Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRoot Radio. This is the Halacha Hour, live on Wednesday afternoon, on Erev Rosh Chodesh Adar, Tav Shin Ayin0:11 Hey. We're here in the studio. We'll be on from 2 to 3 o'clock. In the Halacha Hour,0:15 it's the halacha class based on the Ben Ish Chai, where we go through the halachot, clarify the sources of the halachot and the practical application,0:24 how to apply the halachot in our days, bringing up all the different whatever we can, whatever we could have our hands on, basically.0:32 We're here in JRoot in the studio. You can listen to us live on0:39 JRootRadio.com. Also, you could watch us live on JRootRadio.com. There is live streaming.0:43 You could also listen on your phone in a number of ways.0:47 Number one is you download the app. The app is called JRoot Radio Pro app.0:52 The other way is by calling in either 718-506-9099, or you could call in, the other number is1:07 712-432-4217. Before we give the numbers to the studio, let's tell everybody who's listening that today's class is dedicated again, l'refuah sheleimah of Rita1:15 Bat Vania, as well as Eliyahu Chaim ben Shafika Sofia, and as well as Ayala Gazale Bat Rima.1:20 Hashem should give them all a speedy recovery bimheirah, very, very soon.1:24 Our class today, the subject is shvut d'shvut, which we began to speak about last week.1:29 This is a very, very important halacha in the halachot and the laws of Amira l'akum, of what one is allowed to command a goy to do for him on Shabbat.1:39 This is probably one of the most practical halachot of Amira l'akum that we probably will use in our days.1:47 It's a very important halacha. We began last week, for more details, just as the background from the Gemara and the Rishonim,1:54 you'll have to listen to last week's classes on the archives.1:59 Today, be'ezrat Hashem, we're going to review very quickly what we mentioned last week, very quickly,2:03 and move on now to the more practical side of the2:07 halacha, several examples of when a person may or may not. Or if he could or could not tell a goy to do something for him on Shabbat,2:17 we'll bring some more common examples, and then you're more than welcome to call in or text in your questions.2:23 Better to text in your question. Hopefully we're able to answer it in2:27 Amiyah La'Akum. I do have to note, this is not going to cover all the halachot of2:32 Amiyah La'Akum. What we'd like to do on the halacha hour is that we give a clear explanation of what the halachot are, the backgrounds, the reasons, and then the practical application.2:44 Things that we did not discuss, I don't like to give really so much of it because it could be misunderstood.2:49 It could be sometimes a certain case may be permitted or a certain case may be forbidden, and a person will learn from it something else.2:57 So that's why we ask that if you call in, try to call in on things that we specifically speak about.3:03 The number to the station is 718-683-5858. The text number is3:12 347-927-8398. As we mention every week, at the end of the class, we are still here. We'll be here in the studio for another few minutes,3:20 and then you could call in and ask whatever questions you like, especially on the subject of3:24 Amiyah La'Akum. I want to point out that next week we are now Erev Rosh Chodesh.3:28 Tonight is Rosh Chodesh Adar. It's the 30th of Shvat, really, two days Rosh Chodesh.3:33 Friday is Rosh Chodesh Adar, which means Adar Aleph,3:37 which means that next week already we'll begin the laws of Purim.3:43 That's right, Purim is right around the corner. Thursday, March 5th.3:46 Wednesday, March 4th at night is the Leil Purim, when we have to hear the Megillah,3:51 and March 5th is when we have to already listen to the Megillah in the day and all the mitzvot of the Purim.3:56 So right before we get into our halachot, let's just mention a small idea.4:03 Chazal tell us that Rosh Chodesh Adar,4:07 משמיעין על השקלים. When it comes to Rosh Chodesh Adar, we already make announcements about bringing the4:11 shekalim. What does this mean?4:12 Once upon a time, when we had the Beit HaMikdash, and that was the center and that was the focus of Jewish life,4:19 everything revolved around the Beit HaMikdash. It wasn't the Super Bowl, it wasn't what's going on in the news.4:24 It's the Beit HaMikdash, our service and our relationship to HaKadosh Baruch Hu.4:30 The period of Rosh Chodesh Adar was the time when they prepared already for the korbanot of the next year.4:36 The Torah commands that every single year we bring korbanot on behalf of all the Jewish people,4:42 and the year must have a collection for it.4:46 Meaning to say, in order for everybody to be considered a partner in the korbanot that are brought on a daily basis,4:54 as well as the ones that are brought on the holiday, those are all called korbanot4:58 tzibur. These are sacrifices which are offered on behalf of all the Jewish people.5:02 If it's offered on behalf of me, as well as you and everybody else, so we all have to be partners in it.5:07 How do we become partners in it?5:09 We all can't slaughter the animal, we can't throw the blood. That's services.5:12 Those are avodot that are unique and designated only for the Kohanim.5:17 So what do they do?5:19 The way we participate, the way we joined the korbanot that were brought by the Kohanim,5:23 is by giving money.5:25 How much do we have to give?5:27 Mahatzit ha-shekel. It's not a lot of money, but a little bit of money from a lot of people makes big money.5:33 A little bit of each person.5:34 Each person has to give just a mahatzit ha-shekel, a half a shekel, a silver shekel, to the Beit HaMikdash,5:39 and that was all collected together, and that was enough to buy the korbanot,5:44 to buy the animals for the following year, which began on Rosh Chodesh Nisan.5:50 Rosh Chodesh Adar is the time we already make announcements, and5:54 we remind everybody, Rabotai, make sure you bring in your mahatzit ha-shekel for the following year,5:59 and that we don't have the Beit HaMikdash,6:01 that we are already how many years, almost 2,000 years without a Beit HaMikdash.6:08 We still remember the times we used to bring mahatzit6:12 ha-shekel, and we still announce and we tell,6:16 Rabotai, mashmi'in al ha-shekalim. Even though we cannot bring a shekel, it's asur for us to say,6:20 This is mahatzit ha-shekel, because we're making it kodesh,6:23 we're making it holy for the Beit HaMikdash, which is not around,6:26 and chas v'shalom, if somebody would use it or really misuse it,6:29 it could be very, very problematic.6:31 Still, zecher le-mahatzit ha-shekel, as a commemoration for the mahatzit ha-shekel that was given,6:39 we still read Parashat... Shekalim, like we read last week in shul,6:43 we still give, as a minhag, as a custom, we still give a certain amount of money,6:49 whatever that money is every year, depending on the silver or whatever custom you have,6:54 for the memory, in memory of machatzit hashekel.6:57 And we want to know, a little bit on a practical level, how does this apply to us?7:01 What can we learn, a small thing about shekalim, about Rosh Chodesh?7:05 So a small idea, mainly taken from the Chiddushei Harim, the Or7:12 Gedalyahu, and other sefarim as well. The Chassidish sefarim explain7:17 that shekel, the machatzit hashekel, Chazal tell us7:22 that when Hashem told Moshe Rabbeinu machatzit hashekel,7:26 He showed him a shekel made out of fire.7:29 He showed him, basically, a silver coin made out of fire,7:33 so it's really a fire coin, which was a shekel.7:35 Now the question is, what connection?7:37 I understand when Hashem showed Moshe Rabbeinu, you know, other things, how to make;7:42 he didn't know how to build certain parts of the Mishkan,7:44 okay, that's understandable,7:46 a coin. Why did Hashem have to show him that the coin should be made out of7:50 fire? And the answer is, fire is something that's, in order for fire to exist,7:55 it has to be burning, it has to be active.7:57 And you see, fire is always moving. Fire doesn't—8:01 And still, when you can't see, you could feel it.8:03 But sometimes it could be a very quiet day,8:05 and there's barely any wind, especially in the summer when it's very humid.8:09 Fire, in order for fire to exist,8:12 there's got to be, first of all, life.8:13 There's got to be air. We all know8:15 if you put a match in a bottle8:17 and you close it up, you don't allow any air to come in,8:20 no life to come in, no air, the fire dies.8:24 Fire only exists with life,8:26 and fire is constantly moving.8:27 That's what fire represents.8:30 