Torah · Halacha Rabbi Uri Nahum teaches the laws and customs of Shabbat in the Ben Ish Hai archive. The precise recording date is unconfirmed. The displayed date is from the archive.
Transcript 0:00 Welcome to JRoot Radio. This is the Halacha Hour on JRoot Radio on Wednesday afternoon, live at 2 p.m. on, I believe it's0:15 Chaf Bet, Shvat, Merzat Hashem, Tav Shin Ayin Hey. Let's first give you the number to the station, then an introduction to the class, and Merzat Hashem we'll go on straight into the class.0:23 Today's class is dedicated l'refuah shelemah of Ayala Gazale bat Rima, as well as Rita bat0:30 Vanya. Hashem should give both of them a speedy, full recovery, Merzat Hashem, very, very soon.0:37 We should say amen. The class today is going to be on the halachot of Shabbat. We're back to the Ben0:42 Ish Chai. We're back to the discussions we were in the middle of, and that is the laws of0:46 amirah l'akum. Last week we took a break; it was Tu B'Shvat. We're now back to the halachot of0:50 amirah l'akum, what we could tell a goy on Shabbat, what we cannot tell a goy to do on Shabbat.0:56 Merzat Hashem, we will continue from the Ben Ish Chai inside, and these halachot, hopefully today, are much more practical.1:03 The cases, hopefully, Merzat Hashem, will be much more. I know the last time we spoke, the cases were a little bit complicated,1:08 but it's a Ben Ish Chai class; I have to go through it. But today, Merzat Hashem, the halachot will be a little bit clearer.1:14 Number to the station are 718-683-5858. If you have a question, we always prefer that you call in after the end of a certain segment,1:24 or towards the end of the class, or after the class. This way we could answer you much better.1:30 We don't have to interrupt the class and take a question in the middle. Sometimes the questions are answered in the class itself.1:36 Also, if you'd like to text in, that's probably the best way. I see the text right next to me. If I'm able to answer it, I'll answer it right away.1:43 If I'm not able to answer it right away, Merzat Hashem will give you an answer. As soon as we finish the class,1:48 the text number is 347-927-8398. You could listen to this class also over the phone by calling 712-432-4217 or2:02 718-506-9099. You could also view and watch this class live, live streaming that is, with a video on2:11 jrootradio.com. Go to the website, www.jrootradio.com. And of course, if you have the smartphone, you could always tap the app, JRoot Radio Pro app, and just listen.2:23 And if you're waiting and get a phone call, you get a phone call, JRoot Radio Pro app will go on low voice. You can answer your call and come right back to class.2:31 Like we said, we are now in the discussion of the halachot of amirah l'akum, what we can and cannot tell the goy over Shabbat.2:38 In the halacha hour, in this time that we give the class, we try to, besides, you know, obviously bringing it from the Ben Ish Chai, read from the Ben2:48 Ish Chai, give you the source of the halacha, reasons, and then to try to bring some applicable cases, practical applicable cases in our days.2:58 We're up to halacha yud dalet. If you look in your Ben Ish Chai, Parashat Vayishlach, halacha yud dalet, you'll see it's a long halacha. We are not going to read the whole thing.3:06 We're just going to read the part that's applicable to us, explain the halacha, and then we'll jump to halacha tet zayin,3:16 because we did tet-vav last time, as we're keeping track.3:20 Let's begin.3:26 אסור לתן מעות לנוכרי מערב שבת לקנות לו בשבת. As a general rule, we said usually you should keep in mind if you're, you know, just coming in into the halachot of3:33 HaRav... and those who, especially those who listen beforehand, you know by now that in general you have to assume that you cannot tell the goy to do something that you cannot do.3:41 That's pretty much3:42 a halacha. When you're allowed to tell the goy to do something where you couldn't have done it, it's usually the exception.3:48 So therefore, anytime you're mesupak, even though you can tell me safek d'rabbanan lekula, this is not a case of3:54 safek d'rabbanan lekula. Safek d'rabbanan lekula means when I have two different opinions, I can't decide because the halacha hasn't decided for me which opinion I should go like,4:01 so then we try to be lenient.4:04 In this case, where you don't know the halacha, it's not called4:07 a safek. In any case, if you are not sure what the halacha is when it comes to something on Shabbat, if you're allowed to tell the goy or not,4:13 assume that's asur unless you heard otherwise.4:15 It sounds a little harsh, but that's the way it really comes out that way.4:19 There are exceptions, and those exceptions, if you heard it from a competent person, a person who knows what he's talking about, then you can follow it.4:30 If you assume I know what I'm talking about, then you can follow that.4:33 If you didn't hear from a person who knows what he's talking about, then don't follow it.4:37 Make sure you run it by a rav who knows what he's talking about.4:40 And even in cases where it's mutar, you should know, as we're going to explain later on,4:45 the rav has to decide also if he will give the permission to allow the person to follow the4:53 heter. What do you mean? Don't we have a Shulchan Aruch?4:55 Well, you have to know there are certain rabbanim who are poskim. They give5:00 psak halacha. They're not dealing so much with a kahal; they're not dealing with a community.5:04 A rav who's dealing with a community, certainly a bigger community, and/or even he's dealing with his kahal.5:11 He has a kahal, that means he has a congregation.5:15 They're all adhered to him; they follow him.5:17 He has a responsibility to take them, keep them on the track of Hashem in whatever way he feels is necessary.5:23 And sometimes, even though there are leniencies in halacha, he may choose to go with the more stringent opinion,5:28 or not even that, maybe not to go with the leniencies in5:31 halacha. Why? Because it may lead to other things.5:34 He has to know his customers. He has to know his clientele5:37 over the radio, where we're speaking to everybody. We bring about certain exceptions,5:43 but again, you have to run it by your own rav.5:45 Perhaps he has a reason for being stringent in this area, or whatever it may be.5:51 Let's come back over here now to the halacha that we're speaking about.5:55 You can't tell the goy to go buy you something on Shabbat. Why?5:58 Because you can't buy something on Shabbat. We learned that already.6:01 So you can't give money to the goy and tell him,6:03 Listen, there's a sale in Macy's on Shabbat. I want you to go and buy me this thing.6:07 It's a one-day sale, and of course, they always love to make it on Shabbat when Jews can't buy.6:12 I don't know, because they figure, anyway, we're going to bargain for it anyway. We're going to get the sale price,6:16 so they make the sale for the6:18 non-Jews. In any case, you can't tell the goy, Go and buy me something on Shabbat.6:24 Likewise, you can't have him sell your merchandise on Shabbat.6:29 If there is a flea market, if there is a place where many people are gathering,6:34 it's the Super Bowl, and you want to sell your peanuts,6:37 and you want to give it to a goy to go walk outside the Super Bowl.6:39 I know Super Bowl is on Sunday, whatever.6:40 If you're giving the goy your peanuts and you want him to go sell it,6:44 or your newspaper is extra, extra, and you're telling him, Go sell it over here6:47 on Shabbat, that's also asur.6:51 Aval, however, there is an exception to this rule6:55 where the goy may be able to sell for you