Torah · MussarMussar99. Accomplishing תשובה שלימהTzidkat HaTzadikPart 99Rabbi Uri Nahum · September 9, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0011:11Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat hatzaddik ot tzaddiket. This is a very appropriate piece that we're going to hear this in the month of Elul and Teshuvah, as we're preparing ourselves for Rosh Hashanah, Aseret Yemei Teshuvah, and Yom Kippur.0:13So it's good to understand the goal of Teshuvah, the highest goal of Teshuvah.0:18I'm going to begin with something that's not in Rav Tzadok, but something I've always heard since my journey of, you know, embracing Torah,0:29and things, you know, that I've heard that used to bother me. I've had different answers along, you know, the road of understanding them,0:37but here's also what Rav Tzadok is going to say today will also explain it.0:42One statement I've heard from Rabbi Yehuda Ades, I heard it directly on the recording, and he says about Rav Chatzkel Levenstein, who used to be the mashgiach in the Mir Yeshiva in0:53Eretz Yisrael, who was one of the great baalei mussar. He says, it says about himself that he did teshuvah every single day.1:01Now, I guarantee you, when Rav Chatzkel Levenstein started doing teshuvah, he was on a much greater level than I can even imagine.1:07And yet, somehow he did teshuvah every single day, but he wasn't even a baal teshuvah. He grew up so religious.1:12He was, you know, he grew up in the Ran Torah, he was in yeshiva, he was big talmid chacham, one of the1:18gedolim, and one of the gedolim certainly in mussar. What in the world exactly are you doing teshuvah on?1:23What did you do wrong? Okay, so of course there are details, and we're not familiar with, everybody knows themselves,1:29but every single day, okay, we pick one thing, we work on it for an entire year, and we hope that we get there by the end of the year.1:34What does that mean, that you do teshuvah every single day and you're a different person every day?1:39Now, it's not Rav Chatzkel Levenstein. It's not something that he was mechadesh. It's what I heard about him,1:43but I started to notice that. You know, David HaMelech himself, through Sefer Tehillim, is bemoaning his sins.1:51And we all know that there was a sin with Bat Sheva, but you know what? At the end of the day,1:55look, it wasn't really a sin according to the Gemara, and even if it was, not on this level and things.2:01Still, why can't you see talking about it?2:05Vechatati negdi tamid, and, you know, hered kebesen me'avoni, Hashem, cleanse me from my sin.2:09You know, what's going on? I mean, okay, you did teshuva. Hashem told you on the spot,2:13like it says in the pasuk in Sefer Shmuel Bet, that okay, you know, you're forgiven.2:19You can get your punishment, but you're forgiven. But constantly David is praying.2:23What's going on over here? Obviously, we're missing something. The question is not on them.2:27The question is, why are we not understanding them?2:30So I've heard different answers along the way, like I said, but in Rav Tzadok's piece today,2:35in Tzaddi Tet, we'll get to see yet another level, another answer, and a really beautiful answer.2:42Says Rav Tzadok, siman l'teshuva gemurah. You want to know a good way to find out if you really did 100%2:52teshuva, a siman that you did 100% teshuva? Keshe'eino zocher klal hachet, when you completely forget that you did the sin, completely.3:01You know, we perhaps have done sins when we were younger, and we stopped.3:07We don't do the sins anymore, Baruch Hashem. We feel bad, perhaps when people remind us of them,3:13or we remind ourselves of them, or when situations come up and we remember them,3:17we feel terrible. We don't feel good about it. We don't like them. We did them. We don't like them.3:23But to completely forget them, you might think that you might have dementia.3:28I remember something, but I don't remember what I did. Completely forget it.3:31But that's actually a siman that you completely are forgiven.3:36Kemo she'amru. Like the Gemara says,3:41שלא יאמר לבעל תשובה זכור מעשיך הראשונים. The Gemara in Masechet Bava Metzia, when it talks about the issur of onaat devarim, of hurting other people with words,3:48the Gemara says an example of hurting other people with words is3:52going up to a person who is a baal teshuva, a person who used to do sins and now he's coming,3:58you know, Baruch Hashem, he's come a long way.4:00You're not allowed to tell him, Ah, you, remember what you used to do? You gangster.4:05You're not allowed to do that. That's an4:08issur de'oraita. So he says also from here, you see that the fact the Gemara uses the term zechor, remember, that means the guy forgot it.4:14That means a real baal teshuva completely forgot it.4:16What do you have to tell him zechor? Of course he remembers.4:19That means you're talking about a guy who completely forgot, and now you're coming back and bringing it4:28to him. וכן השם יתברך אין משכיח לבעל תשובה גמור, וממילא אינו זוכר. And that's what Hashem does. Hashem doesn't let the baal teshuva, a real4:33baal teshuva, a person who is 100% level of teshuva, He doesn't let him remember it,4:37and that's why he can't remember it. Why is that so? How does that work?4:43כי כל כוחות האדם מהשם יתברך. All the powers of a person come from Hashem.4:46As Hashem tells Moshe Rabbeinu, Moshe Rabbeinu says, I don't have the ability to4:50speak. What does Hashem tell him?4:53מי שם פה לאדם? Who do you think gives the ability to speak?4:56Now we're talking about Moshe Rabbeinu. At that point he was at least 79 years old, perhaps 80,5:02and he had a problem since he was a baby, since he took the coal in his mouth.5:09He was כבד פה וכבד לשון. Moshe Rabbeinu is not just, you know, trying to get out of it.5:12He's saying, Look, Hashem, I really have a speech impediment.5:15You know, they didn't give me therapy in Egypt. I was running away.5:19I didn't get a chance to have therapy. I can't speak. I stutter.5:25If