Torah · MussarMussar82. Exile for KillingTzidkat HaTzadikPart 82Rabbi Uri Nahum · August 23, 2022−15Play+30Position0:0012:37Save⌄ShareRabbi Uri Nahum teaches Tzidkat HaTzadik (צדקת הצדיק).Transcript0:00Tzidkat Tzadik, ot peh bet,0:0482.0:15כי כשאדם נע ונד, אף על פי שמנדבא שהוא צריך לכך לטובתו, מכל מקום ודאי חטא ברציחה דוגמת קין. If a person is always on the move,0:18even though he thinks that this is for his own0:23good—we'll give you a few examples in a0:25second—however, the Rav Tzadok explains that this is actually0:28a result of a sin.0:31And which sin? The sin of killing,0:35like we find by0:36Cain. So let's give you a little bit of background.0:39We go back all the way to the beginning of the Torah,0:42Parashat Bereishit. We know the story of the two brothers, Cain and0:46Hevel. Cain gets up and kills0:48Hevel, and Hashem tells him,0:50Look what you do.0:51After a whole discussion back and forth,0:53Hazal tell us that Cain did0:55chatzi teshuvah; he didn't do full0:56teshuvah, and therefore he deserves punishment.0:58What was his punishment?1:00Hashem tells him,1:01Oh, you killed, therefore1:02na1:04vanad tihyeh baaretz. You'll always be on the go.1:06You will never be in one place.1:07You're always going to be traveling from place to place.1:10You will not be able to settle in one place.1:12That was the punishment of1:14Cain, and that punishment came because of what?1:16Because of killing.1:18We find something similar that the Torah gave1:21for a person who kills by mistake.1:23Killing beshogeg requires the person to go to galut.1:27He has to run away from his place1:28and go to exile to somewhere else.1:32So you see that the punishment of killing, murdering,1:38is a person has to be on the go,1:40has to go in exile.1:41He's always going to be on the move.1:43Na1:44vnad. Na means to move, like1:46shvana means you pronounce it,1:47and nad, like pushed away, pushed to the side.1:50A person who's always on the go1:53is a result of killing.1:56It's basically Hashem is putting the person in killing.1:58Now you might say, What are you talking about?1:59I love traveling.2:00I'm always on the go, traveling from here to there, to there,2:03to there, to there, to there.2:04Yes,2:05that is a result of—2:07that's what he says over here.2:08Even though a person might think it's for his own good.2:10So this could be in a number of situations.2:14This could be maybe2:16that a person is always moving houses,2:19gets into one house,2:21has to move out,2:21there's problems, has to move out,2:23has to go from place to place.2:25That could be one place, one area.2:27Another thing is that a person is always traveling.2:30He's always going. He's picking up,2:31he's going on a flight,2:32one to a different one,2:33and2:34a business one. Now you might say, What do you mean?2:37He has to move.2:38I agree.2:39But why does he have to move?2:41He has to travel.2:42I agree.2:43Yeah, a lot of salesmen, they have to travel.2:44But why do a lot of salesmen,2:46Baruch Hashem, they make it2:47that they don't have to travel?2:48They can do their work from2:49wherever the remote location they are, they're in.2:53And again, you can argue2:55with many, many different things2:56and say he has to.2:57All this,2:58Rav Tzadok concludes in one line.3:00He says,3:03Even though the guy thinks that this is for his own good.3:06He loves going on vacations,3:07traveling from place to place.3:08It's actually a result of killing.3:09Now you might say,3:10I've never murdered before.3:12And you say,3:13Oh, okay, maybe gilgul, perhaps3:15that could be an answer, that3:16maybe in your previous gilgul you killed.3:18But he says,3:20not dafka. But the sin of murder3:22is not only killing actually a person3:25and, you know, making him dead.3:27We find the Chazal tell us3:29that there are certain things that people do3:31that are considered like murder.3:33The famous one is, for example,3:40כגון, המלבין פני... So, dimuya Chazal, the Gemara says, במסכת בבא מציעא, if a person embarrasses another person,3:43it's like you killed him.3:44And over there it says,3:48the Gemara, הלבנת—it calls it הלבנת פנים, making—turning the person white.3:50The Gemara says, what do you mean, turning a person white?3:52When you embarrass somebody, he turns red.3:54He says, yeah, but right afterwards he pales.3:56So it's like you spilled his blood.3:59That's like4:00retzichah. Retzichah is the same thing:4:01murdering somebody4:02is spilling somebody else's blood.4:03So yeah, if you've embarrassed somebody,4:06so you have a sin of killing on your hands.4:09We're not going to bring you to court