Hashem was showing Moshe Rabbeinu a shekel,8:33 but not a regular shekel, a shekel made out of fire.8:36 Meaning, really the pasuk says,8:38 Li8:40 hakesef v'li hazahav, a pasuk in Mishlei. Hashem says,8:42 What do I need money for?8:44 I'm the one who distributes money.8:46 You're a billionaire, you're a millionaire,8:48 you're a thousandaire, you only have ten thousand.8:50 I give everybody the money.8:52 I give the gold to everybody.8:54 Nobody, I don't need anybody's money.8:56 Nobody needs to give me money.8:58 If I want to bring9:00 korbanot, I'll make a miracle,9:03 and instead of apples coming out of trees,9:06 I'll have animals coming out of trees.9:08 Hashem can do whatever He wants.9:09 But He wants the Jewish people to participate.9:11 Why?9:12 Not because He needs their money,9:14 but because He wants their feelings inside of it.9:17 Money. Yeah,9:19 in Hebrew it's also called kesef.9:22 Kesef has another meaning besides money,9:24 but they're both related.9:27 Kesef means a strong desire.9:30 Ki chasof9:31 nichsafti. This is one of the songs that we sing on Shabbat,9:34 Yedid Nefesh.9:35 Ki chasof9:36 nichsafti, I have a strong yearning and a desire.9:39 Kasof9:41 nichsafta l'beit avicha is what Laban tells Yaakov Avinu on his way back to Eretz Yisrael.9:46 He tells him,9:46 You strongly yearn to go back to your parents' house.9:49 This is what it means over here,9:52 the kesef.9:52 Money has another meaning,9:55 which is yearning,9:55 which is we all could understand and relate to.9:59 Everybody yearns,9:59 everybody desires,10:00 and everybody's running after money.10:02 Everybody knows this.10:04 And that's why kesef is called what it's called.10:05 It's a form of yearning.10:08 When we give a machatzit hashekel10:09 to the10:10 Beit HaMikdash, it has to be made out of silver,10:11 not out of gold,10:12 even though gold is more valuable,10:13 it's more expensive,10:15 it's more10:16 chashuv, it's more important,10:16 and not made out of copper,10:17 which is very cheap,10:18 very little.10:20 Kesef,10:20 like the fire that Hashem showed Moshe Rabbeinu,10:24 people have to not just give their money,10:25 but they have to want to give their money,10:27 have to want to be part of the korbanot.10:29 They have to yearn to participate in the avodah of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.10:34 We've went through a long winter,10:36 a winter with no holidays.10:38 Chanukah comes in,10:39 sheds a little bit of light on us.10:41 Tu B'Shvat,10:41 a little bit of blessings over here and there,10:43 but really we haven't gone through real holidays.10:47 Adar ushers in the period already10:49 when the winter is finishing,10:53 hopefully. I don't know,10:53 maybe New York a little different,10:54 but winter is finishing,10:56 cold is going away,10:57 spring is back in the air,10:59 the trees are budding,11:01 the weather is becoming nicer,11:02 days becoming longer,11:03 and the holidays are coming.11:04 It's a time of physical rejuvenation11:08 as well as A spiritual rejuvenation.11:12 We're coming back into this world.11:14 We're coming back to participate11:16 into this world of11:19 ruchaniyut, and Hashem wants us not just be part of it,11:21 okay, new korbanot.11:23 He wants us to rejuvenate ourselves also spiritually,11:27 to feel part of the kedushah,11:30 to yearn to serve HaKadosh Baruch Hu.11:33 We shouldn't be dry in our service of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.11:37 Unfortunately, in halacha, a lot of times,11:39 if people follow11:41 halacha, they may follow every single law in the halacha in Shulchan Aruch,11:44 but sometimes they use it11:46 and they—not use it,11:48 but basically they apply it11:50 or they keep it in a dry fashion.11:52 This is what it says.11:53 That's what I got to do.11:54 And Baruch Hashem,11:55 there's a certain ma'alah to it.11:56 There's a certain level of just doing,11:58 even though you don't understand.11:59 But Hashem doesn't want us to just be robots12:02 and to just do without understanding.12:05 No, Hashem gave us a Torah.12:06 Hashem gave us12:07 chachamim. Hashem gave us a Gemara.12:08 Hashem gave us mefarshim to explain to us12:10 and to make us understand the12:12 halacha. And that's why it's so important12:14 when we learn12:16 halachot, we first have to learn what we have to do, 100%.12:18 Even if you don't understand12:19 why, you got to learn what you have to do.12:21 But you can't stop there.12:22 This is going on men and women as well.12:25 You have to understand what you're doing,12:26 because when you understand what you're doing,12:28 besides that you may learn new things12:30 of what to do and what not to do,12:31 what you have to do,12:33 okay,12:33 repeat that ten times.12:34 But also,12:36 when you learn and understand what you're doing,12:39 you enjoy it.12:40 You feel, as I say, a geshmak when you're doing it.12:44 You know exactly how to navigate yourself around12:46 on Shabbat.12:47 You know what to do when you're dealing with goyim,12:50 with a housekeeper,12:50 with a maid.12:51 You know you don't have to be nervous,12:53 and you have a great feeling.12:54 You have an understanding exactly what you're doing12:56 and a reason to what you're doing.12:58 And that is the fire.13:00 That is the fire.13:01 The fire is the Torah,13:02 as the Torah was given through13:05 Mimino es dat lamo. It's an understanding.13:07 It's being alive.13:08 It's living.13:09 It's the oxygen of our spirituality,13:12 to understand what we're doing,13:14 to understand why we do what we do.13:16 And with that,13:17 we'll move in.13:18 We'll go right into our13:20 halachot, the laws of13:21 shvut de-shvut. As we explained last week,13:23 and very, very short,13:24 we'll just give another five-minute review,13:26 and then we'll go on to the13:28 halachot. There is a halacha that says13:30 that in certain circumstances,13:32 a person may command a13:34 goy to do something for him13:35 that otherwise would have been forbidden,13:37 based on whatever these circumstances may be.13:42 Those circumstances will be explained soon,13:44 but that the heter,13:46 the way to tell a13:47 goy is by commanding the13:49 goy to do something that's only forbidden13:51 miderabbanan. This is known as13:54 shvut de-shvut. Shvut is a terminology13:56 that's used in13:58 halacha as well as the13:59 Gemara to describe an act14:02 that is forbidden14:05 miderabbanan. Anything that's forbidden14:06 miderabbanan on Shabbat14:09 is categorized under the name14:11 called14:12 shvut. That's all it is.14:13 It's not so complicated.14:15 So basically,14:15 if you're speaking about an14:16 issur derabbanan on Shabbat,14:17 you'd call it,14:18 Oh, this is a14:19 shvut. This is a14:20 shvut. Muktzeh, it's14:21 shvut. It's14:23 an issur derabbanan. Whatever it may be,14:24 things which are14:26 issurei derabbanan are known as14:27 shvut. We learned already14:28 that commanding a goy on Shabbat14:30 is forbidden,14:31 but the14:32 issur, the source of the14:33 issur, is14:34 miderabbanan. It's rabbinical.14:35 So therefore,14:36 commanding a14:37 goy to do something for you on Shabbat14:38 that you cannot do14:40 is known as a14:41 shvut. It's an14:43 issur derabbanan. When you command a14:44 goy to do something that's14:46 an issur derabbanan, it is known as14:49 shvut de-shvut. Shvut de-shvut is permitted14:50 in certain circumstances,14:52 as the14:53 Gemara in Masechet14:54 Eruvin brings the source of this halacha.14:56 The Rishonim14:56 had a split exactly14:57 how to understand it,14:58 but we're going with the ruling15:00 of the15:01 Shulchan Aruch, who goes with the Rambam.15:02 And the15:05 Shulchan Aruch is the manhig, halacha heh, rules like the Rambam15:07 that15:09 shvut de-shvut, commanding a15:09 goy to do something that's only forbidden15:12 miderabbanan, is15:14 mutar in three... Areas.15:16 I say areas,15:18 I don't mean cases,15:19 I mean areas.15:20 Each area may include many cases,15:22 but these three areas are:15:24 number one,15:25 if it's15:28 l'tzorech choleh, but it's not a full15:30 choleh, we'll explain all this afterwards,15:32 a sick person.15:33 Number two15:34 is for the sake of a mitzvah,15:36 and number three,15:37 if it's15:39 tzorech harbeh. Let's review them again.15:40 Let's make them actually15:41 in a simpler way.15:42 This way15:43 we will clarify each one by itself.15:46 Shbut d'shbut, commanding a15:47 goy to do only something15:48 that's15:49 asur d'rabbanan, is permitted15:50 if you're asking him15:52 to do this thing for you15:53 for the sake of a mitzvah.15:57 That's area number one.15:59 In the second