavad, and you have bitul, it's batel, you can eat it.42:02Chadash, if it got mixed up with other foods, it's davar sheyesh lo matirin;42:05you have to wait until the next year when it's Nissan, when it's Pesach, to be able to eat it.42:13The question is now, what is the halacha? What does the halacha say?42:17The Beit Yosef brings that the three Rishonim, the three major42:21Rishonim, the Rif, the Rambam, and the Rosh, all of them hold42:27that kemach chadash, the new produce which grows or takes root after42:36Pesach, is asur mideoraita. It's asur from the Torah,42:40b'chol makom uv'chol zman. It's asur everywhere. It's asur in42:45Eretz Yisrael, it's asur outside of Eretz Yisrael, it's asur in China, it's asur in America, everywhere it's asur.42:50That's what the Beit Yosef quotes, three42:53Rishonim. However, the Biur Halacha brings a list of nine42:58Rishonim. Nine Rishonim means nine rabbis that lived from the times before the43:02Shulchan Aruch. They all ruled that kemach chadash is asur min43:08haTorah. However, there are other opinions, there are other43:13Rishonim. The Penei Yehoshua brings Rabbeinu Baruch, the Or Zarua, and the Bahag.43:19These are three Rishonim that hold that kemach chadash is only asur43:27miderabbanan. And being that it's only asur miderabbanan, so that's in Eretz Yisrael.43:32So therefore, only the countries that are close to Eretz Yisrael,43:36they're the ones who have a problem with43:38derabbanan. But the countries that are far away from Eretz Yisrael, they don't have the problem of43:43chadash. So therefore, if you lived in Europe, or if you live in Europe, or you live in America, or if you live in China,43:47according to these three Rishonim, Rabbeinu Baruch, Or Zarua, and Bahag,43:50they hold that it's mutar.43:53However, the Rosh comments on Rabbeinu Baruch, and he says,43:57Devarav temuhin.43:59All the words of Rabbeinu Baruch are very strange,44:02ura'ayotav ein bahem mamash.44:05All the proofs that he brought have no substance to them.44:09I don't know what he means, that says the Rosh, and you cannot follow Rabbeinu Baruch.44:13That's what the Rosh says.44:14Okay, so it's a machloket rishonim.44:17At best, it's a machloket rishonim.44:19You have nine major Rishonim that hold asur44:21min haTorah, and a few Rishonim that hold44:24it's only asur miderabanan, and outside of Eretz Yisrael, it's not, you know, far away from44:28it, it's not even asur at all.44:32What's the psak halacha in Shulchan Aruch? Maran writes in two places,44:34here in Hilchot of the Sefrat HaOmer,44:37siman taf-pei-tet in Orach Chaim, the last44:40halacha, and in44:42Yoreh De'ah, siman reish tzadi-gimmel, Maran writes the following:44:48Asur le'echol chadash af bizman hazeh. It's asur to eat any of the new produce even nowadays,44:52bein lechem, bein kali, no matter what it is,44:57ad techilat leil yud-chet b'Nisan, until the beginning of the 18th of Nisan,44:59which we know is the first night of45:03Chol HaMoed, u'be'eretz Yisrael ad techilat leil zayin b'Nisan, in Israel, until the first night of45:06Chol HaMoed, which is on the 17th of Nisan.45:08He adds in45:14reish tzadi-gimmel, issur chadash noheg bein ba'aretz bein bachutz la'aretz. This issur applies in Israel45:18as well as outside of Israel,45:22bein b'shel Yisrael, bein b'shel ovdei kochavim, whether the produce belongs to a Jew45:26or belongs to a goy.45:27Don't think that, oh, you know, it's a non-Jewish produce.45:30What do you want from him? He doesn't have to keep the Torah,45:32so I'm buying from him. No. It doesn't go by the owner;45:36it goes by the plant. Where was it planted?45:40When was it planted? Was45:43the plant—did it take root before Tet-Zayin Nisan,45:46or did it take root afterwards? That's45:49the ikar. If it took root afterwards, it becomes45:52chadash, and according to Shulchan Aruch, it is asur45:55mide'oraita, like we said, equivalent to eating non-kosher meat.45:59The Rama in Yoreh Deah, however,46:02brings that in general,46:04if you don't know about the produce that you have in front of you,46:07and you know that it came to you obviously after46:11Pesach, you don't know