Torah · MussarMussar9. Sinner for Not Doing מצות עשהTzidkat HaTzadikPart 9Rabbi Uri Nahum · May 12, 2022−15Play+30Position0:008:27Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat Tzadik, ot tet.0:02The next couple letters, tet, yud, and yud aleph, are very short.0:05We're still going to keep them in separate recordings0:09because we want to have it on file clearly,0:12you know, which one is0:15eight, nine, ten, and we're keeping the same numbers.0:17And also, sometimes we start, even though it's short,0:21the idea may take us a little bit further.0:23So, like we said in the beginning,0:25most of the beginning part of Tzidkat Tzadik0:27deals primarily with the first couple of pages of0:31Masechet Berachot, and he goes deeper0:34into what Chazal are saying.0:35Of course, we have to understand that the simple words of0:39Chazal, the halacha is not changing,0:40but this is just a deeper level, as we know,0:42as the Ben Ish Chai brings down many places.0:45He says a lot of times when Chazal spoke,0:47they didn't just speak.0:48Yes, of course, they told you the0:51gashmiyut, you know, the physical thing and what you have to do,0:53but there was something deeper0:55that they were covering up for,0:57and they didn't want to mention it.0:58So he brings a few halachot like that,1:00where al pi sod, al pi Kabbalah,1:02there's something deeper that Chazal didn't want to reveal to us,1:05and they said it only in a way1:08that, you know, in a halacha,1:09with the reason that the halacha kind of covers for it.1:12For example, there's a halacha that1:16you're not allowed to leave drinks uncovered overnight.1:18Why?1:19Because we're worried that maybe a snake might come to drink from it1:22and leave poison in there.1:24That's a halacha.1:25Now, because that's a practical halacha,1:28first of all, we don't have snakes in our days.1:29They lived in Europe about seven, eight hundred years ago.1:31There's no snakes in Europe eight hundred years ago in the homes,1:34so he said you can leave it overnight,1:35and that's how Maran is1:36poskening Shulchan Aruch,1:37siman kuf tet zayin in Yoreh1:40Deah, that in our days,1:42where there is no snakes, at least,1:44you could keep the water uncovered.1:45However, the mekubalim come and they say,1:47but— Chazal only said this because1:49there's something spiritual, a little bit more deeper to it.1:51If you leave water uncovered overnight,1:54there's some sort of spiritual1:57pegam or something1:59defect on it.2:01So although the reason of snakes doesn't apply,2:03but sod shebo, the Kabbalistic part of it,2:05does apply,2:06and therefore a person should make sure to cover his drinks also overnight.2:09Now if you're going to call me and you're going to ask me,2:11Rabbi, I left my drinks overnight uncovered,2:12I'm going to tell you it's mutar.2:13Why?2:14Because you have to be posek according to halacha.2:16But understand that2:17I'll speak about this, something always deeper from what Chazal said.2:19So in a way also, what we're explaining over here2:22is besides the, yes, you have to be2:24mekabel ol malchut shamayim,2:25when you say Shema, you accept upon yourself2:28Hashem's kingdom,2:28there's also something much deeper.2:30Now let's get to the words of the2:33Tzaddik in Ot Tet.2:35Before that, let me just give you2:37a background.2:39The Gemara says, the Mishnah says2:42that really the zman of Kriat Shema2:45min haTorah2:47is2:47b'shochbecha, as long as people are sleeping.2:49When is that?2:50That's the entire night.2:51You have the entire night to read Kriat Shema.2:54However,2:55Chachamim said until2:57chatzot, that you only have up to midnight,2:58and that's3:01gezeirah miderabanan. And the Mishnah proves3:02that even the Chachamim will agree3:04that3:04mideoraita you have the entire night to read,3:06although there's one opinion,3:07one of the Tanaim holds only up to the night,3:09up to3:10chatzot, but we don't hold like that.3:11We hold that you have the entire night.3:13So why did the Chachamim make a3:15gezeirah to make you say it earlier,3:19that you should say Shema only up to3:22chatzot? The words of the3:26Mishnah is, kedei l'harchik et ha'adam min ha'aveirah, to distance a person from3:28an aveirah. Good?3:29Now based on that,3:30Reb Tzadok takes it a little step further.3:31He says beautifully,3:37he says, ישב אדם ולא עשה מצוה שחובה עליו לעשותה. We know3:38all the mitzvot can be divided into two parts.3:41One category of mitzvot is3:43mitzvot aseh,3:44and the other category is3:47mitzvot lo taaseh. Mitzvot aseh means3:48things that you have to do,3:49like giving tzedakah.3:52Like shaking the lulav and etrog,3:56wearing a head covering for married women,4:01tefillah at least once a day,4:02those are mitzvot de'oraita. Under the category of mitzvat aseh.4:05There's4:07mitzvat lo ta'aseh, which most people are more familiar with:4:10don't eat taref,4:11don't break Shabbat,4:13and so on and so forth,4:15the