area...16:00 where a person may tell a goy to do an issur d'rabbanan, or known as16:04 shvut d'shvut. Shvut d'shvut bimkom choli, or really the words are16:09 mikzat choli, when there's a little bit, a partial sickness, somebody is not feeling well.16:13 And finally, it's permitted to tell a goy to do16:19 an issur d'rabbanan in the area where it is considered tzorech harbeh, a great need.16:24 All of this, b'ezrat Hashem, will be explained as we go through the16:29 class and will be explained in depth.16:32 One point we have to point out, and we mentioned it last week,16:36 is that shvut d'shvut in an area which is16:39 mutar, which is in these three areas that we just listed,16:43 is not really16:45 lechatchila. Even though that's also a little bit debatable,16:47 but seems to be from the Mishnah Berurah and a lot of Acharonim, as we'll point out,16:50 it is not lechatchila. It even seems that way from Maran16:55 Shulchan Aruch. It is not lechatchila to go ahead and to rely on16:59 shvut d'shvut, meaning if there is any way that you could avoid17:03 commanding a goy to do something that's forbidden,17:05 even though the halacha permits it,17:07 the halacha only permits it if you have no other choice.17:09 But if you had a choice from before Shabbat,17:11 that's the option you're supposed to do.17:14 We'll see. Let's give a few examples, and then we'll explain17:16 how these examples should work.17:19 You know, when you go to a hotel,17:20 there are today in the hotels, in most hotels,17:25 unless, you know, it's a really, really old hotel,17:27 and I don't think you'll be spending your time over there on Shabbat.17:30 In any case, in most hotels, the doors have a magnetic lock,17:34 which means they have a key,17:36 and the key is made out of this card that looks like a credit card,17:39 and you slide in the key, which is this card,17:43 and then the door automatically opens up, okay,17:46 because it can read the number on your card to your specific room.17:49 That is assur to be done on Shabbat.17:52 You're playing with electricity.17:53 How you define electricity is a different subject,17:56 but that is assur to be done on Shabbat,17:59 Sefardim as well as Ashkenazim,18:00 if a Jew is doing it.18:02 In cases where a person is spending Shabbat in a hotel18:06 and he needs to get into his room18:08 for whatever reason is,18:09 remember, coming out of your room, there's no problem18:11 because you just turn the doorknob and you walk out.18:13 That's not a problem.18:14 The problem is coming back in.18:16 In order to get back in,18:17 the way to get back in is by placing this card,18:20 which will send this digital signal and open the18:24 door. You can't do it.18:26 It's asur miderabanan for you to do it.18:28 However, to tell a goy to open the door for you,18:30 so you see one of the custodians18:32 and you say,18:32 Please, I need to get into my room,18:33 and he opens it for you,18:36 then that would be considered18:41 shvut d'shvut b'makom tzorech harbeh. You're telling a goy to do18:42 an issur derabanan, opening the door for you.18:44 It's not always mutar.18:45 It's mutar in this case18:47 because it's considered a great need to get into your room.18:49 I don't think it's so nice,18:50 you know, to spend the whole Shabbat outside your room,18:53 you know, stuck in the lobby.18:54 Okay, one hour, two hours,18:55 you want to relax,18:56 beseder. But I want to go back.18:58 I want to take a nap.18:58 I want to schlaf a little bit.18:59 So that is considered19:02 a tzorech harbeh. Example number two.19:04 Let's say you look outside your window19:07 and you see in your backyard19:08 all the merchandise that you just got a delivery for19:10 out of Shabbat.19:11 You didn't have time to put it inside the house,19:13 and okay, it's not a big deal.19:14 It could stay outdoors.19:15 But then you realize that there's a great storm coming.19:18 It's supposed to be a big thunderstorm,19:20 you know, one of those summer thunderstorms19:22 where the sky gets dark19:24 and anytime soon19:27 it'll be19:28 mabul, you know, it'll be19:29 mei Noach again, and it's going to ruin all your merchandise,19:31 and there's going to be a great financial loss over here.19:34 That's called a19:35 tzorech harbeh. Big financial loss is considered19:38 tzorech harbeh. You can't move that merchandise19:40 if it's19:41 muktzeh. Why? Because it's19:42 muktzeh. It's muktzeh to you.19:44 Let's say we're talking about phones,19:45 we're talking whatever it may be over there.19:46 It's19:47 muktzeh. So therefore, since you can't move it,19:49 it's19:49 asur miderabanan. However, you could tell a goy to move19:53 that merchandise that you have in your backyard19:54 and put it inside of your house.19:56 Why? Because you're commanding a19:59 goy, which is only a20:01 shvut derabanan. You're telling him to move something that's20:03 muktzeh, which is20:05 derabanan. That's20:06 shvut d'shvut. Why is he doing it?20:07 For the purpose of saving you20:10 from a great financial loss.20:11 We're talking about a ten thousand dollar loss,20:12 a five thousand dollar loss,20:13 whatever it may be,20:14 a big loss for you.20:16 It's proportional, by the way.20:17 So therefore, it's20:19 shvut d'shvut b'makom hefsed gadol,20:22 and that will be mutar.20:24 Third example.20:26 Third example is20:28 you share a backyard with your neighbor,20:33 or you have a backyard20:34 and he has a backyard,20:35 but they're open to each other,20:35 but you don't have an eruv together.20:37 So now what happened is20:41 you have a—you're sitting now for Shabbat,20:42 and you realize that Shabbat day20:44 you come to eat,20:45 the kids ate up all the20:48 challah ערב שבת, and then you ate up the rest of it20:49 on Friday night on Leil Shabbat,20:51 and now you're stuck without20:53 challah, you're stuck without bread.20:54 You need to have seudat Shabbat.20:55 It's a mitzvah.20:56 Seudat Shabbat is a mitzvah,20:57 like we explained last year20:59 according to the21:00 Taz, it's even lechem mishneh is21:02 mid'oraita. So over here,21:04 you're allowed to tell a goy21:05 to go to your neighbor21:07 who has extra bread21:09 and to bring it to your house21:10 through the backyard.21:11 Why? Because going from one reshut to another,21:14 going from21:15 reshut hayachid to21:15 reshut hayachid, right next door to each other,21:16 from one private house21:18 to another private house,21:20 is21:21 a issur mid'rabbanan to carry something over.21:23 So you're telling a21:24 goy to carry something over21:25 in the area where there's no21:26 eruv, which is only21:28 a issur mid'rabbanan. That's called21:29 shvut d'shvut. Why?21:30 For the need of my21:32 seudah, which is considered mitzvah.21:35 Shvut d'shvut bimkom mitzvah,21:36 and therefore it's permitted.21:37 Case number four.21:39 Case number four is probably more applicable.21:42 You have your children's room,21:43 they put on the light21:44 and they can't fall asleep.21:45 So what happens21:46 when your kids can't fall asleep?21:48 You can't fall asleep21:49 because they're going to keep on coming to you saying,21:52 Mommy, Abba, I can't fall asleep.21:55 Okay, what do you want from me?21:56 You put on the light.21:56 Okay, what am I supposed to do?21:58 You told me not to shut it.21:58 Yeah, it's Shabbos, you can't shut the light.22:00 So you can't tell your kid22:01 to shut off the light on Shabbat.22:03 You can't shut off the light on Shabbat,22:04 so what do you do?22:05 If you know of a goy,22:07 if you could stop a goy from the street,22:09 you could bring him inside the house22:11 and ask him to shut off the light.22:13 Why?22:13 This is also considered a tzorech harbeh.22:16 For the kids to22:16 sleep, for the adults to go to sleep,22:19 shutting off the lights is asur22:22 mid'rabbanan. We cannot do this on Shabbat or on the holidays,22:24 but to tell a goy to shut it off for us22:27 is permitted in such a scenario.22:29 Why?22:30 Specifically here,22:31 because the kids need to sleep.22:33 It's a tzorech harbeh,22:34 and it'll be mutar.22:36 Another example.22:37 This actually, the following example22:38 happened to me a few times.22:41 We're sitting down on Shabbat table,22:42 and I have a stereo over there22:43 for the kids22:44 usually when they go to sleep at night.22:45 And usually we have it on,22:47 you know, a Jewish station,22:49 Jewish radio. Usually we have it on.22:51 And what happened is22:52 the kids came, milah Shabbat,22:54 babies at the time,22:56 and they were pressing the buttons22:57 as they usually do.22:58 Now, I forgot that the plug was inside.22:59 In any case,23:01 the