Torah · MussarMussar87. A גזירה Must Get the Validation of the צדיקTzidkat HaTzadikPart 87Rabbi Uri Nahum · August 29, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:32Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat HaTzadik, ot pei zayin. It's going to begin a little simple, but it's going to get0:07very, very deep afterwards. And he himself writes that I can't talk longer at the0:13end, as we'll see. Very interesting piece.0:17Ein0:20gezeirah yotzah מפי הקדוש ברוך הוא, אלא בהסכמת צדיקי הדור. There's no decree that comes out from Shamayim unless the tzaddikim of the0:25generation agree. Agree. Now, the tzaddikim we're talking about are the tzaddikim here in0:33this world, in our generation, that's still alive. Hashem does not send out a0:37gezeirah unless the tzaddikim in this generation agree. Now he says over here in0:43brackets, שהם בית דינו. They're considered always the0:47beit din, כמו שמובא, as is brought down in the Idra Rabba in the Zohar. Says in the Zohar0:53on the pasuk, סוד ה' ליראיו. The secret of Hashem is for His0:59yere'im. It says, ועד דלא אסכימו, לא נחתין דינין לעלמא. The Zohar says until the people, the1:06yere'av of Hashem, agree, there's no din that comes down to this world. Now, question1:13you're going to ask is, first of all, I have at least to ask, do these tzaddikim1:18know about it? And that's question number one. That means today, he's saying that1:25till today, we're today in Tavshin Pei Bet, we're going to Tavshin Pei Gimel1:29very soon. There are tzaddikim, a lot of tzaddikim in this generation. I don't know who1:33those tzaddikim are, but do those tzaddikim know who they are, that1:38Hashem doesn't do things without them? Do they know about it? And question number two is,1:43if they know about it, why would they agree? Hashem says, I'm going to bring1:48a gezeirah down to this world, and I'm going to whatever it is. Why would they agree? So1:53he's going to explain the second answer. The first answer, you'll see based on how1:57he explained the first answer, we're going to—I'm going to build personally, I'm2:00going to tell you what I believe the answer is. Let's begin. Ready? He says,2:06Ve'ech yeheyeh zeh? How could this be possible that a gezeirah, a bad decree, will come down to2:10this world if you need the tzaddikim to agree upon it?2:14We know that tzaddikim are always praying on behalf of the2:18Jewish people. They always want the Jewish people to have something good. How could2:21they pray? How could they agree to anything bad to come? So he explains,2:27it's not exactly as simple as we think, that Hashem comes and2:32He asks them, Hey, do you want this to happen or not? No, it doesn't look like2:37that. It's k'inyan shehayah b'David HaMelech alav hashalom b'Kipsa. He leaves it at that. He explains. So let's explain. It's like the way we2:44find by David HaMelech by the sheep. So for those who are not familiar, it's an amazing, amazing sefer2:50to read, Sefer Shmuel Aleph and Bet. You know, it's all one sefer, but it's2:55divided in Aleph and Bet. In Shmuel Bet, it talks about when David was the king, and he3:01saw—of course, Chazal explained to us, you know, al pi Ruach HaKodesh—he saw that3:05Bat Sheva really belonged to him, and although she was still married, he3:11asked to be with her, and he was with her. Her husband was at war, and he gave a3:16get beforehand. The get was ineffective unless he dies, and eventually3:20David HaMelech set him up to die. So technically, David never really went with3:25an eshes ish who was Bat Sheva. And the proof is that eventually David HaMelech3:30has a son from Bat Sheva. The first son dies, and the second son that's born to3:35David from Bat Sheva is Shlomo HaMelech, who obviously built the Beit HaMikdash.3:39So although everything was done al pi halacha, Hashem wasn't happy in the way it was done,3:44and therefore He wanted to punish David. Had he punished him, had he sent him to3:49be punished. So he sent Natan HaNavi to go and give him a fake case and let3:56David be a judge of it. The case was, there was a man, two neighbors. One was a4:03very, very rich man, and the other one was a very, very poor person. The rich man