or may be able to buy for you.6:59 We're going to read from the Ben Ish Chai, and then we're going to specify clearly when it's mutar.7:07 However, if you did not command the goy to buy or sell your item or something for you on Shabbat,7:17 rather you gave it to him in the middle of the week,7:23 even though the goy himself, on his own, decides to buy or sell your merchandise,7:29 to buy something for you, then on Shabbat, then it's mutar.7:39 However, there's a condition here that the Ben Ish Chai brings.7:45 We're going to just speak out the condition of the Ben Ish Chai, but I'm telling you from now,7:50 there are four conditions for this halacha to be mutar.7:53 Ben Ish Chai just brings one; the other ones should be understood,7:56 or you have to really look in the poskim to understand it. The British.8:00 explains that you have to make sure that the goy does it on his own.8:05 Adata d'nafshei. These are our make words.8:07 Adata, l'daat nafshei atzmo.8:11 He has to do it for his own sake, not for you.8:14 Remember, we mentioned several times already,8:16 even if you don't command the goy,8:18 and certainly if you command, but even if you don't command the goy to do something for you8:22 and he does it for you on his own, it's asur.8:24 However, if the goy does something for himself,8:28 you may derive benefit from it.8:30 There are limitations to this heter,8:33 but in general, if a goy does something8:35 where it's a one-shot deal, he does it for himself,8:38 and the Jew is going to get hana'ah, is going to get benefit from it, it's mutar.8:42 Let's give a short example.8:44 The goy walks into a dark room.8:47 For his own sake, he wants to read a letter that he has.8:50 He wants to read a book that he has.8:51 The room is completely dark. It's Friday night.8:53 It's ten o'clock at night,8:55 shkia was at8:56 six, which means it's Shabbat according to all opinions,8:59 and he puts on the light not for you,9:01 not because he has to do work for you.9:02 He wants to read his book.9:04 He finally got off from work.9:06 Maybe it's your shifchai, maybe it's your housekeeper.9:10 She wants to sit down and read a book.9:12 And now you walk in and you say,9:13 Oh, you know, lights are on.9:15 I wanted to read what it says on the wall.9:17 I wanted to benefit from this light.9:20 It's mutar.9:21 The goy didn't do it for you.9:23 The goy did it for themselves.9:24 Here, the housekeeper put on the light for herself9:27 so she could read.9:29 So since she didn't do it for you,9:31 you're allowed to have hana'ah from it.9:32 Oh, but melachah that was done on Shabbat,9:33 but it was not done for you. It was done for her.9:35 It was done for the sake of the goy.9:37 That's called9:38 adata d'nafshei. If you make sure that the goy is doing it for his own sake,9:43 even though he comes on, he does it on Shabbat.9:45 Then it's going to be mutar.9:47 How could this be mutar?9:49 We'll explain just soon.9:50 I just want to finish the words of the Ben9:52 Ish Chai so I could explain everything outside in a very orderly fashion.9:57 Let's continue.9:58 The Ben Ish Chai says,10:04 When we allowed you to benefit from the10:09 melacha that the goy has done for himself10:12 by making sure that he gets paid for it,10:14 which is a da'atad nefshei, basically,10:16 where the goy is doing it for his own sake10:18 by paying him for it,10:19 that's only if you don't force him to do it on Shabbat.10:24 What does that mean?10:29 Where the goy had the option of buying or selling your item10:34 during the weekday,10:37 meaning there is a four-day sale.10:40 The sale begins on Thursday,10:42 goes to Friday, Saturday, and the weekend, Sunday.10:45 Now, Saturday is Shabbat for us.10:47 Friday night is Shabbat for us.10:48 You tell the goy, you give him money from Monday,10:52 and you say, Listen, Mr. Goy,10:54 here's the money. I want you to go to Macy's10:56 and buy me this thing on sale.10:58 He could go on Thursday, he could go on Friday,11:01 he could go on Shabbat, he could also go11:03 on motzaei Shabbat, he could also go on Sunday.11:06 If the goy on his own decides to go on Shabbat,11:09 it's mutar for you to have that item that he bought you.11:14 Let's use for argument's sake,11:15 you're buying a new fur coat.11:19 Not fur, you're an animal11:21 guy. Okay, fine. You're buying a wool coat,11:22 okay? You're buying a brand new wool coat.11:24 It's usually $300, and they have it on sale for $50.11:28 You tell the goy, Please, clearance.11:30 It's a four-day clearance sale.11:31 I want you to go buy me the coat.11:33 He could have purchased it during the weekday,11:35 Thursday, Friday, Shabbat, or Sunday.11:37 The goy decides on his own that he's going to go on Shabbat11:41 because, you know, it's easier for him,11:43 and he's going to take his kids or whatever it may be11:45 for his own sake,11:46 and you paid him for it. He's not doing it just for you.11:49 You're paying him for it. You're telling him,11:51 Listen, here's $50 for the coat.11:53 Here's another $10 for your shipping and handling.11:56 So now the goy on his own decides to go on Shabbat,11:58 then it's going to be mutar.12:00 However, if the goy does not have the option12:04 of buying during the weekday,12:05 that means the sale is only Friday night at 712:10 p.m. until Shabbat day at 4 p.m., right on Shabbat.12:15 They don't want any Jews to come and buy,12:17 and you go ahead and you tell the goy,12:19 Go buy it for me.12:21 Since you're forcing the goy to go and buy it12:24 on Shabbat itself, it's going to be a problem.12:31 Everybody is oser? Not everybody is oser in this case.12:33 There are those who are a little bit12:36 lenient when you don't mention Shabbat.12:38 However, that's a heter, a kula, leniency12:41 that the Ben Ish Chai himself brings later on12:43 from the Natziv, Beit Yosef.12:46 I'm only saying this very quickly12:47 for those who basically are going to learn the books inside,12:50 so they'll know a little bit what to look up.12:52 But for our sake at least,12:54 most of the Acharonim, most of the later authorities,12:57 have ruled like the way Ben Ish Chai rules over here,12:59 that is, if you're forcing the goy to buy it on Shabbat,13:04 that means he has no other option to buy it13:06 except for Shabbat,13:07 even if you pay him for his effort,13:10 if you pay him for his shipping and handling,13:12 it's still going to be a problem for you13:16 to benefit from his13:18 melacha. Okay,13:19 now let's summarize the halacha outside.13:22 A goy cannot be told to do an issur deRabbanan for you,13:25 just like buying and selling.13:27 He cannot buy something for you.13:28 He cannot take your merchandise13:29 and sell it for you on Shabbat.13:31 That is if you commanded him.13:32 However, if you didn't command him13:34 to do it for you on Shabbat,13:36 and he did it on his own,13:38 it might be mutar in the following case:13:41 one, with the following conditions.13:42 You need basically four conditions13:45 when you want the goy to do something.13:47 If a goy is going to do something for you on Shabbat,13:50 you need four conditions,13:51 and you need all these four conditions.13:53 If you don't have these four conditions,13:55 it's going to be a problem.13:57 What are they?13:57 Number one, condition number one13:59 is, again, we're going to use the mashal14:01 just to make it easier for us.14:03 We're going to use the mashal of buying14:05 an item that's on sale in a store. Okay,14:09 so you want to buy this new jacket14:11 that's on sale in Macy's,14:14 and14:16 you can't get it because whatever you can't get it for.14:19 So now you want to tell the goy, Buy it for me.14:21 Number one