and kill you,4:11as the halacha prescribes for a murderer,4:14but it's something like that,4:16and therefore4:17a person may see himself always on the go.4:20V'chein, another example:4:25מצער לחברו צער קשה כיוצא בו. If a person hurts other people4:27and he inflicts them with a lot of pain,4:29it could be people that work for you,4:31it could be people that don't work for you,4:32it could be a sibling,4:33it could be a wife,4:35it could be a spouse,4:36it could be a husband,4:37whoever it is.4:37But if you cause other people4:39צער, a lot of4:40צער, it could be even your own kids,4:41it could be your parents,4:43that's also a form of murder.4:45Another example that he says in the4:50remez over here, וכן נחמים באלים כדרשת חזל. The Gemara says in4:52Masechet Niddah that a person4:53who's—sorry to be a little4:58explicit—but who's שופך זרע לבטלה, and that may come up in,5:02you know, he talks,5:03he dedicates a lot actually5:04to talk about this,5:05as the5:06Chassidish sefarim talk about that.5:07Zera levatala is a person wasting seed,5:09and we're not going to use that term again;5:11we're just going to call it5:13zera levatala. So that's also,5:14the Gemara compares it to murder.5:17The Gemara says it actually doesn't compare5:19it, but it says straight out,5:19it's like a person is killing;5:21he's killing those neshamot.5:22So all that,5:23a person could actually,5:25you know—5:27Say, you know,5:27could have those as a sin5:29without realizing.5:30He says,5:30I never killed anybody.5:31I'm such a good person.5:33I don't hurt people.5:33But if you have any of those sins,5:35that could be an indication5:39of having the sin of murder on your hands,5:43and therefore the punishment is,5:43like the way we found by Cain,5:45is to always be on the go,5:46to always traveling.5:48He says, however,5:52ולפעמים תפילה מכפרת מחצה, כמו שנאמר בקין. And sometimes, like we found by Cain,5:54he prayed to Hashem.5:55He says, Come on, Hashem,5:57I have no hope.5:58Hashem tells him, Okay,5:59but he didn't do full teshuva.6:01He didn't do a full teshuva,6:02but he prayed.6:04And praying without doing a full teshuva6:05could actually also be mechaper,6:08but not all the way.6:09It's only mechaper half,6:10like we find by Cain.6:11It says in the pasuk,6:14וישב בארץ נוד. He settled in the land of Nod.6:18Now, what do you mean, Nod?6:19It says in the pasuk,6:21נע ונד תהיה בארץ. There was two6:23gezeirot, נע ונד, and he only settled in the land of Nod.6:26Nod is from the word of movement.6:27So you see that his prayer helped him,6:30that he was able to cancel out6:33half of the6:34gezeirah. So too, if a person has any of those sins,6:37his prayer,6:38and he sees himself always on the move,6:39his prayer can actually help him6:41in canceling out only half of6:43the6:44gezeirah. והיינו. How does that work exactly?6:46He says, What's the idea with this?6:49He says, כי הן מקום עליו שביו. Chazal told us something very interesting.6:52You ever see people that live in certain parts of the world,6:55and you wonder,6:56why in the world are you living there?6:58Is it by choice?6:59And you'll be surprised7:00that most people by choice want to live there.7:03And if you come from different parts of the world,7:06of a different type of settlement,7:08you think they're crazy.7:09Let's give you a few examples.7:12I grew up in Brooklyn.7:13I mean, I was born in a different country,7:16but when I grew up, I grew up in Brooklyn,7:18and we loved living in Brooklyn.7:20It was great.7:21In the summer, people didn't go away.7:22People were here.7:23It was great.7:24And then when I went to yeshiva,7:26ended up going to yeshiva7:30in—first I started in Israel for about 40 days,7:33and then I ended up going to7:36Monsey. Monsey is a very rural area,7:38very quiet.7:39When I first got there, I said,7:41This is crazy.7:42How do people live here?7:44Like, to get to the grocery store,7:46you need to drive or hitch a ride, you know?7:48In Brooklyn, I need something,7:49I just walk down the block7:51and have stores all around me.7:52And it's nuts.7:53How can people live in7:55Monsey? I ended up spending five years in yeshiva in Monsey.8:00I remember coming back to yeshiva after my second year, and I'm like, whoa, what a8:09peaceful place. I can't believe people live in Brooklyn. It's so noisy. Now, if8:14you think Brooklyn is noisy, you go to the city and you see how people live in the8:19city, you think, what, are they crazy? How do people live in the city? How do people8:23live in Manhattan? They're crazy. Yet, when you ask every single person, the person8:28who lives in