you really hear Moshe Rabbeinu, you wouldn't be able.5:28What does Hashem tell him? Who gives a mouth to a person?5:31Yeah, Hashem, You give the mouth to a person. You give the ability to people to speak,5:33but that's when they were born. I have a speech impediment. No.5:37The fact that we're able to speak, Hashem constantly gives us the ability to5:40speak. And goes to say also that the fact that we're able to remember, it's because Hashem lets us remember.5:48And that is one of the thousands of different powers that a human being has5:53that all comes from Hashem.5:58All powers of thought and remembering comes from Hashem.6:03And true, we have the choice to do as we like.6:07We have the freedom to choose as we like. Hashem lets us choose.6:09Hashem gives us the ability, and sometimes Hashem takes it away from certain people6:12to remind us that He's the one who usually gives it to them.6:24And if Hashem is not mashpia to him, hu mazkir lo and reminds him of something, eino zocheh, he won't remember it. And that's why would Hashem do that?6:27For whatever reason He does it, for other things,6:29but for a sin, Hashem doesn't let the person remember his sin6:32because he's already baal teshuva gamur, doesn't need to remember the sin.6:36And he brings down the Tana d'Bei Eliyahu Rabbah6:39in Midrash. It's called Tana d'Bei Eliyahu,6:41she'atid HaKadosh Baruch Hu lomar, eini zocher avonotav,6:45ve'einu עולין על לבי. Hashem in the future, when baal teshuva comes to Him, He's going to say,6:47I don't remember his sins. I don't remember them.6:51Has v'shalom, there's shechachah lifnei HaMakom; there's no6:55shechachah lifnei ra. U'va'amru, HaKadosh Baruch Hu leban sheל Yisrael. And the explanation is that Chazal told us,7:03Hashem in the Midrash, shir hashirim Rabbah, Hashem is the heart of the Jewish people,7:09shene'emar, it says in pasuk, Suru levavi v'chelki. Hashem is the rock of my heart.7:11Hashem is the heart of the Jewish people.7:16ממילא גם הלבוש של אדם אינו עולה. So if Hashem doesn't remember your sin,7:18it means you also won't remember, because our heart is Hashem's heart;7:21it's all connected.7:25וזהו מעין עולם הבא. This is a little bit of a sample of7:28Olam Haba, that a person could actually achieve in this world.7:35דחוזר אדם לעומק התשובה כזה. And as long as the person didn't get to the depths of7:38teshuvah, like we said over here, he still remembers the sin,7:41and he didn't get to this level,7:45שהוא תכלית שלימות הכפרה, which is really the highest level of atonement that a person can reach,7:51then guess what?7:53אינו בנחה. He should not calm; he should not relax yet,7:56because he hasn't really done teshuvah completely. As long as...8:00Just to remember your sins, you really haven't done teshuvah properly.8:06Now you can understand the question that we started in the beginning of the recording.8:10How could these tzaddikim be always worried that they have to do teshuvah?8:15And how could David always ask, like he quotes over here,8:18Heref kebeseni me'avoni, please, Hashem, continue to cleanse me, give me kibus, do laundry from my8:25sin. Ki feshaai ani eda. What does David HaMelech say? I know my sins. That's a continuation of the pasuk.8:29What is the connection? I know my sins. Hashem, cleanse me.8:33No, the fact that I know my sins, I still remember my sins, Hashem,8:37that means I am not on the level of teshuvah8:44shleimah. But on my end, I have to always put the sin in front of me at all times.8:48I shouldn't come to do it again.8:51But You, Hashem, from Your end, let me forget.8:54You can't work on forgetting the sin.8:56That's not what Rav Sadok is saying over here, that you should work on forgetting your sin.9:00No. You always have to remind yourself of the sin.9:03But if it comes to the point that you can't remember it anymore, it's gone completely,9:07then you know that you're cleansed from it.9:09To give you a little bit of a story that's not really a proof to this,9:13but just a zecher ba'alma, just a good way to get an idea of what Rav Sadok is trying to say.9:20Again, this is not exactly the same thing.9:22There was a great gadol that passed away a number of years ago.9:25His name was, probably now it's ten years ago, his name was9:29Rav Pinchas Scheinberg. Rav Pinchas Scheinberg actually grew up in America,9:32right here, born and bred over here.9:34He was known as the rabbi with9:36the 160. He had a yeshiva, or Torah, he was one of the9:40gedolim, a huge9:42talmid chacham. But he also grew up in America, so we could relate to him.9:45Of course he spoke English, and, you know, that's pashut.9:48But also— He says about himself that he was a big Yankee fan.9:54And he says that after, you know, obviously becoming the Rosh9:59Yeshiva, and after many, many years, he was once in a cab in New York City,10:02and the cab driver had the news on,10:06and they were talking, the guy was talking sports,10:08and he mentioned that the Yankees lost.10:10And says the rabbi, he said that when he heard that,10:14he had a little bad feeling, like, Ah, the Yankees lost.10:17It's still bothering him a little bit.10:19That means he still had it inside of him10:21after all those years that he hasn't even followed the Yankees,10:25he hasn't even spoken about the Yankees.10:26It still was in his system a little bit.10:28But he said that perhaps ten years after that,10:33he heard the same thing, and it didn't bother him,10:35didn't have any effect on him.10:38You follow? That is, that is exactly what we're saying till now,10:44is that this person that still remembers his sin,10:50yes, you're supposed to remind yourself that10:51you shouldn't come to do it again.10:52But if you still remember your10:53sin, it means you haven't really yet gotten to the level that,10:59you know, it's a completely out of your system.11:02Only when you don't have it in your system anymore,11:05that completely you can't connect to it anymore,11:07that's when you know you did teshuvah shleimah.