Torah · MussarMussar89. How to Become a Professional SpeakerTzidkat HaTzadikPart 89Rabbi Uri Nahum · August 31, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0015:45Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot petet.0:03In this following piece, it's a beautiful idea,0:07but as a style of Rav Tzadok, as we mentioned in the introduction to the0:11sefer, he brings a lot of different0:14maamarei Chazal, and if you're familiar with it, it makes it so beautiful.0:18So I'm not sure how familiar we might be with every single one,0:21and therefore I'm going to have to explain every single one just to make it all tie in.0:24But it's really not such a long, long paragraph, but it's a beautiful idea.0:28Just there's so many different0:32maamarei Chazal, and the beauty of this is how they all come together.0:34He starts with the Gemara Masechet0:36Chulin. The Gemara quotes a pasuk Masechet0:39Tehillim. The pasuk says, Haumnam elem tzedek tedaberun.0:44Okay, that's what the pasuk says0:46in Tehillim. The pasuk says, Haumnam elem tzedek tedaberun.0:51The literal translation of0:53that, and haumnam is, I guess you could say, is it possible?0:58Elem usually means strength or might or silence.1:02Tzedek tedaberun.1:04Comes the Gemara, makes a derashah.1:05As we know, derashot of Chazal take sometimes the words out of1:09context, but they teach you a different level of understanding in the pasuk.1:14Comes the Gemara and says the word haumnam can be from the word1:18umanut. Umanut means a profession.1:19It says, Ma umanato shel adam ba'olam hazeh?1:24What should be a person's profession in this world?1:28Yasim atzmo1:31ke'illem. He should make himself like a mute.1:34That means be quiet, don't say anything.1:36Good? That's what the Gemara says,1:38that your work—you want to work on something,1:41a profession, like a doctor, a lawyer, anybody, right,1:45that has a specific job that's1:48professional—he is called an uman in Hebrew.1:51And the Gemara says, you know what your profession should be in this world,1:53in olam hazeh?1:55And that is1:56elem. Elem means silence.1:58Mi kamocha ba'elim Hashem. The Gemara says,1:59illem—illem is a person who's mute, doesn't speak.2:02Your profession in this world is to try to be mute.2:05And he explains,2:07פירוש הלשון אומנות. And what does umanut really, really mean?2:09We call the profession.2:10He says, Davar gadol she'ein kol echad yachol2:13la'asotah. Really, umanut is something that not everybody can do.2:15In fact, we have this halacha in2:21Hilchot Chol HaMoed. Ma'aseh uman on Chol HaMoed is2:24asur, and ma'aseh hedyot, in specific cases, is mutar.2:28Chol HaMoed, we know that although we can do2:31melachot, but we're restricted; we can't do everything.2:32One of the categories of melachot that we cannot do is something called2:37ma'aseh uman. What's a2:38ma'aseh uman? Something that takes a professional to do.2:41And the halacha says that, for example,2:45sewing a button is not such a big profession.2:48Anybody can sew a button.2:50But let's say a person gets a rip,2:53or a person has to tailor his pants.2:55That's not something everybody can do.2:56You need to be trained for that.2:59So you need to be an uman, basically in Hebrew.3:02That's called a ma'aseh uman, and that would be forbidden during3:05Chol HaMoed, even though you may need it for the holiday.3:08If you need it for the holiday, you can stitch a3:10button. Not a big deal.3:11Everybody can just take a pin with a thread,3:13although people don't know about it. Once you tell them, they can do it.3:16But to be able to tailor exactly to the size,3:20that is a ma'aseh uman, and that would be3:22asur. So it comes out that umanut is something that not everybody else can do.3:26Good?3:27Now, I'm going to skip the next line;3:29he brings a proof from somewhere else.3:34So, ve'eimat hu umanut. However, when do we say that this is called a professional?3:40So you might say, What's a big deal?3:41You can be quiet.3:43So you can be quiet,3:44although it's not easy.3:45We see nowadays it's really not easy.3:48In fact, I'll tell you a nice