Monsey, the person who lives in Lakewood, the person who lives in Manhattan, the person who lives in8:31Brooklyn, and the person who lives in Yerushalayim, the person who lives in Tzfat, and every8:34single place, right, where you think they're crazy for living there, each8:38person that actually lives there actually says, I love this place. I never8:42want to move out. Where does that come from? So Chazal tell us,8:48hen makom al yoshevav. There's a certain hen. Hen, it's very hard to explain. Hen is, they8:53translate as grace, but I don't know what grace really means. But, you know, there's8:57a certain liking that people have. It comes, hinam. It makes no sense. It's for9:02free. There's no logical explanation to it. But people have a certain liking.9:07There are certain people that have just hen, v'noach matza hen b'einei Hashem. And so too for the9:14place that people live in. Hen makom al yoshevav. But people that live in that place have9:18a certain, you know, the place gives it a certain hen, and people like where they9:23live. Now what happens, כאשר אין חן מקומו עליו? What happens when you live in a certain place?9:28You live in a certain apartment, you live in a certain house, you live in a certain9:32neighborhood, you live in a certain city, and all of a sudden you don't feel9:36comfortable anymore. You don't want to be there. You want to leave.9:41V'hu keger v'noded sham. You feel like you're a stranger there. You don't feel9:44comfortable there. You want to get out of there.9:48על כן לא קיבלת כפרה עד שיהיה חן מקומו עליו. So you didn't get your kaparah. Here's where it's coming from. The fact that you9:51have to go, you don't feel comfortable. It's part of that9:55gezeirah Hashem is making you go and move. It means you haven't really fixed that aveirah that you10:02had that's connected to the tzechah. So now, that really up to here, the piece is10:07over. He has in brackets a little bit more of an explanation on this idea. He10:11says, Ki keshe'ein chin mekuma alav, az adayin hu na' ve-nad bemachshavah. You may not10:17move physically from a place. Sometimes you settle in a place, and physically10:22you're settled. That's it. I bought my house. I'm not buying another house. I can't10:25afford to buy another house. I'm not selling. I'm not moving. I'm here. I'm good.10:28But in your head, you don't feel comfortable. You always want to go. So he10:33says, in that case, when it's your mind that's always traveling and it's not10:38your physical body, hu siman she-tiken hama'aseh. It could be it's a sign that you10:43fixed the action, but you haven't fixed10:47the thought. As we all know, when you do teshuvah, you have to do teshuvah all10:52the way. When you do an aveirah, it's done with many, many parts of yourself.10:57There's a physical part of yourself where you could do the aveirah. For example,11:00eating taref. You take the hand, you reach out to the non-kosher food, you grab it,11:06you pick it up, you put it in your mouth, you chew and you swallow it. There's also11:10machshavah, the thought that goes into the eating. Mmm, that was so enjoyable. I really11:14enjoyed it. Ah, terrible, I did an aveirah, but, you know, I enjoyed it. It's worth11:18the aveirah sometimes, or some people, I want to do the aveirah. So you see11:22that you could do also the same aveirah. It's with thought and action, and there's, you11:28know, many, many other parts to it as well. But let's take these two for a second. A11:32person who has killed—it could be in action, you embarrass somebody,11:39הלבנת פנים, or literally a person killed somebody. So he's always on the go. It could be11:43also b'machshavah, where the thoughts are still in the aveirah. The aveirah means to say he's11:48not really regretful of the aveirah. He doesn't want to do it again. Ah, it's so bad.11:52So he hasn't fixed really the machshavah. Ah, why the guy has to be so sensitive to11:57get embarrassed? Ah, relax a little bit. He's got to take a chill pill. But12:00you embarrassed him, no? Yeah, but he's got to relax. So you're not really so12:03regretful of what you did. So that's also, in a way, what a person, that's12:09what a person also needs to be metaken as well. That's called b'machshavah. So12:13although physically may not be on the go, but if your thoughts are still not calm12:18and settled, it means you still need to fix that as well. Amazing, powerful piece,12:24because if you think about this idea, and you see how far it could take you, really,12:30there's much more depth to this idea. You'll find really much more the12:35more you think about it.