Torah · MussarMussar84. Getting Punished for Other People’s SinsTzidkat HaTzadikPart 84Rabbi Uri Nahum · August 24, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0014:06Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:01It's a Kad HaTzadik, ot pei dalet. A very deep idea.0:06The idea deals with Hashem's judgment and how things run,0:10because we know that the basic thing, you know, and it's part of the seven mitzvot of Bnei Noach,0:16is to have a court with rules. Basically what we call, what has become famous as law and order.0:25You do A, you get rewarded for it. You do B, you get punished for it.0:30You know, there's got to be law and order. There's got to be a justice system in the world,0:33and we know that the world stands on that.0:36Asosai d'varim, ha'olam omed, and that is what—olam kayam, excuse me, kayam,0:42difference from omed, it's different from...—and that is0:46al ha-din. You need din, you need mishpat, you need justice.0:48So when we deal with this concept, and we, you know, we all know that one of the biggest questions in Jewish history0:59that all the great people asked it, which is basically what seems to appear as lack of justice.1:08Things don't look right, you know, or not fair, or it seems to be not fair.1:12One of those questions is, for example, tzaddik v'ra lo. How can it be that somebody is righteous and yet he's suffering?1:21That's only one of the questions. There are many questions, all falling under the same category.1:25So this piece kind of deals with it a little bit. So that's why it's a deep concept.1:30We'll try to explain as much as we can, but we, of course, when we say it's deep,1:33we hope that everybody thinks about it a little bit deeper than what we just said as well.1:37He says, Pa'amim yesh nispa b'lo mishpat. Sometimes we find people that pass away without—I'm going to add those words—without seemingly, without justice.1:50Hainu adinah shelemala, we find the pasuk says in Kohelet,1:55Yetz tzaddik oved b'tzidko. Kohelet, with Shlomo HaMelech, his review of the entire world at the end of his life, looking back at his life2:01and the whole world, how it runs, some very, very deep things over there.2:05He says it seems like there's a righteous person who dies because of his righteousness.2:12Ha kedabi, al yedei tzidkato, he dies because he's righteous. Here's an example,2:17like Hevel, right? Second generation in world history. Adam had two children, Hevel and2:25Kayin. Hevel sheharago Kayin. Hevel was killed by Kayin. Why? Because Hashem accepted the korban of Hevel, therefore he got killed.2:32Where's the justice over there? The guy did something good. He brought a korban, it was accepted,2:37and ended up causing his brother jealousy and he killed him.2:40He says, Uvadai hayah harigah zo mimishpat Hashem yitbarach, but nobody should think that there's no justice.2:46This is certainly from the judicial system of Hashem.2:52How does that make sense then?2:54So he explains, V'hainu ki lo ratzah Hashem yitbarach sheyeh ba'olam nivra mazik lenivra acher. What a powerful statement.3:00Hashem does not want in this world to have any creature damaging others.3:09V'kach asah oto chasid beTaanit. We find the same thing in Masechet Taanit about this certain chasid that the Gemara talks about,3:16shebikesh al bito shetashuv la'afarah shelo yekashlu bah bnei adam. He had the most beautiful daughter, and people were stumbling upon her.3:21What does that mean? People were sinning by checking her out,3:25כביכול. And he saw that this is not good.3:27Now the Gemara calls him a chasid. That means he went beyond the letter of the law,3:30but that means he did something good.3:32What did he do? He prayed that she should pass away,3:34that nobody should get hurt through her.3:36Now over there they're getting hurt spiritually through her.3:39Now I guarantee you she was dressed all modestly and everything else,3:42and still he prayed for her such a thing. Why?3:45Because he didn't want anybody else— To get damage, hurt from her,3:54because that's not ratzon Hashem.3:56Hashem doesn't want that anybody should hurt anybody else.3:58We find a similar thing in Masechet Sotah.4:00The Gemara talks about a tzadeket, a certain batulah, a certain young lady,4:04she used to pray to Hashem, saying,4:10Shelo yikashlu bi bnei adam. She used to pray to Hashem, please.4:12She knew that she was a beautiful girl.4:14Don't let other people be nichshal or sin because of me.4:20Like it says, Kol chaverim nachnas al yado, imachnisin oto b'mechitzato shel HaKadosh Baruch Hu. The Gemara says4:27in Masechet Shabbat, whoever causes another Jew, or whoever is the cause of another Jew sinning,4:32they don't allow him to enter the circle of HaKadosh Baruch Hu.4:36So we have to be careful that we can't be the cause of anybody else sinning,4:40because that will be actually a ta'anah on us.4:43That will be our problem.4:46It's not his problem. It's not their problem. It's our problem.4:48And we find the same thing. He brings in Yerushalmi Masechet4:54Berachot, says that Rabbi