Dvar Torah,3:49a very, very short Dvar Torah.3:51We find that Hashem gave a reward3:56in the whole story of3:58Yetziat Mitzrayim. He gave a reward to two animals4:01for participating in Hashem's salvation of the Jewish people4:06and punishing the Egyptians.4:07Who are these two animals?4:09The frogs and the dogs.4:12The frogs, if you want to say that tzfardea is a frog,4:15it's machloket, but the frogs, it says,4:17Hashem, Moshe tells4:19Paro that the frogs will go into your ovens,4:22they'll go into your bedrooms,4:23they'll go everywhere.4:26The frogs will be everywhere.4:28And the frogs actually jumped into the fire,4:31and they actually died.4:33They were moser nefesh.4:34They gave up their lives4:36for the sake of HaKadosh Baruch Hu,4:38because Hashem said they should jump in the ovens,4:40and the frogs listened. They killed themselves.4:42And therefore,4:46the frogs participated.4:49And Chananiah, Mishael, and Azariah, when they were about to be thrown in the fire,4:52they learned from the frogs.4:53Look, the frogs jumped in the fire.4:55We should also jump in the fire4:56for the sake of Hashem.4:57The second animal that participated in Yetzias Mitzrayim is the5:00dog.5:01Moshe Rabbeinu says5:02that when makat bechorot comes,5:04not one dog amongst the Jewish people5:07will even slip, you5:09know, will make a sound with his tongue,5:11and they were quiet.5:12Now, the Torah tells us,5:14If you have a5:16tereifah, lakelev tashlichun oto. Give it to the dogs.5:19And Chazal5:20explain, why should you give a tereifah to the dogs?5:22Why is it preferable that if you have a dog,5:24you should give it an animal that you found5:26tereifah? The answer is5:28because they were quiet5:31when Bnei Yisrael came out of Mitzrayim5:33during5:34makat bechorot. When all the Egyptians were yelling,5:36it was totally peaceful and quiet5:38in the Jewish camp.5:40Not even the dogs made a sound.5:41So they participated in the Kiddush Hashem.5:45And everybody asks the question,5:46one second,5:47who's greater, the frogs or the dogs?5:49Who did such a—who did a greater act?5:51The frogs actually jumped in the fire.5:54They were moser nefesh, and the dogs were just quiet.5:57Why is Hashem rewarding the dogs6:00with such a tremendous reward,6:03to give them a6:04tereifah, and we don't find a reward for the frogs?6:07So I saw6:08brought down, it's a nice6:10פירוש, it's a little bit more of6:12al derech bedichuta, has a lot of truth to it,6:14that it's much harder to be quiet6:16than to jump into the fire.6:17It's very, very difficult to be quiet.6:19Very, very difficult for a person6:20to restrain himself6:21and not to answer back6:23and not to speak.6:24And that's why the frogs,6:26they jumped into the fire.6:28Okay, mesirut nefesh al kiddush Hashem, it's a big thing,6:30but, you know,6:30it's a one-time thing6:31and you're done.6:32But to be quiet time and time again,6:34that's a tremendous,6:35tremendous amount of restraint6:37that a person has to exercise.6:39So comes6:40Rav Soloveitchik and says,6:40even though we might say, hey,6:41being quiet,6:43that's what the Gemara says,6:45right? Ha'umnam elem. Your umanut is to be quiet.6:47He says, however,6:48it's not really6:49umanut. It's not such a professional.6:51Anybody can do it.6:53Remember,6:53umanut is something6:54that not everybody can do.6:55He says,6:55you know when it's a real7:05umanut? Rak shetzarich umanut gadol.7:08That's when you need to be7:10a real professional.7:16That a person,7:18in the middle of a conversation,7:19could speak7:20and gets to a7:21point and says,7:22No, I can't say anymore.7:24This will be mutar.7:24This will not be mutar.7:25Not only mutar, asur.7:27This is not needed7:29to be spoken about anymore.7:30It's enough.7:31Gemara tells us,7:32I forgot who it was,7:33I think it was Rabbi Shimon7:34bar Yochai or Rabbi7:35Yochanan ben Nuri, I forgot who it was,7:36that he saw his mother7:37talking excessively on Shabbat.7:39He says,7:39Ima, Shabbat,7:40and she got quiet right away.7:41She wasn't doing any7:44issur, but she,7:45Shabbat...7:50You're supposed to7:52not