now if it's from the new crop or from the last year's crop,46:15he says it's mutar because of a46:18safek sfeika, which we'll discuss later on.46:20However, that's only if you don't know.46:23If you do know that the produce that you have at hand,46:27the majority at least of the produce came from the new stuff,46:30even though there's a possibility that also maybe some of the things that you have46:32may have been planted from way before46:35Pesach, since the majority comes from produce46:38that has taken root after Pesach, which we know as46:43chadash, then he says46:45yesh lachmir v'lachush min hastam, then you have to be stringent and to be46:49choshesh. That's the Rama here46:51in siman רסג, yoreh deah. That's his ruling.46:53He says it straight out:46:57אסור לאכול חדש אפילו בזמן הזה. So it comes out really now47:00that this issur of47:02kemach chadash is not a minhag, it's not a custom.47:08For the Sefardim, it's halacha lemaaseh, it's asur.47:10For the Ashkenazim, the47:13Rama writes, okay, you have to have47:16safek sfeika, right? If you're not sure when it was planted, and even if it was planted47:20beforehand, maybe it's this year's produce, last year's produce.47:22The big question is exactly how the safek sfeika works,47:25but that's the Rama. So that's a very, very big thing.47:28If it's so asur, how come people don't talk about it?47:32How come people don't keep it?47:34How come people feel that kemach yashan is only a47:38chumra? So because of that,47:40you look in the sefarim and the poskim,47:42you find that it's very, very strange when it comes to47:47kemach. Chadash, all the poskim, when they discuss it, they bring47:50heterim, but the heterim, the leniencies that they bring47:52are very, very, very weak.47:54You see that the approach to the poskim themselves, when they begin to discuss it47:58and they want to bring some leniencies.48:00is there themselves don't feel like they can, you know, like they're telling you48:07lechatchila. Ninety-five percent of the poskim don't say that this is lechatchila, with the exception of the48:12Bach. Everybody else, whole—you see the lashon. You have to always look in the halacha,48:16not only what the poskim say, but how they say it. You know, they're not writing you mutar, asur.48:21There's books and books and books discussing every psak halacha that they give.48:24You see the approach to this halacha by the poskim, even those who are lenient.48:28Of course, like we just saw, many poskim are not lenient. Even those who are lenient,48:33it always sounds like they're trying to dig themselves out of a hole. Most of the time they're saying,48:39lelamed zechut, meaning people are doing this anyway,48:42and we're going to try to somehow figure out a way that it could be mutar according to them.48:48Why? Because it's very, very necessary. I want to read you two poskim that are known by anybody who learns halacha,48:55and what they write about the leniencies about48:58kemachadash. First, the Kaf HaChaim. He is siman taf-pei-tet, kuf yud alef. He writes,49:02Haheter shel chadash bizman hazeh bachutz laaretz hu49:08poreach vaavir. The leniency of allowing kemachadash in our days outside of Eretz Yisrael49:13is something that's up in the air, which means it has no real foundation.49:17Verov harishonim sorim deasumna Torah gam49:21bachutz laaretz. Majority of the poskim hold, the majority of rishonim hold, that's forbidden49:27mideoraita, even outside of Eretz Yisrael.49:28Verabim dachaku acharin lelamed zechut al otam49:32sheein nizharim bazeh, and the acharonim squeezed themselves very, very, very much to try to find some sort of49:40zechut, some sort of leniency, to try to allow the people who are not careful with chadash.49:45That's what the Kaf HaChaim writes.49:47The Beit HaLevi. Which one of the commentaries found on the side of the Shulchan Aruch in49:52Yoreh Deah, he writes,50:02Heter chadash b'zman hazeh, barabu פירושים שונים וגאונים שחיפשו בדקו בשבע חקירות ובדיקות, ולא עלתה בידם היתר גמור וברור. The lenient to allow a person to eat chadash,50:05many, many people tried, many geonim, geniuses in the50:10poskim tried