is you have to pay the goy for the job,14:24 not per day, but per job.14:26 Meaning, in this case, you want him to buy the coat,14:29 so you tell him, I'm going to give you14:31 ten dollars when you buy me the coat.14:33 That's condition number one.14:34 If you don't pay him for it,14:35 he decides to volunteer on his own to give it to you,14:38 that's going to be a problem.14:39 You must pay him for his effort.14:41 That's number one.14:43 Number two. Now, some people are asking,14:46 why is it that you have to pay the goy for his job?14:49 That's called14:50 ketzitzat sachar. And the answer is, when you pay him for it,14:52 when you tell the goy,14:53 Mister goy, I'm giving you ten dollars for your job,14:56 then why is the goy buying it?14:57 Not for you. He's buying it for himself.14:59 He wants the ten dollars. He wants to earn the15:03 ten dollars. So that makes it that he's doing it for himself, at least.15:06 Okay. Number two, condition number two is15:08 you cannot force him to buy it on Shabbat.15:11 For example, you can't tell him,15:13 Go on Saturday and buy the coat for me,15:17 the jacket for me on Saturday.15:19 You're telling him to do it on Shabbat. That's asur.15:22 Also, you cannot force him means, like we said,15:25 like the way, even though, like we said,15:26 there's a machloket over here,15:28 but majority of the Acharonim hold15:30 that you cannot corner him15:33 that he can only buy it on Shabbat.15:34 Meaning, if the sale is only on Shabbat,15:37 you're not giving him any other option,15:39 that's not mutar, even though you don't mention Shabbat.15:41 If you tell him, Go buy me this jacket,15:43 which is on $50, it's on sale for $50 by Macy's,15:46 and the sale is only on Shabbat,15:48 it's also going to be a problem.15:50 You have to give him an option15:52 to be able to do it either before Shabbat or after Shabbat.15:56 So let's say it's a two-day sale.15:59 It's from—16:00 Friday and Shabbat, and the goy has the option. He could have worked Friday, even though I know he probably will go Shabbat because it's easier for him. Who cares? I gave him the option.16:08 He could have worked Friday, he could have worked Shabbat. I'm paying him ten dollars for his job, for his effort.16:14 Okay, so far I'm good. I have fulfilled these two conditions. I'm paying him for it, and I'm not forcing him to do it on Shabbat.16:22 Condition number three: if the goy is doing something that's asur, it cannot be done in your house.16:30 So in this case, happens to be it's Macy's. Macy's is not your house, so you don't have that issue.16:35 But in the case where you're going to say, you know what, let me allow the goy to tailor my jacket for me.16:40 I'm going to get my, you know, happens to be my housekeeper used to be a seamstress in her old country, and now I want her to, you know, take in the dress.16:49 I'm paying her for it. I'm paying her extra. I'm telling her, listen, I'm going to give you an extra twenty dollars if you do my dress.16:54 She could have done it anytime she wants, but if she's doing it in your house, in your property, that is asur.17:00 You cannot allow her to do it in your property.17:03 In the mashal that we're using, where the goy is buying it from Macy's and Macy's is not your house, so you don't have such an issue.17:10 Number four, condition number four. Even when we allow the goy to do something in his own house,17:15 it cannot be something where the job that he's doing is connected to the ground, like building a house or digging a house.17:23 Now, this last condition really is going to be much more in detail,17:30 parashat Terumah. I don't want to spend time on it, but these are the four conditions that one could tell the goy to do something for him,17:37 even though the goy may do it on Shabbat, it'll be mutar when you have these four17:42 conditions. Condition number one: you're paying the goy for his job.17:45 Condition number two: you're not forcing him to do it on Shabbat.17:48 He has the option to do it before or after Shabbat.17:51 Condition number three: it's not being done in your house.17:53 And finally, condition number four: it's not a job which he has to do his work where it's connected to the ground.18:01 For example, he has to work in the real estate. He has to do melacha like building or fixing up a wall, painting a house, etc.18:10 Let's give you now some practical cases and explain why they're18:16 mutar. You have a car, it has a problem, and you need to take it to a mechanic.18:20 Your mechanic is a18:22 non-Jew. And by the way, this only applies to18:25 non-Jews. If you want the goy to do something for you,18:28 you can't take your car to a mechanic, to a Jew who doesn't keep anything.18:33 You say, Listen, anyway he lives like a goy, he's doing it anyway, he's open anyway.18:36 No, you cannot do that.18:37 It's still an aveirah. This is only true by a goy.18:41 So now you have a problem with your car.18:43 You need the car, I don't know, you need new axles, you need new steering wheel, you need to rotate the tires.18:50 All these are18:52 melachot, fixing the car, and all these things are18:54 melachot. So you want to give it to your mechanic, and you want to drop it off on Friday.18:59 Mutar or asur? The answer is, are you giving him enough time to be able to fix it?19:05 Let's say it takes two hours for your car to be fixed,19:07 so you can't drop it off five minutes before Shabbat and tell him, I need it to be ready five minutes after Shabbat,19:15 because it doesn't take ten minutes for the car to be fixed.19:17 You have to give him enough time that he's able to fix your car.19:21 Two hours. You have to give him at least two hours, either before Shabbat or after Shabbat.19:25 So therefore, if I drop off my car to a mechanic and I tell him, Listen, I'm picking it up on Tuesday,19:30 and all it takes him is one or two hours, even though I may know that he's going to do it for me on Shabbat.19:36 Doesn't make a difference. It's not my job.19:38 It's not my business. It's his problem.19:40 I'm paying him $300 to fix my car,19:43 so that's condition number19:45 one. Number two is I'm giving him—I'm not forcing him to do it on Shabbat, I'm giving him time to do it before or after Shabbat.19:49 Number three is he's not doing it in my house; it's his garage.19:52 And number four is it's a car. It's not something that's attached to the ground;19:55 therefore, it will be mutar.19:57 I'll give you another case for the ladies.19:59 Ladies don't drive off the car by the mechanic,20:01 and if they do—let me speak to your husbands.20:04 Gotta fix up the husbands.20:05 Anyway, the next case is you're giving your clothes to the dry cleaners on Friday.20:11 You have a wedding on Tuesday or Wednesday.20:14 You're giving your dress or your shirts or your suit,20:16 you're giving it to the dry cleaners, and you need it to have cleaned.20:19 So how long does the dry cleaners take?20:22 An hour, two hours, I don't know how they do it, but I'm assuming two, three hours.20:25 You're giving them enough time. You're dropping it off Friday,20:28 even though it's right before Shabbat, but you're allowing—you're giving them time.20:31 They're telling you, Come back by Wednesday,20:33 right? They always give you like three, four days later,20:35 and we all know it takes them ten minutes,20:37 but still they tell you, Come back four or five days later.20:40 Fine. It's good. It's mutar.20:43 But I know they're going to work on it on Shabbat20:46 because nobody's coming into the store on Shabbat;20:48 it's in the Jewish neighborhood.20:48 But still, since they have ample time to do it after20:52 