had4:06many, many, many sheep, and the poor man only had one sheep. And that sheep he4:12took care of like a child. He tended to its every need. He sheared it when4:18its wool got too much, and he milked it, and he ate from it. And, you know, basically4:22that was his whole life. And the rich man one time had a guest coming to his4:26house, and he was supposed to serve him. He wanted to serve him sheep. He looked at4:31his flock, and he felt bad that he should take from one of his flocks of many,4:35many animals that he has. So he decided to go to the neighbor, who wasn't there, and he4:40took the neighbor's sheep and slaughtered it and presented it to his guest. So4:46David HaMelech says, What a terrible crime. For the aveirah itself, the Torah dictates4:52that a person who steals a sheep and slaughters it should pay four times the4:56amount. This guy should not only pay four times the amount, but he's also5:02chayav mita, because it's such a cruel thing that he did, and that is only something that the5:06king could decide. So after David gives a psak, Natan HaNavi turns to David and tells him,5:12You are that rich man. You, David, have already, you know, twelve wives, and you could5:21have as many wives as you like. And you go ahead and you take Uriah's wife, one5:27and only wife that he has, and therefore you are that rich man, and therefore you5:33decided, you basically were gozer your own decree against yourself.5:37There were going to be chayav four punishments, and yourself will be chayav mitah. David HaMelech on the spot does5:43teshuvah, and Hashem tells Natan to tell David that he's forgiven; he will not die, but the5:49other four punishments will come to him. That's the story that we find in5:55Sefer Shmuel Bet. Rav Tzadok HaKohen explains, you see from this story that here David was, or David6:03brought a gezeirah upon himself without realizing that he's doing it. So6:07Hashem kind of sets them up in a way where they themselves, the tzaddikim, don't realize6:14what they're exactly saying or what they're posek, and that brings a, you know, a6:19decree down here. I remember once hearing from Chacham Yitzchak Yosef that he saw in a certain6:23sefer about the rabbi writes in his hakdamah that one time on Shabbat6:28afternoon he felt all of a sudden very tired and he fell asleep. And when he fell asleep, he dreamt that there was a certain6:34halachah question that they asked him, and there he ruled that the person who6:39breaks this is chayav mitah. And when he woke up, he found out that one of his6:44neighbors, you know, all of a sudden died, and he was involved in an act similar to what they6:54asked him in Shamayim. So you see that sometimes Hashem will bring— not sometimes, Hashem brings gezeirah down here only with the haskamah of the6:59Beit Din, the Beit Din over here in this world. Do they know themselves? Do they not know themselves?7:03I personally don't believe that they know who they are. That's my7:08personal belief. At one point when people were like Abraham Avinu or great tzaddikim7:12knew that they actually, you know, were the ones to decide, but I believe today7:17they don't know who they really are, but they don't need to know who they are, and they7:20don't even know that they're being actually tested and that they're being7:25really asked the question to be posek, because if they know, obviously they can prevent it.7:29He brings them back. It's a few other cases. I'm going to say them very quickly.7:33Some of them we might know, some of them we might not know.7:45Yirmiyah hayah b'ma'anotot, galut aseret ha-shvatim hayah yeshayah b'shivnah, v'Rabbi Hama Binu b'Sdom b'ma shefrid Lot mikodem, v'chen hakol v'chen kamokom l'haarich. We'll pick on the last one he gave, and that is regarding7:50Rabbi Hama Binu in Sedom. Avraham Avinu was alive when Sedom was destroyed, which eventually became7:56Yam HaMelach. And Hashem says clearly, I'm going to destroy Sedom.8:00But Sedom, ki Rabbah, it's terrible, the sins of Sedom. But I have to run it by Abraham8:06Avinu. And he says to Abraham Avinu, I want to destroy Sedom, and Abraham Avinu starts to bargain.8:11He saw that he can't, you know, he saw that, you