kids put on the radio,23:02 and they pressed the FM button,23:03 and now went to AM,23:04 and it wasn't even on the right station.23:06 So all you hear is this big loud noise of,23:09 right?23:10 And it wasn't so gishmak23:12 to really sing Shabbat,23:14 zemirot Shabbat,23:15 with that background music in the back.23:17 It was horrible.23:19 So you can't sit and have a seudah like this,23:22 whether you want to call it Torah,23:24 whatever it is,23:25 you can't function.23:26 Shabbat is not a Shabbat atmosphere like this,23:27 and you can't really function.23:28 You can't go to a different room.23:29 So in such a case,23:30 we called over a23:33 non-Jew and asked them to shut off the radio.23:35 Shutting off the radio on Shabbat23:37 is also a23:38 issur d'rabbanan. I'm commanding23:39 the goy to do an issur d'rabbanan for me.23:41 It's called23:43 a shvut d'shvut b'makom tzorech harbeh over here as well.23:45 I'm sitting there,23:46 I don't want to hear the goyish music in the background.23:48 I don't want to hear the static in the background.23:51 It's not allowing me to have my meal on Shabbat.23:54 That is another example of shvut d'shvut where it's23:58 mutar. And finally, one last example.24:02 is, let's say you put on your heat in the house, and it's so hot in the house, it's boiling, everybody's shvitzing,24:09 and you have the fire from the blech, which means from the stove that you left on for Shabbat,24:14 and it's really, really very, very hot, and you need to shut off the AC because you can't, you're suffocating.24:21 So in such a case also, to call over a goy and ask him, please shut off the heat, it's too hot in the house.24:26 Or vice versa, let's say it's too cold in the house because the AC is blasting and it's freezing cold,24:33 then I could call over the goy and ask him, please shut off the AC, lower the AC, shut off the heat, it's too hot or it's too cold.24:41 Now, I want to point out something very important. We gave six examples over here.24:47 You have to point out something very, very important.24:49 It's only, like we said beforehand, it's only mutar to tell a goy to do a shvut d'shvut, which means telling him to do a shvut,24:57 right? To command a goy to do an issur d'rabbanan on Shabbat is only permitted if you have no other choice.25:04 If you have another choice, you can't do that.25:07 Which means, erev Shabbat, if I could have taken care of it, I'm not supposed to do it.25:12 Meaning, if I have the—let's give the example with the25:15 lights. My kid's room has the lights on. I could shut off the lights right now or get a timer from before Shabbat.25:20 I can't say, you know what, let me wait for Shabbat, let the kids have their light, and now I'll call over the non-Jew and ask the non-Jew to shut off the lights in the room.25:28 No, I can't do that. I have to make sure to shut off the lights.25:31 In case I forgot, or the kids are the ones who put on the light on Shabbat and now the light needs to be turned off,25:37 okay, I have no other choice. Then I have to call over the goy.25:41 That's a very important rule to keep in mind.25:43 If it could be avoided from before Shabbat, I must avoid it before Shabbat.25:48 And if it cannot be avoided before Shabbat and has to be done on Shabbat, then you have to know25:53 if I could also minimize it on Shabbat, I must do so.25:57 If I can minimize the issur,25:58 meaning, although this was not a subject over here about remez, we didn't talk so much about remez and hinting to a goy.26:06 Hinting to a goy is also forbidden if the goy does a melacha for you.26:10 However, hinting is not as severe as speaking to a goy.26:14 In both cases, if the goy does a melacha for you, as we will learn in Parashat Terumah, it's forbidden for you to benefit from it. But26:19 if you have to, if you're allowed to tell the goy something, and you have the option of either telling them or hinting to them,26:28 then you have to hint to the goy.26:30 So all the examples that we gave, for example, you need to get into your room in the hotel,26:37 so you need the goy to open the door for you.26:38 Or you need to bring the merchandise from your backyard into your house.26:42 Or you need the goy to carry for you the food from your neighbor to bring it inside,26:47 shutting off the lights in the room or shutting off the radio.26:50 If you can minimize the issur of commanding the goy by hinting to him, by giving a remez,26:56 then you must take that option first.26:58 Lemashal,26:59 let's take the case with the radio.27:01 Okay, the non-Jew walks into my house, sees me in the dining room,27:04 I have the table beautifully set up, wonderful dishes, all the kids sitting around with their hands on their ears,27:09 and one other kid is yelling at the baby who put on the radio.27:13 And I come to him, I say,27:14 Mister goy, you know, I could either tell him, Shut off the radio,27:18 or I could tell him, It is very hard for us to sit here and enjoy our meal with that noise in the background.27:24 I'm hinting to him that he should shut off the radio.27:26 If I could do that, then I must do that.27:29 If the goy would understand me by that remez,27:32 then that's what I'm supposed to do.27:34 Now, not every person is so intelligent,27:38 and not always would understand the remez.27:40 Sometimes you bring a person into the room and you tell27:42 him, Listen, it's mucho frio in here.27:45 It's very, very cold. The AC is blasting.27:47 It's very, very cold.27:48 And as a Jew, I'm not allowed to shut off the AC.27:51 And then they nod their head and they say,27:52 Ah, yes, yes, yes, I know your religion.27:55 Okay.27:56 And they're standing there just waiting,27:58 Okay, tell me what to do.27:59 And then you hint to them again and they don't understand.28:02 Okay, in such a case, you tried the other option.28:05 You tried to hint to the goy to shut off the AC because it's too cold in the room.28:09 Okay,28:10 so in that case you have to tell him, Listen, I need you to shut off the AC.28:12 It's freezing in this house. Please shut it off.28:15 So again, we want to point out the rule28:18 that if you could avoid28:20 shvut d'shvut, if you could avoid commanding the goy even though you're entitled to,28:24 if you could avoid it, you have to try to avoid it.28:26 If you could prepare yourself from before Shabbat,28:28 or even on Shabbat, if you could hint to the goy, minimize28:32 the issur instead of directly commanding him, you have to try to do so.28:35 I'll give you another case where you don't even have to come on to ask a goy,28:38 and this happens also a lot of times.28:41 Let's say the AC is blasting in the summer,28:43 and instead of a 90-degree day,28:46 and the temperature dropped, it was cloudy, whatever it may be,28:49 it dropped to 75,28:50 and now the AC is blasting and it's really, really cold in the room.28:53 So you could either call the goy and ask him to shut off the AC,28:57 or you know what, you have another two options to do.28:59 You know what you could do?29:00 If you have a shade, a curtain, which could go over the AC29:06 and block the cold air from filling up your room29:09 and making it cold in the room,29:10 then that's what you have to do.29:12 Ah, but the AC is running and I'm wasting so much money,29:15 it doesn't make a difference.29:16 You can't call a goy over to shut off the AC in order that you should save money.29:20 There's no heter for that.29:22 When we said29:25 a hefsed, you're allowed to tell a goy shvut d'shvut, in makom hefsed, that's only29:28 hefsed gadol. Running the AC through the duration of Shabbat,29:31 yes, you will have an extra ten dollars on your bill,29:33 but that's not a called29:35 hefsed gadol. Hefsed gadol is going to cause you a great financial loss.29:39 That's when it'll be29:41 asur. Another way, if I could keep the window open.29:43 Remember the case we gave29:45 when? The person is in the house,29:48 and the person is in the house,29:52 and it's very, very hot,29:52 and you have to call over the goy to shut off the heater.29:56 So if I could open the window and not have to call the goy,29:59 or the AC is blasting,30:01 I could open the window and make it a little hotter in here,30:03 let the cold air come out.30:05 I have to do that before calling the goy.30:06 It's not 100% just go ahead and call the goy,30:09 it'll be30:11 mutar. Whenever I have an option to be able to minimize or avoid30:15 the heter of30:17 shvut d'shvut, I must do so.30:18 We have a call.30:19 I hope I'm able to work this.30:24 Hello?30:26 Hello? JRoot, you're on the air.30:32 Fine,30:33 we come back to our class.30:34 