Shabbat—Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, and20:54 Wednesday—they're telling me to come Thursday,20:56 I don't know, whatever, that's up to them.20:58 Mutar. I'm paying them for the job.21:00 I'm not forcing them to work on Shabbat.21:02 It's not being done in my house,21:04 and it's a dress. It's a suit.21:06 It's not connected to the ground.21:08 Third example is what we mentioned already,21:11 where you're having a tailor, a non-Jewish tailor,21:15 tailor your suit or, you know, take in a dress or tailor a dress, whatever it may be.21:20 Again, mutar to give it to them on Friday.21:23 If you give them time to be able to fix it even after Shabbat.21:29 So if I need my cuffs on my pants,21:32 if a lady needs her dress to be taken in,21:35 and you give them time to work on it21:38 either before or after Shabbat,21:39 you're paying them for the job.21:40 It's not being done in your house.21:42 Like we mentioned before, it cannot be done in your house.21:44 If your housekeeper knows how to do it,21:46 she's going to be doing it in your house, it's a problem.21:48 If she wants to take it home, let her do it in her house.21:50 But even though she's going to do it in her house on Shabbat,21:52 again, you're giving her time to do it.21:55 She could have done it in your house on Friday21:56 or done it in your house on Thursday.21:58 She decides to take it to her house and do it on Shabbat.22:01 That's her business.22:02 It is mutar.22:04 These are the halachot for this22:08 halacha, meaning to say the practical halachot with these four conditions.22:11 I hope we gave enough examples.22:12 I see a question here on the text.22:14 I ask you if you're still listening,22:17 just, you know, to help me out over here,22:19 what do you mean when you say,22:20 What about sending mail?22:22 I don't understand exactly the question you want me to answer.22:25 So go ahead and retext your question a little bit clearer, please,22:30 just to understand the question.22:31 What about sending mail on Shabbat?22:33 I don't know what you mean.22:34 Let's go on now to22:40 Halacha Tet-Zayin. Halacha Tet-Zayin. Now, this is really a halacha that has nothing to do with telling goyim on Shabbat,22:45 but it's here because it's in22:49 siman Shin-Zayin, and we haven't done it yet,22:51 and we have to finish the22:53 parasha. We already did the last halacha, which is Yud-chet and22:56 Yud-tet already, we did it.22:57 We spoke about Daber davar and23:00 mimtzo cheftzecha. So over here, this halacha is brought down,23:03 Shin-Zayin. It's talking about Jews and Jews dealing with Jews on Shabbat,23:07 and okay, we'll explain it.23:10 And we'll come back again to the next23:12 halacha, which is a big halacha in the laws of23:18 amira l'akum. Let's say you want to borrow something from your friend on Shabbat,23:22 and the person who's lending you the item doesn't trust you.23:26 He says, Listen, how do I know I'm going to get it back?23:27 You go to somebody's house, and23:30 you say, Listen, it's freezing outside.23:32 May I borrow your jacket?23:34 You say, We're doing this again23:36 every year. You take my jacket, and I have to buy a new one the next season.23:39 I know what's going to happen.23:41 No, no, no, I promise I'll bring it back on Sunday.23:43 I don't know. You said that last year and two years ago.23:47 Listen, we're neighbors, but I don't own a jacket store.23:51 Buy yourself a jacket.23:52 So the guy doesn't trust you.23:53 He's not going to let you take his jacket on Shabbat23:57 unless you leave a collateral.24:00 Leaving collateral, is that like a payment or something?24:03 Is that24:04 mutar on Shabbat? Says the Ben Ish Chai, and24:06 that's the halacha24:08 in Shulchan Aruch, Yachol laniach mashkon etzlo. You could keep a collateral,24:13 אך יניח המשכון בסתם ולא יאמר לו בפירוש, הניח משכון זה. But you have to be careful in how you speak and how you deal with it.24:17 Don't say, Okay, here is my watch as a collateral for your jacket.24:22 Don't say that.24:23 That's like, that's the way business is done,24:25 right? It's a trade.24:27 I give you something, you give me something back.24:28 True, today, in our days, we don't do trading, but it happens to be24:32 that online you can do still some trading,24:35 but still, that's the way, זהו מעשה. That's the way you do it on a weekday.24:39 What you could do, however, what you could do is24:43 you could leave over your watch without saying anything.24:47 Says, I can't, I don't know, I don't trust you, you take my jacket again, not give it back.24:51 So listen, I'm going to leave my watch over here.24:53 You're not saying anything. So I'm leaving my watch over here.24:55 If I want to leave my watch somewhere, can I do it?24:57 Yeah, I can do it on Shabbat.24:59 So I'm not saying this is my watch as a collateral.25:01 He understands my watch is here,25:03 which means I'm going to bring you back my jacket in order to get my more expensive watch.25:06 That's fine.25:07 That's mutar on Shabbat with the following condition.25:10 Says the Ben Ish Chai, what is that condition?25:12 When can I leave something over as a collateral when I'm not25:16 expressly, when I'm not expressing that it is a collateral?25:19 Says the Ben25:26 Ish Chai, במידי במאמרים, בשואל מנכר אחד ומשקה ומלבושים לצורך השבת. That's only if I'm borrowing from my friend on Shabbat, another Jew,25:30 if I'm borrowing something that is for the sake of Shabbat,25:34 like food, drinks, clothing,25:38 אבל שלא לצורך השבת. But if I'm borrowing something that's not for the sake of Shabbat,25:41 let's say I want to take, I don't know, something25:45 I need, what do you call it, the trays, serving bowls.25:48 Why, you have guests on25:49 Shabbat? No, actually, I'm having a nice party,25:53 מוצאי שבת, a lot of people are coming over, it's a big25:56 melaveh malka. So that's not for Shabbat,25:57 that's for after Shabbat.25:59 Even though, let's say you're in the case where you don't have a problem of26:02 eruv. Okay, you don't have a problem of carrying on Shabbat.26:04 You can leave over. You can borrow something, that's fine,26:07 okay? There's nothing wrong with taking a dish in the area where you have a problem of26:12 eruv. I mean to say, an area where you don't have a problem of carrying,26:15 there's nothing wrong with taking a dish to your house.26:17 But to leave over a collateral for it, that's going to be a problem.26:23 That already looks like you're buying it.26:26 Even though we both know you're just borrowing it and leaving a collateral,26:29 since it's not being used for Shabbat itself, they were not matir.26:33 Okay, but we did learn from this halacha something very important.26:37 You're allowed to take something from other Jews on Shabbat,26:39 again in an area where there is no problem of carrying,26:43 there is a kosher26:46 eruv, it's a private property, whatever the case may be.26:49 You're allowed to carry from one place to another. You're allowed to take something from your friend,26:53 even though, by the way, that may be his job.26:56 I'll give you a few examples.26:57 Let's say you need to get some groceries.27:02 What does that mean?27:03 You need some tomatoes, you need some oranges,27:06 and you want to take from your neighbor.27:08 You live upstairs, they live downstairs, or vice versa,27:11 and you need to borrow some. You're not borrowing,27:13 you're taking. You're not giving back the tomato, right?27:16 You're taking the tomato, you're taking the orange,27:18 and you're using it for Shabbat.27:20 You're allowed to take it.27:20 There's nothing wrong. They're giving me something on Shabbat.27:23 Let's say that's his job.27:24 He is