to find some sort of50:13heter, and nobody really found a clear heter that they themselves are convinced by.50:18But yet we find some leniencies.50:20The first one that we do find some leniencies,50:22we're going to bring you over here a few leniencies50:24and the issues with each leniency.50:26Let's begin with the50:27Rama. The Rama writes that from the new50:32crop—no, but the Rama, by the way, never says that chadash is mutar.50:35The Rama just says if you don't know from the five grains,50:39let's say you bought flour,50:40you're not sure if it's kemach yashan, it's not50:42kemach yashan. So the Rama says50:44if you know that the majority of the produce is from last year's stuff,50:48it's probably yashan,50:50then okay, you don't have to ask,50:51you're fine,50:52you could be50:54somech, you could say50:56safek sfeika. I can't go into the details now50:58of safek sfeika, but Rav Akiva Eiger already has a question51:00that this safek sfeika doesn't follow the rules of51:03safek sfeika. It's really one safek, not really two.51:05Also, the Rama himself writes51:11that even though really a person should be51:14machmir, if people will not listen to him,51:17don't say anything because mutav sheyihyu shogegin v'al yihyu mezidin.51:20Like we explained51:21beforehand, mutav sheyihyu shogegin means they're really doing51:24an aveirah, but if you publicize it and they're not going to listen to you,51:27so they're going to do it on purpose,51:28which means according to the Rama it's really a problem.51:30Also, the Rama's heter of51:32safek sfeika, even if you want to hold that's a valid51:35safek sfeika, as Aruch HaShulchan and others try to explain,51:38still it doesn't work if you do know51:41that the produce in front of you is51:42chadash. If you know for sure that what I have in front of me51:44is really from this year's crop.51:47You can eat it according even according to the Ashkenazim.51:50And finally, this whole heter of the51:52Rama is really only according to the Ashkenazim,51:55if they want to be relying on it.51:57But according to the51:58Sefardim, we have to follow the ruling of52:00Shulchan Aruch, who holds that's52:03asur min haTorah. That's one heter and the issues with it.52:05The second heter that's very famous52:07is the heter of the52:09Bach. The Bach comes out with a major, major52:13chiddush, and he says52:16that—he argues, of course, on52:18Shulchan Aruch, he argues on ... סעיף 14,52:19he writes that chadash does not apply52:23if the owner of the produce is a goy.52:27If the owner of the produce is52:28a goy, it does not apply.52:29It's a major52:30chiddush by the Bach. It's arguing on52:33almost all the52:34Rishonim; for sure it's arguing on52:35Shulchan Aruch. And not only that,52:37all the Acharonim disagreed with52:39the Bach. The Bach remains52:41a daat yachid. Nobody agreed with the52:42Bach. Listen to the words of the52:44Gra. The Gra writes52:48in Yoreh Deah, ... כל אחרונים. All the Acharonim hit the Bach on his head,52:51which means to say52:54they all knocked him out, ... and says the52:56Gra—we can't say52:56this—but the Gra writes52:58there was a mistake.52:59The Bach made a mistake in his53:02psak halacha. His own son-in-law, the Taz,53:03goes and refutes the proofs that he brings.53:07The some Chassidim are53:09lenient when it comes to53:11chadash because they hold53:12of—they say because the Baal53:14Shem Tov, the Baal Shem Tov didn't keep this53:17halachot. Why?53:17Because Baal Shem Tov relied on the53:19Bach. I want to bring53:19you—I have in my house53:21Baal53:22Shem Tov al haTorah, in Parashat53:23Emor, they bring over there53:24this whole source of the Baal Shem Tov being lenient.53:27It says over there53:28the Baal Shem Tov asked53:30a she'elat chalom, which means he asked53:31the question which he was answered to in this dream.53:34He asked,53:35what is the din with53:39chadash bizman hazeh? In his days, in the 1700s,53:41he wanted to53:42know what should be the psak, what should we rule53:43when it comes to53:45chadash. So I'm going to read you word for word53:47what it says.53:48It53:48says, they answered him in his dream,53:56shele'achar