know, whatever he tries to do to save Sedom from being destroyed,8:18he says, okay, you know what? At least maybe we could save Lot.8:22So you see again that gezeirah will not come down to this world unless the tzaddikim will agree.8:28And again, how does it happen? It's not that they actually sit down and they make a conference8:33and they make a meeting and they vote on it. But it happens, it could be happening in many, many different ways.8:39And therefore it says,8:43That's why we always have to be careful, especially if you feel you're a tzaddik.8:48A person has to be, tzaddikim have to be more careful that no bad should ever come out of their mouth.8:52Should always be saying positive, good things about the Jewish people,8:56and in general always looking positively at things.9:00And that's why also tzaddikim get fast. We find that the tzaddik himself also actually gets, you know, picked on in a way.9:11Why does the tzaddik get picked on? Because the whole world depends on him.9:14The whole world is standing on his shoulders.9:16And the small little, you know, branches, the karba, this is a kruv, what's it called, that gets hurt.9:34Now, how could it be that Hashem picks on tzaddikim? Why is it so?9:38He says, of course, everything is justified. He explains9:41that could be perhaps that they didn't realize, and they9:45brought puranut la'olam. And that's why they have to be very, very careful.9:47The tzaddikim have to be very careful.9:49Always talk positively and say good things about the Jewish people and every part of the Jewish people,9:55every community in the Jewish people, even if it's not your type,9:59even people that are in communities that don't hold like you.10:03But— Like the way the Gemara says, you know, it doesn't say10:10yitamu chot'im. Excuse me, it doesn't say that the sinners should be gone.10:16Yitamu chata'im, let the sins be gone.10:18Don't pray that sinners should die; pray that sinners should do teshuvah.10:22That has to be the attitude of everybody, especially tzaddikim.10:27And if not, he says sometimes there are the ones who are10:31gorem pera'anut, and that's why they're in10:35netzach. U'kach mimenu matchil kedei teh bakamah, and that's why it starts from them.10:37Like it says in10:39Bava Kamma, Tzadik bet amud aleph, there it talks about that a person who prays for his friend,10:44he gets answered first.10:49Like it quotes it over here. When a person prays for his friend, he gets answered first.10:52So too works in a negative way.10:55If a person is posek negatively to somebody else,10:59he gets picked on first.11:00We find this also by Sarah and Abraham.11:03Sarah tells Abraham,11:06Yishpot Hashem beini uveinecha. Let Hashem be the judge between me and you.11:09And we know that Sarah died before Abraham11:13Avinu, because she asked for judgment, so they judged her first.11:16That's why when you do it in a positive way,11:19when you ask for something good for other people,11:21then you yourself get judged11:25good first,11:26like we find by Abraham and11:28Avimelech. Avimelech got punished for taking Sarah.11:32His whole entire household wasn't able to go out.11:36They couldn't have children,11:37they couldn't go out to the bathroom.11:39And when Abraham Avinu prayed for them,11:41because he prayed that they should have the ability to go to the bathroom and to have children,11:46since Abraham also needed to have a child,11:48we find that right after the story of11:50Avimelech, Sarah gets pregnant and she has a child.11:53Good.11:53So he says,11:57V'lo haya tzaddik shenitzol mizeh legamrei. There was no tzaddik who was ever completely safe from this,12:01because we're not always careful.12:03People don't even know that there's tzaddikim.12:05He says,12:07Rak Mashiach, only Mashiach. Now who's Mashiach?12:08We don't know,12:12but only Mashiach. But again,12:14there's no tzaddik that's ever safe from this.12:17This is a very deep statement.12:18Personally, I don't understand.12:19He has something obviously very deep,12:22and we should be zocheh to understand it one day.12:25But we'll read it and translate it, let you guys do the thinking about it12:28and see the depth of this concept.