the minimart owner,27:27 and he has all these sodas and drinks in his house.27:32 Yeah, but he uses them also.27:34 So since he uses them also, he's allowed to give it to me.27:37 He's allowed to give it to me,27:38 and if he wants to work out the money later on after Shabbat,27:43 that's already a different issue.27:45 That's already—but I'm not buying it from him on Shabbat.27:46 He's giving it to me right now on Shabbat. I can use it.27:49 Same thing will be if I'm taking medicine from a pharmacist.27:54 Now, this is not a black and white.27:56 Meaning to say, in an area where medicine is28:00 mutar to be taken on Shabbat, for example, antibiotics.28:03 Antibiotics, if you're prescribed or if you're told that you have to take antibiotics,28:06 you're allowed to take it on Shabbat.28:07 So, in that case, where a person has to take antibiotics,28:11 and the kids went and took all the antibiotics and flushed it down the28:14 toilet because they like to see how the pills float in water and then disappear.28:20 It's a real magic show for the kids, right?28:22 And they decide to do it with your $200 bottle of antibiotics.28:26 Now you don't have your antibiotics on Shabbat,28:28 and you need it because you have to take it six days,28:30 and if you don't, it's going to come back.28:32 So you go over to your neighbor,28:34 who is not a problem, who is in your enclosed area.28:40 It's not a problem of carrying,28:41 and you ask him, Can I please have some antibiotics from your house?28:44 You're allowed to take from him the antibiotics,28:46 even though he's a pharmacist and he carries the medicine.28:49 He sometimes works out of the house.28:50 You're allowed to take it from him on Shabbat.28:52 You can't talk money.28:53 You can't leave over something as a collateral for trusting.28:59 If you're saying that's a collateral,29:00 you may leave something behind just29:02 to remind, but you cannot speak.29:05 You cannot use terminologies that imply that you're buying it.29:09 Say, Can I have some medicine?29:10 You can say, Can I have some oranges?29:12 Can I have some tomatoes?29:13 But the words, you have to be very careful.29:16 You can take an item.29:17 You have to be careful with your words29:18 that shouldn't sound like you're purchasing the item.29:21 It shouldn't sound like there's a buying and selling going on.29:23 That is Halacha Tet Zayin.29:25 We move on now to Halacha Yud Zayin,29:27 and this is really a short halacha in the Ben29:30 Ish Chai, but29:35 it's a huge halacha in all the29:38 poskim, because the details and the applications of it are a lot,29:47 huge. So we're not going to read it from the Ben Ish Chai yet.29:50 We are gonna start with a background,29:54 a huge background,29:55 meaning to say we're gonna start from the Gemara,29:57 go on to the different opinions,30:00 to the Shulchan Aruch,30:01 and hopefully discuss each part in a clear way.30:06 And if you don't understand something,30:08 we ask you please to call in30:10 or to text in your question.30:12 The numbers are30:16 347-927-8398. Text in your question, text in any comment30:18 that we need to clarify a little bit more.30:21 And if we didn't get to it yet,30:23 just have a little patience.30:24 Hopefully we'll get to it.30:24 Next halacha speaks about a famous heter30:28 where you're allowed to tell a goy to do something on Shabbat,30:31 known in the poskim as30:36 shvut d'shvut. Okay?30:38 Shvut d'shvut. Before we come to start talking about the background,30:41 let's first translate.30:43 What is30:46 shvut? Shvut means30:47 any—it's a terminology,30:49 it's a halachic terminology,30:50 which is used for anything30:53 that's asur30:56 miderabanan, things that we cannot do on Shabbat,30:58 which are rabbinic,30:59 which are made by the rabbis31:01 that we can't do,31:01 which, by the way,31:02 is the majority of halachot Shabbat,31:04 that is known as31:07 shvut, no matter how they come in,31:08 that's called a31:11 shvut. Shvut d'shvut means31:13 when there's a double derabanan taking place,31:17 two actions which are derabanan taking place31:19 in order for my intended act to be completed.31:25 Meaning, we're learning so far, up till now,31:27 we have learned a lot about31:29 what you can tell the goy,31:30 you cannot tell the goy.31:32 We've stressed it a few times31:34 that according to31:37 halacha... Telling a goy on Shabbat31:39 to do something for you31:41 is a violation31:43 miderabbanan. It's31:45 stam min haTorah. With the31:46 halacha, psak halacha according to most of the opinions,31:48 and this is Shulchan Aruch as well,31:50 is that to command a goy to do something for you on Shabbat31:55 is an issur derabbanan. Which means31:56 anybody who tells a goy to do something for him on Shabbat31:58 that he could not have done, he—32:00 is doing an issur shvut, so instead of saying derabbanan, I could say32:05 shvut. Now, what have you told the goy to do for you?32:07 If you told the goy to put on the fire on the stove,32:11 lighting a fire on Shabbat is32:14 an issur de'oraita. This is actually the only melachah de'oraita that's clearly expressed in the pasuk:32:21 Lo32:24 teva'aru esh b'chol moshvoteichem b'yom haShabbat. Do not put on the fire.32:25 If a Jew comes over and tells a goy, Put on the fire on Shabbat,32:29 so the Jew didn't put on the fire, so that means the Jew didn't32:33 commit an issur de'oraita, but he told the goy to do32:35 an issur de'oraita. Means I've done a shvut. I've done32:40 an issur derabbanan. Of what? Of commanding the goy to do32:42 an issur de'oraita. Now, what if I tell the goy to do something that's32:49 asur miderabbanan? What does that mean? Like, let's say muktzeh. Muktzeh is also32:54 miderabbanan. Hachamim were gozer of certain items that should be in the category of32:58 muktzeh. In fact, next parashah, parashat Meketz is, and the one afterwards, parashat Vayigash, in the33:05 Beinish Hai, discuss the laws of muktzeh in depth.33:09 We'll probably only get up to that after the holidays of Pesach,33:13 because already from next week I think we have to jump already to Hilchot Purim,33:17 and then from Purim we jump right away into Hilchot Pesach,33:20 and after Pesach, Sefirat HaOmer, and then we come back already to the Hilchot of33:25 muktzeh. In any case, let's come back over here.33:27 What about a case where a person is commanding a goy to do33:31 an issur derabbanan? Muktzeh. He tells a goy, let's say you have a—what's it called? I'm trying to think what's33:37 muktzeh. Let's say you have your phone. That's a good example.33:41 You have your phone. You have your smartphone.33:44 It's expensive, and you have it in a place where your kids could get to it.33:49 You tell the goy, Could you please move the phone and put it somewhere else?33:54 That's called—33:56 Shvut d'shvut. I'm telling the goy, which in the sefer is in the issur d'rabbanan, to move my phone for me.34:02 Moving the phone is asur because it's34:06 muktzeh, the phone is muktzeh, and by me moving it would have been34:10 an issur d'rabbanan. Here I'm committing two34:11 d'rabbanans. I'm telling a goy to do34:13 an issur d'rabbanan. That's called shvut d'shvut. Good?34:16 Now we want to know, what is the din of this34:22 shvut d'shvut? And the answer is that there are cases where we find that shvut d'shvut would be permitted on Shabbat.34:29 Not all cases of shvut d'shvut is permitted on Shabbat.34:32 There are specific cases.34:34 Shvut d'shvut, meaning to say, if I tell a goy to do an issur that's only rabbinic on Shabbat,34:40 it would be permitted in specific cases.34:43 What are those cases?34:44 Well, let's begin from the Gemara.34:47 We have 15 