petirat haBach, sanenu tagehinam mim yom, michmat shehaya tzaddik, zelichvod haBach. After the passing of the53:58Bach, in Shamayim53:59they cooled off54:01Gehinam for 40 days.54:03Why?54:04Because they needed to do this54:05in honor of the54:08Bach. Now, this over here,54:10the continues over there.54:12After he woke up,54:12the Baal Shem Tov woke up,54:13what does he say?54:15He asked people,54:15do me a54:16favor, go and bring me54:17sheicha, go give me some alcohol from the goyim,54:19even though it's54:21chadash. And he says the following words:54:25Kedai haBach shematir, kedai lismoch alav. I see from my dream54:27that since they cooled off54:30Gehinam for 40 days,54:32it must be that the Bach is somebody that's so important in Shamayim.54:34They cooled off all of54:36Gehinam in honor of the54:37Bach. Then you know what?54:40He's a good enough opinion54:41that I should rely on him.54:43What does that mean?54:44So it means that54:46the Bach is a big54:46posek, I can rely on him.54:47I have three issues over here.54:50First of all,54:51we have a rule,54:53lo bashamayim hi. As great as the Bach was,54:55at the end of the day54:55it doesn't take him away from54:56being a daat54:57yachid according to54:58halacha. We find in the Gemara54:59that there was a55:01bat kol, a heavenly voice came out55:03and said,55:03This rabbi is correct,55:05leave him alone,55:05and still55:06Rabban Gamliel gets up and says,55:07We don't rule halacha this way.55:09Lo bashamayim hi. We decide the halacha over here.55:11We always have55:12machloket between poskim.55:13And even55:14if Shamayim, they tell us this rabbi is so great,55:16at the end of the day55:17we have to follow our rules,55:19acharei rabim lehatot, and not only that,55:21when we have a daat55:22yachid, it's usually dismissed.55:24Number two is,55:25from the words of the Baal Shem Tov,55:27even from the Baal Shem Tov55:28it sounds like it's a problem,55:29because what did he say?55:31Kedai ha-bach shematir kedei lismoch alav.55:33If you need to rely on somebody,55:35the bach is good enough to rely on him.55:37It sounds like he's not so glad with it.55:39The third, which55:41most people do not know55:42and have it in this book,55:43it says over there in55:45Midrash—he quotes from a55:46book called Midrash55:46Pinchas, which is one of the55:48Chassidush sefarim—he says,55:49I'm going to read you word for word55:50what it says over there:55:51HaBaal Shem Tov haya mekel55:53bechadash. Baal Shem Tov used to be very lenient55:55in the issur of chadash. U'paam nasa im Rabbi Chiel keshena'asa rav beHorodna.56:00And one time he traveled with Rabbi Noam Rabbi56:02Yechiel. When he became an official rabbi in56:04Horadna, v'ra'ah shechmir, his own Rabbi Yechiel was also stringent,56:08hitchil gam hu lehachmir. So therefore, the Baal Shem Tov decided56:11that he also wants to begin to be stringent as well.56:15So you see, it sounds like the Baal Shem Tov himself was56:18chozer. He already said, I'm going to become machmir again,56:23and I'm going to keep already kema yashan.56:25In any case, that is the opinion of the56:28Bach. We have still a lot more to speak on the subject,56:31but I'm already overdue on time.56:33We're going to take a break here.56:34Next week, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll continue with this important subject of kemach yashan and56:40kemach chadash. Make sure you join us next week, be'ezrat Hashem, on Wednesday,56:42and the extra time we'll dedicate also to speak about lag56:46ba'omer. We want to give you the numbers.56:47If anybody has questions, you could call into the station right now.56:51The number is56:55718-683-5858, and if you'd like to text in,56:58347-927-8398. Again, this class is dedicated to Iran and the whole J Radio staff57:03and Nissim, of course,57:04and we want to tell them a thank you.57:07On behalf of all the Jewish people, we want to tell them a thank you for the57:10avodat hakodesh. This class will be aired on again tonight on Wednesday at 1157:15p.m. Till next week, rabotai, have a wonderful week,57:18Shavua tov,57:19and don't forget, Pesach Sheni is on Sunday.