speak like the way7:52you speak during the weekday.7:54But that alone,7:55to be able to just hold yourself7:56and to understand7:57when it's too much7:58or it's not too much.7:59Imagine.8:00You're an undercover spy, living like the mista'arvim, living amongst the Arabs,8:06and you're really connected to the top, top officials by the terrorist organizations.8:12How careful would you be with your words, to measure every word, to make sure that nobody could pick up who you are,8:18right? That's an umanut; you need to be professional,8:22because a lot of us can't keep it secret, really. We can't work with those such organizations.8:26That's what Rav Tzadok says over here.8:28It's not just—it's not an umanut to not speak at all.8:36Not to say anything at all is not a professionalism.8:39The professionalism is to speak and to know when it's tzedek and when it's not8:45tzedek. That's one way to become a professional and to work on your speech.8:51Inami, he says, I can give you another one. Etza hu, eich yuchal le'umanut zo. I'll give you another advice, says Rav Tzadok, of how a person could attain this professionalism,8:59how can he get his certificate in speech?9:02Keshetzadik—of course, you want to speak9:05tzedek. Kemo she'amru, I'll tell you, based on the Gemara, Masechet Arachin. It's also brought down in Midrash Rabbah, in the beginning of Eleh HaDevarim. Eleh HaDevarim asher diber Moshe el9:17kol Bnei Yisrael, in the Midrash over there. It's amazing that asher diber Moshe—Moshe spoke this? How can Moshe speak?9:22The same person who says that Kaved peh ve'lashon anochi, kaved peh, kaved lashon anochi. Moshe says, I can't speak. I stutter.9:32How do you want me to speak9:34to Pharaoh? That Moshe had to get Aharon to speak on his behalf.9:37Now we find Moshe Rabbeinu, at the end of forty years in the9:40desert, that he's able to speak, says the Gemara and the Midrash,9:46debrei Torah al peh halashon. The fact that Moshe is speaking Torah, Moshe spoke Torah for forty years, that healed him.9:53Now, you can understand it simply that it actually healed his stutterness and physically healed him.9:59But there's something even deeper than that,10:01and he explains, Torah allows a person to speak everything without measurement.10:09Now, of course, if you are only speaking—if you're speaking Torah—then you can speak everything.10:14If you become a person of Torah, then whatever you speak actually becomes Torah.10:18Like we find this in10:20Chazal. Chazal say, on another pasuk in Tehillim, says, Ve'alehu lo10:25yibol, that a person who is a person of Torah, even the leaves do not wither, do not die.10:31What is that going on? says the Gemara,10:37Even the regular, normal conversation, even the conversation of10:42talmidei chachamim that are talking about mundane things, they're not talking Torah.10:45Of course, most of the sichah of talmidei chachamim is Torah,10:47but even when they talk casual conversation, tzrichah limud needs to be learned.10:53How does that happen?10:54How could you turn a regular casual conversation, a non-kodesh conversation,10:59to turn it into something that needs limud?11:02That's what the Gemara says: Shekol sichatan Torah.11:04All this, every sichah, even the regular speech, is Torah.11:09We find this also in the Torah itself.11:11The story of Eliezer eved Avraham in Parashat11:17Chayei Sarah, the Torah there says the story and then it repeats the whole conversation of Eliezer11:22eved Avraham. And it says, Afilu the avadim of the11:27Avot, right? Even the11:32yafah sichatan shel avdei Avot yoter miToratan shel banim. That's the lashon of the Gemara.11:35It's the speech, the regular speech of the slaves of the Avot is better than the whole Torah.11:39Look, when it comes to us,11:47halachot of Shabbat, nes, ta'arovet, it's one pasuk, two pesukim perhaps in the whole entire Torah. And here, the story of Eliezer, which we know already, the Torah repeats it completely.11:52Why? Because Eliezer said it.11:54Isn't that11:54amazing? How do you get to such a thing? And that is through Torah. That's, afilu sichatan