don'ts.4:17So, in definition,4:20in terminology,4:21if a person breaks mitzvat aseh,4:24he's not really breaking anything;4:25he's just not doing anything,4:27right? A guy was not4:29mekayem mitzvah. He didn't put on tallit. Did he break anything?4:31He didn't break anything.4:33He just, you know, just didn't do mitzvat aseh.4:35That's how it's4:37used. He just bitel mitzvat aseh,4:38as Chazal say, or he wasn't mekayem mitzvat aseh.4:40But he didn't do a sin, really, per4:42se. The word aveirah, sin,4:44will apply to the4:46mitzvot lo ta'aseh. And when a guy eats taref,4:48so he was4:50over. Over means he transgressed;4:51he went against.4:52That's4:53aveirah. A guy drove on Shabbat;4:55he was4:56over. That's an aveirah, right?4:58That means he broke.5:00So now, says5:01the tzaddik, from the words of the Mishnah5:04that say5:05that Chazal want to make sure you say5:07Kriat Shema, so they said,5:08if I let you say it all the way until the end of the night,5:10you might forget about it.5:11So I want you to say it by5:13chatzot. Why?5:14This way,5:15I distance you from5:17the aveirah. One second, it doesn't make sense.5:18We just told you that the word5:20aveirah, the term5:21aveirah, is only applicable5:22when a person is breaking a5:27mitzvat lo ta'aseh. Mitzvah of kriat Shema is a mitzvat aseh.5:29So how could you say that if a guy5:31didn't do the5:33mitzvah of Kriat Shema, he's doing an5:34aveirah, that the chachamim had to5:36be gozer, you have to say by5:37chatzot, leharchik adam min5:38ha'aveirah. And we all know, by the way,5:40the language of5:41Chazal, especially in Mishnayot,5:43are not to be taken lightly.5:45They are very precise,5:47and there are chapters and5:49chapters in Shulchan Aruch5:50based on the diyukim from the Mishnayot.5:53So,5:55says over here,5:56Rabbi Tzadok,5:57that's exactly what it's telling you:6:00kach shamati meduyak lashon Mishnah, derech bechol larchikten min6:01ha'aveirah. That a person,6:03it's a6:04klal, any mitzvat aseh6:06that a person has an obligation to do6:07and he doesn't do it,6:08it's called an6:09aveirah. We're always assumed to think,6:11Oh, he didn't do a6:12mitzvah. No, it's called an6:13aveirah. And he brings another proof to that.6:15What's the proof?6:16The Gemara, Masechet Rosh Hashanah, says,6:18who are the,6:19you know,6:19people who enter6:20Gehinom and they have different levels in6:22Gehinom, how they get punished?6:24The Gemara says6:25there are people that6:27posh'ei Yisrael begufan, and those, even when6:29Gehinom, you know,6:29kind of like extinguishes6:31and shuts off,6:32they're still burning in there.6:35Who's posh'ei Yisrael begufan? says the Gemara,6:36who is that?6:39Karkafta delo manach tefillin. That's a head6:40that doesn't put on tefillin.6:42Now, if you look,6:43Maran brings this in6:45Shulchan Aruch, in Siman lamed6:48zayin, se'if alef. Over there Maran says6:49that a person6:51who doesn't put on tefillin,6:52as the6:56poskim explain, b'mezid, not because he's6:56an ones, he's sick6:57and he has a stomachache,6:59like it's brought down7:00in7:02Mishnah Berurah, chelek alef, right?7:03It is not doing it by mistake;7:04he's doing it on purpose.7:05That's called7:08posh'ei Yisrael begufan. He's a7:09poshe'a. Poshe'a is a guy7:10who does it on purpose.7:12Now, one second,7:13says Rabbi Tzadok,7:16af al gav de'eino over b'shev v'al ta'aseh, what is he doing?7:17He's just didn't put on tefillin.7:18He didn't go ahead7:21and break anything.7:23Posh'ei is a person7:24who does7:25aveirot. This guy just didn't put on tefillin.7:26Mitzvat tefillin7:30is ukshartam le'ot al yadecha, vehayu letotafot bein einecha. Ah,7:30what do you see from here?7:31says Rav Tzadok7:32HaKohen. You see7:33the Chazal7:34are not telling you that.7:35In the words of Maran,7:36Gadol zechar mitzvat tefillin,7:38... he says,7:42U'chol mi she'eino menicham hu bichlal poshe'a begufan. And whoever does put them7:42is called a7:44poshe'a. What do you mean7:44it's a mitzvat aseh?7:45I'm mevatel mitzvat aseh.7:46No.7:47A guy,7:48the two types7:48of mitzvot aseh.7:49There's mitzvat aseh7:50that you have an obligation7:51to go ahead7:51and look for ways to do it,7:53like mitzvat tefillin,7:54like kriat Shema.7:55It's not an option;7:56you have to do it.7:57Praying is not an option;7:58you have to do it.8:00Tzedakah, if you have the money, you give8:02tzedakah. Lending money to people, it's a8:04mitzvah. If you have money to lend people, it's a8:06mitzvah. You don't have to go out of your way to go8:08get your, you know, take out a home mortgage8:10in order to lend other people money.8:11You have no8:13chiyuv. If you have a limited amount of money also, you don't have to lend people money.8:15It's not a chiyuv. But there are mitzvot that are8:18chiyuv, and those category of8:20mitzvot, a person who doesn't do them,8:21he's called an avaryan, he's called a sinner,8:24even though we're supposed to think in that way.