minutes. Hopefully we'll go through the Gemara,34:50 the Rishonim, the different opinions on this Gemara,34:53 and the halacha in34:55 Shulchan Aruch, and some short examples.34:57 Hopefully we can squeeze that in all in 15 minutes,34:59 and next week already we'll discuss this halacha in much more depth.35:03 Gemara Masechet Eruvin, daf samech zayin amud bet,35:06 if you want to look it up, towards the bottom.35:08 The Gemara says that one time there was a child.35:12 It was the day of his brit milah,35:13 and what happened is they had hot water that was there35:17 that was being warmed up from before Shabbat,35:19 boiling hot water, which obviously they mixed it with a little bit of cold water35:22 in order to wash up the baby prior to the milah.35:27 And what happened is that that hot water spilled.35:30 They came and they told Rabba in the Gemara.35:33 So Rabba tells them, Okay, listen,35:36 go to my house. I have some hot water.35:38 Go bring the kid some hot water from my house.35:40 So they told him, One second,35:43 we didn't make eruv this week,35:45 meaning to say, we all share... A courtyard together,35:49 and when you have different owners,35:52 different baalei batim sharing one property,35:56 you must make an eruv together.35:58 We didn't make an eruv this week.36:00 So how do you tell them, you can't carry?36:02 That means it's a shared driveway, it's a shared backyard.36:05 I can't take from your house,36:07 take it outside through the backyard36:09 into the house over here with the child.36:11 We didn't make36:13 an eruv. So the rabbi says, okay, do it through a goy.36:17 Go tell the goy to do it.36:19 Go tell the goy to take the hot water from my house36:23 and to bring it into this house.36:25 Why? Because carrying in an area where there's no36:28 eruv, meaning to say where the backyard is36:30 over here, this is a closed area,36:32 but still there's no36:33 eruv. We didn't join all the houses together through36:40 an eruv. Carrying in it is a36:42 issur d'rabbanan. To tell the goy to carry,36:44 in general commanding a goy to do something36:46 for you is a36:47 issur d'rabbanan. Over here he's carrying the hot water36:50 from the rabbi's house into the child's house.36:53 It's36:55 shvut d'shvut. Okay, now the Gemara has a question on it back and forth.36:58 In general, we hold that you cannot do37:01 an issur d'rabbanan for a child, for, excuse me, for an issur d'oraita, for a mitzvah d'oraita. The Gemara explains whatever it explains over there,37:09 but the maskana, the conclusion of this Gemara is37:12 that you see a goy was commanded,37:14 and this is37:15 a halacha, a goy was commanded to carry something in an37:19 area which is only forbidden37:22 mid'rabbanan, to bring it to the child's house.37:24 This is the Gemara.37:25 Question is, what halacha do we derive from this Gemara?37:30 So we have three main approaches in37:35 halacha. Now, I mean to say, different ways to explain the Gemara,37:38 but the halachic differences between them are three.37:43 The three approaches in halacha to this Gemara,37:46 we'll start with the first one.37:47 The first one, which basically is the most stringent explanation of the Gemara,37:52 is the opinion of the Tosafot, the Ramban, and the Rashba.37:55 They explain that this Gemara,37:56 what happened in this Gemara is that37:58 a goy carried hot water38:00 for the sake of a child who was about to be circumcised.38:04 Why was it permitted?38:07 He's, you're telling the goy to do38:08 an issur d'Rabbanan. You can't carry the hot water,38:09 so why is it permitted to tell the goy to do it?38:11 We learn you can't tell the goy to do anything that you can't do.38:14 So these Rishonim explain38:16 that it was only permitted because it was a special case.38:19 It was a case where the mitzvah was a mitzvah of brit milah.38:24 And what's so special about brit milah?38:25 Well, the Torah tells us,38:30 Uvayom hashmini yimol besar orlato. On the eighth day, you could do circumcision.38:35 What do you mean, on the eighth day?38:36 We already know that eighth day you do circumcision.38:39 The Gemara tells us38:41 even if a baby is born on Shabbat,38:43 which means that his eighth day in his life will be on a Shabbat,38:47 you could circumcise him also on Shabbat.38:50 Milah docheh Shabbat.38:51 The mitzvah of brit milah is so important38:55 that it pushes away Shabbat.38:56 Meaning to say, the mohel is allowed to cut the39:01 orlah, he's allowed to make an incision,39:02 he's allowed to basically39:05 allow—otherwise it would have been an39:07 issur d'Oraita—he's allowed to do this on Shabbat.39:09 Why?39:10 Because for the sake of a mitzvah of milah.39:13 With that in mind, comes the39:14 Tosafot and explains this Gemara.39:16 The Gemara that allowed us to take hot water39:19 for the sake of a child who's about to be circumcised,39:22 you know why it was39:24 mutar? Because it was a mitzvah of milah.39:26 But you can't do this for any mitzvah.39:28 You can't go ahead and start saying,39:30 you know what, let me tell a goy to do an39:32 issur d'Rabbanan now, only for the sake of milah,39:34 or in the case where a person is sick.39:36 That's already a different category also.39:38 A person who's sick,39:40 hacha mi mutar. But otherwise,39:41 you can't tell a goy to do something for you,39:42 whether it's d'Oraita or39:44 d'Rabbanan. That's the opinion of these Rishonim,39:46 Tosafot,39:47 Ramban, Rashba, as well, of course, as others who go39:50 in this shittah. The next explanation.39:53 A second understanding of this Gemara39:54 is the opinion of the Rambam.39:56 The Rambam says39:57 that this Gemara39:59 is basically sending...40:00 It's a model for all cases.40:03 It happened to be that the case in the Gemara40:05 where they brought the hot water was for the sake of40:10 brit milah. But it's a formula. The Gemara is giving us a formula.40:13 If you tell a goy to—tell another—excuse me, if you tell a goy to do an40:19 issur derabbanan for the sake of a mitzvah, it's mutar.40:22 The Gemara's case was a mitzvah of40:24 milah. It could have been any mitzvah, really.40:26 So therefore, says the Rambam,40:28 if you want to tell a goy to do an40:32 issur derabbanan, like climbing the40:33 tree—you know, you can't climb a tree on Shabbat;40:35 it's asur miderabbanan, though.40:36 You're worried that you might break a branch off of it.40:39 So therefore, Chachamim said you can't climb a tree,40:41 you can't lean on the tree on Shabbat.40:43 That's halacha40:44 lemaaseh. It's40:45 asur miderabbanan. Let's say on top of the tree there is40:49 a—I don't know how this40:51 happened—but there's a Sefer Torah40:52 that you need to bring down in order that you should40:55 read in front of the kahal on Shabbat.40:57 You're allowed to tell a goy40:59 go up the tree.41:00 Now, climbing the tree is41:01 asur miderabbanan. I'm telling the goy, which is usually41:04 asur miderabbanan, it's okay.41:05 Shvut d'Shvut. I'm telling the goy,41:07 which is one41:08 issur derabbanan, to do another issur derabbanan, which is called41:11 shvut d'Shvut. L'tzorech mitzvah,41:12 I need the Sefer Torah right now to read it in the41:14 tzibbur, to read it in shul.41:15 That is mutar on Shabbat.41:18 But that's not the case of the Gemara.41:20 The Gemara was a case of41:21 brit milah. Still, the Rambam understands41:22 that when the Gemara says41:24 milah, it doesn't mean only41:25 brit milah; it means any mitzvah,41:28 as long as you're only doing41:32 issur derabbanan by telling the goy to do an41:35 issur derabbanan. That's called41:38 shvut d'Shvut l'tzorech mitzvah,41:40 which is usually41:42 asur derabbanan, to do an issur