shel... kasher hu Torah.12:01When you're a person of Torah, even your regular casual conversation, it's also Torah.12:11And that's the meaning also in another Gemara.12:16The Gemara, Masechet Megillah, deals with sefarim.12:21What language could you write the Sefer Torah?12:23In what language?12:28The Gemara says, Sefarim nichtavim b'chol lashon. Sefarim can be written in any language.12:31What does it mean, sefarim can be written in any language?12:33So simply, yes, you could write it in English and whatever it is, you could write in every language that you want.12:37That's a simple meaning.12:38But he's explaining, lashon here doesn't necessarily mean only the regular simple meaning of every language.12:49When you are Torah, kashahu Torah,12:52when you are Torah, even any lashon, anything that you speak becomes automatically Torah.12:59Like it says in Masechet Berachot in Yerushalmi,13:05pitputei de'oraita tavin. Even the pitputim, even the mundane things of the Torah are also good.13:09See that? That's two ways of becoming a professional speaker.13:13You want to graduate and get a certificate in speaking?13:17There are two ways,13:18and we call it two and a half ways.13:20The halfway is to be quiet,13:23like the pashut pshat of the Gemara,13:24Haumnam elim, just be quiet,13:27do ta'anit dibur. Like we find a lot of13:29tzaddikim, they felt that they were not on the level to get that certificate.13:32They were quiet.13:33The second way is to measure every word, and everything that you say should be measured,13:37tzedek. I'm not talking about only issur and mutar.13:39They say that the Chafetz Chaim, one out of his way to become a great conversationalist.13:44He would speak a lot to show people that keeping the laws of lashon hara does not mean you have to be quiet.13:50You know, people when they hear13:51lashon hara, Oh, you can't say anything anymore.13:53That's not true.13:54If your whole speech is about putting people down,13:56sad,13:56it's pretty sad.13:57You can have great conversation.13:59A lot of14:00gedolim, they talk,14:00they talk,14:01but they're very careful in what they say.14:03I remember having a conversation once with Rav Chaim Yosef14:06Rafuel, and Rav Chaim Yosef was a great conversationalist.14:08Anybody who knows him could speak to him.14:10He could speak about any subject,14:11and he knows a lot,14:12and he gets into a big conversation.14:15And in the middle, I said something that was inappropriate.14:17Right away he stopped me.14:20He says, Zeh rechilut. He was holding in the sefer not just in knowledge, but in living.14:25You can't just say whatever comes to mind.14:26You have to know,14:27you have to think before you say14:29what's14:30mutar, what's14:31asur. That's tzedek tedaberun.14:33Like we said, the high level of that is not just what's mutar and what's14:37asur; it's also how much to say and how much not to say.14:41And then he says,14:42but if you're a person of Torah, whatever you say becomes automatically Torah.14:47Even in regular conversation, you have to measure.14:49Again, we're not talking about issur and heter.14:51Of course everything is mutar,14:52but even what's mutar, beforehand the other person has to measure.14:55But if you're a person of Torah,14:57Torah is14:59marpe lashon. Everything you say becomes Torah.15:01This piece is over at this point.15:03If you look in the book, you see in brackets he brings a side question,15:06because he explained the words in the Gemara and Megillah,15:10sefarim nichtavim b'chol lashon.15:14We know the Gemara deals with another opinion over there that says,15:17what about Greek also?15:18You could perhaps write it in Greek.15:20So how does that fit with what he's explaining?15:22So he explains as a side point how the Greeks, at a certain point,15:25they have some sort of connection to Klal Yisrael, and15:30why—what does that mean, the Greek,15:32if it could not be written in lashon,15:34so why Greek also?15:35So it's a side point also in his style,15:39very, very short but very, very deep.15:41I'm not going to get to it because we got through the point.