We have a question.30:39 Okay, this is not a question relevant right now.30:41 We have a question by text.30:43 Cannot answer it right now,30:44 but Be'ezrat Hashem we'll answer it after the class.30:47 It's not exactly on the subject that we're speaking about.30:48 I really want to finish these30:50 halachot because next week is Purim.30:52 The week after is also Purim.30:53 Meaning to say, the halachot of Purim.30:54 The next two weeks will be Purim,30:55 and then we go into the laws of Pesach and all the holidays,30:58 and then after all that31:00 we'll come back to the laws of Shabbat,31:02 and I don't want to stop in the middle of something.31:05 Okay,31:07 so I believe we gave enough examples of31:10 shvut d'shvut, when it's31:11 mutar, when it's not31:12 mutar. I just want to point one last thing out,31:14 and that is the Shevet HaLevi in31:16 chelek gimmel. Shevet HaLevi writes31:18 that you cannot rely,31:21 you cannot prepare yourself31:23 to use the heter of31:26 shvut d'shvut on a regular basis.31:28 That means31:29 you know every single week31:31 that you need to command a goy31:32 to do something that's assur mid'rabbanan for the sake of a mitzvah.31:35 You cannot set yourself up every Shabbat31:39 to come and have to tell the goy31:40 this leniency.31:44 Why?31:45 It says in31:46 Shevet HaLevi, Rav Shmuel31:48 Wosner shlita, probably one of the greatest poskim alive in our days,31:50 if not the greatest today.31:52 He says, Rav Shmuel31:54 Wosner, you know why?31:55 Because it's zilzul Shabbat.31:58 Keep in mind what we mentioned before.32:00 First time we learned the halachot of amira l'akum on Shabbat, what you tell a goy on Shabbat,32:04 we learned that you could only tell the goy—excuse me—that the reason why Chachamim forbade us to command the goy to do something for us on Shabbat,32:12 because it creates laxity. It lowers the sanctity of Shabbat.32:18 So if we find, al pi halacha, ways in which we could circumvent the system,32:24 but at the same time still lower the kedushah of Shabbat,32:27 we haven't accomplished the purpose of the32:31 Chachamim's gezeirah. Chachamim's gezeirah was that the kedushah of Shabbat should be intact, but if I'm commanding the goy left and right,32:36 it lowers the kedushah of Shabbat.32:38 So therefore, if I have to rely on shvut d'shvut, beseder, okay, we gave cases where it's mutar,32:44 and now we're going to explain how they are mutar, you know, elaborate on these cases.32:48 But I cannot do this on a regular basis.32:50 I can't do this every single Shabbat, come and tell the goy, please do this and this and this for me.32:54 Oh, it's only derabbanan and it's for the sake of a mitzvah.32:57 No. I must prepare myself that I shouldn't have to use this heter.33:01 Now we go on to the next subject.33:04 We explained, like we said beforehand, special cases, areas where a person is allowed to tell the goy to do33:11 an issur derabbanan, which we called33:14 shvut d'shvut. We said three areas.33:15 Number one is bimkom mitzvah.33:18 Number two is bimkom33:20 choli, and number three is33:21 tzorech harbeh. We'll now define, we'll now elaborate on these three areas, be'ezrat Hashem, whatever we can in the time that we have.33:29 Number one, shvut d'shvut is permitted bimkom mitzvah.33:33 What does it mean, bimkom mitzvah?33:34 What kind of mitzvah do we permit it?33:36 And the answer is any mitzvah, whether the mitzvah is mid'Oraita or whether the mitzvah is33:43 miderabbanan. If there is a mitzvah that I need to tell the goy to do it, then I can do it,33:48 even a mitzvah derabbanan, like seudah Shabbat.33:53 But it has to be a real mitzvah,33:55 not like what people say, Oh, it's a mitzvah, it's a mitzvah.33:58 You know, people just make up mitzvot as they go along.34:00 You know, Uvacharta bachayim, says in the Torah you should choose life.34:04 To live is a mitzvah, right?34:06 Okay, so listen, I need this to live.34:08 You can't make up mitzvot. It has to be a real mitzvah.34:10 I'll give you an example.34:11 The Rama writes in34:14 siman shin mem gimmel, seif aleph, as well as the Kaf HaChaim brings it also in siman shin zayin over here.34:17 They bring down, we know that guests, having guests is a mitzvah.34:21 So, oh, if I have a guest and I need to tell a goy to do34:24 an issur d'rabbanan, not for me.34:25 Me, I could care less.34:26 I'm doing it for the sake of a guest.34:28 It's mutar, right?34:29 It's a guest.34:30 Well, not all guests are considered a mitzvah.34:32 What kind of guest is considered a mitzvah?34:35 says the Rama, and the Kaf HaChaim brings it over here as well,34:38 it's got to be a guest that wouldn't have a place to sleep otherwise.34:45 It's not a guest that you called, you invited your sister or your cousin34:48 that lives down the block who has food anyway.34:51 You just want to spend time with them, your friends,34:53 and you invited your friends and his families and their families to come over.34:57 It's, listen, they're guests. I have to do for them.34:59 No, that's not called a guest, which we allow you to do,35:04 issur d'rabbanan. It's got to be a guest that otherwise wouldn't have a35:07 place. I'll give you, you want to know what's a good example of a guest?35:10 A guest is, let's say you have some yeshiva bachurim coming over for Shabbat35:14 and they're sleeping by your house.35:15 They're coming from a different place. They don't have a place to sleep.35:18 They're coming from a yeshiva in Lakewood or Monsey or whatever it may be. They're visiting.35:22 Or you have guests that came from Eretz Yisrael that don't have a place otherwise35:25 and they're being hosted.35:26 You have rabbis, shluchim, especially now in this period,35:30 where they're coming from Eretz Yisrael, they need a place for Shabbat.35:33 They come to collect money and they're staying by your35:35 house. Those are guests. You're right.35:38 Without you, they wouldn't be, you know, okay, of course they could find somewhere else.35:41 But me to say they need a place to sleep,35:45 they're not just coming. You're not just inviting them to have fun with them,35:48 although you may have fun with them. That's not the point.35:50 The point is they don't have a place otherwise. That's a guest.35:53 And therefore, in such a scenario where a person has such people over by him35:58 and then he sees that, Oh my gosh, I don't have enough blankets for them.36:01 It's too cold. I can't give him this thin summer blanket.36:04 I need another blanket for my neighbor who has a lot of blankets.36:07 In fact, they have a blanket gemach,36:08 but there's no eruv between my backyard and their backyard.36:12 In that case, I could tell a goy, Do me a favor, go get me some. Blankets.36:17 Give me some pillows from my neighbor for our guests over here.36:21 And this could happen many times on the holiday of Sukkot,36:23 where you have a sukkah and you have guests coming over.36:26 They're sleeping; they don't have another place to sleep. They need your sukkah.36:29 You could also have them in your sukkah.36:32 You could also have them sleep by your sukkah,36:35 but you don't have mattresses for them, you don't have covers for them,36:37 and your neighbor does have.36:40 Even though there's no eruv between your house and their house,36:43 your backyard and their backyard,36:44 since carrying through your neighbor's backyard is only36:47 mid'rabbanan, it qualifies for shvut d'shvut bimkom mitzvah.36:51 Okay, that's important.36:55 What about, here's a question, what about shvut d'shvut for a mitzvah37:00 that's not today, but a mitzvah that's going to come later on,37:04 machar, afterwards?37:05 Meaning to say, I'm commanding you to go do something that's37:08 assur mid'rabbanan for a second mitzvah, but the mitzvah will not be today.37:11 The mitzvah will be after37:13 Shabbat. I need to do a mitzvah tomorrow.37:15 Let's say on Sunday, I need to, you know, on Sunday I need to shake the lulav and37:20 etrog, and I can't get it on Sunday. I need to get it today.37:22 Can I command the goy to go and get something for me,37:27 in the case, of course, that he's only doing37:30 an issur d'rabbanan, carrying it for me in only37:32 an issur d'rabbanan, in order to fulfill a mitzvah for tomorrow?37:35 So guess what? The answer is a37:39 machloket. Yes, it's a machloket, but really it's a37:41 machloket based on how to understand the Shulchan Aruch.37:44 We have people who say asur, people who say mutar.37:47 On the list of people who say it's asur, it seems to be even some37:50 Rishonim: the Tur, Tashbetz, Eliyah Rabbah, Acharon, and Taz.37:54 And on the matirim, you