derabbanan for the sake of mitzvah.41:44 That's the opinion of the Rambam.41:46 There's a third understanding of this Gemara,41:49 and that is, I believe41:51 the Baal HaItur for sure,41:53 who's brought down in the41:55 halacha. The Baal HaItur is one of the Rishonim.41:57 He understands it the most lenient way.42:00 He says, you see from this Gemara,42:02 to tell a goy on Shabbat—42:05 To do something asur42:08 is mutar when it's being done for the sake of any mitzvah,42:13 any mitzvah.42:15 Actually, it's not the Bahag; it's42:16 the Ritur. Bahag has a different—sorry, something else.42:18 The Ritur explains that,42:20 look, the Gemara told us that you're bringing hot water,42:23 you're carrying hot water for the sake of a child,42:26 for the sake of42:27 milah. Happens to be, in the case of the Gemara,42:29 the happens to be was only42:31 issur d'rabbanan. But otherwise, says the42:34 Ritur, any42:35 issur, even if the issur is42:37 de'oraita, according to the42:39 Ritur, it will be permitted for the sake of mitzvah.42:42 Which means, according to the42:44 Ritur—I'm not saying this is42:45 halacha—according to the42:46 Ritur, he would say that42:48 if you need to cook something on Shabbat,42:51 and let's say you need42:53 it—it's very, very important42:54 because you would not be able to fulfill the mitzvah of,42:57 let's say, seudat Shabbat.42:58 How about this?42:59 You need to have seudat Shabbat.43:02 You need to have a seudah on Shabbat, right?43:03 You need to have bread.43:04 The dough is ready43:06 and the oven is on,43:07 and now there's a problem43:10 because the bread is still dough;43:11 you don't have bread.43:12 So according to the43:15 Ritur—it's not43:15 halacha—according to the43:16 Ritur, you could tell the43:17 goy, Please bake the bread for me.43:19 Please bake the bread for me,43:20 assuming the bread43:21 in its dough state43:23 was not43:24 mukzeh. You could tell him,43:25 Go bake the bread for me.43:26 Why?43:27 Because43:27 it's being done for the sake of mitzvah.43:29 I'm not telling him to do it43:31 for no reason.43:31 I'm just, you know, I just want a snack on the bread.43:34 It's the mitzvah of seudat Shabbat.43:36 That's how the Ritur understands the Gemara.43:38 Those are the three opinions.43:40 The43:41 Ramban, the43:41 Rashba, and the Tosafot,43:42 which are very43:43 machmir, who say43:43 even43:45 shvut d'shvut, even telling a goy to do43:47 an issur d'rabbanan, is only permitted43:48 for the sake of43:49 mitzvat milah43:50 or43:50 choleh or somebody who's not feeling well.43:53 The43:54 Rambam who holds43:55 shbut d'shbut is always43:57 mutar for the sake of a mitzvah,43:58 and the43:59 Aruch holds any time44:01 to tell44:02 a goy for the sake of a mitzvah44:03 is44:04 mutar. The halacha, who do we hold like?44:06 Let me read you the words44:07 of Shulchan Aruch44:07 in44:09 Siman Shin Zayin, halacha hei. This is44:11 the halacha, and the halacha says,44:17 דבר שאינו מלאכה ואינו אסור לעשותו בשבת אלא משום שבות. Something which is44:19 not44:21 asur mideoraita, and it's only forbidden44:23 because it's44:30 derabbanan, מותר לישראל לומר לגוי לעשותו בשבת. A Jew may command a44:31 goy to do it on Shabbat,44:34 when,44:37 והוא שיהיה שם, as long44:38 as—in this case,44:40 as long as you tell him44:40 in the following44:43 three44:44 areas.44:44 Number one,44:48 שיהיה שם מקצת חולי. There has to be44:48 a little bit of sickness,44:51 or,44:54 ויהיה צריך לדבר צורך הרבה, or that you need44:56 very much44:57 the thing to be done44:58 for you on Shabbat,45:00 or45:01 מפני מצוה, or for the sake45:02 of a mitzvah.45:04 All of a sudden,45:05 when we read these words45:06 of Shulchan Aruch,45:06 which are word for word45:07 from the Rambam,45:08 we're45:09 introduced to another45:12 two heterim. We said45:13 from the Gemara45:14 it seems like you're allowed45:14 to tell the goy45:16 to bring the hot water45:17 for you45:20 from the one house45:21 to another45:22 because he's only45:23 carrying in an area45:24 which is forbidden45:25 miderabbanan, his backyard,45:26 even though45:27 it doesn't have an45:29 eruv. And we said45:30 it's because for the sake45:31 of a mitzvah.45:32 In the words of the Rambam,45:33 he brings45:34 only mitzvah.45:34 He learns from that45:35 Gemara—the Gemara is talking about45:36 not only for the sake of mitzvah;45:37 the child was45:39 before circumcision,45:41 which means45:41 he was a little bit sick,45:42 he was45:43 mitzta'er, he needed to be washed45:44 in45:45 hot water. Also,45:45 he says,45:46 צורך הרבה. He felt it was very,45:48 very necessary45:48 for the child to be washed.45:49 Maybe he wasn't even sick.45:50 That's the way45:51 the Minchat Cohen explains him.45:53 So...45:54 The Rambam tells us45:55 in three areas45:56 I'm allowed to do45:58 shbut d'shbut. What are the three areas?46:00 Number one is46:01 there's a little bit of a sickness.46:03 Number two is46:04 it's very,46:05 very necessary.46:06 Number three is46:06 for the sake of a mitzvah.46:08 Comes now46:09 the Shulchan Aruch46:09 and brings us a few examples.46:12 Ketzad? Omeres hagoy b'Shabbat la'alot be'ilan lehavi shofar l'tkiat mitzvah. A46:17 goy could be commanded on Shabbat46:18 by a Jew46:19 to climb up the tree46:21 to bring down the shofar46:22 so we could blow with it.46:24 What does that mean?46:25 Well,46:26 blowing the shofar46:27 on46:28 Rosh Hashanah is a mitzvah.46:29 So46:30 I'm telling the46:30 goy, go up the tree,46:32 which is46:34 asur miderabanan, and bring down with you46:35 the shofar46:38 so we could fulfill the mitzvah46:40 of blowing the shofar.46:42 So here is a46:43 shbut d'shbut. I'm telling the46:44 goy, which is46:46 asur miderabanan, to climb up the tree,46:47 which is also46:49 asur miderabanan, for the sake of bringing down the shofar,46:51 which is a mitzvah.46:52 Shbut d'shbut l'tzorech mitzvah. That's one case.46:54 Another case46:55 the Shulchan Aruch brings us:47:00 o l'havi mayim derech chatzer shelo eirvu l'rchutz bo metza'er. Or47:01 to bring hot water,47:03 like the case of the Gemara,47:04 to bring hot water47:05 through an area47:07 where it's forbidden to carry47:08 only47:09 miderabanan for the sake of a person47:10 who is not feeling well.47:12 Okay?47:13 That's a person47:15 who's metza'er. These are the words of Shulchan Aruch.47:16 However,47:17 the Shulchan Aruch concludes47:18 with the following words:47:20 v'yesh osrin. Even though47:21 we told you47:22 it's mutar, v'yesh osrin. Who's the yesh osrin?47:24 We already learned47:25 that's the opinion47:25 of the47:26 Tosafot, the Ramban,47:26 and the47:27 Rashba. So Maran brings the Shulchan Aruch47:30 a stam v'yesh. Stam means47:31 he rules this way,47:33 and then he also tells you,47:34 by the way,47:35 v'yesh osrin.47:35 It's not so simple47:36 to be so lenient.47:37 There's osrin as well.47:39 Fine.47:40 The47:40 Rama over there47:41 on that point47:42 writes two things.47:43 Number one is47:43 he says47:44 that Shulchan Aruch47:45 in Hilchot Shofar47:47 rules47:47 like the opinion47:48 who is lenient.47:49 That means47:50 he doesn't bring Yesh47:51 Osrim over there47:51 in47:54 סימן תקפ״ז. He also mentions47:55 that there are those opinions47:56 who are even more lenient.47:58 Maran doesn't bring that opinion.48:00 Who's so lenient that say that you could tell a goy to do48:04 an issur d'oraita. The Rama does say there is somebody who is also more lenient,48:08 look in the halachot of Reish Ayin Vav.48:10 Those halachot, be'ezrat Hashem, we'll talk about them at a different time.48:13 We can't discuss them now,48:14 but that's the Rama on that.48:16 So what comes out, basically, from this halacha,48:19 according