Eliezer prayed the following:5:01Velo ta'aleh kenat adam alai. He doesn't want that anybody should be jealous because of me.5:06You have to pay for that.5:07In fact, in some Sifrei Chassidim, if you look at the end of the Amidah,5:12right before you finish, you step back,5:14there's some tefilot over there that says,5:19Yehi ratzon shelo ta'aleh kin'at adam, lo kin'at adam alai. I should not be jealous of others, and others should not be jealous of me.5:27I understand I should not be jealous of others. I have bad middot.5:30Others should not be jealous of me? That's their problem.5:35No, shegam ze mazik lo. When others are jealous of you... And they have a problem becomes your problem.5:45Kishal yedei tzitkuto mitkan'im bo, v'ne'enas al yado, אז גם הוא נענש. Because if other people are jealous of you and they get punished for that5:48because their bad middot, you will be punished also because you caused it to them.5:55U'mekom makom, now you can say, what do you mean? How do you live like this?5:59Whatever I do, I have to worry? Yes, you have to worry, number one.6:03Number two is also, you have to know that it's all just, it's all fair.6:16U'makom makom, kol mi shemistakel b'ma'asecha, halev eino nig'alet me'neged chaveiro b'tzidkato. You hear that? How is that fair that somebody else is jealous of me and I get punished?6:22Oh, what are you doing? And the answer is, he says, it is fair.6:26Because if people are jealous of you, it means that deep, deep, deep down,6:31you had some sort of inclination that you wanted to actually be better than others.6:41You know, there's a concept, there's a term in Arabic, Israelis also say6:47it, Shufuni anas, look at me. You want that people should look at you.6:51Now, there are people that take this concept of check me out a little, you know, a little too extreme.6:58For example, all the social media, they're always posting things.7:02Why are you posting it? Why are you posting your great artwork, your great things?7:08People tell you, you know, I have to make parnassah, I have to advertise.7:13Yeah, exactly. So you want to be7:15mitpa'er. And sometimes you want people to see how great you are.7:19And why am I saying how great you are? Let me talk about myself.7:21We want people to see how great we are.7:24And look how much I'm accomplishing.7:27And look at what I'm doing.7:29So there is this—I don't want to call it7:33gaava. Gaava is not exactly7:37l'hitpa'er. I want to show that I'm better. I want to show that I'm great.7:40I want people to admire me. So you want that.7:43So because we want that, of course it's going to create jealousy,7:45and if it creates jealousy, then guess what?7:48That is our problem. It's not their problem that7:51they become jealous. It's our problem.7:52You know, if you think about it, it's a very interesting idea,7:55right? We don't feel jealousy from, for example, Rav Chaim Kanievsky.8:01We do feel jealousy from8:04chacham uvadia so much. There's certain great people, when we hear about8:06them, we don't feel so jealous of them.8:07I'm not talking about because they passed away.8:09I'm talking about even when they were alive,8:10we don't feel certain jealousy from them,8:13because they zekei gedolim lived their lives.8:16They want to be great8:17not because other people should know it;8:19they want to be great for themselves.8:20Other people found out about them.8:22We don't feel jealousy; we feel admiration for them.8:25So he's telling you8:27that when people are feeling jealousy,8:28it could be that deep down,8:31deep, deep, deep down,8:32we wanted them to feel jealousy.8:35He says, of course,8:36vehnistarot laShem Elokeinu.8:40And the nistarot, the things, the deep, deep things8:42of the reasons why things happen,8:43that's all Hashem.8:45That's not for us to understand.8:49But what looks to the surface,8:51it looks like it's not fair.8:53Hevel, he did such a good thing8:56and he gets killed for it.8:57This guy is a tzaddik8:59and he gets punished for it.9:00It looks like it's not fair, but deep down,9:02that's9:07nistar laShem. כי יש נסתרות שנסתר גם לאדם עצמו, מה שהשם יתברך יודע. There are certain things that are deep within us9:09that we ourselves are not even aware of it.9:13You know, there are people that go to psychologists and therapists,9:15and they dig out some deep things.9:19So you see there are certain concepts9:20that we don't—there are certain things about ourselves9:22that we don't even know about ourselves,9:24but Hashem knows.9:25So how do you uncover it?9:27How do you bring it to the surface?9:28There's no other way,9:32רק תפילה ורחמים. You just got to pray and beg Hashem for mercy,9:38כי מי שנקי באמת אז השם יברך שומרו. Because if you're really clean,9:40if you're—that means whenever you're doing something,9:41you got to pray,9:43Please, Hashem,9:45let it be l'shem shamayim. Please help me do the right thing9:48for the sake of the right thing9:50without trying to show off.9:51It's not easy,9:52because we live in a generation9:54where we lack9:57self-esteem. That's the truth.9:58And you see