have more of the famous ones:37:59 the Ben38:02 Ish Chai, Rav Pe'alim, Chacham Ovadia, Chazon Ovadia, Rav Akiva Eiger, the Magen Avraham. These are the— Rabbeis are matir.38:07 So therefore, as a compromise, we tell you what the halacha b'rab brings down.38:10 If a person will not be able to fulfill the mitzvah,38:15 unless, let's say on Sunday,38:17 if a person cannot fulfill the mitzvah on Sunday38:19 unless he commands the goy today to go get him this thing,38:21 so you have what to rely on.38:22 Even though you're commanding him to do an issur d'rabbanan on Shabbat for a mitzvah38:25 that's only going to take place after Shabbat,38:30 shvut d'shvut l'tzorech mitzvah d'machar will be mutar if you would not be able to do it the next day.38:38 Okay. Here's another question.38:40 What about if there's a person who38:45 wants—what about a person who wants to ask a goy to do38:50 an issur d'rabbanan for the sake of a mitzvah,38:52 but you're not sure if the mitzvah is going to take place or not?38:55 Here's an example.38:57 You invited over some guests,39:00 and it happens a lot when you invite a lot of people39:02 who are not religious 100% yet;39:05 they're becoming religious.39:07 They don't know that when they give you their word39:10 that you expect them to come,39:12 and you actually prepared for them,39:13 okay? So now you prepared for them,39:15 but sometimes they don't show up.39:17 Sometimes they call you after Shabbat39:18 and they say, I was embarrassed to come by myself.39:20 My friend was supposed to come,39:21 didn't come,39:21 and this happens many, many times.39:23 You invite a guest39:24 who really needs a place to stay.39:25 They have no Shabbos meal,39:27 and you're, you know, you're doing it39:29 l'shem Shamayim. You want them to come over,39:30 but they don't show up.39:31 That's what happens.39:32 Now, these people skipped on you a few times.39:34 Sometimes they come,39:35 sometimes they don't come.39:36 But, you know, pretty much you invite them,39:38 and you know that they should be coming,39:40 but you're not sure.39:41 It's very possible.39:42 In fact, it's almost39:44 50-50 if they will show up or not.39:45 It could be even they told you before Shabbat,39:47 I'm not sure if I'm going to come or not.39:48 You come Shabbat day,39:50 and they're supposed to come Shabbat day,39:51 and you realize39:52 that you don't have enough bread for them.39:54 All the bread was eaten up.39:56 You miscalculated.39:56 You don't have enough challah for them,39:58 and it's not going to be nice.40:00 Numbers, leftover breads, everybody's going to eat challah, and they're going to get this or something.40:04 It's not going to look good on the table. They need it.40:06 And, or in the situation when you need extra food for them,40:10 you don't want them to feel that you're being burdened by their coming.40:14 So you want to show that you have plenty of food for them.40:16 You don't want to just squeeze whatever you have.40:19 You don't put out cream cheese either,40:20 you know. So what do you do in such a case?40:22 You have a neighbor that's next door,40:25 and again, there's no eruv between you and them,40:27 and it's not a problem of carrying in the street where it might be40:30 de'oraita. We're talking about just in the backyards.40:32 Can I ask to go to bring me food from my neighbor's house for the sake of a guest40:36 who I'm not sure will be showing up or not?40:38 It's a safek. I'm in doubt if he will come or not.40:42 The answer is that it will be mutar.40:46 Although some argue, but in such a case,40:48 if you're not sure if the mitzvah will be fulfilled or not,40:52 it still will be mutar,40:54 because when you're commanding him, you're commanding for a sake of mitzvah.40:57 You're not doing it really for, you know, just for leisure.40:59 You're not doing it to prepare for something else.41:01 You think, for all you know, it's supposed to be a mitzvah,41:04 so therefore it'll be mutar.41:07 That is the heter of shvut d'Shvut bimkom mitzvah,41:11 telling a goy to do an issur d'rabbanan in the area of a mitzvah.41:14 We move on now to the second area which mutar to tell a goy to do41:19 an issur d'rabbanan, and that is bimkom41:21 choleh. What does choleh mean?41:21 What does it mean when a person is sick?41:23 You have to know, we mentioned this in the past.41:25 If a person is sick, choleh sheyesh41:29 bo sakanah, where if I don't do something for him, he could be in danger,41:33 or there's a safek, maybe he'll be in danger,41:35 somebody that I have to call Hatzalah for him,41:36 it's a mitzvah on every Jewish person,41:39 including the biggest rabbi in the world,41:41 to go ahead and be mechalel Shabbat,41:43 even if it means driving,41:44 even if it means mechalel Shabbat through committing an issur mid'oraita on Shabbat.41:50 It's a mitzvah for Jews to save another Jewish person's life,41:54 even if it's a41:56 safek sakanah. That's very important to know,41:58 and every rabbi has to teach his kahal this.42:00 Chas v'shalom, they should doubt, and they should have to, you know, be lenient in such an42:04 area where choleh sheyesh42:06 bo sakanah. However, there's another category of a person who is sick,42:09 and that's called42:11 choleh she'ein bo sakanah. This is a sick person who is not in serious grave danger,42:16 but he is so sick that he has to be in bed.42:23 It's a sickness that's covering his whole body.42:25 He has a flu where aches the whole body.42:28 He has a high fever.42:29 He has, you know, right in the beginning when a person gets an infection,42:33 he has to be in bed.42:34 That's called42:36 choleh she'ein bo sakanah. In such an area, a Jew may not be mechalel Shabbat,42:39 but a goy could be asked to do even an issur42:45 de'oraita. You can even tell a goy to do an issur de'oraita if the sick person needs it.42:50 So then we come back now.42:52 We said shvut d'shvut is mutar for42:58 a choleh. Why do you have to tell me that I could tell a goy to do an issur43:01 derabanan? You told me even an issur de'oraita I could do.43:03 And the answer is, you're right.43:04 This choleh that we're talking about over here is not a choleh sheyesh43:06 bo sakanah. This is a choleh who is in great pain.43:10 He's not a choleh sheyesh bo sakanah, which means he has to be in bed.43:14 He is in great pain.43:16 He's suffering a lot.43:16 It's very, very painful.43:17 For example, I'll give you a practical case.43:20 A person burnt his hand.43:22 It's not a choleh sheyesh43:23 bo sakanah. He burnt his hand before Shabbat.43:25 It's burning him.43:26 He can't—it's really, really hurting him,43:28 and he needs to put some ointment on it.43:30 The problem is he ran out of the ointment.43:33 The only way he could get the ointment is by asking the goy to go buy it from the drugstore.43:38 And we're talking about a case where carrying the ointment from the drugstore to your house43:43 is not a problem of carrying through43:47 reshut harabim. It's not a problem where you're carrying through an area that's considered public domain43:52 that will be43:54 reshut harabim. So what's the issur then?43:55 The issur is the goy is buying for you.43:58 Buying, though, is44:00 asur miderabanan. So I could tell the goy,44:01 go and buy an ointment for this person who has this painful, painful burn, just to relieve his pain.44:08 I could tell the goy to do that.44:09 It's44:11 shvut d'shvut b'makom choli. It's not a choleh sheyesh44:14 bo sakanah, but it's a44:16 mitzta'er harbeh. That is the definition of44:19 choli. Now let's move on to the third area.44:22 Third area where it's mutar to tell a goy something that's44:26 asur miderabanan, shvut d'shvut is mutar,44:28 we mentioned is something called tzorech harbeh, a great need.44:32 What qualifies as a great need?44:34 It has to be a real need.44:36 Meaning, if you're sitting for Shabbat and you need44:40 challah, that's called a great need.44:41 In fact, that's also a mitzvah, like we mentioned.44:43 But if you're missing your tehina, or if you're Ashkenazi,44:48 you have your liver, but you don't have your egg salad.44:52 Every week I have my egg salad.44:54 So big deal.44:55 As Rav Scheinberg says, kugel is not called a44:59 tzorech harbeh. Kugel is not45:00 tzorech harbeh. You have your cholent, you have your main seudah, you have your bread.45:02 That's it.45:03 Yeah, but I always have my kugel.45:04 I always have my45:05 tehina. Who cares?45:06 You're right, I agree with you.45:08 I'll cry with you after45:09 Shabbat. On Shabbat, you can't just go ahead and tell the goy to carry from your neighbor some kugel.45:16 That's not called45:18 