to the Shulchan Aruch, in fact48:20 seems to be also the way of the Rama over here,48:24 that shvut d'shvut, they're going with the Rambam.48:25 Meaning to say, shvut d'shvut mutar for the sake of a mitzvah.48:30 You're allowed to tell a goy to do something for you48:32 that's issur d'rabbanan for the sake of either a mitzvah48:35 or important, so necessary,48:38 and number three is if there's a little bit of sickness.48:40 All these three cases, by the way,48:42 will be discussed in full detail, be'ezrat Hashem, next week.48:45 We just don't have the time to;48:46 we're just listing them this week.48:48 I want to give you a few examples,48:51 but before I give you a few examples,48:52 I want to point out something very important.48:54 All this halacha of48:57 shvut d'shvut is not49:00 lechatchila. What does it mean it's not lechatchila? Meaning to say, you cannot set up your Shabbat49:03 where you're forced to come and tell the49:06 goy to do this for you on Shabbat.49:09 If you could take care of it before Shabbat,49:11 you have no permission to go ahead and do it on Shabbat.49:17 Meaning, let's say, for example,49:20 one of the cases we're49:21 gonna, you know, let's go through the49:22 examples and then we'll talk what I mean.49:27 You know, let's first do this, actually.49:28 Let me tell you what I mean.49:30 Okay, the halacha says, for example,49:31 when it comes to bit milah,49:32 let's say you know the child needs hot water,49:35 okay, and you know that he's gonna need the hot water49:39 to be bathed before the milah,49:41 let's say in the case of the Gemara,49:42 so you can't say, you know what,49:44 my neighbor has hot water.49:45 I didn't make an eruv, okay.49:47 Don't worry, I'll worry about49:48 Shabbat. I'll tell49:50 a goy to go carry the hot water from my neighbor's house49:52 and to bring it into my house.49:53 That cannot be done.49:54 You have the shofar on top of the tree.49:57 You say, now it's Friday.49:58 Why should I go climb?49:59 My goy's going to come tomorrow.50:01 Let me ask the goy to climb up the50:03 tree and bring it down.50:04 You can't do that.50:05 You could have done that on Friday.50:06 You can't delay it now on Shabbat50:09 to use this leniency of50:11 shvut d'shvut. Shvut d'shvut is a leniency,50:14 meaning to say50:15 it's only mutar when it's necessary.50:18 But if you could take care of it from beforehand,50:20 that you shouldn't have to come to50:22 a shvut d'shvut, you must take care of it beforehand.50:24 These are not my words.50:25 These are the words of50:27 Mishnah Berurah in two places. Look50:29 in siman reish nun hei, se'if katan50:30 aleph, and50:32 in siman shin lamed aleph, and on the Shulchan Aruch se'if vav.50:34 Let's give you a few examples,50:35 and this will conclude.50:36 And then afterwards,50:37 if you have any questions,50:38 please call in.50:39 We're here for a few more minutes50:40 to answer your questions,50:41 and certainly50:42 if you text,50:43 we'll answer your questions as well.50:45 Let's give you a few examples.50:48 Sometimes you go to a hotel,50:51 and—not sometimes,50:52 but that's the way to get into the50:54 hotel—you need to get in with this special key.50:56 The key is not a regular key.50:58 It's like a credit card,50:59 and you slide it in.51:01 It's called a magnetic door,51:02 and then it sends off like a digital sign51:05 and recognizes your key51:06 and opens your door.51:08 What do you do on Shabbat now?51:09 How do you get into your room on Shabbat?51:11 And the answer is,51:13 this is how you come in:51:14 either by,51:15 if you trust yourself,51:17 whatever it is,51:18 either by locking up the door from beforehand,51:20 meaning to say51:20 that you make sure that it doesn't close,51:22 so this way you can walk in51:23 and out of your room on Shabbat,51:25 assuming again that it's safe51:26 and all the other things,51:27 you're not running away from anybody,51:29 whatever it may be.51:30 But if you're stuck on Shabbat51:31 in such hotels51:33 where you,51:34 if you walk out of your room—51:35 You cannot come back in51:36 unless you use the card.51:38 You may ask from one of the workers of the hotel51:40 to take your51:41 card and open the door for you.51:43 Of51:44 course, you have to try51:45 to—it's better to set this up51:46 from before Shabbat.51:47 That's one example.51:48 Another example is,51:50 you have a lot of51:51 merchandise sitting in your backyard.51:53 You couldn't bring them into the house,51:55 whatever reason,51:56 you keep them out.51:57 It's the summer,51:58 and all of a sudden you look outside51:59 and you see a great storm coming,52:01 you know,52:01 with these dark clouds.52:03 You're allowed to tell52:05 a goy to bring the merchandise52:06 inside of the house52:07 in order to avoid financial damage.52:10 Why?52:11 Because the merchandise are52:13 muktzeh. To tell52:17 a goy is a issur d'rabbanan. Shvut d'Shvut l'tzorech harbeh, to avoid a huge financial loss,52:19 is mutar.52:20 Another case:52:22 you share a backyard52:24 with your neighbor,52:26 okay,52:27 but you forgot to make an52:29 eruv, so therefore you can't carry in that backyard.52:31 However,52:32 you realize that you didn't have any52:34 challah for Shabbat,52:35 for the sake of seudat Shabbat.52:36 But you know your neighbor52:37 made tons of52:38 challah. They were expecting guests52:39 and didn't come.52:40 You're allowed to tell52:41 a goy to carry for you52:43 rolls of52:44 challah, or bread,52:45 whatever that may be,52:46 from your neighbor52:47 to bring it into your house52:49 through this backyard,52:51 because carrying in the52:52 backyard is asur only52:54 mid'rabbanan. To tell the goy to do it52:55 is52:57 a shvut d'Shvut, two52:58 d'rabbanans, for the sake of52:59 a mitzvah of bringing the bread.53:00 That's mutar.53:02 I'll just give53:03 you—I know we're running out of53:05 time—I'll give you one last example.53:07 Let's say,53:09 by accident,53:10 your kids put on the radio.53:11 And the radio is all53:14 staticky and,53:14 you know, or, you know,53:15 they put on sometimes53:16 the goyish music by mistake,53:18 it was forgot on,53:20 and it's making,53:21 you53:21 know, kids like to play,53:22 and they made a lot of noise,53:23 and now the radio is blasting in the house,53:25 and you can't sit to have your53:27 meal with the goyish music in the background53:29 and listening to these people53:31 talk about all the nonsense on the radio53:33 on Shabbat.53:34 You're allowed to call over a goy53:36 and ask him to shut off53:38 the radio on Shabbat.53:40 Why?53:41 Shutting off the radio on Shabbat53:42 is53:43 a issur d'rabbanan. Calling a goy to do it for you53:45 is also53:48 a issur d'rabbanan. Shvut d'shvut, l'tzorech harbeh, as well as53:50 l'tzorech mitzvah, then maybe it's going to be mutar.53:53 Is this a black and white53:55 heter? No.53:55 Like we said beforehand,53:57 this, you have to make sure53:58 that you don't have to come to such a point.54:01 If you're stuck54:02 and you need to rely54:03 on such a heter in these cases,54:05 then you rely on them.54:06 Also, there's another exception,54:08 bezrat Hashem we'll talk about it next week.54:09 We'll come back to the examples,54:11 and we'll elaborate more on this54:13 halacha next week, bezrat Hashem, Wednesday on the Halacha Hour here on54:17 JRadio.com. This class will be aired on again tonight54:20 at 11 p.m. tonight.54:22 We want to give our thanks to54:24 Iran and the whole JRadio staff,54:25 and to you for listening.54:28 And whoever has a question54:29 could call in54:33 718-683-5858, 347-927-8398. Should have a wonderful week,54:37 bracha vhatzlacha and nachat from whatever you do.