all these people9:59that are posting things on social media,10:01trying to boast themselves,10:03trying to, you know, give recognition to themselves.10:06It's not because they're10:07gaavah; it's10:08ahavas hagaavah. They lack10:09self-esteem. They need recognition.10:10They may be lacking recognition10:12because, you know, they know they're talented.10:15They know they have certain things,10:16but the people that are close to10:18them don't appreciate them.10:20You know, there could be a husband10:21that could do wonderful things.10:22They could help people,10:23do tzedakah,10:24and he's wonderful also at home,10:25but his wife doesn't appreciate it.10:27She's always demanding more and more.10:29Or it could be the wife10:29is not demanding more and more,10:31but she's asking for simple things,10:34but the husband doesn't take it that way.10:35He understands it that10:37she's always criticizing him.10:38She's never happy with him,10:39when she's really just, you know, not asking him10:42perhaps in the right way,10:43or maybe she's asking in the right way,10:44but he's not understanding in the right way.10:46So there are many, many people like that.10:50And there are many people10:51that have the10:51talent that they feel that they could do more,10:55and they're not in the right position11:00to be able to express their talent11:01or people to appreciate their talent.11:03So they, well, it looks like they're showing off;11:05they're really just looking for recognition.11:07We're very weak in this generation,11:10and especially when we see everybody else11:12seemingly getting recognition11:14for, like, some silly things.11:16You know,11:16kal vachomer it should apply to us, perhaps.11:18We are in that generation,11:20but we got to be11:21careful that it shouldn't be to become to look better.11:25We should feel satisfied with the recognition11:28that Hashem recognizes that we're good,11:30that Hashem recognizes that what we're doing is great,11:33and we have to pray for that.11:35Not easy.11:36Like we said,11:37in our generation it's much harder,11:38so we have to pray harder11:40that Hashem should help us feel satisfied11:43merely by doing just the good thing,11:45even though other people don't necessarily recognize it,11:47as long as we know that Hashem recognizes it.11:50Then,11:52v'lo ye'uneh lo kol aven. Then Hashem will make sure that11:54no bad should come upon you.11:57Sheni, acher nechasha al yado, nobody will stumble upon you.11:59Nobody will become jealous of you.12:01Nobody will make a sin because of you.12:09V'kach tefilat Rabbi Nechunya ben HaKanah k'shenichnas laTorah, de-sham hu yoter, ki nodad Moshe Rabbeinu alav hashalom tikun Havel, v'haydesen nitkan ve'ein kan mekomo. This brings a different idea,12:13that tefilah of Rabbi Nechunya ben HaKanah when it comes to learning Torah,12:17that my friend should not stumble upon me.12:21As we all know that in Torah12:22it's even more so12:23we have to be careful12:24that sometimes people's success in Torah,12:28it can hurt other people.12:29So we have to be careful12:30that nobody should,12:33again,12:34nobody should feel bad because of me,12:36and nobody should, you know, make averot because of me.12:39We know,12:41just to end off with a story,12:42you got to read this unbelievable book12:44about the wife of12:48Rav Chaim Kanievsky, Rebbetzin Kanievsky, that's what it's called.12:49Really unbelievable book12:50if you want to see12:51people who lived in the mashal in our days,12:53how they lived that way.12:54It's not like stories;12:55they actually lived that way.12:58Rebbetzin Kanievsky, anybody who went to Eretz12:58Yisrael and visited the Kanievsky home in Bnei Brak,13:02Rechov Rashbam, knows it's a very, very small apartment.13:04And you should know13:05they had floods and floods of people13:07that came to their houses,13:09including millionaires13:09who offered to give them anything.13:11They set up dishes and as were matched,13:13the oven was an old oven that broke down a13:15lot, and life could have been much simpler.13:18People offered to give it to them for free,13:19no problem.13:20But you know her statement was,13:22her response was always,13:24You know how many ladies come into my13:26house from the neighborhood13:26who can't afford such an oven,13:28who can't afford such,13:30you know, what she called13:31luxuries, which were really basic things,13:33and they're going to feel bad if I have it.13:35It's an unbelievable level,13:37but that's why she's13:40Rabbi Zinganievsky. Understand?13:41There are people that are on a higher level.13:43I'm not telling you not to get the new oven.13:44I'm telling you to think about13:45when you get a new oven,13:47and to be just a little bit concerned,13:49and to just be a little bit sensitive13:50of other people's feelings13:51in whatever we do.13:53And of course, we need the new oven.13:55We should pray,13:55Hashem help us that we shouldn't have13:57any stumbling block13:57when we get that new oven,14:00a homer, everything else that we're accomplishing14:04and attaining.