tzorech harbeh. I need soda.45:18 Do you have water?45:19 I have water,45:20 so what do you need soda for?45:22 What do you mean? Oneg Shabbos.45:23 Everything can become oneg Shabbos.45:25 Everything is oneg Shabbos.45:26 You can make anything oneg Shabbos.45:28 Like we said, you can't make up mitzvot.45:30 You can't make up—45:31 it has to be a real45:33 tzorech harbeh. Bread is45:35 tzorech harbeh. The main—45:35 if you don't have the main dish that you really need,45:38 without it45:39 it's not a Shabbat45:39 seudah at all,45:41 then okay, there's what to rely on.45:43 But smaller things are not called45:45 tzorech harbeh. Another thing that's included in45:48 tzorech harbeh is something that we spoke— we mentioned in the beginning of the class,45:51 and that is something called45:54 hefsed45:55 merubeh. If there's a great financial loss,45:57 as Maggid Avraham points out,45:58 it has to be a big financial loss.45:59 It can't be like a small—46:00 we're not talking about a few dollars,46:01 but a big financial loss,46:02 then it'll be46:04 mutar to tell a goy to do something for you46:06 that's only46:07 asur miderabanan, not to point out something.46:09 Hefsed merubeh means over here46:11 you're about to incur a loss,46:14 not that you are not going to profit.46:17 Sometimes, let's say you have certain items,46:19 certain merchandise, right?46:22 That, you know, you may not incur a loss,46:26 but, you know, you're not going to sell them.46:29 You're not, you're not, you know, need to say if you don't sell the merchandise,46:31 yes, I can hear that's a loss46:32 because you bought it.46:34 But if you don't buy it,46:36 it's not going to be a loss.46:37 It's just you're not profiting.46:39 Lemashal, let's say this big sale is going on.46:42 You have a big sale going on on Shabbat,46:45 the time that you can't buy it.46:47 They're selling certain tickets online,46:49 and you have to be on,46:50 you have to be waiting,46:51 and you have to get it at a certain time.46:53 And if you don't get it,46:54 you will be basically,46:56 you could, they're having something that's worth46:59 a thousand dollars, and they're selling it for47:01 three hundred dollars. You are saving47:03 seven hundred dollars. That's not a financial loss for you,47:06 even though you're going to say,47:07 yeah, but if I buy it after Shabbat,47:08 I'm going to have to spend an extra47:10 seven hundred dollars. That's fine. You're right.47:11 That's called47:13 miniat revach. That's called, I'm not getting a profit.47:18 The real price is47:20 a thousand. You're supposed to pay47:22 a thousand. You found now a great deal for47:25 three hundred dollars, seventy percent off.47:27 That's not called a financial loss.47:29 You're just not gaining that extra47:32 seven hundred dollars, and that's very important to point out.47:35 There's a big difference between a loss,47:37 which means you have the items47:39 and you're going to lose them.47:40 You're going to lose the money47:42 or the value of the item.47:43 Like let's say the case we gave before,47:45 you have your backyard with boxes of laptops,47:49 and if you don't bring it inside the house,47:51 it's going to get ruined.47:53 That's because a great thunderstorm is coming.47:56 That's called47:57 hefsed merubeh. You have it already.47:58 But miniat revach, where—48:00 I'm saving money by buying something on sale. That's not called sorech harbeh, and certainly48:06 not48:08 hefsed merubeh. Another example of this is, in the area of sorech harbeh, where I'm allowed to tell48:12 a goy to do an issur d'rabbanan, is a category called48:18 kevod habriyot. What is48:19 kevod habriyot? Kevod habriyot means if something is, if a person has to tell a goy to do something for48:26 him that's a d'rabbanan, otherwise he will be embarrassed in front of people, really embarrassed in48:34 front of people, then he can ask the goy to do something for him.48:38 Lemashal, a person is, or a lady—it's probably more practical by a lady—a lady is coming, she48:43 has a simcha, and everybody's coming to the simcha hall, and she's coming, and she gets48:48 to the simcha hall, and all of a sudden she realizes that the dress that she wanted to48:53 wear the whole time, and she's wearing it, she realizes, uh-oh, it's stained.48:58 She took the wrong dress.48:59 It was early in the morning when she was getting dressed, and she didn't bother to look at herself49:04 20,000 times. She only looked 19,000 times, and she didn't realize that she had this big49:08 stain on her dress.49:09 Oh my gosh,49:11 what am I going to do?49:11 If I walk out now in front of everybody, it's so embarrassing.49:14 It's my son's shavua brachos, and I'm in a simcha with 200 people, and I'm going to walk around,49:20 everybody's going to see me.49:21 It's very embarrassing, and it is embarrassing.49:23 That's called kevod habriyot in such a case.49:26 So what can we do?49:27 For her to go all the way back home, she can't.49:29 It's very hard for her to walk back home because everybody's saying, Where is she? Where49:31 is she?49:31 To sit there with her jacket, she can't avoid. She can't sit there with her jacket.49:35 So then, the only other option, if she lives in an area where the goy who would bring her49:40 this other dress to change is not going to have to do an issur. De'oraita, only in issur49:46 d'rabbanan, let's say he's walking in an area which is not a reshut d'oraita, so then we49:50 could ask the goy, could you please go over and carry her dress, whatever the dress may be,49:55 and bring it for her. Carrying, again, in an area which is only50:00 asur miderabbanan, that is called50:02 kevod habriyot. Same thing would be if a man ripped his jacket, his suit jacket, and he needs the goy to carry50:07 something for him. Again,50:07 this is kevod habriyot. It falls under the category of tzorech harbeh, where it would50:14 be permitted to ask a goy on Shabbat to do an issur d'rabbanan in a case where otherwise50:18 it cannot be avoided.50:21 Looking at the time, we have only seven minutes left. I'd love to take questions, but50:25 I'm going to be here. I already see a lot of texts coming in. I will answer,50:28 bezrat Hashem, bli neder, all the texts that come in, but not now, a little bit later. We ask50:32 also that if you have questions, call please after the show. We're not going to be able50:36 to answer. I really want to finish this before we take our break.50:43 I'm going to have to skip a little bit of the halachot. I'm going to point out some50:47 things, although I don't like to do this, but I have to do it just very quickly, and50:50 that is as following. There's certain times, those who are a little bit more learned, will,50:57 you know, we said shvut d'shvut is mutar. To tell a goy to do an issur d'rabbanan is51:00 mutar for the sake of mitzvah, tzorech harbeh, which is financial loss, or51:06 choleh. You have to know, in order for something to qualify as an issur d'rabbanan, you have51:10 to know you can't just go ahead and, you know, decide what is d'rabbanan, what's not51:17 d'rabbanan. You really have to know your stuff very, very well.51:20 We know that commanding a goy is an issur d'rabbanan. So a person might say, you51:24 know what, let me go and tell one goy to tell another goy to do something for me. I'm telling a51:29 goy to tell another goy. That's also issur d'rabbanan, to do something for me.51:33 That's called— Amira le'amira. I'm telling the goy to tell another goy.51:37 This, the Mishnah Berurah brings a machloket on this, and it seems to be from the Mishnah Berurah as51:41 well as all the other poskim that they're not so happy with it.51:44 There are those who permit. I'm not telling you there's no heterim. Of course, there51:47 are those who permit, Havot Ya'ir. I believe Derech Chaim is matir in certain cases. But51:53 I wanted to point this out: don't go ahead and jump on it. Not everybody holds of it.51:59 Number two is to tell a goy to do something b'shinui, meaning to say it's52:05 asur mid'oraita, but to do b'shinui, like instead of putting on the switch directly with my hand, I ask52:09 him—I mean, with his hand—to turn on the switch, I ask him to do it with his elbow. Again,52:14 some hold it's mutar. A lot of opinions may hold it's mutar. Some hold it's only mutar52:19 if the outcome of the melacha will be different because the goy is doing it in a different way,52:23 which means that if you ask the goy to put on the light switch with his elbow, since52:27 the outcome is the same because the lights are going to go on, they're not so easy to52:30 be matir, and some just permit it straight out. I've seen all different types of opinions. Ask52:36 your rabbi what to do. In all these cases, you must run it by a rabbi. If it's like a52:42 strange thing, it's not the simple, straightforward things that we said in the class, make sure52:46 you run it by a rav. Mentioned several times, and we'll mention it again. All these52:51 cases, when you tell a goy, even though mehalacha may permit it, they may see it straight out52:57 in a book, black and white, sometimes your rav, if he's a talmid chacham, if he knows his halachot, may still53:02 forbid it because he feels that, listen, it's going to create a zilzul Shabbat. It53:09 might not be a zilzul Shabbat according to halacha, but in your situation, in your community,53:13 in your shul, in your special circumstance, it might create a zilzul Shabbat, might53:20 degrade the kedushah of Shabbat, and therefore they have to be more stringent. And they're53:25 not being machmir more than Shulchan Aruch. That's what halacha permits them to do. The rabbis were given the authority53:31 and the responsibility to make sure that Shabbat remains kodesh. Shabbat should not become53:37 just another day. And therefore, if the rabbis feel that they have to be machmir where the53:41 halacha permits it for a specific situation, then we must listen to what our rabbis tell53:47 us. Let me go now to the final category over here, even though it's not the final category53:52 on my list, but what we're going to cover for the class. Some common examples. A lot53:56 of people have questions on this. In fact, that's some of the questions over here in54:00 the text, and that is telling the goy to put on a heat or air conditioner. If you lived54:05 in New York City or around for the last week, and you've been here, you know what cold means.54:12 We all felt it, and we all experienced it, and it doesn't seem to be ending. Baruch54:17 Hashem, today and yesterday were wonderful, but it's still cold outside. It's still going54:21 to be cold, I believe, for the weekend. So we know what cold really means. So there's54:27 a halacha in Shulchan Aruch, in siman reish ayin vav, where Maran says over there, and54:31 that's a halacha, in the places where it's very, very cold. One may tell a goy to even54:37 put on a fire for heating. Fire is a issur de'oraita. Fire on Shabbat, to tell a54:46 goy to put on a fire, how can you tell a goy to do an issur de'oraita? We're not doing54:51 it for any of the three cases, and the answer is, says the Shulchan Aruch, because54:56 hakol cholim etzel hakor. When it's very, very cold, everybody is considered like a sick person,55:02 which means, for a sake—we said already many times—a goy is allowed to be told to55:07 do an issur de'oraita for the sake of a sick person. And that's why over here, we're allowed55:12 to tell a goy to put on the heat for the sake of, when it's very, very cold, because55:17 we're all considered like sick people from the cold. How cold does it have to be? There's55:21 no halacha that tells me 40 degrees, 50 degrees, 60, I don't know. If it's cold, very cold,55:27 and you can't bear it, for sure you can tell the goy. Not only that, if you have children55:31 or elderly people in the house and it's cold for them, and chas v'shalom they55:34 could get sick, you can tell a goy to do it. Especially the heaters in our days, most of them work55:41 through a digital way, which would only make it derabanan, so anyone would make it55:46 shvut d'shvut l'tzorech harbeh in this case, and it'll be permitted. There's a special,55:51 basically what we're trying to say is that there's a special exemption when it comes55:56 to commanding the goy to do an issur de'oraita.56:00 When it comes to putting on the heat.56:02 So therefore, to tell a goy when it's cold outside,56:05 to tell a goy that you forgot to put on the heat,56:06 or the heat was not on the right temperature,56:09 the thermometer, whatever it may be,56:11 you could tell the goy to raise the heat,56:13 put on the heat on Shabbat56:15 when it's cold outside.56:16 Like [unclear] says, but it has to be really cold,56:18 not just lightly cold.56:19 It has to be really cold,56:20 and you can't do it any other way.56:21 You can't put extra blankets or sweaters,56:23 which most of the times you cannot.56:25 The question is, though, the other way:56:26 can I tell a goy when it's very hot outside56:29 to put on the AC?56:31 Cold, okay, I understand,56:34 kol cholim etzel hakor. What about to tell a goy to put on the AC?56:37 So Chacham Ovadia has a56:40 teshuva in Yabia56:41 Omer where he matir, he permits to tell a goy to put on the AC,56:44 and the reason is for a few reasons.56:47 Number one is,56:48 he explains that the way the ACs work,56:50 and I believe56:52 Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach also explains this way,56:53 is that the way the ACs work56:55 is not the way the lights work. The lights work,56:57 the way the lights work on Shabbat,56:59 the electricity of the lights work,57:01 you are committing an57:03 issur de'oraita with putting on the light, whatever it may be,57:05 that's already a big discussion.57:07 The way the ACs work,57:09 when you put on the AC,57:10 it's only igniting a spark.57:13 Sparks are asur57:14 miderabbanan, but not57:15 mid'oraita. So therefore,57:16 I'm telling a goy to put on the AC,57:18 I'm commanding a goy,57:19 which is asur57:21 miderabbanan, shvut, to put on the AC, which is sparks only,57:24 which is57:25 shvut, letzorech what? Is anybody sick?57:27 No, but57:28 choleh, remember we said it could be somebody57:29 even who is57:31 mitzta'er harbeh. So57:33 letzorech choleh, because the person is57:35 mitzta'er harbeh. That's one of the reasons57:37 that Chacham Ovadia is matir.57:38 Another reason that Chacham Ovadia is matir57:40 is based on the Yerushalmi.57:41 The Yerushalmi says57:43 that people, when it comes to the heat,57:46 they cannot tolerate it57:48 as much as they can tolerate the cold.57:49 I think the logic is as follows:57:51 when it's very cold,57:52 you put on extra blankets.57:53 When it's very hot,57:54 what are you going to do?57:55 There's only enough that you could do.57:57 So therefore,57:58 the heat sometimes can be very intolerable.58:00 So you came on Shabbat,58:01 you didn't expect it to be this hot,58:02 and all of a sudden58:03 it's 95 degrees.58:04 It's very humid and muggy,58:06 and you can't,58:07 and you forgot to put on the AC58:08 or the AC was shut off,58:09 your kids shut it off,58:10 and there's nothing else to do,58:12 so you could call58:13 and ask them to put on the AC.58:15 And again,58:16 like we mentioned beforehand,58:17 if you could minimize58:19 the issur by only hinting to the goy,58:20 you must take that approach first.58:22 But if you cannot minimize it,58:24 then you can tell them directly.58:26 And also,58:27 like we said beforehand,58:29 shev v'al ta'aseh, do not use this on a regular basis.58:32 You can't just wait every Shabbat58:33 to tell the goy to put on the AC.58:35 Only if you couldn't prepare from before Shabbat,58:37 even though you may have to spend58:38 a few extra bucks.58:40 Likewise,58:40 if you want to tell the58:41 goy to shut off the AC to save money,58:43 it's also58:44 asur. It's only58:44 mutar because you need it,58:45 and you need it a lot on Shabbat,58:47 then it would be58:50 mutar. Also,58:51 like we said beforehand,58:52 in all these cases,58:54 a person must always check with his rabbi,58:55 because a rabbi may have certain reasons58:57 why he wants to permit or forbid certain things.59:00 We're up on time,59:02 and I believe we covered enough59:04 on the subject of59:07 amirah l'akum. Be'ezrat Hashem, the next week,59:08 the next few weeks already,59:09 really the next few months,59:10 we'll be already going into the laws59:12 and the halachot of the holidays,59:14 Purim, Pesach,59:17 Sefirat HaOmer, and59:18 Minhagei HaOmer, and then whatever,59:20 be'ezrat Hashem. And then after that,59:21 we'll come back already59:22 and continue in the Binyan Shulchan Shabbat.59:24 And we want to wish everybody a chodesh tov,59:27 have a wonderful week,59:29 brachah v'hatzlachah in everything that you do,59:30 simchah from everything,59:31 Shalom Bayit,59:31 and then everything else in the world.59:34 And give a big thank you to59:36 Iran and59:37 Rav Nissim Lazari for their wonderful station,59:39 their wonderful work that they do over here.59:40 This class will be aired on again tonight59:43 at 1159:44 o'clock, and those who have questions59:44 can call into the station now,59:48 718-683-5858, or you can text at 347-927-8398.